UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE ... - WordPress.com

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 1 of 434

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK THOMAS E. BURNETT, SR., individually as the Parent of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., Deceased BEVERLY BURNETT, individually as the Parent of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., Deceased DEENA BURNETT BAILEY, individually and as the Administrator of the Estate of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr. and on behalf of minor children H.B., A.C.B., and M.B. MARY MARGARET JURGENS, individually as the Sibling of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., Deceased MARTHA BURNETT PETTEE, individually as the Sibling of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., Deceased WILLIAM DOYLE, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Michael Doyle, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Michael Doyle REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Camille Doyle, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joseph Michael Doyle WILLIAM DOYLE, JR., individually as the Sibling of Joseph Michael Doyle, Deceased DOREEN LUTTER, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Michael Doyle, Deceased DR. STEPHEN J. ALDERMAN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Peter Craig Alderman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Craig Alderman ELIZABETH ALDERMAN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Peter Craig Alderman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Craig Alderman JANE ALDERMAN, individually as the Sibling of Peter Craig Alderman, Deceased ELAINE ABATE, individually as the Parent of

Civil Case No. 03-CV-9849 (GBD)(SN)

PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT ADDING DEFENDANT KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 2 of 434

Andrew Anthony Abate, Jr., Deceased CAROLYN CRUTCHFIELD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andrew Anthony Abate, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Anthony Abate ELAINE ABATE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent Abate, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Abate ANN M. ABRAHAMSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William F. Abrahamson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William F. Abrahamson and on behalf of minor child E.A.A. JOSEPHINE ACQUAVIVA, individually as the Parent of Paul Andrew Acquaviva, Deceased KARA HADFIELD, individually as the Sibling of Paul Andrew Acquaviva, Deceased COURTNEY LIZABETH ACQUAVIVA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Andrew Acquaviva, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Andrew Acquaviva and on behalf of minor children P.A.A. and S.L.A. ALFRED ACQUAVIVA, individually as the Parent of Paul Andrew Acquaviva, Deceased JEAN ADAMS, individually as the Parent of Donald L. Adams, Deceased DOE 96, individually as spouse and as the Personal Representative of the ESTATE OF DOE 96, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 96 and on behalf of minor child DOE 96 ROBERT C. ADAMS, individually as the Parent of Donald L. Adams, Deceased DWIGHT D. ADAMS, individually as the Sibling of Donald L. Adams, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Anne B. 2

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 3 of 434

Adams, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stephen George Adams JESSICA MURROW-ADAMS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen George Adams, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen George Adams LAWRENCE SCOTT ADAMS, individually as the Sibling of Stephen George Adams, Deceased AFFIONG ADANGA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ignatius Udo Adanga, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ignatius Udo Adanga and on behalf of minor children E.U.A., E.U.A., and N.U.A. RITA ADDAMO, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Christy A. Addamo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christy A. Addamo DAWN ADDAMO, individually as the Sibling of Christy A. Addamo, Deceased GREGORY ADDAMO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Christy A. Addamo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christy A. Addamo ALICE FAY DOERGE ADLER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lee Alan Adler, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lee Alan Adler and on behalf of minor child L.A. STACEY AFFLITTO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Thomas Afflitto, Sr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Thomas Afflitto, Sr. and on behalf of minor children J.D.A. and D.A. RITA AGNELLO, individually as the Parent of Joseph Agnello, Deceased ROSARIA MARTINGANO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Agnello, Deceased VINNIE CARLA AGNELLO, individually and 3

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 4 of 434

as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Agnello, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Agnello and on behalf of minor children S.R.A. and V.J.A. SALVATORE AGNELLO, individually as the Parent of Joseph Agnello, Deceased ANTHONY AGNELLO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Agnello, Deceased DIANE B. AGUIAR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joao A. Aguiar, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joao A. Aguiar, Jr. TACIANA AGUIAR, individually as the Sibling of Joao A. Aguiar, Jr., Deceased JOAO A. AGUIAR, SR., individually as the Parent of Joao A. Aguiar, Jr., Deceased CATHERINE FRANCES JEZYCKI, individually as the Parent of Margaret Alario, Deceased MICHAEL JOHN JEZYCKI, individually as the Sibling of Margaret Alario, Deceased STEPHEN FRANK JEZYCKI, JR., individually as the Sibling of Margaret Alario, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Stephen Jezycki, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Margaret Alario JAMES ALARIO, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Margaret Alario, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Margaret Alario and on behalf of minor children J.A. and D.A. EDWARD ALBERT, individually as the Parent of Jon L. Albert, Deceased LOUISA ALLEGRETTO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward L. Allegretto, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward L. Allegretto and on behalf of minor children M.A. and E.A. JENNIFER D'AURIA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joseph R. 4

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 5 of 434

Allen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph R. Allen MICHAEL J. ALLEN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joseph R. Allen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph R. Allen MADELYN GAIL ALLEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Dennis Allen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Dennis Allen LYNN P. ALLEN, individually as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen, Deceased MARGUERITE G. ALLEN, individually as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen, Deceased JUDITH M. AIKEN, individually as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen, Deceased RICHARD D. ALLEN, individually as the Parent of Richard Dennis Allen, Deceased LUKE C. ALLEN, individually as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen, Deceased MATTHEW J. ALLEN, individually as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen, Deceased PATRICIA CLEARY ALLINGHAM, individually as the Parent of Christopher Edward Allingham, Deceased PEGGY ALLINGHAM CICCARELLI, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Edward Allingham, Deceased KATHARINE ALLINGHAM CLARK, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Edward Allingham, Deceased DONNA ALLINGHAM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Edward Allingham, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Edward Allingham and on behalf of minor children C.T.A. and K.P.A. JAMES JOSEPH ALLINGHAM, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Edward Allingham, Deceased 5

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 6 of 434

WILLIAM JOHN ALLINGHAM, JR., individually as the Sibling of Christopher Edward Allingham, Deceased WILLIAM J. ALLINGHAM, SR., individually as the Parent of Christopher Edward Allingham, Deceased V. BLAKE ALLISON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anna Allison, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anna Allison GIANINA ALVIAR, individually as the Child of Cesar A. Alviar, Deceased GEMMA ALVIAR, individually as the Child of Cesar A. Alviar, Deceased GRACE ALVIAR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cesar A. Alviar, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Cesar A. Alviar CHRISTOPHER ALVIAR, individually as the Child of Cesar A. Alviar, Deceased SHARON AMBROSE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Paul Wesley Ambrose, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Wesley Ambrose KENNETH P. AMBROSE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Paul Wesley Ambrose, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Wesley Ambrose MARIE L. ANAYA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Calixto Anaya, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Calixto Anaya, Jr. and on behalf of minor children B.M.A, K.M.A, and R.R.A. CHRISTINE A. ANCHUNDIA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joseph P. Anchundia, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Anchundia ELIZABETH R. ANCHUNDIA, individually as the Sibling of Joseph P. Anchundia, Deceased ELIAS A. ANCHUNDIA, individually and as 6

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 7 of 434

the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joseph P. Anchundia, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Anchundia ELIAS J. ANCHUNDIA, individually as the Sibling of Joseph P. Anchundia, Deceased SELMA ANN VERSE, individually as the Sibling of Kermit C. Anderson, Deceased JILL ELVA GRASHOF ANDERSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kermit C. Anderson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kermit C. Anderson and on behalf of minor children D.J.A. and B.L.A. EDWARD S. ANDREWS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Rourke Andrews, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Rourke Andrews KUI LIONG LEE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of SiewNya Ang, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Siew-Nya Ang and on behalf of minor children J.L. and W.L. DONNA L. ANGELINI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph John Angelini, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph John Angelini, Jr. and on behalf of minor children J.A., J.A., and J.A. CLAIRE ANGELL MILLER, individually as the Sibling of David Lawrence Angell, Deceased DOROTEA ANGILLETTA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Laura Angilletta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Laura Angilletta MARIA GARBARINO, individually as the Sibling of Laura Angilletta, Deceased CARMELO ANGILLETTA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Laura Angilletta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Laura Angilletta 7

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 8 of 434

AL ANGILLETTA, individually as the Sibling of Laura Angilletta, Deceased RALPH ANGRISANI AND GINA GIOVANNIELLO, as the Co-Administrators of the Estate of Doreen J. Angrisani, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Doreen J. Angrisani, and as Co-Administrators of the Estate of Irene T. Angrisani, Deceased, Parent of decedent Doreen J. Angrisani GINA GIOVANNIELLO, individually as the Sibling of Doreen J. Angrisani, Deceased RALPH ANGRISANI, individually as the Sibling of Doreen J. Angrisani, Deceased BRIAN WILKES, individually as the Fiancé of Lorraine Antigua, Deceased CECILE M. APOLLO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Peter Paul Apollo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Paul Apollo DENISE MAUTHE, individually as the Sibling of Peter Paul Apollo, Deceased LISA CONSIGLIO, individually as the Sibling of Peter Paul Apollo, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Peter Apollo, Jr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Peter Paul Apollo MARGARET APOSTOL, individually as the Sibling of Faustino Apostol, Deceased CAROL ANN AQUILINO, individually as the Parent of Frank Thomas Aquilino, Deceased TARA CHIARI, individually as the Sibling of Frank Thomas Aquilino, Deceased JILL WALTON, individually as the Sibling of Frank Thomas Aquilino, Deceased FRANK J. AQUILINO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank Thomas Aquilino, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frank Thomas Aquilino LORI ANN ARCZYNSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 8

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 9 of 434

Michael G. Arczynski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael G. Arczynski and on behalf of minor children E.N.A., M.P.A., M.S.A., and S.E.A. WANDALEE ARENA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Louis Arena, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Louis Arena and on behalf of minor children N.A. and J.C.A. LAUREN ARIAS LUCCHINI, individually as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias, Deceased LORRAINE M. ARIAS-BELIVEAU, individually as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias, Deceased DONALD C. ARIAS, individually as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias, Deceased THOMAS ARIAS, individually as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias, Deceased ANDREW ARIAS, individually as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias, Deceased CATHERINE M. NOLAN, individually as the Fiancé of Michael Joseph Armstrong, Deceased MARY E. ARMSTRONG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Joseph Armstrong, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Joseph Armstrong LAURA A. ARMSTRONG, individually as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Armstrong, Deceased MARIAN ARMSTRONG, individually as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Armstrong, Deceased GABRIEL ARMSTRONG, individually as the Parent of Michael Joseph Armstrong, Deceased GERARD ARMSTRONG, individually as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Armstrong, Deceased RUTH GREEN ARON, individually as the Parent of Joshua Todd Aron, Deceased 9

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 10 of 434

JULES PHELAN ARONSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Myra Joy Aronson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Myra Joy Aronson AYIKAILE ARYEE, individually as the Child of Japhet Aryee, Deceased MARIA ARYEE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Japhet Aryee, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Japhet Aryee and on behalf of minor child A.A. TEIKO ARYEE, individually as the Child of Japhet Aryee, Deceased AYITEY ARYEE, individually as the Child of Japhet Aryee, Deceased VIVIAN ASCIAK, individually as the Parent of Michael Asciak, Deceased ELAINE V. ASCIAK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Asciak, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Asciak and on behalf of minor child L.A. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Ethel Asher, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael Edward Asher RACHEL ASHER, individually as the Child of Michael Edward Asher, Deceased DANA ASHER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Edward Asher, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Edward Asher MARLENE ASHER as the Representative of the Estate of Stuart Asher, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Michael Edward Asher JEREMY ASHER, individually as the Child of Michael Edward Asher, Deceased DOE 15, individually as parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of DOE 15, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE DOE 15, individually as parent and as the Co10

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 11 of 434

Administrator of the Estate of DOE 15, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 15 DOE 15, individually as the Sibling of DOE 15, Deceased MARIA TRANSITO QUINTUNA SACTA, individually as the Parent of Manual Asitimbay, Deceased WILSON ASITIMBAY, individually as the Child of Manual Asitimbay, Deceased RICARDO ASITIMBAY, individually as the Child of Manual Asitimbay, Deceased EDWIN ASITIMBAY, individually as the Child of Manual Asitimbay, Deceased WILMER MIJIA, individually as the step-child of Manual Asitimbay, Deceased JULIA ROCIA ASITIMBAY QUINTUNA, individually as the Sibling of Manual Asitimbay, Deceased MARIA MACLOVIA ASITIMBAY QUINTUNA, individually as the Sibling of Manual Asitimbay, Deceased ROSA ELENA ASITIMBAY QUINTUNA, individually as the Sibling of Manual Asitimbay, Deceased CARMEN CECILIA MEJIA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Manual Asitimbay, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Manual Asitimbay ELAINE M. ATWOOD (SIBLING), individually as the Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood, Deceased ELAINE M. ATWOOD (PARENT), individually as the Parent of Gerald T. Atwood, Deceased JANE M. DUFFY, individually as the Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood, Deceased GERALD ATWOOD, individually as the Parent of Gerald T. Atwood, Deceased RAYMOND J. ATWOOD, individually as the 11

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 12 of 434

Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood, Deceased GREGORY P. ATWOOD, individually as the Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood, Deceased JOHN G. ATWOOD, individually as the Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood, Deceased JUANA BACCHUS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eustace R. Bacchus, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eustace R. Bacchus and on behalf of minor child C.B. GRACE MARIE BADAGLIACCA, individually as the Parent of John J. Badagliacca, Deceased JODI SCOLARO, individually as the Sibling of John J. Badagliacca, Deceased JOHN EDWARD BADAGLIACCA, individually as the Parent of John J. Badagliacca, Deceased JOHN P. BAESZLER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jane Ellen Baeszler, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jane Ellen Baeszler CHRISTINE GOGGINS, individually as the Sibling of Andrew Joseph Bailey, Deceased PAULA VIRGINIA BAILEY, individually as the Sibling of Andrew Joseph Bailey, Deceased VINCENT HENRY BAILEY, individually as the Parent of Andrew Joseph Bailey, Deceased JUDITH A. BAILEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brett T. Bailey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brett T. Bailey YARAH BAILEY, individually as the Sibling of Brett T. Bailey, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Kevin J. Bailey, Deceased, Parent of decedent Brett T. Bailey YURIAH BAILEY, individually as the Sibling of Brett T. Bailey, Deceased KATHERINE BAILEY, individually and as the 12

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 13 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of Garnet Bailey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Garnet Bailey TODD G. BAILEY, individually as the Child of Garnet Bailey, Deceased MARINA BAKALINSKAYA, individually as the Child of Tatyana Bakalinskaya, Deceased NATALIE BAKALINSKAYA, individually as the Child of Tatyana Bakalinskaya, Deceased ANATOLIY BAKALINSKIY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Tatyana Bakalinskaya, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Tatyana Bakalinskaya MARTHA BAKSH, individually as the Parent of Michael S. Baksh, Deceased MARVINA BAKSH, individually as the Sibling of Michael S. Baksh, Deceased MAUREEN BAKSH GRIFFIN, individually as the Sibling of Michael S. Baksh, Deceased MICHELLE BAKSH, individually as the Sibling of Michael S. Baksh, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Morris Baksh, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael S. Baksh CHRISTINA BANE-HAYES, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Bane, Deceased TARA BANE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael A. Bane, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael A. Bane J. DONALD BANE, individually as the Parent of Michael A. Bane, Deceased SOULTANA BANTIS, individually as the Parent of Katherine Bantis, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Evangelos Bantis, Deceased, Parent of decedent Katherine Bantis ARISTIDES BANTIS, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Katherine Bantis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors 13

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 14 of 434

of Katherine Bantis REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Gerard Jean-Baptiste, Deceased, Parent of decedent Gerard Baptiste REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Gerard Baptiste, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gerard Baptiste ANNA M. GRANVILLE, individually as the Sibling of Walter Baran, Deceased CAROL ANN BARAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Walter Baran, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Walter Baran and on behalf of minor children S.B. and S.B. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Carol Barbaro, Deceased, Parent of decedent Paul Barbaro JACQUELINE VENEZIA, individually as the Sibling of Paul Barbaro, Deceased KIM BARBARO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Barbaro, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Barbaro and on behalf of minor children P.B. and J.B. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Nicholas Barbaro, Deceased, Parent of decedent Paul Barbaro THOMAS BARBARO, individually as the Sibling of Paul Barbaro, Deceased NICHOLAS BARBARO, JR., individually as the Sibling of Paul Barbaro, Deceased NANCY SANTANA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Victor Daniel Barbosa, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Victor Daniel Barbosa and on behalf of minor child S.B. JO ANN MEEHAN, individually as the Parent of Colleen Ann Barkow, Deceased DARYL JOSEPH MEEHAN, individually as the Sibling of Colleen Ann Barkow, Deceased 14

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 15 of 434

THOMAS JOSEPH MEEHAN, III, individually as the Parent of Colleen Ann Barkow, Deceased ALAN M. MENNIE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Melissa Rose Barnes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Melissa Rose Barnes AUDRIENE BARRY, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Arthur T. Barry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Arthur T. Barry KATHLEEN MEGAN POSS, individually as the Sibling of Arthur T. Barry, Deceased PATRICIA ANNE BARRY, individually as the Sibling of Arthur T. Barry, Deceased CLARE ELLEN SKARDA, individually as the Sibling of Arthur T. Barry, Deceased BERTRAND FRANCIS BARRY, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Arthur T. Barry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Arthur T. Barry BERTRAND ARTHUR BARRY, individually as the Sibling of Arthur T. Barry, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Maureen Barry, Deceased, Child of decedent Diane Barry BRIAN BARRY, individually as the Child of Diane Barry, Deceased KEVIN WILLIAM BARRY, individually as the Child of Diane Barry, Deceased EDMUND BARRY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Diane Barry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Diane Barry MARIANNE JOAN BARRY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maurice V. Barry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Maurice V. Barry and on behalf of minor children C.B. and J-M.B. GILA BARZVI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Guy 15

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 16 of 434

Barzvi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Guy Barzvi DOE 35, individually as the Sibling of DOE 35, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Arie Barzvi, Deceased, Parent of decedent Guy Barzvi FRIMA KOGAN, individually as the Parent of Inna Basin, Deceased JEAN BASNICKI, individually as the Parent of Kenneth William Basnicki, Deceased MAUREEN ELIZABETH BASNICKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth William Basnicki, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth William Basnicki BRENNAN BASNICKI, individually as the Child of Kenneth William Basnicki, Deceased WILLIAM BASNICKI, individually as the Parent of Kenneth William Basnicki, Deceased CHRIS BASNICKI, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth William Basnicki, Deceased ROBERT J. BASNICKI, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth William Basnicki, Deceased JOAN PUWALSKI, individually as the Fiancé of Steven J. Bates, Deceased NARCISA G. CAPITO, individually as the Parent of Marlyn Capito Bautista, Deceased ANISIA C. ABARABAR, individually as the Sibling of Marlyn Capito Bautista, Deceased RUFINA C. COQUIA, individually as the Sibling of Marlyn Capito Bautista, Deceased RAMESES GARCIA BAUTISTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marlyn Capito Bautista, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Marlyn Capito Bautista MARY BAVIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Lawrence Bavis, Deceased and on behalf of all 16

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 17 of 434

survivors of Mark Lawrence Bavis MARY ELLEN MORAN, individually as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis, Deceased KELLY BAVIS MORRISSEY, individually as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis, Deceased KATHLEEN M. SYLVESTER, individually as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis, Deceased MICHAEL T. BAVIS, individually as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis, Deceased PATRICK J BAVIS, individually as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis, Deceased JOHN M. BAVIS, individually as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis, Deceased MATTIE L. BAXTER, individually as the Parent of Jasper Baxter, Deceased JUANITA WHATLEY, individually as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter, Deceased DIANE BAXTER, individually as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter, Deceased LILLIAN BAXTER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jasper Baxter, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jasper Baxter DONALD BAXTER, individually as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter, Deceased DENNIS BAXTER, individually as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter, Deceased LAWRENCE BAXTER, individually as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter, Deceased JEDELLE BAXTER, JR., individually as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter, Deceased BRENT MCINTOSH, individually as the Child of Jane Beatty, Deceased DREW MCINTOSH, individually as the Child of Jane Beatty, Deceased ROBERT W. BEATTY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jane Beatty, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jane Beatty 17

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 18 of 434

THEODORE BECK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lawrence I. Beck, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lawrence I. Beck EDWARD C. WILLIAMS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Manette M. Beckles, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Manette M. Beckles and on behalf of minor child B.W. DOLORES BEDIGIAN, individually as the Parent of Carl Bedigian, Deceased ROBERT BEDIGIAN, individually as the Sibling of Carl Bedigian, Deceased JOSEPH J. BEDIGIAN, individually as the Sibling of Carl Bedigian, Deceased THEODORA BEEKMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael E. Beekman, Sr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. Beekman, Sr. and on behalf of minor children T.N.B. and M.E.B. INMACULADA BEHR, individually as the Parent of Maria Behr, Deceased GEORGE BEHR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maria Behr, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Maria Behr EMMA TISNOVSKIY, individually as the Parent of Helen Belilovsky, Deceased LEONID TISNOVSKIY, individually as the Parent of Helen Belilovsky, Deceased ROSTYSLAV TISNOVSKIY, individually as the Sibling of Helen Belilovsky, Deceased BORIS BELILOVSKY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Helen Belilovsky, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Helen Belilovsky and on behalf of minor child E.B.B. SUZANNE ABENMOHA, individually as the Parent of Debbie Bellows, Deceased SEAN BELLOWS, individually and as the 18

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 19 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of Debbie Bellows, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Debbie Bellows REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Maria Giordano, Deceased, Parent of decedent Denise Lenore Benedetto MARINA BENEDETTO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Denise Lenore Benedetto, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Denise Lenore Benedetto and on behalf of minor child D.B. RINA RABINOWITZ, individually as the Sibling of Denise Lenore Benedetto, Deceased MICHAEL GIORDANO, individually as the Sibling of Denise Lenore Benedetto, Deceased JOHN BENEDETTO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Denise Lenore Benedetto, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Denise Lenore Benedetto and on behalf of minor child D.B. ONDINA BENNETT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bryan Craig Bennett, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Bryan Craig Bennett LOURDES BENNETT O'CONNOR, individually as the Sibling of Bryan Craig Bennett, Deceased DOE 125, individually as spouse and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of DOE 125, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 125 DOE 125, individually as parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of DOE 125, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 125 DOE 125, individually as the Sibling of DOE 125, Deceased SUZANNE J. BERGER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James P. Berger, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James P. Berger and on behalf of 19

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 20 of 434

minor children A.M.B, C.D.B., and N.J.B. GARY BERGER, individually as the Sibling of Steven Howard Berger, Deceased AGNES BERGIN, individually as the Parent of John P. Bergin, Deceased MARY ELLEN O'ROURKE, individually as the Sibling of John P. Bergin, Deceased GEORGE R. BERGIN, individually as the Parent of John P. Bergin, Deceased GEORGE M. BERGIN, individually as the Sibling of John P. Bergin, Deceased RENEE HOFFMAN, individually as the Sibling of Alvin Bergsohn, Deceased MICHELE ZAPKEN BERGSOHN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alvin Bergsohn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alvin Bergsohn and on behalf of minor children H.B. and S.B. KENNETH BERGSOHN, individually as the Parent of Alvin Bergsohn, Deceased DOE 29, individually as the Child of DOE 29, Deceased DOE 29, individually as spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 29, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 29 DOE 29, individually as the Child of DOE 29, Deceased DOE 29, individually as the Child of DOE 29, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Norma Bernstein, Deceased, Parent of decedent William M. Bernstein REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Murray Bernstein, Deceased, Parent of decedent William M. Bernstein DAVID M. BERNSTEIN, individually as the Sibling of William M. Bernstein, Deceased ROBERT J. BERNSTEIN, individually and as 20

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 21 of 434

the Personal Representative of the Estate of William M. Bernstein, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William M. Bernstein KIMBERLY A. BERRY, individually as the Child of Joseph John Berry, Deceased EVELYN BERRY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph John Berry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph John Berry TODD P. BERRY, individually as the Child of Joseph John Berry, Deceased JOSEPH S. BERRY, individually as the Child of Joseph John Berry, Deceased JOAN C. BETTERLY, individually as the Parent of Timothy D. Betterly, Deceased JOANNE F. BETTERLY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Timothy D. Betterly, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Timothy D. Betterly and on behalf of minor children C.B. and S.B. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Donald A. Betterly, Deceased, Parent of decedent Timothy D. Betterly MARK BETTERLY, individually as the Sibling of Timothy D. Betterly, Deceased DONALD BETTERLY, JR., individually as the Sibling of Timothy D. Betterly, Deceased INDIRA BHUKHAN, individually as the Parent of Bella J. Bhukhan, Deceased JAGDISH BHUKHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bella J. Bhukhan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Bella J. Bhukhan IRENE BILCHER, individually as the Parent of Brian Bilcher, Deceased TINA MARIE BILCHER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian Bilcher, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brian Bilcher and on behalf of minor child G.J.B. 21

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 22 of 434

MILES BILCHER, individually as the Parent of Brian Bilcher, Deceased ALICE HOAGLAND, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark K. Bingham, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark K. Bingham GERALD W. BINGHAM, individually as the Parent of Mark K. Bingham, Deceased LILLIAN BINI, individually as the Parent of Carl Bini, Deceased ROSEMARIE CORVINO, individually as the Sibling of Carl Bini, Deceased LILLIAN BINI as Representative of the Estate of Raymond Bini, Deceased, Parent of decedent Carl Bini BASMATTIE BISHUNDAT, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Kris Romeo Bishundat, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kris Romeo Bishundat BHOLA P. BISHUNDAT, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Kris Romeo Bishundat, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kris Romeo Bishundat HYACINTH BLACKMAN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr. ALBERT A. BLACKMAN, SR., individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr. JANE BLACKWELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Blackwell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Blackwell and on behalf of minor children A.B., S.B., and R.B. SALLY T. WHITE, individually as the Parent of Susan L. Blair, Deceased LESLIE R. BLAIR, individually and as the 22

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 23 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan L. Blair, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Susan L. Blair DANIEL A. WALISIAK, individually as the Fiancé of Susan L. Blair, Deceased SCOTT BLANEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Janice Blaney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Janice Blaney BARBARA LYNN BLASS, individually as the Parent of Craig Michael Blass, Deceased BARBARA LYNN BLASS as Representative of the Estate of Neil Blass, Deceased, Parent of decedent Craig Michael Blass KEITH BLASS, individually and as the Representative of the Estate of Craig Michael Blass, Deceased, and on behalf of all survivors of Craig Michael Blass MICHELE BUFFOLINO, individually as the Child of Rita Blau, Deceased NICOLE EFFRESS, individually as the Child of Rita Blau, Deceased IRA BLAU, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rita Blau, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Rita Blau DEBORAH A. BORZA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Deora Frances Bodley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Deora Frances Bodley REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Derrill Bodley, Deceased, Parent of decedent Deora Frances Bodley JOYCE BOLAND, individually as the Parent of Vincent M. Boland, Jr., Deceased ERIN BOLAND, individually as the Sibling of Vincent M. Boland, Jr., Deceased GREGORY BOLAND, individually as the Sibling of Vincent M. Boland, Jr., Deceased VINCENT BOLAND, SR., individually and as 23

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 24 of 434

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent M. Boland, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent M. Boland, Jr. DOE 118, individually as the Child of DOE 118, Deceased DOE 20, individually as spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 20, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 20 WILLIAM BONDARENKO, individually as the Child of Alan Bondarenko, Deceased JOSEPH BONDARENKO, individually as the Child of Alan Bondarenko, Deceased ROXANE BONHEUR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andre Bonheur, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Andre Bonheur, Jr. and on behalf of minor children A.A.B. and M.P.B. SONIA BONOMO, individually as the Parent of Yvonne Bonomo, Deceased JOHN BONOMO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Yvonne Bonomo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Yvonne Bonomo GEORGE BONOMO, individually as the Sibling of Yvonne Bonomo, Deceased ROSE ANN BOOKER, individually as the Parent of Sean Booker, Deceased SHARON BOOKER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Booker, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Booker and on behalf of minor children D.B., D.B., and S.B. RICHARD L. BOOMS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kelly Ann Booms, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kelly Ann Booms DEANNA G. DEMOTTE, individually as the Sibling of Canfield D. Boone, Deceased LINDA K. BOONE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 25 of 434

Canfield D. Boone, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Canfield D. Boone JASON BOONE, individually as the Child of Canfield D. Boone, Deceased ANDREW BOONE, individually as the Child of Canfield D. Boone, Deceased CHRISTOPHER BOONE, individually as the Child of Canfield D. Boone, Deceased KRYSTYNA BORYCZEWSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Boryczewski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Boryczewski MICHELE BORYCZEWSKI, individually as the Sibling of Martin Boryczewski, Deceased JULIA BORYCZEWSKI, individually as the Sibling of Martin Boryczewski, Deceased MICHELE BORYCZEWSKI and JULIA BORYCZEWSKI as Co-Administrators of the Estate of Michael Boryczewski, Deceased, Parent of decedent Martin Boryczewski WILLIAM J. BOSCO, JR., individually as the Parent of Richard E. Bosco, Deceased KENNETH E. DELLEFEMINE as the Representative of the Estate of Hope DelleFemine, Deceased, Parent of decedent Carol Marie Bouchard KENNETH E. DELLEFEMINE, individually as the Sibling of Carol Marie Bouchard, Deceased RICHARD E. DELLEFEMINE, individually as the Sibling of Carol Marie Bouchard, Deceased FREDERICK EARL BOUCHARD, JR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carol Marie Bouchard, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Carol Marie Bouchard DOE 119, individually as the Parent of DOE 119, Deceased DOE 119, individually as spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 26 of 434

119, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 119 and on behalf of minor child DOE 119 DOE 119, individually as the Sibling of DOE 119, Deceased SHEILAH L. BOWDEN, individually as the Parent of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr., Deceased KATHRYN C. BOWDEN, individually as the Sibling of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr., Deceased THOMAS H. BOWDEN, individually as the Parent of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of minor sibling, M.B. PAUL BOWDEN, individually as the Sibling of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr., Deceased RUTH BOWMAN WHITE, individually as the Parent of Larry Bowman, Deceased STEPHANIE AYN BOWSER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin Leah Bowser, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Leah Bowser and on behalf of minor children P.A.B. and K.L.B. BELLA BOYARSKY, individually as the Parent of Gennady Boyarsky, Deceased VLADIMIR BOYARSKY, individually as the Parent of Gennady Boyarsky, Deceased LAURA ALESSI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Pamela J. Boyce, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Pamela J. Boyce GINA GRASSI, individually as the Sibling of Pamela J. Boyce, Deceased DESIREE A. GERASIMOVICH, individually as the Sibling of Pamela J. Boyce, Deceased DEANNA WIRTH, individually as the Child of Alfred J. Braca, Deceased CHRISTINA CAMBEIS, individually as the Child of Alfred J. Braca, Deceased DAVID JOHN BRACA, individually as the Child of Alfred J. Braca, Deceased

26

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 27 of 434

CHRISTOPHER JONATHAN BRACA, individually as the Child of Alfred J. Braca, Deceased NELLY BRAGINSKY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alexander Braginsky, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alexander Braginsky NANCY BRANDEMARTI, individually as the Parent of Nicholas W. Brandemarti, Deceased NICOLE BRANDEMARTI, individually as the Sibling of Nicholas W. Brandemarti, Deceased NICHOLAS M. BRANDEMARTI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nicholas W. Brandemarti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Nicholas W. Brandemarti JASON BRANDEMARTI, individually as the Sibling of Nicholas W. Brandemarti, Deceased DAVID B. BRANDHORST, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Raymond Brandhorst, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Raymond Brandhorst MARY E. BRATTON, individually as the Parent of Michelle Renee Bratton, Deceased ERIN G. BRATTON, individually as the Sibling of Michelle Renee Bratton, Deceased CHRISTOPHER B. BRATTON, individually as the Sibling of Michelle Renee Bratton, Deceased WILLIAM J. BRATTON, III, individually as the Sibling of Michelle Renee Bratton, Deceased WILLIAM J. BRATTON, JR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michelle Renee Bratton, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michelle Renee Bratton PAOLA STORER, individually as the Parent of Patrice Braut, Deceased MICHEL BRAUT, individually as the Parent of 27

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 28 of 434

Patrice Braut, Deceased ANTHONY BENGIVENGA, individually as the Fiancé of Lydia Bravo, Deceased BARBARA H. BRENNAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francis H. Brennan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Francis H. Brennan EILEEN WALSH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael E. Brennan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. Brennan VERONICA BRENNAN, individually as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan, Deceased MARY M. WALSH, individually as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan, Deceased PATRICIA WALSH, individually as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan, Deceased MARGARET WALSH, individually as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Michael Brennan, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael E. Brennan BRIAN T. BRENNAN, individually as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan, Deceased MATTHEW J. WALSH, individually as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan, Deceased JAMES JOHN BRENNAN, individually as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan, Deceased CAROL A BRETHEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel J Brethel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel J Brethel and on behalf of minor children K.M.B. and M.J.B. JACQUELINE ISKOLS, individually as the Sibling of Mark Brisman, Deceased MICHELE PRIEST, individually as the Sibling of Mark Brisman, Deceased JULIETTE BRISMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Brisman, Deceased and on behalf of all 28

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 29 of 434

survivors of Mark Brisman GERARD BRISMAN, individually as the Parent of Mark Brisman, Deceased STEVEN A. BRISMAN, individually as the Sibling of Mark Brisman, Deceased DOE 127, individually as the Parent of Paul Gary Bristow, Deceased DOE 127, individually as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 127, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 127 ISOLINE BROOMFIELD, individually as the Parent of Keith Broomfield, Deceased SINITA BROWN, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Bernard Curtis Brown, II, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Bernard Curtis Brown, II BERNARD CURTIS BROWN, I, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Bernard Curtis Brown, II, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Bernard Curtis Brown, II EVERTON JAMES BROWN, individually as the Parent of Lloyd Brown, Deceased CAROLYN M. NEGRON, individually as the Sibling of Patrick J. Brown, Deceased MICHAEL EVERETT BROWN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick J. Brown, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick J. Brown SIGALIT BRUNN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andrew C. Brunn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew C. Brunn CHARILYN S. BUCHANAN, individually as the Parent of Brandon J. Buchanan, Deceased RONALD B. BUCHANAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brandon J. Buchanan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brandon J. Buchanan 29

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 30 of 434

JOSEPHINE BUCK, individually as the Parent of Gregory J. Buck, Deceased CATHERINE MORRISON BUCK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory J. Buck, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory J. Buck ERNST H. BUCK, individually as the Parent of Gregory J. Buck, Deceased ERIC BUCK, individually as the Sibling of Gregory J. Buck, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Kathleen M. Buckley, Deceased, Parent of decedent Dennis Buckley JANE MARIE SMITHWICK, individually as the Sibling of Dennis Buckley, Deceased KATHLEEN M. BUCKLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis Buckley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis Buckley and on behalf of minor children M.E.B., M.K.B., and M.A.B. JOHN C. BUCKLEY, individually as the Parent of Dennis Buckley, Deceased CHARLES GAVIN MCNULTY as Executor of the Estate of Helen R. McNulty, Deceased, Parent of decedent Nancy Clare Bueche REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Mary Ellen McNulty, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Nancy Clare Bueche STEPHEN J. MCNULTY, individually as the Sibling of Nancy Clare Bueche, Deceased MARTIN L. MCNULTY, individually as the Sibling of Nancy Clare Bueche, Deceased JAMES T. BUECHE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nancy Clare Bueche, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Nancy Clare Bueche and on behalf of minor child B.B. CHARLES GAVIN MCNULTY, individually as the Sibling of Nancy Clare Bueche, Deceased 30

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 31 of 434

FRAN (FRANCES) BULAGA, individually as the Parent of John E. Bulaga, Jr., Deceased GAIL M. BULAGA, individually as the Sibling of John E. Bulaga, Jr., Deceased MICHELLE A. BULAGA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John E. Bulaga, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John E. Bulaga, Jr. and on behalf of minor children R.B. and A.B. JOHN E. BULAGA, SR., individually as the Parent of John E. Bulaga, Jr., Deceased PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Stephen Bunin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Bunin; the REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Aseneth Bunin, Deceased, Spouse of decedent Stephen Bunin CORINNE BUNIN, individually as the Parent of Stephen Bunin, Deceased KITTY BUNIN, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Bunin, Deceased ALICIA P. BURKE, individually as the Parent of Matthew J. Burke, Deceased JOHN J. BURKE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew J. Burke, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew J. Burke CHRIS BURKE, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Daniel Burke, Deceased JAMES M. BURKE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William F. Burke, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William F. Burke, Jr. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Wendy Burlingame, Deceased, Child of decedent Charles F. Burlingame, III DEBRA BURLINGAME, individually as the Sibling of Charles F. Burlingame, III, Deceased MARK W. BURLINGAME, individually as the Sibling of Charles F. Burlingame, III, Deceased 31

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 32 of 434

BRADLEY M. BURLINGAME, individually as the Sibling of Charles F. Burlingame, III, Deceased AGNES DELORES BURNS, individually as the Parent of Keith James Burns, Deceased COLLEEN COOPER, individually as the Sibling of Keith James Burns, Deceased LINDA ELLICOTT, individually as the Sibling of Keith James Burns, Deceased MAUREEN BURNS-DEWLAND, individually as the Sibling of Keith James Burns, Deceased DIANE MARIE SHEPHERD, individually as the Sibling of Keith James Burns, Deceased JENNIFER C. BURNS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith James Burns, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Keith James Burns REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Bernard J. Burns, Deceased, Parent of decedent Keith James Burns MICHAEL JOHN BURNS, individually as the Sibling of Keith James Burns, Deceased SANDRA BURNSIDE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John P. Burnside, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John P. Burnside ANNE BYRNE, individually as the Parent of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased JUDITH BYRNE, individually as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased CATHRINE M. TOLINO, individually as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased JOANNE FINN, individually as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased WILLIAM J. BYRNE, individually as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased THOMAS BYRNE, individually as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased GARETT C. BYRNE, individually as the 32

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 33 of 434

Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased FRANCIS X. BYRNE, individually as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased ROBERT G. BYRNE, JR., individually as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased ROBERT G. BYRNE, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick D. Byrne, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick D. Byrne VICTORIA CABEZAS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jesus Cabezas, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jesus Cabezas JULIO CACERES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lillian Caceres, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lillian Caceres and on behalf of minor child J.C. GRACE KNESKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Cafiero, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Cafiero VERONICA CAGGIANO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard M. Caggiano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard M. Caggiano DOE 105 individually as the Sibling of DOE 105, Deceased DOE 105 individually as the Sibling of DOE 105, Deceased DOE 105 individually as the Sibling of DOE 105, Deceased DOE 105 individually as the Sibling of DOE 105, Deceased DOE 105 individually as the Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 105, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 105 DOE 105 individually as the Sibling of DOE 105, Deceased 33

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 34 of 434

SHARON CAHILL CASTLE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John B. Cahill, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John B. Cahill and on behalf of minor children S.C. and B.C. EVELYN CAHILL, individually as the Parent of Michael Cahill, Deceased DENISE TROISE, individually as the Sibling of Michael Cahill, Deceased COLLEEN CAHILL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Cahill, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Cahill and on behalf of minor children F.C. and C.C. JAMES CAHILL, individually as the Parent of Michael Cahill, Deceased ROSEMARY CAIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George C. Cain, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of George C. Cain DOE 67, individually as spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 67, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 67 GLORIA ESPERANZA CALDERONGARCIA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jose Orlando Calderon-Olmedo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jose Orlando Calderon-Olmedo and on behalf of minor children V.C. and J.L.C. JOAN E. CALLAHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Liam Callahan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Liam Callahan and on behalf of minor child B.J.C. JAMES CALLAHAN, individually as the Child of Liam Callahan, Deceased BRIDGET GANNELLO individually as the Child of Liam Callahan, Deceased NORMA J. KELEHER, individually as the Parent of Suzanne M. Calley, Deceased 34

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 35 of 434

FRANK JENSEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Suzanne M. Calley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Suzanne M. Calley REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Linda Cammarata, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael F. Cammarata KIMBERLY CAMMARATA, individually as the Sibling of Michael F. Cammarata, Deceased JOSEPH CAMMARATA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael F. Cammarata, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael F. Cammarata JOSEPH CAMMARATA, JR., individually as the Sibling of Michael F. Cammarata, Deceased CYNTHIA J. CAMPBELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Otey Campbell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David Otey Campbell and on behalf of minor children C.R.C. and T.W.C. MALCOLM PHILLIP CAMPBELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Geoff Thomas Campbell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Geoff Thomas Campbell JEANNE M. MAURER, individually as the Parent of Jill Marie Campbell, Deceased LINDA MAURER, individually as the Sibling of Jill Marie Campbell, Deceased JOSEPH MAURER, individually as the Parent of Jill Marie Campbell, Deceased STEVEN T. CAMPBELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jill Marie Campbell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jill Marie Campbell MARGARET CANAVAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Canavan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Canavan KATHLEEN MCKEON, individually as the Sibling of Sean Canavan, Deceased 35

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 36 of 434

TERESA MCCAFFERY, individually as the Sibling of Sean Canavan, Deceased ROSEMARY CELINE TRAYNOR, individually as the Sibling of Sean Canavan, Deceased THOMAS CANAVAN, individually as the Parent of Sean Canavan, Deceased CIARAN CANAVAN, individually as the Sibling of Sean Canavan, Deceased HELEN JEFFREY CANGIALOSI, individually as the Parent of Stephen J. Cangialosi, Deceased KATHLEEN CANGIALOSI RUE, individually as the Sibling of Stephen J. Cangialosi, Deceased ELIZABETH ANNE DICKEY, individually as the Sibling of Stephen J. Cangialosi, Deceased KAREN D. CANGIALOSI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen J. Cangialosi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen J. Cangialosi and on behalf of minor children J.S.C., and P.T.C. THOMAS JEROME CANGIALOSI, individually as the Parent of Stephen J. Cangialosi, Deceased THOMAS J. CANGIALOSI, JR., individually as the Sibling of Stephen J. Cangialosi, Deceased TERESA DIFATO, individually as the Parent of Lisa Cannava, Deceased ANTONIO DIFATO, individually as the Parent of Lisa Cannava, Deceased RICHARD CANNAVA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lisa Cannava, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lisa Cannava CAROL CANNIZZARO, individually as the Parent of Brian Cannizzaro, Deceased SIMONE CANNIZZARO, individually as the Parent of Brian Cannizzaro, Deceased 36

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 37 of 434

CHARLES CANNIZZARO, individually as the Sibling of Brian Cannizzaro, Deceased CRAIG CANNIZZARO, individually as the Sibling of Brian Cannizzaro, Deceased ERIN RYAN, individually as the Fiancé of Michael R. Canty, Deceased KATHRYN F. CANTY, individually as the Parent of Michael R. Canty, Deceased CATHERINE DEASY, individually as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty, Deceased MARY K. CANTY, individually as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty, Deceased EDWARD J. CANTY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael R. Canty, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael R. Canty THOMAS P. CANTY, individually as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty, Deceased PETER M. CANTY, individually as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty, Deceased JAMES E. CANTY, individually as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty, Deceased TIMOTHY M. CANTY, individually as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty, Deceased JOHN W. CANTY, individually as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty, Deceased WILLIAM J. CANTY, individually as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty, Deceased PATRICIA CAPORICCI, individually as the Parent of Louis A. Caporicci, Deceased NICHOLAS CAPORICCI, individually as the Parent of Louis A. Caporicci, Deceased JOSEPH CAPORICCI, individually as the Sibling of Louis A. Caporicci, Deceased FRANK CAPORICCI, individually as the Sibling of Louis A. Caporicci, Deceased NICHOLAS F. CAPORICCI, JR., individually as the Sibling of Louis A. Caporicci, Deceased CLAUDIA CAPPELLO, individually as the 37

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 38 of 434

Parent of Jonathan Cappello, Deceased JAMES CAPPELLO, individually as the Sibling of Jonathan Cappello, Deceased ROBERT E. CAPPELLO, JR., individually as the Sibling of Jonathan Cappello, Deceased ROBERT CAPPELLO, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jonathan Cappello, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jonathan Cappello KATHLEEN CAPPERS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James C. Cappers, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James C. Cappers DOLORES CAPRONI, individually as the Parent of Richard M. Caproni, Deceased LISA CAPRONI, individually as the Sibling of Richard M. Caproni, Deceased RICHARD A. CAPRONI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard M. Caproni, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard M. Caproni CHRISTOPHER CAPRONI, individually as the Sibling of Richard M. Caproni, Deceased MICHAEL CAPRONI, individually as the Sibling of Richard M. Caproni, Deceased NICOLE T. CAREY, individually as the Child of Dennis M. Carey, Deceased JEAN CAREY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis M. Carey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis M. Carey DENNIS M. CAREY, JR., individually as the Child of Dennis M. Carey, Deceased PHYLLIS CARLO, individually as the Parent of Michael Scott Carlo, Deceased ROBERT D. CARLO, individually as the Parent of Michael Scott Carlo, Deceased ROBERT E. CARLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Scott Carlo, Deceased and on behalf of 38

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 39 of 434

all survivors of Michael Scott Carlo CRAIG D. CARLSON on behalf of minor children K.C., S.R.C., D.C., and J.D.C. CATHERINE MARY ROSS, individually as the Parent of Jeremy Mark Carrington, Deceased DOE 128, individually as the Sibling of DOE 128, Deceased SARAH JANE CARRINGTON, individually as the Sibling of Jeremy Mark Carrington, Deceased DOE 128, individually as the Parent of DOE 128, Deceased MARY E. JONES, individually as the Parent of Christoffer Mikael Carstanjen, Deceased MIKAEL CARSTANJEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christoffer Mikael Carstanjen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christoffer Mikael Carstanjen MICHELLE WRIGHT, individually as the Child of Sandra Wright Cartledge, Deceased STEPHEN CARTLEDGE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sandra Wright Cartledge, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sandra Wright Cartledge TANGELA WILKES, individually as the Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver, Deceased JANET CARVER, individually as the Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver, Deceased VERONICA CARVER, individually as the Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver, Deceased SYLVIA ANNETTE CARVER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sharon Ann Carver, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sharon Ann Carver REGINALD CARVER, individually as the Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver, Deceased ARTHUR CARVER, individually as the 39

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 40 of 434

Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver, Deceased DOE 06, individually as the spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 06, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 06 MAUREEN HUNT AND EILEEN ANN MOSCA as Co-Representatives of the Estate of Mary Ann Hunt, Deceased, Parent of decedent Kathleen Ann Hunt Casey MAUREEN HUNT, individually as the Sibling of Kathleen Ann Hunt Casey, Deceased EILEEN ANN MOSCA, individually as the Sibling of Kathleen Ann Hunt Casey, Deceased ANNE T. HEFFERNAN, individually as the Parent of Neilie Anne Heffernan Casey, Deceased MICHAEL W. CASEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Neilie Anne Heffernan Casey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Neilie Anne Heffernan Casey and on behalf of minor child R.E.C. MARGARET ANN CASHMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Joseph Cashman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Joseph Cashman TERESA A. LANZISERO, individually as the Fiancé of Thomas A. Casoria, Deceased DOE 30, individually as the Sibling of DOE 30, Deceased DOE 30 individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 30, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 30 DOE 30 as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 30, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 30 DOE 30 as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 30, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 30 LYNN M. CASTRIANNO, individually as the 40

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 41 of 434

Sibling of Leonard Castrianno, Deceased ALISON GAIL HENDERSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Sean Caton, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Sean Caton LINDA ALICIA CAVALIER, individually as the Parent of Judson Cavalier, Deceased ANDREW CAVALIER, individually as the Sibling of Judson Cavalier, Deceased BRADFORD CAVALIER, individually as the Sibling of Judson Cavalier, Deceased GERARD C. CAVALIER, JR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Judson Cavalier, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Judson Cavalier MARGARET M. CAWLEY, individually as the Parent of Michael Joseph Cawley, Deceased KRISTIN A. CAWLEY, individually as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Cawley, Deceased JOHN J. CAWLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Joseph Cawley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Joseph Cawley BRENDAN K. CAWLEY, individually as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Cawley, Deceased SUZAN CAYNE, individually as the Parent of Jason David Cayne, Deceased JORDAN CAYNE, individually as the Parent of Jason David Cayne, Deceased DOE 50 individually as the Sibling of DOE 50, Deceased DOE 50 individually as the Sibling of DOE 50, Deceased DOE 50, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 50, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 50 and on behalf of minor children DOE 50 and DOE 50 41

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 42 of 434

LAKSHMI CHALASANI, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Swarna Chalasani, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Swarna Chalasani SUJANA CHALASANI, individually as the Sibling of Swarna Chalasani, Deceased SANDHYA CHALASANI, individually as the Sibling of Swarna Chalasani, Deceased NAGESWARARAO CHALASANI, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Swarna Chalasani, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Swarna Chalasani VENKATESWANANGO CHALASANI, individually as the Sibling of Swarna Chalasani, Deceased MABLE CHALCOFF, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Chalcoff, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Chalcoff and on behalf of minor children B.C. and E.C. HAIM CHALOUH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eli Chalouh, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eli Chalouh JULIA CHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles L. Chan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Charles L. Chan JOHN OLAND CHAN, individually as the Parent of Charles L. Chan, Deceased CHRISTOPHER J. CHAN, individually as the Sibling of Charles L. Chan, Deceased MARK A. CHAN, individually as the Sibling of Charles L. Chan, Deceased MATTHEW P. CHAN, individually as the Sibling of Charles L. Chan, Deceased CRAIG A. CHAN, individually as the Sibling of Charles L. Chan, Deceased GRACE ELAINE ELLIS, individually as the Child of Rosa M. Chapa, Deceased 42

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 43 of 434

ELZA M. MCGOWAN, individually and as the Executor of the Estate of Rosa M. Chapa, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Rosa M. Chapa JULIE CHAPA FIELD, individually as the Child of Rosa M. Chapa, Deceased JULIE CHAPA FIELD, as the Executor of the Estate of Jose Javier Chapa, Deceased, Spouse of decedent Rosa M. Chapa DENISE REID CHAPA as the Representative of the Estate of John L. Chapa, Deceased, Child of decedent Rosa M. Chapa ROGER A. CHAPA, individually as the Child of Rosa M. Chapa, Deceased CHERYL A. DESMARAIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark L. Charette, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark L. Charette and on behalf of minor children A.C., J.C., and L.C. DENISE BURGER, individually as the Sibling of David Michael Charlebois, Deceased MARMILY CABRERA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Pedro Checo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Pedro Checo and on behalf of minor children J.C. and J.C. SHARON RITCHIE MULLIN, individually as the Parent of Stephen Patrick Cherry, Deceased MARY ELLEN CHERRY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen Patrick Cherry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Patrick Cherry and on behalf of minor children B.S.C. and C.P.C. DONALD R. CHERRY, individually as the Parent of Stephen Patrick Cherry, Deceased SHAWN R. CHERRY, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Patrick Cherry, Deceased ZENEIDA CHEVALIER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr., Deceased and on 43

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 44 of 434

behalf of all survivors of Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr. MAURICIO CHEVALIER, individually as the Sibling of Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr., Deceased NESTOR J. CHEVALIER, SR., individually as the Parent of Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr., Deceased DOE 55, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 55, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 55 DOE 55 individually as the Sibling of DOE 55, Deceased DOE 55 individually as the Sibling of DOE 55, Deceased VERNON F. CHEVALIER, JR., individually as the Parent of Swede Joseph Chevalier, Deceased LISA MARIA DREHER, individually as the Child of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, Deceased IRENE ARGUELLES, individually as the Sibling of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, Deceased EVELYN DIAZ, individually as the Sibling of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, Deceased NICHOLAS JAMES CHIARCHIARO, individually as the Child of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, Deceased NICHOLAS MARIO CHIARCHIARO, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro JOAN A. CHIOFALO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nicholas Paul Chiofalo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Nicholas Paul Chiofalo and on behalf of minor child N.P.C. EILEEN CHIPURA CELLA, individually as the Sibling of John G. Chipura, Deceased NANCY J. CHIPURA, individually as the 44

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 45 of 434

Sibling of John G. Chipura, Deceased SUSAN G. COHEN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of John G. Chipura, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John G. Chipura GERARD M. CHIPURA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of John G. Chipura, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John G. Chipura CATHERINE DEBLIECK, individually as the Sibling of Peter Chirchirillo, Deceased LIVIA CHIRCHIRILLO, individually as the Sibling of Peter Chirchirillo, Deceased CLARA CHIRCHIRILLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Chirchirillo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Chirchirillo SYDNEY CHIRLS, individually as the Child of Catherine Ellen Chirls, Deceased DYLAN CHIRLS, individually as the Child of Catherine Ellen Chirls, Deceased NICHOLAS CHIRLS, individually as the Child of Catherine Ellen Chirls, Deceased DAVID S. CHIRLS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Catherine Ellen Chirls, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Catherine Ellen Chirls YUREE CHO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kyung Hee Cho, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kyung Hee Cho MYUNG CHO, individually as the Sibling of Kyung Hee Cho, Deceased JIN HEE CHO, individually as the Sibling of Kyung Hee Cho, Deceased CHARLES CHRISTOPHE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kirsten L. Christophe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kirsten L. Christophe and on behalf of minor child G.D.C. 45

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 46 of 434

PUI LIN CHUNG, individually as the Parent of Wai C. Chung, Deceased WINNIE CHUNG, individually as the Sibling of Wai C. Chung, Deceased JULIE TAM, individually as the Sibling of Wai C. Chung, Deceased YING KWAN CHUNG, individually as the Parent of Wai C. Chung, Deceased STEVE CHUNG, individually as the Sibling of Wai C. Chung, Deceased RICHARD CHUNG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wai C. Chung, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Wai C. Chung THERESA A. CILENTE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frances Cilente, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frances Cilente LYNNE CILLO-CAPALDO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Elaine Cillo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Elaine Cillo NUNZI C. CILLO, individually as the Parent of Elaine Cillo, Deceased GARY CILLO, individually as the Sibling of Elaine Cillo, Deceased ALICIA LEGUILLOW, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nestor A. Cintron, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Nestor A. Cintron CHRISTOPHER J. CINTRON, individually as the Sibling of Nestor A. Cintron, Deceased FRED GONZALEZ, JR., individually as the Sibling of Nestor A. Cintron, Deceased JESSICA CIRRI, individually as the Child of Robert D. Cirri, Sr., Deceased EILEEN MARY CIRRI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert D. Cirri, Sr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert D. Cirri, Sr. and as Parent 46

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 47 of 434

of as parent of Bianca I. Jerez, Kara L. Jerez, and Francesca M. Jerez ROBERT CIRRI, JR., individually as the Child of Robert D. Cirri, Sr., Deceased TRACEY CLARK BOURKE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sarah Miller Clark, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sarah Miller Clark JOHN CLARKE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Clarke, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Clarke JAMES CLARKE, individually as the Sibling of Michael Clarke, Deceased MARGARET ALEXANDRA CLARKE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Suria R. E. Clarke, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Suria R. E. Clarke THOMAS J.W. CLARKE, individually as the Sibling of Suria R. E. Clarke, Deceased JOHN A.G. CLARKE, individually as the Sibling of Suria R. E. Clarke, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Betty B. Cleere, Deceased, Parent of decedent James Durward Cleere JUDY CLEERE GORDON, individually as the Sibling of James Durward Cleere, Deceased PATRICIA CLEERE WILGUS, individually as the Sibling of James Durward Cleere, Deceased JAN CLEERE PEAVY, individually as the Sibling of James Durward Cleere, Deceased JEAN LORRAINE CLEERE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Durward Cleere, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Durward Cleere A. SCOTT CLEERE, individually as the Child of James Durward Cleere, Deceased JEFFREY K. CLEERE, individually as the Child of James Durward Cleere, Deceased 47

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 48 of 434

LESLIE BROWN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey Alan Coale, Deceased, and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey Alan Coale, and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Coale, Deceased, Parent of Jeffrey Alan Coale, Deceased FRANCES M. COFFEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel M. Coffey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel M. Coffey KEVIN M. COFFEY, individually as the Child of Daniel M. Coffey, Deceased DANIEL D. COFFEY, individually as the Child of Daniel M. Coffey, Deceased FRANCES M. COFFEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jason M. Coffey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jason M. Coffey KEVIN M. COFFEY, individually as the Sibling of Jason M. Coffey, Deceased DANIEL D. COFFEY, individually as the Sibling of Jason M. Coffey, Deceased MARCIA ELAINE COHEN, individually as the Parent of Kevin Sanford Cohen, Deceased BARRY COHEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin Sanford Cohen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Sanford Cohen JEAN COLAIO STEINBACH, individually as the Sibling of Mark J. Colaio, Deceased JUNE COPPOLA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark J. Colaio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark J. Colaio VICTOR J. COLAIO, individually as the Parent of Mark J. Colaio, Deceased VICTOR J. COLAIO as Executor of the Estate of Mary C. Colaio, Deceased, Parent of decedent Mark J. Colaio DOE 120 individually as the Fiancé of DOE 48

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 49 of 434

120, Deceased JEAN COLAIO STEINBACH, individually as the Sibling of Stephen J. Colaio, Deceased VICTOR J. COLAIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen J. Colaio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen J. Colaio, and as Executor of the Estate of Mary C. Colaio, Deceased, Parent of decedent Mark J. Colaio KELLY COLASANTI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Colasanti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Colasanti REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Marie Colbert, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michel P. Colbert ELIZABETH J. TODD-COLBERT, individually as the Spouse of Michel P. Colbert, Deceased WILLIAM J. NIELSEN, as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Michel P. Colbert, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michel P. Colbert RAYMOND COLBERT, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michel P. Colbert, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michel P. Colbert JEAN COLEMAN, individually as the Parent of Keith Eugene Coleman, Deceased DOE 60 individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 60, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 60 and on behalf of minor children DOE 60 and DOE 60 NEIL KEITH COLEMAN, individually as the Parent of Keith Eugene Coleman, Deceased TODD DOUGLAS COLEMAN, individually as the Sibling of Keith Eugene Coleman, Deceased DOE 106 individually as the Fiancé of DOE 106, Deceased 49

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 50 of 434

JEAN COLEMAN, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Scott Thomas Coleman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Thomas Coleman NEIL KEITH COLEMAN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Scott Thomas Coleman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Thomas Coleman TODD DOUGLAS COLEMAN, individually as the Sibling of Scott Thomas Coleman, Deceased MARY E. COLL, individually as the Parent of Robert Joseph Coll, II, Deceased ELIZABETH C. WEPPNER, individually as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II, Deceased MARY JEAN TURANICA, individually as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II, Deceased MARGARET COLL, individually as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II, Deceased SUZANNE VALENTINO, individually as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II, Deceased EILEEN COLL, individually as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II, Deceased JENNIFER B. COLL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Joseph Coll, II, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Joseph Coll, II and on behalf of minor children M.B.C. and R.J.C. EDWARD A. COLL, III, individually as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Edward Coll, Jr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Anna E. Collins, Deceased, Parent of decedent John Michael Collins PATRICIA AMO, individually as the Sibling of John Michael Collins, Deceased EILEEN BYRNE, individually as the Sibling of John Michael Collins, Deceased 50

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 51 of 434

ANNE M. COLLINS, individually as the Sibling of John Michael Collins, Deceased MARTIN J. COLLINS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Michael Collins, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Michael Collins MARTIN COLLINS, individually as the Sibling of John Michael Collins, Deceased MARY ANNE COLLINS, individually as the Parent of Michael L. Collins, Deceased NANCY M. KASAK, individually as the Sibling of Michael L. Collins, Deceased LISSA L. COLLINS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael L. Collins, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael L. Collins RICHARD S. COLLINS, individually as the Sibling of Michael L. Collins, Deceased JAMES R. COLLINS, JR., individually as the Parent of Michael L. Collins, Deceased CARLOS R. COLON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Linda M. Colon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Linda M. Colon and on behalf of minor children C.N.C. and T.M.C. LAUREN HANSEN, individually as the Child of Ronald E. Comer, Deceased DOE 63, individually as the Child of DOE 63, Deceased JOHN CONLON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Clancy Conlon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Clancy Conlon KIMBERLY P. CONLON, individually as the Child of Susan Clancy Conlon, Deceased VERA CLANCY, individually as the Parent of Susan Clancy Conlon, Deceased KEVIN STEVEN CLANCY, individually as the Sibling of Susan Clancy Conlon, Deceased CORNELIUS PATRICK CLANCY, III, 51

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 52 of 434

individually as the Sibling of Susan Clancy Conlon, Deceased KEVIN M. BURNS, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francine BurnsChristensen, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Margaret Mary Conner CORRINE E. BOUNTY, individually as the Child of Margaret Mary Conner, Deceased PATRICIA CUOZZO, individually as the Sibling of Margaret Mary Conner, Deceased KEVIN F. BURNS, individually as the Sibling of Margaret Mary Conner, Deceased ROBERT BURNS, individually as the Sibling of Margaret Mary Conner, Deceased MICHAEL A. CONNER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Margaret Mary Conner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Margaret Mary Conner SHEILA CONNOLLY, individually as the Parent of Cynthia Marie Connolly, Deceased DONALD JACQUES POISSANT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cynthia Marie Connolly, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Cynthia Marie Connolly DAWN A. CONNOLLY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John E. Connolly, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John E. Connolly, Jr. and on behalf of minor children D.A.C., J.P.C., and P.L.C.C. KEVIN CONNOLLY, individually as the Sibling of John E. Connolly, Jr., Deceased JAYMEL E. CONNOR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James L. Connor, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James L. Connor SYLVIA L. CONNORS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin P. Connors, Deceased and on behalf of 52

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 53 of 434

all survivors of Kevin P. Connors WILLIAM K. CONNORS, individually as the Sibling of Kevin P. Connors, Deceased DOUGLAS CONNORS, individually as the Sibling of Kevin P. Connors, Deceased CHRISTOPHER CONNORS, individually as the Sibling of Kevin P. Connors, Deceased DANA DONOHUE, individually as the Spouse of Dennis Cook, Deceased and on behalf of minor children S.C.C. and L.C. MARY CHRISTINE COOMBS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey W. Coombs, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey W. Coombs and on behalf of minor children J.C., M.C., and M.C. ANGELA RAPOPORT, individually as the Child of Gerard J. Coppola, Deceased CYNTHIA LOUISA COPPOLA, individually as the Sibling of Gerard J. Coppola, Deceased PUI YEE (ALICE) COPPOLA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gerard J. Coppola, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gerard J. Coppola and on behalf of minor child A.J.C. GEORGE JOSEPH COPPOLA, JR., individually as the Sibling of Gerard J. Coppola, Deceased GEORGE J. COPPOLA, JR. as the Executor of the Estate of George J. Coppola, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Gerard J. Coppola DIANN CORCORAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John J. Corcoran, III, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John J. Corcoran, III and on behalf of minor child J.J.C. CAROLINE CORDICE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert J. Cordice, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert J. Cordice MARIE CORRIGAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James 53

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 54 of 434

J. Corrigan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James J. Corrigan J. BRENDAN CORRIGAN, individually as the Child of James J. Corrigan, Deceased SEAN M. CORRIGAN, individually as the Child of James J. Corrigan, Deceased DOE 21, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 21, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 21 CHARLES P. COSTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Delores M. Costa, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Delores M. Costa NANCY E. COSTELLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael S. Costello, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael S. Costello JAMES P. COSTELLO, individually as the Parent of Michael S. Costello, Deceased TIMOTHY J. COSTELLO, individually as the Sibling of Michael S. Costello, Deceased MICHELLE COTTOM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Asia SiVon Cottom, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Asia SiVon Cottom CLIFTON COTTOM, individually as the Parent of Asia SiVon Cottom, Deceased SINEAD COUGHLAN, individually as the Child of Martin Coughlan, Deceased DENISE COUGHLAN, individually as the Child of Martin Coughlan, Deceased AILISH COUGHLAN, individually as the Child of Martin Coughlan, Deceased ORLA BOWIE, individually as the Child of Martin Coughlan, Deceased CATHERINE COUGHLAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Coughlan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Coughlan 54

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 55 of 434

MAURA A. COUGHLIN, individually as the Spouse of Timothy J. Coughlin, Deceased and on behalf of minor children R.C., S.C., and R.C. PRINCINA COX, individually as the Parent of Andre Cox, Deceased GLENICE COX-ROACH, individually as the Sibling of Andre Cox, Deceased WENDELL COX, individually as the Sibling of Andre Cox, Deceased NIGEL COX, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andre Cox, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Andre Cox ANN DOUGLAS, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Fred John Cox, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Fred John Cox FREDERICK OSTERHOUDT COX, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Fred John Cox, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Fred John Cox MARILYN ELIZABETH CRAMER, individually as the Parent of Christopher Seton Cramer, Deceased SUSAN LYNNE KINNEY, individually as the Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Seton Cramer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Seton Cramer MARILYN ELIZABETH CRAMER as Representative of the Estate of Walter S. Cramer, Deceased, Parent of decedent Christopher Seton Cramer MARC SETON CRAMER, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Seton Cramer, Deceased KEITH DOUGLAS CRAMER, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Seton Cramer, Deceased WALTER HENRY CRAMER, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Seton Cramer, 55

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 56 of 434

Deceased DOE 33, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 33, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 33, and on behalf of minor children DOE 33 and DOE 33 MARY ELIABETH CREGAN, individually as the Parent of Joanne Mary Cregan, Deceased GRACE ELIZABETH CREGAN, individually as the Sibling of Joanne Mary Cregan, Deceased RONALD BERNARD CREGAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joanne Mary Cregan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joanne Mary Cregan RONALD PATRICK CREGAN, individually as the Sibling of Joanne Mary Cregan, Deceased MARIA CRIFASI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lucy Crifasi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lucy Crifasi FRANCESCO CRIFASI, individually as the Sibling of Lucy Crifasi, Deceased RAFFAELLA RITA CRISCI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John A. Crisci, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John A. Crisci and on behalf of minor child J.C. and M.E.C. JOHN CRISCI, individually as the Child of John A. Crisci, Deceased KEVIN F. KITTLE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Helen P. Crossin-Kittle, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Helen P. Crossin-Kittle DOE 14, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 14, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 14, and on behalf of minor children DOE 14, DOE 14, and DOE 14 PATRICIA M. CROTTY, individually as the 56

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 57 of 434

Parent of Thomas G. Crotty, Deceased JOANNE C. CROTTY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas G. Crotty, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas G. Crotty THOMAS M. CROTTY, individually as the Parent of Thomas G. Crotty, Deceased JOHN CROTTY, individually as the Sibling of Thomas G. Crotty, Deceased KENNETH CROTTY, individually as the Sibling of Thomas G. Crotty, Deceased JAMES G. CROTTY, individually as the Sibling of Thomas G. Crotty, Deceased MARYANN CROWE, individually as the Sibling of John R. Crowe, Deceased MARGARET RITA ZOCH, individually as the Sibling of John R. Crowe, Deceased PAMELA M. CROWE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John R. Crowe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John R. Crowe JEFFREY CROWE, individually as the Child of John R. Crowe, Deceased BRIAN CROWE, individually as the Child of John R. Crowe, Deceased ALISON REMY CROWTHER, individually as the Parent of Welles Remy Crowther, Deceased PAIGE H. CROWTHER, individually as the Sibling of Welles Remy Crowther, Deceased HONOR ELIZABETH CROWTHER, individually as the Sibling of Welles Remy Crowther, Deceased JEFFERSON H. CROWTHER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Welles Remy Crowther, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Welles Remy Crowther DOROTHY PRISCILLA CUBAS, individually as the Parent of Kenneth J. Cubas, Deceased

57

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 58 of 434

REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Lawrence Cubas, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Kenneth J. Cubas ALFONSO CUBAS, JR., individually as the Sibling of Kenneth J. Cubas, Deceased MARIA CUCCINELLO, individually as the Child of Thelma Cuccinello, Deceased LAURIE FOLCIK, individually as the Child of Thelma Cuccinello, Deceased CHERYL O'BRIEN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Thelma Cuccinello, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thelma Cuccinello CHERYL O'BRIEN as the Representative of the Estate of Albert C. Cuccinello, Deceased, Spouse of decedent Thelma Cuccinello GEORGIA CUDINA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard J. Cudina, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard J. Cudina WILLIAM CUDINA, individually as the Sibling of Richard J. Cudina, Deceased CHRISTOPHER C. CUDINA, individually as the Sibling of Richard J. Cudina, Deceased MARCUS N. CUDINA, individually as the Sibling of Richard J. Cudina, Deceased DOE 129, individually as the Parent of DOE 129, Deceased DOE 129, individually as the Sibling of DOE 129, Deceased DOE 129, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 129, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 129 DOE 129, individually as the Sibling of DOE 129, Deceased DOE 129, individually as the Sibling of DOE 129, Deceased BLAISE JOUDZEVICH, individually as the Sibling of Joan Mcconnell Cullinan, Deceased 58

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 59 of 434

THOMAS CULLINAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joan Mcconnell Cullinan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joan Mcconnell Cullinan MITCHUM KELVIN CUMMINGS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joyce Cummings, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joyce Cummings DEBORAH L. BARRETT, individually as the Fiancé of Brian T. Cummins, Deceased MAUREEN CUMMINS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian T. Cummins, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brian T. Cummins LAURENCE CUNNINGHAM, individually as the Parent of Michael J. Cunningham, Deceased MARY ANN CURATOLO, individually as the Parent of Robert Curatolo, Deceased CAROLYN PICCIRILLO, individually as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo, Deceased KATHLEEN CURATOLO, individually as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo, Deceased CHRISTINE FRISCIA, individually as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo, Deceased DENA NELSON, individually as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo, Deceased CHRISTINE CURATOLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Curatolo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Curatolo JOHN CURATOLO, individually as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo, Deceased WILLIAM CURATOLO, individually as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo, Deceased ANTHONY CURATOLO, JR., individually as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo, Deceased ANTHONY CURATOLO, SR., individually as the Parent of Robert Curatolo, Deceased 59

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 60 of 434

REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Alice Curia, Deceased, Parent of decedent Laurence Curia ALICE SCIUSCO, individually as the Sibling of Laurence Curia, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Joseph Curia, Deceased, Parent of decedent Laurence Curia DANIEL CURIA, individually as the Sibling of Laurence Curia, Deceased DOE 93, individually as the Sibling of DOE 93, Deceased DOE 93, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 93, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 93 and on behalf of minor children DOE 93 and DOE 93 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Louis Curioli, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Paul Dario Curioli LAWRENCE CURIOLI, individually as the Sibling of Paul Dario Curioli, Deceased DOROTHY LAVERNE GREEN, individually as the Parent of Beverly L. Curry, Deceased DEBORAH MARSHELL CREW-JOHNSON, individually as the Sibling of Beverly L. Curry, Deceased SHEILA ANNETTE LOLLIS, individually as the Sibling of Beverly L. Curry, Deceased GENEE MARIE CHASE, individually as the Sibling of Beverly L. Curry, Deceased FREDERICK E. CURRY, III, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Beverly L. Curry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Beverly L. Curry SUSANN BRADY, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gavin Cushny, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gavin Cushny RUPERT EALES-WHITE, individually as the 60

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 61 of 434

Sibling of Gavin Cushny, Deceased SELENA DACK FORSYTH, individually as the Parent of Caleb Arron Dack, Deceased DOE 84, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 84, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 84 and on behalf of minor children DOE 84 and DOE 84 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Sandra Dahl, Deceased, Spouse of decedent Jason M. Dahl SHERYL CLARK STOLL, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jason M. Dahl, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jason M. Dahl DOE 88, individually as the Sibling of DOE 88, Deceased RAQUEL D'AMADEO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent Gerard D'Amadeo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Gerard D'Amadeo and on behalf of minor child F.D., J.D., M.D., and V.D. JENNIFER JEANNE DAMASKINOS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Damaskinos, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Damaskinos and on behalf of minor child M.D. and J.D. CATHERINE ELIZABETH DAMIANI, individually as the Parent of Jeannine DamianiJones, Deceased ROBERT DAMIANI, individually as the Parent of Jeannine Damiani-Jones, Deceased BRIAN ROBERT DAMIANI, individually as the Sibling of Jeannine Damiani-Jones, Deceased SHAWN M. JONES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeannine Damiani-Jones, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeannine Damiani61

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 62 of 434

Jones BARBARA E. DAMOTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Manuel DaMota, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Manuel DaMota and on behalf of minor child M.J.D. and C.D. MARY-ANNE DWYER DANAHY, individually as the Parent of Patrick William Danahy, Deceased MARYANNE DANAHY, individually as the Sibling of Patrick William Danahy, Deceased KATHLEEN A. DANAHY SAMUELSON, individually as the Sibling of Patrick William Danahy, Deceased DENISE DANAHY DUFFY, individually as the Sibling of Patrick William Danahy, Deceased JOHN M. DANAHY, individually as the Sibling of Patrick William Danahy, Deceased MICHAEL FRANCIS DANAHY, individually as the Sibling of Patrick William Danahy, Deceased FRANCIS L. DANAHY, JR., individually as the Parent of Patrick William Danahy, Deceased LOUISA D'ANTONIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary D'Antonio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mary D'Antonio and on behalf of minor child E.G.D. LINDA D'ATRI-POTENZA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward A. D'Atri, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward A. D'Atri and on behalf of minor child A.J.D. and M.E.D. NANCY DARIA CIMEI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael D'Auria, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael D'Auria CHRISTINE RINALDI, individually as the Sibling of Michael D'Auria, Deceased 62

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 63 of 434

CARMEN D'AURIA, individually as the Parent of Michael D'Auria, Deceased ELLEN R. DAVIDSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael A. Davidson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael A. Davidson JEFFREY S. DAVIDSON, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Davidson, Deceased AMY WATERS DAVIDSON, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Davidson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Davidson and on behalf of minor children C.D. and P.D. CARLA DIMAGGIO, individually as the Parent of Scott Davidson, Deceased STEPHEN DAVIDSON, individually as the Parent of Scott Davidson, Deceased MICHAEL DAVIDSON, individually as the Sibling of Scott Davidson, Deceased ZENOVIA M. CUYLER, individually as the Child of Ada M. Davis, Deceased YOLANDA L. DAVIS, individually as the Child of Ada M. Davis, Deceased ROSSLYN D. DAVIS, individually as the Child of Ada M. Davis, Deceased CHRISTINE FLORENCE PATTERSON, individually as the Sibling of Ada M. Davis, Deceased CLEMENTENE SUE DAVISWESTMORELAND, individually as the Sibling of Ada M. Davis, Deceased GEORGIA DARLENE DAVIS-LEGGETT, individually as the Sibling of Ada M. Davis, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Norris Davis, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Ada M. Davis REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Phillip Davis, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Ada M. Davis 63

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 64 of 434

REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of William M. Davis, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Ada M. Davis NOLTON CHRISTOPHER DAVIS, individually as the Child of Ada M. Davis, Deceased SIMONE MITCHELL on behalf of minor child J.M.D. DAPHNE RACHELL DAVIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Clinton Davis, Sr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Clinton Davis, Sr. and on behalf of minor children P.D.D. and C.D. HELEN KATRINA DAWSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony Richard Dawson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony Richard Dawson BRIGITTE DAY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Day, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Day JOAQUIM T. DE ARAUJO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dorothy Alma de Araujo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dorothy Alma de Araujo REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Aurora de la Torre, Deceased, Parent of decedent Azucena de la Torre GLADYS DE LA TORRE, individually as the Sibling of Azucena de la Torre, Deceased DIANA DE LA TORRE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Azucena de la Torre, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Azucena de la Torre DOE 43, individually as the Spouse of DOE 43, Deceased PAUL DEANGELIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert J. DeAngelis, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all 64

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 65 of 434

survivors of Robert J. DeAngelis, Jr. CHRISTINE CAPUTO, individually as the Child of Thomas P. DeAngelis, Deceased THOMAS JAMES DEANGELIS, individually as the Child of Thomas P. DeAngelis, Deceased MARIA LUISA POCASANGRE, individually as the Parent of Ana Gloria deBarrera, Deceased IVONNE POCASANGRE LOPEZ, individually as the Sibling of Ana Gloria deBarrera, Deceased ALFREDO POCASANGRE, individually as the Parent of Ana Gloria deBarrera, Deceased OMAR WILFREDO POCASANGRE, individually as the Sibling of Ana Gloria deBarrera, Deceased PEDRO E. POCASANGRE, individually as the Sibling of Ana Gloria deBarrera, Deceased JACQUES DAN-EL DEBEUNEURE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of James D. Debeuneure, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James D. Debeuneure GEORGE DEBIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anna M. DeBin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anna M. DeBin and on behalf of minor child T.D. DOE 32 individually as the Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 32, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 32 DOE 32 individually as the Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 32, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 32 VIRGINIA M. DECOLA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul DeCola, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul DeCola VITORA DEDVUKAJ, individually as the 65

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 66 of 434

Parent of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased LINDA DEDVUKAJ, individually as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased LISABETA DEDVUKAJ, individually as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased DRANA VUKAJ, individually as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased JOANNA DEDVUKAJ, individually as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased ELIZABETA DEDVUKAJ, individually as the Spouse of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased MARASH DEDVUKAJ, individually as the Parent of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased KOLA DEDVUKAJ, individually as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased MICHAEL DEDVUKAJ, individually as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased NIK DEDVUKAJ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Simon Marash Dedvukaj, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Simon Marash Dedvukaj ROSE ANN DEFAZIO, individually as the Parent of Jason DeFazio, Deceased MICHELE DEFAZIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jason DeFazio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jason DeFazio REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Michael DeFazio, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Jason DeFazio JAMES CHRISTOPHER DEFAZIO, individually as the Parent of Jason DeFazio, Deceased LUIS PEREZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jennifer DeJesus, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer DeJesus GRICEL G. ZAYAS-MOYER, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Manuel Del Valle, Jr., Deceased and on behalf 66

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 67 of 434

of all survivors of Manuel Del Valle, Jr. MANUEL DEL VALLE, SR., individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Manuel Del Valle, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Manuel Del Valle, Jr. LILLIAN RITA DELEO, individually as the Parent of Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr., Deceased SALLY DELEO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr. and on behalf of minor children K.L.D. and V.J.D. MICHAEL DELEO, individually as the Sibling of Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr., Deceased KRISTEN DEMEO, individually as the Child of Martin N. DeMeo, Deceased JOAN DEMEO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin N. DeMeo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Martin N. DeMeo and on behalf of minor child N.D. ROSEMARY DEMING-PHALON, individually as the Sibling of Francis Deming, Deceased and on behalf of minor child C.D. BRIAN D. DEMING, individually as the Child of Francis Deming, Deceased CRAIG D. DEMING, individually as the Child of Francis Deming, Deceased CHRISTOPHER DEMING, individually as the Child of Francis Deming, Deceased ROBERT J. DEMING, individually as the Sibling of Francis Deming, Deceased PATRICIA BINGLEY, individually as the Parent of Kevin Dennis, Deceased MICHELE CAVIASCO, individually as the Sibling of Jean C. Depalma, Deceased DOE 114, individually as the Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 114, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 114 67

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 68 of 434

ANGELINA MARY TRIMBOLI, individually as the Parent of Edward DeSimone, III, Deceased MICHELE YOUNG, individually as the Sibling of Edward DeSimone, III, Deceased JOANNE DESIMONE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward DeSimone, III, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward DeSimone, III and on behalf of minor children S.D. and E.D. MARY ELLEN DESIMONE as Representative of the Estate of Edward DeSimone, Jr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Edward DeSimone, III GRACE LIEBERMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Jude D'Esposito, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Jude D'Esposito and on behalf of minor child A.M.D. RALPH D'ESPOSITO, individually as the Parent of Michael Jude D'Esposito, Deceased RUTH DE VERE, as Executor of the Estate of Margaret H. Owen, Deceased, Parent of decedent Melanie Louise de Vere DOE 130, individually as the Sibling of DOE 130, Deceased DAVID DE VERE, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Melanie Louise de Vere, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Melanie Louise de Vere FREDERICK DE VERE, individually as the Sibling of Melanie Louise de Vere, Deceased WILLIAM G. DEWAN, individually as the Sibling of Gerard P. Dewan, Deceased MARIE CIRMIA, individually as the Sibling of Debra Ann Di Martino, Deceased CECILIA UCEDO DE RUIZ DIAZ, individually as the Parent of Obdulio Ruiz Diaz, Deceased PETRONILO RUIZ DIAZ CANTERO, 68

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 69 of 434

individually as the Parent of Obdulio Ruiz Diaz, Deceased ARCELIA DIAZ, individually as the Parent of Judith Berquis Diaz-Sierra, Deceased LASHAWN DICKENS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rodney Alonzo Dickens, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Rodney Alonzo Dickens ERIN R. DICKINSON, individually as the Child of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, Deceased HELENE JANICE DICKINSON, individually as the Parent of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, Deceased DEIRDRE DICKINSON SULLIVAN, individually as the Sibling of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, Deceased LINDA M. DICKINSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson and on behalf of minor child P.J.D. JOSEPH LAWRENCE DICKINSON, individually as the Sibling of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, Deceased LOISANNE DIEHL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael D. Diehl, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael D. Diehl and on behalf of minor children J.D. and J.D. TERESA DIFATO, individually as the Parent of John DiFato, Deceased SUSAN DIFATO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John DiFato, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John DiFato and on behalf of minor children A.D., N.D., and J.D. ANTONIO DIFATO, individually as the Parent of John DiFato, Deceased PATRICIA A. DIFAZIO, individually and as 69

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 70 of 434

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent Francis DiFazio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Francis DiFazio and on behalf of minor children D.M.D., G.M.D., and J.V.D. CAROLE DIFRANCO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carl A. DiFranco, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Carl A. DiFranco NANCY DI FRANCO LEVY, individually as the Sibling of Carl A. DiFranco, Deceased CAROLE DIFRANCO as the Representative of the Estate of Carmelo A. DiFranco, Deceased, Parent of decedent Carl A. DiFranco EDRICK DILLARD, individually as the Child of Eddie Dillard, Deceased ANGELA M. GUTERMUTH, individually as the Fiancé of Christopher More Dincuff, Deceased GEORGIA ROSE DIPASQUALE, individually as the Child of George DiPasquale, Deceased MELISSA M. DIPASQUALE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George DiPasquale, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of George DiPasquale and on behalf of minor child G.R.D. MARJORIE A. DITULLIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald A. DiTullio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Donald A. DiTullio JOANNA M. COOK, individually as the Sibling of Donald A. DiTullio, Deceased JANICE L. FLEMING, individually as the Sibling of Donald A. DiTullio, Deceased EVELENA DOCTOR, individually as the Parent of Johnnie Doctor, Jr., Deceased JOANN DOCTOR, individually as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr., Deceased EVON ARNOLD, individually as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr., Deceased 70

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 71 of 434

ELAINE DOCTOR MCGRAW, individually as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr., Deceased ANDREA GALE DOCTOR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Johnnie Doctor, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Johnnie Doctor, Jr. WILLIAM LAWRENCE DOCTOR, individually as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr., Deceased SHELDON DEWAYNE DOCTOR, individually as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr., Deceased LISA T. DOLAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert E. Dolan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert E. Dolan and on behalf of minor children R.L.D. and R.E.D. HELEN DOLLARD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Neil M. Dollard, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Neil M. Dollard DIANA E. DOLLARD, individually as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard, Deceased MARY K. DOLLARD, individually as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard, Deceased MEGAN FAJARDO, individually as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard, Deceased ANNE ZUCCHI, individually as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard, Deceased ROBERT M. DOLLARD, individually as the Parent of Neil M. Dollard, Deceased PETER DOLLARD, individually as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard, Deceased MICHAEL J. DOLLARD, individually as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard, Deceased PUBLIC ADMINISTRATOR OF SUFFOLK COUNTY, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benilda Domingo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Benilda Domingo and on behalf of minor children Y.D., D.D. and L.A.D. 71

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 72 of 434

FRANK DOMINGUEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jerome Dominguez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jerome Dominguez CECILIA E. DONNELLY, individually as the Parent of Kevin W. Donnelly, Deceased MARY CAY MARTIN, individually as the Sibling of Kevin W. Donnelly, Deceased MARY COUGHLIN, individually as the Spouse of Kevin W. Donnelly, Deceased BRIAN J. DONNELLY, individually as the Sibling of Kevin W. Donnelly, Deceased EDWARD L. DONNELLY, JR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin W. Donnelly, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin W. Donnelly EDWARD L. DONNELLY, SR., individually as the Parent of Kevin W. Donnelly, Deceased MARION DONOVAN PUIIA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jacqueline Donovan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jacqueline Donovan JEANINE WIESE, individually as the Sibling of Jacqueline Donovan, Deceased PATRICE KELLEHER, individually as the Sibling of Jacqueline Donovan, Deceased JAMES T. DONOVAN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jacqueline Donovan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jacqueline Donovan MICHAEL DONOVAN, individually as the Sibling of Jacqueline Donovan, Deceased JAMES DONOVAN, JR., individually as the Sibling of Jacqueline Donovan, Deceased ELAINE MARIE DONOVAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Howard Donovan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Howard Donovan and on behalf of minor children K.E.D., B.D., and M.L.D. 72

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 73 of 434

ANN MARIE DORF, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Scott Dorf, Deceased LINDA SAMMUT, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Scott Dorf, Deceased MICHELLE DORF, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Stephen Scott Dorf, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Scott Dorf REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Morris Dorf, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stephen Scott Dorf ROBERT DORF, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Scott Dorf, Deceased JOSEPH DORF, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Scott Dorf, Deceased KERRI ANN DOWD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Francis Dowd, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Francis Dowd DOE 78, individually as the Sibling of DOE 78, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Adelaide Maureen Driscoll, Deceased, Spouse of decedent Patrick Joseph Driscoll PAMELA MARIE GOULD, individually and as the Executor of the Estate of Patrick Joseph Driscoll, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick Joseph Driscoll STEPHEN MICHAEL DRISCOLL, individually as the Child of Patrick Joseph Driscoll, Deceased CHRISTOPHER JOHN DRISCOLL, individually as the Child of Patrick Joseph Driscoll, Deceased PATRICK THOMAS DRISCOLL, individually as the Child of Patrick Joseph Driscoll, Deceased JOHN M. DRISCOLL, individually as the Sibling of Patrick Joseph Driscoll, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 97, 73

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 74 of 434

Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 97 DOE 97, individually as the Sibling of DOE 97, Deceased DOE 97, individually as the Sibling of DOE 97, Deceased DOE 97, individually as the Sibling of DOE 97, Deceased DOE 97, individually as the Sibling of DOE 97, Deceased ANN P. DRISCOLL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen Patrick Driscoll, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Patrick Driscoll and on behalf of minor child B.D. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 97, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 97 DOE 97, individually as the Sibling of DOE 97, Deceased ROBERT M. DUFFY, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Gerard J. Duffy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gerard J. Duffy THOMAS DUFFY, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Gerard J. Duffy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gerard J. Duffy DOE 121, individually as the Child of DOE 121, Deceased DOE 121, individually as the Child of DOE 121, Deceased DOE 86, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 86, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 86, and on behalf of minor child DOE 86 DIANA J. SAYEGH, individually as the Parent of Jackie Sayegh Duggan, Deceased MITCHELL DUGGAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jackie Sayegh Duggan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jackie Sayegh Duggan 74

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 75 of 434

REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of George A. Sayegh, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Jackie Sayegh Duggan JOEL GARY SHAPIRO, individually and as the Executor; Personal Representative of the Estate of Sareve Dukat, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sareve Dukat LAURA D. DUNSTAN, individually as the Child of Richard A. Dunstan, Deceased JANET A. DUNSTAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard A. Dunstan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard A. Dunstan LAURA EATON, individually as the Parent of Robert Douglas Eaton, Deceased BARBARA J. STEPHENSON, individually as the Sibling of Robert Douglas Eaton, Deceased ANGELA RIDGE, individually as the Sibling of Robert Douglas Eaton, Deceased DOUGLAS EATON, individually as the Parent of Robert Douglas Eaton, Deceased JOHANNA L. KMETZ, individually as the Sibling of Margaret R. Echtermann, Deceased CHERYL OLIVIERI, individually as the Fiancé of Paul R. Eckna, Deceased AUDREY ECONOMOS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Constantine Economos, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Constantine Economos FRANK MICHAEL EDWARDS, individually as the Child of Barbara Gollan Edwards, Deceased SCOTT C. EDWARDS, individually as the Child of Barbara Gollan Edwards, Deceased DOUGLAS C. EDWARDS, individually as the Child of Barbara Gollan Edwards, Deceased ELLEN R. JUDD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Egan, Deceased and on behalf of all 75

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 76 of 434

survivors of Christine Egan DENISE EGAN, individually as the Sibling of Christine Egan, Deceased PATRICIA EGAN, individually as the Parent of Martin Egan, Jr., Deceased COLLEEN D'AMATO, individually as the Sibling of Martin Egan, Jr., Deceased DIANE EGAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Egan, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Egan, Jr. MARK EGAN, individually as the Sibling of Martin Egan, Jr., Deceased MICHAEL EGAN, individually as the Sibling of Martin Egan, Jr., Deceased MARTIN EGAN, SR., individually as the Parent of Martin Egan, Jr., Deceased ANNA MARIA EGAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Egan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Egan JONATHAN J. EGAN, individually as the Child of Michael Egan, Deceased MATTHEW B. EGAN, individually as the Child of Michael Egan, Deceased PAULA SHAPIRO, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Eric Adam Eisenberg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Adam Eisenberg JOSEPHINE ELDER, individually as the Parent of Daphne Elder, Deceased JIMMY PAUL ELDER, individually as the Parent of Daphne Elder, Deceased MARY ELFERIS, individually as the Parent of Michael J. Elferis, Deceased NANCY CHALMERS, individually as the Sibling of Michael J. Elferis, Deceased ELIZABETH WILD, individually as the Sibling of Michael J. Elferis, Deceased 76

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 77 of 434

ROBERT E. ELFERIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael J. Elferis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael J. Elferis JOSEPH ELFERIS, individually as the Sibling of Michael J. Elferis, Deceased ROBERT G. ELFERIS, individually as the Sibling of Michael J. Elferis, Deceased IRINIE GUIGUIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Albert W. Elmarry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Albert W. Elmarry and on behalf of minor child L.M.E. DOE 68, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 68, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 68 ROGELIO R. ESCARCEGA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sarah Ali Escarcega, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sarah Ali Escarcega MARLYSE BOSLEY, individually as the Sibling of Jose Espinal, Deceased MICHAEL ESPOSITO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bridget Ann Esposito, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Bridget Ann Esposito DOROTHY HELEN ESPOSITO, individually as the Parent of Francis Esposito, Deceased CATHERINE ESPOSITO, individually as the Sibling of Francis Esposito, Deceased DAWN MARIE PICCIANO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francis Esposito, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Francis Esposito MICHAEL A. ESPOSITO, individually as the Parent of Francis Esposito, Deceased DOMINICK ESPOSITO, individually as the Sibling of Francis Esposito, Deceased RICHARD ESPOSITO, individually as the Sibling of Francis Esposito, Deceased 77

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 78 of 434

VINCENT ESPOSITO, individually as the Sibling of Francis Esposito, Deceased ROSE ESPOSITO, individually as the Parent of Michael Esposito, Deceased SALVATORE ESPOSITO, individually as the Sibling of Michael Esposito, Deceased SIMONE ESPOSITO, individually as the Sibling of Michael Esposito, Deceased FRANK ESPOSITO, individually as the Sibling of Michael Esposito, Deceased JOSEPH ESPOSITO, individually as the Sibling of Michael Esposito, Deceased SIMONE ESPOSITO, SR., individually as the Parent of Michael Esposito, Deceased SUSAN ESPOSITO, individually as the Child of William J. Esposito, Deceased STEPHANIE ESPOSITO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William J. Esposito, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William J. Esposito CRAIG ESPOSITO, individually as the Child of William J. Esposito, Deceased MARIA LUISA BEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ruben Esquilin, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ruben Esquilin, Jr. PRISCILLA ESQUILIN, individually as the Sibling of Ruben Esquilin, Jr., Deceased JEAN ETZOLD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Barbara Etzold, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara Etzold DAVID KONIGSBERG, individually as the Fiancé of Barbara Etzold, Deceased CORRINE J. EVANS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Eric Brian Evans, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Brian Evans REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Charles R. Evans, Deceased, Parent of decedent Eric 78

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 79 of 434

Brian Evans CATHERINE EWART, individually as the Parent of Meredith Emily June Ewart, Deceased JENNIFER EWART, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Meredith Emily June Ewart, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Meredith Emily June Ewart ROBERT G. EWART, individually as the Parent of Meredith Emily June Ewart, Deceased DIANE DOROTHY FAIRBEN, individually as the Parent of Keith George Fairben, Deceased KENNETH BRUCE FAIRBEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith George Fairben, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Keith George Fairben PATRICIA A. FALLON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jamie Lynn Fallon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jamie Lynn Fallon RUTH M. FANGMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert John Fangman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert John Fangman CAROLE L. RICCI, individually as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman, Deceased DEBORAH A. FANGMAN, individually as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman, Deceased THERESA M. FRAKES, individually as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman, Deceased STEPHEN G. FANGMAN, individually as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman, Deceased PAUL M. FANGMAN, individually as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman, Deceased MICHAEL W. FANGMAN, individually as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman, Deceased BEVERLY FARAGHER, individually as the Parent of Kathleen Faragher, Deceased 79

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 80 of 434

MARY F. WATERMAN, individually as the Sibling of Kathleen Faragher, Deceased BETH ANN FARAGHER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kathleen Faragher, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kathleen Faragher WILLIAM E. FARAGHER, individually as the Parent of Kathleen Faragher, Deceased JAMES A. FARAGHER, individually as the Sibling of Kathleen Faragher, Deceased WILLIAM FARAGHER, individually as the Sibling of Kathleen Faragher, Deceased MARIE A. FARRELL, individually as the Parent of John G. Farrell, Deceased JAMES F. FARRELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John G. Farrell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John G. Farrell HELENORA M. FARRELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Terrence Patrick Farrell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Terrence Patrick Farrell REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Theresa Farrelly, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joseph Farrelly STACEY FARRELLY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Farrelly, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Farrelly RYAN FARRELLY, individually as the Child of Joseph Farrelly, Deceased DEVIN FARRELLY, individually as the Child of Joseph Farrelly, Deceased JOSEPH FARRELLY, individually as the Parent of Joseph Farrelly, Deceased PATRICK M. FARRELLY, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Farrelly, Deceased DENNIS FARRELLY, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Farrelly, Deceased 80

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 81 of 434

MICHAEL FARRELLY, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Farrelly, Deceased LORNA CLELLAND MORRIS, individually as the Parent of Wendy Ruth Faulkner, Deceased JEANETTE MORRIS-FRIEDRICH, individually as the Sibling of Wendy Ruth Faulkner, Deceased GAY L. MORRIS, individually as the Sibling of Wendy Ruth Faulkner, Deceased ROSE JEAN NIELSEN, individually as the Parent of Shannon Marie Fava, Deceased FRANK JOSEPH FAVA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Shannon Marie Fava, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Shannon Marie Fava DENNIS NIELSEN, JR., individually as the Sibling of Shannon Marie Fava, Deceased DENNIS JOSEPH NIELSEN, SR., individually as the Parent of Shannon Marie Fava, Deceased LINDA ANN FAVUZZA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bernard Favuzza, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Bernard Favuzza REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Felicia C. Fazio, Deceased, Parent of decedent Robert Fazio, Jr. CAROLE LOVERO, individually as the Sibling of Robert Fazio, Jr., Deceased ROBERT FAZIO, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Fazio, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Fazio, Jr. LAUREN MARIE FAZIO, individually as the Child of Ronald C. Fazio, Sr., Deceased JANET FAZIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald C. Fazio, Sr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald C. Fazio, Sr. ROBERT FAZIO, individually as the Child of 81

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 82 of 434

Ronald C. Fazio, Sr., Deceased RONALD C. FAZIO, JR., individually as the Child of Ronald C. Fazio, Sr., Deceased ELIZABETH FEEHAN, individually as the Child of William M. Feehan, Deceased TARA FEEHAN DAVAN, individually as the Child of William M. Feehan, Deceased JOHN FEEHAN, individually as the Child of William M. Feehan, Deceased WILLIAM B. FEEHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William M. Feehan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William M. Feehan DOROTHY A. FERGUS, individually as the Parent of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., Deceased ALLISON M. FERGUS, individually as the Sibling of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., Deceased MAUREEN FERGUS SHEEHAN, individually as the Sibling of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., Deceased ANNE MARIE FERGUS RAYHILL, individually as the Sibling of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., Deceased LINDA FERGUS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr. EDWARD T. FERGUS, SR., individually as the Parent of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., Deceased DOE 09, individually as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 09, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 09 DOE 09, individually as the Parent of DOE 09, Deceased ROSANNA M. FERRUGIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 82

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 83 of 434

David Francis Ferrugio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David Francis Ferrugio MINNIE FERRO, individually and as Parent of Louis V. Fersini, Jr., Deceased CATHY LYN FERSINI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Louis V. Fersini, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Louis V. Fersini, Jr. DOE 103, individually as the Parent of DOE 103, Deceased DOE 103, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 103, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 103 EVELYN L. FIALKO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jennifer Louise Fialko, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Louise Fialko ROBERT J. FIALKO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jennifer Louise Fialko, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Louise Fialko ANDREW C. FIALKO, individually as the Sibling of Jennifer Louise Fialko, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Isabel Fiedel, Deceased, Parent of decedent Kristen Nicole Fiedel LINDSEY BETH FIEDEL, individually as the Child of Kristen Nicole Fiedel, Deceased WARREN FIEDEL, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Kristen Nicole Fiedel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kristen Nicole Fiedel WILLIAM H. FIELDS, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Amelia V. Fields, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Amelia V. Fields LORETTA J. FILIPOV, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alexander M. Filipov, Deceased and on behalf 83

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 84 of 434

of all survivors of Alexander M. Filipov REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Madeline F. Fiore, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael Curtis Fiore LINDA S. FIORE, individually as the Sibling of Michael Curtis Fiore, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Michael Fiore, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael Curtis Fiore KAREN FIORITO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John B. Fiorito, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John B. Fiorito JEAN C. FISCHER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John R. Fischer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John R. Fischer DOE 107, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 107, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 107 SERENA FISHER DUGAN, individually as the Child of Gerald Paul Fisher, Deceased CHRISTINE KARAS FISHER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gerald Paul Fisher, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gerald Paul Fisher JONATHAN MICHAEL FISHER, individually as the Child of Gerald Paul Fisher, Deceased DENISE DILEO FISHER on behalf of minor children A.F. and D.F. SUSAN M. FISHER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Fisher, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. Fisher and on behalf of minor child S.M.F. MARY FRANCES BRACKEN, individually as the Parent of Lucy Fishman, Deceased EDWARD P. BRACKEN, individually as the Sibling of Lucy Fishman, Deceased 84

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 85 of 434

DIANE KEATING, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ryan D. Fitzgerald, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ryan D. Fitzgerald ROSEANNA FITZPATRICK, individually as the Parent of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Deceased MARIANNE FITZPATRICK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick and on behalf of minor children C.F. and B.F. MICHAEL J. FITZPATRICK, individually as the Parent of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Deceased MICHAEL S. FITZPATRICK, individually as the Sibling of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, Deceased LORETTA A. PALISAY, individually as the Parent of Salvatore A. Fiumefreddo, Deceased JOAN FIUMEFREDDO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Salvatore A. Fiumefreddo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Salvatore A. Fiumefreddo MICHAEL E. FLAGG, individually and as the Co-Executor of the Estate of Darlene Embree Flagg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Darlene Embree Flagg MICHAEL E. FLAGG, individually as the Child of Wilson Falor Flagg, Deceased LILA MAY WALKDEN FLOUNDERS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph W. Flounders, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph W. Flounders CHRISTIAN C. CRONER, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patricia V. Flounders, Deceased MICHAEL THOMAS FODOR as the Representative of the Estate of Deborah Fodor, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael N. Fodor MICHAEL THOMAS FODOR, individually and as the Representative of the Estate of 85

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 86 of 434

Michael N. Fodor, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael N. Fodor and the Representative of the Estate of Deborah Fodor, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael N. Fodor JUDITH FODOR, individually as the Sibling of Michael N. Fodor, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Michael Fodor, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael N. Fodor ANDREW FODOR, individually as the Child of Michael N. Fodor, Deceased SAMANTHA LEE FOO, individually as the Child of Chih Min Foo, Deceased MARY LOU LEE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Chih Min Foo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Chih Min Foo JASON LEE FOO, individually as the Child of Chih Min Foo, Deceased DORRETTE WILLIAMS, individually as the Sibling of Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham, Deceased DUNSTON FORBES, individually as the Parent of Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham, Deceased CARLTON FORBES, individually as the Sibling of Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham, Deceased CHRISTOPHER R. FORBES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Del Rose ForbesCheatham CHERYL D. COOPER, individually as the Domestic Partner of Donald A. Foreman, Deceased TESSIE MOLINA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Hugh Forsythe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Hugh Forsythe 86

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 87 of 434

MARION ROSETTE FOSTER, individually as the Parent of Noel John Foster, Deceased JOHN ALFRED FOSTER, individually as the Parent of Noel John Foster, Deceased MARY GRACE FOTI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Foti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Foti DOE 94, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 94, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 94 and on behalf of minor children DOE 94, DOE 94, and DOE 94 MICHAEL J. FOX, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey L. Fox, Deceased ANNIE MARIE CARTER, individually as the Sibling of Virginia E. Fox, Deceased KAREN M. CARLUCCI, individually as the Fiancé of Peter Christopher Frank, Deceased HENRY LAMBERT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lillian Frederick-Lambert, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lillian Frederick-Lambert CAROL FREUND, individually as the Sibling of Peter Louis Freund, Deceased BARBARA FREUND SALVADORE, individually as the Sibling of Peter Louis Freund, Deceased MARY FROEHNER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregg J. Froehner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregg J. Froehner REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Margaret Fumando, Deceased, Parent of decedent Clement Fumando CATHERINE MAROTTE, individually as the Sibling of Clement Fumando, Deceased KATHERINE MARIE FUMANDO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Clement Fumando, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Clement 87

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 88 of 434

Fumando STEPHEN FUMANDO, individually as the Child of Clement Fumando, Deceased GREGORY FUMANDO, individually as the Child of Clement Fumando, Deceased CARLO FUMANDO, individually as the Sibling of Clement Fumando, Deceased MARGARET FURMATO, individually as the Parent of Paul Furmato, Deceased CAROL MARGARET DEBENEDICTIS, individually as the Sibling of Paul Furmato, Deceased JILL MARY KEOUGH, individually as the Sibling of Paul Furmato, Deceased CYNTHIA ANNE VELARDI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Furmato, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Furmato MARK FURMATO, individually as the Sibling of Paul Furmato, Deceased JOSEPH FURMATO, JR., individually as the Sibling of Paul Furmato, Deceased JOSEPH FURMATO, SR., individually as the Parent of Paul Furmato, Deceased HAVEN A. FYFE-KIERNAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karleton D. Fyfe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Karleton D. Fyfe DOE 40, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 40, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 40 KEVIN RICHARD GAFF, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Pamela Lee Gaff, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Pamela Lee Gaff PATRICIA A. HILL, individually as the Sibling of Irving Vincent Gailliard, Deceased MARGARET ANN MICCIULLI, individually as the Parent of Deanna Micciulli Galante, 88

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 89 of 434

Deceased TINA LOUISE MICCIULLI, individually as the Sibling of Deanna Micciulli Galante, Deceased JOSEPH ANTHONY MICCIULLI, individually as the Parent of Deanna Micciulli Galante, Deceased JOSEPH CHRISTOPHER MICCIULLI, individually as the Sibling of Deanna Micciulli Galante, Deceased ANTHONY GALANTE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Deanna Micciulli Galante, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Deanna Micciulli Galante LUCREZIA IDA SUSCA, individually as the Parent of Grace Catherine Galante, Deceased CATHY MARIE CAVA, individually as the Sibling of Grace Catherine Galante, Deceased FRANCESCO SUSCA, individually as the Parent of Grace Catherine Galante, Deceased FRANK SUSCA, individually as the Sibling of Grace Catherine Galante, Deceased GIOVANNI GALANTE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Grace Catherine Galante, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Grace Catherine Galante PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of Daniel James Gallagher, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel James Gallagher. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Regina E. Gallagher, Deceased, Parent of decedent Daniel James Gallagher MARYANN GAMBALE, individually as the Parent of Giovanna G. Gambale, Deceased ANTONIA GAMBALE, individually as the Sibling of Giovanna G. Gambale, Deceased ANTHONY J. GAMBALE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Giovanna G. Gambale, Deceased and on behalf 89

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 90 of 434

of all survivors of Giovanna G. Gambale MATTHEW GAMBALE, individually as the Sibling of Giovanna G. Gambale, Deceased MARIA REGINA MERWIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald L. Gamboa, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald L. Gamboa DOE 117, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 117, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 117, and on behalf of minor children DOE 117, DOE 117, and DOE 117 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Virginia Garbarini, Deceased, Parent of decedent Charles Garbarini JOAN CUNEO, individually as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini, Deceased DONNA MARIE GARBARINI, individually as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini, Deceased BERYL ANN ZAWATSKY, individually as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini, Deceased CATHY JEAN KOSTIW, individually as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini, Deceased PEGGY MARY GARBARINI, individually as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini, Deceased JANET GARBARINI, individually as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini, Deceased ANDREA DEGEORGE GARBARINI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Garbarini, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Garbarini REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Charles Garbarini, Deceased, Parent of decedent Charles Garbarini DOROTHY GARCIA, individually and as the Executor of the Estate of Andrew Garcia, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Garcia ANDREW T. GARCIA, individually as the 90

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 91 of 434

Child of Andrew Garcia, Deceased CELESTE MARINO GARCIA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cesar R. Garcia, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Cesar R. Garcia DEBORAH ANN GARCIA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Garcia, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David Garcia SUSAN L. GARDNER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher S. Gardner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher S. Gardner and on behalf of minor child A.H.G. JENNIFER RADDING GARDNER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Douglas B. Gardner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Douglas B. Gardner JOSEPH W. GARDNER, individually and as Personal Representative of the Estate of Harvey J. Gardner, Deceased, Parent of decedent Harvey Joseph Gardner, III JOSEPH W. GARDNER, individually as the sibling of Harvey Joseph Gardner, III, Deceased JUDITH TOREA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Harvey Joseph Gardner, III, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Harvey Joseph Gardner, III ANTHONY GARDNER, individually as the Sibling of Harvey Joseph Gardner, III, Deceased AMY GARDNER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey B. Gardner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey B. Gardner ANTONIA GARGANO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rocco Nino Gargano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Rocco Nino Gargano

91

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 92 of 434

DOE 145, individually as the Child of DOE 145, Deceased DOE 145, individually as the Child of DOE 145, Deceased DOE 145, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 145, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 145 SUZANNE MASCITIS as the Representative of the Estate of Rosemarie Gavagan, Deceased, Parent of decedent Donald R. Gavagan, Jr. SUZANNE MASCITIS, individually as the Sibling of Donald R. Gavagan, Jr., Deceased JACQUELINE S. GAVAGAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald R. Gavagan, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Donald R. Gavagan, Jr. DONALD RICHARD GAVAGAN, individually as the Parent of Donald R. Gavagan, Jr., Deceased JOSEPH BERNARD GAVAGAN, individually as the Sibling of Donald R. Gavagan, Jr., Deceased LINDA ROSE GAY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter A. Gay, Sr., Deceased on behalf of minor child L.L.G. and on behalf of all survivors of Peter A. Gay, Sr. TRACY M. GAZZANI, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Terence D. Gazzani, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Terence D. Gazzani MAURIZIO D. GAZZANI, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Terence D. Gazzani, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Terence D. Gazzani REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Patricia M. Geidel, Deceased, Parent of decedent Gary Paul Geidel CHRISTINE ANN NORRIS, individually as 92

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 93 of 434

the Sibling of Gary Paul Geidel, Deceased MATHILDA M. GEIDEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gary Paul Geidel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gary Paul Geidel PAUL ERNEST GEIDEL, individually as the Parent of Gary Paul Geidel, Deceased MICHAEL GEORGE GEIDEL, individually as the Sibling of Gary Paul Geidel, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Ralph W. Geidel, Sr., Deceased, Sibling of decedent Gary Paul Geidel SHELLY GENOVESE, individually as the Spouse of Steven G. Genovese, Deceased and on behalf of minor child J.G. CAROLYN M. GEORGE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Linda George, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Linda George RICHARD A. GEORGE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Linda George, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Linda George HANS J. GERHARDT, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Ralph Gerhardt, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ralph Gerhardt STEPHAN J. GERHARDT, individually as the Sibling of Ralph Gerhardt, Deceased LORRAINE ADELE GERLICH, individually as the Sibling of Robert J. Gerlich, Deceased ROCHELLE GERLICH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert J. Gerlich, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert J. Gerlich MATT GERLICH, individually as the Child of Robert J. Gerlich, Deceased DANIEL GERLICH, individually as the Child of Robert J. Gerlich, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Anna 93

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 94 of 434

Gertsberg, Deceased, Parent of decedent Marina Romanovna Gertsberg ROMAN GERTSBERG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marina Romanovna Gertsberg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Marina Romanovna Gertsberg REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Jo Ann S. Geyer, Deceased, Parent of decedent James G. Geyer GERALYN MARASCO, individually as the Sibling of James G. Geyer, Deceased GERALYN MARASCO AND JOHN E. GEYER as Co-Fiduciaries of the Estate of Philip G. Geyer, Deceased, Parent of decedent James G. Geyer PHILIP JOSEPH GEYER, individually as the Sibling of James G. Geyer, Deceased JOHN EDWARD GEYER, individually as the Sibling of James G. Geyer, Deceased THERESA GIAMMONA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent F. Giammona, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent F. Giammona HEATHER GIBBON, individually as the Child of Debra L. Gibbon, Deceased J. FREDERICK GIBBON, on behalf of the Estate of Adam Gibbon, Deceased, Child of Decedent Debra L. Gibbon ZACHARY GIBBON, individually as the Child of Debra L. Gibbon, Deceased J. FREDERICK GIBBON, individually as the Spouse of Debra L. Gibbon, Deceased SUSAN GIBERSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Giberson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Giberson ERIC PATRICK GIBSON, individually as the Child of Brenda Colbert Gibson, Deceased JOSEPH MILTON GIBSON, III, individually 94

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 95 of 434

and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brenda Colbert Gibson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brenda Colbert Gibson JACQUELINE GILBERT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Timothy Paul Gilbert, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Timothy Paul Gilbert JANE JONES on behalf of minor child H.G. DEENA GILBEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Stuart Gilbey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Stuart Gilbey and on behalf of minor children M.G. and M.G. MARIA ACOSTA, individually as the Domestic Partner of Paul John Gill, Deceased GISELE JEAN-GILLES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Y. Gilles, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Y. Gilles MYRIAM JEAN-GILLES, individually as the Sibling of Mark Y. Gilles, Deceased ELEANOR GILLETTE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Evan Gillette, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Evan Gillette ASHLEY GILLIGAN, individually as the Child of Ronald L. Gilligan, Deceased AINSLEY GILLIGAN, individually as the Child of Ronald L. Gilligan, Deceased ELIZABETH GILLIGAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald L. Gilligan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald L. Gilligan DHERRAN GILLIGAN, individually as the Child of Ronald L. Gilligan, Deceased RAYMOND L. GILLIGAN, individually as the Sibling of Ronald L. Gilligan, Deceased COLIN VINCENT GILLIGAN, individually as the Sibling of Ronald L. Gilligan, Deceased 95

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 96 of 434

GERALDINE GILLIAM, individually as the Parent of Rodney C. Gillis, Deceased RONALD C. GILLIS, individually as the Sibling of Rodney C. Gillis, Deceased APRIL GRACE GINLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John F. Ginley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John F. Ginley DOE 95, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 95, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 95, and on behalf of minor children DOE 95, DOE 95, and DOE 95 DOE 95, individually as the Parent of DOE 95, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Domenica Giovinazzo, Deceased, Parent of decedent Martin Giovinazzo CONCETTA BONNER, individually as the Sibling of Martin Giovinazzo, Deceased ANGELA CARMELA QUINN, individually as the Sibling of Martin Giovinazzo, Deceased ROSEMARIE MAHONEY, individually as the Sibling of Martin Giovinazzo, Deceased DOROTHY GIOVINAZZO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Giovinazzo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Giovinazzo and on behalf of minor children A.M.G., T.J.G., and A.D.G. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Martin Giovinazzo, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Martin Giovinazzo SALI GJONBALAJ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mon Gjonbalaj, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mon Gjonbalaj JAYNE MARIE MARX, individually as the Sibling of Dianne Gladstone, Deceased HERBERT GLADSTONE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 96

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 97 of 434

Dianne Gladstone, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dianne Gladstone VERONICA SQUEF, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith Alexander Glascoe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Keith Alexander Glascoe and on behalf of minor children O.A.G, N.S.G., and K.A.G. GLORIA OLIVER (MAIDEN) GLASCOE, individually as the Parent of Keith Alexander Glascoe, Deceased BENJAMIN ALEXANDER GLASCOE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith Alexander Glascoe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Keith Alexander Glascoe JUDITH M. GLICK, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Barry H. Glick, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Barry H. Glick and on behalf of minor children C.G. and C.G. MARI GLICK STUART, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven L. Glick, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven L. Glick ALEESE MILLS HARTMANN, individually as the Fiancé of William Robert Godshalk, Deceased GRACE M. PARKINSON-GODSHALK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Robert Godshalk, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Robert Godshalk DANIELA GOGLIORMELLA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Gogliormella, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Gogliormella MARILYN GOLDBERG, individually as the Parent of Brian F. Goldberg, Deceased GERALD GOLDBERG, individually as the Parent of Brian F. Goldberg, Deceased

97

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 98 of 434

ASHLEY GOLDFLAM, individually as the Child of Jeffrey Goldflam, Deceased RISE GOLDFLAM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey Goldflam, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey Goldflam JOSHUA GOLDFLAM, individually as the Child of Jeffrey Goldflam, Deceased CECILIA GOLDSTEIN, individually as the Parent of Monica Goldstein, Deceased ADRIENNE TRIGGS, individually as the Sibling of Monica Goldstein, Deceased MORRIS SONNY GOLDSTEIN, individually as the Parent of Monica Goldstein, Deceased ALYCE GOLDSTEIN, individually as the Parent of Steven Ian Goldstein, Deceased ROBERT JAY GOLDSTEIN, individually as the Sibling of Steven Ian Goldstein, Deceased SARA CLARK, individually as the Child of Ronald F. Golinski, Deceased MARCELLIA POTLER, individually as the Child of Ronald F. Golinski, Deceased AMANDA GOLINSKI, individually as the Child of Ronald F. Golinski, Deceased IRENE MARY GOLINSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald F. Golinski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald F. Golinski MIGDALIA COLEMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rosa J. Gonzalez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Rosa J. Gonzalez ELLEN REYNOLDS GOODCHILD, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Lynn Catherine Goodchild, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lynn Catherine Goodchild NEIL K. GOODCHILD, individually as the Sibling of Lynn Catherine Goodchild, Deceased 98

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 99 of 434

WILLIAM CLARK GOODCHILD, III, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Lynn Catherine Goodchild, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lynn Catherine Goodchild HELENE W. NELSON, individually as the Parent of Catherine C. Gorayeb, Deceased CLAIRE A. GORAYEB, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Catherine C. Gorayeb, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Catherine C. Gorayeb JOSEPH GORAYEB, individually as the Parent of Catherine C. Gorayeb, Deceased CHRISTOPHER J. GORAYEB, individually as the Sibling of Catherine C. Gorayeb, Deceased ANDREW T. GORAYEB, individually as the Sibling of Catherine C. Gorayeb, Deceased THERESA RACHEL GORMAN, individually as the Parent of Thomas E. Gorman, Deceased THERESA MARY CREEDON, individually as the Sibling of Thomas E. Gorman, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of John Edward Gorman, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Thomas E. Gorman EDWARD THOMAS GORMAN, individually as the Parent of Thomas E. Gorman, Deceased KATHRYN G. ANDERSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Edward Gould, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Edward Gould ROBERT W. GOULD, individually as the Sibling of Michael Edward Gould, Deceased JESSICA GOWELL, individually as the Child of Douglas A. Gowell, Deceased BARBARA GOWELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Douglas A. Gowell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Douglas A. Gowell MICHAEL GOWELL, individually as the 99

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 100 of 434

Child of Douglas A. Gowell, Deceased PATRICK MICHAEL GRADY, individually and as the Representative of the Estate of Rita M. Grady, Deceased, Parent of decedent Christopher Michael Grady DEIRDRE MARIE GRADY, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Michael Grady, Deceased DOE 70, individually as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 70, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 70 and on behalf of minor children DOE 70 and DOE 70 BRENDAN MICHEAL GRADY, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Michael Grady, Deceased RUTH GRAIFMAN, individually as the Parent of David Martin Graifman, Deceased CHRISTINE R. HUHN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Martin Graifman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David Martin Graifman JULIUS GRAIFMAN, individually as the Parent of David Martin Graifman, Deceased BRIAN DALE GRAIFMAN, individually as the Sibling of David Martin Graifman, Deceased JACK A. GRANDCOLAS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lauren C. Grandcolas, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lauren C. Grandcolas JAMES S. GRAY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Stewart Gray, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Stewart Gray LISA ANNE GRAY, individually as the Child of Ian J. Gray, Deceased ANNE MARGARET POLICELLI, individually as the Sibling of Ian J. Gray, Deceased 100

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 101 of 434

ANA M. RALEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ian J. Gray, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ian J. Gray MARY MADDEN, individually as the Parent of James Michael Gray, Deceased DOE 49, individually as the Sibling of DOE 49, Deceased DOE 49, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 49, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 49 and on behalf of minor children DOE 49 and DOE 49 DOE 49, individually as the Parent of DOE 49, Deceased TINA GRAZIOSO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Grazioso, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Grazioso and on behalf of minor child M.J.G. DANIELLE TIFFANY GREEN, individually as the Child of Wade Brian Green, Deceased WILHELMINA MARY GREEN, individually as the Parent of Wade Brian Green, Deceased ALICIA MARIE GOVIA, individually as the Sibling of Wade Brian Green, Deceased ROXANNE GREEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wade Brian Green, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Wade Brian Green REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Thomas Green, Deceased, Parent of decedent Wade Brian Green BARRY VINCENT GREEN, individually as the Sibling of Wade Brian Green, Deceased ANTHONY GREEN, individually as the Sibling of Wade Brian Green, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Eva Greenstein, Deceased, Parent of decedent Eileen Greenstein 101

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 102 of 434

EDWARD W. GREENSTEIN, individually as the Sibling of Eileen Greenstein, Deceased HOWARD GREENSTEIN, individually as the Sibling of Eileen Greenstein, Deceased MICHAEL J. GREENSTEIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eileen Greenstein, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eileen Greenstein AMANDA MARIE WALLING, individually as the Child of Donald H. Gregory, Deceased SARA ELIZABETH CARPENTER, individually as the Child of Donald H. Gregory, Deceased MAUREEN A. GREGORY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald H. Gregory, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Donald H. Gregory VICTORIA BLAKSLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Pedro Grehan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Pedro Grehan REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Teresa L. Grimner, Deceased, Parent of decedent David Joseph Grimner MARY ANN ELIZABETH PETERS, individually as the Sibling of David Joseph Grimner, Deceased VIRGINIA MARGARET KWIATKOSKI, individually as the Sibling of David Joseph Grimner, Deceased JUDITH A. GRIMNER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Joseph Grimner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David Joseph Grimner CHARLES GREGORY GRIMNER, individually as the Sibling of David Joseph Grimner, Deceased ANN M. BROWNE, individually as the Sibling of Francis E. Grogan, Deceased JOANNE GRZELAK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph 102

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 103 of 434

Grzelak, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Grzelak PATRICIA GRZYMALSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew James Grzymalski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew James Grzymalski CAI ZHANG, individually as the Parent of Liming Gu, Deceased YUAU KU, individually as the Sibling of Liming Gu, Deceased JIN LIU, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Liming Gu, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Liming Gu FUSHAN GU, individually as the Parent of Liming Gu, Deceased YU ZHOU GU, individually as the Sibling of Liming Gu, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Beatrice Josephine Guadagno, Deceased, Parent of decedent Richard J. Guadagno LORI M. GUADAGNO, individually as the Sibling of Richard J. Guadagno, Deceased JERRY F. GUADAGNO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard J. Guadagno, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard J. Guadagno ELISE S. GUADALUPE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jose Antonio Guadalupe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jose Antonio Guadalupe and on behalf of minor child A.J.G. EDWIN H. YUEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cindy Yanzhu Guan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Cindy Yanzhu Guan NAOEMI P. GULLICKSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph P. Gullickson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Gullickson 103

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 104 of 434

THOMAS GUZA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Philip T. Guza, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Philip T. Guza ANTHONY C. GUZZARDO, individually as the Child of Barbara Guzzardo, Deceased ANTHONY GUZZARDO, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Barbara Guzzardo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara Guzzardo MARJORIE ANN FARLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paige Farley Hackel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paige Farley Hackel ALLAN R. HACKEL, individually as the Spouse of Paige Farley Hackel, Deceased PATRICIA ANN THOMPSON-HAENTZLER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Philip Haentzler, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Philip Haentzler MARYJANE HAGIS, individually as the Parent of Steven M. Hagis, Deceased STACY HAGIS BRUNO, individually as the Sibling of Steven M. Hagis, Deceased GLORIA HAGIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven M. Hagis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven M. Hagis CHRISTOPHER HAGIS, individually as the Sibling of Steven M. Hagis, Deceased STEVE HAGIS, SR., individually as the Parent of Steven M. Hagis, Deceased ELIZABETH J. ADAMS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marylou Hague, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Marylou Hague CYNTHIA J. HAGUE, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eugene T. Hague, Jr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Marylou Hague GERALDINE HALDERMAN, individually 104

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 105 of 434

and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Halderman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David Halderman MARIANNE ANGELO, individually as the Sibling of David Halderman, Deceased YANIQUE HALL, individually as the Child of Vaswald George Hall, Deceased BEVERLY HALL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vaswald George Hall, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vaswald George Hall REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Brenda Halligan, Deceased, Parent of decedent Robert John Halligan LARA STACEY, individually as the Child of Robert John Halligan, Deceased SARAH JANE ROBBINS, individually as the Child of Robert John Halligan, Deceased EMMA LOUISE ARRO, individually as the Child of Robert John Halligan, Deceased MARY KATHLEEN LYNN, individually as the Sibling of Robert John Halligan, Deceased JERALDINE HALLIGAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert John Halligan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert John Halligan JAMES E. HALLIGAN, individually as the Child of Robert John Halligan, Deceased TREVOR ANDREW HALLIGAN, individually as the Child of Robert John Halligan, Deceased WILLIAM G. HALLIGAN, individually as the Sibling of Robert John Halligan, Deceased DAVID MITCHELL HALLIGAN, individually as the Sibling of Robert John Halligan, Deceased MARY ALICE HALLORAN, individually as the Parent of Vincent Gerard Halloran, Deceased MAUREEN RUTH HALVORSON, 105

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 106 of 434

individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James D. Halvorson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James D. Halvorson LISA A. VENTURA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Felicia Hamilton, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Felicia Hamilton WALTER E. HAMILTON, individually as the Child of Felicia Hamilton, Deceased ELIZABETH HAMILTON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Hamilton, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Hamilton SUE HAMMOND, individually as the Parent of Carl Max Hammond, Jr., Deceased CYNTHIA SUE SUMNER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carl Max Hammond, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Carl Max Hammond, Jr. CARL M. HAMMOND, SR., individually as the Parent of Carl Max Hammond, Jr., Deceased PATRICIA ROSE HANLEY, individually as the Parent of Sean Hanley, Deceased GERALD HANLEY, individually as the Parent of Sean Hanley, Deceased GERALD T. HANLEY, individually as the Sibling of Sean Hanley, Deceased KEVIN E. HANLEY, individually as the Sibling of Sean Hanley, Deceased BRYAN T. HANLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Hanley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Hanley NANCY ELIZABETH HANNAFORD, individually as the Parent of Kevin James Hannaford, Deceased ELIZABETH L. SARACENO, individually as the Sibling of Kevin James Hannaford, 106

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 107 of 434

Deceased EILEEN A. HANNAFORD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin James Hannaford, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin James Hannaford JAMES JOSEPH HANNAFORD, individually as the Parent of Kevin James Hannaford, Deceased PATRICK GERARD HANNAFORD, individually as the Sibling of Kevin James Hannaford, Deceased GAYE HANNON, individually as the Parent of Dana Rey Hannon, Deceased KYLE HANNON, individually as the Sibling of Dana Rey Hannon, Deceased PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of Dana Rey Hannon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dana Rey Hannon. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Thomas Hannon, Deceased, Parent of decedent Dana Rey Hannon C. LEE HANSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Lee Hanson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christine Lee Hanson EUNICE KATHERINE HANSON, individually as the Parent of Peter Burton Hanson, Deceased KATHRYN LEE BARRERE, individually as the Sibling of Peter Burton Hanson, Deceased C. LEE HANSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Burton Hanson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Burton Hanson JOHN HYUNSOOL KIM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sue Ju Hanson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sue Ju Hanson JULIA K. HARAMIS, individually as the Child of Vassilios G. Haramis, Deceased 107

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 108 of 434

GLORIA HARAMIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vassilios G. Haramis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vassilios G. Haramis GEORGE VASSILION HARAMIS, individually as the Child of Vassilios G. Haramis, Deceased JUDITH KAY HARDACRE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gerald Hardacre, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gerald Hardacre REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Lawrence Hardacre, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Gerald Hardacre PATRICIA E. HARGRAVE, individually as the Spouse of Timothy J. Hargrave, Deceased CAROLINE ANNA HARLIN, individually as the Parent of Daniel Edward Harlin, Deceased JOAN PATRICIA HARLIN, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Edward Harlin, Deceased DEBRA A. HARLIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Edward Harlin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Edward Harlin REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Wilbur Harlin, Deceased, Parent of decedent Daniel Edward Harlin JAMES HARLIN, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Edward Harlin, Deceased ROBERT W. HARLIN, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Edward Harlin, Deceased ANDREA CALDARELLA, individually as the Child of Frances Haros, Deceased MARIA ANN GALEA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frances Haros, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frances Haros NICHOLAS HAROS, JR., individually as the Child of Frances Haros, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Miriam F. 108

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 109 of 434

Harrell, Deceased, Parent of decedent Harvey L. Harrell MOLLY DUNE, individually as the Sibling of Harvey L. Harrell, Deceased DOE 37, individually as the Sibling of DOE 37, Deceased DAVID W. HARRELL, individually as the Sibling of Harvey L. Harrell, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Harvey L. Harrell, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Harvey L. Harrell REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Miriam F. Harrell, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stephen G. Harrell MOLLY DUNE, individually as the Sibling of Stephen G. Harrell, Deceased DOE 37, individually as the Sibling of DOE 36 Deceased DAVID W. HARRELL, individually as the Sibling of Stephen G. Harrell, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Harvey L. Harrell, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Stephen G. Harrell ARVETTE DENISE HARRIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Aisha Ann Harris, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Aisha Ann Harris MARCUS J. HARRIS, individually as the Sibling of Aisha Ann Harris, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Robert Harris, Jr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Aisha Ann Harris MILDRED HARRIS, individually as the Parent of Stewart D. Harris, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Rubin Jay Harris, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stewart D. Harris LLOYD HARRIS, individually as the Sibling of Stewart D. Harris, Deceased

109

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 110 of 434

REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Betty J. Mathwig, Deceased, Parent of decedent John P. Hart CHRISTINE LOUISE REICHERT-HART, individually as the Sibling of John P. Hart, Deceased MARY ELIZABETH MEIXELSPERGER, individually as the Sibling of John P. Hart, Deceased SANDRA ELLEN SHELLEY, individually as the Sibling of John P. Hart, Deceased JEANINE HART SEAMAN, individually as the Sibling of John P. Hart, Deceased LAURIE SUE HART, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John P. Hart, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John P. Hart REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of James A. Hart, Jr., Deceased, Sibling of decedent John P. Hart RITA A. HASHEM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Paul Hashem, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Paul Hashem GRACE SUSAN HATTON, individually as the Parent of Terence Sean Hatton, Deceased GRACE SUSAN HATTON, individually as the Sibling of Terence Sean Hatton, Deceased ELIZABETH PETRONE HATTON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Terence Sean Hatton, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Terence Sean Hatton and on behalf of the minor child T.H. KENNETH ROBERTS HATTON, individually as the Parent of Terence Sean Hatton, Deceased ERIKA ANN HAUB, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Haub, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Haub and on behalf of minor child K.E.H. SUSAN CONKLIN, individually as the Sibling 110

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 111 of 434

of Donald G. Havlish, Jr., Deceased FIONA MICHAELA HAVLISH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald G. Havlish, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Donald G. Havlish, Jr. WILLIAM HAVLISH, individually as the Sibling of Donald G. Havlish, Jr., Deceased DONALD G. HAVLISH, SR., individually as the Parent of Donald G. Havlish, Jr., Deceased ELIZABETH GAIL HAYDEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James E. Hayden, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James E. Hayden DEBORAH LYNN HAYES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Jay Hayes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Jay Hayes and on behalf of minor child R.A.H. JANICE HAZELCORN, individually as the Parent of Scott Hazelcorn, Deceased CHARLES HAZELCORN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Hazelcorn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Hazelcorn ERIC HAZELCORN, individually as the Sibling of Scott Hazelcorn, Deceased BERNARD HEERAN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Charles F.X. Heeran, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Charles F.X. Heeran THOMAS P. HEIDENBERGER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michele M. Heidenberger, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michele M. Heidenberger DEBORA HEMSCHOOT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Hemschoot, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Hemschoot DAVID C. HEMSCHOOT, individually as the Child of Mark Hemschoot, Deceased 111

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 112 of 434

JEFFREY W. HEMSCHOOT, individually as the Child of Mark Hemschoot, Deceased DOE 11, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 11, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 11 PATRICIA A. HENRIQUE, individually as the Parent of Michelle Marie Henrique, Deceased CHRISTINA HENRIQUE, individually as the Sibling of Michelle Marie Henrique, Deceased GEORGE HENRIQUE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michelle Marie Henrique, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michelle Marie Henrique PAUL R. HENRIQUE, individually as the Sibling of Michelle Marie Henrique, Deceased MICHAEL HENRIQUE, individually as the Sibling of Michelle Marie Henrique, Deceased ALICE A. HENRY, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Joseph P. Henry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Henry KATHLEEN S. HENRY, individually as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry, Deceased MARY HENRY, individually as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry, Deceased EDWARD HENRY, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joseph P. Henry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Henry MICHAEL HENRY, individually as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry, Deceased DANIEL HENRY, individually as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry, Deceased EDWARD HENRY, JR., individually as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry, Deceased ETHEL M. HENRY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Henry, Deceased and on behalf of all 112

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 113 of 434

survivors of William Henry ALLYSON HEPBURN, individually as the Child of Robert Allan Hepburn, Deceased JENNIFER HEPBURN, individually as the Child of Robert Allan Hepburn, Deceased THERESA LYNN HEPBURN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Allan Hepburn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Allan Hepburn MARGARET MCCRANE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Herencia, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Herencia REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Peter Carr, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Mary Herencia REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Kevin Carr, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Mary Herencia JULIO HERENCIA, individually as the Child of Mary Herencia, Deceased JOSEPH HERENCIA, individually as the Child of Mary Herencia, Deceased CARMEN ENEIDA IRIZARRY, individually as the Parent of Claribel Hernandez, Deceased MARIBEL TOPALTZAS, individually as the Sibling of Claribel Hernandez, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Jaime Villalobos, Deceased, Parent of decedent Claribel Hernandez ESLYN HERNANDEZ, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Claribel Hernandez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Claribel Hernandez JACQUELINE HERNANDEZ, individually as the Child of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased CATHERINE HERNANDEZ, individually as the Child of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased ALEJANDRINA FELICIANO, individually as the Parent of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased 113

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 114 of 434

MARISOL HERNANDEZ, individually as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased MIRIAM LUZ KHATRI, individually as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased LUZ MILAGROS LUNA, individually as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased MERQUIADES DIAZ, individually as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased EULOGIA HERNANDEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Norberto Hernandez WILLY ALBERTO HERNANDEZ, individually as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased PABLO LUIS HERNANDEZ, individually as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased HECTOR LUIS HERNANDEZ, individually as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased VENANCIO HERNANDEZ, JR., individually as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased VENANCIO HERNANDEZ, SR., individually as the Parent of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased ESLYN HERNANDEZ, SR., individually as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez, Deceased LESLIE SUE HERSCH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey A. Hersch, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey A. Hersch BARBARA MARILLE HETZEL, individually as the Parent of Thomas J. Hetzel, Deceased DORINE HETZEL, individually as the Sibling of Thomas J. Hetzel, Deceased DIANA HETZEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Hetzel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. Hetzel and on behalf of minor child A.C.H. EGON HERMANN HETZEL, individually as 114

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 115 of 434

the Parent of Thomas J. Hetzel, Deceased DANIEL HETZEL, individually as the Sibling of Thomas J. Hetzel, Deceased ANA ROSARIO, individually as the Domestic Partner of Emencio Dario Hidalgo, Deceased CAREN HIGGINS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Timothy Higgins, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Timothy Higgins RACHAEL HIGLEY, individually as the Sibling of Robert Dale Warren Higley, II, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Todd E.H. Higley, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Robert Dale Warren Higley, II JOHN DOUGLAS HIGLEY, individually as the Parent of Robert Dale Warren Higley, II, Deceased VIRGINIA A. HINDY, individually as the Parent of Mark D. Hindy, Deceased GEORGE V. HINDY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark D. Hindy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark D. Hindy GREGORY J. HINDY, individually as the Sibling of Mark D. Hindy, Deceased SEAN MICHAEL HOBIN, as the Representative of the Estate of Sheila C. Hobin, Deceased, Spouse of decedent James J. Hobin DONNA DIETRICH, individually as the Sibling of James J. Hobin, Deceased SEAN MICHAEL HOBIN, individually and as the Representative of the Estate of James J. Hobin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James J. Hobin DERRICK J. HOBIN, individually as the Child of James J. Hobin, Deceased JUDITH HOBSON, individually as the Parent of Robert Wayne Hobson, III, Deceased LISA ANN HOPKINS, individually as the 115

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 116 of 434

Sibling of Robert Wayne Hobson, III, Deceased LAURA J. DECOSTER, individually as the Sibling of Robert Wayne Hobson, III, Deceased CYNTHIA HOBSON MCNUTT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Wayne Hobson, III, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Wayne Hobson, III MATTHEW HOBSON, individually as the Sibling of Robert Wayne Hobson, III, Deceased BARBARA A. HOERNER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald George Hoerner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald George Hoerner DOE 03, individually as the Child of DOE 03, Deceased DOE 03, individually as the Parent of DOE 03, Deceased DOE 03, individually as the Sibling of DOE 03, Deceased DOE 03, individually as the Sibling of DOE 03, Deceased DOE 03, individually as the Sibling of DOE 03, Deceased DOE 03, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 03, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 03 DOE 03, individually as the Child of DOE 03, Deceased DOE 03, individually as the Child of DOE 03, Deceased DOE 03, individually as the Child of DOE 03, Deceased DOE 03, individually as the Sibling of DOE 03, Deceased DOE 03, individually as the Sibling of DOE 03, Deceased

116

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 117 of 434

ALICIA HOFER, individually as the Child of John Hofer, Deceased BILLIE ANN HOFER, individually as the Parent of John Hofer, Deceased SUSAN CANESO, individually as the Sibling of John Hofer, Deceased REBECCA HOFER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Hofer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Hofer RICHARD HOFER, individually as the Sibling of John Hofer, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Parent of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 76, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 76 and on behalf of minor child DOE 76 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 76, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 76 DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, 117

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 118 of 434

Deceased DOE 76, individually as the Sibling of DOE 76, Deceased GAIL HOFFMANN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frederick Hoffmann, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frederick Hoffmann GAIL HOFFMANN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michele Hoffmann, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michele Hoffmann PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of Judith Florence Hofmiller, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Judith Florence Hofmiller RICHARD J. WINKIS as the Representative of the Estate of Robert Thomas Winkis, Deceased, Domestic Partner of decedent Judith Florence Hofmiller ROBIN HOHLWECK, individually as the Child of Thomas Warren Hohlweck, Jr., Deceased RANDOLPH T. HOHLWECK, individually as the Child of Thomas Warren Hohlweck, Jr., Deceased TODD W. HOHLWECK, individually as the Child of Thomas Warren Hohlweck, Jr., Deceased JESSICA LIN HIDALGO HOLLAND, individually as the Child of Cora Hidalgo Holland, Deceased STEPHANIE DENISE HIDALGO HOLLAND-BRODNEY, individually as the Child of Cora Hidalgo Holland, Deceased MARIA Y. ALDACO, individually as the Sibling of Cora Hidalgo Holland, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Gonzalo A. Hidalgo, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Cora Hidalgo Holland NATHANIEL K. HOLLAND, individually as the Child of Cora Hidalgo Holland, Deceased 118

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 119 of 434

ERNIE HIDALGO, individually as the Sibling of Cora Hidalgo Holland, Deceased STEPHEN K. HOLLAND, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cora Hidalgo Holland, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Cora Hidalgo Holland CAROL ANN O'TOOLE, individually as the Parent of Joseph Holland, Jr., Deceased TARA HOLLAND-HICKEY, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Holland, Jr., Deceased JOSEPH HOLLAND, individually as the Parent of Joseph Holland, Jr., Deceased MARTHA R. JACKSON-HOLLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jimmie I. Holley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jimmie I. Holley REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Beaulah Holmes, Deceased, Parent of decedent Elizabeth Holmes DORIS HOLMES, individually as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes, Deceased LOUISE ELLERBE, individually as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes, Deceased VIVIAN BYAS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Elizabeth Holmes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Elizabeth Holmes WALTER BYAS, individually as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes, Deceased THOMAS HOLMES, individually as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes, Deceased CHRISTOPHER HOLMES, JR., individually as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes, Deceased WINIFRED M. HOMER, individually as the Parent of Herbert Wilson Homer, Deceased KAREN L. HOMER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Herbert Wilson Homer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Herbert Wilson Homer WILLIAM T. HOMER, individually as the 119

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 120 of 434

Parent of Herbert Wilson Homer, Deceased STEPHEN H. HOMER, individually as the Sibling of Herbert Wilson Homer, Deceased RITA HOPPER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James P. Hopper, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James P. Hopper LISA HORD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Montgomery Hord, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Montgomery Hord MARY A. HORN, individually as the Parent of Michael Joseph Horn, Deceased CHRISTINE M. GRAUER, individually as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Horn, Deceased MAUREEN ANN HORN, individually as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Horn, Deceased CHARLES H. HORN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Joseph Horn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Joseph Horn DOE 108, individually as the Parent of DOE 108, Deceased DOE 108, individually as the Sibling of DOE 108, Deceased DOE 108, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 108, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 108 PATRICIA M. HOROHOE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. PATRICIA M. WITSCHEL, individually as the Sibling of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., Deceased DONNA M. ERSKINE, individually as the Sibling of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., Deceased MICHAEL E. HOROHOE, individually as the Sibling of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., Deceased ROBERT L. HOROHOE, SR., individually and 120

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 121 of 434

as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. MIRIAM HORROCKS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Robert Horrocks, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Robert Horrocks ELIZABETH HORWITZ, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Aaron Horwitz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Aaron Horwitz TARA HORWITZ, individually as the Sibling of Aaron Horwitz, Deceased ALLAN HORWITZ, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Aaron Horwitz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Aaron Horwitz BLAKE HORWITZ, individually as the Sibling of Aaron Horwitz, Deceased ROBERT HORWITZ, individually as the Sibling of Aaron Horwitz, Deceased SONYA M. HOUSTON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Uhuru Gonja Houston, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Uhuru Gonja Houston and on behalf of minor child H.H. JULIA P. SHONTERE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angela Marie Houtz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Angela Marie Houtz EMILY HOWELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael C. Howell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael C. Howell KEVIN M. HOWELL, individually as the Child of Michael C. Howell, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Donna M. Howell, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Steven Leon Howell FAY CAPUTO, individually as the Parent of 121

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 122 of 434

Steven Leon Howell, Deceased RALPH L. HOWELL, individually as the Parent of Steven Leon Howell, Deceased JOSEPH W. HROMADA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Milagros Hromada, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Milagros Hromada KATELYN ANN HUCZKO, individually as the Child of Stephen Huczko, Jr., Deceased KATHLEEN C. MCGUIRE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen Huczko, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Huczko, Jr. ELAINE L. HUGHES, individually as the Parent of Kris Robert Hughes, Deceased KIMBERLY FRANCO, individually as the Sibling of Kris Robert Hughes, Deceased HENRY R. HUGHES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kris Robert Hughes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kris Robert Hughes KEITH HUGHES, individually as the Sibling of Kris Robert Hughes, Deceased DONNA SARA HUGHES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Rexford Hughes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Rexford Hughes LOUISE HUGHES, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Robert T. Hughes, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert T. Hughes, Jr. LEIGHA HUGHES, individually as the Sibling of Robert T. Hughes, Jr., Deceased SHANIN HUGHES, individually as the Sibling of Robert T. Hughes, Jr., Deceased LYNDSEY HUGHES, individually as the Sibling of Robert T. Hughes, Jr., Deceased ROBERT T. HUGHES, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Robert T. Hughes, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all 122

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 123 of 434

survivors of Robert T. Hughes, Jr. ROSANNE HUGHES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas F. Hughes, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas F. Hughes, Jr. TENNYSON HUIE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Huie, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Huie GORDON HUIE, individually as the Sibling of Susan Huie, Deceased JENNIFER WOODWARD HUNT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Christopher Hunt, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Christopher Hunt and on behalf of minor child E.K.H. NATALIE CHRISTINA CONNERS, individually as the Child of Robert Joseph Hymel, Deceased BEATRIZ E. HYMEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Joseph Hymel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Joseph Hymel CAROLYNE YACOUB HYNES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Edward Hynes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Edward Hynes MONICA PALATUCCI, individually as the Fiancé of Joseph A. Ianelli, Deceased BARBARA ELLEN IANELLI, individually as the Parent of Joseph A. Ianelli, Deceased JENNIFER THOMPSON, individually as the Sibling of Joseph A. Ianelli, Deceased JOSEPH IANELLI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph A. Ianelli, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph A. Ianelli AYSE IBIS, individually as the Parent of Zuhtu Ibis, Deceased 123

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 124 of 434

HACER IBIS, individually as the Sibling of Zuhtu Ibis, Deceased LEYLA UYAR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Zuhtu Ibis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Zuhtu Ibis and on behalf of minor child M.I. ALI IBIS, individually as the Parent of Zuhtu Ibis, Deceased MEHMET IBIS, individually as the Sibling of Zuhtu Ibis, Deceased CAROLANN HABEEB, as Representative of the Estate of Anne Habeeb, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Michael Patrick Iken MONICA IKEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Patrick Iken, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Patrick Iken GERARD IKEN, individually as the Sibling of Michael Patrick Iken, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Alice Ill, Deceased, Parent of decedent Frederick J. Ill, Jr. JANE C. ILL, individually as the Sibling of Frederick J. Ill, Jr., Deceased FREDERICK J. ILL, SR., individually as the Parent of Frederick J. Ill, Jr., Deceased GLORIA INGRASSIA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Noble Ingrassia, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Noble Ingrassia ELISA M. INGRASSIA, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Noble Ingrassia, Deceased ANTHONY ARCANGELO INGRASSIA, individually as the Parent of Christopher Noble Ingrassia, Deceased ANTHONY W. INGRASSIA, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Noble Ingrassia, Deceased 124

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 125 of 434

PAUL B. INGRASSIA, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Noble Ingrassia, Deceased LUCY A. AITA, individually as the Fiancé of Paul W. Innella, Deceased JOANNE IRGANG, individually as the Parent of Doug Irgang, Deceased STEVEN IRGANG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Doug Irgang, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Doug Irgang LAURI T. ISBRANDTSEN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Erik Hans Isbrandtsen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Erik Hans Isbrandtsen DIRK H. ISBRANDTSEN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Erik Hans Isbrandtsen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Erik Hans Isbrandtsen MAY MARCONET, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Waleed Iskandar, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Waleed Iskandar ANTHONY DETULLIO, individually as the Sibling of Virginia Jablonski, Deceased BARRY JABLONSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Virginia Jablonski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Virginia Jablonski DOE 47, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 47, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 47 and on behalf of minor child DOE 47 JENNIFER BRADY, individually as the Child of Michael Grady Jacobs, Deceased MARY BRADY, individually as the Child of Michael Grady Jacobs, Deceased PETER BRADY, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Michael Grady Jacobs, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Grady Jacobs 125

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 126 of 434

MICHAEL JOHN BRADY, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael Grady Jacobs, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Grady Jacobs REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Deborah B. Jacobson, Deceased, Spouse of decedent Steven A. Jacobson PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of Steven A. Jacobson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven A. Jacobson RACHEL BESS JACOBSON, individually as the Child of Steven A. Jacobson, Deceased KIMBERLY H. JACOBY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Donald Jacoby, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Donald Jacoby ANNA MAY JAGODA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jake D. Jagoda, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jake D. Jagoda LOUIS JOHN JAGODA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jake D. Jagoda, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jake D. Jagoda SNEH JAIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Yudh V. Jain, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Yudh V. Jain JULIE ANN JALBERT, individually as the Child of Robert A. Jalbert, Deceased SUZANNE E. MCCORMICK, individually as the Child of Robert A. Jalbert, Deceased CATHERINE L. JALBERT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert A. Jalbert, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert A. Jalbert MICHAEL A. JALBERT, individually as the Child of Robert A. Jalbert, Deceased PAUL H. JALBERT, individually as the Sibling of Robert A. Jalbert, Deceased MARILYN R. TRUDEAU, individually and as 126

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 127 of 434

the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Amy Nicole Jarret, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Amy Nicole Jarret ALICIA N. CURRAN, individually as the Sibling of Amy Nicole Jarret, Deceased MATTHEW R. JARRET, individually as the Sibling of Amy Nicole Jarret, Deceased MARC DOUGLAS JARRET, individually as the Sibling of Amy Nicole Jarret, Deceased ARAM P. JARRET, III, individually as the Sibling of Amy Nicole Jarret, Deceased ARAM P. JARRET, JR., individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Amy Nicole Jarret, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Amy Nicole Jarret JENNIFER JENKINS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Jenkins, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Jenkins, Jr. ALINE JENKINS, individually as the Parent of Joseph Jenkins, Jr., Deceased DEBRA JENKINS, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Jenkins, Jr., Deceased STEVEN JENKINS, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Jenkins, Jr., Deceased GORDON R. JENKINS, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Jenkins, Jr., Deceased MICHAEL JENKINS, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Jenkins, Jr., Deceased DOE 17, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 17, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 17 DOE 17, individually as the Child of DOE 17, Deceased FUMEI CHIEN HUANG, individually as the Parent of Hweidar Jian, Deceased HUI-CHENG CHIEN, individually as the Sibling of Hweidar Jian, Deceased

127

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 128 of 434

HUI-CHUAN JIAN, individually as the Sibling of Hweidar Jian, Deceased HIUCHUN JIAN, individually as the Sibling of Hweidar Jian, Deceased JU-HSIU JIAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hweidar Jian, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Hweidar Jian HAOMIN JIAN, individually as the Child of Hweidar Jian, Deceased HUI-ZON JIAN, individually as the Sibling of Hweidar Jian, Deceased DOE 131, individually as the Parent of DOE 131, Deceased DOE 131, individually as the Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 131, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 131 DOE 131, individually as the Sibling of DOE 131, Deceased DOE 131, individually as the Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 131, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 131 DAWN MARIE JOHNSON, individually as the Child of Dennis M. Johnson, Deceased ELVA JOHNSON, individually as the Parent of Dennis M. Johnson, Deceased GAIL LINDNER, individually as the Sibling of Dennis M. Johnson, Deceased DIANE CZLAPINSKI, individually as the Sibling of Dennis M. Johnson, Deceased JOYCE L. JOHNSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis M. Johnson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis M. Johnson ROBERT JOHNSON, individually as the Parent of Dennis M. Johnson, Deceased HARRY T. JONES, IV, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Allison 128

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 129 of 434

H. Jones, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Allison H. Jones MARY J. JONES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Edward Jones, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Edward Jones SUSAN JONES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Jones, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Jones JUDITH JONES, individually as the Parent of Donald T. Jones, II, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Donald T. Jones, Deceased, Parent of decedent Donald T. Jones, II WILLIAM B. JONES, II, individually as the Sibling of Donald T. Jones, II, Deceased ELLEN JORDAN, individually as the Parent of Andrew B. Jordan, Deceased ELLEN GREEN, individually as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan, Deceased ELIZABETH KOBEL, individually as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan, Deceased BERNADETTE M GIULIANI, individually as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan, Deceased MARY B JORDAN-POTASH, individually as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan, Deceased MARGARET GREGORY, individually as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan, Deceased THOMAS JORDAN, individually as the Parent of Andrew B. Jordan, Deceased THOMAS P JORDAN, individually as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan, Deceased JOHN C. JORDAN, individually as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan, Deceased JENNIFER E. JOSIAH, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jane Eileen Josiah, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jane Eileen Josiah

129

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 130 of 434

KELLY C. JOSIAH, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jane Eileen Josiah, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jane Eileen Josiah SENTIJA JOVIC, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony Jovic, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony Jovic MIRIAM JUARBE, individually as the Parent of Angel L. Juarbe, Jr., Deceased ANGEL L. JUARBE, SR., individually as the Parent of Angel L. Juarbe, Jr., Deceased RICHARD A. PECORELLA, individually as the Fiancé of Karen S. Juday, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Joan C. Kane, Deceased, Parent of decedent Vincent D. Kane, Jr. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Patricia E. Flanders, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Vincent D. Kane, Jr. ELIZABETH KANE REICH, individually as the Sibling of Vincent D. Kane, Jr., Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Vincent D. Kane, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Vincent D. Kane, Jr. PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of Vincent D. Kane, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent D. Kane, Jr. PILSOON KANG, individually as the Parent of Joon Koo Kang, Deceased JAMIE KANG, individually as the Sibling of Joon Koo Kang, Deceased JANET KANG, individually as the Sibling of Joon Koo Kang, Deceased REBECCA S. HOANG, individually as the Sibling of Joon Koo Kang, Deceased SEONG SOON KANG, individually as the Parent of Joon Koo Kang, Deceased DOE 27, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 130

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 131 of 434

27, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 27 DOE 27, individually as the Child of DOE 27, Deceased DOE 27, individually as the Child of DOE 27, Deceased HAROLD T. KAPLAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Deborah H. Kaplan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Deborah H. Kaplan FRANCINE CHARLOTTE KAPLAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robin Kaplan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robin Kaplan EDWARD HARVEY KAPLAN, individually as the Parent of Robin Kaplan, Deceased MARK KAPLAN, individually as the Sibling of Robin Kaplan, Deceased BRENDA VANDEVER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William A. Karnes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William A. Karnes KARA KASPER, individually as the Child of Charles Kasper, Deceased MELISSA KASPER, individually as the Child of Charles Kasper, Deceased LAUREEN KASPER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Kasper, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Kasper CYNTHIA ANN POLO, individually as the Child of Edward T. Keane, Deceased BARBARA E. KEANE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward T. Keane, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward T. Keane MARK EDWARD KEANE, individually as the Child of Edward T. Keane, Deceased CHARLOTTE FLORENCE KEANE, individually as the Sibling of Richard M. 131

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 132 of 434

Keane, Deceased CONSTANCE ANNE KEANE, individually as the Sibling of Richard M. Keane, Deceased THERESA IRENE WILSON, individually as the Sibling of Richard M. Keane, Deceased JUDITH ANN KEANE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard M. Keane, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard M. Keane REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Richard Matthew Keane, Deceased, Parent of decedent Richard M. Keane REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Robert F. Keane, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Richard M. Keane MATTHEW EAMON KEANE, individually as the Child of Richard M. Keane, Deceased SEAN MICHAEL KEANE, individually as the Child of Richard M. Keane, Deceased TIMOTHY BRENDAN KEANE, individually as the Child of Richard M. Keane, Deceased PATRICK JAMES KEANE, individually as the Child of Richard M. Keane, Deceased PAUL ANTHONY KEANE, individually as the Sibling of Richard M. Keane, Deceased GARRETT PAUL KEANE, individually as the Sibling of Richard M. Keane, Deceased DENISE K. KEASLER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karol Ann Keasler, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Karol Ann Keasler JOANN ANDERSON, individually as the Child of Barbara A. Keating, Deceased MICHAEL KEATING, individually and as the Administrator of the Estate of Barbara A. Keating, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara A. Keating JOHN KEATING, individually as the Child of Barbara A. Keating, Deceased

132

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 133 of 434

PAUL J. KEATING, individually as the Child of Barbara A. Keating, Deceased MARTHA SUSAN GRIMM, individually as the Parent of Leo Russell Keene, III, Deceased KRISTA SUE KEENE, individually as the Sibling of Leo Russell Keene, III, Deceased JENNIFER KEENE CLYDE, individually as the Sibling of Leo Russell Keene, III, Deceased KRISTEN M. KEENE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Leo Russell Keene, III, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Leo Russell Keene, III and on behalf of minor child M.K. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Leo R. Keene, II, Deceased, Parent of decedent Leo Russell Keene, III ALICE BUCHHOLZ KELLY, individually as the Parent of Joseph Anthony Kelly, Deceased CAROLYN KELLY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard J. Kelly, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard J. Kelly, Jr. JOANNE MARIE KELLY, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of William Hill Kelly, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Hill Kelly, Jr. MEIGAN KELLY, individually as the Sibling of William Hill Kelly, Jr., Deceased KATHLEEN K. HAMILTON, individually as the Sibling of William Hill Kelly, Jr., Deceased MAUREEN KELLY DONEGAN, individually as the Sibling of William Hill Kelly, Jr., Deceased WILLIAM HILL KELLY, SR., individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of William Hill Kelly, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Hill Kelly, Jr. CATHERINE KENNEDY MILLER, individually as the Child of Robert C. Kennedy, Deceased 133

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 134 of 434

MEREDITH ANDREWS, individually as the Child of Robert C. Kennedy, Deceased MAUREEN KENNEDY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert C. Kennedy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert C. Kennedy MARY KEOHANE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of John Richard Keohane, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Richard Keohane DARLENE KEOHANE, individually as the Sibling of John Richard Keohane, Deceased DONALD KEOHANE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of John Richard Keohane, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Richard Keohane HEDI N. KERSHAW, individually and as the Executor of the Estate of Ralph Francis Kershaw, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ralph Francis Kershaw DIANNE P. KERWIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald T. Kerwin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald T. Kerwin GRANVILETTE W. KESTENBAUM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Howard L. Kestenbaum, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Howard L. Kestenbaum ROBERT DOW, individually as the Domestic Partner of Ruth Ketler, Deceased NAZAM KHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sarah Khan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sarah Khan TAHIRA KHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Taimour Khan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Taimour Khan ZARA KHAN, individually as the Sibling of Taimour Khan, Deceased 134

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 135 of 434

SOLOMON GAYLE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Seilai Khoo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Seilai Khoo PATRICIA LYNN KIEFER, individually as the Parent of Michael Vernon Kiefer, Deceased HENRY F. KIEFER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Vernon Kiefer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Vernon Kiefer DARLENE THERESE KINNEY, individually as the Parent of Brian Kevin Kinney, Deceased ALISON KINNEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian Kevin Kinney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brian Kevin Kinney NORMAN P. KINNEY, individually as the Parent of Brian Kevin Kinney, Deceased DONNA M. KIRBY, individually as the Parent of Chris M. Kirby, Deceased KELLYANN RACANELLI, individually as the Sibling of Chris M. Kirby, Deceased JENNIFER M. KIRBY, individually as the Sibling of Chris M. Kirby, Deceased JAMES M. KIRBY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Chris M. Kirby, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Chris M. Kirby BRIAN P. KIRBY, individually as the Sibling of Chris M. Kirby, Deceased JAMES M. KIRBY, III, individually as the Sibling of Chris M. Kirby, Deceased LAUREN KIRSCHBAUM, individually as the Child of Howard Barry Kirschbaum, Deceased ROCHELLE KIRSCHBAUM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Howard Barry Kirschbaum, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Howard Barry Kirschbaum 135

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 136 of 434

MATTHEW ADAM KIRSCHBAUM, individually as the Child of Howard Barry Kirschbaum, Deceased BARBARA KIRWIN, individually as the Parent of Glenn Davis Kirwin, Deceased PAUL HARRIS KIRWIN, individually as the Parent of Glenn Davis Kirwin, Deceased LAUREN KLEINBERG, individually as the Child of Alan D. Kleinberg, Deceased VIVIAN LERNER SHOEMAKER, individually as the Parent of Alan D. Kleinberg, Deceased MARCI KLEINBERG-BANDELLI, individually as the Sibling of Alan D. Kleinberg, Deceased MARLA PARKER, individually as the Sibling of Alan D. Kleinberg, Deceased DOE 05, individually as the Sibling of DOE 05, Deceased MINDY KLEINBERG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alan D. Kleinberg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alan D. Kleinberg REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 05, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 05 JACOB KLEINBERG, individually as the Child of Alan D. Kleinberg, Deceased SAM KLEINBERG, individually as the Child of Alan D. Kleinberg, Deceased PATRICIA B. KNOX, individually as the Parent of Thomas Patrick Knox, Deceased MARY ELLEN KNOX, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox, Deceased PATRICIA B. LALLEY, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox, Deceased KATHLEEN DOOLAN, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox, Deceased NANCY S. KNOX, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 136

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 137 of 434

Thomas Patrick Knox, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Patrick Knox DENIS KNOX, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox, Deceased JAMES KNOX, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Leokadia Kobus, Deceased, Parent of decedent Deborah Kobus ROBERT KOBUS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Deborah Kobus, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Deborah Kobus IRENE SMOLICZ, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank J. Koestner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frank J. Koestner and on behalf of minor child C.K. MICHELLE A. STABILE, individually as the Fiancé of Frank J. Koestner, Deceased MARIA KOESTNER, individually as the Parent of Frank J. Koestner, Deceased JULIANNA M. LANZER, individually as the Sibling of Frank J. Koestner, Deceased MELISSA WHITE, individually as the Fiancé of Ryan Ashley Kohart, Deceased JOY A. KOHART, individually as the Parent of Ryan Ashley Kohart, Deceased BRETT D. KOHART, individually as the Sibling of Ryan Ashley Kohart, Deceased ADAM P. KOHART, individually as the Sibling of Ryan Ashley Kohart, Deceased GEOFFREY A. KOHART, JR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ryan Ashley Kohart, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ryan Ashley Kohart GEOFFREY A. KOHART, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ryan Ashley Kohart, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ryan Ashley Kohart 137

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 138 of 434

PATRICIA ANNE KONDRATENKO, individually as the Parent of Suzanne Kondratenko, Deceased KATHERINE J KONDRATENKO, individually as the Sibling of Suzanne Kondratenko, Deceased CAROLINE RUESTOW, individually as the Sibling of Suzanne Kondratenko, Deceased PATRICIA KONDRATENKO-COLLINS, individually as the Sibling of Suzanne Kondratenko, Deceased SARAH M. KONDRATENKO, individually as the Sibling of Suzanne Kondratenko, Deceased AIMEE E GARRISON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Suzanne Kondratenko, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Suzanne Kondratenko ERIC KONDRATENKO, individually as the Parent of Suzanne Kondratenko, Deceased JOYCE MERCER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Kopytko, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Kopytko CHRISTINE KOPYTKO, individually as the Sibling of Scott Kopytko, Deceased SUSANNA FERM, individually as the Fiancé of Bojan Kostic, Deceased NINA KOSTIC, individually as the Sibling of Bojan Kostic, Deceased OLGA KOSTIC-JOVANOVIC, individually as the Sibling of Bojan Kostic, Deceased ZOE P. KOUSOULIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Danielle Kousoulis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Danielle Kousoulis ELENI KOUSOULIS, individually as the Sibling of Danielle Kousoulis, Deceased FAITH K. HAGERTY, individually as the Sibling of Danielle Kousoulis, Deceased GEORGE P. KOUSOULIS, individually as the 138

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 139 of 434

Sibling of Danielle Kousoulis, Deceased LISA MARIA INZERILLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William E. Krukowski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William E. Krukowski DOE 51, individually as the Child of DOE 51, Deceased DOE 51, individually as the Child of DOE 51, Deceased DOE 51, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 51, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 51 and on behalf of minor child DOE 51 YACHIYO KUGE, individually as the Parent of Toshiya Kuge, Deceased HAJIME KUGE, individually as the Parent of Toshiya Kuge, Deceased NAOYA KUGE, individually as the Sibling of Toshiya Kuge, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Lois H. Kumpel, Deceased, Parent of decedent Kenneth B. Kumpel NANCY KUMPEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth B. Kumpel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth B. Kumpel KRISTEN KUVEIKIS, individually as the Child of Thomas J. Kuveikis, Deceased JAMES KUVEIKIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Kuveikis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. Kuveikis HARLAN GENE YANCEY, individually as the Parent of Kathryn Laborie, Deceased ERIC LABORIE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kathryn Laborie, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kathryn Laborie SONIA GAWAS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ganesh 139

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 140 of 434

Ladkat, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ganesh Ladkat DOLORES LADLEY, individually as the Parent of James Patrick Ladley, Deceased EILEEN LADLEY, individually as the Sibling of James Patrick Ladley, Deceased MARY ANN RAYMOND, individually as the Sibling of James Patrick Ladley, Deceased DANIEL EDWARD LADLEY, individually as the Sibling of James Patrick Ladley, Deceased PATRICK JOHN LADLEY, individually as the Sibling of James Patrick Ladley, Deceased DOMINICK V. LAFALCE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph A. LaFalce, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph A. LaFalce ANITA LAFOND KORSONSKY, individually as the Sibling of Jeanette Lafond-Menichino, Deceased SAMUEL J. LAFORTE, individually as the Sibling of Michael LaForte, Deceased MADELYN BEATRICE LAFRANCE, individually as the Parent of Alan Charles LaFrance, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Aubrey J. LaFrance, Deceased, Parent of decedent Alan Charles LaFrance HUI FEN PAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Neil Kwong-Wah Lai, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Neil Kwong-Wah Lai LINDA LALAMA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Franco Lalama, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Franco Lalama FONGPEIN L. CHAN, individually as the Sibling of Chow Kwan Lam, Deceased AMY ZHANG LAM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Chow Kwan Lam, Deceased and on behalf of all 140

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 141 of 434

survivors of Chow Kwan Lam CHOW LEING LAM, individually as the Sibling of Chow Kwan Lam, Deceased JANET L. LANE, individually as the Parent of Robert T. Lane, Deceased SUZANNE R. STEVENSON, individually as the Sibling of Robert T. Lane, Deceased RICHARD L. LANE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert T. Lane, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert T. Lane JASON M. LANE, individually as the Sibling of Robert T. Lane, Deceased SANDRA PANGBORN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brendan Mark Lang, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brendan Mark Lang DONNA MARSH O'CONNOR, individually as the Parent of Vanessa Lang Langer, Deceased JOSEPH P. LANGLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Lou Langley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Lou Langley REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Ethel Chamberlain, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michele Lanza CYNTHIA D. ORICCHIO, individually as the Sibling of Michele Lanza, Deceased SUSAN GAIL CHAMBERLAIN, individually as the Sibling of Michele Lanza, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Albert A. Chamberlain, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michele Lanza ALBERT G. CHAMBERLAIN, individually as the Sibling of Michele Lanza, Deceased DOE 65, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate ofDOE 65, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 65 and on behalf of minor child DOE 65 DANIELLE LEMACK, individually and as the 141

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 142 of 434

Co-Administrator of the Estate of Judith Camilla Larocque, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Judith Camilla Larocque CARIE LEMACK, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Judith Camilla Larocque, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Judith Camilla Larocque JANET L. SATTERFIELD, individually as the Parent of Christopher R. Larrabee, Deceased NICOLE LARRABEE, individually as the Sibling of Christopher R. Larrabee, Deceased PAIGE M. LARRABEE, individually as the Sibling of Christopher R. Larrabee, Deceased JESSICA LARRABEE, individually as the Sibling of Christopher R. Larrabee, Deceased STEPHEN R. LARRABEE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher R. Larrabee, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher R. Larrabee SCOTT LARRABEE, individually as the Sibling of Christopher R. Larrabee, Deceased CAROLANN LARSEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Larsen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Larsen and on behalf of minor child A.L. LINDA LEBLANC, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Natalie Janis Lasden, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Natalie Janis Lasden BARBARA J. LASKO, individually as the Parent of Gary E. Lasko, Deceased KIM LOMBARD LASKO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gary E. Lasko, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gary E. Lasko EDWARD R. LASKO, individually as the Parent of Gary E. Lasko, Deceased JENNIFER LASZCZYNSKI, individually as the Child of Paul Laszczynski, Deceased 142

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 143 of 434

AMY LASZCZYNSKI, individually as the Child of Paul Laszczynski, Deceased CHARLENE TALARICO, individually as the Fiancé of Paul Laszczynski, Deceased RAPHAEL P. EVANS, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey LaTouche, Deceased DONNA D. BHAGWAN, individually as the Child of Jeffrey LaTouche, Deceased ROSANNA LATOUCHE, individually as the Parent of Jeffrey LaTouche, Deceased ESTHER G. LATOUCHE, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey LaTouche, Deceased VIRGINIA LATOUCHE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey LaTouche, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey LaTouche JEFFERSON PATTERSON, individually as the Child of Jeffrey LaTouche, Deceased KARL LATOUCHE, individually as the Child of Jeffrey LaTouche, Deceased MICHAEL SAMUEL, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey LaTouche, Deceased BIRTHER LAURENCIN-BANNISTER, individually as the Child of Charles Augustus Laurencin, Deceased JERCIENNE LAURENCIN, individually as the Child of Charles Augustus Laurencin, Deceased MARY JANE LAVACHE, individually as the Child of Maria LaVache, Deceased BERNICE M. LAVACHE, individually as the Child of Maria LaVache, Deceased JOSEPH L. LAVACHE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maria LaVache, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Maria LaVache BARBARA J. DZIADEK, individually as the Sibling of Denis Lavelle, Deceased PATRICIA CALOIA, as Representative of the 143

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 144 of 434

Estate of Emily Lavelle, Deceased, Parent of decedent Denis Lavelle KATHLEEN C. PALACIO, individually as the Sibling of Denis Lavelle, Deceased PATRICIA CALOIA, individually as the Sibling of Denis Lavelle, Deceased MARIE ANN PAPROCKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Denis Lavelle, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Denis Lavelle DOLORES LAVERDE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeannine LaVerde, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeannine LaVerde THOMAS A. LAVERDE, individually as the Sibling of Jeannine LaVerde, Deceased DEENA LAVERTY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anna A. Laverty, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anna A. Laverty KEVIN P. LAVERTY, individually as the Spouse of Anna A. Laverty, Deceased VICTORIA LOUISE LAWN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Lawn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Lawn EILEEN LAWRENCE, individually as the Parent of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., Deceased ELIZABETH E. LAWRENCE ANDERSEN, individually as the Sibling of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., Deceased SUZANNE LAWRENCE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr. ROBERT A. LAWRENCE, individually as the Parent of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., Deceased WALTER LAWRENCE, individually as the Sibling of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., Deceased 144

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 145 of 434

LAURIE MILLER LAYCHAK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David William Laychak, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David William Laychak JEANETTE LEAHY, individually as the Parent of James P. Leahy, Deceased MICHELE SAFATLE, individually as the Sibling of James P. Leahy, Deceased DANIELLE VELLA, individually as the Sibling of James P. Leahy, Deceased DENISE HENECK, individually as the Sibling of James P. Leahy, Deceased ARTHUR LEAHY, individually as the Sibling of James P. Leahy, Deceased CAROLE LEAVEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Leavey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Leavey BRIAN LEAVEY, individually as the Child of Joseph Leavey, Deceased ANN LEAVY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Neil J. Leavy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Neil J. Leavy JOHN P. LEAVY, individually as the Parent of Neil J. Leavy, Deceased MARK LEAVY, individually as the Sibling of Neil J. Leavy, Deceased ROSANNE HELEN COSTANZA, individually as the Parent of Daniel John Lee, Deceased DEBORAH ANN SCHUMANN, individually as the Sibling of Daniel John Lee, Deceased DOE 138, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 138, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 138 and on behalf of minor children DOE 138 and DOE 138 TIMOTHY PROVENZANO, individually as the Sibling of Daniel John Lee, Deceased 145

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 146 of 434

DOE 90, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 90, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 90 and on behalf of minor child DOE 90 JUNGMI LEE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dong Chul Lee, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dong Chul Lee and on behalf of minor children C.L., M.L., and D.L. NICHOLE WILLIAMS, individually as the Child of Juanita Lee, Deceased GENEVA JOHNSON, individually as the Parent of Juanita Lee, Deceased JANET JOHNSON, individually as the Sibling of Juanita Lee, Deceased CHERYL WITHERSPOON, individually as the Sibling of Juanita Lee, Deceased SHIRLEY WALKER, individually as the Sibling of Juanita Lee, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Edward N. Lee, Deceased, Spouse of decedent Juanita Lee REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Juanita Lee, Deceased, and on behalf of all survivors of Juanita Lee ANTHONY JOHNSON, individually as the Sibling of Juanita Lee, Deceased JOHN JOHNSON, individually as the Sibling of Juanita Lee, Deceased HYONG O. LEE, individually as the Parent of Linda C. Lee, Deceased MYONG H. LEE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Linda C. Lee, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Linda C. Lee REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Joan Greene, Deceased, Parent of decedent Lorraine Lee BARBARA WENTWORTH, individually as the Sibling of Lorraine Lee, Deceased 146

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 147 of 434

PATRICIA MARIE REILLY, individually as the Sibling of Lorraine Lee, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Timothy R. Greene, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Lorraine Lee THOMAS MICHAEL GREENE, individually as the Sibling of Lorraine Lee, Deceased TERENCE JOSEPH GREENE, individually as the Sibling of Lorraine Lee, Deceased JOHNNY LEE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lorraine Lee, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lorraine Lee MI YONG LEE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Myoung Woo Lee, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Myoung Woo Lee REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Lillian Lefkowitz, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stephen Paul Lefkowitz REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Rubin Lefkowitz, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stephen Paul Lefkowitz DANIEL JAY LEFKOWITZ, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Paul Lefkowitz, Deceased HAYLEY NATALIE LEHRFELD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eric Andrew Lehrfeld, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Andrew Lehrfeld and on behalf of minor child L.L. RUTH M. LEMAGNE, individually as the Parent of David Prudencio Lemagne, Deceased MAGALY J. LEMAGNE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Prudencio Lemagne, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David Prudencio Lemagne PRUDENCIO LEMAGNE, individually as the Parent of David Prudencio Lemagne, Deceased 147

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 148 of 434

REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Ann K. Lenihan, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joseph A. Lenihan SUZANNE L. FAULKNER, individually as the Sibling of Joseph A. Lenihan, Deceased INGRID MARIA LENIHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph A. Lenihan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph A. Lenihan and on behalf of minor child J.L. JOHN LENIHAN, individually as the Sibling of Joseph A. Lenihan, Deceased MELISSA LENNON, individually as the Child of John J. Lennon, Jr., Deceased LUCILLE LENNON, individually as the Parent of John J. Lennon, Jr., Deceased NANCY LENNON FRAIN, individually as the Sibling of John J. Lennon, Jr., Deceased PATRICIA LENNON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John J. Lennon, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John J. Lennon, Jr. JOHN LENNON, individually as the Child of John J. Lennon, Jr., Deceased JAMES L. LENNON, individually as the Sibling of John J. Lennon, Jr., Deceased JOHN J. LENNON, SR., individually as the Parent of John J. Lennon, Jr., Deceased JENNIFER A. LEVI-LONGYEAR, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of John D. Levi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John D. Levi DENNIS J. LEVI, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of John D. Levi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John D. Levi STEPHANIE GIGLIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Levine, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Levine, and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roni M. Levine, 148

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 149 of 434

Deceased, Parent of decedent Robert Levine JUDY LEVINHAR, individually as the Parent of Shai Levinhar, Deceased IRIS KRAMER, individually as the Sibling of Shai Levinhar, Deceased LIAT LEVINHAR, individually as the Spouse of Shai Levinhar, Deceased ZVI LEVINHAR, individually as the Parent of Shai Levinhar, Deceased RAZ LEVINHAR, individually as the Sibling of Shai Levinhar, Deceased MOR LEVINHAR, individually as the Sibling of Shai Levinhar, Deceased PEGGY SUE LEWIN, individually as the Parent of Daniel Lewin, Deceased CHARLES JAY LEWIN, individually as the Parent of Daniel Lewin, Deceased MICHAEL LEWIN, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Lewin, Deceased JONATHAN A. LEWIN, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Lewin, Deceased DOLORES LIBRETTI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Libretti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Libretti JOSEPH LIBRETTI, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Libretti, Deceased CARMEL-ANN SULLIVAN, individually as the Sibling of Ralph M. Licciardi, Deceased JENNIFER LICCIARDI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ralph M. Licciardi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ralph M. Licciardi and on behalf of minor child M.L. RALPH LICCIARDI, individually as the Child of Ralph M. Licciardi, Deceased SEBASTIANO LICCIARDI, individually as the Parent of Ralph M. Licciardi, Deceased ANTHONY LICCIARDI, individually as the 149

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 150 of 434

Sibling of Ralph M. Licciardi, Deceased DOE 44, individually as the Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 44, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Lichtschein VYACHESLAV LIGAY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Zhentta Ligay, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Zhentta Ligay and on behalf of minor child A.L. MARCIA LILLIANTHAL, individually as the Parent of Steven Barry Lillianthal, Deceased MINDI COHEN, individually as the Sibling of Steven Barry Lillianthal, Deceased SHERMAN LILLIANTHAL, individually as the Parent of Steven Barry Lillianthal, Deceased HAYDEE C. LILLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carlos R. Lillo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Carlos R. Lillo CAROLINE LILORE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Craig Damian Lilore, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Craig Damian Lilore RONG DI YOU, individually as the Parent of Wei Rong Lin, Deceased SE JUA AU, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wei Rong Lin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Wei Rong Lin and on behalf of minor children K.X.X.L. and K.Y.Z.L. ZENG LU LIN, individually as the Parent of Wei Rong Lin, Deceased HONG LIN, individually as the Sibling of Wei Rong Lin, Deceased DURYEL LINDO, individually as the Child of Nickie Lindo, Deceased DERYCK D LINDO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nickie Lindo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors 150

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 151 of 434

of Nickie Lindo CAROL ANN LINEHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas V. Linehan, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas V. Linehan, Jr. SHARON L. LINTON, individually as the Parent of Alan Patrick Linton, Jr., Deceased LAURA RENEE ANSPACH, individually as the Sibling of Alan Patrick Linton, Jr., Deceased ALAN PATRICK LINTON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alan Patrick Linton, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alan Patrick Linton, Jr. SCOTT P. LINTON, individually as the Sibling of Alan Patrick Linton, Jr., Deceased SEELOCHINI LIRIANO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francisco Alberto Liriano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Francisco Alberto Liriano and on behalf of minor child F.L. JIUN-MIN H. LIU, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of MingHao Liu, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ming-Hao Liu and on behalf of minor children A.L. and A.L. DOE 123, individually as the Parent of DOE 123, Deceased DOE 123, individually as the Sibling of DOE 123, Deceased DOE 123, individually as the Sibling of DOE 123, Deceased DOE 123, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 123, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 123 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Leopold Victor Lizzul, Deceased, Parent of decedent Martin Lizzul 151

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 152 of 434

EUGENIA R. LLANES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George Andrew Llanes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of George Andrew Llanes REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Jorge Llanes, Deceased, Parent of decedent George Andrew Llanes DOUGLAS C. CLEARY, individually as the Fiancé of Elizabeth C. Logler, Deceased ROBERT LOGLER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Elizabeth C. Logler, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Elizabeth C. Logler CATHERINE MASAK, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Catherine Lisa Loguidice, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Catherine Lisa Loguidice REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Sandra S. Weaver, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stephen V. Long MICHAEL LOGUIDICE, individually as the Sibling of Catherine Lisa Loguidice, Deceased DENING LOHEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jerome Lohez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jerome Lohez REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Sandra S. Weaver, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stephen V. Long CYNTHIA LONG, individually as the Sibling of Stephen V. Long, Deceased NANCY A. BURCHAM, individually as the Sibling of Stephen V. Long, Deceased DOE 66, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 66, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 66 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of David B. Long, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Stephen V. Long 152

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 153 of 434

GEORGE T. LONG, individually as the Parent of Stephen V. Long, Deceased GEORGE W. LONG, individually as the Sibling of Stephen V. Long, Deceased ANNE MARIA PETTUS, individually as the Parent of Laura M. Longing, Deceased KEVIN RUSSEL PETTUS, individually as the Parent of Laura M. Longing, Deceased KEITH B. PETTUS, individually as the Sibling of Laura M. Longing, Deceased CHRISTOPHER LONGING, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Laura M. Longing, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Laura M. Longing and on behalf of minor children W.A.L. and B.C.L. ELIZABETH DAVILA-LOPEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Lopez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Lopez RHONDA LOPEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maclovio Lopez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Maclovio Lopez THERESANN LOSTRANGIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Lostrangio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Lostrangio DOE 64, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 64, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 64 and on behalf of minor children DOE 64 and DOE 64 MAXINE MCCORMACK, individually as the Child of Joseph Lovero, Deceased JAMES LOVERO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Lovero, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Lovero BOBBIE JEAN LOW, individually as the Parent of Sara Elizabeth Low, Deceased REBECCA ALYSON LOW, individually as 153

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 154 of 434

the Sibling of Sara Elizabeth Low, Deceased GARY MICHAEL LOW, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sara Elizabeth Low, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sara Elizabeth Low REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Rosemary Lozowsky, Deceased, Parent of decedent John Peter Lozowsky DEBRA A. RHODY, individually as the Sibling of John Peter Lozowsky, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of John Peter Lozowsky, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent John Peter Lozowsky MAUREEN KELLY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark G. Ludvigsen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark G. Ludvigsen ASHLEY MICHELLE LUDWIG, individually as the Child of Lee Charles Ludwig, Deceased LUANN MARTIN, individually as the Sibling of Lee Charles Ludwig, Deceased MICHELLE LUDWIG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lee Charles Ludwig, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lee Charles Ludwig REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Louis Ludwig, Deceased, Parent of decedent Lee Charles Ludwig CHRISTOPHER LUDWIG, individually as the Child of Lee Charles Ludwig, Deceased LAWRENCE ANDREWS LUDWIG, individually as the Sibling of Lee Charles Ludwig, Deceased LOUIS LUDWIG, JR., individually as the Sibling of Lee Charles Ludwig, Deceased EILEEN D. LUGANO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Thomas Lugano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Thomas Lugano STEPHANIE MCCUIN, individually as the 154

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 155 of 434

Sibling of Sean Thomas Lugano, Deceased MICHAEL LUGANO, individually as the Sibling of Sean Thomas Lugano, Deceased JOHN C. LUGANO, individually as the Sibling of Sean Thomas Lugano, Deceased MARIE LUKAS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marie Lukas, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Marie Lukas MAUREEN C. LUNDER, individually as the Parent of Christopher Edmund Lunder, Deceased ROSEMARY SERCIA, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Edmund Lunder, Deceased KAREN B. LUNDER, individually and as the Administrator of the Estate of Christopher Edmund Lunder, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Edmund Lunder EDMUND LUNDER, individually as the Parent of Christopher Edmund Lunder, Deceased DAVID LUNDER, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Edmund Lunder, Deceased GERALDINE CANILLAS, individually as the Child of Anthony Luparello, Deceased MARIA LIPARI, individually as the Child of Anthony Luparello, Deceased GERALDINE LUPARELLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony Luparello, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony Luparello ANTHONY LUPARELLO, JR., individually as the Child of Anthony Luparello, Deceased EDITH LUTNICK, individually as the Sibling of Gary Frederick Lutnick, III, Deceased HOWARD LUTNICK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gary Frederick Lutnick, III, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gary Frederick Lutnick, III 155

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 156 of 434

DEBRA LUZZICONE, individually as the Sibling of Linda Anne Luzzicone, Deceased CHERYL ZAFFUTO, individually as the Sibling of Linda Anne Luzzicone, Deceased RALPH LUZZICONE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Linda Anne Luzzicone, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Linda Anne Luzzicone RALPH LUZZICONE, JR., individually and as the Administrator of the Estate of Linda Anne Luzzicone, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Linda Anne Luzzicone VALENTINA LYGINA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Alexander Lygin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alexander Lygin NATASHA LYGINA, individually as the Sibling of Alexander Lygin, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Vladimir Lygin, Deceased, Parent of decedent Alexander Lygin LORNE LYLES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of CeeCee Louise Lyles, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of CeeCee Louise Lyles MARGARET DUGDALE, individually as the Sibling of James Francis Lynch, Deceased CAROL A. PENNA, individually as the Sibling of James Francis Lynch, Deceased WILLIAM F. BURNS-LYNCH, individually as the Sibling of James Francis Lynch, Deceased DAVID W. LYNCH, individually as the Sibling of James Francis Lynch, Deceased PETER J. LYNCH, individually as the Sibling of James Francis Lynch, Deceased CATHERINE T. LYNCH, individually as the Parent of Michael F. Lynch, Deceased BARBARA MCMANUS, individually as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch, Deceased 156

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 157 of 434

BERNADETTE RAFFERTY, individually as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch, Deceased ROSEMARY ELIZABETH PUMILIA, individually as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch, Deceased MARY L. COSTER, individually as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch, Deceased DENISE LYNCH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael F. Lynch, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael F. Lynch and on behalf of minor child J.R.L. DANIEL F. LYNCH, individually as the Parent of Michael F. Lynch, Deceased DANIEL J. LYNCH, individually as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch, Deceased KATHLEEN V. LYNCH, individually as the Parent of Michael Francis Lynch, Deceased KATHLEEN ANN LYNCH, individually as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch, Deceased COLLEEN M. PARIGEN, individually as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch, Deceased MAUREEN LYNCH BAKER, individually as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch, Deceased JOHN B. LYNCH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Francis Lynch, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Francis Lynch FREDERICK LYNCH, individually as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch, Deceased PAUL LYNCH, individually as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch, Deceased JOHN B. LYNCH, JR., individually as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Marguerite Lynch, Deceased, Parent of decedent Robert H. Lynch 157

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 158 of 434

BARBARA COTTER, individually as the Sibling of Robert H. Lynch, Deceased LINDA HELCK, individually as the Sibling of Robert H. Lynch, Deceased PATRICIA CURRY, individually as the Sibling of Robert H. Lynch, Deceased DOE 69, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 69, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 69 MARGARET A. LYNCH, individually as the Parent of Sean Patrick Lynch, Deceased LAUREEN A. SUTERA, individually as the Sibling of Sean Patrick Lynch, Deceased KATHLEEN A. HALLSTROM, individually as the Sibling of Sean Patrick Lynch, Deceased COLLEEN M. WATSON, individually as the Sibling of Sean Patrick Lynch, Deceased JOHN J. LYNCH, individually as the Parent of Sean Patrick Lynch, Deceased MICHAEL J. LYNCH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Patrick Lynch, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Patrick Lynch ASHLEY NICOLE LYNCH, individually as the Child of Terence M. Lynch, Deceased TIFFANY M. LYNCH, individually as the Child of Terence M. Lynch, Deceased JACQUELINE E. LYNCH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Terence M. Lynch, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Terence M. Lynch PATRICIA LYONS, individually as the Parent of Patrick John Lyons, Deceased KELLY JEAN LYONS, individually as the Sibling of Patrick John Lyons, Deceased KRISTEN ELIZABETH LYONS, individually as the Sibling of Patrick John Lyons, Deceased IRENE LYONS- LOEFFLER, individually and 158

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 159 of 434

as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick John Lyons, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick John Lyons and on behalf of minor child P.L. BRIAN PATRICK LYONS, individually as the Parent of Patrick John Lyons, Deceased BRIAN CHARLES LYONS, individually as the Sibling of Patrick John Lyons, Deceased SEAN LYONS, individually as the Sibling of Patrick John Lyons, Deceased KENNETH J. MACE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Francis Mace, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Francis Mace KAZIMIERZ MACIEJEWSKI, individually as the Parent of Jan Maciejewski, Deceased PAWEL MACIEJEWSKI, individually as the Sibling of Jan Maciejewski, Deceased DOUGLAS MACKAY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Mackay, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Mackay MICHELLE MARIE MADDEN, individually as the Parent of Richard B. Madden, Deceased MELISSA MADDEN CROWLEY, individually as the Sibling of Richard B. Madden, Deceased MAURA LEZYNSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard B. Madden, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard B. Madden JOSHUA POWERS MADDEN, individually as the Sibling of Richard B. Madden, Deceased ROBERT TWINING MADDEN, JR., individually as the Sibling of Richard B. Madden, Deceased PENELOPE JOAN HASSELL, individually as the Sibling of Simon Maddison, Deceased ELIZABETH COLLIS, individually as the Sibling of Simon Maddison, Deceased 159

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 160 of 434

MAUREEN MADDISON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Simon Maddison, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Simon Maddison PETER JOHN MADDISON, individually as the Parent of Simon Maddison, Deceased STEPHEN PETER MADDISON, individually as the Sibling of Simon Maddison, Deceased JENNIFER LYN MAERZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Noell Maerz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Noell Maerz and on behalf of minor child N.B.M. RALPH S. MAERZ, JR., individually as the Parent of Noell Maerz, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Jean Maffeo, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joseph Maffeo SUSAN MAFFEO DRURY, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Maffeo, Deceased LINDA MAFFEO MANFREDI, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Maffeo, Deceased DEBRA MAFFEO MORRI, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Maffeo, Deceased DONNA MAFFEO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Maffeo, Deceased LINDA MAFFEO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Maffeo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Maffeo LOUIS MAFFEO, individually as the Parent of Joseph Maffeo, Deceased BETH A. MAHON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas A. Mahon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas A. Mahon and on behalf of minor child S.E.M. DONNA MAHONEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William J. Mahoney, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William J. Mahoney, 160

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 161 of 434

Jr. BEVERLY M. MALER, individually as the Parent of Alfred Russell Maler, Deceased BEVERLY V. MALER, individually as the Sibling of Alfred Russell Maler, Deceased JEANINE M. SHERMAN, individually as the Sibling of Alfred Russell Maler, Deceased DOE 59, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 59, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 59 and on behalf of minor children DOE 59 and DOE 59 KEITH E. MALER, individually as the Sibling of Alfred Russell Maler, Deceased EDWARD DWAIN MALER, individually as the Sibling of Alfred Russell Maler, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Michael A. Maler, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Alfred Russell Maler KATHLEEN MALONEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Maloney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Maloney and on behalf of minor children M.M. and J.M. DOE 58, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 58, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 58 and on behalf of minor children DOE 58, DOE 58, AND DOE 58 KATHLEEN MANGANO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Mangano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Mangano ROBERT WILLIAM HARVEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sarah Elizabeth Manley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sarah Elizabeth Manley KENNETH R. MANNETTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Debra M. Mannetta, Deceased and on behalf of 161

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 162 of 434

all survivors of Debra M. Mannetta and on behalf of minor child J.M. and A.M. MELISSA EZRO as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Elizabeth Kemmerer, Deceased, Daughter of decedent Hilda Marcin CAROLE O'HARE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hilda Marcin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Hilda Marcin SHAKEH MARDIKIAN, individually as the Parent of Peter Edward Mardikian, Deceased MONICA N. MARDIKIAN, individually as the Sibling of Peter Edward Mardikian, Deceased ALEXANDER PAUL MARDIKIAN, individually as the Parent of Peter Edward Mardikian, Deceased AMELIA J. MARGIOTTA, individually as the Parent of Charles Joseph Margiotta, Deceased NORMA MARGIOTTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Joseph Margiotta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Joseph Margiotta CHARLES V. MARGIOTTA, individually as the Parent of Charles Joseph Margiotta, Deceased MICHAEL MARGIOTTA, individually as the Sibling of Charles Joseph Margiotta, Deceased CHARLES VITO MARGIOTTA, III, individually as the Child of Charles Joseph Margiotta, Deceased MARY ANN MARINO, individually as the Parent of Kenneth Marino, Deceased LYNDA ANN MARINO, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth Marino, Deceased KATRINA MARGIT MARINO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth Marino, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth Marino and on behalf of minor child T.K.M. 162

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 163 of 434

PAT MARINO, individually as the Parent of Kenneth Marino, Deceased ANTONINA JOAN MARINO, individually as the Parent of Vita Marino, Deceased JAMES MARTIN MARINO, individually as the Sibling of Vita Marino, Deceased MARTIN ANTHONY MARINO, individually as the Sibling of Vita Marino, Deceased MICHAEL PATRICK MARINO, individually as the Sibling of Vita Marino, Deceased DOE 38, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 38, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 38 ROSEMARY CLAIRE MEYER, individually as the Parent of Kevin D. Marlo, Deceased DENNIS MARLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin D. Marlo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin D. Marlo JODI A. MARRERO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jose Marrero, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jose Marrero REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Doreen E. Rowland, Deceased, Sibling of decedent John Daniel Marshall JEANETTE A. MARSHALL, individually as the Parent of John Daniel Marshall, Deceased LORI T. MARSHALL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Daniel Marshall, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Daniel Marshall and on behalf of minor child J.M.M. DONN E. MARSHALL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Shelley A. Marshall, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Shelley A. Marshall and on behalf of minor child C.H.M. JOHN A. MARTIN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Karen A. 163

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 164 of 434

Martin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Karen A. Martin REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Paul R. Martin, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Karren A. Martin DEBORAH D. MARTIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William J. Martin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William J. Martin REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Luis Gaston, Deceased, Parent of decedent Betsy Martinez REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Betsy Martinez, Deceased, and on behalf of all survivors of Betsy Martinez DOE 124, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 124, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 124 and behalf of minor children DOE 124, DOE 124, DOE 124, and DOE 124 MICHAEL JESSE MARTINEZ, individually as the Child of Jose Angel Martinez, Jr., Deceased LOURDES LEBRON, individually as the Sibling of Waleska Martinez, Deceased MARINO CALDERON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lizie Martinez-Calderon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lizie MartinezCalderon LISA MARTINI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Richard Martini, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Richard Martini REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Mildred Martino, Deceased, Parent of decedent Anne Marie Martino-Cramer PATRICIA NILSEN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Anne Marie Martino-Cramer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anne Marie Martino-Cramer 164

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 165 of 434

ANTHONY DEMITRIO MARTINO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Anne Marie Martino-Cramer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anne Marie Martino-Cramer THERESA BEVILACQUA as Personal Representative of the Estate of Joan Masi, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stephen F. Masi THERESA BEVILACQUA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen F. Masi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen F. Masi STEPHEN J. MASI, individually as the Child of Stephen F. Masi, Deceased ANNA ELLA CIMAROLI, individually as the Parent of Patricia Ann Massari, Deceased RICHARD PATRICK CIMAROLI, individually as the Parent of Patricia Ann Massari, Deceased JOSEPH CIMAROLI, individually as the Sibling of Patricia Ann Massari, Deceased JOSEPHINE HOLUBAR, individually as the Parent of Michael Massaroli, Deceased JOANN CLEARY, individually as the Sibling of Michael Massaroli, Deceased DIANE MASSAROLI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Massaroli, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Massaroli ROSALIE ANNETTE MASTRANDREA, individually as the Parent of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., Deceased LYNN MARIE PARAGANO, individually as the Sibling of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., Deceased KAREN ELIZABETH MASTRANDREA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr. ROBERT MASTRANDREA, individually as 165

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 166 of 434

the Sibling of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., Deceased PHILIP WILLIAM MASTRANDREA, SR., individually as the Parent of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., Deceased ISABELLE MASTROCINQUE, individually as the Parent of Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr., Deceased SHARON SWAILES, individually as the Sibling of Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr., Deceased RUDY MASTOCINQUE, SR., individually as the Parent of Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr., Deceased RUDY MASTROCINQUE, SR., individually as the Parent of Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr., Deceased TERESA MATHAI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Mathai, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Mathai MARGARET LOUISA MATHERS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles W. Mathers, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Charles W. Mathers REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Marguerite Mattson, Deceased, Parent of decedent Robert Mattson JEAN E. MATTSON, individually as the Child of Robert Mattson, Deceased ELIZABETH A. MATTSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Mattson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Mattson JAMES F. MATTSON, individually as the Child of Robert Mattson, Deceased WILLIAM G. MATTSON, individually as the Sibling of Robert Mattson, Deceased DENISE MATUZA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Walter Matuza, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Walter Matuza 166

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 167 of 434

MARGARET MAURO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dorothy Mauro, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dorothy Mauro NANCY A. MAY, individually as the Parent of Renee A. May, Deceased RONALD F. MAY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Renee A. May, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Renee A. May JEFFREY M. MAY, individually as the Sibling of Renee A. May, Deceased KENNETH MAY, individually as the Sibling of Renee A. May, Deceased DAVID SPIVOCK, JR., individually as the Fiancé of Renee A. May, Deceased, and on behalf of his unborn child, Deceased SUSAN M. BRANNIGAN, individually as the Child of Edward Mazzella, Jr., Deceased CATHERINE MAZZELLA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Mazzella, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Mazzella, Jr. MICHAEL T. MAZZELLA, individually as the Child of Edward Mazzella, Jr., Deceased CATHERINE MAZZOTTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jennifer Mazzotta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Mazzotta MICHELLE BONETTI, individually as the Sibling of Jennifer Mazzotta, Deceased ANTHONY ROMAN, individually as the Fiancé of Jennifer Mazzotta, Deceased VITO V. MAZZOTTA, individually as the Parent of Jennifer Mazzotta, Deceased CHARLES MAZZOTTA, individually as the Sibling of Jennifer Mazzotta, Deceased VERTISTINE BEAMAN MBAYA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kaaria William Mbaya, 167

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 168 of 434

Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kaaria William Mbaya KIBABU MBAYA, individually as the Sibling of Kaaria William Mbaya, Deceased NJUE W. MBAYA, individually as the Sibling of Kaaria William Mbaya, Deceased DAWN MCALEESE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian G. McAleese, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brian G. McAleese and on behalf of minor children A.M. and L.M. MARGARET E. CRUZ, individually as the Domestic Partner of Patricia A. McAneney, Deceased JAMES MCANENEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patricia A. McAneney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patricia A. McAneney SHEILA MCPHERSON, individually as the Sibling of Colin Richard McArthur, Deceased PHILOMENA MCAVOY, individually as the Parent of John K. McAvoy, Deceased PAULA M. MCAVOY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John K. McAvoy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John K. McAvoy MICHAEL MCAVOY, individually as the Sibling of John K. McAvoy, Deceased MARSHA K. MCBRAYER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth M. McBrayer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth M. McBrayer LYNN C. MCCABE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael J. McCabe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael J. McCabe NATALIE MARY MCCANN, individually as the Parent of Thomas J. McCann, Deceased NATALIE MARY MORIARTY, individually as the Sibling of Thomas J. McCann, Deceased 168

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 169 of 434

ANNE MARIE MCCANN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. McCann, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. McCann GEORGE GERARD MCCANN, individually as the Sibling of Thomas J. McCann, Deceased MARIE MCCARTHY, individually as the Parent of Kevin Micheal McCarthy, Deceased KATHLEEN MARIE SULLIVAN, individually as the Sibling of Kevin Micheal McCarthy, Deceased DEBRA MENICH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin Micheal McCarthy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Micheal McCarthy CHARLES MCCARTHY, JR., individually as the Sibling of Kevin Micheal McCarthy, Deceased CHARLES MCCARTHY, SR., individually as the Parent of Kevin Micheal McCarthy, Deceased RUFUS J. MCDAY as Personal Representative of the Estate of Cynthia Elaine McDay, Deceased, Parent of decedent Tonyell F. McDay REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Tonyell F. McDay, Deceased, and on behalf of all survivors of Tonyell F. McDay RUFUS J. MCDAY, individually as the Parent of Tonyell F. McDay, Deceased RUVAUGHN MCDAY, individually as the Sibling of Tonyell F. McDay, Deceased JACQUELINE A. MCDERMOTT, individually as the Parent of Matthew Thomas McDermott, Deceased MARGARET MCDERMOTT, individually as the Sibling of Matthew Thomas McDermott, Deceased SUZANNE P. MCDERMOTT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew Thomas McDermott, Deceased and 169

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 170 of 434

on behalf of all survivors of Matthew Thomas McDermott JOHN E. MCDERMOTT, individually as the Parent of Matthew Thomas McDermott, Deceased JOHN C. MCDERMOTT, individually as the Sibling of Matthew Thomas McDermott, Deceased DOE 139, individually as Spouse and as the Personal Representative DOE 139, Deceased, and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 139, and on behalf of minor children DOE 139 and DOE 139 ANN CLAIRE MCDONNELL, individually as the Parent of Brian G. McDonnell, Deceased ALICIA ARANCIBIA, individually as the Sibling of Brian G. McDonnell, Deceased MARGARET MCDONNELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian G. McDonnell, Deceased and on behalf of minor children K.M. and T.M. and on behalf of all survivors of Brian G. McDonnell ROBERT MCDONNELL, individually as the Sibling of Brian G. McDonnell, Deceased KEVIN MICHAEL MCDONNELL, individually as the Sibling of Brian G. McDonnell, Deceased CHERYL ANN MCDONNELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Patrick McDonnell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Patrick McDonnell and on behalf of minor children B.M.M. and K.M.M. BONNIE MCENEANEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eamon McEneaney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eamon McEneaney AGNES MARIE MCERLEAN, individually as the Parent of John T. McErlean, Jr., Deceased MARIE MCERLEAN HUNTER, individually as the Sibling of John T. McErlean, Jr., 170

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 171 of 434

Deceased AGNES MARIE DUHAMEL, individually as the Sibling of John T. McErlean, Jr., Deceased CATHERINE FRANCESE, individually as the Sibling of John T. McErlean, Jr., Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Thomas M. McErlean, Deceased, Sibling of decedent John T. McErlean, Jr. JOHN T. MCERLEAN, SR., individually as the Parent of John T. McErlean, Jr., Deceased PATRICIA D. MCGINLY, individually as the Parent of Mark Ryan McGinly, Deceased WILLIAM C. MCGINLY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Ryan McGinly, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Ryan McGinly SEAN M. MCGINLY, individually as the Sibling of Mark Ryan McGinly, Deceased ANDREW M. MCGINLY, individually as the Sibling of Mark Ryan McGinly, Deceased MARILYN MCGOVERN ZURICA, individually as the Sibling of William J. McGovern, Deceased MARY SUE MCGOVERN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William J. McGovern, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William J. McGovern FRANCES N. SENNAS, individually as the Parent of Stacey Sennas McGowan, Deceased SEMO P. SENNAS, individually as the Parent of Stacey Sennas McGowan, Deceased DANIELLE MCGUINN, individually as the Child of Francis Noel McGuinn, Deceased LYNN S. MCGUINN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francis Noel McGuinn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Francis Noel McGuinn DANIELLE MCGUIRE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick McGuire, Deceased and on behalf of all 171

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 172 of 434

survivors of Patrick McGuire DOE 56, individually as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 56, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 56 DOE 56, individually as the Sibling of DOE 56, Deceased DOE 56, individually as the Sibling of DOE 56, Deceased BERNADETTE MARIE MCHUGH, individually as the Parent of Denis J. McHugh, III, Deceased BERNADETTE MCHUGH TORRES, individually as the Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Denis J. McHugh, III, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Denis J. McHugh, III TIMOTHY S. MCHUGH, individually as the Sibling of Denis J. McHugh, III, Deceased UNA MARGARET MCHUGH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis P. McHugh, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis P. McHugh and on behalf of minor children J.M., C.M., and S.M. MARIA C. MCHUGH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael E. McHugh, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. McHugh, Jr. and on behalf of minor child C.J.M. JEANNINE MCINTYRE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald J. McIntyre, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Donald J. McIntyre and on behalf of minor child L.M. AGNES MCKENNA, individually as the Parent of Stephanie McKenna, Deceased PATRICIA MCKENNA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephanie McKenna, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephanie McKenna EUGENE MCKENNA, individually as the 172

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 173 of 434

Parent of Stephanie McKenna, Deceased MAUREEN SPROHA, as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Gavin McMahon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gavin McMahon JOHN A. SPROHA, SR., as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Gavin McMahon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gavin McMahon KATHRYN WALKER MCNEAL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel W. McNeal, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel W. McNeal JENNIFER MCNULTY-AHERN, individually as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty, Deceased CATHERINE MCNULTY, individually as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty, Deceased HELEN MCNULTY, individually as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty, Deceased CLIVE MCNULTY, individually as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty, Deceased MIKE MCNULTY, individually as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty, Deceased LUKE MCNULTY, individually as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty, Deceased WILLIAM JORN SKEAD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Sheila McNulty, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christine Sheila McNulty RICHARD MCNULTY as Personal Representative of the Estate of Rosanne McNulty, Deceased, parent of decedent Sean Peter McNulty RICHARD MCNULTY as Personal Representative of the Estate of Gerald R. McNulty, III, Deceased, parent of decedent Sean Peter McNulty RICHARD MCNULTY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 173

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 174 of 434

Sean Peter McNulty, Deceased, and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Peter McNulty, SARA SCHULTZ, individually as the Sibling of Sean Peter McNulty, Deceased BRIDGETTE MCNULTY, individually as the Sibling of Sean Peter McNulty, Deceased MICHELLE MCNULTY, individually as the sibling of Sean Peter McNulty, Deceased KATHERINE M. RICHARDSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert W. McPadden, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert W. McPadden LYNN MCWILLIAMS, individually as the Sibling of Martin Edward McWilliams, Deceased DOE 85, individually as the domestic partner as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 85, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 85 and on behalf of minor child S.R.M. MARY MCWILLIAMS, individually as the Parent of Martin Edward McWilliams, Deceased BARBARA MCWILLIAMS, individually as the Sibling of Martin Edward McWilliams, Deceased JOSEPH MCWILLIAMS, individually as the Sibling of Martin Edward McWilliams, Deceased ENID MEDINA, individually as the Child of Abigail Medina, Deceased ELI MEDINA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Abigail Medina, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Abigail Medina MICHAEL TAVOLARELLA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Deborah Medwig, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Deborah Medwig MAUREEN E. MEEHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 174

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 175 of 434

William J. Meehan, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William J. Meehan, Jr. DANIEL A. MEEHAN, individually as the Child of William J. Meehan, Jr., Deceased WILLIAM MEEHAN, III, individually as the Child of William J. Meehan, Jr., Deceased GOPAL MEHTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alok K. Mehta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alok K. Mehta JOANNE MEISENHEIMER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Raymond Meisenheimer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Raymond Meisenheimer JULIA HERNANDEZ, individually as the Domestic Partner of Antonio Melendez, Deceased RAMON MELENDEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Melendez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Melendez JOYCE MELTZER, individually as the Parent of Stuart Todd Meltzer, Deceased LISA MELTZER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stuart Todd Meltzer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stuart Todd Meltzer ZACHARY MELTZER, individually as the Parent of Stuart Todd Meltzer, Deceased KENNETH MELTZER, individually as the Sibling of Stuart Todd Meltzer, Deceased LAWRENCE MELTZER, individually as the Sibling of Stuart Todd Meltzer, Deceased VICTOR BARAHONA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Diarelia J. Mena, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Diarelia J. Mena and on behalf of minor child K.A.B. EARL A. DORSEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dora 175

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 176 of 434

Marie Menchaca, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dora Marie Menchaca KERRI ANN MENDEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Mendez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Mendez MYRTLE BAZIL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Shevonne Olicia Mentis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Shevonne Olicia Mentis DEBRA MERCURIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ralph Mercurio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ralph Mercurio BARBARA MERDINGER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alan Merdinger, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alan Merdinger REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Zenaida Merino, Deceased, Parent of decedent George Merino MARIA LOURDES LEHR, individually as the Sibling of George Merino, Deceased LUIS MERINO, individually as the Parent of George Merino, Deceased WENDY ANNE METZ, individually as the Sibling of Raymond Joseph Metz, III, Deceased RAYMOND JOSEPH METZ, JR., individually as the Parent of Raymond Joseph Metz, III, Deceased MAUREEN RACIOPPI, individually as the Sibling of Peter T. Milano, Deceased PATRICIA MILANO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter T. Milano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter T. Milano ALFRED MILANO, individually as the Sibling of Peter T. Milano, Deceased THOMAS MILANO, individually as the Sibling of Peter T. Milano, Deceased 176

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 177 of 434

FRANK MILANO, individually as the Sibling of Peter T. Milano, Deceased ADELE MILANOWYCZ, individually as the Parent of Gregory Milanowycz, Deceased JOSEPH M. MILANOWYCZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory Milanowycz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory Milanowycz STEVEN MILANOWYCZ, individually as the Sibling of Gregory Milanowycz, Deceased HOLLY ANN MILLER HEDLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Craig James Miller, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Craig James Miller and on behalf of minor children C.J.M. and C.J.M. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Stella Lazarra, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joel Miller SONDRA BEVERLY FONER, individually as the Sibling of Joel Miller, Deceased ADAM ERIC MILLER, individually as the Child of Joel Miller, Deceased PATRICIA SKIC, individually as the Fiancé of Michael Matthew Miller, Deceased BETTY ANN MILLER, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael Matthew Miller, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Matthew Miller REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of James H. Miller, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael Matthew Miller CATHERINE STEFANI, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Nicole Carol Miller, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Nicole Carol Miller TIFFNEY MILLER, individually as the Sibling of Nicole Carol Miller, Deceased DAVID JAMES MILLER, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Nicole Carol Miller, Deceased and on behalf of all 177

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 178 of 434

survivors of Nicole Carol Miller MITOKO MILLER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert C. Miller, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert C. Miller, Jr. TERRY RICHARD MILLER, individually as the Sibling of Robert C. Miller, Jr., Deceased JAMES RONALD MILLER, individually as the Sibling of Robert C. Miller, Jr., Deceased IVY MARIA MORENO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Yvette Nicole Miller, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Yvette Nicole Miller TOBY MILLMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benjamin Millman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Benjamin Millman CHARLES M. MILLS, III, individually as the Child of Charles M. Mills, II, Deceased PAULA A. MINARA, individually as the Spouse of Robert Minara, Deceased CHRISTIAN MINARA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Robert Minara, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Minara RYAN PAUL MINARA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Robert Minara, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Minara ANTONINA MINGIONE, individually as the Parent of Thomas Mingione, Deceased GERALD MINGIONE, individually as the Parent of Thomas Mingione, Deceased PHILOMENA MISTRULLI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph D. Mistrulli, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph D. Mistrulli ANGELA M. MISTRULLI-CANTONE, individually as the Child of Joseph D. Mistrulli, Deceased 178

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 179 of 434

JOSEPH J. MISTRULLI, individually as the Child of Joseph D. Mistrulli, Deceased MARY ANN MISTRULLI-ROSSER, individually as the Child of Joseph D. Mistrulli, Deceased CHRISTINE MITCHELL, individually as the Child of Paul T. Mitchell, Deceased JENNIFER MITCHELL, individually as the Child of Paul T. Mitchell, Deceased MARIE D. MITCHELL, individually as the Sibling of Paul T. Mitchell, Deceased MAUREEN MITCHELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul T. Mitchell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul T. Mitchell LAURA MARIE LOPEZ, individually as the Child of Richard P. Miuccio, Deceased MARY URS, individually as the Sibling of Richard P. Miuccio, Deceased JOYCE MIUCCIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard P. Miuccio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard P. Miuccio OWEN RICHARD MIUCCIO, individually as the Child of Richard P. Miuccio, Deceased THOMAS PAUL MIUCCIO, individually as the Child of Richard P. Miuccio, Deceased ROBERT PETER MIUCCIO, SR., individually as the Sibling of Richard P. Miuccio, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Kathleen Mladenik, Deceased, Parent of decedent Jeffrey P. Mladenik SUZANNE S. MLADENIK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey P. Mladenik, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey P. Mladenik and on behalf of minor child B.M. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Richard Mladenik, Deceased, Parent of decedent Jeffrey P. Mladenik 179

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 180 of 434

SCOTT L. MLADENIK, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey P. Mladenik, Deceased MICHAEL MLADENIK, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey P. Mladenik, Deceased HORTENSIA GONZALEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis Mojica, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis Mojica VALENTINA FERREIRA DIAZ, individually as the Spouse of Manuel Dejesus Molina, Deceased MARINA MOLINA, individually as the Parent of Manuel Dejesus Molina, Deceased MARIA CARMEN MOLINA, individually as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina, Deceased FANNY DEJESUS MOLINA, individually as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina, Deceased MILEDE ATLAGRACIA MOLINA, individually as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina, Deceased JUAN JOSE MOLINA, individually as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina, Deceased RAMON DEJESUS MOLINA, individually as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina, Deceased JOAN OLIVIA MOLINARO, individually as the Parent of Carl Eugene Molinaro, Deceased DEBORAH ANN ATCHLEY, individually as the Sibling of Carl Eugene Molinaro, Deceased DOE 41, individually as the Sibling of DOE 41, Deceased DOE 41, individually as the Sibling of DOE 41, Deceased DOE 41, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate ofDOE 41, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 41 and on behalf of minor child DOE 41 EUGENE MOLINARO, individually as the 180

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 181 of 434

Parent of Carl Eugene Molinaro, Deceased LAWRENCE CHARLES MOLINARO, individually as the Sibling of Carl Eugene Molinaro, Deceased JODI ANN MOLISANI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Justin John Molisani, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Justin John Molisani, Jr. and on behalf of minor child M.L.M. JEANNE ANN MONAGHAN, individually as the Parent of Brian Patrick Monaghan, Deceased DANIELLE MONAGHAN, individually as the Sibling of Brian Patrick Monaghan, Deceased BERNARD J. MONAGHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian Patrick Monaghan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brian Patrick Monaghan MATTHEW MONAHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Franklyn Monahan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Franklyn Monahan DOE 75, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 75, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 75 and behalf of minor children DOE 75, DOE 75, and DOE 75 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Margaret P. Montesi, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael G. Montesi MARIA E. LAURIA, individually as the Sibling of Michael G. Montesi, Deceased NANCY EILEEN MONTESI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael G. Montesi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael G. Montesi REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of George R. Montesi, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael G. Montesi DORIS MARIE MONYAK, individually as the 181

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 182 of 434

Parent of Cheryl Ann Monyak, Deceased MICHAEL J. MONYAK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cheryl Ann Monyak, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Cheryl Ann Monyak BARBARA BRIDGES, individually as the Parent of Sharon Moore, Deceased KARINA MOORE, individually as the Sibling of Sharon Moore, Deceased ARINA BRIDGES, individually as the Sibling of Sharon Moore, Deceased VIOLET MADDIX, individually as the Sibling of Sharon Moore, Deceased EUGENE MOORE, individually as the Parent of Sharon Moore, Deceased RAYBURN MOORE, individually as the Sibling of Sharon Moore, Deceased BETTY E. MORAN, individually as the Parent of John Christopher Moran, Deceased ELIZABETH LOUISE MORAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Christopher Moran, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Christopher Moran KEVIN M. MORAN, individually as the Sibling of John Christopher Moran, Deceased MARY ANN MORAN, individually as the Sibling of Kathleen Moran, Deceased KATHLEEN S. MAYCEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lindsay S. Morehouse, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lindsay S. Morehouse THEODORE C. MOREHOUSE, individually as the Parent of Lindsay S. Morehouse, Deceased NYKIA MORGAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dorothy R. Morgan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dorothy R. Morgan DOE 48, individually as the Sibling of DOE 48, 182

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 183 of 434

Deceased GLENN MORGAN, individually as the Child of Richard J. Morgan, Deceased KEVIN J. MORGAN, individually as the Sibling of Richard J. Morgan, Deceased MARIA MOROCHO SANCHEZ, individually as the Parent of Blanca Morocho, Deceased MANUEL LLANOS MOROCHO, individually as the Sibling of Blanca Morocho, Deceased MARIA MOROCHO SANCHEZ, individually as the Parent of Leonel G. Morocho, Deceased MANUEL LLANOS MOROCHO, individually as the Sibling of Leonel G. Morocho, Deceased PATRICIA M. MORRIS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Lynne Irene Morris, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lynne Irene Morris CHRISTINE MORRIS, individually as the Sibling of Lynne Irene Morris, Deceased EDWARD G. MORRIS, individually as the Sibling of Lynne Irene Morris, Deceased HAROLD C. MORRIS, JR., individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Lynne Irene Morris, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lynne Irene Morris LYNN MORRIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Seth A. Morris, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Seth A. Morris LAURA MAZZARELLA, individually as the Fiancé of Stephen Phillip Morris, Deceased DOE 91, individually as the Parent of DOE 91, Deceased DOE 91, individually as the Sibling of DOE 91, Deceased DOE 91, individually as the Sibling of DOE 91, Deceased DOE 91, individually as the Parent of DOE 91, Deceased 183

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 184 of 434

LORRAINE MOSKAL, individually and as the Fiduciary of the Estate of William David Moskal, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William David Moskal REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Alexandra Mouchinskaia, Deceased, Parent of decedent Iouri Mouchinski IRYNA USHAKOVA, individually as the Child of Iouri Mouchinski, Deceased OLENA PAVLOVA, individually as the Child of Iouri Mouchinski, Deceased NADEJDA GRIB, individually as the Sibling of Iouri Mouchinski, Deceased NATALIA MUSHINSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Iouri Mouchinski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Iouri Mouchinski VLADIMIR MUSHINSKY, individually as the Sibling of Iouri Mouchinski, Deceased DOE 89, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 89, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 89 LYDIA MOZZILLO, individually as the Parent of Christopher Mozzillo, Deceased DOE 80, individually as the Sibling of DOE 80, Deceased MICHAEL MOZZILLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Mozzillo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Mozzillo DANIEL MOZZILLO, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Mozzillo, Deceased CONSTANCE MULDOWNEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Muldowney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Muldowney NANCY MULLIGAN, individually as the Parent of Peter James Mulligan, Deceased SARA M. MULLIGAN, individually and as the 184

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 185 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter James Mulligan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter James Mulligan THOMAS MULLIGAN, individually as the Parent of Peter James Mulligan, Deceased LYNN ANNE MULLIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Joseph Mullin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Joseph Mullin FREDRIC JOHN MULLIN, individually as the Parent of Michael Joseph Mullin, Deceased SUSAN KING MUNHALL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Donald Munhall, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Donald Munhall MARITZA ARZAYUS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carlos Munoz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Carlos Munoz CHRISTINE M. MUNSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Theresa Ann Munson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Theresa Ann Munson LAURIE MURACH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Murach, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Murach NILVIA MITCHELL, individually as the Parent of Cesar A. Murillo, Deceased CAROLYN ALDERMAN, individually as the Sibling of Cesar A. Murillo, Deceased CATHERINE GOLDSBOROUGH WHITE MURPHY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher W. Murphy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher W. Murphy and on behalf of minor child H.M. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Evelyn M. Murphy, Deceased, Parent of decedent Edward Charles Murphy 185

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 186 of 434

RYAN LEWIS MURPHY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Charles Murphy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Charles Murphy DANIEL W. MURPHY, individually as the Sibling of Edward Charles Murphy, Deceased RICHARD E. MURPHY, individually as the Sibling of Edward Charles Murphy, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Helen Marie Murphy, Deceased, Parent of decedent James Francis Murphy, IV KRISTIN M. MURPHY, individually as the Sibling of James Francis Murphy, IV, Deceased KATHLEEN MARIE MURPHY, individually as the Sibling of James Francis Murphy, IV, Deceased HELEN MARIE SWEENEY, individually as the Sibling of James Francis Murphy, IV, Deceased ELIZABETH MURPHY COOKE, individually as the Sibling of James Francis Murphy, IV, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of James F. Murphy, III, Deceased, Parent of decedent James Francis Murphy, IV JOAN V. MURPHY, individually as the Parent of James Thomas Murphy, Deceased MARY L. MURPHY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Thomas Murphy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Thomas Murphy THOMAS J. MURPHY, individually as the Sibling of James Thomas Murphy, Deceased WILLIAM C. MURPHY, III, individually as the Sibling of James Thomas Murphy, Deceased WILLIAM C. MURPHY, JR., individually as the Parent of James Thomas Murphy, Deceased DOLORES BARBARA MURPHY, 186

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 187 of 434

individually as the Parent of Patrick Sean Murphy, Deceased THOMAS JOSEPH MURPHY, individually as the Parent of Patrick Sean Murphy, Deceased LINDA MURPHY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Raymond E. Murphy, Sr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Raymond E. Murphy, Sr. RAYMOND MURPHY, JR., individually as the Child of Raymond E. Murphy, Sr., Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Mary Louise Murray, Deceased, Parent of decedent John J. Murray JAYNE E. DELLOSE, individually as the Sibling of John J. Murray, Deceased VIRGINIA M. REGAN, individually as the Sibling of John J. Murray, Deceased CATHERINE MARIE DATZ, individually as the Sibling of John J. Murray, Deceased RORY OWENS MURRAY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John J. Murray, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John J. Murray and on behalf of minor child A.R.M. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Philip C. Murray, Deceased, Parent of decedent John J. Murray MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER MURRAY, individually as the Sibling of John J. Murray, Deceased PHILIP J. MURRAY, individually as the Sibling of John J. Murray, Deceased DOE 07, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 07, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 07 MARJORIE NAPIER, individually as the Parent of Alexander Napier, Deceased 187

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 188 of 434

NICOLA NAPIER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alexander Napier, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alexander Napier GERALD NAPIER, individually as the Parent of Alexander Napier, Deceased MARK NAPIER, individually as the Sibling of Alexander Napier, Deceased MADHU NARULA, individually as the Parent of Maniki Narula, Deceased BALDEV NARULA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maniki Narula, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Maniki Narula MARGARET M. NASSANEY, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Shawn Michael Nassaney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Shawn Michael Nassaney RYAN A. NASSANEY, individually as the Sibling of Shawn Michael Nassaney, Deceased PATRICK J. NASSANEY, JR., individually as the Sibling of Shawn Michael Nassaney, Deceased PATRICK JOHN NASSANEY, SR., individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Shawn Michael Nassaney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Shawn Michael Nassaney KEOLAHMATIE NATH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Narender Nath, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Narender Nath ROSEMARIE NAVAS, individually as the Parent of Joseph Michael Navas, Deceased LISA ANN LOPICCOLO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Michael Navas, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Joseph N. Navas, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joseph Michael Navas JULIANNE NAZARIO, individually and as the 188

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 189 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of Francis J. Nazario, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Francis J. Nazario and on behalf of minor child L.N. ZANDRA LENA NEBLETT, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Rayman Marcus Neblett, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Rayman Marcus Neblett PATRICIA B. NEE O'KEEFE, individually as the Sibling of Luke G. Nee, Deceased MARY NEE REILLY, individually as the Sibling of Luke G. Nee, Deceased JOHN G. NEE, individually as the Parent of Luke G. Nee, Deceased LEILA NEGRON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Pete Negron, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Pete Negron and on behalf of minor child A.N. FRANCISCA A. WESTER, individually as the Child of Laurie Ann Neira, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Gilberto A. Neira, Deceased, Spouse of decedent Laurie Ann Neira REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Laurie Ann Neira, Deceased, and on behalf of all survivors of Laurie Ann Neira CHRISTOPHER O. NEIRA, individually as the Child of Laurie Ann Neira, Deceased JENETTE NELSON, individually as the Parent of Ann Nicole Nelson, Deceased GARY S. NELSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ann Nicole Nelson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ann Nicole Nelson SCOTT T. NELSON, individually as the Sibling of Ann Nicole Nelson, Deceased ROSANNE NELSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Nelson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors 189

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 190 of 434

of James Nelson LILLIAN C. TETREAULT, individually as the Parent of Renee Tetreault Newell, Deceased RONNIE R. TETREAULT, individually as the Sibling of Renee Tetreault Newell, Deceased PAUL NEWELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Renee Tetreault Newell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Renee Tetreault Newell TU A. HONGUYEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Khang N. Nguyen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Khang N. Nguyen CHARLES W. NIEDERER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Stewart Niederer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Stewart Niederer CAROL NIEDERMEYER, individually as the Parent of Alfonse J. Niedermeyer, Deceased NANCY NIEDERMEYER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alfonse J. Niedermeyer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alfonse J. Niedermeyer and on behalf of minor child A.J.N. ALFONSE NIEDERMEYER, individually as the Parent of Alfonse J. Niedermeyer, Deceased ADELMA REYES JIMINEZ, individually as the Sibling of Gloria Reyes Nieves, Deceased MICHELLE NIEVES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Juan Nieves, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Juan Nieves, Jr. IRMA NIEVES, individually as the Spouse of Juan Nieves, Jr., Deceased JOHN NIEVES, individually as the Child of Juan Nieves, Jr., Deceased DAVID NIEVES, individually as the Child of Juan Nieves, Jr., Deceased 190

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 191 of 434

JENNIFER NILSEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Troy Edward Nilsen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Troy Edward Nilsen EDWARD CARL NILSEN, individually as the Parent of Troy Edward Nilsen, Deceased ELLEN NIVEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Ballentine Nivin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Ballentine Nivin KATHRYN M. MCGARRY, individually as the Parent of Katherine McGarry Noack, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Everett Joseph McGarry, Deceased, Parent of decedent Katherine McGarry Noack THERESA NOEL, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Curtis T. Noel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Curtis T. Noel MICHAEL NOEL, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Curtis T. Noel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Curtis T. Noel RENEE E. NOLAN-RILEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel R. Nolan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel R. Nolan JOANNE LOVETT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian Nunez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brian Nunez NEAL GREEN, individually as the Sibling of Brian Nunez, Deceased ERIC NUNEZ, individually as the Sibling of Brian Nunez, Deceased DENISE I. OAKLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James A. Oakley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James A. Oakley CHRISTINE M. O'BERG, individually and as 191

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 192 of 434

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis P. O'Berg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis P. O'Berg JAMES O'BRIEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James O'Brien, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James O'Brien, Jr. MARY LOU O'BRIEN, individually as the Parent of Michael P. O'Brien, Deceased BRIDGET ANN PALUZZI, individually as the Sibling of Michael P. O'Brien, Deceased MARY KATHLEEN DISHAW, individually as the Sibling of Michael P. O'Brien, Deceased RACHEL O'BRIEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael P. O'Brien, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael P. O'Brien REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Robert T. O'Brien, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael P. O'Brien ANDREW THOMAS O'BRIEN, individually as the Sibling of Michael P. O'Brien, Deceased MARILYN JEANNE O'BRIEN, individually as the Parent of Timothy M. O'Brien, Deceased KATHLEEN MARIE TIGHE, individually as the Sibling of Timothy M. O'Brien, Deceased THERESE A. VISCONTI, individually as the Sibling of Timothy M. O'Brien, Deceased BERNARD JOSEPH O'BRIEN, individually as the Parent of Timothy M. O'Brien, Deceased PATRICK O'BRIEN, individually as the Sibling of Timothy M. O'Brien, Deceased ROBERT L. O'BRIEN, individually as the Sibling of Timothy M. O'Brien, Deceased RHONDA LEE O'CALLAGHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel O'Callaghan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel O'Callaghan DOE 22, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 192

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 193 of 434

22, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 22 and on behalf of minor children B.P.O. and K.R.O. ESTHER R. BARBUTO, BLAISE J. OGNIBENE, AND ANNA M. RUESS, individually and as Co-Representatives of the Estate of Antoinette D. Ognibene, Parent of decedent Philip Paul Ognibene THERESA OGONOWSKI, individually as the Parent of John Alexander Ogonowski, Deceased CAROL A. OGONOWSKI, individually as the Sibling of John Alexander Ogonowski, Deceased MARGARET MARY OGONOWSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Alexander Ogonowski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Alexander Ogonowski and on behalf of minor children L.E.O., C.J.O., and M.K.O. JAMES OGONOWSKI, individually as the Sibling of John Alexander Ogonowski, Deceased JOSEPH OGONOWSKI, individually as the Sibling of John Alexander Ogonowski, Deceased RACHEL UCHITEL, individually as the of Andrew O'Grady, Deceased MARY ELLEN MALONE, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased ANNE MARIE MORAN, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased KATHLEEN BRIGID GAETANO, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased JEANNE THERESA MCCABE, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased CLARE R. MAYER, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased ANDREA O'HAGAN, individually and as the 193

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 194 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan JOHN O'HAGAN, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased RAYMOND T. O'HAGAN, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased JOSEPH E. O'HAGAN, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased FRANCIS PATRICK O'HAGAN, JR., individually as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Francis P. O'Hagan, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan KAREN LISA O'KEEFE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick Joseph O'Keefe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick Joseph O'Keefe VIRGINIA O'KEEFE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William S. O'Keefe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William S. O'Keefe LYNN A. OLCOTT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gerald M. Olcott, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gerald M. Olcott CHRISTOPHER GRAIG OLCOTT, individually as the Child of Gerald M. Olcott, Deceased GRAIG AARON OLCOTT, individually as the Child of Gerald M. Olcott, Deceased STELLA OLENDER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Olender, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christine Olender THERESE WINTERS, individually as the Sibling of Christine Olender, Deceased JOHN CASIMIR OLENDER, individually as 194

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 195 of 434

the Parent of Christine Olender, Deceased CONRAD S. OLENDER, individually as the Sibling of Christine Olender, Deceased BARBARA OLSEN, individually as the Parent of Eric Taube Olsen, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Taube Olsen, Deceased, Parent of decedent Eric Taube Olsen PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of Eric Taube Olsen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Taube Olsen CLIFFORD I. OLSEN, individually as the Sibling of Eric Taube Olsen, Deceased KENNETH OLSEN, individually as the Sibling of Eric Taube Olsen, Deceased TODD OLSEN, individually as the Sibling of Eric Taube Olsen, Deceased DOE 82, individually as the Parent of DOE 82, Deceased DOE 82, individually as the Sibling of DOE 82, Deceased DENISE MARIE OLSEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey James Olsen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey James Olsen DOE 82, individually as the Sibling of DOE 82, Deceased DOE 82, individually as the Sibling of DOE 82, Deceased PATRICIA OLSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven J. Olson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven J. Olson and on behalf of minor children J.O. and J.O. KENNETH D. OLSON, individually as the Sibling of Steven J. Olson, Deceased HELEN O'MAHONY BRADLEY, individually as the Parent of Matthew T. O'Mahony, Deceased

195

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 196 of 434

KAREN O'MAHONY SPEIDELL, individually as the Sibling of Matthew T. O'Mahony, Deceased JOHN O'MAHONY, individually as the Sibling of Matthew T. O'Mahony, Deceased STEPHEN O'MAHONY, individually as the Sibling of Matthew T. O'Mahony, Deceased ROBERT J. O'MAHONY, individually as the Sibling of Matthew T. O'Mahony, Deceased JEANNE O'NEILL, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr. BRIDIE O'NEILL, individually as the Sibling of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr., Deceased THOMAS W. O'NEILL, individually as the Sibling of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr., Deceased PETER J. O'NEILL, SR., individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr. CAROL A. SMEE, individually as the Sibling of Michael C. Opperman, Deceased JOYCE CHRISTOPHER, individually as the Parent of Christopher T. Orgielewicz, Deceased LAURIE ANN CHRISTOPHER, individually as the Sibling of Christopher T. Orgielewicz, Deceased OLGA ORGIELEWICZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher T. Orgielewicz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher T. Orgielewicz and on behalf of minor child K.O. CORINNE O'ROURKE, individually as the Child of Kevin M. O'Rourke, Deceased HANNAH O'ROURKE, individually as the Parent of Kevin M. O'Rourke, Deceased PATRICIA O'KEEFE, individually as the Sibling of Kevin M. O'Rourke, Deceased MARYANN J. O'ROURKE, individually and 196

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 197 of 434

as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin M. O'Rourke, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin M. O'Rourke JAMIE O'ROURKE, individually as the Child of Kevin M. O'Rourke, Deceased DENNIS O'ROURKE, individually as the Parent of Kevin M. O'Rourke, Deceased DENNIS P. O'ROURKE, individually as the Sibling of Kevin M. O'Rourke, Deceased GILBERT ORTALE, individually as the Sibling of Peter Keith Ortale, Deceased AGATINA IACI, individually as the Parent of Jane Marie Orth, Deceased GAE FERRUOLO, individually as the Sibling of Jane Marie Orth, Deceased WANDA GARCIA-ORTIZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Emilio Ortiz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Emilio Ortiz and on behalf of minor children E.O. and A.O. EDNA VELEZ-MUNDO, individually and as the Administrator of the Estate of Pablo Ortiz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Pablo Ortiz ELIZABETH SHERRY, individually as the Sibling of Robert O'Shea, Deceased BEVERLY ANN OSTROWSKI, individually as the Parent of James Robert Ostrowski, Deceased DOE 81, individually as the Sibling of DOE 81, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Stephen V. Ostrowski, Deceased, Parent of decedent James Robert Ostrowski STEPHEN W. OSTROWSKI, individually as the Sibling of James Robert Ostrowski, Deceased MARION SUSAN OTTEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael J. Otten, Deceased and on behalf of all 197

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 198 of 434

survivors of Michael J. Otten ANDREA OUIDA, individually as the Parent of Todd Joseph Ouida, Deceased AMY MORIK, individually as the Sibling of Todd Joseph Ouida, Deceased HERBERT OUIDA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Todd Joseph Ouida, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Todd Joseph Ouida JORDAN OUIDA, individually as the Sibling of Todd Joseph Ouida, Deceased ANNIE GUERRERO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roland Pacheco, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Roland Pacheco RYAN PACHECO, individually as the Child of Roland Pacheco, Deceased REKHA D. PACKER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael B. Packer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael B. Packer REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Juana B. Borrero, Deceased, Parent of decedent Diana B. Padro REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Miriam Borrero, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Diana B. Padro LILLIAN BORRERO, individually as the Sibling of Diana B. Padro, Deceased JOSE JAVIER PADRO, individually as the Child of Diana B. Padro, Deceased JUAN CARLOS PADRO, individually as the Child of Diana B. Padro, Deceased JOSE E. PADRO-LEBRON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Diana B. Padro, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Diana B. Padro ANNETTE M. PALAZZOLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard A. Palazzolo, Deceased and on behalf 198

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 199 of 434

of all survivors of Richard A. Palazzolo DOE 54, individually as the Parent of DOE 54, Deceased DOE 54, individually as the Sibling of DOE 54, Deceased DOE 54, individually as the Sibling of DOE 54, Deceased DOE 54, individually as the Sibling of DOE 54, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 54, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 54 DOE 54, individually as the Sibling of DOE 54, Deceased DOE 54, individually as the Sibling of DOE 54, Deceased FORTUNATA PALOMBO, individually as the Parent of Frank Palombo, Deceased MARIE PALOMBO, individually as the Sibling of Frank Palombo, Deceased BARBARA POLISAR, individually as the Sibling of Frank Palombo, Deceased BARBARA PANDOLFO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dominique Lisa Pandolfo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dominique Lisa Pandolfo REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Linda Ellen Panik, Deceased, Parent of decedent Jonas Martin Panik MARTINA LYNE-ANNA PANIK, individually as the Sibling of Jonas Martin Panik, Deceased MARTIN ANTHONY PANIK, individually as the Parent of Jonas Martin Panik, Deceased LORETTA HALPERT, individually as the Sibling of Paul J. Pansini, Deceased JANICE PANSINI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul J. Pansini, Deceased and on behalf of all 199

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 200 of 434

survivors of Paul J. Pansini JOSEPH PANSINI, individually as the Sibling of Paul J. Pansini, Deceased ROBERT JOSEPH PANSINI, SR., individually as the Sibling of Paul J. Pansini, Deceased PATRICIA N. PAPA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward J. Papa, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward J. Papa THERESA PAPASSO, individually as the Parent of Salvatore T. Papasso, Deceased CHRISTINE E. PAPASSO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Salvatore T. Papasso, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Salvatore T. Papasso SALVATORE PAPASSO, individually as the Parent of Salvatore T. Papasso, Deceased VINCENT PAPASSO, individually as the Sibling of Salvatore T. Papasso, Deceased GINA PINOS, individually as the Fiancé of James N. Pappageorge, Deceased JUANA OLGA PAPPAGEORGE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James N. Pappageorge, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James N. Pappageorge HELEN PAPPAGEORGE, individually as the Sibling of James N. Pappageorge, Deceased MARIA KOUTNY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marie Pappalardo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Marie Pappalardo VERNON ALFRED RANDLETT, individually as the Sibling of Marie Pappalardo, Deceased GARY PAPPALARDO, individually as the Sibling of Marie Pappalardo, Deceased GANGADEI RAMRUP, individually as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu, Deceased PARBOTI PARBHU, individually as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu, Deceased

200

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 201 of 434

DENESH N. PARBHU, individually as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu, Deceased RAJARAM PARBHU, individually as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu, Deceased KENNETH PERSAUD, individually as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu, Deceased LACHMAN PARBHU, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hardai Parbhu, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Hardai Parbhu ROSE PARIS, individually as the Parent of George Paris, Deceased CHRISTINA PARIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George Paris, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of George Paris and on behalf of minor child C.P. JUNG HEA SHIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gye Hyong Park, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gye Hyong Park MYONG KYU PARK, individually as the Parent of Gye Hyong Park, Deceased JIN HAN PARK, individually as the Sibling of Gye Hyong Park, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 141, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 141 BHARTI PARMAR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hashmukhrai C. Parmar, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Hashmukhrai C. Parmar and on behalf of minor children R.P. and S.P. DOE 141, individually as the Sibling of DOE 141, Deceased DOE 141, individually as the Sibling of DOE 141, Deceased KAREN PARRO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Parro, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Parro 201

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 202 of 434

KAREN TATUM, individually as the Child of Diane Moore Parsons, Deceased FRANK TATUM, individually as the Child of Diane Moore Parsons, Deceased IMELDA REYES SORIANO, individually as the Domestic Partner of Leobardo Lopez Pascual, Deceased SARAH P. RUBINSTEIN, individually as the Sibling of Jerrold H. Paskins, Deceased INEZ PASKINS- SLICK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jerrold H. Paskins, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jerrold H. Paskins ROBERT R. PASKINS, individually as the Child of Jerrold H. Paskins, Deceased MARIE PASSANANTI, individually as the Parent of Horace Robert Passananti, Deceased SANDRA PASSANANTI, individually as the Sibling of Horace Robert Passananti, Deceased MICHAEL ROBERT PASSANANTI, individually as the Child of Horace Robert Passananti, Deceased SEAN ROBERT PASSANANTI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Horace Robert Passananti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Horace Robert Passananti SUSHILABEN R. PATEL, individually as the Parent of Avnish Ramanbhai Patel, Deceased RAMANBHAS M. PATEL, individually as the Parent of Avnish Ramanbhai Patel, Deceased YOGESH R. PATEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Avnish Ramanbhai Patel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Avnish Ramanbhai Patel KAPILA JAYANT PATEL, individually as the Parent of Dipti Patel, Deceased VIBHUTI PATEL, individually as the Sibling of Dipti Patel, Deceased NIMISHA PATEL, individually as the Sibling 202

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 203 of 434

of Dipti Patel, Deceased JAYANT R. PATEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dipti Patel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dipti Patel RANTIK PATEL, individually as the Sibling of Dipti Patel, Deceased NIRAJ PATEL, individually as the Sibling of Dipti Patel, Deceased SAKAE TAKUSHIMA, individually as the Fiancé of Manish Patel, Deceased LOIS PATERSON GALLO, individually as the Sibling of Steven Bennett Paterson, Deceased LISA PATERSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Bennett Paterson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Bennett Paterson GEORGE PATERSON, individually as the Sibling of Steven Bennett Paterson, Deceased JOSEPH J. PATERSON, individually as the Sibling of Steven Bennett Paterson, Deceased BARBARA A. PATRICK, individually as the Parent of James Matthew Patrick, Deceased KATHRYN M. PATRICK, individually as the Sibling of James Matthew Patrick, Deceased ALICIA M. PATRICK, individually as the Sibling of James Matthew Patrick, Deceased JERRY GALE PATRICK, individually as the Parent of James Matthew Patrick, Deceased KEVIN M. PATRICK, individually as the Sibling of James Matthew Patrick, Deceased FRANCES PATTI, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Cira Marie Patti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Cira Marie Patti JULIANN PATTI-ANDOLPHO, individually as the Sibling of Cira Marie Patti, Deceased MICHAEL PATTI, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Cira Marie Patti, 203

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 204 of 434

Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Cira Marie Patti RICHARD P. PATTI, individually as the Sibling of Cira Marie Patti, Deceased MICHAEL PATTI, JR., individually as the Sibling of Cira Marie Patti, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Bobbie Catherine Peak, Deceased, Parent of decedent Stacey Lynn Peak REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of Stacey Lynn Peak, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stacey Lynn Peak TONI PEAK, individually as the Sibling of Stacey Lynn Peak, Deceased JUDY PEAK RHODES, individually as the Sibling of Stacey Lynn Peak, Deceased PHILLIP PEAK, individually as the Sibling of Stacey Lynn Peak, Deceased MICHAEL R. PEAK, individually as the Sibling of Stacey Lynn Peak, Deceased NATALEE MOORE, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Pecorelli, Deceased KIA POLYXENA PAVLOFF, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Pecorelli, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Pecorelli PAMELA MORACE, as Executor of the Estate of Nancy N. Pedicini, Deceased, Parent of decedent Thomas Pedicini JUNE COPPOLA, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Pedicini, Deceased ANNE PEDICINI, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Pedicini, Deceased PAMELA MORACE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Pedicini, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Pedicini PAMELA MORACE, as Executor of the Estate of Albert Pedicini, Deceased, Parent of decedent Thomas Pedicini 204

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 205 of 434

MICHELE T. PENA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angel R. Pena, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Angel R. Pena CIELITA PERALTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carl Allen Peralta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Carl Allen Peralta OSCAR FIGUEROA PERALTA, individually as the Parent of Carl Allen Peralta, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Lucia Perconti, Deceased, Parent of decedent Jon A. Perconti TAMMY PERCONTI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jon A. Perconti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jon A. Perconti and on behalf of minor child J.A.P. CARMEN RODRIGUEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angel Perez, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Angel Perez, Jr. MARIELA FLORES, individually as the Sibling of Angel Perez, Jr., Deceased RAMON RODRIGUEZ, individually as the Sibling of Angel Perez, Jr., Deceased SHAWN BITTNER, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angela Susan Perez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Angela Susan Perez PATRICIA J. PERRY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John William Perry, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John William Perry JANICE LYNN MONTOYA, individually as the Sibling of John William Perry, Deceased JOEL R. PERRY, individually as the Sibling of John William Perry, Deceased CHIARA PESCE, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Danny Pesce, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of 205

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 206 of 434

Danny Pesce ANGELA FRUNZI, individually as the Sibling of Danny Pesce, Deceased PAUL PESCE, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Danny Pesce, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Danny Pesce FRANK PESCE, individually as the Sibling of Danny Pesce, Deceased ANNE MARIE PESCHERINE, individually as the Parent of Michael John Pescherine, Deceased NANCY GIONCO, individually as the Sibling of Michael John Pescherine, Deceased LYNN PESCHERINE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael John Pescherine, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael John Pescherine WILLIAM KEVIN PESCHERINE, individually as the Sibling of Michael John Pescherine, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Thomas F. Pescherine, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael John Pescherine DOE 16, individually as the Parent of DOE 16, Deceased DOE 16, individually as the Sibling of DOE 16, Deceased DAWN PETERSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Davin N. Peterson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Davin N. Peterson REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Norman Peterson, Deceased, Parent of decedent Davin N. Peterson DOE 16, individually as the Sibling of DOE 16, Deceased CHARLES R. PETERSON, individually as the Child of Donald A. Peterson, Deceased 206

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 207 of 434

D. HAMILTON PETERSON, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Donald A. Peterson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Donald A. Peterson VIRGINIA ANN PETROCELLI, individually as the Parent of Mark James Petrocelli, Deceased NICOLE PETROCELLI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark James Petrocelli, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark James Petrocelli ALBERT PETER PETROCELLI, JR., individually as the Sibling of Mark James Petrocelli, Deceased ALBERT PETER PETROCELLI, SR., individually as the Parent of Mark James Petrocelli, Deceased CATHERINE PETTI, individually as the Parent of Philip S. Petti, Deceased JACQUELINE LEE BUTT, individually as the Sibling of Philip S. Petti, Deceased ADRIAN LEE FORAN, individually as the Sibling of Philip S. Petti, Deceased EILEEN R. PETTI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Philip S. Petti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Philip S. Petti REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Antimo Petti, Deceased, Parent of decedent Philip S. Petti THOMAS DANIEL PETTI, individually as the Sibling of Philip S. Petti, Deceased SUSAN L. PICARRO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ludwig John Picarro, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ludwig John Picarro PETRINA M. PICERNO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew M. Picerno, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew M. Picerno MARIE E. PUCCIO-PICK, individually and as 207

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 208 of 434

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Pick, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Pick PATRICIA MARIE PIETRONICO, individually as the Parent of Bernard Pietronico, Deceased PATRICIA KEELAN, individually as the Sibling of Bernard Pietronico, Deceased JACQUELINE PIETRONICO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bernard Pietronico, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Bernard Pietronico MICHAEL PIETRONICO, individually as the Sibling of Bernard Pietronico, Deceased JANET CIARAMELLO, individually as the Sibling of Nicholas P. Pietrunti, Deceased JOHN J. PIETRUNTI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nicholas P. Pietrunti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Nicholas P. Pietrunti DOROTHY ANCONA, individually as the Parent of Susan Pinto, Deceased BARBARA GRAY, individually as the Sibling of Susan Pinto, Deceased DOUGLAS PINTO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Pinto, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Pinto VIRGINIA MARTHA DOMINGUEZ, individually as the Child of Alberto Dominguez Piriz, Deceased MARIA REINA DOMINGUEZ PIRIZ, individually as the Sibling of Alberto Dominguez Piriz, Deceased MARTHA ISABEL DOMINGUEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alberto Dominguez Piriz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alberto Dominguez Piriz DIEGO DOMINGUEZ, individually as the Child of Alberto Dominguez Piriz, Deceased 208

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 209 of 434

ALVARO DOMINGUEZ, individually as the Child of Alberto Dominguez Piriz, Deceased ALBERTO DOMINGUEZ, individually as the Child of Alberto Dominguez Piriz, Deceased CARLOS DOMINGUEZ PEREZ, individually as the Sibling of Alberto Dominguez Piriz, Deceased LAURA MARIE PISKADLO, individually as the Child of Joseph Piskadlo, Deceased ROSEMARY PISKADLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Piskadlo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Piskadlo BRIAN JOSEPH PISKADLO, individually as the Child of Joseph Piskadlo, Deceased STEVEN JOHN PISKADLO, individually as the Child of Joseph Piskadlo, Deceased ERIC J. PITMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Todd Pitman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Todd Pitman SUSAN PIVER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joshua Michael Piver, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua Michael Piver DOREEN PLUMITALLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Plumitallo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Plumitallo LAURA A. GRYGOTIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John M. Pocher, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John M. Pocher BERNARD POLATSCH, individually as the Parent of Laurence Michael Polatsch, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Olga L. Polhemus, Deceased, Parent of decedent Thomas H. Polhemus JANE LYNN SKRZYNIARZ, individually as the Sibling of Thomas H. Polhemus, Deceased 209

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 210 of 434

DOROTHY GAIL MCGRATH, individually as the Sibling of Thomas H. Polhemus, Deceased BARBARA L. POLHEMUS, individually and as the Administrator of the Estate of Thomas H. Polhemus, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas H. Polhemus HAROLD LOWE POLHEMUS, individually as the Parent of Thomas H. Polhemus, Deceased PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of Susan M. Pollio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Susan M. Pollio. The REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Phyllis Pollio, Deceased, Parent of decedent Susan M. Pollio SANDRA GONZALES, individually as the Sibling of Susan M. Pollio, Deceased JOYCE OXLEY, individually as the Sibling of Susan M. Pollio, Deceased DEVORA WOLK PONTELL, individually and as the Administrator of the Estate of Darin Howard Pontell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Darin Howard Pontell VASILE POPTEAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joshua I. Poptean, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua I. Poptean NIKKI L. STERN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James E. Portorti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James E. Portorti LISA SARNI, individually as the Child of Richard N. Poulos, Deceased MARGARET POULOS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard N. Poulos, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard N. Poulos ERIN POULOS, individually as the Child of Richard N. Poulos, Deceased RICHARD J. POULOS, individually as the Child of Richard N. Poulos, Deceased 210

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 211 of 434

NORMA L. POWELL, individually as the Parent of Brandon J. Powell, Deceased HARRY J. POWELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brandon J. Powell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brandon J. Powell CATHERINE POWELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Allen Powell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Allen Powell REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Asmareli Sago, Deceased, Domestic Partner of Antonio Pratt, Deceased DOLORES ALBA PREZIOSE, individually as the Parent of Gregory M. Preziose, Deceased LORI A. PREZIOSE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory M. Preziose, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory M. Preziose REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Alexander Preziose, Deceased, Parent of decedent Gregory M. Preziose CHRISTOPHER PAUL PREZIOSE, individually as the Sibling of Gregory M. Preziose, Deceased JOHN MICHAEL PREZIOSE, individually as the Sibling of Gregory M. Preziose, Deceased JAMES ALEXANDER PREZIOSE, individually as the Sibling of Gregory M. Preziose, Deceased EDWARD PRINCE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wanda Prince, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Wanda Prince MARIAN A. PRIOR, individually as the Parent of Kevin M. Prior, Deceased GERARD J. PRIOR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin M. Prior, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin M. Prior REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Catherine 211

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 212 of 434

B. Proctor, Deceased, Parent of decedent Everett M. Proctor, III MARY E. GRIFFIN, individually as the Sibling of Everett M. Proctor, III, Deceased PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of Everett M. Proctor, III, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Everett M. Proctor, III. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Everett Proctor, Jr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Everett M. Proctor, IIII KATHLEEN A. PROGEN, individually as the Parent of Carrie Beth Progen, Deceased DONALD H. PROGEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carrie Beth Progen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Carrie Beth Progen MATTHEW ERIC PROGEN, individually as the Sibling of Carrie Beth Progen, Deceased KATHRYN S. PRUIM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David L. Pruim, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David L. Pruim and on behalf of minor child C.P. DOE 42, individually as the Spouse of DOE 42, Deceased DOE 42, individually as the Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 42, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 42 and on behalf of minor child DOE 42 MELISSA PULLIS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Frank Pullis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Frank Pullis and on behalf of minor children A.P., E.P., and M.F.P. ELEANOR WILSON, individually as the Parent of Patricia Ann Puma, Deceased ANTOINETTE NICHOLASI, individually as the Sibling of Patricia Ann Puma, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of William Wilson, Deceased, Parent of decedent Patricia Ann Puma 212

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 213 of 434

ROBERT WILSON, individually as the Sibling of Patricia Ann Puma, Deceased KEVIN PUMA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patricia Ann Puma, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patricia Ann Puma DOMINIC J. PUOPOLO, JR., individually as the Child of Sonia Morales Puopolo, Deceased DOE 45, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 45, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 45 and on behalf of minor child DOE 45 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 45, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 45 DOE 45, individually as the Sibling of DOE 45, Deceased GAIL QUACKENBUSH, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Quackenbush, Deceased MICHAEL ALLEN QUACKENBUSH, individually as the Sibling of Christopher Quackenbush, Deceased JAMES DUNNE, III, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Quackenbush, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Quackenbush LOUELLA JEAN QUIGLEY, individually as the Parent of Beth Ann Quigley, Deceased JOHN EUGENE QUIGLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Beth Ann Quigley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Beth Ann Quigley MIJA QUIGLEY, individually as the Parent of Patrick J Quigley, IV, Deceased RUTH QUIGLEY-LAWRENCE, individually as the Sibling of Patrick J Quigley, IV, Deceased JOHN V. QUIGLEY, individually as the Sibling of Patrick J Quigley, IV, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Patrick J. Quigley, Jr., Deceased, Parent of decedent 213

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 214 of 434

Patrick J Quigley, IV ANNA MARIA MORALES, individually as the Parent of Ricardo J. Quinn, Deceased VIRGINIA A. QUINN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ricardo J. Quinn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ricardo J. Quinn REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Nicholas Monaco, Deceased, Child of decedent Ricardo J. Quinn ADAM QUINN, individually as the Child of Ricardo J. Quinn, Deceased GREGORY VINCENT QUINN, individually as the Sibling of Ricardo J. Quinn, Deceased BERNARD J. QUINN, individually as the Sibling of Ricardo J. Quinn, Deceased SANDRA L. RACANIELLO, individually as the Parent of Christopher Anthony Peter Racaniello, Deceased FRANK V. RACANIELLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Anthony Peter Racaniello, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Anthony Peter Racaniello EDWARD RADBURN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Betty Browne Radburn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Betty Browne Radburn MAUREEN FRANCES RAGAGLIA, individually as the Parent of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased COLLEEN RAGAGLIA, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased DEBRA ANN RAGAGLIA, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased JANICE PUCCIARELLI, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased LAUREN PIETRINA LACAPRIA, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased 214

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 215 of 434

CHRISTINE TERESA DURANTE, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased LINDA MARIE TACCETTA, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased MAUREEN ELIZABETH SCPARTA, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased DONNA RAGAGLIA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Leonard J. Ragaglia LEONARD SALVATORE RAGAGLIA, individually as the Parent of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased PAUL JOSEPH RAGAGLIA, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased DANNY RAGAGLIA, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased STEPHEN ANTHONY RAGAGLIA, individually as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia, Deceased DOMENICA RAGUSA, individually as the Parent of Michael Paul Ragusa, Deceased CHRISTINE SALADEEN, individually as the Sibling of Michael Paul Ragusa, Deceased VINCENT JOSEPH RAGUSA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Paul Ragusa, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Paul Ragusa VINCENT CARL RAGUSA, individually as the Sibling of Michael Paul Ragusa, Deceased KENNETH RAGUSA, individually as the Sibling of Michael Paul Ragusa, Deceased LENORE RAIMONDI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter F. Raimondi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter F. Raimondi LAUREN CHRISTINE RAINES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate 215

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 216 of 434

of Harry A. Raines, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Harry A. Raines and on behalf of minor children J.R., K.R., and K.R. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Marilyn Raines, Deceased, Parent of decedent Lisa Joy Raines REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Sosamma George, Deceased, Parent of decedent Valsa Raju AMMINI G. ABRAHAM, individually as the Sibling of Valsa Raju, Deceased SARAMMA JOHN, individually as the Sibling of Valsa Raju, Deceased ANNAMMA THOMAS, individually as the Sibling of Valsa Raju, Deceased SOSAMMA MUKKADAN, individually as the Sibling of Valsa Raju, Deceased THANKACHAN RAJU, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Valsa Raju, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Valsa Raju JOAN P. RALL, individually as the Parent of Edward J. Rall, Deceased DARLENE G. RALL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward J. Rall, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward J. Rall EDWARD A. RALL, individually as the Parent of Edward J. Rall, Deceased WILLIAM F. RALL, individually as the Sibling of Edward J. Rall, Deceased KEITH G. RALL, individually as the Sibling of Edward J. Rall, Deceased MIGDALIA RAMOS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Harry Ramos, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Harry Ramos and on behalf of minor child A.G.R. JESSICA BORS, individually as the Sibling of Vishnoo Ramsaroop, Deceased 216

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 217 of 434

REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Barbara B. Rancke, Deceased, Parent of decedent Alfred Todd Rancke CYNTHIA RANCKE BIENEMANN, individually as the Sibling of Alfred Todd Rancke, Deceased BARBARA R. SPENI, individually as the Sibling of Alfred Todd Rancke, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Alfred E. Rancke, Deceased, Parent of decedent Alfred Todd Rancke VIRGINIA BLADEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jonathan Randall, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jonathan Randall DOE 46, individually as the Child of DOE 46, Deceased DOE 46, individually as the Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 46, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 46 DOE 46, individually as the Spouse of DOE 46, Deceased ANNA RASMUSSEN STANSBURY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert A. Rasmussen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert A. Rasmussen and on behalf of minor children S.R.R., R.J.R, and T.M.R. CLAUDIA MARIE STALLWORTH, individually as the Parent of Marsha Ratchford, Deceased CYNTHIA WATTS, individually as the Sibling of Marsha Ratchford, Deceased ANGELIA STALLWORTH BLUNT, individually as the Sibling of Marsha Ratchford, Deceased REGINALD SIMPSON, individually as the Sibling of Marsha Ratchford, Deceased RODNEY RATCHFORD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 217

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 218 of 434

Marsha Ratchford, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Marsha Ratchford REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Roosevelt Stallworth, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Marsha Ratchford DOE 104, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 104, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 104 and on behalf of minor children DOE 104, DOE 104, and DOE 104 MAUREEN A. RAUB, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Ralph Raub, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Ralph Raub and on behalf of minor child L.M.R. DOE 133, individually as the Parent of DOE 133, Deceased JANE MARIE THOMPSON, individually as the Sibling of Sarah Anne Redheffer, Deceased DOE 133, individually as the Parent of DOE 133, Deceased ALICE REGAN, individually as the Parent of Donald Regan, Deceased JOSEPH REGAN, individually as the Sibling of Donald Regan, Deceased MARGARET REGAN, individually as the Sibling of Donald Regan, Deceased EILEEN REGAN, individually as the Sibling of Donald Regan, Deceased KATHERINE REGAN DEY, individually as the Sibling of Donald Regan, Deceased MARY L. REIDY, individually as the Parent of Gregory Reidy, Deceased THOMAS REIDY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory Reidy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory Reidy JOAN E. REILLY, individually as the Parent of Kevin Owen Reilly, Deceased REGINA REILLY MADIGAN, individually as 218

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 219 of 434

the Sibling of Kevin Owen Reilly, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of George M. Reilly, Deceased, Parent of decedent Kevin Owen Reilly BRENDAN H. REILLY, individually as the Sibling of Timothy E. Reilly, Deceased ROSEMARIE REINA, individually as the Parent of Joseph Reina, Jr., Deceased JOANN O' KEEFE, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Reina, Jr., Deceased LISA REINA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Reina, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Reina, Jr. MICHAEL REINA, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Reina, Jr., Deceased JOSEPH REINA, SR., individually as the Parent of Joseph Reina, Jr., Deceased DOE 24, individually as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 24, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 24 DOE 24, individually as the Child of DOE 24, Deceased DOE 24, individually as the Child of DOE 24, Deceased GAYLE REISMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank Reisman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frank Reisman JUDITH JACKSON REISS, individually as the Parent of Joshua Scott Reiss, Deceased DANIEL RENDA, individually as the Child of Karen Renda, Deceased CHARLES RENDA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karen Renda, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Karen Renda CHRISTINA RESTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John 219

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 220 of 434

Thomas Resta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Thomas Resta DAWN ANGRISANI, individually as the Sibling of John Thomas Resta, Deceased CHRISTINE MAZZEO, individually as the Sibling of John Thomas Resta, Deceased BERNARD THOMAS RESTA, individually as the Parent of John Thomas Resta, Deceased MICHAEL RESTA, individually as the Sibling of John Thomas Resta, Deceased THOMAS RESTA, individually as the Sibling of John Thomas Resta, Deceased JO ANN R. RICCIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rudolph N. Riccio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Rudolph N. Riccio MARIA ELENA SANTORELLI, individually as the Child of Ann Marie Riccoboni, Deceased JANINE PASSELIS, individually as the Child of Ann Marie Riccoboni, Deceased JOHN RICCOBONI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ann Marie Riccoboni, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ann Marie Riccoboni CYNTHIA J. RICE, individually as the Parent of David H. Rice, Deceased HUGH DAVID RICE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David H. Rice, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David H. Rice DOE 102, individually as the Sibling of DOE 102, Deceased DOE 102, individually as the Sibling of DOE 102, Deceased DOE 102, individually as the Sibling of DOE 102, Deceased DOE 102, individually as the Sibling of DOE 102, Deceased DOE 102, individually as Sibling and as the 220

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 221 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 102, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 102 PAULA A. RIGO, individually as the Sibling of John Matthews Rigo, Deceased THEODORE P. RIGO, individually as the Sibling of John Matthews Rigo, Deceased JULIA RIVAS, individually as the Parent of Moises Rivas, Deceased NANCY ELIZABETH RIVAS MOLINA, individually as the Sibling of Moises Rivas, Deceased CARMEN RIVERA, individually as the Sibling of Isaias Rivera, Deceased GLORIA GONZALEZ, individually as the Sibling of Isaias Rivera, Deceased NILSA MILAGROS RIVERA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Isaias Rivera, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Isaias Rivera ADRIAN ISAAC RIVERA, individually as the Child of Isaias Rivera, Deceased JOSUE RIVERA TRUJILLO, individually as the Sibling of Isaias Rivera, Deceased MOISES RIVERA, individually as the Sibling of Isaias Rivera, Deceased TERESA RIVERSO, individually as the Parent of Joseph R. Riverso, Deceased MARIA RIVERSO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph R. Riverso, Deceased DOMENICO RIVERSO, individually as the Parent of Joseph R. Riverso, Deceased RALPH J. RIVERSO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph R. Riverso, Deceased WILLIAM D. RIVERSO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph R. Riverso, Deceased VIVIAN RIZZA, individually as the Parent of Paul V. Rizza, Deceased ELAINE M. RIZZA, individually and as the 221

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 222 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul V. Rizza, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul V. Rizza PAUL RIZZA, individually as the Parent of Paul V. Rizza, Deceased CONCETTA RIZZO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Rizzo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Rizzo LUCY ROBERTO, individually as the Parent of Joseph Roberto, Deceased LORRAINE CAIAZZO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Roberto, Deceased ROBERT ROBERTO, JR., individually as the Sibling of Joseph Roberto, Deceased ROBERT ROBERTO, SR., individually as the Parent of Joseph Roberto, Deceased DEBRA ROBERTS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Leo A. Roberts, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Leo A. Roberts PAULETTE ROBERTS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael E. Roberts, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. Roberts THOMAS ROBERTS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael E. Roberts, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. Roberts VERONICA M. ROBERTS, individually as the Parent of Michael Edward Roberts, Deceased KAREN E. ROBERTS, individually as the Sibling of Michael Edward Roberts, Deceased JOHN J. ROBERTS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Edward Roberts, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Edward Roberts MARCEE E. ROBERTSON, individually as the Parent of Donald W. Robertson, Jr., Deceased 222

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 223 of 434

KATHLEEN ROBERTSON CUNNINGHAM, individually as the Sibling of Donald W. Robertson, Jr., Deceased ELIZABETH ROBERTSON, individually as the Sibling of Donald W. Robertson, Jr., Deceased DONALD W. ROBERTSON, SR., individually as the Parent of Donald W. Robertson, Jr., Deceased WILLIAM H. ROBOTHAM, III, individually as the Spouse of Michell L. Robotham, Deceased MARILYN ROCHA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Antonio Rocha, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Antonio Rocha and on behalf of minor child E.R. REGINA E. RODAK, individually as the Parent of John Rodak, Deceased JOANNE RODAK GORI, individually as the Sibling of John Rodak, Deceased JOYCE ANN MARIE RODAK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Rodak, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Rodak JOHN J. RODAK, individually as the Parent of John Rodak, Deceased SARA RODRIGUES, individually as the Child of Antonio J. Rodrigues, Deceased CRISTINA RODRIGUES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Antonio J. Rodrigues, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Antonio J. Rodrigues DEIVI RODRIGUEZ, individually as the Child of David Bartolo Rodriguez, Deceased LENNY RODRIGUEZ, individually as the Child of David Bartolo Rodriguez, Deceased MELANIA GIL individually as domestic partner of David Bartolo Rodrigquez, Deceased, and as Parent of their children 223

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 224 of 434

DOE 98, individually as the Sibling of DOE 98, Deceased ELIZABETH A. SOUDANT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory E. Rodriguez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory E. Rodriguez and on behalf of minor child S.G. CINDY RODRIGUEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Rodriguez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Rodriguez MARIAN ROGAN, individually as the Parent of Matthew Sean Rogan, Deceased JOHN ROGAN, individually as the Parent of Matthew Sean Rogan, Deceased DOE 133, individually as the Parent of DOE 133, Deceased DOE 133, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 133, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 133 DOE 133, individually as the Sibling of DOE 133, Deceased DOE 140, individually as the Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 140, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 140 DOE 140, individually as the Sibling of DOE 140, Deceased DOE 140, individually as the Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 140, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 140 KRISTEN NEPOLA, individually as the Sibling of Scott W. Rohner, Deceased KATIE A. ROHNER, individually as the Sibling of Scott W. Rohner, Deceased THOMAS G. ROHNER, individually as the Sibling of Scott W. Rohner, Deceased STEPHEN J. ROHNER, individually as the 224

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 225 of 434

Sibling of Scott W. Rohner, Deceased MICHAEL R. ROHNER, individually as the Sibling of Scott W. Rohner, Deceased ROSEMARY ROMA, individually as the Parent of Keith Roma, Deceased MAUREEN ROMA, individually as the Sibling of Keith Roma, Deceased ARNOLD ROMA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith Roma, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Keith Roma KEVIN ROMA, individually as the Sibling of Keith Roma, Deceased DIANE ROMERO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Elvin Romero, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Elvin Romero PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Sean Rooney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Rooney. The REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Beverly Eckert, Deceased Parent of Sean Rooney PATRICIA ROSEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark H. Rosen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark H. Rosen BOBBI ROSNER, individually as the Parent of Sheryl Rosenbaum, Deceased BARRY ROSNER, individually as the Parent of Sheryl Rosenbaum, Deceased SUSAN S. ROSENBLUM, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joshua Rosenblum, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua Rosenblum REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Richard M. Rosenblum, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joshua Rosenblum DEAN ROSENBLUM, individually as the Sibling of Joshua Rosenblum, Deceased HELEN ROSENTHAL as the Personal 225

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 226 of 434

Representative of the Estate of Marilynn M. Rosenthal, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joshua Alan Rosenthal HELEN ROSENTHAL, individually as the Sibling of Joshua Alan Rosenthal, Deceased AVRAM ROSENTHAL, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joshua Alan Rosenthal, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua Alan Rosenthal LOREN ROSENTHAL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Rosenthal, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Rosenthal SHIRLEY ANN ROSETTI, individually as the Parent of Daniel James Rosetti, Deceased DARLENE ROSETTI, individually as the Sibling of Daniel James Rosetti, Deceased CHERYL ROSETTI, individually as the Sibling of Daniel James Rosetti, Deceased RICK ROSETTI, individually as the Sibling of Daniel James Rosetti, Deceased ROBERT J. ROSETTI, SR., individually as the Sibling of Daniel James Rosetti, Deceased DONNA MATTERA, individually as the Sibling of Nicholas P. Rossomando, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Peter A. Rossomando, Deceased, Parent of decedent Nicholas P. Rossomando CHRISTOPHER ROSSOMANDO, individually as the Sibling of Nicholas P. Rossomando, Deceased PETER CHARLES ROSSOMANDO, individually as the Sibling of Nicholas P. Rossomando, Deceased IRIS E. ROTHBERG, individually as the Parent of Michael C. Rothberg, Deceased RHONDA B. ROTHBERG, individually as the Sibling of Michael C. Rothberg, Deceased JASON ROTHBERG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 226

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 227 of 434

Michael C. Rothberg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael C. Rothberg MEREDITH H. ROTHENBERG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark D. Rothenberg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark D. Rothenberg NANCY KELLY on behalf of minor children P.R. and J.R. ALEXANDER WILLIAM ROWE, individually as the Parent of Nicholas Charles Alexander Rowe, Deceased MAUREEN MURPHY, individually as the Sibling of David Michael Ruddle, Deceased FERN RUHALTER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Adam K. Ruhalter, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Adam K. Ruhalter MARIE RUSSELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen P. Russell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen P. Russell WILLIAM RUSSELL, individually as the Sibling of Stephen P. Russell, Deceased CLIFFORD S. RUSSELL, JR., individually as the Sibling of Stephen P. Russell, Deceased CLIFFORD RUSSELL, SR., individually as the Parent of Stephen P. Russell, Deceased GLORIA RUSSIN, individually as the Parent of Steven Harris Russin, Deceased EDWARD RUSSIN, individually as the Parent of Steven Harris Russin, Deceased BARRY RUSSIN, individually as the Sibling of Steven Harris Russin, Deceased ARLENE RUSSO, individually as the Parent of Wayne A. Russo, Deceased ARTHUR RUSSO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wayne A. Russo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Wayne A. Russo REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Colleen 227

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 228 of 434

Ryan, Deceased, Sibling of decedent John Joseph Ryan, Jr. MARY V. RYAN, individually as the Parent of John Joseph Ryan, Jr., Deceased AILEEN ANNE RYAN, individually as the Sibling of John Joseph Ryan, Jr., Deceased PATRICK RYAN, individually as the Sibling of John Joseph Ryan, Jr., Deceased TEAGUE M. RYAN, individually as the Sibling of John Joseph Ryan, Jr., Deceased JOHN JOSEPH RYAN, SR., individually as the Parent of John Joseph Ryan, Jr., Deceased MARTINE SAADA, individually as the Parent of Thierry Saada, Deceased CINDY SAADA, individually as the Sibling of Thierry Saada, Deceased JEAN MARC SAADA, individually as the Parent of Thierry Saada, Deceased RUDY SAADA, individually as the Sibling of Thierry Saada, Deceased ROHY SAADA, individually as the Sibling of Thierry Saada, Deceased ANTHONY SAADA, individually as the Sibling of Thierry Saada, Deceased GARY SAADA, individually as the Sibling of Thierry Saada, Deceased BRIGITTE SABBAG, individually as the Parent of Jason Elazar Sabbag, Deceased LAURENCE HAGAN, individually as the Sibling of Jason Elazar Sabbag, Deceased RALPH SABBAG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jason Elazar Sabbag, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jason Elazar Sabbag CLIFTON SABBAG, individually as the Sibling of Jason Elazar Sabbag, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Angelina Sabella, Deceased, Parent of decedent Thomas E. Sabella 228

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 229 of 434

LORETTA SABELLA-VIGLIONE, individually as the Sibling of Thomas E. Sabella, Deceased DIANA SABELLA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas E. Sabella, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas E. Sabella REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Edward Sabella, Deceased, Parent of decedent Thomas E. Sabella CHARLES THOMAS SABELLA, individually as the Sibling of Thomas E. Sabella, Deceased ELAINE SABER, individually as the Parent of Scott Saber, Deceased BRUCE D. SABER, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Scott Saber, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Saber BRIAN SABER, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Scott Saber, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Saber PAUL SABIN, individually as the Child of Charles E. Sabin, Deceased CHARLES E. SABIN, JR., individually as the Child of Charles E. Sabin, Deceased ANDREA SACERDOTE, individually as the Child of Joseph Francis Sacerdote, Deceased ARLENE SACERDOTE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Francis Sacerdote, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Francis Sacerdote KAREN A. SACHS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jessica Leigh Sachs, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jessica Leigh Sachs KATHERINE SCOVILLE, individually as the Sibling of Jessica Leigh Sachs, Deceased STEPHEN R. SACHS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jessica Leigh 229

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 230 of 434

Sachs, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jessica Leigh Sachs ERIC M. SACHS, individually as the Sibling of Jessica Leigh Sachs, Deceased NORMA T. SADOCHA, individually as the Parent of Francis John Sadocha, Deceased SUSAN T. SADOCHA, individually as the Sibling of Francis John Sadocha, Deceased FRANK CARL SADOCHA, individually as the Parent of Francis John Sadocha, Deceased JOHN S. SADOCHA, individually as the Sibling of Francis John Sadocha, Deceased ELIAS SAFI, individually as the Parent of Jude Elias Safi, Deceased AHLAM SAFI, individually as the Parent of Jude Elias Safi, Deceased JOHN SAFI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jude Elias Safi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jude Elias Safi SILVERIA SEGURA, individually as the Domestic Partner of Juan G. Salas, Deceased DEBRA SALOMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wayne J. Saloman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Wayne J. Saloman ROSEMARIE GIALLOMBARDO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Richard Salvio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Richard Salvio DINA GIALLOMBARDO, individually as the Sibling of Paul Richard Salvio, Deceased VINCENT GIALLOMBARDO, individually as the Sibling of Paul Richard Salvio, Deceased ROBERT GIALLOMBARDO, JR., individually as the Sibling of Paul Richard Salvio, Deceased GLADYS H. SALVO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Samuel 230

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 231 of 434

Robert Salvo, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Samuel Robert Salvo, Jr. EUGENIA BOGADO, individually as the Parent of Carlos A. Samaniego, Deceased LUIS S. SAMANIEGO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carlos A. Samaniego, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Carlos A. Samaniego LINDA J. SAMUEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James K. Samuel, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James K. Samuel, Jr. JENNIFER AGRESTO, individually as the Sibling of James K. Samuel, Jr., Deceased JAMES K. SAMUEL, SR., individually as the Parent of James K. Samuel, Jr., Deceased JOSE LUIS SAN PIO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Sylvia San Pio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sylvia San Pio MARIA CARMEN PENAFIEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hugo Manuel Sanay-Perefiel, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Hugo Manuel Sanay-Perefiel FELICITA MARIA SANCHEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jesus Sanchez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jesus Sanchez REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Jesus Sanchez Rosado, Deceased, Parent of decedent Jesus Sanchez CAROL SUE SANDLER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Herman S. Sandler, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Herman S. Sandler JENNIFER SANDS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Sands, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Sands, Jr. DOE 10, individually as the Parent of DOE 10, 231

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 232 of 434

Deceased DOE 10, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 10, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 10 MAUREEN SANTORA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Christopher A. Santora, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher A. Santora JENNIFER SANTORA, individually as the Sibling of Christopher A. Santora, Deceased KATHLEEN SANTORA-MONTALI, individually as the Sibling of Christopher A. Santora, Deceased PATRICIA SANTORA, individually as the Sibling of Christopher A. Santora, Deceased ALEXANDER SANTORA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher A. Santora, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher A. Santora FRANCES SANTORE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John A. Santore, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John A. Santore ALBERTO ANGEL SANTORO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mario L. Santoro, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mario L. Santoro REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Anne C. Saracini, Deceased, Parent of decedent Victor J. Saracini JOANNE RENZI, individually as the Sibling of Victor J. Saracini, Deceased ELLEN LOUISE SARACINI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Victor J. Saracini, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Victor J. Saracini DOE 04, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 232

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 233 of 434

04, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 04 and on behalf of minor child DOE 04 KISHAN SARKAR, individually as the Child of Kalyan K. Sarkar, Deceased MANISH RAI, individually as the Sibling of Deepika Sattaluri, Deceased RYAN PEMBERTON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Marie Sauer, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Marie Sauer VALENTINA SAVINKINA, individually as the Parent of Vladimir Savinkin, Deceased GALINA SAVINKINA, individually as the Sibling of Vladimir Savinkin, Deceased VALERIY SAVINKIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vladimir Savinkin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vladimir Savinkin JUDE MONTESERRATO, individually as the Fiancé of John Michael Sbarbaro, Deceased MARGARET SCANDOLE, individually as the Parent of Robert L. Scandole, Deceased SHEILA MARIE SCANDOLE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert L. Scandole, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert L. Scandole ROBERT SCANDOLE, individually as the Parent of Robert L. Scandole, Deceased CHRISTOPHER SCANDOLE, individually as the Sibling of Robert L. Scandole, Deceased STEVEN SCARPITTA as the Represenative of the Estate Julie Scarpitta, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michelle Scarpitta STEVEN SCARPITTA as the Represenative of the Estate of Michelle Scarpitta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michelle Scarpitta STEVEN SCARPITTA, individually as the Sibling of Michelle Scarpitta, Deceased MARGARET TI SCHARDT, individually as the Parent of John Schardt, Deceased 233

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 234 of 434

DEBRA SACCO, individually as the Sibling of John Schardt, Deceased JEANETTE SCHARDT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Schardt, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Schardt and on behalf of minor children C.S. and J.S. ROBERT ALBERT SCHARDT, individually as the Parent of John Schardt, Deceased KENNETH SCHARDT, individually as the Sibling of John Schardt, Deceased ELLIOT SCHEINBERG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angela Susan Scheinberg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Angela Susan Scheinberg DOE 28, individually as the Parent of DOE 28, Deceased DOE 28, individually as the Sibling of DOE 28, Deceased DOE 28, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 28, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 28 LAUREN J. OSNATO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Karen Helene Schmidt, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Karen Helene Schmidt KARL H. SCHMIDT, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Karen Helene Schmidt, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Karen Helene Schmidt DINA M. SCHOTT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank G. Schott, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frank G. Schott, Jr. and on behalf of minor child J.S. LISA A. SCHUNK, individually as the Spouse of Edward W. Schunk, Deceased JENNIFER ABBE LEVINE, individually as the Child of Mark Schwartz, Deceased 234

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 235 of 434

NANCY BERLINER, individually as the Sibling of Mark Schwartz, Deceased PATRICIA SCHWARTZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Schwartz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Schwartz ANDREW DAVID SCHWARTZ, individually as the Child of Mark Schwartz, Deceased CHARLES SCIBETTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Adriana Scibetta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Adriana Scibetta and on behalf of minor child V.P.S. CRYSTAL MARIE SCOTT, individually as the Child of Janice Marie Scott, Deceased GERALDINE HOLMES, individually as the Parent of Janice Marie Scott, Deceased DARLENE BONITA CALDWELL, individually as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott, Deceased DELORES DIANE JAMES, individually as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott, Deceased DENISE M. HOLMES, individually as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott, Deceased CLAUDETTE MCKAHN STALEY, individually as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott, Deceased WILLETTE WAGES, individually as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of George A. Holmes, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Janice Marie Scott ABRAHAM SCOTT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Janice Marie Scott, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Janice Marie Scott DOE 34, individually as the Child of DOE 34, Deceased DOE 34, individually as the Child of DOE 34, Deceased 235

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 236 of 434

DOE 34, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 34, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 34 and on behalf of minor child DOE 34 DANIEL PAUL SEAMAN, individually as the Sibling of Michael Herman Seaman, Deceased LOREEN SELLITTO, individually as the Parent of Matthew Carmen Sellitto, Deceased MATTHEW T. SELLITTO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew Carmen Sellitto, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew Carmen Sellitto JONATHAN DIGIOVANNI SELLITTO, individually as the Sibling of Matthew Carmen Sellitto, Deceased FRANCES RUTH SELWYN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Howard Selwyn, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Howard Selwyn JAMES SELWYN, individually as the Child of Howard Selwyn, Deceased DEBBI ELLEN SENKO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Larry John Senko, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Larry John Senko and on behalf of minor child T.J.S. CHRISTINA SERVA, individually as the Child of Marian Teresa Serva, Deceased BRUCE E. SERVA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marian Teresa Serva, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Marian Teresa Serva IRENE SESSA, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Adele Sessa, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Adele Sessa ELENA SANDBERG, individually as the Sibling of Adele Sessa, Deceased CHRISTINE PATTERSON, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Adele 236

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 237 of 434

Sessa, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Adele Sessa ALBERICO SESSA, individually as the Sibling of Adele Sessa, Deceased JENNY RAHAMAN, individually as the Sibling of Sita N. Sewnarine, Deceased LILMATIE DIDORA, individually as the Sibling of Sita N. Sewnarine, Deceased BHOOPAUL SEWNARINE, individually as the Sibling of Sita N. Sewnarine, Deceased DOE 73, individually as the Domestic Partner and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 73, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 73 and on behalf of minor children DOE 73 and DOE 73 JANINE L. VAN RIPER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Barbara A. Shaw, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara A. Shaw DEBRA SHAW, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey J. Shaw, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey J. Shaw MAUREEN SHAY, individually as the Parent of Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased KATHLEEN SHAY, individually as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased LEANNE SHAY, individually as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased EILEEN SHAY, individually as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased CAROLYN SHAY, individually as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased MAUREEN SURKO, individually as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased DAWN M. SHAY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert J. Shay, Jr. JAMES SHAY, individually as the Sibling of 237

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 238 of 434

Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased MICHAEL A. SHAY, individually as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased ROBERT J. SHAY, SR., individually as the Parent of Robert J. Shay, Jr., Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Daniel J. Sheehan, Deceased Parent of Linda June Sheehan PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Linda June Sheehan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Linda June Sheehan ROBERT D. SHEEHAN, individually as the Sibling of Linda June Sheehan, Deceased ESTHER SHEFI, individually as the Parent of Hagay Shefi, Deceased PAZIT SHEFI BAUM, individually as the Sibling of Hagay Shefi, Deceased SIGAL SHEFI ASHER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hagay Shefi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Hagay Shefi DOV SHEFI, individually as the Parent of Hagay Shefi, Deceased YISHAI SHEFI, individually as the Sibling of Hagay Shefi, Deceased DOE 71, individually as the Parent of DOE 71, Deceased DOE 71, individually as the Sibling of DOE 71, Deceased DOE 71, individually as the Sibling of DOE 71, Deceased DOE 71, individually as the Sibling of DOE 71, Deceased DOE 71, individually as the Sibling of DOE 71, Deceased DOE 71, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 71, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 71 and on behalf of minor children DOE 238

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 239 of 434

71 and DOE 71 FRANK SHERRY, individually as the Parent of John Anthony Sherry, Deceased SACHIKO SHIRATORI, individually as the Parent of Atsushi Shiratori, Deceased HARUHIRO SHIRATORI, individually as the Parent of Atsushi Shiratori, Deceased AHUVA SHWARTZSTEIN, individually as the Parent of Allan Abraham Shwartzstein, Deceased ORLY SMALL, individually as the Sibling of Allan Abraham Shwartzstein, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Avigdor Shwartzstein, Deceased, Parent of decedent Allan Abraham Shwartzstein MICHAEL SHWARTZSTEIN, individually as the Sibling of Allan Abraham Shwartzstein, Deceased DOE 99, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 99, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 99 and on behalf of minor children DOE 99, DOE 99, DOE 99, DOE 99, and DOE 99 KATHLEEN H. SIMMONS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bruce E. Simmons, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Bruce E. Simmons DOE 57, individually as the Child of DOE 57, Deceased CHRISTOPHER SIMMONS, individually as the Child of George W. Simmons, Sr., Deceased GEORGE W. SIMMONS, JR., individually as the Child of George W. Simmons, Sr., Deceased EILEEN HEATHER SIMON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael John Simon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael John Simon SCOTT S. SIMON, individually as the Sibling 239

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 240 of 434

of Michael John Simon, Deceased SHELLEY SIMON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul J. Simon, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul J. Simon LISA CARDINALI, individually as the Child of Marianne Simone, Deceased TERESA HARGRAVE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marianne Simone, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Marianne Simone REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Virginia M. Liquori, Deceased, Sibling of Decedent Marianne Simone LUCILLE BLEIMANN, individually as the Sibling of Marianne Simone, Deceased STEPHEN SIMONE, individually as the Child of Marianne Simone, Deceased ANN SIMPKIN, individually as the Parent of Jane Louise Simpkin, Deceased HELEN C. SIMPKIN-WHALEN, individually as the Sibling of Jane Louise Simpkin, Deceased DIANE JAVA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeff L. Simpson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeff L. Simpson CRAIG W. SINCOCK, individually as the Spouse of Cheryle D. Sincock, Deceased ALANA SIRACUSE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Siracuse, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Siracuse and on behalf of minor child R.S. IRENE LESIW, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John P. Skala, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John P. Skala MICHAEL SKALA, individually as the Sibling of John P. Skala, Deceased 240

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 241 of 434

JAROSLAWA SKALA, individually as the Sibling of John P. Skala, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Loretta T. Slavin, Deceased, Parent of decedent Vincent R. Slavin ANNA L. BAEZ, individually as the Fiancé of Vincent R. Slavin, Deceased PATRICIA B. SLOAN, individually as the Parent of Paul Kenneth Sloan, Deceased RONALD S. SLOAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Kenneth Sloan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Kenneth Sloan LAWANDA SIMMONS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wendy L. Small, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Wendy L. Small ELBA CEDENO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Catherine T. Smith, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Catherine T. Smith ANNETTE SMITH, individually as the Parent of Catherine T. Smith, Deceased LISA ANN ETHREDGE, individually as the Sibling of Catherine T. Smith, Deceased BARBARA SCHIELZO, individually as the Sibling of Catherine T. Smith, Deceased VINCENT J. SMITH, individually as the Sibling of Catherine T. Smith, Deceased WALTER SMITH, individually as the Sibling of Catherine T. Smith, Deceased MADELINE W. SMITH, individually as the Parent of Jeffrey R. Smith, Deceased BRENDA SMITH CLARK, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey R. Smith, Deceased DOE 61, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 61, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 61 and on behalf of minor children DOE 61 and DOE 61 241

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 242 of 434

ARTHUR ABRAHAM SMITH, individually as the Parent of Jeffrey R. Smith, Deceased MILLICENT MILLER, individually as the Sibling of Joyce Patricia Smith, Deceased DOE 135, individually as the Sibling of DOE 135, Deceased GEORGIA RUTH SMITH, individually as the Parent of Karl T. Smith, Sr., Deceased DOE 87, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 87, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 87 and on behalf of minor child DOE 87 PETER HIBBARD SMITH, individually as the Sibling of Karl T. Smith, Sr., Deceased MATTHEW G. SMITH, individually as the Sibling of Karl T. Smith, Sr., Deceased DOE 87, individually as the Sibling of DOE 87, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Philip Trumbull Smith, Jr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Karl T. Smith, Sr. DOE 87, individually as the Child of DOE 87, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 52, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 52 DOE 52, individually as the Sibling of DOE 52, Deceased DOE 52, individually as the Sibling of DOE 52, Deceased JENNIFER ANN TUCKER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rochelle Monique Snell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Rochelle Monique Snell CHARLES O'NEAL SNYDER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Ann Snyder, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christine Ann Snyder JOHN B. SNYDER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dianne 242

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 243 of 434

Bullis Snyder, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dianne Bullis Snyder MARION ELAINE KMINEK, individually as the Parent of Mari-Rae Sopper, Deceased TAMMY LYNN SOPPER-SERGOVIA, individually as the Sibling of Mari-Rae Sopper, Deceased CHRISTINA KMINEK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of MariRae Sopper, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mari-Rae Sopper REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of R. Bill Sopper, Deceased, Parent of decedent Mari-Rae Sopper ELDA GIRON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Fabian Soto, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Fabian Soto and on behalf of minor child J.F.S. PAUL A. SPAGNOLETTI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory T. Spagnoletti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory T. Spagnoletti REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Doreen Lanza, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Thomas Sparacio EDITH A. SPARACIO, individually as the Parent of Thomas Sparacio, Deceased DEBORAH ANN KLEMOWITZ, individually as the Sibling of Thomas Sparacio, Deceased CHERI MAGNUS SPARACIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Sparacio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Sparacio and on behalf of minor childred E.S. and J.S. JACK JOSEPH SPARACIO, SR., individually as the Parent of Thomas Sparacio, Deceased PATRICIA ELLEN WELLINGTON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Anthony Spataro, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John 243

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 244 of 434

Anthony Spataro IRENE DESANTIS, individually as the Parent of Robert W. Spear, Jr., Deceased BARBARA P. KEANE, individually as the Sibling of Robert W. Spear, Jr., Deceased CHRISTINE VOLLKOMMER, individually as the Sibling of Robert W. Spear, Jr., Deceased LORRAINE SPEAR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert W. Spear, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert W. Spear, Jr. DOE 136, individually as the Child of DOE 136, Deceased DOE 136, individually as the Child of DOE 136, Deceased DOE 136, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate ofDOE 136, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 136 and on behalf of minor child DOE 136 IRENE SPINA, individually as the Parent of Lisa L. Spina-Trerotola, Deceased MARIO FRANCIS SPINA, individually as the Parent of Lisa L. Spina-Trerotola, Deceased PAUL M. SPINA, individually as the Sibling of Lisa L. Spina-Trerotola, Deceased MICHELLE SPINELLI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank J. Spinelli, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frank J. Spinelli, Jr. PAMELA SPITZ, individually as the Child of William Edward Spitz, Jr., Deceased LAUREN SPITZ, individually as the Child of William Edward Spitz, Jr., Deceased MICHAEL J. SPITZ, individually as the Sibling of William Edward Spitz, Jr., Deceased COLLEEN CASEY SPOR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph P. Spor, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Spor, Jr. and on 244

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 245 of 434

behalf of minor child C.M.S. LAUREN STABILE, individually as the Child of Michael F. Stabile, Deceased MICHELE STABILE, individually as the Child of Michael F. Stabile, Deceased ROSEANNA STABILE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael F. Stabile, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael F. Stabile ROBERT STABILE, individually as the Child of Michael F. Stabile, Deceased VEE STADELBERGER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Stadelberger, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Stadelberger and on behalf of minor child A.S. RENEE STAHLMAN, individually as the Parent of Eric Stahlman, Deceased BLANCA STAHLMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eric Stahlman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Stahlman and on behalf of minor children A.S. and J.S. SAMUEL STAHLMAN, individually as the Parent of Eric Stahlman, Deceased ELLEN STAJK SHELNUTT, individually as the Sibling of Gregory Stajk, Deceased JEANIE SOMERVILLE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory Stajk, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory Stajk LUCIA BALZAN, individually as the Sibling of Mary Domenica Stanley, Deceased PAUL J. STANLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Domenica Stanley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Domenica Stanley ROSEMARY ANN STARK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey Stark, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey Stark 245

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 246 of 434

KATHLEEN STARK, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey Stark, Deceased THERESE STARK, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey Stark, Deceased JOHN STARK, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey Stark, Deceased JOSEPH C. STARK, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey Stark, Deceased NANCY STATKEVICUS, individually as the Parent of Derek James Statkevicus, Deceased JOSEPH R. STATKEVICUS, individually as the Parent of Derek James Statkevicus, Deceased JOEL STATKEVICUS, individually as the Sibling of Derek James Statkevicus, Deceased FLORENCE WITTNER STAUB, individually as the Parent of Craig William Staub, Deceased CAROLYN STAUB BILELIS, individually as the Sibling of Craig William Staub, Deceased BARBARA MANEJA, individually as the Sibling of Craig William Staub, Deceased STACEY A. STAUB, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Craig William Staub, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Craig William Staub and on behalf of minor child J.S. KENNETH DONOHUE, individually as the Sibling of Craig William Staub, Deceased BLANCHE STEEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eric Thomas Steen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Thomas Steen GEORGE D. STEEN, II, individually as the Sibling of Eric Thomas Steen, Deceased MEREDITH ALAYNE STEINER, individually as the Child of William R. Steiner, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Wilma E. Steiner, Deceased Parent of William R. Steiner, Deceased

246

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 247 of 434

RUSSA STEINER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William R. Steiner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William R. Steiner JORDON CHRISTOFER-WILLIAM STEINER, individually and as the of the Estate of William R. Steiner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William R. Steiner DARREN ALEXANDER STEINER, individually and as the of the Estate of William R. Steiner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William R. Steiner ROBERT STEINER, individually as the Sibling of William R. Steiner, Deceased GEORGE STEINER, individually as the Sibling of William R. Steiner, Deceased ANGELA STERGIOPOULOS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Andrew Stergiopoulos, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Stergiopoulos KATHLEEN STERGIOPOULOS, individually as the Sibling of Andrew Stergiopoulos, Deceased GEORGE N. STERGIOPOULOS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Andrew Stergiopoulos, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Stergiopoulos GEORGE STERGIOPOULOS, JR., individually as the Sibling of Andrew Stergiopoulos, Deceased KATHERINE STERN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andrew Stern, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Stern and on behalf of minor children D.S. and E.S. NANCY A. COSBAN, individually as the Parent of Daniel E. Stewart, Deceased RICHARD W. STEWART, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel E. Stewart, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel E. Stewart 247

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 248 of 434

RUSSEL F. STEWART, individually as the Sibling of Daniel E. Stewart, Deceased JAMES R. STEWART, individually as the Sibling of Daniel E. Stewart, Deceased DOE 25 on behalf of minor children DOE 25 and DOE 25 ELIZABETH STEWART, individually as the Parent of Michael James Stewart, Deceased JANET STEWART, individually as the Sibling of Michael James Stewart, Deceased JOAN B. STEWART, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Richard H. Stewart, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard H. Stewart, Jr. SUSAN STEWART TILLIER, individually as the Sibling of Richard H. Stewart, Jr., Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Richard H. Stewart, Sr., Deceased Parent of decedent Richard H. Stewart, Jr. CHARLES PARKER, III, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Douglas Stone, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Douglas Stone and on behalf of minor child Z.S.S. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Evelyn Stone, Deceased Parent of Decedent Lonny Jay Stone GAYLE STONE, individually as the Sibling of Lonny Jay Stone, Deceased BEN STONE, individually as the Parent of Lonny Jay Stone, Deceased TERRY STRADA, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas S. Strada, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas S. Strada and on behalf of minor child J.T.S. KAITLYN C. STRADA, individually as the child of Thomas S. Strada, Deceased THOMAS J. STRADA, individually as the child of Thomas S. Strada, Deceased 248

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 249 of 434

MARY EMMA STRAINE, individually as the Parent of James J. Straine, Jr., Deceased PATRICIA A. STRAINE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James J. Straine, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James J. Straine, Jr. and on behalf of minor children C.J.S. and F.P.S. JAMES JOSEPH STRAINE, individually as the Parent of James J. Straine, Jr., Deceased KEVIN JOSEPH STRAINE, individually as the Sibling of James J. Straine, Jr., Deceased DANIEL MATTHEW STRAINE, individually as the Sibling of James J. Straine, Jr., Deceased MICHAEL STRAINE, individually as the Sibling of James J. Straine, Jr., Deceased SANDRA N. STRAUB, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward W. Straub, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward W. Straub SAMUEL E. STRAUB, individually as the Child of Edward W. Straub, Deceased VIRGINIA STRAUCH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George Strauch, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of George Strauch REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Olga C. Strickland, Deceased, Parent of decedent Larry L. Strickland JULIA DILL, individually as the Child of Larry L. Strickland, Deceased DONNA M. MCBRIDE, individually as the Sibling of Larry L. Strickland, Deceased DEBRA LOUISE STRICKLAND, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Larry L. Strickland, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Larry L. Strickland REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Lee Strickland, Deceased, Parent of decedent Larry L. Strickland MATTHEW LEE STRICKLAND, individually 249

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 250 of 434

as the Child of Larry L. Strickland, Deceased CHRISTOPHER ROBERT STRICKLAND, individually as the Child of Larry L. Strickland, Deceased THELMA STUART, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Walwyn W. Stuart, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Walwyn W. Stuart, Jr. and on behalf of minor child A.C.S. SALLY ANN SUAREZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benjamin Suarez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Benjamin Suarez and on behalf of minor children C.S., J.S., A.S. and J.S. ELMA A. SUGRA, individually and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of William Christopher Sugra, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Christopher Sugra WILLIAM J. SUGRA, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of William Christopher Sugra, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Christopher Sugra JEAN SUHR RYAN, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Suhr, Deceased LEEANN M. SUHR KLEIN, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Suhr, Deceased NANCY SUHR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Suhr, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Suhr and on behalf B.S. CHRISTOPHER SUHR, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Suhr, Deceased EVELYN SULLINS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Marc Sullins, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David Marc Sullins and on behalf of minor children J.A.S. and C.M.S. MARY SULLIVAN, individually as the Parent of Patrick Sullivan, Deceased PATRICK J. SULLIVAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of 250

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 251 of 434

Patrick Sullivan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick Sullivan GERALD SULLIVAN, individually as the Sibling of Patrick Sullivan, Deceased GREGORY SULLIVAN, individually as the Sibling of Patrick Sullivan, Deceased ARLENE R SULLIVAN, individually as the Parent of Thomas G. Sullivan, Deceased NORENE SCHNEIDER, individually as the Sibling of Thomas G. Sullivan, Deceased DEIRDRE DICKINSON SULLIVAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas G. Sullivan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas G. Sullivan and on behalf of minor children C.L.S. and D.J.S. ESTRELLA SUMAYA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr. CHRISTINE TROTTA, individually as the Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., Deceased MARIVEL PASSACANTANDO, individually as the Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., Deceased CHARITO LEBLANC, individually as the Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., Deceased LISA SUMAYA, individually as the Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., Deceased REYNALDO SUMAYA, individually as the Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., Deceased NOREEN SUPINSKI, individually as the Parent of Colleen M. Supinski, Deceased STEVEN A. SUPINSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Colleen M. Supinski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Colleen M. Supinski 251

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 252 of 434

NATHAN SUPINSKI, individually as the Sibling of Colleen M. Supinski, Deceased BENJAMIN SUPINSKI, individually as the Sibling of Colleen M. Supinski, Deceased PATRICIA SUTCLIFFE, individually as the Parent of Robert Sutcliffe, Deceased MARGARET SUTCLIFFE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Sutcliffe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Sutcliffe and on behalf of minor children K.S., K.S., and B.S. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Robert Sutcliffe, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Robert Sutcliffe BERNELL SUTTON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Claudia Sutton, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Claudia Sutton and on behalf of minor children K.S. and K.S. JULIE SWEENY ROTH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian D. Sweeney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Brian D. Sweeney MICHAEL GERARD SWEENEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Madeline Amy Sweeney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Madeline Amy Sweeney and on behalf of minor children A.E.S. and J.M.S. MAUREEN SULLIVAN, individually as the Fiancé of Derek O. Sword, Deceased MICHAEL SZTEJNBERG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gina Sztejnberg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gina Sztejnberg ELEANOR NEVILLE, individually as the Parent of Joann Tabeek, Deceased MAUREEN PICKERING, individually as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek, Deceased PATRICIA A. HEYNE, individually as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek, Deceased 252

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 253 of 434

ALEX TABEEK as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joann Tabeek, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joann Tabeek, and on behalf of minor child K.T. VINCENT A. MILOTTA, individually as the Fiancé of Joann Tabeek, Deceased JAMES E. SMITH, individually as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek, Deceased WILLIAM SMITH, individually as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek, Deceased MICHAEL SMITH, individually as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek, Deceased DANIELLE TADDONIO, individually as the Child of Michael Taddonio, Deceased NICOLE TADDONIO, individually as the Child of Michael Taddonio, Deceased DENISE TADDONIO, individually as the Spouse of Michael Taddonio, Deceased MICHAEL TADDONIO, individually as the Child of Michael Taddonio, Deceased JOSEPH KEITH TALBOT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Phyllis Talbot, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Phyllis Talbot DIANA TALHAMI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert R. Talhami, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert R. Talhami and on behalf of minor children J.E.T. and N.T. EILEEN BERTORELLI-ZANGRILLO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Marcy Talignani, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Marcy Talignani ALICE BERTORELLI, individually as the Sibling of John Marcy Talignani, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Armand Talignani, Deceased, Sibling of decedent John Marcy Talignani 253

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 254 of 434

GLORIA TALTY, individually as the Parent of Paul Talty, Deceased KERRY MCCALL, individually as the Sibling of Paul Talty, Deceased PATRICIA DOUGAN, individually as the Sibling of Paul Talty, Deceased BARBARA TALTY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Talty, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Talty and on behalf of minor children K.T., P.T., and L.T. JOHN PAUL TALTY, individually as the Parent of Paul Talty, Deceased KEVIN TALTY, individually as the Sibling of Paul Talty, Deceased STEVEN TALTY, individually as the Sibling of Paul Talty, Deceased MARK TALTY, individually as the Sibling of Paul Talty, Deceased JULIE M.Y. TAM, individually as the Parent of Maurita Tam, Deceased STEPHANIE TAM, individually as the Sibling of Maurita Tam, Deceased JIN ARK TAM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maurita Tam, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Maurita Tam DONALD TAM, individually as the Sibling of Maurita Tam, Deceased PAMELA M. TAMAYO, individually as the Child of Hector R. Tamayo, Deceased ELNA R. TAMAYO-PRADO, individually as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo, Deceased SHEILA R. TAMAYO-PUNZALAN, individually as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo, Deceased EVANGELINE R. TAMAYO-IGUINA, individually as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo, Deceased

254

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 255 of 434

EVELYN MERCENE TAMAYO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hector R. Tamayo, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Hector R. Tamayo JULIAN IAN TAMAYO, individually as the Child of Hector R. Tamayo, Deceased LUTHER ROGAN TAMAYO, individually as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo, Deceased SEVERINO ROGAN TAMAYO, JR., individually as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo, Deceased SEVERINO Y. TAMAYO, SR., individually as the Parent of Hector R. Tamayo, Deceased PATRICIA E. TAMUCCIO, individually as the Parent of Michael Andre Tamuccio, Deceased DANA M. TAMUCCIO, individually as the Sibling of Michael Andre Tamuccio, Deceased JAMES W. TAMUCCIO, II, individually as the Sibling of Michael Andre Tamuccio, Deceased JAMES W. TAMUCCIO, SR., individually as the Parent of Michael Andre Tamuccio, Deceased DIANE TAORMINA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis G. Taormina, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis G. Taormina, Jr. and on behalf of minor children J.T. and M.T. THERESA MARIE TARANTINO, individually as the Parent of Kenneth J. Tarantino, Deceased VICTORIA JANE MELONE, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth J. Tarantino, Deceased DOE 62, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 62, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 62 and on behalf of minor children DOE 62 and DOE 62 KENNETH THOMAS TARANTINO, individually as the Parent of Kenneth J. Tarantino, Deceased 255

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 256 of 434

MEHR A. TARIQ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Amanulah Tariq, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Amanulah Tariq PATRICIA PETERSON TARROU, individually as the Parent of Michael C. Tarrou, Deceased DEMETRA T. LUMIA, individually as the Sibling of Michael C. Tarrou, Deceased GIGI T. HINTZ, individually as the Sibling of Michael C. Tarrou, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of James Tarrou, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael C. Tarrou CHARLES J. TARROU, individually as the Sibling of Michael C. Tarrou, Deceased TERESA TARTARO, individually as the Parent of Ronald G. Tartaro, Deceased ROSANNA P. TARTARO, individually as the Sibling of Ronald G. Tartaro, Deceased KAREN REILLY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald G. Tartaro, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald G. Tartaro and on behalf of minor children D.T. and A.T. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of William Tartaro, Deceased, Parent of decedent Ronald G. Tartaro SARAH TAYLOR, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donnie B. Taylor, Sr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Donnie B. Taylor, Sr. and on behalf of minor children D.T. and S.L.T. CLARA S. TAYLOR, individually as the Parent of Michael M. Taylor, Deceased KATHRYN TAYLOR TEARE, individually as the Sibling of Michael M. Taylor, Deceased MARY KAYE CRENSHAW, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael M. Taylor, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael M. Taylor 256

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 257 of 434

REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of James H. Taylor, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael M. Taylor JAMES J. TAYLOR, individually as the Sibling of Michael M. Taylor, Deceased ELAINE S. TEAGUE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sandra D. Teague, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sandra D. Teague WENDY TEEPE GREEN, individually as the Child of Karl W. Teepe, Deceased DONNA D. TEEPE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karl W. Teepe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Karl W. Teepe ADAM KARL TEEPE, individually as the Child of Karl W. Teepe, Deceased DOROTHY MARIA TEMPESTA, individually as the Parent of Anthony Tempesta, Deceased ANA TEMPESTA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony Tempesta, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony Tempesta and on behalf of minor child A.T. and M.T. CLIFFORD DANIEL TEMPESTA, individually as the Parent of Anthony Tempesta, Deceased CLIFFORD M. TEMPESTA, individually as the Sibling of Anthony Tempesta, Deceased MICHAEL TEMPESTA, individually as the Sibling of Anthony Tempesta, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Rosalyn Temple, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Dorothy Temple REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Dorothy Temple, Deceased, and on behalf of all survivors of Dorthy Temple JACQUELINE TEMPLE, individually as the Sibling of Dorothy Temple, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Louis 257

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 258 of 434

Temple, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Dorothy Temple WILLIE TEMPLE, individually as the Nephew of Dorothy Temple, Deceased LARRY J. TEMPLE, individually as the Sibling of Dorothy Temple, Deceased BRITT EHNAR, individually as the Parent of David Tengelin, Deceased PETRA EHNAR, individually as the Sibling of David Tengelin, Deceased PATRIC TENGELIN, individually as the Sibling of David Tengelin, Deceased LUCY E. THOMPSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Clive Thompson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Clive Thompson and on behalf of minor children R.T. and E.C.T. KEITH B. THOMPSON, individually as the Sibling of Clive Thompson, Deceased VIOLET THOMPSON, individually as the Parent of Glenn Thompson, Deceased CHRISTINE E. THOMPSON, individually as the Sibling of Glenn Thompson, Deceased KAI HERNANDEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Glenn Thompson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Glenn Thompson EDWARD THOMPSON, individually as the Parent of Glenn Thompson, Deceased SCOTT M. THOMPSON, individually as the Sibling of Glenn Thompson, Deceased CHARLETTE THOMPSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Perry Thompson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Perry Thompson and on behalf of minor children A.T. and C.T. MARILYN WILLIAMS THORPE, individually as the Parent of Eric R. Thorpe, Deceased SUSAN THORPE BURGHOUWT, 258

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 259 of 434

individually as the Sibling of Eric R. Thorpe, Deceased LINDA PERRY THORPE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eric R. Thorpe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eric R. Thorpe and on behalf of minor child A.M.T. RAYMOND R. THORPE, individually as the Parent of Eric R. Thorpe, Deceased MAUREEN TIERI, individually as the Spouse of Salvatore Tieri, Deceased and on behalf of minor children A.T. and J.T. HELEN MARY TIERNEY, individually as the Parent of John P. Tierney, Deceased MARY E. DIGIACOMO, individually as the Sibling of John P. Tierney, Deceased JEANNE NEUMEYER, individually as the Sibling of John P. Tierney, Deceased HELEN MARY TIERNEY as Representative of the Estate of John Tierney, Deceased, Parent of decedent John P. Tierney PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE, of the Estate of John P. Tierney, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John P. Tierney THOMAS TIERNEY, individually as the Sibling of John P. Tierney, Deceased LINDA G TIESTE, individually as the Sibling of William R. Tieste, Deceased DEBRA ANNE TIESTE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William R. Tieste, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William R. Tieste REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Ronald Tieste, Deceased, Sibling of decedent William R. Tieste WILLIAM CHARLES TIESTE, individually as the Child of William R. Tieste, Deceased KEITH TIESTE, individually as the Child of William R. Tieste, Deceased KAREN DALLAVALLE, individually as the 259

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 260 of 434

Fiancé of Kenneth F. Tietjen, Deceased JANICE TIETJEN, individually as the Parent of Kenneth F. Tietjen, Deceased CINDY TIETJEN, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth F. Tietjen, Deceased LAURIE TIETJEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth F. Tietjen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth F. Tietjen KENNETH A. TIETJEN, individually as the Parent of Kenneth F. Tietjen, Deceased JANE M. O'DEA, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Edward Tighe, Deceased ROBERTA L. SHEA, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Edward Tighe, Deceased KATHLEEN MARIE TIGHE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen Edward Tighe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Edward Tighe and on behalf of minor children E.A.T., L.G.T., M.J.T., and P.J.T. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Timothy J. Tighe, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Stephen Edward Tighe JAMES H. TIGHE, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Edward Tighe, Deceased KRISTINE TIMMES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Charles Timmes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Charles Timmes and on behalf of minor child S.E.T. JENNA TINLEY MATHER, individually as the Child of Michael Ernest Tinley, Deceased LISA KENNEDY, individually as the Child of Michael Ernest Tinley, Deceased JOAN E. TINO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jennifer M. Tino, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer M. Tino PAMELA SCHIELE, individually as the 260

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 261 of 434

Sibling of Jennifer M. Tino, Deceased RICHARD TIPALDI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Tipaldi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Tipaldi ARLENE M. TIPPING, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John J. Tipping, Ii, II, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John J. Tipping, Ii, II STEPHANIE L. TIPPING, individually as the Sibling of John J. Tipping, Ii, II, Deceased JOHN J. TIPPING, individually as the Parent of John J. Tipping, Ii, II, Deceased MARINA IRENE UGARTE TIRADO, individually as the Child of Hector Luis Tirado, Jr., Deceased SHENEQUE TIRADO JACKSON, individually as the Spouse of Hector Luis Tirado, Jr., Deceased ANGEL LUIS TIRADO, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Hector Luis Tirado, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Hector Luis Tirado, Jr. and on behalf of minor children A.T., H.T., D.T., R.T., D.T. R.A.T. BEVERLY J. TITUS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alicia Nicole Titus, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alicia Nicole Titus JOHN L. TITUS, individually as the Parent of Alicia Nicole Titus, Deceased MARIA TERESA RUEDA DE TORRES, individually as the Parent of Luis Eduardo Torres, Deceased MONICA TORRES, individually as the Sibling of Luis Eduardo Torres, Deceased MARTIN TOYEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Amy E. Toyen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Amy E. Toyen HADIDJATOU TRAORE, individually and as 261

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 262 of 434

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Abdoul Karim Traore, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Abdoul Karim Traore ELYSE TRAVERS, individually as the Child of Walter P. Travers, Deceased ROSEMARY TRAVERS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Walter P. Travers, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Walter P. Travers KEVIN TRAVERS, individually as the Child of Walter P. Travers, Deceased BRIAN FRANCIS TRAVERS, individually as the Child of Walter P. Travers, Deceased SHARON B. SCHULTZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karamo Trerra, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Karamo Trerra BRENDA TRINIDAD, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad, Deceased CAROL PAYNE, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad, Deceased BETTY ANDRADE, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad, Deceased JEANETTE TRINIDAD RZEK, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad, Deceased JANE TRINIDAD HENNES, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad, Deceased MILLIE CASERES SCHIFANO, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad, Deceased DENISE TRINIDAD, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad, Deceased MONIQUE PADILLA-FERRER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael A. Trinidad, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael A. Trinidad and on behalf of minor children T.M.T. and T.M.T. ROBERT TRINIDAD, individually as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad, Deceased 262

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 263 of 434

MARIE CLAIRE TROST, individually as the Parent of Gregory J. Trost, Deceased JEANNE TROST, individually as the Sibling of Gregory J. Trost, Deceased GEORGE D. TROST, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory J. Trost, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory J. Trost RENEE M. TROY, individually as the Child of Willie Quincy Troy, Deceased JUDY S. TROY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Willie Quincy Troy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Willie Quincy Troy and on behalf of minor child J.A.T. ELIZABETH RACHEL TURNER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Simon James Turner, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Simon James Turner and on behalf of minor child W.S.T. JOHN RICHARD TURNER, individually as the Parent of Simon James Turner, Deceased NANCY DORIS TZEMIS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis SOPHIA TZEMIS, individually as the Sibling of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis, Deceased NICOLE TZEMIS, individually as the Sibling of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis, Deceased STAMATIOS K. TZEMIS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis LINDA BUFFA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael A. Uliano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael A. Uliano SUSAN RUTH BLOMBERG, individually as the Parent of Jonathan Uman, Deceased, and as Executrix of the Estate of Harvey Blomberg, 263

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 264 of 434

Deceased, Parent of decedent Jonathan Uman ANNE MARIE VACCACIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Damien Vaccacio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Damien Vaccacio JAMES R. VACCACIO, individually as the Parent of John Damien Vaccacio, Deceased CHRISTOPHER J. VACCACIO, individually as the Sibling of John Damien Vaccacio, Deceased DONALD JOSEPH VADAS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bradley H. Vadas, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Bradley H. Vadas CARMEN GARCIA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Felix Antonio Vale, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Felix Antonio Vale CARMEN GARCIA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ivan Vale, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ivan Vale GRISSEL RODRIGUEZ VALENTIN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benito Valentin, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Benito Valentin REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 08, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 08 SARAH B. VAN AUKEN, individually as the Child of Kenneth Warren Van Auken, Deceased DOE 08, individually as the Sibling of DOE 08, Deceased DOE 08, individually as the Sibling of DOE 08, Deceased LORIE JILL VAN AUKEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth Warren Van Auken, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth Warren Van Auken 264

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 265 of 434

REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 08, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 08 MATTHEW D. VAN AUKEN, individually as the Child of Kenneth Warren Van Auken, Deceased RITA M. WILEY and PAUL VAN LAERE as Co-Administrators of the Estate of M. Rita Van Laere, Deceased, Parent of Decedent Daniel Maurice Van Laere CHERYL RINBRAND, individually as the Fiancé of Daniel Maurice Van Laere, Deceased JACQUELINE VAN LAERE, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Maurice Van Laere, Deceased RITA M. WILEY and PAUL VAN LAERE as Co-Administrators of the Estate of Daniel Maurice Van Laere, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Maurice Van Laere RITA M. WILEY, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Maurice Van Laere, Deceased PAUL VAN LAERE, individually as the Sibling of Daniel Maurice Van Laere, Deceased EILEEN VARACCHI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frederick Varacchi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frederick Varacchi and on behalf of minor children T.V., T.V., and C.V. VASUNDARA VARADHAN, individually as the Parent of Gopalakrishnan Varadhan, Deceased SRINIVASA VARADHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gopalakrishnan Varadhan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gopalakrishnan Varadhan ROSA CAICEDO, individually as the domestic partner of David Vargas, Deceased and on behalf of decedent's children Kevin Robert Vargas and Leslie Michelle Vargas REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 53, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 53 265

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 266 of 434

DOE 53, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 53, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 53 and on behalf of minor child DOE 53 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 53, Deceased, Parent of decedent DOE 53 REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of DOE 53, Deceased, Sibling of decedent DOE 53 ELOISA RODRIGUEZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Azael Vasquez, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Azael Vasquez and on behalf of minor child G.V. MELISSA VAZQUEZ, individually as the Child of Arcangel Vazquez, Deceased MARCELLA T. VELING, individually as the Parent of Lawrence J. Veling, Deceased TERESA VELING CZARK, individually as the Sibling of Lawrence J. Veling, Deceased MARCELLA J. TUOHY, individually as the Sibling of Lawrence J. Veling, Deceased DIANE J. VELING, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lawrence J. Veling, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Lawrence J. Veling and on behalf of minor children K.V.. C.V., and R.V. LISA A. VENTURA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony M. Ventura, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony M. Ventura and on behalf of minor children J.V. and N.V. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Marion Rita Paolo, Deceased, Parent of decedent Loretta A. Vero CATHERINE PEDERSEN, individually and as the Fiduciary of the Estate of Loretta A. Vero, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Loretta A. Vero KATHERINE VIALONGA, individually as the Parent of Christopher Vialonga, Deceased GARY VIALONGA, individually and as the 266

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 267 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Vialonga, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Vialonga JILL ROBIN VICARIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Vicario, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Vicario and on behalf of minor child S.R.V. JEANETTE VIGIANO, individually as the Parent of John Thomas Vigiano, II, Deceased JOHN T. VIGIANO, individually as the Parent of John Thomas Vigiano, II, Deceased JEANETTE VIGIANO, individually as the Parent of Joseph Vincent Vigiano, Deceased KATHLEEN VIGIANO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Vincent Vigiano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Vincent Vigiano and on behalf of minor children J.V., J.V., and J.V. JOHN T. VIGIANO, individually as the Parent of Joseph Vincent Vigiano, Deceased FRANCES VIGNOLA, individually as the Parent of Frank J. Vignola, Jr., Deceased DIANE FRANCES ANTOLOS, individually as the Sibling of Frank J. Vignola, Jr., Deceased ELLEN B. VIGNOLA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank J. Vignola, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frank J. Vignola, Jr. and on behalf of minor children S.C.V. and A.F.V. JAMES ANTHONY VIGNOLA, individually as the Sibling of Frank J. Vignola, Jr., Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Antionette Vilardo, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joseph B. Vilardo DIANE BRAITSCH, individually as the Sibling of Joseph B. Vilardo, Deceased MARGARET MAHON, individually as the Sibling of Joseph B. Vilardo, Deceased 267

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 268 of 434

JANET VILARDO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph B. Vilardo, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Benedict Vilardo, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joseph B. Vilardo TANYA VILLANUEVA TEPPER, individually as the Fiancé of Sergio Villanueva, Deceased DELIA VILLANUEVA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sergio Villanueva, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sergio Villanueva MARIA SUAREZ, individually as the Sibling of Sergio Villanueva, Deceased STEVE VILLANUEVA, individually as the Sibling of Sergio Villanueva, Deceased LUCILLE A. VINCENT, individually as the Parent of Melissa Vincent, Deceased CARRIE B. VINCENT, individually as the Sibling of Melissa Vincent, Deceased DAVID RELF VINCENT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Melissa Vincent, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Melissa Vincent MATTHEW D. VINCENT, individually as the Sibling of Melissa Vincent, Deceased NUNZIO G. VIRGILIO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francine Virgilio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Francine Virgilio MARIE VISCIANO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Gerard Visciano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Gerard Visciano REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Frank Visciano, Deceased, Parent of decedent Joseph Gerard Visciano ROBERT VISCIANO, individually as the Sibling of Joseph Gerard Visciano, Deceased JASON VISCIANO, individually as the Sibling 268

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 269 of 434

of Joseph Gerard Visciano, Deceased INA LEVENTHAL, individually as the Fiancé of Joshua S. Vitale, Deceased SUSAN R. ROSEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joshua S. Vitale, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua S. Vitale DOE 112, individually as the Sibling of DOE 112, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Irma Vukosa, Deceased, Parent of decedent Alfred Vukosa SONJA M. VUKOSA, individually as the Sibling of Alfred Vukosa, Deceased SHIRIMATTIE LALMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alfred Vukosa, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alfred Vukosa and on behalf of minor child A.V. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Sime Vukosa, Deceased, Parent of decedent Alfred Vukosa AUSTIN VUKOSA, individually as the Child of Alfred Vukosa, Deceased NASSIMA M. WACHTLER, individually as the Parent of Gregory Kamal Bruno Wachtler, Deceased PAUL W. WACHTLER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory Kamal Bruno Wachtler, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory Kamal Bruno Wachtler SCOTT E. WAHLSTROM, individually as the Child of Mary Alice Wahlstrom, Deceased MICHAEL O. WAHLSTROM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Alice Wahlstrom, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Alice Wahlstrom MARY LOUISE WHITE, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Honor 269

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 270 of 434

Elizabeth Wainio, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Honor Elizabeth Wainio CLARA ROSARIO, individually as the Parent of Wendy A. Wakeford, Deceased ADA DOLCH, individually as the Sibling of Wendy A. Wakeford, Deceased RAQUEL NEGRON, individually as the Sibling of Wendy A. Wakeford, Deceased MIRIAM PAINE, individually as the Sibling of Wendy A. Wakeford, Deceased CLARA L. PACHOMSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wendy A. Wakeford, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Wendy A. Wakeford EDWIN ROSARIO, individually as the Sibling of Wendy A. Wakeford, Deceased LAURA WALKER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benjamin James Walker, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Benjamin James Walker and on behalf of minor children C.W., S.W., and H.W. NOREEN V. MCDONOUGH, individually as the Fiancé of Mitchel Scott Wallace, Deceased RITA WALLACE, individually as the Parent of Mitchel Scott Wallace, Deceased MICHELE MILLER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mitchel Scott Wallace, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mitchel Scott Wallace KEN WALLACE, individually as the Parent of Mitchel Scott Wallace, Deceased SUSAN ANN WALLACE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roy Wallace, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Roy Wallace and on behalf of minor children C.W. and M.W. RAINA WALLENS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew Blake Wallens, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew Blake 270

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 271 of 434

Wallens ASHLEY JORDAN WALLENS, individually as the Sibling of Matthew Blake Wallens, Deceased CHRISLAN FULLER MANUEL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Meta L. Waller, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Meta L. Waller ALLISON A. DIMARZIO, individually as the Child of Barbara P. Walsh, Deceased JENNIFER L. LANDSTROM, individually as the Child of Barbara P. Walsh, Deceased JEFFREY M. WALSH, individually as the Child of Barbara P. Walsh, Deceased JAMES J. WALSH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Barbara P. Walsh, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara P. Walsh JAMES J. WALSH, JR., individually as the Child of Barbara P. Walsh, Deceased KATE WALSH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Walsh, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Walsh and on behalf of minor children F.W. and C.W. JENNIE WALZ, individually as the Parent of Jeffrey P. Walz, Deceased KAREN CIACCIO, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey P. Walz, Deceased RANI DEBORAH WALZ, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey P. Walz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey P. Walz and on behalf of minor child B.M.W. RAYMOND G. WALZ, individually as the Parent of Jeffrey P. Walz, Deceased RAYMOND E. WALZ, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey P. Walz, Deceased WEN SHI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Weibin Wang, 271

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 272 of 434

Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Weibin Wang and on behalf of minor children R.W., R.W., and M.W. ZHENJIE WANG, individually as the Parent of Weibin Wang, Deceased DENIS A. WARCHOLA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Warchola, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Warchola REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Michael Warchola, Sr., Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael Warchola VICTORIA RANDALL, individually as the Parent of Stephen Gordon Ward, Deceased SUSAN MOORE, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Gordon Ward, Deceased KATHRYN WARD HAZEL, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Gordon Ward, Deceased GORDON M. WARD, individually as the Parent of Stephen Gordon Ward, Deceased KENNETH R. WARD, individually as the Sibling of Stephen Gordon Ward, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Susanne Ward Baker, Deceased, Parent of decedent Timothy Ray Ward REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Timothy Ray Ward, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Timothy Ray Ward. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Doyle Raymond Ward, Deceased, Parent of decedent Timothy Ray Ward MARIA A. WARING, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Arthur Waring, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Arthur Waring and on behalf of minor children M.C.W., J.R.W., J.M.W., and S.A.W. LETTIE WASHINGTON, individually as the Parent of Derrick Christopher Washington, Deceased 272

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 273 of 434

KEISHA WASHINGTON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Derrick Christopher Washington, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Derrick Christopher Washington and on behalf of minor children C.W., D.W., M.W., and J.A. TRACEY WASHINGTON, individually as the Sibling of Derrick Christopher Washington, Deceased BRANDON WASHINGTON, individually as the Sibling of Derrick Christopher Washington, Deceased EARNEST WASHINGTON, JR., individually as the Parent of Derrick Christopher Washington, Deceased BARBARA WATERS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Waters, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Waters and on behalf of minor children A.W., J.W., and C.E.W. JOANNE MARIE WATERS, individually as the Parent of James Thomas Waters, Jr., Deceased KAREN MARIE SMART, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Thomas Waters, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Thomas Waters, Jr. KRISTOPHER T. WATERS, individually as the Sibling of James Thomas Waters, Jr., Deceased JANICE WATERS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick J. Waters, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick J. Waters and on behalf of minor children C.W. and D.W. DOE 74, individually as the Sibling of DOE 74, Deceased ZOE LOUISE GHIRARDUZZI, individually as the Child of Dinah Webster, Deceased SONIA HOPWOOD, individually as the Parent 273

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 274 of 434

of Dinah Webster, Deceased PETER HERBERT HOPWOOD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dinah Webster, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dinah Webster CLIVE HOPWOOD, individually as the Sibling of Dinah Webster, Deceased LISA ANNE WEEMS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Michael Weems, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Michael Weems and on behalf of minor child Z.W. REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Mary P. Weinberg, Deceased, Parent of decedent Michael T. Weinberg PATRICIA WANGERMAN, individually as the Sibling of Michael T. Weinberg, Deceased MORTON WEINBERG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael T. Weinberg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael T. Weinberg JOHN WEINBERG, individually as the Sibling of Michael T. Weinberg, Deceased MARILYN WEINBERG, individually as the Parent of Steven Weinberg, Deceased LAURIE SUE WEINBERG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Weinberg, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Weinberg and on behalf of minor children J.W., L.W., and S.W. MARILYN WEINBERG, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Leonard Weinberg, Deceased, Parent of decedent Steven Weinberg PAUL WEINBERG, individually as the Sibling of Steven Weinberg, Deceased KATHLYN MAE CARRIKER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven George Weinstein, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Steven George Weinstein and on behalf of minor child A.L.W. 274

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 275 of 434

ALISSA LORIANN WEISS, individually as the Child of David Martin Weiss, Deceased JOAN WEISS PROWLER, individually as the Parent of David Martin Weiss, Deceased MICHELE WEISS-LITTLE, individually as the Sibling of David Martin Weiss, Deceased KARLA WEISS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Martin Weiss, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David Martin Weiss and on behalf of minor child M.P.W. MICHAEL PAUL WEISS, individually as the Child of David Martin Weiss, Deceased BARRY WEISS, individually as the Sibling of David Martin Weiss, Deceased JULIA ANN WELLS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Vincent Michael Wells, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Michael Wells DOE 137 individually as the Sibling of DOE 137, Deceased CHARLES THOMAS WELLS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Vincent Michael Wells, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Michael Wells DOE 137 individually as the Sibling of DOE 137, Deceased ADELE NINA WELTY, individually as the Parent of Timothy Welty, Deceased SHU-NU CHEN, individually as the Parent of Ssu-Hui Wen, Deceased YUN-JU WEN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of SsuHui Wen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ssu-Hui Wen SHUN-FA WEN, individually as the Parent of Ssu-Hui Wen, Deceased MEREDITH W. NELSON, individually as the Child of Peter Matthew West, Deceased 275

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 276 of 434

MARY LOUISE BALL, individually as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West, Deceased CATHERINE CECILIA MCLAUGHLIN, individually as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West, Deceased REGINA MARIE TOWNSEND, individually as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West, Deceased EILEEN K. WEST, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Matthew West, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Matthew West MATTHEW PETER WEST, individually as the Child of Peter Matthew West, Deceased GREGORY J. WEST, individually as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West, Deceased VINCENT MATTHEW WEST, individually as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Arthur H. West, Jr., Deceased, Sibling of decedent Peter Matthew West PATRICIA J. WHALEN, individually and as the Administrator of the Estate of Meredith Lynn Whalen, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Meredith Lynn Whalen KRISTEN E. WHALEN, individually as the Sibling of Meredith Lynn Whalen, Deceased JOAN A. WHELAN, individually as the Parent of Eugene Michael Whelan, Deceased ALFRED L. WHELAN, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eugene Michael Whelan, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Eugene Michael Whelan JOAN A. WHITE, individually as the Parent of James Patrick White, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Alphonse J. White, Deceased, Parent of decedent James Patrick White MICHAEL JOHN WHITE, individually and as 276

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 277 of 434

the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Patrick White, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Patrick White REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Elaine Clancy, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Kenneth W. White LAURA JEANNE KENNY, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth W. White, Deceased ELIZABETH ANN ALVERSON, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth W. White, Deceased CATHERINE C. WHITE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth W. White, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth W. White and on behalf of minor children THOMAS GEORGE WHITE, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth W. White, Deceased ALLISON VADHAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kristin White-Gould, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kristin White-Gould CAROL ANN WHITFORD, individually as the Parent of Mark P. Whitford, Deceased LISA A. WALKER, individually as the Sibling of Mark P. Whitford, Deceased RENEE WHITFORD, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark P. Whitford, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark P. Whitford and on behalf of minor children M.W. and T.W. ROGER PAUL WHITFORD, individually as the Parent of Mark P. Whitford, Deceased CHRISTOPHER WHITFORD, individually as the Sibling of Mark P. Whitford, Deceased DENNIS WHITFORD, individually as the Sibling of Mark P. Whitford, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Ruth S. Koch, Deceased, Parent of decedent Leslie Ann Whittington SARA GUEST, individually as the Sibling of 277

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 278 of 434

Leslie Ann Whittington, Deceased HORACE G. WHITTINGTON, individually as the Parent of Leslie Ann Whittington, Deceased MICHAEL T. WHITTINGTON, individually as the Sibling of Leslie Ann Whittington, Deceased KIRK WHITTINGTON, individually as the Sibling of Leslie Ann Whittington, Deceased MARGARET WINIFRED WHOLEY, individually as the Parent of Michael T. Wholey, Deceased MARYANN WHOLEY, individually as the Sibling of Michael T. Wholey, Deceased DIANE WHOLEY BUGGE, individually as the Sibling of Michael T. Wholey, Deceased BERNADETTE WHOLEY, individually as the Sibling of Michael T. Wholey, Deceased JENNIFER WHOLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael T. Wholey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael T. Wholey and on behalf of minor children E.W., M.W., and P.W. MICHAEL JOSEPH WHOLEY, individually as the Parent of Michael T. Wholey, Deceased MARC WIEMAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Wieman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Wieman and on behalf of minor children A.W., M.J.W., and C.W. WILMA WIENER, individually as the Parent of Jeffrey David Wiener, Deceased ROBIN KIM WIENER, individually as the Sibling of Jeffrey David Wiener, Deceased DONALD S. WIENER, individually as the Parent of Jeffrey David Wiener, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of June M. Wildman, Deceased, Parent of decedent Alison M. Wildman JILL SALADINO, individually as the Sibling of Alison M. Wildman, Deceased 278

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 279 of 434

ROBERT E. WILDMAN, individually as the Sibling of Alison M. Wildman, Deceased RICHARD M. BORQUIST, individually as the Sibling of Alison M. Wildman, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Arthur S. Wildman, III, Deceased, Sibling of decedent Alison M. Wildman ARTHUR S. WILDMAN, JR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alison M. Wildman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alison M. Wildman MARGARET E. WILKINSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Glenn E. Wilkinson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Glenn E. Wilkinson SHIRLEY N. WILLCHER, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ernest M. Willcher, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ernest M. Willcher JOEL WILLCHER, individually as the Child of Ernest M. Willcher, Deceased BENJAMIN WILLCHER, individually as the Child of Ernest M. Willcher, Deceased LUCILLE C. WILLETT, individually as the Parent of John Charles Willett, Deceased RONALD J. WILLETT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Charles Willett, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John Charles Willett COREY G. GAUDIOSO, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sherri A. Williams, Deceased Parent of decedent Candace Lee Williams COREY G. GAUDIOSO, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Candace Lee Williams, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Candace Lee Willliams VALRIE M. WILLIAMS, individually as the Parent of Crossley R. Williams, Jr., Deceased CROSSLEY R. WILLIAMS, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate 279

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 280 of 434

of Crossley R. Williams, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Crossley R. Williams, Jr. DEBRA JOHNSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David J. Williams, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David J. Williams TAMMY G. WILLIAMS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dwayne Williams, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Dwayne Williams and on behalf of minor children K.S.W. and S.T.W. PATRICIA ANN WILLIAMS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Kevin Michael Williams, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Michael Williams ROGER MICHAEL WILLIAMS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Kevin Michael Williams, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Michael Williams MURNA T. WILLIAMS, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Louie Anthony Williams, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Louie Anthony Williams REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Lucy Williamson, Deceased, Parent of decedent John P. Williamson MARY B. WILLIAMSON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John P. Williamson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John P. Williamson and on behalf of minor children J.W. and M.W. SALLY A. WILLIAMSON, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George P. Williamson, Deceased, Sibling of decedent John P. Williamson MAUREEN RUTH HALVORSON, individually as the Sibling of William Eben Wilson, Deceased 280

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 281 of 434

JEANNE MCDERMOTT, individually as the Sibling of William Eben Wilson, Deceased ELIZABETH ANN PAYNE, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Eben Wilson, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Eben Wilson JOAN W. WINTON, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David H. Winton, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of David H. Winton SARA WINTON COFFEY, individually as the Sibling of David H. Winton, Deceased ELAINE WINUK, individually as the Parent of Glenn J. Winuk, Deceased JAY S. WINUK as of the Representative of the Estate of Seymour Winuk, Deceased, Parent of decedent Glenn J. Winuk JEFF M. WINUK, individually as the Sibling of Glenn J. Winuk, Deceased JAY S. WINUK, individually as the Sibling and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Glenn J. Winuk, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Glenn J. Winuk CAROL D. WISNIEWSKI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank Thomas Wisniewski, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Frank Thomas Wisniewski and on behalf of minor children A.A.W. and J.P.W. UTE MITCHELL, individually as the Parent of Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe, Deceased BIRGIT WISWE, individually as the Sibling of Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe, Deceased VICTOR M. TURCIOS, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe BARBARA WITTENSTEIN, individually as the Parent of Michael Robert Wittenstein, Deceased CARYN HINSON, individually and as the Co281

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 282 of 434

Administrator of the Estate of Michael Robert Wittenstein, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Robert Wittenstein ARNOLD R. WITTENSTEIN, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael Robert Wittenstein, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Robert Wittenstein JEFFREY WITTENSTEIN, individually as the Sibling of Michael Robert Wittenstein, Deceased SUSAN WOHLFORTH, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Phillips Wohlforth, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Phillips Wohlforth DOE 26, individually as the Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 26, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 26 MARY ELIZABETH WOODALL, individually as the Parent of Brent James Woodall, Deceased ERIN ELIZABETH KONSTANTINOW, individually as the Sibling of Brent James Woodall, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of John W. Woodall, Deceased, Parent of decedent Brent James Woodall CRAIG WALKER WOODALL, individually as the Sibling of Brent James Woodall, Deceased JOYCE A. WOODS, individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of James Woods, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of James Woods EILEEN J. WOODS, individually as the Sibling of James Woods, Deceased JOHN F. WOODS, JR., individually and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of James Woods, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors 282

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 283 of 434

of James Woods EILEEN WOODS, individually as the Parent of Patrick Woods, Deceased CHRIS WOODS, individually as the Sibling of Patrick Woods, Deceased THOMAS WOODS, individually as the Sibling of Patrick Woods, Deceased PATRICK WOODS, SR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick Woods, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick Woods PAMELA WOODWELL GEERDES, individually as the Sibling of Richard H. Woodwell, Deceased LINDA PRESTON WOODWELL, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard H. Woodwell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Richard H. Woodwell JOHN KNOWLES WOODWELL, III, individually as the Sibling of Richard H. Woodwell, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Mary A. Otto, Deceased, Parent of decedent David T. Wooley EDGAR B. WOOLEY, III, individually as the Sibling of David T. Wooley, Deceased TIMOTHY EDWIN WORKS, individually as the Sibling of John Bentley Works, Deceased KAREN L. WORTLEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Wortley, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Wortley DOE 01, individually as the Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 01, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 01 and on behalf of minor children DOE 01 and DOE 01 MARTHA OLIVERIO WRIGHT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Wayne Wright, III, Deceased and on 283

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 284 of 434

behalf of all survivors of John Wayne Wright, III NANCY YAMBEM, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jupiter Yambem, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Jupiter Yambem SANTI YAMBEM, individually as the Child of Jupiter Yambem, Deceased LORRAINE YAMNICKY DIXON, individually as the Child of John David Yamnicky, Sr., Deceased JENNIFER LYNN YAMNICKY, individually as the Child of John David Yamnicky, Sr., Deceased JANET W. YAMNICKY, individually as the Spouse of John David Yamnicky, Sr., Deceased MARK YAMNICKY, individually as the Child of John David Yamnicky, Sr., Deceased JOHN DAVID YAMNICKY, JR., individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John David Yamnicky, Sr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of John David Yamnicky, Sr. AJITHA VEMULAPALLI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Suresh Yanamadala, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Suresh Yanamadala DAVID M. YANCEY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vicki L. Yancey, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Vicki L. Yancey and on behalf of minor children M.Y. and C.N.Y. RUI ZHENG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Shuyin Yang, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Shuyin Yang SHIDONG ZHENG, individually as the Child of Shuyin Yang, Deceased MICHELE YARNELL, individually as the Parent of Matthew David Yarnell, Deceased TED YARNELL, individually and as the 284

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 285 of 434

Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew David Yarnell, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew David Yarnell REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Adele Pearl, Deceased, Parent of decedent Myrna Yaskulka BONNIE SHIMEL, individually as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka, Deceased LORNA KAYE, individually as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka, Deceased INA STANLEY, individually as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka, Deceased HAL YASKULKA, individually as the Child of Myrna Yaskulka, Deceased BRIAN YASKULKA, individually as the Child of Myrna Yaskulka, Deceased JAY YASKULKA, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Myrna Yaskulka, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Myrna Yaskulka SHAWN PEARL, individually as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka, Deceased PHILIP PEARL, individually as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka, Deceased IVAN PEARL, individually as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka, Deceased KIMBERLY G. YORK, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Philip York, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Philip York and on behalf of minor children K.Y., P.Y., and P.Y. MARY E. PELED, individually as the Sibling of Kevin Patrick York, Deceased SUSAN YORK, individually as the Sibling of Kevin Patrick York, Deceased FELICIA YOUNG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald McArthur Young, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Donald McArthur Young 285

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 286 of 434

MEHASEN A. ZAKHARY, individually as the Sibling of Adel A. Zakhary, Deceased NADIA A. ZAKHARY, individually as the Sibling of Adel A. Zakhary, Deceased NAGAT H. ZAKHARY, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Adel A. Zakhary, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Adel A. Zakhary and on behalf of minor child M.Z. GEORGE ADEL AGAIBY, individually as the Child of Adel A. Zakhary, Deceased TALAT A. ZAKHARY, individually as the Sibling of Adel A. Zakhary, Deceased PATRICIA ZAMPIERI, individually as the Parent of Robert Alan Zampieri, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Robert Zampieri, Deceased, Parent of decedent Robert Alan Zampieri REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Robert Alan Zampieri, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Alan Zampieri JILL ZANGRILLI, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Zangrilli, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Zangrilli and on behalf of minor children A.Z. and N.Z. SHEILA A. KIERNAN, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Rudolph Zarba, Jr., Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Rudolph Zarba, Jr. and on behalf of minor child C.J.Z. FELICE ZASLOW, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ira Zaslow, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Ira Zaslow ADAM ZASLOW, individually as the Child of Ira Zaslow, Deceased BRYAN ZASLOW, individually as the Child of Ira Zaslow, Deceased RUTH ZELMAN, individually as the Parent of 286

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 287 of 434

Kenneth Albert Zelman, Deceased CARRIE BURLOCK, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth Albert Zelman, Deceased JACK ZELMAN, individually as the Parent of Kenneth Albert Zelman, Deceased BARRY ZELMAN, individually as the Sibling of Kenneth Albert Zelman, Deceased LEONA ZEPLIN, individually as the Parent of Marc Scott Zeplin, Deceased JOSLIN ZEPLIN, individually as the Sibling of Marc Scott Zeplin, Deceased LEONARD ZEPLIN, individually as the Parent of Marc Scott Zeplin, Deceased RUI ZHENG, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Yuguang Zheng, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Yuguang Zheng SHIDONG ZHENG, individually as the Child of Yuguang Zheng, Deceased ROSEMARIE C. MARTIE, individually as the Sibling of Salvatore J. Zisa, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Sue Zucker, Deceased, Parent of decedent Andrew Steven Zucker CHERYL DIANNE SHAMES, individually as the Sibling of Andrew Steven Zucker, Deceased GAYLE MOSENSON, individually as the Sibling of Andrew Steven Zucker, Deceased REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Saul Zucker, Deceased, Parent of decedent Andrew Steven Zucker STUART CRAIG ZUCKER, individually as the Sibling of Andrew Steven Zucker, Deceased ALLA PLAKHT, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Igor Zukelman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Igor Zukelman and on behalf of minor child A.Z. 287

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 288 of 434

YVONNE V. ABDOOL as an Injured Person CELSO J ABREU as an Injured Person JOHN J. ACERNO as an Injured Person HUMBERTO R. ACOSTA as an Injured Person KEVIN JOHN ADAMS as an Injured Person DARRYL J. ADONE as an Injured Person MARK AIKEN as an Injured Person JAMES F. ALBACH, JR. as an Injured Person THOMAS ALBERT as an Injured Person KARIUM ALI as an Injured Person RONALD ALLEN as an Injured Person INGRID ALLEYNE-ROBERTSON as an Injured Person IVAN ALMENDAREZ, JR. as an Injured Person NEIL ALPER as an Injured Person LEONOR ALVAREZ as an Injured Person ROBERT E. ALVERSON as an Injured Person JOCELYNE AMBROISE as an Injured Person MITCHELL B. AMERBACH as an Injured Person DOUGLAS WILLIAM ANDERSON as an Injured Person THOMAS ANDERSON as an Injured Person MORIEN ANGAROO as an Injured Person IOANNIS ANTONIADIS as an Injured Person JOSEPH P. ANTONY as an Injured Person DANIEL J. ARCHBOLD as an Injured Person PETER ARCHER as an Injured Person TONY ARCHER as an Injured Person JOSEPH ARIOLA as an Injured Person MICHAEL ARNIERO as an Injured Person CYNTHIA ARNOLD as an Injured Person 288

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 289 of 434

SUZANNE ARNOLD as an Injured Person BENJAMIN ARROYO as an Injured Person ANDREA L. ASBURY as an Injured Person SHAWN ASHE as an Injured Person PHILIPSON AZENABOR as an Injured Person GEORGE BACHMANN as an Injured Person PAUL J. BADER as an Injured Person DIANA BAEZ as an Injured Person LYNETTE BANGAREE as an Injured Person GENTIL BAPTISTE as an Injured Person MARY ELLEN BARBIERI as an Injured Person GARRETT RAYMOND BARBOSA as an Injured Person ARMANDO BARDALES as an Injured Person DOE 72 as an Injured Person THOMAS J. BAROZ as an Injured Person JOHN T. BARRY as an Injured Person PATRICK T. BARRY as an Injured Person FRANK BARTON as an Injured Person BURNEY BATES as an Injured Person PEDRO GARRIDO BATISTA as an Injured Person JAMES A. BAUER as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER A. BAUMANN as an Injured Person FAVEUR BAZILME as an Injured Person FRANK J. BAZZICALUPO as an Injured Person LARRY BEALER as an Injured Person THOMAS A BEATTIE as an Injured Person JANICE BEATTY as an Injured Person RICHARD A. BEATTY as an Injured Person 289

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 290 of 434

JONATHAN M. BECKER as an Injured Person CHRISTIAN BEDIAKO as an Injured Person MICHAEL BEEHLER as an Injured Person THOMAS JOSEPH BEIRNE as an Injured Person MICHAEL J. BELL as an Injured Person JOHN BELLEW as an Injured Person ANTHONY BELLISARI as an Injured Person SCOTT R. BELOTEN as an Injured Person VANESSA BENJAMIN as an Injured Person DEREK P. BENNETT as an Injured Person IAN J. BENNETT as an Injured Person FRANCES BERDAN as an Injured Person JAMES W. BERGHORN as an Injured Person JULIETTE BERGMAN as an Injured Person DEBORAH E. BERK as an Injured Person ERIC BERNTSEN as an Injured Person JOSEPH T. BERRY as an Injured Person DOMINIC BERTUCCI as an Injured Person FRANCISCO BETANCOURT as an Injured Person PRAKASH BHATT as an Injured Person DONALD S. BIGI as an Injured Person STEPHEN BILESKI as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER BILOTTI as an Injured Person JAMES A. BITTLES as an Injured Person DANIEL BIVONA as an Injured Person PATRICK CHARLES BLAINE as an Injured Person JAMES BLAKE as an Injured Person ROBERT BLAKE as an Injured Person JODY BLANCHARD as an Injured Person 290

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 291 of 434

STAN BLASKEY as an Injured Person RICHARD J. BLATUS as an Injured Person AARON BOGAD as an Injured Person EDWARD P. BOLGER as an Injured Person JAN BONANZA as an Injured Person LUIS BONILLA as an Injured Person QUINCEYANN BOOKER-JACKSON as an Injured Person CHESTER P. BOTCH, JR. as an Injured Person RONALD BOYCE as an Injured Person JAMES J. BOYLE as an Injured Person JAMES R. BOYLE as an Injured Person JOHN W. BOYLE as an Injured Person JOSEPH M. BOYLE as an Injured Person KEVIN BRADBURY as an Injured Person FRANK BRANCATO as an Injured Person GEORGE BRENNAN as an Injured Person DOE 142 as an Injured Person RAYMOND BRESSINGHAM as an Injured Person JEFFREY A. BREZIL as an Injured Person CARMEN BRIDGEFORTH as an Injured Person DAVID ALLEN BRIDGEFORTH as an Injured Person JAMES M. BRIORDY as an Injured Person MICHAEL P. BRODBECK as an Injured Person ERIC J. BRODIN as an Injured Person BORIS BRONSHTEYN as an Injured Person ROBERT BROOME as an Injured Person EDWARD M. BROWN as an Injured Person ERNEST O. BROWN as an Injured Person

291

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 292 of 434

KEVIN JEROME BROWN as an Injured Person MICHAEL P. BROWN as an Injured Person STEPHEN CHARLES BROWN as an Injured Person EDUARDO E. BRUNO as an Injured Person THOMAS J. BUBELNIK as an Injured Person JOHNATHAN BUCHSBAUM as an Injured Person JOSEPH L. BUDA as an Injured Person BROOK A. BUDD as an Injured Person VINCENT BULZOMI as an Injured Person JAVIER BURGOS as an Injured Person THOMAS BURKE as an Injured Person TIMOTHY J. BURKE as an Injured Person MICHAEL R. BURNS as an Injured Person BARRY L. BUSS as an Injured Person KEVIN BUTLER as an Injured Person LOIS BUXBAUM as an Injured Person PASQUALE BUZZELLI as an Injured Person RICHARD BYLICKI as an Injured Person LOUIE D. CACCHIOLI as an Injured Person JAMES PATRICK CADDIGAN as an Injured Person KEVIN CAHILL as an Injured Person KEVIN J. CAHILL as an Injured Person MICHAEL CAIN as an Injured Person JOHN A. CAIRNEY as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER CALAMIA as an Injured Person RONALD CALCAGNO as an Injured Person WILLIAM CALLAHAN as an Injured Person JOSE CALLEJAS as an Injured Person FERNANDO CAMACHO as an Injured 292

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 293 of 434

Person WILLIAM CANTRES as an Injured Person ROBERT CARBERRY as an Injured Person LUIS CARBONELL as an Injured Person SALVATORE F. CARCATERRA as an Injured Person MARTHA F. CARDEN as an Injured Person RALPH CARDINO as an Injured Person COLETTE CARDOZA as an Injured Person MICHAEL J. CARLISI as an Injured Person ANITA CARMINE as an Injured Person DOMINICK J. CAROLEI as an Injured Person DAVID W. CARPENTER, JR. as an Injured Person GARY E. CARPENTIER as an Injured Person VENUS CHRISTINE CARRERAS-ORTIZ as an Injured Person CHARLES F. CARROLL, JR. as an Injured Person ROBERT J. CARROLL as an Injured Person EUGENE J. CARTY as an Injured Person DESIRET CARVACHE as an Injured Person FRANK CASALINO as an Injured Person VINCENT CASCONE as an Injured Person JOSEPH CASTELLANO as an Injured Person MARIA E. CASTILLO as an Injured Person JOHN J. CASTLES as an Injured Person FRANK CASTROGIOVANNI as an Injured Person JUAN CAYETANO as an Injured Person MARIA CEBALLOS as an Injured Person DOMINGO CEPEDA as an Injured Person ROBERT CERESIA as an Injured Person ARLENE CHARLES as an Injured Person 293

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 294 of 434

SALVATORE CHILLEMI as an Injured Person ARTHUR CHRISTENSEN as an Injured Person GARY CHRISTENSEN as an Injured Person ANTHONY CIARNELLA as an Injured Person NICHOLAS CICERO, JR. as an Injured Person THOMAS ALFRED CINOTTI as an Injured Person MICHAEL CIOFFI as an Injured Person JOHN CITARELLA as an Injured Person PATRICIA CIUZIO as an Injured Person GUILLERMO CLARK as an Injured Person BRIAN CLARKE as an Injured Person THOMAS J. CLARKE as an Injured Person CHRISTINE CLAUDI-PETOSA as an Injured Person JOHN J. CLAVIN as an Injured Person SHARRON L. CLEMONS as an Injured Person ROBERT COBB as an Injured Person STEVE COFFIN as an Injured Person LISA COHN as an Injured Person ANTHONY J. COIRO as an Injured Person DAVID COLLINS as an Injured Person GEORGE A. COLLINS, III as an Injured Person RICHARD L. COLLINS as an Injured Person BRUCE R. COLLISTER as an Injured Person CARMEN COLON as an Injured Person JOHN A. COLON as an Injured Person JOHN COMBOS as an Injured Person GARY K. CONNELLY as an Injured Person 294

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 295 of 434

THOMAS J. CONNOLLY as an Injured Person WILLIAM V. CONNOLLY as an Injured Person JOSE M. CONTES as an Injured Person THEODORE COOK as an Injured Person WALTER COOPER as an Injured Person BRIAN CORCORAN as an Injured Person GREGORY A. CORONA as an Injured Person PATRICK CORR as an Injured Person STEPHEN CORR as an Injured Person MATTHEW CORRIGAN as an Injured Person LAWRENCE COSTELLO as an Injured Person JOEL COUNCIL as an Injured Person SCOTT COWAN as an Injured Person ANDRE COX as an Injured Person DUDLEY COX as an Injured Person STEPHEN A. COX as an Injured Person BRIAN COYLE as an Injured Person JOHN J. COYLE as an Injured Person WALTER HENRY CRAMER as an Injured Person PETER J. CREEGAN as an Injured Person JOHN CRETELLA as an Injured Person CRAIG CRICHLOW as an Injured Person ROBERT H. CRISTADORO as an Injured Person BRENT G. CROBAK as an Injured Person ENRIQUE CRUZ as an Injured Person LUIS CRUZ as an Injured Person DOE 101 as an Injured Person JAMES J. CSORNY as an Injured Person FERNANDO CUBA as an Injured Person CARMEN CUBERO as an Injured Person 295

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 296 of 434

SEAN CUMMINS as an Injured Person THOMAS CUNNEEN as an Injured Person MURIEL CUNNINGHAM as an Injured Person RONALD CURABA as an Injured Person EDWARD JAMES CUSACK as an Injured Person ALAN W. DAGISTINO as an Injured Person PHILIP D'AGOSTINO as an Injured Person JOANNE DALTON as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER D'AMBROSIO as an Injured Person MARK DAMITZ as an Injured Person FLORY DANISH as an Injured Person ROGER DANVERS as an Injured Person RICHARD DAVAN as an Injured Person FELIPE DAVID as an Injured Person JEREMY BRANDON DAVIDS as an Injured Person JEAN. L. DAVIS as an Injured Person THOMAS P. DAVIS as an Injured Person JAMES E. D'AVOLIO as an Injured Person JUDITH DAY as an Injured Person ANDRES DE LA ROSA as an Injured Person MARIA DE OLIO-BEATO as an Injured Person ANTHONY W. DE VITA, JR. as an Injured Person BEVERLY DIANE DE WITT as an Injured Person JOHN DEBENEDITTIS as an Injured Person CARLOTA RODRIGUEZ DECASTILLO as an Injured Person HENRY DECKER as an Injured Person KEVIN DEEHAN as an Injured Person 296

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 297 of 434

EDWARD J. DEGAETANO as an Injured Person WARREN DEGEN as an Injured Person JOHN DELANEY as an Injured Person PAUL DELEO as an Injured Person EDWARD DELFINO as an Injured Person JULIO DELGADO as an Injured Person BRUCE DELGIORNO as an Injured Person RICHARD DELL ITALIA as an Injured Person AUGUST C. DELORENZO as an Injured Person TODD C. DEMAYO as an Injured Person JAN DEMCZUR as an Injured Person MICHAEL T. DEMPSEY as an Injured Person STEPHEN DEMPSEY as an Injured Person GARY A. DEMRY as an Injured Person JOHN M. DENEAU as an Injured Person DWAYNE DENT as an Injured Person PETER DEPALMA as an Injured Person JOHN M. DEPRIZIO as an Injured Person ANTHONY DESIMONE as an Injured Person GEORGE J. DESIMONE as an Injured Person ANEX DESINOR as an Injured Person JAMES F. DESTASIO as an Injured Person JOHN DESTEFANO as an Injured Person RICHARD DION DESTEFANO as an Injured Person KIERNAN B. DETO as an Injured Person GREGORY J. DEVERNA as an Injured Person JAMES EDWARD DEVERY as an Injured Person KEVIN D. DEVINE as an Injured Person DAVID DEVITO as an Injured Person 297

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 298 of 434

JOHN DEVOTI as an Injured Person NELSON RAFAEL DIAZ as an Injured Person SALVATORE DIBLASI as an Injured Person JERROLD DIETZ as an Injured Person JESSICA DIGGS as an Injured Person JOHN M. DILILLO as an Injured Person STEVEN DIMAGGIO as an Injured Person OMAR A. DIXON as an Injured Person VINCENT DODD as an Injured Person KEVIN JOHN DOHERTY as an Injured Person SCOTT DOHERTY as an Injured Person HIPOLITO D'OLEO as an Injured Person STEPHEN DOMINICK as an Injured Person WALTER DONAHUE as an Injured Person JOHN DONNELLY as an Injured Person JAMES F. DONOVAN, JR. as an Injured Person KENNETH DONOVAN as an Injured Person MICHAEL DONOVAN as an Injured Person VINCENT D'ORIO as an Injured Person GREGORY DOUGHERTY as an Injured Person MICHAEL J. DOWLING as an Injured Person HEATHER DOWNEY as an Injured Person DANIEL D. DOYLE as an Injured Person EDWARD DOYLE as an Injured Person STEVEN T. DOYLE as an Injured Person THOMAS M. DOYLE as an Injured Person DOE 18 as an Injured Person DUNCAN DRISCOLL as an Injured Person EUGENE DRURY as an Injured Person ROMAN DUCALO as an Injured Person ELAINE DUCH as an Injured Person 298

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 299 of 434

DENNIS G. DUFFY as an Injured Person TIMOTHY DUFFY as an Injured Person WILLIAM DUFFY as an Injured Person KEVIN DUGGAN as an Injured Person PATRICK D. DUIGNAN as an Injured Person DARRELL DUNBAR as an Injured Person PHILIP DUNCAN as an Injured Person THOMAS DUNN as an Injured Person THOMAS M. DUNNE as an Injured Person MICHAEL DUNPHY as an Injured Person CURTIS DURNING, SR. as an Injured Person FRANCIS B. DURR as an Injured Person BRIAN EAGERS as an Injured Person DOUGLAS EDEL as an Injured Person JEFF EHRET as an Injured Person BARBARA EINZIG as an Injured Person JOSEPH EIVERS as an Injured Person DUKE A. ELLIS as an Injured Person JUSTIN ENZMANN as an Injured Person GABE ESPOSITO as an Injured Person JOSEPH J. FALCO as an Injured Person JAMES J. FALCONE as an Injured Person JOHN C. FALCONITE as an Injured Person PAUL FANARA as an Injured Person ROBERT FARLEY as an Injured Person PETER V. FARR as an Injured Person PATRICIA FARRAR as an Injured Person JOHN S. FARRELL as an Injured Person ANTHONY FARRINGTON as an Injured Person FRANCIS FEE, JR. as an Injured Person JOHN T. FEE, SR. as an Injured Person MARK FELDMAN as an Injured Person 299

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 300 of 434

RUSSELL FELICIANO as an Injured Person EDGAR FELIX as an Injured Person DELIO A. FELIZ as an Injured Person FERN L. FELLER as an Injured Person BARTON FENDELMAN as an Injured Person STEPHEN P. FENLEY as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER M. FENYA as an Injured Person FRANK FERDINANDI as an Injured Person ERASMO FERNANDES as an Injured Person NUNO FERNANDES as an Injured Person ANTONIO FERNANDEZ as an Injured Person HERNANDO FERNANDEZ as an Injured Person JENNY FERNANDEZ as an Injured Person LARISSA FERNANDEZ as an Injured Person ROGER FERNANDEZ as an Injured Person VINCENT FERRANTI as an Injured Person MICHAEL A. FERRARA as an Injured Person DOUGLAS FERRETTI as an Injured Person GERARD FERRIN as an Injured Person STEVEN FERRIOLO as an Injured Person JOHN FINAMORE as an Injured Person JOSEPH P. FINLEY as an Injured Person EDWARD FINNEGAN as an Injured Person MICHAEL FINNEGAN as an Injured Person TERENCE P. FINNERAN as an Injured Person VICTOR J. FIORELLA as an Injured Person GLENN FISCHER as an Injured Person JAY F. FISCHLER as an Injured Person STEPHEN FISH as an Injured Person NEIL C. FITZPATRICK as an Injured Person ZACHARY H. FLETCHER as an Injured 300

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 301 of 434

Person PATRICK FLYNN as an Injured Person THERESA E FOLINO-MONTUORI as an Injured Person THOMAS J. FORBES as an Injured Person FREDERICK J. FORD as an Injured Person NICHOLAS FORNARIO as an Injured Person GREGORY A. FORSYTH as an Injured Person LEILETH FOSTER as an Injured Person EUGENE W. FOX as an Injured Person MICHAEL ANTHONY FRANCESE as an Injured Person STANLEY FREEDNER as an Injured Person CHARLES FREEMAN as an Injured Person DENNIS FREYRE as an Injured Person ROBERT T. FRONER as an Injured Person XIANG QUN FU as an Injured Person DANIEL FUCELLA as an Injured Person STEVEN FUCILE as an Injured Person HENRY FUERTE as an Injured Person SHEILA M. FULLER as an Injured Person PAUL P. FUSARO as an Injured Person THOMAS A. GABAY as an Injured Person THOMAS R. GABY as an Injured Person PHILIP GAETANI as an Injured Person MICHAEL D. GAGER as an Injured Person EMMA F. GAITAN as an Injured Person ANA GALANG as an Injured Person BRIAN J. GALLAGHER as an Injured Person HUGH J. GALLAGHER as an Injured Person JOHN GALLAGHER as an Injured Person JOHN F. GALLAGHER as an Injured Person KEVIN P. GALLAGHER as an Injured Person 301

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 302 of 434

TERENCE GALLAGHER as an Injured Person APRIL D. GALLOP as an Injured Person LAWRENCE J. GARDA as an Injured Person ROBERT C. GARRETT as an Injured Person JOHN T. GATTO as an Injured Person JOSEPH M. GAVITT as an Injured Person BRENDAN GEBERT as an Injured Person GETACHEW GEDFE as an Injured Person JOHN D. GENNOSA as an Injured Person GREG GESSNER as an Injured Person DANIEL P. GEYSEN as an Injured Person RONALD GHIRALDI as an Injured Person LOUIS GIACONELLI as an Injured Person JOSEPH A. GIAMPA as an Injured Person GARRY GEORGE GIANNANDREA as an Injured Person MICHAEL J. GIBBONS as an Injured Person JOSEPH GIBNEY as an Injured Person ROBERT F. GIBSON as an Injured Person BONNIE JEAN GIEBFRIED as an Injured Person JOHN C. GIEBLER as an Injured Person THOMAS GILLAM as an Injured Person ANDREW FRANK GILMORE as an Injured Person JOHN E. GINTY as an Injured Person VINCENT GIORDANO as an Injured Person THEODORE GODDARD as an Injured Person RAYMOND GOING as an Injured Person FAUSTO A. GOMEZ as an Injured Person LISA F. GONG as an Injured Person PAUL E. GONZALES as an Injured Person 302

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 303 of 434

MANUEL GONZALEZ as an Injured Person RUBEN GORDILLO as an Injured Person EDWIN J. GORDON as an Injured Person FRANK GORGLINOE as an Injured Person THOMAS EDWARD GORHAM as an Injured Person GERARD J. GORMAN as an Injured Person JOSEPH R. GORMAN as an Injured Person ALBERT GOTAY as an Injured Person ANDREW GRAF as an Injured Person CARMEN GRAY as an Injured Person JOSEPH GRAZIANO as an Injured Person ALBERT GREENE as an Injured Person EDMUND JAMES GREENE as an Injured Person MICHAEL SEAN GREENE as an Injured Person JAMES GREGORETTI as an Injured Person JAMES T. GRILLO as an Injured Person MICHAEL GRILLO as an Injured Person JOHN F. GROGAN as an Injured Person THOMAS J. GROGAN as an Injured Person DANIEL P. GROSSI as an Injured Person SCOTT F. GRUBERT as an Injured Person JOHN GUARNERI as an Injured Person ARTHUR GUASTAMACCHIA as an Injured Person JOHN GUBELLI as an Injured Person RAFAEL GUDMUCH as an Injured Person NICHOLA GUGLIEMO as an Injured Person VINCENT A. GUGLIUZZO as an Injured Person JOHN GULOTTA as an Injured Person KENNETH M. GUNTHER as an Injured 303

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 304 of 434

Person PETER STEPHEN GUNTHER as an Injured Person WILBERT CARNELL GURGANIOUS as an Injured Person STEVEN GURNICK as an Injured Person EDGAR GUTIERREZ as an Injured Person FRANCINE GUTWILIK as an Injured Person ANGEL GUZMAN as an Injured Person MARITZA GUZMAN as an Injured Person MATTHEW HACKETT as an Injured Person MICHAEL HADDEN as an Injured Person ALEXANDER HAGAN as an Injured Person STEVE HAGIS as an Injured Person PAUL V. HALEY as an Injured Person ROBERT HALL as an Injured Person DAVID HANDSCHUH as an Injured Person WILLIAM HANKINS as an Injured Person DAVID R. HANLEY as an Injured Person PHILIP A. HANNA as an Injured Person ANTHONY K. HANSON as an Injured Person RAJKUMAR HARDEO as an Injured Person CATHERINE HARDING as an Injured Person DENNIS HARGETT as an Injured Person DARREN C. HARKINS as an Injured Person ROBERT I. HARPER as an Injured Person THOMAS HARRIS as an Injured Person CARMELA M. HARRISON as an Injured Person JAMES P. HARTEN as an Injured Person SHIRLEY HARVEY as an Injured Person PAUL HASHAGEN as an Injured Person WILLIAM R. HASSECK as an Injured Person HOWARD HAWKINS as an Injured Person 304

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 305 of 434

SCOTT WILLIAM HAWKINS as an Injured Person RAYMOND HAYDEN as an Injured Person NORMA HAYNES as an Injured Person JOSEPH HEALY as an Injured Person JOSEPH JOHN HEALY as an Injured Person MARILYN DENISE HECKSTALL as an Injured Person DENNIS J. HEEDLES as an Injured Person JAMES A. HEEREY as an Injured Person GLEN HEFFEL as an Injured Person EUGENE R. HEGHMANN as an Injured Person JOHN HEIGL as an Injured Person MARK B. HEINTZ as an Injured Person WILLIAM T. HEINTZ as an Injured Person ROBERT J. HELLMERS as an Injured Person ELAINE HELMS as an Injured Person ROBERT G. HENEY as an Injured Person JEFFREY A. HENKEL as an Injured Person EDWARD HENRY as an Injured Person LUCILLE D. HENRY as an Injured Person PATRICIA ANN HERBERT as an Injured Person THOMAS HERRLICH as an Injured Person THOMAS HICKEY as an Injured Person JOHN A. HINCHEY as an Injured Person WILLIAM GERARD HINEY as an Injured Person MICHAEL R. HIPSMAN as an Injured Person GREGG ANDREW HIRSCHFIELD as an Injured Person WILLIAM HODGENS as an Injured Person DANIEL HOGAN as an Injured Person

305

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 306 of 434

VINCENT D. HOGAN as an Injured Person TODD A. HOLGAN as an Injured Person CLIFFORD J. HOLLYWOOD as an Injured Person JANETH HOLMES-ALFRED as an Injured Person GEORGE HOLZMANN as an Injured Person JAMES JOSEPH HORCH as an Injured Person DOUG R. HORNING as an Injured Person ALICIA T. HOWARD as an Injured Person MARY HRABOWSKA as an Injured Person VINCENT F. HUBNER as an Injured Person GERALD M. HUNT as an Injured Person JEAN MARLENE HUNT as an Injured Person JOHN HUNT as an Injured Person KENNETH HUTCHINSON as an Injured Person AMIRHA VICTORIA HUTTO as an Injured Person PAUL HYLAND as an Injured Person JAMES ANDREW HYNES as an Injured Person FREDERICK J. ILL, III as an Injured Person SHARON IMBERT as an Injured Person PATRICK IMPERATO as an Injured Person JOSEPH P. INTINTOLI as an Injured Person MICHAEL A. IOVINO as an Injured Person ERIC IVERSEN as an Injured Person WALTER NICHOLAS IWACHIW as an Injured Person JOHN JACKSON as an Injured Person NEIL JACOBSON as an Injured Person BRENDA JAMES as an Injured Person JOSEPH JAMES as an Injured Person

306

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 307 of 434

MATTHEW R. JAMES as an Injured Person ELIAN JARAMILLO as an Injured Person CLIFFORD JENKINS as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER C. JENSEN as an Injured Person MARC C. JENSEN as an Injured Person ROSE JEUNES as an Injured Person HUMBERTO JIMENEZ as an Injured Person LUIS B. JIMENEZ as an Injured Person YSIDRO JIMENEZ as an Injured Person FITZ-HARRY ALEXANDER JOHNSON as an Injured Person JOHN JOHNSON as an Injured Person KURT DOMINICK JOHNSON as an Injured Person ROBERT JOHNSON, JR. as an Injured Person ROBERT JOHNSON, SR. as an Injured Person SYLVIA J. JOHNSON as an Injured Person JOHN T. JONES as an Injured Person TERRENCE GEORGE JORDAN as an Injured Person MARK D. JOSEPH as an Injured Person LUKE J. JURAIN as an Injured Person JOSEPH F. KADILLAC as an Injured Person JAMES A. KADNAR as an Injured Person JANE KAHORO as an Injured Person RAZI S. KALISH as an Injured Person GEORGE KAPERONIS as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER KAZIMER as an Injured Person DENNIS P. KEANE as an Injured Person LAWRENCE GERALD KEATING as an Injured Person THOMAS KEELING as an Injured Person 307

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 308 of 434

JOHN E. KEENAN as an Injured Person MICHAEL M. KELLEHER as an Injured Person RACQUEL K. KELLEY as an Injured Person DEREK T. KELLY as an Injured Person JAMES J. KELLY as an Injured Person JOHN KELLY as an Injured Person JOHN J. KELLY as an Injured Person KEVIN KELLY as an Injured Person PATRICK KELLY as an Injured Person ROBERT KELLY as an Injured Person WILLIAM C. KELLY as an Injured Person DONALD P. KENNEDY as an Injured Person LISA ANN KENNEDY as an Injured Person RICHARD KENNEY as an Injured Person PETER A. KENNY as an Injured Person JOHN F. KERSHIS as an Injured Person ROBERT T. KEYS as an Injured Person PATRICK M. KIERNAN as an Injured Person SUSANNE BACHMANN KIKKENBORG as an Injured Person MICHAEL KILLARNEY as an Injured Person MICHAEL J. KILLCOMMONS as an Injured Person DAVID J. KING, JR. as an Injured Person EMANUEL G. KING as an Injured Person STEPHEN J. KING, III as an Injured Person JOHN L. KINTA as an Injured Person BLAIK KIRBY as an Injured Person RONALD J. KIRCHNER as an Injured Person ROBERT KLAUM as an Injured Person STEVEN J. KLEIN as an Injured Person DAVID KLETSMAN as an Injured Person LARRY J. KLINGENER as an Injured Person 308

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 309 of 434

RICHARD KOBBE as an Injured Person EDWARD R. KOHLER as an Injured Person NICHOLAS KOLOSZUK as an Injured Person ROBERT KORFMAN as an Injured Person ARMEN KOROGHLIAN as an Injured Person DANIEL KRUESI as an Injured Person KEVIN KUBLER as an Injured Person LOUISE A. KURTZ as an Injured Person SIDNEY KYLE as an Injured Person JOHN R. LA SALA as an Injured Person ROSETTA LA VENA as an Injured Person DAVID LABATTO as an Injured Person ORFELINA LACHAPEL as an Injured Person JOHN J. LAFEMINA as an Injured Person ROMANO ESTEBAN LAKE as an Injured Person THOMAS LAMACCHIA as an Injured Person GEORGE LAMOREAUX as an Injured Person BRIAN LANDAU as an Injured Person JAMES C. LANG as an Injured Person PAUL P. LANG as an Injured Person GEORGE LANTAY as an Injured Person JAMES LANZA as an Injured Person JAMES F. LANZE as an Injured Person RICHARD JAMES LAPIEDRA as an Injured Person JEAN JACQUES LARAQUE as an Injured Person PHILIP LARIMORE as an Injured Person BRAIN R. LARNEY as an Injured Person JOHN LAROCCHIA as an Injured Person ANTHONY R. LAROSA as an Injured Person 309

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 310 of 434

JOSEPH M. LASHENDOCK, III as an Injured Person PETER LAUDATI as an Injured Person KEVIN LAVELLE as an Injured Person MICHAEL J. LAVIN as an Injured Person KEVIN P. LAWE as an Injured Person BARRY ROGER LEE as an Injured Person LARRY LEE as an Injured Person ROBERT LEE as an Injured Person ALICIA LEGUILLOW as an Injured Person JOYCE LEIGH as an Injured Person ROBERT J. LEONICK, JR. as an Injured Person HURSLEY H. LEVER as an Injured Person JAMES W. LEWIS as an Injured Person OTIS LEWIS as an Injured Person VERONICA O. LI as an Injured Person MICHAEL LIANTONIO as an Injured Person JOSEPH LIBRETTI as an Injured Person FRANK A. LICAUSI as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER LINDBERG as an Injured Person ELENA LINIS as an Injured Person ROSEMARIA LIPARI as an Injured Person EMANUEL ALEXANDER LIPSCOMB, JR. as an Injured Person ANTONIO R. LLORET as an Injured Person ANTHONY P. LOMELI as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER V. LONG as an Injured Person ARNALDO LOPEZ as an Injured Person MARIO LOPEZ as an Injured Person DANIEL LOPUZZO as an Injured Person JOSEPH LOWNEY as an Injured Person 310

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 311 of 434

BRENDAN P. LOWREY as an Injured Person EDMUND SCOTT LUCIA as an Injured Person KENNETH J. LUCIANIN as an Injured Person EVELYN A. LUGO as an Injured Person LEONCIO LUIS as an Injured Person DENNIS A. LUSARDI as an Injured Person JANE LUTHER-UMSTADTER as an Injured Person JESSE L. LYNCH as an Injured Person MICHAEL P. LYNCH as an Injured Person THOMAS S. LYNCH as an Injured Person CHARLIE LYONS as an Injured Person JOHN LYONS as an Injured Person MICHAEL LYONS as an Injured Person PETER M. MABANTA as an Injured Person NEIL MACINTYRE as an Injured Person MICHAEL A. MACKO as an Injured Person JANISSA EVALINE MACON as an Injured Person RICO MAGALHAES as an Injured Person THOMAS JAMES MAGEE as an Injured Person ROBERT MAGUIRE as an Injured Person EUGENE S. MAHLSTADT as an Injured Person JOSEPH FRANCIS MAHONEY as an Injured Person THOMAS MAHONEY as an Injured Person LLEWELLYN MALCOLM as an Injured Person JOSE MALDONADO as an Injured Person FRANK HISRBA as an Injured Person PATRICK M. MALLOY as an Injured Person FRANK MALONE as an Injured Person 311

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 312 of 434

JOHN M MALONEY as an Injured Person ADRIANA BELO MALUENDAS as an Injured Person JUDY MARIA MANALASTAS as an Injured Person MICHAEL MANDALA as an Injured Person RALPH MANDIA as an Injured Person THOMAS MANLEY as an Injured Person DOE 109 as an Injured Person ROBERT J. MANSBERGER as an Injured Person WAYNE N. MANZIE as an Injured Person JODIE MARCUSI as an Injured Person CLAUDIA P. MARIN as an Injured Person PATRICK MICHAEL MARINELLI as an Injured Person ANTHONY J. MARINO, JR. as an Injured Person DONALD MARINO as an Injured Person MARTIN ANTHONY MARINO as an Injured Person MICHAEL PATRICK MARINO as an Injured Person JESSIE MARIUS as an Injured Person TIMOTHY MARMION as an Injured Person JUAN R. MARRERO as an Injured Person ROBERT W. MARSHALL as an Injured Person DENNIS J. MARTIN as an Injured Person EDWARD E. MARTIN as an Injured Person EDWARD P. MARTIN as an Injured Person MICHAEL G. MARTIN as an Injured Person ANGELA MARTINEZ as an Injured Person JOSE MARTINEZ as an Injured Person RAFAELA MARTINEZ as an Injured Person 312

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 313 of 434

JAMES MASCARELLA as an Injured Person ANTHONY MASTRELLI as an Injured Person VINCENZO MASTROPASQUA as an Injured Person ANTHONY JOHN MATTONE as an Injured Person RICHARD ANTHONY MATTONE as an Injured Person SHAWN MAY as an Injured Person MICHAEL A. MAYE as an Injured Person JAYSEN JEFFREY MAYO as an Injured Person THOMAS MAZZA as an Injured Person EDWARD MCALEER as an Injured Person JOHN P. MCALEESE as an Injured Person JOHN R MCALLISTER as an Injured Person THOMAS H. MCALLISTER as an Injured Person JOHN MCANDREWS as an Injured Person MAUREEN B MCARDLE-SCHULMAN as an Injured Person JOSEPH MCAULEY as an Injured Person CARL R. MCBRATNEY, JR. as an Injured Person MARY L. MCCALL as an Injured Person MICHAEL MCCALL as an Injured Person KEVIN MCCARREN as an Injured Person JAMES RAYMOND MCCARTHY as an Injured Person DAN MCCARVILL as an Injured Person TIMOTHY MCCARVILL as an Injured Person MICHAEL MCCLELLAND as an Injured Person DENNIS MCCONVILLE as an Injured Person 313

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 314 of 434

CHARLES MCCORMACK as an Injured Person MARIANNE MCCORMACK as an Injured Person RICHARD G MCCOY as an Injured Person ARTHUR MCCROSSEN as an Injured Person JAMES P. MCDERMOTT as an Injured Person SCOTT ASHLEY MCDONNELL as an Injured Person DAVID J. MCDONOUGH as an Injured Person GREGORY L. MCFARLAND as an Injured Person KEVIN MCGEARY as an Injured Person LAWRENCE G. MCGEE as an Injured Person STEPHEN MCGEE as an Injured Person JON J. MCGILLICK as an Injured Person MARK MCGINTY as an Injured Person JOSEPH G. MCGOVERN as an Injured Person THOMAS F. MCGRADE as an Injured Person PATRICK J. MCGREEN as an Injured Person JOSEPH F. MCGRORY as an Injured Person DANIEL M. MCGUINN as an Injured Person JAMES P. MCGUIRE as an Injured Person ROBERT MICHAEL MCGUIRE as an Injured Person JOHN F. MCGURREN as an Injured Person JAMES MCHUGH as an Injured Person EDWARD M. MCKALLEN as an Injured Person JOHN J. MCKENNA as an Injured Person PATRICK MCKENNA as an Injured Person RICHARD D. MCKENNA as an Injured Person MARTIN MCKEON as an Injured Person 314

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 315 of 434

JAMES MCLOUGHLIN as an Injured Person KEVIN M. MCLOUGHLIN as an Injured Person GERARD F. MCMAHON as an Injured Person FREDERICK J. MCNEELY as an Injured Person KEVIN J. MCPIKE as an Injured Person KEVIN MCQUILLY as an Injured Person ERNEST MEDAGLIA as an Injured Person DONALD MEEG as an Injured Person OSCAR H. MEJIA as an Injured Person NEXHAT MELA as an Injured Person JOSEFINA MENDEZ as an Injured Person BENJAMIN MERCADO as an Injured Person CARMELO MERCADO as an Injured Person RONALD F. MERRILL as an Injured Person ROBERTO MESA as an Injured Person JOHN J. MESSINA, JR. as an Injured Person EDWARD F. METZ as an Injured Person RAFAELA J. MEURER as an Injured Person HAROLD MEYERS as an Injured Person THOMAS MEYERS as an Injured Person KENNETH G. MICCIO as an Injured Person RICHARD FRANK MICCIO as an Injured Person JUDY MICHAELS as an Injured Person JOSEPH MICKIEWICZ as an Injured Person GLEN A. MIDBO as an Injured Person CIRO MILANO as an Injured Person ROLAND MILETTI as an Injured Person ROBERT MILLER as an Injured Person THOMAS A. MILTON as an Injured Person JOSEPH MICHAEL MINOGUE as an Injured Person 315

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 316 of 434

WILLIAM J. MIRRO as an Injured Person DONALD H. MISCHKE as an Injured Person STEVE S. MODICA as an Injured Person BILL MOFFAT as an Injured Person RAM ANTHONY MOHABIR as an Injured Person MICHAEL MOLLOY as an Injured Person JOSEPH WILLIAM MONTAPERTO as an Injured Person FRANK J. MONTARULI as an Injured Person JOSEPHINE MONTE as an Injured Person JOHN P. MOONEY as an Injured Person JOSEPH PATRICK MOONEY as an Injured Person KEVIN MOORE as an Injured Person ROBERT E. MOORE, JR. as an Injured Person TARNISA TETENYA MOORE as an Injured Person EDWIN MORALES as an Injured Person NOEL A. MORAN as an Injured Person JAMES L. MORANDI as an Injured Person MARC J. MORELLO as an Injured Person DAVID M. MORIARTY as an Injured Person STEVEN MORMINO as an Injured Person JOHN MORRIS as an Injured Person NANCY MARIE MORRISON as an Injured Person PETER MORRISSEY as an Injured Person MICHAEL MOSCHITTA as an Injured Person STEVEN MOSS as an Injured Person OMAR MOTA as an Injured Person DENNIS A. MUIA as an Injured Person MATTHEW S. MULHAN as an Injured Person

316

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 317 of 434

MICHAEL J. MULLARKEY as an Injured Person GEORGE E. MULLEN, JR. as an Injured Person BRIAN D. MULLER as an Injured Person STEVEN J. MULLER as an Injured Person MICHAEL P. MULLIGAN as an Injured Person MICHAEL MULQUEEN as an Injured Person THOMAS J. MUNDY as an Injured Person LOIS J. MUNGAY as an Injured Person VALERIY MURATOV as an Injured Person JENNIFER MURAWSKI as an Injured Person ALLEN P. MURPHY as an Injured Person DAVID S. MURPHY as an Injured Person JOSEPH J. MURPHY as an Injured Person RICHARD MURPHY as an Injured Person VINCENT JOSEPH MURPHY as an Injured Person JAMES A. MURRAY as an Injured Person RICHARD S. MURRAY as an Injured Person ROBERT J. MURRAY as an Injured Person KENNETH J. MUXIE as an Injured Person JOHN E. NAJMY as an Injured Person PARASAR NANDAN as an Injured Person LOUIS NAPOLI as an Injured Person THOMAS NAPOLITANO as an Injured Person ROBERT V. NARDUCCI as an Injured Person DANIEL NARLOCK as an Injured Person RALPH NEGRON as an Injured Person DEAN A. NELIGAN as an Injured Person JOHN NESBITT as an Injured Person ALLAN P. NEUENDORF as an Injured Person 317

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 318 of 434

BRIAN A. NEVILLE as an Injured Person SEAN S. NEWMAN as an Injured Person FOOK SAM NGOOI as an Injured Person JAMES NIEBLER as an Injured Person ELIZABETH NIELSEN as an Injured Person JOHN NIMMO, III as an Injured Person JOSE L. NIVAR as an Injured Person RICHARD E. NOGAN as an Injured Person TERRY LIN NORTON as an Injured Person SANTOS NUNEZ as an Injured Person DOE 23 as an Injured Person DOE 23, individually as the Spouse of DOE 23, Injured Party DOE 23, individually as the Child of DOE 23, Injured Party DOE 23, individually as the Child of DOE 23, Injured Party KOFI OSEI NYANTAKYI as an Injured Person FRANK O'BRIEN as an Injured Person JOHN O'BRIEN as an Injured Person JOHN F. O'BRIEN as an Injured Person MICHAEL O'BRIEN as an Injured Person RICHARD O'BRIEN as an Injured Person LUIS S. O'CAMPO as an Injured Person RADAMES OCASIO as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER O'CONNELL as an Injured Person SEAN M. O'CONNOR as an Injured Person GERARD O'DONNELL as an Injured Person JOHN J. O'DONNELL as an Injured Person BRIAN O'FLAHERTY as an Injured Person ROBERT E. O'FLAHERTY as an Injured Person

318

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 319 of 434

JOSEPH T. O'HAGAN as an Injured Person EDWARD O'HARE as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER O'KEEFE as an Injured Person PATRICK J. O'KEEFE as an Injured Person KAYODE OLADUNJOYE as an Injured Person DALISAY SAENZ OLAES as an Injured Person MARTIN J. O'LEARY as an Injured Person THOMAS O'MEARA as an Injured Person JOSEPH O'NEIL as an Injured Person KEVIN O'NEILL as an Injured Person EUGENE F. O'REILLY as an Injured Person FRANCISCO ORTIZ as an Injured Person PETERO R. OTIGHO as an Injured Person VINCENT J. PANARO as an Injured Person KEITH PANDER as an Injured Person CAROL A. PANTALONE as an Injured Person JENNIFER PANZELLA as an Injured Person VICTOR D. PANZELLA, JR. as an Injured Person THOMAS PAPACCIO as an Injured Person MARK PAPADOPULOS as an Injured Person DEAN G. PAPPAS as an Injured Person RALPH PAPROCKI as an Injured Person VALENTIN PAREDES as an Injured Person SALVATORE PARISI as an Injured Person WILSTON LAMBERT PARRIS as an Injured Person ANANT PATEL as an Injured Person GREGORY PATSOS as an Injured Person PAUL PATSOS as an Injured Person LOUIS M. PECORA as an Injured Person 319

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 320 of 434

RICHARD PEITLER as an Injured Person MARIA I. PELLOT as an Injured Person MICHAEL PENA as an Injured Person MILCIA C. PENA as an Injured Person FRANCESCA PENORA as an Injured Person RALPH PEPE as an Injured Person STEVEN M. PEREZ as an Injured Person STEVEN C. PERRY as an Injured Person WILLIAM J. PESATURE as an Injured Person JOSEPH G. PESCE as an Injured Person ROBERT E. PETERS as an Injured Person NATHAN PETERSON as an Injured Person JOSEPH M. PETRASSI as an Injured Person GREGORY M. PETRIK as an Injured Person LORI A. PFEIL as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER P. PIAZZA as an Injured Person MANUELA PICHARDO as an Injured Person PEDRO PICHARDO as an Injured Person RUBEN DARIO PIMENTEL as an Injured Person VINCENT A. PINTO as an Injured Person GERARD PIRRAGLIA as an Injured Person CARL J. PISANI as an Injured Person LEONARD PITTZ as an Injured Person LARRIE PLACIDE as an Injured Person EDMUND L. PLUNKETT as an Injured Person DANIEL J. POLLICINO as an Injured Person DAN J. POTTER as an Injured Person SHARON PREMOLI as an Injured person JOHN PRENDERGAST as an Injured Person KEVIN J. PRENDERGAST as an Injured Person 320

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 321 of 434

JOHN PRENTY as an Injured Person FRANK PRESCIA as an Injured Person SALVATORE T. PRINCIOTTA, JR. as an Injured Person MICHAEL J. PRIOR as an Injured Person BRIAN PRITCHARD as an Injured Person WILLIAM PRIVITAR as an Injured Person VINCENT PULEO as an Injured Person ROBERT PULIZZOTTO as an Injured Person DANIEL P. PURCELL as an Injured Person FRANCIS PAUL PURSLEY as an Injured Person JOHN M. QUEVEDO, JR. as an Injured Person MICHAEL J. QUEVEDO as an Injured Person EDWIN QUINN as an Injured Person PETER ADAM QUINN as an Injured Person ANTONIO QUINONES as an Injured Person GODWIN QUINONES as an Injured Person PAUL G. QUIRKE as an Injured Person JAMES P. RAE as an Injured Person ROBERT RAE as an Injured Person RAYMOND RAGUCCI as an Injured Person KENNETH M. RALLIS as an Injured Person RICHARD RAMAIZEL as an Injured Person JUAN RAMIREZ as an Injured Person VIGITA RAMNATH as an Injured Person ALFONSO RAMOS as an Injured Person MILDRED RAMOS as an Injured Person ROBERT RAMOS as an Injured Person MICHAEL RAMPUTI as an Injured Person SEBASTIAN RASPANTI as an Injured Person JAMES REDDAN as an Injured Person JOSHUA M. REDER as an Injured Person 321

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 322 of 434

DANIEL JAMES REEBER as an Injured Person PAMELA ROSE REEVES as an Injured Person RICHARD REGIS as an Injured Person JOSEPH REID as an Injured Person TIMOTHY J. REID as an Injured Person CHARLES REILLY as an Injured Person THOMAS P. REILLY as an Injured Person JOHN E. REINHARDT as an Injured Person LLOYD RENDALL as an Injured Person JOHN RENNA as an Injured Person FRANCIS W. RENOIS as an Injured Person RICHARD RESTO as an Injured Person ALFRED W. RETUNDIE as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER REVERE as an Injured Person FERNANDO REYES as an Injured Person JUAN L. REYES as an Injured Person KAREM REYNOSO as an Injured Person FRANK RICCA as an Injured Person WILLIAM J. RICCARDULLI as an Injured Person DANIEL RICCIARDI as an Injured Person ARTHUR J. RICCIO as an Injured Person STEVEN J. RICHARDS as an Injured Person MAURICE RICHARDSON as an Injured Person FRANCO RIGGIO as an Injured Person WILLIAM RIORDAN as an Injured Person DAVID M. RIVAS as an Injured Person CARLOS A. RIVERA as an Injured Person EDWIN RIVERA as an Injured Person EDWIN RIVERA as an Injured Person 322

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 323 of 434

GRACE RIVERA as an Injured Person JOSE RIVERA as an Injured Person OMAYRA RIVERA as an Injured Person VINCENT RIVERA as an Injured Person MICHAEL RIZZO as an Injured Person DOUGLAS ROBINSON as an Injured Person KENNETH JAMES ROBULAK as an Injured Person ANTHONY ROCCO as an Injured Person NELSON ROCHA as an Injured Person JOHN ROCHE as an Injured Person BRYAN A. RODRIGUES as an Injured Person ABIMAEL RODRIGUEZ as an Injured Person CARLOTA RODRIGUEZ as an Injured Person DAVID RODRIGUEZ as an Injured Person MIRIAM RODRIGUEZ as an Injured Person ROSAULINA RODRIGUEZ as an Injured Person JOHN ROBERT ROGERS as an Injured Person JULIO ROIG, JR. as an Injured Person SUSANA ROJAS as an Injured Person JOHN T. ROKEE as an Injured Person ARNOLD ROMA as an Injured Person WILLIAM ROMAKA as an Injured Person FILOMENA ROMAN as an Injured Person FRANK J. ROMANO as an Injured Person JOHN B. ROONEY as an Injured Person VICTOR J. ROSA as an Injured Person ANTHONY A. ROSADO as an Injured Person GWENNETT ROSARIO as an Injured Person MICHAEL J. ROSSELLO as an Injured Person JOSEPH CAMILLO ROTONDI as an Injured 323

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 324 of 434

Person LOUIS ROTONDO as an Injured Person DAVID ROWAN as an Injured Person MARK J. ROWAN as an Injured Person JAMES J. ROZAS as an Injured Person STEVEN RUGGIERO as an Injured Person LOUIS RUGGIRELLO as an Injured Person DONALD J. RULAND as an Injured Person MARK RUPPERT as an Injured Person DAMIAN RUSIN as an Injured Person MARSHALL RYAN as an Injured Person SUSAN S. RYAN as an Injured Person THOMAS D. RYAN as an Injured Person MICHAEL G. RYNN as an Injured Person MATTHEW JOHN SALMON as an Injured Person ROBERT SALMON as an Injured Person REINA SALZEDO as an Injured Person AUDREY J. SAMMIS as an Injured Person CLIDE R. SAMPSON as an Injured Person CARLOS H. SANCHEZ as an Injured Person CONCEPCION SANCHEZ as an Injured Person JOSE ANTONIO SANCHEZ, JR. as an Injured Person JOE N. SANDERS as an Injured Person OSCAR F. SANDOVAL as an Injured Person DAVID P. SANDVIK as an Injured Person ROBERT SANTANDREA as an Injured Person LUIS SANTIAGO as an Injured Person DAVID A. SANTISE as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER SANTOS as an Injured Person 324

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 325 of 434

LASHEA SAUNDERS as an Injured Person GLENN SAVERY as an Injured Person THELMA SAVERY as an Injured Person THOMAS SCALLY as an Injured Person PHILIP J. SCARFI as an Injured Person BENEDICT SCARSELLA as an Injured Person CARL SCHEETZ as an Injured Person DOE 28 as an Injured Person DONALD SCHIPF as an Injured Person BRIAN M. SCHMITT as an Injured Person ROBERT SCHMITT as an Injured Person EDWARD J. SCHNEIDER as an Injured Person PETER A. SCHOEPE as an Injured Person DANIEL R. SCHOFIELD as an Injured Person DANIEL SCHUG as an Injured Person ROBERT SCHUMACKER as an Injured Person RICHARD EDWARD SCOLA as an Injured Person ANTHONY F. SCOLAVINO as an Injured Person HOWARD SCOTT as an Injured Person DANIEL PAUL SEAMAN as an Injured Person DAVID SEARS as an Injured Person DAVID SEDACCA as an Injured Person RALPH P. SEITER as an Injured Person ROBERT SENN as an Injured Person JEFFREY SENTOWSKI as an Injured Person LAWRENCE R. SENZEL as an Injured Person ANTHONY E. SERCIA as an Injured Person WILLIAM J. SERGIO as an Injured Person

325

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 326 of 434

BARBARA SERNA as an Injured Person KEVIN SHAEFFER as an Injured Person ABIDA SHAIKH as an Injured Person STEPHEN J. SHARP as an Injured Person KEVIN M. SHEA as an Injured Person JOHN B. SHEEHAN as an Injured Person MARILYN JOY SHEPARD as an Injured Person RODNEY C. SHERARD as an Injured Person EDWARD JOHN SHIELDS as an Injured Person SCOTT SHIELDS as an Injured Person STEVE M. SHTAB as an Injured Person FREDERIC SIBOULET as an Injured Person JOHN SIGNORELLI as an Injured Person FABIAN SILVA, JR. as an Injured Person WENDY CHRISTINA SILVA-SMITH as an Injured Person BRIAN SINGER as an Injured Person DONNA SINGER as an Injured Person DOE 77 as an Injured Person CLARENCE SINGLETON as an Injured Person NEIL JEFFREY SKOW as an Injured Person TERENCE P. SLANE as an Injured Person EUGENE SLATER as an Injured Person BRANDON J. SMITH as an Injured Person GARETH A. SMITH as an Injured Person LAUREN A. SMITH as an Injured Person MICHAEL A. SMITH as an Injured Person NETA SMITH as an Injured Person PETER SMITH as an Injured Person TODD M. SMITH as an Injured Person ANDREW W. SOCHINSKI as an Injured 326

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 327 of 434

Person SALVATORE SODANO as an Injured Person RICHARD SOUTO as an Injured Person DAVID SOZIO as an Injured Person MICHAEL SPILLER as an Injured Person ROBERT S. SPINELLI as an Injured Person DONALD J. SPURRELL as an Injured Person ANTHONY JOSEPH SQUILLANTE as an Injured Person CLIFFORD WILLIAM STABNER as an Injured Person JOSEPH R. STACH, JR. as an Injured Person NELLY STANICICH as an Injured Person DOE 111 as an Injured Person JOHN STARACE as an Injured Person PETER STATHIS as an Injured Person DENNIS STEFANAK as an Injured Person HARRY F. STEFANDEL as an Injured Person WILLIAM A. STEINBUCH, III as an Injured Person MAXIMINO STERLING as an Injured Person JOHN M. STIASTNY as an Injured Person EUGENE STOLOWSKI as an Injured Person ETHAN STRAUSS as an Injured Person RASMOND E. STREKER as an Injured Person PAUL STROESSNER as an Injured Person STEPHEN E. STROH as an Injured Person SCOTT C. STROMER as an Injured Person ANTHONY E. SUCHON as an Injured Person GERARD SUDEN as an Injured Person DEVINDRA SUKHRAM as an Injured Person LINDA SULFARO as an Injured Person EDWARD SULLIVAN as an Injured Person JOHN JOSEPH SULLIVAN as an Injured 327

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 328 of 434

Person JOHN M. SULLIVAN as an Injured Person LAWRENCE J. SULLIVAN as an Injured Person MICHAEL P. SULLIVAN as an Injured Person KENNETH A. SUMMERS as an Injured Person RANDOLPH J. SUPEK as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER SUHR as an Injured person ROBERT SUTTON as an Injured Person ALFRED SUWARA as an Injured Person OTTO W. SUWARA as an Injured Person RONALD SVEC as an Injured Person THOMAS SWANNICK as an Injured Person GERARD F. SWEENEY as an Injured Person JOSEPH SWICK as an Injured Person STEVEN M. SYROP as an Injured Person JOSEPH SZYMANSKI as an Injured Person SOUDABEH TABATABAI as an Injured Person JOHN FRANCIS TAGGART as an Injured Person CAROL L. TANNENBAUM as an Injured Person TIMOTHY J. TARPEY as an Injured Person EXPEDITO TAVAREZ as an Injured Person HAVERGAIL TAYLOR as an Injured Person ROXANNE TAYLOR as an Injured Person GERALDINE TEIXEIRA as an Injured Person MICHAEL A. TELESCA as an Injured Person BIDIAWATTIE TEWARI as an Injured Person RECIOE THOMAS as an Injured Person DENISE THOMPSON as an Injured Person

328

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 329 of 434

LLOYD ANTHONY THOMPSON as an Injured Person DENNIS J. THOMSON as an Injured Person FRANK R. THURLOW as an Injured Person DOE 92 as an Injured Person RODERIC S. TIERNEY as an Injured Person RICHARD TISHLER as an Injured Person JOHN A. TISKA as an Injured Person ANTHONY TITO as an Injured Person MICHAEL K. TOBIN as an Injured Person EDWARD H. TOMASZEWSKI as an Injured Person SALVATORE S. TORCIVIA as an Injured Person GABRIEL TORRES as an Injured Person JOHNNY TORRES as an Injured Person LOUIS TORRES as an Injured Person MIGUEL TORRES as an Injured Person MICHAEL TRACY as an Injured Person JOHN TREGLIA as an Injured Person JOSEPH M. TREZZA as an Injured Person ALFRED TRINIDAD as an Injured Person DOUGLAS TRIPKEN as an Injured Person MICHAEL TRIPPTREE as an Injured Person LOUIS M. TROISI as an Injured Person STANLEY TROJANOWSKI as an Injured Person LARRY TROY as an Injured Person DELL TRUAX as an Injured Person KEVIN M. TULLY as an Injured Person STEVEN TURILLI as an Injured Person THOMAS V. TURILLI as an Injured Person JOSEPH A. TURSI as an Injured Person ANTONINA TUTKAJ as an Injured Person 329

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 330 of 434

JOHN M. TYSON as an Injured Person NOSA E. UGIAGBE as an Injured Person GISELA VALENCIA as an Injured Person DENNIS J. VALENTIN as an Injured Person HILDA VALENTINE as an Injured Person ROBERT VAN HOUTEN as an Injured Person WILLIAM C. VAN NAME as an Injured Person BRUCE J. VAN NOSDALL as an Injured Person JENNIFER LEIGH VAN ZANTEN as an Injured Person ANTHONY VANACORE as an Injured Person ROBERT VARESE, JR. as an Injured Person YUNI VASQUEZ as an Injured Person AL VEGA as an Injured Person EMMANUEL VEGA as an Injured Person CHARLES VELLA as an Injured Person JAMES A. VELLA as an Injured Person LAWRENCE VENTO as an Injured Person NELLIE VERDEJO as an Injured Person JOHN S. VERME as an Injured Person JOHN VERRENGIA as an Injured Person TIMOTHY VILLARI as an Injured Person DOMINICK VINCENTI as an Injured Person BRYAN VIOLETTO as an Injured Person DARLENE HELEN VOLLENBERG as an Injured Person GERARD VON ESSEN as an Injured Person BRIAN VOOS as an Injured Person EDWARD WAGNER as an Injured Person DANIEL S. WALIS as an Injured Person

330

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 331 of 434

MICKEY WALKER as an Injured Person BRIAN P. WALL as an Injured Person PATRICK WALL as an Injured Person KERRY M. WALSH as an Injured Person DOE 113 as an Injured Person NEIL PATRICK WALSH as an Injured Person CECIL R. WARD as an Injured Person FRANK J. WARD as an Injured Person RICHARD H. WARD as an Injured Person SANDRA WARD as an Injured Person THOMAS P. WARD as an Injured Person THOMAS A. WARKENTHIEN as an Injured Person CYNTHIA WARREN as an Injured Person WAYNE A. WARREN as an Injured Person ROMUALD WASZIELEWICZ as an Injured Person CHRISTIAN R. WAUGH as an Injured Person MICHAEL A. WEAVER, SR. as an Injured Person DAVID WEBER, SR. as an Injured Person WILLIAM G. WEINERT as an Injured Person GREGG WEISENBURGER as an Injured Person GARY DENNIS WELGE as an Injured Person MICHAEL WELSH as an Injured Person JAMES M. WERNER as an Injured Person KEVIN WHALEN as an Injured Person PAUL A. WHALEN as an Injured Person BRENDAN J. WHELAN as an Injured Person HENRY W. WHITE as an Injured Person YAENO WHITE as an Injured Person STEVE WIESNER as an Injured Person MICHAEL WILBUR as an Injured Person 331

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 332 of 434

BARBARA MATILDA WILLIAMS as an Injured Person GEORGE WILTON, JR. as an Injured Person KEN WILTSE as an Injured Person KENNETH WINKLER as an Injured Person WALTER WISSELL as an Injured Person JOHN J. WOJCIK as an Injured Person CLIFFORD WOLKEN as an Injured Person PHIDIA WONG as an Injured Person WILLIAM E. WOODLON as an Injured Person WILLIAM WOYTKIN as an Injured Person ROBERT ERIC WRIGHT as an Injured Person WILLIAM K. WRIGHT as an Injured Person GREGORY WYCKOFF as an Injured Person JOHN D. YATES as an Injured Person NEAL YELLEN as an Injured Person KAH L. YEOH as an Injured Person CHRISTOPHER YOUNG as an Injured Person DIANNE YOUNG as an Injured Person JOHN E. YOUNG as an Injured Person THOMAS H. YOUNG as an Injured Person ANGELO ZECCA as an Injured Person HELEN ZERLIN as an Injured Person DENNIS ZIMMERMAN as an Injured Person RICHARD STEPHEN ZLETZ as an Injured Person TERI D. FIELDS, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Adolfo Martin Arzu, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Adolfo Martin Arzu HILLARY KATZMAN, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Howard Katzman, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Howard Katzman 332

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 333 of 434

DENISE E. KELLY, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Kelly, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. Kelly MICHELLE LUCHETTI, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alfred Luchetti, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Alfred Luchetti LYNN MCKNIGHT, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roger J. McKnight, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Roger J. McKnight LISA ORTIZ, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angel R. Ortiz, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Angel R. Ortiz IRENE PROVENZANO, as the Executrix of the Estate of Salvatore Provenzano, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Salvatore Provenzano KATHLEEN SHAGI, as the Executor of the Estate of Michael Shagi, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Shagi THOMAS D. DULING, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marion Morvet Ward, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Marion Morvet Ward PEGGY J. WATERS, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory A. Waters, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory A. Waters DANIELLE CIOFFI, as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Tracy, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of William Tracy INA BARNES, individually and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roy J. Barnes, Deceased and on behalf of all survivors of Roy J. Barnes PERSONAL REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of Louis M. Garriz, Deceased MARY JEAN HOLLY as the Representative of 333

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 334 of 434

the Estate of James Holly, Deceased MELANIE A. HUNT, individually as the Child of Jean Marlene Hunt, Injured Party CANDEE J. MALTESE, individually as the Child of Jean Marlene Hunt, Injured Party AMERICA PERALTA as Representative of the Estate of Guido Omar Peralta, Deceased VIRTUDES PRIATNO as Representative of the Estate of Bambang Priatno, Deceased TERESA ROIG, individually and on behalf of the minor children of Julio Roig, Jr., injured REPRESENTATIVE of the Estate of James W. Sullivan, Deceased Plaintiffs, v. KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA Defendant.

334

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 335 of 434

BURNETT PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT ADDING DEFENDANT KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA

I.

INTRODUCTION 1.

The Burnett Plaintiffs hereby supplement and amend their operative pleadings to

add claims against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia arising out of the attacks of September 11, 2001 (“the September 11th attacks” or “9/11 attacks”). 2.

Through actions filed between 2002 and the present date in the Multi-District

Litigation in which this case has been joined, the estates of individuals murdered in the September 11th attacks, thousands of family members of those killed in the attacks, thousands of individuals who were physically injured by the attacks, and commercial victims that incurred billions of dollars in property damage losses as a result of the attacks (collectively “the 9/11 plaintiffs” or “plaintiffs”), brought claims against inter alia the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (“the Kingdom” or “Saudi Arabia”) and/or the Saudi High Commission for Relief of Bosnia & Herzegovina (“SHC”) for their injuries caused by the attacks. 3.

In support of those claims, the 9/11 plaintiffs presented facts and evidence that:

(1) da’awa (Arabic for proselytizing) organizations (a/k/a “charities”) established, funded, directed, and controlled by the government of Saudi Arabia to propagate Wahhabi Islam throughout the world (including the SHC), as a core function of the Saudi state and under the supervision of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs and embassies and consulates outside of Saudi Arabia, were responsible for providing the funding and material support that allowed Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda to acquire the global strike capabilities employed by al Qaeda with such tragic results on September 11, 2001, and acted as agents and alter-egos of the Saudi government in doing so; (2) individual employees, officials, and agents of the government of Saudi Arabia knowingly provided direct assistance to the September 11th hijackers and plotters

335

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 336 of 434

and al Qaeda organization, while acting in the performance of their duties in promoting the antiwestern and anti-American agenda of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs; and (3) the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs and related components of Saudi Arabia’s vast government apparatus established to proselytize Wahhabi Islam knowingly channeled extensive funds and material support to al Qaeda, through the da’awa organizations and other government platforms under their control. 4.

The evidence submitted by the 9/11 plaintiffs between 2002 and 2015 and

incorporated herein by reference included dozens of declassified U.S. and foreign government intelligence reports; State Department diplomatic cables; evidence submitted by the U.S. government in terrorism prosecutions and military tribunal proceedings; affidavits of members of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States (“9/11 Commission”) and the co-chair of the Congressional Joint Inquiry Into the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001 (“Congressional Joint Inquiry”); public statements of additional 9/11 Commission members; testimony and evidence presented to foreign and international courts; internal records produced by the Saudi government-controlled charities in discovery proceedings in this litigation; testimony of convicted al Qaeda members, including Zacarias Moussaoui and SHC employee Ali Ahmed Ali Hamad; affidavits filed by Saudi officials in the litigation; Royal Decrees issued by the Saudi government; statements of Saudi officials; documents authored and disseminated by the Saudi government and its controlled charities; expert affidavit testimony; statements and testimony of U.S. counter-terrorism officials, members of Congress and senior Executive Branch officials; evidence from al Qaeda criminal prosecutions in Germany, Spain, and Bosnia; academic studies; and related materials.

336

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 337 of 434

5.

Plaintiffs’ facts and evidence in support of their claims have taken on additional

significance as a result of the recent enactment of the Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act (“JASTA”), Pub. L. No. 114-222, 130 Stat. 852 (Sept. 28, 2016). 6.

From the commencement of the first suits against Saudi Arabia through

September 28, 2016, the proceedings in this litigation pertaining to the Kingdom have focused exclusively on the availability of subject matter jurisdiction for plaintiffs’ claims under the noncommercial tort exception of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (“FSIA”), 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(5), which provides an exception to foreign sovereign immunity for cases “in which money damages are sought against a foreign state for personal injury or death, or damage to or loss of property, occurring in the United States and caused by the tortious act or omission of that foreign state or of any official or employee of that foreign state while acting within the scope of his office or employment.” 7.

Plaintiffs in this case have not previously asserted claims against the Kingdom of

Saudi Arabia; however, the passage of JASTA has opened an avenue for these Plaintiffs to assert their claims against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for what they have known has been the Kingdom’s involvement in the September 11th attacks. 8.

On September 28, 2016, Congress enacted JASTA, following passage by both

chambers and overwhelming votes in both the Senate and House to override a Presidential veto. See 162 Cong. Rec. S2845–48 (May 17, 2016) (unanimous consent); 162 Cong. Rec. H5239–44 (Sept. 9, 2016) (voice vote); 162 Cong. Rec. S6166–73 (Sept. 28, 2016) (veto override vote of 97-1); 162 Cong. Rec. H6023–32 (Sept. 28, 2016) (veto override vote of 348-77). 9.

Through JASTA, Congress established an additional exception to foreign

sovereign immunity for cases against foreign states arising from acts of international terrorism occurring in the United States, supplementing the jurisdictional grant provided by the non-

337

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 338 of 434

commercial tort exception, which continues to provide an independent basis of jurisdiction for such cases as well. JASTA § 3(a) (enacting 28 U.S.C. § 1605B). In addition, JASTA made foreign sovereigns subject to Anti-Terrorism Act (“ATA”) claims, see id. § 3(a) (enacting 28 U.S.C. § 1605B(c)), and amended the ATA’s civil liability provisions to “recognize the substantive causes of action for aiding and abetting and conspiracy liability.” Id. § 2(a)(4); see id. § 4(a) (enacting 18 U.S.C. § 2333(d)). 10.

Although JASTA is a law of general application, its legislative history makes

clear that Congress intended JASTA to provide a jurisdictional grant and basis of relief applicable specifically to plaintiffs’ claims against the Kingdom, and to eliminate immunity defenses advanced by the Kingdom proceedings in 03 MDL 1570.1 11.

JASTA does so by “provid[ing] civil litigants with the broadest possible basis …

consistent with the Constitution … , to seek relief against persons, entities, and foreign countries, wherever acting and wherever they may be found, that have provided material support, directly or indirectly, to foreign organizations or persons that engage in terrorist activities against the United States.” JASTA, § 2(b). 1

See 162 Cong. Rec. at H6025 (Sept. 28, 2016) (Rep. King) (“What [JASTA] is going to do is finally allow the 9/11 families to have their day in court to seek the justice they have long been denied. And if the Government of Saudi Arabia has no involvement, if there is no liability, they have nothing to worry about.”); 162 Cong. Rec. at H6029 (Sept. 28, 2016) (Rep. Smith) (“[T]he Second Circuit dismissed legal action against Saudi Arabia and other defendants . . . . JASTA corrects that. . . . Anyone who has read the recently de-classified 28 pages of findings from the House-Senate Intelligence Committee’s joint inquiry in 2002 . . . knows the provocative evidence of Saudi complicity in 9/11, and that remains unexamined.”); 162 Cong. Rec. at S6167 (Sept. 28, 2016) (Sen. Blumenthal) (“[T]he Justice Against Sponsors of Terrorism Act simply closes a loophole that was created by the courts, contrary to the intent of this body. . . . Saudi Arabia, is able to evade all responsibility under the decision made by the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in New York, which created that loophole. . . . That is wrong. . . . This loophole will be closed by this measure for the benefit of not only the 9/11 victims but also potential victims in the future.”); 162 Cong. Rec. at S6172 (Sept. 28, 2016) (Sen. Schumer) (“Unfortunately, the courts in New York have dismissed the 9/11 victims’ claims against certain foreign entities alleged to have helped the 9/11 attacks. These courts are following what I believe is a fundamentally incorrect reading of the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act. . . . For the sake of these families, it should be made clear—beyond a shadow of a doubt—that every entity, including foreign states, will be held accountable if they are sponsors of heinous acts like 9/11. It is very simple. If the Saudis were culpable, they should be held accountable. If they had nothing to do with 9/11, they have nothing to fear.”); cf. 162 Cong. Rec. at H6026 (Sept. 28, 2016) (Rep. Nadler) (“If the Saudi Government was not complicit in the attack on 9/11, the plaintiffs will fail to prove such complicity in an American court. Justice will have been served, and the Saudis will be vindicated after years of suspicion. But if it is proven in an American court that the Saudi Government was complicit in the attacks on 9/11, justice will have been served and we—not the Saudis—will have justification to be very angry.”); 162 Cong. Rec. at H5241 (Sept. 9, 2016) (Rep. Poe) (“Based on the 28 pages held secret for years, there may be evidence that the country of Saudi Arabia and their officials may have had some involvement in planning the elements of that attack. I don’t know. That is what the courtroom is for. Whether this involvement rises to the level to be held accountable at trial is an issue for a jury of Americans to decide.”).

338

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 339 of 434

12.

To that end, JASTA removed non-textual judicial limitations on federal courts’

jurisdiction over foreign sovereigns under the FSIA for acts of international terrorism occurring in the United States, and eliminated judicial constrictions on ATA claims, in order to ensure the rights of victims of terrorism in the United States to “pursue civil claims against … countries that have knowingly or recklessly provided material support or resources, directly or indirectly, to the persons or organizations responsible for their injuries.” JASTA, § 2(a)(7). 13.

Among other features, JASTA’s exception to foreign sovereign immunity

confirms that jurisdiction can be based on a sovereign entity’s actions undertaken abroad (not just in the United States), and predicated on acts undertaken by a sovereign entity’s agent (not just an employee, official, or alter-ego). JASTA § 3(a) (enacting 28 U.S.C. § 1605B(b)(2)). 14.

Through these and other provisions, JASTA “incorporates traditional principles of

vicarious liability and attribution, including doctrines such as respondeat superior, agency and secondary liability,” thus confirming that a foreign state is subject to jurisdiction and liability for tortious acts of employees and agents at every level acting within the scope of their employment or agency. 162 Cong. Rec. at S2845 (May 17, 2016) (Sen. Cornyn). 15.

JASTA also confirms that there is no “discretionary function” limitation on

jurisdiction for claims against a foreign state arising from an act of international terrorism occurring in the United States, and that the “caused by” language of the new exception to sovereign immunity, codified at 28 U.S.C. § 1605B, requires only some “reasonable connection” between defendant’s actions and plaintiffs’ injuries, 162 Cong. Rec. at S2845 (May 17, 2016) (Sen. Cornyn) (citing case law affirming “reasonable connection” standard), a flexible standard that may be met based on a showing of “tortious act or acts” attributable to the defendant. JASTA § 3(a) (enacting 28 U.S.C. § 1605B(b)(2)).

339

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 340 of 434

16.

Following JASTA’s enactment, the Kingdom – as an appellee in an appeal

pending before the Second Circuit arising out of these MDL proceedings – joined a motion for vacatur of the appeal acknowledging that “JASTA was intended to apply to” cases arising out of the September 11th Attacks, and that “JASTA makes significant changes to the legal framework addressed in the district court’s” September 29, 2015 decision that had previously dismissed claims against the Kingdom predicated on 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(5). 17.

On February 7, 2017, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals granted the joint

motion for vacatur and remand in all respects, and remanded the cases in issue “for further proceedings in light of Congress’s enactment of [JASTA].” 18.

This Amended Complaint is filed on behalf of estates of individuals murdered in

the September 11th attacks, thousands of family members of those killed in the attacks, and individuals who were physically injured by the attacks (the “Plaintiffs”) to incorporate claims against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. 19.

This Amended Complaint sets forth facts and evidence in support of the

Plaintiffs’ claims and theories of jurisdiction as to the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, under both JASTA and other law, for Plaintiffs’ injuries caused by the September 11th attacks. 20.

This Amended Complaint is in the form of an amendment that supplements by

incorporation the Burnett Third Amended Complaint, Case No. 02 Civ. 1616 (D.D.C.), ECF No. 29, and Burnett’s Notice of Consolidation of Pleadings, 03 MDL 1570, ECF No. 1377, and relates solely to Plaintiffs’ claims against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, and does not apply to any other defendants in the September 11th MDL, as to which Burnett Plaintiffs’ operative complaints, pleadings, and related submissions remain in effect.

340

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 341 of 434

II.

PARTIES 21.

Plaintiffs include the estates of thousands of individuals murdered in the

September 11th attacks, several thousand family members of those victims, and individuals who themselves suffered physical injuries caused by the September 11th attacks. 22.

Plaintiffs listed in the caption of this action are citizens or residents of the United

States of America, and citizens or residents of foreign nations, who lost loved ones on September 11, 2001. Plaintiffs include the Executors, Administrators and/or Personal Representatives of the Estates of persons killed, along with the close family members, parents, spouses, children and siblings of those lost. Also included are persons injured in the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. The attacks utilized commercial aircraft which crashed into the World Trade Center North and South Towers in New York City, the Pentagon in Virginia and a field in Shanksville, Pennsylvania. Plaintiffs’ include passengers or crew members on board American Airlines Flights 11 and 77, United Airlines Flights 175 and 93, persons present at both towers of the World Trade Center in New York, and persons present at the Pentagon in Virginia. Plaintiffs herein number over 3,000, and include persons from all walks of life. The names, numbers, residency, familial relationship and additional specific allegations for each Plaintiff can be found in the Burnett Appendix 5 filed herewith.

Burnett Appendix 5 is incorporated herein by

reference. 23.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is a foreign state within the meaning of 28

U.S.C. § 1603(a). Saudi Arabia maintains an Embassy within the United States at 601 New Hampshire Avenue, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20007.

341

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 342 of 434

III.

VENUE AND JURISDICTION 24.

Venue in this district is proper pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391(b)(2) and

1391(f)(1), as a substantial part of the events giving rise to the claims asserted herein occurred in this district. Venue is also proper in this district pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2334(a). 25.

This Court has subject matter jurisdiction over plaintiffs’ claims against defendant

Saudi Arabia pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1330, as the claims against the defendant falls within the exceptions to foreign sovereign immunity set forth at 28 U.S.C. §§ 1605(a)(5) and 1605B of the FSIA, 28 U.S.C. § 1602 et seq. Jurisdiction Pursuant to 1605B – JASTA 26.

JASTA’s exception to foreign sovereign immunity applies when a plaintiff

presents plausible allegations satisfying the following elements: (1) the suit seeks monetary damages for a physical injury to person, property, or death occurring in the United States; (2) caused by an act of international terrorism occurring in the United States; and (3) caused by a tortious act or acts of the foreign state defendant, or of any official, employee, or agent of that foreign state while acting within the scope of his or her office, employment, or agency, regardless of where the tortious act or acts of the foreign state occurred; provided that (4) the claim does not rest on allegations of “mere negligence.” 28 U.S.C. § 1605B. 27.

In satisfaction of JASTA’s first and second elements, plaintiffs’ suits present

claims for money damages for physical injuries to person and wrongful deaths occurring in the United States and caused by the September 11th attacks, including among others claims on behalf of the nearly three thousand innocent people killed in the attacks and their family members, claims for severe physical injuries suffered on September 11, 2001 by survivors of the attacks. 28.

Further, plaintiffs’ allegations, facts, and evidence, along with the declarations of

the United States government and Supreme Court, establish that the September 11th attacks were an “act of international terrorism” within the meaning of JASTA. 342

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 343 of 434

29.

Plaintiffs’ claims satisfy JASTA’s third element as well, in four ways.

30.

First, plaintiffs plausibly allege (and offer facts and evidence) that several Saudi

government da’awa organizations collaborated intimately with al Qaeda during the decade leading up to the 9/11 attacks, providing funding and other forms of material support that enabled Osama bin Laden to build and sustain the al Qaeda organization and acquire the global strike capabilities employed on September 11, 2001. These organizations were components of the Saudi government, and officials and employees of those organizations were officials and employees of the Kingdom. Their material support of al Qaeda included assistance closely related to the September 11th attacks, such as the funding of the terrorist camps in Afghanistan where the 9/11 attacks were planned and the hijackers received training. 31.

The Saudi government da’awa organizations that engaged in that material support

of al Qaeda, while acting as arms and components of the Saudi government, include the Muslim World League (“MWL”), International Islamic Relief Organization (“IIRO”), Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, Al Haramain al Masjed al Aqsa, Rabita Trust, World Assembly of Muslim Youth (“WAMY”), Saudi Red Crescent Society (“SRC”), Saudi Joint Relief Committee for Kosovo and Albania (“SJRC”), and the SHC (collectively “the da’awa organizations,” “proselytizing organizations,” or “charities”). 32.

These organizations were repeatedly implicated in terrorist activities and the

sponsorship of al Qaeda during the years preceding the September 11th attacks, and officials throughout the Saudi government were thus aware that those government components were actively supporting al Qaeda. 33.

Second, plaintiffs plausibly allege (and offer facts and evidence) that the

Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs and other components of the Kingdom’s Wahhabi proselytizing apparatus broadly used the resources under their control to fund and materially

343

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 344 of 434

support al Qaeda. This material support included the direct involvement of employees of the Ministry in recruitment and fundraising activities for al Qaeda, to include the recruitment of several of the 9/11 hijackers. In addition, officials of the Ministry were directly involved in directing and supervising organizations like Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, which was channeling massive resources and support to al Qaeda in the years immediately before the September 11th attacks. In recent years, the Kingdom has removed thousands of extremists employed by the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and undertaken other reforms of the Ministry, and described those activities as measures necessary to counter terrorism. 34.

Third, plaintiffs plausibly allege (and offer facts and evidence) that individual

Saudi government employees and agents knowingly provided material support to the September 11th hijackers and plotters, both from within the United States and elsewhere, while acting within the scope of their employment and agency in advancing the extremist agenda of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Wahhabi proselytizing apparatus. 35.

Over recent months, three significant additional and previously unavailable U.S.

government investigative records have been declassified that provide further evidence of the involvement of employees and agents of the Saudi government in providing direct aid and assistance to the 9/11 hijackers and plotters, and the true nature of their roles with the Saudi government: (1) the so-called 28 pages of the Report of the Congressional Joint Inquiry (“CJI”), attached as Appendix 2 hereto; (2) a 2012 “Summary Report” (“SR”) concerning the status of the continuing criminal investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (“FBI”) and Department of Justice (“DOJ”) of Saudi government employees and agents who, in the FBI’s own words, provided “substantial assistance” to the 9/11 hijackers, attached as Appendix 3 hereto; and (3) the investigative memo of the 9/11 Commission concerning evidence of Saudi

344

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 345 of 434

government involvement in the attacks known as “Document 17,” attached as Appendix 4 hereto. 36.

As reflected in those documents and by plaintiffs’ further factual allegations and

evidence, the individual Saudi government employees and agents who provided such material support to the 9/11 hijackers and plotters and al Qaeda include: •

Fahad al Thumairy and Omar al Bayoumi (both employees and agents of the Saudi government performing functions on behalf of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs), who working together provided “substantial assistance” to 9/11 hijackers Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Mihdhar from within the United States (SR at p. 3);

•

an as-yet unidentified individual who is also a “subject” of the ongoing U.S. criminal investigation and “tasked al-Thumairy and al-Bayoumi with assisting the hijackers” (SR at pp. 3-4);

•

Saleh al Hussayen, a Saudi cleric and government employee who precipitously switched to the same hotel as Hazmi and Mihdhar the night before the 9/11 attacks, and was “deceptive” about his relationship with the hijackers when interviewed by the FBI according to the recently declassified pages of the 9/11 Congressional Joint Inquiry Report, going so far as to feign seizure and flee the United States to avoid further questioning (CJI at p. 418);

•

Osama Bassnan, a Saudi government employee and close associate of Bayoumi and “a number of other individuals connected to the hijackers,” who according to the FBI was an ardent supporter of Osama bin Laden and bragged to an FBI asset that he “did more than al-Bayoumi did for the hijackers” (CJI at pp. 417, 426);

•

Muhammed Jaber al Fakihi, another employee of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs with extensive ties to terrorism, who according to declassified intelligence documents directly aided the Hamburg al Qaeda cell that coordinated the 9/11 attacks;

•

Mohammed al Qudhaeein, another Saudi government agent whose “profile is similar to that of al-Bayoumi,” who participated, along with another long-time Saudi government agent named Hamdan al Shalawi, in a dry run for the 9/11 attacks during a 1999 flight from Phoenix to Washington, D.C. “to attend a party at the Saudi embassy,” attempting “on two occasions to enter the cockpit,” in order “to test the security procedures of America West Airlines in preparation for and in furtherance of UBL/Al Qaeda operations” (CJI at pp. 419, 433-34); 345

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 346 of 434

37.

•

Omar Abdi Mohamed, another employee of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs stationed in California, who funded al Qaeda through a purported charity he established called the Western Somali Relief Agency;

•

individual government officials and employees who headed and worked in the Kingdom’s so-called charities; and

•

individual Saudi government imams who served as recruitment agents and fundraisers for bin Laden’s organization.

Fourth, pursuant to state and federal law theories of secondary liability (aiding

and abetting and conspiracy), plaintiffs’ factual allegations and evidence support the attribution of the September 11th attacks themselves to Saudi Arabia for purposes of both jurisdiction and liability. Jurisdiction Pursuant to 1605(a)(5) – Non-Commercial Torts Exception 38.

The text of the FSIA’s non-commercial tort exception provides that foreign states

do not enjoy immunity for tort claims that: “(1) are noncommercial, (2) seek ‘money damages,’ (3) for ‘personal injury or death, or damage to or loss of property,’ (4) that ‘occur[ed] in the United States,’ and (5) that was ‘caused by the tortious act,’ (6) ‘of [a defendant] foreign state or [its] employee . . . acting within the scope of his . . . employment,’ unless (7) the claim is based on a discretionary act or (8) it is for ‘malicious prosecution, abuse of process, libel, slander, misrepresentation, deceit, or interference with contract rights.’ 28 U.S.C. § 1605(a)(5).” Doe v Bin Laden, et al., 663 F.3d 64, 66 (2d Cir. 2011). 39.

As summarized above and set forth with particularity below, plaintiffs’ claims

seek money damages for personal injury, wrongful death, and damage to property occurring in the United States, pursuant to common law and statutory tort claims that are non-commercial and are not “for malicious prosecution, abuse of process, libel, slander, misrepresentation, deceit, or interference with contract rights,” in satisfaction of the first four and eighth textual requirements of § 1605(a)(5).

346

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 347 of 434

40.

Further, plaintiffs’ facts and evidence relating to the attributable tortious acts of

Saudi Arabia and its employees, agents, and alter-egos in support of the September 11th attacks and al Qaeda, and implicated doctrines of secondary liability, satisfy the non-commercial tort exception’s requirements that the claim seek redress for injuries that were “caused by” a tortious act of the foreign state, or of an employee or official of the foreign state acting within the scope of his employment or office. 41.

Plaintiffs’ claims also satisfy any potential non-textual requirement under the non-

commercial tort exception of an “entire tort” committed in the United States, as plaintiffs plead and offer facts and evidence that: (1) individuals who were employees and agents of the Kingdom, acting within the scope of their employment and agency, knowingly provided critical support to the September 11th hijackers and plotters through activities undertaken in the United States; (2) several ostensible “charities” that extensively funded and supported al Qaeda, including from offices in the United States, were agents and controlled alter-egos of the Kingdom or discharged core government functions, making their U.S.-based torts attributable to the Kingdom; (3) the tortious acts of Saudi employees, agents, and alter-egos in support of al Qaeda outside of the United States were intimately related to, and thus part of the same tort as, the September 11th attacks here; and (4) the September 11th attacks were themselves an “entire tort” in the United States, attributable to the Kingdom under state and federal common law secondary liability principles. 42.

Further, the tortious acts which form the basis of plaintiffs’ claims do not fall

within the discretionary function limitation of the non-commercial tort exception, as they involve the provision of material support and resources to al Qaeda in violation of U.S. and international law, and were prohibited by the laws of numerous other jurisdictions where such support was provided.

The activities facilitating the provision of that material support, including the

347

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 348 of 434

placement of employees and agents of the Saudi government in the United States to perform undisclosed functions, violated other U.S. laws as well, including the Espionage Act and U.S. immigration laws. 43.

Recognizing this Court’s considerable familiarity from prior proceedings in these

MDL proceedings with the historical facts that inform and provide context for plaintiffs’ claims, this Amended Complaint now proceeds, in the interests of clarity, to discuss the September 11th attacks themselves, and then surveys the key evidence and facts concerning the tortious acts of the Saudi government and its employees, agents, and alter-egos in furtherance of those attacks. 44.

In further support of the claims set forth herein, plaintiffs incorporate by reference

in its entirety the February 3, 2015 Averment of Facts and Evidence in Support of Their Claims Against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the Saudi High Commission for Relief of Bosnia & Herzegovina (“Averment”), ECF No. 2927-1, attached as Appendix 1 hereto, which sets forth relevant details concerning al Qaeda’s origins in the Afghan jihad and development of bin Laden’s terrorist organization in the ensuing years (Averment ¶¶ 15-48); al Qaeda’s targeting of the United States from the date of its foundation through September 11, 2001 (Averment ¶¶ 86101, 307-308); the role of Wahhabi Islam in the Saudi state and the power and influence of the Kingdom’s government clerics (Averment ¶¶ 49-124); the links between Saudi Wahhabism and terrorism (Averment ¶¶ 125-130); details concerning the September 11th plot itself (Averment ¶¶ 131-263); counter-terrorism reforms targeting the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs after the September 11th attacks that reflect and evidence the Ministry’s involvement in terrorist activities prior to September 11, 2001 (Averment ¶¶ 264-285); the Saudi government da’awa organizations’ material support of al Qaeda and terrorist activities (Averment ¶¶ 286-580); and the Kingdom’s knowledge of the involvement of its charities and components of its proselytizing apparatus in supporting al Qaeda (Averment ¶¶ 581-587).

348

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 349 of 434

45.

Plaintiffs also incorporate by reference the evidence they filed of record in the

MDL proceedings in further support of the factual allegations of their Averment and their claims against the Kingdom and the Saudi High Commission. ECF Nos. 2927, 2927-1 – 2927-24.2 IV.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND 46.

On September 11, 2001, nineteen members of the al Qaeda terrorist organization,

fifteen of whom were citizens of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, hijacked four commercial airliners, and used those planes as weapons in a coordinated terrorist attack upon the United States and its citizens (the “September 11th attacks”). The hijackers caused two jets to crash into the World Trade Center Towers in New York, and a third to crash into the Pentagon Building in Arlington County, Virginia. The fourth airliner crashed into a field near the town of Shanksville, Pennsylvania, after innocent passengers challenged the hijackers and prevented them from reaching their apparent target in Washington, D.C. 47.

At the time of the September 11th attacks, al Qaeda was a designated foreign

terrorist organization under section 219 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. § 1189). 48.

The September 11th attacks resulted in the tragic loss of several thousand lives,

physical injuries to countless other persons, and property damage on a catastrophic scale, including the complete destruction of the World Trade Center Complex. 49.

The September 11th attacks were an “act of international terrorism” within the

meaning of 18 U.S.C. § 2331. See Final Report of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States (“9/11 Commission Final Report”) at pp. 172-73 (describing the 9/11 attacks as a “complex international terrorist operation”); see also Hamdan v. Rumsfeld, 548 U.S. 557, 567-568 (2006) (“On September 11, 2001, agents of the al Qaeda terrorist organization

2

Pursuant to the Court’s Order of August 31, 2016, plaintiffs are not relying on the documents that were the subject of that Order and identified as exhibits 9, 10, and 11 in ECF No. 2927-24 (bates stamped PEC-KSA000191-196).

349

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 350 of 434

hijacked commercial airplanes and attacked the World Trade Center in New York City and the national headquarters of the Department of Defense in Arlington, Virginia. Americans will never forget the devastation wrought by these acts. Nearly 3,000 civilians were killed. Congress responded by adopting a Joint Resolution authorizing the President to ‘use all necessary and appropriate force against those nations, organizations, or persons he determines planned, authorized, committed, or aided the terrorist attacks . . . in order to prevent any future acts of international terrorism against the United States by such nations, organizations or persons.’ Authorization for Use of Military Force (AUMF), 115 Stat. 224, note following 50 U.S.C. § 1541 (2000 ed., Supp. III).”) (Emphasis added). 50.

As confirmed by countless investigations, the September 11th attacks were the

culmination of a more than decade long campaign by al Qaeda to carry out spectacular terrorist attacks against the United States, set in motion with the formation of al Qaeda in 1988. 51.

As further detailed below, the Kingdom provided material support to al Qaeda for

more than a decade leading up to the September 11th attacks, with knowledge of al Qaeda’s intent to conduct terrorist attacks against the United States, and an awareness that al Qaeda would use the support provided by the Kingdom to achieve that objective. 52.

As further detailed below, the support provided by the Kingdom enabled al Qaeda

to obtain the global strike capabilities necessary to carry out the September 11th attacks, and was essential to the success of those attacks. Indeed, the material support provided to al Qaeda by employees, agents, and alter-egos of the Saudi government, all of which is attributable to the Kingdom itself, included direct assistance to the September 11th plotters and hijackers and massive funding and logistical support that enabled Osama bin Laden to build and sustain the al Qaeda organization.

350

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 351 of 434

53.

As further detailed below, the material support provided by the Kingdom to al

Qaeda encompasses the tortious acts of: (1) individual Saudi government employees, officials, and agents, who knowingly provided direct aid and support to the September 11th hijackers and plotters and al Qaeda organization, from within the United States and elsewhere, while acting within the scope of their employment, office, or agency; (2) proselytizing organizations (including the SHC) established, funded, directed, and supervised by the Saudi government to propagate Wahhabi Islamist ideology throughout the world, as a core function and duty of the Saudi state, which knowingly, directly, and extensively supported al Qaeda’s targeting of the United States by funding and collaborating intimately with al Qaeda, including through offices located in the United States; (3) additional components of the Kingdom’s vast Wahhabi proselytizing apparatus in support of al Qaeda; and (4) the September 11th hijackers themselves, pursuant to theories of secondary liability (aiding and abetting and conspiracy).

V.

MATERIAL SUPPORT FOR AL QAEDA AND THE 9/11 ATTACKS FROM SAUDI ARABIA’S PROSELYTIZING AGENTS AND ALTER-EGOS 54.

The emergence of al Qaeda under the patronage of the Saudi government’s

proselytizing apparatus is rooted in the unique relationship between the House of Saud and Wahhabi Islam. 55.

The modern Saudi state is a product of a pact forged in the 18th century between

Muhammad Ibn al Saud, the head of the al Saud tribe in Arabia, and Muhammad Ibn Abd al Wahhab, a Muslim scholar from the Najd region of Arabia. 56.

Ibn Abd al Wahhab’s ideas and teachings form the basis of the Islamic school of

thought commonly known as Wahhabism, which forms the ideological foundation for the al

351

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 352 of 434

Qaeda movement. According to the 9/11 Commission, al Qaeda finds inspiration and religious justification for its actions in “a long tradition of extreme intolerance” that flows “through the founders of Wahhabism.” See 9/11 Commission Final Report at p. 362. 57.

Pursuant to the compact between the House of Saud and the Saudi Ulema

(Wahhabi scholars and clerics), the Ulema provide religious legitimacy for the House of Saud’s political rule. In exchange, the House of Saud provides the Ulema with government platforms and resources to promote their Wahhabi religious agenda. 58.

One of the most absolute conditions of this arrangement is the requirement that

the Saudi state propagate Wahhabi Islam globally. See 9/11 Commission Final Report at p. 372 (confirming the “dedication of the [Saudi] government to propagating the Islamic faith, particularly the Wahhabi sect that flourishes in Saudi Arabia”). 59.

In this regard, the Kingdom’s Basic Law of Governance expressly provides that

“[t]he State shall…undertake its duty regarding the propagation of Islam (Da’wah).” See ECF No. 2927-9 (Affirmation of Evan Francois Kohlmann) (hereinafter “Kohlmann Affirmation”) at ¶ 16, n. 2. 60.

To comply with this obligation, the Kingdom established several state da’awa

organizations to serve as instruments for conducting proselytizing activities and otherwise advancing the Wahhabi agenda of the Saudi Ulema globally, including MWL, IIRO, WAMY, Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, Rabita Trust, the SHC, SJRC, SRC, Benevolence International Foundation (“BIF”), and Al Haramain al Masjed al Aqsa. 61.

From the formation of al Qaeda in 1988 through the September 11, 2001, those

Wahhabi proselytizing organizations established, funded, directed and controlled by the government of Saudi Arabia, and supervised by the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs and embassies and consulates outside of Saudi Arabia, were responsible for providing the massive

352

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 353 of 434

funding and other forms of support that allowed Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda to acquire the global strike capabilities employed by al Qaeda on September 11, 2001, and were at all times components of the Saudi government itself. 62.

Osama bin Laden’s collaboration with the Saudi state da’awa organizations began

during the jihad against the Soviet Union in Afghanistan, when several of those organizations formed the nucleus of a support network to provide funds, arms, and other assistance to the mujahideen (jihad fighters), at the direction of the Saudi government and working in close coordination with bin Laden. 63.

When Osama bin Laden formed al Qaeda in 1988 to conduct jihad against the

United States, the support network established by the da’awa organizations during the Afghan campaign was adapted to support bin Laden’s targeting of the United States. 64.

Indeed, internal al Qaeda documents detailing the formation of bin Laden’s terror

organization, seized by the United States during a 2002 raid of an al Qaeda front charity and analyzed in detail in a DOJ evidentiary proffer, indicate that Dr. Abdullah Omar Naseef, the then head of MWL and a member of the Kingdom’s Majlis al Shura (government consultative council), personally met with bin Laden and other founding members of al Qaeda at the time of al Qaeda’s formation, and agreed that MWL offices would be used as a platform for the new jihad organization, and that attacks would be launched from MWL’s offices. See Averment ¶ 345; ECF No. 2927-24 (Index of Evidence Supporting Plaintiffs’ Averment of Facts) (hereinafter referred to as “Index of Evidence”), Ex. 125. 65.

Contemporaneous with this agreement, Saudi government officials installed

founding al Qaeda members in leadership posts of the Saudi da’awa organizations, in locations of strategic importance to al Qaeda.

353

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 354 of 434

66.

For example, Naseef appointed Wa’el Hamza Jelaidan, a founding al Qaeda

member whom the United States designated as a terrorist after 9/11 for “direct[ing] organizations that have provided financial and logistical support to al-Qaida,” to serve as the head of the Peshawar, Pakistan office of MWL in 1989. See Averment ¶ 564. 67.

Naseef also appointed Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, another founding al Qaeda

member and Osama bin Laden’s brother in law, to serve as the director of a new IIRO office in the Far East in this time period, another location of strategic importance to the new al Qaeda organization for recruitment and other reasons. See id. ¶ 350. 68.

Shortly after assuming that post, Khalifa used IIRO funds and resources to

support a terrorist cell in the Philippines, which included 9/11 masterminds Khaled Sheikh Mohammed and Ramzi Yousef, in relation to the development of an aviation-based terrorist plot involving the planned simultaneous in-flight detonations of twelve U.S. flag commercial airplanes. That very plot, often referred to as “Operation Bojinka,” was adapted by Khaled Sheikh Mohammed, using the knowledge he had acquired during its development about vulnerabilities in the aviation security system, into the September 11th plot. See id. 69.

The internal documents relating to al Qaeda’s establishment and other evidence

indicate that founding al Qaeda members held senior posts in WAMY/BIF (Adel Batterjee), SRC (Wa’el Jelaidan), and Al Haramain Islamic Foundation (Aqeel al Aqeel) during the period surrounding al Qaeda’s formation. 70.

In the years following al Qaeda’s formation with the direct assistance of the Saudi

officials who directed the Kingdom’s da’awa organizations, support flowed continuously from the Kingdom’s da’awa organizations to al Qaeda, providing the massive funding and other essential resources that enabled bin Laden to build and maintain al Qaeda.

354

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 355 of 434

71.

As the 9/11 Commission’s Staff Monograph on terrorist financing explained, “al

Qaeda was funded, to the tune of approximately $30 million per year, by diversions of money from Islamic charities.” 72.

State Department cables, U.S. intelligence and counter-terrorism reports,

declarations of U.S. officials, foreign intelligence reports, and other evidence confirm that the “Islamic charities” most responsible for channeling this essential support to al Qaeda were MWL, IIRO, WAMY, Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, Rabita Trust, SHC, SJRC, SRC, BIF and Al Haramain al Masjed al Aqsa. 73.

Plaintiffs have offered particularized facts and evidence in their Averment,

spanning over 80 pages, documenting the terrorist activities of each of those organizations in support of al Qaeda. See Averment at ¶¶ 286-587, incorporated herein by reference. 74.

Those factual allegations (and the evidence supporting them) document those

da’awa organizations’ massive funding of al Qaeda, intimate involvement in all aspects of al Qaeda’s operations, and broad use of their infrastructures and resources to advance al Qaeda’s terrorist agenda. 75.

The tortious acts of those da’awa organizations in support of al Qaeda included: (a)

raising and laundering funds on behalf of al Qaeda and its affiliates;

(b)

channeling funds to al Qaeda;

(c)

providing financial and logistical support and physical assets to al Qaeda members;

(d)

directly participating in al Qaeda’s terrorist activities, including the planning, coordination, funding and execution of terrorist attacks;

(e)

permitting al Qaeda members to use ostensible employment with their organizations as a cover for their travels and terrorist activities;

(f)

serving as liaisons to localized terrorist organizations on behalf of al Qaeda, thereby assisting al Qaeda in expanding its operational base and sphere of influence; 355

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 356 of 434

76.

(g)

funding and facilitating shipments of arms and supplies to Islamic terrorist organizations and associated separatist movements, including al Qaeda;

(h)

funding camps used by al Qaeda and associated jihadist organizations to train soldiers and terrorists, including camps used to train the September 11th hijackers;

(i)

actively recruiting new members for al Qaeda;

(j)

working throughout the world to spread al Qaeda’s jihadist ideology and draw new adherents to its cause;

(k)

serving as channels for distributing information and documentation within Islamic terrorist organizations and associated separatist movements, including al Qaeda, and from Islamic terrorist organizations and separatist movements to the media;

(l)

disseminating publications designed to advance al Qaeda’s Wahhabi Islamist ideology throughout the Muslim world and legitimize violent jihad against Christians and Jews on the grounds that they are “infidels” who do not deserve to live; and

(m)

openly advocating for young Muslims to take up arms against Western and democratic societies, including the United States.

The intimate collaborations between the Saudi government da’awa organizations

and al Qaeda are further reflected by actions, statements, and reports by the U.S. government pertaining to each in the years immediately before and after the September 11th attacks. 77.

For instance, following the September 11th attacks, the United States designated

the entire Al Haramain Islamic Foundation organization and its senior leadership pursuant to the Executive Order 13224 Specially Designated Global Terrorist program, explaining that Al Haramain was one of the principal organizations “providing support for the al Qaeda network and promoting militant Islamic doctrine worldwide.” See Averment ¶¶ 483-92, 503. 78.

The United States also designated Rabita Trust on October 12, 2001 “for its close

ties to senior al Qaida leadership and for providing logistical and financial support to al Qaida.” See id. ¶ 580.

As reflected in the designation, Rabita Trust’s director during the period

immediately before and through the 9/11 attacks was al Qaeda founding member Wa’el Jelaidan, 356

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 357 of 434

who was again serving in a position of authority in a Saudi government da’awa organization by appointment of the Saudi government. 79.

The U.S. designated several offices of the IIRO as well, along with a senior IIRO

official in Saudi Arabia (who in that capacity was an employee of the Saudi government), describing him as the “million dollar man’ for supporting Islamic extremists.” See id. ¶¶ 403-05. 80.

State Department cables further identify IIRO as “the principal sponsor of

terrorist training camps in Afghanistan during the Taliban regime” and indicate that “Usama bin Ladin used the entire IIRO network for his terrorist activities.” See id. ¶¶ 326, 330-32, 393-94. 81.

State Department cables similarly reveal that the U.S. embassy in Sarajevo

recommended that the SHC be designated pursuant to Executive Order 13224 based on its activities in support of al Qaeda, and that U.S. counter-terrorism officials included the SHC in a group of terrorist fronts they referred to as the “dirty dozen.” See Index of Evidence, Ex. 229. 82.

Department of Defense records likewise confirm the United States’ determination

that “WAMY is a Tier 1 Counterterrorism NGO target, defined as those that have demonstrated sustained and active support for terrorist organizations willing to attack U.S. persons or interests.” 83.

In a confidential communication to UN peacekeeping forces, the United States

identified SJRC as an organization that “move[s] money and men” for Osama bin Laden, and noted that SJRC’s director, Wa’el Jelaidan (once again, by appointment of the Saudi government), was an associate of Osama bin Laden. See Averment ¶¶ 551, 566. 84.

Plaintiffs’ Averment cites a range of additional U.S. actions, reports, and

statements concerning the al Qaeda support activities of MWL, IIRO, WAMY, BIF, Al Haramain, SHC, SRC, SJRC, Al Haramain al Masjed al Aqsa, and Rabita Trust. See id. ¶¶ 40,

357

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 358 of 434

316-31, 342, 364, 369, 381-83, 385-90, 392-95, 397-404, 426-38, 472-75, 483, 484, 486-92, 503, 503, 507, 509-18, 536-42, 555-58, 562, 564, 566, and 580. 85.

The material support provided by the Saudi da’awa organizations included aid

and operational assistance closely related to al Qaeda’s efforts to target the United States through large scale terrorist attacks, including the September 11th attacks themselves. 86.

For example, U.S. government reports indicate that IIRO and Al Haramain

Islamic Foundation funded the very terrorist camps where the 9/11 hijackers received their training. See id. ¶¶ 315, 330-31, 382, 393-94. 87.

An IIRO official interrogated by Indian officials in relation to a 1999 al Qaeda

plot to attack the U.S. diplomatic missions in Calcutta and Madras, Sayed Abu Naser, confirmed this funding program, telling his interrogators that he personally visited al Qaeda camps in Afghanistan on behalf of IIRO, to assess their funding needs. Naser estimated that as much as 50-60% of IIRO funds were channeled to terrorist training camps in Afghanistan and Kashmir. 88.

The findings of a partial audit conducted by a Pakistani affiliate of Ernst & Young

of funds distributed by IIRO’s Saudi headquarters through its office in Pakistan align with this estimate. See Index of Evidence, Ex. 166. 89.

Completed just months before the September 11th attacks and covering the period

between January 1996 through February 2001, the partial audit found that over half of the funds distributed through the office – totaling millions of dollars – could not be accounted for, and that senior officials of IIRO had engaged in the wholesale fabrication of invoices, receipts, and entire construction projects to conceal the illicit use of the funds. See id. 90.

According to Jamal al Fadl, a former al Qaeda official who became a cooperating

witness for the United States and testified at length in the African embassy bombing trials, IIRO

358

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 359 of 434

officials had been using fraudulent orphan distribution lists to conceal the funding of al Qaeda since at least the early 1990s. 91.

U.S. and foreign investigations also document the direct involvement of both

IIRO and Al Haramain Islamic Foundation in the planning, coordination, and execution of the 1998 al Qaeda bombings of the U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, as well as IIRO’s role in the aviation-related terrorist plot that was adapted and became the September 11th plot. See Averment ¶¶ 362, 419, 486, 502. 92.

In addition, the director of Al Haramain Islamic Foundation’s office in Belgium,

Tarek Maaroufi, was arrested in late 2001 by Belgian authorities and thereafter convicted for involvement in the assassination of anti-Taliban Northern Alliance commander Ahmed Shah Massoud. 93.

The assassination was a component of the 9/11 plot itself: Massoud was killed in

Afghanistan just two days before the September 11th attacks, as part of al Qaeda’s efforts to limit operational capabilities of the Northern Alliance to mount an offensive against al Qaeda in response to the attacks. Maaroufi, who was hired by Al Haramain following his release from prison for involvement in a terrorist grenade attack in Belgium, recruited the assassins and provided them with fake passports for the operation. 94.

A post-9/11 counter-terrorism raid of the Sarajevo office of the SHC, meanwhile,

uncovered a range of materials confirming the SHC’s direct involvement in the portfolio of plots al Qaeda was developing during that time period to attack the American homeland (of which the September 11th plot was a component), including photographs of the World Trade Center before and after its collapse, photographs of the United States embassies in Kenya and Tanzania and the U.S.S. Cole, files on deploying chemical agents with crop dusters, information about how to

359

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 360 of 434

make fake State Department badges, and photographs and maps of Washington marking prominent government buildings. See Averment ¶¶ 533-34. 95.

The subject matter of those materials recovered in the raid of the SHC’s offices,

within weeks of the September 11th attacks, mirrors several of the plots Zacarias Moussaoui testified that he was sent to the United States by al Qaeda to explore. ECF No. 2927-8 (describing plot to use crop dusting plane in terrorist attack on U.S. soil). 96.

Separately, convicted al Qaeda member and SHC employee Ali Ahmed al Hamad

affirmed in his testimony that al Qaeda members were broadly embedded in SHC offices, and were using SHC facilities to plot attacks against the West. See Averment ¶¶ 525-27. 97.

The SHC’s material sponsorship of al Qaeda also encompassed arms trafficking

on behalf of Osama bin Laden’s organization, and the laundering of millions of dollars for al Qaeda’s benefit, as reflected by U.N. and Bosnian investigations. See id. ¶¶ 530, 542. The SHC’s fundraising activities in support of al Qaeda included money laundering operations carried out in collaboration with Wa’el Jelaidan, Yassin Kadi and Chafiq Ayadi, all of whom were designated by the United States after the September 11th attacks pursuant to Executive Order 13224. 98.

More broadly, statements of U.S. officials and government reports demonstrate

how the expansive support provided by the Saudi government da’awa organizations enabled Osama bin Laden to build and sustain the al Qaeda organization, and acquire the resources and assets necessary to carry out the September 11th attacks. See id. ¶¶ 316-32. 99.

In this regard, the 9/11 Commission expressly found that the “9/11 attack was a

complex international operation, the product of years of planning.” See 9/11 Commission Final Report at p. 365.

360

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 361 of 434

100.

The 9/11 Commission’s Final Report further confirms that plans for the attacks

were carefully vetted through al Qaeda’s most senior leadership over a period of nearly six years, while those leaders were safely ensconced in training camps and safe houses funded by al Qaeda’s financial supporters; that the individuals selected to participate in the attacks were chosen from an enormous pool of potential candidates, all of whom were recruited, trained, and indoctrinated with funds provided by the organization’s supporters; and that details of the plans were revised up until the last minute, through a sophisticated global communication network capable of evading the surveillance and intelligence operations of the United States and its allies, the development and existence of which was also dependent on the financial sponsorship of al Qaeda’s supporters. See Averment ¶ 33. 101.

The cost of maintaining this essential infrastructure in the years immediately

leading up to the September 11th attacks was massive: al Qaeda’s budget included $20 million in payments to the Taliban alone, in exchange for the safe haven the Taliban provided to al Qaeda, from which al Qaeda planned, coordinated, and directed the September 11th attacks. 102.

Based on these and other findings of its investigation concerning the relationship

between al Qaeda’s global infrastructure and the organization’s operational capability to plan, coordinate, and mount the September 11th attacks, the 9/11 Commission reached the following conclusions regarding the basic organizational requirements for staging a sophisticated terrorist attack: A complex international terrorist operation aimed at launching a catastrophic attack cannot be mounted by just anyone in any place. Such operations appear to require •

time, space, and ability to perform competent planning and staff work;

•

a command structure able to make necessary decisions and possessing the authority and contacts to assemble needed people, money, and materials; 361

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 362 of 434

•

opportunity and space to recruit, train, and select operatives with the needed skills and dedication, providing the time and structure required to socialize them into the terrorist cause, judge their trustworthiness, and hone their skills;

•

a logistics network able to securely manage the travel of operatives, move money, and transport resources (like explosives) where they need to go;

•

access, in the case of certain weapons, to the special materials needed for a nuclear, chemical, radiological, or biological attack;

•

reliable communications operatives; and

•

opportunity to test the workability of the plan.

between

coordinators

and

See 9/11 Commission Final Report at pp. 365-66. 103.

U.S. counter-terrorism officials have expressed complete agreement with these

empirical conclusions, affirming consistently and repeatedly the critical importance of al Qaeda’s broader infrastructure and resources to its capacity to conceive, plan, coordinate, and successfully conduct sophisticated terrorist attacks, including the September 11th attacks themselves. See Averment ¶¶ 316-31. 104.

Plaintiffs’ facts and evidence establish that the Saudi government da’awa

organizations were principal providers of the funds and other resources used to build and sustain that infrastructure and acquire the organizational assets al Qaeda required to plan and carry out the attacks, thus drawing a direct and clear causal nexus between their contributions of support and the attacks. The Tortious Acts of the Kingdom’s Da’awa Organizations in Support of al Qaeda Are Attributable to Saudi Arabia 105.

The tortious acts of the Saudi da’awa organizations in support of al Qaeda are

attributable to the Kingdom on three separate grounds: (1) the da’awa organizations perform core functions of the Saudi state; (2) the da’awa organizations are agents of the Kingdom; and 362

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 363 of 434

(3) the Saudi government dominates and controls the da’awa organizations, making them alteregos of the Saudi government as well. 106.

Saudi Arabia’s Basic Law of Governance expressly provides that “[t]he State

shall … undertake its duty regarding the propagation of Islam (Da’wah),” thus confirming that the propagation of Wahhabi Islam globally is both a core function and duty of the Saudi government.

See Affirmation of Evan Francois Kohlmann ¶ 16, n. 2 (ECF No. 2927-9)

(“Kohlmann Affirmation”). 107.

Indeed, in a speech on the issuance on the Basic Law of Governance in 1992,

then-King Fahd bin Abdulaziz identified the nine bases for the foundation of the modern Saudi state, including “the undertaking of the Propagation of Islam (Dawah) and its dissemination, since the Propagation of Islam is one of the most important functions of an Islamic state.” See Kohlmann Affirmation ¶ 17. 108.

Reinforcing this point, a senior Saudi official has testified in this litigation that

da’awa activities have been a “core policy and function of the Kingdom since its founding.” See Declaration of Abdulaziz H. Al Fahad ¶ 8 (ECF No. 85-3). 109.

During the period from al Qaeda’s formation through the September 11th attacks,

MWL, IIRO, WAMY, BIF, Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, SHC, SRC, SJRC, Al Haramain al Masjed al Aqsa, and Rabita Trust served as the primary agents through which the Saudi government fulfilled this core function and duty to proselytize Wahhabi Islam globally. 110.

The legal characterizations several of the charities have assigned to themselves in

this litigation confirm their governmental character, and necessarily establish their status as agents of the Saudi government responsible for conducting the Saudi government’s da’awa activities abroad.

363

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 364 of 434

111.

In this regard, the SHC, MWL, IIRO, SJRC, and SRC each has asserted status as

a “foreign state” within the meaning of 28 U.S.C. § 1603, in filings submitted to the Court in this litigation. 112.

Because none of those entities issues stock, their claims to such status necessarily

rest on the assertion that they are “organs” of the Saudi government. 113.

By claiming organ status, the SHC, MWL, IIRO, SJRC, and SRC have

themselves affirmed that they were created to fulfill a state obligation or purpose, and operate under the supervision of the state. See, e.g., Filler v. Hanvit Bank, 378 F.3d 213, 217 (2d Cir. 2004) (describing characteristics of “organ”). 114.

Consistent with these and other facts and evidence of record, the da’awa

organizations are agents of the Saudi government, engaged in the performance of core functions and duties of the Kingdom. 115.

Further on this point, plaintiffs’ expert Evan Kohlmann has offered testimony

concerning the architecture of the government apparatus established and operated by the Saudi government to fulfill its obligation to spread Wahhabi doctrine and practice globally, and the roles of the da’awa organizations within that government framework.

See Kohlmann

Affirmation, incorporated herein by reference. 116.

As reflected by the Kohlmann Affirmation and related evidence, the Kingdom’s

government proselytizing apparatus is comprised of three principal components: the Supreme Council for Islamic Affairs; the Ministry of Islamic Affairs; and the individual da’awa organizations themselves (MWL, IIRO, WAMY, Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, SHC, SRC, SJRC, Al Haramain al Masjed al Aqsa, and Rabita Trust). See Kohlmann Affirmation ¶ 20. 117.

As Saudi officials quoted in the Kohlmann Affirmation have explained, the

Supreme Council for Islamic Affairs is the “planning body” responsible for “the Islamic work by

364

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 365 of 434

the Kingdom abroad,” a function that includes coordinating “Saudi activities undertaken by the Islamic [da’awa] organizations.” See id. ¶ 21. 118.

The Ministry of Islamic Affairs is, in turn, an operational body that implements

the Supreme Council’s decisions, including through its funding, supervision, and direction of the individual da’awa organizations. See ECF No. 2927-16; Averment ¶¶ 115-16. 119.

The da’awa organizations undertake their Wahhabi proselytizing work pursuant to

the policies established by the Saudi government, with funding provided by the government, under the supervision of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and local embassies and consulates, subject to the approvals of the Saudi government (including the Supreme Council of Islamic Affairs and Ministry of Islamic Affairs), and under the leadership of the “government officials who head those organizations.” See ECF No. 85-3 (Declaration of Abdulaziz H. Al Fahad) at ¶ 11; Averment ¶¶ 117-18. 120.

Consistent with this framework described in the Kohlmann Affirmation, the

Kingdom regularly cites the activities of the da’awa organizations as achievements of the state itself, and employees of those organizations have in various settings confirmed that their activities are supervised by the Saudi government, undertaken pursuant to policies set by the Kingdom, and overwhelmingly funded by the Saudi government. See Kohlmann Affirmation ¶ 24. 121.

For example, Al Haramain Islamic Foundation submitted an affidavit in this

litigation attesting that “al Haramain operates under the supervision of the Saudi Islamic Affairs, who appoints its Board of Directors and senior management personnel,” and a senior Al Haramain official elsewhere has stated that “we work under the supervision of Saudi government.” See Averment ¶ 47. That same official confirmed that 95% of Al Haramain’s funding comes from Saudi Arabia. See id.

365

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 366 of 434

122.

Arafat El Asahi, the Director of IIRO in Canada and a full-time employee of the

MWL, similarly testified as follows during a Canadian court proceeding: Let me tell you one thing, the Muslim World League, which is the mother of IIRO, is a fully government funded organization. In other words, I work for the government of Saudi Arabia. I am an employee of that government. Second, the IIRO is the relief branch of that organization which means that we are controlled in all of our activities and plans by the government of Saudi Arabia. Keep that in mind, please … I am paid by my organization which is funded by the [Saudi] government . . . The [IIRO] office, like any other office in the world, here or in the Muslim World League, has to abide by the policy of the Government of Saudi Arabia. If anybody deviates from that, he would be fired; he would not work at all with IIRO or with the Muslim World League. See Averment ¶ 340. 123.

Consistent with Asahi’s testimony, MWL Secretary General Abdullah Mohsen al

Turki confirmed in November of 2000 that the Saudi government provides “over 90%” of MWL’s budget. 124.

Dr. Mutlib bin Abdullah Al Nafissa, Minister of State of the Council of Ministers

of Saudi Arabia, has testified that the SHC “is an arm of the Saudi Arabian government. Actions taken by the SHC properly are viewed as actions of the Government of Saudi Arabia.” See Averment ¶ 521; ECF Nos. 141-5, 262-5 (Declaration of Dr. Mutlib Bin Abdullah Al Nafissa) at ¶ 3. SHC official Saud bin Mohammad Al Roshood has separately attested that “[t]he largest source of funding for the Saudi High Commission is the treasury of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.” See ECF No. 262-3 (Declaration of Saud Bin Mohammad Al Roshood) at ¶ 24. 125.

Mutaz Saleh Abu Unuq, Financial Director of WAMY, has similarly confirmed in

affidavit testimony that “WAMY is governed principally by its General Assembly and President who was appointed by the Saudi Government. The current President of WAMY is the Minister of Islamic Affairs in Saudi Arabia.” See Averment ¶ 441. Officials of WAMY have also confirmed in correspondence that WAMY is subordinate to the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and 366

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 367 of 434

supervised by the Ministry of Islamic Affairs.

Senior WAMY officials have elsewhere

confirmed that WAMY’s primary source of funding comes from the Saudi government’s annual budget. 126.

Abdulrahman al Swailem, President of SRC, has testified that the Government of

the Kingdom “sponsors and supervises the Saudi Arabian Red Crescent Society, and the Saudi Government appoints all of its directors.” See Averment ¶ 545; ECF No. 96-2 (Declaration of Abdul Rahman Al Swailem) at ¶ 9. 127.

Swailem further attested that SJRC has “always functioned as a political

subdivision, agency, or instrumentality of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia,” was “supervised by the Minister of Interior of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia,” and that “SJRC’s mission was largely subsidized by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.” See Averment ¶ 560; ECF No. 631-3 (Declaration of Dr. Abdulrahman A. Al-Suwailem) at ¶¶ 2, 7, 11. 128.

These and other facts demonstrating that the da’awa organizations are the

principal instruments through which the Saudi government fulfills its state duty to propagate Wahhabi Islam, are funded by the government and headed by government officials, and act in accordance with policies set by the government and under the supervision of the government, readily establish that they are agents of the Saudi government engaged in the performance of core functions and duties of the Kingdom. 129.

The facts and evidence of record also demonstrate that the Saudi government

rigidly controlled the operations of the da’awa organizations, a showing that both further confirms that they are agents of the Kingdom, and establishes that their conduct is attributable to the Kingdom on the separate legal basis that they also are controlled alter-egos of the Saudi government.

367

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 368 of 434

130.

The Kohlmann Affirmation surveyed facts and evidence reflecting this control,

separately as to the individual da’awa organizations, accumulated without the benefit of an opportunity to conduct discovery of the Kingdom concerning its relationship with the charities (which plaintiffs request). See Kohlmann Affirmation ¶¶ 26-129. 131.

As reflected by the facts presented in the Kohlmann Affirmation and in other

sources, including the limited materials produced by a handful of the da’awa organizations in discovery, the Kingdom’s complete domination of the da’awa organizations is manifested through a broad range of legal, financial, policy, supervisory, administrative, and operational controls, applied in substantially the same manner as to each of the entities, as evidenced by the following: (a)

The da’awa organizations are established by royal decree, issued by the King of Saudi Arabia and with the formal approval of high-ranking officials of the Saudi government.

(b)

The da’awa organizations are funded almost entirely by the government of Saudi Arabia.

(c)

Funds are allocated to the da’awa organizations via government grants authorized by the Special Committee of the Council of Ministers, which are paid from Saudi government bank accounts with government funds.

(d)

The government of Saudi Arabia appoints the senior officials of the da’awa organizations.

(e)

Leadership positions of the da’awa organizations are dominated by highranking officials of the Saudi government, who typically hold other senior posts in the Saudi government. For example, Dr. Maneh el Johani simultaneously served as both the Secretary General of WAMY and a member of the Kingdom’s Shura Council. Additionally, Saleh bin Abdul Aziz al Sheikh, while serving as the Minister of Islamic Affairs, also served as a chairman of WAMY and Al Haramain Islamic Foundation. The Secretary General of MWL holds a position equivalent to that of a “Minister” in the Saudi government. As the director of the SRC, Abdul Rahman al Swailem held a position at an “Excellency level” per the appointment by the Saudi King.

368

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 369 of 434

(f)

The da’awa organizations report to senior Saudi officials, including in certain cases the King, concerning their operations and activities outside of Saudi Arabia.

(g)

The da’awa organizations submit resolutions prepared by their governing bodies to the Saudi government’s Council of Ministers for approval.

(h)

The da’awa organizations operate under significant administrative guidance and regulation from senior members of the Saudi government. Indeed, the activities and projects undertaken by the da’awa organizations, including the collection and transferring of funds, are approved at the highest levels of the Saudi government.

(i)

The da’awa organizations seek approval from the Ministry of Islamic Affairs for the annual operating budgets of projects managed by the da’awa organizations.

(j)

Policy making bodies of the Saudi government commonly direct the da’awa organizations concerning the projects and activities they are to conduct abroad, and determines which of the da’awa organizations will conduct those activities.

(k)

The provision of aid by the da’awa organizations is subject to the approval of senior Saudi officials, including in certain instances the Saudi Foreign Minister and Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

(l)

Senior officials of the Saudi government, including from within the Special Ministers Council, are embedded in the governing bodies of the da’awa organizations.

(m)

The Supreme Council for Islamic Affairs issues guidelines concerning relief activities to be undertaken by the da’awa organizations outside of Saudi Arabia.

(n)

The Ministry of Islamic Affairs has primary responsibility for supervising and directing the operations and activities of the da’awa organizations in the Kingdom and abroad. The Minister of Islamic Affairs appoints individuals to the organizations’ board of directors, committees, and senior management.

(o)

The Minister of Islamic Affairs has confirmed that the da’awa organizations’ activities are based on the institutional principles of the Kingdom, and that the Kingdom provides clear work plans which the da’awa organizations must follow.

(p)

Meetings of senior leaders of the da’awa organizations are in certain cases conducted at the government offices of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs. 369

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 370 of 434

(q)

The operations of the da’awa organizations’ overseas branch offices are directed and closely supervised by the local Saudi embassies in the region, under the supervision of the embassy’s Islamic Affairs Division.

(r)

Operations of the da’awa organizations outside of Saudi Arabia are commonly carried out under the direction of a joint committee consisting of representatives of the da’awa organizations and Saudi embassy personnel.

(s)

Saudi officials serving within the Islamic Affairs Departments of the Saudi embassies and consulates abroad simultaneously hold positions in the committees of the local branch offices of the da’awa organizations.

(t)

Employees of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs have worked for the da’awa organizations, while being paid by the Ministry of Islamic Affairs.

(u)

Internal correspondence of the da’awa organizations confirms that aid distributed by the da’awa organizations abroad is monitored by the Saudi embassies and the committees of the overseas offices, which include representatives of the embassies;

(v)

The da’awa organizations have indicated that the operations abroad are undertaken on behalf of the Saudi government and local Saudi embassy in those countries.

(w)

The Kingdom commonly requests that host countries grant the da’awa organizations diplomatic status, and issues diplomatic passports to employees of those offices.

(x)

Employees of the da’awa organizations have confirmed that the organizations operate as government arms, and that they themselves are Saudi government employees in their roles working for the da’awa organizations.

(y)

The branch offices of the da’awa organizations are subject to the direction of the local Saudi embassies on projects undertaken by those offices, as reflected by a 1996 directive from the IIRO’s Director of the Overseas Offices Administration reminding “all managers of the IIRO overseas offices, its representatives and delegates” of “the duty to cooperate and coordinate with the brothers in charge in the host country,” including the representative of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs office within the Saudi embassy and other government officials.

(z)

Branch offices of the da’awa organizations have been opened under the auspices of the local representative of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, pending establishment of a local office.

370

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 371 of 434

(aa)

Internal correspondence of the IIRO indicated that the opening of offices of the da’awa organizations is subject to the approval of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

(bb)

Officials of the Saudi embassies abroad initiated the opening of offices of the da’awa organizations.

(cc)

The da’awa organization seek approval from the Ministry of Islamic Affairs to establish delegations to visit foreign countries.

(dd)

The Saudi government often purchases or leases buildings to house the operations of the da’awa organizations, as for example was the case with MWL’s headquarters in the Kingdom, which was donated by the King, and WAMY’s office in Washington, D.C., the purchase of which was coordinated by the Under Secretary of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, and handled by the local embassy.

(ee)

Representatives of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs directly intervened in personnel decisions of the da’awa organizations at every level, such as the appointment of Abdullah bin Laden to serve as WAMY’s representative in the United States.

(ff)

Saudi diplomats have held signatory authority over bank accounts of the da’awa organizations.

(gg)

The Saudi government has issued diplomatic license plates for vehicles of the da’awa organizations abroad.

(hh)

Funds transferred from the organization’s headquarters in Saudi Arabia to the overseas branch offices cannot be used for anything other than the objectives for which they are allocated.

(ii)

The senior Saudi officials who head the da’awa organizations retain stringent administrative and financial control over the daily operations of the various branch offices and affiliates around the world.

(jj)

The senior Saudi officials who head the da’awa organizations have the authority to appoint and terminate employees in the overseas branch offices.

(kk)

Per the directives of the senior Saudi officials who head the da’awa organizations, the overseas branch offices are incapable of independent action. All significant administrative or financial decisions or undertakings by the overseas offices, even relatively minor decisions, are reviewed and approved at the highest levels of the organization inside the Kingdom, by the offices of the senior Saudi officials who head those organizations. 371

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 372 of 434

(ll)

The overseas branch offices are required to submit quarterly and annual operations and financial reports to the senior Saudi officials who head the da’awa organizations.

(mm) The overseas branch offices are required to send copies of their monthly bank statements to the senior Saudi officials who head the da’awa organizations for review.

132.

(nn)

The overseas branch offices are required to send monthly expense reports to the senior Saudi officials who head the da’awa organizations.

(oo)

Requests for financial aid submitted to the overseas branch offices must be sent to the senior Saudi officials who head the da’awa organizations for review.

(pp)

The overseas branch offices are forbidden from opening any bank account, or withdrawing any office funds or capital, without prior written consent of the senior Saudi officials who head the da’awa organizations.

(qq)

The overseas branch offices are forbidden from spending their own independently raised donations on projects or other activities without authorization from the senior Saudi officials who head the da’awa organizations.

As reflected by the foregoing facts, the Saudi government thoroughly dominates

the da’awa organizations and controls their day-to-day operations.3 133.

The tortious acts of the da’awa organizations in support of al Qaeda were, in turn,

undertaken in furtherance of their core mission to spread Wahhabi doctrine and practice, and therefore within the scope of their agency as the Saudi government’s principal instruments for spreading Wahhabism globally. See infra pp. 63-65; Averment ¶¶ 115-129.

VI.

TORTIOUS ACTS OF SAUDI GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS AND EMPLOYEES WHO DIRECTED AND CONTROLLED THE KINGDOM’S DA’AWA ORGANIZATIONS

3

At a minimum, these facts demonstrate how an opportunity to conduct discovery of the Kingdom concerning its relationships with the various da’awa organizations is reasonably calculated to adduce further evidence establishing that the charities are agents and controlled alter-egos of the government.

372

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 373 of 434

134.

As discussed above and further detailed in plaintiffs’ Averment, the Saudi

government’s proselytizing organizations extensively aided and abetted al Qaeda’s targeting of the United States, and provided funding and other assistance closely related and essential to the September 11th attacks. 135.

Apart from the fact that the tortious acts of those organizations are attributable to

the Saudi state, the tortious acts of the Saudi officials who directed those organizations’ support of al Qaeda, many of whom held broader roles in the Saudi government beyond their positions with the da’awa organizations, also are attributable to the Kingdom for purposes of both jurisdiction and liability. 136.

The facts and evidence documenting the terrorist activities of these so-called

charities reflect broad institutional partnerships between those organizations and al Qaeda, confirming the involvement of those government officials in directing and facilitating their support for al Qaeda, as indicated by: (a)

The direct involvement of government officials who headed the da’awa organizations in the formation of al Qaeda;

(b)

the sheer magnitude of the financial and other forms of material support they provided to Osama bin Laden’s organization;

(c)

the systematic placement of al Qaeda members and collaborators in positions of authority within the da’awa organizations;

(d)

the intimacy of their collaboration in al Qaeda’s operations, as documented in government investigations;

(e)

the evidence showing that offices of the charities throughout the world were simultaneously all acting in identical ways to advance al Qaeda’s terrorist agenda;

(f)

the duration of their support for al Qaeda, spanning in most cases more than a decade;

(g)

the fact that their support for al Qaeda continued without interruption even after offices and employees of those organizations were repeatedly and publicly implicated in terrorist activities; and 373

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 374 of 434

(h) 137.

their ideological alignment with al Qaeda’s jihadist agenda, as reflected in their own publications, statements, and speeches.

As also detailed above, the individuals who headed these proselytizing

organizations throughout the duration of their institutional partnerships with al Qaeda were Saudi government officials and employees. 138.

Individuals who controlled and worked in the branch offices of those

organizations that were directly involved in al Qaeda’s operations were Saudi government employees as well, as reflected by the issuance of diplomatic passports to employees of those offices, the appointment of embassy personnel from the Ministry of Islamic Affairs to the operating committees and leadership positions of those offices, and the statements of numerous employees of those da’awa organizations describing themselves as employees of the Saudi government. 139.

The material sponsorship of al Qaeda by these da’awa organizations under the

direction of these Saudi government officials and employees was in furtherance of their core mission to spread Wahhabi influence throughout the world, and the tortious acts of the government officials who directed and participated in those organizations’ support for al Qaeda thus fall squarely within the scope of their office and employment.

See infra pp. 63-65;

Averment ¶¶ 115-129. VII.

TORTIOUS ACTS OF THE MINISTRY OF ISLAMIC AFFAIRS AND EMPLOYEES AND OFFICIALS OF THE MINISTRY OF ISLAMIC AFFAIRS 140.

Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs was broadly involved in the promotion

of al Qaeda’s terrorist activities during the period leading up to the September 11th attacks. 141.

The Ministry of Islamic Affairs has been described as a “stronghold of zealots”

during the period before 9/11, and 9/11 Commissioner John Lehman has testified that it was “well known in intelligence circles that the Islamic Affairs Departments of Saudi Arabia’s diplomatic missions were deeply involved in supporting Islamic extremists.” 374

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 375 of 434

142.

The Ministry of Islamic Affairs assumed control over the Kingdom’s global

da’awa apparatus following the Ministry’s formation in 1993. 143.

In the ensuing years, and under the Ministry of Islamic Affairs’ direction and

supervision, the Kingdom’s da’awa organizations pervasively channeled resources provided to them by the Ministry to al Qaeda, and collaborated intimately with bin Laden’s terrorist organization. 144.

Employees of the Ministry used additional resources and institutions under their

control to launder funds for al Qaeda as well, including from within the United States. 145.

For example, in or around 1998, the FBI became aware of millions of dollars in

transfers from the Somali community in San Diego to fronts associated with Osama bin Laden. The FBI’s further investigations indicated that “some of the funding originated from Saudi Arabia” and that the funds were laundered through mosques and Islamic centers under the control and influence of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs. 146.

Representatives of the Islamic Affairs offices of the Kingdom’s embassies and

consulates also provided large cash transfers to al Qaeda.

In this regard, U.S. Defense

intelligence investigations determined that Saudi embassies in the Far East were providing large sums of cash, including individual transfers totaling several hundred thousand dollars, to the al Qaeda affiliated Umm al-Qura Islamic Foundation, an organization whose “activities in support of terrorism include suspicious money transfers, document forgery, providing jobs to wanted terrorist suspects, and financing travel for youths to attend jihad training.” See CJI at p. 435. 147.

In addition, documents recovered from the personal files of Taliban leader Mullah

Omar following the September 11th attacks indicate that on November 21, 1999, Omar instructed the Afghan Ambassador in Pakistan to distribute “$2 million from Saudi aids” to Jon Juma

375

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 376 of 434

Namangani, a close associate of Osama bin Laden who was then serving as al Qaeda’s commander in Uzbekistan. 148.

The Ministry of Islamic Affairs’ broad collaboration with al Qaeda before 9/11 is

further reflected by the evidence implicating at least seven employees and agents of the Ministry in providing support to the 9/11 hijackers and plotters, and the fact that employees of the Ministry have been implicated in separate terrorist activities in the Netherlands, Germany, Paris, Brussels, and elsewhere. 149.

In addition, Zacarias Moussaoui has testified that Osama bin Laden maintained

strong relationships with the clerics who controlled the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and related components of the Kingdom’s government proselytizing and Wahhabi religious apparatus. Based on his personal knowledge, Moussaoui stated that bin Laden’s attitude toward the Saudi Ulema “was of complete reverence and obedience;” bin Laden’s activities were conducted with the “consent and directive of the Ulema;” bin Laden would not undertake any operations without the Ulema’s approval; and representatives of the senior Ulema regularly traveled to Afghanistan to visit with bin Laden. 150.

Saudi government imams were deeply involved in recruitment and fundraising for

al Qaeda, as reflected in records from the detainee tribunal proceedings at Guantanamo Bay and prominent academic studies. 151.

Indeed, Saudi government clerics recruited certain of the 9/11 hijackers, as

confirmed by the 9/11 Commission’s investigation. 152.

In the wake of the September 11th attacks, the United States took action to address

the extremist activities of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs through its offices in the United States, removing between 60-70 individuals associated with the Islamic Affairs and religious offices of

376

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 377 of 434

the Kingdom’s embassies and consulates in what a State Department official described as part of “an ongoing effort to protect the homeland.” 153.

In addition, following al Qaeda’s 2003 attacks in Saudi Arabia, the Kingdom

itself removed thousands of clerics from the payroll of the Ministry, and has characterized those removals as part of a counter-terrorism effort, thus drawing a direct connection between the Ministry and terrorism in earlier periods. 154.

The nature and extent of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs’ support for al Qaeda and

other terrorists demonstrate that collaborating with jihadists was within the scope of the activities of the Ministry and its employees, in furtherance of the Ministry’s efforts to export Wahhabi doctrine and practice. VIII. ATTRIBUTABLE TORTIOUS ACTS OF INDIVIDUAL EMPLOYEES AND AGENTS OF THE SAUDI GOVERNMENT IN SUPPORT OF THE 9/11 HIJACKERS AND PLOTTERS 155.

On July 15, 2016, the United States released a partially declassified version of

Part Four of the 2002 Report of the Congressional Joint Inquiry into the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001, commonly described in media reports as the so-called “28 pages.” 156.

Thereafter, in December of 2016, the FBI and DOJ released a declassified version

of a 2012 FBI/DOJ “Summary Report” describing the status and principal findings of ongoing investigations into sources of support for the 9/11 hijackers, in response to a Freedom of Information Act lawsuit. 157.

These documents offer additional facts and evidence in support of plaintiffs’

claims that employees and agents of the Saudi government, while engaged in performing functions on behalf of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Saudi proselytizing apparatus, directly aided and assisted the 9/11 hijackers and plotters.

377

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 378 of 434

158.

Among other factors, these newly released documents further corroborate and

provide further evidence in support of the following facts: (a)

the Saudi government maintained a network of agents in the United States in the years preceding the 9/11 attacks, whose undisclosed functions involved performing activities on behalf of and at the direction of the Wahhabi clerics who populated the Islamic Affairs Offices of the Kingdom’s embassies and consulates in the United States (CJI at pp. 41537);

(b)

members of that network maintained extensive contacts and supportive dealings with members of al Qaeda and related terrorist organizations (CJI at pp. 420-21, 428-29, 430-37);

(c)

Saudi government employees and agents who were members of that network directly aided the 9/11 hijackers at the direction of more senior Saudi officials (CJI at pp. 416-28, 430-31, 433-34) (SR at pp. 2-4);

(d)

the FBI has confirmed that Saudi government employees Omar al Bayoumi and Fahad al Thumairy provided “substantial assistance” to 9/11 hijackers Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Mihdhar (SR at p. 3);

(e)

Thumairy and Bayoumi substantially assisted the 9/11 hijackers by, among other things, providing “(or direct[ing] others to provide) the hijackers with assistance in daily activities, including procuring living quarters, financial assistance, and assistance in obtaining flight lessons and driver’s licenses” (SR at p. 4);

(f)

Thumairy, an extremist Wahhabi cleric who held diplomatic credentials with the Saudi consulate in Los Angeles and was denied re-entry into the United States by the State Department in 2003 based on his ties to terrorism, “immediately assigned an individual to take care of them [al Hazmi and al Mihdhar]” upon their arrival in the United States (SR at p. 4);

(g)

Bayoumi, one of the Kingdom’s employees and agents in the United States performing undisclosed functions on behalf of the Kingdom’s embassies and consulates and reporting to Thumairy, simultaneously maintained both extensive ties to terrorists and to Islamic Affairs representatives employed in the Kingdom’s embassies and consulates in the United States and elsewhere;

(h)

Bayoumi proffered a letter from the Saudi embassy representing that he would be studying in the United States pursuant to “a full scholarship from the Saudi government” but in fact was “living in San Diego [at the time he assisted the hijackers] on a student visa despite not taking classes and 378

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 379 of 434

receiving a salary from the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for job duties he never performed” (CJI at p. 423; SR at p. 4);

159.

(i)

the continuing FBI and DOJ joint criminal investigation “seeks to prove these subjects [referring to Thumairy, Bayoumi and a third individual whose name is redacted but is identified as having “tasked al-Thumairy and al-Bayoumi with assisting the hijackers”] provided such assistance with the knowledge that al-Hazmi and al-Mihdhar were here to commit an act of terrorism” (SR at p. 4);

(j)

another member of the Kingdom’s network of agents in the United States whose “profile is similar to that of al-Bayoumi,” Mohammed alQudhaeein, participated along with an al Qaeda member named Hamdan al-Shalawi, who “had trained at the terrorist training camps in Afghanistan,” in a dry run for the 9/11 attacks during a 1999 flight from Phoenix to Washington, D.C. “to attend a party at the Saudi embassy” (CJI at pp. 419, 433-34);

(k)

during that 1999 flight, al-Qudhaeein “went to the front of the plane and attempted on two occasions to enter the cockpit,” and the FBI “believes both men [whose airline tickets were paid for by the Saudi Embassy] were specifically attempting to test the security procedures of America West Airlines in preparation for and in furtherance of UBL/Al Qaeda operations” (CJI at pp. 419, 433-34);

(l)

the Congressional 9/11 Joint Inquiry documented numerous other contacts, dealings, and transactions between individuals employed or associated with the Saudi government and known terrorists and extremists, reflecting a broad presence of al Qaeda supporters within Saudi government institutions in the years leading up to 9/11 (CJI at pp. 415-37); and

(m)

the former head of the CIA’s unit established in 1996 to “focus specifically on Usama bin Laden” told U.S. investigators that “it was clear from about 1996 that the Saudi Government would not cooperate with the United States on matters relating to Usama bin Laden,” explaining that “Saudi assistance to the U.S. Government on this matter was contrary to Saudi national interests” (CJI at p. 438).

The additional details and findings presented in these documents and summarized

above reinforce and augment a far broader range of facts and evidence that Saudi government employees and agents associated with the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs directly aided the September 11th hijackers and plotters, from within the United States and elsewhere, as surveyed below. 379

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 380 of 434

9/11 Hijackers Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Mihdhar 160.

Al Qaeda members and future 9/11 hijackers Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al

Mihdhar arrived in Los Angeles on January 15, 2000, to commence critical U.S.-based preparations for the September 11th attacks. 161.

As the 9/11 Commission confirmed in its Final Report, Hazmi and Mihdhar were

“ill prepared for a mission in the United States. Their only qualifications for this plot were their devotion to Usama bin Laden, their veteran service, and their ability to get valid U.S. visas. Neither had spent any substantial time in the West, and neither spoke much, if any, English.” See 9/11 Commission Final Report at p. 215. 162.

For those and other reasons, the 9/11 Commission correctly concluded that it was

“unlikely that Hazmi and Mihdhar … would have come to the United States without arranging to receive assistance from one or more individuals informed in advance of their arrival.” See id. 163.

Consistent with the 9/11 Commission’s conclusion on this point, the facts and

evidence confirm that several individuals with extensive ties to terrorism immediately mobilized to provide the precise forms of assistance Hazmi and Mihdhar most needed to assimilate into the United States without detection and initiate essential preparations for the attacks. 164.

Those individuals were employees and agents of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia,

whose duties involved the performance of functions in furtherance of the extremist agenda of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs, including in particular Fahad al Thumairy, Omar al Bayoumi, and Osama Bassnan. Substantial Assistance Provided by Thumairy, Bayoumi, and Bassnan 165.

Witnesses interviewed by the FBI after 9/11 placed Hazmi and Mihdhar at the

Saudi government-funded King Fahd Mosque near Los Angeles in the days immediately after

380

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 381 of 434

their arrival in the United States. At the time, Thumairy was the resident imam at the mosque, by appointment of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs. 166.

Thumairy was an extremist Wahhabi cleric employed by the Islamic Affairs

Department of the Saudi consulate in Los Angeles, where he held diplomatic credentials, also by appointment of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs. 167.

As reflected in the 9/11 Commission’s Final Report, Thumairy led a particularly

radical faction within the local Muslim community, including persons “supportive of the events of September 11, 2001,” and “had a network of contacts in other cities in the United States.” See 9/11 Commission Final Report at pp. 216-17. 168.

As also detailed in the 9/11 Commission Final Report, the State Department

banned Thumairy from re-entering the United States in 2003, based on his apparent ties to terrorism. See id. at p. 217. 169.

Thumairy was squarely at the center of orchestrating the U.S.-based support

network for the hijackers upon their arrival in the United States, as reflected by the 2012 Summary Report’s finding that “Al-Thumairy immediately assigned an individual to take care of them [Hazmi and Mihdhar] during their time in the Los Angeles area.” See SR at p. 4; see also 9/11 Commission Final Report at p. 217 (“The circumstantial evidence makes Thumairy a logical person to consider as a possible point of contact for Hazmi and Mihdhar”); October 25, 2002 FBI Report, Fahad Althumairy (NON-USPER), IT-OTHER (UBL/AL-QAEDA) (detailing evidence that Thumairy tasked a member of the King Fahd Mosque named Benomrane to assist the hijackers and “that he [Benomrane] was told by Sheik Fahad Althumairy to keep the presence of the two Saudis to himself.”).

381

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 382 of 434

170.

Just two weeks after the hijackers’ arrival in the United States, Thumairy met for

an hour in his office at the Saudi consulate with Bayoumi, a Saudi national who was residing in San Diego. 171.

At the time, Bayoumi was one of several employees and agents of the Saudi

government in the United States, whose undisclosed duties involved the advancement of the agenda of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, under the direction of Thumairy and other more senior representatives of the Ministry’s offices in the United States. 172.

Immediately following that meeting, Bayoumi traveled to a restaurant located in

the Los Angeles area, where he met with Hazmi and Mihdhar and promptly offered to assist the future hijackers settle in San Diego, the precise city al Qaeda leadership had identified as the preferred location for the hijackers to carry out their preparations for the attacks. 173.

Following that meeting, Bayoumi did in fact provide critical assistance to the

hijackers, including by helping them find an apartment in San Diego, co-signing the lease for that apartment as a guarantor, opening a bank account for the hijackers with $9000 from his own account, and paying their rent on occasion. 174.

In addition, Bayoumi took steps to ensure that the hijackers received essential

assistance from other members of the San Diego Muslim community who shared the hijackers’ extremist views, including Anwar al Aulaqi (a/k/a Anwar al Awlaki) and Mohdar Abdullah. 175.

In this regard, U.S. investigations have confirmed that Hazmi and Mihdhar

arrived in San Diego on February 4, 2000, and that Bayoumi spent the day with the hijackers undertaking extraordinary efforts to facilitate their settlement in the area. 176.

On that same day, four telephone calls were placed from Bayoumi’s cell phone to

Aulaqi, who would later flee the United States and assume a leadership position in al Qaeda, prompting the United States to target and kill him in a drone attack on September 30, 2011.

382

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 383 of 434

177.

Investigators have determined that additional calls from Bayoumi’s cell phone to

Aulaqi were placed on February 10, 16, and 18, and that Bayoumi and Aulaqi were in telephone contact another five times between November of 1998 and April of 2000, and again on December 8, 2000. 178.

In an interview with 9/11 Commission staff members, Bayoumi admitted to

having a relationship with Aulaqi, describing him as someone “with whom he discussed religious matters and ideas similar to those he would discuss with other imams.” 179.

Aulaqi, who was covertly acting as a senior recruiter for al Qaeda and affiliated

terrorist organizations and advocating jihad against the United States, had spent nearly five years as the imam of the Al Ribat Al Islami Mosque (or “Rabat”) in La Mesa, CA, northeast of San Diego.

Aulaqi had a following of approximately 200-300 people and would become an

important religious leader to Hazmi and Mihdhar. 180.

FBI sources reported that “Aulaqi met consistently and privately with Alhazmi

and Almidhdir for prayers,” and a witness interviewed by the FBI specifically recounted seeing Hazmi and Mihdhar in the guest room on the second floor of the mosque and, on one occasion, leaving the room just after Aulaqi, at the conclusion of a meeting. Other witnesses “informed the FBI after September 11 that [Aulaqi] had closed-door meetings in San Diego with al-Mihdhar, al-Hazmi, and another individual, whom al-Bayoumi had asked to help the hijackers.” 181.

Aulaqi eventually left San Diego in mid-2000, and by January 2001 had relocated

to Virginia where he took a position at the Dar al Hijra Mosque in Falls Church, VA. The Department of Treasury’s Enforcement Communications System’s (“TECS”) records state that Dar al Hijra “is a mosque operating as a front for Hamas operatives in U.S.,” “is associated with Islamic extremists,” “has been under numerous investigations for financing and providing aid

383

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 384 of 434

and comfort to bad orgs and members,” and has “been linked to numerous individuals linked to terrorism funding.” 182.

Hazmi and 9/11 hijacker Hani Hanjour arrived in Virginia in April 2001 to begin

critical last-phase preparations for the attacks, and immediately sought out Aulaqi at Dar al Hijra. Upon their arrival, Aulaqi tasked a Jordanian named Eyad al Rababah to assist the hijackers get settled and find an apartment. They eventually moved into Rababah’s friend’s apartment in Alexandria, VA. On May 8, 2001, Rababah went back to the apartment to pick up Hazmi and Hanjour for a trip to Connecticut, and found they had new roommates – muscle hijackers Ahmed al Ghamdi (United Airlines Flight 175) and Majed Moqed (American Airlines Flight 77). 183.

Following the September 11th attacks, Aulaqi submitted to four FBI interviews

between September 15 and 19, 2001. Although Aulaqi admitted meeting with Hazmi several times, he claimed not to remember any specifics of what they discussed. Aulaqi told the FBI that he did not recognize Mihdhar, but did admit to knowing fellow 9/11 hijacker Hani Hanjour. According to the FBI, information in their possession at the time of the interviews suggested “a more pervasive connection” between Aulaqi and the 9/11 hijackers than he was willing to admit. 184.

These contacts and circumstances, coupled with Aulaqi’s pervasive connections

to terrorism (Averment ¶¶ 210-12), have led investigators, including Senator Bob Graham, the Co-Chair of the 9/11 Congressional Joint Inquiry, to conclude that Aulaqi served as Hazmi’s and Mihdhar’s spiritual leader during the year preceding the September 11th attacks, and that he was a trusted confidant of the hijackers who was fully aware of the planned 9/11 attacks. 185.

Bayoumi also introduced Hazmi and Mihdhar to Mohdhar Mohamed Abdullah

(a/k/a “Mihdar Mohammad al Mihdar Zaid”), and directed Abdullah to assist the two hijackers. 186.

Abdullah was a member of Aulaqi’s mosque over whom both Bayoumi and

Aulaqi exercised influence.

384

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 385 of 434

187.

According to the 9/11 Commission, Abdullah was “perfectly suited to assist the

hijackers in pursuing their mission” as he “clearly was sympathetic to [their] extremist views” and shared their “hatred for the U.S. government.” See 9/11 Commission Final Report at p. 218. 188.

In a post-9/11 interview with law enforcement, Abdullah claimed that Bayoumi

specifically tasked him “to be the individual to acclimate the hijackers to the United States, particularly San Diego, CA,” and that Bayoumi told him “to assist in any way in their affairs.” 189.

Per Bayoumi’s instructions to provide unqualified assistance, Abdullah helped

Hazmi and Mihdhar locate and apply to language and flight schools, and assisted them in translating between English and Arabic. Abdullah also undertook extensive efforts to secure fake driver’s licenses for Hazmi and Mihdhar, driving the hijackers from San Diego to an area in Los Angeles, where Abdullah purchased approximately four or five fraudulent California Department of Motor Vehicle identification cards and gave them to Hazmi and Mihdhar. 190.

Abdullah also helped Hazmi conduct surveillance of the Los Angeles

International Airport in June 2000. On June 9, Abdullah traveled with Hazmi and Mihdhar to Los Angeles where they visited the King Fahd Mosque, where Abdullah learned that the hijackers already knew several people at the mosque, including an individual identified as “Khallam.” 191.

FBI investigators believe the individual identified as Khallam is Khallad bin

Attash, a trusted member of Osama bin Laden’s inner al Qaeda leadership circle who is linked to the 1998 U.S. Embassy bombings and the purported mastermind behind the U.S.S. Cole bombing. CIA reports and other evidence indicate that bin Attash was in the United States that same month and was seen in the company of Fahad al Thumairy.

385

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 386 of 434

192.

On June 10, Los Angeles International Airport security tapes show Abdullah,

Hazmi and an unidentified man (potentially Khallad) using a video camera to scout out the airport. 193.

During a number of interviews with the FBI following the 9/11 attacks, Abdullah

admitted knowing of Hazmi’s and Mihdhar’s extremist leanings and Mihdhar’s involvement with the Islamic Army of Aden, an Islamic extremist group in Yemen with ties to al Qaeda. 194.

Just eight days after the September 11th attacks, Abdullah “was arrested by FBI

San Diego on charges of immigration fraud for his claim of being a Somali asylee” and “pled guilty to the immigration charges and was deported to Yemen in 2004.” See SR at p. 3. 195.

While “detained in an immigration facility he bragged to two fellow inmates that

he assisted the hijackers.” See id. Those individuals have cooperated with the FBI and federal prosecutors and would be available to testify as witnesses. 196.

Consistent with this and other evidence, the 2012 Summary Report confirms that

“[s]hortly after February 4, 2000, al-Bayoumi tasked Mohdar [Abdullah] to assist al-Hazmi and al-Mihdhar” and that “Mohdar [Abdullah] played a key role facilitating the daily lives and assisting future Flight 77 hijackers Nawaf al-Hazmi and Khalid al-Mihdhar.” See SR at p. 3. 197.

Another close associate of Bayoumi and fellow employee of the Saudi

government, Osama Yousef Bassnan (or “Basnan”), was in contact with and aided Hazmi and Mihdhar from within the United States as well, as reflected in evidence developed by the FBI and Congressional Joint Inquiry. 198.

Like Bayoumi, Bassnan was another employee and agent of the Saudi government

engaged in performing undisclosed functions for and at the direction of the extremists in the Ministry of Islamic Affairs’ offices in the United States and elsewhere.

386

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 387 of 434

199.

Witnesses interviewed by the FBI described Bayoumi and Bassnan as “the closest

of friends” and confirmed that the two were “close to each other for a long time.” According to the FBI, Bayoumi and Bassnan were in telephone contact “several times a day while they were both in San Diego” and “phone records reveal roughly 700 calls between various phones subscribed to by Bayoumi and Basnan over a one year period.” 200.

FBI investigations have further confirmed that Bassnan had extensive ties to

terrorism and was an “ardent UBL [Osama bin Laden] supporter,” who spoke of bin Laden “as if he were a god” and was “in contact with UBL family members.” According to a federal law enforcement official, Bassnan “celebrated the heroes of September 11” and talked about “what a wonderful, glorious day it had been” at a party shortly thereafter. 201.

As detailed in the Congressional Joint Inquiry Report, “Bassnan made a comment

to an FBI source after the September 11 attacks suggesting that he did more for the hijackers than al-Bayoumi did.” See CJI at p. 426. 202.

Consistent with this claim, an October 3, 2001 FBI report indicates that Bassnan

also was in telephone contact with Anwar Aulaqi, and an FBI agent interviewed by the 9/11 Commission indicated that an associate of Bassnan was in “phone and email contact with Ramzi Binalshibh in September 2000.” At the time of those contacts, Binalshibh was a senior al Qaeda figure who was actively involved in planning and coordinating the September 11th attacks. 203.

The FBI’s investigation has also documented “contact between the hijackers and a

close friend of Bassnan’s, Khaled al-Kayed, a commercial airline pilot and certified flight instructor living in San Diego. Al-Kayed admitted to the FBI that in May 2000, al-Mihdhar and al-Hazmi contacted him about learning to fly Boeing jet aircraft.” 204.

In addition, U.S. investigations have established that contemporaneous with the

arrival of Hazmi and Mihdhar in the United States, Bassnan’s wife began signing checks issued

387

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 388 of 434

to her by a charity associated with the wife of the Saudi Ambassador to the United States over to Bayoumi’s wife. 205.

According to Senator Graham, the Co-Chair of the Congressional Joint Inquiry,

these transfers, which coincided with Bayoumi’s provision of assistance to the hijackers, “looked suspiciously like another backdoor way of channeling money to al-Hazmi and al-Mihdhar.” 206.

9/11 Commissioner John Lehman has, in turn, expressed his understanding based

on the investigation conducted by the 9/11 Commission that the charity that issued the payments was under the control of “the radicals who worked in the embassy’s Islamic Affairs office in Washington.” 207.

During the course of their investigation, members of the 9/11 Commission staff

interviewed Thumairy, Bayoumi, and Bassnan in Saudi Arabia. During those interviews, all three lied pervasively about their relationships with one another and other material issues raised by the Commission investigators. 208.

According to the 9/11 Commission’s Memorandum for the Record concerning its

interviews of Thumairy: “Our general impression of Thumairy is that he was deceptive during both interviews.

His answers were either inconsistent or, at times, in direct conflict with

information we have from other sources. During some of the more pointed exchanges, his body language suggested that he grew increasingly uncomfortable (for instance, he would cross his arms, sit back in his chair, etc.).” 209.

In an interview with the Guardian last year, a 9/11 Commission staff member

reaffirmed those conclusions and offered further details about the interview, stating that “[i]t was so clear Thumairy was lying,” and “[i]t was also so clear he was dangerous.” 210.

The memorandum recounting the Commission’s Bassnan interview similarly

explains that “The interview [of Bassnan] failed to yield any new information of note. Instead,

388

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 389 of 434

in the writer’s opinion, it established beyond cavil the witness’ utter lack of credibility on virtually every material subject. This assessment is based on: the witness’ demeanor, which engendered a combination of confrontation, evasiveness, and speechmaking, presumably for the benefit of his Mabahith [Saudi Intelligence] audience; his repudiation of statements made by him on prior occasions; and the inherent incredibility of many of his assertions when viewed in light of the totality of the available evidence.” 211.

Particularly when viewed collectively, these and plaintiffs’ additional facts and

evidence relating to the relationships among Thumairy, Bayoumi, Abdullah, and Bassnan; their respective ties to terrorism and extremist views; their concentrated dealings leading to the provision of the precise forms of assistance the hijackers most needed to assimilate into the United States and begin preparations for the attacks without detection; their deceitfulness to U.S. investigators4; the findings and focus of the ongoing criminal investigations of Bayoumi and Thumairy; and the broader spectrum of evidence documenting the extensive involvement of elements of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs in supporting al Qaeda, readily establish: (1) that Thumairy, Bayoumi, and Bassnan knew that Hazmi and Mihdhar were extremists who were engaged in efforts to target the United States; (2) that Thumairy, Bayoumi, and Bassnan knew that they were substantially advancing that tortious endeavor through the assistance they were providing; and (3) that Thumairy, Bayoumi, and Bassnan played witting roles in orchestrating and providing a critical support network for Hazmi and Mihdhar. 212.

Congressional Joint Inquiry Co-Chair Bob Graham has testified, based on his

decades of experience in intelligence matters and personal knowledge of the evidence collected by the Congressional Joint Inquiry, that “I am convinced that there was a direct line between at least some of the terrorists who carried out the September 11th Attacks and the government of

4

See Tatum v. City of N.Y., 668 F. Supp. 2d 584, 593 (S.D.N.Y. 2009) (in a civil proceeding, it is a “general principle of evidence law that the factfinder is entitled to consider a party’s dishonesty about a material fact as affirmative evidence of guilt”).

389

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 390 of 434

Saudi Arabia,” that “a Saudi government agent living in the United States, Omar al Bayoumi, provided direct assistance” to two of the hijackers, and that “al Bayoumi was acting at the direction of elements of the Saudi government.” 213.

9/11 Commissioner John Lehman has likewise testified, based on his personal

knowledge of the 9/11 Commission’s separate investigation and his work for more than four decades in the national security arena, that “[b]y the time our Commission began its work, it was already well known in intelligence circles that the Islamic Affairs Departments of Saudi Arabia’s diplomatic missions were deeply involved in supporting Islamic extremists,” and that “it is implausible to suggest that the broad spectrum of evidence developed by the 9/11 Commission concerning the relationships among Omar al Bayoumi, Fahad al Thumairy, the Islamic Affairs Departments of the Saudi diplomatic missions, and 9/11 hijackers Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Mihdhar can be explained away as merely coincidental. To the contrary, I believe Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Mihdhar knew who to go to for support” and that “Fahad al Thumairy and Omar al Bayoumi knew that al Mihdhar and al Hazmi were bad actors who intended to do harm to the United States.” Nature and Scope of Employment and Agency 214.

At the time they were substantially assisting the 9/11 hijackers, Thumairy,

Bayoumi, and Bassnan were employees and agents of the Saudi government, and their activities in support of the hijackers were directly related to their core functions and duties involving the advancement of the Wahhabi agenda of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs. 215.

As documented in the 9/11 Commission Final Report, 2012 FBI Summary

Report, and numerous other U.S. investigative records, Thumairy held diplomatic credentials with the Saudi consulate in Los Angeles, where he served as an employee in the consulate’s

390

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 391 of 434

Islamic Affairs office, and also served as an imam at the Saudi government-funded King Fahd Mosque. 216.

Thumairy was appointed to both positions by the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic

Affairs. 217.

The U.S. government’s investigations also document Thumairy’s extremist

beliefs, jihadist sermons, and terrorist connections, thus reinforcing both the radical character and agenda of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and of Thumairy’s scope of work for the Ministry. 218.

Bayoumi and Bassnan were, in turn, employees and agents of the Saudi

government whose undisclosed duties involved the performance of activities on behalf of the Saudi embassies and consulates in the United States, under the direction of the clerics embedded in the Islamic Affairs offices and other officials of the Kingdom’s embassies and consulates. 219.

Nominally, Bayoumi entered the United States in or around 1994 on a student

visa, and thereafter proffered a letter from the Saudi embassy representing that he would be studying pursuant to “a full scholarship from the Government of Saudi Arabia.” See CJI at p. 423. 220.

Bayoumi remained in the United States pursuant to student visas for nearly seven

years, until he departed the United States very shortly before the September 11th attacks, despite never pursuing any meaningful academic studies during that period. Saudi officials actively perpetuated the false claim that Bayoumi was undertaking studies in the United States during that seven year period. 221.

Throughout that time, including the period when he was substantially assisting the

hijackers, Bayoumi received a salary from the Saudi government, for alleged job duties he never performed.

391

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 392 of 434

222.

As the 2012 Summary Report succinctly confirms, at the time of Bayoumi’s

critical meeting with Thumairy and assistance to the hijackers, “Omar al-Bayoumi was living in San Diego on a student visa, despite not attending classes, and receiving a salary from the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for job duties he never performed.” See SR at p. 4. 223.

These findings indicate that Bayoumi was an employee and agent of the Saudi

government, stationed in the United States to perform undisclosed duties that the Kingdom sought to conceal. 224.

The facts concerning Bayoumi’s actual activities while he was in the United

States, and receiving a salary from the Saudi government, demonstrate that his undisclosed functions for the Kingdom involved the performance of activities in furtherance of the agenda of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, reporting to officials in the Kingdom’s embassies and consulates, including Thumairy. 225.

In this regard, Bayoumi had extensive and systematic dealings and

communications throughout his residency in the United States with the Saudi embassies and consulates in the United States. 226.

An FBI review of Bayoumi’s telephone records confirmed that he called Saudi

diplomatic missions in the United States at least 74 times during the period between JanuaryMarch of 2000 alone, coinciding with his assistance to the hijackers, including 34 calls to the Saudi Consulate in Los Angeles where Thumairy worked. 227.

In addition, U.S. investigations established that Bayoumi was directly connected

to numerous employees and officials of Saudi Arabia’s embassies and consulates and Ministry of Islamic Affairs, including the Minister of Islamic Affairs in Saudi Arabia; Thumairy; “an individual at the Saudi consulate in London[;]” and “at least three individuals at the Saudi Embassy in Washington, DC; two individuals at the Saudi Arabian Cultural Mission in

392

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 393 of 434

Washington, DC; and three individuals [likely including Thumairy] at the Saudi Consulate in Los Angeles.” 228.

Bayoumi also had pervasive contacts and dealings with Bassnan, who was himself

deeply intertwined with the Saudi government structure in the United States, and according to FBI reports may have succeeded Bayoumi in 2001. 229.

This range of contacts with officials of the Saudi diplomatic missions and

Ministry of Islamic Affairs, and pattern of communications with the Kingdom’s consulates and embassies, reflect that Bayoumi was reporting to officials in the embassies and consulates, including representatives of the Islamic Affairs offices, in relation to his undisclosed work for the Saudi government. 230.

Bayoumi’s “seemingly endless” access to funds from Saudi Arabia, and use of

those funds in support of causes within the core mission of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, further evidence that Bayoumi’s functions for the government involved the performance of activities to advance the Ministry of Islamic Affairs’ Wahhabi agenda. 231.

For instance, as detailed in the Congressional Joint Inquiry Report, “Al-Bayoumi

was known to have access to large amounts of money from Saudi Arabia, despite the fact that he did not appear to hold a job.

On one occasion prior to September 11, the FBI received

information that al-Bayoumi had received $400,000 from Saudi Arabia to fund a new mosque in San Diego.” See CJI at p. 424. 232.

FBI investigations also determined that Bayoumi communicated with Al

Haramain Islamic Foundation concerning Al Haramain’s “interest[] in appointing the imam of the mosque in Cajon, California, that al-Bayoumi managed.” Id. at p. 436. 233.

The construction of mosques outside of Saudi Arabia and placement of Wahhabi

imams in mosques and Islamic centers abroad were two of the most important goals and

393

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 394 of 434

functions of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs during this period, in support of its mission to spread Wahhabi Islam globally. 234.

Relatedly, at the time of Bayoumi’s communications with Al Haramain about the

selection of an imam for the mosque Bayoumi managed, that organization was headed by the Saudi Minister of Islamic Affairs, supervised by the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, and actively collaborating with al Qaeda. 235.

Bayoumi’s other reported activities while in the United States closely relate to the

mission and work of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs as well. 236.

For example, Bayoumi maintained extensive connections to extremist clerics

engaged in propagating Wahhabi Islamic doctrine in the United States and elsewhere, with regard to “religious” matters in particular, including Thumairy, Aulaqi, and “Abd al-Rahman Barzanji, an imam in Norway who, according to FBI documents, has suspected ties to high-level al-Qa’ida members.” See Document 17 at p. 35. 237.

In addition, Bayoumi’s own writings could “be interpreted as jihadist” according

to FBI analysts, CJI at p. 425, and his Saudi passport contained “a cachet that intelligence investigators associate with possible adherence to al Qaeda,” according to the 9/11 Commission, further indications of his role in advancing extremist Wahhabi objectives. See 9/11 Commission Final Report at p. 516. The Saudi passports of at least three of the 9/11 hijackers, including Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Mihdhar, included the same indicator of extremism and “adherence to al Qaeda.” See id. 238.

Bayoumi also interjected himself aggressively into the activities of the local

Muslim community, and the Saudi student community in particular (despite his advanced age), including through involvement in the Saudi student club.

394

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 395 of 434

239.

Several witnesses who interacted with him in those settings indicated to the FBI

that Bayoumi was responsible for monitoring Saudi students and citizens living in the United States, as reflected by his persistent videotaping of their activities and other factors, and described him as some kind of “agent” working for the Saudi government in an undisclosed capacity. See Averment ¶¶ 149, 188-89, 194. 240.

The covert monitoring of Saudi students living outside of the Kingdom was a

common function and activity of the Saudi embassies and consulates during that period, carried out principally by the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, as a component of the Ministry’s role in protecting the Kingdom’s “Islamic” character. See Averment ¶ 119. 241.

In this regard, a report published by the Sydney Morning Herald concerning

activities of the Saudi embassy in that country, based on a review of Saudi government cables, is insightful. According to the report, the cables reflect “sustained Saudi efforts to influence political and religious opinion within [local] Arabic and Islamic communities,” that the Saudi embassies “pay close attention to the political and religious beliefs of Saudi university students studying [abroad] with reports sent to” officials in the Kingdom, and that the embassies coordinate “funding for building mosques and supporting Islamic community activities.” 242.

Bayoumi’s activities undertaken in the United States while receiving a salary

from the Saudi government (and performing no other duties for the Kingdom), and while communicating on a systematic basis with the Kingdom’s diplomatic missions, align completely with these documented functions of the Kingdom’s embassies and consulates. 243.

The circumstances surrounding Bayoumi’s assistance to the hijackers further

evidence that his undisclosed duties for the Saudi government involved the performance of tasks assigned to him by the Wahhabi extremists in the Kingdom’s embassies and consulates.

395

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 396 of 434

244.

In this regard, U.S. investigations have established that Bayoumi met and offered

to assist the hijackers immediately following a meeting with Thumairy in the Saudi consulate, and that a third subject of the ongoing investigation “tasked al-Thumairy and al-Bayoumi with assisting the hijackers.” See SR at p. 4. 245.

These facts indicate that Bayoumi was acting within a chain of command and

direction in which he was subordinate to Thumairy, a Saudi government official, and a third person with common authority over both of them. The fact that the third individual had such authority over both Thumairy and Bayoumi indicates that that person was a more senior Saudi official. 246.

The declassified 28 pages of the Congressional Joint Inquiry Report, meanwhile,

draw a direct parallel between Bayoumi’s role for the Saudi government and that of another extremist with deep connections to the Saudi government’s Wahhabi proselytizing apparatus in the United States, Mohammed al Qudhaeein, who as discussed below also provided aid to the September 11th plotters from within the United States. 247.

Like Bayoumi, Qudhaeein was purportedly in the United States as a student; was

“in frequent contact with Saudi government establishments in the United States,” including officials from the Ministry of Islamic Affairs; was “very involved in the affairs of the local Saudi community,” and was “receiving money from the Saudi government.” See CJI at p. 438. 248.

Based on these and other factors, the FBI described Qudhaeein’s “profile” as

“similar to that of al-Bayoumi and Bassnan.” See id. at p. 434. 249.

This assessment and the facts supporting it, coupled with the related findings

pertaining to Bassnan, further evidence that the Saudi government had a network of employees and agents in the United States prior to 9/11 performing undisclosed functions for the Kingdom;

396

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 397 of 434

that the duties of those employees and agents involved the advancement of the Wahhabi agenda of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs; and that Bayoumi was one of those employees and agents. 250.

Bassnan’s true functions for the Saudi government mirrored those performed by

Bayoumi, with whom Bassnan closely interacted and had unusual financial dealings. 251.

Bassnan entered the United States in 1996 on a tourist visa, even though he was in

fact working for the Saudi government. 252.

Bassnan had “many ties to the Saudi Government, including past employment by

the Saudi Arabian Education Mission,” a component of the Saudi embassy falling under the Ministry of Islamic Affairs’ authority. See CJI at p. 417. 253.

“According to a CIA memo, Bassnan reportedly received funding and possibly a

fake passport from Saudi Government officials.” Id. 254.

This funding included substantial transfers from a charity under the control of the

extremists in the Kingdom’s embassy in Washington, D.C. 255.

Like Bayoumi, Bassnan had extensive ties to Wahhabi extremists and terrorists in

the United States and elsewhere, and witnesses who interacted with him also described Bassnan as some kind of “agent” for the Saudi government. See Averment ¶¶ 197-99, 206; Index of Evidence, Exs. 26 and 49. 256.

These and other facts establish that Bassnan was, like Bayoumi, an employee and

agent of the Saudi government responsible for performing activities in furtherance of the agenda of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, under the direction of the Saudi embassies and consulates in the United States. 257.

The critical support Thumairy, Bayoumi, and Bassnan provided to the 9/11

hijackers as employees and agents of the Saudi government was, meanwhile, well within the

397

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 398 of 434

scope of their office, employment, and agency in furthering the radical mission and agenda of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Kingdom’s government proselytizing apparatus. 258.

Saudi Arabia established the Ministry of Islamic Affairs in 1993, in response to

intensive pressure from the Kingdom’s Wahhabi clerics, who sought greater government resources and platforms to advance their Wahhabi agenda globally. 259.

As the 9/11 Commission explained, al Qaeda finds inspiration and religious

justification for its actions “in a long tradition of intolerance” that flows “through the founders of Wahhabism,” and the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs “uses zakat and government funds to spread Wahhabi beliefs throughout the world.” See 9/11 Commission Final Report at pp. 362, 372. 260.

Following its formation and under the control of the Kingdom’s government

clerics, the Ministry of Islamic Affairs quickly evolved into “a stronghold of zealots,” with global reach and operations. See Averment ¶ 125. The Ministry assumed control over Saudi Arabia’s da’awa activities outside of the Kingdom, carried out principally through the Kingdom’s proselytizing arms under the direction and control of the Ministry, and established offices in the Kingdom’s diplomatic missions, which it populated with extremist clerics like Thumairy. 261.

During the decade preceding the September 11th attacks, the Ministry of Islamic

Affairs used the government platforms and funds available to it to pursue an extremist and antiAmerican global agenda, which included broad support for jihadist causes. See Averment ¶¶ 120-29. 262.

Of particular relevance in these respects, 9/11 Commissioner John Lehman has

testified, again based on his decades of experience in national security and intelligence matters and involvement in the 9/11 Commission’s investigation, that:

398

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 399 of 434

At least until September 11, 2001, the Islamic Affairs Departments of Saudi Arabia’s diplomatic missions throughout the world were populated and controlled by Wahhabi imams from the Kingdom Ministry of Islamic Affairs, like Fahad al Thumairy. Wahhabism is a puritanical, intolerant and virulently anti-American strand of Islam, and the state religion of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The Kingdom has dedicated vast sums over the last several decades to promote the Islamist agenda of Saudi Arabia’s Wahhabi clerics. This vast Saudi funding has been deployed to promote Wahhabi teachings throughout the world, fueling the jihadist tide that now confronts the civilized world. Wahhabi teachings from the ideological foundation for al Qaeda and a host of other jihad organizations that threaten our national security, including the socalled Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (ISIL, a/k/a ISIS). The links between Saudi Arabia’s Wahhabi clerics and al Qaeda did not exist solely at the ideological level, but rather also involved collaboration on financial and logistical fronts. Saudi clerics, paid by the government of the Kingdom and preaching at state funded mosques, issued fatwas that provided religious justification for al Qaeda’s terrorist actions. By the time our Commission began its work, it was already well known in intelligence circles that the Islamic Affairs Departments of Saudi Arabia’s diplomatic missions were deeply involved in supporting Islamic extremists. 263.

Commissioner Lehman’s testimony concerning the Ministry of Islamic Affairs’

extremist agenda, and deep involvement in jihadist causes during the years preceding the September 11th attacks, is amply supported by the pervasive involvement of the da’awa organizations under its control in supporting al Qaeda; the extensive connections between employees of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and terrorists; the involvement of employees of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs in recruiting and fundraising activities on behalf of al Qaeda; the jihadist content of literature distributed by the Ministry of Islamic Affairs; and the numerous counter-terrorism initiatives targeting the Ministry of Islamic Affairs after 9/11 (including the Kingdom’s removal of 3,500 clerics from the Ministry’s payroll and re-education of an additional 20,000). 264.

The range of terrorist connections maintained by the very employees of the

Ministry of Islamic Affairs who aided the 9/11 hijackers, including Thumairy, Bayoumi, and 399

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 400 of 434

Bassnan, further demonstrate the Ministry’s extremist character during the period leading up to the September 11th attacks, and confirm that collaborating with jihadists was within the scope of the office, employment, and agency of those individuals. Additional Assistance Provided by Saudi Government Employees and Agents Qudhaeein, Shalawi, Hussayen, Fakihi, and Mohamed 265.

Plaintiffs’ claims concerning the witting involvement of Thumairy, Bayoumi, and

Bassnan in supporting the September 11th hijackers, and deep connections between the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and terrorism during the period leading up to the attacks, are further reinforced and supported by declassified intelligence documents evidencing the involvement of five additional employees of the Saudi government’s religious apparatus in also knowingly providing substantial assistance to the September 11th hijackers, plotters and al Qaeda: Mohammed al Qudhaeein, Hamdan al Shalawi, Muhammed Jabar Fakihi, Saleh al Hussayen, and Omar Abdi Mohamed. 266.

The tortious acts of those additional employees and agents of the Saudi

government were likewise committed in the course of their employment and agency in advancing the extremist agenda of the Kingdom’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs and related components of the Saudi government’s Wahhabi proselytizing apparatus. Mohammed al Qudhaeein and Hamdan al Shalawi 267.

Mohammed al Qudhaeein and Hamdan al Shalawi were additional undeclared

employees and agents of the Saudi government, whose duties also involved the performance of activities on behalf of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs. 268.

Like Bayoumi, Qudhaeein was purportedly in the United States as a student, was

“in frequent contact with Saudi government establishments in the United States,” was “very involved in the affairs of the local Saudi community,” and was “receiving money from the Saudi government.” See CJI at p. 434. 400

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 401 of 434

269.

Based on these and other factors, FBI investigators described Qudhaeein’s

“profile” as “similar to that of al-Bayoumi and Bassnan.” See id. 270.

During a 1999 flight from Phoenix to Washington, D.C. to attend an event “at the

Saudi embassy,” Qudhaeein participated along with a fellow Saudi named Hamdan al Shalawi, who “had trained at the terrorist training camps in Afghanistan,” in a dry run for the 9/11 attacks. See id. at pp. 419, 433. 271.

During that flight, Qudhaeein “went to the front of the plane and attempted on

two occasions to enter the cockpit,” and the FBI “believes both men were specifically attempting to test the security procedures of America West Airlines in preparation for and in furtherance of UBL/Al Qaeda operations.” See id. at pp. 433-34. 272.

Shalawi was himself a long time employee of the Saudi government as well, and

was receiving a stipend from the Saudi government at the time of the incident. 273.

Both Qudhaeein and Shalawi told investigators that the Saudi embassy in

Washington had paid for their tickets. See id. at p. 433. 274.

The event they were traveling to attend was a symposium hosted by the Saudi

embassy in collaboration with the Institute for Islamic and Arabic Sciences in America (“IIASA”), a Saudi government proselytizing arm with extensive ties to terrorism. 275.

Following the September 11th attacks, the United States revoked the diplomatic

visas of 16 people associated with IIASA, who were using their diplomatic status as representatives of the Saudi Embassy in Washington D.C. to promote and spread radical Wahhabi ideology in the United States. According to senior U.S. law enforcement officials, in all, approximately seventy (70) individuals with Saudi diplomatic credentials were expelled from the United States as part of “an ongoing effort to protect the homeland.”

401

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 402 of 434

276.

In response to the revocation of the visas, IIASA issued a “Declaration About the

Revoking of Diplomatic Visas,” in which IIASA confirmed that it was a Saudi government arm conducting da’awa activities under the auspices of the Saudi embassy: The Institute of Islamic and Arabic Sciences in America (IIASA) is a non-profit educational institution affiliated with Al-Imam Muhammad Ibn Saud Islamic University (IMSIU) in Riyadh, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, which was established by the order of the Custodian of the Two Holy Sanctuaries King Fahd Ibn Abdul Aziz more than fifteen years ago. This Institute continues to receive support from the University and from the Royal Embassy of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia… *** Under the auspices of the Royal Embassy of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and its Ambassador to the USA, the personnel of the Institute were registered at the Imam Muhammad Ibn Saud Islamic University and the US State Department as diplomatic personnel and consequently were granted diplomatic A2 visas since the IMSIU is a government University. 277.

The State Department’s actions coincided with investigations conducted by the

Internal Revenue Service and Senate Finance Committee into IIASA and its links to terrorist groups, which eventually led to its closure. 278.

In the years after the 1999 incident, both Qudhaeein and Shalawi held posts as

government employees at the Imam Muhammed Ibn Saud Islamic University, the parent of IIASA, a further indication of their longstanding ties to the Saudi government. 279.

In the fall of 2000, Shalawi received training at an al Qaeda camp in Afghanistan

where several of the 9/11 muscle hijackers were simultaneously receiving training. 280.

Based on intelligence indicating Shalawi’s presence at the camp, the United States

placed him on a terrorist watch list and he was denied a visa when he attempted to re-enter the United States in August 2001, likely as part of an al Qaeda operation. Saleh al Hussayen 402

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 403 of 434

281.

Saleh al Hussayen was a senior government cleric who held various positions in

the Saudi government over a period of many years, and asserted in filings in this litigation that plaintiffs’ direct claims against him implicated his activities as a government official. 282.

In the weeks prior to the attacks, Hussayen was in the United States on a

fundraising mission with members of the Islamic Association of North America (“IANA”), a radical Islamic organization in Ypsilanti, Michigan, which receives money from the Saudi government and other Saudi donors. The IANA has promoted teachings and fatwas issued by radical Saudi clerics Safar Hawali and Salman Ouda, which advocated violence against the United States. Hawali and Ouda were identified in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing trial as spiritual advisors to Osama bin Laden. 283.

On September 6, 2001, Hussayen arrived in Herndon, VA. Then, just days before

the September 11th attacks, Hussayen abruptly moved from his original hotel to the Marriott Residence Inn, where September 11th hijackers Hazmi, Mihdhar, and Hanjour also were staying on the eve of the September 11th attacks. 284.

Directly after the attacks, FBI agents attempted to interview Hussayen in his hotel

room, but Hussayen “feigned a seizure, prompting the agents to take him to a hospital, where the attending physicians found nothing wrong with him.”

Averment ¶ 239.

Hussayen then

“managed to depart the United States despite law enforcement efforts to locate and re-interview him.” See CJI at p. 431. 285.

The recently declassified 28 pages of the Congressional Joint Inquiry Report

provide further details of the FBI’s investigation of Hussayen, including the FBI’s determination that Hussayen “is apparently a ‘Saudi Interior Ministry employee/official’” and that the FBI agents who interviewed him “believed he was being deceptive” when he “claimed to not know the hijackers.” Id. at pp. 418, 430-31.

403

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 404 of 434

286.

Hussayen’s ties to terrorist elements, precipitous relocation to the same hotel as

the 9/11 hijackers on the eve of the attacks, deceitfulness to U.S. investigators, and remarkable efforts to avoid questioning by U.S. authorities concerning his ties to the hijackers, all indicate that he provided aid and assistance to the hijackers in support of the September 11th attacks. 287.

Even before disclosure of the additional facts in the Congressional Joint Inquiry

Report, the United States Second Circuit Court of Appeals found that Hussayen’s “travels to the United States shortly before the September 11, 2001 attacks, as well as his decision to switch hotels to stay in the same hotel as at least three of the hijackers … not only suggest the possibility that he may have provided direct aid to members of al Qaeda, but they also raise a plausible inference that he may have intended his alleged indirect support of al Qaeda to cause injury in the United States.” O’Neill v. Asat Trust Reg. (In Re: Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001 (Asat Trust Reg.)), 714 F.3d 659, 679 (2d Cir. 2013). (Emphasis in original). Mohammed Jabar Fakihi 288.

Muhammed Jabar Fakihi was an employee of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, who

served as head of the Islamic Affairs office at the Saudi Embassy in Berlin, beginning in or around June of 2000, and like Thumairy was a Wahhabi extremist with extensive ties to terrorism. 289.

Investigations following the September 11th attacks revealed that Fakihi was in

direct contact with members of the Hamburg al Qaeda cell that coordinated the September 11th attacks, diverted extensive funds to al Qaeda from Saudi embassy accounts, and was “organizationally involved” in bin Laden’s organization. See Averment ¶ 261. 290.

The “Hamburg cell” consisted of key operatives in the September 11th attacks,

including Mohammad Atta (the ringleader of the 19 hijackers who piloted American Airlines Flight 11), Marwan al Shehhi (piloted United Airlines Flight 175), Ziad Jarrah (piloted United

404

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 405 of 434

Airlines Flight 93), Ramzi Binalshibh, Mounir el Motassadeq, Said Bahaji, Zakariya Essabar, Abdelghani Mzoudi, and others. 291.

As a representative of the Saudi Embassy and Ministry of Islamic Affairs, Fakihi

frequently attended the Saudi funded Al Nur Mosque in Berlin. 292.

A notorious haven for Islamic extremists, the mosque often hosted clerics that

preached intolerance of non-Muslims and justified violence in the name of defending Islam. Dr. Salem Rafei, a Lebanese cleric who served as an imam at the mosque, openly supported Palestinian suicide attacks and called Muslims to kill all unbelievers standing in the way of Islam. Documents containing the mosque’s address were seized from individuals detained by Pakistani authorities who are alleged to have received military training at al Qaeda camps in Afghanistan in 2001. 293.

Fakihi, himself an adherent to the most extreme teachings of Wahhabi ideology,

advocated for the development of mosques across Europe and told his superiors in the Kingdom that his ultimate goal was to turn Berlin into an Islamic proselytizing center for Eastern Europe. In June 2000, Fakihi wrote a letter to the Saudi Minister of Islamic Affairs, Saleh bin Abdulaziz al Ashaikh, proposing to turn the Al Nur Mosque into a center for Islamic missionary activity aimed at “ethnic European” populations in Eastern Europe. Fakihi, who planned to move his office to the Al Nur Mosque, proposed to carry the word of Islam to Poland, the Czech Republic and Hungary, the last of “which once belonged to the Islamic Caliphate under Ottoman Empire rule.” See Averment ¶ 256. 294.

The expansion of the Al Nur Mosque was originally conceived by Ahmad al-

Dubayan, Fakihi’s predecessor in the Islamic Affairs office in the Saudi embassy in Berlin, who served as a mentor to Fakihi and likely had contact with members of the Hamburg al Qaeda cell at the al Nur Mosque as well.

405

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 406 of 434

295.

Fakihi arranged for the expansion of the Al Nur Mosque consistent with the

vision outlined in his letter, using funds from Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, one of the al Qaeda affiliated charities supervised and directed by the Saudi Ministry of Islamic Affairs and headed by the Minister of Islamic Affairs. 296.

Mohammad Atta and other members of the Hamburg cell, including Mounir el

Motassadeq, were seen visiting the mosque and German investigators believe Fakihi met with Motassadeq at al Nur. Fakihi’s business card was found in the apartment of Motassadeq, who was later arrested and convicted in a German court for being an accessory to murder relative to the September 11th attacks, given his membership in the Hamburg cell and his knowledge and involvement in the preparation of the plans to hijack the planes. 297.

In March 2003, German police raided a suspected terrorist cell in Berlin and

arrested a half-dozen men who were planning a large scale terrorist attack in Germany. Bombmaking equipment, forged passports, flight-simulator software, chemicals and a handbook for brewing poisons were seized during the raid. German police said Fakihi met frequently at the Al Nur Mosque with the terror cell’s leader, Ihsan Garnaoui, a Tunisian al Qaeda member. 298.

Two days after the arrests, on March 22, 2003, the German Foreign Ministry,

following a recommendation from the country’s domestic-intelligence service, told the Saudi Embassy that Fakihi’s diplomatic accreditation would be withdrawn unless he left the country. That same day, Dubayan flew from London to Berlin to meet Fakihi, and Fakihi then flew back to Saudi Arabia the following day. 299.

Saudi authorities thereafter obstructed the German government’s further

investigation into links between Fakihi and the members of the Hamburg cell. The Saudi Embassy in Berlin never responded to a formal request from German prosecutors to explain the presence of Fakihi’s business card in Motassadeq’s apartment or an alleged meeting between

406

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 407 of 434

Fakihi and Motassadeq in Berlin shortly before the al Qaeda member’s arrest in November 2001. In an interview with the Wall Street Journal in 2003, a German police official stated that the Saudi Embassy failed to cooperate in the probe. 300.

Nonetheless, evidence presented to U.S. officials led them to conclude that Fakihi

was “more than just a sympathizer of bin Laden” and was “organizationally involved” with bin Laden’s al Qaeda network. See Averment ¶ 261. 301.

The 9/11 Commission staff conducted an interview with Fakihi in October 2003

in Riyadh relative to his duties with the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, his association with the Al Nur Mosque, and his relationships with Motassadeq and Garnaoui. The interview was conducted under the watchful eye of the Saudi secret police, the Mabahith.

According to 9/11

Commission’s memorandum concerning the interview, Fakihi’s testimony on a material issue “did not appear credible.” See Averment ¶ 263. Omar Abdi Mohamed 302.

Omar Abdi Mohamed entered the United States in or around 1998 as a religious

worker. 303.

In fact, Mohamed was an employee of Saudi Arabia’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs,

holding the title “Propagator,” material facts that neither he nor the Kingdom disclosed on his visa application. 304.

Following his entry into the United States and while employed by the Ministry of

Islamic Affairs, Mohamed established a purported charity called the Western Somali Relief Agency in San Diego under supervision of his superiors with the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, to serve as a front for funding al Qaeda. 305.

Between December 1998 and May 2001, Mohamed issued 65 checks totaling

nearly $400,000 to another prominent al Qaeda front called Dahab Shil, the Pakistan office of

407

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 408 of 434

which was at the time under the control of 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohamed, who at that very time was planning the September 11th attacks and providing funds to the 9/11 hijackers. 306.

Following the September 11th attacks, Mohamed was deported from the United

States following his conviction on immigration charges, including for failing to disclose that he was employed by the Saudi government. Additional Saudi Government Contacts With the 9/11 Hijackers, Plotters, and al Qaeda 307.

U.S. investigations concerning the September 11th attacks and sources of support

for al Qaeda before the attacks have documented a range of other links between persons and institutions associated with the Saudi government and elements of al Qaeda, including the September 11th hijackers and plotters. 308.

The Congressional Joint Inquiry and Document 17 survey some of these ties,

which indicate additional sources of support from within the Saudi government for al Qaeda and the September 11th plot. 309.

In addition, a federal judge in Florida currently is reviewing, for possible

declassification, approximately 80,000 pages of FBI records relating to investigations concerning the extensive links between 9/11 hijackers Mohammed Atta, Marwan al Shehhi, and Ziad Jarrah, and a Saudi family residing in Florida with ties to Saudi officials, in connection with an ongoing FOIA lawsuit. 310.

Discovery relating to these additional linkages between Saudi government

officials, employees, and agents and elements of al Qaeda is likely to adduce further evidence in support of plaintiffs’ claims.

408

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 409 of 434

IX.

U.S. INVESTIGATIONS FULLY SUPPORT PLAINTIFFS’ CLAIMS 311.

Investigations conducted by the U.S. government, including those of the 9/11

Commission and Congressional Joint Inquiry, broadly and directly support the 9/11 plaintiffs’ factual allegations and theories. 312.

As discussed above, 9/11 Commission members John Lehman and Bob Kerrey,

along with 9/11 Congressional Joint Inquiry Co-Chair Bob Graham, have offered sworn affidavit testimony, based on their decades of experience in national security matters and direct involvement in two of the principal investigations in to the September 11th attacks, in support of plaintiffs’ claims. 313.

Further, several additional 9/11 Commission members and staff have joined

Secretary Lehman and Senator Kerrey in the last year in directly rejecting the Kingdom’s false (and irrelevant) claims of exoneration and characterizations of the Commission’s investigation. 314.

Most recently, the declassification of the 2012 Summary Report of the ongoing

FBI and DOJ investigations of Bayoumi and Thumairy and associated individuals who aided the 9/11 hijackers has confirmed central facts underlying plaintiffs’ claims based on the tortious acts of Bayoumi and Thumairy. 315.

Separately, plaintiffs’ claims based on the funding and material sponsorship of al

Qaeda by the Kingdom’s proselytizing arms are fully supported by the 9/11 Commission’s finding that there was a substantial “likelihood that charities with significant Saudi government sponsorship diverted funds to al Qaeda.” 316.

Stated most simply, U.S. investigations broadly support plaintiffs’ claims herein. COUNT I

AIDING AND ABETTING AND CONSPIRING WITH AL QAEDA TO COMMIT THE SEPTEMBER 11th ATTACKS UPON THE UNITED STATES IN VIOLATION OF 18 U.S.C. § 2333(d) (JASTA)

409

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 410 of 434

ON BEHALF OF ALL “U.S. NATIONAL” PLAINTIFFS5 317.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

318.

As set forth above, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia knowingly provided

material support, resources, and substantial assistance to, and conspired with, al Qaeda over many years, with an awareness and intent to further al Qaeda’s campaign to carry out terrorist attacks against the United States and its citizens on September 11, 2001. 319.

As set forth above, plaintiffs’ claims against defendant Kingdom of Saudi

Arabia relating to its tortious acts in support of al Qaeda fall within the exception to foreign sovereign immunity set forth at 28 U.S.C. § 1605B, and plaintiffs are thus authorized to assert causes of action against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia pursuant to the Anti-Terrorism Act, 18 U.S.C. § 2331 et seq. 320.

Through the tortious acts in support of al Qaeda described above, defendant

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia aided and abetted, and conspired with, al Qaeda to carry out acts of international terrorism against the United States and its citizens on September 11, 2001, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2333(d). 321.

At the time of the September 11th attacks, al Qaeda was a designated foreign

terrorist organization under section 219 of the Immigration and Nationality Act (8 U.S.C. § 1189). 322.

The funding and other material support defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

provided to al Qaeda, as described above, enabled al Qaeda to acquire the global strike capabilities employed on September 11, 2001, and was essential to al Qaeda’s ability to carry out the attacks. 323.

During the decade preceding the September 11th attacks, al Qaeda repeatedly

made clear, through both declarations and actions, its intent to use funds and resources provided 5

The causes of action pursuant to the ATA, 18 U.S.C. § 2331 et seq., are asserted on behalf of plaintiffs who are U.S. nationals; estates, heirs, and survivors of U.S. nationals. The term “U.S. National Plaintiffs” refers to all such parties.

410

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 411 of 434

to it to conduct large scale terrorist attacks in order to kill innocent civilians, destroy property on a mass scale, and cause catastrophic economic harm. 324.

The September 11th attacks were a direct and foreseeable result of the material

support and sponsorship of al Qaeda by defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. 325.

Plaintiffs suffered injuries to their persons, property or businesses by reason of the

September 11th attacks and defendant’s tortious acts in support of al Qaeda. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with treble damages, punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, attorney’s fees, costs of this action and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. COUNT II AIDING AND ABETTING AND CONSPIRING WITH AL QAEDA TO COMMIT THE SEPTEMBER 11th ATTACKS UPON THE UNITED STATES IN VIOLATION OF 18 U.S.C. § 2333(a) ON BEHALF OF ALL “U.S. NATIONAL” PLAINTIFFS 326.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

327.

As enacted in 1992, the express civil cause of action established under 18 U.S.C.

§ 2333(a) authorized claims for aiding and abetting and conspiring to commit an act of international terrorism. 328.

Through the tortious acts in support of al Qaeda described above, defendant

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia aided and abetted, and conspired with, al Qaeda to carry out acts of international terrorism against the United States and its citizens on September 11, 2001, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2333(a). 329.

The relentless campaign by al Qaeda and its material supporters to carry out

terrorist attacks against the United States and its citizens, which culminated in the September 11th

411

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 412 of 434

attacks, involved continuous acts of violence and acts dangerous to human life, that violate the criminal laws of the United States, including the prohibitions set forth in 18 U.S.C. § 2332. See 18 U.S.C. § 2332b(a) (prohibiting conduct transcending national boundaries:

killing or

attempting to kill persons within the United States; causing serious bodily injury or attempting to cause serious bodily injury to persons within the United States; destroying or damaging any structure, conveyance, or other real or personal property within the United States; or attempting or conspiring to destroy any or damage any structure conveyance, or other real or personal property within the United States). 330.

Plaintiffs suffered injuries to their persons by reason of acts committed by al

Qaeda that involved the murder and attempted murder of persons within the United States, and the mass destruction of real and personal property within the United States, in violation of the criminal laws of the United States, including the prohibitions set forth in 18 U.S.C. § 2332. 331.

Through the tortious acts in support of al Qaeda described above, defendant

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia aided and abetted, and conspired with, al Qaeda to carry out acts of international terrorism against the United States and its citizens on September 11, 2001, in violation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2332(a), 2332(b), 2332(c), and 2333. 332.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia knew at all times that it was providing

material support for al Qaeda’s campaign to carry out acts of international terrorism against the United States and its citizens, and was aware and intended that the resources it provided would substantially assist al Qaeda in that objective. 333.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia also agreed to combine and conspire with al

Qaeda and other persons to act unlawfully, in the manners set forth in this complaint, and committed overt acts in furtherance of the conspiracy. At all relevant times, defendant Kingdom

412

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 413 of 434

of Saudi Arabia knew of the conspiracy and of the roles of the al Qaeda elements it was supporting in furtherance of the conspiracy. 334.

By aiding and abetting violations of 18 U.S.C. § 2332 that have caused injuries to

plaintiffs, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is liable pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2333 for any and all damages that plaintiffs have sustained as a result of such injuries. 335.

By conspiring to act with al Qaeda and other components of that terrorist

organization’s financial, logistical, and operational infrastructures, in furtherance of their campaign to conduct terrorist attacks against the United States and its citizens, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2332, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is liable pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2333 for any and all damages that plaintiffs have sustained by reason of the September 11th attacks. 336.

The September 11th attacks were a direct and foreseeable result of the material

support and sponsorship of al Qaeda by defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with treble damages, punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, attorney’s fees, costs of this action and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. COUNT III COMMITTING ACTS OF INTERNATIONAL TERRORISM IN VIOLATION OF 18 U.S.C. § 2333 ON BEHALF OF ALL “U.S. NATIONAL” PLAINTIFFS 337.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

338.

The actions of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in providing funding and

other forms of material support to al Qaeda and its agents would constitute “a criminal violation if committed within the jurisdiction of the United States or of any State” and “appear to be intended to intimidate or coerce a civilian population ... to influence the policy of a government 413

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 414 of 434

by intimidation or coercion or to affect the conduct of a government by mass destruction” within the meaning of 18 U.S.C. § 2331. 339.

The actions of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in providing funding and

other forms of material support to al Qaeda and its agents, and in providing substantial assistance to al Qaeda and its agents in planning, coordinating and carrying out the September 11th attacks in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 2333, caused injuries to the persons, businesses, or property of plaintiffs. 340.

By participating in the commission of violations of 18 U.S.C. § 2339A and 18

U.S.C. § 2339B that have caused plaintiffs to be injured in their persons, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has engaged in acts of international terrorism and is liable pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2333 for any and all damages that plaintiffs have sustained as a result of such injuries. 341.

By virtue of its willful violations of 18 U.S.C. § 2339C, which proximately

caused the injuries suffered by plaintiffs, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia committed acts of international terrorism and is liable pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2333 for any and all damages that plaintiffs have sustained as a result of such injuries. 342.

The actions of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in providing funding and

other forms of material support to al Qaeda and its agents were dangerous to human life, by their nature and as evidenced by their consequences. 343.

The actions of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in providing funding and

other forms of material support to al Qaeda and its agents either occurred outside the territorial jurisdiction of the United States or transcended national boundaries in terms of the means by which they were accomplished. 344.

Accordingly, the actions of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in providing

funding and other forms of material support to al Qaeda and its agents constitute acts of

414

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 415 of 434

international terrorism as defined by 18 U.S.C. §§ 2331 and 2333 and through incorporation of 18 U.S.C. §§ 2339A, 2339B, and 2339C. 345.

As set forth above, but for the assistance provided by defendant Kingdom of

Saudi Arabia, al Qaeda could not have successfully planned, coordinated, and carried out the September 11th attacks, which were a foreseeable and intended result of the Kingdom’s material support and sponsorship of al Qaeda. 346.

For the reasons set forth above, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is liable

pursuant to 18 U.S.C. § 2333 for any and all damages that plaintiffs have suffered to their persons, businesses or property as a result of the September 11th attacks. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with treble damages, punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, attorney’s fees, costs of this action and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. COUNT IV WRONGFUL DEATH ON BEHALF OF ALL PLAINTIFFS BRINGING WRONGFUL DEATH CLAIMS 347.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

348.

Plaintiffs herein bring this action for the wrongful death proximately caused by

defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia engaging in, materially supporting or sponsoring, financing, aiding and abetting, scheming and/or otherwise conspiring to commit or cause to occur acts of murder and wrongful death, specifically, the mass murder committed by the terrorist attacks acts of September 11, 2001. 349.

Surviving family members or estates of those wrongfully killed are entitled to

recover damages from defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for these illegal and wrongful deaths.

415

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 416 of 434

The family members or estates are entitled to recover full damages incurred, as fair and just compensation for the injuries resulting from these wrongful deaths. Those responsible for these deaths must be held accountable for the losses incurred. 350.

The injuries and damages suffered by plaintiffs were proximately caused by the

intentional, malicious, reckless, criminal, violent, grossly negligent or negligent acts of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia as described herein. 351.

As a direct and proximate result of the wrongful deaths of the decedents, their

heirs and families have suffered financially and been deprived of all future aid, income, assistance, services, comfort, companionship, affection and financial support of their loved ones. 352.

As a direct and proximate result of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s acts of

international terrorism, torture, conspiracy, and racketeering resulting in the wrongful death of decedents, the heirs and families of those murdered suffer and will continue to suffer permanent, physical and emotional distress, severe trauma, and lasting physical, emotional, and psychological injuries. 353.

As a further result of intentional, willful, wanton, malicious, reckless, criminal,

negligent, wrongful, illegal and tortious acts and conduct of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, plaintiffs have incurred actual damages including but not limited to ongoing medical expenses related to psychological trauma, physical injuries, and other expenses and losses for which they are entitled to full and fair recovery. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. COUNT V

416

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 417 of 434

SURVIVAL ON BEHALF OF ALL PLAINTIFFS BRINGING WRONGFUL DEATH CLAIMS 354.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

355.

As a result of the intentional, malicious, reckless, conspiratorial, criminal,

unprivileged, nonconsensual, grossly negligent and negligent acts of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia as described herein, those killed on September 11, 2001, were placed in a severe, often prolonged, extreme, traumatic, apprehension of harmful, offensive unwarranted bodily contact, injury and assault. Those murdered suffered intensely severe and offensive harmful bodily contact, personal injury and battery; including but not limited to extreme fear, terror, anxiety, emotional and psychological distress, knowledge of pending death and physical and emotional trauma, and intentionally inflicted physical pain. Decedents were mentally, physically and emotionally damaged, harmed, trapped, and falsely imprisoned prior to their personal physical injury and deaths. 356.

As a result of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s criminal and tortious conduct, those

killed suffered damages including pain and suffering, severe trauma, fear, anxiety, permanent physical and emotional distress, ultimate loss of life and life’s pleasures, companionship and consortium, loss of family, career, earnings and earning capacity, loss of accretion to their estates, and other immeasurable items of damages to be shown at trial. Plaintiffs herein seek and are entitled to survival damages for those tortured and killed on September 11, 2001. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances.

417

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 418 of 434

COUNT VI ALIEN TORT CLAIMS ACT6 ON BEHALF OF ALL ALIEN NATIONAL PLAINTIFFS 357.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

358.

The Alien Tort Claims Act, 28 U.S.C. § 1350, allows aliens to sue for torts

committed in violation of the law of nations or a treaty of the United States. Certain of the plaintiffs in this action are non-U.S. citizen aliens. 359.

As set forth above, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia aided and abetted,

sponsored, financed, promoted, fostered, materially supported, or otherwise conspired to proximately cause the death and injury of innocent persons namely the alien plaintiffs herein through and by reason of acts of international terrorism – the heinous attacks of September 11, 2001. These terrorist acts constitute a clear violation of the law of nations, otherwise referred to as customary international law, which includes international legal norms prohibiting crimes against humanity, mass murder, genocide, torture, extrajudicial killing, air piracy, financing of terrorism, and terrorism. These international legal norms can be found in and derived from, among other things, the following conventions, agreements, U.N. declarations and resolutions, and other documents: (1)

Charter of the International Military Tribunal, Aug. 8, 1945, 59 Stat. 1544, 82 U.N.T.S. 279;

(2)

Allied Control Council Law No. 10 (Dec. 20, 1945);

(3)

Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, Dec. 9 1948, 78 U.N.T.S. 277;

(4)

Geneva Convention (IV) Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War, Aug. 12, 1949, 75 U.N.T.S. 287;

6

The causes of action pursuant to the Alien Tort Claims Act (ATCA), 28 U.S.C. § 1350, are asserted on behalf of plaintiffs who are alien nationals; and estates, heirs, and survivors of alien nationals who are not themselves U.S. nationals who were injured or killed in the September 11th attacks.

418

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 419 of 434

(5)

Hague Convention for the Suppression of Unlawful Seizure of Aircraft (Hijacking), Dec. 16, 1970, 22 U.S.T. 1641, 860 U.N.T.S. 105;

(6)

International Convention for the Suppression of Terrorist Bombings, Dec. 15, 1997, 2149 U.N.T.S. 284 (entered into force May 23, 2001);

(7)

International Convention for the Suppression of the Financing of Terrorism, Dec. 9, 1999, 2178 U.N.T.S. 229 (entered into force Apr. 10, 2002);

(8)

U.N. Security Council Resolution 1267, U.N. Doc. S/RES/1267 (Oct. 15, 1999);

(9)

U.N. Security Council Resolution 1373, U.N. Doc. S/RES/1373 (Sept. 28, 2001);

(10)

Protocol Additional (I) to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and Relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflict, June 8, 1977, 1125 U.N.T.S. 3;

(11)

Protocol Additional (II) to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and Relating to the Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conflicts, June 8, 1977, 1125 U.N.T.S. 609;

(12)

Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY), in Report of the Secretary-General pursuant to paragraph 2 of S.C. Res.808, May 3, 1993, U.N. Doc. 8/25704, adopted unanimously by S.C. Res. 827, U.N. SCOR, 48th Sess., 3217th mtg., 16, U.N. Doc. S/PV.3217 (1993);

(13)

The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Crimes Against International Protected Persons, Including Diplomatic Agents, 28 U.S.T. 1975, T.I.A.S. No. 8532 (1977), implemented in 18 U.S.C. § 112l;

(14)

The General Assembly Resolutions on Measures to Prevent International Terrorism, G.A. Res. 40/61 (1985) and G.A. Res. 42/159 (1987); and

(15)

The Convention on the High Seas, April 29, 1958, arts. 14-22 (piracy), 13 U.S.T. 2312, 450 U.N.T.S. 11.

360.

As a result and proximate cause of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s activities set

forth above in violation of the law of nations, the alien plaintiffs suffered injury and damages as set forth herein. 361.

As a result and proximate cause of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s sponsorship of

terrorism in violation of the law of nations and customary principles of international law, the plaintiffs suffered injury and damages as set forth herein.

419

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 420 of 434

362.

Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1350, the plaintiffs herein who are alien nationals; and

estates, heirs, and survivors of alien nationals who are not themselves U.S. nationals who were injured or killed in the September 11th attacks are entitled to recover damages they have sustained by reason of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s actions in furtherance of this crime against humanity. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs who are alien nationals; and estates, heirs, and survivors of alien nationals who are not themselves U.S. nationals who were injured or killed in the September 11th attacks, demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. COUNT VII ASSAULT AND BATTERY ON BEHALF OF ALL PLAINTIFFS BRINGING WRONGFUL DEATH AND PERSONAL INJURY CLAIMS 363.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

364.

As a result of the intentional, malicious, reckless, conspiratorial, criminal,

unprivileged, nonconsensual, grossly negligent and negligent acts of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia as described herein, which culminated in the September 11th attacks, plaintiff decedents and/or personal injury plaintiffs were placed in apprehension of harmful and/or offensive bodily contact, and suffered harmful, offensive bodily contact, from which they ultimately died or suffered serious permanent personal injury. 365.

By reason of all of the foregoing, plaintiffs were killed, seriously and severely

injured, shocked, bruised and wounded and suffered great physical, mental, and emotional pain and injury, and they were rendered sick, sore, lame and disabled, and were otherwise injured or 420

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 421 of 434

killed, and/or were confined to a hospital, and/or to bed and home for a period of time by reason thereof, and/or required and received medical care and treatment, and/or incurred medical expenses and will continue to incur future expenses therefor, and were prevented from attending to the duties of their employment and prevented from pursuing the furthering their careers and lost salary and earnings and will lose future salary and earnings thereby. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances.

COUNT VIII CONSPIRACY ON BEHALF OF ALL PLAINTIFFS 366.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

367.

As set forth above, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia unlawfully, willfully and

knowingly combined, conspired, confederated, aided and abetted, tacitly and/or expressly agreed to participate, cooperate and engage in unlawful and tortious acts pursuant to a common course of conduct, namely the promotion and sponsoring of international terrorism, resulting in the death and injury of plaintiffs and/or their insureds. 368.

As set forth above, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia conspired with;

encouraged; and furthered and agreed to provide material support, funding, sponsorship, aiding and abetting and/or other material resources to al Qaeda, Osama bin Laden, and the hijackers in furtherance of this conspiracy. 369.

As set forth above, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia engaged in commonly

motivated, organized, concerted and conspiratorial acts, efforts, transactions, material support, 421

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 422 of 434

and activities designed, intended, and foreseeably to cause acts of international terrorism including the terrorist attack on the United States, its citizens and society on September 11, 2001. Co-conspirators herein continue in their quest to attack the United States, resulting in the harm to plaintiffs, which was done pursuant to and in furtherance of this concert of action, agreement, enterprise, civil and criminal conspiracy and common scheme. 370.

The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s concert of action, scheme, enterprise and

conspiracy to support and promote Osama bin Laden, al Qaeda, the hijackers and international terrorism was a proximate cause of the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks that killed and injured plaintiffs and/or their insureds. 371.

As a result of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s concert of action and conspiracy to

further international terrorism, plaintiffs have suffered damages as will be shown at trial. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances.

422

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 423 of 434

COUNT IX AIDING AND ABETTING ON BEHALF OF ALL PLAINTIFFS 372.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

373.

As set forth above, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia knowingly and

substantially assisted in the sponsorship of Osama bin Laden, al Qaeda, international terrorism and the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks that killed and injured plaintiffs and/or their insureds. 374.

At the time of such aiding and abetting, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia

knew or should have known that its role was part of an overall and ongoing illegal, criminal and/or tortious activity. 375.

As set forth above, defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia aided and abetted in

concerted efforts, transactions, acts and activities designed to cause the attacks of September 11, 2001, on the United States, its citizens, foreign citizens, its liberties and freedoms. 376.

The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s aiding and abetting of international terrorism

through material sponsorship of al Qaeda was a proximate cause of the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks that killed and injured plaintiffs. 377.

As a direct and proximate result of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s aiding and

abetting activities, plaintiffs have suffered damages as set forth herein. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances.

423

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 424 of 434

COUNT X INTENTIONAL INFLICTION OF EMOTIONAL DISTRESS ON BEHALF OF ALL INDIVIDUAL PLAINTIFFS 378.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

379.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia intended or knew or should have known,

that its conduct and actions would lead to the killing of or injury to innocent persons and resulting severe emotional distress. 380.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia intended, knew or should have known that

the September 11, 2001, suicide hijackings and intended mass murder would kill, maim, and/or permanently injure innocent people, leaving devastated family members to grieve for their losses with ongoing physical, psychological and emotional injuries and ongoing post-traumatic stress disorder on a horrific and massive scale. 381.

The actions of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia were unconscionable,

extreme, outrageous, and done with an intentional, malicious, and willful disregard for the rights and lives of those murdered, those injured, and the surviving loved ones. 382.

As a direct and proximate cause of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s intentional

misconduct and reckless disregard for human life, plaintiffs have suffered and will forever continue to suffer severe, debilitating, permanent emotional, physical and psychiatric disorders, ongoing emotional distress and anxiety, physical and mental distress, and significant mental injury and impairment causing ongoing and long-term expenses for medical treatment, services, and counselling and long-term care, particularly for all minor plaintiffs. 383.

The acts and conduct of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia were undertaken in

an intentional manner intended to or reasonably foreseeable to result in the killing and injuring of innocent people. These criminal and tortious acts culminated in the murder and maiming of

424

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 425 of 434

innocent people on September 11, 2001, and beyond, causing continuing, permanent emotional, mental and physical suffering to the families and heirs of the decedents. 384.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, by engaging in this intentional, and

unlawful conduct, intentionally inflicted emotional distress upon the plaintiffs. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. COUNT XI LIABILITY PURSUANT TO RESTATEMENT (SECOND) OF TORTS § 317 AND RESTATEMENT (THIRD) OF AGENCY § 7.05: SUPERVISING EMPLOYEES AND AGENTS ON BEHALF OF ALL PLAINTIFFS 385.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

386.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia was reckless in its supervision of its agents

or employees, including Fahad al Thumairy, Omar al Bayoumi, Osama Bassnan, Saleh al Hussayen, Mohammed al Qudhaeein, Muhammed Jaber al Fakihi and others, in that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia knew of these employees’ and agents’ propensity for the conduct that caused injury to plaintiffs prior to the injuries’ occurrence, and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia failed to exercise due care in supervising its employees and agents. 387.

The ability of the above-referenced agents or employees to provide wide-ranging

material support to al Qaeda, Osama bin Laden, and the September 11th hijackers, referenced above, and the resulting injuries to plaintiffs, were caused by reason of the reckless supervision by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia of its agents or employees.

425

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 426 of 434

388.

Due to the reckless supervision on the part of defendant Kingdom of Saudi

Arabia, plaintiffs sustained injuries. 389.

The injuries sustained by plaintiffs, as a result of the recklessness of defendant

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, were foreseeable and defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia knew or should have known of the risk of injury to the plaintiffs. 390.

The torts committed by the above-referenced employees and agents of defendant

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia were committed, among other places, on the premises of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia or with the chattels of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as these employees and agents provided wide-ranging material support to al Qaeda and the September 11th hijackers from, among other places, facilities owned and operated by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia using money and resources of the Kingdom. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. COUNT XII LIABILITY PURSUANT TO RESTATEMENT (SECOND) OF TORTS § 317 AND RESTATEMENT (THIRD) OF AGENCY § 7.05: HIRING, SELECTING, AND RETAINING EMPLOYEES AND AGENTS ON BEHALF OF ALL PLAINTIFFS 391.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

392.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia was reckless in hiring, selecting, and

retaining as and for its employees and agents individuals, including Fahad al Thumairy, Omar al Bayoumi, Osama Bassnan, Saleh al Hussayen, Mohammed al Qudhaeein, Muhammed Jaber al

426

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 427 of 434

Fakihi and others, in that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia knew of these employees’ and agents’ propensity for the conduct that caused injury to plaintiffs prior to the injuries’ occurrence. 393.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia hired, selected, and retained the above-

referenced agents and employees and placed them in a situation where they could create an unreasonable risk of harm to others. 394.

The ability of the above-referenced agents and employees to provide wide-

ranging material support to al Qaeda and the September 11th hijackers, referenced above, and the resulting injuries to plaintiffs, were caused by reason of the reckless hiring, selecting, and/or retention by defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. 395.

The injuries sustained by plaintiffs, as a result of the recklessness of defendant

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, were foreseeable and defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia knew or should have known of the risk of injury to the plaintiffs. 396.

The torts committed by the above-referenced employees and agents of defendant

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia were committed, among other places, on the premises of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia or with the chattels of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as these employees and agents provided wide-ranging material support to al Qaeda and the September 11th hijackers from, among other places, facilities owned and operated by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia using money and resources of the Kingdom. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. COUNT XIII 18 U.S.C. § 1962(a)-(d) – CIVIL RICO

427

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 428 of 434

ON BEHALF OF ALL PLAINTIFFS 397.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

398.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia constitutes a “person” as such term is used

in 18 U.S.C. § 1961(3). 399.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as principal, agent and co-conspirator,

performed “racketeering activity” as defined in 18 U.S.C. § 1961(1) by knowingly providing material support to Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda prior to the September 11th attacks, as described above. 400.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, including the agents, officials, officers, and

employees of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia whose attributable conduct in support of al Qaeda is discussed above, and Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda, were associated in fact with a common purpose of spreading extremist Wahhabi doctrine and rule, including through acts of jihad, and constituted an “enterprise” as that term is defined in 18 U.S.C. § 1961(4), which enterprise was engaged in, and the activities of which affected, interstate and foreign commerce (the “RICO Enterprise”). 401.

The RICO Enterprise constitutes an “enterprise” because all members thereof,

including but not limited to defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, had the same goal of spreading Wahhabi doctrine and rule, including through acts of jihad, and in fact worked together to achieve that goal. 402.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia committed two or more of the aforesaid acts

of racketeering activity within ten years of one another by continuously participating in the sponsorship of al Qaeda, and thereby committed a “pattern” of racketeering activity as defined in 18 U.S.C. § 1961(5). 403.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as principal, agent of, and co-conspirator

with Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda, used and invested, both directly and indirectly, the income 428

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 429 of 434

and the proceeds of the pattern of racketeering activity, to establish the RICO Enterprise in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1962(a). 404.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as principal, agent of, and co-conspirator

with Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda, maintained, directly and indirectly, an interest in and control of the RICO Enterprise through a pattern of racketeering activity in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1962(b). 405.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as principal, agent of, and co-conspirator

with Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda, conducted and participated, directly and indirectly, in the conduct of the affairs of the RICO Enterprise through a pattern of racketeering activity in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 1962(c). 406.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as a person associated with the RICO

Enterprise, which engaged in acts of racketeering activity which affected interstate and foreign commerce, did conspire with other persons known and unknown, to violate 18 U.S.C. § 1962(d). It was part of the conspiracy that defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and co-conspirators devised, intended to devise, and participated in a scheme to defraud and to obtain money and property by means of materially false and fraudulent pretenses, representations, and promises, and material omissions. It was a further part of the conspiracy that defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and others would and did misrepresent, conceal and hide, and cause to be misrepresented, concealed and hidden the purposes of, and acts done, in furtherance of the conspiracy. 407.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia violated 18 U.S.C. § 1962(a-d) by investing

in, maintaining an interest in, conducting and participating, directly and indirectly, or by conspiring to do the same, in the RICO Enterprise through a pattern of racketeering activity, that is, through multiple acts indictable under the laws of the United States, including but not limited to:

429

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 430 of 434

408.

(a)

18 U.S.C. § 1341 (mail fraud);

(b)

18 U.S.C. § 1343 (wire fraud);

(c)

18 U.S.C. § 1503 (obstruction of justice);

(d)

18 U.S.C. § 1956 (money laundering);

(e)

18 U.S.C. § 2339A (material support to organizations engaged in violent activities); and

(f)

18 U.S.C. § 2339B (material support to designated foreign terrorist organizations).

The damages suffered by plaintiffs, as described herein, were the direct and

proximate result of the aforesaid pattern of racketeering activity by defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, acting individually and in concert with other members of the RICO Enterprise. 409.

The loss of business and property by plaintiffs included loss of tangible and

intangible personal property, loss of employment, personal effects, pecuniary losses, past and future wages and profits, business opportunities, personal property, support, funeral and burial expenses, prospective inheritance, and the other economic contributions that plaintiffs’ decedents would have made to plaintiffs’ households (“losses”). Such losses were a direct and proximate result of the racketeering activities of defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with treble damages, punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, attorney’s fees, costs of this action and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances. COUNT XIV VIOLATIONS OF INTERNATIONAL LAW ON BEHALF OF ALL PLAINTIFFS 410.

Plaintiffs incorporate all previous allegations by reference.

430

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 431 of 434

411.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is liable for plaintiffs’ injuries under the

principles of international law. 412.

It is long settled that the law of nations is part of federal common law, and that

federal courts are empowered to address claims against those that commit, aid, or abet violations of international law. 413.

The terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001 involved the hijacking of four

airplanes. Aircraft hijacking is widely recognized as a violation of international law of the type that gives rise to liability against the hijackers and those who aided or abetted the aircraft hijacking. 414.

Through the tortious acts in support of al Qaeda described above, defendant

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia aided and abetted, and conspired with, al Qaeda in the commission of a violation of international law, aircraft hijacking, because their conduct substantially assisted al Qaeda’s commission of the September 11th attacks. 415.

In addition, and in the alternative, the tortious conduct of the Kingdom of Saudi

Arabia aided and abetted the violation of the following additional conventions, agreements, U.N. declarations, resolutions, and principles of international law: (1)

Charter of the International Military Tribunal, Aug. 8, 1945, 59 Stat. 1544, 82 U.N.T.S. 279;

(2)

Allied Control Council Law No. 10 (Dec. 20, 1945);

(3)

Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, Dec. 9 1948, 78 U.N.T.S. 277;

(4)

Geneva Convention (IV) Relative to the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War, Aug. 12, 1949, 75 U.N.T.S. 287;

(5)

Hague Convention for the Suppression of Unlawful Seizure of Aircraft (Hijacking), Dec. 16, 1970, 22 U.S.T. 1641, 860 U.N.T.S. 105;

(6)

International Convention for the Suppression of Terrorist Bombings, Dec. 15, 1997, 2149 U.N.T.S. 284 (entered into force May 23, 2001); 431

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 432 of 434

(7)

International Convention for the Suppression of the Financing of Terrorism, Dec. 9, 1999, 2178 U.N.T.S. 229 (entered into force Apr. 10, 2002);

(8)

U.N. Security Council Resolution 1267, U.N. Doc. S/RES/1267 (Oct. 15, 1999);

(9)

U.N. Security Council Resolution 1373, U.N. Doc. S/RES/1373 (Sept. 28, 2001);

(10)

Protocol Additional (I) to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and Relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflict, June 8, 1977, 1125 U.N.T.S. 3;

(11)

Protocol Additional (II) to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and Relating to the Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conflicts, June 8, 1977, 1125 U.N.T.S. 609;

(12)

Statute of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia (ICTY), in Report of the Secretary-General pursuant to paragraph 2 of S.C. Res.808, May 3, 1993, U.N. Doc. 8/25704, adopted unanimously by S.C. Res. 827, U.N. SCOR, 48th Sess., 3217th mtg., 16, U.N. Doc. S/PV.3217 (1993);

(13)

The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Crimes Against International Protected Persons, Including Diplomatic Agents, 28 U.S.T. 1975, T.I.A.S. No. 8532 (1977), implemented in 18 U.S.C. § 112l;

(14)

The General Assembly Resolutions on Measures to Prevent International Terrorism, G.A. Res. 40/61 (1985) and G.A. Res. 42/159 (1987); and

(15)

The Convention on the High Seas, April 29, 1958, arts. 14-22 (piracy), 13 U.S.T. 2312, 450 U.N.T.S. 11.

416.

Plaintiffs suffered injuries by reason of the above conduct for which defendant the

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is responsible. WHEREFORE, plaintiffs demand judgment against defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia for an amount authorized by governing law to be determined at trial, together with punitive damages, pre- and post-judgment interest, attorney’s fees, costs of this action and such other and further relief as the Court may deem appropriate under the circumstances.

JURY DEMAND Plaintiff demands a trial by jury as to all claims so triable.

432

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 433 of 434

Dated: March 17, 2017

Respectfully submitted,

/s/ Jodi Westbrook Flowers Jodi Westbrook Flowers, Esq. Donald A. Migliori, Esq. Michael Elsner, Esq. Robert T. Haefele, Esq. John Eubanks, Esq. MOTLEY RICE LLC Mount Pleasant, SC 29464 Tel. (843) 216-9000 Fax (843) 216-9450 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] /s/ Paul Hanly Paul Hanly, Esq. Jayne Conroy, Esq. Andrea Bierstein, Esq. SIMMONS HANLY CONROY 112 Madison Avenue 7th Floor New York, NY 10016 Tel: (212) 784-6400 Fax: (212) 213-5949 [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] /s/ Allan Gerson Allan Gerson, Esq. AG INTERNATIONAL LAW, PLLC 2131 S Street NW Washington, DC 20008 Tel: (202) 234-9717 Fax: (202) 234-9727 [email protected] Harry Huge HARRY HUGE LAW FIRM LLP 25 East Battery Street Charleston, SC 29401 433

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741 Filed 03/17/17 Page 434 of 434

Tel: (843) 722-1628 Fax: (843) 720-8794 [email protected]

434

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-1 Filed 03/17/17 Page 1 of 157

Appendix 1

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 2 of2 157 of 157

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

In re: Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001

03 MDL 1570 (GBD) (FM) ECF Case

This document relates to: All Actions PLAINTIFFS’ AVERMENT OF FACTS AND EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF THEIR CLAIMS AGAINST THE KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA AND THE SAUDI HIGH COMMISSION FOR RELIEF OF BOSNIA & HERZEGOVINA Plaintiffs in the above-referenced actions submit this Averment of Facts and Evidence in further support of their theories of liability and subject matter jurisdiction under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (“FSIA”), for their claims against the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the Saudi High Commission for Relief of Bosnia & Herzegovina. I.

PLAINTIFFS 1.

This Averment of Facts and Evidence is submitted on behalf of all plaintiffs in the

following actions, including all members of any putative class represented by any such plaintiffs: Federal Insurance Co., et al. v. al Qaida, et al., Case No. 03 Civ. 6978, Pacific Employers Ins., et al., v. Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, et al., Case No. 04 Civ. 7216, Vigilant Insurance Co., et al., v. Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, et al., Case No. 03 Civ. 8591, Thomas Burnett, Sr., et al. v. Al Baraka Inv. & Dev. Corp., et al., Case No. 03 Civ. 9849, Euro Brokers Inc., et al., v. Al Baraka, et al., Case No. 04 Civ. 7279, Kathleen Ashton, et al. v. Al Qaeda Islamic Army, et al., Case No. 02 Civ. 6977, Estate of John P. O’Neill, Sr., et al. v. Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, et al., Case No. 04 Civ. 1922, Continental Casualty Co., et al. v. Al Qaeda, et al., Case No. 04 Civ. 5970, and Cantor Fitzgerald & Co., et al. v. Akida Bank Private Ltd, et al., Case No. 04 Civ. 7065.1 2

1

The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia is presently named in the following actions: Federal Insurance Co., et al. v. al Qaida, et al., Case No. 03 Civ. 6978; Pacific Employers Ins., et al., v. Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, et al., Case No. 04 Civ. 7216; Vigilant Insurance Co., et al., v. Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, et al., Case No. 03 Civ. 8591; and Estate of John P. O’Neill, Sr., et al. v. Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, et al., Case No. 04 Civ. 1922. The O’Neill suit is a putative class action.

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 3 of3 157 of 157

2.

All Plaintiffs adopt and incorporate by reference the following operative

complaints and pleadings in their entireties, including all allegations and counts presented therein: Federal Insurance First Amended Complaint with Incorporated More Definite Statements, RICO Statements and Rule 15(d) Supplemental Pleadings, Filed in Accordance with Paragraph 13 of Case Management Order Number 2, Case No. 03 Civ. 6978, ECF No. 772; Pacific Employers Complaint, Case No. 04 Civ. 7216, ECF No. 1; Vigilant Insurance Complaint, Case No. 03 Civ. 8591, ECF No. 1; Burnett Third Amended Complaint, Case No. 02 Civ. 1616 (D.D.C.), ECF No. 29,3 and Burnett’s Notice of Consolidation of Pleadings, 03 MDL 1570, ECF No. 1377; Euro Brokers Complaint, Case No. 04 Civ. 7279, ECF No. 1, and Euro Broker’s Notice of Consolidation of Pleadings, 03 MDL 1570, ECF No. 1078; Ashton Sixth Amended Complaint, Case No. 02 Civ. 6977, ECF No. 465; O’Neill Class Action Complaint, Case No. 04 Civ. 1922, ECF Nos. 1, 21-22, as amended by the O’Neill First Consolidated Complaint, Case No. 03 MDL 1570, ECF No. 1569; Continental Casualty Second Amended Complaint, Case No. 04 Civ. 5970, ECF No. 195; and Cantor Fitzgerald Complaint, Case No. 04 Civ. 7065, ECF No. 5. 3.

In further support of their theories of subject matter jurisdiction and liability as to

defendants Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and the Saudi High Commission for Relief of Bosnia & Herzegovina, as presented in the complaints adopted by reference in paragraph 2 above, plaintiffs offer the following additional factual allegations and evidence.

2

The Saudi High Commission for Relief of Bosnia & Herzegovina is presently named in the following actions: Federal Insurance Co., et al. v. al Qaida, et al., Case No. 03 Civ. 6978; Thomas Burnett, Sr., et al. v. Al Baraka Inv. & Dev. Corp., et al., Case No. 03 Civ. 9849; and Continental Casualty Co., et al. v. Al Qaeda, et al., Case No. 04 Civ. 5970. 3 The Burnett action, originally filed in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, was transferred to the Southern District of New York by Order of the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation on December 9, 2003. 2

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 4 of4 157 of 157

II.

DEFENDANTS KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA AND SAUDI HIGH COMMISSION FOR RELIEF OF BOSNIA & HERZEGOVINA 4.

Defendant Kingdom of Saudi Arabia (“the Kingdom” or “Saudi Arabia”) is a

foreign state within the meaning of 28 U.S.C. §1603(a). Saudi Arabia maintains an Embassy within the United States at 601 New Hampshire Avenue, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20037. 5.

Defendant Saudi High Commission for Relief of Bosnia & Herzegovina (“Saudi

High Commission” or “SHC”) is a controlled agent and alter-ego of the government of Saudi Arabia. Although the Saudi High Commission has its headquarters in the Kingdom, its operations are conducted primarily outside of Saudi Arabia. As the SHC has itself acknowledged in affidavit testimony submitted of record in these proceedings, “[a]ctions undertaken by the Saudi High Commission may be viewed as actions of the government of Saudi Arabia.” The acts and conduct of the SHC are thus attributable to the Kingdom for purposes of both subject matter jurisdiction under the FSIA and liability. III.

JURISDICTION 6.

The jurisdiction of this Court for the claims against Saudi Arabia and the SHC is

invoked pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1330, as the claims against those defendants fall within the exception to foreign sovereign immunity set forth at 28 U.S.C. §1605(a)(5), the non-commercial tort exception of the FSIA. 7.

Venue in this district is proper inasmuch as the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict

Litigation (“JPML”) assigned the cases to this district for purposes of MDL management, and pursuant to 28 U.S.C. §§ 1391(b)(2) and 1391(f)(1), as a substantial part of the events giving rise to the claims asserted herein occurred in this district. IV.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND 8.

On September 11, 2001, nineteen members of the al Qaeda terrorist organization,

fifteen of whom were citizens of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, hijacked four commercial airliners, and used those planes as weapons in a coordinated terrorist attack upon the United States and its citizens (the “September 11th Attacks”).

3

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 5 of5 157 of 157

9.

The September 11th Attacks resulted in the tragic loss of several thousand lives,

personal injuries to countless other persons, and property damage on a catastrophic scale, including the complete destruction of the World Trade Center Complex. 10.

To al Qaeda and its adherents and supporters, the September 11th Attacks

represented a single targeted operational strike, carried out as part of a broader and long ongoing campaign to wage jihad against the United States. 11.

The success of al Qaeda’s jihadist campaign, including the September 11th

Attacks themselves, was made possible by the lavish sponsorship al Qaeda received from its material sponsors and supporters, including the Kingdom and SHC, over more than a decade leading up to September 11, 2001. 12.

As further detailed below, the Kingdom and the SHC provided material support to

al Qaeda with knowledge of al Qaeda’s intent to conduct terrorist attacks against the United States, and an awareness that al Qaeda would use the support provided by the Kingdom and SHC to achieve that objective, a goal al Qaeda has tragically realized on numerous occasions, including on September 11, 2001. 13.

As further detailed below, the support provided by the Kingdom and SHC enabled

al Qaeda to obtain the global strike capabilities necessary to carry out the September 11th Attacks, and was essential to the success of those attacks. Indeed, the material support provided by agents of the Kingdom, all of which is attributable to the Kingdom itself, included direct assistance to the September 11th plotters and hijackers. 14.

Absent the support provided by the Kingdom and SHC, al Qaeda would not have

possessed the capacity to conceive, plan and execute the September 11th Attacks. V.

THE ORIGINS OF AL QAEDA 15.

Al Qaeda has its origins in the jihad against the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan,

although the ideological foundation for the al Qaeda movement long pre-dates that conflict.

4

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 6 of6 157 of 157

16.

The Soviet invasion of Afghanistan served as a rallying point for Islamic

extremists in the Middle East, who flocked to Afghanistan to wage jihad against the Soviet Union. 17.

Osama bin Laden travelled to Afghanistan in 1980 to participate in the jihad, and

gained prominence during this period for his role in establishing the financial and logistical infrastructure that sustained the Arab-Afghan fighters, commonly referred to as the mujahideen. According to the Final Report of the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States (the “9/11 Commission”): Bin Ladin understood better than most of the volunteers the extent to which the continuation and eventual success of the jihad in Afghanistan depended on an increasingly complex, almost worldwide organization. This organization included a financial support network that came to be known as the “the Golden Chain,” put together mainly by financiers in Saudi Arabia and Persian Gulf states. Donations flowed through charities and other nongovernmental organizations (NGOs). Bin Ladin and the “Afghan Arabs” drew largely on funds raised by this network, whose agents roamed world markets to buy arms and supplies for the mujahideen or “holy warriors.” 18.

Together with Abdullah Azzam, bin Laden founded the Maktab al Khidmat (“the

Office of Services”) to facilitate the provision of financial and logistical support to the mujahideen. 19.

Throughout the Afghan jihad, Maktab al Khidmat worked in concert with a

network of purported charities and relief organizations (including among others the Muslim World League (“MWL”), International Islamic Relief Organization (“IIRO”), World Assembly of Muslim Youth (“WAMY”), Al Haramain Islamic Foundation (“al Haramain”), Rabita Trust, Saudi Red Crescent Society (“SRC”), and Benevolence International Foundation (“BIF”)) to provide travel documents, funds, transportation, training, facilities, arms, physical assets, and other support to the mujahideen.

5

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 7 of7 157 of 157

20.

This network of ostensible charities and relief organizations established a vast

financial and logistical infrastructure to support the mujahideen opposition to the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan. 21.

At the conclusion of the Afghan jihad, bin Laden determined that the network

that supported the mujahideen in Afghanistan should not be abandoned, but rather adapted to serve as a foundation for waging a global jihad against all of the perceived enemies of Islam, and in particular, the United States. April 19, 1988 brought victory for the Afghan jihad. Moscow declared it would pull its military forces out of Afghanistan within the next nine months. As the Soviets began its withdraw, the jihad’s leaders debated what to do next. Bin Ladin (and Abdullah Azzam) agreed that the organization successfully created for Afghanistan should not be allowed to dissolve. They established what they called a base or foundation (al Qaida) as a potential general headquarters for future jihad. 9/11 Report at p. 56 VI.

AL QAEDA’S OBJECTIVES AND TACTICS 22.

In establishing al Qaeda in 1988, bin Laden sought to create a multi-national

Islamic army to challenge the perceived domination of the democratic West, and to engage in armed combat wherever Muslim communities were perceived to be under duress, in furtherance of the ultimate objective of establishing a Pan-Islamic Caliphate. 23.

Al Qaeda employs a range of operational tactics and initiatives in the pursuit of its

goals, which complement one another as part of a carefully conceived and coordinated global strategy. 24.

Although high profile terrorist attacks are an important aspect of that campaign, al

Qaeda has historically devoted a significant portion of its vast resources to military campaigns in conflict regions, and to supporting and fostering regional jihadist organizations and Islamic separatist movements throughout the World.

6

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 8 of8 157 of 157

25.

In this context, al Qaeda has been deeply involved in regional jihad campaigns,

involving both traditional forms of combat and terrorist activities, in Bosnia, Chechnya, Kosovo, Sudan, Kashmir, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Iraq, Turkey, Indonesia, Malaysia, Algeria, the Philippines, Somalia, Palestine, Yemen, Kenya, Tanzania and Egypt. 26.

Al Qaeda’s participation in these regional conflicts has taken many forms. Al

Qaeda provides funding and logistical assistance to local extremist and terrorist organizations, in support of their military and terrorist activities. In addition, al Qaeda deploys its own members to fight in these conflicts, train new volunteers, and assist in the planning and execution of terrorist attacks. 27.

Through its engagement in these regional jihad campaigns, al Qaeda aims to

establish and support radical Islamic regimes and extend its sphere of influence, as critical components of its long-term objective to eradicate democratic societies and establish a panIslamic Caliphate. 28.

In describing the importance of these regional military campaigns within the

overall context of al Qaeda’s jihad against the West, a 1998 Department of Defense Intelligence Report states as follows: [al Qaeda] seeks to establish a worldwide Islamic state capable of directly challenging the US, China, Russia, and what it views as judeo-Christian and Confucian domination. The means by which the above goals are to be met are via terror, ethnic cleansing, “latent penetration” (NEI), and control over nuclear and biological weapons (Jikhad). Further, radical Islamic (predominantly Sunni) regimes are to be established and supported everywhere possible, including Bosnia, Albania, Chechnya, Dagestan, the entire northern Caucasus “from Sea to Sea,” central Asian Republics, Tatarstan, Bashkortostan, all of Russia, Afghanistan, Pakistan, Turkey, Indonesia, Malaysia, Algeria, Morocco, Egypt, Tunisia, Sudan, and the states of the Persian Gulf. 29.

In addition to the value its participation in regional military conflicts yields in

relation to its long-term strategic objectives, al Qaeda’s participation in these regional jihad

7

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 9 of9 157 of 157

campaigns also enabled al Qaeda to acquire the global infrastructure needed to plan and execute sophisticated international terrorist attacks, including the September 11th Attacks themselves. 30.

Al Qaeda’s military operations bolster the organization’s image among local

Muslims, thereby facilitating al Qaeda’s ongoing recruiting and fundraising efforts. These campaigns also afford the organization an efficient vehicle to provide new members with battle experience, in preparation for terrorist operations and the ongoing military conflict with the United States. In addition, al Qaeda’s financial and operational support for local Islamist and separatist movements has allowed al Qaeda to co-opt local conflicts and organizations to its own ends. As a result, many pre-existing terror and extremist organizations evolved into al Qaeda proxies, thereby extending al Qaeda’s operational capabilities, resources, and sphere of influence. 31.

Al Qaeda’s participation in such regional conflicts and jihad campaigns fueled al

Qaeda’s growth and development in the years leading up to the September 11th Attacks. Indeed, according to the 9/11 Commission, al Qaeda’s operational involvement in regional conflicts between 1988 and 1998 served to establish the organization as the vanguard of the global jihadist movement, and directly enhanced al Qaeda’s operational capacity to carry out large scale terrorist attacks: By the time he issued his February 19, 1998 declaration of war, bin Ladin had nurtured (the al Qaeda) organization for nearly ten (10) years. He could attract, train, and use recruits for ever more ambitious attacks, rallying new adherents with each demonstration that his was the movement of the future. 9/11 Report at p. 55. 32.

The findings of the 9/11 Commission further confirm that al Qaeda relied heavily

on its global infrastructure in planning, coordinating and staging the September 11th Attacks, and that al Qaeda could not have successfully mounted those Attacks absent the impressive resources and assets amassed by the organization over the thirteen years preceding the Attacks.

8

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 10 10 of 157 of 157

33.

In this regard, the 9/11 Commission found that the “9/11 attack was a complex

international operation, the product of years of planning.” The 9/11 Report confirms that plans for the Attacks were carefully vetted through al Qaeda’s most senior leadership over a period of nearly six years, while those leaders were safely ensconced in training camps and safe houses funded by al Qaeda’s financial supporters; that the individuals selected to participate in the Attacks were chosen from an enormous pool of potential candidates, all of whom were recruited, trained, and indoctrinated with funds provided by the organization’s supporters; and that details of the plans were revised up until the last minute, through a sophisticated global communication network capable of evading the surveillance and intelligence operations of the United States and its allies, the development and existence of which was also dependent on the financial sponsorship of al Qaeda’s supporters. 34.

Based on the findings of its investigation concerning the relationship between al

Qaeda’s global infrastructure and the organization’s operational capability to plan, coordinate and mount the September 11th Attacks, the 9/11 Commission reached the following conclusions regarding the basic organizational requirements for staging a sophisticated terrorist attack: A complex international terrorist operation aimed at launching a catastrophic attack cannot be mounted by just anyone in any place. Such operations appear to require Time, space, and ability to perform competent planning and staff work; A command structure able to make necessary decisions and possessing the authority and contacts to assemble needed people, money, and materials; Opportunity and space to recruit, train, and select operatives with the needed skills and dedication, providing the time and structure required to socialize them into the terrorist cause, judge their trustworthiness, and hone their skills; A logistics network able to securely manage the travel of operatives, move money, and transport resources (like explosives) where they need to go;

9

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 11 11 of 157 of 157

Access, in the case of certain weapons, to the special materials needed for a nuclear, chemical, radiological, or biological attack; Reliable communications between coordinators and operatives; and Opportunity to test the workability of the plan. 35.

Consistent with the findings of the 9/11 Commission, U.S. counter-terrorism

officials have repeatedly affirmed the critical importance of al Qaeda’s broader infrastructure and resources to its capacity to conceive, plan, coordinate, and successfully conduct sophisticated terrorist attacks, including the September 11th Attacks, as reflected by the following statements: There are some who question the effectiveness of our strategy to prevent terrorism by attacking the financing that supports it. They note that terrorist attacks themselves cost very little money to carry out – the trivial cost of a suicide belt or similar device – and then leap to the conclusion that our efforts to combat terrorism by attacking terrorist resources are wasted or futile. The 9/11 Commission wisely rejected this point of view. In the first place, the cost of financing terrorist activity cannot be measured by the cost of a primitive destructive act. The maintenance of those terrorist networks, like al Qaeda, which threaten our national security, is expensive – even if a particular attack does not cost much to carry out. As the 9/11 Commission explained, groups like al Qaeda must spend money for many purposes – to recruit, train, plan operations, and bribe corrupt officials for example. If we can eliminate or even reduce their sources and conduits of money, we can degrade their ability to do all of these things, and thus can make them less dangerous. Testimony of Stuart A. Levey, Undersecretary of Terrorism and Financial Intelligence, August 23, 2004. As this Committee knows well, tracking and combating terrorist financing are critical facets of our overall efforts to protect our citizens and other innocents around the World from terrorist attacks…. While any single terrorist attack may be relatively inexpensive to carry out, terrorist groups continue to need real money. They depend on a regular cash flow to pay operatives and their families, arrange for travel, train new members, forge documents, pay bribes, acquire weapons and stage attacks. Disrupting money flows stresses terrorist networks and undermines their operations. In recent months, we have seen at least one

10

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 12 12 of 157 of 157

instance of what we look for most – a terrorist organization indicating that it could not pursue sophisticated attacks because it lacks adequate funding. Testimony of Stuart Levey, Undersecretary of Terrorism and Financial Intelligence, before the House Financial Services Subcommittee on Oversight and Investigations, July 11, 2006. (T)errorist organizations require significant funding. Although individual terrorist attack may be inexpensive, terrorist organizations require far more than explosives to sustain themselves. They need money to train, recruit, pay operatives and their families, travel, bribe officials, procure cover and false documents, as well as purchase arms. If implemented effectively, targeted financial sanctions can put terrorist organizations in a financial box, effectively depriving them of the resources they need to conduct this range of activity. Prepared remarks of Daniel L. Glaser, Acting Assistant Secretary for Terrorist Financing and Financial Crimes before the Annual Meetings Program of Seminars: The Importance of Expanding Targeted Financial Transactions Programs Around the Globe: Challenges and Opportunities, September 23, 2005. The primary reason why combating the financing of terrorism efforts are both necessary and important is that terrorist groups need money. Although mounting an individual terrorist attack is relatively inexpensive, the cost to maintain the infrastructure to support terrorist activities is high. Terrorist networks need cash to train, equip and pay operatives, to secure materials and to promote their cause. To eliminate or reduce the cell’s means of raising and transferring funds is to significantly degrade that cell’s capabilities. The Money Trail: Finding, Following and Freezing Terrorist Finances, Michael Jacobsen and Matthew Levitt (Deputy Assistant Secretary for Intelligence and Analysis of the Treasury Department from 2005 – 2007), November 2008, at p. 3. Although manning a terrorist attack is relatively inexpensive, the cost to maintain a terrorist infrastructure is high. Terrorist networks need cash to train, equip and pay operatives and their families and to promote their causes. Recruiting, training, traveling, bribing corrupt officials and other such activities also cost money. Limiting their ability to raise funds therefore limits their ability to function. Follow the Money – The Obama Administration Should Continue to Track How Terrorists get Their Money, Michael J. Jacobsen and Matthew Levitt, December 23, 2008

11

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 13 13 of 157 of 157

36.

Given the financial needs of terrorist organizations, as documented above,

Congress has concluded that money is the lifeblood of terrorism, and that any contribution to a terrorist organization furthers acts of terrorism. The State Department has affirmed in proceedings before the United States Supreme Court that “[t]he experience and analysis of the U.S. government agencies charged with combating terrorism strongly suppor[t]” Congress’s findings on those points. VII.

THE MEANS THROUGH WHICH AL QAEDA BUILT AND SUSTAINS ITS GLOBAL INFRASTRUCTURE 37.

Given the infrastructural requirements inherent in al Qaeda’s mission to wage

jihad globally, and its ambitious goal to stage spectacular international terrorist attacks against the United States as a component of that mission, the development and sustainment of the al Qaeda organization required massive funding on an ongoing basis over a period of many years, through secure and reliable channels. 38.

Indeed, in the wake of the September 11th Attacks, U.S. counter-terrorism

officials estimated that al Qaeda required $35 million annually to sustain the infrastructure that supported the September 11th Attacks, a view that was endorsed by the 9/11 Commission as well. 39.

To realize these immense fundraising needs, al Qaeda simply and ingeniously

adapted the network developed during the Afghan jihad, relying from its inception on Islamic da’awa organizations (frequently described inaccurately as “charities”) to fuel its growth and development. 40.

As the United Nations Security Council Committee concerning al Qaeda and the

Taliban succinctly explained: From its inception, al-Qaida has relied heavily on charities and donations from its sympathizers to finance its activities. Charities provide al-Qaida with a very useful international channel for soliciting, collecting, transferring and distributing the funds it needs for indoctrination, recruitment, training, and logistical and operational support. These funds are often merged with and hidden among funds used for other legitimate humanitarian or social programs. Al-Qaida supporters and financiers have also

12

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 14 14 of 157 of 157

established front charity networks whose main purpose is to raise and deliver funds to al-Qaida. The roots of these charity networks stem from the anti-Soviet Jihad in Afghanistan during the last 1980s. During that time, al-Qaida could draw on a number of state-assisted charities and other deep pocket donors that supported the anti-Soviet cause. Today, al-Qaida continues to rely heavily on those charities to facilitate and mask the collection and movement of its funds. 41.

The 9/11 Commission’s Staff Monograph on terrorist financing similarly

concluded that “al Qaeda was funded, to the tune of approximately $30 million per year, by diversions of money from Islamic charities.” 42.

Purported charities provide an attractive mechanism for al Qaeda to raise and

launder funds for a variety of reasons. Unlike for-profit organizations, charitable funds are meant to move in one direction only, meaning that large purported charitable transfers can move without any corresponding return of value. In addition, charities are often cash intensive, and frequently have considerable access to funds. Charities with global operations offer an infrastructure for international transactions, often within or near areas that present strategic opportunities for terrorist activity and recruitment. Further, the legitimate relief work carried out by charities related to terrorist organizations allows terrorists to generate recruitment, financial, and other support for their causes and assists terrorists in propagating violent and extremist ideologies. 43.

Although al Qaeda has in limited instances established its own charities to serve

as channels of support for particular initiatives, al Qaeda’s development into a sophisticated global terrorist network was fueled primarily by the massive support it received from purported charities acting as agents and alter-egos of the government of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, many of which worked with the al Qaeda leadership during the Afghan jihad. These governmental agents have served as the primary conduits for channeling financial, logistical, operational, and ideological support for al Qaeda’s global jihad for more than twenty years. To this day, many of these arms of the Saudi government remain dedicated to promoting al Qaeda’s

13

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 15 15 of 157 of 157

goals and operational objectives, and continue to play a singular role in propagating the violent and virulently anti-Western ideology that provides religious legitimacy for al Qaeda’s terrorist activities and draws new adherents to al Qaeda’s cause. 44.

Although representing themselves to the West as traditional “charities” or

“humanitarian organizations,” these organizations are more accurately described as Islamic da’awa organizations, created by the government of the Kingdom to propagate a radical strain of Islam throughout the World, commonly referred to as Wahhabism. 45.

Under the direction of the Saudi government, and especially the Kingdom’s

Ministry of Islamic Affairs, these organizations have aggressively pressed the view that Western society, under the leadership of the United States, is conducting a coordinated “Western Cultural Attack” (Ghazu Fikari in Arabic) on Islam, designed to destroy the fabric of Muslim society as a predicate for Western conquest of Muslim territories. 46.

These organizations fervently believe that this so-called “Western Cultural

Attack” (and other perceived or imagined threats to Islam) must be aggressively countered through jihad and worldwide indoctrination into Wahhabi Islam, a strategy the Kingdom has promoted and implemented through government agencies, state controlled media, government sponsored publications, and a variety of other channels. 47.

Consistent with this view, the Saudi government controlled charities have

embraced al Qaeda (an organization founded on the same Wahhabi ideology the Kingdom’s da’awa organizations were established to propagate) and its affiliates as partners, and actively supported al Qaeda’s global jihad at every level, from the organization’s inception. 48.

These so-called charities, including among others the MWL, IIRO, SHC,

WAMY, BIF, Al Haramain Islamic Foundation (“Al Haramain”), Saudi Red Crescent Society (“SRC”), Saudi Joint Relief Committee (“SJRC”), and Al Haramain al Masjil al Aqsa have provided the vast majority of the funding that allowed al Qaeda to build and sustain its massive global infrastructure over the thirteen years leading up to the September 11th Attacks. Beyond their massive financial sponsorship of al Qaeda’s global jihad, the Saudi government charities 14

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 16 16 of 157 of 157

have been intimately involved in all aspects of al Qaeda’s operations, and allowed al Qaeda to use their infrastructures and resources as platforms for carrying out jihad. As further detailed herein, the Saudi government controlled charities have: (1) raised and laundered funds on behalf of Islamic terrorist organizations and associated separatist movements, including al Qaeda; (2) channeled donated funds to Islamic terrorist organizations, fighters and associated separatist movements, including al Qaeda; (3) provided financial and logistical support and physical assets to Islamic fighters and terrorists, including al Qaeda; (4) directly participated in al Qaeda’s terrorist activities, including the planning, coordination, funding and execution of terrorist attacks; (5) permitted Islamic fighters and terrorists, including al Qaeda members, to use ostensible employment with their organizations as a vehicle for gaining access to conflict regions, thereby allowing those individuals to carry out militant and terrorist activities in those areas; (6) performed reconnaissance within conflict regions on behalf of Islamic terrorist organizations and separatist movements, including al Qaeda; (7) served as liaisons to localized terrorist organizations on behalf of al Qaeda, thereby assisting al Qaeda in expanding its operational base and sphere of influence; (8) funded and facilitated shipments of arms and supplies to Islamic terrorist organizations and associated separatist movements, including al Qaeda; (9) funded camps used by al Qaeda and associated jihadist organizations to train soldiers and terrorists, including camps used to train the September 11th hijackers; (10) actively recruited new members for Islamic terrorist organizations and associated separatist movements, including al Qaeda; (11) worked throughout the World to spread al Qaeda’s jihadist ideology and draw new adherents to its cause; (12) served as channels for distributing information and documentation within Islamic terrorist organizations and associated separatist movements, including al Qaeda, and from Islamic terrorist organizations and separatist movements to the media; (13) disseminated publications designed to advance al Qaeda’s radical Islamist ideology throughout the Muslim world and legitimize violent jihad against Christians and Jews on the grounds that they are “infidels” who do not deserve to live; and (14) openly advocated for young Muslims to take up arms against Western and democratic societies, including the United States. 15

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 17 17 of 157 of 157

VIII. THE HISTORICAL CONTEXT OF SAUDI ARABIA’S SUPPORT FOR AL QAEDA 49.

The emergence of al Qaeda and the global Sunni jihadist movement under the

patronage and stewardship of the Saudi government charities is rooted in the origins of the Saudi state itself, and the unique relationship between the House of Saud and Wahhabi Islam. 50.

The modern Saudi state is a product of a pact forged in the 18th century between

Muhammad Ibn al Saud, the head of the al Saud tribe in Arabia, and Muhammad Ibn Abd al Wahhab, a Muslim scholar from the Najd region of Arabia. 51.

Ibn Abd al Wahhab’s ideas and teachings form the basis of the Islamic school of

thought commonly known as Wahhabism, which forms the ideological foundation for the al Qaeda movement. According to the National Commission on Terrorist Attacks Upon the United States, al Qaeda finds inspiration and religious justification for its actions “in a long tradition of intolerance” that flows “through the founders of Wahhabism.” 52.

In the late 1730’s, Ibn Abd al Wahhab began a campaign to impose a puritanical

Islamic rule in the Najd region, zealously preaching and writing against Shia Islam as well as the “popular” practices of many Sunni Muslims. 53.

In furtherance of his goal to establish broad rule pursuant to Wahhabi doctrine,

and to eradicate Islamic practices he deemed deviant or improper, Ibn Abd al Wahhab sought out an alliance with a political and military leader. 54.

In 1744 Ibn Abd al Wahhab achieved that goal, when he swore a traditional

Muslim oath with Ibn al Saud, pursuant to which they promised to work together to establish a state run according to Islamic law (Shariah). 55.

The pact with Ibn Abd al Wahhab provided religious legitimacy and justification

for Ibn al Saud’s political authority, and offered Ibn Abd al Wahhab political and military resources to compel adherence to Wahhabi religious doctrine by force. 56.

In keeping with the pact forged with Ibn Abd al Wahhab, Ibn al Saud began

leading his armies in a campaign to eradicate Islamic practices deemed deviant by Ibn Ab Wahhab, and to establish Wahhabi Islamic rule throughout the Najd region of Arabia. 16

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 18 18 of 157 of 157

57.

Over the ensuing century, the decedents of Ibn al Saud and Ibn Abd al Wahhab

sustained and reinforced their politico-religious alliance, even as the political fortunes of the Saud clan waned. 58.

With the aid of a movement of fervent Wahhabi fundamentalists known as the

Ikhwan, the House of Saud mounted a military offensive in the early 20th Century under the leadership of Abd al Aziz, which succeeded in uniting much of the Arabian Peninsula under Saudi rule, culminating in the establishment of the modern Saudi state. 59.

Upon taking control of Mecca and Medina, Abd al Aziz assumed the title Khadim

al Haramain (servant of the Two Shrines), thus reaffirming the religious precondition and justification for the House of Saud’s political authority. 60.

During the early years of the Saudi state, the Kingdom’s affairs were governed

pursuant to a generalized power-sharing agreement between the House of Saud and the Wahhabi Ulema (Islamic Religious Leaders), under which the Saudi kings and princes controlled political and financial decisions, while the Ulema governed religious and judicial affairs, including the issuance of fatwas (religious edicts that judged the compatibility of temporal decisions with Islamic law). 61.

In the early period of the Saudi state, the balance of power tipped heavily in favor

of the House of Saud, largely because the King appointed the Ulema to their positions, and retained largely unchecked authority to dismiss them from their posts. 62.

However, in the last three decades of the 20th Century, several developments

occurred that fundamentally transformed Saudi society, leading to a massive investment by the Kingdom in the promotion of Islamic extremism as an accommodation to the Ulema, and the establishment of new ministries and governmental agencies that afforded the Ulema direct access to government resources and platforms to advance its Islamist and jihadist causes, including through the direct support of al Qaeda and the September 11th Attacks.

17

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 19 19 of 157 of 157

63.

First, the oil boom of the 1970s thrust the Kingdom into the modern era, a

development that created tension between the regime and Ulema, given the latter’s deep animosity and resistance to modernization and technological advancements. 64.

In order to gain the approval of the Ulema for modernization essential to the

exploration and development of Saudi Arabia’s oil reserves, and thereby maintain the Ulema’s endorsement of the legitimacy of the regime’s rule, the regime embedded the Ulema in the Kingdom’s developing administrative and bureaucratic systems, thereby further integrating the Ulema into the power structure of the Saudi state. 65.

In addition, the regime channeled resources from its new-found oil wealth to

support the religious goals and priorities of the Wahhabi Ulema. In this setting, the Kingdom increased the funding of existing organizations like the Muslim World League, and created a host of new da’awa organizations, to promote the propagation of Wahhabi Islam and the establishment of states governed pursuant to Shariah outside of Saudi Arabia. 66.

Although these accommodations succeeded in appeasing certain segments of the

Ulema, an emerging group of clerics and scholars, largely influenced by prominent members of the Muslim Brotherhood who fled Egypt and were welcomed by Saudi Arabia and given prominent positions in the Kingdom’s state controlled Islamic universities and mosques, became increasingly wary of the modernization of Saudi society. These religious scholars were especially discontented by the perceived failure of the Saudi state to adequately apply its newfound wealth to the service of Wahhabi Islam, the failure of the Saudi government to support Islamist movements throughout the world, the absence of a banking system adhering to principles of Shariah, and the un-Islamic excesses of the Saudi royals themselves. 67.

In the face of modernization, these Sheikhs increasingly advocated that the

Ummah (the Muslim community throughout the globe) were under a sophisticated cultural and intellectual attack organized by the West, the objective of which was to destroy the fabric of Muslim society as a precursor to a Western re-conquest of the Middle East, and the subordination of Muslims to Western faiths and values. In this context, the Saudi Ulema did not 18

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 20 20 of 157 of 157

differentiate between the United States and Communist Russia, advocating that the two “superpowers” were but opposite sides of the same coin, and that both were enemies of Islam. 68.

In 1979, three events occurred that empowered these members of the Ulema, and

provided a platform for them to press their worldview. 69.

In January of 1979, the Shah of Iran fled his country in response to popular

protests, leading to the establishment shortly thereafter of a Shia’h Islamic regime in Iran, a direct threat to the Saudi state’s then perceived hegemony as the preeminent “Islamic” nation in the world. To the Saudi Ulema, who viewed as heretical the version of Islam espoused by the Iranian clergy, the Iranian Revolution presented a threat to Islam itself, to be countered at all costs. 70.

Shortly thereafter, on November 20, 1979, a group of armed insurgents stormed

and took control of the Grand Mosque in Mecca, the holiest site of Islam. The insurgents were led by Juhaiman ibn Muhhamed ibn Saif al Utaibi, a member of a powerful Saudi family and student of Sheikh Abdel Aziz bin Baz, a revered member of the Ulema who would later become the Grand Mufti of Saudi Arabia, the Kingdom’s supreme religious leader. 71.

Broadcasting throughout Mecca over the Grand Mosque’s speakers during a siege

that lasted for several weeks, the jihadists asserted that the House of Saud had lost its legitimacy through corruption and imitation of the West, and called for a purification of Islam and the absolute repudiation of modernizing influences. 72.

Because any violence within the Grand Mosque is strictly forbidden by Islamic

law, the Saudi regime was paralyzed from taking action to oust the jihadists from the Grand Mosque without a formal fatwa from the senior Ulema authorizing force, a reality that underscored the increasing influence and power of the Ulema within the modernizing Kingdom. 73.

After the senior Ulema issued a fatwa authorizing the use of deadly force to retake

the Grand Mosque, Saudi forces under the command of senior members of the Royal family mounted several offensives to oust the jihadists, but were repelled and suffered massive casualties in a series of embarrassing clashes. In the end, the regime had to turn the entire 19

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 21 21 of 157 of 157

mission over to the Pakistani military, which then carried out a successful operation to reclaim the Grand Mosque. 74.

The regime’s inability to protect and recapture the Grand Mosque on its own

further undermined the legitimacy of its rule, requiring greater reliance by the House of Saud on the continuing support of the Ulema, and compelling the regime to find new ways to bolster its Islamic credentials within the Muslim world. 75.

On the heels of the Grand Mosque siege, the Soviet army invaded Afghanistan on

December 27, 1979. For the Ulema who had been cautioning against the Western Cultural Attack, the invasion validated their thesis, and offered a compelling platform for promoting their Islamist agenda. 76.

In response to the invasion, Abdullah Azzam, a Palestinian member of the

Muslim Brotherhood who fled to Saudi Arabia and was appointed by the government of the Kingdom to a prominent lecturing position at the King Abdul Aziz University in Jeddah, issued a fatwa entitled Defense of the Muslim Land, in which he declared it the personal obligation of all Muslims to wage jihad against the Russians in Afghanistan and the Israelis in Palestine. 77.

Azzam’s fatwa was endorsed by Sheikh bin Baz and the senior Saudi Ulema,

which endorsement necessarily required the approval of the Saudi regime. 78.

In response to the Ulema’s call for jihad, the most radical young Saudis – many of

whom were graduates of the Kingdom’s new religious universities and had been indoctrinated into Wahhabi jihadist ideology by members of the Ulema who taught at those universities – flocked to Afghanistan to join the mujahideen. 79.

As discussed above, Osama bin Laden was among the Saudis who went to

Afghanistan to wage jihad during this time period, and worked closely with Abdullah Azzam in organizing the infrastructure to support the mujahideen fighters. 80.

For the Saudi government, the Afghan jihad presented an opportunity to restore

the Kingdom’s Islamic credentials. By supporting the jihad, the regime could portray itself to the Muslim world as a leading force in the defense of the Ummah against the Western Attack, 20

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 22 22 of 157 of 157

without requiring that the Kingdom directly intervene in the conflict. At the same time, the jihad drew the most radicalized young Saudis away from the Kingdom, thus limiting the ideological and security threat they posed to the regime. 81.

The Kingdom seized on the opportunity, mobilizing and deploying its vast da’awa

infrastructure to support the jihad. Under the guise of performing humanitarian work, Saudi government controlled organizations, including among others the MWL, IIRO, WAMY, SRC, and Rabita Trust established an efficient network to channel support to the mujahideen fighters. Pursuant to fatwas issued by the Saudi Ulema and under the direction of the Saudi government, these organizations recruited new volunteers for the conflict, established safe houses for new recruits arriving in the region, provided false documentation to the fighters and otherwise assisted them in gaining entry to the conflict zone, supported training camps for the fighters, purchased and delivered weapons and equipment to the mujahideen, raised funds to support the jihad, performed reconnaissance for military initiatives, and evacuated wounded jihadists. 82.

In connection with its support of the Afghan jihad, the government of the

Kingdom appointed a young Saudi jihadist named Wa’el Jelaidan to serve as Director of the SRC in Pakistan in 1986. Jelaidan served in that position until the Kingdom appointed him as the Director of the MWL/IIRO offices in Peshawar, Pakistan in 1989. Prior to those appointments, Jelaidan had served for several years as the Director of the Islamic Center of Tucson, the de facto office of Makhtab al Khidmat in the United States. Jelaidan developed close ties to bin Laden during the Afghan jihad, and as detailed below would go on to become a founding member of al Qaeda. 83.

Bin Laden and Jelaidan were joined in their organizing efforts by another young

Saudi named Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, who would later become bin Laden’s brother-in-law. Khalifa and bin Laden had become close friends while studying together at King Abdulaziz University, where they became further radicalized by government-paid religious scholars. The two joined the Afghan jihad together, and Khalifa excelled at recruiting volunteers to the cause from throughout the world, including over 100 Philippino Muslims, among them Abdulrak 21

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 23 23 of 157 of 157

Janjalani. Following the Afghan jihad, Janjalani was selected by Khalifa and al Qaeda to head Abu Sayyaf Group, a Philippine proxy for al Qaeda established by Khalifa using funds and resources of the International Islamic Relief Organization. 84.

After nine years of combat, in 1988, the Soviet army began withdrawing from

Afghanistan, delivering the Afghan mujahideen and young jihadists a stunning victory. 85.

To the leaders of the Afghan jihad, the defeat of the Soviets demonstrated the

divine supremacy of their Islamist movement, and reinforced their belief that the United States could be defeated by guerilla warfare and terrorism. By virtue of their unwavering belief in the Western Cultural Attack narrative, this group viewed waging jihad against the United States as an absolute religious duty and imperative, and established al Qaeda in 1988 for that purpose. 86.

Around this same time, bin Laden returned to Saudi Arabia to fulfill his

responsibilities and duties relative to the bin Laden family construction empire, which through a reorganization in 1989 became known as Saudi Binladen Group, and began organizing al Qaeda and planning for the next phase of the global jihad. 87.

From the outset, the Saudi regime was aware of bin Laden’s ongoing efforts to

organize a mujahideen army to conduct jihad throughout the world, and in particular bin Laden’s desire to wage jihad against the United States. 88.

Indeed, during a February 13, 2006 speech at the Council on Foreign Relations,

Prince Turki al Faisal al Saud, the Saudi Intelligence Chief from 1977 through September 1, 2001, stated that “we [the Saudi regime] were pretty much aware of bin Laden from the very beginning, if you like.” Turki confirmed that he personally met with bin Laden after the conclusion of the Afghan jihad, and that bin Laden presented himself at that time as the leader of a jihad army, recounting as follows: I met Osama bin Laden five times in my life as intelligence director. Mid-’80s to end of 1989 or beginning of 1990 was the last time I saw him. And when the withdrawal of Soviet troops in Afghanistan occurred, bin Laden and his supporters within Afghanistan—and by the way, that’s where al Qaeda was born. As I like to—prefer to say, the al Qaeda was born in the hills of 22

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 24 24 of 157 of 157

Afghanistan rather than in the deserts of Saudi Arabia. And they decided that they were going to form a group that will, in their view, protect Muslim interests throughout the world as they identified themselves as being the primary claimants to the credit of driving the Soviets out of Afghanistan. And so, by 1990 when I last saw him at the beginning of that year, he had come to me with a proposition that he wants to bring his Mujaheddin as he called them, to liberate the then-Marxist regime in south Yemen. 89.

Moreover, bin Laden made no effort to conceal his jihadist ambitions in public

speeches within the Kingdom during this period. Upon returning from Afghanistan, bin Laden was greeted as a hero by the Saudi populace, who were astonished that a wealthy member of the Saudi elite had risked his life to carry out jihad. Bin Laden was in great demand to give speeches and interviews, and made clear in his statements his continuing dedication to jihad against the perceived enemies of Islam. 90.

Speaking in 1988, bin Laden expressly affirmed what he believed to be the

personal obligation of all Muslims to wage jihad against the enemies of Islam, stating as follows: the blessing of jihad in the cause of God – the peak of true Islam, which people in this age have forgotten is a religious duty….Praise be to God for allowing us to perform jihad in Afghanistan as he did for the best of men, our Prophet, may God’s peace and prayers be upon him…I would like to advise my brother Muslims in all parts of the East and West to take the initiative and leave what they are doing to assist in raising the banner of jihad for the cause of God. This banner is the best banner and the mujahidin are the best people…May God accept our and your prayers and our urging of believers to perform jihad in order to deter the infidel forces and be truthful. 91.

Speaking in 1990 to an audience of hundreds in the Bin Laden family mosque in

Jeddah, bin Laden singled out the United States as the primary target of this global jihad, asserting that “[t]he Americans won’t stop their support of Jews in Palestine until we give them a lot of blows. They won’t stop until we do jihad against them.”

23

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 25 25 of 157 of 157

92.

In that same year, bin Laden organized and funded the travel of an estimated

4,000 mujahideen fighters to Afghanistan for training, as part of his ongoing efforts to build his jihadist army. 93.

To the regime, neither bin Laden’s status as an organizational leader of a jihad

movement nor his ambition to target America were at all surprising. The Saudi government was intimately familiar with bin Laden’s role as a logistical, financial and operational organizer of the Afghan jihad, and the Saudi regime knew well that the young radicals who had travelled to Afghanistan to wage jihad had no intention of abandoning the cause. Through its security apparatus, the government of the Kingdom closely monitored the activities of the returning mujahideen, chief among them bin Laden, to ensure that their jihadist fervor remained focused on targets outside of the Kingdom. The Kingdom also knew that several of the chief organizers of the Afghan jihad network (including Jelaidan and Khalifa) remained embedded in senior positions within the Saudi government da’awa infrastructure, and therefore had access to that infrastructure in relation to their ongoing jihadist efforts. More fundamentally, the jihadist worldview bin Laden was promoting was firmly grounded in Wahhabi ideology and the Western Cultural Attack narrative, as promoted by the Saudi Ulema (and Kingdom itself) over a period of many years. In simple terms, the Saudi regime had unique access to information concerning bin Laden’s jihadist agenda and organizational efforts from the earliest date. Moreover, the House of Saud understood implicitly that the ideological foundation for bin Laden’s global jihadist movement was grounded in the teachings of the Saudi Ulema, and that his jihadist agenda and goals enjoyed widespread support among the Ulema. The Kingdom also was well aware that members of that movement, including broad segments of the Ulema, firmly believed that they owed a religious duty to wage jihad against the United States. 94.

On August 2, 1990, bin Laden’s ongoing efforts to build support for the global

jihad received a transformative boost, when Iraq invaded Kuwait. The invasion of Kuwait by the region’s most sophisticated army posed an imminent threat to the security of the Kingdom.

24

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 26 26 of 157 of 157

95.

At the height of the security crisis, bin Laden again used his prominence and

family’s close ties to the House of Saud to secure a meeting with a senior member of the Saudi royal family, in this case Prince Sultan, the Saudi Minister of Defense. 96.

Accompanied by several mujahideen commanders and veterans of the Afghan

jihad, bin Laden laid out a detailed plan of attack, indicating where trenches and protective measures would be constructed along the border using the Saudi bin Laden Group’s earthmoving equipment. Again making clear his continuing role as an organizer of a jihadist army, bin Laden assured Sultan that he could amass 100,000 mujahideen quickly to defend the Kingdom, drawing primarily on the Arab veterans of the Afghan jihad. 97.

Prince Sultan treated bin Laden with warmth and respect at the meeting, but

rejected bin Laden’s plan out of hand, as did Prince Turki, with whom bin Laden also met. Instead, the Kingdom invited the United States army to Saudi Arabia to protect the Kingdom. 98.

The presence of an infidel crusader army on Saudi soil reinforced and energized

the Western Cultural Attack narrative, and prompted outrage among many prominent Ulema (and bin Laden), who again questioned the legitimacy of the House of Saud’s rule given its inability to protect Islam without foreign assistance. 99.

Recognizing the gravity of the threat to its rule, the Saudi regime prevailed upon

members of the Senior Ulema to issue a fatwa authorizing the presence of U.S. troops on Saudi soil. 100.

The issuance of that fatwa did not, however, appease the majority of the Ulema or

their followers, but rather merely convinced them that some members of the senior religious establishment had been co-opted by the regime, and that decisive action was needed to restore the primacy of Islam within the Kingdom and counter the Western Cultural Attack. 101.

A vibrant movement rapidly spread at mosques and universities within the

Kingdom, demanding the removal of the “crusader” U.S. forces from Muslim soil and advocating for extensive reforms in accordance with Shariah.

25

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 27 27 of 157 of 157

102.

The leaders of this emerging reformist movement were known as the Awakening

Sheiks and included Salman al Awda, a professor of Islamic law at Imam Muhammad bin Saud University in Riyadh, and Safar al-Hawali, the head of the Department of Theology at Umm alQuarra University in Mecca. Al Awda and al Hawali were, not coincidentally, spiritual mentors to bin Laden, and many of bin Laden’s ideas about jihad were derived directly from the teachings of these Saudi government-paid scholars. 103.

In the view of these members of the Ulema, the Iraqi occupation of Kuwait was

itself organized by the United States as a predicate for its occupation of the Muslim world. Hawali in particular theorized that Washington engineered the rift between Iraq and Kuwait, and then encouraged Sadaam Hussein to invade. At that point, Hawali argued that Washington used the pretext of defending Arab states from Iraqi aggression as a predicate for occupying sacred Muslim soil. According to Hawali, the United States was motivated to this course of action by its recognition that Islam was the only threat to America’s world domination, and that the United States consequently determined that it must subordinate Muslims to its rule. 104.

When the war ended with the defeat of Hussein’s armies, many of the Ulema

demanded a complete U.S. withdraw from Saudi soil, but the House of Saud declined to accede to that demand, effectively acknowledging that the regime was incapable of defending Saudi Arabia on its own. 105.

The decision to allow American forces to remain on Saudi soil, and the

implications that followed from that decision, prompted an even more acute crisis of legitimacy for the Saudi Royal Family. To many prominent and influential members of the Ulema, the House of Saud’s self-evident inability to protect Saudi Arabia was a product of its own corruption under Western influences, and its failure to govern and rule in strict accordance with Shariah. To the extent the regime would not embrace and fulfill its duty to rule in accordance with the requirements of Islam, these Ulema concluded that they should exercise greater authority relative to the governance of the Kingdom.

26

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 28 28 of 157 of 157

106.

In March 1991, a group of prominent Ulema drafted a “Letter of Demands”

detailing their principal criticisms with the House of Saud’s rule, and reforms they deemed imperative to restoring Saudi Arabia’s Islamic character, and by extension, the regime’s legitimacy. Broadly speaking, the document demanded a greater role for the Ulema in the conduct of Saudi domestic and foreign affairs; the abolition of any laws and regulations that did not adhere with Shariah; a ban against the collection of interest by financial institutions; the establishment of a strong and sophisticated military; the repudiation of any alliances which in their view contradicted Shariah, to include Riyadh’s alliance with Washington; and a drastic increase in the funding of Saudi Arabia’s da’awa institutions, in order to spread Wahhabi Islam and foster the establishment of Shariah-based states outside of the Kingdom. In particular, the Letter of Demands insisted on the following reforms: The formation of a consultative council to decide internal and external issues on the basis of the Shari’a. Its members must be honest, straightforward and representing all fields of expertise. They must be totally independent and not be subject to any pressure that may affect the authority of the council. All laws and regulations of political, economic, administrative or other nature must be reconciled with the principles of the Shari’a. Trusted committees with expertise in Shari’a should be authorized to repeal legislation not conforming to Shari’a principles. In addition to possessing specialized expertise, dedication and honesty, government officials and their overseas representatives must be unswervingly moral. Failing any one of the requirements for any reasons is an abuse of public trust and a fundamental cause of injury to the national interest and reputation. Justice must be applied, rights granted and duties assigned in full equality among all citizens, not favoring the nobles or begrudging the weak. Abuse of authority by anyone whether by shirking obligations or denying people what is their right is a cause for breakup and annihilation of society. All government officials, especially those occupying the highest positions, must be diligently scrutinized and must all be made accountable with no exceptions. Government agencies must be

27

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 29 29 of 157 of 157

cleansed of anyone whose corruption or dereliction is proven, regardless of any other consideration. Public wealth must be distributed fairly among all classes and groups. Taxes must be eliminated and fees that have overburdened citizens must be reduced. Government revenues must be protected from exploitation and abuse; priority in expenditure must be given to the most urgent necessities. All forms of monopoly or illegitimate ownership must be eliminated. Restrictions imposed on Islamic banks must be lifted. Public and private banking institutions must be cleansed of usury, which is an affront to God and His Prophet, and a cause for stunting the growth of wealth. A strong and fully-integrated army must be built and fully equipped with weapons of all kinds, from any source. Attention must be given to manufacturing and developing arms. The goal of the army must be to protect the country and the Holy Sites. Information media must be remodeled according to the adopted media policy of the Kingdom. The goals must be to educate, serve Islam and express the morals of society. The media must be purged of anything conflicting with these objectives. Its freedom to spread awareness through truthful reporting and constructive criticism must be safeguarded within the confines of Islam. Foreign policy must be based on national interest without relying on alliances not sanctioned by the Shari’a. It must also embrace Muslim causes. The Kingdom’s embassies must be reformed to enable them to reflect the Islamic nature of the country. Religious and proselytizing institutions must be developed and strengthened with financial and human resources. All obstacles preventing them from fully carrying out their objectives must be removed. Judicial institutions must be unified and granted full and effective independence. Juridical authority must apply to all. It is necessary to establish an independent body whose function is to ensure carrying out judicial orders. The rights of individuals and society must be guaranteed. Every restriction on people’s rights and their will must be removed, to ensure the enjoyment of human dignity, within the acceptable religious safeguards. 107.

The Letter of Demands was broadly supported among the Ulema, bearing the

signatures of approximately 400 clerics, judges and scholars, and the endorsement of Sheik bin

28

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 30 30 of 157 of 157

Baz. In addition, thousands of copies of the Letter of Demands were distributed throughout the country, in a rare public denunciation of the practices and policies of the Saudi regime. The rebuke was especially problematic in that the criticisms and demands set forth therein were grounded in well-established beliefs and principles of Wahabbi Islam, the ultimate source of all law in the Kingdom and of the authority of the Saudi regime. 108.

Approximately one year later, in March 1992, a smaller group of Ulema

submitted a second petition to the regime, entitled the Memorandum of Advice, which expanded upon and refined the arguments presented in the Letter of Demands. In the Memorandum of Advice, the Ulema offered particularly harsh criticisms of the Saudi government’s conduct of foreign affairs, and its perceived failure to provide adequate funding to Saudi da’awa institutions or support to Islamist separatists and jihad movements outside of the Kingdom. It also criticized the government’s failure to maintain an adequate and competent army “motivated by the spirit of jihad and sacrifice.” The Memorandum of Advice asserted that Islam should be central to Saudi foreign policy, and again attacked Saudi Arabia’s relationship with the United States, given “America’s general hostile policies towards Muslims.” The Memorandum of Advice further criticized the regime for failing to use Saudi Arabia’s embassies throughout the world to promote Wahhabi Islam, and advocated that the Kingdom’s embassies be reformed to serve that goal. 109.

Together, the Letter of Demands and Memorandum of Advice presented a

withering criticism of the Saudi regime, and a direct challenge to its legitimacy of a far more serious nature than any the House of Saud had previously faced. 110.

In response to the renewed crisis of legitimacy, the regime sought to diminish the

Ulema’s challenge by positioning itself as a leading force in combating the Western Cultural Attack and in advancing the global Islamist movement, much as it had done in response to the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan. 111.

Rhetorically, the regime enthusiastically embraced the concept of the Western

Cultural Attack, promoting through official speeches and the state-run media the idea of a clash of civilizations between the infidel West and a spiritual Muslim civilization led by Saudi Arabia. 29

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 31 31 of 157 of 157

The regime fully endorsed the view, advocated by the Ulema, that Saudi Arabia must launch a counter attack against Western civilization, in defense of the Ummah. 112.

To demonstrate its commitment to these ideas, and simultaneously appease the

Ulema and their followers, the House of Saud used the Letter of Demands and Memorandum of Advice as a roadmap for its course of action, subject to limitations necessary to protect the regime’s own power and self-interest. Of particular note, the regime acceded to the Ulema’s demands that the Ulema be given a more formal and expansive role within the Saudi government, and increased access to government structures and resources to serve the Ulema’s Islamist agenda. 113.

As demanded by the Ulema in the Letter of Demands, the regime announced the

formation of a Majlis al Shura (Consultative Council) in 1992, to which King Fahd appointed senior members of the Ulema. 114.

A year later, King Fahd issued a Royal Decree appointing Sheikh bin Baz as

Grand Mufti of Saudi Arabia, and as the head of both the “Council of Senior Scholars” (Hayat Kibar al-Ulama) and the “The General Presidency of Scholarly Research and Ifta” (Idarat alBuhuth al-Ilmiyya wal-Ifta), and formally designating bin Baz as a Minister of the Saudi government in those roles. 115.

In the same Royal Decree, King Fahd established a new “Ministry of Islamic

Affairs, Endowment (Waqf), Guidance and Da’awa” (the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa). The new Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa was given authority over all matters of Islamic affairs, other than the Hajj, including Saudi da’awa activities. The Royal Decree noted that the establishment of the new Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa was undertaken on recommendation of Sheikh bin Baz, and appointed Abdullah Mohsen al Turki as the first Minister of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa. The Royal Decree further directed that steps be taken to transfer authority over all matters concerning Islamic affairs and da’awa activities to the newly formed Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa.

30

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 32 32 of 157 of 157

116.

With its formation, the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa assumed primary

responsibility for supervising and directing the activities of Saudi Arabia’s charity alter-egos, including among others the MWL, IIRO, WAMY, and al Haramain, in keeping with the new ministry’s authority over all Saudi da’awa activities outside of the Kingdom. As the 9/11 Commission explained, “international relief organizations, such as the World Assembly of Muslim Youth (WAMY), are [] regulated by the Ministry of Islamic Affairs. This Ministry uses zakat and government funds to spread Wahhabi beliefs throughout the world.” In many cases, members of the Ulema simultaneously held senior positions within both the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa and the charities under its supervision. In addition, members of the Ulema routinely cycled between positions within the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa and leadership posts within the charities. 117.

Consistent with the Ulema’s demands that the Kingdom reform its embassies to

support the propagation of Wahhabi Islam and the Ulema’s agenda outside of Saudi Arabia, the regime also established Islamic Affairs Departments in its embassies throughout the world, populated by Wahhabi religious clerics from the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, many of whom held diplomatic credentials. 118.

The Islamic Affairs Departments in the Saudi embassies carried out a range of

functions in service of the Wahhabi Ulema’s Islamist agenda. Among other activities, the Islamic Affairs Departments of the embassies closely supervised and directed the activities of the local offices of the Saudi da’awa organizations, ensuring that the priorities and activities of those offices were directed in furtherance of the strategic goals of the Saudi Ulema and Ministry of Islamic Affairs. Indeed, internal documents produced by the Saudi da’awa organizations in these proceedings confirm that the Islamic Affairs Departments in the embassies and Ministry of Islamic Affairs officials in Saudi Arabia held authority to dictate the projects and causes to be supported by the local da’awa offices. 119.

The Islamic Affairs Departments within the Saudi embassies and consulates also

had authority for monitoring the activities of Saudi citizens living outside of the Kingdom, as a 31

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 33 33 of 157 of 157

component of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa’s role in protecting the Kingdom’s “Islamic” character. 120.

In addition, the Islamic Affairs Departments of the Saudi embassies and

consulates were responsible for establishing Wahhabi mosques and Islamic centers throughout the world, and distributing Wahhabi texts and literature in an effort to spread Wahhabi teachings. Texts and literature disseminated by the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa through the Islamic Affairs Departments, including in the United States, often advocated intensely antiAmerican views, condemned democracy as un-Islamic, vilified Christians and Jews as infidels, and glorified jihad against the infidels. 121.

In the years following the establishment of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, the

regime enthusiastically embraced the external religious priorities of the Ulema concerning the propagation of Wahhabi Islam and support for Islamist movements abroad. 122.

Pursuant to this strategy, the regime dramatically increased the budget and

resources of the State controlled da’awa institutions, dedicating incomprehensible sums to support the priorities and objectives of the Ulema and the propagation of Wahabbi Islam outside of the Kingdom. Indeed, according to recent estimates, the Kingdom has expended between $23 billion dollars annually to further the priorities of the Ulema outside of Saudi Arabia. 123.

The Kingdom deployed thousands of Wahhabi clerics from the Ministry of

Islamic Affairs to teach at Saudi government funded mosques and Islamic centers throughout the globe, many of which were themselves established under the auspices of the Saudi government controlled da’awa organizations. 124.

The reach and authority of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs swelled as a result of

these initiatives, affording the Ulema who populated and controlled the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Saudi da’awa organizations (as officials of the Kingdom) access to a vast governmental platform to pursue their Islamist agenda. 125.

The Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa soon became “a stronghold of

zealots,” according to knowledgeable Saudi sources cited by the Washington Post. 32

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 34 34 of 157 of 157

126.

It is thus not surprising that, under the supervision of the Ministry of Islamic

Affairs and Da’awa, the Saudi da’awa organizations, themselves agents and alter-egos of the Saudi government, aggressively deployed their resources to support Islamic extremist movements throughout the world, including al Qaeda and its affiliates. Other movements and organizations that benefited from this Islamist largesse included (among others): Abu Sayyef Group, Moro Islamic Liberation Front, Hamas, Palestine Islamic Jihad, Jemaah Islamiyya, Egyptian Islamic Jihad, Asbat al-Ansar, Salafist group for Call and Combat, Al Gama’a al Islamiyya, Lashkar-Tayyiba, Lashkar I Janghvi, and Algerian Islamic Group. That many of these organizations used terrorism as a tool to achieve their religious and political goals was not an impediment to the Kingdom’s support of their causes. 127.

Al Qaeda represented a natural partner for the Saudi da’awa organization and

radicals within the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa, given their shared Wahhabi ideology, past collaboration in the cause of jihad in Afghanistan, common desire to spread Wahhabi rule beyond the Kingdom’s borders, and mutual belief in raising the banner of jihad in service of those goals. 128.

As referenced above and discussed in further detail below, the support channeled

to al Qaeda by Saudi Arabia’s charity-alter-egos during the decade preceding the September 11th attacks enabled and fueled al Qaeda’s growth and development, and directly enabled bin Laden to build an international terrorist organization capable of mounting a sophisticated international terrorist attack on American soil. Without the support provided by those agents of the Saudi government, al Qaeda could not have successfully conceived, planned, coordinated, and mounted the September 11th attacks. 129.

In addition to the support that flowed to al Qaeda from the Kingdom’s charity

agents and alter-egos, investigations by the United States and its allies have confirmed that officials within the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa collaborated directly with al Qaeda members, and that agents of the Saudi government, including representatives of the Islamic Affairs Departments in the Saudi embassy in Berlin and the Saudi consulate in Los Angeles, 33

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 35 35 of 157 of 157

provided direct assistance to the September 11th plotters and hijackers, which was essential to the success of the attacks. 130.

The claims and theories of jurisdiction advanced as to the Kingdom of Saudi

Arabia are predicated on the aforementioned: (1) attributable tortious acts of the Saudi government’s charity alter-egos, including the SHC itself, involving their provision of myriad forms of material support directly to al Qaeda for more than a decade leading up to the September 11th attacks, which included support provided through offices in the United States; and (2) attributable tortious acts of individual agents and officials of the Kingdom, who provided direct assistance to the September 11th plotters and hijackers. The hand of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs and Da’awa is evident in both contexts. The facts and evidence underlying and supporting these theories is surveyed in further detail below. IX.

THE ATTRIBUTABLE TORTIOUS ACTS OF INDIVIDUAL SAUDI GOVERNMENT OFFICIALS AND AGENTS IN SUPPORT OF THE SEPTEMBER 11TH ATTACKS 131.

The September 11th plot was planned and developed by al Qaeda over a period of

many years, beginning no later than 1996 when Osama bin Laden and his al Qaeda terror group were completing their migration from Sudan to the mountains of Afghanistan. 132.

Khalid Sheikh Mohammed (“KSM”), the mastermind behind the September 11th

attacks, initially briefed bin Laden on his proposed operation during a meeting with the al Qaeda leader in Tora Bora, Afghanistan that same year. 133.

The proposal was an adaptation of a component attack of the earlier “Bojinka”

plot conceived by KSM and Ramzi Yousef in 1994 while in the Philippines. Yousef, KSM’s nephew, was the mastermind of the 1993 World Trade Center bombing. KSM divulged to U.S. interrogators after his capture in 2003 that Yousef’s successful attack on the World Trade Center inspired him to begin planning attacks against the United States. 134.

The Bojinka plot was a complex collection of planned terrorist attacks, including

a plot to bomb twelve U.S. commercial airplanes over the Pacific Ocean as they flew from Asia to the United States, as well as plans to assassinate President Clinton and Pope John Paul II 34

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 36 36 of 157 of 157

during planned trips to the Philippines. The plot was disrupted by the Philippine National Police in January 1995 when a chemical fire erupted in an apartment used by Yousef and Abdul Hakim Ali Hashim Murad to plan for the attacks. 135.

The cell that hatched the Bojinka plot, which included KSM and Yousef, was

affiliated with Abu Sayyef Group, an al Qaeda affiliate in the Philippines, and supported by al Qaeda, through the Philippine branch of the IIRO, headed by bin Laden’s brother-in-law Mohammed Jamal Khalifa. 136.

Khalifa, appointed to head the IIRO’s branch office in the Philippines following

his participation in the Afghan jihad, used the IIRO as a platform for al Qaeda’s expansion into Southeast Asia and personally orchestrated IIRO’s funding and support for the Bojinka plot. Khalifa’s appointment was endorsed by the Secretary General of the MWL, Dr. Abdullah Omar Naseef. 137.

According to the 9/11 Commission, Osama bin Laden directed KSM to proceed

with the operational planning for the September 11th attacks in late 1998 or early 1999. Soon thereafter, several individuals were personally selected by bin Laden to serve as suicide operatives, including Saudi nationals Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Mihdhar. 138.

Hazmi and Mihdhar, considered experienced al Qaeda veterans at the time of their

selection, were described by Director of Central Intelligence George Tenet as “having trained and fought under al Qa’ida auspices in three different countries.” In 1995, Hazmi and Mihdhar traveled to Bosnia to participate in jihad with other Muslims against the Serbs. Both men similarly traveled to Chechnya to fight with the Chechen rebels. 139.

Hazmi first traveled to Afghanistan as a teenager in 1993, returning to the country

sometime before 1998 to swear allegiance (“bayat”) to bin Laden. Hazmi fought against the Northern Alliance and returned to Saudi Arabia in early 1999. 140.

Mihdhar made his first trip to Afghanistan in early 1996 to attend al Qaeda

training camps. He returned in 1998 and also swore bayat to bin Laden.

35

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 37 37 of 157 of 157

141.

In April 1999, Hazmi and Mihdhar obtained visas through the U.S. Consulate in

Jeddah, Saudi Arabia. Soon thereafter, they traveled to Afghanistan to attend an elite training course at al Qaeda’s Mes Aynak camp. Located in an abandoned Russian copper mine near Kabul, the camp offered a full range of vigorous instruction to the future hijackers, including an advanced commando course. 142.

Following completion of their advanced training at Mes Aynak, Hazmi and others

traveled to Karachi, Pakistan where they received basic instruction on western culture and travel from KSM. Mihdhar did not attend the training, instead traveling to Yemen. 143.

In early January 2000, Hazmi and Mihdhar flew to Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia to

attend an al Qaeda summit hosted by the leader of the al Qaeda affiliate Jemaah Islamiyah in Asia, Hambali (a/k/a “Riduan Isamuddin”). The meetings took place from January 5-8 in a condominium owned by Yazid Sufaat. Sufaat is linked to Zacarias Moussaoui and was arrested by Malaysian police in December 2001 based on evidence that he had procured four tons of bomb material, ammonium nitrate, for an Indonesian jihadist cell. 144.

Approximately a dozen individuals attended the meetings, including al Qaeda

members KSM, Ramzi Binalshibh, Tawfiq bin Attash (a/k/a “Khallad”), and Abu Bara al Yemeni. Key operational details of the September 11th attacks were discussed at this summit and Hazmi and Mihdhar were directed to fly to the United States. 145.

Following the meetings, Hazmi and Mihdhar flew to Bangkok, Thailand where

they boarded an American Airlines flight to the United States. On January 15, 2000, they arrived in Los Angeles, establishing themselves as the first of the future September 11th hijackers to set foot on United States soil in preparation for the attacks. 146.

As the 9/11 Commission correctly observed, the two hijackers were “ill prepared

for a mission in the United States. Their only qualifications for this plot were their devotion to Usama Bin Ladin, their veteran service, and their ability to get valid U.S. visas. Neither had spent any time in the West, and neither spoke much, if any, English.”

36

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 38 38 of 157 of 157

147.

The Commission concluded it was therefore “unlikely that Hazmi and Mihdhar –

neither of whom, in contrast to the Hamburg group, had any prior exposure to life in the West – would have come to the United States without arranging to receive assistance from one or more individuals informed in advance of their arrival.” 148.

As discussed below, the support network that received Hazmi and Mihdhar upon

their arrival in the United States, and assisted them in settling in the United States and beginning their preparations for the September 11th Attacks, included Saudi officials Fahad al Thumairy, Omar al Bayoumi, and Osama Basnan. A.

OMAR AL BAYOUMI, FAHAD AL THUMAIRY, OSAMA BASNAN AND SALEH AL HUSSAYEN

149.

Bayoumi (a/k/a “Omar Ahmad Mustafa Al-Baioomi”), was a long-time employee

of the Saudi Arabian government, and according to witnesses who knew him personally, served as a Saudi intelligence agent responsible for monitoring the activities of Saudi citizens in the United States. 150.

As discussed in further detail below, Bayoumi’s status as an agent and official of

the Saudi government is corroborated and confirmed by: (1) the findings of the Congressional Joint Inquiry into the September 11th attacks; (2) the affidavit testimony of former Senator Bob Graham, who co-chaired the Congressional Joint Inquiry; (3) the testimony and statements of people who knew Bayoumi personally and interacted with him frequently; (4) the character, extent, and pattern of his contacts with Saudi government agencies and diplomatic missions; (5) the nature of his relationship with Osama Basnan, another agent of the Saudi government; (6) the very status the FBI itself assigned to Bayoumi during an investigation prior to the September 11th attacks; (7) the particular circumstances surrounding his initial meetings with the September 11th hijackers; (8) his access to “seemingly endless” funds, despite his alleged status as a student and mere project manager for Dallah Avco, a contractor to the Presidency of Civil Aviation; (9) the unusual circumstances of his alleged employment with Dallah Avco, including the fact that he performed no actual work for that company; (10) Dallah Avco’s specific assertion in ongoing

37

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 39 39 of 157 of 157

discovery proceedings that Bayoumi was, at all times, an employee of the Saudi government; (11) Dallah Avco’s assertion in ongoing discovery proceedings that virtually all documents in its possession concerning Bayoumi are “classified” materials under a Saudi Royal Decree prohibiting the dissemination by public employees of information “the disclosure of which [would] prejudice[ ] the State’s national security, interests, policies or rights;” (12) Fahad al Thumairy’s implausible attempts to deny any relationship with Bayoumi when interviewed by U.S. officials; and (13) Osama Basnan’s equally implausible attempts to deny any relationship with Bayoumi when interviewed by U.S. officials. 151.

It is undisputed that Bayoumi provided extensive and critical assistance to 9/11

hijackers Hazmi and Mihdhar, which enabled them to establish themselves in the United States despite their lack of preparation for that transition, and to begin their operational preparations for the attacks. The character of that support, and its criticality to the success of the September 11th plot, is surveyed in further detail below. 152.

As also summarized below, a broad array of evidence, including the testimony of

9/11 Joint Inquiry Co-Chair Bob Graham, indicates that Bayoumi was acting at the direction of elements of the Saudi government, and elements of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs in particular, in providing that support to the hijackers. Further, a top FBI official has stated that “We [the FBI] firmly believed that he [Bayoumi] had knowledge [of the 9/11 plot], and that his meeting with them [Hazmi and Mihdhar] that day was more than coincidence.” 153.

An employee of the Saudi Arabian Presidency of Civil Aviation (“PCA”) since

the mid-1980’s, a branch of the Saudi Ministry of Defense, Bayoumi moved to the United States in August 1994 at the direction of the Saudi government where he enrolled in an ESL program (English as a Second Language) at San Diego State University (“SDSU”). 154.

Bayoumi lived in the San Diego suburb of Clairemont Mesa with his wife, Manal

Bajadr, and four children. On his rental application for an apartment, Bayoumi listed his job as student and his income as $2,800 a month, a stipend he claimed came from a family in India.

38

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 40 40 of 157 of 157

But U.S. intelligence reports indicate that claim was false. Instead, Bayoumi’s finances were supported by the government of Saudi Arabia itself. 155.

Bayoumi was well known throughout the San Diego Muslim community,

spending much of his time interacting with all of the regional mosques, including the Islamic Center of San Diego (“ICSD”). According to various sources, Bayoumi knew everyone and was widely accepted in the local community. If Bayoumi vouched for certain people, they would be immediately accepted. 156.

During his initial year in San Diego, Bayoumi was granted a secondment by the

PCA to work as an employee of Dallah Avco Trans Arabia Company (“Dallah Avco”) in Saudi Arabia. Dallah Avco, an aviation contractor, is a wholly-owned subsidiary of the Dallah al Baraka Group (“DBG”) which is owned by wealthy Saudi businessman, Saleh Abdullah Kamel. DBG and Kamel directed tens of millions of dollars in funding to support al Qaeda and other radical Islamic causes. Kamel has been publicly identified on the “Golden Chain” as one of al Qaeda’s principal financiers. 157.

In or around 1995, Bayoumi began receiving a $3,000 monthly salary from Dallah

Avco. Although the salary was given to Bayoumi as payment for his work on an aviation project commissioned by the Saudi government and taking place in the Kingdom, Bayoumi remained in San Diego and did not report for the job. Despite his absence, Bayoumi remained in the employment of Dallah Avco for the next seven years. The Saudi government reimbursed Dallah Avco for Bayoumi’s salary. For its part, Dallah Avco has stated in ongoing discovery proceedings that Bayoumi was, at all time, an employee of the Saudi government. Further, Dallah Avco has asserted that virtually all documents in its possession concerning Bayoumi are “classified” materials under a Saudi Royal Decree prohibiting the dissemination by public employees of information “the disclosure of which [would] prejudice[ ] the State’s national security, interests, policies or rights.” 158.

After obtaining his degree from SDSU, Bayoumi continued to seek higher

education in the United States and submitted his application for an executive doctorate in the 39

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 41 41 of 157 of 157

Management Program at the Weatherhead School of Management at Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland, Ohio. On his application, Bayoumi stated that he was employed by the Saudi Civil Aviation administration and was the “Assistant to the Director of Finance, Contracts and Finance Control Division, PCA, Airways Engineering” of Dallah Avco. His application was ultimately rejected. 159.

Thereafter, Bayoumi enrolled in a George Washington University program in

Project Management, which he pursued both in San Diego and Washington, D.C. While attending classes in Washington, Bayoumi resided with an employee of the Saudi Embassy in D.C. 160.

Bayoumi first caught the attention of the FBI in 1995 in connection with other

ongoing investigations at the time. Several years later, on September 8, 1998, the FBI’s San Diego Field Office opened a preliminary inquiry into Bayoumi based on allegations raised by the manager in the apartment complex where he was living. According to the manager, she had been notified by the U.S. Postal Inspection Service in March 1998 that a suspicious package had been sent to Bayoumi from the Middle East. The package had broken open and a number of wires were protruding from it. The manager also reported that a maintenance worker for the apartment complex had noticed strange wires protruding beneath the bathroom sink in Bayoumi’s master bedroom. In addition, the manager reported frequent gatherings of young Middle Eastern men at Bayoumi’s apartment on weekend nights. The FBI case agent conducted a limited investigation, but the preliminary inquiry was closed on June 7, 1999 and Bayoumi was no longer actively investigated by the FBI. However, in connection with its pre-9/11 investigation, the FBI identified Bayoumi as an agent of the Saudi government. 161.

On February 1, 2000, Bayoumi and Caysan bin Don (a/k/a “Isamu Dyson”) got

into Bayoumi’s car and drove nearly two hours from San Diego to the Saudi Arabian Royal Consulate in Los Angeles. Bayoumi had previously disclosed to friends at the ICSD that he had friends at the Saudi Consulate. Although the stated purpose of the trip was to resolve a visa issue

40

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 42 42 of 157 of 157

and obtain Islamic religious materials and Korans, Bayoumi had told at least one other person prior to the trip that he was going to Los Angeles to pick up visitors. 162.

Upon arriving at the Saudi Consulate, Bayoumi met for an hour with an official

from the Consulate’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs office, Fahad al Thumairy. U.S. officials have concluded that Thumairy and Bayoumi discussed the recent arrival of future 9/11 hijackers Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Mihdhar in the United States, and Bayoumi was tasked with getting them welcomed and assimilated into the San Diego Muslim community. 163.

Thumairy, who was twenty-nine years old at the time of the meeting with

Bayoumi, graduated with a degree in Islamic studies from the Imam Muhammad Bin Saudi Islamic University in the Kingdom and immediately joined the Saudi Ministry of Islamic Affairs. The Ministry directed Thumairy to serve in the United States and he was sent to the Saudi Embassy in Washington, D.C. The Embassy then assigned Thumairy to the Saudi Consulate in Los Angeles. Thumairy does not recall the name of the individual that sent him to Los Angeles, but noted it was the person in charge of the Islamic Affairs office at the Embassy. 164.

Thumairy was an accredited diplomat at the Saudi Consulate from 1996 to 2003,

and further served as a religious leader at the King Fahd Mosque in Culver City, CA, a mosque that had been built with financial assistance from the government of Saudi Arabia. As of January 2000, Thumairy acted as the Saudi Consulate’s liaison to the King Fahd Mosque, per the request of his superiors at the Ministry of Islamic Affairs. 165.

After arriving in the United States on January 15, Hazmi and Mihdhar reportedly

spent time at the King Fahd Mosque until their move to San Diego a few short weeks later. 166.

Thumairy was well known at the King Fahd Mosque and within the Los Angeles

Muslim community. However, he was reputed to be an Islamic fundamentalist who believed in strict adherence to the orthodox Wahhabi doctrine. According to the 9-11 Commission, some Muslims from the mosque expressed concerns regarding Thumairy’s religious teachings, stating that he “injected non-Islamic themes into his guidance/prayers at the [King Fahd] Mosque” and further had followers “supportive of the events of September 11, 2001.” The Commission 41

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 43 43 of 157 of 157

further stated that “Thumairy appears to have associated with a particularly radical faction within the community of local worshippers, and had a network of contacts in other cities in the United States.” 167.

In an interview with 9/11 Commission members in 2003, Bayoumi identified

Thumairy as the imam at the King Fahd Mosque and described him as his religious advisor, conceding that he had telephone conversations with Thumairy to discuss religious matters. Despite having personally met with Thumairy at the Saudi Consulate on the same day he met the hijackers, Bayoumi implausibly professed surprise during the interview that Thumairy might have also held a position at the Saudi Consulate. 168.

On February 23, 2004, 9/11 Commission members Dietrich Snell and Raj De

interviewed Thumairy in Saudi Arabia under the watchful eye of Major Khalid, a Saudi official with the Mabahith (the secret police agency of the Ministry of Interior). To their astonishment, when Thumairy was asked about his relationship with Bayoumi, he denied knowing Bayoumi: Al-Thumairy stated that he did not recognize the name Omar alBayoumi. When shown a photo of al-Bayoumi, al-Thumairy first denied recognizing him. At this time, Major Khalid whispered something to him in Arabic, and Thumairy said in English, “Oh Bayoumi.” Al-Thumairy then acknowledged that he recognized al-Bayoumi because he had seen him on television, but denied ever seeing him in Los Angeles. 169.

9/11 Commission members Snell and De interviewed Thumairy again the next

day and received similar stone-walling from him: At this point, al-Thumairy was asked again about Omar alBayoumi. Al-Thumairy was reminded that at his interview the previous night, he had initially denied recognizing al-Bayoumi until Major Khalid said something to him, which was when he acknowledged recognizing al-Bayoumi from the media. AlThumairy was also informed that we have information that shows numerous phone calls between him and al-Bayoumi over a short period in December 1999, from both al-Thumairy’s cell and landline phones. Finally, al-Thumairy was told that since speaking with him the prior night, we were told by another witness [i.e. Khalil al-Khalil] that he had been seen meeting with al-Bayoumi on several occasions at the [King Fahd Mosque]. 42

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 44 44 of 157 of 157

Despite being confronted with these facts, al-Thumairy continued to deny knowing al-Bayoumi. 170.

Despite Thumairy’s apparent resistance to their investigators’ questioning, the

Commission uncovered evidence confirming that “Bayoumi and Thumairy had numerous telephone contacts between December 1998 and December 2000. Specifically, Bayoumi called Thumairy’s home telephone 10 times during this period, and Thumairy called Bayoumi’s cellular and home phone 11 times between December 3 and December 20, 2000.” 171.

Given his apparent terrorist ties, the United States revoked Thumairy’s diplomatic

visa in May 2003, banning him from entering the United States again. 172.

Immediately following their stop at the Saudi Consulate, Bayoumi and bin Don

drove to the King Fahd Mosque. After prayers, the men traveled to a nearby Middle Eastern restaurant known as the Mediterranean Café, where they met with Hazmi and Mihdhar over lunch. Hazmi and Mihdhar explained to Bayoumi in Arabic that they had just arrived in the United States and were living in a nearby apartment. Bayoumi exchanged his telephone number with Hazmi and invited the men to relocate to San Diego. Following their meeting, Bayoumi and bin Don returned to the King Fahd Mosque for the evening prayer. Soon thereafter, Hazmi called Bayoumi to arrange for his and Mihdhar’s relocation to san Diego, with Bayoumi’s assistance. 173.

Hamzi and Mihdhar arrived in San Diego on February 4, 2000 and Bayoumi

began undertaking extraordinary efforts to get the future hijackers assimilated into the local Muslim community. This same day, four telephone were placed from Bayoumi’s cell phone to Anwar Aulaqi, a senior al Qaeda recruiter who was involved in planning terrorist operations for al Qaeda and was killed by a United States drone attack on September 30, 2011 in Yemen. Additional calls from Bayoumi’s cell phone to Aulaqi took place on February 10, 16, and 18. 174.

In an interview with 9/11 Commission members, Bayoumi admitted to having a

relationship with Aulaqi, describing him as someone “with whom he discussed religious matters and ideas similar to those he would discuss with other imams.”

43

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 45 45 of 157 of 157

175.

The two hijackers initially moved in with Bayoumi and his family at their

residence at the Parkwood Apartment complex (6333 Mount Ada Road, Apt. #152, San Diego, CA 92111) until Bayoumi was able to secure similar housing for them at the same apartment building (Apt. #150) a few days later. 176.

Public records indicate that Suleiman al Ali, a member of the Saudi Ulema who

served as an official of the IIRO’s branch office in the United States and its financial arm SanaBell, Inc., maintained a shared address with Bayoumi from October 1999-Janaury 2000, just prior to the arrival of Hazmi and Mihdhar. According to U.S. intelligence documents, Ali maintained longstanding relationships with Islamic radicals and terror groups, and was implicated in the diversion of IIRO funds for the 1998 U.S. Embassy bombings. 177.

Bayoumi recommended Hazmi and Mihdhar to the property manager of the

Parkwood Apartments and appears as co-signer and guarantor for them on their rental application. Bayoumi is further listed as the co-signor and guarantor on their lease agreement because they did not have established credit. When the real estate agent refused to take cash for a deposit on the apartment, Bayoumi helped Hazmi and Mihdhar open a bank account with a $9,000 deposit. According to the manager at the Parkwood Apartments, Bayoumi would occasionally pay the hijackers’ rent. 178.

Future 9/11 hijacker Hani Hanjour was also seen in Bayoumi’s apartment at least

twice in early 2000 according to witnesses. 179.

After Hazmi and Mihdhar moved into their own apartment at the Parkwood

Apartments, Bayoumi organized a party to welcome the two men to San Diego. The party was attended by approximately 20 men from the local Muslim community, including members of the ICSD. Cayson bin Don attended the party and used Bayoumi’s video camera to videotape the party. According to bin Don, Hamzi and Mihdhar mingled with the attendees, explaining that they were students.

44

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 46 46 of 157 of 157

180.

By all accounts, the party was successful in welcoming and introducing Hazmi

and Mihdhar to the San Diego Muslim community, and the 9/11 hijackers would soon form trusted relationships with other key Muslims in the area as a result of Bayoumi’s efforts. 181.

Despite Bayoumi’s modest income and student status, witnesses reported that

Bayoumi had access to “seemingly endless” funds while in the United States, serving as a conduit for large sums of money from Saudi Arabia to the United States. In 1998, a FBI source identified Bayoumi as the individual who delivered approximately $400,000 from Saudi philanthropist Saed al Habib (a/k/a Mohamed Barak) for the construction of a Kurdish mosque in in El Cajon, CA, approximately 15 miles northeast of San Diego. 182.

The substantial donation was made on the condition that the Al Medina Al

Munawara Mosque hire Bayoumi as the building manager and provide him with a private office. Following completion of the mosque, however, the mosque’s leadership became unhappy with Bayoumi due to his failure to show up for work and the discovery of financial irregularities relating to his collection and distribution of funds. They neither liked nor trusted him and eventually asked him to leave the premises. 183.

The Report of the Joint Inquiry into the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001

(“9/11 Joint Inquiry Report”), authored by the United States House Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence and the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, similarly concluded that Bayoumi “had access to seemingly unlimited funding from Saudi Arabia.” 184.

Bayoumi’s primary source of income originating from Saudi Arabia came from

his employment with Dallah Avco. Although the project for which Bayoumi was allegedly hired was based in the Kingdom, Bayoumi showed up for work only once during the seven years he was receiving a salary from Dallah Avco. Bayoumi’s chronic absence led employees at the company to describe him as a “ghost employee,” one of many Saudis on the payroll who were not required to work. According to U.S. intelligence, there were approximately fifty (50) individuals who were being carried on the books at Dallah Avco who were being paid for doing nothing. 45

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 47 47 of 157 of 157

185.

Dallah Avco records indicate that, in or around April 1999, Dallah Avco sought to

terminate Bayoumi’s annual employment contract. To that end, a Dallah Avco official wrote to the PCA advising that “the company is not willing to renew the period for another year and we wish this to be known.” A PCA official immediately responded with an “extremely urgent” letter informing Dallah Avco that the Saudi government wanted Bayoumi’s contract renewed “as quickly as possible.” According to FBI documentation, Bayoumi “was a representative that PCA personnel wished to keep in America.” From his “ghost job,” Bayoumi was receiving a monthly salary of about $3,000 with allowances of $465 per month. 186.

In or around March 2000, a month after he had invited Hazmi and Mihdhar to

relocate to San Diego, found them an apartment, opened a bank account for them with his own money, and introduced them to the local Muslim community, Dallah Avco awarded Bayoumi with a promotion, raised his salary, and further increased his “other allowances” stipend from approximately $465 to $3,925 a month, remaining at that level until December 2000.In January 2001, the stipend was reduced to $3,427. 187.

According to the Joint Inquiry Report, “one of the FBI’s best sources in San

Diego informed the FBI that he thought that al-Bayoumi must be an intelligence officer for Saudi Arabia or another foreign power.” 188.

A number of witnesses in San Diego also believed that Bayoumi was closely

connected to the Saudi government and likely working as an intelligence agent. One witness, noting that Bayoumi did not work while in the United States, stated that he “had more money than he knew what to do with.” Another witness told the FBI that Bayoumi “always had a significant source or supply of money and observed him driving a new Toyota.” 189.

A U.S. intelligence document titled “Connections of San Diego PENTTBOMB

Subjects to the Government of Saudi Arabia,” details a prevailing feeling within the San Diego Muslim community that Bayoumi was more than he seemed: 4. Witness Reports: Various SD witnesses have described AlBayoumi as “associated with the Saudi government”

46

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 48 48 of 157 of 157

[REDACTED]; “a frequent traveler to Saudi Arabia” [REDACTED]; “member of the Aviation Board for Saudi Arabia” [REDACTED]; “having regular contact with the Saudi Arabian Consulate in LA” [REDACTED]; “making frequent trips to the Saudi Consulate during the six years he was known to live in San Diego” [REDACTED]; “working for the Saudi government to watch the actions of Saudis in the U.S.” [REDACTED]; inquiring about the welfare of Saudi students in San Diego [REDACTED]; “on a scholarship and financially supported by the Saudi government” [REDACTED]; “having friends at the Saudi Consulate in LA” [REDACTED]; “a spy for the Saudi government” (hijacker Al-Hazmi as reported by Shaikh); “receiving support from the Saudi Arabian Government or Saudi Airlines” [REDACTED]; a reputed “Saudi Arabian intelligence officer” due to his prolific videotaping of services at the mosque (Abukar); “an engineer for the Saudi Arabian government” [REDACTED]; “providing a $500 check to the SD Kurdish Community Islamic Center drawn on the account of the Royal Embassy of Saudi Arabia [REDACTED]; considered by some in the community as “some type of intelligence agent for the Saudi Arabian government [REDACTED] “frequently traveling to the Los Angeles airport to drop off or pick up Saudis visiting southern California” [REDACTED] traveling to WDC every one to two months” to visit the civil aviation office of the Saudi Consulate on Wyoming Street in WDC [REDACTED] “disclosing to others at the Islamic Center that he has friends/contacts in the Saudi Consulate in LA” [REDACTED], a “ghost employee” of Dallah/Avco and one of “approximately 50 individuals carried on the books of Dallah and being paid for doing nothing” [REDACTED] “working for the Saudi Intelligence Service to report on dissident Saudis” [REDACTED]. 190.

Former Senator Bob Graham, who in his role as the Chairman of the Senate

Select Committee on Intelligence, and who also served as the Co-Chair of the Congressional Joint Inquiry Into Intelligence Community Activities Before and After the Terrorist Attacks of September 11, 2001 (“9/11 Joint Inquiry”), similarly concluded in affidavit testimony that Bayoumi was an agent of the Saudi government, and that Bayoumi was acting at the direction of elements of the Saudi government in providing support to the September 11th hijackers. Senator Graham testified as follows: Based on my experiences as Co-Chair of the Joint Inquiry, and the evidence collected by the Joint Inquiry during the course of its

47

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 49 49 of 157 of 157

investigation into the events of September 11, 2001, the information contained in the Final Report of the 9/11 Commission, and reports and published materials I have reviewed, I am convinced there was a direct line between at least some of the terrorists who carried out the September 11th attacks and the government of Saudi Arabia, and that a Saudi government agent living in the United States, Omar al Bayoumi, provided direct assistance to the September 11th hijackers Nawaf al Hazmi and Khalid al Mihdhar. Based on the evidence discovered by the Joint Inquiry, I further believe that al Bayoumi was acting at the direction of elements of the Saudi government and that an official from the Islamic and Cultural Affairs section of the Saudi Consulate in Los Angeles, Fahad al Thumairy, likely played some role in the support network for the 9/11 attacks. In May 2003, the United States revoked al Thumairy’s diplomatic visa and banned him from the United States. 191.

Senator Graham’s testimony is consistent with recent disclosures relating to the

investigation and findings of the 9/11 Commission, as well as the views of senior 9/11 Commission members concerning evidence of the Saudi Ministry of Islamic Affairs’ role in supporting al Qaeda’s global operations and the September 11th attacks themselves. For instance, the definitive account of the 9/11 Commission’s investigation confirms that the staff members responsible for conducting the inquiry into Bayoumi’s role in the attacks “felt strongly that they had demonstrated a close Saudi government connection to the two hijackers in San Diego,” but that political considerations led to the omission of that conclusion from the 9/11 Commission’s Final Report. Philip Shenon, The Commission: The Uncensored History of the 9/11 Investigation, pp. 398-99 (2008). 192.

9/11 Commissioner John Lehman also endorsed this position, expressing his view

that “it was clear early on that there was some sort of Saudi support network in San Diego that had made it possible for the hijackers to hide in plain sight.” Id. at p. 185. 193.

Intelligence collected by the FBI also demonstrates a deeply rooted relationship

between the Saudi government and Bayoumi. According to an April 5, 2002 FBI report titled “Omar Al Bayoumi, Employed by Dallah Al Baraka,” the FBI obtained and analyzed Bayoumi’s telephone records revealing extensive contacts between Bayoumi and Saudi officials in

48

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 50 50 of 157 of 157

Washington D.C. and Los Angeles, CA, particularly during the January-March 2000 timeframe when 9/11 hijackers Hazmi and Mihdhar arrived in Los Angeles and subsequently settled in San Diego with Bayoumi’s assistance. Telephone records indicate that Bayoumi made approximately 141 calls to Saudi officials in Washington D.C. at the Saudi Arabian Royal Embassy, the Saudi Islamic Affairs Department, the Saudi Arabian Cultural Mission, the Saudi Arabian Education Mission, and the Saudi National Guard. Bayoumi also made approximately 34 calls to the Saudi Arabian Royal Consulate in Los Angeles. 194.

The extent and pattern of these contacts are consistent with witness statements

identifying Bayoumi as an agent of the Saudi government responsible for monitoring the activities of Saudi citizens living in the United States, a role in which he would have reported to the Islamic Affairs departments in the Kingdom’s embassies and consulates. 195.

Moreover, the U.S. Postal Service advised the FBI that on January 18, 2001,

Bayoumi received a package at his San Diego apartment from the Saudi Arabian Royal Embassy, 601 New Hampshire Ave., N.W., Washington, D.C. 196.

Evidence further indicates that an additional source of Saudi government funding

used to support the activities of Hazmi and Mihdhar while in the United States came by way of Bayoumi’s relationship with Osama Yousef Basnan, another agent of the Saudi government who was being groomed to replace Bayoumi in San Diego. 197.

Basnan, known as a vocal al Qaeda sympathizer and further described by U.S.

intelligence as an “ardent UBL [Osama bin Laden] supporter” who “has been in contact with UBL family members,” was a target of FBI investigations as early as 1992. In May of that year, the State Department provided the FBI with a box of documents recovered from a parked car that was abandoned on Wisconsin Avenue near the residence of then Secretary of State, James A. Baker. The car, belonging to Basnan’s used car business in Alexandria, VA, had been parked there by Basnan while allegedly visiting a friend’s nearby clothing business. The documents, consisting of jihadist literature, included a “Confidential” newsletter written in Arabic to supporters of the Eritrean Islamic Jihad (EIJ) Movement, providing updates on the EIJ’s council. 49

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 51 51 of 157 of 157

A high level EIJ member reportedly sat on al Qaeda’s Shura Council. The documents also included a number of letters addressed to Basnan outlining plans to import used cars to the United States. 198.

That same year, on October 17, 1992, Basnan hosted a party in Washington D.C.

for Omar Abdul Rahman (a/k/a the “Blind Sheikh”) who is currently serving a life sentence following his conviction for his role in supporting the 1993 World Trade Center bombing and for plotting a “day of terror” in which he planned to attack the United Nations in New York City, bomb the Holland and Lincoln tunnels, and assassinate then-Senator Alfonse D’Amato. 199.

FBI sources further report that in September 2000, Basnan was in phone and e-

mail contact with senior al Qaeda member and key facilitator for the September 11th attacks, Ramzi Binalshibh. Binalshibh himself confirmed his relationship with Basnan during interrogations by U.S. officials following his capture in Karachi, Pakistan on September 11, 2002. 200.

According to U.S. intelligence reports, Basnan’s wife, Majeda Ibrahin Dweikat,

reportedly required thyroid surgery in April 1998. Basnan contacted the health attaché at the Saudi Embassy in Washington D.C., requesting financial assistance for the surgery on his wife’s behalf. Soon thereafter, Basnan received a $15,000 check from the Saudi Embassy to pay for the surgery. That amount was apparently insufficient to cover the cost of her treatments and Basnan’s wife submitted her own request to Princess Haifa al Faisal, the wife of Prince Bandar bin Sultan bin Abdul Aziz al Saud, the Saudi Ambassador to the United States. 201.

Basnan’s wife was placed on Princess Haifa’s charity list in January 1999, and

began receiving cashier’s checks totaling between $2,000 and $3,000 a month. At the same time that Hazmi and Mihdhar arrived in the United States in January 2000, Basnan’s wife began signing her checks over to Bayoumi’s wife, Manal Bajadr. According to Senator Graham: “Beginning in 2000, Basnan’s wife began signing her checks over to a woman named Manal Bajadr – the wife of Omar al Bayoumi. It looked suspiciously like another backdoor way of channeling money to al-Hazmi and al-Mihdhar. This would also justify Bassan’s boast to the 50

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 52 52 of 157 of 157

FBI that he had done more for the two future hijackers than had al-Bayoumi.” Senator Bob Graham, Intelligence Matters, p. 168 (2004). The payments, drawn from Princess Haifa’s account at Riggs Bank in Washington D.C., total nearly $150,000. 202.

9/11 Commissioner John Lehman believed that Princess Haifa had no knowledge

that the money would end up in the hands of the hijackers, but was simply signing checks that had been placed in front of her by Wahhabi radicals who worked out of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs office in the Saudi Embassy. According to Lehman, “it was well-known in intelligence circles that the Islamic Affairs office functioned as the Saudis’ ‘fifth column’ in support of Muslim extremists.” Philip Shenon, The Commission: The Uncensored History of the 9/11 Investigation, p. 185 (2008). 203.

Basnan remained in San Diego through the September 11th attacks and

“celebrated the heroes of September 11” and talked about “what a wonderful, glorious day it had been” at a party shortly thereafter. In August 2002, Basnan and his wife were arrested for visa fraud, ultimately admitting they used false immigration documents to remain in the United States. Basnan was deported to Saudi Arabia on November 17, 2002. His wife was deported to Jordan the same day. 204.

Interviewed by the FBI and members of the 9/11 Commission following the

September 11th attacks, both Bayoumi and Basnan rejected claims that the two men had a close relationship. Bayoumi denied having any relationship at all with Basnan, asserting that he did not like Basnan, but volunteered that their wives were close. Basnan, in turn, incredibly claimed not to know Bayoumi at all. 205.

But those statements are directly contradicted by FBI witness testimony

describing the two men as “the closest of friends.” Both Bayoumi and Basnan were well known at the ICSD and their families both lived at the Parkwood Apartments at the same time Hazmi and Mihdhar resided there in 2000. Additionally, their wives were arrested together in April 2001 for shoplifting at a J.C. Penney. Moreover, a FBI agent assigned to a counter-terrorism squad investigating Basnan confirmed the friendship between Bayoumi and Basnan, noting that 51

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 53 53 of 157 of 157

“phone records reveal roughly 700 calls between various phones subscribed to by Bayoumi and Basnan over a one year period.” 206.

Witness testimony further confirms that Basnan had close ties to other persons

connected to the hijackers, and made a number of in-person visits to the Saudi Consulate in Los Angeles. According to an October 3, 2001 FBI report titled “PENTTBOMB; MAJOR CASE 192,” Basnan also had telephone contact with Anwar Aulaqi. 207.

9/11 Commission member Dietrich L. Snell, who conducted the October 2003

interview of Basnan in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia with representatives of the Mabahith in attendance, noted the deceitful and misleading nature of Basnan’s testimony: The interview failed to yield any new information of note. Instead, in the writer’s opinion, it established beyond cavil the witness’ utter lack of credibility on virtually every material subject. This assessment is based on: the witness’ demeanor, which engendered a combination of confrontation, evasiveness, and speechmaking, presumably for the benefit of his Mabahith audience; his repudiation of statements made by him on prior occasions; and the inherent incredibility of many of his assertions when viewed in light of the totality of the available evidence. 208.

In addition to being the point person to facilitate the future hijackers’ preparations

in the United States, Bayoumi was responsible for introducing Hazmi and Mihdhar to certain members of the San Diego Muslim community that not only shared their extremist beliefs and hatred for the United States, but would also provide significant logistical and ideological support to the hijackers as they plotted the attacks. 209.

One such individual was Anwar Aulaqi. Aulaqi, who was covertly acting as a

senior recruiter for al Qaeda and affiliated terrorist organizations and advocating jihad against the United States, had spent nearly five years in the public eye as the imam of the Al Ribat Al Islami Mosque (or “Rabat”) in La Mesa, CA, northeast of San Diego. Aulaqi had a following of approximately 200-300 people and would become an important religious leader to Hazmi and Mihdhar.

52

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 54 54 of 157 of 157

210.

Aulaqi has been linked to Fort Hood shooter Nidal Malik Hasan, as well as

Christmas Day bomber Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab. According to U.S. intelligence, Aulaqi was one of Abdulmutallab’s al Qaeda trainers who assisted in planning the attack and providing religious justification for it. Moreover, Faisal Shahzad, the individual responsible for the failed New York Times Square car bombing attempt on May 1, 2010, told U.S. investigators that he was inspired by Aulaqi. 211.

Aulaqi was also the subject of FBI investigations in 1999 and 2000 after learning

that he may have been contacted by a “possible procurement agent” for Osama bin Laden. During the investigation, the FBI learned that Aulaqi knew individuals with the Holy Land Foundation and others involved in raising money for Hamas. 212.

Aulaqi had other extremist connections. U.S. intelligence reports link Aulaqi to

other FBI counter-terrorism investigations, including the activities of “the Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ) in the United Sates.” Moreover, according to the Joint Inquiry Report, Aulaqi was visited in early 2000 “by a subject of a Los Angeles investigation closely associated with Blind Sheikh [Omar Abdel] al-Rahman.” The FBI closed its inquiry into Aulaqi’s activities in March 2000, two months after Hazmi and Mihdhar arrived in San Diego, claiming that the evidence collected by the agency was not considered strong enough to support a criminal prosecution at the time. 213.

Aulaqi, Hazmi, and Mihdhar developed a very close relationship and FBI sources

reported that “Aulaqi met consistently and privately with Alhazmi and Almidhdir for prayers.” Another witness recalled meeting Hazmi through Aulaqi and Mohdar Abdullah, and later meeting Mihdhar at Aulaqi’s mosque. The witness also remembered seeing Hazmi and Mihdhar in the guest room on the second floor of the mosque and, on one occasion, leaving the room just after Aulaqi, at the conclusion of a meeting. Other witnesses “informed the FBI after September 11 that [Aulaqi] had closed-door meetings in San Diego with al-Mihdhar, al-Hazmi, and another individual, whom al-Bayoumi had asked to help the hijackers.”

53

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 55 55 of 157 of 157

214.

These contacts have led investigators, including Senator Graham, to conclude that

Aulaqi was not only Hazmi’s and Mihdhar’s spiritual leader but also a trusted confidant who was fully aware of the planned 9/11 attacks. 215.

Aulaqi eventually left San Diego in mid-2000, and by January 2001 had relocated

to Virginia where he took a position at the Dar al Hijra Mosque at 3159 Row Street, Falls Church, VA 22044. He resided at 3331 Kaywood Drive, Falls Church, VA 22041. 216.

Hamzi and 9/11 hijacker Hani Hanjour arrived at Dar al Hijra in early April 2001.

Upon their arrival, Aulaqi tasked a Jordanian named Eyad al Rababah to assist the hijackers get settled and find an apartment. They eventually moved into Rababah’s friend’s apartment in Alexandria, VA. On May 8, 2001, Rababah went back to the apartment to pick up Hazmi and Hanjour for a trip to Connecticut. When Rababah arrived at the apartment, he found they had new roommates – muscle hijackers Ahmed al Ghamdi (United Airlines Flight 175) and Majed Moqed (American Airlines Flight 77). 217.

Following the September 11th attacks, Aulaqi submitted to four FBI interviews

between September 15 and 19, 2001. During an interview on September 17, the FBI showed Aulaqi a picture of the American Airlines Flight 77 hijackers. Aulaqi stated that he knew Hazmi from the Al Ribat Al Islami Mosque in San Diego, provided a physical description of him, and further described some of his personality traits, explaining that Hazmi was “a loner who did not have a large circle of friends,” “was slow to enter into personal relationships,” and “was always very soft spoken, a very calm and extremely nice person.” Although Aulaqi admitted meeting with Hazmi several times, he claimed not to remember any specifics of what they discussed. 218.

Aulaqi told the FBI that he did not recognize Mihdhar, but did admit to knowing

Hani Hanjour. According to the FBI, information in their possession at the time of the interviews suggested “a more pervasive connection” between Aulaqi and the 9/11 hijackers than he was willing to admit. 219.

Bayoumi was also responsible for introducing Hazmi and Mihdhar to Mohdhar

Mohamed Abdullah (a/k/a “Mihdar Mohammad al Mihdar Zaid”). Abdullah, who was a friend 54

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 56 56 of 157 of 157

to both Bayoumi and Aulaqi, lived in an apartment complex around the corner from Aulaqi’s mosque. According to the 9/11 Commission, in a post-9/11 interview with law enforcement, Abdullah claimed that Bayoumi specifically asked him “to be the individual to acclimate the hijackers to the United States, particularly San Diego, CA.” 220.

Per Bayoumi’s instructions, Abdullah helped Hazmi and Mihdhar locate and

apply to language and flight schools, and assisted them in translating between English and Arabic. Abdullah also helped Hazmi and Mihdhar obtain fake driver’s licenses with false names from an unknown individual in Los Angeles. Abdullah drove the hijackers from San Diego to an area in Los Angeles, near McArthur Park, and a second location near Huntington Park, where the unknown individual was selling the fake cards. Abdullah purchased approximately four or five fraudulent California Department of Motor Vehicle identification cards and gave them to Hazmi and Mihdhar. 221.

Abdullah further helped Hazmi conduct surveillance of the Los Angeles

International Airport in June 2000. On June 9, the day before Mihdhar left the United States and returned to Yemen to visit his family, Abdullah traveled with Hamzi and Mihdhar to Los Angeles where they visited the King Fahd Mosque. Abdullah was surprised that the hijackers already knew several people at the mosque, including an individual named Khallam. FBI investigators believe the individual is Khallad bin Attash, an al Qaeda operative and trusted member of Osama bin Laden’s inner circle who is linked to the 1998 U.S. Embassy bombings and the purported mastermind behind the U.S.S. Cole bombing. Their belief is based on witness reporting that Khallad was in the United States that same month and was seen in the company of Fahad al Thumairy. On June 10, Los Angeles International Airport security tapes show Abdullah, Hazmi and an unidentified man (potentially Khallad) using a video camera to scout out the airport. 222.

During a number of interviews with the FBI following the 9/11 attacks, Abdullah

reportedly admitted knowing of Mihdhar’s and Hazmi’s extremist leanings and Mihdhar’s involvement with the Islamic Army of Aden, an Islamic extremist group in Yemen with ties to al 55

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 57 57 of 157 of 157

Qaeda. According to the 9/11 Commission, Abdullah was clearly sympathetic to those extremist views and expressed hatred for the U.S. government. 223.

Although Abdullah denied having advance knowledge of the 9/11 attacks when

interviewed by the FBI, Abdullah bragged to fellow inmates in September-October 2003 (during his incarceration for immigration charges), that he knew that Hazmi and Mihdhar intended to carry out a terrorist attack in the United States. Abdullah told the inmates that he first learned of the terrorist plot from Hazmi and Mihdhar themselves during a dinner at a restaurant in San Diego after praying together at a nearby mosque. Hazmi and Mihdhar invited Abdullah to join them on the airplane and participate in the attack. Abdullah knew that the attack would consist of an airplane flying into a building, but Abdullah reportedly did not know any further details. 224.

Abdullah further boasted that he was responsible for driving Hazmi and Mihdhar

from Los Angeles to San Diego after meeting Bayoumi in the Mediterranean Café with Cayson bin Don. 225.

After spending nearly 3 years in U.S. prisons, and multiple challenges to

deportation proceedings arising from immigration violations, Abdullah was deported to Yemen on May 21, 2004. 226.

While residing in San Diego in 2000, Mihdhar and Hazmi drew little attention to

themselves. They enrolled in English language classes at the Language Instruction Centrum, took flying lessons at the National Air College and Sorbi Flying School in San Diego, opened a new bank account at Bank of America with a $4,900 deposit, bought a 1988 Toyota Corolla for $2,300 and purchased automotive insurance, and obtained local phone service that included Hazmi’s listing in the local telephone directory. 227.

On March 20, 2000, a long distance telephone call was placed from Mihdhar and

Hazmi’s apartment to a suspected terrorist facility in the Middle East linked to al Qaeda activities. 228.

In May 2000, disappointed with their housing arrangements at the Parkwood

Apartments, Hazmi and Mihdhar vacated their apartment and moved to a home at 8451 Mount 56

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 58 58 of 157 of 157

Vernon Avenue, Lemon Grove, CA, which they had found through an advertisement at the ICSD. 229.

Mihdhar stayed at the Lemon Grove residence until June 10, 2000, when he left

the United States for Yemen. Hazmi continued to reside at the house and remained in the San Diego area until he moved to Phoenix, Arizona with fellow hijacker Hani Hanjour on December 10, 2000, and then eventually the east coast. 230.

According to the records at the Parkwood Apartments, Bayoumi and his family

moved out of their apartment just prior to the attacks on June 23, 2001. Bayoumi advised he was leaving the United States, but left no forwarding address with the property management company. 231.

In their final hours before boarding American Airlines Flight 77, overtaking the

crew, and crashing the plane into the Pentagon, September 11th hijackers Hazmi, Mihdhar, and Hanjour, again found themselves in close proximity to a senior member of the Kingdom’s Ulema, Saleh Ibn Abdul Rahman Hussayen. 232.

Hussayen, a member of the Saudi Ulema, had maintained a long career as a

government official for the Kingdom, holding positions with the Ministry of Finance and National Economy, the Council of Prime Ministers, the MWL Constituent Council, and other appointed positions within the Saudi government. 233.

Hussayen also spent five years as a member of Al Rajhi Bank’s Sharia Board, the

committee at the bank charged with ensuring compliance with Islamic law, and ultimately responsible for approving Al Rajhi Bank’s own zakat contributions, including those Al Rajhi Bank channeled to al Qaeda through the IIRO. 234.

In the weeks prior to the attacks, Hussayen was in the United States on a

fundraising mission with members of the Islamic Association of North America (“IANA”), a radical Islamic organization in Ypsilanti, Michigan which receives money from the Saudi government and other Saudi donors. The IANA has promoted teachings and fatwas issued by radical Saudi clerics Safar Hawali and Salman Ouda, which advocate violence against the United 57

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 59 59 of 157 of 157

States. Hawali and Ouda were identified in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing trial as spiritual advisors to Osama bin Laden. 235.

Hussayen’s nephew, Sami Omar al Hussayen, was employed by the IANA to

create and maintain websites and other internet media which were used to recruit personnel and raise funds for violent jihad. From March 1995 until February 2002, the IANA received $3 million from Sami’s resources, including two checks from his uncle totaling $100,000. In March 2004, Sami was charged with conspiracy to provide material support to Hamas and other violent jihadists through his work at the IANA and the Al Haramain Islamic Foundation. 236.

During this fundraising trip, Hussayen was scheduled to visit officials at the

offices of the MWL and WAMY in the Washington, D.C. area. The WAMY office was headed at that time by Abdullah bin Laden. 237.

On September 6, 2001, Hussayen arrived in Herndon, VA. Then, just days before

the September 11th attacks, Hussayen abruptly moved from his original hotel to the Marriott Residence Inn just a few miles away. The Marriott Residence Inn is the same hotel where September 11th hijackers Hazmi, Mihdhar, and Hanjour were staying before they woke up on the morning of September 11th, hijacked American Airlines Flight 77 and crashed it into the Pentagon killing approximately 125 military personnel and civilians, and injuring countless others. 238.

The United States Second Circuit Court of Appeals has concluded that

Hussayen’s “travels to the United States shortly before the September 11, 2001 attacks, as well as his decision to switch hotels to stay in the same hotel as at least three of the hijackers … not only suggest the possibility that he may have provided direct aid to members of al Qaeda, but they also raise a plausible inference that he may have intended his alleged indirect support of al Qaeda to cause injury in the United States.” O’Neill v. Asat Trust Reg. (In Re: Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001 (Asat Trust Reg.)), 714 F.3d 659, 679 (2d Cir. 2013). (Emphasis original).

58

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 60 60 of 157 of 157

239.

Directly after the attacks, FBI agents attempted to interview Hussayen in his hotel

room. However, according to the FBI, Hussayen “feigned a seizure, prompting the agents to take him to a hospital, where the attending physicians found nothing wrong with him.” The FBI returned to his hotel room the next day, but found Hussayen unwilling to cooperate. 240.

In March 2002, just months after the September 11th attacks, King Fahd bin Adbul

Aziz al Saud appointed Hussayen as the President of the Committee of the Two Holy Mosques in Mecca and Medina, the two most sacred sites in Islam. Hussayen has since died. 241.

From the moment they first set foot in the United States on January 15, 2000, to

the end of their journey almost two years later in a hotel with a senior member of the Saudi Ulema, Hazmi, Mihdhar and Hanjour were the benefactors of a broad support network orchestrated by agents of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, who helped provide them with the necessary tools to plot, prepare for, and ultimately conduct the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. 242.

Absent the critical financial, logistical, ideological and other support provided to

them by Omar al Bayoumi, Fahad al Thumairy, Osama Basnan, Anwar Aulaqi, Mohdhar Abdullah, and others, the hijackers would have been incapable of successfully carrying out the single worst enemy attack on United States soil this country had seen in 60 years. 243.

The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has asserted during the course of this litigation that

Plaintiffs’ claims relating to the activities of Bayoumi, Thumairy and other Saudi agents have been “directly rebutted by facts found by the United States government,” and that the 9/11 Commission “concluded that the government of Saudi Arabia had no role in the attacks of September 11, 2001.” These statements are incorrect, and directly rebutted by evidence of record. 244.

Former United States Senator and 9/11 Commission member, Bob Kerrey, has

testified in an affidavit submitted in support of Plaintiffs that “it is fundamentally inaccurate and misleading for the Kingdom and SHC to suggest that the 9/11 Commission’s investigation exonerated them for the events of September 11, 2001, or that the 9/11 Commission’s 59

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 61 61 of 157 of 157

investigation directly rebutted Plaintiffs’ claims.” Kerrey further affirms in his affidavit that “significant questions remain unanswered concerning the possible involvement of Saudi government institutions and actors in the financing and sponsorship of al Qaeda, and evidence relating to the plausible involvement of possible Saudi government agents in the September 11th Attacks has never been fully pursued.” See the Affirmation of Joseph Robert “Bob” Kerrey, In Re: Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001, MDL Case No. 1:03-md-01570, ECF No. 2557-3, which is incorporated herein in its entirety by reference. 245.

Former United States Senator and 9/11 Joint Inquiry Co-Chair Bob Graham has

similarly affirmed in affidavit testimony submitted of record that the “Kingdom is mistaken” in arguing that it “has been fully exonerated of any culpability for the events of September 11, 2001, whether through the investigation and findings of the 9/11 Commission or any other investigation of the United States government.” To the contrary, and as mentioned previously, Senator Graham has testified that he is “convinced that there was a direct line between at least some of the terrorists who carried out the September 11th attacks and the government of Saudi Arabia.” See the Affirmation of Daniel Robert “Bob” Graham, In Re: Terrorist Attacks on September 11, 2001, MDL Case No. 1:03-md-01570, ECF No. 2558, which is incorporated herein in its entirety by reference. 246.

The testimony from Senators Kerrey and Graham is consistent with the views of

the 9/11 Commission staff members who led the investigation into the involvement of Bayoumi and Thumairy in the attacks. As detailed in the definitive account of the 9/11 Commission’s investigation, those staff members “felt strongly that they had demonstrated a close Saudi government connection to the two hijackers in San Diego,” but that political considerations led to the omission of that conclusion from the 9/11 Commission’s Final Report. Philip Shenon, The Commission: The Uncensored History of the 9/11 Investigation, pp. 398-99 (2008). 247.

Commissioner John Lehman also endorsed this position, expressing his view that

“it was clear early on that there was some sort of Saudi support network in San Diego that had made it possible for the hijackers to hide in plain sight.” Id. at p. 185. 60

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 62 62 of 157 of 157

248.

Further undermining the Kingdom’s efforts to characterize the 9/11 Commission

investigation as “exhaustive,” recent disclosures make clear that both the 9/11 Commission and 9/11 Joint Inquiry were deprived of critical investigative information by the FBI. 249.

For example, a Freedom of Information Act (“FOIA”) lawsuit brought against the

FBI by BrowardBulldog.org has revealed that the FBI never disclosed to the 9/11 Commission or 9/11 Joint Inquiry the existence of a massive investigation into an apparent Saudi support network for the 9/11 hijackers in Florida. The investigation concerns the extensive links between 9/11 hijackers Mohammed Atta, Marwan al Shehhi, and Ziad Jarrah, and a Saudi family residing in Florida with ties to the Saudi Royal Family. 250.

U.S. District Judge William J. Zloch, who currently presides over

BrowardBulldog.org’s FOIA suit, is currently reviewing more than 80,000 pages of records recently turned over by the FBI concerning the FBI’s Florida investigation. The FBI initially responded to the lawsuit by claiming that it had no responsive documents. 251.

Senator Graham insists the FBI never disclosed the existence of the Sarasota

investigation to either the Congressional Joint Inquiry or the 9/11 Commission, nor provided them with a single document relating to the investigation. According to Graham, the FBI’s Florida probe “opens the door to a new chapter of investigation as to the depth of the Saudi role in 9/11.” B.

MOHAMMED JABER HASSAN FAKIHI AND THE HAMBURG CELL

252.

The Saudi Ministry of Islamic Affairs is further implicated in the September 11th

terrorist attacks by virtue of the relationship between the 9/11 plot’s “Hamburg cell” and the head of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs office in the Saudi Arabian Embassy in Berlin, Germany, Muhammad Jaber Hassan Fahiki. 253.

The “Hamburg cell” consisted of key operatives in the September 11th attacks,

including Mohammad Atta (the ringleader of the 19 hijackers who piloted American Airlines Flight 11), Marwan al Shehhi (piloted United Airlines Flight 175), Ziad Jarrah (piloted United

61

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 63 63 of 157 of 157

Airlines Flight 93), Ramzi Binalshibh, Mounir el Motassadeq, Said Bahaji, Zakariya Essabar, Abdelghani Mzoudi, and others. 254.

Fakihi, who worked for the Ministry of Islamic Affairs in Riyadh following his

graduation from the King Saud University in 1995, was assigned to head the Islamic Affairs office at the Saudi Embassy in Berlin in or around June 2000. Fakihi answered directly to the Saudi Minister of Islamic Affairs in Riyadh, Saleh bin Abdulaziz al Ashaikh. 255.

As a representative of the Saudi Embassy and Ministry of Islamic Affairs, Fakihi

frequently attended the Al Nur Mosque in Berlin. The mosque was a notorious haven for Islamic extremists, often hosting Muslim clerics that preached intolerance of non-Muslims and justified violence in the name of defending Islam. Dr. Salem Rafei, a Lebanese cleric who ran the mosque, openly supported Palestinian suicide attacks and called Muslims to kill all unbelievers standing in the way of Islam. Documents containing the mosque’s address were seized from individuals detained by Pakistani authorities who are alleged to have received military training at al Qaeda camps in Afghanistan in 2001. 256.

Fakihi, himself an adherent to the most extreme teachings of Wahhabi ideology,

advocated for the development of mosques across Europe and told his superiors in the Kingdom that his ultimate goal was to turn Berlin into an Islamic proselytizing center for Eastern Europe. In June 2000, Fakihi wrote a letter to the Saudi Minister of Islamic Affairs, Saleh bin Abdulaziz al Ashaikh, proposing to turn the Al Nur Mosque into a center for Islamic missionary activity aimed at “ethnic European” populations in Eastern Europe. Fakihi, who planned to move his office to the Al Nur Mosque, proposed to carry the word of Islam to Poland, the Czech Republic and Hungary, the last of “which once belonged to the Islamic Caliphate under Ottoman Empire rule.” 257.

Fakihi arranged for Saudi charities to fund the expansion of the Al Nur Mosque

consistent with his vision. In particular, the Saudi-based Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, a purported charity that was itself headed by the Saudi Minister of Islamic Affairs, donated $1.2 million to help the mosque purchase a newer, larger building outfitted with prayer rugs, 62

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 64 64 of 157 of 157

classrooms, kitchens, shops, and an Internet server. According to municipal records in Berlin, Aqeel al Aqeel, Al Haramain’s Director-General, was one of the building’s owners. Aqeel was designated by the U.S. Treasury Department as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist (“SDGT”) on June 2, 2004. According to the Treasury Department, the Al Haramain Islamic Foundation provided “financial and material support to the al Qaida network” while under Aqeel’s leadership. 258.

Mohammad Atta and other members of the Hamburg cell, including Mounir el

Motassadeq, were seen visiting the mosque and meeting with Fakihi. Fakihi’s business card was found in the apartment of Motassadeq, who was later arrested and convicted in a German court for being an accessory to murder relative to the September 11th attacks, given his membership in the Hamburg cell and his knowledge and involvement in the preparation of the plans to hijack the planes. 259.

Fakihi further used the Al Nur Mosque to meet with other al Qaeda members and

Islamic extremists. In March 2003, German police raided a suspected terrorist cell in Berlin and arrested a half-dozen men who were planning a large scale terrorist attack in Germany. Bombmaking equipment, forged passports, flight-simulator software, chemicals and a handbook for brewing poisons were seized during the raid. German police said Fakihi met frequently at the Al Nur Mosque with the terror cell’s leader, Ihsan Garnaoui, a Tunisian al Qaeda member. 260.

Two days after the arrests, on March 22, 2003, the German Foreign Ministry,

following a recommendation from the country’s domestic-intelligence service, told the Saudi Embassy that Fakihi’s diplomatic accreditation would be withdrawn unless he left the country. Four days later, Fakihi flew back to Saudi Arabia. 261.

Amid concerns that Fakihi may have funneled hundreds of thousands of dollars

out of official Saudi Embassy accounts to al Qaeda operatives in Europe, Saudi investigators interrogated him upon his return to the Kingdom. According to testimony presented during a September 10, 2003 hearing before the Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Terrorism, Technology, and Homeland Security by Matthew Levitt (a former counterterrorism intelligence 63

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 65 65 of 157 of 157

analyst for the FBI who would later be appointed to serve as deputy assistant secretary for intelligence and analysis at the U.S. Department of the Treasury from 2005-2007), Fakihi confessed to his interrogators that he in fact transferred Saudi Embassy funds to certain charities, mosques and other recipients per the instructions he received from al Qaeda loyalists and “close friends” of Osama bin Laden. U.S. officials familiar with the Saudi investigation claim that Fakihi was “more than just a sympathizer of bin Laden” and was “organizationally involved” with bin Laden’s al Qaeda network. Saudi investigators reportedly reviewed some $800,000 in funds that were doled out by the Saudi Embassy’s Ministry of Islamic Affairs office while under Fakihi’s leadership. 262.

Saudi authorities nevertheless obstructed the German government’s investigation

into links between Fakihi and the members of the Hamburg cell. The Saudi Embassy in Berlin never responded to a formal request from German prosecutors to explain the presence of Fakihi’s business card in Motassadeq’s apartment or an alleged meeting between Fakihi and Motassadeq in Berlin shortly before the al Qaeda member’s arrest in November 2001. In an interview with the Wall Street Journal in 2003, a German police official stated that the Saudi Embassy failed to cooperate in the probe. 263.

9/11 Commission member Dietrich L. Snell conducted an interview with Fakihi in

October 2003 in Riyadh relative to his duties with the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, his association with the Al Nur Mosque, and his relationships with Motassadeq and Garnaoui. The interview was conducted under the watchful eye of the Saudi secret police, the Mabahith. According to Snell, Fakihi’s testimony “did not appear credible.” C.

POST 9/11 COUNTER-TERRORISM INITIATIVES TARGETING THE MINISTRY OF ISLAMIC AFFAIRS

264.

As further evidence of the depth of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs’ ties to terrorist

movements, including al Qaeda, came to light in the wake of the September 11th Attacks, the United States and other governments directly targeted the Ministry and officials of the Ministry in a series of counter-terrorism initiatives.

64

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 66 66 of 157 of 157

265.

In December 2003, the State Department deported and revoked the visas of

approximately sixteen (16) individuals who were using their diplomatic status as representatives of the Saudi Embassy in Washington D.C. to promote and spread the radical and extremist Wahhabi ideology in the United States. 266.

The group included Jaafar Idris, an influential cleric who worked out of the

Ministry of Islamic Affairs office in the Saudi Embassy, who from his position at the Embassy worked extensively with Fairfax, VA-based Institute for Islamic and Arabic Sciences in America (“IIAS”), to promote extremist Wahhabi propaganda via student lectures and textbooks. 267.

IIAS, fully funded by the Saudi government, was operating as a satellite campus

of the Al Imam Muhammad Ibn Saud Islamic University in Riyadh. Saudi Ambassador Prince Bandar bin Sultan bin Abdul Aziz al Saud acted as the Chairman of IIAS’s Board of Trustees. 268.

Idris, who was well-known in Islamic radical circles, was president of American

Open University in Alexandria, VA, and further founded the Islamic Foundation of America in Springfield, VA, which operated a school, a mosque, and a prison-outreach program. According to U.S. government sources, the Foundation’s office was regularly visited by celebrated Islamic extremists, including Siraj Wahhaj, a New York imam who was identified as an unindicted conspirator in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing. 269.

The State Department’s actions coincided with investigations conducted by the

Internal Revenue Service and Senate Finance Committee into IIAS and its links to terrorist groups, forcing the Saudi government to end its sponsorship of the school. 270.

In a January 29, 2004 letter to then Secretary of State Colin L. Powell, Senator

Charles Schumer urged the State Department to follow up its decision to revoke the visas of the Saudi officials and increase pressure on the Saudi government “to shut down the Islamic Affairs sections at their American diplomatic posts and to cease funding the Institute for Islamic and Arabic Sciences (IIAS).” According to Senator Schumer, “the Saudis continue to sponsor and promote the spread of religious extremism in the U.S.,” particularly the Islamic Affairs offices

65

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 67 67 of 157 of 157

which “supply textbooks to Muslim schools in the U.S. that promote an intolerant Wahhabi line.” 271.

In late June 2004, dozens of federal agents connected to the FBI, Bureau of

Immigration and Customs, and the IRS raided and searched IIAS as part of the U.S. government’s on-going investigation into the school’s links to radical Islam. 272.

On July 22, 2004, Senator Schumer introduced a resolution, co-sponsored by

Senator Susan B. Collins, urging the State Department to add the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia to the U.S. list of religiously intolerant nations. Citing “Saudi efforts to export militant ideology” and “Saudi-funded schools and mosques [that] continue to teach hatred and preach violence around the world,” the Schumer-Collins resolution called on Saudi Arabia to cease its support of religious ideologies that promoted hatred, intolerance, violence, and other abuses of international recognized human rights. Moreover, the resolution called on Saudi Arabia to cease providing undeserved diplomatic status to Islamic clerics and educators teaching outside of Saudi Arabia, and further demanded that the Kingdom close any Ministry of Islamic Affairs office in any Saudi Embassy that has been responsible for propagating intolerance. 273.

Authorities in the Netherlands took similar action as well. Based on evidence that

Saudi-educated clerics and Saudi-funded mosques and other missionary organizations were propagating an intolerant Wahhabi ideology within Muslim communities in the Netherlands, and encouraging young Muslim men to engage in jihad, the Dutch Intelligence and Security Service (“AIVD”) conducted surveillance of six Saudi-funded mosques that government officials maintain were consciously contributing to the radicalization of Muslims in the Netherlands. 274.

The mosques included the El Tawheed Mosque (Amsterdam), Al Fourqaan

Mosque (Eindhoven), Sjeikh Al Islam Ibn Taymia (Hague), Al Mouahidine Mosque (Helmond), Society of Islamic Youth (Breda), and the Islamic Society for Education and Knowledge Transfer (Tilburg). 275.

Beginning in December 2001, the AIVD began closely monitoring the El

Tawheed Mosque due to growing concerns of radical Egyptian and Saudi influences. The Saudi66

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 68 68 of 157 of 157

based Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, designated by the U.S. Treasury Department as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist (“SDGT”) entity, was responsible for establishing and financing the mosque. In 2002, the AIVD identified a group of Muslim youth affiliated with the El Tawheed Mosque known as the “Hofstad Group.” This group, an indigenous Islamist terrorist cell of approximately twenty young Dutch Muslims of mainly North African descent, met often at the mosque where they received inspiration to develop their skills as jihadists and were urged to travel abroad to wage jihad. 276.

In the summer of 2004, several members of the Hofstad Group were arrested for

planning to launch terrorist attacks against Amsterdam International Airport Schipol, a nuclear reactor, and other targets. In November 2004, the group attracted international attention when a member, Mohammed Bouyeri, murdered Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh on an Amsterdam sidewalk in broad daylight. 277.

The Saudi-funded Al Fourqaan Mosque itself has a history of Islamic extremism

and has been widely considered the most radical mosque in the Netherlands. For instance, the Al Fourqaan Mosque is closely affiliated with the Saudi-based Al Waqf Foundation, a Muslim cultural organization which opened its doors in Eindhoven in 1989 and operates from the Al Fourqaan Mosque itself. According to the AIVD, Al Waqf promotes the radical teachings of Wahhabi Islam and serves as a recruiting ground for jihad. Ahmad al Hussaini, the head of Al Waqf in Eindhoven and a member of its Board of Directors since June 1991, is a known financier of the al Qaeda network. Hussaini transferred funds to Muhammad Galeb Zouaydi, al Qaeda’s principal financier in Europe. 278.

Al Waqf, which maintained close ties with Islamic primary schools in the

Netherlands, frequently hosted educational courses and seminars as part of its effort to propagate the Wahhabi strain of Islam and promote anti-Western sentiment. Attendance at the seminars became a critical credential for young Muslim men aspiring to join jihad. 279.

In early 1999, Hamburg cell members and future 9/11 hijackers Mohammad Atta

and Marwan al Shehhi attended a religious training seminar hosted by Al Waqf at the Al 67

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 69 69 of 157 of 157

Fourqaan Mosque. Following the seminar, Atta and Shehhi traveled to al Qaeda camps in Afghanistan for training. 280.

Later that same year, Hamburg cell members Mounir el Motassadeq and Zakariya

Essabar attended Al Waqf’s Ramadan seminar at the Al Fourqaan Mosque. The five-day event was organized by the Saudi Ministry of Islamic Affairs. Not long after attending the seminar, Motassadeq also traveled to Afghanistan to train at an al Qaeda-run camp. 281.

In June 2005, concerned that foreign-born and trained imams were becoming a

threat to public order and national security, Dutch Immigration and Integration Minister Rita Verdonk announced the deportation of three radical imams from the Al Fourqan Mosque, accusing the men of radicalizing Muslims, recruiting men for jihad, and inciting violence within the mosque. The imams were also accused of using their sermons to urge Muslims to “isolate” themselves from the rest of Dutch society, 282.

Charged with “contributing to the radicalization of Muslims in the Netherlands”

and “advocating violence through their militant, anti-Western sermons,” the Dutch government deported Galal Osman Ahmed Kehil (a Saudi national), Eisha Eltayeb Bersham (a/k/a “Abu Tareq;” a Bosnian national), and Mohamud Mohamed Mohamud (a Kenyan national who studied at the University of Medina in Saudi Arabia). 283.

A fourth imam, from the Iskender Pasa Camil Mosque in Rotterdam, was also

deported by Dutch authorities that same year for provoking hatred and inciting people to jihad. 284.

Under pressure from the United States, the Saudis themselves ultimately

acknowledged the depth of the problem regarding the radical and extremist teachings of the Saudi-educated clerics connected to the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, albeit only after al Qaeda carried out attacks within the Kingdom itself in 2003. 285.

Beginning in 2003, the Saudi government began to remove the most radical

clerics within its ranks and sent others to rehabilitation programs for training and monitoring. According to a February 1, 2007 diplomat cable originating from the U.S. Embassy in Riyadh,

68

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 70 70 of 157 of 157

approximately 2,000 extremist clerics were terminated by the government, while another 2,160 clerics were sent to reeducation training programs. X.

THE ATTRIBUTABLE TORTIOUS ACTS OF SAUDI ARABIA’S CHARITY AGENTS AND ALTER-EGOS IN PROVIDING MATERIAL SUPPORT AND RESOURCES TO AL QAEDA 286.

As discussed previously, da’awa organizations established and controlled as arms

and alter-egos of the Saudi government collaborated intimately with al Qaeda from that terrorist organization’s establishment through September 11, 2001, serving as the most important sources of financial and logistical support necessary to build and sustain the al Qaeda organization, and essential to obtaining the global strike capabilities necessary to carry out the September 11th attacks. 287.

The Saudi-government da’awa organizations that worked most closely with al

Qaeda in the years preceding the September 11th attacks, and whose support was most critical in the success of those attacks, include the IIRO, MWL, SHC, SJRC, SRC, WAMY, al Haramain Islamic Foundation (al Haramain), al Haramain al Masjil al Aqsa, and Rabita Trust. 288.

The collaboration between the Saudi da’awa organizations and al Qaeda dated to

the Afghan jihad, when several of those da’awa organizations worked with the future al Qaeda leadership to support the jihad against the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan. 289.

Their partnerships with al Qaeda were continuously reinforced and expanded

during the years before the September 11th attacks, through their intimate collaborations in a range of conflicts where they joined in conducting jihad, as in Bosnia-Herzegovina, where a war broke out in 1992, primarily between Bosnian Muslims and Bosnian Serbs, just as the Saudi regime campaign to restore its legitimacy by supporting the Islamist agenda of the Ulema outside of Saudi Arabia was unfolding. 290.

For the Saudi regime, the outbreak of the Bosnian war presented a timely

opportunity for the House of Saud to demonstrate its dedication to the defense of the Ummah, one of the duties the Ulema had called on the Kingdom to fulfill in the Letter of Demands and Memorandum of Advice. 69

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 71 71 of 157 of 157

291.

The Bosnian war presented a timely opportunity for al Qaeda as well. As

discussed above, al Qaeda was formed to carry out jihad throughout the globe, and participation in military conflicts involving Muslim communities (as the mujahideen had done in Afghanistan) was a central pillar of its strategy to establish Islamic regimes throughout the World. Waging jihad in Bosnia also offered al Qaeda an opportunity to establish a base of operations in Europe, from which it could launch future terrorist attacks against the West. At the same time, the Arab veterans of the Afghan jihad were being expelled from Pakistan. For many of these jihadists, return to their home countries was impossible, as they were viewed as extremists and faced potential imprisonment. Finding a new jihad front for these fighters was therefore essential to maintaining the nascent al Qaeda army. Beyond these strategic considerations, as an Islamist organization deriving its ideological foundation from the teachings of Wahhabi Islam and the Western Cultural Attack theory, al Qaeda believed Muslims owed a personal obligation to carry out jihad in defense of the Bosnian Muslims, a view that was shared by the Saudi Ulema. 292.

In 1992, bin Laden, who was by then residing in Sudan under the protection of the

National Islamic Front, sent a delegation of senior al Qaeda members to Bosnia to assess the situation and evaluate the logistical needs for waging jihad in the region. The delegation was led by Abu Abdel Aziz, a Saudi veteran of the Afghan jihad and senior al Qaeda member. Abu Adbel Aziz, also known by the aliases Barabarossa (Red Beard), Abdelrahman al-Dosari, and Hown (for his proficiency during the Afghan jihad with Russian made “Hound” artillery), succinctly explained in an interview the circumstances under which al Qaeda sent him to Bosnia following the conclusion of the Afghan jihad, as part of al Qaeda’s broader efforts to find new regions for waging jihad: Then the conquest of Kabul came, and we thanked Allah, praised be He. The joy of Jihad overwhelmed our hearts. The Prophet, peace be upon him, said, “The highest peak of Islam is Jihad.” We were looking for Jihad (after Afghanistan). We found it in the Philippines, and in Kashmir. Only fifteen days lapsed (after the conquest of Kabul) and the crisis of Bosnia begun. This confirmed the saying of the Prophet (of Islam), peace and blessings be upon

70

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 72 72 of 157 of 157

him, who said, “Indeed Jihad will continue till the day of Judgment.” A new Jihad started in Bosnia, (we moved there), and we are with it, if Allah wills. [W]hen Jihad in Afghanistan was over, with the conquest of Kabul, I went with four of those who participated in Afghanistan to Bosnia to check out the landscape. 293.

In that same interview Abu Abdel Aziz confirmed the convergence of interests

between al Qaeda and the Saudi Ulema in relation to the Bosnian War, and the importance as a religious matter of the latter’s specific authorization for al Qaeda’s proposed jihad in Bosnia: Interviewer: We heard, and many brothers heard, that you met with prominent Ulema and scholars in the Muslim World and discussed with them the question of Jihad in Bosnia. Can you tell us some of their views and the issues you discussed? Abu Abdel Aziz: First, we consider our scholars the light and guidance of Islam. They are the heirs of prophets (as the Hadith says, “warathat al-Anbiya”). Our duty is to seek knowledge from them and guidance from their scholarly light (sic). I alhamdulillah - met several prominent Ulema. Among them Sheikh Nasir ad-Din al-Albani, Sheikh Abdel Aziz Bin Baz and Sheikh Muhammad Bin Otheimin and others in the Gulf area. Alhamdulillah, all grace be to Allah, they all support the religious dictum that “the fighting in Bosnia is a fight to make the word of Allah supreme and protect the chastity of Muslims.” It is because Allah said (in his holy book), “Yet, if they ask you for succor against religious persecution, it is your duty to give [them] this succor.” (Lit. “to succor them in religion”, Qur’an, al-Anfal, 8:72). It is then our (religious) duty to defend our Muslim brethren wherever they are, as long as they are persecuted because they are Muslims and not for any other reason. 294.

At the time he endorsed al Qaeda’s jihad in Bosnia, Sheikh bin Baz was both

Saudi Arabia’s Grand Mufti and a senior Saudi official with the rank of Minister. Thus, Abu Abdel Aziz’s statements confirm that al Qaeda’s jihad in Bosnia was formally sanctioned by the Saudi government. 295.

Bin Baz used his governmental post as the Kingdom’s highest religious authority

to encourage public support for al Qaeda’s Bosnian jihad as well, issuing a fatwa calling on

71

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 73 73 of 157 of 157

Muslims to support that jihad by any means available to them, including by way of “money, arms and prayers.” 296.

In accordance with the fatwas issued by its senior religious leaders, the Kingdom

aggressively deployed its da’awa infrastructure to support the Bosnian jihad. Existing Saudi da’awa organizations such as the IIRO, WAMY, al Haramain Islamic Foundation, and al Haramain al Masjil al Aqsa Foundation promptly established physical operations in Bosnia and the surrounding region to support the jihad. In addition, the Kingdom established a new da’awa organization under the leadership of Prince Salman bin Abdul Aziz al Saud, called the Saudi High Commission for Relief to Bosnia and Herzegovina (SHC), to steward and centralize the Kingdom’s Bosnian efforts. 297.

From the inception of the conflict, these organizations sponsored the entry into

the region of hundreds of jihadists eager to join the fighting. Many of these jihadists were Saudi veterans of the Afghan jihad, known to the Kingdom by virtue of its intimate participation in that earlier conflict and subsequent monitoring of their activities to be associates of bin Laden, and members of his nascent jihad organization. 298.

Throughout the course of the Bosnian war, the Saudi government controlled

da’awa organizations, including the SHC, al Haramain, IIRO and WAMY, provided money, food, shelter and supplies to al Qaeda fighters. In many cases, this support was coordinated by senior al Qaeda members who were embedded in the da’awa organizations themselves as directors, managers and officials. These organizations also transported al Qaeda members throughout the region in their vehicles bearing UNHCR plates, thereby allowing al Qaeda to circumvent UN checkpoints. After the conclusion of the war, the Saudi da’awa organizations provided ostensible employment to many al Qaeda members, so that they could remain in Bosnia in furtherance of al Qaeda’s operational goals. Several of those al Qaeda members planned and carried out terrorist attacks from offices of the SHC, while ostensibly employed by that organization.

72

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 74 74 of 157 of 157

299.

The methodology employed by the Kingdom to support the Bosnian jihad was

implemented in regions throughout the world to advance al Qaeda’s global agenda, but ably adapted to suit the particular objectives and conditions presented by the local context. 300.

For example, at the time of its founding, al Qaeda identified the Philippines as a

potential fertile ground for jihad. Muslims in the southern Philippines had been engaged in a long-running but unsuccessful campaign to establish an independent Muslim state, which had taken on an increasingly militant and Islamist character under the banner of the Moro Islamic Liberation Front, following a failed peace agreement in 1976. Al Qaeda had strong relationships with members of MILF and Philippine jihadists, as a result of Mohammed Jamal Khalifa’s successful campaign to recruit Philippine Muslims to join the Afghan jihad. The opportunity presented by these circumstances fit perfectly into al Qaeda’s global strategy, and in particular its plans to exploit regional conflicts to expand its global reach and promote the establishment of Shariah based states. 301.

The Saudi Ulema had likewise long identified with the Philippine Islamic

movement, and advocated that the Saudi state support the effort of Philippine Islamists to establish an independent Shariah state. From at least the 1980’s, the Muslim World League was actively engaged in da’awa and political activities aimed at supporting the Philippine Islamist independence movement. 302.

To both al Qaeda and the Saudi Ulema, the inability of Muslims in the Philippines

to achieve their goal of establishing an independent state was largely attributable to a lack of understanding and application of the true (Wahhabi) Islam. In addition, based on their joint activities in Afghanistan, the al Qaeda leadership and Saudi da’awa organizations believed that the goals of the Philippine Islamist movement could be achieved only through jihad by trained, indoctrinated, dedicated, highly ideologized, and organized mujahid. 303.

Based on this understanding of the circumstances and challenges facing the

Philippine Islamist movement, al Qaeda implemented a comprehensive strategic plan for

73

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 75 75 of 157 of 157

promoting the jihadist movement in the Philippines, to be carried out under the cover of humanitarian activities of the MWL, IIRO and AHIF. 304.

In furtherance of that plan, the MWL and IIRO established offices in the

Philippines and Indonesia in approximately 1989. The Kingdom appointed Mohammed Jamal Khalifa to serve as Director of those offices. At the time of his appointment, the Kingdom was aware that Khalifa was a prominent veteran of the Afghan jihad and close associate of bin Laden. Khalifa has affirmed that all of his activities as Director of the IIRO in the Philippines and Indonesia were carried out under the supervision and direction of the Saudi Embassy in the Philippines. 305.

Using IIRO funds and resources, Khalifa established an Islamic “school” called

Dar al Imam al Sahfi’e, and personally selected and invited the most promising young Philippine jihadists to become students. The curriculum of Dar al Imaam al Shafi’e was designed to indoctrinate the students in the most intolerant conceptualization of Wahhabi Islam, and prepare them to carry out jihad and terrorist activities as members of a covert organization. 306.

Simultaneously, Khalifa entered into negotiations with Abdurajik Janjalani, a

local Islamist leader whom Khalifa had recruited to the Afghan jihad, regarding the establishment of an al Qaeda proxy in the Far East. In basic terms, Khalifa offered to provide funding through the IIRO for a jihad organization to be headed by Janjalani, subject to Janjalani’s agreement that the organization would take direction from al Qaeda. The negotiations ultimately led to the establishment of Abu Sayyaf Group. Khalifa filled the ranks of Abu Sayyaf with graduates of Dar ul Imaam al Sahfi’e, and using IIRO funds arranged for them to be trained in terrorist techniques at camps operated by MILF. Khalifa gave certain Abu Sayyaf members ghost positions with the IIRO, typically as “da’awa instructors,” to provide an income to support them while they carried out jihad. 307.

Since its formation through the patronage of the MWL/IIRO, the Abu Sayyaf

Group has systematically targeted U.S. citizens in a series of kidnappings, bombings and brutal killings. These include the beheading of an American citizen in 2001, the 2002 bombing of a bar 74

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 76 76 of 157 of 157

across the street from a United States military camp, and a 2009 bombing which killed two U.S. soldiers on a humanitarian mission. 308.

Beyond its role in establishing and supporting Abu Sayyaf, the IIRO used its

Philippine and Indonesian offices to support the terrorist activities of 1993 World Trade Center Bomber Ramzi Youssef and 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. The plots developed by Youssef and Mohammed in conjunction with Khalifa and the IIRO included a plan to assassinate of Pope John Paul II during a January 1995 trip to the Philippines and a plot to simultaneously bomb multiple U.S. airliners as they flew from Asia to the United States, dubbed Operation Bojinka. The Operation Bojinka plot served as inspiration for the September 11th Attacks. 309.

In Kosovo and Albania, the partnership between al Qaeda and the Saudi da’awa

organizations more closely tracked the program implemented in Bosnia, owing to the similarity of the of the conflicts that drew al Qaeda to those regions. 310.

The conflict in Kosovo erupted in 1998, when ethnic Albanians in Kosovo

demanded their independence from Serbia and the Kosovo Liberation Army came out in open rebellion against Serbian rule. 311.

As was the case in Bosnia, al Qaeda saw in the Kosovo conflict an opportunity to

extend the global jihad and advance its strategic interests. 312.

Consistent with the model which had been applied in Afghanistan and Bosnia, the

Saudi da’awa institutions quickly established physical operations in the region to support al Qaeda’s intervention in the Kosovo conflict. The Kingdom again established an umbrella organization, called the Saudi Joint Relief Committee for Kosovo and Albania, to coordinate Saudi Arabia’s activities in the region. In a move that plainly demonstrated the SJRC’s true mission in the region, the Kingdom appointed Wa’el Jelaidan to serve as Director of the Pristina offices of the SJRC, thereby embedding a founding al Qaeda member in a powerful and pivotal role in the organization. Contemporaneous to Jelaidan’s appointment to his position in the SJRC by the government of the Kingdom, bin Laden described Jelaidan as a close associate in a widely 75

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 77 77 of 157 of 157

disseminated interview with al Jazeera. Not surprisingly, Jelaidan promptly began using the SJRC as a front for planning terrorist attacks against Western interests and moving men and weapons into the region for bin Laden, according to the U.S. government. 313.

Within Africa, al Qaeda’s charity partners worked closely with bin Laden to build

al Qaeda’s infrastructure, and directly supported al Qaeda’s military and terrorist operations throughout the continent. In this context, the SHC facilitated arms shipments to General Mohammad Farah Hassan Aideed, the al Qaeda affiliated Somali warlord responsible for the massacre of American troops during the Battle of Mogadishu, according to a Defense Intelligence Agency Report. The IIRO and al Haramain were, in turn, directly implicated in the 1998 African embassy bombings. 314.

In Europe and the United States, the Saudi da’awa organizations have focused

primarily on spreading al Qaeda’s jihadist ideology, encouraging Muslim communities to reject Western culture and values, recruiting Western Muslims to al Qaeda’s cause, raising funds to support al Qaeda’s global jihad, and providing cover for the planning and execution of terrorist attacks. In explaining the role of the da’awa organizations in promoting the jihadist agenda in Europe, the Dutch Intelligence Service explained as follows: The groups focusing on Dawa follow a long-term strategy of continuous influencing based on extreme puritanical, intolerant and anti-Western ideas. They want Muslims in the West to reject Western values and standards, propagating extreme isolation from western society and often intolerance towards other groups in society. They also encourage these Muslims to (covertly) develop parallel structures in society and to take the law into their own hands. 315.

As a complement to their financial, ideological and operational support for these

regional objectives and activities, the Saudi da’awa organizations provided a robust, secure and consistent source of funding for al Qaeda’s global infrastructure. For example, a 1996 CIA Report concerning the involvement of purported charities in the sponsorship of terrorism indicates that the IIRO provided the funding for six al Qaeda training camps in Afghanistan. Al

76

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 78 78 of 157 of 157

Haramain has separately been described by the U.S. government as a “principal” source of funding for al Qaeda. 316.

U.S. officials and knowledgeable experts have repeatedly confirmed the

intersection among Wahhabi ideology, the activities of Saudi Arabia’s government-controlled charities, and al Qaeda, in both sworn testimony and public statements: The Committee is also well aware that the challenges posed by terrorist financing from within Saudi Arabia are among the most daunting we have faced. Wealthy Saudi financiers and charities have funded terrorist organizations and causes that support terrorism and the ideology that fuels the terrorists’ agenda. Even today, we believe that Saudi donors may still be a significant source of terrorist financing, including for the insurgency in Iraq. Saudi Arabia-based and funded organizations remain a key source for the promotion of ideologies used by terrorists and violent extremists around the world to justify their hate-filled agenda. Saudi Arabian charities, particularly the International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO), the World Association of Muslim Youth (WAMY), and the Muslim World League (MWL) continue to cause us concern. Money Laundering and Terror Financing Issues in the Middle East, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs (July 13, 2005), Testimony of Treasury Department Undersecretary for Terrorism and Financial Intelligence Stuart Levey. Saudi Arabia has been one of the most significant funding mechanisms for terrorist organizations, especially Al Qaeda. Money Laundering and Terror Financing Issues in the Middle East, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs (July 13, 2005), Testimony of Dennis M. Lormel. It is widely known that the Saudi government has permitted and even encouraged fundraising by charitable Islamic groups and foundations that have been linked to known terrorist organizations. Saudi Arabia: Friend or Foe in the War on Terror, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary (November 8, 2005), Statement of Senator Patrick J. Leahy. Troubling reports continue to question Saudi Arabia’s efforts to curb terrorist financing. Saudi officials have yet to clearly separate themselves from radical Islamic charities that seek to manipulate

77

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 79 79 of 157 of 157

misperceptions of the US and its relations with Israel and to promote violence. Saudi Arabia: Friend or Foe in the War on Terror, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary (November 8, 2005), Statement of Senator Russell D. Feingold. On May 23 of this year, just a few months ago, the Under Secretary of the Department of the Treasury, Stuart Levey, made this statement, quote, “In addition to the export of terrorist funds, we are extremely concerned about the export of terror ideologies. These teachings are as indispensable to terrorists as money and possibly even more dangerous. We must do all we can to ensure that extremists’ violent ideologies are not disseminated under the cover of religious organizations, charities, or schools.” Saudi Arabia: Friend or Foe in the War on Terror, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on the Judiciary (November 8, 2005), Statement of Senator Arlen Specter. Last month, the General Counsel of the Treasury Department testified before the Terrorism Subcommittee of the Judiciary Committee that in many cases Saudi Arabia is the “epicenter” of terrorist financing. The Council on Foreign Relations report found that for years individuals and charities based in Saudi Arabia have been the most important source of funds for al-Qaeda and that for years Saudi officials have turned a blind eye to this problem. As our witnesses Ambassador Dore Gold and Steven Emerson will describe in some detail, there is evidence that enormous sums of money flow from Saudi individuals and charitable organizations to al-Qaeda, to Hamas, and other terrorist organizations. Terrorism Financing: Origination, Organization, and Prevention, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs (July 31, 2003), Statement of Senator Susan M. Collins. Saudi government officials and prominent Saudi citizens have routinely contributed millions of dollars to Muslim charities which support terrorism, including supporting families of terrorists killed in bombings or other terrorist attacks. Terrorism Financing: Origination, Organization, and Prevention, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs (July 31, 2003), Opening Statement of U.S. Senator Carl M. Levin. Using an elaborate network of mosques, schools, “charitable” and “humanitarian” organizations, and even official diplomatic facilities, Saudi Arabia has for years fostered the growth and spread of a militant doctrinal interpretation of Islam. The ideology 78

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 80 80 of 157 of 157

of Wahhabism has been exported not only throughout the Middle East but throughout the world resulting in the indoctrination of anti-American, anti-Christian, anti-Semitic and anti-western hatred among new generations of militant Islamic youth. Coupled with its virtually unlimited financial resources, the Wahhabi dawah invariably leads to acts of terror against nonMuslims and moderate Muslims alike. For years, components of Saudi charities have been used to funnel money or divert resources to terrorist organizations. Terrorism Financing: Origination, Organization, and Prevention, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs (July 31, 2003), Prepared Testimony of Steven Emerson and Jonathan Levin. Today’s hearing is the second in a series of hearings to investigate the roots of terrorist ideology, terrorist support networks, and state sponsorship – especially the continued financial support from Saudi Arabia – estimated at billions of dollars per year for nearly 40 years – and what the U.S. government can do to counter these terrorists and their supporters. Saudi Arabia has a deep historical and symbiotic relationship with the radical Islamic ideology of Wahhabism. The Saudis continue aggressively to export this intolerant and violent form of Islam to Muslims across the globe, and to inculcate it in the major institutions of Islam worldwide. Terrorism: Two Years After 9/11, Connecting the Dots, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Terrorism, Technology and Homeland Security (September 10, 2003), Statement of Senator Jon Kyl. In order to maintain its leadership in the Islamic world, Saudi Arabia sends aid and builds mosques that spread its Wahhabi variant of Islam around the world. Some of this money goes via official Saudi channels, some goes via what are claimed to be nonofficial channels, and some goes via Islamic charities linked to the Saudi government. Each of these has been linked to al-Qaeda and Islamic terrorism. The Saudi Foreign Ministry and its network of embassies provides a crucial structure for the propagation of Wahhabism and distributing state funds to support the growth of Wahhabism across the world. Until 9/11 it was not widely realized that Saudi embassies had Islamic affairs departments charged with this role. Saudi Arabia depicts this role of their embassies in innocent terms. But here in Washington, funds from the ambassador’s wife were 79

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 81 81 of 157 of 157

reaching Saudi individuals in California linked to 9/11. And several countries, including the US, have withdrawn diplomatic credentials from Saudis working in Islamic affairs departments because of links with terrorism. Terrorism: Two Years After 9/11, Connecting the Dots, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Terrorism, Technology and Homeland Security (September 10, 2003), Testimony of Simon Henderson. [M]ilitant Islamists command a disproportionate share of media and political attention as a result of substantial funding received from wealthy benefactors, led by the Saudis and their Wahhabi brand of Islam. With deep pocketbooks and religious conviction, the Saudi Wahhabists have bankrolled a series of Islamic institutions in the United States that actively seek to undermine U.S. counterterrorism policy at home and abroad. In the United States, the Saudi Wahhabis regularly subsidize the organizations and individuals adhering to the militant ideology espoused by the Muslim Brotherhood and its murderous offshoots Hamas, Palestinian Islamic Jihad and al-Qaeda, all three of which are designated terrorist organizations. Several of these U.S. based organizations drawing Saudi support have recently been shuttered and many of their leaders indicted. Terrorism: Two Years After 9/11, Connecting the Dots, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Terrorism, Technology and Homeland Security (September 10, 2003), Testimony of Matthew Epstein. I have testified before that Saudi Arabia has been an “epicenter” of terrorist financing. Efforts to Combat Terrorism Financing, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs (September 25, 2003), Testimony of former Treasury Department General Counsel David D. Aufhauser. I want to focus for a moment one of the primary topics examined in the report and that is the role of Saudi Arabia. Right now, Saudi Arabia has two primary exports to the rest of the world: oil and an extreme form of Islam that advocates hatred and violence to achieve its ends. The report before us today does not shy away from this reality. It describes “the fundamental centrality persons and institutions based in Saudi Arabia have had in financing militant Islamist groups on a global basis.” It repeats a statement made in its earlier report: “It is worth stating clearly and unambiguously what official U.S. government spokespersons have not: For years, 80

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 82 82 of 157 of 157

individuals and charities based in Saudi Arabia have been the most important source of funds for al-Qaeda; and for years, Saudi officials have turned a blind eye to this problem.” An Assessment of Current Events to Combat Terrorism Financing, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs (June 15, 2004), Statement of Senator Carl M. Levin. As a core tenet of its foreign policy, Saudi Arabia funds the global propagation of Wahabism, a brand of Islam that, in some instances, supports militancy by encouraging divisiveness and violent acts against Muslims and non-Muslims alike. We are concerned that this massive spending is helping to create the next generation of terrorists and therefore constitutes a paramount strategic threat to the United States. Through the support for madrassas, mosques, cultural centers, hospitals, and other institutions, and the training and export of radical clerics to populate these outposts, Saudi Arabia has spent what could amount to hundreds of millions of dollars around the world financing extremism. Such Saudi financing is contributing significantly to the radicalization of millions of Muslims in places ranging from Pakistan to Indonesia to Nigeria to the United States. An Assessment of Current Events to Combat Terrorism Financing, Hearing Before the U.S. Senate Committee on Governmental Affairs (June 15, 2004), Statement of Lee S. Wolosky. 317.

Diplomatic cables authored by senior U.S. officials in the years following the

September 11th attacks have reported on the continuing problem of Saudi charities engaging in illicit and criminal activities to fund and support terror organizations such as al Qaeda, Abu Sayyaf Group, Jemaah Islamiya, Hamas and others. 318.

A February 12, 2010 cable from the U.S. Embassy in Riyadh advises that

“[t]errorist funding emanating from Saudi Arabia remains a serious concern.” 319.

According to a December 30, 2009 diplomatic cable originating from Secretary of

State Hillary Clinton’s office, titled Terrorist Finance: Action Request for Senior Level Engagement on Terrorism Finance, “it has been an on-going challenge to persuade Saudi officials to treat terrorism financing emanating for Saudi Arabia as a strategic priority.” Secretary Clinton adds that “donors in Saudi Arabia constitute the most significant source of funding to Sunni terrorist groups worldwide,” and further warns that “organizations such as the

81

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 83 83 of 157 of 157

International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO), Muslim World League (MWL) and the World Assembly of Muslim Youth (WAMY) … continue to send money overseas and, at times, fund extremism overseas.” 320.

An April 1, 2009 diplomatic cable from the U.S. Embassy in Sudan to the office

of Secretary Clinton identifies “the World Assembly of Muslim Youth” and “Al-Haramayn” as organizations in that country with links to terrorist groups, including al Qaeda, Hamas, Hezbollah, and Palestinian Islamic Jihad. 321.

A March 25, 2009 cable from the U.S. Embassy in Riyadh titled Saudi Ministry of

the Interior on Terrorist Financing Issues, advises that because of “concerns about Saudi-based non-governmental organizations (NGOs) financing terrorist networks,” the United States government continues “to look strategically at entities such as the International Islamic Relief Organization, the World Assembly of Muslim Youth, and Hamas as organizations of concern.” 322.

A March 12, 2009 cable from the U.S. Embassy in Uganda advises that

organizations operating in that country, such as the MWL and IIRO, have connections to transnational terrorism and have relationships with al Qaeda. 323.

A March 2, 2009 cable from the U.S. Embassy in Sana’a to the office of Secretary

Clinton identifies the IIRO, WAMY and Al Haramain as Saudi organizations in Yemen that have a relationship with terrorist groups in that country, including al Qaeda, Egyptian Islamic Jihad, Hamas and Palestinian Islamic Jihad. 324.

An August 21, 2008 cable from the U.S. embassy in Indonesia identifies

Muhammad Thalib, “a commission member of the Muslim World League since 1989,” as the new leader of the Majelia Mujahiddin Council. The Council operates as the political wing of the terrorist organization Jemaah Islamiya. 325.

A March 24, 2008 cable from Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice’s office

identifies “the World Assembly of Muslim Youth and the Muslim World League” as organizations with ties to terrorist organizations.

82

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 84 84 of 157 of 157

326.

A February 13, 2007 cable originating from the U.S. Embassy in Khartoum,

Sudan, identifies the IIRO as “one of the major Saudi Arabian humanitarian organizations suspected of maintaining links with al-Qaeda.” According to the U.S. government, “Usama bin Ladin used the entire IIRO network for his terrorist activities.” 327.

A June 16, 2006 cable from the office of Secretary Rice, titled Terrorism

Financing: International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO), states that “the United States is also aware of IIRO’s significant illegitimate and illegal activities that fund terrorist activity. We have been concerned about IIRO for many years now and have shared our concerns with the Government of Saudi Arabia on a regular basis.” 328.

An October 11, 2005 diplomatic cable titled Islam and Islamic Extremism in

Bulgaria, states that “the Bulgarian branch of the Saudi-based International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO)” is linked to “the Muslim Brotherhood, Al Qa’ida, and other extremist groups.” 329.

A May 23, 2005 cable titled, Islamic NGOs in the Philippines, details the IIRO’s

illicit activities: “Operated by Usama Bin Laden’s brother-in-law, Saudi businessman Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, and with links to captured al-Qaeda lieutenant Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, the IIRO served as a legal front to conceal the transfer of al-Qaeda funding and material to the Abu Sayyaf Group and possibly other insurgents or terrorists operating in the Philippines.” 330.

A June 2004 cable originating from Secretary of State Colin Powell’s office

similarly describes the IIRO’s support for al Qaeda and the Abu Sayyaf terrorist group. According to the cable: “The USG believes that some elements of the International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO) have been exploited by terrorists and their financiers as a means of transferring assets, providing organizational cover, or otherwise supporting extremist, violent operations.” The cable further states the “IIRO has been cited as the principal sponsor of terrorist training camps in Afghanistan during the Taliban regime. IIRO has also been cited as the conduit for funds from Usama Bin Laden to terrorist organizations, specifically that the Abu 83

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 85 85 of 157 of 157

Sayyaf cell in Manila was founded with money sent by Bin Laden to Mohamed Jamal Khalifa through IIRO.” 331.

An April 2004 cable from Secretary Powell’s office states that the IIRO is “tied to

al-Qaida and other terrorist organizations. For example, IIRO has been cited as the principal sponsor of terrorist training camps in Afghanistan during the Taliban regime. IIRO has also been cited as the conduit for funds from Usama Bin Laden to terrorist organizations, specifically that the Abu Sayyaf cell in Manila was founded with money sent by Bin Laden to Mohamed Jamal Khalifa through IIRO.” 332.

The pervasive involvement of the government of Saudi Arabia in sponsoring al

Qaeda’s global jihad through its state controlled da’awa organizations is further demonstrated by the facts and evidence set forth below as to each of those organizations. By virtue of their status as agents and alter-egos of the Saudi government, the terror sponsorship activities of these organizations, as described herein, are properly viewed as activities of the Saudi government itself, and attributable to the Kingdom for purposes of both subject matter jurisdiction under the FSIA, and substantive liability. As discussed previously and below, the support provided by the Kingdom’s charity agents and alter-egos was singularly important to al Qaeda’s growth and sustainment in the years leading up to the September 11th Attacks, and essential to al Qaeda’s development of the global strike capabilities employed to carry out the September 11th Attacks. THE MUSLIM WORLD LEAGUE 333.

Founded in 1962 by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the Muslim World League

(“MWL”) is among the world’s largest Islamic charitable organizations, with offices in more than thirty (30) countries. The MWL serves as an umbrella organization for a number of other Islamic charities, commonly referred to as bodies or members of the League, including the International Islamic Relief Organization (“IIRO”), World Assembly of Muslim Youth (“WAMY”), Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, Al Haramain Al Masjed Al Aqsa Foundation, and Rabita Trust, among others.

84

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 86 86 of 157 of 157

334.

The MWL is a controlled agent and alter-ego of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

The Kingdom controls and directs MWL operations, appoints and terminates MWL personnel, provides the MWL with virtually all of its funding, determines how funds will be distributed throughout the world, and otherwise stringently controls the MWL’s operations. In many countries, MWL conducts operations from the local Saudi embassy, under the supervision of the embassy’s Islamic Affairs Division. 335.

Senior officials of the MWL have expressly acknowledged that the MWL and its

subsidiary bodies are agents and alter-egos of the Saudi government. 336.

According to the affidavit testimony of Ali Mohammed al Kamal, Manager for

Financial Affairs of the MWL, “the MWL’s policies are established by its Constitutive Council, which is chaired by the Grand Mufti of Saudi Arabia. The MWL’s daily operations are conducted and supervised by its General Secretariat, which is headed by a Secretary General appointed by the Constitutive Council based on a nomination by the Saudi Government. The MWL’s annual budget is $80 million Saudi Riyals, which is funded by an annual grant from the Saudi Government.” 337.

Abdulaziz H. al Fahd, a member of the Saudi Council of Ministers, confirmed in a

separate affidavit that organizations such as the MWL and World Assembly of Muslim Youth are headed by Saudi officials, and that the Saudi government uses its da’awa organizations as tools to spread Wahabbi Islam outside of Saudi Arabia. 338.

Abdullah bin Saleh al Obaid, Secretary-General of the Muslim World League

from 1995 through 2000, has similarly affirmed the intimate relationship between the government of Saudi Arabia and MWL, explaining in an affidavit that the MWL is “sponsored and financially supported by the Saudi Government,” and that he was appointed to his position as the Secretary General of the MWL by Royal Decree. 339.

In a 1984 edition of the Muslim World League Journal, then MWL Secretary

General, Dr. Abdullah Omar Nasseef, briefly discussed the relationship between the MWL and Government of Saudi Arabia, noting that the Kingdom founded the League “in order to serve” 85

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 87 87 of 157 of 157

the Ummah throughout the World and that the MWL receives an annual budget from the Kingdom. 340.

Arafat El Asahi, the Director of IIRO in Canada and a full-time employee of the

Muslim World League, was even more explicit concerning the Kingdom’s absolute domination of the MWL and IIRO during testimony in a Canadian immigration proceeding captioned Minister of Citizenship and Immigration v. Mahmoud Jaballah, Federal Court of Canada, Docket DES-6-99, stating under oath as follows: Q: During those eight years that you have been with the IIRO here in Canada, have you ever heard anything to the effect that the Canadian government has any concern whatsoever with respect to your office? A: Let me tell you one thing, the Muslim World League, which is the mother of IIRO, is a fully government funded organization. In other words, I work for the government of Saudi Arabia. I am an employee of that government. Second, the IIRO is the relief branch of that organization which means that we are controlled in all of our activities and plans by the government of Saudi Arabia. Keep that in mind, please. . .I am paid by my organization which is funded by the [Saudi] government . . . The [IIRO] office, like any other office in the world, here or in the Muslim World League, has to abide by the policy of the Government of Saudi Arabia. If anybody deviates from that, he would be fired; he would not work at all with IIRO or with the Muslim World League. 341.

Consistent with the statements of its senior officials, the MWL has asserted in

pleadings filed in American court proceedings that it is an “instrumentality” of the government of Saudi Arabia. 342.

The MWL’s close affiliation with Osama bin Laden and other high ranking al

Qaeda officials dates to the 1980’s. During the war against the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan, Abdullah Azzam, bin Laden’s spiritual mentor and partner in Makhtab al Kidhmat, headed the office of the MWL in Peshawar, Pakistan, which served as the rear base for mujihadeen operations. That office was thereafter led by Wa’el Jelaidan, who also served as Director General and a member of the Board of Trustees of Rabita Trust, a financial arm of the

86

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 88 88 of 157 of 157

MWL. Wa’el Julaidan is a founding member of al Qaeda. On September 6, 2002, the United States Department of Treasury designated Jelaidan as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist pursuant to Executive Order 13224. The Treasury Department statement regarding the designation provided as follows: Wa’el Hamza Julaidan, a Saudi citizen, is an associate of Osama bin Laden. Julaidan fought with bin Laden in Afghanistan in the 1980s. Julaidan is also associated with several individuals and entities linked to al Qaida, including bin Laden’s lieutenants, Ayman al Zawahri, Abu Zubaida, and Mohammed Atef; and the organizations: Maktab al Khidmat, the Rabita Trust, and alGamma al Islamiya. These individuals and entities have been previously designated under President Bush’s Executive Order and by the United Nations. Bin Laden himself acknowledged close ties to Julaidan during a 1999 interview with al-Jazeera TV. When referring to the assassination of al Qaida co-founder Abdullah Azzam, bin Laden stated that “we were all in one boat, as is known to you, including our brother, Wa’el Julaidan.” Julaidan has established contacts with several known Islamic extremists, including bin Laden’s principal lieutenant, Ayman al-Zawahri. Another bin Laden lieutenant, Abu Zubaida, claimed that he had accompanied Julaidan from Pakistan to Kandahar, Afghanistan during the summer of 2000. Zubaida said that Julaidan met with bin Laden and senior bin Laden lieutenant Mohammed Atef soon after arriving in Kandahar. In February 2000, Julaidan was appointed to the Board of Trustees of the Rabita Trust and served as its director general. The Rabita Trust is an NGO designated under President Bush’s Executive Order as an organization that provided logistical and financial support to al-Qa’ida. BASIS FOR DESIGNATION The United States has credible information that Wa’el Hamza Julaidan is an associate of Osama bin Laden and several of bin Laden’s top lieutenants. Julaidan has directed organizations that have provided financial and logistical support to al-Qa’ida. Accordingly, the United States is designating Julaidan under Executive Order 13224 as a person who supports terror.

87

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 89 89 of 157 of 157

343.

Consistent with bin Laden’s plan to adapt the network established for the Afghan

resistance to support al Qaeda’s global jihad, al Qaeda has from its establishment used the MWL as a front to conceal the terrorist organization’s existence and true purpose, as confirmed by documents seized throughout the world in conjunction with investigations into al Qaeda’s global support infrastructure. 344.

Internal al Qaeda documents chronicling the formation of the organization, seized

during a 2002 raid of the Sarajevo office of an al Qaeda front, the Benevolence International Foundation (“BIF”), confirm that al Qaeda planned from its inception to use the MWL and its subsidiary bodies, to include the IIRO, to provide support and cover for al Qaeda’s operations. A BIF computer file named “Tareekh Osama” (or “Osama’s History”) contained numerous documents regarding al Qaeda’s formation and the participation of purported Islamic charities in al Qaeda’s support infrastructure, including the MWL and IIRO. 345.

For instance, the files include a document on MWL/IIRO letterhead detailing a

meeting between Abu Abdullah (a/k/a “Osama bin Laden”), Dr. Abdullah Omar Naseef, in his capacity as the Secretary General of the MWL, and others where it was agreed that al Qaeda attacks would be launched from MWL offices: “And if he is being subjected to any pressures, let it be a secret (agreement), in a way that [Muslim World] League offices will be opened as (illegible) for the Pakistanis, and the attacks will be launched from the (these offices) …”). 346.

As the senior most official of the MWL and as a member of the Saudi

government’s Majlis al Shura, the advisory body to the Saudi King, Naseef had systematic interaction and dealings with the Kingdom’s most senior officials, including senior members of the Saudi Royal Family. 347.

Dr. Naseef was also a member of the Board of Directors of Faisal Islamic Bank-

Sudan (“FIBS”), which has long provided financial services and other forms of material support to terrorist organizations, including al Qaeda. FIBS was implicated as an al Qaeda bank during the 2001 U.S. trial relating to the 1998 U.S. Embassy bombings in Kenya and Tanzania. FIBS

88

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 90 90 of 157 of 157

was also one of the main founders of the Al Shamal Islamic Bank, the Sudanese bank Osama bin Laden helped establish in 1991 by providing $50 million in capital. 348.

During the 2002 searches of BIF’s offices, investigators also recovered a list of

orders from Osama bin Laden regarding the management of Islamic charities. On point 10 of his list, bin Laden urges the creation of a committee to receive and distribute donations to al Qaeda, and suggests the participation of the MWL, SRC and IIRO. 349.

Another al Qaeda document seized during the March 2002 raids, written on the

joint letterhead of the MWL and IIRO, suggests using the name of the “League” as “an umbrella which you can stay under.” 350.

Consistent with this plan, as head of the MWL, Dr. Naseef approved the

appointment of Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, a founding al Qaeda member and Osama bin Laden’s brother-in-law, to open a joint MWL/IIRO branch office in the Philippines contemporaneous with the formation of al Qaeda. As a result of that appointment, Khalifa was able to use the MWL/IIRO office as a platform for al Qaeda’s expansion into Southeast Asia, and provide funds and other support for the 1993 World trade Center bombing and the 1995 “Bojinka” plot to simultaneously bomb multiple airlines while in transit to the United States. The Bojinka plot was conceived by September 11th mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, and was a precursor to the September 11th attacks. 351.

Khalifa was tried in absentia by a Jordanian court for his involvement in a 1994

attack on a movie theater in Amman, Jordan by a local terrorist cell. One of Khalifa’s codefendants in that case, Abdul al Hasheikeh, testified at length concerning the impressive terrorist platform Khalifa established in the Far East through the MWL and IIRO. Al Hasheikh explained that he traveled from Jordan to the Philippines in July 1993 to meet with Khalifa and request his support for the Jordanian terrorist cell. According to al Hasheikeh: “The principal of the League’s office in the Philippines is the named Mohammed Gamal Khalifa, a Saudi citizen, who is the in-law of Osama Ben Laden, a wealthy Saudi, who supports extremist Islamic organizations around the world and has training camps in Yemen.” 89

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 91 91 of 157 of 157

352.

Al Hasheikeh testified that Khalifa established a terrorist training academy in the

Philippines under the auspices of the IIRO called Dar ul Imam al Shafi’e, and that Khalifa recruited al Hasheikh to work as a teacher at the school. 353.

Khalifa was detained by U.S. law enforcement officials on December 16, 1994 by

U.S. law enforcement officials as he was returning to the Philippines from San Francisco, California. Documents found in Khalifa’s possession at the time of his arrest confirm al Hasheikheh’s testimony, detailing that students at the Dar al Imam al Shafi’e received training in assassination, kidnapping, bombing churches, martyrdom operations, methods of torture, explosives and weapons. 354.

As al Qaeda developed and expanded its operations into new geographical regions

over the years, the MWL extended its infrastructural support accordingly. In Bosnia, for instance, the MWL was instrumental in transferring hundreds of millions of dollars to al Qaeda and the Arab mujihadeen in that region, including military equipment and weapons. 355.

As a “beacon” of Wahhabi ideology and propagation, the MWL took a leading

role in rallying Muslims throughout the World to support al Qaeda’s Bosnian jihad as well. In the April 20, 1992 edition of the Al Alam Al Islami, the Arabic edition of the MWL Journal, the MWL published an article by Isma’il Fath Alh Salamah calling for the Islamic world to prepare an army for jihad for Allah. In the article, Salamah incites readers to fight all infidels, calls on them to gather weapons, and quotes militant verses praising jihad and terrorizing the enemies of Islam. In the August 10, 1992 edition of the Al Alam Al Islami, the MWL published a fatwa issued by Sheikh Muhmmad al Ghazali in reference to Bosnia. Al Ghazali’s fatwa warns that any Muslim ignoring the plight of the Muslims in Bosnia is an infidel, and further asserts that the duty to help Muslims in Bosnia is a religious one akin to jihad. An article in the April 19, 1993 edition of Al Alam Al Islami similarly advocates that the first step to saving Bosnia is to equip the jihad fighters in Bosnia with everything necessary for jihad for Allah. 356.

MWL officials, including then Secretary General of the MWL, Dr. Abdullah

Omar Naseef, have similarly issued statements calling for Muslims to support jihad in Bosnia 90

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 92 92 of 157 of 157

and other regions of strategic importance to al Qaeda. For instance, in the April 17, 1992 edition of Al Alam Al Islami, Secretary General Naseef issued an announcement relating to the state of Muslim affairs in countries such as Bosnia-Herzegovina, the Philippines, Kashmir, Somalia, and Burma, stating that Muslims can have a role in caring for their Muslim brothers in these countries by carrying out jihad with their money and lives. At the time of that statement, al Qaeda was engaged in ongoing efforts to promote jihad in each of those countries. 357.

Intent on spreading the message that Muslims have a duty to carry out jihad in

support of their Muslim brothers, Dr. Naseef sent a letter to the Saudi Arabian Minister of Religious Affairs in October 1992 advising of the recent recommendation from the “Conference of the Mosque’s Message” that Friday sermons in the mosques should be used to spread belief in Allah and the study of the Islamic religion. Dr. Naseef recommended in his letters that Friday sermons should be used to revive the spirit of jihad. 358.

At an April 1993 press conference in Cairo, Dr. Naseef again stressed the

importance of providing money and weapons to Muslims in Bosnia. According to Naseef: “We cannot solve the problem of Bosnia with talks and not with action. We must act in all manners possible to equip the Muslims in Bosnia with financial support and military equipment.” 359.

In May 1993, Dr. Naseef released a statement thanking Saudi Arabia’s King Fahd

for his contribution of $20 million which would be used for immediate relief of Muslims in Bosnia so that they may continue their jihad against the Serbs. 360.

Dr. Naseef similarly called on Muslims to support the Palestinian Intifada against

Israel. In the March 23, 1992 edition of the Al Alam Al Islami, the MWL published a manifesto issued by Dr. Naseef urging Muslims to support jihad and the Palestinian Intifada, and further directing donations be deposited into a MWL bank account to support the Intifada. The bank account was identified as being at the National Commercial Bank, Account No. 01/14807000107. 361.

Ahmad Muhammad Ali, the MWL’s Secretary General following Dr. Nassef, also

called on Muslims to help the Bosnian people with funds and weapons. 91

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 93 93 of 157 of 157

362.

The MWL also played a role in supporting the 1998 U.S. Embassy bombings in

Kenya and Tanzania. While working for the MWL in Kenya, Ihab Ali relayed messages between Osama bin Laden and Wadi El Hage in connection with the coordination of the bombings of the U.S. embassies. El Hage, who was convicted for his role in the embassy bombings, was himself at one time an employee of the MWL. 363.

The MWL also provided direct financial assistance to al Qaeda members involved

in the attempted assassination of Egyptian President Hasni Mubarak in 1995. 364.

The MWL was further implicated in a terrorism finance investigation conducted

jointly by the U.S. Department of Justice and the government of Spain. According to diplomatic cables authored by the State Department in June 2005, money was transferred by the Saudi Embassy in Madrid to the MWL, which in turn transferred the funds to the Islamic Cultural Center (“ICC”), a prominent Islamic institution located in Madrid. Several million dollars that flowed through three accounts managed by the ICC between 1998 and 2003 were suspected of being “diverted to persons suspected of supporting international jihadist activities.” 365.

The MWL further sponsored al Qaeda through its participation in the Saudi Joint

Relief Committee for Kosovo and Chechnya (“SJRC”), a body established by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia to coordinate ostensible relief efforts among several charitable organizations under its control and direction in Kosovo and Chechnya. The other purported charities compromising the SJRC include the International Islamic Relief Organization, Saudi Red Crescent Society, World Assembly of Muslim Youth, al Haramain Foundation, Islamic Endowments and Makk Establishment, among others. 366.

The United Nations’ mission in Kosovo declared that the SJRC in Pristina,

Kosovo served as a cover for several al Qaeda operatives, including Adel Muhammad Sadi bin Kazam and Wa’el Hamza Julaidan, both of whom served as directors of the SJRC. 367.

Between 1998 and 2000, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, through the SJRC,

diverted more than $74 million to al Qaeda members and loyalists affiliated with SJRC bureaus.

92

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 94 94 of 157 of 157

Throughout this time, the Committee was under the supervision and control of Saudi Interior Minister Prince Naif bin Abdul Aziz. 368.

MWL officials have publicly acknowledged the organization’s funds were being

funneled to terrorist organizations. In an interview with Dr. Abdullah bin Saleh al Obaid, Secretary General of the MWL, published in The Muslim World magazine on July 21-27, 1997, al Obaid was asked about reports that the MWL’s funds were being funneled to extremist groups. Al Obaid responded: “This is a closed chapter …. It has already been proven that there were people who exploited the situation and misused some funds ….” 369.

Despite Dr. Obaid’s public admission, the State Department has made clear that

“it has been an on-going challenge to persuade Saudi officials to treat terrorism financing emanating for Saudi Arabia as a strategic priority.” According to a December 30, 2009 diplomatic cable originating from Secretary of State Hillary Clinton’s office, titled Terrorist Finance: Action Request for Senior Level Engagement on Terrorism Finance, “donors in Saudi Arabia constitute the most significant source of funding to Sunni terrorist groups worldwide.” Secretary Clinton further warned that “organizations such as the International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO), Muslim World League (MWL) and the World Assembly of Muslim Youth (WAMY) … continue to send money overseas and, at times, fund extremism overseas.” 370.

As further detailed herein, the MWL has also provided substantial material

support and resources to al Qaeda through its subsidiary bodies, including the IIRO, WAMY, and Rabita Trust. INTERNATIONAL ISLAMIC RELIEF ORGANIZATION 371.

The International Islamic Relief Organization (“IIRO”) is a subsidiary body of the

Muslim World League (“MWL”), with offices throughout the globe. 372.

Like the MWL, the IIRO is a controlled agent and alter-ego of the Kingdom of

Saudi Arabia. The Kingdom controls and directs IIRO operations, appoints and terminates IIRO personnel, provides the IIRO with virtually all of its funding, determines how funds will be

93

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 95 95 of 157 of 157

distributed throughout the world, and otherwise stringently controls the IIRO’s operations. In many countries, IIRO conducts operations from the local Saudi embassy, under the supervision of the embassy’s Islamic Affairs Division. 373.

Senior officials of the IIRO have expressly acknowledged that the IIRO and the

other subsidiary bodies of the MWL are agencies, instrumentalities and organs of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. According to the affidavit testimony of the Manager of Financial Administration of the IIRO, Saleh Abdullah al Saykan, himself a Saudi government official, the IIRO was “established by the Muslim World League in 1978,” and “is governed by a 15-member Board of Directors chaired by the Secretary General of the Muslim World League, who is nominated by the Saudi Arabia Government.” 374.

The IIRO’s Annual Reports further document the direct involvement of senior

Saudi Government officials in the “supervision,” and “direction” of the IIRO offices within Saudi Arabia, which in turn supervise and direct the activities of the IIRO branch offices abroad. 375.

As referenced above, IIRO’s relationship with al Qaeda also grew out of IIRO’s

participation in the Afghan jihad in the 1980s, during which the IIRO worked within the network of ostensible charities to support the mujihadeen. During the conflict Wa’el Hamza Jelaidan ran the IIRO offices in Peshawar, Pakistan, and was a leading supporter of jihad through the relief organization network. As a member of al Qaeda, Jelaidan remained in the Saudi da’awa infrastructure, serving as the director of the IIRO’s Peshawar, Pakistan offices, an officer of the MWL, and later as a director of the SJRC. 376.

With the formation of al Qaeda, Jelaidan and the al Qaeda leadership continued to

draw on the IIRO to support al Qaeda’s global jihad, as documented by the previously discussed documents chronicling al Qaeda’s formation. 377.

According to Jamal al Fadl, a former al Qaeda official who became a cooperating

witness for the United States and testified at length in the African Embassy bombing trials, the IIRO provided false identification cards to al Qaeda members to enable them to cross the Pakistan-Afghanistan border for training at al Qaeda camps. Additionally, a June 2, 2004 FBI 94

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 96 96 of 157 of 157

report summarizing an interview with al Fadl states that the IIRO office in Peshawar, under Jelaidan’s leadership, facilitated the purchase of weapons for al Qaeda. According to the FBI report, “Julidan was one of Bin Laden’s closest friends at the time.” 378.

Other representatives of the IIRO in Pakistan provided funds for salary, travel and

health benefits for al Qaeda members. For instance, the IIRO’s branch office in Pakistan was managed by Abu Hamam al Saudi, who was also Osama bin Laden’s cousin. Al Saudi would transfer IIRO funds to Madani al Tayyib, who would then distribute the amounts to individuals who were in charge of salary, travel, and health benefits for al Qaeda. 379.

The IIRO also played a critical role in supporting al Qaeda’s expansion into the

Far East, as discussed previously. 380.

Using IIRO funds and resources, Mohammed Jamal Khalifa established a network

of charities, businesses, and Islamic institutions in the Philippines to support international terrorism. To assist Khalifa, Ramzi Yousef, a bomber of the World Trade Center in 1993, and Wali Khan Amin Shaw, also an IIRO employee in Pakistan, came to the Philippines. Yousef began training Philippine terrorist groups in bomb-making, while also conducting further research and refining his bomb-making technique. 381.

While working as the Director of the IIRO’s Philippines branch, Khalifa

maintained close connections with al Qaeda and employed members of the Abu Sayyaf Group, the al Qaeda proxy organization established by Khalifa using IIRO funds. According to a U.S. Department of the Treasury memorandum detailing the designation of the IIRO’s Philippine and Indonesian branch offices and a senior IIRO official in Saudi Arabia: “The Abu Sayyaf Group [ASG] is the most violent of the separatist groups operating in the Southern Philippines and was designated as an SDGT pursuant to E.O. 13224 on September 24, 2001. It was formed in the early 1990’s and received support and seed money from al Qaida.” 382.

According to the U.S. government, one of the plots devised by Ramzi Yousef in

conjunction with Khalifa and the IIRO office was to assassinate Pope John Paul II during a planned January 1995 visit to the Philippines and to simultaneously attack multiple U.S. airliners 95

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 97 97 of 157 of 157

as they flew over the Pacific Ocean from Asia to the United States (the “Operation Bojinka” plot). According to a 1996 Central Intelligence Agency report regarding the involvement of Islamic charities in the sponsorship of terrorism, the “former head of the IIRO office in the Philippines, Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, has been linked to Manila-based plots to target the Pope and U.S. airlines; his brother-in-law is Usama Bin Ladin.” The CIA report further states that another high-ranking IIRO official in the Philippines leads Hamas meetings and that the majority of Hamas members in the Philippines are employed by the IIRO. Moreover, the “IIRO helps fund six militant training camps in Afghanistan,” including camps from which al Qaeda planned, approved and coordinated the September 11th Attacks, and at which some or all of the September 11 hijackers received indoctrination and training. 383.

As mentioned above, American law enforcement officials detained Khalifa on

December 16, 1994, as he was returning to the Philippines from San Francisco, California. FBI documentation relating to his arrest identifies Khalifa as a “Known Terrorist.” Traveling with Khalifa at the time of his detention was Mohamed Loay Bayazid, an al Qaeda founding member and top official who had tried to purchase uranium on behalf of al Qaeda. 384.

At the time of his arrest, the FBI discovered a trove of information in Khalifa’s

possession including documents referring to the plot to kill Pope John Paul II, as well as documentation identifying the curriculum for the Dar al Imam al Shafi’e in the Philippines. These documents confirmed that students at the school received training in assassination, kidnapping, bombing churches, martyrdom operations, methods of torture, explosives and weapons. 385.

Jamal al Fadl identified Khalifa as a close associate to Osama bin Laden. During

testimony as a cooperating witness for the United States, al Fadl stated that he knew Khalifa by his alias (“Abu Bara”), “who was close to bin Laden.” According to al Fadl: “Hammam [IIRO’s branch manager in Pakistan], Bara, and bin Laden are part of the group that has been around a long time.”

96

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 98 98 of 157 of 157

386.

In connection with immigration proceedings following Khalifa’s arrest, Philip C.

Wilcox, Jr., the Department of State’s Coordinator for Counterterrorism, submitted several letters to the immigration judge urging for Khalifa’s continued detention. In a December 16, 1994 letter, Wilcox advised the Court that Khalifa financed a 1994 attack on a Jordanian movie theater, and that “the United Stated Government has evidence that Muhammad Jamal Khalifa, who has lived in the Philippines for a number of years, has provided financial support to the Philippine terrorist group Abu Sayyaf. We also have information that while in the Philippines he has been involved in organizations closely linked to Hamas….” 387.

In a December 20, 1994 letter the Court, Wilcox asserted that (i) Khalifa has

provided support to terrorist groups in the Philippines; (ii) Khalifa has helped organize efforts by former fighters in Afghanistan to provide training and assistance to terrorists in the Philippines; (iii) Khalifa has extensive ties to Hamas; and (iv) Khalifa has ties to the terrorist organization Gama’t Islamiya. 388.

Department of State cables following Khalifa’s detention in the United States

further detail Khalifa’s and the IIRO’s support for terrorist organizations and their activities in the Philippines and Afghanistan. For instance, a July 1994 cable from the American Embassy in Amman, Jordan concerning the Jordanian cinema bombing trial states that one of the defendants in the case worked “in the Imam al-Shafi center led by Muhammad Jamal Khalifa, another defendant who is an in-law of Saudi financier Usama Bin-Ladin.” 389.

A December 1994 cable from the Secretary of State Warren Christopher’s office

states: “Khalifa is an officer of an Islamic NGO in the Philippines that is a known Hamas front and has financed terrorist operations. Khalifa is reported to be the brother in law of Usama Bin Laden, the Sudan-based financier of Islamic extremists. Khalifa is believed to have provided support to the Philippine terrorist group Abu Sayyaf.” An additional December 1994 cable from the Secretary of State’s office states that Khalifa is a “known financier of terrorist operations and an officer of an Islamic NGO in the Philippines that is a known Hamas front.”

97

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 99 99 of 157 of 157

390.

An April 1995 cable from the American Embassy in Amman, Jordan to Secretary

of State Warren Christopher discusses an attack by Abu Sayyaf Group, with possible assistance from Moro Islamic Liberation Front and Moro National Liberation Front, which left 53 people dead. According to the cable: “President Ramos said that Prime Minister Bhutto had disclosed to him the existence of training camps in Afghanistan where international terrorists, including ASG, are being trained …. Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, the former head of the International Islamic Relief Organization in Manila, [i]s a principal financier of Abu Sayyaf.” 391.

In an August 1993 interview concerning the Moro Islamic Liberation Front’s call

for jihad against the Philippine government, Sheikh Savila Salih, who was in charge of MILF’s religious rulings, confirmed that MILF also received support from the IIRO: “The IIRO and other Islamic bodies who deal with the da’awa and aid, are the leaders of those who give the Front considerable support and are deserving of their gratitude.” 392.

An October 2001 cable from the Secretary of State Colin Powell’s office states

that “Philippine authorities reported that Saudi national Muhammad Jamal Khalifa who ran two Islamic nongovernmental organizations in Manila was the major financier of the terrorists arrested there. Khalifa who has also been implicated in terrorist activities in Jordan is Bin Ladin’s brother-in-law.” 393.

An April 2004 cable from Secretary of State Colin Powell states that the IIRO is

“tied to al-Qaida and other terrorist organizations. For example, IIRO has been cited as the principal sponsor of terrorist training camps in Afghanistan during the Taliban regime. IIRO has also been cited as the conduit for funds from Usama Bin Laden to terrorist organizations, specifically that the Abu Sayyaf cell in Manila was founded with money sent by Bin Laden to Mohamed Jamal Khalifa through IIRO.” 394.

A June 2004 cable from the Secretary of State’s office similarly details the IIRO’s

support for al Qaeda and the Abu Sayyaf terrorist group. According to the cable: “The USG believes that some elements of the International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO) have been exploited by terrorists and their financiers as a means of transferring assets, providing 98

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 100100 of 157 of 157

organizational cover, or otherwise supporting extremist, violent operations.” The cable further states the “IIRO has been cited as the principal sponsor of terrorist training camps in Afghanistan during the Taliban regime. IIRO has also been cited as the conduit for funds from Usama Bin Laden to terrorist organizations, specifically that the Abu Sayyaf cell in Manila was founded with money sent by Bin Laden to Mohamed Jamal Khalifa through IIRO.” 395.

A May 23, 2005 State Department cable titled, Islamic NGOs in the Philippines,

also discusses the IIRO’s illicit activities: “Operated by Usama Bin Laden’s brother-in-law, Saudi businessman Mohammed Jamal Khalifa, and with links to captured al-Qaeda lieutenant Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, the IIRO served as a legal front to conceal the transfer of al-Qaeda funding and material to the Abu Sayyaf Group and possibly other insurgents or terrorists operating in the Philippines.” 396.

Prior to his death in January 2007, Khalifa confirmed in writing that all of his

activities as Director of the IIRO in the Philippines were conducted under the direct supervision of the Saudi embassy. 397.

Other U.S. diplomatic cables have described the IIRO’s illicit activities. For

instance, an October 3, 2005 cable concerning OFAC Director Robert Werner’s meetings a month earlier in Bahrain with the government’s Minister of Finance, Minister of Social Affairs, and the Governor of the Bahrain Monetary Agency, details the closing of an IIRO bank account with Shamil Bank of Bahrain. According to information presented by Director Werner, the IIRO headquarters transferred over $7 million from the IIRO account at Shamil Bank to 18 different IIRO satellite offices. Among those transactions, the IIRO transferred funds from the Bahrain account to three Saudi Embassies. According to Director Werner, the second largest recipient of those funds was the IIRO’s Djibouti branch office. Director Werner pointed out that the IIRO transactions represented a violation of the Kingdom’s ban imposed on Saudi charities preventing them from engaging in extraterritorial financial activities. In a follow-up meeting with the Governor of the Bahrain Monetary Agency on January 23, 2006, Treasury Undersecretary Stuart

99

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 101101 of 157 of 157

Levey thanked the Governor for closing the IIRO account which had been used to circumvent Saudi restrictions on sending money abroad. 398.

In an October 9, 2006 cable from the American Consulate in Jeddah, titled IIRO

Secretary-General Talks of Saudi Programs and Expansions, IIRO Secretary-General Dr. Adnan Basha conceded that Islamic extremists have lectured at IIRO summer youth camps. Dr. Basha explained that the Ministry of Islamic Affairs is responsible for vetting both the programs and lecturers for all of IIRO’s summer camps within the Kingdom, but that no such process was available to prevent radicals from passing their extremist ideologies on to young men and women at summer camps outside of Saudi Arabia. 399.

A February 13, 2007 cable originating from the U.S. Embassy in Khartoum,

Sudan, identified the IIRO as “one of the major Saudi Arabian humanitarian organizations suspected of maintaining links with al-Qaeda.” According to the U.S. government, “Usama bin Ladin used the entire IIRO network for his terrorist activities.” 400.

A February 24, 2007 cable details a meeting between Assistant to the President

for Homeland Security and Counterterrorism Francis Fragos Townsend with the Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Saud al Faisal at his home in Jeddah on February 6. Townsend raised concerns of the U.S. government regarding the involvement of the Saudi Ambassador to the Philippines Muhammad Amin Waly in terrorism facilitation and his intervention to get two members of the IIRO released from prison. 401.

An August 22, 2007 diplomatic cable reported that the IIRO’s branch office in

Macedonia was closed and its members were expelled from the country in March 1995 amid concerns of terrorism financing. 402.

Finally, a November 3, 2008 cable authored by the U.S. Embassy in Dhaka,

Bangladesh describes the freezing of IIRO accounts at Islami Bank Bangladesh as a result of terrorism financing investigations. 403.

On August 3, 2006, the U.S. Department of the Treasury designated the IIRO’s

Philippine and Indonesian branch offices and a senior IIRO official in Saudi Arabia, Abd al 100

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 102102 of 157 of 157

Hamid Sulaiman al Mujil, “for facilitating fundraising for al Qaida and affiliated terrorist groups.” According to U.S. Treasury officials, “Abd Al Hamid Sulaiman Al-Mujil, a highranking IIRO official in Saudi Arabia, has used his position to bankroll the al Qaida network in Southeast Asia. Al Mujil has a long record of supporting Islamic militant groups, and he has maintained a cell of regular financial donors in the Middle East who support extremist causes.” Often referred to as the “Million Dollar Man” for supporting Islamic militant groups, al Mujil provided donor funds directly to al Qaeda and is identified as a major fundraiser for the Abu Sayyaf Group and Jemaah Islamiyah. 404.

The August 3rd designation details al Mujil’s long record of supporting terrorist

organizations such as al Qaeda, Abu Sayyaf and Jemaah Islamiyah through the IIRO: Abd Al Hamid Sulaiman Al-Mujil (Al-Mujil) is the Executive Director of the IIRO Eastern Province (IIRO-EP) branch office in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Al-Mujil has been called the “million dollar man” for supporting Islamic militant groups. Al-Mujil provided donor funds directly to al Qaida and is identified as a major fundraiser for the Abu Sayyaf Group (ASG) and Jemaah Islamiyah (JI). Both ASG and JI are al Qaidaassociated terrorist groups in Southeast Asia designated pursuant to the authorities of E.O. 13224. These terrorist groups are also on the United Nations 1267 Committee’s consolidated list of individuals and entities associated with the Taliban, al Qaida and/or Usama Bin Ladin. In 2004, Al-Mujil invited a Philippines-based JI supporter to Saudi Arabia under the cover of traveling for the hajj (the Muslim pilgrimage), and planned to provide him with cash to carry back to the Philippines to support organizations including JI. Al-Mujil was also present in Afghanistan in the late 1990s and personally knew Usama Bin Ladin and deceased al Qaida cofounder Abdallah Azzam. Al-Mujil traveled continuously to meet with members of Bin Ladin’s organization in Arab countries. In the 1990s, Al-Mujil established a relationship with senior al Qaida operational planner Khalid Shaykh Muhammad. Al-Mujil has a long history of providing support to terrorist organizations. He has contributed direct financial assistance to ASG leaders, including Abdurajak Janjalani (deceased). 101

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 103103 of 157 of 157

The Indonesian and Philippines branches of IIRO have received support from IIRO-EP, which in turn is controlled by Al-Mujil. Indeed, he is often responsible for authorizing payment transfers for IIRO Philippines (IIRO-PHL) and IIRO Indonesia (IIRO-IDN). The Treasury Department’s findings regarding the IIRO’s branch offices in the Philippines and Indonesia are just as damaging. According to the August 3rd designation: The IIRO-PHL is a source of funding for the al Qaida-affiliated ASG. IIRO-PHL has served as a liaison for the ASG with other Islamic extremist groups. A former ASG member in the Philippines familiar with IIRO operations in the country reported that a limited amount of foreign IIRO funding goes to legitimate projects and the rest is directed to terrorist operations. *** The IIRO Indonesia director has channeled money to two Indonesia-based, JI-affiliated foundations. Information from 2006 shows that IIRO-IDN supports JI by providing assistance with recruitment, transportation, logistics, and safe-havens. As of late 2002, IIRO-IDN allegedly financed the establishment of training facilities for use by al Qaida associates. 405.

In conjunction with the designations, the Saudi government imposed a travel ban

on al Mujil, barring him from traveling outside of the Kingdom. The Saudis further froze his bank accounts, including an account at Al Rajhi Bank. 406.

However, despite assurances from Saudi officials that it had “shut down” the

IIRO’s Eastern Province Branch where al Mujil maintained his office and facilitated fundraising in direct support of al Qaeda, a March 2, 2009 State Department cable warned “that money continued to be funneled overseas from the Eastern Province Branch.” 407.

The IIRO was also instrumental in supporting al Qaeda’s operations in Bosnia, as

one of the first da’awa organizations to enter the Balkans following the outbreak of the war. According to Dr. Farid Qurashi, former Secretary General of the IIRO: “From the very beginning of the Bosnia war, we were there to help.” 408.

Former American mujahideen recruit Randall Todd Royer (a/k/a Ismail Royer),

who participated in the Bosnian jihad, acknowledged that the IIRO’s reputation as a front for

102

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 104104 of 157 of 157

jihad was well known in the Balkans: “It was well known that they helped get ‘people’ into Bosnia.” Royer explained that another mujahideen fighter in Zenica had openly discussed his efforts to use the IIRO in order to obtain identity cards for fellow jihadists. 409.

In September 1992, Balkan press agencies published photos depicting the severed

heads of Serb soldiers killed by foreign mujahideen collected in boxes. The photos were seized from the belongings of fallen Saudi Arabian jihadists, which also included an IIRO humanitarian worker identification card. The recovered card was labeled with the name and photo of “Khalil Abdel Aziz,” a teacher from Saudi Arabia, and indicated that it had been printed by the Peshawar, Pakistan office of the IIRO. 410.

By mid-1993, the operations of the IIRO in Bosnia-Herzegovina were under the

primary oversight of a Palestinian national known as Abdelaziz Zaher (a/k/a Abu Anas; Abu Enes) and his deputy, an Algerian national, Djamel Lamrani (a/k/a Abu Musab al Djazairi). Zaher was expelled from his former residence in Belgrade in early 1993 after Serbian officials tied him to various organizations suspected of aiding armed fundamentalist militant groups, including the IIRO. . 411.

Zaher’s top lieutenant at the IIRO, Jamal Al-Jibouri, was personally responsible

for oversight of a massive logistical operation to provide al Qaeda and al Qaeda affiliated Islamic militants in the Balkans with weapons and ammunition. 412.

While working for the IIRO, Zaher participated in the 1994 murder of British aid

worker Paul Goodall near Zenica. Two days following the murder, Bosnian police arrested Saudi national Abdul Hadi al Qahtani, Abdu Khulud al Yemeni and Abu Enes (a/k/a IIRO chief Abdelaziz Zaher). At the time of his arrest, al Qahtani was carrying an identification card issued by the Zenica office of the Saudi High Commission. 413.

Following the arrest of the three men, Dr. Abdul Harith al Liby, deputy

commander of the mujahideen, sent a letter to “authorized individuals” in the BosniaHerzegovina Military Police and security services requesting the release of the two “mujahideen” arrested alongside al Qahtani. Al Liby’s letter identified both “Abu Enes” (Zaher) and al 103

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 105105 of 157 of 157

Qahtani interchangeably as “mujahideen” and as “employees” of “IGASE” (IIRO), who were detained by authorities while traveling in an IIRO employee-owned vehicle. 414.

Following the end of the war in Bosnia-Herzegovina in late 1995, Zaher and the

IIRO continued their operations in the Balkans. The same year, “with the financial help of Selim Ben Mafuz, the executive director of ‘Igasa’ in Vienna,” Zaher and other local IIRO organizers founded two commercial enterprises, “Sahara” and “Isra-Trade” which allegedly were the recipient of suspicious financial transfers from “residential accounts of the H.O. ‘Igasa.’” 415.

International law enforcement and intelligence investigations targeted the IIRO’s

mission in the Balkans as well. According to a guidebook on Islamic charitable organizations printed by NATO in April 1995, “the regional financial accountant for the IIRO, an Egyptian named Hossam Meawad Mohammad Ali, was detained by Croatian authorities in a raid in Zagreb” for his involvement in alleged criminal activity. 416.

In 1993, officials linked members of the Zagreb office of the IIRO to an Islamic

extremist group headed by Muhammad Sa’d Darwish al Shazy, which was planning to conduct anti-Jewish bombings in Croatia. In addition to representatives of IIRO, al Shazy’s organization included the heads of the Zagreb offices of the Saudi High Commission and the Kuwaiti Joint Relief Committee, representatives of the Human Relief International, and members of the Qatar Charitable Society. 417.

The IIRO’s branch office in Vienna, Austria is linked to the Third World Relief

Agency (“TWRA”), a purported charitable organization that became an integral component of al Qaeda’s support infrastructure. Founded in 1987 in Vienna by Dr. El Fatih Ali Hassanein, a well-connected leader of the Sudanese National Islamic Front (“NIF”) and fervent supporter of Osama bin Laden, the TWRA was a primary conduit for channeling financial, logistical, and operational support for al Qaeda’s global jihad. Together with his brother, Sukarno Ali Hassanein, the Hassanein brothers simultaneously managed the IIRO’s Vienna branch office, which shared office space with the TWRA.

104

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 106106 of 157 of 157

418.

In September 1995, German authorities and members of the Austrian anti-

terrorism task force raided the TWRA’s Vienna headquarters, as well as the IIRO’s office, uncovering a trove of records detailing the transfer of approximately $220 million from radical Islamic organizations and Islamic countries in the Middle East to the Bosnian region. According to Western intelligence officials, at least half of the $220 million was used primarily to purchase and transport illegal weapons on behalf of the Bosnian government and foreign Arab fighters associated with Osama bin Laden’s Islamic Army. The 9/11 Commission concluded that Osama bin Laden used the TWRA to covertly provide support for terrorist activities. 419.

Through its offices in Kenya, the IIRO provided direct financial and logistical

support to al Qaeda terrorists involved in the 1998 bombings of the United States Embassies in Dar Es Salam, Tanzania and Nairobi, Kenya. As a result of an investigation into the involvement of the IIRO in the bombings, Kenyan officials deregistered the IIRO’s Nairobi office. 420.

In October 2001, Pakistani officials identified and expelled some two dozen al

Qaeda members who had been working for the IIRO in Pakistan. 421.

According to the Indian government, IIRO officials were behind the 1999 al

Qaeda plot to attack the U.S. consulates in Madras and Calcutta, in response to the American military retaliation for the 1998 bombings of the United States Embassies in Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania and Nairobi, Kenya. The operational cell designated to carry out the planned attacks on the U.S. consulates was led by Sayed Abu Nesir, a Bangladeshi national who was directed to launch the attacks by Shaykh Ahmed al-Gamdin, Director of IIRO operations in Asia. 422.

During his subsequent interrogation, Abu Nesir declared that 40 to 50% of IIRO’s

charitable funds were being diverted to finance terrorist training camps in Afghanistan and Kashmir. Among other duties, Abu Nesir visited the training camps on behalf of IIRO to assess their funding needs. At the direction of al-Gamdin, Nesir himself attended one of the al Qaeda camps to receive training, where he met Osama bin Laden.

105

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 107107 of 157 of 157

423.

Mahmoud Jaballah, head of IIRO’s Canadian office, was arrested and jailed by

Canadian officials based on his links to al Qaeda and Egyptian al Jihad. Jaballah was accused of having contact with al Qaeda operatives and had spent three years working for the IIRO in Pakistan. 424.

In 1991, the IIRO established a U.S. branch in Virginia, under the name

International Relief Organization, Inc. (“IRO”). The IRO operated from offices at 360 South Washington Street, Washington, D.C., where it shared office space with the MWL. The Washington, D.C. offices of the IIRO and MWL were part of a complicated web of for-profit and ostensible charitable organizations within the United States, referred to by the U.S. government as the Safa Group or SAAR Network, the majority of which maintained offices at 555 Gross Street, Herndon, VA. The SAAR Network of businesses and charities was created to provide funding, money laundering and other material support to terrorist organizations, including al Qaeda. In March of 2003, federal authorities executed search warrants at the offices of IIRO in Washington, DC, in connection with an ongoing federal investigation of the illegal activities of the Northern Virginia and Washington based charities and for-profit enterprises within the SAAR Network. Through that investigation, federal authorities determined that the IIRO and MWL offices in Washington, DC provided funding and material support to al Qaeda and Hamas. 425.

The IIRO further sponsored al Qaeda through its participation in the Saudi Joint

Relief Committee for Kosovo and Chechnya (“SJRC”). As set forth herein, the SJRC offices in Pristine, Kosovo served as a cover for al Qaeda operatives. Furthermore, between 1998 and 2000, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, through SJRC, diverted more than $74 million to al Qaeda members and loyalists affiliated with SJRC bureaus. 426.

Not surprisingly, given the breadth of the IIRO’s ties to al Qaeda, the United

States has detained several IIRO officials and employees as “enemy combatants.” In support of the continued detention of those individuals, the U.S. government has cited their affiliations with

106

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 108108 of 157 of 157

IIRO as a “primary factor” favoring detention, and expressly labeled the IIRO as an al Qaeda front. 427.

The U.S. government has identified the IIRO (a/k/a “Hay’at al-Igatha al-

Islamiyya al-Alamiyah”) as a Tier 1 Terrorist Non-Government Organization and a National Intelligence Priority Framework (NIPF) Counter-Terrorism (CT) Priority 2 Terrorist Support Entity (TSE). According to the United States, “Priority 2 TSEs have demonstrated sustained and active financial support for terrorist organizations willing to attack U.S. persons or interests, or provide witting operational support to Priority 2 terrorist groups.” 428.

Detainee Samir N. Al Hasan (ISN No. 043) traveled to Afghanistan from Yemen

in 1999 or 2000, attended the training camp at al Farouq, and became a bodyguard in August 2001. Al Hasan told U.S. authorities that he was in Afghanistan as a relief worker for the IIRO and that he received the position from the head of the IIRO. The United States government’s unclassified evidentiary summaries relating to al Hasan assert: “The International Islamic Relief Organization was identified as an Islamic humanitarian organization with headquarters in Mecca, Saudi Arabia, and is financed by Usama bin Laden.” 429.

Detainee Rashed Awad Khalaf Balkhair (ISN No. 186) traveled from Saudi

Arabia to Pakistan and Afghanistan in early 2001 and worked for “Al-Ighatha Al-Islamiya, International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO).” Balkhair was associated with the Taliban and al Qaeda, and stayed approximately 3 months in a Taliban guesthouse in Jalalabad, Afghanistan. Moreover, Balkhair’s name was listed on a computer hard drive associated with a known terrorist and was further discovered on a list of al Qaeda mujahedin who were in Afghanistan. The unclassified evidentiary summaries filed in support of Balkhair’s continued detention at Guantanamo Bay state that “the International Islamic Relief Organization is a non-governmental organization, which has ties to Usama Bin Laden and the Abu Sayyaf Group.” 430.

Detainee Said Muhammad Husayn Qahtani (Detainee No. 200) traveled multiple

times from Saudi Arabia to Afghanistan between 2000 and 2001. In May 2000, Qahtani met and stayed with Abu Zubaydah in a safehouse while waiting to travel to Afghanistan. Moreover, 107

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 109109 of 157 of 157

during a trip in June 2000, Qahtani joined the Taliban against the Northern Alliance and spent a considerable amount of time on the front lines. Qahtani joined al Qaeda after giving an oath of allegiance (“al bay’ah”) to Osama bin Laden, and further met 2 of the 9-11 hijackers – Saeed al Ghamdi and Ahmed Alnami. According to Department of Defense documentation, Qahtani contacted relief organizations such as the IIRO and al Haramain with the intention “to join a relief organization because those entities would offer him a way to get into Chechnya, whose borders were closed at that time. Once there, the detainee would be free to leave the relief organization and join the fighting.” 431.

Detainee Abdallah Ibrahim al Rushaydan (ISN No. 343) was captured on

December 10, 2001 on the border of Pakistan and Afghanistan. According to the U.S. government: “The International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO) is also known as Al Hayat Al Igatha Al Islamiya Al Aalamiya. According to the media in Asia, the Islamic Nongovernment Organization known as the International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO), which is managed by Osama Bin Laden’s brother-in-law, has maintained links with the Abu Sayyaf group (ASG) in the Philippines. Executive Order 13224, which blocks property and prohibits transactions with persons who commit, threaten to commit, or support terrorism, designates the Abu Sayyaf Group as a global terrorist entity.” 432.

Significantly, in response to the U.S. government’s assertion that the IIRO is a

front for terrorism, al Rushaydan testified that the IIRO “is a government organization managed by Dr. Adnan Basha who holds the rank of Minister. [IIRO] is a government organization under the Islamic World League and all charity organizations are under the Senior Director for charity organizations, Ameer Nayef (King Nayef), who is the Saudi Minister of Interior.” 433.

Detainee Rashid Abd al Muslih Qaid al Qaid (ISN No. 344) traveled from his

home in Saudi Arabia to Afghanistan in October 2001 with an individual who was identified as a member of the al Qaeda mujahideen. Al Qaid himself was also designated by the Saudi government as a high priority target. The United States government’s unclassified evidentiary summaries relating to al Qaid state: “The detainee and both of his traveling companions, Al Nur 108

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 110110 of 157 of 157

and Wasim, traveled to carry out charity work in conjunction with a Saudi charity, al-ighatha alkhairia.” “Al Ighatha is a large Saudi NGO with field offices worldwide, many of which are staffed by or support terrorists or mujahidin. The NGO is linked to al Qaida and other extremist NGOs.” 434.

Detainee Ghanim Abd al Rahman Ghanim al Huwaymadi al Harbi (ISN No. 516)

was working in the IIRO finance department in Jeddah during the summer of 2000. Al Harbi responded to a fatwa that requires all Muslims to train and be prepared to defend Islam at any time. Although he was prohibited from traveling outside of Saudi Arabia, al Harbi traveled to Afghanistan during the summer of 2001 via Bahrain and Pakistan. Al Harbi testified that he was a “governmental employee of a charitable organization” known as the International Islamic Relief Organization. In addition, al Harbi acknowledged during his testimony that he received training at the al Farouq camp in Afghanistan, a known al Qaeda facility, which he understood to be a “charity funded camp.” 435.

Detainee Tariq Mahmoud Ahmed al Sawah (ISN No. 535) is a former relief

worker for the IIRO in Bosnia and Croatia. Al Sawah testified that he chose to go to the Balkans region after watching videos depicting the atrocities committed by Serbs against Bosnians, and eventually joined the Bosnian Third Army, whose members were predominantly Arab Mujahideen fighters. Al Sawah admitted to being a member of the mujihadeen since 1992. According to the U.S. government: “The International Islamic Relief Organization, also known as the World Islamic Relief Organization, is the largest Islamic charity organization in Saudi Arabia. International investigations have disclosed the organization has connections to terrorist financing activities and its field offices throughout the world have supported terrorist activity.” 436.

Al Sawah was expelled from Bosnia in 2000 and traveled to Afghanistan where

he attended the al Farouq training camp and further served as an advanced explosives trainer at the Tarnak Farm training camp. In 2002, he met Ayman al Zawahiri and also attended a banquet dinner with Osama bin Laden and a senior al Qaeda lieutenant. Moreover, al Sawah authored a 400 page manuscript containing bomb-making techniques and provided it to al Qaeda members. 109

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 111111 of 157 of 157

His design for a shoe bomb technically matched the design of the failed explosive device used by shoe bomber Richard Reid. 437.

Detainee Ahmed Hassan Jamil Suleyman (ISN No. 662), who performed

volunteer work for the IIRO, was identified as a senior al Qaeda commander and trainer with contacts to Osama bin Laden, Sheikh al Liby and Abu Zubayda. Suleyman was also a member of Makthab al Khidmat and associated with Makhtab al Khidmat (the “Office of Services”). According to Department of Defense documentation: “The detainee occasionally would perform volunteer work with the International Islamic Relief Organization (IIRO). The IIRO has connections to terrorist organizations and has channeled funds to Islamic extremists from Afghanistan.” 438.

Detainee Abdul Latif Elbanna (ISN No. 905) worked for the IIRO. The

unclassified evidentiary summaries filed in support of Elbanna’s continued detention at Guantanamo Bay state: “In 1990 the detainee worked at an Islamic Relief organization (IRO) called Haiat Ali Ghatha Al Islami Al Alamia. He lived for free at a guesthouse owned by the charity in the Hayat Abad district of Peshawar. Fighters from Afghanistan stayed at the guesthouse. The International Islamic Relief Organization/Hay-at al-Igathat al-Islamiyya alAlamiyah of Saudi Arabia is designated a Tier 1 Non-Governmental Organization having demonstrated sustained and active support for terrorist organizations willing to attack U.S. persons or interests.” WORLD ASSEMBLY OF MUSLIM YOUTH 439.

The World Assembly of Muslim Youth (“WAMY”) is also a subsidiary of the

MWL. Founded in 1972 and headquartered in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, WAMY has a physical and operational presence in at least 56 countries worldwide. In addition, WAMY conducts activities in many countries in which it does not maintain a formal physical presence, through its association and membership in other Islamic organizations and committees, including its membership in the Saudi Joint Relief Committee for Kosovo and Chechnya (“SJRC”).

110

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 112112 of 157 of 157

440.

Like the MWL and IIRO, WAMY is a controlled agent and alter-ego of the

Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. WAMY was established by MWL, itself an alter-ego of the Kingdom, with the formal approval of high ranking officials of the Kingdom. The vast majority of WAMY’s funding is provided by the Kingdom. In addition, WAMY’s leadership is dominated by high ranking officials of the Kingdom. For example, Dr. Maneh el Johani simultaneously served as both the Secretary General of WAMY and a member of the Kingdom’s Shura Council. While head of the Ministry of Islamic Affairs, Saleh bin Abdul Aziz al Sheikh also served as a chairman of WAMY and al Haramain Islamic Foundation. 441.

Mutaz Saleh Abu Unuq, Financial Director of WAMY, has confirmed in affidavit

testimony that WAMY was established by Royal Decree in 1972, and that “WAMY is governed principally by its General Assembly and President who was appointed by the Saudi Government. The current President of WAMY is the Minister of Islamic Affairs in Saudi Arabia. The daily operations of WAMY are supervised by its Secretary General. The Government of Saudi Arabia funds a large portion of WAMY’s budget.” 442.

Outside of Saudi Arabia, the operations of WAMY’s branch offices are directed

and closely supervised by local Saudi embassies. According to Dr. Abdullah Wahab Noorwali, Assistant Secretary General of WAMY, the Kingdom “provides us with protection abroad through Saudi embassies and consulates, in addition to financial support.” As Arafat el Asahi’s previously cited Canadian court testimony confirms, the Saudi embassies do not tolerate any deviation by the Saudi da’awa organizations under their supervision from Saudi government policy. 443.

The operations of WAMY’s branch offices are closely supervised and directed by

WAMY’s central leadership in Saudi Arabia as well, and functionally operate as agents of the central organization. WAMY’s central authority in Saudi Arabia uses a variety of mechanisms to rigidly control the branch offices. WAMY’s General Assembly and Board of Trustees in Saudi Arabia set policies and procedures for all WAMY branch offices, and hand-pick the officials who run those branch offices. WAMY headquarters also selects the projects and causes 111

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 113113 of 157 of 157

for which funds are to be raised by the WAMY offices throughout the world. Funds raised by the branch offices are transferred back to the organization’s headquarters, which then redistributes those funds to the regional offices, to be applied to projects and causes selected by WAMY’s central leadership. WAMY’s branch offices are required to submit detailed reports of their activities and finances to the central leadership in Saudi Arabia, for review and approval. High ranking WAMY officials from Saudi Arabia also conduct periodic inspections of the branch offices. In addition, by virtue of its close relationship with the Kingdom’s government, WAMY is able to use the Kingdom’s governmental apparatus throughout the world, including the embassies, to monitor the day to day activities of the branches. 444.

For more than a decade, WAMY has knowingly and intentionally used its

international infrastructure as a tool for supporting the al Qaeda movement, on both the ideological and military fronts. As a result of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia’s extensive patronage, WAMY possesses a multi-million dollar annual budget. WAMY dedicates a significant portion of that budget to the publication and worldwide dissemination of literature calculated to promote the global jihadist agenda, convince young Muslims to reject the United States and democratic ideas as evil and non-Muslim, demonize Christians, Jews and nonWahhabi Muslims, and convince young Muslims to engage in violent jihad against the West and Israel. 445.

Virulently anti-American, anti-Semitic and pro-jihadist propaganda pervade

WAMY’s “educational” publications. For example, under the heading “The Prophet asks for Jihad,” the WAMY book Islamic Views says, “The Prophet Mohammad fought against the infidels and the Jews till he triumphed over them and conducted himself about twenty invasions and he sent tens of regiments led by his companions for Jihad…Damn from Allah to the Jews who made graves of their prophets as Masjid.” Later, Islamic Views says Islam “is a religion of Jihad” and that jihad “was an answer for the Jews, the liars.” “[T]each our children to love taking revenge on the Jews and the oppressors, and teach them that our youngsters will liberate Palestine and al-Quds when they go back to Islam and make Jihad for the sake of Allah.” 112

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 114114 of 157 of 157

Islamic Views further exhorts Muslims to wage “Jihad against the Satan,” and that “You should not back the Jews and the Christians and the Communists against the Muslims; the Communists, the Infidels, the Jews, and the Christians, those who do not believe in Mohammed. You should say they are infidels.” 446.

The jihad WAMY advocates in its publications is intensely violent. According to

a WAMY policy statement, “[a] Christian should be asked to repent. If he does not he must be killed.” See Written Statement of James B. Jacobsen, President of Christian Solidarity International, submitted to the Sub-Committee of International Relations and Human Rights, Hearing on Persecution of Christians Worldwide, February 15, 1996. The book Islamic Camps: Objectives, Program Outlines and Preparatory Steps, prepared by WAMY’s Camps and Conferences Unit and intended to serve as a manual for Islamic youth camps, suggests that youths attending WAMY camps be led in the following refrain: Hail! Hail! O Sacrificing Soldiers! To Us! To Us! So we may defend the flag on this Day of Jihad, are you miserly with your blood?! And has life become dearer to you? And staying behind sweeter? Is staying in this world of torment more pleasing to us? You are amongst those called upon by Destiny. Come! So we may revive the times of our predecessors! 447.

Through these and other WAMY publications, as well as the madrassas, camps,

Islamic Centers, mosques, conferences and other events it sponsors, WAMY has provided the ideological foundation for the al Qaeda movement, and actively advocated young Muslims to take up arms and engage in violent jihad against the United States. In this regard, WAMY has played a critical role in al Qaeda’s cultural assault on the United States and democratic institutions throughout the world.

113

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 115115 of 157 of 157

448.

Consistent with the extremist agenda it advocates, WAMY has immersed itself

deeply in the militant endeavors of the global jihadist movement as well, actively supporting the militant and terrorist activities of al Qaeda and associated organizations in Bosnia, Chechnya, Kosovo, Kashmir, Pakistan, South East Asia, the United States and elsewhere. 449.

WAMY’s pervasive involvement in supporting al Qaeda fighters and associated

local jihadist groups in regional conflicts was well documented prior to September 11, 2001. On December 5, 1992, the New York Times identified WAMY as a front for armed Islamic jihad in Bosnia. According to the article, Muslims From Afar Joining “Holy War” in Bosnia: The conflict between Serbs and Muslims in Bosnia and Herzegovina… has been adopted by Islamic fundamentalists as the newest holy war against Christian infidels bent on the destruction of Islam. In the last few weeks, the conflict has lured several hundred militants, many of them veterans of the war in Afghanistan, to volunteer for the Bosnian forces…. The volunteers are sponsored by a variety of militant religious organizations and often have their expenses and plane fare covered…. Despite formal denials from the relief organizations, Saudi officials say an increasing amount of the charity on behalf of the Bosnians is now used to provide arms and logistical support for Arab volunteers. “Since August, most of the money raised for relief has been turned over to the Bosnians for weapons,” a Saudi official…. The World Assembly of Muslim Youth, which organized relief operations in Afghanistan and is now deeply involved in the conflict in the Balkans, flies back wounded Saudi fighters and provides free medical care in the Saudi German hospital. 450.

Within the same article, Adel Batterjee, the then chairman of WAMY,

acknowledged the organization’s role in supporting armed Islamic jihad in Bosnia: “if a relief worker decides that he wants to join the fighting forces, we would not stop him….” Following the September 11, 2001 attack, Adel Batterjee was formally designated as a terrorist sponsor and supporter pursuant to Executive Order 13224.

114

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 116116 of 157 of 157

451.

In May of 2000, Russian officials similarly accused the SJRC, the committee

through which WAMY conducted activities in Chechnya, of financing and otherwise supporting Islamic terrorists and separatists in that region. According to a May 19, 2000 article in the Russian newspaper ITAR-TASS, Chechen Separatists Said Funded by Several Foreign Sources: The aid to Chechens fighting against Russia, is delivered from the organization of humanitarian assistance to Muslims of Kosovo and Chechnya (the SJRC)…. Officially, the money is sent to Chechnya to be used for religious events and Islamic feasts, but is actually used to finance rebel troops [a representative of the Russian Federal Security Service (FSB)]. According to available information, part of the money is transferred to banking accounts of some warlords, including Shamil Basayev and Khattab… Russia’s security services are aware that these people are financing rebel forces, overseeing arms, food and medicine deliveries, as well as arranging treatment for the wounded and paying allowances to guerillas. 452.

Significantly, Amir Khattab, one of the individuals who received financing

directly from WAMY and the SJRC, is a senior al Qaeda member who was deployed to Chechnya by Osama bin Laden to organize al Qaeda’s operations in that area. According to the 1998 Department of Defense Intelligence Report: In 1995, Khattab appeared in Chechnya to carry out a special mission assigned to him by Usama ben Laden to organize training camps for international terrorists…. He was a colonel, fought as a field commander, and was wounded in the hand. Khattab organized three training camps in the Vedeno and Nojai-Urt areas of the forested mountain zone. Graduation is held at the three camps every two months. They are very equipped, with firing range facilities and capabilities to create models of “sites of diversion,” as well as classes for sappers and snipers. 453.

By no later than 1999, the details of bin Laden’s direct links to Khattab and the

Chechen mujihadeen were the subject of widespread reporting in the mainstream media. For instance, in August of 1999, NBC News published a report, U.S. Links bin Laden to Chechnya,

115

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 117117 of 157 of 157

stating that “Osama bin Laden is financing the Chechen operation in Dagestan…” The article, which was based on information provided by senior U.S. intelligence officials, explained that the “key bin Laden connection” to the Chechen jihadists was Amir Khattab, and that their relationship was so close that bin Laden was considering relocating from Afghanistan to areas of Chechnya under Khattab’s control. 454.

Prior to the September 11th Attack, WAMY officials made little effort to conceal

their involvement in sponsoring armed jihad in Chechnya. To the contrary, at least within the Arabic press, WAMY officials openly acknowledged that the organization was deeply involved in sponsoring militant activities in Chechnya. For example, in a January 15, 2000 article published in Al Jazeera newspaper, The Chechen Tragedy – The Reality and the Required Role, Dr. Maneh al Johani, the Secretary General of WAMY, wrote as follows: [I] want to stress that these heroic Moslems, the Mujihadeen who are standing strong, deserve to receive our support and we must invest all of our energy in aiding them when they are being fed the taste of defeat once again. … It should be pointed out that WAMY has doubled its efforts and has placed all of its branches inside and outside of the Kingdom on alert to serve the Chechen issue and to implement the aid program for the Chechen refugees. 1. The question that must be asked is: What do the Chechen Muslims need from us today? 2. They need money to buy arms and ammunition. (emphasis supplied) The Islamic awakening, which is growing, praise be to Allah, is that which worries the Communist East and Heretic West, and they are afraid they will awaken one day and the Muslims will demand payment of a poll tax. Triumph is coming and Islam will remain and Allah will rise and be victorious. I request Allah for our brothers Mujihadeen in Chechnya and Dagestan, stability, reinforcements and victory. 455.

Significantly, al Jahari published his call for Muslims to donate funds to WAMY

to buy “arms and ammunition” for the “mujihadeen” in Chechnya and Dagestan well after the

116

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 118118 of 157 of 157

direct and close relationship between those militants and al Qaeda had been widely detailed in the media and elsewhere. 456.

Philippine officials also publicly implicated WAMY in the financing of terrorist

activities in Southeast Asia in the years prior to the September 11th Attacks. According to a January 15, 1999 article in the Australian General News, Philippines Suspect Australian Group of Helping Rebels, the government of the Philippines accused WAMY’s Australian branch of financing the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (“MILF”). MILF was responsible for several bombings and attacks on remote villages in the Philippines that forced 400 civilians to flee in January of 1999. In February of 1999, MILF Chief Hashim Salamat publicly confirmed that MILF had received funds from Osama bin Laden. 457.

Statements by government officials and press reports in the years preceding the

September 11th attack also reveal WAMY’s extensive role in supporting al Qaeda activities in Kashmir. According to a December 8, 1995 article in the periodical Money Clips, Kashmiri Leader Thanks WAMY for Help, a Kashmiri leader publicly thanked WAMY during a press conference for “helping the Mujihadeen in their struggle for independence from India.” Separate articles published prior to September 11, 2001 reveal that WAMY funneled support to the Students’ Islamic Movement of India (SIMI), Lashkar-e-Taibah and Hizb ul Mujahideen, three violent jihadist groups operating under the broader al Qaeda umbrella. See SIMI: Nursery of Hate, India Today, April 2, 2001; ISI Twin Plan – Attack Christians, Defame Hindu Outfits, The Economic Times of India, July 15, 2000; Kashmir: Hizb-Ul-Mojahedin Chief Explains Reasons Behind Cease Fire, BBC Worldwide Monitoring, August 23, 2000; Pakistani Behind Church Blast Say Police, The Statesmen (India), July 14, 2000. In an interview contained in one of the articles, SIMI head Safdar Nagori publicly confirmed his organization’s allegiance to al Qaeda: Q:

In your conferences, you have openly eulogized Osama bin Laden.

A:

Not once, but dozens of times. We believe he has shown great character in standing up the Americans, the biggest terrorists in the World. 117

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 119119 of 157 of 157

458.

In March of 2003, al Qaeda military chief Abu Zubaydah was arrested at a

Lahkar-e-Taibah safehouse in Islamabad, confirming the depth of collaboration and reciprocal support between those two terrorist organizations. 459.

WAMY Secretary General, Dr. Maneh al Johani, said that Muslims should come

forward to wage jihad to liberate Kashmir. Speaking at a Muslim World League auditorium in 1991, al Johani stated that jihad could be performed in many forms, asserting that Muslims can go to the battlefield to wage a war against the enemies of Islam or they can give their moral, physical and financial support to the cause of jihad. 460.

WAMY’s sponsorship of jihadist activity in Kashmir was channeled through its

offices in Pakistan, which sponsored al Qaeda activity in that country as well. In connection with a crackdown on terrorist activity prompted by the September 11th Attack, Pakistani authorities deported 89 employees of ostensible NGOs in October of 2001, based on their suspected ties to terrorism. WAMY was among the organizations whose “employees” were specifically targeted by the measure. Pakistani intelligence officials, operating in conjunction with agents of the Federal Bureau of Investigations of the United States, raided WAMY’s Pakistani offices approximately one year later, as part of ongoing counter-terrorism efforts. WAMY’s close ties to senior al Qaeda cells in Afghanistan and Pakistan were revealed just one week after the raid, when an employee of WAMY hand delivered a recorded message from Osama bin Laden to an Arab television network in Islamabad. 461.

That incident did not represent the first occasion on which WAMY was involved

in transferring information on behalf of al Qaeda. During the investigation into the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, U.S. officials discovered an al Qaeda training manual in the possession of Ahmed Ajaj, who was later convicted for his role in that attack. The manual, entitled “Military Lessons In The Jihad Against The Tyrants,” was distributed to Ajaj by WAMY and detailed how to establish and maintain clandestine operational sales. The same manual was subsequently recovered from the London apartment of African embassy bomber Khalid alFawwaz in 1998. 118

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 120120 of 157 of 157

462.

Until shortly after the September 11th Attack, WAMY also maintained a physical

presence in the United States, from which the organization channeled material support and resources to al Qaeda. WAMY’s U.S. offices were established in Falls Church, VA in 1992 by Abdullah bin Laden and Omar bin Laden, blood nephews of al Qaeda leader Osama bin Laden. Under Abdullah bin Laden’s leadership, WAMY’s U.S. branch was deeply involved in the terrorist activities of the SAAR Network of businesses and charities. Federal authorities raided WAMY’s U.S. offices in 2004, in connection with an ongoing investigation of the SAAR Network’s role in sponsoring al Qaeda. Abdullah bin Laden was specifically selected by the Saudi Ministry of Islamic Affairs to head WAMY’s branch office in the United States and maintained an office at the Saudi Embassy in Washington, D.C. 463.

Despite the increased scrutiny of WAMY’s operations following the September

11th Attack, the organization continues to sponsor al Qaeda and associated terrorist organizations and separatist movements to this day, demonstrating the organization’s deep and longstanding commitment to al Qaeda’s global jihad. 464.

In June of 2002, Indian authorities arrested two men under the Prevention of

Terrorism Act, after determining that they had transferred funds to Sayed Ali Shah Geelani, the leader of the Fundamentalist Jamaat-e-Islami party. According to sources within India’s government, the two men, Farooq Ahmed and Mohammed Maqbool, were given funds by Nazir Qureshi, a senior WAMY official, to be covertly delivered to Geelani. Geelani previously had been arrested under the Prevention of Terrorism Act based on his involvement in transferring money to militant organizations in Kashmir. 465.

In September of 2003, Romanian intelligence officials implicated WAMY in an al

Qaeda plot to hijack a plane departing from Romania and crash it into Heathrow Airport in London. According to an article published by the Global New Wire on September 5, 2003, Intelligence Service “Alert” Watches Egypt’s “Muslim Brothers” in Romania, the plot was being coordinated by al Qaeda affiliated members of the Muslim Brotherhood in Romania. Quoting information obtained from Romanian intelligence officials, the article asserts that the 119

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 121121 of 157 of 157

Romanian wing of the Muslim Brotherhood acts under the cover of various humanitarian organizations, and receives most of its funds from WAMY. 466.

As recently as March 2012, the Canadian government concluded an investigation

revealing that WAMY’s Canadian branch office “maintained close relationships with and provided funding to organizations that were engaged in providing resources to entities engaged in terrorist activities.” 467.

The Canada Revenue Agency (“CRA”), the government agency responsible for

administering provincial and territorial tax programs, promoting compliance with Canada’s tax legislation and regulations, and ensuring the administration and enforcement of the country’s tax laws, undertook an extensive investigation into the operations and activities of WAMY’s Canadian branch office, located at 3024 Cedarglen Gate, Unit 70, Mississauga, Ontario, arising from concerns that the branch office was failing to comply with certain reporting requirements expected of charitable organizations that wish to maintain their tax exempt status under Canadian law. 468.

As part of that investigation, the CRA conducted an audit of the WAMY branch

office’s financial and operations records, including a review of the office’s Registered Charity Information Returns (T3010). Upon completion of the audit, the CRA determined that the WAMY branch office was in serious non-compliance with the core requirements of the Canadian Income Tax Act, including: (1) failure to comply with Section 230 of the Act requiring WAMY to maintain proper financial books and records; (2) ceasing to comply with certain provisions of the Act requiring WAMY to devote all of its resources to charitable purposes and activities; and (3) failing to file Registered Charity Information Returns as and when required under the Act. 469.

More importantly, the investigation conducted by the CRA uncovered

documentation and information linking the WAMY Canadian branch office, and the WAMY headquarters in Saudi Arabia, to terrorism. For instance, the CRA uncovered evidence that the WAMY branch office shared common officers, office space, contact information, and bank accounts with Executive Order 13224 Specially Designated Global Terrorist (“SDGT”) entity 120

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 122122 of 157 of 157

Benevolence International Fund-Canada (“BIF-Canada”). In addition, the CRA’s investigation discovered that the WAMY branch office was funding Executive Order 13224 SDGT entity Benevolence International Foundation (“BIF”) in the United States. 470.

On November 19, 2002, the U.S. Department of the Treasury designated

Benevolence International Foundation and Benevolence International Fund-Canada as “financiers of terrorism.” According to Treasury, the organization’s leadership, including BIF’s Chief Executive Officer, Enaam Arnaout, were closely associated with Osama bin Laden and “worked with others – including members of al Qaida – to purchase rockets, mortars, rifles, and offensive and defensive bombs, and to distribute them to various mujahideen camps, including camps operated by al Qaida.” 471.

As a result of those findings, the CRA revoked WAMY’s designation as a tax

exempt registered charitable organization. 472.

Statements by Treasury Department officials, testifying before Congress, further

confirm that WAMY continues to serve as a front for al Qaeda and other terrorist organizations. During a July 13, 2005 Hearing on Money Laundering and Terror Financing Issues in the Middle East before the U.S. Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, Treasury Under Secretary Stuart Levey asserted that “wealthy Saudi financiers and charities have funded terrorist organizations and causes that support terrorism and the ideology that fuels the terrorists’ agenda… Even today, we believe that Saudi donors may still be a significant source of terrorist financing, including for the insurgency in Iraq.” Levey expressed particular concern about the continued involvement of WAMY, the IIRO and MWL in the financing of terrorist activities throughout the globe. 473.

As is the case with the MWL and IIRO, the United States has detained a number

of WAMY employees as enemy combatants, and the unclassified evidentiary summaries prepared by the Department of Defense for those detainees specifically detail WAMY’s support for al Qaeda and other terrorist organizations.

121

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 123123 of 157 of 157

474.

For instance, the United States government’s unclassified evidentiary summaries

relating to detainee Mammar Ameur (ISN No. 939) state the following regarding WAMY: “In 1996, the detainee resigned from the EHRO [Egyptian Human Relief Organization] and remained unemployed afterward. The detainee was arrested with an individual, who worked for several years for a Saudi organization called WAMY. The World Assembly of Muslim Youth (WAMY) is an NGO operating in Afghanistan and may be associated with Usama Bin Laden and/or al Qaeda.” 475.

Detainee Adel Hassan Hamed (ISN No. 940) was employed by Lajnat al Daawa

al Islamiya (“LDI”) in Afghanistan and Pakistan from 1986-1999. LDI is a non-governmental organization that operates in Afghanistan and is affiliated with Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda operations. When Hamed was laid off from the LDI in 1999, he was hired as the Director of the WAMY hospital in Afghanistan. “WAMY is a non-government organization operating in Afghanistan that may be affiliated with Usama Bin Ladin and al Qaeda operations. According to top WAMY officials, both the United States and Israel must be destroyed. WAMY provides financial support to the Palestinians fighting against Israel. In addition, WAMY has put forward a proposal that the Palestinians should declare open war on Israel.” AL HARAMAIN ISLAMIC FOUNDATION 476.

Defendant al Haramain Islamic Foundation (“al Haramain”) is a Saudi Arabia-

based ostensible charity, with branch offices in approximately 50 countries. 477.

Al Haramain is an agent and alter-ego of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The

Kingdom controls and directs al Haramain operations, appoints and terminates al Haramain personnel, provides al Haramain with virtually all of its funding, determines how funds will be distributed throughout the world, and otherwise stringently controls al Haramain’s operations. In many countries, al Haramain conducts operations from the local Saudi embassy, under the supervision of the embassy’s Islamic Affairs Division.

122

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 124124 of 157 of 157

478.

Al Haramain officials have acknowledged that their operations are under the

control and direction of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. According to the affidavit testimony of the Financial and Administrative Manager of al Haramain, Khalid bin Obaid Azzahri, “al Haramain operates under the supervision of the Saudi Minister of Islamic Affairs, who appoints its Board of Directors and senior management personnel.” Moreover, al Haramain’s general director, Sheik Aqeel Abdulaziz al Aqil, stated that “we work under the supervision of Saudi government.” Al Aqil has also acknowledged that more than 95% of al Haramain’s funding comes directly from the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. In an August 25, 2002 report posted on al Haramain’s website, the Chairman of the Africa Committee of al Haramain, al Sheikh Muhmad al Tujri, declared that al Haramain’s activities in Kenya were under the “direct supervision” of the Saudi embassy in that country. A separate report on al Haramain’s website that month indicated that the Saudi Interior Minister had directed the organization to provide assistance to Afghani refugees. 479.

The 9-11 Commission Staff Monograph on terrorism financing further indicates

that at least two government ministers held supervisory roles over al Haramain. 480.

International investigations have confirmed al Haramain’s direct and pervasive

complicity in al Qaeda’s operations and attacks throughout the world. 481.

In 2002, an intelligence report from the Bosnian Intelligence Services (Agency for

Investigation and Documentation or “AID”) revealed the active role of Vakufska Banka D.D. in terrorism funding. Indeed, AID described Vakufska Banka D.D. and the merged Depozitna Banka D.D., as a financial platform assisting al Haramain Islamic Foundation and al Qaeda activities: The HO (al Haramain) spent around 13 KM ($7,647,000) between its foundation in 1997 and the end of last year 2000. Financial transactions were through accounts at the Depozit[na] Bank, now the Vakufska Bank, whose major shareholders have been linked with PIS operating illegal money laundering.

123

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 125125 of 157 of 157

The Bosnian Intelligence memo regarding the activities of al Haramain states the following: Given all the above security factors, we believe that the clear lack of any concrete humanitarian projects indicates that the existence of this HO [Humanitarian Organization] was a fictitious cover (…) The report establishes al Haramain’s role in financing and assisting Osama bin Laden operations: Saudi HO [Humanitarian Organization] Al Haramain, (…) has acted as a channel for financing the activities of terrorist organizations. (…) According to available intelligence, the Sarajevo office assisted the terrorist organization Gama Al Islamija, while members of Bin Laden’s El Itihad al Islamija (AIAI) terrorist groups were employed at the Somalia offices, which also financed their operations. 482.

The charity allegedly wired $1 million to Chechen rebels in 1999 and arranged to

buy 500 heavy weapons for them from Taliban units. The Russian security service, FSB, has publicly alleged that Al Baraka Bank was used by al Haramain to funnel money to Islamic resistance fighters in Chechnya. 483.

On March 11, 2002, the United States designated the Bosnia-Herzegovina and

Somalia branches of al Haramain, based on their extensive and pervasive involvement in the funding of al Qaeda’s activities in those two countries. According to the designation: The Bosnia office of Al Haramain is linked to Al-Gama’at alIslamiyya, an Egyptian terrorist group (designated under Executive Order 13224 on October 31, 2001) that was a signatory to UBL’s February 23, 1998 fatwa against the United States. U.S. Treasury Department officials further noted the Somalia branch’s support for the al Qaeda network and a Somali terrorist organization: The Somalia office … is linked to Usama bin Laden’s al Qaida network and Al-Itihaad al-Islamiyya (AIAI), a Somali terrorist group (designated under Executive Order 13224 on September 23, 2001). Al Haramain Somalia employed AIAI members and provided them with salaries through al Barakaat Bank (designated under Executive Order 13224 on November 7, 2001), which was a primary source of terrorist funding. Al Haramain Somalia continued to provide material and financial support for AIAI even after the group’s designation under E.O. 13224 and UNSCR 1333.

124

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 126126 of 157 of 157

Money was funneled to AIAI by disguising funds as if they were intended for orphanage projects or Islamic schools. 484.

On January 22, 2004, the United States designated the al Haramain branches in

Indonesia, Kenya, Tanzania and Pakistan for providing “financial, material and logistical support to Usama bin Laden’s (UBL’s) al-Qaida network and other terrorist organizations.” 485.

The Indonesian Office of al Haramain had diverted funds to al Qaeda affiliated

terrorists for weapons procurement, and directly funded the deadly October 12, 2002 Bali nightclub bombing. In addition to providing financial support to al Qaeda operatives in the country and to the Jemaah Islamiyah terrorist group, a senior al Qaeda official apprehended in Southeast Asia, Omar al Faruq, told authorities that al Haramain served as a primary source of al Qaeda funding throughout Southeast Asia. 486.

In the press release issued in conjunction with the designation of the Kenyan and

Tanzanian offices of al Haramain, the U.S. Treasury Department described al Haramain’s extensive involvement in terrorist activity within Africa as follows: As early as 1997, U.S. and other friendly authorities were informed that the Kenyan branch of AHF was involved in plotting terrorist attacks against Americans. As a result, a number of individuals connected to AHF in Kenya were arrested and later deported by Kenyan authorities. In August 1997, an AHF employee indicated that the planned attack against the U.S. Embassy in Nairobi would be a suicide bombing carried out by crashing a vehicle into the gate of the Embassy. A wealthy AHF official outside East Africa agreed to provide the necessary funds. Information available to the U.S. shows that AHF was used as a cover for another organization whose priorities include dislike for the U.S. government’s alleged anti-Muslim stance and purposed [sic] U.S. support for Christian movements fighting Islamic countries. Also in 1997, AHF senior activities in Nairobi decided to alter their (then) previous plans to bomb the U.S. Embassy in Nairobi and instead sought to attempt the assassination of U.S. citizens. During this time period, an AHF official indicated he had obtained five hand grenades and seven “bazookas” from a source in Somalia. According to the information available to the U.S., these

125

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 127127 of 157 of 157

weapons were to be used in a possible assassination attempt against a U.S. official. Information available to the U.S. shows that a former Tanzania AHF director was believed to be associated with UBL [Usama Bin Laden] and was responsible for making preparations for the advance party that planned the August 7, 1998 bombings of the U.S. Embassies in Dar Es Salaam, Tanzania, and Nairobi, Kenya. As a result of these attacks, 224 people were killed. Shortly before the dual-Embassy bombing attacks in Kenya and Tanzania, a former AHF official in Tanzania met with another conspirator to the attacks and cautioned the individual against disclosing knowledge of preparations for the attacks. Around the same time, four individuals led by an AHF official were arrested in Europe. At that time, they admitted maintaining close ties with EIJ and Gamma Islamiyah. Wadih-El-Hage, a leader of the East African al Qaida cell and personal secretary to UBL [Osama Bin Laden], visited the Kenya offices of AHF before the 1998 dual Embassy attacks. Searches conducted by authorities revealed that El-Hage possessed contact information for a senior AHF official who was head of AHF’s Africa Committee, then overseeing authority for AHF’s offices in Kenya and Tanzania. In early 2003, individuals affiliated with AHF in Tanzania discussed the status of plans for an attack against several hotels in Zanzibar. The scheduled attacks did not take place due to increased security by local authorities, but planning for the attacks remained active. Information made available to the U.S. shows that AHF offices in Kenya and Tanzania provided support, or act for or on behalf of al Qaida and AIM. 487.

The Pakistan office of al Haramain provided funding and logistical support for the

acquisition and delivery of Zenit missiles, Sting anti-aircraft missiles, and hand-held anti-tank weapons to al Qaeda and al Qaeda affiliated militants. In addition: Before the removal of the Taliban from power in Afghanistan, the AHF in Pakistan supported the Taliban and other groups. It was linked to the UBL-financed and designated terrorist organization, Makhtab al-Khidemat (MK). In one instance, sometime in 2000, the MK director instructed funds to be deposited in AHF accounts in Pakistan and from there transferred to other accounts.

126

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 128128 of 157 of 157

At least two former AHF employees who worked in Pakistan are suspected of having al-Qaida ties. One AHF employee in Pakistan is detained at Guantanamo Bay on suspicion of financing al-Qaida operations. Another former AHF employee in Islamabad was identified as an alleged al-Qaida member who reportedly planned to carry out several devastating terrorist operations in the United States. In January 2001, extremists with ties to individuals associated with a fugitive UBL lieutenant were indirectly involved with a Pakistani branch of the AHF. As of late 2002, a senior member of AHF in Pakistan, who has also been identified as a “bin Laden facilitator,” reportedly operated a human smuggling ring to facilitate travel of al-Qaida members and their families out of Afghanistan to various other countries. AHF in Pakistan also supports the designated terrorist organization, Lashkar E-Taibah (LET). 488.

On June 2, 2004, the United States designated the al Haramain branches in

Afghanistan, Albania, Bangladesh, Ethiopia and the Netherlands “for the financial, material and logistical support they provided to the al-Qaida network and other terrorist organizations.” The designation stated the following regarding the al Haramain branch in Afghanistan: In Afghanistan, prior to the removal of the Taliban from power, AHF supported the cause of Jihad and was linked to the UBL financed Makhtab al-Khidemat (MK), a pre-cursor organization of al Qaida and a Specially Designated Global Terrorist pursuant to the authorities of E.O. 13224. Following the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, activities supporting terrorism in Afghanistan continued. In 2002, activities included involvement with a group of persons trained to attack foreigners in Afghanistan. A journalist suspected of meeting with al Qaida and Taliban members in Afghanistan was reportedly transferring funds on behalf of the al Qaida-affiliated AHF and forwarding videotapes from al Qaida leaders to an Arabic language TV network for broadcast. The Albanian branch of al Haramain was closely linked to Osama bin Laden according to U.S. Treasury officials: The U.S. has information that indicates UBL may have financed the establishment of AHF in Albania, which has been used as cover for terrorist activity in Albania and in Europe. In late 2000, a close associate of a UBL operative moved to Albania and was

127

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 129129 of 157 of 157

running an unnamed AHF subsidiary. In 1998, the head of Egyptian Islamic Jihad in Albania was reportedly also a financial official for AHF in Albania. This individual, Ahmed Ibrahim alNagar, was reportedly extradited from Albania to Egypt in 1998. At his trial in Egypt, al-Nager reportedly voiced his support for UBL and al Qaida’s August 1998 terrorist attacks against the U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania. The al Haramain office in Bangladesh conducted surveillance for potential al Qaida attacks on U.S. targets in India: Information available to the U.S. shows that a senior AHF official deployed a Bangladeshi national to conduct surveillance on U.S. consulates in India for potential terrorist attacks. The Bangladeshi national was arrested in early 1999 in India, reportedly carrying four pounds of explosives and five detonators. The terrorist suspect told police that he intended to attack U.S. diplomatic missions in India. The suspect reportedly confessed to training in al Qaida terrorist camps in Afghanistan, where he met personally with Usama bin Laden in 1994. The suspect first heard of plans for these attacks at the AHF office in Bangladesh. 489.

In Ethiopia, the al Haramain branch provided support to Al Itihaad al Islamiyya

(“AIAI”). AIAI has engaged in attacks against Ethiopian defense forces and has been designated both by the United States and the U.N. 1267 Sanctions Committee. Dutch officials confirmed that the al Haramain Humanitarian Aid Foundation located in Amsterdam is part of the larger al Haramain network which has supported terrorism. 490.

Additionally, on June 2, 2004, the United States designated, “the founder and

long-time leader of AHF [al Haramain Islamic Foundation] and a suspected al Qaida supporter,” Aqeel Abdulaziz al Aqil. Al Aqil has been identified as al Haramain’s Chairman, Director General and President. As al Haramain’s founder and leader, al Aqil controlled the organization and was responsible for all of its activities, including its support for al Qaeda and other terrorist organizations. According to U.S. Treasury officials: When viewed as a single entity, AHF is one of the principal Islamic NGOs providing support for the al Qaida network and promoting militant Islamic doctrine worldwide. Under Al Aqil’s leadership of AHF, numerous AHF field offices and representatives operating throughout Africa, Asia, Europe and North America appeared to be providing financial and material 128

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 130130 of 157 of 157

support to the al Qaida network. Terrorist organizations designated by the U.S. including Jemmah Islammiya, Al-Ittihad Al-Islamiya, Egyptian Islamic Jihad, HAMAS and Lashkar ETaibah received funding from AHF and used AHF as a front for fundraising and operational activities. Under Al-Aqil’s leadership, AHF implemented its tasks through its offices and representatives, which span more than 50 countries around the world. AHF maintained nine general committees and several other “active committees” that included the “Continuous Charity Committee, African Committee, Asian Committee, Da’wah and Sponsorship Committee, Masjid Committee, Seasonal Projects Committee, Doctor’s Committee, European Committee, Internet and the American Committee, the Domestic Committee, Zakaat Committee and the Worldwide Revenue Promotion Committee.” 491.

According to the U.S. Treasury Department evidentiary memorandum detailing al

Aqil’s designation pursuant to Executive Order 13224, Mansour Al-Kadi, a Saudi and deputy director general of the al Haramain headquartered in Saudi Arabia, issued an Internet posting which identified al Aqil as the “only individual with final decision making on spending … and the one with authority to hire employees, even if it is just a janitor ….” Al Kadi is also “head” of al Haramain’s Africa Committee, and vice president of the United States al Haramain branch. 492.

On September 9, 2004, the United States designated the United States branch of al

Haramain, along with one of its directors, Soliman al Buthe. In support of the designation, Stuart Levey, U.S. Treasury’s Under-Secretary for Terrorism and Financial Intelligence, said this: “We continue to use all relevant powers of the U.S. government to pursue and identify the channels of terrorist financing, such as corrupted charities, at home and abroad. Al Haramain has been used around the world to underwrite terror, therefore we have taken this action to excommunicate these two branches and Suliman Al-Buthe from the worldwide financial community.” 493.

The United States branch of al Haramain was formally established in 1997. On

the United States branch’s tax Form 990 for 2001 filed with the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”), al Aqil is identified as the President, al Kadi as the Vice-President, al Buthe as the Treasurer, and Perouz Sedaghaty as the Secretary. The U.S. branch’s Article of Incorporation

129

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 131131 of 157 of 157

and application to the IRS for tax-exempt status also list al Aqil and al Kadi as members of the board of directors. Additional documents naming al Buthe as the organization’s attorney and providing him with broad legal authority were signed by al Aqil. 494.

The assets of the al Haramain branch, which is headquartered in Ashland, Oregon,

were blocked as a result of an investigation involving agents from the Internal Revenue Service – Criminal Investigations (“IRS-CI”), the Federal Bureau of Investigation (“FBI”), and the Department of Homeland Security’s Immigration and Customs Enforcement (“ICE”). 495.

In February 2004, the United States Attorney’s Office for the District of Oregon

announced the execution of a federal search warrant against the Ashland, Oregon property which has been purchased on behalf of the Al Haramain Islamic Foundation, Inc. The search was conducted pursuant to a criminal investigation into violations of the Internal Revenue Code, Money Laundering Control Act and Bank Secrecy Act. The accompanying affidavit by IRS Special Agent Colleen Anderson alleges al Haramain and its officers attempted to conceal the transfer of $130,000 in American Express traveler’s checks and a $21,000 cashier’s check intended for aid to Muslims in Chechnya in mid-March of 2000. The affidavit also states that on several occasions from 1997 to 2001, Soliman H. al Buthe, co-founder of the U.S. branch of Al Haramain, brought significant sums of traveler’s checks into the United States, according to declarations he made when entering the country. In 13 trips, he reported bringing in $777,845, of which $206,000 was used to buy the Ashland headquarters in 1997. But there is no explanation for the balance, Anderson wrote. 496.

In early 2000, an Egyptian doctor wired a $150,000 donation from his London

bank account to al Haramain’s Ashland bank, according to the affidavit. An e-mail from the doctor said the money was meant “to participate in your noble support to our Muslim brothers in Chechnya.” At the time, Russian forces were battling Chechen rebels for control of the region. The fight was considered a jihad, or holy war, by some Muslim factions. 497.

The affidavit said that eleven (11) days after the doctor’s donation showed up in

Oregon, al Buthe traveled to Ashland from Saudi Arabia. He joined Perouz Sedaghaty (a/k/a 130

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 132132 of 157 of 157

“Pete Seda”), co-founder of the U.S. branch of al Haramain, at an Ashland bank and the two took out $130,000 – buying 130 traveler’s checks in $1,000 denominations, the affidavit said. A bank clerk suggested it would be easier to issue a cashier’s check, the affidavit said. 498.

“Seda said he could not take a cashier’s check because the money was to help

people and a lot of times these people may not be able to negotiate a cashier’s check,” the affidavit said Seda took an additional $21,000 in a cashier’s check, giving that to al Buthe, the affidavit said. The check had the notation: “Donations for Chichania [sic] Refugees,” the affidavit said. The affidavit said Seda – using the name Abu Yunus – signed an agreement with al Buthe saying he was relinquishing the money for “brothers and sisters in Chechnya.” 499.

Within days, al Buthe returned to Saudi Arabia, failing to declare to Customs, as

required, that he was taking the traveler’s checks out of the United States, the affidavit said. Once back in Saudi Arabia, al Buthe cashed the traveler’s checks in for Saudi riyals at the Al Rajhi Bank. The money then disappeared, presumably to be smuggled into Chechnya. Al Buthe deposited the remainder into his bank account. 500.

Al Haramain’s 2000 tax return underreported income by $21,000, underreported

grants by $150,000, and overstated the price of a second prayer house that al Haramain bought in Missouri. The tax return shows that Sedaghaty, or one of his associates, improperly listed the $131,300 disbursement to al Buthe as funds used to purchase the Springfield prayer house. 501.

On September 9, 2010, a grand jury in Eugene, Oregon convicted Sedaghaty of

two felonies related to the organization’s efforts to send nearly $150,000 to support religious extremist militants in Chechnya. He was convicted of all charges, which included a charge that he filed a false tax return and conspired to file a false tax return as part of al Haramain’s efforts to hide the trail of money. 502.

The United States also further designated the al Haramain branch located in the

Union of the Comoros on September 9, 2004 based on information that two associates of that branch were linked to al Qaeda. According to the transcript from U.S. v. Usama Bin Laden, the Union of the Comoros was used as a staging area and exfiltration route for the perpetrators of the 131

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 133133 of 157 of 157

1998 bombings of the U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania. The al Haramain branches in Kenya and Tanzania were previously designated for providing financial and other operational support to these terrorist attacks. 503.

Finally, on June 19, 2008, the U.S. Treasury Department designated the Saudi-

based headquarters of the al Haramain Islamic Foundation “for having provided financial and material support to al Qaida, as well as a wide range of designated terrorists and terrorist organizations.” According to the designation: Today’s action targets the entirety of the AHF organization, including its headquarters in Saudi Arabia. Evidence demonstrates that the AHF organization was involved in providing financial and logistical support to the al Qaida network and other terrorist organizations designated by the United States and the United Nations. 504.

Al Haramain has also sponsored al Qaeda activity within Europe, through the al

Nur Mosque. According to German officials, the al Nur Mosque served as a meeting place, recruitment center and base of operations for al Qaeda within Germany. At the direction of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, al Haramain contributed in excess of $1 million dollars to the Mosque, funding the purchase of the land for the Mosque as well as its construction. 505.

Al Haramain also sponsored al Qaeda operations in Chechnya and Kosovo

through its participation in the Saudi Joint Relief Committee for Kosovo and Chechnya (“SJRC”). As set forth previously, the SJRC offices in Pristine, Kosovo served as a cover for al Qaeda operatives. Furthermore, between 1998 and 2000, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, through the SJRC, diverted more than $74 million to al Qaeda members and loyalists affiliated with SJRC bureaus. 506.

Al Haramain has advertised its connection to al Qaeda. Al Haramain’s website

used to have a direct link to the al Qaeda site about the Chechen operations (qoqaz.com). The website is part of the al Qaeda propaganda organization, Azzam Publications group of websites, including qoqaz.com, qoqaz.net, and azzam.com (among others).

132

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 134134 of 157 of 157

507.

According to the 1996 Central Intelligence Agency Report, al Haramain directly

funded and supported a mujahideen battalion in Zenica, was involved in illegal smuggling activities, and has further been linked to illegal funding through drugs and prostitution. 508.

Predictably, al Haramain employees and associates feature prominently among

the persons detained as enemy combatants at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba following the September 11, 2001 attacks. 509.

Detainee Zaid Muhamamd Sa’ad al Husayn (ISN No. 050) left Saudi Arabia for

Afghanistan in July 2001 after being inspired by flyers posted by al Haramain. According to the U.S. government: “The al Haramayn Foundation (aka Al Haramayn Islamic Foundation (HIF)) is designated as a Tier 1 Non-Governmental Organization (NGO). Tier 1 targets are defined as terrorist groups, especially those with state support, that have demonstrated the intention and the capability to attack United States Persons or interests.” 510.

Detainee Abdel Hadi Mohammed Badan al Sebaii Sebaii (ISN No. 064) worked

as a volunteer for al Haramain. Department of Defense documentation states that al Haramain “is an NGO with known ties to al Qaida and Usama Bin Laden” and further asserts: “Al Haramain has been connected with violent Islamic groups and possible financial support of militant groups. They’re known to support Islamic extremist elements in 17 countries or regions.” 511.

Detainee Abdul Rahman Owaid Mohammad al Juaid (Detainee No. 179) provided

monetary support to al Haramain, traveled from Saudi Arabia to Afghanistan in 2001, and was identified on a jihadist website on a list of mujahideen captured by the U.S. military in Afghanistan. According to the unclassified evidentiary summaries submitted in support of his continued detention: “The Al Haramain Islamic Foundation is on a terrorism blacklist because of ‘financial, material and logistical support’ they provided to the al Qaida network and other terrorist organization.” “Foreign Government Services officials believe that Al Haramain might be a cover organization for Osama Bin Laden’s al Qaida network. Saudi mujahedin are known to work in Al Haramain regional offices around the world.” 133

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 135135 of 157 of 157

512.

Detainee Said Muhammad Husayn Qahtani (Detainee No. 200) traveled multiple

times from Saudi Arabia to Afghanistan between 2000 and 2001. In May 2000, Qahtani met and stayed with Abu Zubaydah in a safehouse while waiting to travel to Afghanistan. Moreover, during a trip in June 2000, Qahtani joined the Taliban against the Northern Alliance and spent a considerable amount of time on the front lines. Qahtani joined al Qaeda after giving an oath of allegiance (“al bay’ah”) to Osama bin Laden, and further met 2 of the 9-11 hijackers – Saeed al Ghamdi and Ahmed Alnami. According to Department of Defense documentation, Qahtani contacted relief organizations such as the IIRO and al Haramain with the intention “to join a relief organization because those entities would offer him a way to get into Chechnya, whose borders were closed at that time. Once there, the detainee would be free to leave the relief organization and join the fighting.” 513.

Detainee Fahd Muhammed Abdullah al Fouzan (Detainee No. 218), an al

Haramain employee, traveled to Afghanistan after September 11, 2001 and was identified as having attended the Abu Nasir military camp in Afghanistan. Al Fouzan fought in Tora Bora and was a fundraiser and recruiter for both al Qaeda and the Taliban in Saudi Arabia. According to the U.S. government: “The detainee was identified as an employee of the al Haramayn Charitable Institute. Al Haramayn was added on 11 March 2002 to the list of organizations identified under Executive Order 13224 blocking property and prohibiting transactions with persons who commit, threaten to commit, or support terrorism.” 514.

Detainee Wasm Awwad Umar Wasim (Detainee No. 338), traveled from Saudi

Arabia to Afghanistan in late 2001 with another member of al Qaeda. According to the unclassified evidentiary summaries submitted in support of his continued detention: “The detainee volunteered to work with the Al Haramain charity/non-governmental organization (NGO) from time to time. Executive Order 13224, which blocks property and prohibits transactions with persons who commit, threaten to commit, or support terrorism, designated AlHaramain as a global terrorist entity. The detainee stated he was a colleague of the Al-Haramain Director.” In response to allegations concerning his association with al Haramain, Wasim 134

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 136136 of 157 of 157

testified that “al Haramain is an official governmental organization, registered under the administration of the government and the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. It is officially registered and included in the Humanitarian Aid Association, and under the administration of Internal Affairs, led by the Minister of Internal Affairs.” Wasim further stated that al Haramain is “not a secret organization; it’s a governmental organization.” 515.

Detainee Sami al Haj (Detainee No. 345), a senior al Qaeda operative and

logistics expert, traveled to Azerbaijan at least 8 times to courier money to al Haramain, particularly between 1997-1999. The United States government’s unclassified evidentiary summaries relating to al Haj assert: “A source stated the al Haramain Saudi Arabian Foundation’s main mission is to implement and teach true Wahhabism religious doctrine worldwide. Al Haramain has connections with al Qaida. A former head of the al Haramain has been accused of controlling the financial, material and logistical support to al Qaida and other terrorist organizations. Al Haramain is suspected of involvement in weapons smuggling to Algeria and the transfer of radical fundamentalists to Bosnia during the war in the former Yugoslavia.” 516.

Detainee Jamal Muhammad Alawi Mari (Detainee No. 577), began working with

al Haramain as a student in 1995 and was later hired in 1997 to work at the al Haramain office in Baku, Azerbaijan. In August 1998, Mari was appointed as director of the al Haramain office in Baku. A foreign government agency has stated that Mari took part in high-level illegal activity, and further reported that the al Haramain office disseminated propaganda of an extremist and separatist nature in the guise of providing humanitarian assistance. 517.

The unclassified evidentiary summaries filed in support of Mari’s continued

detention at Guantanamo Bay detail al Haramain’s long-standing support for Islamic extremist groups, families of Islamic suicide attackers, the al Qaeda network, and mujahideen fighters in Chechnya: Al Haramayn was founded in 1992 to disseminate the Saudi Arabian version of the Sunni Islamic religion with Wahabistic

135

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 137137 of 157 of 157

influences/teachings. In addition to providing legitimate humanitarian aid to promote Islamic teachings, this organization has provided support to families of Islamic suicide attackers, freed activists from prisons, procured fraudulent travel documents, provided medical care for wounded Mujahedin, smuggled weapons into Algeria and transferred radical fundamentalists into Bosnia. Al Haramayn has provided logistical support to the Mujahedin fighting in Afghanistan since the 1980’s. Their annual budget was between 50 to 60 million United States Dollars. Al Haramayn provides support to Islamic extremist elements in seventeen countries or regions that includes freeing of activists from prisons, procurement of fraudulent travel documents and weapons smuggling to Algeria. Forty bank accounts connect to terrorist activities have been linked to offices and sub-departments of al Haramayn. A source stated al Haramayn worked closely with members of al Wafa. A former al Qaida member stated organizations such as al Haramayn and al Wafa allowed easier access to funds which financed al Qaida. These organizations provided a legitimate cover for al Qaida members to travel world-wide under the guise of humanitarian operations. These groups would build mosques for the purpose of recruiting future al Qaida members. Al Haramayn established an office in Azerbaijan to provide a legitimate organization, which was also providing money and materials to Mujahedin, military leaders throughout Chechnya. Authorities accused Al Haramayn of supporting activities not in alignment with the humanitarian aims of the organization in January 2000 and the office was subsequently closed. 518.

Detainee Khalid Mahomoud Abdul Wahab al Asmr (Detainee No. 589), identified

as an Afghan jihad veteran who had connections with Islamic extremists worldwide, told U.S. military investigators that he had been providing aid to al Qaeda and other extremists since 1996. According to the U.S. government, Al Asmr met with Muhamed Krimi, the director of the al Haramain office in Zenica, Bosnia in July 1999 to discuss a plan to attack the British and American embassies: “HIF [al Haramain] has been sanctioned under Executive Order 13224 for supporting terrorism. HIF has been linked to the Mujahedin Brigade in Bosnia and the Islamic Cultural Institute (ICI) in Milan. HIF uses links to the ICI to remain active in support of the

136

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 138138 of 157 of 157

former mujahideen in Bosnia.” In response to the Tribunal’s contention that al Haramain is associated with al Qaeda, Al Asmr stated: “If you consider al Haramayn as a terrorist organization, you should [be] talking to Saudi Arabia, because Saudi Arabia was the country that established al-Haramayn. Its president is the Royal Prince there. Why don’t you go over there and ask him.” SAUDI HIGH COMMISSION 519.

The Saudi High Commission for Relief of Bosnia and Herzegovina (“SHC”) is a

Saudi Arabia-based da’awa organization, established by the government of Saudi Arabia and headed by Prince Salman bin Abdul Aziz al Saud, who actively directed the SHC’s operations. 520.

The SHC is a controlled agent and alter-ego of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The

Kingdom controls and directs SHC operations, appoints and terminates SHC personnel, provides the SHC with virtually all of its funding, determines how funds will be distributed throughout the world, and otherwise stringently controls the SHC’s operations. 521.

According to the affidavit testimony of the Minister of State of the Council of

Ministers of Saudi Arabia, Dr. Mutlib bin Abdullah al Nafissa, the SHC “is an arm of the Saudi Arabian government. Actions taken by the SHC properly are viewed as actions of the Government of Saudi Arabia.” 522.

Saud bin Mohammad al Roshood, Director of the Executive Office of the SHC,

has likewise affirmed in affidavit testimony that the SHC was created by decision of the President of the Council of Ministers of Saudi Arabia, has been continuously headed by Prince Salman bin Abdulaziz al Saud, and that the Executive Committee and Supreme Commission of the SHC include a number of other Saudi Government officials. 523.

As detailed previously, the SHC was established to coordinate the Kingdom of

Saudi Arabia’s response to the Bosnian War, and served as a primary conduit for the Kingdom’s massive sponsorship of al Qaeda’s jihad in the Balkans.

137

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 139139 of 157 of 157

524.

According to Bosnian officials, al Qaeda mujahideen fighters began entering

Bosnia-Herzegovina in 1992, frequently disguised as relief workers for the SHC. 525.

Throughout the course of the war, the SHC served as a primary front for

channeling financial and logistical support for al Qaeda’s jihad in Bosnia, as confirmed by the testimony of former al Qaeda member Ali Ahmed Ali Hamad. 526.

Ali Hamad was sent to Bosnia in 1992 to help coordinate al Qaeda’s military

operations. Following the war, Ali Hamad was employed by the SHC’s Mostar office as the Department Chief for “dawa.” In 1997, Ali Hamad was arrested and convicted for participation in a car bombing in the city of Mostar. At the time, Ali Hamad was ostensibly employed by the SHC. 527.

Among other things, Ali Hamad has affirmed in sworn testimony that: The SHC provided Ali Hamad and other al Qaeda members with false employment papers to allow them to move freely throughout the Balkans in furtherance of al Qaeda’s objectives. Representatives of the SHC provided extensive financial support and food to the mujahideen forces, and also permitted the mujahideen and al Qaeda members in Bosnia to use the SHC’s offices and rented houses. Al Qaeda members planned terrorist plots and attacks from SHC facilities. The SHC frequently transported mujahideen and al Qaeda members throughout Bosnia-Herzegovina in SHC vehicles bearing the mark of the United Nations High Commission for Refugees (“UNHCR”), thereby allowing those mujahideen and al Qaeda members to pass military and police checkpoints. The SHC also provided the mujahideen with money for other travel expenses. The SHC appointed a number of former mujahideen fighters to serve as officers or directors of its branch offices in BosniaHerzegovina. In 1993 the director of the Sarajevo office of the SHC was a Saudi named Abu al-Miqdad al Dusari. Al Dusari was among the first mujahideen to arrive in Bosnia-Herzegovina at the beginning of the Bosnian War. At the request of the mujahideen in 1994, the Chief Director of the SHC in Zagreb appointed a man named Hasam al Din to serve as the director of the Zenica office. Al Din was also one of the first

138

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 140140 of 157 of 157

mujahideen to arrive in Bosnia-Herzegovina at the beginning of the Bosnian War, and he engaged in significant military activities as a member of the mujahideen forces placed in Tesanj, in the middle of Bosnia. Al Din was wounded during the course of the war, and after recovering from his wounds, returned to BosniaHerzegovina as a representative of the Zenica office of the SHC. SHC directors routinely delivered truckloads of supplies to al Qaeda members. After the conclusion of the Bosnian War, the SHC provided ostensible employment to a number of foreign fighters and al Qaeda members who had fought in the War, knowing full well that they were members of al Qaeda. Moreover, the SHC continued to provide foreign fighters and al Qaeda members with access to vehicles with diplomatic car registrations, and vehicles registered to the UNHCR, which enabled them to move freely throughout Bosnia-Herzegovina. 528.

Ali Hamad’s sworn testimony is independently corroborated by numerous U.S.,

U.N. and NATO investigations. 529.

For instance, wiretap summaries obtained from the International Criminal

Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia reveal that members of the al Qaeda mujahedeen in Bosnia were directed to pick up funds for the purchase of weapons from the SHC. In this regard, a May 25, 1994 entry in from a report of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina’s Ministry of the Interior, detailing intercepted telephone conversations between mujahideen fighters during 1994, identifies the SHC as having provided money to mujahideen fighters to purchase weapons (“In the talk between Abu Talib and Abu Meali, Talib asked for money to purchase weapons and said that he bought an American rifle, three Kalashnikovs and three sniper rifles, and asked Meali for permission for DEM. He picked up the money for the purchase of the weapons at the Saudi High Committee in Visoko.”). 530.

A U.N. sponsored investigation further determined that Prince Salman bin Abdul

Aziz al Saud, the head of the SHC, transferred in excess of $120 million from his personal accounts and SHC accounts under his control to the Third World Relief Agency (“TWRA”), between July of 1992 and July of 1995. According to the 9/11 Commission, the TWRA was an

139

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 141141 of 157 of 157

al Qaeda front and the primary pipeline for illegal arms shipments to al Qaeda fighters in the Balkans. The U.N. sponsored audit of the TWRA’s records suggested that the SHC’s lavish funding of TWRA commenced shortly after a personal meeting between Prince Salman and the head of the TWRA. As the SHC had a robust operational presence of its own in Bosnia, there was no legitimate “humanitarian” reason for it to send any funds to the TWRA. 531.

In 1994, Abdul Hadi al Gahtani, a Saudi who was the Director of the SHC’s

office in Zenica, was arrested for the murder of the British aid worker, Paul Goodall. Al Gahtani admitted the gun used in the murder belonged to him, but escaped police custody under mysterious circumstances and a Bosnian court later convicted him in absentia of Goodall’s murder. Al Gahtani was reportedly “martyred” on November 19, 2001, when a U.S. rocket hit a building where he was staying. 532.

The U.S. government has also concluded that an al Qaeda member associated

with the SHC murdered U.S. citizen William Jefferson in Bosnia on November 18, 1995. In a Federal Bureau of Investigation (“FBI”) memorandum summarizing an interview of Ali Ahmed Ali Hamad on June 16, 2003 regarding the murder Mr. Jefferson, Ali Hamad discusses his relationship with fellow mujahideen and al Qaeda member, Ahmed Zuhair Handala (who “had a good relationship with Usama Bin Laden”). The FBI memo states that Handala attempted to recruit Ali Hamad to join his unit to kill American and British citizens, but he refused. The memo further states that Handala had been arrested in Mostar but had been later released from prison because of a payoff by the SHC (“The Saudi Arabia High Commission gave the Croatians $70,000 or more for his release.”). 533.

In October 2001, officials of the U.S. government and NATO raided the Sarajevo

offices of the SHC. During the raid, investigators found computer hard drives with photographs of the World Trade Center before and after its collapse, as well as photographs of the United States embassies in Kenya and Tanzania and the U.S.S. Cole. Investigators also discovered files on deploying chemical agents with crop dusters, information about how to make fake State

140

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 142142 of 157 of 157

Department badges, and photographs and maps of Washington, marking prominent government buildings. 534.

Following the raid, the Financial Police of the Federation of Bosnia Herzegovina

Ministry of Finance described the SHC as a front for radical and terrorism-related activities, stating: Members of the SFOR (stabilization forces) have on premises on the Saudi high commission relief for Bosnia and Herzegovina confiscated some documentation for which it can be claimed with certainty that it does not belong in the scope of work of a humanitarian organization … 535.

During that same month, officials in Bosnia also arrested six members of the al

Qaeda network (known as the “Algerian Six” or “Bosnian Six”) who were plotting to conduct terrorist strikes on U.S. targets in Bosnia, including an attack on the U.S. Embassy in Sarajevo: Bensayah Belkacem, Saber Lahmar, Mustafa Ait Idir, Hadj Boudella, Lakhdar Boumediene, and Mohamed Nechle. All members of the group were on the SHC’s payroll. According to media reporting on their arrest, intercepted phone conversations between the men spoke of the need to retaliate for U.S. attacks in Afghanistan. It was reported that one of them said, “Tomorrow, we will start.” 536.

The six men were turned over to the U.S. in January 2002 and were incarcerated

at Guantanamo Bay Naval Base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba. Unclassified evidentiary summaries prepared by the Department of Defense for the Combatant Status Review Tribunal (“CSRT”) confirm that the men were closely connected to Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda, were on the SHC’s payroll, and that the SHC was providing financial support to mujahideen fighters in Bosnia. 537.

Department of Defense documentation identifies Bensayah Belkacem as a

primary al Qaeda facilitator in Bosnia. According to the unclassified evidentiary summaries: Belkacem possessed numerous phone numbers that linked him to bin Laden’s operational network in Afghanistan and the global Sunni extremist group; Belkacem was known for his ties

141

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 143143 of 157 of 157

to the Chechen movement during 1999 and reportedly had a connection to a bin Laden operative; and Belkacem planned to join jihadist elements in Afghanistan in September 2001 in anticipation of the U.S. invasion. 538.

The DOD materials relating to Belkacem specifically link the SHC to the

members of the Algerian Six: An open source reported that the detainee, also known to be the leader of a group in Algeria, had 3.5 million Marks of Bosnian currency deposited in a bank in Sarajevo, Bosnia, and several other members of the group had millions also deposited in banks. The open source reported that an investigation revealed the High Saudi Committee had on its payroll almost all of the members of the group from Algeria, which had links to international terrorism. 539.

Bosnian investigators determined that Belkacem was in charge of screening

recruits for al Qaeda training camps in Bosnia and that his cell phone contained the telephone number for senior al Qaeda official Abu Zubaydah. Belkacem worked closely with Zubaydah regarding the procurement of passports. 540.

Saber Lahmar, a member of the al Qaeda network, was also an employee of the

SHC for several years. According to DOD documentation presented in support of Lahmar’s continued detention at Guantanamo Bay: Lahmar is a former Bosnian/Afghan Mujahedin; Lahmar supported the fatwa issued by bin Laden against the U.S.; Lahmar expressed a desire to blow up U.S. soldiers, proposed attacking U.S. troops in Bosnia, and made threats against the international community in Bosnia; Lahmar attempted to assume leadership of the Armed Islamic Group in Bosnia; and finally was known to be a close associate of an al Qaeda member in Bosnia. DOD unclassified evidentiary summaries further stated: •

The detainee worked for the Saudi High Commission for Relief from 1993 to 1994 and again from 1996 until 2002.

•

The Saudi High Commission for Relief and al Haramayn has provided financial support to former Arab Mujahedin in Bosnia. The types of financial support included family stipends or travel to Chechnya and Afghanistan.

142

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 144144 of 157 of 157

•

The detainee worked for El Haramain in Zenica and Sarejevo, Bosnia. He had close leadership ties to the leadership of El Haramain in Zenica.

•

The head organizer for placing a car bomb in Mostar in 1997, who was also close to the Saudi High Commission and El Haramein, frequently visited the detainee.

•

Al Haramayn is directly tied to terrorist activities in the Bosnia-Herzegovina area. They provide shelter and support to persons known to have committed terrorist activities.

541.

DOD materials presented to the CSRT in support of the remaining Algerian Six

members’ further detention at Guantanamo Bay detail their ties to al Qaeda and the Bosnian mujahideen. Mustafa Ait Idir is identified as a member of the Armed Islamic Group and a former Bosnian Mujahideen and chief martial arts instructor for the Bosnian Muj Brigade who made threats against Stabilization Forces in Bosnia and reportedly exhorted Bosnian mujahideen to kill Stabilization Forces. Hadj Boudella is a suspected member of the Bosnian Mujahideen and was associated with known al Qaeda elements in the Balkans. Boudella was in the Tora Bora region with several al Qaeda fighters and operatives, and received training on the Kalashnikov rifle and grenades from an al Qaeda member. Lakhdar Boumediene was also a former member of the Bosnian Mujahideen, a member of the Algerian Armed Islamic Group, and was one of the closest associates of an al Qaeda member in Bosnia. Finally, Mohamed Nechle is a member of the Armed Islamic Group with links to bin Laden’s al Qaeda terrorist network. Nechla is further identified as a supporter of terrorist groups in Africa. 542.

Governmental investigations also indicate that the SHC has played a direct role in

arms trafficking for al Qaeda. Of particular note, a Defense Intelligence Agency report indicates that General Mohammad Farah Hassan Aideed, the al Qaeda affiliated Somali warlord responsible for the Black Hawn down massacre, received “weapons’ shipment from the Saudi Arabian High Commission for Relief.” The weapons were “usually hidden in false bottom containers.”

143

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 145145 of 157 of 157

SAUDI RED CRESCENT SOCIETY 543.

The Saudi Red Crescent Society (“SRC”) is a Saudi Arabia-based da’awa

organization, which conducts operations throughout the world. 544.

The SRC is a controlled agent and alter-ego of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The

Kingdom controls and directs SRC operations, appoints and terminates SRC personnel, provides the SRC with virtually all of its funding, determines how funds will be distributed throughout the world, and otherwise stringently controls the SRC’s operation. In many countries, the SRC conducts operations from the local Saudi embassy, under the supervision of the embassy’s Islamic Affairs Division. 545.

Senior officials of the SRC have expressly acknowledged that the SRC is an alter-

ego of the Saudi Arabia government. According to the affidavit testimony of Abdulrahman al Swailem, President of the Saudi Arabian Red Crescent Society, al Swailem was appointed by “royal order issued by King Fahd bin Abdulaziz, to serve as president of the Saudi Arabian Red Crescent Society,” a position that holds Excellency level status within the Saudi Arabian Government. The affidavit further asserts that the Government of the Kingdom “sponsors and supervises the Saudi Arabian Red Crescent Society, and the Saudi Government appoints all of its directors.” 546.

The SRC’s ties to al Qaeda’s leadership also date to the 1980s, when it operated

within the network established to support the Afghan jihad. 547.

By all accounts, the SRC played a prominent role within that network, providing

extensive financial and logistical support to the mujihadeen in Afghanistan. Indeed, in 1986, Dr. Abu Hazifa, a Director of the SRC, openly acknowledged the organization’s direct ties to the mujihadeen, and that many of those fighters in fact worked for the Saudi Red Crescent. 548.

The SRC’s support for bin Laden’s terrorist organization was orchestrated largely

by Wa’el Hamza Jelaidan, who in addition to his positions within the MWL, IIRO and SJRC headed the SRC’s office in Peshawar, Pakistan during the 1980s.

144

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 146146 of 157 of 157

549.

As discussed previously, documents recovered from the Tareekh Osama file

document al Qaeda’s intent to rely on the SRC to support its global jihad. A later internal al Qaeda document cautioned that the SRC may no longer represent a safe “umbrella” for al Qaeda members, because Jelaidan was being recalled to Saudi Arabia. The import of this statement is clear – under Jelaidan’s direction the SRC was serving as a front for al Qaeda. 550.

During that same search, investigators found a letter on SRC stationary to Abu

Rida, another founding member of al Qaeda, requesting that “weapons be inventoried.” At the bottom of the letter is a note from bin Laden to Jelaidan, then the SRC’s director, stating “we have an extreme need for weapons.” 551.

Years later, Jelaidan facilitated the SRC’s sponsorship of al Qaeda activities in

Kosovo and Chechnya. In 1999, Saudi Arabia formed the Saudi Joint Relief Committee for Kosovo and Chechnya to coordinate the relief efforts of the SRC and other Saudi charities in Kosovo and Chechnya. The Kingdom designated the SRC to serve as the operational arm for SJRC-coordinated relief efforts. Although bin Laden had publicly confirmed that Jelaidan was one of al Qaeda’s founding members in a 1999 interview, the Kingdom appointed Jelaidan Director of SJRC and SRC operations in Pristina. In 2000, U.S. officials sent a written alert to the U.N. Peace Keeping Force in Pristina, asserting that SJRC officials Adel Kazam and Jelaidan were “associates of Osama bin Laden” and that Jelaidan was actively involved in helping bin Laden “move money and men” to and from the Balkans. 552.

Separate incidents revealed that members of the SRC staff working under the

supervision of the SJRC actively participated in the development and planning of terrorist attacks against American interests. 553.

Employees of the SRC were also implicated in the 1995 al Qaeda bombing attack

on the Egyptian Embassy in Islamabad. Following that attack, investigators arrested Muhammed Ali Sayed and Bashir Barbar Qadim, two Sudanese employees of the SRC. The investigation which led to the arrests revealed evidence that Sayed had indirectly funded the attack by channeling SRC funds to Egyptian al Jihad, the terrorist organization run by Ayman al Zawahiri 145

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 147147 of 157 of 157

which formally merged with al Qaeda several years before the September 11th Attack. Egyptian authorities alleged that Zawahiri personally masterminded the Embassy attack. 554.

The SRC continued to serve as a front for al Qaeda through the date of the

September 11th Attack. In fact, just weeks after the September 11th Attack, the Pakistani government deported employees of the SRC, based on evidence that they were involved in al Qaeda related terrorist activities. In 2002, NATO and Bosnian authorities arrested six Algerian al Qaeda members who were plotting attacks on the U.S. and British embassies in Sarajevo. Two of those men, Boumediene Lakhdar and Nechle Mohammed, were employees of the SRC. 555.

Based in part of the U.S. government’s assertion that the SRC is a front for al

Qaeda, several persons associated with the SRC were incarcerated at the Guantanamo Bay Naval Base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba as enemy combatants 556.

Detainee Mohamed Atiq Awayd al Harbi (ISN No. 333) was a member of the

mujahideen in Kandahar, Afghanistan and was further identified as being a fighter in the Tora Bora Mountains. When al Harbi was arrested by Pakistani police, he was in possession of $8,000 U.S. dollars and 12,000 Saudi Riyals which he was planning to deliver to the SRC. Representatives from the Saudi Embassy and from the SRC visited him and provided him with lawyers. Al Harbi was eventually handed over to the United States and transported to Guantanamo Bay, but was subsequently transferred to Saudi Arabia on November 9, 2007 to participate in the Kingdom’s terrorist rehabilitation program. Less than 6 months after returning to Saudi Arabia, al Harbi fled to Yemen with other Saudi al Qaeda members. On January 23, 2009, the al Fajr Media Center – the official online logistical network responsible for disseminating messages from various al Qaeda military factions – released new video footage of joint sermons delivered by a group of Saudi and Yemeni al Qaeda leaders. Al Harbi appeared in the video with the official title of “Field Commander of the al Qaeda Organization in the Arabian Peninsula.” 557.

Detainee Said Ali al Shihri (ISN No. 372) traveled from Saudi Arabia to

Afghanistan following the September 11th attacks with $1,900 U.S. dollars to distribute to the 146

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 148148 of 157 of 157

SRC. Al Shihri trained in urban warfare at the Libyan Camp north of Kabul, and one of his aliases was among 100 names taken from Afghanistan-based military training camp applications. Following his capture, al Shihri was handed over to the United States and transported to Guantanamo Bay, but was subsequently transferred to Saudi Arabia on November 9, 2007 to participate in the Kingdom’s terrorist rehabilitation program. Al Shihri eventually escaped from Saudi security forces and fled with other high profile al Qaeda operatives to Yemen. On January 23, 2009, the al Fajr Media Center released new video footage of joint sermons delivered by a group of Saudi and Yemeni al Qaeda leaders. Al Shihri was featured in the video with the official title of “Secretary General of the al Qaeda Organization in Saudi Arabia.” 558.

Detainee Muhamed Hussein Abdallah (ISN No. 704) was employed as an Arabic

language instructor by the SRC. According to the unclassified evidentiary summaries submitted in support of Abdallah’s continued detention: “Senior officials of the SRCS [Saudi Red Crescent Society] were involved in money laundering operations aimed at assisting Pakistani-based extremist organizations.” Concerning the allegations lodged by the United States regarding his association with various “humanitarian organizations,” Abdallah stated “the only one I was working for the last two years was the Saudi Red Crescent. If these organizations were terrorist organizations, its contrary to what I knew about them. They were official government organizations, recognized as I said, by official governments. So why don’t you bring the officials, the Saudi government…?” SAUDI JOINT RELIEF COMMITTEE FOR KOSOVO AND CHECHNYA 559.

The Kingdom of Saudi Arabia established the Saudi Joint Relief Committee

(“SJRC”) on May 19, 1999 pursuant to High Order 7/B/1863 (the “Albanian High Order”). In accordance with the Albanian High Order, the SJRC was endowed with responsibility for coordinating and carrying out the operations of five constituent charities in Kosovo and Chechnya: Al Haramain al Masjed al Aqsa; IIRO, WAMY, MWL and SRC. Subsequent to the

147

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 149149 of 157 of 157

establishment of the SJRC, those constituent charities continued to solicit funds to support activities in Kosovo and Chechnya throughout the World, including from the United States. 560.

Senior officials of the SJRC have expressly acknowledged that the SJRC is a

controlled agent and alter-ego of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. According to the affidavit testimony of Dr. Abdulrahmann al Swailem, President of the SJRC, the SJRC has “always functioned as a political subdivision, agency, or instrumentality of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. The SJRC was established on May 19, 1999 pursuant to High Order… issued by King Fahd upon the recommendation of the Council of Ministers of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.” The affidavit further reflects that the governing Albanian High Order specified that the SJRC would be supervised by the Minister of Interior of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, and that the SJRC would include a number of other high-ranking representatives from agencies of the Kingdom and other “charity” organizations. Of particular interest, the Order establishing the SJRC required that its leadership include “the Presidency of General Intelligence.” 561.

Between 1998 and 2000, the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, through SJRC, diverted

more than $74 million dollars to al Qaeda members and loyalists affiliated with SJRC bureaus. Throughout this time, the committee was under the supervision and control of Saudi Interior Minister Prince Naif Bin Abdul Aziz. 562.

Each of the constituent charities operating under the SJRC has longstanding ties

to al Qaeda. For instance, al Haramain al Masjed al Aqsa was designated by the Treasury Department on May 6, 2004 pursuant to Executive Order 13224. According to U.S. officials: The Al-Haramain & Al Masjed Al-Aqsa Charity Foundation (AHAMAA) has significant financial ties to the Bosnia-based NGO Al Furqan, and al Qaida financier Wa’el Hamza Julaidan, who was designated by the Treasury Department on September 6, 2002. Wa’el Hamza Julaidan, a Saudi citizen, is a close associate of Usama bin Laden. Julaidan fought with bin Laden in Afghanistan in the 1980s. Bin Laden himself acknowledged his close ties to Julaidan during a 1999 interview with al-Jazeera TV. As a member of the Board of Directors for AHAMAA, Julaidan opened three bank accounts on behalf of the NGO between 1997

148

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 150150 of 157 of 157

and 2001 and continued to have authorization to handle two of their accounts as a signatory on two the NGO’s Bosnian accounts. 563.

As described above, the MWL, IIRO, WAMY and SRC have similar pervasive

ties to al Qaeda, and like its constituent entities, the SJRC provided critical resources to support al Qaeda’s jihad against the United States. 564.

As al Qaeda was establishing its operations in Kosovo and Chechnya, Wa’el

Jelaidan assumed a position as Director of the SJRC’s office in Pristina. As referenced above, Jelaidan is a founding member of al Qaeda and was designated by the United States government on September 6, 2002 pursuant to Executive Order 13224. The Treasury Department press release issued in conjunction with the designation set forth the following basis for the action: The United States’ has credible information that Wa’el Julaidan is an associate of Osama bin Laden and several of bin Laden’s top lieutenants. Julaidan has directed organizations that have provided financial and logistical support to al Qaida. Accordingly, the United States is designating Julaidan under Executive Order 13224 as a person who supports terror. 565.

The United Nation’s mission in Kosovo has declared that the SJRC office in

Pristina, Kosovo, served as a cover for several al Qaeda operatives, including Adel Muhammad Sadi Bin Kazam and Wa’el Hamza Julaidan, both of whom served as Directors of SJRC. 566.

More than a year before the September 11th Attacks, U.S. officials sent a written

request to the U.N. Peace Keeping Force in Pristina, requesting that U.N. police undertake surveillance of the SJRC. In that document, Marked “Secret: U.S. Office Only – Release to UNMIK,” the U.S. government asserted that SJRC officials Adel Muhammad Sadi Bin Kazam and Julaidan were “associates of Osama bin Laden” and that Julaidan was actively involved in helping bin Laden “move money and men to and from the Balkans.” 567.

Acting on that information, the United Nations Mission in Kosovo (“UNMIK”)

raided a house rented by the SJRC in Pristina, and declared that the organization served as a cover for several Usama bin Laden operatives, including Kazem and Jelaidan.

149

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 151151 of 157 of 157

568.

A year earlier, in June 1998, the CIA and Albanian authorities raided several

houses and offices of members of an associate of the SJRC in Tirana. In July 1998, its Director Muhamed Hasan Mahmud, an Egyptian national, was arrested on charges of making false documents and arms possession. He was connected to a 1992 terrorist attack against the Egyptian Parliament. Several of its members and directors were later arrested in connection with the U.S. Embassy bombings in Kenya and Tanzania of August 1998. 569.

Prominent media outlets have also documented the SJRC’s role in facilitating the

movement of “money and men to and from the Balkans” for Osama bin Laden. 570.

Despite his joint designation by the United States and Saudi Arabia on September

6, 2002 for being “an associate of Usama bin Laden and a supporter of al-Qa’ida terror,” Jelaidan continued to work on behalf of the SJRC as late as December 2003. According to the United Nations Security Council Committee’s December 2, 2003 Second Report of the Monitoring Group on Al-Qaida: The Rabita Trust was added to the list in October 2001. Its Saudi Chairman, Wa’el Hamza Julaidan (also spelled Jalaidan) was designated at the request of the United States and Saudi Arabia on 6 September 2002. There are nevertheless reports that Julaidan remains actively engaged in “charitable activities” and financial transactions. Julaidan currently lives in Saudi Arabia and is reportedly still working with the Saudi Joint Relief Committee for Kosovo and Chechnya, and serves as one of the directors of the AlHaramain al-Masjid al-Aqsa Foundation in Bosnia and Herzegovina. 571.

SJRC’s Saudi bank accounts at National Commercial Bank (“NCB”) were

managed by Suleiman Abdel Aziz al Rajhi, Chairman, Managing Director and the largest shareholder of Al Rajhi Banking & Investment Corporation. Historically, Suleiman al Rajhi himself has been an active sponsor of al Qaeda frequently through his own banks. Al Rajhi Bank has been used by the MWL, IIRO and al Haramain to funnel funds to support terrorism. According to a 2003 CIA report: Al-Rajhi Bank: Conduit for Extremist Finance (S//NF)

150

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 152152 of 157 of 157

Islamic extremists have used Al-Rajhi Banking & Investment Corporation (ARABIC) since at least the mid-1990s as a conduit for terrorist transactions, probably because they find the bank’s vast network and adherence to Islamic principles both convenient and ideologically sound. Senior al-Rajhi family members have long supported Islamic extremists and probably know that terrorists use their bank. Reporting indicates that senior al-Rajhi family members control the bank’s most important decisions and that ARABIC’s principle [sic] managers answer directly to Suleiman. The al-Rajhis know they are under scrutiny and have moved to conceal their activities from financial regulatory authorities. 572.

NCB actively sponsored al Qaeda through Muwafaq, IIRO and SJRC. SJRC also

received valuable financial services from NCB which allowed the organization to provide direct financial and logistical support to al Qaeda for several years leading up to the 9/11 attack. 573.

In addition to maintaining the SJRC’s bank accounts, NCB actively promoted

those accounts on behalf of the organization. Advertisements running in multiple issues of the MWL Journal in 2000 and 2001 openly solicited funds and directed donors to SJRC accounts managed by the National Commercial Bank and Al Rajhi Banking & Investment Corporation. 574.

NCB opened two “shared accounts” with Al Rajhi Banking & Investment

Corporation (Special Joint account #22 and #33) for the IIRO as a member of the SJRC, thereby allowing the SJRC to serve as a conduit for funneling donations to al Qaeda fighters in Kosovo and Chechnya. RABITA TRUST 575.

Rabita Trust is a subsidiary body of the Muslim World League (“MWL”), with

headquarters in Lahore, Pakistan and offices throughout the world. 576.

Rabita Trust is an agency, instrumentality and organ of the Kingdom of Saudi

Arabia. The Kingdom controls and directs Rabita Trust operations, appoints and terminates Rabita Trust personnel, provides Rabita Trust with virtual all of its funding, determines how funds will be distributed throughout the world, and otherwise stringently controls Rabita Trust operations. In many countries, Rabita Trust conducts operations from the local Saudi embassy, under the supervision of the embassy’s Islamic Affairs Division. 151

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 153153 of 157 of 157

577.

As set forth previously, senior officials of the MWL have expressly

acknowledged that the MWL and its subsidiary bodies are agencies, instrumentalities and organs of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. 578.

Rabita Trust’s material sponsorship of al Qaeda has been facilitated by the direct

participation of senior at Qaeda officials in the management and operation of Rabita Trust. In fact, Rabita Trust was, for several years prior to September 11, 2001, headed by al Qaeda founding member Wa’el Hamza Jelaidan. 579.

In addition, Rabita Trust has shared common officers and directors with several

other charities operating within al Qaeda’s infrastructure, including the MWL and the SAAR Network of charities and businesses. Abdullah Omar Naseef served as a Chairman of Rabita Trust and as Secretary General of the MWL. Naseef is also an officer of Makkahl-Mukarramah, Inc., a Virginia based charity operating within the SAAR network. The Co-Chairman of the Board of Trustees of Rabita Trust, Abdullah al Obaid, also served as an officer of the MWL and Sanabel al Kheer organizations within the SAAR network. Al Obaid also serves as a senior executive of al Watania Poultry in Saudi Arabia, one of the many businesses owned by Suleiman Abdel Aziz al Rajhi, the founder of the SAAR Network, member of the Board of Directors of the IIRO, and CEO of al Rajhi Banking and Investment. Adnan Basha, a member of the Rabita Trust Board of Directors, is also the Secretary General of the International Islamic Relief Organization (“IIRO”). 580.

Given its pervasive and ongoing involvement in al Qaeda’s operations, and the

direct participation of senior al Qaeda officials in its management, the United States government designated Rabita Trust as a Specially Designated Global Terrorist on October 12, 2001 pursuant to Executive Order 13224. According to the U.S. Treasury Department: Rabita Trust is a Pakistani non-governmental organization (NGO) designated for its close ties to senior al Qaida leadership and for providing logistical and financial support to al Qaida. In February 2000, Wa’el Hamza Julaidan was appointed to the Board of Trustees of the Rabita Trust and served as its Director General.

152

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 154154 of 157 of 157

Julaidan was jointly designated on September 6th, 2002 by Saudi Arabia and by the United States under Executive Order 13224. XI.

THE HOUSE OF SAUD’S KNOWLEDGE CONCERNING ITS CHARITIES’ TERRORIST ACTIVITIES PRIOR TO 9/11 581.

Because the Saudi da’awa organizations were themselves alter-egos of the Saudi

government, their states of mind in knowingly and intentionally sponsoring al Qaeda is itself attributable to the government of the Kingdom. However, the facts and evidence fully establish that the pervasive sponsorship of al Qaeda’s global jihad by the Saudi government controlled da’awa organizations, as reflected by the facts and evidenced set forth above, was carried out with the full knowledge of the Saudi regime. 582.

As discussed previously, the House of Saud made a conscious decision to deploy

the Saudi da’awa infrastructure to support Islamist movements throughout the World in response to the demands of the Saudi Ulema, and was expressly aware when it did so of the longstanding ties between those organizations and the al Qaeda leadership. The Kingdom also knew, from the earliest date, of bin Laden’s organizational activities as the head of a global jihad organization, and the continuing involvement of bin Laden associates as officials of Saudi da’awa organizations. Moreover, by virtue of its own promotion of the Western Cultural Attack paradigm, the regime also understood that members of the Ulema appointed to direct the activities of the Saudi da’awa organizations shared al Qaeda’s belief that conducting jihad against the United States was a religious obligation. 583.

Although these facts render any claim that the Saudi government was unaware of

the terrorist activities of its da’awa organizations implausible, it is worth noting that the Kingdom received continuous warnings concerning their pervasive ties to al Qaeda, through media reports and engagements with other governments, as well as its own monitoring of those organizations. 584.

Indeed, from the early 1990’s through September 11, 2001, the involvement of

the Saudi da’awa organizations in terrorist plots and operations was the subject of intense media scrutiny and reporting. As the regime closely monitors all media reporting referencing its state

153

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 155155 of 157 of 157

controlled da’awa organizations, both through its embassies and via a media surveying program carried out by the Saudi Ministry of Foreign Affairs, this reporting was well known to the House of Saud. 585.

Furthermore, the international community repeatedly cautioned Saudi Arabia

about the imminent threat posed by the activities of its da’awa organizations during the years preceding the September 11th Attacks. For instance, during a 1994 meeting with senior officials of the Kingdom, French Interior Minister Charles Pasqua expressed the French government’s deep concerns regarding the pervasive involvement of the Saudi charities in the sponsorship and funding of terrorist organizations. Pasqua specifically mentioned the MWL during that meeting. At a conference of Arab interior ministers in 1998, the Egyptian Minister of Interior similarly expressed specific concerns about the involvement of Saudi charities in the sponsorship of terrorist activities to Saudi Prince Naif. In 1999 and 2000, senior delegations from the U.S. government met with senior officials of the Kingdom, to address the U.S. government’s concerns regarding the extensive involvement of Saudi charities in the sponsorship of terrorism. As the U.S. and Saudi governments had an intelligence sharing program concerning terrorism in place beginning in 1997, these concerns had no doubt been conveyed to the Saudis earlier. 586.

Despite these repeated warnings about the terrorist agenda being pursued by its

da’awa organizations in partnership with al Qaeda, the Kingdom continued to channel massive support to those organizations, in the hopes of directing the jihadist fervor of Saudi Arabia’s most radical elements at targets other than the House of Saud. This calculated decision by the Saudi regime fueled al Qaeda’s growth and development, culminating in the September 11th Attacks. 587.

Nearly a decade since those Attacks, the Saudi da’awa apparatus continues to

channel material support to al Qaeda and affiliated terrorists, and State Department officials have recently lamented that the United States has had little success in convincing the Saudi regime to treat the matter as a priority.

154

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 156156 of 157 of 157

Dated: February 3, 2015

Respectfully submitted, /s/ Stephen A. Cozen Stephen A. Cozen, Esq. Elliott R. Feldman, Esq. Sean P. Carter, Esq. Scott Tarbutton, Esq. COZEN O’CONNOR 1900 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 (215) 665-2000 Attorneys for Federal Insurance Plaintiffs Jodi W. Flowers, Esq. Robert T. Haefele, Esq. MOTLEY RICE LLC 28 Bridgeside Boulevard P. O. Box 1792 Mount Pleasant, SC 29465 (843) 216-9000 -andAndrea Bierstein, Esq. HANLY CONROY BIERSTEIN SHERIDAN FISHER & HAYES, LLP 112 Madison Avenue 7th Floor New York, NY 10016 (212) 784-6400 Attorneys for Burnett Plaintiffs and Euro Brokers Plaintiffs James P. Kreindler, Esq. Justin T. Green, Esq. Andrew J. Maloney III, Esq. KREINDLER & KREINDLER LLP 750 Third Avenue 32nd Floor New York, NY 10017 (212) 687-8181 Attorneys for Ashton Plaintiffs

155

Case Case 1:03-md-01570-GBD-FM 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document Document 741-1 2927-1 Filed Filed 03/17/17 02/03/15 Page Page 157157 of 157 of 157

Jerry S. Goldman, Esq. ANDERSON KILL, P.C. 1251 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10020 (212) 278-1000 Attorneys for O’Neill Plaintiffs Chris Leonardo, Esq. ADAMS HOLCOMB LLP 1875 Eye Street, NW Suite 810 Washington, DC 20006 (202) 580-8803 Attorneys for Cantor Fitzgerald Plaintiffs Robert M. Kaplan, Esq. FERBER CHAN ESSNER & COLLER, LLP 530 Fifth Avenue, 23rd Floor New York, NY 10036-5101 (212) 944-2200 Attorneys for Continental Casualty Plaintiffs

LEGAL\20631489\1 00000.0000.000/117430.000

156

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 1 of 18

Appendix 2A

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 2 of 18

     

 ̍Ŝ‫޼=ح‬ौʲłWौʳʤʥʺौ ×ƤКौŌē‫
>ܛچ‬ौ˯ҋ‫ݎ‬îौ̎ɾौ×?6Лࠎौ ˩QМϳ;vौ‫ڒ‬ҟौÐҁࣉBौ ‫֝؃ࡓخ‬Ɔ‫د‬ΕНौ ͆£Ĝ4֥,ɿौÑ˓ौ ʴŀʿʾौ ˨͊‫ۮ‬ौˢ֬‫ۯړ‬ौ̴ौ͋‫˄ࠏ͌ذ‬ौ ˑौम ȶौ‫ڔׇ‬एĹौࡧLौӕ[޶ौ‫ܮ‬Ėǧ‫ޔ‬ौǦҠौĦ4Lौ̜!ौ˷‫֭࣪ڈ‬ौ֢ȴौࡨОौҜПٍ࣑ौ‫ڳ‬ौÖ÷ģ
؈âˆÄौʩʪौ

(vCv_n<-kvȵौgvDf87/Ev=AoF*lv%Uvc:vVs+t
v v4R2v ҡǦ޻͢‫ܬ‬ौࢺौ©i‫ݨ‬ौ݉РØ߇‡ौN#vࠝԋƇौ‫ۄ‬ȷ¦؄Ζौ<ñǰǬ‫ޕ‬ौ߶ौUŤȝौѺ‫߈ޖ‬ौ͹ौ۰ѸÁ‫߉ݩ‬ौΥ‫ر‬ौ΁ौ ŜΫС‫ܜ‬ȞѨʀौ

˲͍ऍǖƟौΌ҂ौC‫ݐ‬अ̦ѻпſौࠐ‫ڕ‬ौĊњϴौࡩĆߊौͽ#ۚ,Wौ€ԫΧؒ‫ܝ‬Bौ֣आƈࠇӸiȡՃ ‫ز‬ौĊiߋࠑौऩˆŦ۱ɢौ ऐƈौ͎‫©܃‬ौŸ¼Ԭࣕѩौࢻौu]K'vԭ’ौ࢙ौϫ‫ރ‬Ƈ6Ĥौ˜ٌÿEқौࢼौ‹ѿCौߌϬǸТौ֡¼L,_¤ࢵ,ौ‫ږ‬ƚौ 1v‫ܯ‬Ηǧǐ‘҃ϵ͏࢛Ǩ‫ډ‬ौ ‫س׉‬ौӦ‫ޗ‬ƥ‫ܞ‬έौÀøौ"Ԃ͐"ौӱtqʁौघौ¢ܰौतưsþौࢽौࡪУौ̧֖݊
ࠒौ͑‫ش‬žौ ԧſߍौ‫ڗ‬Ңौ϶
C£޴࣐ौ͒‫ص‬ƁौÚþр[υðȒौiΓऄौĖ‫ޚژ‬AौңौUФौ̏‫ڙ‬Ԯ‫ض‬ȟʂौÓǖۧ࣫ԯ޽ɖߎौ ۲‡ό‫ط?ب‬8Şࢠ‫’ښ‬ĝौȢԃŝࠓौ؉Şपौ;©ौ ҤौCŧ‫׾ޘ‬ŝ۳ौϛΘ?‫ݰ‬ौࢾौȯ«؊ʃौ ̡࣬۴ौӖ‫ތ‬7ौ۵«Ÿ‘1"֧OौΦdžBߏौù‫ڛ‬EौХĝࡋŭ·ԹߐN؋îsࠜौPvØौʼnԽ݈ौēҥौŒşࢸ͓Bौ ˸‫ࡔظ‬ċqԿơMǗήĺौǩ۶ौ̢̝Ŏɣौजǩौŏ[ौŠИ´ģՁǨOौࠔ‫ڜ‬ौͿñԾǗ°ौ࡫Mौ̨ܷĞ´8MࡊĞौ‫ۅ‬QՀ,φ‫͔ۆ‬Bौ԰sࡕ‫֟ד‬ौ ͱऎ۷ौɕԄ͵qौƦ¤इƉौ࡬ौ&56v‫ܟ‬ǘӲЦौÁƛौ1͕‫أ
ٵ‬sࠕĻौŭIJϷӳ
ࡑौi‫ع‬8ौĖґ‫
ڼ‬qौ \SQ`$;bvG vࢿौ= 3vhv v¶ࡖ،ƟЧ‫غ‬ίौL>?pH,mvOTYev avv)[Jdv झ‫·ڝ‬Ɗ˅ौ ̵ौNL‫׊‬DZौ‫ۇ‬ȋ1tࡗौ¦tȠԅौğ"‫ځݸ‬ौШ͖èƍ‫ލ‬ԆԱ‫ۈ‬ौ;ҦौȞƤlौO࢜Qौ˹‫ࡘػ‬B·AƠŮौŅǪ‫ج؍‬,ֶौ 
ͲҐԇՂCौ͡Ǜ8ौisौѹѡˆौ˔~ŃʄौUƊौ̒&Oȡौh,ۨœԲ޾ौť؆ौ۸MŹ؎‫ٸؤ‬Ѫौ࡭ͺौ˝ÿ‫݌‬ौ ‫ۉ‬Q‫ۂ‬ƀЩौ_Ԉ͗ࠖौ࡮ЪौˣÕ~ौO;ࠗौߑԳǑ࣭‫ߟ̥?ࡐ׋‬؇ौߒƋ޹Lौ͸ौƀ#RЫϦǸौ‫ڴ‬ौȯЬौŅ̌ौ‫ڞ‬ÄौͷफौǪࡸˆ۹ौ ͠ԁOϱľौ ‫ؼ׌‬ौϐ‫֗ߓي‬Э‫ݟ‬ौ࡯Դߔौ‫܄‬ѣ‫ة‬Ɨϸ࢝͘‫ؽڟ‬ĽौȠԌЮौžt‫ؾ‬Ӵܱ߼ौख‫̓ט‬ौΰެ´O‫׍‬HɤौङौΏ&ȿЯļौ ΋‫ؿ‬аӞौҧ‫ހ‬ौ‫ݵ؀‬°ौ‫ڵ‬ौऻijQɼऌҝߕौŠâ‫ࣲڠ‬ĦौĤԉбौߖࣇ҄°Ë
Ե‫ڂ‬ौÁƛौࡰïौȋвौÁƜौԨϹौΙҨौࡱгौ ‫ـ׎‬ȢѾ̣ơ‡’Λ©ौ˕ ؏࣮ؐ’Y࣠ʅौ ˈौIq@XvM"viv<ƌύؓƌ‫ف‬Ϻš࢞ǫ‫ߗق‬ौ࠘Ƨš‫׏‬ौӟ‫ה‬+‫ۃ‬ौ͙ϻЙ߽ौǰ‫ݷ‬Dz‫ھ‬ѫौࡒ‫׈‬ौ‫ڶ‬ौࠞƨдौ ÑƲǺеϩǹौ‫ڷ‬ौ̞Ţࢹ͚Bौ˺‫_ك‬ð¸ċԺ°ªǙαɥौ΀IJȟौͣौjvܲӠ‫ݪ‬ौट‫ו‬ौW!r-Zvߠࣝϼबौ͛‫ل‬ϽौϾBԻ΍‫ܠ‬Ȥ֨ĐĽौ ӡ‫܁‬ौࡲжौÓ¼ѬԶÙ"ðौӧࣜܳौȰtȒौӨްMvौܴώؑ҅Ͽţ࢟;‫ڊ‬ौ¤ܵौЀԷ‫ۺ‬Ѧौࣀौ-ԍ«ौˤԸ݇‫ۻ‬ौēƚौ ņM\࣎ौÔĤ
B‫ז‬Լþс,βौÚߘौࡳ?ौC‫ۼ‬ƋߞM‫"م‬ौߙ࠙ŤࠚœࣆौāƍͳौúौÌlौ˻,ģз¸ӵL[δौ˖;1‘࣯OƱ࣡ʆौ ́‫ڡ‬ौ̐;Ʋً`ौॊ‫ࣰ֮۩ن‬ौ®‫هڿ‬ЁौÌţĥौDZ‫ݑ‬QौࣁौŔнDzࡣâо‫۽‬ौʫʬौ ‫۾‡ڀ‬ौįXौŚʇŔʈौ˰‫ہ‬L‫ݶ‬ौ ͜ߚौťौ͈Ǭ‫א‬Ɖौ‫ڇ‬vौࡴиौ~ࠛïċ&Ӷï,γौň¼œ,ַौƧÚ8ौ ौŹǐ‫ۊ‬QйԊ
,ߛֺMौΚtȸǘȣñ‫ޙ‬Ǝ‫ݠއ‬ौ ࠉࡡʉौ ̤‫ٿ‬ौ‫ڸ‬ौ‫ۿࣱڣ‬ौ݅‘r«Ђͼ‫ڋ‬ौŲ·qߜौк‫و‬ौࡵлौ̟͝ࡦ’͞ौ̯Ҟ޶ौ˗‫בٷœڢ‬ɦौ̑,ौ Ϗ‫־‬ȹǚЃ֦ौठࡶौ‫ˆ׃‬ɉौʹªçौØǙƁौЄª‫ޛ͟ۋ‬ª6ȣौ‹LЅߝɧौࣂौCQ÷ǹмौࠍςौŦौࠊ࡙ӷभौҩ;‫܂‬ौ`ԥौ ̩ܶȐ֘҆Ȥɗȑौŧ‫ނۍی‬ş‫ח‬ʊौ ͂‡ौ‫܀‬ѥ‘?‫ى‬ƂŨĦ֫ौࠆƎौࡷŨ-ौʰ?ौࠋࡢौȑԩœ‫ג‬ƂौΎौ




  

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 3 of 18

ŗƩौ˳  ‫΂ܡ‬LJौ˱Ҍ‫܅‬ौ̔ʋौ̶­2ौ ̕đ ޿ौʵłʌौʶʧʻौ ̪ӹʷौ Ɍƣ‫ګ‬ɀ
‫ݱ‬1
ࠟौ3&(
ˇौ Ddz࠰ɉौ> ࠳²ौुԪؔौ“Іौ΃ěÞ ɨɍौͤ ौՄ=
ौɐıौ܏ 3oौȪƓ‫ݛވ‬ौ ȩn<¬Ý`ौۢGléौ¦यौİ
ौP‫ݹ‬ƹҪ‫ܢ‬2Յ ौuҫौऑћǵ½ߡौ Ҭौ' ]ौЇƘ2޷*ࢷौ ‫ٹ‬ौũ߫߹ã#—¬ìौ !Ѣ‫ںי‬A
]ʍूौ ׳
ौ݆ؕ
¾ Ü࠭Նौ ׄFौTԎ ौȲ&ौȫęࠠ
fौҼ
َࢴौ(ौө‫ם‬रौ

ौࡹ
ौ ࠡ
‫ࠬמ‬Əεौ ौɄ
Lj+ौͧ–ौҭǫÆ
֞\ौ۞+՞çɩौт‫ڤܚ‬Շ*Íौ B.90^v١Ѝौ5 ऒौXûĔ‫ܩ‬X‫ڍ‬ौXºу‫ُ࣒
ؖ‬ौ ࡺ2ौ RóौɎ‫ݢ‬ौࣃौौ†PȈ²”F#Ɂ
ौ΄
•‫ݒ‬ौŠ‫ڥ‬ėौȓࣳΜ
Sौµ”ौ"/
ौगौ  ƶFौȥ
‫ݓމ‬ौĿʣौ ̷ԏ
ौ˥$ÅѧÅौ;ҿौ}w ौ˼[
Č՟Ƣò*
ɘGौӪ‫ן‬ौ• ‫ޜ‬µãիPÛ࠮AौµौȱՈߢौऊ
ȃौD‫ ܆‬πौ3‫ؗ‬ौ>
ौ ƘSࢡWौ Sौ3ՠ5ौȦԐ
ौҟɚौ
e
‫ך‬P1
6cौ¯ौ bā
ौq—
¹ҽ$
*ौŸ16ֲķौ §P
ौҮौ ࡻ
ौӫौ]࣊ħlशʎौ ̸ĂƐौ̖ ƷĨौ˽۪=Չ߀ौȇ†ǒǔ½
êौࡼ 2ौÈă
ौ˾
5+ƺ“ŵौ˞ֹȔौ ‫ࠢ ە‬ौ úौȲ
ौe¬‫ܣ‬ौ࠵wÛaऱौՊ§+ࣴ
ौ ौ 1΅¬ौ үौ&ǵޭ٢"ौ$
']ɪौͶौࡽ
ौ
eº‫ࠣ
ێ‬ौ øौN'Þौߣ Ĵοौb ौۛ
࣋-
ौ࡚ę ‫ݔ‬yौ ‫!ڃ܇‬lj‫¾ڦ‬ौ Јौ ¾ࣟ‫ݤ‬ʏौ ¡ ौP‫ݺ‬eՋ
ौ ौȱ
ौgӼ‫܈‬ƙGौ ौ˪Ϯc&ɀ
ौ˒ȃ*ԑौ۟‫נ‬աç ĉ
‫ގ‬ौƳyX5բ
\*
ौ
ࠈ࠱
Sौ‫ڽ‬ौࡤ‫ݜ‬ɫौࡾ
ौ̛o‫ڎ‬ौ˿ۭ$߁ौNĝौĘ
Ż‫
إ‬ƃौ
ࠅ>֯Ă
\ȧौÂǜौࡿ
ौ Õ ࢬĒÜौ~Ȩdž+գ
*ौg ࣵůդ‫ס‬ौҰौTԦौ̰̚#ȫեौǭûौŒࢢ 0ौ̀[˜
+‫ע‬զ
…ौœӓƒ
ौ® Ęौ ̹
‫ݕ ބ‬ȖÎौ Ř/ौϑ'
 ࢣِौӺ
ࠌौ 2ƭÝौÈ/
ौ‫
ۏ‬R߷”ौԒ‫ڧ‬ƃƴƢौÈ/լFौ‫ ې‬Ƶࢤ ौ5߸ौ

SµyौÈԓ
ौࠤb55
‚
ौÐ ՌलौՍौ ई‫כ‬Poौ ौDěӽw ौұ‫ڨ‬Rौࠥ< ȩ
ƣՎΝौÝf–$ʐौ ː࠴ƫRौƔΞ ' ࢫौ ܸȕߴौĄ
ौّ ौҲ ‫܉‬ौņ 
ौ ौࢀ
ौ Ń8Տƶ]࣌2& ौ‫ڬ‬ौ‫ڌ‬Ⱥܹौ
उLj•
ौड#[ौȰौ˦ò• ‫˜
'ޝ‬ौ Ɲौ˴
0Û ौŕџ&ࣤौ ûौ

ْौфӒ
Ϡ&Ɂ
ौ ¸ेĠ *Xौbw‫ݖݻ‬ौŏٓ¯Â‫ࢥ ݫ‬ौҾ=&ǭौŵǝ࡛‫܊‬ʑौ –ौƄĩ
éौ>Ɋौš²
ौ ō 1
 ौŕ
ϭ‫࣢ݗ‬ौˉϡौ ¯ौʸʦŀŁʒौ ̽ăौGŴ߾ौuҳौȳŪĪौҴ=]Րौ§
Ēz
ौ3ƻ»ौ
P
68ĹौÞौ࢚ौ 
†''‫" ٺ‬A ½ौĞࡎ"Ғɬौ ौś
ौŰ
‫ܙ‬ौɟȻौ ” ौࢦ
ळौ άौȵौ ººौźȪ
‫ݘފ
ޞ‬Sि љ—Ə ौ́
»է
*
ौ$Ӭ‫ר"ا‬Íौ&*ljȷ Ցौĸ‫ܤ‬ɄɜौȹD۠‫ޟ‬ՒٔौêĪͥौ ौĒ

Ѯɏौ ͉Ǯȼ‫܋‬ौ*ࢧÂौ ! ौđÅ
ौü=nj»ौϜ•
ǻ ࢶǞौΐࣞ­Ɨौ/ौƑٕࢨǼ
ौÔ‫ڑ‬nj‫ף‬ćӻ
ǞζौŇ‫”=ؘڪ‬ƷzķौɠoŰ0Ĵì#ɭौ;ҵौ ϒ=Ǽߪƒʓौࠦ/ौŇhÏɡौ Љौ‫؁‬ौÒ÷ũ‫‰'ޢ‬ȧौuƜौŌ­‫  ק‬ौ̳<&Ȩķौओըौ>
ौӭٖЊ
˜ ौࣄौࢁ
ौ ߤȺŴ]Ȕौuüौ™4ՓSौeՔȮNJौ<Ɣü‫ݬک‬ʔौ ͇
ौ dz‫ۑ‬ij ौį
ौ̫
ćé
‫ڏ‬əौ ĔVůX1mcौ Ҷौࢂौ
Ȯ>¹ՕSƩࠧौ ҷौ ौ3ौ̺‫—ݙދ‬ौ̻/R
¢˜ौ~bx¢ࢩ ौ}ٗcɮौ3ƪՖΟԔौ3‰ौ٘ë
‫ޏ‬c  ौ3#‫פ‬ौΆौ Nj äĨѯौĴ
ÄौĥƪौÒ՗ǺȦÂRौ Ɲौ˛™ ौ̂ٙ"55թ
ٚ§ƒʕौ ŗĂौA'ۡޮ½࠯ौƒԤǍ
ٛĀ­ɯौचौ¦lNJƸ
ĵÍौ ¸ौĪौ ǻ
ौ—Ƭ
ौӮ»Ǎौ ٜ ौƫ ‫ݭ‬՘ौ֠D
1
y¢A ौ ¯ौΔÌौ™³
ौ$¾ýȊÜp“ौӯߥՙौ RҏƵė
šौ Ҹौšă
ौ˵ '
 ٝ ौ̱Ѡ‫ݣ‬ौˎौ ौࢃ
ौŶ࡜ėौࢄŪ!ौ™Ƭ
ौ̬‫݋‬Ƴ
Ĩौ 66Ǯࣶk8ʖौ ̼ԕौÄ
ϓ'‫ئ‬6ë cƻuGौ$ϊ
ौͦौʭʮȕTौ ҹौ՚ƺӗΨ"ौ‫
܌‬ӢȊߦौࢅ 2ौ˜Ԗ
ौŎ\bò¶$
ٞηौ }Ĕ1$ࣖ
ғौ·х‫ץ‬#e
ौ ܺौƙ
ȥ$5ौҺ ौߧࣈ҇ࢆ
՛ौn
ौ˫ń+ĸौ '
ߨࢪäौA\࡝¹$҈Π
ौ ŲD Έժ‫ֱצ‬fʗौ 5ौѼ ‫ܭ‬ौࠨौ"ƦҔ
ौã‫„ݡ‬¹ऴौ\ѷѭौ<
һ‫ڄ‬GʘौÌौ̗ ´2ौ̃۫Ȼ՜߂ौԗFौ 
Ż''6ë
8ौı ौÐȇ–Fौ/ij ौ ćܻ*cौࢇौś
ौԘ ौúौࠩƭ
ौ‫ל‬ٟ࠲ČĀƓkौŸǒȼ#ࣣɰौ 2
࢈
ौ3ƹ24ौࠪ/
ौˊࣗ‫
ݲ‬वौŊ
ę ौ‫ٻ‬ौ"ԙ
ौÖϞࡌ߃ौƞौōǓ
 ौÖ
ä‫ࠫݚ‬ɊɱौȖā=+Ƅौ x
‫ے‬u‫ޠ‬ौa ौ} ٠Ā<
߿ौ 6ौįƐौˬń¶ɛFौ‫ۓ‬ȌȈF–ʙौ řĄौƑ‫ޡ ۔‬ौȓԚ‫׿ۀ‬ौ՝đЋࣷ ौɋ"Ԝौۜƒ֙ƒौ ц‫܍‬ौ$ौ3ԛ$*/ौ ौl3ौЌ ǔ
GTխΡौ̄™
+Ƽчθौߩ
޺֕ौϝ8ौΑौшࡍ>܎ͨFĄìौ&ौ`/
ौŚƸ2 ौ

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 4 of 18

řn
ौ˶ǟȄjNj
ौŋҍǽ
ौőʚौ̾
٣щ࠶ौ őࣸ߄ौʹ˂WौŁʨʼौ 


Ŗ࠷É ɲौ xƖpा֔ौࢉ
ौ
Ѱौ࠸ौ
9kौ%Iࢭ٤£ौ ϯ‫ࣥݝ‬ौɅ9և0ौӀࣹषौ‫࠹ݼ‬ϧौŮּ֒+ौ ZΉöުծъ^ʛɑौ ¡ąыौg‫))ڰ‬Yࣚҕौ?धǴ‫ݍ‬ѱौĬą#ǾौġÉÇ٥ौżऋ‫׽‬sौࢊ7ौɔ_‹ौ0d‫@ؙ‬ιौ g =DŽࡇऺɞ߬ौHьĜौwĎZौ:࣓ौƠ‫ܐ‬ќ_Җ࠺ौEэߺ.Ȇ‰ˆौ ̓सौǿϚĎǑ%Ўौ࠻/ͩĩौࢋौԝ ौ ŠौaƮौ࠼
‫ٶ‬ौ˘r.կࣦौृ 9. ौܼ۬հܑौࢌßĭौѝ .ܽ߭ौjौ̅
)ࡠौࣅौܾI›Hौ ٦nǤκौࢍ
ौ‫ܒ‬ϟֵ҉Ȭौà(ौ Ķ0Ǵ)
%{ौŠौौढwĉӣ‫ܪ‬ौकDž࠽9ौ y4ौձ٧Įֈ
å
ौĠ‫^ײׅ‬ौū ौ
ɈD‫ޣ‬#ĢmौmK
(ौƞĕौV΢ρौղौϔIJ›‫ࠃݧކޤ‬ौӔ޵ʜॄौ ̲
ĵ‫ܥ‬ौ‫ޥ‬ƽΣ.‫ש‬ौЏ:^ौͪܿौ
7ौӁ‫޳ڱ‬ौŽौ!N
ौ݀źrKĭ֪ʝौ œ%ौƾ ौࢎūÊौ̆¿{Ǐ$űौň)ZࣧौIҊχҗौ Ư ȶ‫ ת‬ौ ?ɈŬǛ ौ(ौ )CȍɂौżV{mަ‫ޅ‬EZrौ֤࣍&ɳौpϋV ǁौ¥j VࡉौŐý‫ݮ‬bĕौ4‫ݞ‬ौ ‫ت‬ǡौ|ौӂǯȆ

›ौͫ ौǥ!
‫״׳‬kौ‫۝‬Ȝĺौ-9ौȽ
ौӑौħƨौ˭Ȁѽौ `m#λौ Ŗȏ։č‫׵‬kौˋϢɴौKौɆßd‚N‫׶‬# ࢮ%Ŀौ ̈́ƕौEƖ‫
ء‬Аdǃौƿψ.(ौ zġौ_ौճ Eȿौ  -Ҁ0Yŷौ˟).ִHौ±@ौ„j$:ࢯȐौ ौ-³
ौࣺ!DžֽT#٨ौӃौUौ߮‫ ׆‬ौ¿Kौ द
:юJôौӄौx
ࢰíौÃȎ
ौ ‫׫‬ौ„߯ौǝौU
ौh%-
čƼ±
J
ौg)Ďࣻ%#`fौȴौɒ٩nÙμौ vяű޸ֳ
"ौӅौौ‫ آ‬Ȁ
ौİ#ų0Hौ% ौϰ!ȾȅHौ ƿĶƕȎ
ौण‫ܫ‬Îॅौ ˌौù.‫<ޱ‬ौ
‫ޓ‬٪¿ौEѤ¨¥ࡈ֓Ǡौ‫
^ށ‬Wौմ%ौÃާɵौÊԞIȭौgǟȉ ौ٫ϣौ ǀ š֊٬Ļौ)‫(
ڲ‬ौौËौ‫ݥ(׼‬ौŋĊ¨|ī‫ܓ‬ɽ̠յJԟ0 ौÑޫďĐzौӆौʼnŠ

ौ ̮Ҏ‫ݏ‬ÙŽऽࢱ‫ڭ‬ौˍåȝौӇौʯ ˃ˁˀɶौĬौ‹
ौ̇ -Ĉौ࢏ौ†‫٭‬ŶÊौøौैֿնÉ ɓौȳȍV@nࣼ7ौTNौ Óȭ‫׷‬Ӿŷौžǯ‫ؚ‬Ⱦշࣨौǡ ौࣽ݁ौaƥ࠾ौǀa ौ†ۙÀ%ÉĜौɅYौɇ‫ݦ‬ौ)v
ौæ Hौ!@ѐİ‫ܔ‬ौ !ԣौŒá ौΊ

ौ࢐
ौ„ȗ
Îौ ŘԠ
ौǓƆJ²£‫ ְٮ‬ौK‰"֚õƅौ$ौU
ौĘ
ϕǕǥ(7Ćौոæ‫(ࣾ׬‬ौ ࣿσौ࢑չ@ ौIșौ‫׀‬պ࠿ौࡀÀ‫ސ‬ौӈĚौ‫
‚
׸
ࡁ׭‬ौ“ƅौͬऔौõӉȂæё‫ٯ‬dौ
ĚȜǢ+ौ ौɆó؅ौIğौ ջ…!ֻ
țौý‫ܕ‬ौׁ AĭौȏYνौy4ÇV@Ʈ ऀ-ौ-Œौhٰ›Č0֋ӿǚ…ौ}.Yࣩʞौ ̈ौ(ɂ
0ռԀौ ǁБ
߰Wौˠȉࠀौɇ.Вौ€Ǣ ‰ӛ7ौӥ‫؛‬ौ!‹
ौˏďս‫ٱ‬վ !Ȅࢲɝ ौ _ZLJѲौ D‫^ۥݽ‬ľौ ̿4
ौ̘‫ڻ‬-ौ̉ǜǷVp߅ौ֐í
-#Ӝ ौ Ƀ‫׮ܦ‬ौ:)Ƕޯ!ौjׂ
ϨɃҘौϖƒ
‫ݳ‬տौГáࠂYӘ(ौ ǂǣӊ‫ͻڅ‬ɷौŐJK:ौनCíĈ‫@ٲ‬ौΪҙ ौjfौӋѳ‫ܧ‬ौJ: ौ ःī ր ौ࢒ौ̊¿ĩ‫׺׹‬Zåौ ž ‫ँ)؜‬%ց!fʟौ>fौġī࡟ौ ौ„ौUxƾ!oїGɸौͭ‫ټ‬ौ€हौ࢓óौÏr
ǽ:ų“ौ‫€ۦ‬ւJौ ̀ौ Ëփौ
 ɹौछौ ϗďrДѴौĬNĮौʌौ˧քÆJTौ‫ڮ‬ӌौ˙{Æà‫ׯ‬ौ̋‫֌׻
ڐ‬ђkɺौǃौϘĠ.ǎࡏ{֍ौ|pࡂ³ौ74
ौ9ў(ȘौӍौ ĉ
Hौϙ‫؝‬ǠࣔौŠौ"4ौhdĆ@
%…ौˡǤָɻौŽ%‚.Kօौĥ9
ौÏࣘ‫ݴ‬HौŊ‫ ܨ‬+ļौĢԡȸ(ौ ȁިौࡃौ"9
ौÔ!čƱ±ξौž;‫؞‬Ǖֆࣙôô ौ%ौॆÃěۣGͯǎ ौӤ‫ܖ‬ौàौ%ö|ौ¨ौ‫ث‬ȁौvö֎߱ࢳ‚ौ ۖ<‫گ‬τौࡄ ौ࢔ौDDž ߵौKौ߲࣏ϪmȚौʱ7ौ9eौĶ‫؟‬ѵौ࢕
ौ  ֑Tpौ‫ڹ‬ौ Ģodǂĵौ‫ٽ‬ौЕIࠁǏӝ ौĈ‫ٳ‬ӎ‫ݯ‬d֏ʠॉौ ¡ą
ौ݂Ƕީौ 4.¨ौI0߻ौЖ Ǿ ȘौɋۗÇ^¥^ौ!ĕौ ÃȌa
Ϥौ@ưࠄौË
ौ
ौ®ौ‫
؂‬ौωŬ ֛ῼौۘ‫
ݿ‬ȗ ौ ौौ 9:
Зौ!ौ‫ݾ‬a
ϥौϲौș
ࡥी :7
x ࡆʢौोौ ¡ƯौŸ݃ ौ ौ࢖
ौÕĮZ%ौ ौौञ
ौ|ƽौ€
ौȅ࡞Ӱ‫װ‬ौùĚौ़ȽÅौࣛõ{Žौ‫پ‬ौ ‫ۤ
ܗ‬ğ
ौ
ࢗ߳ѓौͮèौ࢘іǿौzࡅє‫ޑ‬ौƴèѕǣħ֜ѶौDŽौzŒौΤ‫ޒ‬ौ®ौı
ौ̙ӏौКौhǷंŽ߆ʡौ ˮ޲
‫ܘ‬Wौ|ौáȂौŽә
7ौU¥`ौ-Œ
ौ˚%±EҚȚौथ‫ױ‬ौΒ
ӚȬौӐÆÀ)ौ7Ԣ
Eौ݄Ž)‫ٴؠ‬êߛ֩țौ

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 5 of 18

̋੝ʁߊܴࡣϝ‫ۂ‬ѿ੝ɷԱࡷҀ੝ʞ੝˴ҁܵÍࣸ੝ ʟ£ܶধ£ࢡ੝ǻȜŻ੝Ǽǥȋ੝

̭Ͱÿј ʽौ


 


ࣹ‫ࣺ̟י‬੝ਯন੝5‫ँםڛ‬੝‫ך‬ϛ҂੝֖੝‫ۃ‬Ê֡‫ۈࢥ؜‬¤খË੝߄ࠬ੝̠ыĄ‫ܷ؝‬ýĴंŨ̍৯҃੝̡щܸ੝ঙ੝ʘࠉࢌৰ҄੝ः‫҅מ‬੝ ˆ¤কċŭࢦ੝ о঩߁Ґ࢞੝ЉKࠊKϡ‫ۄإ‬੕‫؞‬Ոƫ੝

 




ɂϞ੝ɸࡤؕ੝ H‫࠭؟̢כ‬5KkF੝¡ґĊ̣ॢ੝ʠĊࣻ҆̎‫҈·ܹ҇_ئ‬੝ Ɍ5‫ڲۿ‬Ëʌ੝Ǩ ǏȔ ɍ߅݉_࠮҉ࣲ੝




 

œ‫̥ܺࢅؠ̤ל‬ż੝ɿ߆পijÌ੝ܻࣼÌ‫ۇ‬۶_ғkЈҊ੝

  
ǩ ǐȕ  Ǫ੝
# Hܼ֢ࡴ࣫ࢧ੝


  ̛‫أ‬ж੝ɜ‫̨݂޹ؤ‬ſ੝ ¡Ïċ̩ࣾҎ੝ý݃ढ़݇‫֧ۆ‬ҏ݄з੝  ɐĄ5‫۾‬ƀ੝ǭǒȗ Hē݅֨࡭ࢭĴ੝

ɥ݆м߉ࢪব࡮Ȩ੝ Ȯࢫ੝ࢬࣿ¥ऀ[ь੝




  



˔‫֣ہ‬੝ʼ‫߇ܽء‬ĩ‫ڴ‬੝ʽÍ‫܀‬ϟҋ࠯Ž੝ ʀফ࣬੝ ‫֤ࢄ[ܾࣽۅ‬Î݈е੝Ɏ߈‫ڳ܂܁‬ÏҒž੝ ǫ ǑȖ
 œĒ֥ܿ࡯ijࢨ੝ ̦݀¿੝ʾԣϠҌ࠰੝Ք੝փ੝੐̧ࢩ੝ʿ‫آ‬kēࡸত੝ ʱ[¥¿ҍĩŹƬ੝ Ǭ–ș ɏĒ֦݁࠱Îࣳ੝

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 6 of 18

໳䞊 ໛௏ຐྫྷ䞊 ั㎮ɫ䞊 чϡ‫ڳ‬Ƞ

2
2%"'*+2 2,-.!

2) 12$02  

Hb?Uv¢Vh…›n‹¢IWwc¢ @¢ ‘ƒ#KPB<$X%¢d˜
”S¢R¡xŒ¢x™¢Ÿ ž¢&t¢ ':dk8¢Y"¢ y)i¢xœ–,¢„(jjdlCoz¢{|Jr¢d;¢ p(f})T*j¢  ¢  •¢


 


†q¢r+Z~)¢s)L,¢d’–[A D„x,,¢d\¢Žx-M‡=.]/¢ 




ˆt¢dšu0¢g9mG‰EZ1^~¢t2N3 x¢ e“Š—€45¢d_¢ ”`‚6OQF> a!7¢ ྪ๏౪ௌྫಒ்໛䞊၈ೌྭಓ䞊 ਲ਼ஔகшྮ⬮Ϣา㟅Ĭන䞊ျ್௎၉໳䞊


/(2 2

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 7 of 18

˖ɋպҢң࠼ ʁˍĖԾ˙ƺҶ[ɷʜˈʎƔ࠼ɳʓ ɢ̉ˠ ªˎƂ࠼Ṳ̌DžƏɴ࠼ [ɔ˞ʛ̠̓˿ʭ̔ʦ࠼˚ɹʏɌǙɵʹˉ©࠼ ɣʌ˛˴ɍʮ [࠼

ɺ˅®ʔ˵ʝ̕ɻ࠼ˆ¥˶ջˏˇ¥ʸ࠼ˡɼɤ²˜ʰDŽ̝̀࠼ ˂Ɏ˷˸ɽ˝®࠼

ȑǠ࠼ʂԋ‫އ‬G'ǝҸȟ࠼ ̖õ'0k࠼‫ݚ࠼ם‬úЃ࠼̊‫س‬#Ίό࠼ˢRͨŽۤƕ࠼‫ֽشۥ‬Є࠼~í࠼ӘЅ࠼ˣІ‫ڀ‬Ї‫ͮ־‬Ј‫࠼ڗ‬Ǩ ǩ ࠼ͯի‫מ‬Ëխf ‫ߛ࠼ۦ‬ЉľØ࠼‫࠼ן‬ ΋‫ص‬ġ‫נ‬Όռ࠼ƃƆԌܹͰƖ࠼̥ h࠼‫ܺژ‬ÄãԍŬЊ‫ݢ‬ė࠼ۧ‫ڙ}ڂځވ‬#࠼‫ߜ‡ۨŠ_࠼ښض‬gЋ࠼Ҩ‫ֿ"ۀ‬T࠼!ύԎŭF‫̦މ‬/ˆ࠼ߝә‫ͱ࠼̧߽׀࠼ط‬Ќ࠼Å‫“ظ‬Ø΍Æ‫ ࠼֟ݣ‬Ǫǡ࠼ ӚЍ࠼ˤȣԶ$ώ࠼ʐ‫߀ع‬Ў ! ‫ס‬Œ࠼˹ӛЏ࠼۩࠼‫ފ‬íIJ‫ڛ‬ĝͩŒ"‫ע‬Ɨ࠼ǫǬĿ̨‫࠼߾ף‬ҘĬ࠼ʃǘʕ࠼ࠩĬ‫ ދ‬ÇА۪Ƙ࠼ùȠ‫࠼ތ࠼פ‬БȒࠪǭ࠼ŔŰĭ࠼ ‫غ‬ҙ࠼֖ü‫ލ‬ņk࠼Ă{Ϗ߁F‫]ގ‬Ň࠼ߞm‚В࠼̩֌ΎðࠫŚ࠼Ͳ߿࠼ň‫ׁػ‬Ù࠼ǮǢ࠼ͳ ࠼ ̪‫ޏ‬ԏ࠼‫ץ‬Г/ҹД1ΏЕ࠼ĶŹֻÈЖ…‫ސ˺࠼ܙ‬З࠼ʧ‫צؼ‬œ࠼ «ؐ‫ڑ‬Ũ ࠀƇʼn࠼‫ڜ‬Hƙࠥ'Иߟ࠼ΐ‫ؽ‬ĢŸԱĿׂΑϐ࠼ӜĤ7࠼öЙ࠼ıܻΒ/ĖñΓ‫ק‬CΔ࠼ɥ‫׃ؾ‬:‫࠼~̫۫࠼ࠁޑ‬/ś‫ש࠼۬ר‬ҦĴ‫ܼ̬ׄڝ‬Ԑ‫ؿ‬ģƚ࠼‫ޒ‬Éӝ࠼‫ـ‬Қ࠼ ̡ƛࠡʹŸΕӞ࠼x̭֚‹࠼ࠂ7࠼Ŝ"࠼͵Ú࠼ۡφ‫ڃޅ‬Ú‫ޓ‬ϑÙ‫֎ ߂࠼ࠃ֍ޔ‬ԲÆÐƜ࠼YYȂϒZ¡V¤‫ת‬ս1ð࠼ӟ?7࠼̮χǯ߃Գ֏ǰ_DZʼn࠼͈‫ܕ‬ŊĮΖվ̯* ܽտ࠼´֐’ּ࠼‫׫‬Η࠼ ˥‫׬‬ϓԑ࠼ʑĮ߄К ‫ ࠼ ࠼׭‬ʥä࠼²‫ ف‬-ϔ࠼¯‫¶ׅ ࠼‰ܾ׮‬Ų࠼ͶĤ߅Θ࠼O#L ࠼‫ݡ‬ĂΙۭ࠼#٣࠼?ƻ˘‫ׯ‬ƈ ͪ࠼̰̱࠼‫ق‬8qЛ࠼ƒ‫ڻ‬Ĺ‫ڞ‬Ԓˆ#࠼ ҺĹ9ࠠ‫ޕ˻ ࠼›ۮ‬Û࠼ʇ¦ʖ࠼ȧԹĢÑ࠼ɪȩʷ̢࠼ͷ%ŮМ࠼ă1ï٤‚zIϕ࠼͸Н࠼ʨ‫ك‬ԓ ࠼Ԕ{‫࠼; 'ޖڒ‬Ŕ÷¸ܿ™࠼ŋ ”ÅО࠼*Ӡ࠼°П‫ڄ‬Р‫׆‬Ē֛Ü࠼Dz   ࠼ ̲ŝ#^Cծ‫݀࠼™ۯ‬qСࠄ࠼ͫ‫ڟ‬Т࠼fȸ݁s‫ޗ‬һ࠼ӡУ࠼˦̳‫ޘ‬ϖ࠼ ۰۱࠼۲Hŀ~:ࠬĒűƝ࠼ ͹$݂࠼xƨ‫ޙ‬Á࠼ ࠭Rԕėē࠼øͬSI࠼į!ēࠅ࠼‫࠼װ‬Ԗ‫ݛ‬іϗ࠼ ť‫ױ‬ÓФ‫ݜܖڠ‬µ‫ײ‬Ϙԗİָ࠼"қ࠼8÷ ࠼˧ȤĆ࠼ƒǗ‫•ل‬Хƒħ‫ׇ‬Ц‫݃م‬Ɖ۳࠼sЧ۴࠼݄"࠼Ш‫ڣنڢڡ‬۵࠼ΩI‫!ڤ׈‬ŕǞ࠼ ˼ ࠼ӢЩ‫࠼ڥ‬Ъ۶݅O‫ࠆ׳‬ƞ࠼ ‫״‬րĘԿЫ‫࠼ڦ‬ɦʗɏ࠼Ŧ‫ه‬Ł࠼ʄ¦«࠼ߠı ЬŊȴҖ࠼ߡЭ‫ڧ‬k࠼̴ͺśż࠼ŕO࠼ԘÒЮģîࠇ࠼ϙΫֺ‫ޚ‬dz8tSȐࠈ࠼Řֹ࠼ɧ̚ց֓ź¡Yւ࠼ĭҜ࠼°ȹ‫ޛ‬Òt࠼۷‫ޜ‬ĻįƟ
ǀ࠼ p"‫࠼ڨ‬H‫ وڪک‬۸࠼·g8ăS'݆ࠉ࠼Ҽ‫̵ͻى‬xű࠼‫ي‬Ł࠼ߢԙRӲً࠼ŖqЯ࠼³‫ޝ‬ԚÊϚ࠼ ݇¶а۹࠼ȗǿȀ̋࠼ӣI࠼Κ߹փ‫ۂ‬Ȫ‫࠼׵‬ҝٌ࠼ŰӤËӥ࠼‫ۺ‬:Λù࠼ ‫ۻ‬:Ļ‫څ‬ĵ‫ګ‬Ơ࠼p࠼N࠼б‫ۉ‬Ĕō֕˭ơ࠼‫࠼ۼ‬կ‫ߣٍ׶‬ԛ ҽ࠼IJ ࠼Ԝŧ̶F߆Û‫ڬ‬8Μ”࠼ ‫‚׸َ࠼׷‬U࠼ ˽úв࠼¨ɚǴƊ‫̛̣࠼۽‬£‫ ޞ‬Á ò݈‫࠼ޠޟ‬ʅԝÜwԽ࠼ ­ҤҥԺÉ‫ڼ‬ǁ࠼C‫ڭ‬г‫݉׹‬дϛ࠼!D ˨Ʉʯ$‫׺‬Ϝ࠼еSжϝ࠼ُ࠼















ࠦ࠼













ࠧV࠼ ː 2wࠊ࠼‫ڮ‬з C࠮ŧ݊քࠋƢ࠼ȡۢϞ࠼ ̷࠼ Ĕи·‫چ ࠼ ࠼݋۾‬%…࠼Gũ࠼Ϊ٥࠼ü࠼ʩِ‫ޡ‬Zŗ࠼ʚ1‫ࠐ„ޢړ‬Ƌ‫࠼ۿ‬ҞijΝ6࠼ij‫࠼׻‬ŘӦŋ࠼ԞŌ‫ޣ܀‬йƣ࠼ԟ࠼řûк࠼օԠɛʪ࠼ ̸ّÓ࠼ɨʘɐ࠼ лŠ#%ӧN‫࠼֜܁‬ ɑ࠼ߤْ‫گ‬ϫٓҾ࠼ҿ ٔ‫࠼ڇޤ‬Ĵ࠼‫׼‬ϋÔ‫ڰ‬g࠯Ō࠼Өм࠼˩^Ũϧ ࠼ͼ‫܂‬:lƾ࠼ ֆ2࠼&н࠼Ɉԡ֔Ż´࠼ٕҟ࠼өо࠼ʫٖ ‫࠼݌‬ևǵǶ‫ࠌڱ ڔ‬Ƥ࠼ŝӳN‹࠼࠰‫࠼׽‬ĥ࠼ ̌œ ࠼N ‫ݍ‬п֑Ӏї،E࠼Ξٗ߇р %Ӂm࠼ō࠼Ħ_DE-ļŖ%ͽ0јƥ࠼ַ߈с‫࠼׾‬ӪɅȨ࠼?ӂ‫ޥ׿‬ϟт࠼]ަi࠼‫׉‬ĝуÕԢ^ΟŲ࠼٘p࠼‫ݎ‬ûф࠼ ‫ڈ‬ĵl{̹ĕ࠼ ‫܃‬հ࠼ř࠼³ U࠼‫ݏ̺؀‬Ķ1¸w࠼‫܄‬хEũ‫ۅ‬sŗʱࠢƿ࠼˾ӫц࠼ֈ ħÝĘԣӃч‫؁‬Em࠼ɩٙ‫ާ׋׊‬2*;࠼‫؂‬HшϠŒ࠼ٚ࠼£Ćϡƒ࠱‹࠼‫ݐ‬Ӭǂ࠲࠼ ̻‫࠼̼ ڲ‬ٛҠ࠼Çٜ‫؃‬Πщ‫ڽ‬ĥ࠼%Š࠼̽ӄӅ Ňň̜ ŷࠍ࠼?2Ϣ࠼؄‫ިڕ࠼܅‬Ρձࠎ࠼؅ʬ࠼ļO‫;܇܆‬/љ࠼ ɶ࠳D”‫܉܈‬tٝġ¤࠼ ˑъ࠼‫ڳ‬ы¹‫܊‬ٞ؆࠼ ҧ٧‫࠼ڴ‬ӭ ࠼։Ԥ‫׌‬ԥ‫ݑ‬ьϣ࠼ťϤÞ‫ݒ܋ڵ‬b jąӆ࠼Ƿ‫࠼܌‬7dž࠴̾࠼Ԧ࠼ߥ‫࠼ܗ؍‬٦;࠼̿ҩ‫ݞ‬э„࠼˪f‫֊ډ‬΢‫ھ‬ȦԸͿÈ‫࠼ڶ‬ Ǹ   ࠼‘Ӯ̀࠼*֠ǹΣ࠼̍W W࠼ʒٟ–ä…؎‫׍‬ß2*࠼֝֞àӇ¹࠼‫́࠼}ݓ‬Ӊӊ‫ہ‬àņŎԧ߉њ0ࠏ࠼Ԩ؇ߊю‫܍‬Ąӈ͂Śá࠼’ӯą࠵࠼Z܎ȾީΤU࠼ ˗‫ۆ‬Ձķ‫*࠼ڷ‬٠࠼˫n‫ݔڊ‬я‫΀׎‬ћ ࠼ Ǻ ǻ ֗Ӵ࠼ Ʀ࠼֘Հ֙â࠼ƍΊ՛ ̓‫ڸ`ڌڋ‬ψŞ0;࠼jԩϥ࠼؈١‫࠼ݕ‬ï٨Υޯ‫࠼ܘ‬Ԫ ߋѐ܏‫ݝ‬Դԫߌё࠼‫ڹ‬Φ‫ܐ‬ķު؉Ȣђܑ࠼ĸ؊࠼Ŷ,,,,,,ࠨ࠼ Ŷ>>>>>࠼ ‫ޫʺݠ‬ϨԵ࠼º’Ԭ}ެºŎ࠼ԭ؋࠼ ‫ݖ‬Ӱã࠼̎ȥԷԮάϪ࠼ˬ‫ݗ‬b-‫࠼ܒ‬Fޭѓ࠼Ǽž࠼ Ɛ$Ϧ࠼ɒ‫ۃ‬µ΁ԯ̈́˜‫࠼ܓ‬ƅƑͅ‫͆ ࠼ܔ»࠼࠶ޮݘ‬ȁŸ࠼ɕ؏ǽυǃ‫ڿ‬Χͭ‫ۇ‬Ղ࠼ ࠣ˜͇ų Ƅ࠼ ɓ࠼‫ۄ‬ѝQҗєؑ7aŜՅߍғ࠼ĸҡ࠼‫ݙ‬ӱѕ࠼ʆ§ʙƼΨƧ࠷԰ԻԼќϩ࠼‫ݟ‬LJƌ‫ۈ‬ՄȺ֒T࠼‫„ڍ‬Ճ٢‫࠼֋࠼ں‬

ǕǾȚ࠼

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 8 of 18








໵ᗬਖ⬯᭕⶿ᔈ᭖㟆䞊೏䞊ы ő 䞊؏ϣϤ䞊೐ Œ 䞊㶪⎝᭗䞊௩ે೑䞊㟗᭘ᗭ᭙☱䍕᭳ᦲ䞊⾿㎯䞊㟇᭚㚰㎰⿱☫⾰≑䞊 ⁍㟴㎱ⷀ䞊რ⾱䕏䙲ⷁᘅⷂᔉᤕ㟖䞊㎲‱䞊㶚⎞᭬䞊ᔊ㵸᭛⭍⬺☱≒ᘤ⿲ᗮ᭜䞊 ஍㏁⾱䅠⾰䅛㟧䅜㵹䙄Ž䞊⬯⎹ᄟ㷇䞊㵹⎟ᗯ㟈ᤖ䞊䐼Ⴙ㫾䞊Ⴚ䞊

㚱㟒᭝㫿᮹⿅ᗰ᭞䞊☠⾱䞊㶪⎠᭟䞊⭎ ⭏⾲☦㶸ᗱ᦭䞊໶㵹Ⴛ㵺᭠㬡ɬ䞊

਴ᗹᘖ㏯㟉ᦁ♴〄≓䞊㵹㎳䞊䍖Ⴜ⾳㎳䄮㬖䞊௪๑♚䞊ᦂ㎴ᘥ䅝ঝ⾻ᮊ⾰㵻㬀䞊ᄊ⿳ᦃ䞊Ⴙ⭊䞊⬰᭡ᄋ㬱㵺 ㎵‫♨܌‬ᘔ䞊ା೒ਵ䞊ⷃ᭢ⷄ㏸㟒ᄌ⿴ᦄ䄯ⷘŘ䞊㬆㎽ⷅ᭣䞊㎶′䞊㵼⎡᭤䞊 ໷䃬Ȩ㚽㵽ᤗⷆऑᗲ㟊䞊೓䞊ൊ䞊 ⏋♲⪣Ⴝᘦ⫐᭥㟋㬁œ䞊䐽⏄♳⬱᭦䞊☱⾴䞊㶹⏁᭜䞊࿳⿃☱㷄᭧ᦅ䞊໸㵼ᄍ㶺ᯂ㬂Œ䞊Ⴞ㚲㚳Ⴚ㟆ᗳ㎷⭁⬼䕐䞊⎭⭩⭪ᦋ䞊ᗴ㎸⾵㵾Ⴟᗹ㶗㬃䞊䐾☡㶗⎳䞊⷇ᦆ☢䍬♛᦭䄯ᄘ⭇㬄䞊䐿⎢㎿䞊 ⷈؐ䕑䞊ᔋ᭜䞊ᗮ㎹⾰⿠᭨ᗵ㵼᭩ᦇ䞊 㵿㎺䞊 㶻⏂᭪䞊໹ჀѢѢᦈь䞊౫㎻䍗᭫㪿ⷉ᭬⾶㶀䞊 ၊⏃☱⬲ 䞊㶌⏌᭭䞊൏㏪ⷊ㶁䞊♵⾾㞗䄰☣㟌䕒䞊䅇ʋছ‫ۻ‬ᗮ㎿䍘ᯃ㟌ᗶ䃶䞊⭁⎟э㬡䞊㟍‫♪ܐ‬ʁჁ㶂ᗷ⾷Ⴢ⬳䞊 ᦉ䄱Δ☫ϗ≔䞊㶃⎭᭮䞊ᗸ㎼䄲㟎㬅᭯䞊㎾″ј㶄㬆䞊㟏ᮋ䍭☤᭰䑀䞊 ㎽‴௫஛ೖ䞊ോɹ⾸ᦊ䞊ି⭤਴䞊ᦋ㎿ᗹ䄳ⷋ᭱⾹㷐㬷Ř䞊☥㶅䞊ᦌ☦ᦍ䞊⾺㎿㶆䞊Ⴣ㵹㶇᭲ⷌ㚴㶎䞊㵺㎾䞊☪㏷䍙⶝ႈ☧€Ⴤ⬴ᗻ䞊Ⴤ䅞ᦎ䞊 ᄞ㬄㬇ᮕ㬶㬈䞊㶈⎣ᮤ䞊Ⴥᗹᘅ䍍ᗺ䞊䕞䙳䞊‫ᦏⷍۼ‬䞊㬉☨⎖♱☱䞊⁈♯ᗹʆю⾻ᘅᘧ䞊㎿‫۽‬䞊㷄⎷☯㬊䞊☱⿵‽㏄ⷎ㟨⿶㟩♣㎶⾼䞊♶々ᦐ᭜㚵᭳⾽ᦑ᭞⾾㶉䞊䕓Ŕ䞊㟖᭴ᗻ㏀≕⾿‾ᄎⷐ≖䞊㶼⏄ᄏ㶽䞊㬋䄴ᗮ⎤䞊჆䞊 㵹᭵㬌⫊䞊䑃㏁䄵я৭൐䞊ᔌ᭶䞊⭣ਏ᭷䕔㏂⿘Ⴧ䞊㵻⏅᭼䞊㬲ᘨ㎿㚶᭸䞊ᗼ㶊䞊㶋☩⿀㬍䞊ൌ㎳⷏㶌䞊⭐ⷫ䄶ѐ㫺ɭ䞊 ൊ。㬑ඵୁ჈᥶ŕ䞊㶍⎥᭹䞊് ㏄ⷐ⬵䞊ѫ⿕㞘䄷ё㟻䕬䞊㟐ᘩ⭑᭺㟝㟆᭞ᦒ䞊⿁䞊 ᦓ᭻㶝ᄣ☪⬶᭼ᦅ䞊ᗽ㎿ⷑ㛅☫⬷჉㶫♊㏃䄸䞊㏄‵☬⿂‹㏳㟑ⷒ჊ђ☭㏅㏆䞊䄹⿃ᘥ㏱䍚᭽㟒ᯋᦤ䞊ᔍ䕕䞊බ⏄᭾䞊Ѭ⿔㞙䄺☱㟓䕖䞊☫⿘䞊ᦔ㎶ᗹ䄲ⷎ࣫‫܋‬Ѯ㶎㬃䞊‫ⷡܒ‬ᯊ 䞊☮⿄㵼᭿㟔䍛☱ᮀ䑁㬎䞊⬸㏇䞊㷋⏍ᮦ䞊 ௬೗൑೔䞊ᄙ⿠ᦂ䞊ୂ⭒ਸ਼䞊⁊㏴㟕䞊‶䅋㠀㵺⎦䃫㟖䞊♜⾾䍜ᮁ㬏㶏☯≗Ⴚ㶐☰㏰⿅䞊⎧䕗䞊㶑⎨ᮂ䞊‷⿆㶒ᦕ⎩≘ᗾ⿇ᗿᮃ䞊ୀ㏄ⷓⷔ䄻⿺⭓䕘䞊჋⿈ᦂŖ䞊☱‸䞊჌㚷㚸㟆㏪㚹㟺♻ॲ㶓ᘀɮ䞊⬹჏䑂䞊 ᘁ⿉⁋㏵㟪ᘪᘂ‫ⷕ۾‬ᤘ⾴㶅䞊Ⴭ≙⩼⿊ᘃ☱ᮄ㬖ɯ䞊਷䞊䄼㟗☱ᤙİ䞊㬐䅣ⷜⷖ჎㟘䕙䞊㏈‹䞊㶔⎪ᮅ䞊Ⴙ䍝ყ☲☳჏ᔎ⬺ᮆ䞊♱⿘ ㎾㟖ʇ‫⷗ۿ‬ѓΜ㏉⾰䞊㟙ᮇ≚ყ㟒ᦍ♖〆≛䞊㬳㏫ⷘᮈ䞊㏊›䞊㶾⏆᭝㬅ᮉ䞊 ☫‫☱ᦇ☣܍‬䍞☴ᦖ䄽ა⬺㬑䞊☵㬒䞊☲࿴䄾㬓⬻㟚☶⭁♸䍟ᮊ䞊‿㏬㟛䞊㚺䄿⭨⫉๐ɯ䛓᭜㬊䞊㏉※䞊㵹Ϙ㬔䞊㟰᭚㛇㎹㫫‫ܔ‬䞊 ๏ⷙთ㟱䞊ϓ⬼ȡૈൎ䕫㏭䅀ʀ‫♣♦܁‬ɰ䞊 ྲ೘єᮋ䞊௭ૉ⬽䞊⎭ᄉ㬎䞊㟫ᘫᘄᮌѢ‫؀‬᭡ᦗ䞊܎☣䅁ⷈΥ㟗㏋䄶㬷䞊㟜ᮍ㚻㏋㟽㶬ʊŗ䞊⁎㟵㏌ⷚ䞊♟㏍ᦘ‫܀‬䍠ѕᦙ䅂ბ㬕䞊ⷛ䞊㷀⎫ᮎ䞊 ก䍉䛔⭥☦♝⿷䞊ஒ⾯䅃㟾䅡㶕䕚Ř䞊ᦓგ㟬☲⿋≜䞊ᔏდᘅ⫋䞊㶖㏎䞊і‫ېۏێ‬ř䞊थ⭔⭕᭩⩮È⭟⁁⭟≝䞊㷎♽ѣؓ㶗䞊द⬾Ȣ૊ე䕛㎴䅓ⷤї䞊،ѣध䕜䞊ᔐᮏ䞊ვ䞊໺ზѤѥᦚј䞊 ☱⾰㵺ᯄ⭖⭗♞≞ᮐ⿌ᘆᮑ䞊㎳⁆⁇♮䛕㟝ɱ䞊 ௪ૈ඲䞊⇦⬼ᮒ㬖䞊㬗䅄≟≠ᮓ㬡㶘䞊㶙⎭უ㶚䞊Ⴚ⬼ȠເႺ䕗㏏䅅ⷪ♔䞊㚼㟭㏮䍡☷ᦛᮔᦜ䞊㬘䅆ᔑ㬙㵺თ⿍㶿♟न⬼䞊ლ㬴㬡☸㬡㶛Ⴚ〃ᘇ 䞊㵺㎵䞊 ⎬☹⪤იᘈ⫌ᮕ㟞㬚䞊ඦ⏊კ⭘♠ᦝ䞊‫٭‬ѭȣข☱⎷ᦵ⭡♭ᄋ㟕䞊ᄐ⿸ᦇ䞊ำლ䑃ܑ♫ʄ⁃䞊მ⬺Ȥ⭦♹ᄠ䙆‫☺⿎܁‬䞊φʁ⁂☻ᮖ㟌䞊㶜⎶ᮗ䕝䞊ʂ♧㪡☼䍢ᘉᦞ䞊ⷄ䞊໻ᄚ⾱䞊஖љ䛖≡㏐䞊☽⿏䞊 ௮ᮘᔒ㫱ნ㫻䞊ؔϪϥϦɲ䞊 ਸȡⶭო䕞㎶䅇⿐䅈䞊⿑ᮙ㶝䞊㷊ᔙᘊ䞊⎭☾⪥ღᘖ⫍ᮚ㟹ঞ䞊Ⴚ㶘䞊პ䞊㚽䅉ᔓ⭙♡ᘋ䞊㚾⬺ჟᘌᮛ䞊㬛⎮㏑‫܂‬㶞☦䕟䞊Ⴙ♬☿ᮜ㟟䞊⎯♀㬜䞊ⷜᮝᮝ䅊⿒≢䞊 䑄☫㶑⎭䞊ᄑ⿹䞊♢⿺ᦓ♣䍤☱ᦟ䅋რ⬺䞊ს㵺䞊㵹⎰㏒䞊໼ტ䅤䄦♁䞊ᘍ㎴⿗㬌䄳⬿უ㶟ᮞ䞊‫ڬ‬ѕѩᦠ䞊⬯ᔔᘎ㟮ᘬ‫܃‬䞊ᄝ㟕ᘡ䞊♂⿘ᦡ♃ᘏფ㶪♋㏀⿓㬝䞊♄㶠‫܄‬䞊㶡⎱ 䞊ⶲ⬺ᯅ㬉䞊㶢⎲ᄒ㷀䞊⏇♣㬞䞊 ᭲⿔ᘐ㏓䄾⾴㶣ᮟ㟖䞊䑅♅㷁⏈䞊њ‫׿‬䃺䞊⎳☱⪦ქᗮ⫎ᮠ㟲㬡䞊ћ㟷ʈႺ䕠䞊⿕㏔㶪䞊⎴ღ䍣᭞䞊ᔔᯆᯇ⿝䞊ყᗮᗮ♋ᦢᮡ⿗㶤შ⭚ɯ䞊 ஗䅌〈〉≣䞊㷌⏄㶥䛗䞊㬟ჩⷝᮢ䞊‫⪢܅‬ᮣ⁏㟜ᄓⷬᯈş䞊 ც⭀ȥૈ Ś㶦䕡㏯㷂‫♺⶿܆‬䞊܏♩ძᘭ⭛䞊ᮤ䔣㶧ᮥ⿖㬠♆䍤ᮦ䞊ᗮ㏕⿗‫܇‬წᗮ㵹䞊䑆♇㵹⎵䞊໽Ⴚⷞ♈♉䞊౬㏖䍥ᮧ㫀⷟ᮨ⿗㶨䞊ᮩ㵳㶩ჭɻᔘ⁄ᄡ⭑䅟⿘Ѫʃྰɼ㶪㬡䞊ⷠ䞊㵺⏌䛘䞊࿵㟾䅢⭁᮹㪱䞊 ໿㶫ხ㶬᮪㬢䞊ჿ⿙ᦣ䞊㟖ᘮᘯᘑ‫܈‬䍣ᘒᦓ䞊⁉♰⿻ɽⷡᘓ♊ჯ⬺䞊㬣䅍㚿㛀㏗⿚䞊⁐㟶㏘ⷢ䞊ჰ䞊໾Ⴞ䅎ᦤ♋䞊ᘔ㏙㫁㛁ᄗʅ⿹䕢䞊ჱ⁀⭜♤⬺☱ऩ㵽ᘕᦥ䞊䑇♌㶭⎶䞊㵹⎭᮫䞊໿Ⴚ䅏ᦦ♍䞊 ฃ♉⿛♎㬤㶮㟝䕗䞊㎽‼ ஘ᮬ⁌㏶⿜㬥ᮭɳ䞊 ਹᘖᘗ㏚㟠ᦧ♏⿝≤䞊㵹㏛䞊௯ોќ䞊⇥⭂ᯌ㬑ɴ䞊

ჲ㶯䞊ѝ⎷ᤚ䞊ᘘ㏜ⷣ㛂ჳ⿞䕣䞊㬦㫲㪰䞊㶰⎸ᄋ㶕䞊ჴ⬼䙩

ૌყ䕞㏄䅐‫☫、ܓ‬䞊㟡᭡ᘙᮮ♐䍦ᮯᦓ䞊ჵ䞊ⷢ㏊⿼㶘⎹⬺䕤䞊㬉Ⴚ⬼კ㟲䕥䞊᮰䍧ᮊ⿟䞊㶎⎭㏝䅑≥⎺䞊⎻ᮊ䞊⎷ჳᦅ䞊¿ᘚᘢ⿠䞊㷆ɵ⎻ᘛ㟋᮱䞊㏞⿠䞊㏟〇⭍䕦䞊㏠⿡᮲䞊㏡ᘜᘅჾ㬵ўϧѦѧɶ䞊 ྯ⏄☲㬉䞊㬧䅎㛃㛄㎴㫪䞊♣⿠ᘆ㟆᭴थ㬉ᘝᦂ䞊㬨䅒ᔕ㬩㷏ⶵ⾰㶱♑Ⴚ⭚⬺䕧䞊♷⿻䞊਺㛅Ε♒⭃䞊ؕϫϬϭś䞊㶲䑈㏞䞊㟯⿽ჶ㟸ʉ㶈⎵㬆䞊ჷ⁑㷈᮳㟢䞊㶳⎼᮴䞊⎽☱⪤ჸᘜ⫏᮵㟣㬪䞊ჹ㟻㟼♼䍨ᯉᦳ䞊 ☢䙇џ䞊ༀᄛ⿄䞊ங☦᮶≦㏢Ŝ䞊ᦨ䃻ᘞ㟒ᘟᄜ㬖ᘠᦩ䞊㬫⬺☫≡⏄㷃⭇䕞䞊♓⿢䞊ங᮷ᗮ᮸ⷤᔖ᮹㟒䞊ؑϦхɷ䞊ᄔ⿾ᦃ䞊㬖Ѡჺ䕞ᥨ䞊ᄕ㷄䞊㷍⏎‫܋‬䄷䞊㬬჻ⷥᮺ䞊⭄ᮻ䍩ᮼ⬼䞊䅓⿗㶿♔⬼䞊 ਺䅔≧䅕㬭⭅䞊ؒϨϩ Ѩɾ䞊 ྭ⎷⿣⭆䞊ᘡ㏲ⷦ㛆ჼ⿤䕨䞊㟤எ㟪㷉ᘡᦪ⭇䛙䞊⎭ჽᦫ䞊䅖ᥔ䞊㶴㏣䞊࿶㬮თⷢჾ䞊ச♕⿥䞊ඳჿ৭⭠ⷧ䞊ᄀ⿦᦬䞊ᄁ⭈ȦແᄂÇ♖ᦓᄖɸ䞊 ႂ⿞䞊 㟿䍐ᦇ㷅♅㏤⾴ŝ䞊㶶⎻ᮽ䞊௰્ѡ䞊᦭ᮾ㶑ᘢ《⾰⭫⭬⭞ᘰᦴ䞊㷆⏉Ⴚ㶅䞊ᄃ⭉ȧ૎ᄄ䕩㏥䅗䞊ⷘ☧䞊䑉Ⴛ㬡䞊♥⿿䞊ᘱ㏰⿧䅘ᘅ㶵䞊䑊☱⭊⎾䞊䛚ᮿ䍪ᯀ㟒ᄅ⭋䞊☱⿨ᦍ‫܉‬ြѯ᦮䅙ᄆᔗ䞊 ႉ࿷⭞᦯ᘣ㟖䞊௲ૈೕ䞊♗⿩䍤ɿ‫܊‬㬨㷈☡≨ᄇ⭧♥㏦㏧䞊ᄈ⿪ᦰ䞊䑋♘㶶⎿䞊㶯⏏ᯁ䞊ಔ㏨⭌䕪䞊පᄜ⿉ᦜ䞊௱㟥Ş䅚⿫ᦱ　⭝♙㏞⿬ɹ䞊䑌⎳♌ᗮ⬼љ䞊⏀ᄊ㬃䞊㏩ᤛ⭢ⶴ䞊။൒ᦃ䃼ി䞊 ♍ʁ⿭䍫ᤜⷨ≩ऒ㶷☱㏞⿮䞊ᄉ㬯䞊ɺყ䞊⁅ᄢ⿯ᦜ㟳䙝♾㬰♣⿰≪䞊∬㏞ⷩ䞊∘㟦䞊ྱपⷪŒজ䞊

щ‫ګ‬ъ䞊ၵၶ଻೎଼൉
䞊

䙧ଽ໴ඥ䞊㵷☟䞊

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 9 of 18

๒㬸ᅪⷢᅋ䞊‫ٮ‬ᄤ㬹㬺⾱ᄥ㠟ʢɳ䞊 ஜᄦ㭏㬌》ᄝ䅥䞊 ⷭᄧ䕭䞊 ⏐ᄨ䍮᭝䞊 ⏑ᯍᮒ䅦䞊 ⚈「䞊 ᘹ㏉」♿䛛ᙕ⭯䞊 䑍♴㸀⏒䞊 ᄩ⭭ȩคѰ⏓㸋⛍⏔ᄪ㠁䞊 ᄫ⿌㪲䞊 『⬿Ȫಕᆃςⷮ⚀䞊 ᦶ䆇㟓⚫』≫䞊㷝⎷ᯎ⚁㠂䞊㶐♋ⷢᯏ䞊☢【䞊໻ᄬ⿌䞊஝⚈䛜…๓ɬ䞊૏ყ㭊㬌】ᄭ⿵䞊䑎ს㬃䞊ѱ䞊ᙄ⬿㏹㬻ᯐ䞊ᄒ㬿㬌㏾ᘲ⚂ᄮѲᯑ䞊㏺⁒䞊΅ʁ ȫૐफ䕮㏻䅙ⷯ⚃䞊 ᄯぅᙝ‫ܕ‬䞊 ๏ⷰᄰ㠃䞊 ૑ᄱ⫑ᄲ㠄ᔚᆇ㬊⏕ᄳ㷑Ŝ䞊 ᄴ〒㎿㵹⏃ᘳট䞊 ㎴〓ᯒ䞊 ㏼⁓䞊㷒⏖ᯓ䞊 ⎮⛆⪪ᄵᘴⶤᯓ㠄㬼 䙴䞊 ᘵ⭚㏽㬸ᯔ䞊 ᔃ㬸㏉ᘶ⚄ᄶ㷓ᯕ㬼ɹ䞊 ಖᯖ䞊 ᄷ⭚㬽㎿䞊 ⭮⚈䍯ᯗᦷ䞊 ყᙒ㟗㐭㫾‫ڝ‬䞊 㷔⏗ᯘ䞊 㬾Ѿ㠅ᯙ⩽⭯䞊 ∭㏾⸆䞊㶺⏘ᯚ䞊⏺⚯⪧ΰᙋ⫒ᯛ㠆㬋Š䞊ᄸ〔ᦸ䞊ⷱ䄢ᦹᯜ䞊ໜ䞊ᘷ㎴ⷲ⶿ᰛう㵹䞊‫ܖ‬㎿䞊


௸૚೙䞊ᅟ㭠㭙ᰜ㷕䞊㶺⏙‫⚽ܨ‬㷖䞊⎷ᯝ䞊ᦃ㷗ᘸ䞊ⷳ㐂㠇ᯞ䞊‫⏚ܗ‬ᄹ‫⚡ܩ‬䞊ᄏ⭰䙪

ેᄺ䕯㎿䆃⸜♋䞊 ᦺ⚈ᤎ䞊 ∙㟆䞊 㠈⎤ᯟ䞊 ⏘♋⪨ᄷᘹ⫓ᯠ㪋ɬ䞊 ਸ਼ᘺᘻ㏾㟆ᦓ☦〽≬䞊㷘㏿䞊 ᅳ⿠䞊 ௹๔⚅䞊ᦃ㎿ᘼ䅧㠇ܲ⛋ᯱ〮㷙š䞊 ஞᆉ㬊〔Ⴜ〟䞊 㶺㎴⮆ᦃ䞊 ᄒ〮㐀㷢⎮ᯡ㟆䞊 ⚆〕ᦻ⚇䍰⚈ᦁ䅨ᄻ⭚䞊 㵹⏩ओ‫ܘ‬䞊 ⏛ᯢ䞊 ⷴᯣ㵺䞊 ᄼ⬿Ȭಗᄽ䙡⚈䞊 㷚⏄㟒㐁䅩≻ʒѳ䞊 ᄾ⭚ȭடᄿ䕰㐂䑏〖‫ܙ‬䞊 ʗ⚼が㸌⛎䞊 ⭸ࣁÍʕ䃽㠉䞊 Ѵ‫ܚ‬Ţ〗ѵ䞊 ⚰⚎ᯤ䞊 ⷵᤌ䞊 㟾䑚㏾䞊 㐃⁔䞊㷹␂ᯥ䞊 ⏮⚋⪩სᘽ⫔᯦㠊㬃䞊 㷛⏫㟮㎿䅪≭⎟䞊 ᅀ൓Ȯ૎ब䕱㐄䅩ⷶ⚱ʓ䞊 ಘ᭹䞊 ყ⬿㬋㐅䞊 Ѷ㎿⭱ᦃ䞊 ѷ⏜᭤䞊 ᅁ㬿㬫ᮻ㷜䞊 㸁⏻ᅂ㷝䞊 ᰠʞ⭲Ȯඣᅃ䕲㐆䅙ⷷ♋䞊 䑐ᅄ㬌䞊 Ⴙ㟆ʣᘾ㬌㸂ᙞᥩ䞊 ᔛᙧᙨ㐇ⶦᘿ䞊⏝ᯧ䞊⫗ぇᯨ䑑䞊〘⭳䞊ಙᅅ䙋⸞⚉䞊〙〚ᙩ⮎䞊〛⭴Ȣฅ⚊⏞৮⚲⏟҄҅㠋䞊䍱ᙖ㠞䖀䞊䙵ʌ䙶ʍ䙷࣬⭴⭵ʎ䞊 ླ⏟ᰋ䞊ᦼ㐈ᙀ䅫ⷸᙁⷹ䞊≮㐉৯ʘ¼䞊㐊〜䞊ѸϮ䞊‫ܦ‬ত䄜㷞ᙂ䞊㷟⏠ࣜ㷠䞊 ૒ᅆ㬌㭀⿘ᅝき䞊 ᅇ〝ᦽ䞊 ţൔ ȯ ૓ᅈ䕳㎯䅬ⷺ⚋䞊⏡ᅉ䍕ᯩ䞊 ᔜᯪᯫ〩䞊 ᙟ⬿㏿㬌ᯬ䞊 㵹㐋䞊 ᯭᅍᙠ⏼䞊㎿㷡⎟ᰝ㟜䞊⁣㐧㟒䞊٤䞊 㐌㏆≯䞊 㠣䆆こᯮ 䞊 ⶫr༊㭁〞ᅊ〟䞊⏢ᅋ㭂䞊 ⷻᄸぎ䕦䞊 㠌☭ᘒ㭃䞊 㷢㐍䞊 ⮆⚳䃾䞊 ໵ᅌ䅕ᦾ⚌䞊 ౭㎿䍲ᯯⷢⷱᙃⷼŤ䞊 ⚍〠ᙄ⭶䄴ᦿ⚎〡≰䞊㛈ᆈ㬋㷣䞊 ᯰⷳ㚹⬿㎿䕴ⷽ᭹〠㷤䞊 ᔝ䕵䞊 㷕⏮ᯱ䞊 ༁ᅍ䄴ᦃ♅䞊 ਼㠝ᅎᔞ⚏ლѹ‫ܛ‬䞊 ⁞ᅿ⏽⮇ᙡყ㵹⚐㐎㐏䞊จ⚴㬌㭄♋㐐⿠Ť䞊 㟮ᰁ⁕᯲ⷾ‫ᦊܜ‬䞊 㶸㐑䞊 ⚵⾾䞊௳ໝ䞊೜䞊 ᧀ㏫ᙗ䅭ⷿ᭟〢㵹㬿䞊 ᅏ㭙䞊䚡䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚣䞊 ྴ⎟᯳䞊 ௺૛೚䞊 䛝Ҁ㭅㷥ť䞊 〣‫ܝ‬ᙅ᯴⚑䍳᯵ᦜ䞊 㟮ᰋ㛁㎿㟆㷣㭓䞊 㫠㐒‫ܫ‬〱䞊 ⚒〠ᧁ⚓䍴♙ᦃ䅮ᅐ⭚㬡䞊⚔⿌䞊 㷦⏣᯶䞊ฆ䅯䛞⬿⚕⸀䞊ᙆ㐓⸁⸂䅰〤⚖㷧䕶䞊ᄩ⬿⬿᯷䛟⚗䅱≱䞊㸃⮈ѕᅑ⭷䞊 ҆‫ٱ‬ყʛș㭆⾾ᆀ⾾䞊ⷳ⚘≲⏤㷕䞊ᔕ᯸䞊ᅒ䞊༂ᅓ䅲ᦃ♔䞊⚀「㷕᯹⭸⬿‫⪑ܤ‬ᘓ〥ᘱ᯺䞊 ㏀⁖⁢⚿ᙇ᯻㟒ɫ䞊 ਻ᙈᙉ㎿㠍ᙊ⚢〻≳䞊㶺䅳䞊ᄧ䞊ିභੂʙ䞊 ⸃᯼⸄㎿Ŧ䞊‫ۑ‬ᅔ䛠ŧ⸅ᅕ〦䞊㠎ᙢ㛓㐔㠠ʤᙋᧂ⭹䕷䞊〧‫ܧ‬ᙦ᯽ѕ䍵ᯱᧃ䞊⁗䅮ʧŨᧅ⚾䅴≴䞊ᆁえᧄ䞊㛉㐕㭇㬋⚐ᔞ⭺䕸䞊〨䞊 ⁠ᆋ⫕᯾䞊㛊ე㭎㭞㛔㐖㟆㷩䞊∰㏻⸆䞊༃ᄿʝ䆅ᦃ⚈䞊౮㎴䍶᯿㫂⸇ᰀ〩㷨䞊㎴⁡⇨ᙌ☡ᄉ⭚㭈ɭ䞊 ಚᰁ䞊 ᄨ⿌ᤅ⮍䞊⏫⚮㭉䞊䑒♀⁤㐨䞊⏥ᅖ䍜ᰂ䞊㟆ᰃᙍᰄ‫ܞ‬䍷ᤝ᧋䞊 ⇧〪ᅗ〫ᙣ⚶ჲ⭻䞊 㭏䄰㛎㛋㎿〬䞊∮㐗⸈䞊㵹⏦ᰅ䞊༄ᅘ䅉ᦃ⚈䞊਼ⷳᔞᅙ㭊㬌Ά᧗㐘㟒䞊㷕䅵䞊㷩⏧᭚䞊࿸〔⚈㷪ᰆᧅ䞊༅㶸٥㷫ᙎ㬌䞊ᅞ⿘ᦃ䞊⏨ਗ㬺䞊䑓ѕ䞊⁘ᙏ䞊 ʐੁɱ䞊 ି⮑ʠɩ䞊㠏᯷৖㐙〭䞊䛡㭋㐚䞊 ⚈〮ᧆѺᙋ࣢㷬ᙤ㭟䞊㶗⏘ᅚ㷭䞊૔ᅛ㬗㭣えᅜ㟯ʥ䞊 㸍㠤䛢䍸ᰇ⭚ᯱᦈ䞊 㶺㎿䞊 ಛ㏍䅙㭌⭼๐‫ܮ‬㷟䞊⚙〯䞊‫ؖ‬ϯϰ‫ؗ‬䞊 ᅝ〰ᧇ䞊⸉ᰈ㷮䞊၌ම㷯⚷⚸䞊ᄰ〳䞊⚚〱ᦐ⚛䍹⚜ᥪ䅶ᅞ⭽䞊䑔⛂⛃㐛䞊䑕औ䛣䞊 Ȱ ྷ⏾᭹䞊 㟆᭚㛌㐜㠢㸆䞊 㭍㶺ᆂʜ㷰䛤㭎䞊 㷱⏩ᅟѻ䞊 ᧈ䅲㠥♀「≵䞊 㶅⏘ᄸ㸅䞊 㷲㠋⛌㛍䞊 ᅠ䞊 ⸊Φ⸋ᔟᯁ㠅䞊 㐝⁙䞊 ‫⎟ܟ‬ᯁ䞊 ໵ᅡ䅎⛈⭮⛉䞊 ໞ㎴䕹Ⴢ⮉䞊 ௴ᄹ⸌Ѽൕ䕺䞊 㛎㠐㎿䍺⚝ᦣᯓᦠ䞊 ૕भ㬿㭏㪌თ㐞䞊 䑄♋ũ⏪䞊 ᅢ䞊 㬌☦⎗⛀♋⛄⛅ᘓᅔく㷕䞊 Ⴜ‫⿗ܬ‬㐟䅷㟾ܱ㷕䞊 ㏉⁚䞊 ᘹᄸ㭟⏫ɱ䞊 㸊ਉ૖䞊 ࿺ൗ⁥㐩〲〳‫⚇⮋⮊ܠ‬㎿〴䞊 ☢⿗ᧉ⚞ᙆᆊ䃨ܳ䞊 㷳⚟ѽᅣ㶘䞊 േᅤ㭃㬋⾾ᅤ〵䞊⚠㭐䞊ᅥ〶䞊ᰉ䔤㶺㟆ᰊ⸌⚡㭑㷕䞊ᆅ〮ᦃ䞊䛥㛏㛐㐠〷ᰞ㟆䞊㎯⁛࿹㭒ᆄ⸌უ䞊૗⸍䞊ඹᅦ᧊⚢〸Ū䞊Ⴠ⿌᧋䞊⏬ᅥ㬋䞊⏭䛦ᰋ〹䞊ᙐ㎴‫⸝ܪ‬ᯚᘒ㷴ᰌᦃ䞊㶺㎿䞊౯ᰍ䞊 ௐ〺䄫ᙑᅧ〠䞊ྵ㬺⬿ᅰ⸑ѕᙒ䞊ൖঠ⏮ᅨ᧌䞊ᅡうᦃ䞊Ѿ⏯ᯱ䞊૘⭾♋〻᧍䞊༆⏰გ䕕⫖⏱ড䞊 䚤䞊 ༇⏲‫ٯ‬䕿⫘⏿䞊ᅩ⭿Ȣྷ␀䅸⸎ჵ⚣㟮䕕ʏ䞊 ਽ᘹᙥ㎿㠑᧎⚈〒≶䞊㶺㎴䞊௵ે೑䞊ᦃ㎴ᘗ䅹⸏᭤⾱㷵㬊䞊け⿌ᦓ䞊ᅪ䞊ୃ೛ਾ䞊⸐ᮑ⸑㐥㠙ᆆ「ᦓ䄯ⷘŜ䞊ᅫ⮀Ȣ⮁⏳䅺ɫ㠡ʦѿ♋䞊 ᅪ〓ᦠ䞊⚤⬿Ȣง♋⎟ᦠ⎳ᄋ㠚䞊⸒ᅬ䕕䞊⎟ᅭ䍻ᰎ䞊ᔠᯞᰢ䅻䞊 ⚱〽䞊ᙪ㎿⿺㵹ᅮᙓ㷶䞊䑖⚥㵹⏴䞊໳⏵ᅯ䕻⬬‫⮐ܯ‬䞊 ʖ⚻Ҁȱྶ⏶䅼⸓ঘ㟆䕼ū䞊უ〼䞊ᅰᙔᙕ㠒ᰏᦃ☢㷷ᰡ᧓䞊 ᧏⚦㛅⭴㐡⸔ᅱ㶺䞊ᅲ⮂䞊㷸⏷ᰉ䞊༈ე䅙ᙫ⮒⛊䞊ୄ㎴〽㭓䅎⭱ᅳ㷹ᰐ䞊☲⿠䞊ය㎴㭔䞊ਾঢѕ≷㠓⮃ᯱ㭡䞊ᅴ〾᧐䞊㎴〿᭹䞊㎴⁜㷺⏸Θ䞊É䙸⚧㠛〠ᅵ㠔⸕ʔÌÊ䞊ᅶ㶒䞊ҁ‫ܡ‬Ȳ‫ܥ‬ᙖ䞊ට⚨‫ܢ‬ѕ≸䞊 ௶s⎮ᅷ᧑䞊⸖㎴㭕㞚䅽⩾䞊⮄぀䞊୅䆄⮌䍼ᰑ㠕䞊୅⚈㷻䕕Ŝ䞊୅ᅸ⭚⚹ ㎴㫃⚩ᄧɳ䞊 ਿ⬿㬌㏝䞊ᅹ㸇‫ܮ‬ᙗ㐦㠜᧒⸗≹䞊㶺㐢䞊 ௷૙䛧䞊᧓㎿ᙘ䅝‫ܭ‬あᙙ⿘㶅㭖ʐ䞊㷕⮆ܰ⪓ʟ䞊⸘㎺㭗㞛䅾ᰒ䞊 䑗ᅞ㭘䞊ᔡ䅿㷼䞊೜㶒䞊⚪「䞊 ҂‫ے‬Â䞊∯㎿⸙䞊⁦㐪⿘ᦓ⚣ぁ≺䞊㛑㟆㎴䍽⚈ᦃᰓᦃ䞊⏹䕽䞊οٰ䆀ᤏ⚫䞊ਿ㟜ᅺᔢ☥ᅻË㭙䞊୆㠖㐣䑘あ䞊ຑぉおᙚᙛ䞊ੀⶩ᧔䆁⬲㐬ʡ䙊҃䙈ɸ䞊 ྸʚŬᰔ䞊⸚㎴㭚㞜䆂ᰕ䞊‫ܣ‬㭛䞊か⚺㛒㎴㟮㷑ᯁৰ⭹⭚䕩䞊ᅼぃ㸈ܴい᧕ᰖᦃ䞊ᔍ䕾䞊⸛᯹⸑ᔣΧ㟮㬌䞊㐤⁝䞊㸄␁ᰗ䞊༉ᅽ္⛇⮏䞊 ି㎿げ㭢䄰ⶥᅾ㷽ᰘ䞊⚈㠗ʑ䞊ර㎴㬺䞊੃⿗⛁থᙜ⬿ᤑ䞊 ᆀぐ᧘䞊⚬㭜䞊䑙⚭ᦃ᧖䕿䞊㟓ᮻᘓ㎴≙〝♀䙉ᰙᦃ䞊⁣㐫㠘䞊☢㷾㭝䞊ᅔ〔㷿☲ȤႳÎᰟ㬗⮅㸉ܵ㫄䞊䍾⚮ᰚ䑚䛨ণ䞊

șȃț࠼

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 10 of 18




  

໳ᆓ⮗ᥕ䞊ᅓ൛ȴ⮰⮱䄲㭹㭤ყ䖁ᤞ⾾ɭ䞊 ҝҞ҇䞊་ᱩ㛘㸎ᰣ⸟ᔫᯓ㠐䞊‫ؘ‬ϴϵŜ 䞊໳ყҟ䄘␖䞊ᆌ⮓ȳಜ䆈㬱㭤ᆍ䕤ᮝご œ䞊㠦ᙬ㛕㐱さᯓᦓ⮗䖂䞊ᆎ䞊༌ᆏ䆉ᦊ⛏䞊ೝܶざᚌぽ㏨㠄䞊 ฉ⛜る✌㭥㸏㟕䖉䞊㏊⁶⁷⛾ᗻ☢ᆐ⮔Ř䞊㭦㸳ᆲ䖃᱕ৱ⮸䞊ᆛ㸐䞊㶏⎻ᰤ䞊㭧ᆐ⸏ᰥ䞊⎝㐮㶑ᯱ⮕䞊♋ 〠 䞊ಝᰦ㫅᧙㐯⾾Ŕ䞊ွ♒㟕⊀☱⾰⛪ᆑ䞊䑛␃ᰧ㟕ᰜ䞊ᆒ⬲Ƞಞᆽ䙍⸠⛐䞊䑜ᆒ㭨䞊 㭩⮖ᆓ䕳⛨じ⊀ʨ䞊 ႊှ␘⛵⮗ᰨ䞊ᄯ⮕Ƞಜ⾭㭪し䖄ᰩ〟䞊ᗹ⮘ᅜ☱⸢ᮄᦃ䞊ე⁧⮹䃿㠧䞊།ᰪ㛖⮙᤟ⷎᔕᱜ㠻䞊҈ ґ 䞊じ㐰㵹䞊㷶㎿䞊⫝ひ㏊䑠䞊㷌␄ᮙ䞊␞⛳⪨ᆔᙚ⫙ᰫ㠨㬱ş䞊௻૜⮚䞊 ᄈ≼ᰬす㸻㮌䞊ᔤᰭ⬲⛑ᰮ䍿᭡ᦁ䞊ᔥ᮪䞊䑝ᆎ㮉䞊ᔕᰯ☢ず≽䞊ᦃ‘᭱㛗㸑☱䎀ᯱɫ䞊 ಒ䞊᙭䞊䑞ᄾ㬖䞊ე␅⮛ᰰ䞊㸒㎹䞊᙮⁲㑎㛑অ䞊㸒⎝ᰱ䞊⮻Ŵま⛶䞊㸓᱁ᦃ䞊༎ʰე㸔᭡㭨䞊ᦃᰲ䛩‫҉ڴ‬㸕ᰳ䞊 ௩✅⮺⮜䞊ᰴ⁴⁵㎿せʕ㭸䞊⸡䞊⮗㐱ᙯᆛ⮝ᰵ䞊しぱ㸺⮼䞊㟕᭯Ƞ⛒〱㸢ᯓ㟕䍦⛓ᰋ䑟䞊␋✀ܼみদ䞊ᆺよ᧚䞊 䚥䞊 ਻ᔦ᧛䆞⮲⮌ᆸ␋䞊{Ҝ϶䞊඼ᅓᦲ⛔⾾ʩ䞊 ੄ᔌᦜ䅎⬲⮳ᄋ⎝䞊૝♴ぺ䞊ලᆕ᦭⛕ぜ䞊ᚍ⮴Ⴜ✇⸢㬥䞊㶌㎿䞊䑠㏊㟫⫚䞊⁹㑓㠩䞊㸸␎ᰶ䞊໻ყ䅎᧛⛖䞊⮠݃⸢ᔧᅞ㮊㭫䖅䞊⩶䞊 ၍Ⴚʳ⸰⛶݄れ≾㸖㐲そŘ䞊஠ɲେɮ䞊¾䞊ᆖ⿥䞊ぞ᧜⸣⛗㠪⸤䆊Γ䛪䑡ᙰ䞊㐳⇙ᙱ᰷㠫ɫ䞊 ೢ⮵᰸䞊Ҋ㭬䞊⛘᧝ᙲ㐴㶲⛔⇩ᙳᙴ䞊ᔨ䖆䞊㸗␆᰹䞊ҋ䙹ι⮞䞊ᆼ㮋䞊࿻㭭㎪ᆗ䞊஡⛔り䞊 වⶶ᦭♀たÏ㭮䞊⎝ᆹ⬲⁧䞊ᔞ㟕㏊㵺␋ᯜ㟕ʏ䞊 ಟ䄀䞊㸘㭯䞊ᄾ䞊ᚎ⭍㐵㭰᭹䞊≂᭞⿻᧌䞊㐶⁨䞊ช㏨␇ᆻ⸏⸢ᱥᦋ䞊ແ䆋ᆘ᦭☯㠬Ƞ⮟⁳㑏㡁䆟⾻ᆙだ⛙œ䞊ᆚ䞊㛘㏊㭱䛫⛚ᔎ⮠᰺䞊 ঈ㐷ᙵ☱ᆛ㵹ᘒ䞊㏊⁩䞊ซ㏋␈ᆜ⸱⸏ᯱᦂ䞊੅㸙Òʁᆝ䞊ᆝち᧞ ฌᆞ㟏䑢ぢっ䞊ᆟ⮡Ƞ໳ⶪ᰻⎝␋✁䞊㛏Ҍ⛛㑐㟕䞊㷶㑑䞊໿ᙶ㛙㶼ᚂⷔ䆌ᙷ㟕䞊ҍ Ҏ ŭ䞊‫ؙ‬ϱϲ ɱ 䞊 ྐྵつᙸ䞊൘㏯⚂⾾㵹䞊⮢Οҗ㞝䅒⚇㟏䖎䞊ᆠ⮣㭨㐸䞊√䆍ば᦭䞊㐹㸚␉ᰞ㠷䞊⸥ᦇҏᗹᆡ㵹☱㎿む㮈䞊⮶⮷ܷყ㸛䞊⛟⾾᧧⛟䎁☱᦭㐺ᆠ⮗㭯䞊ᙹ㐻㡂䅎݅ᮝᙚ㸜᭞᧟䞊㸝㎹䞊㶗␊ᯓ䞊໻ᆢ䆎᧠⛜䞊 ౰㎿䎂ᮝʲ㟵䆏⸦ᙺ⾰㵼䞊␋ყ䎃ᯞ䞊㷌⛟ᱪ㬖䞊㸞㏻䞊㵺ᯱ㟮㠐㏨㠾✎㬥⛝䞊ほ᰼㵺䑣㐼㠅ࣚ㬖Œ䞊✈ぺᙻ⮗䆐ᦓ♀た≙ܸ䞊 ྺ⎣᰽䞊ୈ඾✄ႍ䞊म⾾ᦲ䞊௼૞ೞ䞊⎝ᅜ䎄᭚䞊Ґᥫ᰾㐽㸟☱⁸⛿ᯜᦲ䞊㷢␛᭬䞊⮟ᔩづ䞊ྭᆺⸯѕ䕞ᆣ␛䞊ญųਐʯফ㞞䅎ᙼ䞊☱㠭ʪ䞊୉қΛĤ䎅᱕㠮䞊୊⛞㵺䕳䞊ᅜ㭲䞊ᆤ䞊㭳⚏㸠᰿䞊㏨䞊 ᱦʭႋ ශ㟕ᰆ⸠♀㭯㶼Ȥ㟕ᱧ⬲ᆥ㵹᰻᧡䞊‫ؚ‬ᗹ㵼⛳䍤⛟ᚖ䕞ɹ䞊 ໿ᯇ䎆ᥡპ⮤䞊㬖䄰ᔞ⪫᱀ᚒ㸱༒䞊㏨䞊௽ ે೟䞊⛠ゆ䍦ᙺ㭧јҕ≿ᆪ䆑㏨て㭴䞊㛚㠸✏㐾㠯䞊㵹㎿䞊໳᭞㛘㸡ᰆ⸧ᔩᯓ㠰䞊ґ Ғ 䞊 ⎻ᆦᦃ䞊ᚏ⮗㐿㭨᭯䞊᥻〠⾻᱁ᘓ㸢☱㏨⾴㬗䞊Ů㏨䞊㶾␙᱂䞊⸨㏨㭵㞟䅎᱃䞊ᆛでᦇ䞊 ろ㠳ᙽ䞊␚㑒⭾☱᱄䍦ᙾᦲ䞊㷧㑀䞊␌ყ䎇ᆧ䞊⮗ᆨ䑤љᦂᙿ㠱᱅⬲䞊⸩㏨䆒 䖇䞊㵹⏼㠳㏨䆓⊂⎣䞊 㸝Җ҉☱㭶䞊ⷃ㐂㬖㞠䄲᱆䞊㵹㏨䞊と㑁⾰ȴ㛅ধ㑂⇪⮥䞊㎿㟕⊀ᆛら⛼䙌ᆛ㸴㸵㏊ど㭷䞊㏊䎈᱇㡀㭒ᯇნ㬆䞊ᆩ⇫⮢⛡჊㵺ᯞᦣ䞊䑥⛢㶘⎝䞊࿼㬥ů䚦ʫⷢᆪ䞊૟✉⾾䞊඿ܹ䆔⛣✊⾾ɸ䞊 ႃょ䞊ᆪぺ䞊 ⛤な㸣᱈㡃䍤☢᱉䐽ř䞊ᅞ⾰䞊Ð૖⮦䞊ᅊ⊁ᰋに㸤䞊㬨ᆳ⛥ᦃ䞊⏼ᰵ䞊ᔪ᱊⮧☢᱋䍤᱄᧨䞊㵺␍ᅜ㸥䞊 ༏ᆫ䅒᦭⛷䞊౭㏨䍡ܾܿ݁⾻ႷŲҘᚁめ㸶䞊㠼ʴ⛦㑃そ᱌䖈䞊၎ⶽ䞊㑄ᚂҚΎȵʬ⊂䞊 ⬲ᆪ䄹「᧡ᚃন᰻᧢䞊㸦␟㠐㎿䆕⊃␎䞊㶏␛ᱍ䞊⸏㎹㭸㞡䄲ᱎ঩䞊 ੆⾾㑅㶗␠ᯜ㟢䞊໳ᆐ䄵ᦲ☱䞊ぺᆴ㵼☱㐱⾾ᆾ⮨䞊䑦⛧⮩␏䞊ᚐ⮗㐵㬱ᱏ䞊㵼⛸ᚑ㭦䞊㵺㑆䞊㸧⎣ᯓ䞊໳ᆬ䆖᧡⛨䞊ໟ㎿䖉ᆭ⮗䞊௹݂䆝⾾⚇⮌䙣䞊䚧 䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚩䚪䞊⛩㬌䞊㸹⎻᱐䞊 㬖䄹ᔫ⪬᱑ᘹ㵹䞊㏁䞊௹ેೠ䞊ᚕ㑇䄺ほ㸨ᚄ㠕㸷ᤠ㠖㟮㏯ぬ㭹ⷘ䞊♁ね䎉᱒㬥㸩☱⊄ᅪ㵹⛪㎿⾰㬱䞊჊ごᦲ䞊㟕ᙺ㛒㑇のᯇᚔ⮗⮪䖊䞊䑉Ⴚ㭤䞊ᚅ␐᱓ᗹ⫛♀〝⊅䞊㭺᱔ᚆ䄯㡄✐㵼䖋䞊ᆓ㸪䞊 㶲␡᱕䞊࿽は⛫㵹᱖ᦋ䞊໳㸫Ⴚ㸭᰽㭻Ñ䞊㭼㏊䅐䃹䑟᱕㭽⮫䞊ᔬ㏨㟮᧣ᰩ㠲䞊⛬ば䞊ғ ‫۔ۓۓ‬䞊ნ⾾ᦜ䞊ᦇ⛭㭾ᚇ䄯㭿䛬⛮ほ⊆䞊㵺␑ᮕ䞊㛛㏂㮀㮁☱ႌ൚♀⮗⛯㸬䕳䞊㑈⚇ぱ൙✆⮗㸭㠲ᆮ⮥⛹も⊀䞊 ☱ゃ᧤☱䍦⛰᧥䄵ᅪ⮕㮂䞊♀ほ㵼㏨䞊㸮⎣᱗䞊࿾ひ⛱⮥ᙺ᧩䞊໺㸯Ⴭ⮥ஏপ䞊 ੇᚄᚓ㎹㠳ᦇ☢〠⊇䞊㸝㎿䞊 ௾ૠೡ䞊ᦃ㏻ᚈ䆗䙺⸪ܺ⾾㠸㮃 ʌ䞊㮄ᮝ䍤ᰆ㠹ᆵ⬾䞊㑉䞊㵹␛᱘䞊㛜␒㏊び 䞊⸫䆜やᔞᤡ㠴㬖䞊✍㑔䆘ぴᦓ䞊⛺ゅ䞊㵼␢ 䞊㛝␓㎿ふ᱙䞊␔㏨㑊ජ䞊㎿⁰䞊 ੈᔭ䆙䞊ၷ䄯ᔮᆠ⛚᧙⪗Œ䞊ᆯ䞊㮅ᱚゆ☷㎴㟆䞊ᅳ⮬Ȣແ݀বÏ☱ᦑᆰ䞊㏊㚰ᚉ㠩ʱ⛽㸰⛲䎊ᱛ䞊ᗹᄇ㛞㸱䅎㠴᱕ᦅ䞊⸬䞊ຒᓷ♺㭨㸱ᆐ⿟䞊⸭䞊ฎᆱ㠽ᚗ⏫䞊‫؛‬ϳϴ‫؜‬Ű䞊ᙐ㑋䆚⬲᧦䞊␝ᱫ䞊 ⮌⛳⾾⫝̸ᯜ䄧Ř䞊ᆪ㵺䞊⮭ᱜᆶ㬅㶫䞊☱ぶᦋ☱ܽᗾᘆ࿿䖌ş䞊㠵㎵䞊㵹ᯓ⮮ᱝ㛏⎣㏂ぷᱞ䞊へ䆠ⷃᔍᱨ㠺㬖䞊✋す䞊㸲␕ᯍ䞊✂ʕʬ✃⾾⛳㶑᰹ᦂ䞊༐㸂ᆷ㶋ᰜ㬖ʩ䞊 ๕べᯎ䞊㎹ⁱ䞊㶏␖㑌㬖ᱟ䞊က༑ɳ䞊 ぺ䅶⸮ᔞᱠ㟒㭒䞊♋㬖䞊㮆䆛ᔞ㬖ᚊ㠿✇ᔯᱡᦲ䞊ܻ㏨䞊ᔰ䖍䞊㵻⎝ᱢ䞊੉་ຓୋ๖ව䞊ୌ㑍⛴㛟㏤㠶ᅩű☢㐵ほś䞊䑧␜⛻ᚋ␗䞊⛔㮇䞊⮯㏊ᗽᆛ㶡ᱣ᧡䞊☱ぼ䞊੄㮄㛅ᱤ⾾ś䞊

ʮҙҔ ‫ ہ‬䞊

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 11 of 18

 

୍㎿⬹㑺㡛यᧉ㏗Ś䞊Ⴭゎ᧪䞊⸲Ⴭ【ჴ⊈ᮩ㮏䞊㸼␣ᱬ䞊 ᅰ⁺₆ᇽ✑㡅㬱䞊㏯⁻Ҡ␑ᰨ䞊୎㏛⭀㏁㟆ᇴᚘ㎿䞊㟘㪥Ī᧳ᚽひᚙᱭ䞊஢⁼㡆␤ᱮ䞊༓ᆿ䆡᧫✒䞊ਸ⸳ᔞᄧ㮍㬅ᇀᨇ㑕㡇䞊 ૥ᇵツ᧬ᇻ㡤ɸ䞊 ྻ␥ᱯ䞊௿ૡೣ䞊⿘㑖㵺ᤢ᥷䞊㹁⏝ᇁ㷶䞊੊༔ດ୊๏ෂ䞊⎱Ⴭ㮌䞊Ⴚ⿅䞊䄺ʻҡʁ⮆⑊㵺ᤣᧉ䞊Ңᱰ⮽Ს㛅␦㏯⿘Ӏ঱䞊⿘䆢⹀ᔻᱡ㟚ʵ䞊 ੋ䞊ิ㎿䎋ᚚ⸴ᔱ䛭㡈䞊 Ҁ ‫ۂ‬Ż䞊‫ؠ‬ϴϩ‫؝‬䞊ఈ૕ೞ䞊㟮Ვ㬁㛦㎿ヂ㭙ᱱ䞊㵼㑗䞊㹤⏢᭹䞊൜㑘⛙‫❈ݢ‬㵺䞊೫゛㞢䆣☭㡉䖏䞊㮘ңᇂ㵼ᘠ㬉䞊㵼⏣ᇙ⮾䞊୏⯀ਸ䞊㡆㡪ᇊᙄᱡ㬖䞊␧ਫ䍠᚛䞊㡊᭹䎌ᱲᇃ⮿ᱳᧉ䞊䆤㑙䞊ᦴ⚈㠶ᰔᙄ㵺䞊 ⬺݆㚭㬹䞊ᔳᲝ㹗䑲ᱴᱵ⿅䞊݈⯐ခ㠇ऴᔞ᭜㡜㮤䞊₎㑽䅩わᧉ䞊☤ヅ䞊ၸ䆥ᔲႺ✛ᨃᇄÊ㮎䞊㛠⑇㏈ゐᱶ䞊␍㐅㎿⫞䞊ॼŵᦅ䞊ゑ䅩㫆ᔝ᚜Ό㮏䞊☱㡦ʋ䞊㹧⯀݇᭤䞊ဂ㫳㸽᚝᧪䞊 ໿㸾र݈Შ㬉ɹ‘䞊 ੌᗮᛇ㑚㟮᧭⚈を⊉䞊䛮㏯䞊ᇅ〟䞊ఀૢ೤䞊ᧉ㑛᚞䆦⸵Ხ˃Ҥ㵺Ű䞊㷱␱ᮩ䞊㵺ᱷ⭿Ჩ㛒␨㑜ん‗䞊ゔ䆱⸶ᔍᱸ㡋䞊㑝⁽䞊ᇆ䞊ᔍ㑻㪳䖐⊊䅽ᇿ㟮ᧉ䞊ᇇ㸭䞊‫⑇ݔ‬ᱹ䞊༕⸷Ŷ᧮ҥ䞊 ௑݉ゕᔩᇺ㬉㬉䖑䞊㡝⿘䞊၏ᇌ㬁⏤‫ݡ‬᚟⊋㡌㑞》œ䞊஠୊Ŧ䞊䑨␩㏯䞊䛯㑟⸸ᚠ䞊␑ᇈ䎄᭤䞊ᇹ⬺⬺ᚡ⊌ᥤ䞊ⷤऱ䖒䞊ᔳ᭝䞊ᇉ䞊䚡䚨䚡䚡䚨䚡䚡䚨䚡䚫䞊 8E(A9E'=14$E )5E2EC *%E? E>:!B&,@ +;<"E6#E

੍ᚢᙃ㎽㟆᧸✱ゐ⊅䞊㸿㐍䞊ᄦゕ䞊௯ૣ೟䞊ᆳ⊍ᚣゕ݊䞊ҴҵҊ䞊ຕ␪㏊ᘑ⸫䔥ū䞊㷳␫ᱺ䞊ఆ૤Ҧ䞊㬌䆧㬩㛩ᱻᚤ㸭㮐䞊ฏ㑠ᔴᱼゖ䆽【ᚥ᧯䞊 ᇊ⮕Ȥໂ䅝᧰゗लᚦᱽ✓⿙䞊㑬㡍䞊 ␬ᮩ✔゘≔䞊

੎⯀Ȣໃ㹫㹬᧤␭ᇋᚧᚨ☴゙䞊䑩ᇕ㮚䞊⛙ゕ䍠㑡⬺䎍᱾᧳䞊✕⿅䞊䆨䞊 ҧ ‫ۗۖە‬䞊ⷄᙗ✖ᧂ᱿ゕ㸠䞊ᇌᔵ㑷ლҨ᧱䞊

ᇺひ䞊ĭ⸳ᲀ゚ᙄˀ✿䞊ၐ㚫㬀㸂䞊 䙢⯀☡⊎␮㵺ŷ䞊䑪␯⚇ᘙ⭕䞊 㹘⑈ᲁ䞊ఁ⭿‫ٳ‬ҶÔ‫׹‬䞊ຖ␰㐅‥✲䔦䞊㑢₈₉❅ᙉᲂ䞊〝㎿䑫䞊㮑䅮㮨䎔ᮞᙄ䄭䞊⸹Ⴛ䖕䞊␱˂㹞䎎᚝䞊ᔸ᭤ᚩ‫✻ݛ‬䞊‫؁‬䞊 ’᧲㡣䖔䞊㡇䅩゛“䞊Ÿ㑣䞊㵺᭷㮦㸏䞊ᆪ✗㡎⯃❌゜ᱡ䞊㮒’䆩㡔❍㵺䕟ɸ䞊 ⮆൞䆡ʼȸ♀⾰⊅䞊⭁␯ᚪ䞊₍⬺❇⊏⏢㹀Ś䞊ᇍ⯁ȷໆ䆪ᦲ␲ᇷ᰻Ფ⸺䞊ᇎ⿮᧳䞊␳✜䛰䞊‫؞‬㭏㮓㏁䑬ҷҸᚫʶ䞊ᇋ㮍⫞ᲃ᧦䞊 㸼⏃ᱡ䞊₍⯌✘⊐␴㵼䞊ᇏ㎠Წゝᧉळ⸻㮔䞊ᇐ䞊䍠ᇑ㟆☡ᲄ㸟䕹䞊㎵⁾䞊㬉䅎㬝㛖⚇ᚬ⚑㑙䆫㮕䞊㞣䅩‫‫‬㹁✙㐱ゞ㬉ভ䞊ਬүȤໄ䄷䆬␫ᇒऌᗮ⚈ゟ䞊㹂␵ᲅ゠䞊ҹ⹍Ფ⸼ম਑㹙ᚭ᧴䞊⭁㏯䞊 ᮟ⿅㹣Ფ㡎䞊㵾⏤᭞䞊ᙄ㏪ᙉ⫟㛡ಠ䞊㑤ゾ䞊㹒䑳㑩䞊㏊ᚹᙗई㬩⛟㎵ァ㭦ɲ䞊 ੏⬺䙶໅䆭㡬⯒⏤ᇓᚮʿ‫⸽ݖ‬䞊ᓹ㡭⬺䞊␶✚㮖䞊ᇲ㬹㮗㎵ᚢ✛ᇔ㡒᯿䞊䑭Ც㡞ᲆ䞊∑䖓✜ア䛱䞊Ź㏁䞊 ၑᆷ㮘⏱❋⿘⊑ź㑥‫✣ݜ‬œ䞊ண䞊୍ʷ䞊ҩϷ䞊ᆲナᮬィᧉ䞊ᇕ䞊㚽ᅃ㡧㡰䖜䞊ᇖ㷱䞊㷷␑ᲆ䞊໿Ⴭ䄾᧵✝䞊௒ⷰᔞᇗ㬹㮙䖔Ż䞊ᇘイᦛ䞊ᔶ㏊㵼␷䞊ᚯ⮕ᅉ⛙⸾ᤆ‫᧶ݠ‬䞊ႎ␑ᇙ㹃䞊 ⯊ᔾᲤ✖䛲䞊 ⮙⯋࣭㡟ʽᚰҪ㬉䞊䑧ᲇ㡏ᲈ䞊㛢ᇐ✞᧷䞊⁉㑾㟗䞊ᔷ䕳䞊㹅␾Ᲊ䞊༖ᇚ䆮᧸☱䞊௓ⷳᔸ䛳Ț䖕ʐ䞊 த䆯㡊☫ҫҬ⊒䞊㹇⑇ᲊ䞊୐๗㹩⾮㹢঳䞊㑦ⁿ䞊✞㸭㬖䞊⸎䎏᚝㮥㹚✻⊅ჯ㵼✟㏛࣊㬮ŷ䞊㹥⑃᲋䞊 ఉ⭦‫ٲ‬೥䞊␸ᇁ㬉䞊᧹✠㭻ᛆȻˁ㑯䎐ᛂ㡠Ᲊ㡥⯑䞊㵼ᔿᇛ㹄䞊ᔹ㑧㹛⏫䞊‫؂‬ႏȠໆ䅤᧺ᔺᇋ᭞ᮤ✼⿮䞊ᇁゥ᧻䞊㹅␹᲌䞊㎵㶠㡐ʸᮦ䛴䞊✡ゑᦂ✢䎑✣᧼䅩ᇜ⯁䞊✤㡧˄䍖㑝⬺䎒ᛃᧂ䞊✺ウ䞊㹆⎱☱㮚䞊 ✳⿘ᚱᇝ✥᲍⿰㵺䞊␺ᇴ᧪䞊ᗮ㏛テデ᭜ᚲ㶌⚈㑨ェ㬱䞊㸧㎵䞊㹇ᮤ㡯㡕㐮エ㮛㹜㡡ȶ ం✦ォ‫؃‬Һ⯌䕞ŕ䞊㹈␻᲎䞊୊㑩㡨˅䆼ネ✧㵺㵼ᚦ᚝㮜䞊Ⴟ㟆᲏䞊㛅Ⴟオ✨ᚳ䆡⬲ᇦ㡚⮃䖖䞊ᛉ㑼㑪ᚗᘑ⸿ᚴ᧽䞊ᇸᔞ㑫䆯‫݋‬䞊㵺␑᭤䞊㭉Ძ㟗⛙㑬䆰㬎䞊カᇞ㡑ʁ‫ݗ‬㟆ᚵ䞊㑭₀䞊ᇟ⯍⯁Ფ⊓‫܋‬ガ✩㏛‫❀ݝ‬䛵䞊 ᘙ㑙লҥ㵺❉႒❊キ„䞊✖ギ䞊‫؟‬䞊୑✽㡢ɹ䞊⹀Ა⹁㑮㡒ᇠク᧾䆱⹂䞊₏㑿䆲グ᧿䞊ᔻ䖗䞊㹉␼Ბ䞊൝㑯⹃㵺䞊ᗫ㞤䆳✪㟆䖗䞊༉‫݌‬ᆲ₆₇✫⾰䞊㵼␽Გ䞊₋❆⮕㹡‫ݤ‬㮝䞊㏗₁ ‫⑋ݚ‬ᚶ䞊ఃⶬ⮱Ó㮞䞊 ໿ᇡケ䞊 ஥Დ⊔㑰䞊ఄ ᱡ⮕ᨀ䞊Ϣ‫ݍڭ‬ᤤ䞊 ྼ␾ᇢ㷕䞊⸌ᚷ⹉㏁㡩ᆷゲᦜႰⷿż䞊䑧␿‫ݎ‬ᛈ❄ҭ䞊ᧂ✬㬖ᙐ䆡㬁㮟ऐ䞊ᆠ⯂⯁᭼⊕Ეᨁ䞊₌✦〮ᇶトᚸ⚎ᇁ⬺䞊ᗮ㑱コゴ᭼ᚹ㸱✭㏁サ㮠䞊⏝ᰮ㹊䑮ᱡᲕね䞊 Ү㪍 ༗ᮩ㛣㹋ᮟⷥᔼᲤ㡓䞊ү Ұ 䞊⎺✮⪥Ⴭᙉ⫠Ზ㡔㬞Œ䞊༘ザһҼᨂ✯䞊౱㎵䍽ᱡ㪧ˆȹキᚧゔ㶅䞊㑲₆⇮ᚺ⛙ᇦ⮆㮡ū䞊ᅃ〟‫܋‬䞊⹄Თ⹅‫❁ݞ‬ᰨ㡅㮧䞊㑙₂䞊㷳␑ᮩ䞊༙ᇣ䆴᧳⚎䞊໠㑳䖘ᇋ⯂䞊 ₃ᇕ⹎⚇⬺䖙Ž䞊䑯ᇼ㬹䞊᧳㟚ᇾ₋㹟ᮞᨉ䞊ᔞ䕚䞊ᇤ䞊୒සૃ䞊 ㏔⇚ᙐᰔ㡕䞊

Ŧ䞊䛶ᛄ⯇䖛‫⊖ݙݘݕ‬䞊㛤シযジᇥ㟆✾⯃䕞䞊㑴ᚻ䞊

✛ス∛㡠⹉ᅆ㹝☱㑵ズ䞊∱㑙⹆䞊అૈ೦䞊⇬⯄Ვ㬅ʹ䞊 ྽␬Ი䞊୓⯅νɷ䞊㑶⁾₊♯ᘹ᭤㡖䞊㮢Კヌ㹅䞊☡㹌䞊㵺㐋䞊㵼⑉Ლ䞊୔ྼ୔䞊㹌㏯䞊ᦲᲛ㹍Ც㡮⹇✰ゕᲜ䞊䑰⏢Ო㵺␑᭷㡗䞊୊⬺ ρ䞊⑀ᇏ᧶䞊 ᇦ㪩ᨃ✱䆵㏊【ᇧ⬺䞊✲〓∜㡖ⷰᇨ㹎☫㏁セʓ䞊 ೩⯎ 䞊ᇩ⬺㬖㑙䞊㛥㠁䆻Ք✳㡭⯁ᘠ㪴䞊ᇪ䞊ᚼ㎶㛦䖚䞊㹏㐅䞊㵺⑁ᮩ䞊௷ે೪䞊ᅘ⊘ᰒゼ㵺䞊㡘࣮䛷Ⱥ㛠㑥ソ㮞❎ᔞ⯆Პ䞊₄㑷㠕䞊‫⑂ݏ‬ᮩ䞊 ұक䎓ᤥ㬋㹐♅⊗ᇫᔽ㎿䆶䞊㏗₅䞊㎵ゾᯁ䞊㑐⁙䞊㹑⑃Ჟ䞊⚈〠ᨄ♎䎕❏ᨅҽҾᆴ⯇㬔䞊ᛅ♀㬉ᚽ䅩㬁㵴ᨆ䞊✴⿮䞊㹒⏣Რ䞊⹇Ს‫⿘ݐ‬㑸㡫Ⴭ‫ݣ‬䆷✵ᇬ⹈ʐ䞊 ஦Ტ㮣㛧☱㵺᮪䞊㹦⑆Უ䞊࣯႐ᚾᇭ㡙䞊‫❂ݟ‬ʾҾ㹠ʁҲϸѺҿᇮ⬱䞊 ☤ⷤ㛨⯈ᚿᇯ㵼✖㏯゘㬀䞊㐋‫ݑ‬䞊㵼⑄Ფ䞊୕ೞ੐䞊⸾䛸⹉㏗㡉Ⴭタᧂ䅽⹆ž䞊㹓⑅䛹䞊௺૥೧䞊ᇰ䞊⊅Ფど‫ݒ‬䞊✶ひᚯ⬺ダ᧳ᤦᧂ䞊㹇⑁Ქ䞊⹀⩿⹀㏔㟢ᇷチᤃ䆸⹊䞊✷ヂ䞊ᇱ‫❃ݛ‬䞊⹋ᨇ✸䞊೨䞊✹㹨⬺䍊ᇲÖʋ䞊 ᗮᆪ㬉Ღ䞊⇭⯉ᮄ䞊ᇓ䆹᧶䞊᧶✺Ჭ䞊⿥㏊㹔䞊⁉㑽㫸䛺ド⯏䞊㹕⭁䞊㹖㑹䞊 ఆે೜䞊ಡᛀᆲ᧶㞥䆢Ⴚッᛁࣅʺ䞊 ఇેೞ䞊ಢ᭞ლᨈ㞦䆺ლニᲧ㎤Ř䞊㶌⑆ᱧ㡚ᯓ‼㑥㡣Მſ䞊䑎ॳর䞊႑㹪ウᇳ䑱ƀ⹌‫ݓ‬䞊

 0E 
-3 .E

7 DEE /E

‫ ڔ‬ҳۘ䞊

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 12 of 18

 


⪘෈༧ඤ䞊‫ءڕ‬䞊

㏞ₐ䞊㮪㹯ყ㶎ᯝ⹏Ჯノ㺜㬡䞊❐ハ䞊㶎⑌ᯁ䞊Ѣバᙚ⸾㎴㡱ᅃʓパᨊ䆇⹐䞊䆾⹨➉⯆䞊㶝④Ჰ䞊ൣ㏗❑ヒ㹂䞊೴ヸ㞠䇑❕㢃䕝䞊ᔈ㡲㒀䆿≙␋㶎䞊 㸜⑍ᮭ䞊⹑᱾ⷄ㒁㟐რ˔Ɓᦎ䇝⹦䞊
 Ӂⷿ㛪⮕⚘ᛊᆪӔэ㏁䇀㮩䞊 㹭㎴䞊㶎⑎ᯞ䞊૧䇁㢐Ჹሇ䄷×㯄䞊Ⴛビᯞ⾴㏧㒂ピ䞊䚬䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚣䞊

⯓Ø㒃㮪㭎❒⑏⬼ᛋ䞊໵ሀ䇂ᨋ❓䞊౲㒄Ƃ䙻᱈㢆ヰ⹒Ჱフ㹮䞊ୖ㏾ブヘᲲᛌ㹯❔㒅プł䞊 ⭼㒆䞊྾ᯟ㡳㡴䇞㡴❶㬨හ䛻䞊ሁヘᨌ䞊྿ᛍ㡵㡶㏾ᨍ㮫㹵䞊౳㢇㑰䄮㛫㮬䞊 ၒ⑫❲⯔Ჳ䞊✞ベ䞊㺔 ④Ჴ䞊ဃと✞㶗ᛎ㺗⮆䞊༚ළӜˎ㷁᛭㭦  㮽㒇⹤᮵䞊㒈ₑ䞊㺋 ⏀Ჵ䞊໵ 㹰᱈⹓ᕀᮕ㟕䞊ҍ ӂ 䞊⑐❕⪭ሂᨎƃᘒ㢇㮫䞊䑴Ჶ㡷Ჷ䞊❷⾱䞊ᛏ㒉⾴㹱ᄺᛐ㹲䞊䑵⛔㶝⑑Ƅ䞊ሃペᨏ䞊 ƅ䃧Ჸ☱䍦ᛑ᛫䞊㮭䇃㛬㛭㒊㠖㹾䞊㏾㡸䞊ᆴ㯍䛼❖㮮㹤ረホᙗᛑ䞊∲㒋⹔Ɔ䞊⚘ボᨐ❗䍦❘ᨑ䇄ᅃ⯕㬊䞊䑮⎱㎺䞊⹕ሄ䖝䞊⑒Ჹ䞊ᛒ㒌ヱ⿌Ჺᛓ㶎䄁ᨒ䞊㹳㒍䞊㶝⑤ᯑ䞊༛ᆴ䄾ᨓ⚒䞊 ౴㒎䎖᲻㫇⹖ᱡヲ㹴ʬ䞊࿀⑓᲼㡹Ჽ䞊❙㮯䞊❳ʁәӝ‫ݥ‬㑃ポマህ㺋➏䇅ӕӖ ₒӃϹӄӗӄ䞊ఊ૦೬䞊Ƈ䇆䇇҄৲ˏᛔƈ  㹵ˇ㚬䞊⑥⯝䞊⯖ਊ㹵䞊㹶䑶䎗䞊㒏Ɖ㹷⯫➈䎘Ɗˊ‫ݠ‬䞊⚁Әә⯬⯭⯮䎙❚ൟ䇈ˍ㯌ᕁ䞊䑷ᲾƋƌ䞊 ሆ⭹⮕Ჿ⊙᳀ᨔ䞊ӅϺ䞊ᕂᯱ䞊༜ሇ䇉ᨕ❛䞊❸ゕ㶝Ც⯞⮠☧⊚᳹ヨᛕ᳁䞊㑙⯩Ӟ❿ᘷᛖ㡺㮰ʹ䞊 ࿃⑦᳂䞊൤㏞✣ヺ㹸䞊⯯グ㞧䇊䇟䖨Ù㮑䞊㟏ᮡ䎚❜᳃䑸䞊ᛗ㑙ѢӚₜ➀⹗ӆ᳄ᨖ䞊㹹⎺ለ㷡䞊ೳ˒⑪᳅䞊 ϖˌ㹵᳆⯣⮃❝⊛䃩⯰Ӈᛘᤧ䞊୑㒐⾰䇠こ䅩⿌❬㹺䖞䞊ᆷ⯟㯇㒑䞊␮ᆷ㬆䞊⚘ミ䞊₟㒦㟏ⷿሉ㹻⚘㑙グŦ䞊⹘䄷ᛙ⑔䞊㎳ₓ䞊䑹⑕❞ᛚ⑖䞊 㡻ᤨ➆・ሇ❽」㭷䞊㬉㛮ᙺᘜ䇋⯠ˈƍ㹼⚘䎛ᛛ䞊ር⾱ᨗ䞊䖙᳇㶝䞊㶝㎴䞊ᔐ䛽䞊 ☱グᦎ䛾㛯㢈㒢ᨤ㺛⾾㶎⯗䖟䞊䎐ᱻ㠕⚈⇯᳴ᦁŘ䞊❟ムᨘ❠ᛜᄺ㷘❡ル⊜䞊㹽␋व㶎䞊༝䇌䄷㢑✔☧䞊౱䇍䍦ᛝ⹙⸾᳈ム㶝䞊㏑≃ᛞӈሊ⯆㮱䞊♁メ䞊㺕⑘᳉䞊ငモ☱㶝ᯱᨙ䞊༞㶗η㹾ᮕ㮭䞊⸼ላ䖠䞊⑗ਘː႓Üୗ䞊 㒒㹿⑘⪀㟮䞊㢒❴᳊㮞䞊㹏㒓䞊ሡ⮕Ȥ໇ሌÚ❡ᦌል䞊ሧンᦌ䞊㎿㷽⑙᳊㠕䞊㺀ᮭ㠕㠕㎳㠖⛐㯈㶎䞊≙㟐㎴䇎㚽㬆ʍ䞊 ࿁⑚Ა䞊୘㑙⹩⶿➊㸏㺕᳋ᰨ㮞䞊ᇂ㡼ᮬ䞊㛰ሎ㠕㶝Ӊᛟ䄷⬼ሊ❾䞊⭭ 䖡䞊ᛠ㒔キᘟᱜ㫈ᳵᨡ䞊ሏᕃ㐼䇏㺁䞊㵽⑛᳌䞊㮲ᰣ㠕❱㒕䇋㮳䞊⿗ᅖ⹚㟏᮱䞊㏑ₔ䞊⯘⯡⯢ᙆ⊝რ‫❢ݦ‬㏂た㯉䞊 ᛡ㒖⿗㶎ሐ⷏ᳶᦊ䞊❣ャ䞊‫ٴ‬䞊୙ෆ੕ˑ䞊⶿᭷⹛㒍㟐რ⾾ᨚ䇐ⷄ䞊₟㒧䄾ユ᧑䞊䑺❤㺍②♁⾱䞊෇㢓➋Ჴ䞊₆❠⮳ᯱ㮴䞊㏑❥䞊Ǝ⑜Ფ䞊ఎ૧ೲÝ䞊㮵䞊༟ヤ⾰䞊஧Ѣᛢ䔧㒗䞊ఋ❦᳷⮕ᨋ䞊๏ₕ⇰ᛦᲹ䞊 ࿂⑝ሑ㡽䞊ⷶ᮱ⷶ㎴㢉ᆴ⹜ɱ⮕䇑ⷄŘ䞊䑻⎺➁ᛤ⑞䞊ᨛ❧㬡ᛣ䇒㮶㬡᳍㬡䞊ሒ⯣⯕᮱≯ᮡ᨜䞊₝☧ュᄆキᚱ❹ᄏ⯙䞊ᛓ㎴ゞ⾾᭬᚛䇓㑙⾱㮑䞊ᕄ᮱㺂䑇᳎᳏⿾䞊⯤␑Ჴ䞊༠᳐㛪㶎᳀⹤ᔘ᳑㡾䞊ӊ Ӌ 䞊 ⏋➂⪮ᆐᚏ⫡ᰞ㢊㭦Ű䞊໻ሪ䄾ᦎ❬䞊౵㏞䎜᳒㫉⹝ᮕユ㺃䞊㏦₎ₛ❿ᙐ⚈ლ⯛㮷Œ䞊ረルᨢ䞊⸌ᮎ㢏‫ݩ‬ӈᔐᯱ㡫㮸䞊㐼ₖ䞊䄝Ჴ䞊໳ყ䇔᨝❨䞊໢㒑䕏ሓ⯚䞊ₗሔ⹝❺⯥䖢Ű䞊䑘ሕ㮹䞊ᦁ㢊ሩ≄ᮻᦃ䞊ᕅ䖈䞊ᄏ䞊 ୚ൠੑ䞊㏋ₚ⇳ᛤᰛ㡿䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙽 䙴䞊ヴ‫⯛ݨ‬䕙⹞⊞䞊㚽㢋✣⹟ሖ㢔➌⮆䖣䞊㒘ム䞊⚇ル₠㒨㢖⹪ሗ㺄⛡㒙ル䞊₢㢎㎳⹠䞊ఌ૘೭䞊 ⇱⬼᳓㬣ʓ䞊 ೯ヨ䞊㶎␋ᰎ⛹㟐䞊㺖᭩㮺㺅⚘⷟㎴ョ䖤䞊ᔨᱰ₆㒣㠅᳔䞊ӌ␋᳕䞊൥㒤☱⾾㶎䞊ൡ⹧ӛ䄷❩㟣䖄Ř䞊⿩᳖❪㺆⎝᳗㟐䞊㶕␋ 䞊୛ൢʸ੔䞊を㒌㟐䞊㶎⑟᳘䞊ఏ໡೮䞊䑼መ㮻䞊ᇔᕆ⮕᳙䞊㹵㑙䞊 ᨣᱻ⇲ヵ❻㹵❫䎛ᱰ⯦䕷䞊❬㺗⯧᳚ヨ㺇➃˓₣䖥䞊∝㢀䞊㺈①᭾㯊᳛䞊ଡ଼㒚㏧䇢ラ✞⹡ˋ‫ݤ‬ᛥ㮼䞊စљ᳜䞊᳝䔨㸢᳞‫ݧ‬Ӎӎ䞊䅳ₘ໵঴⹢᨜❐䞊㮅䇕㛍㛱㒌㟡㹤䞊₆㒨㢁䞊㺉ᛦ㢂চ㢄➍㬩ӏ䞊ሙᗵ㺊☱䎝❭㺋䕝䞊 ≙⯙㎴ᔌリ⯨⮕䖦䞊㏁㢃䞊䑽❮㺌⎮✑⿻䞊㶎␋ᯱ䞊ဃ⾰☭㶎᳟᨞䞊༡㺍ᆴ㶎᳠㮽䞊ᆴヹᨘ䞊䄞᳢䞊᳡䔩㵹᳢ヨ㶗䞊㵹㒛䞊䑂⑧❼ᙐ⎝䞊㬗䇖ᙚ⎝䞊㮺䅩㚽㛒᳣㟮ˉŘ䞊⚘ₙ䞊❯㺋䞊᳤䔪❬㮾㵽㮿ś䞊⚋䛿䞊 ❰ル㺋ᮕゕ㶎⚘㒜をሪ⬼䞊㑙㟣䞊⛐ξӐ㒝ᛧᙖヶ㷁䞊✔ル䞊⾰ሚ㺝䇣㠖᳥ɲ䞊 ૧㒞㺘⑨䞊㶑②ᰞ䞊௷ૈ೯䞊ᄈレᦎ䞊ଢ଼೰੒䞊⎱ማ䎞᳦䞊☯䇗ᦡ☱ᛨሜӑ᳧ᦅ䞊㶎㒟䞊㺙⑩᯵䞊୞㒠ⷮ⹣❱䇘ᛩᥢ䞊㶎③ም㶝䞊 ⯪⎺ᯱ䖧䞊ሞ㟣᳨䞊ロ㎳䑾䞊Ⴚ≙≯㡫ᳩ㯀㬆⛐䎟ᳪ⮕䕙䞊㚽䄷㢄༦ဈဉӇ≙䞊༥ᆪ䄷᨟☱Ƞ㢄ᳫ⬼ᆿ㶝ᮞᦁ䞊㺎ᳬ㟐㠰㒖Ӓ➄₤➅⹤䞊❲㯁㯂䇋ᳱ㯎ɫ䞊 ທ㢕➎㒡㟣䞊㺐㏑䞊 ༣᭿㛲㶗ᳯ⹥ᕇᳰ㟏䞊ҝ ӓ Ř䞊㶕⎱ᯱ䞊఍૨ೱ䞊ᓼ㛒ሢ㢅Ზキ㸜⮳䕻䞊ᨠ❳ᦇ䞊ሣ㎴㶸䞊₡㒩᛬䆽㬩䞊➇ホ䍤᚛㬌㺚☢⊟ሤ䇛䎠ȼ ༤ሥ䇋ᦁ⛡䞊ヮᄋ㺑❴㏑ごሦ⬼㭄䞊⛡ー䞊 㶎␋᳭䞊ဆヽ❡㶝ᳮᦃ䞊༢㶎ॴ㶝Ა㬒䞊ᧉ䇙ᱜ䞊㺁㎴䞊໵Ⴜ䇚᧶❯䞊੗㢍ሟᔕ☬ৡÊÄ䞊㯋㶎ᇈ㵹䆿㯃䞊ሠț䞊 ራヷ䞊੖⸌Ჴ㟐☬ᚇሬ䇡䞊•ሡဇ㺏Û䞊ɹ䚬䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚣䞊 䚬䚢䚢䚢䚢䚭 ɱ䞊੓䞊㢌᳸㛳㟏ᤩ㬒ᯃワ㷆ᄋ㶎❵Ə䙾ᳱ䞊㎳ₚ䞊㺒␋ᳲ䞊௩ந⭚Ê㯄 ⯜䙿䙿䙿䙿䙿䙿䙿䙿䙿䚀䞊 㺓ᛪ㯅䇜₞⚁ᙺᨋ䞊✷㒥䞊ᛓ⬲㎿㯆ᳳ᧨䞊




Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 13 of 18

 





   

˙䜀㠅➨ヾ⊯㬠䞊㵹ᔎϚƐ䞊㛴㢗❭㑍㠋䞊⯱㒪䞊༎ᛮ㛵⯲ᳺ‫⾾ޅ‬ᕋᛯ㟆䞊ӟ Ӡ  䚮䞊㻁⒈ᱚ䞊ఐ૭೗䞊㠅᳻ᛰ᱅➐䎄ᴅᩀ䞊ʍʍ䞊⾰㎿䞊㢵ᯎ㛶㒫㢘㻊❭ゆ≵䞊∳㓕‫ݼ‬ㄫ䞊ˣ⺁䕞䞊ⷳ᭟⺂ᔶ᮱㡅䞊㒹₥䞊㵹⎼᭠䞊 ⯳⾰㸢᮹Ⰷ⬶⛒⊠᳼⾾ᙍ᳽䞊ୟ㐘‫⹫⾽ݪ‬䇤ㄬㄭ䖩–䞊㷕⑬‫ݫ‬ヿ䞊㺞⑭ᱧ㢘᭴䞊‫ݬ‬㯏䞊‫آ‬䞊䚡䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚡䞊 㛷㢙ᴏ㬡᳾⾰ᘖ᳿䞊☥㄀䞊㺟⑷ᴀ䞊෉䚁㄁♃㸼ᱭट䞊໹㶄ᆘ㷕ᴁ㯐˕䞊 ⯴㵺䞊㮦⑬㏋䇥⮕ᦂ䞊ᔍᴂ䞊ᘖ⬶ᴃႺ㟆䞊㶡⏃჏㵹䞊㷕␖⟉㬡䞊൫㓐➑⹬䞊⯵⿙㞨䄹❭㟜䖪䞊ᕈሮ㬡䞊ⷢუᦁᴧ䞊㄂㑗䞊₳♂〟ሯ⬶䞊ᦁᯓ㵻ᯓㄶゆ䑿ቚ➹➒㒬㄃䜁䞊უ㯝䞊㷕㎶䞊㷢⑬ᱧ䞊 㢫᭟⯶➓ሰᕉ➕⯷➔㺠䕜䞊㒉㟆䞊㬩䇦₰₱➺ᛱ➕ᴄ⿲ᛲ䕧䞊㏝₀䄥ᛳ䞊➖˚ㄮ₯㓑㪼ˠ⟄㷕➕㏝㄄䞊㢚ᛴ⊡Π‫ހ‬ᨿ➺ㄯ⊢䞊㶗⑱ᴒ㮹Ც䞊⚯㬑㮡䇧ᴷ㯥䞊㶔Ⱅㄅ‫ށ‬ʁ㷕䞊䑅ᴅ䞊∞䅆ㄆ㢷⬶䞊ᙍ㒝⾰㵺უ⚈〮ᰆᨥ䞊‫ݭ‬ㄇ䞊఑૩ӡ䞊 ሱㄈᨦ䞊ୃⰓθ䞊ᨧ㑇ᛵ䇿ⷂᲘ〟㶞㯑˖䞊 ⯸㻈䞊䑻ቀ㯝䞊⿉㒭㵹䞊㺡⑮᭼䞊㷢ᅯ㯧Ⱄ‫ތ‬䞊㒮₦䞊㹖⑯♁㯒䞊൬㎿㢬㄰㺢䞊್ㄵ㞩䇨⟁㟮䖫䞊㷢㎳䞊ᙒ㎿ㄉᨨ䄹ᛶ㺣䞊㵺ᕊᜆ䞊⫢➕㢳˨ᤊ䞊㒯₧䞊ᴆ䔫䞊㺤ᯎゼ䞊㬣㺥䞊䍚 ᴇ䞊 ➗ゆ䎡᜛㬣㷢➘⊣ቄ㷕⚯㒉䇩䞊㺦⑰ᆞ㷕䞊䒀㒰䇥䞊೵ᦉ䞊ᔕᴈ䞊㢛ᲊ㞬䄮⚫㢰᱈ᩀ䞊Ӣϻ䞊ᨩ⹭‫⹮ݮ‬ј➙ㄊᛷᦓ䞊㷢Ⰸ㻂ᚴ䞊㵺㢛䅫ᴉ䞊㯓♰ 䚂ӭӮı⟂ᛚቛㄱᛸᗮ䞊㒱₨䞊⯹⾾䖫䞊㯔䄶᛹⑱䞊᜝Ⰾ⮘ᴊ⊤᭞㻋䞊 ᘖ㏿ㄋ㒲ᮎᗮ঵Ѣ㒳ゆ㬳䞊㶗㏿䞊㷢⑲ᰋ䞊༨ሲ䇪ᦓ➚䞊౶㒴䎢ᴸㄲ⹿᮱ӯӰӣɸ䞊 ๏⾰䞊ࣛᮕ䞊㒵⿥ᴋ䞊⑳ሳマ᨞Ƒ䞊ሴ㹆䞊%
D 㛸㒉㯕㬖➻ᕐ⯺Ფ䞊䚃⑴ࣣӤ䞊㺧⑵ᴌ਋䞊⫤Ⱁ䇫ᦈ㯖䞊㒝₩䞊 ᙈ㒶〟ㄌ᱅ᛲѵӱϼѢӱv䞊᛺হƜƝ䇬⒉Ӳ䞊࣏䅫ε⪐⪒㺨ő ΋䞊❹⹯⯻❹᛻χ⯼᜞䇽䞊➛ㄍ䞊ስ䞊䚨䚢䚨䚢䚨䚨䚨䞊 䇭ᨪ᛼൦䞊‫ݯ‬䇵⯽Ń䞊 ‫أ‬Ƒ䞊‫ؤ‬ϽϾ‫إ‬ż䞊 䚄Ñ➜⾾ᙗ㓒‫ݰ‬Ӵ㵺㢼㎹䎣ᴍ⹰àᔚ⮨᛽䞊Ფ䎤⚝ᦎᴎ⾾ᘨᯎ䞊㹅⑶㯗䞊㵺⑷ᛑ‫ݽ‬ᴏ䞊ƒ㯘䞊㬀䇮㛃㛹㓂㟙㹖䞊‫ݱ‬㒷㟜䞊㶞⑸Ფ˧䜂ᴐ䞊㷕ᤋ࿄㒸㪪㯙්䜃䞊䒁➝㺩⎻⟊ㄎ䞊㺪⑹ᱧ䞊༨ሶ䅁ᩁ❹䞊 ౬㒹䎥㻌‫⹲⹺ލ‬᛾㒺➼ʩ—䞊 ๘ㄏ䞊㵺⑟ᴑ䞊㒻㷢⑺ᴒ㠐䞊⎣ሷ⹱‫ݲ‬Ŕ䞊➞㷢䞊⑻䞊቟⬺㬩㏯䞊㛺㒉㬛㯚➟ᕋ⭀ᴹ䞊㺫⑼ሸ㺬䞊₺䆓㢻㺱⏥᭦㢜䞊 ➠ゾ˜᛿䜄㷕➡
ሹ㶗‫ݳ‬ᜀƚ「䞊㒼₪䞊㺭⑭ᴓ㮜᳻䞊ˡ⟅Ⰹ⬰ᴔ䜅ሺ䇯㏻⿭䜆䞊 ᜁ㒽䆓⯾ᦷ䞊㢶ᴾ䍗᱘ቜ⬲䞊⬼ᴺ⊥♋㻎⛙⹲ქ㷢ᴕƓ䞊ሻㄆ᨞䞊➣㢱ӮˤƔ㏁ᜂᳮㄒ㷕ő䞊ᴖ䔬㛦⬼‫⹳ݾ‬Ⴚ➢☱㏀ㄐ㭆䞊₵㓑㟆䞊㺮⑽ᰔ㬊Ფ䞊ሻ㬎㯛㏁ᜃ⛪䇰䇱㏁㎷㬠ʷ䞊 ౷䒂ᴗゆ䞊㷕⎣ᴘ䞊㯃ᴻ㠹➽㎿䄲㬡䞊ㄑሼ㻃♄㐁ㄒᅤ⬼䞊㬗‚䄹㢞➣㺥䖯䞊➣ⷳ㛻⬼❭ᛤሽ㺯➕㒾ㄓ㮌䞊㏁₫䞊㵺Ⰹӥ❭㯜䞊➕ゆ₶㏴‫ވއކ‬Ӹሾ㠸♁㏁‫ޅބ‬ŕ䞊⑾㒿䎦ƕᰇ䎅ᱧ㢝Ɩ䞊㶗⑽ᯀ䞊 ⮕᭞ሿᜄᜅ䜇㬡⏣☪㛼䞊㎿‼䞊㻄⒊᭬䞊൧㎳➣〟㶝䞊൨⾰㞪䄳➤ Þ䞊⛒㬡䞊㢞ᴙ₷㓖⺃〝⊦䞊㶝⏃ᴚ䞊㯝㷢ቀ€㢟㬥䞊ᙍ㎳⹴㛼➗⯿ቁ㺰❭㎳》䞊㎿‫ݴ‬䞊㢠ᜆŦ ᰩ䎧঄˥㺱䞊☪⿉₵㓗㢨ⷢჴ㺱♁㏋ㄔ䞊㺲㓀䞊ᔍ㓁㺳⏑䞊 ‫␓ݿ‬ᴛ䞊ఒ૪➥䞊ቝㄳᦁ䞊‫⑿ݵ‬᭚䞊ୢ෌‡䞊₸㏴㢡䞊⟍ょ䎨ᴼ㭦㷢⚃≰ቂ㺴➦䍕᱄䞊㢢ᘖ䍕➧஑䎩䞊በマᨫ䞊ቃ㛽㛡㢣㏞㛅㢭❭ቄ㷕ᴜ䞊➣ㄋ䎪ᜇ㯞‫ݶ‬Ӧ⊧ቅѾ➨䎫ᚊ䞊ቆㄕᨬ䞊⚫〱㷕ᴝ⮕⮕✓⊨ᴞㄖᙍᴟ䞊 ˛˜䞊ᘖ㺵➩㓂ㄗ˗䞊

ຒ㓃䜈㭶➪ᕌ⮯ᜈ䞊ୠ㒄䄴㓄ᜉᘺ⭯Ⰺ㐼䇲㭇䞊૫ᴠ㵺䒃ᮞ᮱ㄘ䞊㻅⒋ᴡ䞊༩ᴢ㛅㹮㢮˝⹵ᕍ᮱㡜䞊Ⰰ䞊ӧ䞊 ಣ➫⪯ቇᜊ⫣ᴣ㡜㯦䞊ቈㄙᨭ䞊༪቉䅁㢤⭑➬䞊౸㏞䎬ᜋ㡕䇾⹶ᜌ㓅㺶䞊๙ ₨⇴ᚳ♙ቊⰁ㯟䞊 ➭䇳䞊㺷⟋Ⰿ㺸䞊ည㓆➮㷳ᜍᦛ䞊༉㵻ቋ㺹ᴤ㯠䞊 ೌㄚ䞊㟆᚝䎭⛒ᜎ䒄ⷚ䜉䞊ఓ૬೛䞊ᨮ㐌ᜏ䇴⸠ࣰ⿭㷕㯡䞊቏‫ފ‬Өᨯ䞊㺺⑾ᲊ䞊ୡ⯾㢲ß೹˞䞊⹷ᴥⷔ㎿㢥ቌㄛᨰ䇵⸠Ŧ䞊㶔⎣ᴦ䞊൭㓓䇶҉㸓䞊ೞㄜ㞫䇷➾䖬䞊༨䇼ӳ➯‫⎻ݷ‬ᅯ㭦䞊 ᴧ䔭ቍ⹸➰ㄝᮕᨦ䞊❭〱₹㓑㢡⹾቎㹔➕㏋ㄞ䞊㭓䇸⊩⊪ᴽ㯣㻆➿ㄟ⊫䞊㺻⎶቏㷕‫ݸ‬䞊 ๚ㄠᴨ䞊⛲⿢ᨱ♙䎮➱ᨳ䇹䜊˘൩䞊䒅⒀㏲䞊㛾㢸㒸䎯➲ᨲᴩᨳ䞊ࣤᜐ㯢ө㺼ψࣨᜑᴪ䞊Ⰻ๛䞊ีॵ䒆ቐ₭䞊ࣥӪ䞊‫ئ‬श䜋⹹ӫ䞊ቑ㎦䞊ඨ㢴˩ष➳➴ᨴ䞊‫Ⰲٵ‬Ȫਙ䎰Ⱂʋ⟀ㄴᨵ⒁ॶ㢯䞊Ӭ⾬䜌䚅䞊 ⒂ᴫ䞊᜜㓔ㄑㄸᜆ‫঺ދ‬㻇ᮒᨶ䞊‫ނ‬ʋ㓇䞊㻍⒍᳋䞊༫Ⴚ䄯ᦎ➬䞊౹㏁䎱Ψ㢹㢺࣐ƛ⟃ᜒ⿩㻈ʟ䞊 ੘䞊শষᜓ᜔㓈〝᜕䞊⟎ㄷᨷ➵䎲➶ᨸ䇦ቒ⬼䞊䒇㢦ʍ㓉䞊ⷂቓ䖭䞊Ⰼ൮ˢ⟆䎳ᥖ䞊 ᕎࣱ‫ݹ‬स䞊➣ㄡ䞊 ᘖ㏯ㄢ㷕䇺㶩䞊䒈ㄣ⏃䞊൪೶Ȭ೷䞊Ⴚ䙎ⷳ➰䞊ቔㄤᦂ䞊ਖ਼⬼Ƚฐ➕⟌Ⱀᦰ⒃‫ا‬㢧䞊ह⯄Ɨ㓊䞊⑟㓋㭵䞊㵺✫ᚴ㮌䞊㷕ㄥ䞊㻉⒌ᮟ䞊༬ω䅁ᨹ☯䞊౺㐀⶟᜖⹺ⷥ᜗‫ܮ‬Ӷ‫ݺ‬ū䞊⹻ᤪ⬼䅕ᨺ⹼৞䞊 ‫ݻ‬㑯‫ރ‬ӷ⾺䄙᜘Ѿ♂㒶ㄦ㬱䞊Ⰳ㓌䞊㺽␖ᴬ䞊༭ቕ䇻ᨻ⛙䞊ਗ਼⺀ᕏႺ㬋㬥˟ӵᨼ㓍㢨䞊Ⰴ㒮䞊㵺⎟ᮎ䞊ဋゼ⟏㷢ᴭᦎ䞊༮㷢ᆷⰅᴮ㬡ɫ䞊 ⬺䞊⑌ᴯƘᴰ䞊➷㯣䞊㢩ᴱ㚴㏂⹽ㄧ⊬䞊⛨ㄨ䞊ఔ૮೸䞊₴⟈Ⰽ቞˦䞊 㺾⒄ቖ㺿䞊㛟ᴲ㡕㯤㏝ゆ㬉䞊⒅቗䎴㢪䞊ᆭ⯕⮕ᴳ⊭᮱ᩂ䞊㻅⒆ቘ㸂䞊ᔚ㏞෋ƙ䞊㓎₮䞊㻀⎟ᴴ㮁ᴵ䞊♆ㄩ㪎⛪䞊䎵 ⚘䞊ᨽ䅁቙Ⰶ㬑䞊⹾‫⟇މ‬䖮䞊ᔨᴶ䞊༯ቊ䅕ᨾ☷䞊 ➸ㄪ㹶᧖⒇⊮᜙「᜚ᤫ䞊 㓏₲⇵ᘖ᭬㟙㬡স䞊

࠸ȓȄ࠼

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 14 of 18

    


⪜ஐ๢࿊䞊

࿅㓘ᴜ䞊༰᥾㸢ᜟᵻԒᔫᜠ䜍䞊ӂ ӹ 䞊⎝؎ㄹᘹ⫥᭡㢽㯴䞊⹀ቡ䖰䞊⏬ቢ䎄ᴿ䞊ᕑᵃᵖ⿉䞊⺄䞊ᜡ㏃び㻰ᅤᜢ‫ގ‬䞊䒉♝㶪⒎䞊㓌㻜⒮ᵀުɆ ༉ᅡ䈀ᩃ⟐䞊౭㓙䎶Ჶެޭ⺥ƨᘠ㓚‫ޏ‬䞊 ㏁⃃޴⟛ᜣ✦ᝌⰰ㯨䞊⟑⾾䞊㶢⏃᭫䞊ဌㄺㄻ᮶ᩄ䞊໿㵹ባ㢾ᵴ㬏䞊㛿ㄼ㏁㢿䞊⬴㓛䞊㷒⎭ᵁ䞊༱ᵉ㛙㶌ᱜⷤᔫᵂ㣀䞊Ӻ ѭ 䞊٦ぃჍᝋ⫦䜎˪䞊‫⺅ސ‬ᩅ䞊 ༤൯䆣ᩓ⟒䞊౻㑙䎷ᗾⷃⷣᲿㅃӻ䞊㏙₻‫ڮ‬ᜤѹႺ႔㬗䞊⟓ㄽ䞊‫ޑ‬⒏ᵃ䞊ဍㄾ⟔㶎䜏ᩆ䞊༲㶎ቲ㶌᮹㯩䞊ⷎቤ䖱䞊⎝‫ب‬䎸ᰖ䞊㣁⛜ᵕ㬡䞊㵹㓜䞊ဿ㮢ᆍⷣऺ䞊!‫゛⟕ٷ‬䞊෎޳⟾ᦧ#ޮ☣á㯪䞊 㻏ᯁ㟒㟒㏁㣂⠇㬗㶌䞊ㄿᵄ㻱䒔㒊㣂⫧˫䞊

๜⸢‫⟱ޢ‬㡪䞊ብ⮗Ⱦ૯ቦ䖲㎳䈁㣜䈙⟸䞊ቧㅀᦋ䞊๝㯫ᇔ⸢ᇔ䞊૰ყ㯬㯬ㅁ‫⺆ޒ‬䞊 ࿆䑅㏁䞊♖「᥸♅䍫Ӽᩇ㻦݇ቨ⮃㬣䞊⫮⾾㐒䒊⿉䞊㻲㔁䞊㷎⏃᭻䞊కㅤ㻳䞊㜀ぉ㏁㟏䞊㶖㓞䞊༤ᵅ㛢㸢ᯁ⺇ᔧᵆ㣂䞊ӽ Ӿ œ 䞊‫ة‬Ͽϴ䞊೺䞊䚆䞊 ๞⺈ॽ䞊Ⴚ⬼Ƞ૱٧䖳㓝☣޵⺉☱䞊ቩㅂᩈ䞊 ๠㰋˺䈘ㅬቪ䞊ਜ਼Ⴚ㬆㬆⿉ᩉㅃ䞊ȿ ⷎჍ䕗䞊⑌ᄋ䍮ᴰ䞊㚹㟏㏁䎁⛜ᩊᥞ䞊ቫ㯭㬆⟖㬡㻐ቬㅄᛤᵇ䞊㓞㣃䞊㬁䆡㜁㜂㓟㠕㶎䞊㶂㏹䞊ሏ‫˲ޣ‬ತቭ䙞ⷃ⟗䞊ቮ⿉䄣䞊 䈂⬼ɀฑӿ⒐ᩋ⒑჊㣄䞊䒋⒒✪⮗ 䞊⭊⒭ᜥ䞊 㺐䑭㏁䞊⒜☫⪰ᆠᙄ⫨ᵈ㣅㯮ɂ⭊㒚Ɂᕅᯗ䞊䒌ᵉ㣆ᵊ䞊⮗⠆䎁☱ヌ⊰䞊♏ㅃ䞊໵ᆰㅯ䞊ன☱ᵋ⊱㓌ʍ䞊 ၓԑѥ☫⮗ᵌ䞊㶪⏊ᮙ䞊ᩌ㏁ᗹ䈈⹀᤬「⭊‫⪴ⰳٹ‬æ䞊䃤၀⟘㣇⫩ㅅᘹᜦ䞊㶗␍ቢ㶪䞊ቯⰖɂ૲ተ䖴㎯䈖⺡⟙䞊 㜃㣈㑅䎹♣ᩍᵇᦐ䞊ቱƞ⟲˳⺊ʓ⿗ᜧᥗ䞊㻑㏃䞊ቲ⬷ɀⰧቤ䙏ⷤ⟚䞊ቲㄺᦻ䞊ᅖⰯ䚇ฒ♣⒓᧞⏛‫ڑ‬㢿䞊Ԁ㯯䞊㬡㓠⮗⛙㼀⭿Ř䞊㵹⒜ᵍ䞊⃄⟿Ⱇᵎ㯰䞊ᘴ㏁⿗㹌Ⴭ⛳「䞊㑩ㅆⰘ䖇䞊⮲⟛⺋☱㶌ᵏᦻ䞊ୣ႕â൰ᦧ⩳⿗ᘍᵐ䞊 㶂⎝ታ㵹䞊୧Ⱞwᄩⷣऻ䞊્ᆩ㯱㬆⿗Ⴚㅬ䞊␋ቴ᧞䞊ᜨ㏁「㶌ትᜩ㼁㯱䞊䒍✤㻒⏃䞊㶌⒔䃪䞊‰๟䞊ⷄᩎ☱䎺ӈᦧ䈃ᇠ႖㯱ʏ䞊 ၒᕓᯂㅇ䞊‫Ⱈ⟻ޱ‬Ȣಥቹ䙐⺌⟜䞊ᇠカᦻ䞊ᆐ⬶Ƞณ☱⎝ᩏ⒔ᓴ䞊⺍㓡䎻ᵑᩐ䞊㸯㏁䞊༳ᆐ⾾䞊Ⱈ൵⟝ᯁ≰㏁œ䞊㓢IJɄ૲ቶ䖵㓣䄺⺎⟞䞊㜄㢧㏙䎼⚇ᥬ
䞊㶖⒕ᵑⷃ䞊䒎☱㻒⒖䞊 ᛤ㐛ㅈ㯲☱ᦁᯁ࣋ᔌ⯞ᵵ䞊ቩ㯪㮞⟟㬆㶅ᆩㅰᗹ ɰ䞊 ૳ᮚ⃆㔅㣉ᯇ䞊㻓⒗ᵒ䞊⒘ԁ൱ቷᜧ⫪ᜪ㣋ङ䞊ⷣ㓤䍕ᵶᩣ䞊㻔ㅉ䞊䒏⟳㸡⑤䞊㶪⑆ᮬ䞊⬰㐱ㄓ⊲Ƀ㻕⛜ⷄᵓ䞊ఖ૕್䞊 ☱ㅊ⃇㔅㣉⸏ᄩく‫˴ޤ‬䞊㻖⎾ᵔ䖶䞊 㯳Ⱉቸ䖷ᵗ㪻䞊ᆲ㸯䞊ㅋⰚȠ૴䈄䖸㏄䅑㫊⟠Ô㯴䞊ቹ㛅Ⴭ㟆㸢㪟ᜫㄓ㻗䞊∟㟆䞊㯵Ჶ䎽ᵕ㣊ᄒ⮗䞊ᩑŠ䕝㭨䞊䈅䈆㵹⟚⯥䞊ᆩ⮗Ȣ૵ቺ䖹㏁䈇㫡⪱䞊 ㅌᕒⰛࣲ䞊㻘㓥䞊∏ㅍᦂ䞊‫ޓ‬⒙ᵅⷄ䞊ᅤ「䞊 ᅖ㜃ㅥ˵œ㵻ঐ㻬޹ㅎ⟴˶䞊 ੜⰜɂ"‫ٸ‬ቻ䖺㐱䄻⺏ѕ䞊Ⱘ⎝᤭ㅏ䞊ᘹ㏁Ʉ㬌⟡⎙ᵘᩒ䞊㵹⑤ᜬ㻙೻䞊⮗ᯁႺ㯶ᵖ䞊ᅖ〡᧞䞊ⷱᄫ䕗䞊⎝ᆍ䎁䄂䞊㜅Ⴛ☱ᩓ䞊‫ޔ‬⒚ᵗ⟢㣋䞊ऽ⃁㯷‫ޕ‬䞊⺐㐱「㻴⏃×㯸䞊㟜ᗾⰩⰟ䞊ቼㅐ᧹䞊 㬑ᰜᝇ䈃㟏⛜㻵䗁䞊ᩔᵘ㛍㓦㬑⟣㻰ʓ ӈ䞊 ੣⃂⟽ᵕ㣂䞊ᆡⰝɅⰪⰫᄫ䙑⺑⟤䞊ቤㅱ᧞䞊ች⮆ȩด⟜⎝ᩊ⎝ᆩ㡪䞊⸏㓧䍮ᵙᦁ䞊⟘ㅅ㷻䜐䞊㶌⒛ᵗ⟣Ʃ䚈䞊ቾƟƟ⺒䞊‫ت‬㜆़㣀㶗ⷱᜭ⾾ԂŘ䞊ㅑ⮗Ȣ࿇₿ᄸ䖻㏓䈈⺓⟥䞊 㻚⏃㟒ᵚ䑊䞊Ⴚ䞊㛡ቿ㶠㻶䗂䞊㹸㓨䞊䒐ᜮ႘ᗮㅒ⺔ᵛ䞊㻛⒜ᵜⷢ䞊㸢㏁䞊ԃ⎭ᮃ䞊໵ኀ「䞊ப⛳Ჺ⊳㓩䞊ᜯ㒹㫩ㅍ䈉⶞⪲ 㻜䖼䞊 ಢᵝ䞊ᄿ⮗㯹㓪䞊㻝Ⴭ㮞⫫ᵷᩤ䞊ต㐛ਇ⒝ኁ㣀䞊੝ᔝᩕ䄯Ⱜ⮗ኂ⏘œ䞊 ኘㅄ㑩㻞⒞ɧ䜑䞊❡ㅄᩖ♏䎁⚐ᦐ䄯ኗ⬰䞊⃈㣘㓌ⷃ䞊‫ޖ‬ᕓ⪁䞊Ⱎ㯺Ⱎና⺢⟦ᜰ䞊ୈࣳㅓ㶌⠁޶䜒䞊㏃‼䞊໿ኙㅲ䞊஫☱᤮⊴㓫䞊ij೼୤༴஗ńˬ䞊㻟㓬䞊⏃ᵞ⯥㜇䞊㶵⒟ᘑ‫ޥ‬ㅦ䞊⊵ᵟⰟ䞊ਲᜱᜲ⭿䈊〱ኃ㻠Ფᨀ䞊ԄЀ䞊 㻷⒫ᵠ䞊ဎㅔ⟧㸢᭻ᩤ䞊༵䃳㷿ˍ‫ޠ‬㰍˭䞊 ਫ਼ᕔᩗ䆇⮗⬼ኄ⎰䞊㯻᤯㟆䏃ᗹᩘ䞊ঀ䞊㷨⒔᱄☱䜓䞊⺕䈗㰌⮗჊㵹㓌㟒Ŧ䞊⒠ᚶ⮗㚸ᤰᦐ䞊㻘⎝Ე⺖䞊⊨᭡㶘䞊ᩙԉ⟺䎾ᜳԅ㯁䚉䞊 ⮗⟵᜴ᵡㅕ䜔ᯁ㯼Ř䞊ढ⾾ᦧ䞊 ঁ㯽⟨㮞㻡᜵ᩚ䞊㷹⏃ᵕⷃ䞊❑ㅰ䞊⮗㏈᜘ኅ㹌⛡ㅖ⊶䞊ԏ⮆☲⊸⑆‫ޗ‬䞊㬑ᙗ⒡㏃㓭⯄㭘䞊ʓ 䚯䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚰䞊

ã䞊࿈Ⱐ⠂ᝍ䞊గ૶෍䞊ㅗ㓮㻸ᵸ⶯Ř䞊䈋є䞊⟩㻻㰐䞊ึ㓯䎿ᵢ⺗ᕕᵣ㣍䞊Ⱑ㓰ˮ䞊‫ث‬Ԏ൴୥‫ج‬䞊‫ޘ‬ᵤ㯾㜌㔇ㅴ࣑᜶䞊ⰱ$ⰲঊ႗䞊䚊䚋⃅⠀㣔㣕ΖㅫᜊƠኆ䞊㠮᜷घ㣌᭓䞊Ԑㅭᩛљ᜸‫ޚ⺘ޙ‬䞊  ᜹ኊ㰎⒢䞊ᩜ㓱㜈㏣⺙䞊㓲₼䞊㻺޺Ƌᵥ䞊ႛΡ㻼ㅗ㻢䞊 ኔ⺣㔂䈌㓳㹸䞊‫ح‬㯿䞊㻯⒯ᵦ䞊᜺আⰢ㻿⠈ᵳ‫ޛ‬ä㰀䞊᜼υ䜕‫⫬ޜ‬䞊ഀλ೽஬䞊‫ږ‬ԇɆ₽ᕖ䖽㓴൲ⶮ⠅䞊㰁䞊⒣ኇㅶⰴ޸䞊؈ㅘ䈍ㅙԆ䞊䈎㓵䞊㹸⒤ᵧ䞊㰂䜖⺚ᵨ䞊ᩝϊ䖾Ř䞊䐺䚱⠄㻤ኈ᜻‫ޝ‬䞊༸ဏÆ୦༶ަ༷䞊㻣ᕗⰣ䞊㻤ޯ⚸᜼䞊‫ޞ‬ơ˯⪳ީȗᝂႯ‫ޟ‬ᵹㅧ䞊 㣍ᵩⶨㅚᕘ䈜㣝㰆ᵪᨳ䞊⏤⺛䜗™䞊 ఘ૷೾䞊ื㓶䏀ᵫ⺜ᕙᲱ㣎䞊 ԇ‫ۃ‬䞊໣㣚˼㵶䞊‫ٶ‬ɬ䞊 ௔㓷䒑ᵬ䏁ᵭ㟤Ř䞊ԈԌЃЁԉ⒥ᵣ㣋䞊ఙⶹⰤ䞊ᨳ㔃ᝈ䈏⺤㻹ާ⟶ިƢ䞊ᩞ਒㻺᜽⶷䞊๡ᜪ㹸㓸ᗪ㣏䞊೿䞊㞭Ƣ䞊‫خ‬ЅІ‫ڵ‬ƣ䞊 ኉㜉㜋ᵼኊ㣐㰃䞊㻥㓹䞊㣑ᵺንᘻ⒦䞊ㅛ䞊㰄႙⟷⊷ᕚ㻾⯕঻䚲䞊ᦇ⟪⠃⃉᜾㣖ᝉ‫ޠ‬ㅜ㻦䞊᥼ㅝᝊⰭ䈐㰅Ԋ㓺ㅗ䞊 ࿉⒬⟫㰆䞊ᨱĴႚ᜿䈑㫋Ƥޫ˻ኋ㻧䞊㰇䈒㻾ᵽ㰏䞊㻨⒧ኌ㻩䞊š⟬䞊㟤ᵮ䏂⚸ᵯ䒒䞊ᝀ çħኖኍᕛ᩟䞊੟⭃Ȭʹถ⟭⒨㪵˸è⺝䞊኎ㅞ᩠䞊 ุ኏䒓ⶸ₾䞊੠⯕ɂㅟ䈚ও˹⟹ã㰈䞊ᕜነㅨ⫭䞊‫ޡ‬ᝁᜊ㚮㰃䞊⟼ちᩥ⟮ᝂኑ㻪ᵰ䞊㻻⒬ ᵱ䞊⟯㰉䞊ᝃ㓻䞊ᕝ‫ڗ‬ㅵ⫯䞊ᩡ㒋㣗ㅩ㫧ᝄㅠӈ䜘㻫ԍЄㅡ䞊ԋ⒩ƥ㻬䞊Ʀ䈓䙯㜊㔆㣙㻽˰䞊䄟ᵲ䞊㪝є޲ㅮᕞ䈔㣛˽㰊⺞ᝅ䈕є䞊㔄⃀䞊å㻭䜙ᝆ䞊 ㅳ޷ㅪ㻻䞊⺦㓿ㅢᵳ䖿൳œ䞊㓼㣒䞊Ƨち䗀䞊⺟㓽উ⟼ᜪ㻮䞊㻯㓾䞊ЂԊॷް㣓䞊੡ⰥȢ⪝˱䗃㓲䈛⺧⟶䞊ㅣ㓿⺠䞊৤Ƞದࣦ٨㪦䞊㔀䜚䞊੢ⰦȠท⟰ᩢ⒪ኒ㟯˷›䞊 ;D

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 15 of 18

‫د‬Їԓ䞊 ‫ذٺ‬䛑‫׷‬Ņ䞊

⪙ଽྦྷ؋䞊

ⱎŇ䈝㠁⠷〓⊹䞊㼂⒰ᴓ䞊㚰㔈㰑㼃Ȥ༻᜞㜍㼄ᝮ㎷ߍᕟᚠ䜛䞊ⰵ䞊ғ䞊 ⚘⿩䏄ᜇ㬖ê㼦ҏ⊺ኚ㼅♙㒰䈞Ř䞊㹒⏮ᵾ䞊ఛുԩ䞊ᩦԔ㰒ᙠ㔉䏅⪊ㅷ޻ᩧ䞊䜜⒱ኟ㹁䞊 ኛ⮕Ƞ૸ᇢ䗄㏾䈟⺨♀䞊ㅸኜᩨ䞊 ⃗㔦㠅䞊 ⺩㐐㠅ᵿ䞊ᯱ䔮⬯ᵿお㬏☲䏇ᯞ䞊㶗☯ᚚ㰓䞊㶎㔊䞊 㼆⒲ᮥ䞊໳ᇙ䅝ᦾ✓䞊౼㔋䏆ᶀ㫌⺪ᶁㅹ㼇䞊㼡Ⓧიゾ䞊㛴㡉ᶂ䏇♍㏎䈠㮰⭿䗅䞊㠅ᮝᄕ⮕☢䙒ᶬ᩺ʓ䞊 ഈご䞊 ⃕ዏᛐ㶎ƪ䞊ኝᝎᗳ㔥㣞ᦂ☫⿩≙䞊㼈㏎䞊޼⺫䞊 ๏ᝏ㶗㎵ᕍਃ㟖䞊ԕ‫ژ‬ƫ䞊‫ر‬ЈЉ‫ز‬䞊జⶣ)䞊ᦆ㏞ᗭ䈪ⷘ᭳ㆂ㷀ƪ䞊ዌⱍȡൈኞ䗆㏞䇧㣭㣶ߑ⠉䞊⒳ኞ㰤䞊 㔪ߏ޽ᝐㅺ㰔⟘䍮ᝑ䞊⒴ᯞ㰕䞊㼄㓞䞊 㵹⎟ᶮߎ䞊 ༼ኟ䈡᦭⠊䞊౽㏁žᶃ䜝⺬䈢ᝒㅻ㹤ɸŸ䞊 䙮̆⯐ᶄ䞊 ᝓ㏾ぶへ᝔᝕䈣㏞ㅼ㮀䞊⠋᦭ᰜぶ㶗⠬⇶᭱᩼䞊⒵ਓÞ䞊ԖⒶ᝖䞊ఞૹഃ䞊ࣝ㣮᮶‫ݸ‬䞊 ੨⮕Ȥणᅖ䕿㏞䇤⺭☱䞊⑰ኴᦃ䞊ᔚᶅᶆ⿉䞊አ⾰䞊መᝬߊ᝗㏞䈤へ㶎ኜ㆔ႜ䞊ኡĵ䞊㶞␋ᶇ䞊໳Ⴚ䅝ᩩ޾䞊୩☢䏇☱ⰶ䞊੤䏈ԗኢ㼉⠌㒰Ԧԧ䞊੥ᩪ⺭⠍ㅽ⠎㮣Ԙ㣬㔤㹁✓㏯㣵ߐ䞊⃛㣱㒝ⷘ䞊 &䞊ۙ‫گڶ‬䞊㵹㔌䞊 ԙ ۚۛ‫ٻ‬Ƭ䞊䒕⑁ᵀ⿟䞊 ⑁ᶈ䞊㣟ᶉⰷ㏯ᝤኣ㼊ᯞᦃ䞊ԚЊ䞊ⱅ⒌᝘䞊 တㅾ⠏㼋ᶯ᩽䞊༼㼌ኤ'䜞㰖়䞊 ˫ëႝᗳᙚ㔍㠅ᩫ⺮⊻䞊㺂㏓䞊ĶⒷᶊ䞊⃊ૺѡū䞊ቚ⮃ȭ༽እ䕞㔎䇁ⷯ⠐䞊䑻Ⴚ㮀䞊♀⿟䞊⃜㣲ᶋ㞮䇎ᶌ⿌㼍䞊᝙㣠⺯㶎ኦᙚ⬯䞊䒖➔㶎⒅䞊㷜⎯ᶍ䞊௖⺰⠑㣡䞊ኧ㶗䞊㼎⑁ᰀ䞊༾ᇯ䈥ᩬ⠒䞊 ธ⠓ぼ⠔㮀㷓㣢䗇䞊㏾⃋஫ᗳ⇓㪏㰗᳽ƭ䞊㣣ᘟ㮣㜎㎽⿩㰟♖Ⓒ⬹ᯱ䞊⃘㔧㟒䞊Ⴚ⚈㡈䞊㵹㣻ᆴ⇛᝚䞊᝛㔏߇⠨㶘㟮㔐⮕Ʈ䞊 ࿋Ⓨ᲌䞊ఝૻ೧䞊Ⓘከ㬨䞊ᇯ⭿㮀㏞䞊⮕㔑᝜ዊ㹵ᶎᨗ䞊㣤ᶏ᛬㔒㠬ᩭ㬴ƪ䞊⚘お᝝ⱆⱇᗭᅍ㸟⟘ 㼣⏆ኩ㷲䞊ठҎȢ૥ᅆ䕞㏯䍓⠕䞊㣥ᯡ᝞䜟☱䏉᭸ᩮ䞊༿߅ၖƯϵϦЋ䞊⃝㣳㔓⺱䞊 㹮Ⓓᶐ䞊໳ኪ䈦ᦂ⠖䞊น⠚㟾䈷㬆㸽㣼䕞䞊㏞⃌ఞ⠭⺽⿩ᘓ᮱䞊Ⴚ㹁䞊㔔ㅿ᭱䞊㛃㔕⠗⾰㼢Ŝ䞊 ၔ␋᭸ㆀ䞊ካ⯕ȩૼኬ䕿㓞䈭⺲☱䞊䈧㛹㜏ⱈ♙ᶑᩯ䞊㶗㒰䞊㭦᝟⏘㏀㏞⮕㭎䞊⺳䞊㸟⒅ᴦ䞊ထ⿨޿㹁Ღᦓ䞊ཀ㺅ㆁ㷓ᝠ㰘䞊⠘ㆂ䞊 ԛۜ‫ۄ۝‬Ư䞊⏘ᶒ䞊Ⓔीᦏ䞊ვ䞊൷ᮡㆃᶓ䜠䞊 ⃞㣴㏯ⷃ䞊㼣Ⓩᶔ䞊༉ᅆ䄳ᩳ☱䞊 ⱏ࣒⺴ᕠ‫س‬㰙㬥䕞Ư䞊䒗Ⓕ⠙ᝡⒼ䞊㰚㼏რ㼧ᯞᩰ䞊㼐Ⓗჲ㷦䞊ᕡᶕ䞊䒘჻㬡䞊⊼Șࣩ⪏⊽䞊ᅇ䞊⃒䈵ⱉ⮕䞊 㰛ᘟ⑚㔖ⰸዋ㟒㰜⏲✓㜐䞊⇏㔓⺭䞊é̀␀᭿䞊 ౾㏯䏇ᶖѕ㫶ᶗっ㶞䞊㏎⃍䞊ཁክ䅩᩸☢䞊੨̅ȯპᕢ♜ᇢঽ䞊ኮㆂᩱ䞊 ၕ␋♄ⰹᶘ䞊⚏ㆄ䞊 ໿Ⴚ㔗䞊ங⠚ᶙ⊾㏾Ŧ䞊ኯⰺȦ૽ኰԜ㏯䈨ԉ⹫䞊䒙ዌ㰢䞊㠁ᶚᘅᯞ☱䏊⠛⿩⊿䞊ⷖ㔘ㆅᱏ䗈䞊∴㔙߀Ԩё䞊㼑⏮ᶛ䞊༼኱䆥⠴⭴❺䞊บ⠜⺵㰝ි㣯䗉䞊‫׻‬ԝ䞊 ஫ᶜ⁰ᶖぼ㬎ᰞ䞊㶗Ⓘ㣦㏯䅝⋀⑟䞊ᄸ䞊གᆛ䇦ᩲ⟖䞊ᝊ㏊⺶㛩ው㆑䕞䞊ᗭኲⱊⱋᶝᶞ䞊䚉䚌ௗ㟖ᝢᄸごɰ 䞊 䚨䚨䚨䚨䚳䞊㔌‶ 㶗⏃䜡㷿䞊ᝪ㐐⺌㜑ኳ⿏䖹䞊 ⠝〠⃙㔨ㆆㆂᶟᩳ䞊㵹⎟᮹䞊ఉ૨ഄ䞊ኴ≅ᤱ㟒䞊གྷᶠ㛕㶞ᮝⷘᔶᯞ㢿䞊ґ Ҏ Ɠ 䞊‫ش‬цԞ䞊 㹇ⓓრ‫ݏ‬Ŝ䞊ዎ⮕㵹Ⓙ㏯䄳⋁Ⓚ䞊‫⮕ص‬ɇ௦ኵ䗊㔚䈩⺷ԟ䞊㏯㆒ⱌ䗋䞊㬥߁ј㎿䒚ᝣᩴ䞊 䈪㜒䞊ᆠ䚴ɫ䞊㶎Ⓛᶡ䞊ᝤ㓡ⷈ㚹ᆷㆇ䗌䞊๤ഇ⠳䞊㏞⾰ᯞ䞊㏎ᘟᝫ㣺䍋⠞㏎んş䞊Ⓛ᱀䞊㣧ᶭ᝛᭳⠟䏋᭟ᦂ䞊ᄕ䞊⺸㔛㣨˫㶎⏘⮕䕿䞊㬡኶⠠ा߉䗓䞊኷ⶢᦃ䞊ኸ❓⭳㓞䒛́*̂㆓ᗺ䄛䞊˾䞊 䚨䚨䚨䚢䚢䞊㰞䃴㶗ᮠᥭ䞊㵹⑅ᇯ㼔ū䞊ᅍ㶎䞊⃖⚏㣩㬡㷦ư䞊⑅᭢䞊उ㷓㹇᱓⺹㜓㼒ᶢ᩵䞊㹇㔜䞊㟮ᗳ⃓䈶㰟㼓䞊㼔䈫䞊㚴ि䗍䞊ኴ⮕Ȧ‫ټ‬Ԡ䕿㔝䄳̃ёј☱䞊٩䞊াㆌ㔞ㆈ߂Ⓜ⠡䗎䞊 㭽ᇢ⯣ᓽ䗌ş䞊ᔎ䈬㷹䞊Ⓝᰜ䞊䒜ᆦ㰣䞊㼕㔟⯂ᦂ䞊㶄ⓔኹ㼖䞊␋✷㬮䞊ᛨ㔠⺺ৗᅆ⿃ņ䞊䑐㒔䈭⮕ᨇ䞊⮕㏞䜢䞊㼤ⓐᶣ⠢㠳䞊ᤐㆉ㶗࣌ᝥ㼗䞊 ҏ⃎☜ᘓ䞊᩶⠣ᦃ䞊䜣㔡⬯䞊㚹ᇍ䗏䞊 Ⓗ⠵⺿䞊ɹ 䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䞊 ⠤ㆊ⃚㔩㣹⺩
+䞊㼥Ⓞ䜤䞊ట໤അ䞊㹝Ⓟኺⰻ䞊ኻ㼘䞊㼙Ⓠᶤ䞊㶄⠥⺻ⶠ ʍ䞊Ⓡᶥ䞊ኼ㼥ӱㆋⓈљ҉㣪㣷৴ഉ䞊㣪ⓉƱ䜥䞊䚍㒡䞊ངኽ䈮᩷♍䞊 ᗳ㔉㡉㠬䈨㛃㵹✓㔌䈯ɱ䞊 ੦ⰼȩ૾ኾ䗐㏂䍑⚂䞊Ʋ㼚⮕㭷㏞䞊⑀̄⠱ᦓ䞊⃔ࣆ᰷㞯䅪ᘓ「㶁䞊Ω㔢䈰㼄኿ᗭ㹁䞊䒝䈱⏩䞊ཅი䄲ᦓ⠦䞊ᰞ㬖㼛ክⓒⰽ⠧㰠ⓑ⺾ᗳ˿Ɉ⠰㵹㬖䞊⟿Ѣя䞊ķⓊᶦ䞊ဒボ⠵㹋ᶰᦆ䞊໳㶗ᇈ㼜ᶧ㰡ɰ䞊 Ⓥԡ䞊 ዀ䞊㟮ᯇ䍖⠨ᶨ䒞䞊㎳⃏䞊㼝᳊ⰾᶱ㚹Ⓦ㏯ㆌᴀ䞊ෑ๥ആ(䞊㟮ᶈᗳ㏯㠅ᦂ㬆ő䞊㸻⑁᭠䞊⃐૫൸䞊⯣ᶩᄉ㫍ᶌᦓ䞊㷳⏮዁㶗䞊ᅆⰿȦ૿ዂ䕞㏊䇎ⷘ⠩䞊Ԫ߆ਭⱀⱁᚠߌ᩻䞊ཆਮ䈲ᦓԢ䞊౿㏎䏌᮶㣰㟼䅪ご᝭ߋƴ㼞䞊 ᶕ㭷㶎ᓸⱂ♀㬎߈⠲ⷃᶪ⿩㼍㰥䞊⚂ㆍ䞊㹮⒳ᮠ䞊ဓ〓⠮㷀᭯ᨃ䞊།㷐ዃ㹧᭸㭽䞊ᇯ⭳⺼㒮㬡㹁䞊ⱃ䞊ЌЍ䞊㶎☱⺭ῼƳ䞊 ᕣᶫ㼟䒙ᯞᮩ⿛䞊൹ዄㆎ䜦єዅ߃䗑䞊዆⿩᦭䞊นჀ䗒䞊㑯⃑䞊‫ض‬Ўϩϡʓ䞊 ੧ᝦᝦ㑆㣫㣸ⰷ⠯⿩⋂䞊㸻䈳䞊㼨Ⓧ᮶䞊ఠ଀ԣƪ䞊዇⮕Ȥଁወ䖄㔣䇦䜧☫䞊䒟኶㮀䞊⠪㆏䞊ᘅ㏾㆐㶞ᄉᝧ㵹䞊䒠⟣ැⱐ⠶䞊ყ㷓䞊⯕ᝨዉ䜨ⱄ䞊㷳ⓕ㣻ᝩࣴ䞊⠫㪐᩸Ԥ䏍ԥ᩹䅆‫ⱑط‬㬆䞊䜩߄䞊㼠⏃᭴䞊གდ䈴᦭⚎䞊

ഁ๣ം䞊 ༹௕ාධ䞊

ⶺ%୨༺൶䞊Ώ৳䞊 చ䞊

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 16 of 18

ǽиʤɶԐÃ‫ ؀ן‬й‫؀‬ɦC¡G{΀ĵкƃҙіõ‫؀‬ȓȊǪ‫؀‬ԹÄÅҚ‫<_؀‬ԺԻʥιUճɷ
ԑ‫؀‬ɸǫ‫؀‬Լ̵‫؀‬ɍɹ̜‫؀‬ƄɧÆǰϭ΁κġ‫؀‬ȋմ£֨ӝöĶ‫؀‬ƅÇ͝λԒԓμқї‫؀‬νј‫؀‬ C*4)E˜΂ξљԔԽǶϮԂăÈ‫؀‬ȔȌÉ‫@؀‬њ̝‫ ΃ ؀‬ʯī‫^؀‬ћ̞D°Р̟յɺ!ԕ‫؀‬Ĉ“Ȝ‫؀̶}؀‬ɎƆ1ȩ‫؀‬ȍҜ"Ԗ‚dǓϫķʰ‫؀‬οќ‫؀‬Ƚҝ|‫÷؀‬ǥѝͭʱϺÊ‫ ؀‬Ȫў‫؀‬ɻ‫؀‬ԗʲĩӞʳ‫؀‬նπ‫؀‬ ɊɼֹnշAџ±Ԙ

„„

‫ ؀׉׈‬Ծ̷ֺ‫؀‬ȫЁԙҞ‫̠؀‬ρ‫؀‬ĘMƇѠ‫؀‬ĤѡčƼȬ‫؀‬ȿδɽ ‫נ؀̸΄؀‬F̡‫؀‬աε̹‫؀‬ӊ΅ҟѢ̺‫؀‬ոjʦ̻ӟ‫؀‬ZӉ‫؀ס‬ƈл‫؀‬ >"ȭςô̚չƺċŲЂ‫؀‬ɾԿ‫؀̼ ؀‬ɏɿպUσ‫؀‬ȎѣzС‹
ƉѤ̽‫؀‬τË‫؀‬ɂsԃ֟ϞҠ2‫؀‬ ɡ֩ҡ‫ͧ؀‬ғA.Ϭ‫ע‬Ӡ‫؀‬ɐÌм‫؀‬ȕυ̾ͮҢ‫؀‬ʀ‫ט‬ø‫…׊י‬ѥ‫؀ףך‬ǑcVǷбӡʴ'ԸOǹ ‫؀‬Άʵ‫؀‬žԚջʶ‫؀‬ռ͞‫؀‬Ĝ֧·ʷՀʸӢ‫؀‬ʁЃëȃʂƊңսh‫פ š؀‬ԛ‫؀‬H ‫؀‬ ŢƋբŒΈ
ϹѦЄljNJ‫؀‬Ҥƌծ϶ʹ̿ӣ‫؀‬ЅІ‫؀‬ՁТϟʺ‫ ؀‬ɄՂΉ3ЯΊQĸ‫ ؀‬ƀù‫؀‬ź¸գդ¼ƍ‫̢؀‬վ†ʻȮ‫؀‬΋̀GՃѧͯ/‫ ؀‬ɢζʼ‫؀‬XտѨѩ́Ӥ‫؀‬ŷʃÍʽ‫؀‬ʄͰĥƎţŤ‫ › ؀‬Όp‫؀‬ǣѪ̣!ʾʿ‫؀‬ ǤЇրӋӌˀЈ‫`؀‬ˁԜУФͩǖ˂ȯ‫؀‬

ɥúó0ЉìſǦֻqցhφɳ‫؀‬ʅ˃Əųĝϰğf‫؀‬Њ^ϻ͂‫؀‬ƐĹ‫؀‬ɑƑԄҔ̤‫؀‬k€ĖǯЋ΍ͱ˄ѫP˅‫؀‬o͟ϱˆӥÎ‫؀‬ĺťŦ‫؀‬нּ‫̖؀‬Ӎоҥ#‫ ؀‬ȀxĠ̛‫͠؀‬Ύˇ‫֪؀‬Ҙ‫؀ץ‬ ȨȻХɨ¤ɅЌ֡ĕḁ̇̄‫֫؀‬ƒΏ‫؀‬Մΐ̓‫؀‬χ ǩ̦ƓĦӦԝû‫֬؀‬ψѬˈ‫
؀؀‬n%ϼ‫؀‬ΑϽR‫؀̈́؀‬ɩɪǬȰ‫צ‬ü‫؀ˉ͡؀‬ω‫ק‬ѭˊ̧‫؀‬Ц̎ěժɠLԷ5‫؀‬ϊϋ]ˋ‫؀‬ӎ Ϡ֭όˌϾ̨‫؀‬ Ԟ֢ʆƔT‫'؀‬6Ҧ ‫؀ר‬ҧX‫ͪ؀‬ϯѮɵѯύ<ĻͲ‫؀‬+Ïӧ‫؀‬ӏʇֽпͅl‫؀‬Ҩ͢‫؀‬ԟ̗ǃ.DŽļˍ‫؀‬Ԡҩ‫؀‬ĽÐ‫؀‬Յ̘Ǖ‫؀‬ȝ‫֮؀‬o
̩‫†؀‬ʈǂé‫؀‬Ն\ʉՇ‫؀‬Β͆w͇¥ ԡ ‫؀‬Ǚ‫̙؀‬ľӨ‫؀‬ &ҪԢzώʧϏ
ϐ(‫}؀־‬ʊՈ‫ ؀‬Ȟ‫؀‬Γ͈ө͉‫؀‬р7‫ש‬ΔՉ‫؀‬K͜‫؀‬ʋ‫؀‬ӆ#ˎˏւҫ$‫؀‬ʨW~֯͊͋m‫؀‬ɒʌփ̪‫؀‬ե$Ѝլ•ϡЧͳĎѰːˑ‫؀‬ǧ"ȱ‫ ؀‬Ⱦ¦‫؀‬ĉĢ‫؀‬ɀĄ‫؀‬  ϑȒòƻϧЎӪ‫؀‬ƕɫ'ԣԤЏȲШЩ‫؀‬ɓӐ͌˒_ʍА‫؀‬ȁʹ͍#‫؀‬ѱ‫؀‬ȏΕʢԅ͵ձ‫؀‬Ŀք‫؀‬ɔ=с‫؀‬Ȗϒ˓;Ҭ‫؀‬Պ˔ԥ(ąϲϳ˕ȳ‫(؀‬ΖDž9‫ͣ ؀͎ ؀‬Ȅ‫˗˖ ؀‬ϓ֣˘ȴ‫؀‬

§ ѲƖƗ օƘӫд³ČŸÑ‫ְ࠼֡؀‬ѳηŽ‫؀‬ԦFֿ‫؀‬ΗʎeY‫؀‬ʏ‫؀‬ȐБ‫כ‬ǭ˙Ѵ‫؀׋؀‬uĪ&%Ԍ ‫؀‬ƙ‫׌‬ԋrт‫ ؀‬ŀƚկеŁÒ ł̑/gֆǜ‡ԧ‫ֱ؀‬Θҭ‫؀‬ʩ˚Ι‫׍ת‬ƛƜǔ֠‫ ؀‬ΚH‫׫؀‬ȟíȅȵ‫׀‬tևуŃ‫؀‬ ֲDz‫؀œ ׬‬ɕħֈզń‫؀‬ϔѵSfΛͶLѶ˛˜‫؀‬pϴгϵÓ˝‫) ؀׭‬ǐǘΜĬ‫؀‬ȗɈ
¨Ԩ‫؀‬ɖҮѷƝiΝƞv‫ ؀‬Ƞ‫؀‬ղ*‫؀׮‬w˞‫ׯ‬ӑүѸԩ˟‫؀‬Ԫ‫؀‬ϕ>½ǵѕ‫׎װ‬ѹˠѺ‫؀‬ÔɱĞ·‫ ؀‬İ‫ֳ؀‬В‫׏‬NՋΞȚ‫؀‬ ՌΟ͏‫؀‬ȘȆȡ‫؀‬M‫ ؀‬îĆć‫؀‬фƟׁ‫؀‬ԫ‫؀‬։͐Ԭdz@Ϫ …ѻ¶‫؀‬džŶГ-ˆΠׂęϨ֊iŅ‫؀‬ʐԭ‫؀‬ʑ‫؀‬ՂԮӬˡˢ`ˣ+Ȣ‫؀‬ɗʒėȼ̫ϖ‫ ؀‬8ŧÖN
Ρͷˤ$ӭ˥‫؀‬ѼZƷϢďƽ˦Ӯ‫ ؀‬ȣӯ‫؀‬țɘ‫؀‬ Ӱ˧×ӒѽѾ´˨‫؀‬ՍNjnj‫؀ͤ؀‬ȇ
‫؀‬ѿ͑‫؀ױ‬Ơ΢ĭՎ‫؀‬ǚДïŵŽĮ‫׃‬ҰŨũŪØņ‫؀‬

֋х!‫؀‬ýơǮЕ͒ϗ‫؀‬

əOӓӱ˩ƢӲÙЖŇ‫ײ‬ӳ‫؀‰؀‬B‫؀‬ʪ֌Տ‫\~؀‬Ú‫؀‬ӴǍÛӛt ÜǺ‫؀‬ǢȤ{ʓ‫ל˪؀‬1ňƣµ|‫؀‬ΣʔÝ‫א©؀‬ʼn˫ Ƥ‫؀‬ԯ‫؀‬Ҁq‫֤ˬ؀‬Ŋ̬˭‫׳‬P‫؀ž״‬Ϸ‫؀‬ÞŋҁǟdūŬ̓gŹ‫؀‬ՐΤƥӵ‫ ؀‬ʕ ‫ׇ‬ ȈLJ;ƦƧұ֍цŌ‫؀‬ō԰‫؀‬I‫؀‬ɚĚϩ֎հж6‫؀‬aҕ͓ ϣ͸ˮl˯Q‫؀‬%ͬ˰͔Ԇ4‫؀‬

‫ב‬ŴŎǎǏ‫؀‬șȉB‫؀‬Υʖ̭‫؀‬ӶĐƾ˱˲Ϙ֥Ǡ̮‫؀‬ӷ͕ӔҲԇէϙ҂͹‫ͫ؀‬yҳч‫ ؀‬ʗ‫؀‬ӸĔǁűŏƨßΦϿ‫؀‬Աr֏ӹ˳ɰ”‫ִ؀‬зɯ
‫؀‬ӕ҃ҴӺ‫؀‬Ӈ‫؀‬ǻǛӖՑ˴ш‫ ؀ ˵׵‬ȥ Ϛ þ‫؀‬ǞıªŐɴ‫؀‬ 7ӻà˶őáƩщըҖÂ‫؀‬ΧĊŒ‫؀‬ʘЗ-ɌƸbׄҵ֐j‫؀‬ъϛͺΨ‫؀‬K͖‫؀‬ƪœ‫؀‬ɛĨ֑̔:‫؀‬ϤâИ
ϥͻ˷҄˸˹‫؀‬ҶY[ϸƫ˺Ƭ2‫ ؀‬Ȃ
ðЙɁ‘‫ׅ‬ҷ֒ԍ8‫ Ÿ؀‬J‫؀׶‬Ѐ֓ ɬ‫؀‬ƹc‫؀‬Ȧɉ‫؀‬ Ω,ƭɭ«ȑ‫؀‬ʙ˻̒DZ͗ê‫؀‬IJ‫؀‬ʫÿӼͼ˼‫?؀‬ԎŔij֔҅€‫؀‬Ҹͥ‫؀‬ыьƮ‫[ ؀׷‬yҹэ‫ ؀‬ɜŭŮȶ‫ ؀ם‬Ā²0ԊJʬʣ5‫؀‬ȷ˽ãӗՒ˾‫ ؀‬Ϊ˿‫؀‬ӽ‫؀׸‬ՓΫʚՔ‫ ؀‬ά͘‫ ؀‬VϜ̯‫ ؀‬Օ‫؀‬ǝ9ǾƯέđƿ=аӾ‫؀‬ θǿ‫؀‬ŕɲĴḛ‫؀‬ʛ‫؀‬ȸɆ—‫ ؀‬ɇ҆‫؀‬Һ҇‫ג‬ư‫؀‬һģ̀ʜԲŖҼ҈‫؀‬Ә҉ҽӿ‫؀‬ՖҾ‫؀‬ɝRә՗́ҊŗʭSԀ‫؀‬Ř ř ‫ ؀‬՘ή͙‫ͨ؀‬ЪŻŠ‫ ؀‬x̂̃ɤ̄äК‫؀‬юͦҗԈяāҋֵҌ‫؀‬ՙίʝ՚‫؀‬ʞŚñ Ƀʟ‫׆‬ҿ֕ԁѐ‫’؀‬թʠ̱‫؀‬ҍƱ̅̆śD¬խǗ̏Ы‫؀‬ԳåŜ֖ɋ,»ÁºÀ¹ŝ‫؀‬՛ԉӈё‫؀‬ɞI֗̕ի‫ ؀‬3‫ד‬ɮuǒbΰ՜ʡ‫؀‬α¾‫؀‬βW
Ӛ‫ƒ׹؀‬ůŰ̲‫؀‬Lj;‫؀‬ђƲֶ‫؀‬ҎŞӀԴӜ̇‫؀‬ɣЛ‫؀‬ɟ‫™؀׺מה‬ş̈ͽӁĂ‫؀‬ Мγæ‫؀ו‬ҏç‫؀ז‬T֦Ґ̳֘̉̊Ǽ‫؀‬Ǩ‫̋؀‬s֙НĒ?vēǀԏӂґԵk‫؀‬:Ƴַ͚Զ՝ͿȹЬϦО­ЭЮ‫؀‬ӃҒ‫؀‬E‫ח‬ż‫֛֚׼׻‬ѓa‫ ؀  ؀‬ȧ ‫¿¯®׽‬¢‫ ؀‬įƴŠǸв‫ ؀‬š Ɓ–Ƃè‫؀‬ʮƒ‫؀̴̌׾֜
̐؀‬ ՞͛‫׿ָ̍֝؀‬՟ϝՠƵƶ֞ӄm‫؀‬ȺП‫]؀‬Ǵ‫&؀‬Ӆє‫؀‬

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 17 of 18

ག⚈㆕ᝯᲷ䞊໵ᝰ㜔㼩រⷣᕥ᝱䜪䞊ԭ Ԯ œ 䞊आЏАԯ䞊డଂൺ䞊⠸㆖䏎ᮨ㰦㤒⚈⋇ሔ㶶⠹㔫㆗䞊㡪᮵䎽Ϊዐⱓᮒ⡰߳䞊㽐⑇ዑ㹸䞊ᅦⱔɉଃዒ䗔㏾䈸঑԰䞊ⓖᅡ㰻䞊㰧㆘㫎ᝲ䞊㻜❧ᝳ㬆䞊㤓㕑䞊 ⠺ᘢ㟒⻀Ա⠻㭤㵹䞊᯶⮕᭙⻁ᶲ⿗㸮㬥̇䞊 ຘრ㬆㞰䅽ጅⱕ᭽䞊ൻɸ䞊஗ì਼⻂䉏㤨㔬ʍ䞊 㸮⡚ⱪᴬ䞊௛䔯᭙ᘗ䄳㽑⚈䏏ᲄ䞊੩㰨㬥⟗㰩㼪ዓ㆙㺓䞊஭ⱼ⡲ᶳ᝴㷑㔭䜫䞊₎㕓㣽䞊୫㔮႟ൾⱷՈ㼧᝵㤊㽗ᰎ൅㆚㰪⻃䞊 ዶ「᩾䞊ୢ㔯䒡ё㵹ᤍ㤠⡵ዔ㶗ប⮡⮕⡳⋃ᯁ〠ᛏ᝶䞊㶬ᶴ㰧㼬⠼⇷ᮊ᩿䞊⠽㆛䞊㶗ⓧᮩ䞊๒᝷㵺㔰ᕦᶴ㠅䞊ۛœ䞊‫ظ‬ϦБ‫ع‬䞊ⓗᲧ঎⿧⋄䞊㵹ᕧዕ㼫䞊 ී䒢Ⴕᶵí䏐ᛷ䞊ᔕᶽᷫ㇄䞊㼬ु3ඡൽ㇍⋅䞊䑄⠾㼭ⓘ䞊㼬ⓛᯁ䞊 ౭㐛䎸ᶴ㪕䅹㆜᝸⿞㵺䞊 ኴᔕ㔱䅹㵺䞊ᘷ㎵ⱖⱩ‛㼮ߒ㏞㆝䞊㔲⿠䞊ቛ⿲䞊⡉⿲᪀⠿䏑♊᪁䅕ᅪ⭱䞊 䒣ⓙ㎶䞊ⓚጏ㬆䞊㼼⡊ᵿ㬗䞊㶐㎵䞊ᅔⱸȤໂᄭî⛨ᦇᅉŘ䞊䒤⏄㓦䞊㪑ዖ㮳䞊㵺⡛᭷㰮䞊㺢㐛䞊଄ᅔ䗕㐮䉎⻙⡀̈䞊 ूჲ⻆᭙ᦇ䞊 Շ⾾䞊ረᦓᦓ⡁㶅❱㎴⿠œ䞊㶗ⓛ​䞊ఢଃ೑䞊㣾ᵿ㜕㒈߭㽏᝹ᨩ䞊㼯⏤ᶶ䞊㠅ᘟ㰫㺗߷⮕㽠㱃䞊㔳⃟䞊㶗ⓜᶷ⡂㢧䞊㰬ᵃ䈹ᘒ̎óՂ䞊㏂⃠䞊዗ⱗȮેዘ䗖㔴䄴䜬⡃䚎㼰䚨䚨䚭䞊㼱⏤ጆ㼻Ř䞊 ¡ዙ䞊ஓᶸ㠅䞊ᅖゲ䞊ᶹ䔰⏡ዚ䈺㬉㵹⟒䎂᱓䞊㷘㟆ዽ㆞㬥⭱ღ㵾⚔㔵⾰㭄䞊㎿⃡䞊ଅዛ䖬㔶䆇⻄㻙䞊䚏㰭䞊᪂㔷᝺䈻⺷ᶺ㆟㵺㰮œ䞊☡㼲䞊Ҩ㬆䞊ᙒⱭᶻጇ㣟䞊㵹ߥ⡨ዜ㸮䞊㤔㇅䞊ଆኴ䕪㎿䄾⻚☱䞊Ñ㬖䞊 ᜣ㏂ㆠᘠ㰯㛡㔸ㆡᦓ᝻⿌᝼ᶼ䞊␖ᶂ䞊⡄ 㰰䞊㛃㡪㏞䍠⡅㽞ⱦ✳ㆬ⋆䞊⋇䈼⛫᪀ጎぱ᝽ᶽ䞊㺞㔹䞊䖒㎵䈽「≰䞊ปဘ‫⹷⚈⭱ڠ‬㬣䞊ᅖ⾾ᦉ䞊㬖㔺⻅ᶾ䞊㏾⃢䞊␍ ♘㰱䞊䒥㣽✳㶐✧ㆢ≰㰲䞊ᘢᅈㆣ䞊ᕨࣙ䞊 ߡʁԺԻ㼄᭙̑㟴㜞㠕᭤㼳ᶿ㤣ⲃ䞊ർ༊䞊⪵❱ⓝᅓ᧛ј㭤㷒ʟ¢䞊 ੪ᚏᛥ㑬㠬ᦉ⚈ߦ⡩⊡䞊㼴㏂䞊⡆〠⃮㕔㟔⸙ዝ㶎⡇㎵ㆸ䞊ዞᗭ㞱䉏⡜㤕᭤᪅䞊ᕩ䗁䞊㼵⑇᷀䞊ణે൸䞊ዟ⃪㽒᭘㟒䞊໺᭴㚹㵺ᘕߓㆤᕅᷯ㤚䞊⮕䞊⮕ Ř ‫ؠ‬䞊 АВԲœ䞊㔻ⱘɊՄ‫ڀ‬ϋ䗌㔼䈾㤜̕Ղӈ䞊ृ⮕㰳㏔䞊 ㆥ㔽㵺䄃᪍䞊㔾ㆱ䞊㑶ㆦ᷁䞊㔿ò⃩䞊⎯⚇㰴䞊㭜᝾ⓞ㏂㕀⮕䞊ᅡ㜖㜗ⱙ⚈ᘗዠߔ԰䈿〱㬆䞊㵺⑕ߧ⡪㼶䞊⎮㼷䞊䒦㎵㠅⫰ᷬ᪌䞊⃥㕁㣿䞊რ䞊ល㏔⺈㜘ለҨԼ䕦䞊㼸ዡ䞊Ⱬ⡝᷂᪃䞊£மዢⱫⱾዣⱬ㽓ϛ੫䏒᥽ʩ¤䞊 ੐ᙒᘥ㐛㤀᪄㽟ㆿt䞊㵹㎿䞊㵺⑇᷃䞊‫׺‬ଅⱚƵ䞊௧ᘢዤぎ䞊☫㰵䞊̐ʋ䞊ཇዠぱ䞊ய⡈᷄⋈㎵䞊㰶䅤ᔝ᝿㎵〠㶶㡕ैᗭ㵺㓝㡕䞊㏀⃣䞊ரኴ⮕⭸ღ⎟ϝƶⓟ ក㑬ɰ䞊 ਸ਼ភᘥ㎿㠅ᦉ䞊⹶⋉䞊㸎㏯䞊ߨ⡣䞊 㬺᷅㛶ዥɎɏዽ㵹㪒 ɋ㎵ᘗ䄯⻆᷆⻇Ʈ䞊஗ߕӮ.Խሔ⏃䞊ዓ̓Գម⭍䞊੬䍕ᜁ㕂䞊ᅪ㟒ᯖ䞊 䇄ㆧ᧟ᤲ㠖䞊㼻␽᭙䞊㰷ᅉ㫏ខ䞊䅤⺷ᕪ㤁㼹⮕Ɑᅡ䞊ᜤ㕌ⷈ㜙ዦ⿗䗗Ʒ䞊੭䎁ᘥ㕒䞊஗ጌⱚⱛዧ␱䞊 ࿌㡫Ƹ⻈㰸䞊 ੶㣾ϕᕫƹ䞊䒧ⓠ⡉ᝊ⏝䞊⛐㮉䞊የ䞊㯂䉀ᕬ㯂⛨ᦂӈᓫ߯䗞䞊㕃⃤䞊੮⮕䞊ଇᄭ㡪ሔⱜߖߩ⡫ॄ㷒䞊⮡ㆣ䍛ᰰ㯂䉁ㆨគ㇆㽔䞊䄪ᦜ䞊ற᷇䏓᷈ⱝ㏂㜚⻉᷉ㆩ㼺䞊୬㽝ʁ䚵㫐ਚᅔ「䖄̉䞊 ੯䎽ᙵ㏞䞊 லሔ⮕⯢ዩ␛䞊㤂ᤳ㛼㐛ㆪ᭤᧛☳䗘䞊⏼䉂,⩹㰹䞊㼻⏫᷊䞊ឃ㔟㇇㽕㢃ხង㶎㬖䞊⡱㕘㠅䞊ᘓⱮ᷋ሩひ⡞ㆫ⋊䞊ዪㆬᦂ䞊⸼ᇦ✳㇈䜭ㆭሩ߱⡮ᘥច䞊Ⴚ㹁䞊ՆⱵⱶឆ䞊㵺⎮㤈᷌᳡䞊߫「ᓶ㑊㠅䞊ᅉ⡅㤥㜤䉃㟤߶㯝䞊⛯ߴൿ䞊 ໿ე䄲ᦱ⡊䞊੶㢃ᄄᕭ⡋ያɱ䞊 ࿌␛Ყ̊䞊᪅㐛ជ䉄⻛ᰜ⿞㼼䞊㯂ⱞያ㼽ᯁ㱂䞊Ճ̒Ⲃ䍏Ѿ䞊䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚣䞊 㺌⒗᷄䞊ᘟ㎵⻊㛏ዬㆮ䖒䞊␛ᅈ㬆䞊⮕⡟㇉⫰㰭䞊㷹㔟䞊န㬝ይⷕᄧ䞊ଈ߬ㆥ䞊ුᄕᦂ♣ㆯ䞊 ௹ಧႄ䞊ನᘠዮᧉ㞚䉅ܑ⡠ㆰ᷍㟆㭹䞊䒨䜮㬋䞊⡌㪓∠㤤⺷᷎᧪䞊㕄⃥䞊㼾⎮ᯅ䞊ዯ⃬⃭⚈Ɐ⡡ደ㼿⡍㎿「䞊 ᕮ᷏㽖䒰᷐᭷ㆱ䞊஗ዱ⯥ᕯ⎯Ϝੰ䏔ᘥ㐛䞊ᄒ〱ᦂ䞊ੱⱟ䞊Յ‫⻋ߗॿځ‬㽀䞊♣「䞊ਛ᷑ᔞ㠩䆇䉆㟆ňì䞊‫غ‬Јϡ҈œ䞊ᕅ䉇㵺䞊㸮ⓡ᷒䞊཈㕅ぶ䞊ள⡎ᷓ⋋㑊䞊⃦⡏ᯯ⮕ᦇ䞊๦⃫⃲㽛ᛨᚴ䞊 ᅕ৘㜛ॅߘ᛿⿠Ⱡⱡ䖮䞊⾾ᮻ䏕ᷔ㟤䞊⋌㎵㽁䞊㽂ⓢߙ㰺䞊⠘⾰⃯㕕㇊ぱ‫ޒ‬⡧⮝/㕆䉈ɰ䞊 ੲᙒᚿ㎿㤃᧩⡢⿗⋍䞊㵹㔬䞊⃧๩⬮䞊ᦂ㕇ᘼ䉉ⷈᶾㆲ㽗㬡ƺ䞊ዲ⮕ȡ‫؍‬ድ䗙㕈䅮⿞䅤䞊䚐 㬺 㜜Ⴚ䗚䞊⻌ឈ㠕ᯅ࣪ញ᪆䞊᪇䄲㤢⡍㆞⋎䞊㽃Ɒⱱដ䞊㽄⡐⻍ᷕ䞊⬯⑚㇎ʁߚ䞊ᅔ⮕Ɂ಩ᅪ䙓㤄ㆳ♘䞊 ገ㇋ᦉ䞊ዳ⮕Ȯผ⡑⎯យⱺ⮕㤖ዴ㠅䞊䒩ᷖ㤟ᷰ䞊⡒ㆴ䞊㸮ⓨ᳦䞊ပ「⡣㼄ᷗᦉ䞊໻㵺‫ٽ‬㺢ᵎ㱀ɰ䞊 ਿឋᗳ㏂㟔᪍⡤㤝݅⋏䞊⭁㕉䞊ድ䞊㤅ᮊវឌㆯ㺌 Ɍ⾾ዶ⮕䗛㰻☡㰼䞊㎵⃨Ɫ✷ࣘ㭒䞊ᕰᘟ㽅䑌ᤴឍ㪔䞊 -␍㽜ô䞊Դᷘ㤦㢧ㆵㆶƻԵ䞊ዷⱽ⡴ߠⱲ㤆⫱̗䜯䞊ዸԾӱ᪈䞊ᶂ⭍ᷭ⻛ព̕Ƽ㶭㱁䞊㒈⃩䞊㽆ⓣᷙ䞊ཉዹⱻߵᦜ⡓䞊ಀណ䏖ᷚ⻎⻛ᷛㆷԶƮ䞊ĩ᭴⃰㕖㤞ឍ䞊ॆⱣɀߛɍⓩ䒪㤧䉇䞊ߪ⡬ㆸ᪉䞊߮㽚⮕Ƞฝ⡔ⱤԿՀⱥⓤዺ㤇䞊 ᅓ㤒̙❱䍕‪䞊⛯⾰䞊㽇ᕱ᭤䞊ဖ̋ཊ䞊ɾ̏䞊ᆠ⭋Ȣழღ䕕㎿䒡⾰⚇䞊⊿ᷜ㆞ᷝ㤘ግ⯛⭚䕕䞊㤈ᷞᚏᴬ⡕䏗᳈᨝䞊ʪ⡧㜝㜞Է㕊䔪♂⻏ጉ㽗ផ⯛䗜䞊ཋ‫ڟڰڙ‬䞊㜟ᷟ㤉䞊⻐㎵⾰㵹ⱳ⡥䞊✳⿌䞊 䚉ïዻ⮕⮕㏂䒫ዑ̔ƽᝥត㰽ɸ䚶䚑䞊ੳᘢថ㎿㤊᥵Ձѥ⋐䞊ဗਔ䞊㽈ⓥᷠ ̊䞊᪊㐛ឝ䆄⻑᭙ㆹ㼱Ʈ䞊⻒䞊พዖ㤙ᗳⓦ䞊ʩⱴ๪๧๨ƾ䞊䜰䞊‫⾹܋‬㕋㤋ˬ㽘⓪䞊ჲ⇎ᘢ㠅䞊ᅃ⭚Ƞಪ৛⻜⡅䞊ेㆺᦡ䞊‫ػ‬0䙫 ณ✳⑞ᧉ⑇ዼ㤌䞊䉊㢃㤡⡶䏘᝻ᤀ䞊❕ㆻ䞊໳ዽこ䞊஗☫ᷡ⋑㎵Ŗ䞊⎟⡦㬡䞊 ðਜʑ⮕႞㕌䒬ᇃㆼᙒᴬ㯝䞊ɹʑ䞊⪶䉋⻓㜠ᷢᦓ䞊ទ㎿䞊㎵䏙ᷣ㤍䞊ཌ‫ڷپ‬ϵϦ䞊ᆶ䞊⸙㎵ㆽߤⓚ䞊‫ⱦ⻔ؼ‬䞊㬆㷀Ⴞ䖒ᶂ᧩䞊 ᘷ㏂ㆾ㯂㽉ጊ㇌㽊䞊䉌ㄈ㵺✸Ⱨ䞊஗ᥝᲉⷣᕲᯡ⡖䞊‫ؽ‬ГЈϭƿ䞊䒭⏐ᷤ「䞊ᄄⱹȠಫ਌߰⡭⡉䞊⮕ᯁ≆䞊ཌྷⱿⲀⲁ䞊஗⚈ᷥ⋒㐛˷䞊 ੴⱨȤଉᇫ䗌⻕ߜⷯԸñ㯂䞊ጋ⭿Ⱪ㕍䒮ዾㆿᘢᷦ㰾䞊䒯䜱㤎ធ䞊 1⏫᳥ま䞊᥮ᥥ㇀ߝ̌ᄋΉ⪂ᦂ䞊㷘㎿䞊 ዿ㚹㜡㤏㕎䔲⡷㠅̚⡭ጀ㶗ន⮕䖒䞊ཎ‫ٿ‬ǀ‫ؙ‬ЈЈ䞊Ⴜ䞊⻖㒛㆞㽄␽䞊ა㇁᧛䞊㬆䍎䕕䜲㪶䞊ᅔ㽋䞊⡯̖⓫ღ㵹䞊㠂䜳㽌ᷧ䞊 䅩㤛̘㵺⡗⮕䞊 ጁ⮕䞊 ଊጂ䖒㕏䉍⻗⚈䞊⮕㽙−䞊㵺⑇ߢߣ䞊 ဌ⿠⚈㽍᱕ᦉ䞊༈㽎ጃ㼻ᶾ㬆䞊⡘㇂䞊ੵ䅕⋓䄲㬆㽏䞊‫ؠ‬ДЕԹǁ䞊ት㛁㜢㤗㏞䔱⡙⸏ጄߞᱽ⬹䗝䞊㒰㇃᭬䞊⻛㕐⿲㼌③䞊ᕲᰜ⃱㕗㤐ᷨ䞊㵺⑇߲ᷮ䞊໵ᷩ㜣㷅ᷪ⻘ᔞ᱕㤑䞊҈ ԙ  ᄞ⭁2ࣵ᪋ߟ㰿䞊̍䞊 ഊ䞊ᕤⱒ䞊Κ௘୪೎௙௚ഋච䞊

ԫԬ䛒‫ڞ‬ŏ䞊⪚䞊

ċĭ Ĵ՛

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-2 Filed 03/17/17 Page 18 of 18

ĜĝĞǝΗɠΘϩЬÜ͏Ϝʤ{*Թʥȭ˄ʦԹǾҼ
ӷ ƽ / ԹšĕĖƺ ԹȅȕǬŸЭЮɡɢïƒӸԹϪ҂˅ʧԹÿ͗ԹGͳÉǟĀ(ӹϫ{ηԉёԹÝԹLj ԓlj ,Թ Ӧ̇ŮʹɣԹX¡'ϝ˽Թ͐ϞԹț¢řŚԹ#ȉ2ɤԝÞԹӧɖ1ԞԹ ЯýǙɥ!ğԔ͑ϟ˾ԹȜ 6 ŢėžȇԹEԹуɑϬŃ8ů̈Թ˫аϭeԹ͵’ԊԋƩÂĎɦђѓԹDȮ3̭ƾԹ„΂ΙͶԹԟҽͷфϠ£Թ҃[ԠԹ Ө&ͩԹˬԹȖŰΚɧɨԹǠNJΛʨF ԹĠńҭɩԹȝȯҾ űԹǞѐɘ@‹єßġlŲԹNjϮԹ̉ˆԹΑƶƪà ҄SʩԹȞȋþǽ҅ԡàԹ Ȣ̊ųԹĢáԹǿ͸Թ…΃ɒѾԹŴ<Թ ùƨϯ˺ŵŶθɪʪԹ ҆̋ι҇Թϰκ
ӺԹȎѕLJǁԹ ǡHλȀμ“Թө˭ďԹϡơɫɬ ¤ԹSʫԹΜϱνЪԹʬбʡ͝ƥ҈͹ӻԹWrϲΝԹȗo\ξɭ˩ƴԹǢȰʭâҺэіԹ Ӫ̮ˮˇ¥ԹəӟҮԹxɓүԹȱ
ԇ ǣǂӼlҿьӡїԹãԕ Թ̯˼ԹǚĂŷ҉TΞТҊˈʮԹŸԹˉУϳј̰vԹ̌nˊˋԹ̱Թ ̍ˌԹɮ̎UɯͪљԹWrϴΟԹȘn οɰˍԹǤ0_iʯG njԹӫ̲ͫԹӬ̳ɱ̏ԹӭԢoɲԹ ФȲӽȳɚ
ˎԹͺԹŭ?͒њȴπ”ћԹӮ!˴ИäԹ̴ ҋϵԹ̐ˏpԹ϶ӯρԹ ÷ŗɳɴϷӀςќåԹ ȣ̑ːԹȆЙ̵σҌԹǸhЫӁ̶вӾԹƫÄɛϸԹ˶О|τȁ¦Թ̷υԹгţŹԹ ˵
ˑѝæԹ̸h˷ПCÙÅщƼҍ̹ϹφԹ‘c΄ўɵ§ģŅņŇ˿ԹҎ̒ĔҏԹșŤčΠçĤԹŒȵԖÇÖǗԹԗχԹ fԣӢԹ̓!ĥԌüǘԹȶ
џϺԹOԘź¨Ԥ Թ ' ԹPϻϢҰƻҐԹӰ&ґԹȷ
ԥÊÒ΅Ȍ›ΐʰ̔A( Թ=Ρ˒ԹKͻĦ4ŻŠdψ̺Թ R̕ħұ†ňʼn2ͦԹ

ǥƢҲŪѠk©͡jԹª«ԹǃѡԹHԹԍЬӿԹɶ`ϼѢTԹż­ѣɷĨM>ɸԹω˯ԹȏӱдԹèҒ̻-ǼΆ>͘Ԁӂ΢ĩԹԎsԹϊϋʱԹ®Թé0Թˆ¯Թ̼iԹ˓̽ɹХ̖ʣ Ͻό͓ɔúAԹŽ ·Έ%Թȸ̾ǦȹԁϾӃΣ5Թu˔ӣ˕еȺ
Թwӄύ˖ѤԹIԹʲDžԂԹӲĪͬԹғ̗˗ԃԹ° ˘жԦԹɜmҔǍī ŊŋŌԹȟȂώԹǯ̿V̀ϿԹ ` øŘŬѥ:ōŽΤԹʳѦԹ̘ԧԹʴЀѧһԹҕ̀ɺѨԹҖԹԨԹӅΥ̙ɻ Թӆ́ԹЁ җ%˙зԹ935Ҹƹ~±͂ʵӇȻ
²ԹɼČĬхϣɽɾzɿʶԹҘԹx̚đԹ ̓ͧLPǜ$qѿ Թ ̈́Φǎȃӈ ԏԩԹȐΧȼ ԹťԪͲɕԫ̛E+̜ĭԹ ѩʀӉҀҁԙžяԹO˨
ЂӳêԹӴЃ ԚԬԹ ʁ˰ö×ǀĒʷԹ ĮĘԹ͔ ԹDZǧǹԹ

КӊΨĊϏyѪԹşԹǨȽ+ѫȾj•ѬԹɝįęİUËŎŏ"ɞȬ ³Թ

´ȦͣʂЄԭʸ;́ԹҙmԹǏΩԹȑʃҚЅ̝ʄиԹ6ԹъÆԹ ſǮȈȒ
Թ йͥԹ#Թ ʹІʅқƀΪʆΫ.Թ śŧë7tƿŐ"͙ϐԹϨͼЛцԹeʇʞΉԹƁ9őԹȿѭ+˚ҜԹҝXƱ'Թ̞˪Թ ̟ӋʺԹŒ"ʈͽԹȍӌԹǖ]˱ԹɀaǴFҷĆfͅԹҞ̠чМӍ̡̂ԹI;ŜŨƲ(ԄЇӎά͆Թ ǺԹͭԹӵшϤƂԹЈк.Թ ӏԹµӐԮԹ ҟ̢JԹ̣ƭƮԹ:œ~ԯıԹIJԹЉԹЊ˲Թ ƃ%˛Թϑ͇ϒ˜˝˞ ԹΊƣƄЦʉͮʊijѮԹҠƅĴлЋ¶ĵēû·Թ ȓέƆĶƇԹƳ͚)Ş^}ӥӑή\Թ ƈȧʋʟНмʻƉƊǵ1‰Թ ҡӒԹƋыąƸǐԹDzǩ#Թð͕Ќюӓίʌv¸Թ,ǑԹ ȄѯЍԹķЎ)ΔΕԹĸYĉԹɁѰūǭͿԹҢ̤¹ңƌԹɂ
Ì4ũñ^ԅЏӔӕԹȪȫāwȠԹºĹΰƍѱҤʍʠ΋Թ̥ʎ԰ƎĺӖǒʏԹĈƧԹͯɃQò»Թ ɄaDӗǓƏĻ͈Թ?¼ϓʼԹ K͉Ԉ ԱÍΌ΍ Ʌ ½Թʐн}ԹӶʽ
/Թ Ȥ̦˟ԹʾӘʑә*ʒϥԹÈȨļõœ–ԹĚ;Ŕ ĽěԹtҳNƐŝԹҥ̧ɆҦԹΖŦҴ‡ѲѳϔƑcd8ԹԲƬØ͖ʿԹL͊Ǫì7ԆАӚgǔԹ ɇԹˠԹɟ͟ƵʓԹ—˜ʢΏБѴͤԹ΀ϕԹVɈʔZԹҧľ¾[ʕƒԹ˸РqԹMԹ
ӛ̃ԹҨĿƓŕŖQԹԛԐԹ

bƷ̨uѵϖɉkԹ΁͋ӤҹǛҶƔԹαԹYˡԹNЧ¿_ϦƤϧƕβԹRćÎÀШ€ʖÕƦԹ ϗԹȡB͛ϘԹǰ͌ʗȔԹɊʘоВѶѷԹz͞ÛíԳԹѸƖпċԴҩԹ˻ӜγԹƗŀԑԹǶ=͜ƘԒÏƙƚԹ ɋˀԹDŽ‚ԹÐԵŁԹ͍̬̩<ӠÚƛԹ

ȚԶsϙ@δԹ*ɌˁˢԹdžԹʙГεg͠CƜԹДԹɗ ԹdzǫǻԹѹЕ|pԷʚԹɍ˳Ɲ$рԹҪ)ƞ$ԹѺ-ԸЩƟӝϚЖʛсԹłԹbԹ îΎҵyɎʜͰԹѻӞ̄̅ˣѼ&ϛ̆Թ ΒB]ĄҫԹ̪ˤԹ˂ ˃ԹζЗƠ˥Թ˹СтԹ̫˦Թ͎ͨɏʝͱ˧ѽԹҬZJăÓÁԹ ɐ
ÑȥƯưÔóԜȩȊ™Γ͢šԹ ǷôŠǕԹ

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 1 of 18

Appendix 2B

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 2 of 18

ՉՊՋᚠ䞊తଋഌ䞊
Ⴢ䒱ᇯ㤩ᷱ䞊㎿⃳䞊ឞ䉐ぷ㽡თសⲄ䞊⓬ហ㥃䒴ឡអ⿿䞊㽢⑱ᷲ䞊⮆߸⡸⪷ᅨᗮ⫲ᚠ㤮㯳䞊ጜホᦇ䞊ጦ䞊ᚿ⮗㏎㱄ञ䞊℃ㇱᷳㆇᦧ䞊㕙⃴䞊ଌჂ㱑㬆㇗ᇯ䉑䞊䚒㭮Œ䞊 ණ⓼጗ⱛ䜴⡹䞊ਯ඀ȢඩLJљ䕰ᘺ䄨ǂ䞊ყ䞊ស㎿⻝⻛ᮞ㠅᚛➐ᇒⰹ䞊ᇯ⢒㤵⬼♞⾰ᮎ䞊㛞⡺ⲅ㒡㽣䞊ጐ⿊᪎䞊ឣ̟ࠀ㟈㶎љℂ⢚ḡᦇ䞊4ⲑ⢎⋔⓭㸰䞊♋ࠂ⚳㬖㽤㇫⢏ឤ㶪㕝㤪䞊Ⲇ⛪䍷☱㤽ʉ⋕䞊⻞䞊 ཏᄸ⾰䞊஠☱ᰋ⋖㕚ɰ䞊 ਻⮜Ȧඪᅚ䗟ᷴᦃ䞊጑᪏⻟☱㽥㺩৵ࠊ᪐䞊ѶЖ䞊㽦⓮᷵䞊అ໥9䞊㶎⒂ࠉ䉟䞊☱㇏䞊ฆᇯ䕳䞊‫ؾ‬ЗСТ̛䞊ᇦ⬼䞊ฟ⡻⏝᨞⎱⩯䞊Ⴞ㇏᪑䞊ጒ⬼䙬 ಬᔇ㇧⚈䞊ᗹ㕞㇐㼇ᄸឥ㶗ᵆ᪢䞊⏒❔⻠䞊ჴᔡ㏗䉒㽧䞊⮔Ḗ‫⋗⿊⛩⻦ل‬䞊ՌИ䞊∓䕳䞊ૈЙᮞ☫㇑≣⪸ḕԖ䞊጗☯㟆㤹㟈ᄄ⇊ŕ䞊 థૣ೑䞊᧤㎿ង䉓⻡ᰊ⾰㶟㭯䞊䜵ɪᗽ䆯Ⲋჴⲇ᷶䞊㽨⎣ᅡ㻠䞊๏㱅ᇯ⸏ყ䞊଍ყ㯨㵵ᓬ⿰䞊䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚸䞊 䚡䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚷 䚡䚢䚢䚢䞊 ࿎┄᷷䞊నଘഏø㬡䞊ˆ㒶䎍ឦ⻢ᕳ᷸㟐䞊Ս‫ۅ‬ǃ䞊‫ؿ‬Аϵ‫ـ‬䚂䞊 ㇒߹㭪㜥㎿ㄖ㱆᷹䞊ᗭ㎿⿛㽻᭞⾰᪣㱕䞊㽵⓯ᅔ㸱䞊㽵⓰⓱䞊䒲ጓ㬡䞊 ᅉ〔䞊᷷Ⴚ㟕⬺䕻䞊☱ㇲ䎜‬㽩♋⋘ጔ㵹⡼䏚᷺䞊㽪⎹᭞㎳㠬䕚䞊ᔞংឧ᪒䞊㏿ࠃ⡣䞊ყ㬅छ᪓䞊㟆᮪㜀㎿㟕㸱♋⿠⊀䞊䒳┅⢍ᗺ⑍䞊㽵⓲ᶴ䞊û఩|Վ䞊⏐⩭䞊⿌㐵㽵䞊ᔞ ᷲᮞ⾰䞊ጕᔤⱘ᭜䞊㶎㕛䞊 ឧ㎶঒㎶ᕴ㎿㟓ክ㽪᷍ɫ䞊 ಭ㎿䒴ᰗ䍖᭸㟖š䞊㽫⓳᭫㡔ᮞ䞊⡽㬆䞊Ⴭⲏ㬆㎿䞊ᆠ᪔᪔☱㷴⡾㎿⿠ኞ⭑䞊⢐〒⃵㎳㠐⸾጖䉔㕜㇓䞊㛎㎿㱎㬖❹ᕵⲈ䗠䞊ḛ䗦⢙ㅊ≰䞊଎ॉ㬒㯸⻣⻤䞊Տਂ䞊 䚨䚢䚢䚢䚸䞊 ⯛⾰䞊 ы۞۟‫ف‬ſ䞊䒵⏐⡿Ⲓ᭴䞊ࠄ⢕ᙑ䞊䒶ጯ㬑䞊⮗⢀䏛☰〒⋙䞊⢑㇬䞊ၗᇦ㫾⓴⢁⿊≞㽵㎿〡Ŕ䞊வ୭Ŕ䞊૝ࠅ⢖㰒㯳⾰ጬ̣ú՞䞊⯛㽼㬅㶗Ᲊ᪕䞊⎱☫㮿䞊᷻⻥㜥⯄㐮䗧⻦ᰗ⿄㽬䞊቏㯨䞊 㽭⓵ᴀ䞊ཐ጗䅎ᦧ♞䞊੷㤿ጳᕶ❢ጠゼ䞊䄄ⶻ䉕ᚅჲ㵹⢂㎳㇔䞊น☱㬡㱇⪹㕝㇕䞊 ప૝ⲉ䞊ᨷ㏃ᚺ䉕⻦᷼㇖㷶㬆䞊㱈㹝ღ㤫᷽䞊᪖䉖x㶎䞊

‫ۆ‬ಮ㮢㱑⿏ߺ⻧䞊ጘⲊ㮝㐥䞊⏃ጙ㰽䞊㎿㽮⏃ᴿ㟐䞊⬯⢒ᯎ㮝䞊㽵㎿䞊 㽯⓶᷾䞊ད቏䇋᥯⢃䞊ಁ㐅䏜ᯀ⻮⻠᷿⾰߻ɸ䞊 ⬲┆㬖㱉ヒጚ⾰Ù㱊䞊䒷⢄⃽Ḝ䞊㤷ᷲឨḀ☰䏝ḕᦇ䞊च䞊⻨㕞⿍㶯⓷ⲋ䗡䞊 䜶Ⲍ⢅㜦ᰕ㽰܎᪗䞊℅㟴㕟ⷈ䞊ນ㤉߼䅦ឩḗ㬆㭷䞊ಯ቗⢓⃻ጱɳ䞊 ՘㇭䞊Ⴚ䞊㤶ᯇឪ᱑5ⲓⲔ䞊㬗ᯇᇭ㟈ᗽ␱䞊㏄⁖ଏ٪㬢㮢⾰ᇯ㇗ì㬏䞊㟋ᛸ㬫⚘᧤䄅⾰សᘮ̜䞊㽱⓸ḁ䞊దଓ഍䞊⯛㕠䜷ጛⲍ䄚ⲗ䞊ᘹ㕡㛩⢆Ḃ㱋䞊㕢⃶䞊 ‫ڂ‬Ր䞊ាɑ̢ყ㮝⶧ḃ㟈㭨䞊ᗽ⓹᳷ឲ⫳㱌䞊㶕㎹㸒ჿⲎ⢓㇨≩䞊དྷ‫ښڸ‬ŔКЈϲŖ䞊ᨆ䉗㟮⢓⾰≩䞊㽵⏝Ჽ䞊㜧᷉㟕⢛㎿ᩫ䞊ధ̠ࠁᕷ㫴‫ڃ‬ীɐ䗣䞊‫ق‬ՙŔ䞊6۠ۡۢ䞊㶕㎿䞊ภࠆ⢗䗢䞊‫ڄ‬ϦŤ䞊ՑЛϩ‫ش‬䞊 ࿏⏿ᴬ㭮ᴬ䞊ᛰ⏝Ḏᙄ⫸㬫䞊䒸ᮦ㤮ᵆ䞊㛘ᅉ䗣᪘ᕸ⬲ᘑ䞊㽲㎿䞊ଐ጑㫾ࠈ⻭ᇭ㤖:ù㬡䞊䒹⡣⃾ḝ䞊቏⢘㽽᪙䞊䑐Ḅ㤬᭞䞊᪚㤭ጜ䒺㇘䞊㎿⾰䞊㶗⎻᭫䞊໦♀≚⋚㭪䞊଑ᇯ⿿⫷䞊ጝសᗰ㕣䄶び㽳䞊㕤⃷䞊 ບ㥁⢜⿌ᙄᶟ䞊૕ჴ㇙᪛ჴ㤺Ù㭸䞊䒬♎⃿Ḟ̉䞊 ࿍㇚ᮣ䞊௹૕എ䞊⓶ጰ㯳䞊᪜ᘅ㹇ឫㇴㇵ⢍〡ឬᦇ䞊㽴⎹ጞ㽵䞊㽶⓺᭞㟌᭞䞊⓻ᅚ㬡䞊ᕹḅḆ⿠䞊቗䞊ྩՒᥰ☯㇛⋛䞊㕥㠬ᩫḇ㤮䞊㎿ぷ䞊ປ⿚ឭ㤾ࠋ;߿㱍㭪䞊 Τ⃹ጨ☦⃼ጲõ㭪䞊ጟᗰឮ㎿䆫⿄㶕䞊㭆☱㇜ᚅᶈ䞊ඁጩ㇮䉘ዲ㟮䕻䞊Փۣۤ‫ۥ‬䞊㹝㕦䞊㬝᭞㤭̨᪝䞊ནؔϦМН䞊ጠ䞊⸾䉙ࠇ⡣㪞Ք ՕО䞊଒ჴ㱎㬡㇝ᅔ̤DŽÙ㬆䞊䒻⛩⢇Ḉɱ䞊 ଓጡ㱏㭁㇞ᇦ⿇ä㭯䞊䑄⢈⃸ḉ䞊




䒼ጩ㱖䞊ጮ⯄⬼ᮻ⋜᭞ᦋ⯇䗤䞊㟮᭞ᙄḊ☦䍡♀〒⋝䞊㹝⎻᱄䞊℉䉠〔᪞⚊⾰⋞䞊߽㕧㟮䞊¥㇟ឺ㤻㱒⢝㇠⋟䞊㭯ḋ㥂䏡☦ᘺ‭ǂ¦䞊ᔹ䆖㷯Ř䞊όᛤិɒLjᮻ㤷᪤⢉⿠⋠䞊㽷㎳䞊㽸⓼Ḍ ̊䞊ᦋ㎹ᗭ䄵⻩᯳ホ㺈Ŕ䞊 㺾⓽ᷫ㟌Ḣ䞊⢊㬫䞊㇡㕨䞊ḍ䎲☴ᦃᯀ⾰ᚅḎ䞊㸝␱ি䜸㹝䞊ଔጢ㬫㱎⿍ጝ⾰ö㬺䞊䑁☱℀ḟ䞊㜨㤷㕰䍖☱ᥱḏਈ䞊㇢䉚࣍⚈⾰≙䞊䛚୮̡၁7୯୰བ䞊̝ 䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚹䞊

๫㇣䞊 ጣ㽹䞊 ⰹᰗᄸ㮝㶗䞊㕩㇤ᮎ䞊㕪ᘺឥ̧Dž䜹⢋ጤ㇥Ŗ䞊କሥ㱐㬖ボጨ̦㇯䞊㠅ᥦḐ⟘䏞ᯝឹⲕ䞊ጥ䞊ᛕⓚḘ᚛⫴䞊᧥䉛ḙឳ㤯⭑䕛䞊℈㤼㕲⻪䞊 ຜ㤸⚳㇦ឯᷫ䞊䜺݆⻫ᦃჲ㤰䚓䜻䞊 Ⴚីᛩ㎹䉜㇧㸟̞䞊 ੸ᛏᘮ㕞㤬ᦃ⚢㇨⋡䞊㽵䉝䞊㽺⓾ḑ䞊దૈ೦Œ䞊㑞㇩䞊มዬ䖥䞊ҍ䞊Ĩ ƪ䞊 Ⲏ䞊‫ۇۏۦ‬Š䞊ଖ቏㬏㯨ちჍ⿊䞊ᛩ‫ك‬π⓿ឰ᪒䞊ᅚ䞊ស⎺ᴽ឴⫵䞊℆㟴㕫⸏䞊૘ጭ̥üⲓᦧჍ㟐䞊⚘ㇳ䞊㽵─ಂ䞊 ጪ⻬㕬䆫㤱̛8䞊㕭⁙པՖ‫ڡ‬ŰПРϵɬ䞊 ՚‫ڀ‬ጦ㫾㫾՛՜ጫ⿅Ê㱑䞊䒽☴℁Ḡ䞊Ⴞ⮭㬒㒛䞊㠴Ḓᗹḓ⢌䏟Ḕᦲ䞊‫܁‬䉞䞊ⲏḙጣ㬑㽵䞊㑞㇪ɨ䞊᚛━឵សⲖߴ䞊᪟⢍㤲Ḕឱⲇ⮔ 㤳䞊∵㕮ⷔ䞊டᇭㄖ᪏ᅚ㡠䞊 ༘⎺ᮎ䞊 ሊⰉ㰒㏃䞊㥀ḑᛤḕ♎䏠Ḛ᪥䞊㎿⿊ᵀ䞊Ⴭᦋ᪠♋㶎☷㎿⿇ዲⲐ䞊ហ⎱ᰨᙍ⫶䞊ℇ㣲㒡⸾䞊ଗጩㇰ᪡ጓ㟐÷㱒䞊䒾⢔⃺ḖŒ䞊䒿│✝ᘙ┃䞊㱓䜼Ḗ䞊ងጧ㱔␧ᯀ᪙䞊㕯α䞊ංᓿ䄵ჴ߾䗥䞊ཕŔ䞊 ՗ ۧۨ‫ۈ‬dž䞊℄㕱㤴䞊 Á՝ϩŒϩϩЏɬ䞊

‫ڛ‬Ħ‫ڹ‬䞊

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 3 of 18

' ,"D =>?  D

ഓ㈞䞊㶪⎟ḅ䞊๬᛻㵺㏤ᔞḣ㥄䞊۪Ř䞊‫م‬ϬТ‫ن‬䞊⎺Ḥॊ㟒⢵ㆬ⋢䞊భଝೱ䞊௜䔴㾥Ⲱ୶䄯Ⲙ⛭䎀ḥ䞊ઁ㱮㭼⢤಄㾞ლヒ㽾䞊ஶⲮⲯ⪞ុ㽿㎶㟝䞊ஷý䞊੿⹝䅎㥆㐵䞊ᙐ㐡ⷢⷢᮇㅼ䙴ɱḦᦾ䞊 ㏁ㇶ䞊㾟┘❕㱗䞊ℜ䉵グូ⢞ㇷ⋣ࠌ䞊 ⲙ䞊ᕺḧ⯕⛐Ფ䏢ᱜ䞊㾠␇፨㵹䞊䓀ᷳ䞊ᦎ㎳䞊⎝ጴ䍤Ḩ䞊⻯㓦⾾ᷳ䗨䞊⋉㕳⚘ㇸ≚䞊∶㎶ⷢ䞊ૈ፪ㆬᦁყ㟒ì㯵䞊䓁➿ℊ᱕Ŕ䞊‫ ؙڢ‬ljϬСТ䞊ጵ䞊ⷮ㖓ㅼ㾡┙䞊䅤㛹䞊㥅㕴䞊ጶᕻ㕍䉡㼕䞊 བྷ‫ڜڱ‬ǂϡϬУɬ䞊 ၐ␛ყ㵹䞊㶪ⓛᷨ䞊⻰㎯⿙᮪䕙䞊䒣ᄺ㯵䞊ℙ㖕㣽䞊⚀㰡䞊䑧⒛ጷ㷹䞊䑧ᱡ䞊᪊㐁ㇸþ㾀䞊⫍䉶㕵䓇ʹäÿ䞊


㵹ួɹ䜽ࠍ☲⇐ើ᪦܎䞊 䚯䚨䚺䚻䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨ɱ䞊མ␍᳘䞊⋰✷䏢ᱡ㬡䞊⺺㏞ㇹḩ䗩䞊㾁㏡ ਯ䞊 ⮌㑶㾂䞊㕶ℋ䞊ᦃ⚔ℝ℞Ḫ㥆ᷩ⾻㵹䞊⋥ু㔞䉢㚽㱢䞊ყㇺᪧ䞊㚽ᮞ㏁㜩⯃ṃ䞊⇋㕷ⷃ䞊ქ㥊㑅䅉ㇻᦃ䞊㼄┉ḫ䞊䓂㕸㢌⮗᪨ɸ䞊 ၔᮩĀ䏪ᮄ䞊ᕼ᭬ṅ⿗䞊ጸᔬⲚ᭤䞊㼄㎿ 䄯㪘ᙔ㑆䏣Ṇ㟆䞊ጹ䞊 ⎘䏥᭜㬀䞊㾅㑵䞊‫ه‬ϡ䞊ᦁ㾆※ℚ㖖㟆ᮖ⾻៑䞊㥙̱⢴᪩☫ᚍᄋ⬼䞊 ⾰䅎ⷎᕽᲖ㥇䞊㕴ℌ䞊㷢┇ᮦ㭮᱋䞊ɹ ɸ ɬᕾ䉣㾃䞊ⷎ´䕘ᕲᷨ䞊♏ℍ䞊䓃ᵆ䞊ឿ፫ヒ䞊᧥⢟㮀ᘦ㕹䏤᭼㟆䞊㾄ⓛყ㶰䞊㱟⎤ᮉ䞊 䞊 ⋱㟆㔐䅩㜪㱘œ䞊䑦Ḭ⭕⮕Ŕ䞊Ⴘ⋤ᵜᯡNJ䞊⶿ጺ䗪ᔬᮥ䞊㾇┈᭙㥊ḭã㱙䞊ॸ䞊ਝ䜾㾢㵹Ḯ⻱䞊④ḯ㣉ᯎ˶䞊 ࿐⎝ᰜ䞊మଞೱ䞊⏥ሩ㱚䞊ጻ⭍㬖㓦䞊᪪ᱻ䎞ᮀ⯆㎶㜭ᵆᨢ䞊ჿ᪹ᧁ⢠㹀⢟㏤ヒጼ⯡䞊♥ゆ∡਍ლ΢⢡㐡⾾䞊ᚃ⮕គ㈢㟆ⲛ䕷䞊ࠕ̰㈝ᦰ✷ᙵቛ㺹⢶䉤⋥䞊㾈␛ᇯ㵹䞊ଙቊ㮀㱚㕺፬⾻䞊⢢㯄䞊፩㈖䞊 ᭢䔳㵺㟝ṉ⹇♂㬥㵺䞊৿ᦉ䞊㱛䉥㜦㛷㎶㫬Ḱ㟒䞊㕻ℎ ࿽㱪ፑⷮኴ䞊ଚ⻲䞊රლᨀ⻳̩䞊 ೣㇾ䞊Ⲝ䞊۩Ⴑ‫څ‬œ䞊 㶎┚ḱμૣ೛䞊ᔞ⪃ᜧტⷘៀ䞊Ⴚ䓂ሆ㟆េ䞊㾉┉ᅰ㶪䞊ૈქ㱱㬡⾰Ⴙど䞊┊ጽ᪫䞊 ⑬㕼㱞⬵‰䞊ლ䞊㜫 ქ㈟䕗䞊∢㥈䞊㶗␛Ḳ䞊ଚ⮲✱ㇼᪧ䞊ཙ┋ጾ䗫⫍␍䞊ጿⲝ䞊⎺☫㱜䞊┌㏂䅩㱝᯶䞊⢣ㇽ䞊ၐᔄ⎟♋ㇾ⊹㾊㏻〮Ś䞊஗ୱ䞊♀⿘䞊๭ᛵ㾋㐱ᔞ㪢㥉䞊⮦۪۟‫ؖ‬ɸ䞊 ૲ᄺ㱰㰡⾾ṇ̬՟䞊 ᕿ㮰䞊ⷮყ᪬ḳ䞊ⷔፀ⾾䕘䞊⯁ሆ䆙ᦉፁ㾌㎿㥅䕗䞊㥊᭬⻴ጻ㟆⫶㮰䞊㵺㕽䞊ఫଛ<䞊ች㫾㬝Ḵ㽾㱞䞊ፂᔍ㓣䉦㷨䞊ଛ⚈⿠䞊෕ቲ᪭⢤⾰NJ䞊㠕ែ℘។㥒㥝̯⿗⋦䞊㾍㔎䞊ଆ⢬㈗䞊ූፃᦻ♀ㇿ䞊ყ㱣䞊㹇⎭ᰗ䞊 㕾ℏ⇸ៃ㾎ፄⲞ䞊ඬ␪ፅ⮡⢭ℎქ㷛ោ䞊ፆ䉧ᦃ䞊㵹┛ḵ䞊㥟䉸⫹㠨䞊㕿ℐ䞊㻈┍ᴓ䞊 ഐ㱝ⲟፇ⸒☦ᛵ䞊䓄㎹㥕⮲᪮ɰ䞊 ੎ᗮᘥ㖀㥋ᤁ⢥㪖⋧䞊㶪㑅䞊ፈ䉨䞊௺ૈඃ䞊ნ㱞䜿ᮩ㾏ő䞊૊ፇ㯵䝀㈀ፉ⿵䞊㱟㜬㖁⫺ᮎ䞊 㖂ℑஸⲥ⾰䞊෗ፃṈ┎⾻䞊§ე㯵䞊ՠℒ⎫ᛝ䞊䓅ᮃ㟣ḳ䞊ሩ䞊⋨㒶᪵ɯ¨䞊 ૙ፕ㱘㱠〮პ⾰䞊ፃⲠ㯟㏾䞊 㬀㵹ᄉ㶪᭙ᥲ䞊㶪㐁䞊ፊ㈁䞊⇌రರ䞊㈂㬆㯵ᜠ䝁䞊㾣├ፋ㺋䞊⎝䝂䞊┏ᵅ፭㠅᪯䞊㺹┐ე㾐䞊⪋ա᷿䞊 မɬཚ̍䞊ಃ㕵䍜ៅ㥒㥞䉷㈃᮫㈄㻕䞊␛ፌᦟ䞊ཛ⮋፰㛠㜭ᱜ᪱䞊ፍ㛕㛊㟝㏂䍕☱ゆ≣䞊䏫☱㱡ლ㬆䞊₋㖗㟣䞊ℛ㖘㟈᭹⚘⋩ミ䞊ࠎդ㷹䉩ե⬀「բ㮰̪䞊 ഑⫻䞊ំ䉪ハ࣓☱ᦰះ㢄ᘫΒ䞊䝃䄮ៈ┑䞊 㫑៎ॎ㱢䉫㥌᯿㰱䞊㶌㖃䞊ᔖᯡ䞊♋⾻㱣䉬⇜៉⢦Ḷ㈅㾑䞊ყ㯄䞊㺋␍䝄㟇៊䞊ፎ㠋់䞊ፄⲨ㟙ᶟፏ᪁䖉䞊ḷ⾴㖄䈃⋪⎝䞊䙥‫׸‬㱤⮨♥㥜⻿䞊⸌䞊㷪⏉Ḹ䞊ယㅮ⚈㹋᷏᪰䞊໵㺃ፐ⮋ᯡ㬧䞊ⲡ㑉䞊ᦑḹ㭟㶒㟣㎶䗬䞊 㾒┒䝅䞊୲ㇺ⟗㾓‟䞊ཛྷ㾔ፑ㽾ᮩ㬡䞊Ⴚ㈘᪱䞊ⷘნ⫶᭷䞊⟦㹚䞊፡ㇻ䞊ഒ㱘⮡ኴⷢ⢳ᙚ䞊㱥ࠏፌ㾕ᰗ䞊䓆☫㽋┓ύ㈆䞊㵹ṅグ䞊㾖㕴䞊 ⇹ⲩզ᱀ᯮ⿠䞊䗭̭ࠒቲ㥘㱦䞊 ੹៍Ḻ㖅㥍㥛⯃⻵⋫䞊㷑㕴䞊య໧ೣ䞊 ᦇ㎴᝛䉭⻶ḻ㪗ⲝཡƿ䞊ଜፒ㬀㬑㈇ლㅼ䞊ፓ⮛㱧㏮䞊⬁㈠᭱䑳䞊‫☱چ‬㈈䞊ෙ्ᦟ♥「ā㬊䞊℗፯⻯☦⮌䖉䞊⢧ㆬ䞊ཛྷो䇥ᨮ♂䞊઀㥈ፔᖀ⢧ፕ䞊ፖ㈉᧊䞊㱨㛹Ḽᄺ⫼㱣䞊㖆ソ䞊└⢧㬀䞊 ⸸㐔ᔈ➚Ⲣḽ䞊 㶒᮱⬼ᶐ৥⏮㖇ፗ᭴䞊䒣☦㶪␪䞊⻷្⻾ᔍࠔ=㟆ཝ䞊㎶₥䞊㶰⎟ᲃ䞊ℓᇰ⻺⢟Ⲧ䖞䞊䓇⎟㏞䞊ፘ㠎Ḿ䞊⮌⢭䏦☱⾻⋬䞊⢨㈚䞊㺃⏫ᲊ䞊࿽ゕ⟪㾗ᱜᦅ䞊༪㾙ሶⲣḿ㬀ɸ䞊

ຝⲪ⢰㖈㈊᱕䞊ู䅷⹝ᖁṀ㥎㬖䞊ේ♙㈎⫽⢮ヅ⋭䞊੺ʋᕲ䅔䞊ၹ䅎ᔷौ♙᪁ፙ䞊Ⲥ㖉䞊‫☷ޅ‬䞊୳㕃⻸㜮 ፚ⿭䗮䞊 ⢩፛䞊㵻ᖂ⪄䞊ည䉮☦㹋Ლ᪲䞊་㶂ቊ㾘ᮦ㱩䞊፜ヅ᪳䞊፝䞊ཞ፞䉯᪴♥䞊 ⲧʼn⛐㛷 ⭍㖊ⷶ㈋㾃䞊⚔㈌䞊ၘ㈍㱪⯃ⲭ➟፟ ⋮ ៌㑅㈎䞊 ๮⾴䞊 ซ፣㟒ᘥ⑯䞊 ‫ۉو‬œ䞊 ‫ي‬СФ‫ى‬䞊࿽̉໾ɫ䞊ቯㇽ᪮䞊៍㏋፠⯕⚈㵺⡩㎳㈏䞊 ℘㖙㡕ᘢṁ䝆䞊㥏ᮩ㺃㟙♋᳘䏧ᮄ᪵䞊㵹⑱᱑䞊㾙៎⮕៓㛊⎦㑍ࠖࠗ䄆䞊ᔡ㏋㏊⫶䞊㖋℔䞊੻ᕲ䄯䞊 ၺ䉰ᖃ㈐✷ᦁ፡ő䞊䓈⑞㖌⻹䞊㾤┝Ṃ䞊ပ̉ཟɰ䞊౿㎳䏨ᚄⷎ⻺ᚍ㖍㾚䞊␪ৢ䞊♋ᦅ䝇⿉㹚⠣ⲫ⢱᱕ᦁ䞊፮㱯䞊ჴ䞊㬡Ḥ㈡☫㏾㥐䞊።⯆ɓ ່ዼ×⢪ᦟሪ䞊㏂ਞ䙔㥑ሲ㾛⢀㕵ࠐ㥖㈙⯕䞊 ᗮ㓦㎿㟙ᦊ⠣㈑፣㾜㖎㥒䞊 ੼ᚍᙚ㖏㥚᪻⠗⿏ ⋯䞊㻘㏋䞊ᄕヒ䞊బ૥ೞ䞊ᤒ㖐ᘹ䅷⸏៏〮㹔ő䞊©ᄽ䞊㥓᭙䏩⢫ᵜ䓃䞊㎳ℕ㾝㓣ရ䞊㟆ᥙ㖑㥔᪺㱰䞊␛ূ⢯㱫䞊⬼☷て⫾ᰰᨢ䞊㱫᭜䎁᳘㥈፤⯕䞊㕍№䞊㶪⑱᮲䞊 ⾰䉱㶯㈚ᖆᛩ㢅㱬䞊ℙ㖚䉴㈛᪶䞊☯㈜䞊ၻ㈒ᔧ፥գᦅፌá㬡䞊㛛┕㎴⻻ࠑႠඅ㑅㖒⫿䞊䓉☫㵹⎭䞊ဓ̫འɯ䞊㛎┖㏋ォṃ䞊㈓䉥ⷃ┗Ფ㪜ɰ 䞊 ๯㈔᱀䞊㏁ĸ㷢⎭័䞊⻼̮ࠓ⻽ᔧᤵ㟒㬀䞊㶒㬑䞊 䉲⾾Ⲭ⢲㱭㼱ᶝᩃ䞊ᓺ᪷䞊㱲䅤┟ḫ㠆☦ᖄṄ㪷䞊㾢㏤䞊ᖅ䗯䞊㵺┞᮫䞊੽༉ພ୔๰ෘ䞊୴㎴㥗㜯㎴㠆፦㵹㷅㏊ヒ䞊✱㈕䞊੾㬆㛠~⾰œ䞊୵㎴⭸㖓㟆፧᪸㖔ʓ䞊 ๱⿭䞊඄䉳⬼䖗䞊⮡‫ڡ‬Ŕ䞊ًЦХࣗNj䞊

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 4 of 18


   






䝈ி೛䞊ಱᘡয়ᩳ㞲䉹ᆮ㈣៕㥠㬺䞊㱳᭚⿵㵺䞊ᆪ䞊⬺᭼Ⴚᦋ䞊㵺㒄䞊E⏘ᳱ䞊ஹ᭼㈤䎊Ṋ㥡䞊℟⢷ᱧ⬺ᨓ䞊๲ℬℭ☦ៜṋ䞊㠨៖㞳䇹ᥣⲱ☢ㄒ⋲䞊㾦┠ᆪ㵹䞊 ㉓䓐ៗ㱴⢸☱⋳፱㾧᳽䞊㺉┡☭㱵䞊 ᘹ㖛ㅔ㉒Ṷ᛹㵹☱䉺ॏɯ䞊 ๲ⳂC䞊໻Ṍ㛵㷨ṷⷢᕃṸ㥀䞊Ҧ۫Ŕ䞊‫ؠ‬ϴЧٌ䞊㈥≙៘「㸏㬗䞊㏊‴䞊㸱ᖇ៙䞊஺ṍ〽䏬Ṏ㥢䞊ఱ⛡ṏ⬺᪼䞊๳⃩⇻᝾Ṑ䞊㤴៚㱶㛊㖡゛ᦋ̴᪽ࠢƓ䞊䝉ձ̶ᄧ㾿⼋⋴䞊ෑ⚅⼀>䞊 㶌┼ṑ䕟䞊ᖈ፲ᦋ䞊᝷㏊⹑㜰⭀Ṓ㾨᱕ᦥ䞊㶏┠Ქ⣙㠐䞊♊㥶䄾㸱⣇ࠦ⩷䞊☱㖜䍲ᯖ㲅㼧⡄⋵ࣂ㾩☱㏞㈦ɯ䞊 ં᜴៛㏁㟐᪾⢹⿃⋶䞊㶌㖝䞊㶗⏘ṓ䞊లκ⮜Ă㯱䞊஻ᱜ⿄䍦ṹ㥭䞊๴⇖⣏ៜᯡnj䞊 ਼རຟ୷๏ූ䞊ի㱷䞊㺾┢ᶶ䞊䓏⣚ӿᖉ㢞៝⭀⣝क़䞊᛹㏞㟐㜷㏋㠰፳㵹⢺㖞ㅔ䞊៞⏝፳㵹䞊 ⹑ᆪㅔ኱⋷Ṕ㭉䞊㾬┽᳽䞊፴⇕ጨ⢻㡀㱸䞊㏕℠䞊㾓⑛ṁ䞊୸㏁⯕㎳㥮ቷᦂ㖟䞊㠕᠂㬡☱㿃Fᙺ㖠ᜧᮝ䞊㎳℡䞊ຑ㠐☱㈧ᘙᰒ䞊㈨ᆍ⿅ᪿ፽㡀Ŝ䞊㸏⒍ᮄ䞊ལ፵䉻ᦋ⢼䞊ᄽⷘᖊৃǐ̵㱣㱹፶ᦂ㎽Ǎ䞊㶓㏪䞊⯲⎮࠘䞊 လㅔ⣣㶽ᰀ᪒䞊ཤ㾢ࠫⶼ៟㭉ɱ䞊 ࿑⎭ṕ䞊₻᎖០⠛Ⳉ♌㾪䗰䞊➣㫾䞊㛺㥮㖺㼧᭼᜴㶗Ṗᦂ䞊ᔫ䕟䞊໿ᝦ⢽㉐ࠪ࠙⢾㵹䉼䞊ཥᲛ១䉽㢧⣥㺶䗱䞊 ઃ⋸᭼⿃㵹ζ䞊㎴™䞊㾵ख़២䞊஼᯹㈩䏭᮪㟐䞊ళ☱䝊Ⲳ㿄ⳉ䞊๵℣⇺ៜ᭞䞊 ⾾㏊㾫ṗᦖ䞊㾬┣፷㷿䞊⿥᭳⛡㶗┾ᰟ㥣䞊ਸ໷ຠ୹๲ු䞊㈪㖡㤬䞊ག៫⢿⼁㈫ॐ㟖䞊གᰀᗮ䉾㠴⚮㷿䗲䞊☱㬊䞊ⳃ☥㬉㷛Ṍᫀ䞊☱㈬䞊㵹┴᭼䞊㚻┤㖡ㆫṘ䞊ᖋ㒹㏁⬂䞊㖢㥤䞊⣀㬉䞊᎕㲉☦?䗳䞊 Ⰱ㖣៣㈭ⲳ㉑ᖔⲴ፸ɬ䞊 ⲵ㈮䞊䝋ආ᫁⣁㿀⣛㖤㈯ū䞊㶏┿㖥䞊୺㖦Ⲷ㖧㥯᎒ᨱ㖨䞊ས㖨᠄㥥㖩Dீ㥱Ŏ䞊㖪ℤཧ㹵㈰㾭៤ăಅ䞊㖫℮⇼៥ṙ䞊┥䉿㖬䞊㈱㖭䞊㪉Ṛ៣㖼㡹䃥䞊៦ ⣂ ઄ 䞊 ཨມ୻๶ෛ䞊 ࿓┹ṛ䞊 ஽Ṍ㈲䏯Ṝ㥦䞊㖮⇝៧ࣶ䞊ᦁ☱ᨌ䞊㈳㎴㹁䞊ሎ㈴ṝⷘ㚹៨䞊㵹㏞䞊⼂ᅢ⬃᭼䞊ᅆㅔ䗴䞊⮕㖮ᘙᆪ⭵䞊⟠䊀㞴䊁ⲷ㢃⣦Ṟ㬺䞊፹ᖌ㖡䉽㵺䞊અཀྵຢ୼๲ොŦ䞊፺㫾䞊෡ղէ៩䗵䞊⪔ᜣ⭖⣃៪䏮ṟ᫂䞊㵹┦॑㽆䞊 ॒ㆨ䗶䞊➲ㅔ㞵䊂⣄㥧❤᭚㬧䞊㟐ᮄ⋹ࠤ⣞㠴᪑♌㈵⋺䞊આཪຣୈ๷ො䞊䑮㕆䊃⬺᫃䞊┧᯵䞊㞶䅋❑៫⬄Ⲹ䗷䞊@ਅⳅ㐠䓊㖜䞊ᖍ䗸䞊຤㈶॓ᘯṠ䞊⮗‫ڇ‬㈷㈸਀Ⳇ፻ࣇÊ㭯䞊᭿ⷤ㛁⮗㖡䗹ᯖᲥ䝌ɬ䞊 ா䅩ᰀ䞊 㾮㎽䞊㵹⎮ࣷ䞊㱺Ṻ〞㭁⣅㸏⡼䏯⣆㼧䗺䞊㑇℥䞊ဝ䊑㲇䞊⼃ᅈぃ៬㥨Ɠ䞊㾰⏫ṡ䕤䞊ᦅᰨ᝽⛹᫄ᮻᨶ䞊㶷㎿䞊┨㑇⬺᫅䞊ⲹ┩Ṣ䊄䞊❺㈹䏰᥿ը⣇⋻ᆪ㾯⛡㏊㈺䞊㖯Ω䞊੓ཫລୌ๸ූ䞊♋㇮䞊ᅰᔚᵐ䗻ᄧㆱ៭ᮻ䞊 䇦ゕ㷛☱Ⲏ䞊㾰┪᳕䗼䞊㟆᭨៮ᰉ☱䏱ᰉᩯ䞊፷ᦂ㿅ⲿ⣈㶗♌㎴⺌ӭഔ䞊⌃䊒✤ᦋጉ〽ᚼ᭶䞊∷㏁⼄䞊ఴଣഗ䞊ಲ៼Ϗ㥳⣧㞷䄾᎓̸㪫៯㥪ࣔɳ䞊 ઇ៰᝽㏞㟐᫆⣉ㄸ⋼䞊թШ䞊㵹┫ṣ䞊௹ૈകū䞊㾱⎱Ṥ䞊㜱⑛㖰ぺᷞ䞊ゃ䊅ඇ๹ᖎ៱㡕䞊㖡⃩䞊ᎁㆫ䞊Ѣ〝䊆⠏䏢ҥ᫇䊇ᄏ⬺䞊॔ࠩ䊕ゕ៲᫈䞊䚡䚢䚢䚢䚢䚡䚢䚹䞊㖱℧䞊 ยᘈෝ៳፼⿃ǎ䞊၂➔㥰⋽䊈ࣞᇧ䞊䓂፽㫾䞊℥㖲䄺㈻ᦁ䞊䓋☱㺢⏘⠑⿃䞊㿁⒫ᮄ䞊ṥKÅṦ៴㷿㱻䞊㑙ℨ䞊ੱࠚ⼅䞊 ၼ䆩ᔕቻժ᪬ᄧ̹䞊 䚢䚭䚭䚢䞊ի㭏䞊㟐‧㐎㠐㶓ᯖᦊⲎ䗽䞊ॕ䞊 ᕍ㎴ᩯ䖑⋾⼆⼇⮜䞊ᅑⲺ䞊㶏⏐䝍䞊༨ᇜ䆇᪑⣊䞊 ௓ࠛ㈼␍ᇜ㲋㱳䖀䞊⟪⿮䞊ၗ፾㬊┬լお⋿ⲻ䊉ㄕŰ䞊஺୽ ʍ䞊 ྭ⏐᭚䞊Ⲽ䙶䞊ଟೞ䞊㈽㖡䓌䞊㬉䅀䝎ਟ䝏ᚼࠜ㱼䞊㵺⎤፾㸢䞊┭ṧ䞊㪙⣤৪䗾䞊ᖏ䄇䞊ᄉ䞊 䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢ʟ䞊 ⣡⿺䞊፿䞊໹Ṩ㛅ࠝ៝⹑ᖐᮄ㟖䞊խ ‫ ڳ‬ʍ䞊ٍϬϦَ䞊᦭㖻ᛥ䊊‫㉎ݼ‬ᴾㅔ㵹Ǐ䞊㻠⏃ṩ䞊వଠೞ䞊ㅔ㖲ࠞᯖ˭䝐䞊 㷚⏃ᎀ㺳䞊㿂⏃ᵿ䞊૥䊋㟕Ṫᎁ䊍䞊ѹ㬗䞊 㖳㛊ṫ㇠☱㈾⌀䞊ᎂ ㈿ 䞊⡒ࠟ䓍ᤶ㱽䊌⌁ᎃ㶷⣋㏊⿃䞊㏊㉀ɔ ᦋ䅄ᮝ䞊㾲㑇䞊㷆┃Ṭ䞊㱣⛡⣌៵䞊᎔⿠᪾䞊䏲ᎄ⬺䊍ᵂ䞊㏊ℨ䞊┮⣍㬱䞊㢃ṭ㭩☥᫉Ṯ㉁ᙄṯ䞊ᎉ㉂ᦧ䞊┯⣎㱾䞊㬡䆡㱿㜲⠩៶➣㎴䊖㬗䞊 ώ៷㾳❹䏣⡄㶏䕰䞊ⷲ䞊ᎅ㛡㜳㥩㏞ᎌ᛹┺❼ㆫ⌂䞊သʏ໳ ʍ䞊 ⲽ㉃㵹᳈⯕⮜☦⋓៸ࠧ㉏ᙐ᭼䞊୒㐯㟐㟐䓑⣨䉽お⣏㾴䕑䞊㛒᭼㟐㬼㏞ゃ⾾᯹⬺ɰ䞊 ೑⣐䞊ჽⱮA㐒䞊ُ㛊ਟ៹ᎆ㥪㬩䞊㾵ᖑᎇ䚔䙼䙼䙼䚕䞊 ⎣ᎈ㬊䞊ᔕᮙᮝ㉄䞊⛡⿗䞊ᘖ㏊⿅㵺ᎈ៺㾶䞊䓎⚇㼕┰䞊

ʐ䞊䒯┸⣠ᘙ┱䞊✘㮺䞊⬺㎴ᘹᎉ㷛᳽᫏䞊lj⣑㹇䞊䚼䞊 䚡䚡䚡䚢䚡䚡䚣䚽䞊⣒ヘ䞊ซᜠෞᶢ፳⿮Ŕ䞊၃☱㠅⋾✘ㆫ⛭፶˶䞊 ࿒┲᭿䞊శ્ෟ䞊┳ᎊ㲀䞊⣓ᦋᯂ㉅㵹⚮ࠥ⣟᫊ࣸ䞊㾷⎣⣔㲁䞊ᎋ㪸㉆㢧ᮻ㲂㮚䞊ᄽ‫ڣ‬䞊⭁⏘៻䞊ᎌ᫃᫋㟐ṻ㲈㮽䞊㖡℩䞊 ⲾĄ㈶⼈ࠠ៼䞊ଡᇧ㉄ᫌᅆ㠐ɳ䞊 ઈᘙ៺㖮㤏ᫍ⼉≡䞊㹌㖴䞊㾸┴ḷ䞊సତBŤ ɕ ☱㬉䞊㑇Ϋ㾹⣕៽ծ̷ࠣ⭂⬺䗿䞊ሾ䞊㿆Ⲹ゚䎐ᮝ㥫䞊ℯ㖽㥬䞊㶳⑛Ṱ䞊໷ᎍ䄾ᦂ⢃䞊௝‫ܮ‬ㄕ┵ॖज㲃䕳̫䞊 
ၙ⶛཭䞊ᎎⲿ㬉㖵䞊┻̳㉇⬅៣᫑䞊㵺㏞䞊੪༣຦୩๲෠Ű䞊ਠ㉈㉉ៜ᭚䞊‫ ۊ‬ბ䇫ᦇᎋ㟒ą㲄䞊䅶⼊ᖒ㟐᳻Ⳅ⯕ዘ䞊៾៿ࠨ〝㛁ॗ㣭̺䘀䞊Ⳁ㖶᛹ᎏ㾺ᮟᫎ䞊⣖⿠䞊

୾㎳⬺㔟㥤ᅈᦥ㖷ʩ䞊 ⳁ㾻䞊㫾⑬㖸䅀⯁ᦂ䞊ᕹ᱓䞊⿺㑇㵹ṱ᪚䞊㵹┶৫㼧䞊㾼ⓘ᭼䞊షଢഖĆ㬉䞊ฺ㑦䏳ᮄ⻠ᖓᮝ㤏䞊೐ ཬū䞊ِϡϨّ䞊㠖ᴃ㰙㜴㓏⿅㫾Ṳ䞊㫾䊎㾽ᱜ㭏䞊㾾⎟᎐ࠡ䞊ªୱഘઉ䞊㥴㥵ᅰ䝑㬆䞊 ┷ყ䎐ṳ䞊㥲៼䏴ᛏ჉⮲᠃৶ⳇ䞊կհО䞊 
Ĺ䞊ᯬ⺖㜵┸፱㲊⡼㲅䞊৬᪡᪬ᶢ᫏Ŋ䞊⬺☱㎩䞊ᔞ᠀㥷䒀᳡ᯓ⿺䞊ㆫ䊓⼌ᕾ᭢㡀㭏䞊⣢㖾䊏㉊ᦧ䞊⣜㉍䞊ၽ䊐㖹ნ➖᫐ሮć䞊㲆䞊㜶⏃㏁㉋Ṵ䞊᠁㑛㑇⬆䞊 ሒ㉌᧔䞊ゕ䊔⼍ᔕ…䞊⣗ア䞊㷛┴ṵ䞊࿹ㅔ⣘㵺ṵ᪾䞊໽㶶᎑㵺ᰰ㮀̲«䞊

D52&$DD.DAD

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 5 of 18

Lj̲d՛NJƸ՛Ǝ¡Æʐ҄υʑ³՛Ǘ՛΋ȳǘΌ a՛àͦ’СӁ̆ʒ<՛ǎ̴¤pͶŽ ϥ՛ӵӶφȟ2Ѷ՛Ơ΍՛ҋĕ՛ NjҌ.ϣǙ՛Ŵ̵՛Ʃɥ Ϧ՛ ҿ+˧ȴ̇¢¾¯ʓ՛ϧ՛Ʋ·̶ҍǚϨ÷՛ ǂÒʔ՛ϩӷχ0˝«՛Ģĵ՛ͽ½\Ҏ1Ѿ„0ʕ՛ӂ՛ȠԼ՛՛•Ԗ̷ɦÅNΎ՛ϪŠ3ѻĈÍ՛ Úκʘ՛ Ā՛ Î




















Փ՛ԪǛ՛zӃe<ԗ ʖԫ a՛ȡ Խ՛A̳ʗ՛ƌŻƚ՛̸ϫ՛ Ƣǖő՛ ĮĎďįD՛ Ƒʙ՛ȵ$½!ɧ՛Ϭ$³՛ʚԻшȝ՛Ԭ̈B՛̉ ҏ՛ϭ¾ψ\ˤ՛ʛϮɨʜɩ՛ͷŔщ՛OĹ՛Y՛İ˨ʝsӸҐȶ՛
ƳǜΉ»Șìí
 Ȣ|ŕĖ՛ґӄijΏŪ‡՛ΐ̊τŖ՛ ̋ʞ՛ĺȷqÂΑȎѰΒԾ՛ъќԘ ɪʟҒ՛ғՖѺö̹ȸȹҔ՛ ʠ՛Ⱥӹы‰˞՛ÇśĐ՛șѳʡ՛ьʢ¥±Тϯǝ!՛Ǟҕ­̺­GPѝҖ՛Ӳх՛ƴ҂Žɛ˟՛ƷǟϰɤVў՛ ǃ̻̌®՛ УӺэÜҗ՛ɫϱԙn՛{՛X՛njΫάΓ̼Æӻ*9՛ T;h՛

á՛ԭ̍՛|¯՛ȞҘ̅Пf՛Ф՛Ӆ5 ՛LǠӼӱ‡Ϳ՛

ƅωȣWҙԿ՛ͼϲ՛ǐҚȲλăМpХ‘â՛ƃżE՛ HȻџȼ̽ϳ˹՛Ք&&&&Ƅ =ʣrÀΔɡ¦Հ Ƚǡξ:ȾÍ՛ Ȥ¿қ̾ϴνÛąҼ°՛ Q’ɬ՛ ˴¬ˠћÁ “¶Ձ՛ǢԚʤέҺ՛ȥǣ2†՛+ϵɭ՛˲у=Ӯ̎՛ėđ՛ Ƶ՗Ά ǁGNОø՛ K@̏ʥ¦՛MĘǕήίɮ̿՛ƏЦԛʦѠ϶ϊҀϷӆ՛K˷ɜͧRˆҜ՛”՛ӇȦg՛Ǎ”̀@jɯ՛ƹµǤʧ՛ Ýǒ̫Ч՛ƪŠՂ՛ƒǥԜʨ՛ŵʩʪ—՛́ϸ՛ŽШӽӈǦȿA՛ Ó ͂ΰ̬՛´̐g՛ƺʫюʬŠ]ʭ§՛ģ Ĥ ՛Ɠ̓΀ǧɀ΃ʮѡҝ՛ ų;Щ#˺՛Ӊ̑h՛8ĄН̈́ԝęÅȏΕҞ՛Ç՛ŒǨՃ՛̒ǩԞʯ՛ȧ4 Ÿ՛ČҟѢSӊӴ՛%˩¼–Ɂ՛ŏͰΖՑÏΗՏŒϤͲ՛Ťɰ՛ŶΘՒƫsΙѼĉӭ¬՛ Ԯ-ҽ՛L̓ǪBͻĻù̔՛Κ(ljxÀϋσͅѣՄú՛ ū^`ЪѤɱ͆Ϲq՛ΛЫ՛Ӧ6ɂîĚɃ‹Ьѥ.“ɲϺŒ՛Ѧʰԟ ԯo՛ȨՅ՛̕i՛ơȩ՛ǓЗіӾ͇Ê՛ ƻӋǫ˭ˮ'՛ Ô͈ϻӌ͉/Μ՛͊ϼɳ 1ťĆ}ϽҠ՛Őͱ>ʱ՛uǬӍ՛ȐÐCDž̭ЭόȑѧՆ՛ύRÈ՛̖SԠ՛̗ʊ՛ǭ՛яtÈҡ͋ɄǮΝ՛ϾѨ՛˱͵Ͽώʼn8,՛Ʌ£ѱþЀʲɆļě$›՛ãЮ՛



ǯΞïƔ͸μρϏ~՛-ɴ՛/:CƬ̘͌ɵyȚ§ä՛Ȫӿµ՛԰ʳ՛ǰ¨՛Ңӎαβ՛!%%Έ•˻՛Ο՛ӏ̙ ң՛ѐҤҥ͍ȫ͎Π͏ӐՇ Õ՛ IƣðDŽ̚ԀϐDZ7«Ë՛‚Ҧ՛

Dzɇ^>ibʴɶ՛ɷ͐ёЯϑȒӧ՛dzӑ՛Ӓ̛ʵ՛Ƽԁɸ͑՛J£Ё²ÄTӓj՛͒–՛ƨ ՘՛Ŭ—˼ʶˆ˥ՙ՛œ҃՛͓՛ȓ‰ҧа՛ɈЂҨĜcɉЃŜɹ՛ ЄŨÞ՛б˪՛̜ʷ՛ Ö͔ϒ*‹ҩ×՛ǴӔ՛ӕ̝ʸ՛ƥ͹Рr՛!õßȔ̮ı՛ƭҪїԂʹ՛ͨИ՛žÁΡԡʺѩ՛ſՈå՛ƀ-ͩ˳ф҅€,՛ Î










Օ՛

ŭ_ ¨€ž˽՛Ӗ ՛ Ƈŷ΢՛ɺ%ɊԺӳʻЅ·Ӏæ՛̞ʼ՛Ƨ Ÿ˾՛ƈȕyǵɋ՛ϓ ҫјԃʽ՛ԱȖһ՛ȬԄ͕γ՛͖#՛ĝ ķĸĶ՛˵ѷвŊЙ՛͗ԕ#ɻ͘şŞ՛ ˶Ѹϔ՛Ө̯՚՛)ц¿ũ9 ՛HѽȜȭ+՛JԲĽĞ՛ƶҁІ_ʾ՛ŮȮԅ"UՌ ՍF՛ dž̰ʿ՛ϕг°љÂˀ՛ ՛U@¸ˡ#be՛ȯՉ՛ϖˁѪ˜04Ї՛д˫՛ŝ՛ MVԆʋͪ՛ƁеōĪԇΣǶ¶3՛ Ј՛LJÿж՛ů™˿˂"kҬ՛[šɼ՛‚?՛Գ͙ɽ˃ΤՊ՛΄ĥĦԹК՛ľ©՛ƒө՛Лӗ͚ñǑӰŘÑͺӘ˄ϗ՛ԢԈĿԴҭû՛ ѫŸƛ՛ ɾзɌԉϘ  ·Ү՛͛šɝ͜ɍšәɎ՛A̟Ƿ՛Ʈδͫɿ̠QѴ՛ŰȰʀԊ9εǸ̡՛ɠͳœиԣ˅՛ǹ(ƟζчՐϢ„՛.ŀ͝ʁ՛ǺΥ(īĩͯuʂ5ЉѬ՛ğĒ՛Ӛ̢ˆ՛Ʀ…̀՛Ɖạ̊́ȗʌ՛ Ư¡үњÃkü՛ȱˇ˸©ˈ՛OƤ՛Ċ՛ưǔ6ʃ5Ǽ>՛Ѳoԋ҆ˉʄ՛й՛ƽπԌ՛űѭĂ;Ġǽý՛ ƾˊԤdªț"՛}›ʅ͞ԥʆÃWΦ՛ ԍ՛¸̤ӯŗ՛ƆǾҰç՛ƂкXұ՛Եлϙ՛Ӫ6ˋ՛v͟΁ǿɏӛˌ=Ҿ՛ϚȀÉ՛̥/Ԧˍ՛ϛˎӜ՛҇Ō'՛ ŧ8Χ՛ȁc՛ 2œЊˏ`ӝ͠мЋҲ՛՛Ӟ̦l՛ƿԔ ՛ƐςԧːϜ҈ɐ‘η՛ IFˬӟɑ՛´vm՛¹ˑ¥~±Ӡ՛ȂӡӢȃɒ†?è՛ºw˒՛ƊŹƜ՛͡ҳɓнԨf¤mʏ՛wӫë՛ ԎЌ́՛ )ɔђŁ˦]4ª՛IJĔē ġ ' ՛łϝ՛…˜ʍͬԩ͢ԏȄ՛ЍȅϞ˓՛)̱ŋ̧՛,:òƕԐ?ҴȆÉ˔Ў՛ҵȇՋʎ՛YŃ՛¹t˕՛ҶĬЏńɕ՛АºɖΨ՛ϟ՛Ɩ˖҉$Бé՛ Ǐƒѹ̂7ćВāzȈ՛Զx˗Ѯο՛êħĨóƗ*ՎɢӬ7՛ԷP՛ȉÊ ԑ̃՛ГΩ՛̨˘՛ͭ;˙E՛ Ųɞɟоѯʇ{̄՛п՛ƋźƝ՛ɣ1ԒϠŅņ²՛ȊΪô ƘԓҷҸȋËɗД՛ͣ®՛ ŢѓєZѵˣ™θÌ՛Z՛Øǀ[Äʈ՛ƞЕ»l р<՛Ʊͮ ҹӣѿÌ՛nϡѕ"сB3ˢč˯˰ʹŚȌŇ՛Ù՛ ƙ˚՛ɘιţͤҊ˛ʉ՛ž ¼՛Ӥт՛ŦňЖ¢Ը՛ӥ̩˜՛̪ͥ΂ȍə΅ɚŎřD՛

#/ DDD @D

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 6 of 18

ᕩ䄿㾩䞊ყ⌑Ṽ⹬㲌䞊⣩⿌䞊㿇╀ᮕ䞊హூ⮜Ñ㲌䞊ၚᎋ㲍⑃❰〱⌊㿝㖿〱䞊఺♋᭼Ⳋ᧰䞊๺ℑℑ♯᠅Ფ䞊ᖕ៷╁ẃ䏵ᥠ䞊⑱᭼䞊䒋ፄ㲎䞊ᔍ᭜⣪ヶ⌄䞊᫒䝒㶫☦䎑ᵃ̉䞊 ࿔⏃ᮝ䞊⟓㪣㶎᠆㦍䏽☱᠇䑱䞊 䓂ლ㬿䞊㸝ᤷ㦈ʁ⼎おᅤ㶈ᘉᦁ䞊䑠⎟ṽ㗀䞊კ⬺ȩಳ䄺㬉㲚᎗䘁᠈ঔ䞊Ṿ♙㷶⑃ࠬ㥸䞊㜸ድ㬿㲏Ფᧉ䞊㗁䆳㶓䞊㔰㥹䞊ℸầ⚎⌅⿌᳽᪡䞊Ⴚ䞊㲐᳂☱䙕䅸㥺ṿ䞊㣽Ẁ㞸䉮⚆㦇❲㉔⌆䞊⼏ᙋ᪔⣫ᜤᆫĉ̀䞊 㿈࠭᠋ᎩK⼐ᵃ䊗㿘ɬ䞊 ಴ẁ䞊䑩Ꭳ㲞䞊㟆Ẃ⬺ᯍጒ㭙ẜᦑ䞊∸㔱⻛䞊㸴⎱ᵖ䞊⎥㗂झ㜹☦㹍ᎷH䞊㰵᠉䍠ᤸ㫒⬺䞊ᦇუ䖮㲑䞊 ⬺ᆫ㾈ẃ㟚䞊Ꮋ㉴ᧉ䞊⹾ረ⿉ᄖŐ᠊ᦑ䞊⣬㖡䞊ᧀ᠋㛙䓒䝓䞊⮥␛៝䞊 ဟ㉨⟏㷶ᯝ᫗䞊཮㷶᎘㶣Ẅ㬅䞊ᛆ⤈᠟㲙㛺♋㷶ᯝ䞊ⳋ᎙䑘䞊ẅおℶ㗒㟆ᗹᯀⷎẆお㷕䞊᤹⇍࠽㗃㪊Ξ䞊㷢㕞䞊⮜㒒᠌ᅞ㷶ṃ䞊᎚㉕ᧉ䞊㥻ᜌȦ✜㦉ͅ㼗᠒㤬䍜✷ẇ䓓䞊⎠⢃㫨̻䞊 ໻ႺⰹẈ⏃䞊უⳌȴವ䊘㱹˭Ǒრ䘂᮹ゴ䞊⣭㲒䞊㶎⏔ẉ䞊䉄㆟᠍ⳍ᰻䞊㏔℩཯᎙̓ɖどѢ䞊๺⿩ճᎻ㣽䞊ዪ⬺Ƞಢ䄾㲣㮑ყ䕘᳗お̼䞊 ໿ყ㫓☱䞊Ⴚ⬼Ƞಶ㉖㲓㱉᎛䕢ᰎヶ䞊♋㲔䞊 ᙐ㎸㉷ヶẊᙈ㿉Ả᫡䞊㿊㔰䞊㶎╂᲎䞊ങ㭶⬺ጿ⶿✘᠎䞊ઊ㯞㲕ᯀ⼑ᖖⳎ䕦䞊㓏ℰ䞊฻㒚㠕㶎╅䞊੍̽ⷂᯀ㪬ᛚረ䞊ĺൂઋŋ䞊Ꮈ㇬ᦅ䞊ᖗ䞊㿋⏤ᮕ䞊㱉䅗ᖘ⪺ᯐ᠏㹧䞊㑤ℱ䞊Ꮉ㉱䞊఻ଥച䞊 ᠐㏔䅣⼒ẋ㿙㿚᭙㟻㦌㗄㦋♙㮢ⷎ䞊⤉ヶ䏶ᯂ㲖㶬♋⌇᎜㷀♋㏞ㆴɲ䞊 ࿕⎟ᵃ䞊ీଧⳏ䞊́⒊᎝㱉䞊ე⬲㪈㔱䞊ᦁ⣮㬝᠐㗅䍭ᯞ㟒Ẍ᫓䞊㹝⏘᎝㷹䞊཰ლ⮕ả╃䞊ᄉ⮤Ȥಸ䍌㯼㬈ᄸ䕘ẍ㇗䞊♋㲗䞊ᄿ䞊⺺᎞⪤㗆㟒䞊 ᘖ㗓㐽䊡⤀ᖙĈඈ㶬㎾㥼䞊㿌㎿䞊㷹⎥ᰞ䞊⮜઒ๅઌǀ䞊ᆪ䞊䊙㏂᎟ȡ㚽㟗㒚๻㶎䞊㎳㤉≓ፐお⡀䙠⮥⡀㖂㉗䞊ᔍႺ㲘ᲄ᧪䞊೚㉘䞊ฑ⤇᠑╒⤁⌈᎛ん䞊մ⎥⼓䞊⣯㭵䞊᫔̴࠶᪔յᙗᎠնᠧ᫢䞊㶎㗇䞊㶎╄Ẏ䞊 㲙㜏㥽ẦᎢ᫕䞊㕳⁕䞊⮚㬉Ⳑ࠼䊢ど䞊䓔㗅㠏⬺ᧉ䒽➤᫖ẏɮ䞊 ਺ᙗᛙ㏂㟒᧞⛒ヶ⌉䞊շЩ䞊㷶╅᱕䞊௲໨࿖Ř䞊㷶╆᮶䞊ොૄɘÀઍÉ㭮䞊ⷎ☱㲚㯫☦㗈⿧䞊 ⢃㬉䞊ᅽᛓѶအٔ⬺⮕䗰䞊㸝㎳䞊㬡㜺㟒ᰰᎡ᫗䞊 ഛ㲛ⳑႺ⹁☦᠒䞊≏㉙ᧉᎢⷎẐぺ㿓ᎢⳎ⛜㬿ⷃ䞊Ꭳ㉚᫘䞊ཱग़⬹ᆓ℻㿜㬥㹋䞊ᧀ㏂᠓䄬✘⹯࠮䞊㿟⑑㠲㗔䄺⌊࠸⚽㑤⼔䞊Ⳟ⏃ᯎ䞊ဠ㉚㉸ᶟᧀ䞊໻㸬Ꭴ㶎Jड䞊Ꭵ㉛᫙䞊㾩⎠ᰊ䞊䓕㗈㟗⬺ᦅ䞊Ꭶ㷱䞊 ࠯ඌ⤆⊿᠔ʩ䞊࿗⑷䄈䞊⬶̈́ઑไϠ䞊㲜㗉ⳟ⤊᠛✷㿍㬧䞊∣⿌ᧆ㲚䞊∹㏗⼕䞊䓖ᰊლ⮕㹋╍䗑䞊༨Ꭷ㉜᪔⣰䞊ᖚ᳍㉝䄉⁹㉵᠕㶝㏔㥾㲝ŝ䞊᠖䔵㸏㥿᤺⼖♋㮭ո䞊⣱㰟⬺ᅞⷎչ᜘䞊ི⑱პ䘃⬇␖㭙ǒ䞊 㲚䄿͆䝔㜻ᥧ㹋䞊ヶ㏂㉞ȳ⌋㏔䍜ᵃ㉟䊣㉡ẑお㹆Ⳓ⬺䞊㒒㢐⌌ᅞㆈ⛜䙖ᇧ䄤㕋ヶ㬝ɰ䞊 ઍᘖᚎ㏂㟗᤻⤄⿗⊚䞊㶎㗊䞊㦀૓೛䞊᫚㏔ᘆ䊚⼗Ẓ⿗㷀㬥œ䞊G઎฼એ䞊╇ඉ㬥䞊㬝㏔ⳙ♋᠗⣲㿎Ấᦉ䞊 ⷮ㕵〱Ι䘄䞊∺㗋ⷎ䞊ວ㤉⛚㗌᠘Ḭ䞊ેᆓ⿧ᧆᎽ㟔ŕ䞊ᔍ⼘䞊㾩⎤᭼䞊᫛㏅᠙⭟M⻛ẓへ㶎㲞䞊Ꭸ㠪ᘟ䞊䊛⿧᠚႖᭙䊟䞊Ꮀ㲢䞊պϻ䞊䓗⎣ᮎ㶬╔᠛࠰䞊 ு䊤ヶ᧋ॾ䞊Ꮆᛚ㿏䄵ᄸⳚ⬺䘅䞊 ᘨ㏁㉲㿛㉠ᔍ⼙ᙋ᫜䞊⷏㏈㉡Ẕ䘆䞊ⳝ๾䞊㷑╈☱㲚䞊㖮㦁⌍Ⴚヶ⟏䙗ɰ࠱㉢♋㗍㉣˶䞊 ఼I‫ⳓڈ‬䞊ਁ⬺㎳ᘆ䊜㫔ᮝ㉤㶎㲟䞊ᎩⳔ㬉㒀䞊☦ど᧓☦ᘖ᎜㿐ẕ䞊㶫⎥ኣ㵹䞊㲚ᮒ䎆ẖ㟆ϐ⣳䞊ཱིፐ䊝᧓࠲䞊฽ጩ䏷ᅰ⬺䞊㏔⇞᠜ẗ㥀㬉䞊䓘ẘ㟏ẙ䞊ճտј䞊ᙚ㎵࠳վҠ፥᠝㶧䞊䑘☦㶫࠹⠴䞊㵹╉ẚ䞊 ໻Ṟ㜺㵼᭯ⷎᖛᯀ㢞䞊 ೐䞊ඊ䞊 ⎟✘⪻Ꮀᘆ⬈᱂㦂㲠ɰ䞊 ఽଦⳕ䞊ᦔ㗎᠞䉕⼚᲎ヶ㶎㬩䞊㬩㿑ज़㵹ᯝ䞊㵹⏔ᆟ㹋䞊㶎╊ẛ䞊໻ᄋ㉥䞊த⣴Ჷ⌎㏀䞊ా☫᱙⬶᫝䞊๺Ⅎℶ❲ᗳᮕ䞊㏯㜖ấ㉳ᮇᦑ䞊 ጒ䞊 ᘆ㏔䆳㉚㿒᠟࠺⤅ᠠ㫢㏂㉦㬩ⷃ䞊⤂ヷ䍭᭜㬉㶎⣵⌏ᅞ㶗⣇㗏ヶ䞊㏂㈏䞊ლ㉌䞊♋㉧ᧀ♋䏸⠚ᦁ䈭ᎪⳎ䞊お኶ⷎ᭙ᦁ䞊๼㯼ᅤ⼛ᅪ䞊฾㒚Ꭻ⑱Ɠ䞊इ䞊ུᎬ䉕ᧉ♋䞊฿Ꭽ䏹ᆍ⮕䞊㏞ℷL♯ᘅᘢ㦅ŕ䞊ᦁ䄾ᵖ䞊 㿏䏺䞊╈✘㲡䞊Ꮎ㲡㬀㎳ᘖ♋Ꭾ㿠✜㒑㉨䞊䓙♋㹆╋䞊เᎯ䓙უℳ䞊ᎰⳖȴಷᎿ䔶⹟☱䞊ᓭǓ᧓䞊 ත⑑ጿ⮀♋ᧉ䞊ᎱⳚȴร⣶⑑᪐ⳛ⣷Ꮂ㢻ɰ䞊 ⭋ヶ䞊Ꮃᦁᨾ⛚㿓⚈㗐ԾѢ  ෢Ⴚℹ❲䞊ᄈ⮤䞊ಸᓾᔍ❲Ŕ䞊 Ꮌど㎴㷢␎䄋㥀䞊ཱུჵ䊞ᦁ☦䞊แს䍚ყ⬺䞊㏁⇤᠒ᙄ㟔Ű䞊䓀Ⴚ㲐䞊☦㉩䞊Ⴁᯥ⮨᤺㛉╌㏔ヶ☫ᙈ䞊ᠡ㏔㉹㶈Ⴚᘢ㷀䞊䑎⣸㿔⏄䞊℺Ⳝ⣹≙╍㷶䞊‫ڼڻ‬ɸ⒱☦⪦ᄿᠢ⬉ᷩ㦃㲚䞊ථ⏔ድⳗ➩ᧉ䞊ᅞ⮕ȴฤ♃⎥ᦁ╎䊟䞊 ᅞん᪔䞊โኣ䓎ኣℴ䞊Ꮄ⮨ɓⳜⰫ䏻̾⼜̿☦䞊㎿゜䞊㉶⤋⿗ᯮ䞊㎾ᠣᠤᅰ㬥⣺㑝ん‚䞊∻㎿ⷃ䞊ฑ᎜㢞ᘢ⎮䞊ջ ռ ǔ 䞊‫ؙ‬ЫЪϿ䞊࠴㐍䞊ลპ㤉ᘢ╏䞊ْ‫ں‬ŕ䞊ٓ䝕ЬЬɸ䞊 ࿘⏔ᶍ䞊උኮᘢ⫔㬥㏔ㆈ䏾☣Ⳛ⬺ẜ䞊ు૓എ䞊ి⣻᱓⬺᪔䞊๺⇟ᘖẝ䞊✷㰞䞊ឪ㒚㉪᪐䊠ᘢ㿕☱㉫⊼䞊ᅬお䞊⟓㉬䏼ᮨ㲟㷶☦⌐Ⴚ㷶⟓㏔㉭䞊ജ๽䞊᫞ᶩ㿖ẞ㦁ⷎ✷㉮Ṟ䞊䐼═ᮨ㼂⒗ẟ㢐䞊 ྲྀᎺ⯄Ạ║䞊ઐ╓⼝᮲᫟䞊ஸᠥ᫠ঃ䓚⟓ż ࣹ䞊ཷᎵ䇋ᧀ♋䞊ใㅋ䎜ᎶⳘ䞊㗑⇠ᙈᰥ࠷ɗ ႢႣ⣼㶎ϙヶ䞊☦͂㬒䞊㿗ᘟ㦄࠵⣽㶎㎳㦆䘇䞊䓛Ⴚ㱮䞊⣾ん䞊ᙋ㗅㦊࠾㺢ॹᠦ㶎䞊䒋♀䃭െ䞊սゾ䕙䞊㉯ℵ㿞⑱䄊䞊 ㉰⣿⤃ ლᚽ⬊ạ࠻㬡䞊ʌ 䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䚣䞊




Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 7 of 18

࿱ᯇ䞊ూ໩೐䞊⏮჊㯑䞊ጸ⯙㲤㎽䞊᫣⤌㲥ᗳ㏁䏿᭹ࡇɚẨ᫣䞊㬌㗕⼞ᯇ䞊⼟Ꮐ㎥䞊㸢ẩ࠿⼠‫׼‬䄾㬺䞊ᗹ㕝㊜㊝Ẫᙗ㺾❢㗧⿃㬃䞊ᔫᴆ㿺䑎਎䞊໻ᄮ䊥᧞❢䞊ಆ㏚䍖᭹㦢ࡏ䍒᭞⾰㿯䞊 㚿ẫ㦎㱻㗖㉺㉻ᯜ⮕䞊Ꮑヨ᫤䞊㶗╕᭿䞊⎫⤰⪼Ꮒᚯ⫝ᰵ㟒㯑䞊 ᦃ䆺㥭☱㉼≰䞊㶘╚ᰯ䞊ᙐ㗗䊥㡎㲢ᰀ䞊㗇ℼ䞊㿡⏃㗘䞊ຨ௞֎ĥ࿙⳩Čૈ๏ฦ䞊⤍⿼䍣ᰨ㲦㠣♖⌒ᄠ⳱⤤㖞㊖ɬ䞊 ు㗩㥧䞊ᰯৣड़⼡㜼Ⳡᘝő䞊 ᅙᠵᘟ㗜㠧᫐⤟ひ⌓䞊ⳡ㗙䞊㸡╖Ậ䞊ుૈഝř䞊Ꮓ㉽䞊⤳㊏㿹⯛⤎䎜ր᫥䊦Ꮔ⯛䞊㉾Ꮹ⼱᱑᫦䞊ృᏅ╗ậᠨ䞊ઓᖨ᫪䊧⭚⭚Ꮖ╘䞊ླྀᏇ⬶ẜ⎯䞊ନᏮ͋ⶱᏈⳢࡆO䞊ၛ‫ډ‬䝖䞊ᠩ⭚㗚㬥Ắ䞊≇䞊⤏ắ㦠ࡎ᫧㲧䞊䑖⛡㾾╯䞊 ར䝗㷆ᰨᡃ㗪ᔫᲬࣈ ӽ Ҏ 䞊╙☫⪩ढ़ᠪ⬋ᰞ㦏㬉䞊ઔʁ╭ࡀ㉿ᷫ᫳䞊ᇷⱚɉ౬╚Ꮙⷤ᫨☱䞊Ꮺ㈩ᦈ䞊ొ⤪‫͊ڽ⼢⤨ޒ‬ᄉ䞊ჍPəಇ╛Ꮻ㊗ᦃ⚈ɯ䞊 }Ꮚ⬌Ꮛ⭍Ⴚ䞊㚼㟜ᰦ䐀⤐㏁䊨㮞ⳣ䘈䞊ĊႤΊ㒀㦐⬍৷޹ᨢ䞊 Η䞊 䝘䞊Ꮮ䞊㜽☫ⳤ㎽㿢䞊ℽ㏁㢞䞊㸢╜⪅䞊ཹᄭ䅠ᧉ⤮䞊໪㑮䘉პ⮕䞊⅄Ꮓ⼣♞⯽䝙䚖Ǖ䞊⤲⳴䙅⾰䙘䞊ဃ㬺Ⴚ⹟ᄽ䞊ૈ✜⿿䞊෦ᅙᦏ⤫⿃䞊ᕳ᭹㶗䓎ᮝᴻ㊀䞊ઊℾ٬ցᏣࡌⳲ⠏㯑ւᄺギ䞊Ꮜ⾰᫩䞊໿Ꮜ䊩ᧉ⚈䞊 ૆ጇᔈ⚈჊䞊ᦃ䉳㪭ㆫ⌔䞊ဣ૧෣î㲨䞊Ằ䔷☫⮕ᰜɫ¬䞊 ഞ⿗䞊Ꮝ᫪ᦃ❲㿰♓㐜㊁ƪ䞊ᇰ㊂䞊ె૧N䞊㬉㏀䊴ࡅᠫᙛ䞊㬏㸢ᅔ㺧Ị᫴䞊Ꮒ≈᯹㢞䞊ེᙼ㚿⳥ᷫ㫖㗛ន㦑䞊ѭ փ 䞊㿣␎ᆐ㿤䞊⎫ 㮼╝᮷䞊 䓢Ᏼ㭏䞊‫ڤ‬ЭÃ䞊㲩䄾㊃ࡁ䞊㿷⏃ᅪ㺖䞊Ꮞ⳦ȷๆ㿸⤵╞ᡂ⳺╮ᅙ㟏䞊䒘Ꮵ㬣䞊ᅙ䞊䏘ք㲪օ㷆㗜㦒䞊ᄺ㵹䞊Ꮟ㊄䞊Ꮠ㛲ᆪ㠧䊸⼤ࡂ⿢㷶䞊⛡⾰䞊วᗹ෠ằᏑひʐ䞊 ၄⚈㢞⌝⚈㊅♂ᅙ䞊㶊╟ᅙ㶘䞊䑮ይ㯰䞊 䙲㗇ᠬᠭ䅕㜾⤑Ẳ᦭䞊⚈⾰䞊ඍ䉳⳴䘊䞊Ꮤ㏾ᥳ䞊੻䅯⌕䄾㬣ࡃ䞊‫ر‬ЯЮႏ䞊ᕅ䘋䞊ಹᏒ⶿Ꮣᦐ䞊ક⳧㗗㶗ᓯ☱ᖦ⤒䞊㗝ℿ䞊㶗 ⎻ᰞ䞊ཻᏔ䅸ᡁ❞䞊௟⼥ᖜᓵ㲫䖄䞊䝚⤓⠌⳨⪽㶌Ꮥ㦬䘍䞊௃⤔䏧☱㲬⤕㖵ࡉ⠑ɱ䞊 ౉ກ⤖䞊᤼㑮ᘟ䄴⸲ᠮ㉫㸱㬏䞊Ꮬ⯙㲨㗭䞊㊆㗨㾙ẳ䞊㾟╩ᄕ㿥䞊໻ḑ㛲㶊ᮕ⼦ᖝẼ㠐䞊ֆ ӂ 䞊╠⟠䝛ևࣺ⬄Ẵ㠕䞊ོᏖẵḑ᧡䞊੖⯆⌖╡Ⴭ⼧֌௡䞊ⷄᏗ䕿䞊╚Ꮨ䎞ẵ䞊Ⴚ⮕㬃㕋䞊䐁⤗㲢㊇ច᫫䞊ź╢᳓䞊 Ᏸ᫶৸⬹㠳ᥚ㭎˶䞊 ୿㗞㊈䉮ᠯᠰ㵼⤥㗟㊉㲭䞊૧Ặ㿦䓜Ḷặ㈩䞊ཽᏙ䊪ᩒ♙䞊ಈ㐱䐂ᙸ㫕䊫љẸ 䈁㵼䞊๿⅃ⅇ❔ᠱ⟸Ꮪ⮜㲮䞊❔㈩䞊㵼╣ᲇ䞊ဢヅ⤘㿧ᠲֈ⳩䞊ར㿨ቊ⳪ᰯ㳁䞊Ꮫ⾰᫬䞊 ຀෤ᖞᠳ㦓䞊ຩ㕸㲯㲰⤙ᖟⰉị䞊 ࡋ㦝䝜㦔㠭㗠㦕⤚㲱㾚䞊๜䞊㚱᭙㦖ࡊ⤩䞊⬴ⳳ䞊䍳Ḷ㮺䞊 ࿚╤ẹ䞊ඎ㗡⤍㉻㸱䞊ഠ㊘㞶䄾☱㦞䕝䞊Ꮬ⯃㲲㎴䞊㢞Ღ䍖☱Ẻ䑄᱈ᦇ䞊☱㊊℗㗫㦥⼴Ⴚ㿱♂㎴㊋䞊⼩䞊ే૧೮䞊⇽⯙ᮎ㱴ǖ䞊㬊䇖⊯⊂ᠴ‫ڥ‬㶸㿲㊌⌗䞊㗢㶗╥ẻ㟒䞊㜿㎴㲤㬅⤱ᔫ⯙Ặ䞊 ᠵ㗣㦥䊹ӱᙿᠶ㿩☱㏅⾰㬉䞊ᖠẼ㿫䓠᳼ḑ㈉䞊ཱყ䅕᫦⤯䞊ಉ㔏䎞ᯇ⼳⸢ᠴ⾿Ⳬ䞊㏾⇡ᚯ☱Ꮭ⮕㲳䞊Ꮭ㉼᦭䞊ශᲬ㦘㦩㏾㊙㬅㶎䞊㎽㚸᭝㟆Ꮮ㿪❝䍣Წ㱑͇䞊 ఇ㎽㥭䞊ẽ䔸Ꮯ⹅㛟⭚ẾǗ䞊ᄉᙄᘟ㏾㦏᫭☱㊍⌘䞊㦗㗤䞊ై૧ѭ䞊ᦃ㎴ៜ䊬⼧ᜫㄱⳬ㬉ƪ䞊㦘␛ᘯ㡕ᠷ䞊⤛㲴䞊ế䐃☱᪅᭜⿘ᜬᰀ䞊㶗╦Ꮰ㶗䞊␛☫㝀ᙏ⬎Წ㦙㬉䞊ศ㎭䑘ቛ⿻䞊Ꮱ⮕䙭 ཾ⎫ᰕ⒗⎻✀䞊Ꮼ㊚᫮䞊บ㗥⏙჊⳻⳼č䞊 ⼨ᠸᦐ䞊΍Ⴆ⬯㹈᫷䞊䑉ᵇ㟏᭿䞊❢㈜䞊ᗹ㐼⿢㶘Ꮿᗹ㶸䞊䓝☫㵹╜䞊ਕ։㎽ᖡᄺ⹅⼫Ṭ᫯䞊໫ሏ⇾㞹䊭ᠹ䞊້䅕ᄽ䓞㠧䞊಺㦫䍔䈁ㄱ☢ǘ䞊㿳╪ᶅ䞊 ΐ䞊 ৄ䊮␍⪾῿㶎䞊㏾⅀䞊Ǚ⼩䞊ౄଁട䞊ᙄ㖞䄾ひ㶗ᠺ㦪㿵ά㦧㦨㐜㦚ʥ㲨⼲䞊❢ㅎ䐄ᜳ৅㿴⚈⌙Ⴚ㹁⚊㏾͉⟫䞊㲵⤜⿗ᗳỌ䞊ѭۭ۬۟䞊ᓮǚ᫰䞊㊎䞊ᗵⳭ㗦㮼᭘䞊‫֏ޒ‬㲶㲷㒐ᠻљॺ㿶᷄䞊㏁⅁䞊ખᖢ᦭䅎⳴⳵ᅝ䊯䞊 ૈ⤝゛䞊෥ኴ᭒ş䞊䑯⒗㏁䞊⚋㯰䞊㟜Ề⇔㠐㦙†䞊㿷㗨䞊⚠㊏䞊౅଩೏䞊᧞㎽ᙪ㸱ࡐ⼪ᰨ⿘㶎㲸䞊ᄺ㲫䞊ဤ㬡ᅙ⼫Ꮲ䞊ପ❝㊏䞊෨ঋ᧡㷅㊛ì㲹䞊⏃Ⴚ⮕⤞䞊ᖣ㦦㗨㿫ⓞ᭹㟏ɫ䞊 ગᖤ᫱䊵⬹ⳮᏱ⏙䞊 ଖ⼬䞊෦Ⴚᩃ☢ゕƬ䞊䓟╧㐂䞊⚈㬣䞊㶗╰ề䞊㱳䅎ᔫ⪿ᯡᙐ㶸䞊㏚℩䞊㲪᭹䎜ᳶ㟲Ꮝ⮕䞊శ௄ഡ䞊⟙た䍨Ể㲙㶗⤟⌚ሏ㶘✺㏾぀㲿Ř䞊⤝㲺䞊ᙠ䇖㦘㦭᭹⳶Ⴅ㸚⬼䖎䞊⼭䞊෩⤬ể䞊ဣ㊐♓㸢ᶐ᦭䞊໿㿬Ⴭ㶎‫͈‮‬䞊 ತᯔ䞊៴⳨Ꮳ⚈⼡㬊䞊㸢㗧䞊䓠㎿㦛⬏䞊ⅈ㗬㢞䞊 ෧㦤⟫Ễ䞊ཿጺ䊰ᦱ⤠䞊ઘ㦡य़ᕳ֊Ᏺ⿃䞊௠⶿ᕳफ़㲻㲼䕿䞊♖㊑䞊ၜख㲽⤡䊱㊒⌛㷕㐜㊓Ƭ䞊஗஀䞊ყ㳀䞊Ꮒゕ䞊ᅙᦐ⸢☫㉫⢟㬉㸒㦣Ꮒ㿶⚈䍚ễ䞊㗨ⅅⅆ♖ᠼỆ㡀ɰ䞊 ੨ᖧ᫵䇣⳨⳷Ꮽ╫䞊ૣ⤠⾰䞊ෂᏤ᧡⼮䞊 ╨Ᏻ㲥䞊⅂䊶֋Ꮵ㊔ᠽ䝝᫲䞊໌䊷䊲᪵⤢㢹ì㲾䞊ᠾ㗈⻦㝁Ꮶ㇓䕗䞊ࡄ⼯᫐䞊⤣㲾䞊෪⤭㮓㶗ᰨᦟ䞊ᖥ䘌䞊໊֍ԥ⳯ᦐ⤴㦟䞊Ⴚ㲨䞊ࡈ⎫ᯡ䞊ọ⶿ᮛ㦜⌜᭞⿗ឿ䖅䞊ឿ㎴⿗㿭ɽ⤧㼀ߋ㶗䞊∤㠨䞊໋䄾Νᠿ☫ഢċ㬡䞊 ᙐ␘⤦Ⱊ᧌㠐ᴒ㊕ɰ䞊 ࿛╬ệ䗷䞊ᅝࡍβ䞊⼰䞊℃㟴Ỉ㞺䊳᭿⿗㿮䞊ᮛⷃᏧ⛭⳰䞊Ꮺたᦃ䞊㛩⪌㐜⿃ỉ䞊ࣻ㔘⾿㶫ᏨᡀѲ䞊ყ㱑䞊䓡᷄⳸⳹䞊

)16 7 08D




Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 8 of 18

ઙᡄ᜘㏻㦮᫸☫⿌⌕䞊⬯຃䞊㺹⯀ਡಊ䞊ఉମണɭ䞊ਖ਼ᖪᩱ䄹ⴒ⯀჌⒎䞊ચ⛡㊞䞊෫ᅔᦃ♟⿌䞊⒎Ᏽ㭷䞊䊺䞊㊟䊻㫗ᖩᙽ㟒䞊㗮ႅᤇ㖷ㆈ⼵त㿏♁㗯ㆧ㳂䞊㿻㎿䞊㿏Ỏ㦶㠂㐕㊠㬣㿼䞊 ㏉㦯⌞᏶㊣⡑ၾⴜⴝ㿽✠㕞㊡㬮ɸ䞊 ಘᮀ䞊☱㯼䞊㿾╠ỏ䞊ສ㟆Ố㳃☡᧙ᡅ⼶䞊͏X㷅Ӈᦓ䞊஧♟㟽ố᜴㻻㒑㦓䞊㐃ⅉ䞊㻜⎟Ồ䞊ၝ㗰㟆⮮᫹䞊ਲ਼㧊መᖪ䞊ษ㿿݅㭟⮕⤶⼷䞊ၬ㎴䄹㷅╱䞊છ㮩㳄㎴ᘦ☫ጟ㾁☡㐮㊪䞊 ĻႲ䞊ਖ਼৊䐅⅊ၳ䞊ᐨㆀ䀪ⴥ䞊䀀⏘ᶐ䞊ೲワ㭩㷯☦䀁䇣㽸᱅䞊㎴ℕ䞊ႆ㳅⯆ᓰ⼸⤷ᙒ䞊ᐡ㋃ᦓ䞊ઢ㟇ᐥᖫ⣪ᡆ䞊໳᛹⛡᤽᏷ᙒᙒ㬡䞊⩸֐䞊જ⼹ᮓ㧏⥥ᙦᓱ䞊 ମ㒚㺈⎭䞊㐋㟆≡ᓲ⻁Αᐎ㷅✘㐋⿇㳆䞊ყ㦶ᘫ䞊 ⳽㒋ᘷᅖ⬲䞊ᕦ㠇⼺ᡸ࡫╲ồ㳆䞊㏉㗱㒛⿽Ȥ⌟㕰䎼Ổ〥䋗㋎ᮎピ⳾ᏸ⳿䞊㗲㠖⌠ᐪ⿌⥆䙚დ㷅☫㒛ㆀ㳗䞊ļ็ಋ๕㳇Ō䞊ᖫᄉ㬎Ო䀫⴦䞊☫㊮䞊໬⥐䕿ᏹ᫺⒎ś䞊໵ᏺ䊼ᡮඑ⢧䞊ઝ㠂ჯᖪ✛ᄉ˶䞊 ઞᙒᡯ㐃㦰᫻♥㊢⌡䞊ⴀ㐃䞊䀂⎭᳚䞊౏૧ೞŦ䞊ҁᖬᵵ㡕ᡇ䞊⤸㮅䞊㡕ᱧე㳃㒒ࡤ♝䞊㿏㗳䞊ᖭᶋ⮨⤹ᰎ䐆᮹䞊㸏⎣ᏻ㷆䞊ၞટสၭ䞊⣪㳈䞊­ᙒⴁ㐃㬡᭭⬱䘎䞊ყ㳟㮽㏉ᡰ⢧ᏼ㷯Ḿᦓ䞊䓣⣯㶹█䞊䀃⎭ổ䞊 ⅚䋔⿊ᨉ⤺㊣⌢䞊ᏽ㊤᧊䞊⅔⠸⿗Ỗ⾻ᡈ☱㊥⌣䞊㎴⅋䞊♷⾻㵹ᯣ㪠ᅈ䀚♌㐋㊦ჿ⯕䞊⤻Ფ㦻㠬㐢㧏⥈䝞㾁䞊‫ړ‬㷯⥑䏇㊧☱Ვ㳉䞊ᐑ㊨᦮䞊⣊㊩䞊ࡑ⏘Მ䞊㛲͒⥙䝟ⴂ䞊╳ᐜ㮴䞊㝂㦱㖵䐇⤼᪵ᶴᬋ䞊⯀㒑⌤⠣㳊㵹☱᤾᏾⮕䞊 㳋䆮㝃㚻㗴ⴓⴔ䞊㸏㐋䞊⼻᧪֑䎨ўᦎ䅕᏿⮮㮩䞊䓤⤽㲥⏄⥠ⴠј⊜䞊㼺㎿䞊⇿≦⏓㶞䞊⼼䞊㹇⑟᭹䞊ધ⁖⌳⏘ቢ⾰䞊ၟࡥ⥛㧄ɲ®䞊 Wඒ㷅䞊 ֒‫ۋۯۮ‬Ǜ䞊㿏⎮ᯔ䞊୍ⴕɸĮ䞊㝄䆮ᖮ⯀⥒㬫␋‡䞊Ⴜ䞊㛒ኣ㝅Ỵ㟒䞊 ᡉ␛჌㧎መᘓ㵹᳚㟇⚶䙙ࡒʑㆽ⌥䞊ၠ䞊ન͓၅ࡓၮ䞊䀧ZΈ䞊᐀䞊่౭๕䞊䀄╾ᐁ㷆䞊㛡㣩㐮䐈⚶ᦓἆ㳠䞊⅌䇄ㆽᦓ❀⾰⌦ˮ䞊⬺㒚⌧☱㲲㶷⥓ᡊᐂ⭱䞊㳌䅲㝆㝇㐮㧒㶬䞊ᇭ〱ᦁ䞊㶬㡕ᆢⷖ⣪㊪⌨䞊䓥⤾㺩ࡦ❛䞊 㛘㔷㳍㬥♝ᔌⴃỗ䞊ᡋ㗵⿗ㆈᰎᡌ㵹⤿㔷⿗㬣䞊㵹㕶䞊䀛␀Ộ䞊ਲ਼㟜ᄟᔌ䞊ࡢႩ֓⌲▉ᐃ⿗㳝䞊ワộ䀕䓪㑈㡅⫍Ǫ䞊಻ჯ⹲ᄟ㬡Ŗ䞊ઠⴄ≦ᡍ㊫ᐄ㉁䞊ᡎ䔹৆㠬Ớⷘ֔㳎䀒ৠő䞊ᐩ㈿᫼䞊ຫ▓ⴡ⯆U㝈㛕⥀⼽ࡔ䞊 㧍࡭⥤✪Ⳋ⡑㷅ჯ㊤䀅㬀ɲ䞊ٕ䞊 છ⯕㳏㐋䞊㗶⅍䞊০㗷䀆᤿䅥㸏⥢ᐫ⮕䞊✠》䀇䀨ো㡈ᘼ㬡䀗Ǐ䞊ࣼ⥙䀇䞊⮕ớႼ㬮㵹䞊✪㈏䞊㦲䋘㧘㗸㬀㝉Ờᡏⴅǜ䞊☱㬋䞊㷆▁᭴䞊Ҏ۞۬۰䞊⥁ࣧᡐ⛡ᦓᡑ⿓ⴆ䞊☱㦶͗䐉㐋ࡕǝ䙴෬Ǟ≙䞊࣡⅓㕵⎟Ꮸⷶ⼾᭜ᦓ䞊 ყ⮕Ȧໍ䄾ᦓ⒃ᐅỄἂ⼿䞊ყ⾰᪽䞊ಶᐆⷱᧀቢゼ䞊ᐇⴇȦྀ╴ყ⭇ǟʑ䒣☱䞊 ડ⯞ɛ໎䇄᫽⒃ᐈờᜉ✡㦳䞊 ᐉ㊬ᦓ䞊ᅖ⭍Ȧ䝠╵ᐊ⭇ᐋ䑱⣪䞊䓦Მ㦴Ở䞊∔䗣⛡㊭〈䞊⅘㧋㗹㠖߯⛞䞊ਢ䀜ј㐋ᮩ࡞֩⥂䔺䞊 㵹㕵䞊၊ॠ㯼╾⥆㎷⋝㿏㒛㪚ś䞊௃ି䞊㹋㎴䞊ᐌ࣎᭱㊮ᦓ䞊ყ䞊㝊ᐍ㦵㸨䕪䞊ᐢ㶬䞊㸏╾ᰰ䞊໿ᇁ䅎ᨶ⚋䞊௢⽀ᔔᐫ㮅㬡䖥ʏ䞊 ϞႨ⇑Ჟ㡕䞊䀈⏥ḋ䘏䞊ᖪ㏻ᐎ㦶᫾ở᪵䞊㿏⏷Ỡ䞊㜥ⴈᐚ⿌Ჰ䞊⥃⾾䞊 ຬ⒎㐋ỡ㊯✪䔻ŝ䞊㵹⎟Ợ䕞䞊ᖯᲤ⊰ጢ⿗䞊ᅔ㳉⬐⻹⋞䞊㶬╔᭱䞊∕⊜▏㵹䞊ყ֨㵹ᮞ〱ᦖჄ⿌⭆ྃ䞊䀈ᯣᡙ╠⿓✞ᘔႼ⮲䞊㞻䊽ᮀ㯩㵹⥄㐋⿇㳐䞊ᐏᔞ㖁♦έ䀉䞊㷯⎭䝡䞊㋄☱≙▐ࡖ䞊䀊⏯ᐐ㸨䞊䀝␀ợ䞊 ⥣⯀✡⊜╶㶳䞊ኴ㷯㿏Ụ⿗᫿ᅍ㧌͘෯ྂ䞊∥䋑ゼ᥀䞊㳑ᤓ㳒㛇⥄ᡒ⛡㏁䊾㭏ɱ䞊 ၢ▎ᡚ䊿䞊䀞▊᭜䞊㛊⭕ᐦ͔֦֧ᙛ䞊䑱ᇓ㳓䞊⥅㇔䞊⅖⯥☡〉╷㽅Ǡ䞊ᇭ⮠ȩໃඏᬎ⎟ቊᡓụ⥆㊰䞊ბ㬡⫍ᡔᬀ䞊䓧╸Ủ㟆ᰊ䞊䀄⏓ủ䞊 Ⓡᐑⴀ▔㠂㏁㗺㫘䞊䓨ᐪ㬡ࡗ䞊㒆㊱‌䞊㐋ⅎ䞊䀋╔᭜䞊⪟✛⎕֕㷆䞊ე䀘㼺ᡕゕᦓᐒ䋀㦷㳓䞊㛇㎴☱㆛㵹Ứᦓ䞊⏘☱⻷䞊Ҡа䞊 ဦⴛŁ䞊ᕆ॥ᡄ⬑䞊㏭ℍ䞊㿏⎭ứ䞊㝋⮕ე㦸ǡỪɾ䞊 ้ừǢ䚾ᙽʗ䀥⑉ᬁ᭱㮽ȜŘ䞊 ᅖ⬲Ȥ໏䄯ᦓ⎣Ⴤᡖᡗ✸㊲䞊䑯Ử⾰㷅䞊㿏㐋䞊ⴖ▋ᙛ䞊⅙㟵㗻㊳㺖䞊㐋ℎⴔ▕ử䞊㝌⭀ᇀ㆛Ữ䞊ᅈ⾰৹⬺䞊ኴ㷯㹧᭹⽊㝍㵹᭹ᬂ䞊㐋⿓䞊㫹㗼䞊㏉ឪᜤᅍ㬣ࡘ᡹⽉㮩䞊䀌㏻䞊ữ㈿㸏ᮞ㟒䞊㾲⎭᛾䞊Ľেຂ䀍⬒㚻಼ɯ䞊 ࿜⏥ᯞ䞊㛖⯆㳔ピ᥁䞊⽋ეᬃ‍䞊൪ඓⴉ䞊᥂ⷳᘫ㥸≙Ự⾻ᙐ䕪䞊⥇ყ㋊ᦓ⛪㗽䝢䞊ყ⾰ᦓ䞊㷆╹ự䞊ోଫⴊ䞊⛹⿗䐊Ỳ㬋㷅☫⌫ᐓ㵹᷀ᬄ䞊ǣ⒎‎䞊⽁ᘷ㸭᧴᥃⿌ⴋŘ䞊ᔸ䄹䀎䞊ᦓἃᜨ⥈ᡘ᡻䀦⳽䞊ウ㐋㹤䞊䀏㏁䞊 㝎䋁㦹㬡䋂ỳ䞊ბ䞊㝏㧅㘎㮩᭹ᚸ䋃䀩⥄㎴⾻ɹ䞊 ઢ䀐䞊ࡣᖴ᭹䞊㶌䋒㊴᭿Ŝ䞊ॡ⭺ɂໂ䋄䀂⮕╾ჄỴỗ☫⿉䞊ᄟ⿗᧥䞊ᄧ⮕Ƞ།⎭ኴⴞᄴ䓩☫䞊៶⯀ᐄ⥆⽂᭹ᦀ䞊㵻╺Ⴜ䀑䞊䀒╻ᶪ䞊ཪᇓ䋅ᦡ⛡䞊௣⽃ᕠᄟ㭏㬥䘐䞊 㜥ე͕⥝ᦓ䞊⅗㘑㡊䞊㷆␛ᰉ⠚㠬䞊჌☫㡓㜥⯥჌㋋Ჟ䞊㾆⛡࡟ࡠ⫔ỵ䀓㮴ɫ䞊 ણ≉Ỷ㟒䞊㵹␛᭴䞊౎ଭඐ䞊ᬅ⥉㭩ᡙ㏁䏤ỷ㠰ᮖᬆ䞊㷆⏯ᆢ䀔䞊መ⿌䞊⢈㊵ᦛ⤸䐋⢃ᧆ䅎ᅖ⯆䞊⛡⾰䞊ອ⑘㐋ᡚ㧔䄹䔼䞊䑍⏄㗾䞊䓪ᐬ㳎䞊䀕╼͐࡝䞊㳕䋆ᔰ⫀᭜ᡱ㵹䞊㗿⅏䞊ጢ䞊 ᡛ㒌֡֡⾰㺖⥔࡙㧓㻟ᮞժ࿝㘀㡓⚛㬫⽄䞊☱㊶䐌ἇ㬣㷯⥕≤ᇀ㸏☱㐋㊤䞊䓫ყ㳖䞊ᬇ㪮䍜⛡ㆀ⊰䞊ᐧⴘɀ༜⏐㊷⮕࡚̽㊸䐍⥊õ㭩䞊ᡜᏨ㟒NJ䞊㻟⑉ᮩ䞊⩻䄷㥊䝣৉⥜䋇䞊㖓㝐᷒㊹ἅ᪵䞊ॢ䞊 ᙒ㎿䋈⽅Ồࡡখᙋ㧆㡈㘁㡕⥦㬀㠖݆⥚䞊☱㋍䐎᳭㮴㷆☱⌬ᐔ㷅⣪㘂㆟䞊㐋ピ䞊ᐕ⮕ȩག░͖ኴ⭖Ⴜ䓬⥋͌䞊 ത㋅䞊๊㘃䎾Ỹⷖᔕỹ㦺䞊ٗАϿЬǠ䞊㸏⎣᳭䞊 㧇ἄᡝᮞ⥌䎛Ჯᬈ䞊㦻᭹㛏㐋㫰ゼ⌭䞊 ∼㐃⸢䞊

㷛␖Ⴭ㷅䞊ᐖ⮲ȩཱྀ╽ᐗ⮕ჯ䓭⣊䞊␛ᆴᬉ䞊㵹㢐㋆⛟ルᮞ᧨䞊ᐣ䀟䞊㾸╾᭱䞊㵹ᮩ㦶㦮㕩㧐✘㮩㵹䞊᛹ᐘ⸚㝄㬣䞊⛡㊺䞊ત⅐䐑Ǩ㊻⽆㳗䀠ᐤㆽ䞊ჲ⾰ᦓ䞊╠ਣ͑ᦡ䞊

㦼Ỻᚤᱏ╿䚿Ờ᪵䞊᥄ড়㚽⯆㘄㬖♒䐏᥅㳘䞊䀡㟆०ⷖ⽇≦䞊㷈㘅䞊㛏᲎㦽∦㠖⺓䞊¯†є㘆ᔸ㧕䋕䞊࿞㗾䓮᳘㡃䝤°Ȥ㷯䕗㛖ᡞ䞊ሸဥࡪ䋓݆⬓㳙ɰ䞊 થ≊ỻ㢊䞊䀖⎭Ჟ䞊གỼ㝑㹒᭱⸠ᖰᴒ㦾䞊֖ ԙ ǂ 䞊 ؔвгҎ䞊ᆦ㷈㽾ॣᙒ⬄㮴Ŧ䞊⬯▀᰹䞊ຮ▁㒛ỽ㈿✪䔽䞊ౌ⛫ᯡ⬺ᧆ䞊๕⅑∀ᘼᲝ䞊ϑ㻟㾧ᐙᘮ⏐ᡟ᫺䞊ᮖ䎧ᶐ⿭䞊㝒㕵㽗ᡠ【㿏♝ग⬺ⴗ䕗䞊㫤㟼ᵃᐚ㶬⩴㟒䞊㳚֗⌟㫵⪛ᡡᐛ㊼ᙐ᥆䞊Ⲅ㐮䞊㸏╹ᇫ㷅䞊Q ۞۱໑䞊 䀬㊤ᡲ⣊᧶᳍⿗䀢ɹ䞊 દ䞊ຯ⎨㎴Ỿ㋇⥖䔾䞊్૕ೲ䞊᡺㕞⻚⽈䄴ㆽ☫ᛙᐜ䋉㒑㆟䞊ᷝ䔿㝓⯆।❺㊽᳕৺⭇䞊 㷅▂᮹䞊䀑␖ỿ㘇㧗䕞䞊ᖱ᚛▃⥍䀗Rᡳⴘ䞊䀑⒎⫁㬋䞊 ±ະ␛㎿ᡢ⿖☦䕀䞊௹૕֘䞊䋊㎴䓯䞊 Ď ǤႧᙐᡣ㘈㦿ᬌY㋌⌮䞊㻭㘏䞊֢֣ǥ᜺䞊ⴢđବ೓ď䝥䞊๋㘉䍿㧀⥗㋈ᖲᡴ㣅䞊֙‫ی‬Ǧ䞊෭деٖ ֚᷀㳡㝔㘊㊾ɹ䙨ᡤǦ䞊䛀▄▅㓾䋋⌯ᖳ䞊䝦䐐ᡥ㡹ᐎⴌ䞊㐉∖ᡦ֛䝧ⴍ㯾䞊෮Đ֥䞊 ၡ䞊ૅīSၯ䞊㰇䈏㝕㝖㘋㧈䀣䞊ࡧ⥌ⴎ䚁໐䝨䞊䚗֜ᬍঌ䞊T㠖䋖ⴤ䞊 ᡧ်㧁䞊֝ࡨ㣅ࡩ㓿㡹⩺䀘䞊⎜䋌㝗㳛ʐ䞊ീἀ䞊ǧ㊿֞᷀ⴟ▆⌰ᡵ㋉ᡶᝁ䞊⥎㳢䞊⥘͎ɥৈ䋍⅒⅕⥞ᡨ⥎ᡩ㋀⭟䞊֟б䞊㯾▇㘌䓰䞊䓱▅ᡪⴙ▌ᡫ䀙䞊֝▍ᡷ䞊㘍㧂⌱ক֤ܵV‫ⴏڿ‬䀤࡜㐉㋁䞊ᐝ䝩䞊ᐞ䞊ɦ䛁ⴚǩ䋎ⴐἁ䞊ᐟ㎧䞊⥏ⴣ‫ڦ‬䞊㳜ᡬ㧖䈏䋏㧃䞊 ⴑᐠᬊᡭ㧉㳞▒⥟㝘䞊䝪⥡࡬১㝙䋐㋂䞊࡛֠㡹㧑㘐㎡䛂㫣͍䞊

  

 
 

(3

D



Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 9 of 18

  




ᖵ䃦⮗⥧Ἀ䎆ᚄ㬊䞊ᖶ㏯䀭␲䞊ⷢṬ㋏䞊䑩᤯㧙ᯑ䞊㯫㛳᭢ᗳ⥨∁᡼ᐭ⮦⮗䕗䞊Ⴚগ᭠⼻㛙㵹❫㋐⊿䞊㾉㔌䞊䀮ᥘ䝫⮋䞊㶗⏼‫‏‬䞊㳣⦍߲᡽䋙㧚☫㶗䗑䞊㝚㟆㓂ᗳᢎᬒ䄷㧛ᥛ䞊㎿࡮䞊બⷔ᭷㧚⦏᠍ᄧ䞊ၣᮑ㬡䀯䞊 ફ⦉㧮⴨⦎㋭Ἤ㬋䞊⥻㋚䞊ȟ㟆ᯑ㚰ᑉ㋧㺶➖㏣㋑䞊Ⅶ㘨㧏䞊ᑄ〔᧙䞊⠣⾾䞊Ⅳ䋤㦗㷛⎣Ἁ㟒᏾⿼ᙈᯑ䞊㘗‼䞊ဧ૴࿰ඖ઩೐䞊 ແ኿ᱟᦲს䞊㎿ਤ᭘㧪ᄉ㶒⥩㏞⿲㮰ɳ²䞊 ⮗⿔䞊㵺Ἂ㮰㽊⛤⸸㏯㋒䖒䞊ᖷᷠ⅛㘒㧜ᱟ䞊࡯▖Ἃ䞊ඕ㏅⥪㘓㸜䞊Ⱛ㋨㞶䋚♖㧫䘔ǂ䞊䃷ѥἌ䞊ᆴ⋶ᴬ㋓㻟䞊䓲▗㔉䞊ᦜ㢉ਰⅨ䁃ᯑᬑ䞊㸒⎣Ἅ䞊³ັ⎣㕵Ἆす⦀䕁䞊௤ଡ଼´䞊㮪㵺ᐮ䀰἗ᬖࡰ䞊 ೸⿌䞊ᐯ䞊㝛㔉㬞ǫ䞊۲ϟы Ӡ 䞊䑍㘖㠇⴩᧦ő䞊֘䞊䑄᭜⿽㵺䞊ᕋᐲ᡾⬔䞊ᐲ⿌ᦓ䞊⴪㎿㘔⬕•䞊ე䀱䞊䃮⳺䋛䁁ⴴ䞊ই䞊㚿㔉㳤㲋⥫ᔍ⮲䖅䞊ᖸᵵ⚕⿼⌴䞊㬡㏋⽌ᯑ䞊㬋㔌㧡㸜䞊㔉⅜䞊ᦜ㟒䖪䞊 㟏䋥』ɲ䞊ⴵ^䞊䀲㬣䞊ᜤ䋢㧵㟮ᮍ〓㵹⭿䖬䞊䇥⽛ⴶ᡿䝬䞊⥬ホ䍼Ჶ㬣㸏⥭⌵፶㹳⥮㔌㋔ʩ䞊 પⅩ䁄Ἇ㟒䞊྄᭢㝜㵺᭜ⷢᔢᵘ㧝䞊⭖䞊ඔ Ư 䞊٘ϣж[Ƭ䞊ᄋ⬶ɜ໒䆙ᝬaᖹᐰᚚᢀ⥯〔䚘䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚙䚚䞊

ႇㅆ䞊⟛゜㼕ᰴ㧟䐝⢍᰺䑩㬊Ǭ䞊ᐱ䞊າᖺ㔉ᢋ⽜⥰䕂䞊౐‫ڊ‬ೲ䞊ᅞ⋥ἔㅆ㵹䞊㬊䀳ᅢ㻟ᮨ᨝䞊䀿͝ᗁუ㿋䞊ຳ▘㎿᥇⽍䕃䞊䚡䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚳䞊 ᔧ᭜⮗⚇ᵀ䐒ḽᦓ䞊䀴▙१䀵䞊ᐲ⴫Ƞ໓䋜ᬐ▚ᇥἐᲶ⥱⿌䞊㧟㢖⦓⥲⌶⏧㵺䞊ᔌ᭷ 䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䙼䚛䞊 ಘ☥㯁䞊㝝㤗㐕`⚏⥳᭜䞊⛤㬩䞊㳥☱⽎\Ɱዹ㧬䞊㸒㔉䞊⴯ᖺᐳ㶲䞊㐂⁙䞊 ਱⥴Ȥଯᐴ䘑㘕䆇ࡵ㋫♂䞊ეゑ᦭䞊૒ᇷ㭷㬋⿌Ⴚㅆʓ䞊 ಽἩ䞊⢍㬊䞊⢤ゑ䞊䃸ἑ䞊ဨ㎢㸛ᮝ㪹䞊྅䀶ᆘ㵺᭬㬡䞊ᑏ㬡䞊ᐵ䞊㬊ࡱ䋝ᬑᢁ⽏䞊ს㋩ᢌ]䞊ᦓ㑇Ზ㬋䞊㋕㘕㵺䞊▛ს䎀᭼䞊უ䞊䎟❢㳦⛨ᖻ⮯ऍ䞊 ⽐ᮟᐶ㋞㳧䞊㐂⅝䞊⥵㈪ᘹ㏋⽑䁅ܿʓ䞊 ಾἒ䞊⥶㬡䞊☲ゾ䞊∽ᵑ㞼䋞᭜⿽㸒䞊ᗳ㏣㋖㾨ᐷᙐ㸰䞊䒽⢢䃱䞊྆ᄺ䅩ᦆ☱䞊ಉ㔌䐓ṵ㦗ֳⷢ͜ ㋗㷆䞊᱾㬆ৌʁᐸᖼ⴬☱㳨☞᭬ゾ㵺㬡䞊♋্ৎ䞊䄠ἓ䞊သ⿼⥷㶗἗᦬䞊 ໿㵹Σ㺃䝭㳶䞊ᅆ㋢ᩌ䞊Ⴚ㝜㝚ᮝᐹ㟒㳲䞊䀷㔌䞊ᔹἔ䞊䐔ἕ㧴䖒䞊♊ㅆ䐕㎿⭇䎆Ზᬚ䞊☬㋔䞊䀸⏼ᮝ䞊ᐺⅢ⅝ᅢ⥸㟒㬐䞊㏚⅞䞊㾲▜ᮝ䞊⯛㘖ᙍᑌ⯛䞊྇ᇋࣕ⦈ᤈ➎䞊ᙍ㘦ⷎ͛⽛ၫ⫂䀹䘒ɲ䞊 Ⱎⴷᢂ䞊㟒䋢㋘㳩 ঢ়䞊 µ༃ᐻ䇄᧾♋䞊ଡ଼⭖䆇ᔞ¶䞊⻆䞊ິ⎟㎿ᮝ㋬⚏䕄ŕ䞊უ⾾㪺䞊२㬊㳪✓㬊䀻㬊䞊཈἖䄲ᦾ☫䞊㬌㸒䆇᫰ṃ㋙㸒㳫䞊☲サ䞊㵺▝᭜䞊⽒἗〨ʓ䞊 ࿟㋚᠔䞊௩໭ೝ䞊▞३㳬䞊৙͙⭿㬡㘗䞊ᦐἘ䍷Ჶ⮗㘘㝞᭜ᬒ䞊 ⦌͚ēֲⅧ㏴㪽ᅭ㵹➪㔐㋛䞊㵹⎟Ⴚ㵺䞊ᅭࡲȴ໔䋢ᬒ⏶ᐼᴆᙬ☫ㅆ䞊䓴ᄫ㬡䞊㠇᱾ᚿṃ✳䐖♂⿼⌷䞊⹲㎿どᱰ䕛䞊∾㘙ⷢ䞊䀺⎟᭤䞊ྈᐽ䆝ᦓ☫䞊ಌ㎿䐗᭤㫞ᰜ㋜㵹䞊ᔚ䋟䀻Ű䞊ᅞ㳭䞊㔌⃟䞊 ੍䄲⋥䄲㱜㷓䞊ؔАϵٙǭ䞊␱ᐾᥴ䞊䋠㘖ⴭ䞊㘗ᖽ㶓ᄫ⚇〟Ἧ᦭䞊෰⥹Ἑ䞊㟒Ἒ⴮ᵆ䎆ᑍぁ㻟䞊ᕟუㅆ⬖䞊㟒᭷ᘷ㔌㧞ᬑ㬣䞊⁹㘩㟒䞊㡱Ṭ䐘⚎Ჶ䑴ɱ䞊 ࿢▬᭜䞊ఐର೸Ē㳮䞊ີ▟㔐ᚄ㇉ࡶ䕆䞊ఉ⛠Ἥ⭙ᨶ䞊 ຄ⅟∂ᜠἛ䞊⏧⥺_ྍ䞊ྉ㝟ⶡᝥ䋡Ⲟ኿㵺᳄᧙䞊㶲■኿㶯䞊ᐿ⬺ɝ໕䄲ᦓ□ᑀᜠἏ⚒㋝䞊ᑁ㋞ᬓ䞊㘚㶓▫Ἔ㠂㮝䞊⽓ᄉ䖍䞊ᔹἝ䞊ɞ 䚜䞊

࿡പՠᢃ㟒ᗳ䞊ᐵ㧯ᝥ䞊㔉㧟▢ᝥ㠅䞊☱䄻ᬔ⥻ᢄቌ⴯☱㔉⿼㬩䞊☱㘛䞊౑ଇ࿠䞊‼⦊⭾Ἦ㲋䞊⭼⬺⥼⩪ഥ䞊ᢅ⭖ᰋ⹕ᢄ⽔㬃䞊㐱Ⅰ䃲ᰋ䞊ྊᄫ䆫᨞ࡳ䞊಍㘜䍚Ჶ㧱ࡷ䋦㋞ᢆ㉉㵺䞊ⷔᑂ䕑䞊▣ᑃ䐙ᰚ䞊 㝠㧠㘝䐚⟰ᬕ஌ᨓ䞊ྋႪⴸ㝡㝢㋟㧳㧃䞊֫з䞊֬἞㧡㧭㘧㧲⦐㳯֭䞊㋠἟㤷䓵㘞㧢⬗㳰ʷ䞊 ౒㘟㧣䞊ἠ䕅ᑄ⽕㝣ⴰἡœ䞊㶒▤Ǯʬ䞊 ౓଱೓䞊⏝ᑅᬖ䞊⥽ᬗ㧤㋡䀼➻σᢇᬘ䞊䛃▥㧥䞊࿣▭䞊֮ ֯४⽖⚕䕿ᑆ▦䞊 ห㔐㮶㞽䅷ᯑ䞊„ഩ䞊஁䈻⬺䍚Ṭ㡕䞊ଡ଼⥾䀅䘓䞊ნ㬌䞊ᄕ䞊㳱✷㾄᭷䞊㏿Ⅱ䞊ṭ䔪㾄㧨ἢ⼦⥿㬆䀽ȴ㧦᭷⮕ᄮ䀾᳅ᦁ䞊ᄫᙗ㾸⦔䎈✷㵺䕕䞊ᔹ㘠䁂⏆䞊ᖾ᳄⁨㘪㟒᳡䞊჌⽗ࡴ䞊ᇉ≋Ṭ㧰䞊䝮ᜤ㛳㷳ἧ⺖ᔧᢈ㧁䞊ⴱ䞊ദ ɬ 䞊 ໿ἣ䎜᭠㧧ს⬺䞊㳷䄲ᔹ⫃ἤᢉ㸒㯫䞊㘗 Ⅲ ་䞊 ᄕ㋏䞊஧❱ἥ⌸㘗䞊⦀㋢䐛Ვ㬡㸧♂⌹ს⦁⛛㘖ゕ䞊㛘㟇⦑㘠㠇䞊㶗㑇䞊ྌᯑ㝤㵺ᱮ⽘ᔎṭ㦓䞊ְ Ӡ 䞊╈ᅢᦔ䞊ᗵ⬼㘡㬅ἦ䞊ᢍ㑳⾾㋮ᰡᚄ㸏❍㕾⿏㯁䞊㵺㘢䞊㸏⏧ị䞊 ⷎ㘣㳲㞾䅷᭢ˮ䞊 ૒ᔅ᭷ᬙ䞊㔉㉡䞊☫㋣㶗᠒㠇䐜☫᥉䓳㬊䞊ᑎ㋪ᦓ䞊㟏ᮝ䐜❢᥈䑉䞊㏿⃟䞊౔ૌധ䞊‹ⴹᗾ㲡œ䞊໳Ᏻ㋪䞊஫⦂᱑⌺㔌䞊ౕૌന䞊ᇂ⌻᳄㋢䀿㬌䞊ᖿἧ⬼⦇ᰡ䍠ᱳᬑ䞊Ⴚ㵹䞊㶓▧⪍䞊㶅⡙⽘Ἠ䞊 ⴺᗀᑇ㸜䞊㸒⬼⠑ឫ㳳Ṓ䞊㳴䋢ᔌ⪤᳠ᗳ㶅㯁䞊䓴ᰜ㧨Ἡ䞊ⴲᑊ䄲⿲ᬚ᱃㦅⦒す⌼䞊⸢㘤⿌ᱟ䖪䞊ⴳ␱㟏㓂䋣⌾▮䞊ֱ▨➻㬋䞊ⷢ㏞㯸⦃ѭ䆇Ἢ䞊∃㧨㭷㻻䞊㷛㏞䞊໵㏞⽙ᐲⲏ☱䞊ぁ㘥⿄Ƞ㝥㧩㒈Ⅵ⦋㶲䞊 ㎵㟒⌽ᄷ⿼⦄䙛პ㋤㔐ㅆ㳵䞊ᇉ㊆᧥䞊ľ▩Ἣ㋥䞊㶓㎿䞊㏅䁀▪⪎㟒䞊ᢊ⽚❢㶓⦅៬㳶䞊ნⅤ∄ⲏ⦆ᑈ㶎Ჶ᧵䞊䑽❢䀽▯䞊ဩ㱒ᄫ⸾ᅆ䞊ଲ☱㋦䞊෱ᑋᢌ⭖⥻㧟ͅ䞊

֪‫ڲ‬䞊ྨᬏÅⴧ䞊





Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 10 of 18

ʙ੝R!ࠋࡇਮ̪ॣ4Ŝ੝ ‫ۉ‬੝ȝȞȚƁ੝ऴ‫׳‬Ҕ੝ɫɃʇ੝ϢԈO‫ܜ‬ҕ੝਋)ࡅ/੝
՗੝‫ ܮ‬gb
6{੝՘੝эۘ4̫࢓੝‫ڝ‬੝਌‫گ‬Җ੝ऄࡥ޽ՙҗ࢔੝ ֜੝…Ҙ੝¢o‫܃‬Α‫ا‬੝Њ8ܱভ޵षŞ੝‫ڞ‬੝˕Λ੝ɝ‫ب‬ҙíĔ੝अߋ੝ȵۙ੝Ʉμ੖आ੝˵ࡦѴ޳੝ɑĔ‫̬݊ࠜܟ‬ŝ੝ΜÀ੝p०Դ੝ϣ৩‫ڟ‬Չࢮķ੝ ΍døϑԌ੝ŘóA‫״‬੝࣮̏‫܄‬L੝Ʌ‫ة‬ď੝ʲѱ‫݋‬੝ ȯइ੝१0੝ওÐƂ੝ľҚ੝֠ѻ֩੝Nࠌࠍ/νԠ੝ईĕ੝Ϥқ੝
ࡹì٣‫ބ‬ϓ‫֪ڠ‬੝֛‫ܝ‬੝ň‫׵‬1੝ e,̭‫ۊ‬੝˖ߌ‫܅‬Β‫ت‬੝пąĆE޶থ੝‫ڡ‬੝A‫ ׶‬੝՚
ࢆ੝
ê੝юࠈঈ ĵ੝उ
੝ˆΏ2৪੝'ߨ‫̮ܠ‬۷੝‫ݍ݌‬ƛࠎĪ
քড’੝ ʂŘÑৱÚࡆƃ੝…Ҝ੝ ɱGʈ੝‫ߍݎ‬਍੝ϥҝ ҈Պ੝२̯ऊ੝३Ҟ੝>‫܆‬ҟ੝՛੝४੝֝Čя޴੝VऋŒ̰‫ۻ‬ਰ੝
ࡺ‫©ה‬ľԍ੝֙‫܇‬੝˗̱মѵ੝Ȱ࠲·‫ث‬੝Νѐ੝ऌ‫ן‬Ŀ੝ Іऍ‫נ‬੝५Ҡ੝ʗ‫ݏ‬੝˶̲ĉ‫ج‬ş͛‫׸‬੝ ˀ
ࢯࠪযҡ੝‫ݐح‬੝ʳěࢰ੝Ƚ֫\‫ۋ‬Ñ࣒੝ΞÁ੝६Ң੝ʉzfΟরЋ੝ɒԦң࠳੝՜੝˘¦‫ݑ‬੝ɞ3Ҥ֬੝ਗ/ࡰ੝ ‫&ڢ‬g৲Ԏ੝‫ݒخ‬੝ ̳৊‫އ‬ѳ‫֭ݓ‬੝ऎ‫ס‬ҥ੝Ć
lҦ਱੝

ȱРсࡪ‫֮ڣ‬੝एߎ੝७ҧ੝֊߂Ќƴ١੝ɵʊ੝̴֯Ҩ‫ݔ‬ऐ੝‫ݕد‬੝˙̵঱੝ ɟ‫ذ‬ҩֽߧ੝਎‫ߏע‬੝ਏψ੝‫ر‬ল৳ߐ‫ی‬Ŗъ੝‫ݖز‬੝८‫س‬੗੝Ƅ঳৴Юळ‫אش‬উߑ‫ݗ‬ƅ੝ ߃ࢱ੝ࢲV‫ף‬Ҫ‫܈‬ҫ੝‫(܉‬Ş੝(f4ਐ੝ŀ‫פ‬Ó੝˚(঴‫ص‬੝ɽ&Հ‫ރ‬ऑ੝ऒߒ੝ࠏࢍ৵‫ض‬џÕ੝‫žݘ‬ƜI̶Ů‫ط‬§੝਑‫ظ‬९੝֞mё‫ְݙع‬੝ओ‫ؚ‬Ė঵ë‫ץ‬੝·
&Ҭ࢖੝ <੝‫ڤ‬Á2<ҭЍऔ੝‫܊‬Ԇ‫ࢳݚ‬੝ʚ੝‫ۍ‬শࢴ੝ WशϦԵ੝ȟF੝ǽǓǔǾ੝‫ێ‬хঊć
‫ݛ‬ਲ੝क‫צ‬Ү੝֋࠴‫܋‬Զ੝ǎÔষ‫ۏ‬੝Тę‫ݜ‬সহбखд੝ߓ‫ݝ‬੝ņ‫ק‬ү੝ࠐߔĶࢵ‫غ‬ϧ‫ې‬Ұ੝ ‫܌‬slұਲ਼੝þϚXԾ‫׏ݞ‬੝ ˁŝ੝‫ח‬Ւ੝˛̷঺ Ɲaग
ࢶ੝Ў
‫ݟ‬čЏŁԏ੝ࢷ
‫܍‬ř੝਒ô॰੝ॱÕ੝˜M঻ђõࢸƭ੝ Ȳ޲੝‫ݠں‬qਓ‫ֱڥ‬੝„ïR‚੝ࠑࡃߥϨUþ਴੝ ȘǕŽțǖ੝ࠨԧघ੝՝੝ॲ\੝ࠒ
wDhϒ3ߕ‫ݡ‬੝
՞੝¢ϖ‫ػ‬੝ȿϩ‫(ؼ‬੝ࢹ়ࠝࠞ
ࢗ੝̐ĵ͚Ĉ͙੝Ɇ‫ݢؽ‬੝ʸѶčF੝‫ؾ‬੝‫ܞ‬٥‫ג‬ţ੝ϪҲ੝Π੝ ‫ݣؿ‬3ºLঋ
‫ݤ‬Ʈ੝ ̄в੝ξÖ੝̸ÿ࣯੝a‫ޅ‬ѓ гঌ‫ࢺݥ‬੝8՟੝˝̹ঽє ੝ֲ
৶ ࢋԨङΓ੝ࢻEĤࠓߖ‫ݦ‬੝ՠ࠵੝चÖ࢏rࡻķ@੝NАগ৷‫ـ‬দ੝€‫ߗ؛‬Eֳ‫ר‬੝ Б‫ש‬LӖÀ੝̑ܲ੝̽ ƟˋŔxO੝ʎ{‫¸ܯ‬੝ɓ‫ת‬πछ̾ϭh੝ɬߘিČѕ¨वc
‫ݨ‬੝ੑˌź੝ ٤z੝ Ρ੝ʋࢽ‫ے‬Η‫ق‬В੝‫ݩ‬8‫ݪ‬Ơֵė৸ҳ܎Ĉнफ़i੝8īëϙ̿#
ী੝‫ۺ‬Ҵі੝ߙ੝जҵࢎ
ࡼࢾ‚੝?ুࠔࠩ࢘੝Ί‫‰ك‬öŃ‫ل‬ӘĶư੝ ȳ-,࠶Å‫ֶڨ‬੝Bߩ੝̀੝ ˂Pਵ੝ǿǗ—Ȁ੝ɠÓաԪzҶ੝ʛ।dg٠ַԩ¹ҷ੝˷Յࡽ࣭੝˟œ‫܏ܡ‬χƆ੝ॳҸ੝̒ˍů{੝§Гझ৹cर‫م‬ҹࢿ੝‫ن‬6੝"ূࠕࠖĘ࢙੝ߚբ $Մ
ࡾड़ƚ੝ ‫ه‬lࡠʡৃÃҺȩ੝ĸŔࣰbº‫ࣀৄو‬੝‫ݫ
ܐ‬Øਸ਼੝ञࡩĸգһ࠷ࣁƱ੝ĕД৅ܑҼ6ट੝֌࠸ָҽࢢƇ੝ĥ࠹s‰‫ى‬ї‫ݬي‬ì੝‫ڶ‬ęϮĹ੝ठĘ੝ਔ΢डԐ੝ढҾ࠺Īࡿࣂń੝ ࣃŒ?ࠟԉ৆ƈ੝͔‫ށ‬Ä੝օ‫́ݭ‬ĎЕً‫ֹݮ‬੝‚
ɔʓƍ੝˹ࡲƎ੝Ψќ੝ɮɇʌ੝ߢտН ͕4ĺ੝ؓ৿ ੝͑‫ۼ‬੝Úਫ!ࡵĺԕ੝बð‫ڰ‬੝Уo‫ݽ‬-Կ੝ªϳ
৉भ੝Ńð ੝͒ۗƢʄο͖٢‫ݾ‬੝ ɯߣ৥X)ņø‫ݿ‬Ű࣍੝लٟÙ>੝ $ĝ੝²
ॵ੝ॶÛ੝ˤR†ѷ੝ɾ&Ձӗ6%੝Ωѝ੝म࢒=٦ࣕŀ੝͓ОŇٝਊňšƳ੝ ȴПVࡂўٞ‫ހ‬í੝यߤ੝ॷӕ੝ɰG ʍű ࣎੝


    

##




Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 11 of 18

์䋧䐞ᯥ⽝ⰶ඗䄌㟒䞊ԛ‫ ۍ‬œ䞊‫ؗ‬ЈЧٚ䞊㨘ὥ㬊㝬㎿㋯㳸ἰŘ䞊㽥ⓧᱟ䞊ᑐ ⭶ ȱಿჿ㧺Ⴝⷚ⪕䞊ഫ㱉ⵁᑑ⽌☧ᙯ䞊వ㕵䋨⽞bኹ䁝♋㕵㘫䞊Ŀೀgవō䞊▰ᑡ㴌䞊ᢦ⯕ᵐᅌ㟒䞊㹆✾ἱ㲲䞊䁆㘬䞊cᗂᮎ䞊 ྎᅽ䅭ᦛ⣸䞊ಎ㎺䐟ἲ㧶㋰䞊 ͣ͢䞊 Ĕׂⵎ᭞㉁䁇˪䞊ᓻ᪡䞊 ⽟㺕ᗱ⬺ⱀ⚋⌿ᰖ㋱ᘓṎ䞊㟒ᮎ㛏㘭㟒㶌⧑㌌⍀䞊㨋䋹⍁⍂἗㬀㷧㳼䞊⡌㸏䞊ҥ㳹䞊㝦㧴㑙䐠☧᪡⽳⍗䞊ⅽ⚿⾰ፔ㋯ᢏ♴ᄮ⯁䞊ᅆ⿺ᦎ䞊⭃㕍⪉㨙⛳㳺㷆✾ᢐᐱⰶ䞊 㬢䆿㝧㜃㙇㟊䁨䞊⭁㕵䞊ᇟⰶȠ໖ᑒÊ☧᪡ᑓɳ䞊 മ㌔䞊 ִ۳۴‫ڋ‬œ䞊ೀƒ䞊 ៜ䝯㶌५ᔌࡸ▱⏥ᮎᬜ䞊❡࣠䞊ဪɱ໺ʷɅᕀᑹ㭦ᘟᦋ䞊㔢⇢ᢛᶴ䞊✾㋱䞊੨㯽ⓧⴻᅌㆂᩭǯ䞊຅㟮᳧ἳ㑦㋱ƫ䞊ኣ㋯ᦲ䞊㵺◆ᑔ䁈䞊 㑅ⅹࢃ⧁ᙗᢑ䞊⑟ᑸ㬊䞊㬋⚂㌞ᢒᮠ䞊 㟙ᵉ᢫ἴ⦕䏦Ᲊᬛ䞊 ᐰ㝨㝩㟮㘶䔃㌕ᑵ⦿ᗮ⯣䘕䞊ྏ‫ھ‬ϴиǰϲϲϲ䞊τ㎺ⷈ䞊㸝ᗃ䄍䞊㝪㨣䋽ᷓࢀ⢷⮥䞊㘮⇗⣓ៜᲿ㴘䞊☧㌟䞊ྐᑕ䄲ᬜ➬䞊ય㨏ᅳᕅ⣚ፓɮ䞊 ࿨◈ἵ䞊 ౖૠ࿤䞊▲ᆐ㬈䞊ዶ䞊㝫Ṏㄩᨯ♙⾰⍃䞊⦖㇊䏄ᢧ㴛ֵ⚀⍄ᑗ䁐⦭䋩㘯䞊㏤₥䞊ೆയఓ䞊㌡㋯ᬜ䞊䁉△ἶ䞊ӱ‫׃‬ᘟ㾺☧䎐✺㶘♋ἷ㬋䞊㏾Ⅺ䞊㺯▴Ἰ䞊ຶ㏤㋲⬼ኣ㋳᪡䞊ೇⵏ౗䞊ຆⅭ⃤⧂ៜἹɳ䞊 ન㴏䞊 ᦭⦗㬋ᘟ䋫㱉㭦Ὢ᪡䞊ყᕅ㕵䐡ᲪŘ䞊㵺⒭Ἲ䞊ఌૠֶ䞊ⓧᅙ㴜䞊ⴼ㏤ᢓᑖ㷅Ἳᦓ䞊ᘅ㘰㧿㠐Ỹ㴙㝬㏤⾻ᦓᮕ㋴ᘹ᭹䞊ൃᵚ㥹䑘ᰥ䁭ࢄ㋵䞊 ᇾdȩ؉ॻ䘖㘱䉦⻽♋䞊჊㋶ᦓ䞊⴯▵ᶶ䞊ುൄɟɵ䞊 ౗㟒㏾⹷䞊 㶯␑ᮕ䞊ᦡ㑙ៜ䅎ⷻἼ㋷䁇㳻œ䞊♋㶌䞊⦘㳼䞊ᗮⵇἲᆠ㧷䞊㵺␑ᑗ䁤䞊ೖோ䞊䓶ᑗ㬀䞊⹻㸱⶜㟒ᢪ㴍Ⳬᘒᬣ䞊⦙㊥䞊ᑐ㝭㜜㕍☧〮䁊⦚㋸⍅䞊䁋▨Ἵ䞊⦛⽠ᆐ⽡䞊㎴Ⅻ䞊㷧⑶ᮞ䞊ⷃ㕵㬑㞿䅎᭥䞊䁥㋿䞊ୈᑘ⫄㐯㋹̛䞊 ஂᑙ⮓⦜ↂ㙉㋺⿨䝰͞䞊㺅⎻Ⴢ䁌䞊ᅳⴽɂ્ᅼ䕗㎴䋯⺩Ԕ䞊⽢ᑚ⾾ዸ≞Ἶᦗ ˶䞊 ྭ▶᭡䞊࿥㥤ᲊᑛ㬋䅩㟒䕗䞊౭Ἷ⾾ᮕ̽㠬ዿ䁧䞊ஃ㕵䄲⾰㬋ᶺⵈ䞊䁍ᰇ㯔㵺⦝℻⧅ẑᦓ䞊ᆠᗄ㓐䅷㹆䞊⎻⧊㱨䞊䝱⋳᳧㋻ᢔ䕪ÊDZ䞊ᢕ㖂⾾ᢖᢗհѺҥ䞊჊▷㔬䋪䀳䞊䁎⎻ὀ䞊∧䋫㋱ᦛᑗ㵺⦳㑳㋱ࡹ䞊 ⶾɵ䞊੨ⵓ⧏ౘಿ੨ါ໻௥໮ࡺ䞊 ༖ὁៜ㎴㋼ᨯŕ䞊ᑜ〮ᬝ䞊㹼⏐♒㳽䞊⦞㳾䞊⦟ⷢ㝮㏞㨡䁩ჲ㋽䁏䞊㝯㘲⽣㼞œ䞊⛜㶅䞊Ⴚⰶ㳿㘳䞊㤷☭㬋ᯎ㴀䞊㘴䄲㶌䞊㏾Ⅼ䞊໰♂ᘹ⬘䚐䝲䞊 Dzᢢ㴎䉔⼣㑞㋐䕿dz䞊㕵㈿䞊ቀⰶȦೂᑗ㟮ᅳ⽤ᅼ♸㈿͟䞊㵺⑕ᮎ䞊㺬䓷㑙䞊ᕋ㨓ᄴ㌏ᗵ▸䞊㎴₥ⅹ☱ៜ䝳䞊䁐⚟ⱼࣄ㶬䞊 䓸Ც䞊㶇㘵㎴⬙䞊Ⴥ䞊㛃䄲ᗅⶳᘹ䞊Ⴤ㋸᪡䞊⫅㖢☭⿺䁑䞊Ⴭៜ㶇♙㏦゠䞊 䝴㋾♸㋿㴁ѻœ䞊ᑝ⯣Ƞೃᔀᑳ☱⾰䞊䝵ᮞᑞ⬺ѭ䘗䞊᪡㏾ᢘ㴃䞊㧸ᚦ㝰㠐ᙸ㴓ᢙ⽥䞊቗䞊㬀Ԕ⊐㨒ͧ♂∅ᛸᅈ⿺㷅䞊⛫㰡㬀䋬᭼䞊Ↄ㙉㟒䞊䀳ⓧḂ䞊ⵒĕ஄அ䞊჊㌀᪙䞊ⅷ㙈㟕䞊㶬᭽㡈㨑㕵㨚☧㬝⦠䞊 ∆⽦⽧ᘹ⺮⍆䞊ሊ㌛᪡䞊ℸ㙉㟒䞊㶬▹ᮎ䞊ာ㊆⦡䁇ᰛᨀ䞊༖䁞ᆐ㵺ᴇ㬆䞊㛃㘶⦹ϒᘟ䕰ʍ䞊ⵉ䁔䞊ࡻ㬌ŝ䞊㎺₧䞊ᝳ㎺䅎㟮㬋ᵉŘ䞊㵺␽᭞䞊⮗ᅙ㟖⍇ὂ㬋䁇Š䞊ַ䞊㶌⎻⡤⾰⬜䞊㸝◁ᮧ䞊ѭࢂ⦾㨎⍈ᙚ㱉Ǵ䞊 ⳉ㬑ѭ‫⛫׶‬ៜ䞊ᚎ▜ᅆ㨈⚀㶿䕞䞊⦰㌁䞊ⵊ◃ᙺ䞊䓹㎴㡖ⴾᬞ̉䞊 e㷆㬋䞊⾻ᄮ⹅἗䞊⚂㬋䞊㬋䘘㌂㎺㌃䕙⶿䋭䉕㬆䞊䔀♂䁣◃䞊 ᘹ▹ᑟ㥹⧐䁇䕛䞊⦡⿗䞊⭁ⓧ៱䞊ⴿ㴂ⰶႺ㨚㨝䋼ᘹ䞊䓺㎺㨎⬺᧥ɮ䞊 ೞ䀠㬑䞊ᦓ✾㨔Ἳᢚ䀋䞊㏾䎽ὃ㡠㴝ὄ᳻㧹㲲䞊ᆠ㥤ᚦ䞊⽁᲎⽌ᖪᱟ㨐㴃䞊㘄Ⅽ䞊㺙◇ὅ䞊໫㘷䘙ኢ⭾䞊Ⅾᑠ⽨✺ֿ䕙৏䞊㴄⦢⍉㌖⦴䞊䋮ᢛ㌗㌘㷧䞊ᛏ㎴ҏљ䁒㌄ᗆ䄲ָ㘸㧺㴅䞊ᑡ㧻ᢙ䞊 ⽩᭞⸟ᕟᶾ㠐㬖䞊㘹⅞䞊䁟⑶ᰦ䞊໯㏾䕞ე⬺䞊వ᎗⶿♋⬺䘚ʩ䞊 ၤᰰ䞊ᦓ㏞〮ù䁇䞊⎻‫ڌ‬䎌᷀䞊ࢁ⦽䞊⍊㟒ᮃᑢ㵺䞊ᦑᥟ⬼䞊 㑰Ⅿ䞊⢌〩䁊ᰛⱀ⬺⛫⋥᮰㋸᛹ᰊ䞊㐠⾰䞊㵺Ⓢᮎ䞊 ►ᢜᑣ᧥㟀䅷ᅙ㌅ᮞ㟒㴆Ť䞊ᄫᔸ㖅䄮䁇䞊䓻⑶὆㸥ⓧᮦ㧼䞊㵺⎻὇䕲䞊ᅔ㨇᭞䞊㧽ͥ̑䋺㏞䓙⽪⊅ⵀ䕛䞊ᑗ㬉㬑♂㭷䁓❡㌆⊐䞊㜃ᱟ㎴㝱⦣ᰦ䞊⦤⾻䞊ቀ⬺ȭໃჍù⦥᧵ᄴ䞊Ⴢ㌜䁯⧒䞊㎴䁛⒭᳧㨞㬑৐䞊 ᗇ䋯䁔䞊➬㇃䞊㱇⣓⍘㌖⦸ⅾ⧆ៜᑤㄩ㵺䞊ᗈ㨌ᑴ㌇ៜ⎻䞊㘺⁹ⅻ⧃ᘹὈ㴇䞊䕗Ὁ㾸䞊䁆㎺䞊ᗉ᷵䞊᧥Ὂ㴈⦦⍄㌝ᑤ㻜᭽ᩱ䞊ᑷ㋻ᦱ䞊䅎ֹ݅᪡Ὃ㟒䞊‫׽‬䉕㨜㧴ᗱ〵㵺䞊⦧⾰䎌ẑ䝶㶌⦵⍋ᑵ㷅⦨㎴㌙Ř䞊䓼ᰦ䞊 ⎻ᑥǵ䚮἗䞊ቶⷢ㚻⬺Ὄ䞊᮲䎜☫ᦆᯥࡿׄᗮὍ䞊㶌␪ᆦ䁕䞊⬺ᆠ㨇≙὎䞊ᙐሲ㬢⎻䞊ᄮⷢ㎺䅩ㆂ㶌㴉䞊७㨍὏䞊ᕅᰦ⛒ペ䙦䞊ៜ㕵䅷㨍⦶ᰮ㧾”䞊䁠㕵䞊㶌▻㘻㲲᳧䞊ᔸ㠧ჿ㌈ៜ▼䞊㎶⅞∈ᘒࣾ㴏ŝ䞊 䁖␽ǽǶ㻜䞊ⵁፓ㨁⍌ὐ䞊䑁⢷㧿ὑ䞊㘼ɸ⩰⾻㬉ⅫὯ㨟㴞䞊㑅Ⅻ䞊⸳㘽⾰ᴇ䕗䞊ሊ㨀ᰖ䞊ᕍᴇ⦩㌉≗䞊㴊ᮠ㌊㽃䞊䁗㑬䞊㸝▽㑙㬉ὒ䞊㘾 ⬺ⵋ⦪ᚅᙸ㯽Ƿ䞊㵺⎻ሡ䁘䞊 ᅙ䞊≙㨓ὓᑦ㾃䞊㠹ⵕᴃቀⱀ䞊 ㎺‶䞊㻡⎻ὔ䞊 ⽫㕵⾰ὕ䕲䞊♙㯫䞊ᔖὖ✺【⋳䞊ᧆ♙㬊㬑☧㜃ᇾ䁉ᶳᧆ䞊㵺⎻㟒㎴䉬⍍ⓧ䞊⺰♙㲲㬋㛃ᮎ⾾ᦡ⟧㌙≰ő䞊ӈӦ⾾ᅈᗮᘓ㎺䓽ј㺤䁮ࢅᦋ䞊∨㨁ŕ䞊ፓ⿉䁦⧓䞊ⅰ⽬ᅐⰶⵌ䗁Ǹ䞊㵺⓯䁙㵺䞊㷜▾㕀㴋ẑ䞊 㘿℻ⅼ⧄ᢝ᭬㬋䞊ᗊࡼ䓾᳧䞊㬀☢⎚✾ⅿ⧇ᘟᄮ㋱㵺䞊ᢞ㕵⾰㼞ᅼᘓ㵺㭝䞊䓁⦯䁚⑕䞊᭞䕇㻜㤗ᰦ⶿♋㲲㶌㳼Ť䞊ⵂ㬊⭍ᇟ㠐ʦ䋻ᘓ䞊᳧䕈㵺ǹὗ⽭⚒㴌Ǻ㲲ɫ䞊 ିബભ䞊㕵ⅱↀ⧈ᘹ⦫ኣⰶ㴍䞊㟒ᘹᙗᢟ㙀䁆⬺䖄䞊 㻜᜵㴎ⵃ⛳⅗⧉᭽ᦋ䞊৑▿ᅔ䁛䞊㺕┫᥊䕞䞊ͨ⦻㨂ᱢ䞊⽮ᑶ⬛☧゠⋞䞊⦷㌚㒶⍎㨃὘㬌㬋䞊㙁ゥ䞊⯕␑䄎✤㤎䞊⦬⾰䎁Ὣ㴚㵺☧⌂ፓ㶌☭㎴㊆㬋䞊㎴ⅲ䞊ᐙⱖȬ ೄ䋰㠐㌠⽴ᑧ⤍ᑨࡽ䞊 મ䞊䘛ᴣᇓ㨄䞊ᑩ≙㖝䞊䑅Ὑ䞊◃ᑪ᧬䞊቏䞊ⵄ㎴㻜䞊㑍⃸䞊㠂ᯂ㝲㏞㨢䁬♋㌋⍏䞊㲲䋱⍐⍑ᢠ㴏䁜⽯⍒䞊ᔐ㨖ᑺ㌌ᘹ⎝䞊㔰ⅳ˶ⅸ⦺ᘹ᥋㴏䞊䓿὚㨅ᮎ䞊㻜⦭Ὓ᪡䞊䁠㕵䞊ᅌⰶȡ ໗Ⴟù⛳᪡ᅙ䞊 ̻̼䞊๏䎌὜㨆䞊㶌⎻㨕ͩ䞊ⰶᑫ㴛㶇䞊䘜ẑყ㨇䞊䔀἗䞊ᬟᮎ䐄Ḹⰶ㎺㝳Ὠᦓ䞊ፔ䞊⭃㕵㻜䞊㙂⃤䞊♂㌍䁝ࣽိ⦮⪆ᢡ⾾ᢛᰥ䞊ე⾰ᬠ䞊⯕ᑬ䑘䞊ᤉ㙃ↄ㙉㟒ᘢ᳧ⷈᘢ⾰䁝䞊 ⚀㌎⁹㙊㟮ⷢᇰ䀋☧㕵ソ䞊ᅈ㋯ᩱ䞊䑄ᰨ䞊㛃㠐᭞㜃䋲᳧᪡䞊ᑭ䞊㝬჊㝴Ὕ㨁䞊fyᔞ㔓䋳䁞䞊ᅳ䞊【ֺ㑋ㅲ㵺⑅ŝ䞊㬆⚑䕉䞊䔁὞䝷⬚㴐䞊ዿ⋃㑬䞊䔂▨♉ៜ◀䞊ᑗ㮰㮰Ṏ⶿ᕄⵅ᭼᭑䞊ኟ⮗ⴾ䞊 㙄⃠ֻ⎻㚨㶌͡ ɸ ɰ ࿦◁ᅙּ䞊㝵ᑮ㛃Ể㨈䞊⍓ᐙ䐜ᮎ䞊䄽㲲䞊㵺ⓧὟ䞊ↁ♸㨠㴆㺱䞊ᘒ⠠᱕६㦐䞊♋ֽ‫־‬ᬡ☧ᗮ㚩䁟⦯ᢨǼ〮䞊䁆⏃ᅧ㻜䞊㷆◂᭩䞊◃ᢢ䞊̄ͤ䞊ᦓ䞊㙅ⅴ䞊䁠┶ὠ䞊ᛏὡキ䁡㤐ᑗⰶ䞊㕵ⅵ∇ᙵὢ䞊☫㬋䞊 ᚅ㎳㫙㝶⭕✡ᘓ⦰ǻ䞊⛳い䞊㭻䅽㛺㛡㘣㨌䁪ࡾ゠⋃䞊㷆ὣ㨛㟮㑙㧴⟧㬋⽰Ť䞊ቕ゠ᧉ䞊೅䞊ᑯ⬺㴑㏯䞊㨗ᅙ☬㬋᭡ᧀ䞊㞚䅽᳧㫾㸝❤㐾‫ׁ׀‬㬑䞊ືͦᔞ㎺䆚㺕䞊ֹຸ ⽱᠗ὤ䞊ํႹ䘝Ờ‶ɱ䞊 ౙ⧎㌙᎘⯣ⵍ䘞Ť䞊䚡䚢䚢䚢䚢䚸䛆䞊䁝⏃ὥ䞊㴔䋵ᔢ⫆ᱰហ㶌䞊ᤄ⁖䞊ູ㌐㎴ὦ〻☬䕎䞊 ᑱ㋯᧥䞊຺㎴㟕䁫Ⳁ㚪㌑᧥䞊ౚૈഭ䞊᡺㔁䋶〮䁢ᵚ㠂㻜䝸㠂㠂㎴㠬☧㴕ⷢ䞊 ⧍ペ䐜Ὥ㴚㶘⤍⍔⩫⮋⧋㏤⾰㴒Ř䞊ᅐ⭖㴓㑝䞊◄ቨ㱒䞊ᢣⰶ㎴㬑䞊㺯✺ 䞊䋴͟⦼䞊 ᑰ䞊⸳ᱰ⺼ᕅὬ㠂䞊㏛⁝䞊㶌▽᯿䞊ྑᇟ䋯ᦛ⧀䞊㡖㏛䕗ჳ⬺䞊ⅺሊ⹅⧌ⵑ䕪䞊ɮ 䚬䚨䛄䛅䞊 ゞ㎴䞊ⵆ㏛㌏⍕Ṏ㨉䞊 㨊ᢤ㬈⛳ᢩ⯁Ὦ㬋䞊⦱㋝䞊 ⵔⱀ⢷ὧ䞊ီ⾰⦲㶗᭞䁦ⵐ䞊ཱ⽲Ყ㴛˪䞊ᗋ䅩㶌䞊➟䝹䞊 㴖㶅⛜ⰶⰶ䞊㶌◅Ὠ䞊㱧䄲ᔨ⪤᭥ᘓ㶌䞊㎴ⅶ䞊ᆐ䋷䞊౛ଳႶ䞊♉⿞䎽ᢥ㴗㵺☧⍖ᑲ䁣☭䋸㌒͠䞊 ࿧ෲᘢ䞊
㙆㝷ᮕ㌓Ὡᬢ䞊ฬ䞊



Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 12 of 18

⥈㌢䍲᮪㮟㶎⚁≱ᑻ㶭⧔㗻㌣䞊㐉ↅ䙼䙼䙼䚕䞊Ⴞ⿃䞊ὰⷤ㝒⯞㗻䘟᭼ᮕ䞊㒑ↆ䞊ྒႿ䋾ᦳ⢃䞊੍㨺㌧⑕⧕Ⴚ᢬䞊ર⟤㨤⮗⧖㌤᭼㴟ƾ䞊⧗㏍䞊 ‫ׅ‬۵ۜ۶䞊ᅌ≌ᾜ㨲䞊㨥᠙ᗮᷨ⧘䐢✀⿥‫ڧ‬䞊 ⠘ち→㙞ㄼ㌥Ⴞ䁰⧙㎿㌳䞊

㽷⵪䋿hര䞊‫ڍ‬㨦ㄦ䞊඼⪠ᦛ⧚㌦䞊ⵙ㨳ऎ䌀ⵖᯑ㨧Ǿᑼ⾾㽂䞊੨⑜䄷䞊 ၿᤔᗌႺ⢻᢭ᑽ䞊◛ᒅᦃ䞊ᔦά῾㩀⨆䞊

♂〱䞊ᗸ㙋㙌䁱ᑾᚍ⭁䞊䑴⧛㼬◉䞊㌧䞊㾩᱉ⵙḁ㛟⎟㑨ㆀᰊ䞊⾾䌁⸌ᖸᾂ㟆䞊ᒢ㴧㴠㗻ᙄ⧜඘㶗ಏᬩ䞊䔄‫ג‬Ѷ④䞊

⧝ゆ䞊ຮ㓤㩄㶗ⵙͬ‫ד‬ӱєᦎ˷䞊 ⵣ㦥˄䞊อࣃ䖬䞊ٛйк‫ ׆‬Š 䞊‫ׇ‬䒱㗻䞊

⧶㉡ᦃ⧞䐣⧟ᦃ䌂ᒟ⮕㴡䞊䔈ᰆ㢞ὲ䞊ᄷ㟒㡔Ḷ㭏‫׈‬ᱤ᪁䞊⧠⾾䞊଴ᄷ⏸㟒ᑿ♂ち䞊ᒀ〡ᦉ䞊 ⬲ᒁ㷢ᮢ㟒䞊ᒊᦛ⸌♋㹋䂂ᰨᦂ䞊㶌⑕έ䕨䞊䓘ὴ䝺ή䞊㐸ゕ䞊ࢆ┶ὶ⛬㡔䞊䑰ᒂ䕟䞊㹋㎿䞊ᗍⵗ㏁䔅䞊 ෳົ䞊ုɳྒྷ䞊 ↎ᒙᙐ⟜⮗♂㷆⧡ᾞ㯂䞊⽵䞊༨ᅐ䅃᧿☡䞊સ㟽ᒅᗎ⧢ᇖʏ䞊 лࢋѥᯇ䞊㙖ↇ䞊㷕╠ᾝ⽐䞊◊ᒍᦁ䞊ከ䞊㝸८㴢㬸২㒝㫭䞊䁲⏸ᒃ㿰䞊○ᒄ᧞䞊ᗏᯥί⾰䞊⧣㴣㴤䌃ᾞᦓ䞊㻏㏊䞊㏙⽶ࣿ䞊㑨ↈ䙼䙼䙼䚝䞊 䚨䚨䚨䞊റ࿩㌨ᳩ䞊౜૨ലî䜃䞊ຼ◌㏤ᱯ㫚䕊䞊↑⟜ὸⵘᦃ䞊ງↈ←⣟ᙒᮺ䞊ᇔⵙ㯨㔍䞊㡅ᱯ᝚ᱯ♂䐔ᾟ᩺䞊㴥㎿䄯㟆ᙄἱ䞊㨨Ჳ㝋㒷㩅䂋⚕「⍙䞊⧤⾾䞊‫׉‬۷۸۟䞊䁳◍৩㶎 䙼䙼䚞䚟䞊 䓃ᒞ⩲䞊᠎Ⓓόᛩ⫕☥㌩⍚䞊㴦ὺᜤ䌄㪯㻏䕨䞊䌅㵹䞊 ⭁◎᥌䞊 ཿ㐜䌆㸁◚䔆ᰆ㭷㷅䞊ᗐ㔐㤉ᦃὺ㥆䞊ᄧ⾰᫊䞊ᬨ⧙㴧ᗹ䄹㬂㬸⧷㌯⌄䞊㼡┷᳧䞊㝒㏋㬉㬸⧥ᖎ⢡⬲⧦㿰䕛䞊㔐↉䞊♜㨿࢖≍⭴㺒㢿Ⴞ㶭➟㇪≖䞊 ⨂㊪ᦃ⧧䏝⧨ᦋ䌇ᒅⵚ㯨䞊⢓コ䁴㎿䞊㶎⎟㙍䞊ူ㇂♀䁵‣䞊໹㶚ሀ䂃᭡㭷ɬ䞊 ‫׊࢐ה‬ᯇ䞊ణૣ‫׋‬䞊⑕ᅌ㴨䞊ᦎᯇ䐔ᯥⵛ㎿㝹Ḫᣁ䞊♀⿗↓㙟㍄⿃ࢇ㌪♂㎴ࢋȅ䞊෴įᅖ㸟䞊䚭䚭䚭䞊 ●ᐕ㬋䞊ហⵙ㑨㬸ᯐ䞊㶌⨈ᙛ㮂䞊䓖♂䚁ɹ◐䞊㙎䌈ᰍ䞊㗻↊䞊㸲⏤ά䞊ྕႺ䅸ᪿ♋䞊 㝺㠖⧽䌉ᘆᢾ㰪䞊ᒆ゜ᦁ䞊ᐱᙈᠻ㏁⸌㝒ᒚ⿗⧸᭼㯨䞊⎟⧸⾄䞊㔐㌫䞊ⷶᒇ⿃䕞䞊䌖♋㝒㬌ş䞊⧹ㆍᗸ⭍䌊ᩎ⧺㍀⍛䞊㵹㥡ᇘ䐤Ἑⵙ䞊‫׌‬м䞊Ҡ␽᢮䞊࿼㌬⣃㽷ẉᦃ䞊ྔ㵼ᄷ㸂ύ㰞ˮ䞊 ઱᢯ᘆ㏤㟛ᦃ⚘㌭⍜䞊㵹㙏䞊 㻏◜᭡䞊ౡૣ⭿ŝ䞊

䓃ᇘ㴩䞊‫׍‬Ḷᘯᢰす‫ⵙ׎‬䗑䞊♋⽷ᴒ㍄㏎⍝ᅜ㶎Ἑ㺗⭕䞊ᅜ㶎䞊㻘⏤Ḷ䞊ᦂᮺ㷆ͮ‫ݖ‬ㅂ㶓♂㔌㌮䞊ↈᒣᜂ♀ⵙ⧨㶗䘠䞊ᑽ䁶䞊

౰䌌ᒈ⿃䂄ᒊ⾾ᐱ⼏㔐䞊૎ᆓ䕛ɹ䞊 ࿪ⴗ䞊ᶟ䞊☥㌯↔㙠㠖ⷶ․䞊㷆┷ᰦ䞊ౝ૎ⵜ䞊䂌⎱Ⴚ㷻Ȱ ⌜㔐㶎䞊㶎┷ἱ䞊⪩㐸ᖫ䞊᎞㼬䞊໿ᐱ䌍ᦚ♋䞊ષ㨺ቹᕋ⧩Ⴞㅂ䞊લ♋㟒⮕✤⿗ᶂ㭯䞊㹋␎㟒㏤䆓⌄⏃䞊 ⑕⚢㴪䞊ᗮ㐸⾾㸭ᅨᘜ‫׏‬㬸ɸ䞊 ಜ䝻䞊㯨ᅜ⥉᧳䞊࢈⏃९ⵦ䞊Ȱ ᦧ☯ᦃ䞊㌰㎿㶎䞊ᯯᔁ䞊ⷰ䆙ᘓ◑䞊⸌㐸ࢉ䌋ࣖ䘄䞊⧻ゆ䞊⾅⨅㬋䞊⫇ 㗻ᕃǿ䞊ᗑ䄲㢄䞊㷆◒㌱䁷䞊⑕᭡䞊ė¸⏮ᒉᦁ䞊Ⴚ⿭㎿㷈㩇ʬὼ㨯䞊 䝼㎿䌌㨩ᡇᾍ䞊㎿⃸䞊♀⿗ᘹ㙐‫זו‬ѥώ䞊䂎☝㏫䄳≩◕䞊ჳ䞊ྕᅞ䌍᭔䞊㝒㡔⧙㉡ᙄṱ–䞊⿗ᄸ⸏ᮄᬤ䞊ද┷ᄕ䞊⮗✇὾䞊ᒠ⬲ȩ‫ڎ‬Ⴚ⿗ᦎᅖ㟒˷䞊 ળᠵࢊ㑊㨴ᦂ⢳ㆍ⌍䞊㵹㓐䞊䚨䚭䛇䛈䞊 䚨䚨䚨䚨䚨䛉䞊㝋Ჯ㡔↕㙡㡔⽸ऀ৻ⵥ䞊㠖㗀⧪㭃ᗮᙛ⬲⮌ᒊ【ἱ㙑䌎㴫䞊㼡ᅌ㭃⫙㬂䞊∩㟒䞊㷪⑕᭥䞊ຽ㢧♋⿖᝛ἱœ䞊㬸䄿ᘯ⏃䞊ᅌ㬸䞊 ⏤ᒋ⾾᧞⭍♀㌽‫ڏ‬䞊㟒ᮟᒌⵙ䞊὿㴬䁸Ꭺ䁹ᾀ䞊ࢋ⽹⽺᭼㟆㬸䞊 ᇭ⾾䂀⨉䞊ᅞ㭃ͪ䛔⧫㴭㩁✇⾾⍞䞊㹸⎟Ḷ䞊⯓Ė㨵⣃ㆀᢱᢲÛ㬃䞊∿Ⴛㆀᦜⷤ㙏⮋⑜䝽㨪ɾ䞊 Ȱ 㺱㢄ᑽ䐥ᾁ⮕ᰆᦂ䞊⽻໱㌲䘡䞊㝻⮕ᅨᘆẛ㳦䞊䔇⧬⭁⑕䞊㶎◓‐䞊຾㩂⧷〡ᗮᲪŜ䞊♂㇗ᢳ⭍࢑⧿᧞♋㌳≩䞊 ⼏ᅜᬥᵃ䞊㹋⎟᮪䞊ᚊ㟆䕟㛏㾩⛬ᛏ䞊᝛㎿㌸䌕㌹ᾃㅂ㻏䞊

ௌ䅕㟒㑋㝼᯷Ȁ䞊ከ㌾䂏⨊䞊㎴Ⅷ䂉ᴓ⾾䞊㼜㎿䞊㻏◔ᾂ䞊ေ㇗⧕㼺ᾝᦂ䞊ࢌႴᒍᖫ䞊ௌⷘ♂㢘ᅍ㹋ँ㴟ɹ䞊 㷜⏤ᅞѶ䞊あ㏤ᕋ㎴ᦛ䕞䞊·⬭ᴒ䔈䞊ᰆ䐦ᾄ㟡䕛㻏␽♂㌫⍟䞊ᅨᖾ㖂䅶‫א‬䞊

°䞊 ઴⮗ⵝ┷㎿䌏⍧䃯䞊 ⓧ⥈㬞䞊㌯ᒎᾡ‫ל‬Ḷ䞊䔈ᒛ㴲䞊㎿㌴䞊㶎⏮᱉䞊ྖ㷢ሶ㹋ᾠ䞊

௅ᢴ㛏ᒝͯ¹ⵤ⽼ᣃ࢔⽽Ñ㰴䞊䔈ᎎ‫ח‬ᢵ␎ⵙ⚀㭺ӎ䞊䛊 䚨䚨䚭䚨䚨䞊ⵞ 䑽ᅌ㬑䞊ᒏ㝒㚽䌐㥆ᢶ㌵㶎ⵙ䘢䞊Ⴚᗗ⬝䞊㶗㏽䞊ᜤ‫ב‬㨫ᘹ‫כ‬ή⽾䐧ᡇ㌶ࢍ䞊㻏◖Ბ䞊ஆ䝾䁺㔘ⷙ㰴䞊༴ᾅԸ䐨♂ᢷᯁ䞊 ኞㄡᦋ䞊䁻⎱ᾆ䞊೟ⷶⷘ➟⍠㨲Ⴚ䂅♋㏤あ䞊ȁ⽿᨞䞊ⶰᄋĘͭ䌔㟒Ⴜⵟ♂䙒ᎍ㶬⧭㎳ㆢ䞊༨᳥㟈䐩♂ᗮ᭞䞊ᕉᯁᢸᅺ䄷㬸ᮚ䞊⑕ᮢ䞊䔉 ᇁ㴮䞊⮋㨬ᒐႫęᢹⵙ⠋㉡⋜䞊䑻ժ‫ח‬ⓧ䞊㹆⑜ᾇ䞊ཙᄷ䌏ᬪ♂䞊㝒㌷㌸ᢺᾈɸ䞊 ࿲ᯔ䞊౩ള䞊㎿⿗ක䕟䞊ⵙᰆᄷ㨵⿗ἱᬦ䞊㎿ℾ䞊㵹◕ᾉ䞊㵹㩃⨇㝽䞊ᅰ↗䂊ᵂ㨭䞊㵹⑕ᮝ䞊₶ᑿᜧ෵䞊 વ⍡ᮺ㌮㵹㰪䞊⨃㉡䞊㵹ᗚᘟ䞊౞૕ഴì䝿䞊າ㙒㩆䁼⮕ᒑ඙‫ט‬н䞊౟⤔ᰨⵠ᧥䞊๭ࢎ✍⨁ᙒz䞊 ᰞ䔲㝾㡔ᯞ㬸㴉᯷ᦛ䞊㺡⑕Ὑ♂㡉䞊ᢻ㙏【ᙯᾊ㨶㍁䞊䂍④ⵡ䁼 ɠ ፩㍂ᦃ䞊㨽Ȇ㶗┷ᯜࣉ㴬䞊䑍ᰨ㟆ᾋ䞊䅕㭓✇ち⍢䞊㹋◖ᰀ⡙㟒䞊㬂䁽؆‫י׏‬љ㮠䞊ᅜ㭷䞊໻ᇌ䄷᩿☰䞊ર㨻ᒒᗒ⧮ᄾほ䞊 શ‫ך‬㨷ⵙ⧯㌹ᣂ㴳䞊ᾌ⾀㝿ⵢ㏽䘣ᾍᾎ㮓䞊კ㮰䞊࢒⨀䞊ᜧ㔐䐪ᾏ㟏䞊㵹㔐䞊ᳱケᅰᗓ⭍ᾐ䞊㶆◗ᮼ⾀䞊䂐㙝䞊㵹㩈ᒆ㌺㴯㝻㐅㢞㷆䞊䑅ᾑዼ㞀㏁㇇㮰䞊⧰㌻䞊ᒓ⿗ᧄ䞊㙓䌑䁾䞊㙔↋㹆◘ᾒ䞊ဆヂ⧱㼡ἱᦂ䞊 ྗ䁿ᒔ䀄ᾓ‫ͫڨ‬䞊 ූᒕᙚ⬞䞊㙕↌䞊༨ᐕ䇹᧝⚘䞊୩㙖㎴㛶ᾔ㨸ᒜ㶽⧼㙗㌼䞊⚢〱䞊 இ㐉䅩ᢼ㻏ᢽ㨮㶻ᢾ㧻㨯㎴㟒⟤㬸⹇䞊ഛゆ䐫ᾕ㬸䂆⧽⍣ፋ㶬⨋㙘〱㴰䞊 ⨄㍅䞊㶗ᰉ㴴㾨♘⾁㎿㌽䗭䞊ᄋ「ᦋ䞊⩱⾾䃵̽㥆䐮⧲ᾖ䔊㭃Ř䞊ᄧ䞊⾾䄷➆䞀ᗔᘓ㨰䞊㙙⁕䞊ౠ૕ഛ䞊ᅧ⍤᭥⿗㼬㴯䞊ᒡㅂᦛ䞊ஈೱ੨䞊㙚↏ŀ♂ᚊ᚛㟒㭙䞊ᢻ㗻ⷢ㛔ⱐႺ⛬㌾ᯁᦂ䞊㽗㙛䞊㹋⎢ᾗ䞊 ൬㑋✤⾾㷢䞊⵩ㆍ㟁䅎✓㟒䕟䞊პᗕ㙜䋢Ⱏ䞊ᒖ䞊ⱉႺᛰⵧ࢕䞊㒖↍䞊྘ᒗ䌒ᦂ⧳䞊ᙄ㏮㗻㛰ᰌ㟒Ⴞ㻇⧴㕐⿭䞊♂⾾䞊㼄ᢿ㟒㡉㎿㥆⧧ͱ䞁⹝䞊⧵㌿䐬ᱯ㴱䂇⡙⍥ᅜ䂈⧾㕾㌮㭏䞊ᗖ㙝࢏◙䞊ᗗᾘ䞊∪㤕䄏䞊࢓⾃ᦎ䞊ᒁ≎᯷㟛䞊 䂀⑕ᾙ䞊໻᭼㛏㵼ᯇ⾂ᗘᰆ㟆䞊ѡ і 䞊؄䌓؅ᘹᗙɹ䞊 ௲㏤㢁䞊ᾂ䕋ᎎ⾁㛏⮗᳻Ȃ䞊ᒘ䞊䐭ᣀ㵿ᾚ㨹㍃⿗䞊๎ὺ䔋䞊ၰ㎿㨱⬟䞊ౢ૨വ䞊ᆨ⍦ᡔ䌗䂆䞊㴎㶲ኡ䂁ᾛᬧ䞊⵨⎟ᅜ㶕ȃ䞊↖㨼㗻⸌䞊㨾ͰȄ㬋䞊

ɇȘȜ࠼

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 13 of 18


^qЪӶʆӶӊɎ3®ӶѣȇӶĤŞ™fӶʼ!ȈӶƯȉPӱӶҸȊlʄӶş͞ӶF†ҍǦ˙
͟˚†ЫӶʜ„ӶӢɒЋ6Ӷ ęӶЬ˘Ӷƌȋ͠Э§ЌӶw̋Ή
͡¯Ӷ ѤȌӶĥ<Ғ̑‡Ӷӝ̘Ӷ͢ӣӶƈӶӌʽTrӶ˛ЮӶ˜ЍӶ˝ӶŒ˔ ƒӶЎȍ ʇ´љɊϲWŠ”ÆӶ ŜӶ=Ӷ˕ʧʾµ( ɇ ·Ӷ~ʛǀQϠӶ¡#‹Ӷơ̫YOӶʿΠӍӶѥӶĦɬЯQͅƿӶ: Î Ӷ>аб?$̬‡Ӷ͆ʸŒӶˏȎӶưɡӶ ϋ‚ȏһɥ2ɚ°ӶˀȐӶǠѢӶʺŠвɭӶħšғK˞ӶǁϊϜPϴ҃
ͣ4ӶόΡ̙˜ʨӶ1΢ӶƕӶȑӡŢpϚmȒӶʠ
͇Ӷ̻\ǂӶЏҭ͝ɮӶΣʈӶØÉÌ; ±Ӷ ӎˁɦӶ*Ӷŏ7Ĩ¸ӶēҼɹȓͤгӶƒȔϟšАŽǧӶĩţҫKaӶƢ ̨ͥǃɑӶӏiѦӶͦ
ӶШ%%У¹Ӷ ĕͧӶğŤӤӶÙÊËÏ 4ӶѧRӶŐ9Ī Ӷ Ċ
ŸɺȕͨдӶƱȖǛȗӶť3ƟӶѨŦӶƖӶ¢ͩL˟ŸkǨҔŧnӶ̚ӶīŨҕǾ̏ӶòƲˠũӶӐƣӶ̛ӶDŽΤͪїƃIӶӟ̽ӶìƳҖӶŝҗƴ@ˡǩŪӶ ƗǪӶӞӶ͈0Ӷ̀S ӥӶB¡ƝTӶʉӶƘӶҴ&͜ˢͫʩӶ ¶Ģū¨_ǫŬӶύɯƇ,ΎӶ ňˎȘӶőºĬ7Ӷċ
ҽɸɧéӶώ‚ɾБҘϼӶ ѩșӶĭ̔ҰˣӶĒҾƔǢеӶжΥӶ̰ωΦӶ˗»Ӷ ŊȚӶĮҙҚǬˤВӶ˥ͬʟțǭӶ˂ΧӶś8į8ӶČΨҿȜЅɨзӶѪқӲӶѫȝӦӶ Ͻș̌ӶE'O`и˦+<̱Ӷ̡ʘΩЄC˧ͭӶӶǮӶ-6Ӷ ŋӶŒ¼İӶ čӀɣǕΐӶŭʪɩDžӧӶҁӶ˃ƉӶvϿʶhΑ̼ӨӶ

ƠɛӶ
ʊӶѬ ГӶ̠˨`ǯү©Ӷ̯Ϊӑ ɄʫUӶϡȞʦɅȁӶйwӶϏ„ΫӋLӳӶѭȟӶıƪ˩ДӶӒ˪ѮӶŮǰDŽј˫
rƎӶˬsʝΜк˭άͮӶ ƾůҹӶ_ӶӓӴ›nDzӶϢȠ ƏӶˆҵɿӶƙ'Ӷ͉ѿέȆ½Ӷ ʼnÐȡӶġŰˮήͯƐӶIJɔҷлөӶăҜdža̲Ӷű̓ӶҌɆMӶмӶ ϐϣʃФҶӶѯȢӶijŲҝ̐Е5ӶGœнӶ˄ӶĴAҞȀ0ӶӔ
Ҳ'ӶΞоӶǣ
/ɵ‘ȣӶӠѰҟ’Ӷп˅ӶųǼ̎҄ΝӶ̢ʙΘA˯€ЃӶ ñϹͰʬӶрӶpȤӶĉĖӶɍЈ
Ι( 5ӶZd£ӶҐȥӶʋӶϻ
uХVӶ̧ӶґbǚӶʡ
͊ӶѱȦӶĵƅdz˰ Ӷ ćίϤӶ ʅƑ/ ȧ²ӶΔӶĈó̳Ӷ?ʵɪӶȂ&ЂƼɟӶxͱӶ˱Ӂʀ˲ʷ҅ΰqӶŴʤWϥӶĶϑɢƵɰӶÑ : Ӷ˳ӶӕƽǟӶZȨӶϒϦαӂ˴ǽɠӶс˓Ӷ ķŵœǴcӶđ|Ӄɻt“ӶӖdѲӶ&ϙeʁӶβʌӶѳȩӶЖҠƶ̩ɕ̈́¬ӶĸD™ҡ˵ӶϓƤЗyЉИ¾Ӷ ŌȪӶĹƫȃӶĎγӄǘLJ”Ӷ ͗ƍҎsɐӶт]@уӶѴȫӪӶƷȬǵӶͲzӶ…ɖyϸӶʍӶѵSӶЩF̪ȭLjф9Ӷ íǜδϺͳʭӶхӶѶȮӶ̥͙͚Ӷù[eVʗӶεʎӶî ɗӶĺџζ΍ӶѷȯӶҢΖцӶ˶ʹӶˆȰӶĄúϧЙӶþž̴ljЊǥ
ЀӶ ĂчɱӶȱКќǴˇɜӶf͵ӶÒàáÛӶҊӶʏψ Ӷ ϝɘ˷҆NJœӫӶ
ͶӶŔƓӶô̜ӶĝǶ˸ϳ³Ӷg–ӶӗƄ‹Ӷ$lɓӶʢ,͋ӶŶƸ{ҮӶ ; âãÜӶѡͷ•Ӷ̿ȲӶĻŷңǷhӶĔӅǡǓ1ӶӘηҬӶ ͸-шӶǗzϛȳϨθ—UӶә˹•ˑӶĘȴӶŕΗщɝӶļ–ŸъʂӶ-͹Ӷ͌ŹћXЇӶϩX̵źͺʮӶ ыӶŖЦ" õ̝ӶÓÈM˺ΏӶ ōɶӶ Ӷ>ӶĠ"ӬӶÔ äåÝӶ͍͖Ӷʣ{͎ӶѸ)ӶĆĀª‰ӶûҤͻÿɽЁ0—ӶüɈt)…͂Ӷ ӰӶЛѠʯӶ“˒ьӶњ]ȵӶĽBžǸiӶ[ΒӶМэvϔɞӶϕϪӆ˻ȅʰӶƹŻI̭ʻҥΓӶ˼Ε
ΛƆюcͼӶ|ϫӶιяˈɲӶƧ НÕżêκNjӶλͽӶ ö͏ӶėÇƋӶƺȶǙҺȷӶ÷̞ӶĞӶ\̖ǹӶ¤ҋ}Ӷ͐Ҧnj*Ӷ˽;ʐ~ΚC˜+Ӷ=H}ҧӶ
ʚǍ˾̺ӶľƬ˿ӶǺŽ ̣ʱОӶ3̀ŽˉӶ ěoƒ́ǎӶJӵ¦ȸ͑̂̾ӶjͿӶѹ(ӶÖæßÍӶʞϬӶģӯӶѐμӶǻȹ̶ ӇϭӶ˖͒Ӷb΀ёνӶŗ¿ĿÀӶˊƜŠÁ¥Ӷ ĚӶžӶʖφ͓ëӶ × çèÞӶ ͘ɏ͛Ӷ2ξӶѺӶąāӶïoǞӶŀѝ̃΁ӶϮɤˋƥ̄ÚǝӶ҂ӶmǑ̮ӶʑӶŁſҨǿgӶǤ/ɋ϶҇ο΂ӶƚNӶ ўRNӶѻDђӶѼɷӶ ӚƦӶ̷̅Ř̸ȺӶϖІЧəӶπʒӶʥ›ϯȻӶǏρϗȼϵ҈ς΃ӶϰʲƞȄ+ʳӶøj΋ӶĜƊ̍ Ӷ ŎȽӶ­ƀ͔̆ȾϱӶýː̒ȿʓӶσʔӶð̹)ǖӶł2Ʃ̇΄Ӷ ѽҩʹӶҀѓӶѾɀӶřÂŃÃӶď
ɼɉє«ПӶˌ,ϞӶ€ʕӶYӈɫҏ ӭӶH"̤΅ʴӶńƭkӶ%xχϘɳƁ̓
ΆӶӛ!‰Ӷ ҳ҉ǐӶƻ̕#ҪˆJӶŅұӶƨ̈РƛǒɃӶ’.Ӷ*ɁӶŚņÄӶĐτӉɂΟǔΊ‘ӶυuӶˍ̉ Ӷ͕ƂɴӶӜ#СӶ$.·ѕϷӮӶі.ӶŇƮ̗^Ӷ ΈE1̊Ό! Ӷ̟ɌϾТÅӶ







Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 14 of 18





 

੔੝ ੓ ॥঒çÇ੝Ėn੝ই੝ùࣖࣴÜ੝tĐ੝ ˊ@9ϴәy੝Ƞ Ə੝ ȆǦȇȪ੝  Đ੝ŎÝ੝٧Ļࣶå੝Ğթ੝eˏS‹٨T੝η੝˥্͜Yó੝û‫ވ‬ßʨ‫־‬ԫФލ੝€‫͝׹‬स੝ֿߪӚࣗ੝ϵ«-‫ڽ‬੝ۛ੝২੝Üսp࢟੝हr੝‫ڑ‬nॗÝࡢ»ʼn੝ ੝ Į੝ťӝ੝‫ऻ>;ܢ‬੝ħτ੝٪@੝ਘό੝ Ś‫ॸڗ‬੝#ӛ੝˦ৠ‫ڍ‬੝ऺ:੝ ‫׀‬ӜŌ੝؏ԥ੝%;੝‫׺‬ßăĨ੝৫੝;‫މ‬੝٩‫਀ފ‬ц۸‫ב‬঑ׁ੝ď˒͞ŠÆ͟੝Ƶ ƶ  ֏ ੝ਁՆ੝ঠD϶eԖ੝ࡊ iϔ9߀؎٫ࠠ੝ਙ`įä੝…Ӟ੝˧†.‫}ڎ‬੝řԷà੝n
Ŀ੝ࠡࡋਂ٬Ѡ‫ׂދ٭‬੝৬੝ࠫৡлŢ੝İ੝ˆՇ੝ ਃ‫׃ٮ‬vıu৭ۜ ਺੝ਚ‫ॹٯ‬੝ࡌՑ
‫ޱ‬ļã੝ŏ੝़ٰ੝ ˨o‫ܣ‬ӟঔé੝ʼn‫਻ ׻‬੝Y‫ڏ‬ƙ੝‫਼ީ«ܤ‬੝ʴ‫ܥٱ‬Ռ੝Ŋ‫׼‬Ӡ਽੝ѹÆޫŲƒLJ੝ ʏऽ੝਩~੝‫ ڸ‬৮ा੝ ਄ࢣ੝"‫߫۝‬ਛ੝‫ޮڒ‬੝¹߬ܰ ‫׎‬Ʒ੝ Ɉ
ॺ੝ɲ›ʐ੝ΪY੝ɕʔ੝wԸ࣪ģ޻ ੝,‫ڊ‬#ԗ੝Ϋ੝ޯ.3ਅ2Ç৛΂ ੝ ΘԘ੝˄*Ãθ੝Sž‘˺¬੊Ϸ੝ࣨ੝+੝ࣘࠢԊ‫ښ‬,੝ ½΀"ӡ੝‫ک‬੝Ś‫ؘ‬Х‫׽‬੝őòÐ੝˩͠ড়‫ڱ‬੝ਜԼԅ੝০Ц:ġࠧу͡এŧ0Ƹ੝ ̇Ӣ੝ɖʕ੝άÈ੝ॻӣ੝ɳG۞੝ϸ΋੝³Ӥæ ੝ࠣࡶࣙৎࢀׄ੝ʵŸЧ੝ ˪৚X‫"ٲ‬੝֐ࡍ੝ਾ]͢ࡎ?੝ժuİ੝!޼~Ľ2u‫ތ‬੝੝ॡ੝੝ΐƣ˻*ੋϹƹ੝ ȶ»т࡫‫ׅڪ‬੝ि߭੝ॼÒ੝֑޺ӥı੝ϺӦ­ѡ੝߮ի੝Ȼɗ੝ Jय़ঐ߯Ƿǹ੝‫ۯ‬Ƥ˼ͣੌ´੝‫ܦ‬έQ‫׆‬ԙ੝‫ލ‬Ăۭ੝ լ੝ɉ‫ގٳ‬੝ʹ‫ޏٴ‬ųࣚ੝։ШՍ੝śÛ7੝Ɋ‫ސ‬੝۲ͤѢù‫ޑ‬੝̜̝੝‫ړ‬7੝J৏ζ੝ήѣ੝ίਿ੝ ՖàެĻӧ੝vਆԹ੝Ŭǰ ƐǡǢǣ੝îPÈ੝Bğ੝ϻӨ੝λࠤࡏvŖԚ੝ϼੀ੝®۟Ž˽੍ͥ¶”੝ ȼƥ˾ͦ੎µ੝‫ܧ‬Ġŗá੝ी ੝ʶ߰‫ޒ‬Z ੝‫ޓ‬੝š ȡȢȒ੝ु߱੝ ਝ߲ࢁ੝ਞ‫ॽٵ‬੝ʰÉ੝΅ƦɴͧਟਠϜƑ੝ΰঘDZф੝‫ܨٶ‬Ħ߳࢜­‫ूޔ‬੝ ͨ۠Ƨː*‹öÉͩ੝ֆ‫ט‬੝੘੝Ͻύ੝ࣛ‫ګ‬й੝´ԡ ੝*࢐ńЬƘ‫ڌ‬੝ Ǻ੝ ॾÔ੝ࣜৣԺ੝ėê੝DzȣȤȓƒ੝ ¯ۡƨ˿PŢŠ)Ͼ੝yөণ࢈ԛ੝ृߴ੝'ͪ৐Ѥ੝ɀϿ‫ٷ‬Sƺ੝ ̀‫׾‬Þ੝˫ϗѥ‫ࣝٸ‬੝¼;‫ޕ‬ŋ‫ޖٹ‬৑D}ۢੁ੝ࡐӪ֟ࣞԜ੝ॿâ੝


α੝Còè੝ɘ۳Ŵࣟ੝xԳ৒Վঢ੝Cߵ੝ॠ‫ھ‬੝ȫĚ੝ā́੉‫ژ‬µ Ɠ੝|ॄक़ú‫ׇޗ‬Ɣ੝‫ڬ‬੝ॅ‫ؖ‬੝ਪĬZࣩ੝߶խ੝ު੝ ɶʑ੝ΎԬज़੝ ঀϕ੝Ε੒ ̂ͫ੏Ѐ੝ਡώ੝Njnj੝‫‡ ڹ‬Ľॆ੝¯੝ࠥ߷߸ࡑ੝‫ޘͬܩ‬੝ś‫׿‬੝ ۣq࣠%੝ ñ ~੝ ‫׈‬ƻ੝ ʅ੝Ѧ߹ш੝
 ‫ڿ‬ǍĞਢ੝ͭ‫׉ ޚٺੈޙ‬੝ƼLjlj੝

̈ӫ੝֒ࢇԄ࡙੝Ыãյࠄծ੝ȷ ۤԋ੝ˬॖ°„‫ޛٻ‬੝Ϳă࣡ߺ੝¼ ेԝ੝ै‫؀‬Ӭ੝Օͮćwӭ੝qկ੝˅ ñΚäѧ੝ʢ®7dzͯ‫ۥ‬੝ʫΖշ•੝ ʪ±ā‫ڐ‬նͰ੝‫}ڕ‬੝ɋ‫ޜټ‬੝ʺ ŵ࣢੝²įpঁԻ‫ޝٽ‬Ʃ‫ۦ‬+ਣ੝ͱ‫ޞ‬Ѩ੝β੝ú‫ޟͲ࢛ࠦܭ‬ł੝և‫׊‬ঢ়࡟Ӯ੝‫ްڔ‬੝ͳۧƪˑTŠ ΁ƽ੝ ̉ӯ੝̖ƾ˭ ƿ੝ ɹ:ŗՂԭŋ੝ςՏ@੝ʯ۹ո੝ࡒǴ੝ংå੝̗޷AԞ੝ˮŌ¦ōՐ੝‫ޠپ‬੝š ȥȦȐǀ੝ ʬT‫ۮ‬ûչ੝‫؁‬+Ѱ੝ЁæӰ‫ޡ‬੝ࣣ0đॉԃޭ½ԟ੝ চ੝ӱʹ€‫؂‬੝ ‫ڭ‬੝
¶ੂ੝আ੝ʦĢ࡬ι¬7੝ɻਇՃԮ੝֓ࡓ੝‫ؙࣤ‬੝ࡗࠅ]੝‫ޢٿ‬੝N੝ЇąЂ‫׋ިڋ‬੝‫ ڀ‬੝ŸࠆĮZγǁ੝ Ⱥ੝͵੝ĭՓfC ƕ੝ ʷਖ਼Щ੝ ̚NJ˯੝‫ז‬Ԣ੝#:੝Ӳਬō࡞Όӳ੝‫ڜ؃‬੝ۨ੝ʣğ޸δ”੝ ̊]੝ʤ߻࡜.κQ޿੝ॊԯ੝IJӴो৓ࢉӵѩ੝ ؄‫ܪ‬੝ौt੝˰Ͷ৔Ѻ੝Ɂ‫΄ځ‬੝ ʝ੝॓‫؍‬Ӷ੝
!‫ޣڂ‬ü‫ޤ‬੝հ੝Ŏ؅ӷ੝ə۴੝rրкࡘƖ੝%؆ ੝'ͷ‡Ѫ‫"ڃ‬੝Ŷũ߼৕‫्ד‬੝ վŷ੝ؐӸ੝ʧࠇIJѲεࣥ੝֔ࡔ੝ŏ؇ӹ੝ࡕӺॎ৖ࢊ੝߽ձ੝ʭ͸üպ’੝ ȸW¾࡝‫׌ڮ‬੝
੝ঃâ੝ɚʖ੝ġցWá࡚੝ਤç‫ޥ‬੝ʮ+ղO੝ࣵЃļਗ਼ৗЪđC۰Ŝ੝͹࢑ਈ੝Є੝ ˱৘.‫ڄ‬੝ȹ࡛Έ‫΃څ‬੝؈ӻ੝ਥϏ੝‫^ܫ‬ॕ੝Ѕ੃੝ ॏ੝۩ԇ॔੝߾ ަӼ੝‫ܬچ‬Ħ ࢝ƗŐ੝  ߿ւѫʆʒ ǂ੝ ۱؉ͺĂ‫ڇ‬ջ੝ǵǶǤਦ੝ਧࠀࢂࣦ੝֕ࡖ੝ͻ੝˓੝‫ࢃ੆ڈ‬؊‘‫ڙ۽‬ਜ਼੝ˈɺˉ੝°mѬ੝ ঝ±ਉѭࣧ੝ͼmѮ੝ĢħΆ#ч੝֚èӽ۪੄ǃ੝

̌੝ɼӾࡨ۫੝ɛģŕ޾ੜh੝ ࠁճ੝঄ӿ੝̘DŽ'Dž੝̃ࡱ‡ࢤ੝ɤ^!φ԰ॐ੝ŐéֈԀѯ੝ͽ॑੝Ŋ؋^੝ʥৢ੅੝ȈȎdž੝ȉǧȊ੝ ،ρ‫׍‬੝;³ࠂ৙॒੝%ؑԁ੝۬Ή‫ۀ‬੝ࠃմ੝˲Ϙ੝¾ĠĨԽख़‫ާږ‬੝ਨ‫ډ‬অ੝őؒԂ੝̙“˳•Ȭ੝




 
!  "   # ##  ##

ȑȏȧ੝

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 15 of 18

̇ʤȅўQџ࠼)࠼͉ؒ࠼ȻĜz‫࠼ۊܚ‬Ն‫ްب‬ć‫ݤ‬ŭѠ࠼)ѡ3ܷѢT࠼ӵߦƩࠤߎÌ‫ۋ‬ƪ࠼‫ނ‬գִ͊‫࠼ݥ‬ŢӶՇȯ՞Ӌŏ࠼½ۖÎ࠼3٩‫΂࠼ݦ‬ՈĨ‫•࠼ܛ‬٪ę‫ޱ‬3࠹ѣɁȱѤƫʻ࠼±࠼֢࠼ ߧ@ĩĚ࠼P࠼ҳ޽Ĝĕࠑ࠼‫׏‬ү‫۝ټ‬Ğ࠼ų޲࠼aÃP޳ȫ࠼Ȇƹ࠼ֵԉը֣࠼ߨo࠼ā`ߏѥ࠼ʼ˒࠼ɆȎˮղ࠼ؓȼÑ࠼ߩѦ࠼&͋ߐl࠼‫ݧ‬٫࠼‫ܜ‬ѧѨĐ࠼ͥ3Ϭ࠼+è࠼r͌ߑJ࠼‫ݨ‬ĺ࠼ ȵ‫ݩ‬ń–έ›࠼ ́࠼ߒ̗࠼Ӗ̞ή࠼ ࠒ޴࠼ؔѩšc!ϭƽ͍šøժ࠼Ѫߺ¼zĽ֤ҒܲW࠼̈ѫ࠼ҵ࠼Չ‫ܝ‬Ƭ࠼ǣࠟճȇ࠼ ‫ܞ‬٬‫א‬Ѭ࠼‫ڎ‬ѭۜզ4Ϯƭ࠼ ʽ֭՚ί࠼˯ѮաƸϯȬ‫࠼ܟ‬ ӷ¼ߓѯ࠼½ӗѰåϰ࠼֥࠼ʾ۠ì࠼ÖK)v¾‫࠼ؕ٭‬Ҫ࠼@࠼‫ב‬À‫ג@(࠼ٻ‬nÖ࠼ʳ޺֦͎ࠓϱuȰĈƮ࠼ߪý‫࠼ٮ‬Ȉ‫ٯ࠼ܠ‬şۛȳٰŪ֧ܳࠔ࠼‫ߔؖ‬ƎǏߕѱΰ࠼Պ‫࠼ؗ‬ ȽŽʞ࠼ ҫ࠼ʿǚǛŒɀ࠼B|ϲ࠼ÿć‫࠼ܡ‬ϳK‫ܢ‬Ջӌ‫ݾ͏ؘ‬՛ĺ‫߫࠼ؙ‬Ĉ֮࠼΃J࠼‫ڏ‬ū΄0ĉα࠼߬Ռ‫&ݪ‬Č‫࠼ؚ‬ӸJ࠼‫؛‬Ѳ߻‫ ࠼ݫ‬ʟ ˓ ࠼Ôcࠕˆœ࠼̂rѳࠖ࠼σA‫ד‬Þ࠼Ұ‫͐ˊیٽ‬Q×࠼ ¢Ǥ࠼޵‫ ࠼ܣ‬Ȕ࠼+åѴմ‫¿࠼ܤ‬Ӎ࠼a‫ج‬ϴ࠼ǑţՍGƯ࠼ 5đͧࠗư࠼+Ý࠼‫ݬ‬L3չ࠼߭β࠼őӹ‫ٱ‬9֨j࠼ ó࠼ұ‫پ‬Ņ߸dۙϵ࠼߮ĉ‫ݿ‬ԅ࠼Ӻѵ࠼϶ 6Ąó۟޾ƀְ֯‫࠼ٲ‬ À(h࠼`࠼ҷѶoƱγ࠼‫ۍٳ‬Õo‫࠼ێ‬bӎ¿()࠼ȿ‫†ރ‬Lj࠼ʴ$ž͑࠘×č‫̘࠼؜‬.࠼@‰յ ϷƲ࠼߯LA‫࠼ݭ‬ϸ࠼࠙4$࠼ӻɂߖѷ࠼‫࠼؝‬ӼĠɉ࠼ɜæÍ͒9‫ܥ‬Ѹ࠼ Ԋѹࠚ࠼Ïâۣ»Ċ‫ر‬yࠛ࠼Đ‫د‬4+࠼߰Âʲˀ࠼߱ ࠼ӽ͓ߗn࠼5|࠼Ԇ՜‫ה‬Ƴ࠼Ã.D͔޶Őç࠼+Ѻ࠼‫ܦ‬þd†-Ð࠼ċ‫߲࠼)͕࠼ݮ‬è࠼‫ݯ‬ŅĎѻi࠼‫࠼ٴݰ‬δ(–դĨÍç࠼ &ß‫ ࠼ו‬ŤMɃ‘࠼ŞM-Ŵ࠼ӏÿ‫࠼ݲ࠼ݱ‬լČ ࠼$)lj࠼̃Ӿá࠼ͦ(߳ѼQ࠼΅͖εն࠼ߴAܴƴ࠼‫ٵ‬4ֶýբǒ|Ӑ࠼‫؞‬ѽߵNJ࠼ ˃\࠼ɝɾ\ǜȝ̒̆ʀ˟ȭ࠼ɸ࠼ࠜP9࠼ΆζěčéŬȶ࠼ǔ&͗Ɋ࠼ ˄࠼ɖ̏ʈʠ࠼ʡɗ̐¯ɿ\Nj࠼ˋX Ɠ࠼LĊ‫ز‬đ࠼şĀ͘࠼‫ݳ‬e߼.‫࠼ܧ‬D‫ۏ‬ѾϹyՎ‫ࠝݴ‬Ƶ࠼5‫ ࠼ې‬ĚM࠺‫ۑ‬ѿ࠼Ď6࠼͙(‫ٶ‬ƁÂҀł࠼‫ז‬ηȉůҁ࠼+҂࠼cۚς࠼ĩ4‫࠼ݵ‬ ·K՝‫؟‬ӑ࠼֩ϺV࠼

˰Ž͚œ“‫࠼ܨ‬Ҭ࠼ˁõÄ࠼̑X X࠼ʣŦšθֱֲñÊİικ࠼ɫ€‫ח‬Ğ‫'ؠ‬Šࠞƍ࠼ʢ‫‡҃ߘء‬uò͛RՏ€‫࠼ܩآ‬Ր‫أ‬Š"࠼ɬĪ‫҄ؤ‬λ‫ݶ‬vĦ‡࠼ɞ҅š߶μɲ࠼ ̄҆ŀŃ‫ٷ‬ŃvŐ‫!͜࠼ט‬ϻ࠼˱͝hՑ࠼©€Ůνľ!‫˔࠼“҇י‬îҮՠξՒ͞ę‰࠼ §‫ހ‬ԇ࠼r ࠼ʉɡª࠼]‫ة‬ϼ࠼M҈࠼ɭ̟ə࠼ӿ¾ߙê࠼ċ‫ذ‬Ȳ۞‫ל‬ϊЁ࠼‘Ԁ҉࠼ɮ5ğĠՓŢ֪ω ŏ࠼‫ބ‬էnj͟‫ ࠼ݷ‬ţԁ‫ކ‬Ŵ࠼‫ےإ‬Î࠼Ť‫ۓ‬.͠޻‫ت‬Ӓ࠼‫ݸ‬öæ࠼˲AŪЂ՟࠼ Ք‫޷Œܪ‬Ҋ࠼‫ܫ‬ë‫ܸ޿ئ‬ě;Ǎ࠼ ǟοÏPۗЀ‫ך‬ӓ࠼Ȋǥ࠼āҔ࠼ˌ‫•ٸ‬ҕΈҋ‫ ࠼۔‬ȋȞƶ࠼ȕǦǧȖ࠼¨ɟ¬࠼‫ە‬ê‫ܵثڐܬ‬ìƷ࠼þҌ࠼ʍȌ࠼e‫ح‬Ͻ࠼ɯ¬ɘ࠼Ā͡ůҍ࠼ ǐȮőŽʶΉՕ‫&ܭ‬ÌG࠼͢࠼߷5†ոե‫خ‬ô࠼ôń‫޸ٹ‬Ľ࠼¢ž࠼֫‫ٺ‬շ࠼ďĪ‫ݺ࠼ݹ‬ԂK࠼±d࠻ȍϾՖ࠼ ď‫޹ܯܮ‬Ҏǎ࠼ ̅ԃ.࠼ʊɠҭ࠼Ҳ‫ٿ‬łğéi࠼ͣ࠼ܰ‫ږ‬ūeɱ࠼ͤ࠼‫ݻ‬Ԅҏ࠼ ̙B6Ԉ‫כ‬Ӕֳ˕‫࠼ا‬ʋ՗Ґ֬Ͽ࠼­ҴπJ <——<<—<<ŵ࠼ ‫࠼ݼ‬՘īߚë6‫ݽ‬ՙӕBſґ࠼‫࠼ܱ޼ۘށ‬uܶȷ9ρ࠼Bīτy=====ŵ࠼




D -*D +4  9D

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 16 of 18

ೈ㗹䔌ᯝ䏤ᾶ㩎Ŗ䞊ᔧ⾆⏮䞊䂑⏘ᶴ䞊ౣ૘ೞ䞊㍙㍚ᦇ䞊i⏈ᾢ䞊உ೪હ䞊㮀◝⬺⭾䞊◞ᐊ䎜᭳䞊㕞㍆Ⱨ䘤䞊৒‫ם‬䞊⯛⡜⻛☱㶭Ὰᬽ䞊䄲㙢᫹ṝ㠅δ‫מ‬٫㩏ͷᬫ⨌ぁ䞂䞊㏂↘䞊㼻┣Ო䞊ྙᒤ⾇⨞⨟䞊 ಐ㙣䎞ᵽ㍇䌣㍛ᣄㄩⲺÊ㴵䞊㸅❷២ȇ䞊㶬㏁䞊⭁Ȟ࢞㣓㑃㩘⨧㬀㷆䞊ᣅ⵫ẗ⻙ᾣ㍈㼺㬀Ͳ䞊ഷ㍏䞊෶⏤ᣆ䞊ຈᚤ㼶㙤ᔨᵘȈ䞊 ۹Ŧ䞊ٜУоٝ䞊ᣓ⮗㒉㬀᮵ᬬ䞊⏐ᲅኬ㠅⨨⿉⍨˪䞊ெ⢢㩉᰷ᣇ䀊ᾷ㠊䞊ฮ䌘᥍ග⭖᥎㦰䞊 㲚⵬቙㵽᳠ᨩࡐ䞊 ඛ↚‫ע‬䞊┴ᅞၱᮩ䞊㙥㍉᭺䞊㚸㩐ᬻ⨍⽎⛡ヸᅗ㦩䕘䞊⿠㏯䂒ᾤ䞊㏁ⅉᘹᆪ䌙㵺⛡㏁㍆Ŧ䞊✳㵺䞊⢢㴶䞊䀻ⓦቲȉ䞊ᒁ㵺䞊䂓◟⟚㴷䞊㞊㙷⚝㍊㵺䞊㶗⎤᥏㩊䂔䞊ᒭ㦩ᥐ䞊⾈㐎Ȋᥑ䞊㞚䄾᭳㬹㺖☲㏁「㬱䞊 㵼㩚ɹᓳ»䞊ᄈ㍋㬆䓳ᾥ㟖㬆Ŧ䞊঍⵳⵴ᬭ䞊‫ן‬䞊䒋㏺䌛⬺᧩䞊ᗹਥ䌚㵼☥㙦㍌䞊ㄹ≬ᒶ⾉㴸ࢗ ‫ڐ‬䌛⹲㞁⨎⾱≖䞊䂕㙧䞊ᘆ㏁ゕᬮ䌛㬗ӈ㙨㉥㭟䞊ᔍ᳓↝㙺㩋ᱳ䞊䑇᭳䞊⬡㍐㏯䑁䞊ᅭ䞊⵭㙩㺀䞊 ⾊㙪㥋ᾥɯ䞊 ઺䞊ᬯ㏉ᙍ䌜⼣᳅㇄㶗䞊Ⱨ㑅ᝋᄹ㵼Ᾰᦓ䞊ᖩ䕗䞊㺖◮ᰜ䞊ඎ㙸⚋〒㶗䞊೗〠㟂䌝⨔㩗䕦䞊໻㵼ᅑ⇘䞊ᣔ㎴⾰∐͹㬉䞊㻒◠ᒥ‫ܘ‬䞊㵺◡ᾦ䞊౜ே⮟Ê㮀䞊ၥᒸ㵏⏃⡁࢜⟫≙㼄㏁⾱䞊౤☦᱈⵮ᬰ䞊 ๏↘∌ᘹ䃰࢟䞊⨏㴹䞊㴺㷝⡘ⰰ⬺䞊☫⿉䞊㼄⎝ᷲ䞊ᯝᆪ㡞⮗䕙䞊㬣㺖ᐄ≗ᾬ㬣䞊㏁⨐䞊℄㙻ᘹ䌞㬆⨑ヌ⍌䞊㎿㙫䞊ᣕ◫ᯍ㬈䄐䞊⢢⿠䍼ᣈฯ⨒⍩ᄸ㷹☦㕵㍍㴻ͳ䞊 ѭҜ‫ף‬䞊ᅞ⾰䞊઻䆚⊺䄲㴼䂖䞊‫کנ‬ȋ䞊ٞЈпٟŒ䞊 ᣌ㙹ⷄ⸏䌤㍜⛭ᡚᆭ㺖☱㒐⾱Ȃ䞊ᄹ䞊₆⨑᰻⬺ᦂ䞊㏯↛↜⨣ᠻ‒䞊ᒦ⍪ᾧㄡ㻃䞊㴽㵺ლ㵺ᳳᬱ䞊Җᔴᅞ㶅䞊䛋䚡䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚢䚷䞊 

㼄⏣ዓ㷷䞊㴾ዓ⾑‑䞊᫧㐐ᠻ䌟ⷃὨ⾋Ȃ䞊㶎◬ᾨ䞊ၟγ㮪⎯⢳ͺ㍟⍫㺀㏁㍎䞊ఱ☦ᾩⰺᦎ䞊ຉ䞃∉ᝋं䞊


ᒧ᝗⬠ͻ〒㕵䒾⯛ᣖᣗ⣟≰Ოᦜ䞊⨓㍏䞊◡⢢㴿䞊 ɡ Ȍᾪ㵀䌥⾒㙧㌮䕗䞊㿬ⓦ∗䞊㿎⎦਄䞊䅇〒ᬲᚩ㟖㬺㹸ᒵゕ᧺✳࢛‫ק‬⍬䞊㙬↙䞊㶗⎦⨤㴱䞊➝㵁㮀䌠ᾫ䞊⡁㮀䞊Ⳍ⡘⾌❺䂗ᙑᣉ䞊ᒨ㵂䞊䔍Მ⬺⯔ʹ䞊 ၦ⛡䀻⓪䞊㟐ᾬ⍆ᒶ㟐᪫䞊㺖㏁䞊㿬┡䄗䞊㵃㞂᱒ᙍ☦䞊∊ ᾭ䞊㞴䌛᱒㯩䂟⣹㏎⿩䞊㏎′䞊◢Ⴭ䏄᳌䞊䒋ᮩ䞊㵄ᰜᮩ⿊䞊㷃⏤ᴧ䞊ྚᒩ䇷ᬳ⨔䞊⾍䂘ᮩ⬺⨕⛭⍭ᣙ㩔͵ᘹ᳠䞊㭘᯹㫷♦ᣘ᮵㬉䞊 㬋䌡㞃㞄㏎‫≬⾱⨖ץפ‬䞊㷕Ᾱ㫥㙭㡀䞊≗㩖㙮䌢㞅㵅ƺ䞊ೣ䞊㻻◣⨗⾱⬢䞊䂙⎯ᯓ䞊㩌Ὠᘹ㙯㩍ᦜ䞊➣㬎䞊⿉㙯㷕䞊ᘹ⨘ᣊᅑ㟖䞊ლ㼺䞊ᒪ⨙ⱟ䞊㙰㍐䞊䂠⎯ᆪ㶝ʓ䞊 ຊ㕵ȝ⵵ඝ䞊䂚◤ᾮ䞊౥ଁ⬽䞊ᒫ⿠᫧䞊୘ശઽ䞊㠐ᲄᘹ㑅≙〒⛡‫ۀ‬ᾯᢌ‫ר‬䞊㺖◥ᷧ䞊㞆㏯㬏㱈☱ᖩ⨚ⵯ⚁䂢䘧䞊㶗⎤ᒬ㵼䞊☭〒᪶❑䏌հ‫צ‬j䌛ᅭ⬺㮀䞊ᣋ㙦⾰㍡ᾰᣌ㵻᯹ᦓ䞊k㙱䞊㶫࢝⨠᯷䞊ྛ㩑㍝᧤⟐䞊 ಑㙲䐯ᾱ㫟ᰞ㍑䂛䞊⸙㍒䘥䞊ᗛᮕ䞊㞇㥤㐁䎄⨛ᩐ⨥㍜⍮䞊㭒䌈㛤㞈㑹㫮䞊䂜㏁䞊㶬ᥒ㦰ͼ㐷㩘⨩㮀⬯ྜྷͶ䞊

       ྜ㐮䞊㵺⏃ᮕ㟔ᮚ䞊✱㭦䞊ᘹ᱈㠅䂡ᒴ⨫㍓⵰䕦䞊ᒎ䞊⍯㙳㑭᬴Ŧ䞊⋇㏁㙴ৼ⬺䞊ឪ┡ᒯㄡᚤᶴ䞊㵺⏶ვ㵼䞊㶭⎝ᰜ㟒᭿䞊 ऋ㩓ᾲ䞊㱇䕏⸋䙰ᅤ㸣◦ь䙟ᵘ㩕㬆䞊㙵㠅䞊Ẩ䕌ᣚ㟴ᣍ⾎‫ס‬㵆㷕㵎ȍ䞊 㵇䕰⾓㝹ᒭ㸷⎦⦔䙒Ἇ㟔㮀䞊㞉㕋㱨㵈⛡ᗜ⬺䕰䞊↞㙻৓䞊ᒮ⵱Ȣ໘ლĚ❫ᨂᒯ䞊䓷☲䄡〠䞊㷆⏈ᯥ䞊㮀ếᘹ䄹㩙⨪㹝䘦䞊㮣ᶾ㩒➣ᙈế㮀˾䞊 ᄺ⬼㮛㏁䞊㍔㐸㼻ᾳᬵ䞊㶎⒟ᒰ࢘䞊 ઼ᗝ॰䞊ႀ䆣ᗝऊ䕗᧩ᄮ◧䞊㵉ᄫ☯ᦎ䞊ⓦᾴý㵊䞊ᘢ㙶㍕∋ᬶᲄグ䂝䞊ᣎ◨ᒱ㷽䞊ᆓ⵲ɜ໙ᆓě✳ᬷᒲ䞊⾏䅼㵋࢙䞊◩ᅞ䎲᾵䞊ᣏ㙰㍖㾃ᒷᣐ㷷䞊ឩᣑ㍗৔⨡⨜㍘⬺䕦䞊䓷јl◪䞊༌ᄧ䄾ᬸ♎㵌䞊 ⾐䞊㶭◯Ḯ䞊ဲ㍠⨦㽏ᮕᦜ䞊໺㿓ᅜ㼺ᮟ㵍䞊ሰ〒৽⵮䞊m͸◭ᅚ䂞䞊ᒳ⬼ȱ ໚ᅞÔ ♥ᬹᒴ䞊ᅞ㍏ᬺ䞊ဳ㬣ᒹ⻛ჽ䞊೉⨝⿠䞊෦ᒦᬼ⨢ㄝ䞊ঙᙨ䞊㛇ლ㥸㼶➸ᣒ䅚⮠٠㥸࢚䘧ɢ 㶗㍞ᜠ䕘䞊  

: BC DD

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 17 of 18

⨬㍢䏯᭫㬋䂣䞊㵐❳⍸㎨℻♙ᘹᐧ㍣㶎䞊Ά⾰ᾖ㟓⍰䖫䞊⛡㍤䞊ᣛ䈩⬺䂤⨭㍥䂥⨮㙼⍰䞊䓲⎷ጫ䂦䞊ાᗞ䌦䞊ႁ䇋ᗇჍ䘊৾ⶄᄆ⎷䞊ᛓ㙽⨯⯁ᰔᬾ䞊≰㎯㘙ᬿ䞊㟏ᰲ⵶ࢨ⩈㸭⨰㙾ㆽ㬑␲☫㚲㵑䞊 䒜⨱㸭⎭䞊ྞᒺ䆘ᦂ♌㵒䞊㎶↟䞊Ⴙ⵽⮲䞊㬉㷟Ȏ⾔᥺〽⍱䞊̫ ̍ ˭ ಘ 䞊 ᭞䞊㬁ᅊ♆᪊䞊┌⡙〽䞊෻ᄹᧄ⟦⾱䞊ҥ㬔䞊䐰Ო㟏䗲䞊㛊⵷ᙑⶂྣᲝᧀ䞊䔎␯Ოん䞊༡ᄋ䄯ᭀ⦨㬁䞊⣸㍦䞊㷳◰ᯎ䞊 ⷤ⨲⬺⚓䂰Ⴚ㩭䕞Ř䞊㼭◽㑛㫾ᷠ䞊㵐䌧ᣜᙍᮺ㭎㮌↲䌹⬺䞊☱㙿䞊ᗟ䌩㵦⨳㍧ᮎ㭙㱛䞊ጕ⾰ᦔ䞊㸭⑍㑛㭯ᯔ䞊ᣝ⭀㐻㵓ᯓ䞊㶎㑇 㩫;☇Ế䞊㟏㒾䘨ᅊⰺ䞊⁾ᓕⷶ♂Ⳁ䘩䞊෷㏁䞊⬹Ო㍨ᦂ䞊ጼᙈ䂰⣸䐩ᾼ䞊 㬫䌨㜄㛃㑇㟏䂯䞊㷚㏁䞊⑍♌㵓䞊ᘹድ䆙㬋–ʩ䞊 ೊᲝ䞊㬁ᄹ☱ᦂ䞊ᔎ⨴㩛ɸ䞊෽ᓓᦰ⛚ん䞊ሄᛩ㸭♌䎊ᯠ⵸䘪䞊㮪Ცᰔ⬣㭎䞊㎹䌩䁴䞊⨵ᒻίᘫ◱䞊㠳ᯜ⮯ᒼ㸭⨶㒾㍩㵔◲⨷㜄㭨䞊 ๖䂧⏉᱊㟓䞊୘၆Ⴌ䞊ሄ㎁᪚䞊శଷസ䞊㘀↮ⶉⶊᙍ☧ᑮ⵹㭎䞊ᰎᘹ◳㏁ᯓᭈ䞊䂨⎷ᯓ㬣ờ䞊㤪ᰕ⸆ᅆ㟏⫳㮌䞊♙㍣䞊㢩“៘ࢩ⩉䁔䞊ஊ䌪ん⌋㎄΀ɣ㵣㵕⨸㎹ㆽᅃn䞊㸭᱃㬖㸭❱ⷶ㏞㍪䖃䞊ʩ䞊 䛌 䛍䛎䛎䛏䞊㬥䂼ᄫ㷳ᰨ᨜ࢠ䞊 ၧ⎷჻⭁䞊䑻ᯓ䞊↭⛜㎃ᪿ䞊䁔㢞㏤䌫ᔎ⬺♌㊣⍲䞊ᄋᖉ㏞䄯㼕䞊෸⭀⣚Ო䞊ᣬᓒ㬋ᰕ㬣䞊䂩⎭‫׭׬‬䂪䞊䔏ᯓ䞊⬺᷵ᔂᰨ᦭䞊ᒽᔕ㏁䅇㷚䞊≀㏁⾕䞊 ౗ଶ೗ɮ䞊 ┌㚯⎭䞊䃆⏇ᯔ䞊෼㚌㬁䞊 ી㍽⍳ᮆⲨᱲ㬎䞊ᗳᓁ㬑ᵗ㬑䞊ᄆࢩ‫ש‬р䞊㬑㏞⾖᭝䞊㑇↠䞊㸭⏮᭝䞊ᗵᏜ㬨ᵵ·䞊‫׾‬㸭䞊䃇⎷ᱡ䞊ၨᅃ㭎⏮⩎⾸⌕䂨㗍た䞊↡♌ᰊ⮜᧬䞊຋⇣ᗵ῟Ϳ䞊◴ᐵ㮪䞊⬺㙾㔺⫟ῑᣯ䞊Ⴙ㸭ƪ䞊☫΁㈗䞊 䔐⑟⟦ᡲ◵䞊䗽㏞䌦䞊Ô㠘ᵑ䞊㬣Ị᭞⟦㍑⍴䞊༡ᒼ䅒ᭉ☫䞊ࢫ㍣㔕ん⩍࡝䕝䞊≡㏞⪡≡䞊㸭㏁䞊㛃ᮃ㑇㜏⭿ᲝŦ䞊☱㵖䞊㸭␋ᒾࢡ䞊☧㶌䞊∍䂫㬣䞊㬊㏁㫯䞊㚀 ⃩ Ⴝ䞊 䞊㞋ᅪ䂮㸭᾽㫛䞊㿨ᕈᅃ㽊䞊 䔑ᯓĜ䐱ṁ䞊㬣ᰔ䄑〒䞊⨹㍡䞊㺤ᯓ㎫㬊䞊㏤↢䞊ᦌ⥱㥊ῃᛓ䂨䞊㞌ᅊ䗰⸌ᰕ㍫㷦㭙䞊≁㚅⸙䞊䂬⎟㪛䞊༡ᐭ䅇ᭁ☧㭯Ƶ䞊䀎⑍—䞊༡ᒿ䌬ᭂ⠎䞊஋Ġ࿫ຌ䐲ᰕ⾗⾘ι㍬㸭Ê㬉䞊 ⭿㚁㍭≰㲔䂽Ⴤㆽ᧫☧㎂⍵䞊㬣䆘㚹㞌㚂㍮䞊↯㚏㢞䞊䍼ᴓ㢙䘲䞊↳䇋ㄒᦂᅪⷋ῜㊪㷚ᇕⱐ⚯㭯㸭䞊ၤᓀ⎭ᅉᖉ⚐䞊Ⴙ〽ᦂ䞊༻ᆿ⵷ᒼ⁾☧䞊ᣞ␡ᄫ㟏⩐㹼♌ᵗ㵗䞊ᅪ㍯㩨ⶃ䞊⸆㑇䐳ᯔⷮῠ⾱䂭㬋䞊 ᓁ㧾㏁䆱㍶ᦂ䞊䂮⎫᱃䞊䔒㏞㩜⵷ᦑş䞊䔓⎷⡊ᘅ⎭䞊⚯㍰䞊ᓂ䞊㭥᾽⾸㬋᱄䞊䖫㔰䌭䞊㵘᾿䃅ࢮ䞊㸭⑍ᮃ䞊⸼㐖⾴ᯔ䕞䞊⩒㬊䞊⍶㎯ѕт⌋䞊㸭㚃䞊↴䌺⾰ᭃᅊ⾙᭬㍱㸭ሄⶅ♒㵙䃈㬨䞊ʾႮͽğ‫ဴ׫‬䞊 䗭㏞䌮䞊䔔㏁䅇⭍ᧉ䞊ᔎ䄒䞊䍼Ო㫼䞊㵐䊬㩰㜨㟏☲㬅᭬᧓䞊♌⁙䞊㬣㏁⹉ᵑ䞊㐅 ⃤ 䞊♌㵾䞊᭄㎹⩵㵚ㄏĝ㺕䞊ᔕ⵺ᯓᾖᧉ䞊㏞䐳ᥓ㡈䞊⨺㍲㷦ᣟ䞊㸭῀㤌㩢㏁㍳㵛㸭䞊 㮖䌦㜄㝋㚍㢙㶙䞊ɯ ̜ ɱၩἴý䍮ᚠ䞊 䞊 ⎷ ᅪ᦭䞊ᒽ䞊ⲧ㎵㶎䞊㏁↣䞊㬅䈩㬑㞍☲ᙍ☧㑯⾰΂ȏ䞊◶ᣠ↰㚐㥑᭼䞊ྟ᷀㜄䂵ऄ⾕┌ᣡ㟏䞊⬺䞊അ䞊䔕⵸䅡ᣢ⏇䞊ၪ䄓䞊ਆ㎶ᡄ䆘ࢫㄏᣣ䌯㵿ᥜ䞊☷㎅ ㍴䞊 ㍣䄵⾚ᗠᲬ㟏䞊㏁↤䞊ᣮⶇ⩋ⶈ↪ᣤ㩝ᘉ㍨ࢢ䞊㜨ᓃ䙱ḫ㟏㬉Ŕ䞊ድ〽ᭅ䞊პ⍷ᓄ☧ズ䞊㍵Ï㬣䞊ᓅ䞊⭍㘥㿖䞊㏞ࢣ㬋ⷋ㏁⬤Ო䞊ጕ㍋ᦐ䞊㾏⵸䌰ࢤ䞊⨻㮖㳂䌱᭬㵥䞊⵻☈‫ڌ‬㸭䞊ᙗ㏁ⷤ῁䞊䇤㝉䞊ᓔ㩬᳢䞊 䔖◷㏁䞊⬧㎀㚄䓂㬀䞊ᐻᖶ㏁䊬㸭䞊㽊☈᮪䞊㜄᎘䘨ⷢῌ㍭㼭㬣ǂ䞊㏞⿷䞊䑁⎭㏁㬣ṁ䞊ᔹᮆ◸৕ᭆ⨼䞊ᅪ㠺ᯔ䞊䂲⪈ᙽ䞊㚹ᓆ䘳⾝ᱰㄦ㩞⪇䞊ᔧᴁ⾛⍸䞊㥶ࢭ⩏Ⴚ᫪ᛩš䞊Ⴙ㩟ᯔ䞊䂾☂ᯔ䘫䞊 ᗡᰔ⡙㎆⍹䞊ⷣጕ᫪᭞䞊㎹㍶䞊ᔹᭊ‫ת‬ᓇⱚ↥䞊㏞↦䞊䂲◹᭿䞊ᣥᾖた㼈㩲ᅪ⵼䞊⍺㐻䍼ᣦ⾠ⷶᛩㆽ㷷䞊㎵㢙䞊ዖ㩠ᮄ䞊䂯◹ῂ䘬䞊┌ῃ☱ゑ⌹䞊ⷤᅪិ‫׮‬ᣧ䞊ᗢ䕱䞊ᓈ䞊⬺㏞ᣨᄤ⬺䞊㚅↫‫ڪ‬ᚯ☧ყ⬳䞊 ㏾㢞䞊ፁ䞊㜄ớ㩩㬁㏾㍷ʩ䞊 ஗㍸䞊㩡ᗣῄ䞊㞎ᙽ㒫㜄⨽᭞䞊䔂⑐㏁䞊ሄ㥑ᣩ䞊⸆ሾ⬧⚐⿢⍻䞊䂿☃―䞊㜄ጨ䘴⾞῅㍨䁔㲔䞊⬥〝䌲䐻䞊䔗◺ᓉ䂰ÿ㰯䞊◻㍹㛡㜄ࢥ㍨⨾ㆽ⊫䞊㼈㑇䞊㶘⎟ῆ䞊 ⸌㚆㍨᮲䖫ਦ䞊 ⵽℣ 㶗⎷Ო䖫䞊ᦂ㏞䞊⫳た㗑䓛䞊䔘┌ᓊ㸭Ê㵑䞊⏉ᇁ㞏㞋ῇ㍑⩇ん⍼Ȑ䞊䑂④䖫䞊ᅙ㩢ᮄ䞊㸭⏉Ὲ䘭䞊⾜ᅊ⫰☰㍺⍽䞊㸍⎷ः䞊㜄ᐆ䘵䀗㈏䄩ⶋ෹ȑਧ䞊 ೟㵜䞊ഹ㸭䞊ჿ䞊 ⃤㏞㩞ⷣ䞊㏞↧䞊ᗤ⵾ᅪᘹ⬫⸚ᆿ♙⮡ਨ䞊 ஹ㏞䞊㶣◼ᯓ䘮䞊㩣ᮺᚯ㏞⎛⠎䙜Έ䞊㹇␋ᮑ䞊䂱Ὴ㟏㟏㏞㢩⟚㯴䂲䞊ྠ䌱㞐਩㏤㍻ਪ䞊 ྻ⎷Ή㡞ᮕÊ㴷䞊㸎⎷ῌ䞊⨿㰞㵤䅇ᶟ䞊㏞↨䞊ᇧ㥀ᣪ䞊䃀☄ᴒ䘯䞊 㟏῍⍾䄲⭮ᓋ䂍⩀ㆽ≡䞊䁆⏮ἴⷮ㬖῎⵿䐴᭭㵐䞊ᔆ䞊䑈ᰕဵ䞊ᅃ㬖䞊Ꮬ㡈῏䞊㶗⎭᱃䖄䞊ᦂ㗂☱⿄≴䞊㷦⎟ᾣ䞊ᧄ䅁᭴䞊ᣭ⭿⛜ⶀ⩁⍿ᯄ㈈ឤᙆ䞊㶿⑟ᐍ䂳䞊㸭⎭῝䕠䞊㓧䄰⎄★㶅䞊㸭㚇ɲ䞊 ౧ସ↩䞊௨ᯓᚯ䆳㷚♊䍼‖䞊િ㵝㬺☫㰞㷳ᓌ㍓㶘䞊஫⩂㩤Ὴᣫ㶗㘥㩥䞊຿ጩ㵞㞚䌳ᅗ⯚ᯔ䞊ஹä䞊િ⸆䌴ࢧɐ㚎䞊㷳ῐ㬋㶙⥂ℸ⩌ῑ᧮䞊ᓍ䀭䞊෺ࣟᅙ㼭䞊㵟Ⴚ⾟䞄䞊◽ῒሇࢪ⦨⿢⎀ࢦ䞊 ࿃㚈䞊᧫ዖ㸭᷹䞊೟䞊ᣫპ⾰å㸭䞊㮪㸭䃁䞊⒔᭽㟏᭴䞊Ꮸんᭇ䞊㶌ᯩ⬺⬺䞊䘯㑯䌵䞊㷦⏉ᅪ㶌䞊㸭◾㎵㵑᱓䞊   ⊘㏁䞊ᗥᆡᙍ⫰ş䞊㶌⏉ሡ㸭䞊䔙᱗䞊ᙍჄ〽䞊㜀㟏㎵䎆ΐ䞊䂴⑞ᐆ䂵䞊䃂␁᭳䞊 ྡፕ䌒ᨐ⧲䞊⩃㏤䕧ᐵⶆ䞊↬ᓖ㚒⩉⩄⬺䘰䞊✞㮪䞊䞅㚲ᓎ㎣㏁㩠✞⾸⎁䞊㶎Ო㦿㩪㐷㩮⩑㬅ⷢ̉䞊 ଵ䌶㶘䞊䃃☆῔㩦῕Ğ㬨䞊῞⾴㎶䆱⎂◿䞊㵠ⷢ䊉⬦ᮎ䞊䂶☀Ⴝ㻴䞊䔚ῖ䞊Ⴞ㩪ᵰ䞊 ᗳ㎴㍼ᭅ䌷ᘯ䃄⡊ハ⎃䞊㵡ῗ䍤᭖㟑ᓏ⬺䞊⟦㚉䎆ᮃ㬖䂷⧲≵ᅊ㷨♥㎹㍽㬣䞊㸭㏁䞊㶎㟓䘱䞊㸭㒹䞊᧦ᶖ䂸Ო㩯ⷤ♙ハ᭞䞊䔛⑍ᅜ䂹䞊㎹䂺⏉Ῐ㟑䞊⩅ㄦ↱㚑㪾ᓐ䂨⩆㔋⾰䞊❱㵢䞊㚊䅶䂻䞊㷨⒍Ῑ㩧Მɮ䞊



Ⴍ၇⒵ჿ㸭䞊ѐ㭎䞊ᚤ⬺᭞㚓㥑䞊☫㰒䞊㸭☁ᓑ㾏䞊౦ଶⶁ䞊ᭈ☱᧦䞊㍣㏾㷺䞊㵿㟽᭬㍾o䞊 གᐚ䊬ᧀ♅㬁䞊؇㬨䞊ᒾ䞊ᗮ㐁䌒⾰㶿ᙈࢬ⩊ᰲ㩱㠅㚋㍿㬋㪤䞊 䚢䚭䚭䚭䚭䚭䛐䞊ံ䌸ᙽᅆ㹂䞊㞐ㄼ㏁㟓䞊㸭㏁䞊ྡྷᯓ㞑䀻Ὶ⸙ᔠΊ㠎䞊Ҏ ѡ Ȓ 䞊١ϵс䞊⳴ ɯ 䞊

  

  







Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-3 Filed 03/17/17 Page 18 of 18

ฤ⩓ᣰ╾ᆫᮕ⯁䞊໲㐃⮗⚈㎔ᗭ΅ȓ䞊㵻⏃ḉ䞊⇅㚤㩼᭬ⷳ㟌䞊☖ῧዅ㚔䞊㐃↵䞊㷕⏃ῡ䞊ⶏ㊤㠏ᣱ㫜ᆫ㶌⩔㒌㏧ᏪⰎ䞊࿬ᯞ⡢䞊㥸㏁⩟⚈㮂ⷢ䞊ຎ㜅ḻ㪨䃊☧㚕へ㬆䞊༼ᯞᛵ㵻⛭㏋㎇䞊პ㺌䞊 䙤䞊ହ഼䞊䃋Ό㭹䃌⛭↿⢢΅᪲ʐ䞊 ࿭⏃ᳱ䞊ნ㎈㵧䑥Ვ㡕䞊pຏ䞊䘶㐃䄷㩳䞊㟃䄵ῢ㮂䃍⚇㐃㎉䞊☭㭘䞊㛙㟽ἛȤ۠ϝ҈䞊⮗䞊 䃎⏃ΰ㪀Ნ䞊䓃᭝㟜᱕䞊䌻㚞㶗䞊ᐓ㎊䕗䞊㵨☭⎏䍅☭⇃⩤ᙈᄕ⿥Ⲅ䞊㚵㥸Ἲ⯛☭ⷳ⤍㈉ᓩ㫽䞊 ☱㎋㞚䌌⤠㪁䕗䞊㏁㟆䞊₠䍄⮗⮗䞊 ⚈㈾䐵ᡜ㵰䃋☭⎅ᆚ㷕⚇㐃㪇䍆ŝ䞊䑃♌㪄⎟䞊㤷Ო⮗჊䃏⩕䐶΅⮗䖥䞊‼Ო䔜䞊ᯞ䕍ᙒῤ㞒㷒⩖㎿㎌㭄œ䞊ᘙ㐃⿢ᦍ䉍ᣲ㷨᭬᭏䞊ᗦ䕤䞊㷒⏃ῥ䞊౨଺ഽ䞊 ⮗㐃㐃⬩⩖〞⎆䞊ᒞҠ䞊ྥ჊䍈᭐❕䞊 㐃㟌䞊㮞䅌㜠㞓㏁㟌㶪䞊㵻㑗䞊Ⲕᮺ㫦㐃⩥⩦㮂⽿䞊ɱ ɳ 䞊͌ⶓÛ⾡䞊⾰㏁㷆䞊⎎㐖ࢯへ≙䞊㵻㏁䞊㮂䃢ᓨ㎝ᭋ䞊 ⏃ῦ㩴ῧŝ䞊ะ㵩ɯ䞊ೋ⚈⮗⯁Ư䞊এᭋ䞊䃐Ჳⶔ⮗䞊䗂㏁䌼䞊♀㎍䞊〨⿺䘷䞊䔝ᒜ䘸ŕ䞊㵪⏃ረ㜧ᶶ䞊㓨㣬䞊⇆㚥㎬䞊

࿮⏃᱕䞊 ⇇㚦㎞ゐᾼ㟆䞊ુ㮂㯇⟫㮂㺃ნ㎎㻜䞊໻㚿ᮆᣳ☭ᓗⲖ䞊ૂ⎇᭬⾰㶗䞊 ☭「䞊у‫ׯ‬٣΃㣘⎈ḉ䞊⩗へ䞊 ༉ᄈ㊤䞊ை✘ᮕ≲㐃䞊ᚏ㏋⿅⇄♯⾢‫װ‬ᱥᦘ䞊䃑⏃⦲㮂䞊♋⿼䞊☉☭㬆䞊 㷕Ὕ㵱䂭♋⾫㚞㊤䘹ࢰ䞊 ʐ䞊 ࿯☙᱂䘺䞊 ؊ᄈ㮑☦ᛓᓘ⭀ⲿ䞊 䔞Ῠ㤸᱆䞊⿢㏁㼧䞊჊䞊ᙒ㐃䆁㚖෿½ģ䞊⨗ᤂ᭜⿼㷕☭䞊∎᭹ᦃ䞊ᔡ䕤䞊㶌⩩⶚ḉ䞊໻㺃ᓙ㷢Ῡ䞊௉᭜㜠ᓥ㪂㿱ⷤẛ⿒䃒䞊ᓚ㮞䞊ᅈ䞊䞆⮋ᅥ䀩ᶖ䞊㵫㝱㒚゜㬌㏚㩵䞊㚗↶䞊㵼䄔㪆㠿㑗㟒♋㮞ࣀ〒ʹ䞊 ਲ਼㈉ᭌ䞊㺃☊Ὺ䞊⇀ᓤᲚⷪᣴ䞊㓨㡪䞊䃣⏃ᱧ䞊ᣵ㓨⾣ⷳ㐃㎏䞊ⷂ㚘ᦙ䌽㬋䞊㓨㞔᣶㟆㎙へ᧦⡌䞊㶗⑕ᄊ㺃䞊䑟ᯥ䞊㬖ᓛ䑞䞊⩘Ԧ‫ײ‬䞊ཱུᓜ䋀䞊஥☱Ύ⍏㐃䞊䔟ሏ㮰䞊䃠█ጐ㷕䞊❞↷䞊䃓┈ᮞ㡴Ῥ䞊    
 

㞕㪅♌ⷳᅔ㩶䘻䞊㐃ᖬ⫈᯹᣷㸴⚈䍡᳞䞊 䃔㓧䞊ⷢ㕾㎐❳㸏㑗㤷䞊ᩣ☭㵬㵭❵ᩣᲝ「䃎㯇䞊⛳‫״׳‬䞊㸴☛䞇䞊 ⛭〞㵹Ὼ㪁᭜㬌㿱䞊㏚↸䞊㞖㟗㎿㼗Ẩឿ㵹♌〒⊣䞊㸮⏓ᱧ䞊 㠿㐎䕗ᓥⰆ䞊‼ᓪⷤ⩕ⶌ䘼ɫ䞊 ໿㎿䞊 㼗☋῭䖥䞊䑻᭫㩷ᯁ䞊⿼㏟䃕䞊䐷⛡ᘫ䑳᣸⶙⩨䞊ᇠ㬋䞊 ዅ㎑䞊⥾㎚⩠⾤⚈ᘓნⶖ䞊㶗⑕㟒Ẩ⩬Ȕ䞊ⶍ㏈䞊 ࢱ㫝Ⲅⶕ㚙へᏚ⩙䞊㵮ῆᙒ䊛エ㷢䘽ɳ䞊 ാ㎜䞊㺃⏄᱑䞊๏ᚺ㼗㎺ᖦ᭹㟒䞊‫ۺ‬ŕ䞊‫ز‬фф٢䞊ᘹⶖ㐃㮂ᮟᧀ䞊☌᣹჊΄ɤ⚇㋘⎉œ䞊ொ⩡㠁ᲄࢲ㶗㎿㡸䞊ซ䇕एⶎ☍ࢳ㩸䞊ቤ᣺⬪⿍㩹nj䓩⩚᭜ᨈ⎊Ḗᩰ䞊㺞⏄ᆪ㷒䞊⏃΅䞊ᗧ᭹ᘢᅆ⽿΅䞊 ጐ䑮ᅈ㟽ᮕ䞊㚚↹䞊㮞㓨ⷤẛ䞊㚛↺䞊㶗⏃ᯁ䞊⇈㚧ᾭ䞊⩛㬆䞊㩺ẗ⎋ॱ㩻ᦃ⩜へ≡䞊䃖☎ᾋ䞊༉ᓝ䉢ᦌ☭䞊☫㰰㮟䆯᳷䞊㐃㎒⮗䘾䞊ᆪȕ䞊ᓞ䞊㠑᣹㬆䚠ʐժ☏䞊㚜↻䞊㼗ⓝᮕ䞊❫㎓䐸ᣱ㭄㷕⚈⎌Ꭷ䌾䐹ὲ䞊䑧㎺㡸⫧䞊㐃↼䞊 ࢴ▹䄕䞊ඞ㙇း⶗䃗䞊ഽ「㞙䌿☭㟌䕘䞊ྌ㶗ᓟ⇁⇂ࢵ䞊 ೐Û⾥䞊㮆ᓠ䙂⩢へ⍏䞊䃘␒ᮕ䞊㬌᱂㟄䅎ῢ⿍ᘅᮕ䞊㚝↽䞊`䎜ᷫへ㾩䞈䞊☐῰㤷ᷫȖ䞊ⶏ䞊㶗ϔ✘㎛⬨䞊㺃┈ᶶ䞊৚㢂㚞ᗨἛ᭍䞊ࢶࢾʁ㎔ᭋſ䞊ე㮣䞊 ᆜ䞊㢭ᘡ㬆䄵ࢷ‫ױ‬䞊㐃↾䞊䃙☑῱䞊 㛙㪂㚡ᔋ⩝⿅⎍ŕ䞊㫾㐃⾦΅䞊⇁ᓪᙐ㸂㬊䞊ᣱᓦ⾪ᰮ䞊㸮㐃䞊ⶐ⛭⍽☒㺃䞊⏃ῧ㩼Ნ䞊ᓡࢸџᭋ䞊 㶗㐃䞊⹅ᲝŠ䞊u‫׵ڒ‬䔠䕗Ť䞊䃚☓ሏࢹ䞊☔ᓢᭋ䞊⿅㏕㹤䞊ᗰ㐃ⷳᮕ䞊䃛㚟䞊⮗⚈⎎◥䃜䞊 ᗩῲ∫㟗ῳŘ䞊 ㎟⾰ᦃ䞊㛙᳞㟌⎟Ⴭ㚺㫾䞊䑥㐃䉍⶘ᧀ䞊⿍㓨㶌䞊⏃ጟ䏒ᮝ䞊ᙒ㙜⾧᭜䞊㼗㓨䞊⯁➵⎏⏃㶽䞊⎨ᓧ᭎䞊 䃡⏃᭜䞊㵯㺃ᅆ㪃⇉へ㐃䃝䞊㛙㟗㎽ᕴ΅ඟɱ䞊 ࿮☚Ⴚ㼗ġ㬆䞊䔡⑛ዅ㸂䞊 ೱä⾨䞊㺃Ὕ⯇⮗⚈へ≙䞊䘿㐃䉍ʓ䞊 ྦ㐃䞊ാä⾩䞊ᓣ⎏㣂ΏẨ❕⾰≙䞊䓃⦫㵹◼䞊䖥㓨䅕䞊฀┸ᇠ㽆䞊㻟⏃ῴ䞊㴎䃞ዣ⪖㝝㟒䍇ᔐ⡌〞⎐䞊☕㪀㚢䍀⎑⏸㺃䞊㏞䇕㷙䞊⇒᛾䃎㵲䞊㷕⏃ᇦ䃏䞊 ⹇ቊ䖥䞊᣻㐃࢏䞊☖ᆫ䍻䄖䞊ᘅ㏞⺭῵䞊㺃㏈䞊ࢺⓛ⡌㮂䞊஁㏋⸏ⷳ⛭့΅ᰌ˭º䞊 ໻᣼へࢽ䍁㚠㩽䞊ங΅䔢⩧⿺ᰉࢻ䞊 ૒䍂㼎䞊䑊⏃ᄊ㷕䞊䙀㐃䇄䞊Ģ㟌ῶ䞊Ⴝ⩞㲜㏈䞊㲙ዅ䙃⣷⿒⋄Ű䞊㽵⏃㓨䇕⎒⏃ʓ䞊⚈㮂䞊㷕⏃჊㷲䞊㷕☗თ㸂䞊㛅㤐㚣अ㎕ケ⎓䞊㸂⏃᣽ࢿ⩣䞊ᔐ㠅㚞䍃⎔☘᣾䞊 ≐ῷⶑ䞉䞊ⶒ㐃䞊䙁㐖䇕㦏䞊ᄕ㎖Ნ㎗㷕♥㐃㎘̉䞊 த⚈㧪ᮕ᣿䃟㐃㩾䞊ၴ䄵Ὸ⯥qᣱ㩿ࢼ䞊 ၲᲖ㬌ɸ䞊

ഺຍ഻䞊ྤ䃉᥹෾䞊

թ࠼ɰ˳ʵǖȏ࠼

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-4 Filed 03/17/17 Page 1 of 5

Appendix 3

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-4 Filed 03/17/17 Page 2 of 5

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-4 Filed 03/17/17 Page 3 of 5

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-4 Filed 03/17/17 Page 4 of 5

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-4 Filed 03/17/17 Page 5 of 5

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 1 of 24

Appendix 4A

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 2 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 3 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 4 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 5 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 6 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 7 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 8 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 9 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 10 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 11 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 12 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 13 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 14 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 15 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 16 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 17 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 18 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 19 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 20 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 21 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 22 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 23 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-5 Filed 03/17/17 Page 24 of 24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 1 of 25

Appendix 4B

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 2 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 3 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 4 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 5 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 6 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 7 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 8 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 9 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 10 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 11 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 12 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 13 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 14 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 15 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 16 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 17 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 18 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 19 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 20 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 21 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 22 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 23 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 24 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-6 Filed 03/17/17 Page 25 of 25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 1 of 978

Appendix 5

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 2 of 978

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK THOMAS E. BURNETT, SR., et al., Plaintiffs,

Civil Case No. 03-CV-9849 (GBD)(SN)

v. KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA Defendant. BURNETT PLAINTIFFS’ AMENDED COMPLAINT ADDING DEFENDANT KINGDOM OF SAUDI ARABIA

PLAINTIFFS 1.

Plaintiff Thomas E. Burnett, Sr. is a resident of the State of Minnesota, the Parent

of Decedent Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2.

Plaintiff Beverly Burnett is a resident of the State of Minnesota, the Parent of

Decedent Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3.

Plaintiff Deena Burnett Bailey is a resident of the State of Arkansas, the Spouse

of Decedent Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Administrator of the Estate of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas E. Burnett, Jr. was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 3 of 978

4.

Plaintiff Mary Margaret Jurgens is a resident of the State of Minnesota, the

Sibling of Decedent Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 5.

Plaintiff Martha Burnett Pettee is a resident of the State of Minnesota, the Sibling

of Decedent Thomas E. Burnett, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas E. Burnett, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 6.

Plaintiff William Doyle, Sr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Joseph Michael Doyle, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Michael Doyle and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Michael Doyle and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Michael Doyle was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 7.

Plaintiff Camille Doyle, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and

the Parent of Decedent Joseph Michael Doyle; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 8.

Plaintiff William Doyle, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Joseph Michael Doyle, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Michael Doyle and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 9.

Plaintiff Doreen Lutter is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Joseph Michael Doyle, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Michael Doyle and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

2

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 4 of 978

10.

Plaintiff Dr. Stephen J. Alderman is a resident of the State of New York, the

Parent of Decedent Peter Craig Alderman, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Peter Craig Alderman and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Craig Alderman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Craig Alderman was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 11.

Plaintiff Elizabeth Alderman is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Peter Craig Alderman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Peter Craig Alderman and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Craig Alderman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Craig Alderman was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 12.

Plaintiff Jane Alderman is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Peter Craig Alderman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Craig Alderman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 13.

Plaintiff Elaine Abate is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent

Andrew Anthony Abate, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Andrew Anthony Abate, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 14.

Plaintiff Carolyn Crutchfield is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent Andrew Anthony Abate, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andrew Anthony Abate and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Anthony Abate and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

3

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 5 of 978

herein. Andrew Anthony Abate was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 15.

Plaintiff Elaine Abate is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent

Vincent Abate, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent Abate and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Abate and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Abate was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 16.

Plaintiff Ann M. Abrahamson is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse

of Decedent William F. Abrahamson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William F. Abrahamson and on behalf of all survivors of William F. Abrahamson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William F. Abrahamson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 17.

Plaintiff Josephine Acquaviva is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent

of Decedent Paul Andrew Acquaviva, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Paul Andrew Acquaviva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 18.

Plaintiff Kara Hadfield is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Paul Andrew Acquaviva, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Andrew Acquaviva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

4

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 6 of 978

19.

Plaintiff Courtney Lizabeth Acquaviva is a resident of the State of New Jersey,

the Spouse of Decedent Paul Andrew Acquaviva, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Andrew Acquaviva and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Andrew Acquaviva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Andrew Acquaviva was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 20.

Plaintiff Alfred Acquaviva is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Paul Andrew Acquaviva, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Paul Andrew Acquaviva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 21.

Plaintiff Jean Adams is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Donald L. Adams, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Donald L. Adams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 22.

Plaintiff Heda K. Adams is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Donald L. Adams, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald L. Adams and on behalf of all survivors of Donald L. Adams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald L. Adams was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 23.

Plaintiff Robert C. Adams is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Donald L. Adams, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Donald L. Adams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

5

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 7 of 978

24.

Plaintiff Dwight D. Adams is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Donald L. Adams, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Donald L. Adams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 25.

Plaintiff Anne B. Adams, now deceased, was a resident of the State of

Massachusetts, and the Parent of Decedent Stephen George Adams; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 26.

Plaintiff Jessica Murrow-Adams is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the

Spouse of Decedent Stephen George Adams, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen George Adams and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen George Adams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen George Adams was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 27.

Plaintiff Lawrence Scott Adams is a resident of the State of Washington, the

Sibling of Decedent Stephen George Adams, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen George Adams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 28.

Plaintiff Affiong Adanga is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Ignatius Udo Adanga, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ignatius Udo Adanga and on behalf of all survivors of Ignatius Udo Adanga and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ignatius Udo Adanga was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

6

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 8 of 978

29.

Plaintiff Rita Addamo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Christy A. Addamo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Christy A. Addamo and on behalf of all survivors of Christy A. Addamo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christy A. Addamo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 30.

Plaintiff Dawn Addamo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Christy A. Addamo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christy A. Addamo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 31.

Plaintiff Gregory Addamo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Christy A. Addamo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Christy A. Addamo and on behalf of all survivors of Christy A. Addamo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christy A. Addamo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 32.

Plaintiff Alice Fay Doerge Adler is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Spouse

of Decedent Lee Alan Adler, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lee Alan Adler and on behalf of all survivors of Lee Alan Adler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lee Alan Adler was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 33.

Plaintiff Stacey Afflitto is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Daniel Thomas Afflitto, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as

7

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 9 of 978

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Thomas Afflitto, Sr. and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Thomas Afflitto, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Thomas Afflitto, Sr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 34.

Plaintiff Rita Agnello is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Joseph Agnello, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Agnello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 35.

Plaintiff Rosaria Martingano is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Joseph Agnello, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Agnello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 36.

Plaintiff Vinnie Carla Agnello is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse

of Decedent Joseph Agnello, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Agnello and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Agnello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Agnello was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 37.

Plaintiff Salvatore Agnello is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Joseph Agnello, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Agnello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 38.

Plaintiff Anthony Agnello is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Joseph Agnello, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Agnello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

8

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 10 of 978

39.

Plaintiff Diane B. Aguiar is a resident of Portugal, the Parent of Decedent Joao A.

Aguiar, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joao A. Aguiar, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Joao A. Aguiar, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joao A. Aguiar, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 40.

Plaintiff Taciana Aguiar is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of

Decedent Joao A. Aguiar, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joao A. Aguiar, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 41.

Plaintiff Joao A. Aguiar, Sr. is a resident of Portugal, the Parent of Decedent Joao

A. Aguiar, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Joao A. Aguiar, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 42.

Plaintiff Catherine Frances Jezycki is a resident of the State of New York, the

Parent of Decedent Margaret Alario, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Margaret Alario and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 43.

Plaintiff Michael John Jezycki is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Margaret Alario, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Margaret Alario and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 44.

Plaintiff Stephen Frank Jezycki, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the

Sibling of Decedent Margaret Alario, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Margaret Alario and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

9

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 11 of 978

45.

Plaintiff Stephen Jezycki, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Margaret Alario; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 46.

Plaintiff James Alario, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Margaret Alario, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Margaret Alario and on behalf of all survivors of Margaret Alario and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Margaret Alario was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 47.

Plaintiff Edward Albert is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Jon L. Albert, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jon L. Albert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 48.

Plaintiff Louisa Allegretto is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Edward L. Allegretto, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward L. Allegretto and on behalf of all survivors of Edward L. Allegretto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward L. Allegretto was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 49.

Plaintiff Jennifer D'Auria is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Joseph R. Allen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Joseph R. Allen and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph R. Allen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph R. Allen was

10

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 12 of 978

killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 50.

Plaintiff Michael J. Allen is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Joseph R. Allen, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Joseph R. Allen and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph R. Allen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph R. Allen was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 51.

Plaintiff Madelyn Gail Allen is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Richard Dennis Allen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Dennis Allen and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Dennis Allen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Dennis Allen was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 52.

Plaintiff Lynn P. Allen is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard Dennis Allen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 53.

Plaintiff Marguerite G. Allen is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard Dennis Allen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 54.

Plaintiff Judith M. Aiken is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard Dennis Allen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

11

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 13 of 978

55.

Plaintiff Richard D. Allen is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Richard Dennis Allen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Richard Dennis Allen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 56.

Plaintiff Luke C. Allen is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard Dennis Allen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 57.

Plaintiff Matthew J. Allen is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard Dennis Allen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard Dennis Allen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 58.

Plaintiff Patricia Cleary Allingham is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Christopher Edward Allingham, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Christopher Edward Allingham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 59.

Plaintiff Peggy Allingham Ciccarelli is a resident of the State of Illinois, the

Sibling of Decedent Christopher Edward Allingham, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Edward Allingham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 60.

Plaintiff Katharine Allingham Clark is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the

Sibling of Decedent Christopher Edward Allingham, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Edward Allingham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 61.

Plaintiff Donna Allingham is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Christopher Edward Allingham, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse

12

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 14 of 978

and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Edward Allingham and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Edward Allingham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Edward Allingham was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 62.

Plaintiff James Joseph Allingham is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Christopher Edward Allingham, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Edward Allingham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 63.

Plaintiff William John Allingham, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Christopher Edward Allingham, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Edward Allingham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 64.

Plaintiff William J. Allingham, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Christopher Edward Allingham, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Christopher Edward Allingham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 65.

Plaintiff V. Blake Allison is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Spouse

of Decedent Anna Allison, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anna Allison and on behalf of all survivors of Anna Allison and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anna Allison was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North

13

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 15 of 978

Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 66.

Plaintiff Gianina Alviar is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Cesar A. Alviar, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Cesar A. Alviar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 67.

Plaintiff Gemma Alviar is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Cesar A. Alviar, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Cesar A. Alviar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 68.

Plaintiff Grace Alviar is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Cesar A. Alviar, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cesar A. Alviar and on behalf of all survivors of Cesar A. Alviar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cesar A. Alviar was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 69.

Plaintiff Christopher Alviar is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Cesar A. Alviar, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Cesar A. Alviar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 70.

Plaintiff Sharon Ambrose is a resident of the State of West Virginia, the Parent of

Decedent Paul Wesley Ambrose, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Paul Wesley Ambrose and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Wesley Ambrose and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Wesley Ambrose was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon

14

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 16 of 978

as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 71.

Plaintiff Kenneth P. Ambrose is a resident of the State of West Virginia, the

Parent of Decedent Paul Wesley Ambrose, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Paul Wesley Ambrose and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Wesley Ambrose and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Wesley Ambrose was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 72.

Plaintiff Marie L. Anaya is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Calixto Anaya, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Calixto Anaya, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Calixto Anaya, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Calixto Anaya, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 73.

Plaintiff Christine A. Anchundia is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Joseph P. Anchundia, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joseph P. Anchundia and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Anchundia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph P. Anchundia was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 74.

Plaintiff Elizabeth R. Anchundia is a resident of the State of New York, the

Sibling of Decedent Joseph P. Anchundia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling

15

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 17 of 978

of Joseph P. Anchundia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 75.

Plaintiff Elias A. Anchundia is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Joseph P. Anchundia, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Joseph P. Anchundia and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Anchundia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph P. Anchundia was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 76.

Plaintiff Elias J. Anchundia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Joseph P. Anchundia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph P. Anchundia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 77.

Plaintiff Selma Ann Verse is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Kermit C. Anderson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kermit C. Anderson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 78.

Plaintiff Jill Elva Grashof Anderson is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the

Spouse of Decedent Kermit C. Anderson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kermit C. Anderson and on behalf of all survivors of Kermit C. Anderson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kermit C. Anderson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 79.

Plaintiff Edward S. Andrews is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Rourke Andrews, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Rourke Andrews and on behalf of all survivors

16

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 18 of 978

of Michael Rourke Andrews and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Rourke Andrews was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 80.

Plaintiff Kui Liong Lee is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Siew-Nya Ang, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Siew-Nya Ang and on behalf of all survivors of Siew-Nya Ang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Siew-Nya Ang was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 81.

Plaintiff Donna L. Angelini is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Joseph John Angelini, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph John Angelini, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph John Angelini, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph John Angelini, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 82.

Plaintiff Claire Angell Miller is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the

Sibling of Decedent David Lawrence Angell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of David Lawrence Angell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 83.

Plaintiff Dorotea Angilletta is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Laura Angilletta, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Laura Angilletta and on behalf of all survivors of Laura Angilletta

17

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 19 of 978

and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Laura Angilletta was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 84.

Plaintiff Maria Garbarino is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Laura Angilletta, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Laura Angilletta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 85.

Plaintiff Carmelo Angilletta is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Laura Angilletta, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Laura Angilletta and on behalf of all survivors of Laura Angilletta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Laura Angilletta was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 86.

Plaintiff Al Angilletta is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Laura Angilletta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Laura Angilletta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 87.

Plaintiff Ralph Angrisani, a resident of the State of Texas and plaintiff Gina

Giovanniello, a resident of the State of New York, bring this action as the Co-Administrators of the Estate of Doreen J. Agrisani and on behalf of all survivors of Doreen J. Agrisani and are entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Doreen J. Angrisani was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. Plaintiff Irene T. Angrisani, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York and the Parent of Decedent Doreen J. Angrisani; the Co-

18

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 20 of 978

Administrators of her Estate, Ralph Angrisani and Gina Giovanniello, bring this action on behalf of her Estate and are entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 88.

Plaintiff Gina Giovanniello is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Doreen J. Angrisani, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Doreen J. Angrisani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 89.

Plaintiff Ralph Angrisani is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of

Decedent Doreen J. Angrisani, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Doreen J. Angrisani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 90.

Plaintiff Brian Wilkes is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé of

Decedent Lorraine Antigua, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Fiancé of Lorraine Antigua and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 91.

Plaintiff Cecile M. Apollo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Peter Paul Apollo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Peter Paul Apollo and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Paul Apollo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Paul Apollo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 92.

Plaintiff Denise Mauthe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Peter Paul Apollo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Paul Apollo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 93.

Plaintiff Lisa Consiglio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Peter Paul Apollo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Paul Apollo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

19

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 21 of 978

94.

Plaintiff Peter Apollo, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Peter Paul Apollo; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 95.

Plaintiff Margaret Apostol is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Faustino Apostol, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Faustino Apostol and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 96.

Plaintiff Carol Ann Aquilino is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Frank Thomas Aquilino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Frank Thomas Aquilino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 97.

Plaintiff Tara Chiari is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Frank Thomas Aquilino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Frank Thomas Aquilino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 98.

Plaintiff Jill Walton is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Frank Thomas Aquilino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Frank Thomas Aquilino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 99.

Plaintiff Frank J. Aquilino is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Frank Thomas Aquilino, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank Thomas Aquilino and on behalf of all survivors of Frank Thomas Aquilino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

20

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 22 of 978

herein. Frank Thomas Aquilino was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 100.

Plaintiff Lori Ann Arczynski is a resident of the State of Vermont, the Spouse of

Decedent Michael G. Arczynski, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael G. Arczynski and on behalf of all survivors of Michael G. Arczynski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael G. Arczynski was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 101.

Plaintiff Wandalee Arena is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Louis Arena, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Louis Arena and on behalf of all survivors of Louis Arena and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louis Arena was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 102.

Plaintiff Lauren Arias Lucchini is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Adam P. Arias, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 103.

Plaintiff Lorraine M. Arias-Beliveau is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Adam P. Arias, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 104.

Plaintiff Donald C. Arias is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Adam P. Arias, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

21

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 23 of 978

105.

Plaintiff Thomas Arias is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Adam P. Arias, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 106.

Plaintiff Andrew Arias is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Adam P. Arias, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Adam P. Arias and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 107.

Plaintiff Catherine M. Nolan is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of

Decedent Michael Joseph Armstrong, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Michael Joseph Armstrong and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 108.

Plaintiff Mary E. Armstrong is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Joseph Armstrong, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Joseph Armstrong and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Joseph Armstrong and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Joseph Armstrong was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 109.

Plaintiff Laura A. Armstrong is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael Joseph Armstrong, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Armstrong and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 110.

Plaintiff Marian Armstrong is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael Joseph Armstrong, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

22

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 24 of 978

Michael Joseph Armstrong and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 111.

Plaintiff Gabriel Armstrong is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Joseph Armstrong, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael Joseph Armstrong and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 112.

Plaintiff Gerard Armstrong is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael Joseph Armstrong, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Armstrong and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 113.

Plaintiff Ruth Green Aron is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Joshua Todd Aron, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joshua Todd Aron and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 114.

Plaintiff Jules Phelan Aronson is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling

of Decedent Myra Joy Aronson, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Myra Joy Aronson and on behalf of all survivors of Myra Joy Aronson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Myra Joy Aronson was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 115.

Plaintiff Ayikaile Aryee is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Child of

Decedent Japhet Aryee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Japhet Aryee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

23

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 25 of 978

116.

Plaintiff Maria Aryee is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Spouse of Decedent

Japhet Aryee, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Japhet Aryee and on behalf of all survivors of Japhet Aryee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Japhet Aryee was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 117.

Plaintiff Teiko Aryee is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Japhet Aryee, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Japhet Aryee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 118.

Plaintiff Ayitey Aryee is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent

Japhet Aryee, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Japhet Aryee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 119.

Plaintiff Vivian Asciak is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Asciak, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Asciak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 120.

Plaintiff Elaine V. Asciak is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Michael Asciak, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Asciak and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Asciak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Asciak was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

24

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 26 of 978

121.

Plaintiff Ethel Asher, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New york, and

the Parent of Decedent Michael Edward Asher; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 122.

Plaintiff Rachel Asher is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Michael Edward Asher, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Michael Edward Asher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 123.

Plaintiff Dana Asher is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Michael Edward Asher, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Edward Asher and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Edward Asher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Edward Asher was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 124.

Plaintiff Stuart Asher, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York,

and the Sibling of Decedent Michael Edward Asher; Marlene Asher, the Representative of his Estate, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 125.

Plaintiff Jeremy Asher is a resident of the State of California, the Child of

Decedent Michael Edward Asher, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Michael Edward Asher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 126.

Plaintiff DOE 15 is a resident of the state of New York, the Parent of Decedent

DOE 15, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of

25

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 27 of 978

DOE 15 and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 15 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 15 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 127.

Plaintiff DOE 15 is a resident of the state of New York, the Parent of Decedent

DOE 15, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 15 and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 15 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 15 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 128.

Plaintiff DOE 15 is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 15, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 129.

Plaintiff Maria Transito Quintuna Sacta is a resident of Ecuador, the Parent of

Decedent Manual Asitimbay, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Manual Asitimbay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 130.

Plaintiff Wilson Asitimbay is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Manual Asitimbay, and brings this action on own behalf as the Child of Manual Asitimbay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 131.

Plaintiff Ricardo Asitimbay is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Manual Asitimbay, and brings this action on own behalf as the Child of Manual Asitimbay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

26

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 28 of 978

132.

Plaintiff Edwin Asitimbay is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Manual Asitimbay, and brings this action on own behalf as the Child of Manual Asitimbay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 133.

Plaintiff Wilmer Mijia is a resident of the State of New York, the step-child of

Decedent Manual Asitimbay, and brings this action on own behalf as the step-child of Manual Asitimbay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 134.

Plaintiff Julia Rocia Asitimbay Quintuna is a resident of Ecuador, the Sibling of

Decedent Manual Asitimbay, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Manual Asitimbay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 135.

Plaintiff Maria Maclovia Asitimbay Quintuna is a resident of Ecuador, the Sibling

of Decedent Manual Asitimbay, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Manual Asitimbay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 136.

Plaintiff Rosa Elena Asitimbay Quintuna is a resident of Ecuador, the Sibling of

Decedent Manual Asitimbay, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Manual Asitimbay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 137.

Plaintiff Carmen Cecilia Mejia is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse

of Decedent Manual Asitimbay, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Manual Asitimbay and on behalf of all survivors of Manual Asitimbay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Manual Asitimbay was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

27

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 29 of 978

138.

Plaintiff Elaine M. Atwood (sibling) is a resident of the State of New York, the

Sibling of Decedent Gerald T. Atwood, and brings this action on own behalf as the Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 139.

Plaintiff Elaine M. Atwood (parent) is a resident of the State of New York, the

Parent of Decedent Gerald T. Atwood, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gerald T. Atwood and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 140.

Plaintiff Jane M. Duffy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Gerald T. Atwood, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 141.

Plaintiff Gerald Atwood is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Gerald T. Atwood, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Gerald T. Atwood and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 142.

Plaintiff Raymond J. Atwood is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Gerald T. Atwood, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 143.

Plaintiff Gregory P. Atwood is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Gerald T. Atwood, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 144.

Plaintiff John G. Atwood is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Gerald T. Atwood, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gerald T. Atwood and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 145.

Plaintiff Juana Bacchus is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Eustace R. Bacchus, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

28

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 30 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Eustace R. Bacchus and on behalf of all survivors of Eustace R. Bacchus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eustace R. Bacchus was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 146.

Plaintiff Grace Marie Badagliacca is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent John J. Badagliacca, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John J. Badagliacca and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 147.

Plaintiff Jodi Scolaro is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent John J. Badagliacca, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John J. Badagliacca and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 148.

Plaintiff John Edward Badagliacca is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent John J. Badagliacca, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John J. Badagliacca and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 149.

Plaintiff John P. Baeszler is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jane Ellen Baeszler, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jane Ellen Baeszler and on behalf of all survivors of Jane Ellen Baeszler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jane Ellen Baeszler was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 150.

Plaintiff Christine Goggins is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of

Decedent Andrew Joseph Bailey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew Joseph Bailey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

29

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 31 of 978

151.

Plaintiff Paula Virginia Bailey is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of

Decedent Andrew Joseph Bailey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew Joseph Bailey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 152.

Plaintiff Vincent Henry Bailey is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of

Decedent Andrew Joseph Bailey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Andrew Joseph Bailey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 153.

Plaintiff Judith A. Bailey is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Brett T. Bailey, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brett T. Bailey and on behalf of all survivors of Brett T. Bailey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brett T. Bailey was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 154.

Plaintiff Yarah Bailey is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent

Brett T. Bailey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Brett T. Bailey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 155.

Plaintiff Kevin J. Bailey, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and

the Parent of Decedent Brett T. Bailey; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 156.

Plaintiff Yuriah Bailey is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Brett T. Bailey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Brett T. Bailey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 157.

Plaintiff Katherine Bailey is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse

of Decedent Garnet Bailey, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

30

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 32 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Garnet Bailey and on behalf of all survivors of Garnet Bailey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Garnet Bailey was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 158.

Plaintiff Todd G. Bailey is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of

Decedent Garnet Bailey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Garnet Bailey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 159.

Plaintiff Marina Bakalinskaya is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Tatyana Bakalinskaya, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Tatyana Bakalinskaya and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 160.

Plaintiff Natalie Bakalinskaya is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Tatyana Bakalinskaya, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Tatyana Bakalinskaya and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 161.

Plaintiff Anatoliy Bakalinskiy is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse

of Decedent Tatyana Bakalinskaya, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Tatyana Bakalinskaya and on behalf of all survivors of Tatyana Bakalinskaya and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Tatyana Bakalinskaya was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 162.

Plaintiff Martha Baksh is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Parent of

Decedent Michael S. Baksh, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael S. Baksh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

31

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 33 of 978

163.

Plaintiff Marvina Baksh is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael S. Baksh, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael S. Baksh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 164.

Plaintiff Maureen Baksh Griffin is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the

Sibling of Decedent Michael S. Baksh, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael S. Baksh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 165.

Plaintiff Michelle Baksh is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael S. Baksh, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael S. Baksh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 166.

Plaintiff Morris Baksh, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey,

and the Parent of Decedent Michael S. Baksh; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 167.

Plaintiff Christina Bane-Hayes is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael A. Bane, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Bane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 168.

Plaintiff Tara Bane is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of

Decedent Michael A. Bane, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael A. Bane and on behalf of all survivors of Michael A. Bane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Bane was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

32

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 34 of 978

169.

Plaintiff J. Donald Bane is a resident of the State of Delaware, the Parent of

Decedent Michael A. Bane, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael A. Bane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 170.

Plaintiff Soultana Bantis is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Katherine Bantis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Katherine Bantis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 171.

Plaintiff Evangelos Bantis, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Katherine Bantis; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 172.

Plaintiff Aristides Bantis is a resident of the State of New York, the Uncle of

Decedent Katherine Bantis, and brings this action on his own behalf as Uncle and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Katherine Bantis and on behalf of all survivors of Katherine Bantis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Katherine Bantis was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 173.

Plaintiff Gerard Jean-Baptiste, now deceased, was a resident of the State of

Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Gerard Baptiste; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 174.

Representative of the Estate of Gerard Baptiste brings this action on behalf of the

Estate ofGerard Baptiste and on behalf of all survivors of Gerard Baptiste and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard Baptiste was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

33

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 35 of 978

175.

Plaintiff Anna M. Granville is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Walter Baran, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Walter Baran and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 176.

Plaintiff Carol Ann Baran is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Walter Baran, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Walter Baran and on behalf of all survivors of Walter Baran and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Walter Baran was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 177.

Plaintiff Carol Barbaro, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York,

and the Parent of Decedent Paul Barbaro; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 178.

Plaintiff Jacqueline Venezia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Paul Barbaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Barbaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 179.

Plaintiff Kim Barbaro is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Paul Barbaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Barbaro and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Barbaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Barbaro was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

34

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 36 of 978

180.

Plaintiff Nicholas Barbaro, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Paul Barbaro; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 181.

Plaintiff Thomas Barbaro is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Paul Barbaro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Barbaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 182.

Plaintiff Nicholas Barbaro, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Paul Barbaro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Barbaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 183.

Plaintiff Nancy Santana is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Victor Daniel Barbosa, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Victor Daniel Barbosa and on behalf of all survivors of Victor Daniel Barbosa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Victor Daniel Barbosa was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 184.

Plaintiff Jo Ann Meehan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Colleen Ann Barkow, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Colleen Ann Barkow and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 185.

Plaintiff Daryl Joseph Meehan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Colleen Ann Barkow, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Colleen Ann Barkow and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 186.

Plaintiff Thomas Joseph Meehan, III is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Colleen Ann Barkow, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent

35

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 37 of 978

of Colleen Ann Barkow and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 187.

Plaintiff Alan M. Mennie is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of

Decedent Melissa Rose Barnes, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Melissa Rose Barnes and on behalf of all survivors of Melissa Rose Barnes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Melissa Rose Barnes was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 188.

Plaintiff Audriene Barry is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Arthur T. Barry, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Arthur T. Barry and on behalf of all survivors of Arthur T. Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Arthur T. Barry was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 189.

Plaintiff Kathleen Megan Poss is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Arthur T. Barry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Arthur T. Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 190.

Plaintiff Patricia Anne Barry is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Arthur T. Barry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Arthur T. Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 191.

Plaintiff Clare Ellen Skarda is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of

Decedent Arthur T. Barry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Arthur T. Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

36

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 38 of 978

192.

Plaintiff Bertrand Francis Barry is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Arthur T. Barry, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Arthur T. Barry and on behalf of all survivors of Arthur T. Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Arthur T. Barry was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 193.

Plaintiff Bertrand Arthur Barry is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling

of Decedent Arthur T. Barry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Arthur T. Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 194.

Plaintiff Maureen Barry, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey,

and the Child of Decedent Diane Barry; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 195.

Plaintiff Brian Barry is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Diane Barry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Diane Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 196.

Plaintiff Kevin William Barry is a resident of the State of Texas, the Child of

Decedent Diane Barry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Diane Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 197.

Plaintiff Edmund Barry is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Diane Barry, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Diane Barry and on behalf of all survivors of Diane Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Diane Barry was killed at

37

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 39 of 978

Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 198.

Plaintiff Marianne Joan Barry is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse

of Decedent Maurice V. Barry, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maurice V. Barry and on behalf of all survivors of Maurice V. Barry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maurice V. Barry was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 199.

Plaintiff Gila Barzvi is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Guy Barzvi, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Guy Barzvi and on behalf of all survivors of Guy Barzvi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Guy Barzvi was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 200.

Plaintiff DOE 35 is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 35, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 201.

Plaintiff Arie Barzvi, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and

the Parent of Decedent Guy Barzvi; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 202.

Plaintiff Frima Kogan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Inna Basin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Inna Basin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

38

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 40 of 978

203.

Plaintiff Jean Basnicki is a resident of Canada, the Parent of Decedent Kenneth

William Basnicki, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth William Basnicki and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 204.

Plaintiff Maureen Elizabeth Basnicki is a resident of Canada, the Spouse of

Decedent Kenneth William Basnicki, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth William Basnicki and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth William Basnicki and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth William Basnicki was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 205.

Plaintiff Brennan Basnicki is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Kenneth William Basnicki, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Kenneth William Basnicki and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 206.

Plaintiff William Basnicki is a resident of Canada, the Parent of Decedent

Kenneth William Basnicki, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth William Basnicki and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 207.

Plaintiff Chris Basnicki is a resident of Canada, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth

William Basnicki, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth William Basnicki and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 208.

Plaintiff Robert J. Basnicki is a resident of Canada, the Sibling of Decedent

Kenneth William Basnicki, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth William Basnicki and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

39

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 41 of 978

209.

Plaintiff Joan Puwalski is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of

Decedent Steven J. Bates, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Steven J. Bates and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 210.

Plaintiff Narcisa G. Capito is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Marlyn Capito Bautista, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Marlyn Capito Bautista and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 211.

Plaintiff Anisia C. Abarabar is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Marlyn Capito Bautista, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Marlyn Capito Bautista and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 212.

Plaintiff Rufina C. Coquia is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Marlyn Capito Bautista, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Marlyn Capito Bautista and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 213.

Plaintiff Rameses Garcia Bautista is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Spouse of Decedent Marlyn Capito Bautista, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marlyn Capito Bautista and on behalf of all survivors of Marlyn Capito Bautista and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marlyn Capito Bautista was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 214.

Plaintiff Mary Bavis is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of

Decedent Mark Lawrence Bavis, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the

40

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 42 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Lawrence Bavis and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Lawrence Bavis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Lawrence Bavis was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 215.

Plaintiff Mary Ellen Moran is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling

of Decedent Mark Lawrence Bavis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 216.

Plaintiff Kelly Bavis Morrissey is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the

Sibling of Decedent Mark Lawrence Bavis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 217.

Plaintiff Kathleen M. Sylvester is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the

Sibling of Decedent Mark Lawrence Bavis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 218.

Plaintiff Michael T. Bavis is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling

of Decedent Mark Lawrence Bavis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 219.

Plaintiff Patrick J Bavis is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of

Decedent Mark Lawrence Bavis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

41

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 43 of 978

220.

Plaintiff John M. Bavis is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of

Decedent Mark Lawrence Bavis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Lawrence Bavis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 221.

Plaintiff Mattie L. Baxter is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of

Decedent Jasper Baxter, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jasper Baxter and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 222.

Plaintiff Juanita Whatley is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Jasper Baxter, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 223.

Plaintiff Diane Baxter is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Jasper Baxter, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 224.

Plaintiff Lillian Baxter is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of

Decedent Jasper Baxter, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jasper Baxter and on behalf of all survivors of Jasper Baxter and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jasper Baxter was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 225.

Plaintiff Donald Baxter is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Jasper Baxter, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

42

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 44 of 978

226.

Plaintiff Dennis Baxter is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Jasper Baxter, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 227.

Plaintiff Lawrence Baxter is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Jasper Baxter, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 228.

Plaintiff Jedelle Baxter, Jr. is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling

of Decedent Jasper Baxter, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jasper Baxter and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 229.

Plaintiff Brent McIntosh is a resident of Canada, the Child of Decedent Jane

Beatty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Jane Beatty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 230.

Plaintiff Drew McIntosh is a resident of Brooklin, Ontario, the Child of Decedent

Jane Beatty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Jane Beatty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 231.

Plaintiff Robert W. Beatty is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Jane Beatty, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jane Beatty and on behalf of all survivors of Jane Beatty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jane Beatty was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 232.

Plaintiff Theodore Beck is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Lawrence I. Beck, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the

43

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 45 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Lawrence I. Beck and on behalf of all survivors of Lawrence I. Beck and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lawrence I. Beck was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 233.

Plaintiff Edward C. Williams is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of

Decedent Manette M. Beckles, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Manette M. Beckles and on behalf of all survivors of Manette M. Beckles and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Manette M. Beckles was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 234.

Plaintiff Dolores Bedigian is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Carl Bedigian, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Carl Bedigian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 235.

Plaintiff Robert Bedigian is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Carl Bedigian, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Carl Bedigian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 236.

Plaintiff Joseph J. Bedigian is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Carl Bedigian, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Carl Bedigian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 237.

Plaintiff Theodora Beekman is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Michael E. Beekman, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael E. Beekman, Sr. and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. Beekman, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action

44

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 46 of 978

set forth herein. Michael E. Beekman, Sr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 238.

Plaintiff Inmaculada Behr is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of

Decedent Maria Behr, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Maria Behr and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 239.

Plaintiff George Behr is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of

Decedent Maria Behr, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maria Behr and on behalf of all survivors of Maria Behr and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maria Behr was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 240.

Plaintiff Emma Tisnovskiy is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Helen Belilovsky, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Helen Belilovsky and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 241.

Plaintiff Leonid Tisnovskiy is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Helen Belilovsky, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Helen Belilovsky and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 242.

Plaintiff Rostyslav Tisnovskiy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Helen Belilovsky, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Helen Belilovsky and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 243.

Plaintiff Boris Belilovsky is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Helen Belilovsky, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Helen Belilovsky and on behalf of all survivors of Helen

45

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 47 of 978

Belilovsky and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Helen Belilovsky was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 244.

Plaintiff Suzanne Abenmoha is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Debbie Bellows, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Debbie Bellows and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 245.

Plaintiff Sean Bellows is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent Debbie Bellows, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Debbie Bellows and on behalf of all survivors of Debbie Bellows and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Debbie Bellows was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 246.

Plaintiff Maria Giordano, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York,

and the Parent of Decedent Denise Lenore Benedetto; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 247.

Plaintiff Marina Benedetto is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Denise Lenore Benedetto, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Denise Lenore Benedetto and on behalf of all survivors of Denise Lenore Benedetto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Denise Lenore Benedetto was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 248.

Plaintiff Rina Rabinowitz is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Denise Lenore Benedetto, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

46

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 48 of 978

Denise Lenore Benedetto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 249.

Plaintiff Michael Giordano is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling

of Decedent Denise Lenore Benedetto, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Denise Lenore Benedetto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 250.

Plaintiff John Benedetto is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Denise Lenore Benedetto, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Denise Lenore Benedetto and on behalf of all survivors of Denise Lenore Benedetto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Denise Lenore Benedetto was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 251.

Plaintiff Ondina Bennett is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of

Decedent Bryan Craig Bennett, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bryan Craig Bennett and on behalf of all survivors of Bryan Craig Bennett and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bryan Craig Bennett was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 252.

Plaintiff Lourdes Bennett O'Connor is a resident of the State of Florida, the

Sibling of Decedent Bryan Craig Bennett, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Bryan Craig Bennett and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

47

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 49 of 978

253.

Plaintiff DOE 125 is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent DOE

125, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 125 and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 125 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 125 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 254.

Plaintiff DOE 125 is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent DOE

125, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 125 and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 125 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 125 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 255.

Plaintiff DOE 125 is a resident of the State of Maine, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 125, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 256.

Plaintiff Suzanne J. Berger is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent James P. Berger, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James P. Berger and on behalf of all survivors of James P. Berger and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James P. Berger was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 257.

Plaintiff Gary Berger is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent

Steven Howard Berger, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Steven Howard Berger and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

48

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 50 of 978

258.

Plaintiff Agnes Bergin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent John P. Bergin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John P. Bergin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 259.

Plaintiff Mary Ellen O'rourke is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent John P. Bergin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Bergin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 260.

Plaintiff George R. Bergin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent John P. Bergin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John P. Bergin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 261.

Plaintiff George M. Bergin is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent John P. Bergin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Bergin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 262.

Plaintiff Renee Hoffman is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Alvin Bergsohn, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alvin Bergsohn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 263.

Plaintiff Michele Zapken Bergsohn is a resident of the State of New York, the

Spouse of Decedent Alvin Bergsohn, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alvin Bergsohn and on behalf of all survivors of Alvin Bergsohn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alvin Bergsohn was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

49

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 51 of 978

264.

Plaintiff Kenneth Bergsohn is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Alvin Bergsohn, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Alvin Bergsohn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 265.

Plaintiff DOE 29 is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of

Decedent DOE 29, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 266.

Plaintiff DOE 29 is a resident of the state of Massachusetts, the Spouse of

Decedent DOE 29, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 29 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 29 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 29 was killed at Seven World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 267.

Plaintiff DOE 29 is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of

Decedent DOE 29, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 268.

Plaintiff DOE 29 is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of

Decedent DOE 29, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 269.

Plaintiff Norma Bernstein, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent William M. Bernstein; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

50

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 52 of 978

270.

Plaintiff Murray Bernstein, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent William M. Bernstein; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 271.

Plaintiff David M. Bernstein is a resident of the State of Hawaii, the Sibling of

Decedent William M. Bernstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of William M. Bernstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 272.

Plaintiff Robert J. Bernstein is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent William M. Bernstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William M. Bernstein and on behalf of all survivors of William M. Bernstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William M. Bernstein was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 273.

Plaintiff Kimberly A. Berry is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Joseph John Berry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Joseph John Berry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 274.

Plaintiff Evelyn Berry is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Joseph John Berry, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph John Berry and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph John Berry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph John Berry was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

51

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 53 of 978

275.

Plaintiff Todd P. Berry is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Joseph John Berry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Joseph John Berry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 276.

Plaintiff Joseph S. Berry is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Joseph John Berry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Joseph John Berry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 277.

Plaintiff Joan C. Betterly is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of

Decedent Timothy D. Betterly, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Timothy D. Betterly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 278.

Plaintiff Joanne F. Betterly is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Timothy D. Betterly, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Timothy D. Betterly and on behalf of all survivors of Timothy D. Betterly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy D. Betterly was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 279.

Plaintiff Donald A. Betterly, now deceased, was a resident of the State of

Pennsylvania, and the Parent of Decedent Timothy D. Betterly; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 280.

Plaintiff Mark Betterly is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Timothy D. Betterly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Timothy D. Betterly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

52

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 54 of 978

281.

Plaintiff Donald Betterly, Jr. is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling

of Decedent Timothy D. Betterly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Timothy D. Betterly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 282.

Plaintiff Indira Bhukhan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Bella J. Bhukhan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Bella J. Bhukhan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 283.

Plaintiff Jagdish Bhukhan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Bella J. Bhukhan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bella J. Bhukhan and on behalf of all survivors of Bella J. Bhukhan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bella J. Bhukhan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 284.

Plaintiff Irene Bilcher is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Brian Bilcher, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Brian Bilcher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 285.

Plaintiff Tina Marie Bilcher is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Brian Bilcher, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian Bilcher and on behalf of all survivors of Brian Bilcher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Bilcher was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

53

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 55 of 978

286.

Plaintiff Miles Bilcher is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Brian Bilcher, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Brian Bilcher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 287.

Plaintiff Alice Hoagland is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of

Decedent Mark K. Bingham, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark K. Bingham and on behalf of all survivors of Mark K. Bingham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark K. Bingham was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 288.

Plaintiff Gerald W. Bingham is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Mark K. Bingham, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Mark K. Bingham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 289.

Plaintiff Lillian Bini is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Carl Bini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Carl Bini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 290.

Plaintiff Rosemarie Corvino is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Carl Bini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Carl Bini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 291.

Plaintiff Raymond Bini, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York,

and the Parent of Decedent Carl Bini; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

54

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 56 of 978

292.

Plaintiff Basmattie Bishundat is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of

Decedent Kris Romeo Bishundat, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Kris Romeo Bishundat and on behalf of all survivors of Kris Romeo Bishundat and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kris Romeo Bishundat was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 293.

Plaintiff Bhola P. Bishundat is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of

Decedent Kris Romeo Bishundat, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Kris Romeo Bishundat and on behalf of all survivors of Kris Romeo Bishundat and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kris Romeo Bishundat was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 294.

Plaintiff Hyacinth Blackman is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 295.

Plaintiff Albert A. Blackman, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the

Parent of Decedent Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Albert Balewa Blackman, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as

55

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 57 of 978

a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 296.

Plaintiff Jane Blackwell is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Christopher Blackwell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Blackwell and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Blackwell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Blackwell was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 297.

Plaintiff Sally T. White is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of

Decedent Susan L. Blair, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Susan L. Blair and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 298.

Plaintiff Leslie R. Blair is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Susan L. Blair, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan L. Blair and on behalf of all survivors of Susan L. Blair and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susan L. Blair was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 299.

Plaintiff Daniel A. Walisiak is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Fiancé of

Decedent Susan L. Blair, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Fiancé of Susan L. Blair and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 300.

Plaintiff Scott Blaney is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Child of

Decedent Janice Blaney, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Janice Blaney and on behalf of all survivors of Janice Blaney and

56

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 58 of 978

is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Janice Blaney was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 301.

Plaintiff Barbara Lynn Blass is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Craig Michael Blass, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Craig Michael Blass and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 302.

Plaintiff Neil Blass, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and

the Parent of Decedent Craig Michael Blass; Barbara Lynn Blass brings this action as the the Representative of his Estate and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 303.

Plaintiff Keith Blass is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Craig Michael Blass, and brings this action on his own behalf and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Craig Michael Blass and on behalf of all survivors of Craig Michael Blass and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Craig Michael Blass was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 304.

Plaintiff Michele Buffolino is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of

Decedent Rita Blau, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Rita Blau and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 305.

Plaintiff Nicole Effress is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Rita Blau, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Rita Blau and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

57

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 59 of 978

306.

Plaintiff Ira Blau is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent

Rita Blau, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rita Blau and on behalf of all survivors of Rita Blau and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rita Blau was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 307.

Plaintiff Deborah A. Borza is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of

Decedent Deora Frances Bodley, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Deora Frances Bodley and on behalf of all survivors of Deora Frances Bodley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Deora Frances Bodley was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 308.

Plaintiff Derrill Bodley, now deceased, was a resident of the State of California,

and the Parent of Decedent Deora Frances Bodley; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 309.

Plaintiff Joyce Boland is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Vincent M. Boland, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Vincent M. Boland, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 310.

Plaintiff Erin Boland is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Vincent M. Boland, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Vincent M. Boland, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

58

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 60 of 978

311.

Plaintiff Gregory Boland is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Vincent M. Boland, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Vincent M. Boland, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 312.

Plaintiff Vincent Boland, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Vincent M. Boland, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent M. Boland, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent M. Boland, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent M. Boland, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 313.

Plaintiff DOE 118 is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent

DOE 118, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 314.

Plaintiff DOE 20 is a resident of the state of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent DOE

20, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 20 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 20 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 20 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 315.

Plaintiff William Bondarenko is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of

Decedent Alan Bondarenko, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alan Bondarenko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 316.

Plaintiff Joseph Bondarenko is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Alan Bondarenko, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alan Bondarenko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

59

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 61 of 978

317.

Plaintiff Roxane Bonheur is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent Andre Bonheur, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andre Bonheur, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Andre Bonheur, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andre Bonheur, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 318.

Plaintiff Sonia Bonomo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Yvonne Bonomo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Yvonne Bonomo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 319.

Plaintiff John Bonomo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Yvonne Bonomo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Yvonne Bonomo and on behalf of all survivors of Yvonne Bonomo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Yvonne Bonomo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 320.

Plaintiff George Bonomo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Yvonne Bonomo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Yvonne Bonomo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 321.

Plaintiff Rose Ann Booker is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Sean Booker, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Sean Booker and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 322.

Plaintiff Sharon Booker is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Sean Booker, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

60

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 62 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Sean Booker and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Booker and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean Booker was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 323.

Plaintiff Richard L. Booms is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Parent of

Decedent Kelly Ann Booms, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kelly Ann Booms and on behalf of all survivors of Kelly Ann Booms and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kelly Ann Booms was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 324.

Plaintiff Deanna G. Demotte is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Sibling of

Decedent Canfield D. Boone, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Canfield D. Boone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 325.

Plaintiff Linda K. Boone is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of

Decedent Canfield D. Boone, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Canfield D. Boone and on behalf of all survivors of Canfield D. Boone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Canfield D. Boone was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 326.

Plaintiff Jason Boone is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent

Canfield D. Boone, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Canfield D. Boone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

61

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 63 of 978

327.

Plaintiff Andrew Boone is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Canfield D. Boone, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Canfield D. Boone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 328.

Plaintiff Christopher Boone is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Child of

Decedent Canfield D. Boone, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Canfield D. Boone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 329.

Plaintiff Krystyna Boryczewski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent

of Decedent Martin Boryczewski, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Boryczewski and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Boryczewski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martin Boryczewski was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 330.

Plaintiff Michele Boryczewski is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the

Sibling of Decedent Martin Boryczewski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Boryczewski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 331.

Plaintiff Julia Boryczewski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Martin Boryczewski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Boryczewski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 332.

Plaintiff Michael Boryczewski, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Martin Boryczewski; MICHELE BORYCZEWSKI and JULIA BORYCZEWSKI bring this action as Co-Administrators of his Estate and are entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

62

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 64 of 978

333.

Plaintiff William J. Bosco, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Richard E. Bosco, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Richard E. Bosco and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 334.

Plaintiff Hope DelleFemine, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Rhode

Island, and the Parent of Decedent Carol Marie Bouchard; the Representative of her Estate Kenneth E. Dellefemine brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 335.

Plaintiff Kenneth E. DelleFemine is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the

Sibling of Decedent Carol Marie Bouchard, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Carol Marie Bouchard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 336.

Plaintiff Richard E. DelleFemine is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the

Sibling of Decedent Carol Marie Bouchard, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Carol Marie Bouchard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 337.

Plaintiff Frederick Earl Bouchard, Jr. is a resident of the State of Rhode Island,

the Spouse of Decedent Carol Marie Bouchard, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carol Marie Bouchard and on behalf of all survivors of Carol Marie Bouchard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carol Marie Bouchard was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

63

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 65 of 978

338.

Plaintiff DOE 119 is a resident of Venezuela, the Parent of Decedent DOE 119,

and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 339.

Plaintiff DOE 119 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent

DOE 119, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 119 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 119 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 119 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 340.

Plaintiff DOE 119 is a resident of Venezuela, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 119,

and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 341.

Plaintiff Sheilah L. Bowden is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Thomas H. Bowden, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 342.

Plaintiff Kathryn C. Bowden is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Thomas H. Bowden, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 343.

Plaintiff Thomas H. Bowden is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Thomas H. Bowden, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of

64

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 66 of 978

Thomas H. Bowden, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 344.

Plaintiff Paul Bowden is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Thomas H. Bowden, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas H. Bowden, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 345.

Plaintiff Ruth Bowman White is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Larry Bowman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Larry Bowman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 346.

Plaintiff Stephanie Ayn Bowser is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the

Spouse of Decedent Kevin Leah Bowser, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin Leah Bowser and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Leah Bowser and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Leah Bowser was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 347.

Plaintiff Bella Boyarsky is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Gennady Boyarsky, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gennady Boyarsky and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 348.

Plaintiff Vladimir Boyarsky is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Gennady Boyarsky, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Gennady Boyarsky and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 349.

Plaintiff Laura Alessi is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Pamela J. Boyce, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the

65

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 67 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Pamela J. Boyce and on behalf of all survivors of Pamela J. Boyce and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pamela J. Boyce was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 350.

Plaintiff Gina Grassi is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Pamela J. Boyce, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Pamela J. Boyce and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 351.

Plaintiff Desiree A. Gerasimovich is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Pamela J. Boyce, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Pamela J. Boyce and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 352.

Plaintiff Deanna Wirth is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent

Alfred J. Braca, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Alfred J. Braca and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 353.

Plaintiff Christina Cambeis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Alfred J. Braca, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Alfred J. Braca and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 354.

Plaintiff David John Braca is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Alfred J. Braca, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alfred J. Braca and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 355.

Plaintiff Christopher Jonathan Braca is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Child of Decedent Alfred J. Braca, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alfred J. Braca and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

66

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 68 of 978

356.

Plaintiff Nelly Braginsky is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Alexander Braginsky, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alexander Braginsky and on behalf of all survivors of Alexander Braginsky and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alexander Braginsky was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 357.

Plaintiff Nancy Brandemarti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Nicholas W. Brandemarti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Nicholas W. Brandemarti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 358.

Plaintiff Nicole Brandemarti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Nicholas W. Brandemarti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Nicholas W. Brandemarti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 359.

Plaintiff Nicholas M. Brandemarti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Nicholas W. Brandemarti, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nicholas W. Brandemarti and on behalf of all survivors of Nicholas W. Brandemarti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nicholas W. Brandemarti was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 360.

Plaintiff Jason Brandemarti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Nicholas W. Brandemarti, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of

67

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 69 of 978

Nicholas W. Brandemarti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 361.

Plaintiff David B. Brandhorst is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Daniel Raymond Brandhorst, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Raymond Brandhorst and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Raymond Brandhorst and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Raymond Brandhorst was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 362.

Plaintiff Mary E. Bratton is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michelle Renee Bratton, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michelle Renee Bratton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 363.

Plaintiff Erin G. Bratton is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michelle Renee Bratton, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michelle Renee Bratton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 364.

Plaintiff Christopher B. Bratton is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Michelle Renee Bratton, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michelle Renee Bratton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 365.

Plaintiff William J. Bratton, III is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Michelle Renee Bratton, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of

68

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 70 of 978

Michelle Renee Bratton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 366.

Plaintiff William J. Bratton, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Michelle Renee Bratton, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michelle Renee Bratton and on behalf of all survivors of Michelle Renee Bratton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michelle Renee Bratton was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 367.

Plaintiff Paola Storer is a resident of Belgium, the Parent of Decedent Patrice

Braut, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patrice Braut and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 368.

Plaintiff Michel Braut is a resident of Belgium, the Parent of Decedent Patrice

Braut, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Patrice Braut and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 369.

Plaintiff Anthony Bengivenga is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé

of Decedent Lydia Bravo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Fiancé of Lydia Bravo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 370.

Plaintiff Barbara H. Brennan is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the

Spouse of Decedent Francis H. Brennan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francis H. Brennan and on behalf of all survivors of Francis H. Brennan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francis H. Brennan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

69

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 71 of 978

371.

Plaintiff Eileen Walsh is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael E. Brennan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael E. Brennan and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. Brennan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael E. Brennan was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 372.

Plaintiff Veronica Brennan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael E. Brennan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 373.

Plaintiff Mary M. Walsh is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael E. Brennan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 374.

Plaintiff Patricia Walsh is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael E. Brennan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 375.

Plaintiff Margaret Walsh is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael E. Brennan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 376.

Plaintiff Michael Brennan, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Michael E. Brennan; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

70

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 72 of 978

377.

Plaintiff Brian T. Brennan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael E. Brennan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 378.

Plaintiff Matthew J. Walsh is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael E. Brennan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 379.

Plaintiff James John Brennan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Michael E. Brennan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael E. Brennan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 380.

Plaintiff Carol A Brethel is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Daniel J Brethel, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel J Brethel and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel J Brethel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel J Brethel was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 381.

Plaintiff Jacqueline Iskols is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Mark Brisman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Brisman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 382.

Plaintiff Michele Priest is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of

Decedent Mark Brisman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Brisman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 383.

Plaintiff Juliette Brisman is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of

Decedent Mark Brisman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

71

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 73 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Mark Brisman and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Brisman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Brisman was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 384.

Plaintiff Gerard Brisman is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of

Decedent Mark Brisman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Mark Brisman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 385.

Plaintiff Steven A. Brisman is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Mark Brisman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Brisman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 386.

Plaintiff DOE 127 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent

DOE 127, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 387.

Plaintiff DOE 127 is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent DOE

127, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 127 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 127 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 127 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 388.

Plaintiff Isoline Broomfield is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Keith Broomfield, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Keith Broomfield and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

72

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 74 of 978

389.

Plaintiff Sinita Brown is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Parent of

Decedent Bernard Curtis Brown, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Bernard Curtis Brown, II and on behalf of all survivors of Bernard Curtis Brown, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bernard Curtis Brown, II was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 390.

Plaintiff Bernard Curtis Brown, I is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the

Parent of Decedent Bernard Curtis Brown, II, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Bernard Curtis Brown, II and on behalf of all survivors of Bernard Curtis Brown, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bernard Curtis Brown, II was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 391.

Plaintiff Everton James Brown is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Lloyd Brown, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Lloyd Brown and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 392.

Plaintiff Carolyn M. Negron is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick J. Brown, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick J. Brown and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 393.

Plaintiff Michael Everett Brown is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Sibling

of Decedent Patrick J. Brown, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick J. Brown and on behalf of all survivors of

73

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 75 of 978

Patrick J. Brown and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick J. Brown was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 394.

Plaintiff Sigalit Brunn is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Andrew C. Brunn, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andrew C. Brunn and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew C. Brunn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andrew C. Brunn was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 395.

Plaintiff Charilyn S. Buchanan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Brandon J. Buchanan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Brandon J. Buchanan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 396.

Plaintiff Ronald B. Buchanan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Brandon J. Buchanan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brandon J. Buchanan and on behalf of all survivors of Brandon J. Buchanan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brandon J. Buchanan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 397.

Plaintiff Josephine Buck is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Gregory J. Buck, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gregory J. Buck and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 398.

Plaintiff Catherine Morrison Buck is a resident of the State of New York, the

Spouse of Decedent Gregory J. Buck, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as

74

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 76 of 978

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory J. Buck and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory J. Buck and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory J. Buck was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 399.

Plaintiff Ernst H. Buck is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Gregory J. Buck, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Gregory J. Buck and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 400.

Plaintiff Eric Buck is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent

Gregory J. Buck, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gregory J. Buck and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 401.

Plaintiff Kathleen M. Buckley, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Dennis Buckley; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 402.

Plaintiff Jane Marie Smithwick is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Dennis Buckley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dennis Buckley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 403.

Plaintiff Kathleen M. Buckley is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse

of Decedent Dennis Buckley, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis Buckley and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis Buckley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis Buckley was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

75

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 77 of 978

404.

Plaintiff John C. Buckley is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Dennis Buckley, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Dennis Buckley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 405.

Plaintiff Helen R. McNulty, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Nancy Clare Bueche; Charles Gavin McNulty brings this action as the Representative of her Estate and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 406.

Plaintiff Mary Ellen McNulty, now deceased, was a resident of the State of

Connecticut, and the Sibling of Decedent Nancy Clare Bueche; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 407.

Plaintiff Stephen J. McNulty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Nancy Clare Bueche, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Nancy Clare Bueche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 408.

Plaintiff Martin L. McNulty is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Nancy Clare Bueche, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Nancy Clare Bueche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 409.

Plaintiff James T. Bueche is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Nancy Clare Bueche, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nancy Clare Bueche and on behalf of all survivors of Nancy Clare Bueche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nancy Clare Bueche was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

76

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 78 of 978

410.

Plaintiff Charles Gavin McNulty is a resident of the State of New York, the

Sibling of Decedent Nancy Clare Bueche, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Nancy Clare Bueche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 411.

Plaintiff Fran (Frances) Bulaga is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent

of Decedent John E. Bulaga, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John E. Bulaga, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 412.

Plaintiff Gail M. Bulaga is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent John E. Bulaga, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John E. Bulaga, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 413.

Plaintiff Michelle A. Bulaga is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse

of Decedent John E. Bulaga, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John E. Bulaga, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of John E. Bulaga, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John E. Bulaga, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 414.

Plaintiff John E. Bulaga, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent John E. Bulaga, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John E. Bulaga, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 415.

Plaintiff Aseneth Bunin, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York,

and the Spouse of Decedent Stephen Bunin; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. The Representative of the Estate of Decedent Stephen Bunin brings this action and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen

77

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 79 of 978

Bunin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Bunin was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001 416.

Plaintiff Corinne Bunin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Stephen Bunin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Stephen Bunin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 417.

Plaintiff Kitty Bunin is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Stephen Bunin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Bunin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 418.

Plaintiff Alicia P. Burke is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Matthew J. Burke, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Matthew J. Burke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 419.

Plaintiff John J. Burke is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Matthew J. Burke, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew J. Burke and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew J. Burke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew J. Burke was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 420.

Plaintiff Chris Burke is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Thomas Daniel Burke, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Daniel Burke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 421.

Plaintiff James M. Burke is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent William F. Burke, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the

78

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 80 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of William F. Burke, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of William F. Burke, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William F. Burke, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 422.

Plaintiff Wendy Burlingame, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Child of Decedent Charles F. Burlingame, III; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 423.

Plaintiff Debra Burlingame is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Charles F. Burlingame, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Charles F. Burlingame, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 424.

Plaintiff Mark W. Burlingame is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the

Sibling of Decedent Charles F. Burlingame, III, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Charles F. Burlingame, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 425.

Plaintiff Bradley M. Burlingame is a resident of the State of California, the

Sibling of Decedent Charles F. Burlingame, III, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Charles F. Burlingame, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 426.

Plaintiff Agnes Delores Burns is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the

Parent of Decedent Keith James Burns, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Keith James Burns and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

79

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 81 of 978

427.

Plaintiff Colleen Cooper is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Keith James Burns, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Keith James Burns and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 428.

Plaintiff Linda Ellicott is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Keith James Burns, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Keith James Burns and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 429.

Plaintiff Maureen Burns-Dewland is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the

Sibling of Decedent Keith James Burns, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Keith James Burns and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 430.

Plaintiff Diane Marie Shepherd is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Sibling of

Decedent Keith James Burns, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Keith James Burns and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 431.

Plaintiff Jennifer C. Burns is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of

Decedent Keith James Burns, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith James Burns and on behalf of all survivors of Keith James Burns and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Keith James Burns was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 432.

Plaintiff Bernard J. Burns, now deceased, was a resident of the State of

Pennsylvania, and the Parent of Decedent Keith James Burns; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

80

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 82 of 978

433.

Plaintiff Michael John Burns is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Keith James Burns, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Keith James Burns and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 434.

Plaintiff Sandra Burnside is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent John P. Burnside, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John P. Burnside and on behalf of all survivors of John P. Burnside and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John P. Burnside was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 435.

Plaintiff Anne Byrne is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 436.

Plaintiff Judith Byrne is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 437.

Plaintiff Cathrine M. Tolino is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 438.

Plaintiff Joanne Finn is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

81

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 83 of 978

439.

Plaintiff William J. Byrne is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 440.

Plaintiff Thomas Byrne is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 441.

Plaintiff Garett C. Byrne is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 442.

Plaintiff Francis X. Byrne is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 443.

Plaintiff Robert G. Byrne, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 444.

Plaintiff Robert G. Byrne, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Patrick D. Byrne, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick D. Byrne and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick D. Byrne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick D. Byrne was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 445.

Plaintiff Victoria Cabezas is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Jesus Cabezas, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

82

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 84 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Jesus Cabezas and on behalf of all survivors of Jesus Cabezas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jesus Cabezas was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 446.

Plaintiff Julio Caceres is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Lillian Caceres, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lillian Caceres and on behalf of all survivors of Lillian Caceres and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lillian Caceres was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 447.

Plaintiff Grace Kneski is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Parent of

Decedent Steven Cafiero, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Cafiero and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Cafiero and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Cafiero was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 448.

Plaintiff Veronica Caggiano is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Richard M. Caggiano, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard M. Caggiano and on behalf of all survivors of Richard M. Caggiano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard M. Caggiano was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

83

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 85 of 978

449.

Plaintiff DOE 105 is a resident of the Philippines, the Sibling of Decedent DOE

105 , and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 450.

Plaintiff DOE 105 is a resident of the Philippines, the Sibling of Decedent DOE

105 , and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 451.

Plaintiff DOE 105 is a resident of the Philippines, the Sibling of Decedent DOE

105 , and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 452.

Plaintiff DOE 105 is a resident of Australia, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 105 ,

and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 453.

Plaintiff DOE 105 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 105 , and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 105 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 105 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 105 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 454.

Plaintiff DOE 105 is a resident of the Philippines, the Sibling of Decedent DOE

105 , and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 455.

Plaintiff Sharon Cahill Castle is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent John B. Cahill, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

84

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 86 of 978

Representative of the Estate of John B. Cahill and on behalf of all survivors of John B. Cahill and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John B. Cahill was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 456.

Plaintiff Evelyn Cahill is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Cahill, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Cahill and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 457.

Plaintiff Denise Troise is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael Cahill, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Cahill and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 458.

Plaintiff Colleen Cahill is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Michael Cahill, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Cahill and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Cahill and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Cahill was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 459.

Plaintiff James Cahill is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Cahill, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael Cahill and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 460.

Plaintiff Rosemary Cain is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent George C. Cain, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George C. Cain and on behalf of all survivors of George C. Cain

85

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 87 of 978

and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George C. Cain was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 461.

Plaintiff DOE 67 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent

DOE 67, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 67 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 67 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 67 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 462.

Plaintiff Gloria Esperanza Calderon-Garcia is a resident of the State of Virginia,

the Spouse of Decedent Jose Orlando Calderon-Olmedo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jose Orlando CalderonOlmedo and on behalf of all survivors of Jose Orlando Calderon-Olmedo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jose Orlando Calderon-Olmedo was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 463.

Plaintiff Joan E. Callahan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Liam Callahan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Liam Callahan and on behalf of all survivors of Liam Callahan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Liam Callahan was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

86

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 88 of 978

464.

Plaintiff Ellen Callahan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Liam Callahan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Liam Callahan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 465.

Plaintiff James Callahan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Liam Callahan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Liam Callahan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 466.

Plaintiff Bridget Gannello is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Liam Callahan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Liam Callahan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 467.

Plaintiff Norma J. Keleher is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of

Decedent Suzanne M. Calley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Suzanne M. Calley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 468.

Plaintiff Frank Jensen is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of

Decedent Suzanne M. Calley, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Suzanne M. Calley and on behalf of all survivors of Suzanne M. Calley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Suzanne M. Calley was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 469.

Plaintiff Linda Cammarata, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Michael F. Cammarata; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

87

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 89 of 978

470.

Plaintiff Kimberly Cammarata is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Michael F. Cammarata, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael F. Cammarata and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 471.

Plaintiff Joseph Cammarata is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Michael F. Cammarata, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael F. Cammarata and on behalf of all survivors of Michael F. Cammarata and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael F. Cammarata was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 472.

Plaintiff Joseph Cammarata, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Michael F. Cammarata, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael F. Cammarata and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 473.

Plaintiff Cynthia J. Campbell is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse

of Decedent David Otey Campbell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Otey Campbell and on behalf of all survivors of David Otey Campbell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Otey Campbell was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 474.

Plaintiff Malcolm Phillip Campbell is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of

Decedent Geoff Thomas Campbell, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Geoff Thomas Campbell and on behalf of all survivors of Geoff Thomas Campbell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

88

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 90 of 978

herein. Geoff Thomas Campbell was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 475.

Plaintiff Jeanne M. Maurer is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Jill Marie Campbell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jill Marie Campbell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 476.

Plaintiff Linda Maurer is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jill Marie Campbell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jill Marie Campbell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 477.

Plaintiff Joseph Maurer is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Jill Marie Campbell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jill Marie Campbell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 478.

Plaintiff Steven T. Campbell is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Jill Marie Campbell, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jill Marie Campbell and on behalf of all survivors of Jill Marie Campbell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jill Marie Campbell was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 479.

Plaintiff Margaret Canavan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Sean Canavan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Canavan and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Canavan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean Canavan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

89

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 91 of 978

480.

Plaintiff Kathleen McKeon is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Sean Canavan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Canavan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 481.

Plaintiff Teresa McCaffery is a resident of Ireland, the Sibling of Decedent Sean

Canavan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Canavan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 482.

Plaintiff Rosemary Celine Traynor is a resident of Ireland, the Sibling of

Decedent Sean Canavan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Canavan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 483.

Plaintiff Thomas Canavan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Sean Canavan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Sean Canavan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 484.

Plaintiff Ciaran Canavan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Sean Canavan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Canavan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 485.

Plaintiff Helen Jeffrey Cangialosi is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Stephen J. Cangialosi, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Stephen J. Cangialosi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 486.

Plaintiff Kathleen Cangialosi Rue is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Stephen J. Cangialosi, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen J. Cangialosi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

90

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 92 of 978

487.

Plaintiff Elizabeth Anne Dickey is a resident of the State of Vermont, the Sibling

of Decedent Stephen J. Cangialosi, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen J. Cangialosi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 488.

Plaintiff Karen D. Cangialosi is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse

of Decedent Stephen J. Cangialosi, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen J. Cangialosi and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen J. Cangialosi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen J. Cangialosi was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 489.

Plaintiff Thomas Jerome Cangialosi is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Stephen J. Cangialosi, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Stephen J. Cangialosi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 490.

Plaintiff Thomas J. Cangialosi, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Stephen J. Cangialosi, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen J. Cangialosi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 491.

Plaintiff Teresa DiFato is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Lisa Cannava, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Lisa Cannava and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 492.

Plaintiff Antonio DiFato is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Lisa Cannava, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Lisa Cannava and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

91

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 93 of 978

493.

Plaintiff Richard Cannava is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Lisa Cannava, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lisa Cannava and on behalf of all survivors of Lisa Cannava and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lisa Cannava was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 494.

Plaintiff Carol Cannizzaro is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Brian Cannizzaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Brian Cannizzaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 495.

Plaintiff Simone Cannizzaro is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Brian Cannizzaro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Brian Cannizzaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 496.

Plaintiff Charles Cannizzaro is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Brian Cannizzaro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Brian Cannizzaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 497.

Plaintiff Craig Cannizzaro is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Brian Cannizzaro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Brian Cannizzaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 498.

Plaintiff Erin Ryan is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent

Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

92

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 94 of 978

499.

Plaintiff Kathryn F. Canty is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 500.

Plaintiff Catherine Deasy is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling

of Decedent Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 501.

Plaintiff Mary K. Canty is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 502.

Plaintiff Edward J. Canty is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael R. Canty and on behalf of all survivors of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael R. Canty was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 503.

Plaintiff Thomas P. Canty is a resident of Germany, the Sibling of Decedent

Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 504.

Plaintiff Peter M. Canty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

93

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 95 of 978

505.

Plaintiff James E. Canty is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 506.

Plaintiff Timothy M. Canty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 507.

Plaintiff John W. Canty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 508.

Plaintiff William J. Canty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael R. Canty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael R. Canty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 509.

Plaintiff Patricia Caporicci is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Louis A. Caporicci, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Louis A. Caporicci and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 510.

Plaintiff Nicholas Caporicci is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Louis A. Caporicci, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Louis A. Caporicci and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 511.

Plaintiff Joseph Caporicci is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Louis A. Caporicci, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Louis A. Caporicci and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

94

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 96 of 978

512.

Plaintiff Frank Caporicci is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Louis A. Caporicci, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Louis A. Caporicci and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 513.

Plaintiff Nicholas F. Caporicci, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Louis A. Caporicci, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Louis A. Caporicci and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 514.

Plaintiff Claudia Cappello is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Jonathan Cappello, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jonathan Cappello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 515.

Plaintiff James Cappello is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jonathan Cappello, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jonathan Cappello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 516.

Plaintiff Robert E. Cappello, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Jonathan Cappello, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jonathan Cappello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 517.

Plaintiff Robert Cappello, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Jonathan Cappello, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jonathan Cappello and on behalf of all survivors of Jonathan Cappello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jonathan Cappello was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 518.

Plaintiff Kathleen Cappers is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent James C. Cappers, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

95

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 97 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of James C. Cappers and on behalf of all survivors of James C. Cappers and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James C. Cappers was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 519.

Plaintiff Dolores Caproni is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of

Decedent Richard M. Caproni, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Richard M. Caproni and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 520.

Plaintiff Lisa Caproni is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard M. Caproni, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard M. Caproni and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 521.

Plaintiff Richard A. Caproni is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of

Decedent Richard M. Caproni, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard M. Caproni and on behalf of all survivors of Richard M. Caproni and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard M. Caproni was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 522.

Plaintiff Christopher Caproni is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard M. Caproni, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard M. Caproni and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 523.

Plaintiff Michael Caproni is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard M. Caproni, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard M. Caproni and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

96

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 98 of 978

524.

Plaintiff Nicole T. Carey is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Dennis M. Carey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Dennis M. Carey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 525.

Plaintiff Jean Carey is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Dennis M. Carey, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis M. Carey and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis M. Carey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis M. Carey was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 526.

Plaintiff Dennis M. Carey, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Dennis M. Carey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Dennis M. Carey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 527.

Plaintiff Phyllis Carlo is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent

Michael Scott Carlo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Scott Carlo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 528.

Plaintiff Robert D. Carlo is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Scott Carlo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael Scott Carlo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 529.

Plaintiff Robert E. Carlo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael Scott Carlo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Scott Carlo and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Scott Carlo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

97

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 99 of 978

Michael Scott Carlo was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 530.

Plaintiff Craig D. Carlson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, brings this

action on behalf of the minor children K.C., S.R.C., D.C., and J.D.C. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 531.

Plaintiff Catherine Mary Ross is a resident of France, the Parent of Decedent

Jeremy Mark Carrington, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jeremy Mark Carrington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 532.

Plaintiff DOE 128 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 128, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 533.

Plaintiff Sarah Jane Carrington is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of

Decedent Jeremy Mark Carrington, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jeremy Mark Carrington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 534.

Plaintiff DOE 128 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent

DOE 128, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 535.

Plaintiff Mary E. Jones is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of

Decedent Christoffer Mikael Carstanjen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Christoffer Mikael Carstanjen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

98

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 100 of 978

536.

Plaintiff Mikael Carstanjen is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent

of Decedent Christoffer Mikael Carstanjen, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christoffer Mikael Carstanjen and on behalf of all survivors of Christoffer Mikael Carstanjen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christoffer Mikael Carstanjen was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 537.

Plaintiff Michelle Wright is a resident of the State of California, the Child of

Decedent Sandra Wright Cartledge, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Sandra Wright Cartledge and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 538.

Plaintiff Stephen Cartledge is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent Sandra Wright Cartledge, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sandra Wright Cartledge and on behalf of all survivors of Sandra Wright Cartledge and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sandra Wright Cartledge was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 539.

Plaintiff Tangela Wilkes is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of

Decedent Sharon Ann Carver, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 540.

Plaintiff Janet Carver is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling of

Decedent Sharon Ann Carver, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

99

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 101 of 978

541.

Plaintiff Veronica Carver is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling of

Decedent Sharon Ann Carver, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 542.

Plaintiff Sylvia Annette Carver is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling

of Decedent Sharon Ann Carver, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sharon Ann Carver and on behalf of all survivors of Sharon Ann Carver and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sharon Ann Carver was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 543.

Plaintiff Reginald Carver is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of

Decedent Sharon Ann Carver, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 544.

Plaintiff Arthur Carver is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of

Decedent Sharon Ann Carver, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sharon Ann Carver and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 545.

Plaintiff DOE 06 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent

DOE 06, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 06 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 06 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 06 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 546.

Plaintiff Mary Ann Hunt, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York,

and the Parent of Decedent Kathleen Ann Hunt Casey; the Co-Representatives of her Estate,

100

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 102 of 978

Maureen Hunt and Eileen Ann Mosca, bring this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 547.

Plaintiff Maureen Hunt is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Kathleen Ann Hunt Casey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kathleen Ann Hunt Casey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 548.

Plaintiff Eileen Ann Mosca is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Kathleen Ann Hunt Casey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kathleen Ann Hunt Casey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 549.

Plaintiff Anne T. Heffernan is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent

of Decedent Neilie Anne Heffernan Casey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Neilie Anne Heffernan Casey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 550.

Plaintiff Michael W. Casey is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse

of Decedent Neilie Anne Heffernan Casey, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Neilie Anne Heffernan Casey and on behalf of all survivors of Neilie Anne Heffernan Casey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neilie Anne Heffernan Casey was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 551.

Plaintiff Margaret Ann Cashman is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Spouse of Decedent William Joseph Cashman, and brings this action on her own behalf as

101

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 103 of 978

Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Joseph Cashman and on behalf of all survivors of William Joseph Cashman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Joseph Cashman was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 552.

Plaintiff Teresa A. Lanzisero is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of

Decedent Thomas A. Casoria, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Thomas A. Casoria and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 553.

Plaintiff DOE 30 is a resident of the state of Massachusetts, the Sibling of

Decedent DOE 30, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 554.

Plaintiff DOE 30 is a resident of the state of Kansas, the Sibling of Decedent DOE

30, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 30 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 30 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 30 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 555.

Plaintiff DOE 30, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Kansas, and the

Parent of Decedent DOE 30; the Representative of the Estate of Parent DOE 30 brings this action on behalf of his estate and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 556.

Plaintiff DOE 30, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Kansas, and the

Parent of Decedent DOE 30; the Representative of the Estate of Parent DOE 30 brings this action on behalf of her estate and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

102

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 104 of 978

557.

Plaintiff Lynn M. Castrianno is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Sibling of

Decedent Leonard Castrianno, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard Castrianno and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 558.

Plaintiff Alison Gail Henderson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Christopher Sean Caton, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Sean Caton and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Sean Caton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Sean Caton was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 559.

Plaintiff Linda Alicia Cavalier is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Judson Cavalier, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Judson Cavalier and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 560.

Plaintiff Andrew Cavalier is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Judson Cavalier, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Judson Cavalier and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 561.

Plaintiff Bradford Cavalier is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Judson Cavalier, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Judson Cavalier and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 562.

Plaintiff Gerard C. Cavalier, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Judson Cavalier, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Judson Cavalier and on behalf of all survivors of Judson Cavalier and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Judson

103

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 105 of 978

Cavalier was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 563.

Plaintiff Margaret M. Cawley is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Joseph Cawley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Joseph Cawley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 564.

Plaintiff Kristin A. Cawley is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael Joseph Cawley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Cawley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 565.

Plaintiff John J. Cawley is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Joseph Cawley, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Joseph Cawley and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Joseph Cawley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Joseph Cawley was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 566.

Plaintiff Brendan K. Cawley is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael Joseph Cawley, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Cawley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 567.

Plaintiff Suzan Cayne is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Jason David Cayne, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jason David Cayne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

104

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 106 of 978

568.

Plaintiff Jordan Cayne is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Jason David Cayne, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jason David Cayne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 569.

Plaintiff DOE 50 is a resident of the state of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent DOE 50, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 570.

Plaintiff DOE 50 is a resident of the state of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent DOE 50, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 571.

Plaintiff DOE 50 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent

DOE 50, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 50 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 50 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 50 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 572.

Plaintiff Lakshmi Chalasani is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Swarna Chalasani, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Swarna Chalasani and on behalf of all survivors of Swarna Chalasani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Swarna Chalasani was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

105

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 107 of 978

573.

Plaintiff Sujana Chalasani is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Sibling

of Decedent Swarna Chalasani, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Swarna Chalasani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 574.

Plaintiff Sandhya Chalasani is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Swarna Chalasani, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Swarna Chalasani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 575.

Plaintiff Nageswararao Chalasani is a resident of the State of New York, the

Parent of Decedent Swarna Chalasani, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Swarna Chalasani and on behalf of all survivors of Swarna Chalasani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Swarna Chalasani was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 576.

Plaintiff Venkateswanango Chalasani is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Swarna Chalasani, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Swarna Chalasani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 577.

Plaintiff Mable Chalcoff is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent William Chalcoff, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Chalcoff and on behalf of all survivors of William Chalcoff and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Chalcoff was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 578.

Plaintiff Haim Chalouh is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Eli Chalouh, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal

106

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 108 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Eli Chalouh and on behalf of all survivors of Eli Chalouh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eli Chalouh was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 579.

Plaintiff Julia Chan is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Parent of Decedent

Charles L. Chan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles L. Chan and on behalf of all survivors of Charles L. Chan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles L. Chan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 580.

Plaintiff John Oland Chan is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Parent of

Decedent Charles L. Chan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Charles L. Chan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 581.

Plaintiff Christopher J. Chan is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling of

Decedent Charles L. Chan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Charles L. Chan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 582.

Plaintiff Mark A. Chan is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling of

Decedent Charles L. Chan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Charles L. Chan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 583.

Plaintiff Matthew P. Chan is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling of

Decedent Charles L. Chan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Charles L. Chan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

107

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 109 of 978

584.

Plaintiff Craig A. Chan is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling of

Decedent Charles L. Chan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Charles L. Chan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 585.

Plaintiff Grace Elaine Ellis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Rosa M. Chapa, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Rosa M. Chapa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 586.

Plaintiff Elza m. McGowan is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of

Decedent Rosa M. Chapa, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Executor of the Estate of Rosa M. Chapa and on behalf of all survivors of Rosa M. Chapa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rosa M. Chapa was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 587.

Plaintiff Julie Chapa Field is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Child of

Decedent Rosa M. Chapa, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Rosa M. Chapa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 588.

Plaintiff Jose Javier Chapa, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Virginia,

and the Spouse of Decedent Rosa M. Chapa; the Representative of his Estate, Julie Chapa Field, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 589.

Plaintiff John L. Chapa, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Virginia, and

the Child of Decedent Rosa M. Chapa; the Representative of his Estate, Denise Reid Chapa, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

108

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 110 of 978

590.

Plaintiff Roger A. Chapa is a resident of the State of California, the Child of

Decedent Rosa M. Chapa, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Rosa M. Chapa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 591.

Plaintiff Cheryl A. Desmarais is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse

of Decedent Mark L. Charette, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark L. Charette and on behalf of all survivors of Mark L. Charette and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark L. Charette was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 592.

Plaintiff Denise Burger is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of

Decedent David Michael Charlebois, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of David Michael Charlebois and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 593.

Plaintiff Marmily Cabrera is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Pedro Checo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Pedro Checo and on behalf of all survivors of Pedro Checo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pedro Checo was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 594.

Plaintiff Sharon Ritchie Mullin is a resident of the State of California, the Parent

of Decedent Stephen Patrick Cherry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Stephen Patrick Cherry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

109

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 111 of 978

595.

Plaintiff Mary Ellen Cherry is a resident of the State of Idaho, the Spouse of

Decedent Stephen Patrick Cherry, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen Patrick Cherry and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Patrick Cherry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Patrick Cherry was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 596.

Plaintiff Donald R. Cherry is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Parent of

Decedent Stephen Patrick Cherry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Stephen Patrick Cherry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 597.

Plaintiff Shawn R. Cherry is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Stephen Patrick Cherry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Patrick Cherry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 598.

Plaintiff Zeneida Chevalier is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 599.

Plaintiff Mauricio Chevalier is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of

110

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 112 of 978

Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 600.

Plaintiff Nestor J. Chevalier, Sr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Nestor Julio Chevalier, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 601.

Plaintiff DOE 55 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent

DOE 55, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 55 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 55 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 55 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 602.

Plaintiff DOE 55 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 55,

and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 603.

Plaintiff DOE 55 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE

55, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 604.

Plaintiff Vernon F. Chevalier, Jr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Swede Joseph Chevalier, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Swede Joseph Chevalier and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

111

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 113 of 978

605.

Plaintiff Lisa Maria Dreher is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 606.

Plaintiff Irene Arguelles is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 607.

Plaintiff Evelyn Diaz is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 608.

Plaintiff Nicholas James Chiarchiaro is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Child of Decedent Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 609.

Plaintiff Nicholas Mario Chiarchiaro, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York,

the Spouse of Decedent Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro and on behalf of all survivors of Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dorothy J. Chiarchiaro was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 610.

Plaintiff Joan A. Chiofalo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Nicholas Paul Chiofalo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nicholas Paul Chiofalo and on behalf of all survivors of

112

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 114 of 978

Nicholas Paul Chiofalo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nicholas Paul Chiofalo was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 611.

Plaintiff Eileen Chipura Cella is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent John G. Chipura, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John G. Chipura and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 612.

Plaintiff Nancy J. Chipura is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent John G. Chipura, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John G. Chipura and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 613.

Plaintiff Susan G. Cohen is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent John G. Chipura, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of John G. Chipura and on behalf of all survivors of John G. Chipura and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John G. Chipura was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 614.

Plaintiff Gerard M. Chipura is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent John G. Chipura, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of John G. Chipura and on behalf of all survivors of John G. Chipura and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John G. Chipura was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

113

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 115 of 978

615.

Plaintiff Catherine Deblieck is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling

of Decedent Peter Chirchirillo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Chirchirillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 616.

Plaintiff Livia Chirchirillo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Peter Chirchirillo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Chirchirillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 617.

Plaintiff Clara Chirchirillo is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent Peter Chirchirillo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Chirchirillo and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Chirchirillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Chirchirillo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 618.

Plaintiff Sydney Chirls is a resident of the State of California, the Child of

Decedent Catherine Ellen Chirls, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Catherine Ellen Chirls and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 619.

Plaintiff Dylan Chirls is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Catherine Ellen Chirls, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Catherine Ellen Chirls and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 620.

Plaintiff Nicholas Chirls is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Catherine Ellen Chirls, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Catherine Ellen Chirls and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 621.

Plaintiff David S. Chirls is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Catherine Ellen Chirls, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the

114

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 116 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Catherine Ellen Chirls and on behalf of all survivors of Catherine Ellen Chirls and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Catherine Ellen Chirls was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 622.

Plaintiff Yuree Cho is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Kyung Hee Cho, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kyung Hee Cho and on behalf of all survivors of Kyung Hee Cho and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kyung Hee Cho was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 623.

Plaintiff Myung Cho is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Kyung Hee Cho, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kyung Hee Cho and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 624.

Plaintiff Jin Hee Cho is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Kyung Hee Cho, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kyung Hee Cho and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 625.

Plaintiff Charles Christophe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Kirsten L. Christophe, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kirsten L. Christophe and on behalf of all survivors of Kirsten L. Christophe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kirsten L. Christophe was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

115

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 117 of 978

626.

Plaintiff Pui Lin Chung is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Wai C. Chung, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Wai C. Chung and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 627.

Plaintiff Winnie Chung is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Wai C. Chung, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Wai C. Chung and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 628.

Plaintiff Julie Tam is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent

Wai C. Chung, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Wai C. Chung and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 629.

Plaintiff Ying Kwan Chung is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Wai C. Chung, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Wai C. Chung and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 630.

Plaintiff Steve Chung is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Wai C. Chung, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Wai C. Chung and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 631.

Plaintiff Richard Chung is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of

Decedent Wai C. Chung, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wai C. Chung and on behalf of all survivors of Wai C. Chung and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wai C. Chung was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 632.

Plaintiff Theresa A. Cilente is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Frances Cilente, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the

116

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 118 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Frances Cilente and on behalf of all survivors of Frances Cilente and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frances Cilente was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 633.

Plaintiff Lynne Cillo-Capaldo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Elaine Cillo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Elaine Cillo and on behalf of all survivors of Elaine Cillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Elaine Cillo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 634.

Plaintiff Nunzi C. Cillo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Elaine Cillo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Elaine Cillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 635.

Plaintiff Gary Cillo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Elaine Cillo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Elaine Cillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 636.

Plaintiff Alicia LeGuillow is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Nestor A. Cintron, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nestor A. Cintron and on behalf of all survivors of Nestor A. Cintron and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nestor A. Cintron was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

117

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 119 of 978

637.

Plaintiff Christopher J. Cintron is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Nestor A. Cintron, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Nestor A. Cintron and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 638.

Plaintiff Fred Gonzalez, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Nestor A. Cintron, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Nestor A. Cintron and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 639.

Plaintiff Jessica Cirri is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Robert D. Cirri, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert D. Cirri, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 640.

Plaintiff Eileen Mary Cirri is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent Robert D. Cirri, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert D. Cirri, Sr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert D. Cirri, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert D. Cirri, Sr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 641.

Plaintiff Robert Cirri, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Robert D. Cirri, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Robert D. Cirri, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 642.

Plaintiff Tracey Clark Bourke is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of

Decedent Sarah Miller Clark, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sarah Miller Clark and on behalf of all survivors of Sarah Miller Clark and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sarah Miller Clark was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the

118

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 120 of 978

Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 643.

Plaintiff John Clarke is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Clarke, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Clarke and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Clarke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Clarke was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 644.

Plaintiff James Clarke is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael Clarke, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Clarke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 645.

Plaintiff Margaret Alexandra Clarke is a resident of England, the Parent of

Decedent Suria R. E. Clarke, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Suria R. E. Clarke and on behalf of all survivors of Suria R. E. Clarke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Suria R. E. Clarke was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 646.

Plaintiff Thomas J.W. Clarke is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of

Decedent Suria R. E. Clarke, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Suria R. E. Clarke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 647.

Plaintiff John A.G. Clarke is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of

Decedent Suria R. E. Clarke, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Suria R. E. Clarke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

119

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 121 of 978

648.

Plaintiff Betty B. Cleere, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Mississippi,

and the Parent of Decedent James Durward Cleere; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 649.

Plaintiff Judy Cleere Gordon is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of

Decedent James Durward Cleere, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Durward Cleere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 650.

Plaintiff Patricia Cleere Wilgus is a resident of the State of Mississippi, the

Sibling of Decedent James Durward Cleere, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Durward Cleere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 651.

Plaintiff Jan Cleere Peavy is a resident of the State of Mississippi, the Sibling of

Decedent James Durward Cleere, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Durward Cleere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 652.

Plaintiff Jean Lorraine Cleere is a resident of the State of Iowa, the Spouse of

Decedent James Durward Cleere, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Durward Cleere and on behalf of all survivors of James Durward Cleere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Durward Cleere was killed at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 653.

Plaintiff A. Scott Cleere is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of

Decedent James Durward Cleere, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of James Durward Cleere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

120

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 122 of 978

654.

Plaintiff Jeffrey K. Cleere is a resident of the State of Iowa, the Child of Decedent

James Durward Cleere, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of James Durward Cleere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 655.

Plaintiff Leslie Brown is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling of

Decedent Jeffrey Alan Coale, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey Alan Coale and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey Alan Coale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey Alan Coale was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. Plaintiff William Coale, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey Alan Coale; the Representative of his Estate, Leslie Brown, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 656.

Plaintiff Frances M. Coffey is a resident of the State of Texas, the Spouse of

Decedent Daniel M. Coffey, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel M. Coffey and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel M. Coffey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel M. Coffey was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 657.

Plaintiff Kevin M. Coffey is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Daniel M. Coffey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Daniel M. Coffey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

121

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 123 of 978

658.

Plaintiff Daniel D. Coffey is a resident of the State of Texas, the Child of

Decedent Daniel M. Coffey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Daniel M. Coffey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 659.

Plaintiff Frances M. Coffey is a resident of the State of Texas, the Parent of

Decedent Jason M. Coffey, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jason M. Coffey and on behalf of all survivors of Jason M. Coffey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jason M. Coffey was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 660.

Plaintiff Kevin M. Coffey is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jason M. Coffey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jason M. Coffey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 661.

Plaintiff Daniel D. Coffey is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of

Decedent Jason M. Coffey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jason M. Coffey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 662.

Plaintiff Marcia Elaine Cohen is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Kevin Sanford Cohen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kevin Sanford Cohen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 663.

Plaintiff Barry Cohen is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Kevin Sanford Cohen, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin Sanford Cohen and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Sanford Cohen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

122

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 124 of 978

Kevin Sanford Cohen was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 664.

Plaintiff Jean Colaio Steinbach is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Mark J. Colaio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mark J. Colaio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 665.

Plaintiff June Coppola is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Mark J. Colaio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark J. Colaio and on behalf of all survivors of Mark J. Colaio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark J. Colaio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 666.

Plaintiff Victor J. Colaio is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Mark J. Colaio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Mark J. Colaio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 667.

Plaintiff Mary C. Colaio, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York,

and the Parent of Decedent Mark J. Colaio; the Representative of her Estate, Victor J. Colaio, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 668.

Plaintiff DOE 120 is a resident of the New York, the Fiancé of Decedent DOE

120, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 669.

Plaintiff Jean Colaio Steinbach is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Stephen J. Colaio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen J. Colaio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

123

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 125 of 978

670.

Plaintiff Victor J. Colaio is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Stephen J. Colaio, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen J. Colaio and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen J. Colaio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen J. Colaio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. Plaintiff Victor J. Colaio also brings this action as the Executor of the Estate of Mary C. Colaio, now deceased Parent of decedent Mark J. Colaio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 671.

Plaintiff Kelly Colasanti is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Christopher Colasanti, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Colasanti and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Colasanti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Colasanti was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 672.

Plaintiff Marie Colbert, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey,

and the Parent of Decedent Michel P. Colbert; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 673.

Plaintiff Elizabeth J. Todd-Colbert is a resident of United Kingdom, the Spouse of

Decedent Michel P. Colbert, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Michel P. Colbert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 674.

Plaintiff William J. Nielsen is a resident of the State of New York, the Not

Related of Decedent Michel P. Colbert, and brings this action on his own behalf as Not Related

124

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 126 of 978

and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michel P. Colbert and on behalf of all survivors of Michel P. Colbert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michel P. Colbert was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 675.

Plaintiff Raymond Colbert is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Michel P. Colbert, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Michel P. Colbert and on behalf of all survivors of Michel P. Colbert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michel P. Colbert was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 676.

Plaintiff Jean Coleman is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of

Decedent Keith Eugene Coleman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Keith Eugene Coleman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 677.

Plaintiff DOE 60 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent

DOE 60, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 60 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 60 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 60 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 678.

Plaintiff Neil Keith Coleman is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent

of Decedent Keith Eugene Coleman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Keith Eugene Coleman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

125

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 127 of 978

679.

Plaintiff Todd Douglas Coleman is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the

Sibling of Decedent Keith Eugene Coleman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Keith Eugene Coleman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 680.

Plaintiff DOE 106 is a resident of the Connecticut, the Fiancé of Decedent DOE

106, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 681.

Plaintiff Jean Coleman is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of

Decedent Scott Thomas Coleman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Scott Thomas Coleman and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Thomas Coleman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Thomas Coleman was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 682.

Plaintiff Neil Keith Coleman is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent

of Decedent Scott Thomas Coleman, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Scott Thomas Coleman and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Thomas Coleman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Thomas Coleman was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 683.

Plaintiff Todd Douglas Coleman is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the

Sibling of Decedent Scott Thomas Coleman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Scott Thomas Coleman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

126

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 128 of 978

684.

Plaintiff Mary E. Coll is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert Joseph Coll, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 685.

Plaintiff Elizabeth C. Weppner is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the

Sibling of Decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 686.

Plaintiff Mary Jean Turanica is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 687.

Plaintiff Margaret Coll is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 688.

Plaintiff Suzanne Valentino is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 689.

Plaintiff Eileen Coll is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 690.

Plaintiff Jennifer B. Coll is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Joseph Coll, II and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Joseph Coll, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

127

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 129 of 978

Robert Joseph Coll, II was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 691.

Plaintiff Edward A. Coll, III is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Joseph Coll, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 692.

Plaintiff Edward Coll, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York,

and the Parent of Decedent Robert Joseph Coll, II; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 693.

Plaintiff Anna E. Collins, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent John Michael Collins; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 694.

Plaintiff Patricia Amo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent John Michael Collins, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Michael Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 695.

Plaintiff Eileen Byrne is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent John Michael Collins, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Michael Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 696.

Plaintiff Anne M. Collins is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent John Michael Collins, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Michael Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 697.

Plaintiff Martin J. Collins is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent John Michael Collins, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Michael Collins and on behalf of all survivors of

128

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 130 of 978

John Michael Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Michael Collins was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 698.

Plaintiff Martin Collins is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent John Michael Collins, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Michael Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 699.

Plaintiff Mary Anne Collins is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael L. Collins, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael L. Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 700.

Plaintiff Nancy M. Kasak is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael L. Collins, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael L. Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 701.

Plaintiff Lissa L. Collins is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Michael L. Collins, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael L. Collins and on behalf of all survivors of Michael L. Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael L. Collins was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 702.

Plaintiff Richard S. Collins is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael L. Collins, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael L. Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

129

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 131 of 978

703.

Plaintiff James R. Collins, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael L. Collins, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael L. Collins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 704.

Plaintiff Carlos R. Colon is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of

Decedent Linda M. Colon, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Linda M. Colon and on behalf of all survivors of Linda M. Colon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Linda M. Colon was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 705.

Plaintiff Lauren Hansen is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of

Decedent Ronald E. Comer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ronald E. Comer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 706.

Plaintiff DOE 63 is a resident of the New Hampshire, the Child of Decedent DOE

63, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 707.

Plaintiff John Conlon is a resident of the State of West Virginia, the Spouse of

Decedent Susan Clancy Conlon, and brings this action on own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Clancy Conlon and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Clancy Conlon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susan Clancy Conlon was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

130

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 132 of 978

708.

Plaintiff Kimberly P. Conlon is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Susan Clancy Conlon, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Susan Clancy Conlon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 709.

Plaintiff Vera Clancy is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Susan Clancy Conlon, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Susan Clancy Conlon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 710.

Plaintiff Kevin Steven Clancy is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Sibling of

Decedent Susan Clancy Conlon, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Susan Clancy Conlon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 711.

Plaintiff Cornelius Patrick Clancy, III is a resident of the State of New York, the

Sibling of Decedent Susan Clancy Conlon, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Susan Clancy Conlon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 712.

Plaintiff Francine Burns-Christensen, now deceased, was a resident of the State of

New York, and the Sibling of Decedent Margaret Mary Conner; the Representative of her Estate, Kevin M. Burns, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 713.

Plaintiff Corrine E. Bounty is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of

Decedent Margaret Mary Conner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Margaret Mary Conner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 714.

Plaintiff Patricia Cuozzo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Margaret Mary Conner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

131

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 133 of 978

Margaret Mary Conner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 715.

Plaintiff Kevin F. Burns is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of

Decedent Margaret Mary Conner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Margaret Mary Conner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 716.

Plaintiff Robert Burns is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of

Decedent Margaret Mary Conner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Margaret Mary Conner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 717.

Plaintiff Michael A. Conner is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent Margaret Mary Conner, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Margaret Mary Conner and on behalf of all survivors of Margaret Mary Conner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Margaret Mary Conner was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 718.

Plaintiff Sheila Connolly is a resident of Canada, the Parent of Decedent Cynthia

Marie Connolly, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Cynthia Marie Connolly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 719.

Plaintiff Donald Jacques Poissant is a resident of the State of New York, the

Spouse of Decedent Cynthia Marie Connolly, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cynthia Marie Connolly and on behalf of all survivors of Cynthia Marie Connolly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action

132

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 134 of 978

set forth herein. Cynthia Marie Connolly was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 720.

Plaintiff Dawn A. Connolly is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent John E. Connolly, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John E. Connolly, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of John E. Connolly, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John E. Connolly, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 721.

Plaintiff Kevin Connolly is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent John E. Connolly, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John E. Connolly, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 722.

Plaintiff Jaymel E. Connor is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent James L. Connor, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James L. Connor and on behalf of all survivors of James L. Connor and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James L. Connor was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 723.

Plaintiff Sylvia L. Connors is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of

Decedent Kevin P. Connors, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin P. Connors and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin P. Connors and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin P. Connors was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

133

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 135 of 978

724.

Plaintiff William K. Connors is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the

Sibling of Decedent Kevin P. Connors, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin P. Connors and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 725.

Plaintiff Douglas Connors is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling

of Decedent Kevin P. Connors, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin P. Connors and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 726.

Plaintiff Christopher Connors is a resident of the State of Maine, the Sibling of

Decedent Kevin P. Connors, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin P. Connors and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 727.

Plaintiff Dana Donohue is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Dennis Cook, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Dennis Cook and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 728.

Plaintiff Mary Christine Coombs is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the

Spouse of Decedent Jeffrey W. Coombs, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey W. Coombs and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey W. Coombs and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey W. Coombs was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 729.

Plaintiff Angela Rapoport is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Gerard J. Coppola, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Gerard J. Coppola and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

134

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 136 of 978

730.

Plaintiff Cynthia Louisa Coppola is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Gerard J. Coppola, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Gerard J. Coppola and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 731.

Plaintiff Pui Yee (Alice) Coppola is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Spouse of Decedent Gerard J. Coppola, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gerard J. Coppola and on behalf of all survivors of Gerard J. Coppola and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard J. Coppola was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 732.

Plaintiff George Joseph Coppola, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Gerard J. Coppola, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gerard J. Coppola and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 733.

Plaintiff George J. Coppola, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Gerard J. Coppola; the Representative of his Estate, George J. Coppola, Jr., brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 734.

Plaintiff Diann Corcoran is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of

Decedent John J. Corcoran, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John J. Corcoran, III and on behalf of all survivors of John J. Corcoran, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. Corcoran, III was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

135

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 137 of 978

735.

Plaintiff Caroline Cordice is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Robert J. Cordice, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert J. Cordice and on behalf of all survivors of Robert J. Cordice and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert J. Cordice was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 736.

Plaintiff Marie Corrigan is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent James J. Corrigan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James J. Corrigan and on behalf of all survivors of James J. Corrigan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James J. Corrigan was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 737.

Plaintiff J. Brendan Corrigan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent James J. Corrigan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of James J. Corrigan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 738.

Plaintiff Sean M. Corrigan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent James J. Corrigan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of James J. Corrigan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 739.

Plaintiff DOE 21 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent

DOE 21, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 21 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 21 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 21 was killed at Two World Trade Center

136

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 138 of 978

as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 740.

Plaintiff Charles P. Costa is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Delores M. Costa, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Delores M. Costa and on behalf of all survivors of Delores M. Costa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Delores M. Costa was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 741.

Plaintiff Nancy E. Costello is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael S. Costello, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael S. Costello and on behalf of all survivors of Michael S. Costello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael S. Costello was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 742.

Plaintiff James P. Costello is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael S. Costello, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael S. Costello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 743.

Plaintiff Timothy J. Costello is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael S. Costello, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael S. Costello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 744.

Plaintiff Michelle Cottom is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of

Decedent Asia SiVon Cottom, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Asia SiVon Cottom and on behalf of all survivors of

137

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 139 of 978

Asia SiVon Cottom and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Asia SiVon Cottom was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 745.

Plaintiff Clifton Cottom is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of

Decedent Asia SiVon Cottom, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Asia SiVon Cottom and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 746.

Plaintiff Sinead Coughlan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Martin Coughlan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Martin Coughlan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 747.

Plaintiff Denise Coughlan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Martin Coughlan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Martin Coughlan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 748.

Plaintiff Ailish Coughlan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Martin Coughlan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Martin Coughlan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 749.

Plaintiff Orla Bowie is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent

Martin Coughlan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Martin Coughlan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 750.

Plaintiff Catherine Coughlan is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Martin Coughlan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Coughlan and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Coughlan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

138

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 140 of 978

Martin Coughlan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 751.

Plaintiff Maura A. Coughlin is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Timothy J. Coughlin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Timothy J. Coughlin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 752.

Plaintiff Princina Cox is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Andre Cox, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Andre Cox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 753.

Plaintiff Glenice Cox-Roach is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of

Decedent Andre Cox, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andre Cox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 754.

Plaintiff Wendell Cox is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Andre Cox, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Andre Cox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 755.

Plaintiff Nigel Cox is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent

Andre Cox, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andre Cox and on behalf of all survivors of Andre Cox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andre Cox was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 756.

Plaintiff Ann Douglas is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Parent of Decedent

Fred John Cox, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Fred John Cox and on behalf of all survivors of Fred John Cox and is entitled to

139

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 141 of 978

recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fred John Cox was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 757.

Plaintiff Frederick Osterhoudt Cox is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent

of Decedent Fred John Cox, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Fred John Cox and on behalf of all survivors of Fred John Cox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fred John Cox was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 758.

Plaintiff Marilyn Elizabeth Cramer is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Christopher Seton Cramer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Christopher Seton Cramer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 759.

Plaintiff Susan Lynne Kinney is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Christopher Seton Cramer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Seton Cramer and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Seton Cramer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Seton Cramer was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 760.

Plaintiff Walter S. Cramer, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Christopher Seton Cramer; the Representative of his Estate, Marilyn Elizabeth Cramer, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

140

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 142 of 978

761.

Plaintiff Marc Seton Cramer is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Christopher Seton Cramer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Seton Cramer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 762.

Plaintiff Keith Douglas Cramer is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Christopher Seton Cramer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Seton Cramer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 763.

Plaintiff Walter Henry Cramer is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Christopher Seton Cramer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Seton Cramer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 764.

Plaintiff DOE 33 is a resident of the state of Massachusetts, the Spouse of

Decedent DOE 33, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 33 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 33 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 33 was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 765.

Plaintiff Mary Eliabeth Cregan is a resident of Ireland, the Parent of Decedent

Joanne Mary Cregan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joanne Mary Cregan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 766.

Plaintiff Grace Elizabeth Cregan is a resident of the State of New York, the

Sibling of Decedent Joanne Mary Cregan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling

141

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 143 of 978

of Joanne Mary Cregan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 767.

Plaintiff Ronald Bernard Cregan is a resident of Ireland, the Parent of Decedent

Joanne Mary Cregan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joanne Mary Cregan and on behalf of all survivors of Joanne Mary Cregan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joanne Mary Cregan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 768.

Plaintiff Ronald Patrick Cregan is a resident of Ireland, the Sibling of Decedent

Joanne Mary Cregan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joanne Mary Cregan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 769.

Plaintiff Maria Crifasi is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Lucy Crifasi, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lucy Crifasi and on behalf of all survivors of Lucy Crifasi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lucy Crifasi was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 770.

Plaintiff Francesco Crifasi is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Lucy Crifasi, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lucy Crifasi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 771.

Plaintiff Raffaella Rita Crisci is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse

of Decedent John A. Crisci, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John A. Crisci and on behalf of all survivors of John A.

142

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 144 of 978

Crisci and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John A. Crisci was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 772.

Plaintiff John Crisci is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent

John A. Crisci, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of John A. Crisci and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 773.

Plaintiff Kevin F. Kittle is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Helen P. Crossin-Kittle, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Helen P. Crossin-Kittle and on behalf of all survivors of Helen P. Crossin-Kittle and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Helen P. Crossin-Kittle was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 774.

Plaintiff DOE 14 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent

DOE 14, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 14 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 14 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 14 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 775.

Plaintiff Patricia M. Crotty is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Thomas G. Crotty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas G. Crotty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 776.

Plaintiff Joanne C. Crotty is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Thomas G. Crotty, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

143

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 145 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas G. Crotty and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas G. Crotty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas G. Crotty was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 777.

Plaintiff Thomas M. Crotty is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Thomas G. Crotty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Thomas G. Crotty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 778.

Plaintiff John Crotty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Thomas G. Crotty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas G. Crotty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 779.

Plaintiff Kenneth Crotty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Thomas G. Crotty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas G. Crotty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 780.

Plaintiff James G. Crotty is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Thomas G. Crotty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas G. Crotty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 781.

Plaintiff Maryann Crowe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent John R. Crowe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John R. Crowe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 782.

Plaintiff Margaret Rita Zoch is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent John R. Crowe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John R. Crowe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

144

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 146 of 978

783.

Plaintiff Pamela M. Crowe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent John R. Crowe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John R. Crowe and on behalf of all survivors of John R. Crowe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John R. Crowe was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 784.

Plaintiff Jeffrey Crowe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent John R. Crowe, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of John R. Crowe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 785.

Plaintiff Brian Crowe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent John R. Crowe, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of John R. Crowe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 786.

Plaintiff Alison Remy Crowther is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Welles Remy Crowther, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Welles Remy Crowther and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 787.

Plaintiff Paige H. Crowther is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling

of Decedent Welles Remy Crowther, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Welles Remy Crowther and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 788.

Plaintiff Honor Elizabeth Crowther is a resident of the State of New York, the

Sibling of Decedent Welles Remy Crowther, and brings this action on her own behalf as the

145

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 147 of 978

Sibling of Welles Remy Crowther and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 789.

Plaintiff Jefferson H. Crowther is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Welles Remy Crowther, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Welles Remy Crowther and on behalf of all survivors of Welles Remy Crowther and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Welles Remy Crowther was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 790.

Plaintiff Dorothy Priscilla Cubas is a resident of the State of New York, the

Parent of Decedent Kenneth J. Cubas, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth J. Cubas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 791.

Plaintiff Lawrence Cubas, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth J. Cubas; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 792.

Plaintiff Alfonso Cubas, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Kenneth J. Cubas, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth J. Cubas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 793.

Plaintiff Maria Cuccinello is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of

Decedent Thelma Cuccinello, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Thelma Cuccinello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 794.

Plaintiff Laurie Folcik is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Child of

Decedent Thelma Cuccinello, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Thelma Cuccinello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

146

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 148 of 978

795.

Plaintiff Cheryl O'Brien is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of

Decedent Thelma Cuccinello, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Thelma Cuccinello and on behalf of all survivors of Thelma Cuccinello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thelma Cuccinello was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 796.

Plaintiff Albert C. Cuccinello, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

Hampshire, and the Spouse of Decedent Thelma Cuccinello; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 797.

Plaintiff Georgia Cudina is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Richard J. Cudina, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard J. Cudina and on behalf of all survivors of Richard J. Cudina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard J. Cudina was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 798.

Plaintiff William Cudina is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard J. Cudina, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard J. Cudina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 799.

Plaintiff Christopher C. Cudina is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Richard J. Cudina, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard J. Cudina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

147

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 149 of 978

800.

Plaintiff Marcus N. Cudina is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Richard J. Cudina, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard J. Cudina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 801.

Plaintiff DOE 129 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent

DOE 129, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 802.

Plaintiff DOE 129 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 129, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 803.

Plaintiff DOE 129 is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent DOE

129, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 129 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 129 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 129 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 804.

Plaintiff DOE 129 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 129, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 805.

Plaintiff DOE 129 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 129, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 806.

Plaintiff Blaise Joudzevich is a resident of the State of United States, the Sibling

of Decedent Joan Mcconnell Cullinan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

148

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 150 of 978

Joan Mcconnell Cullinan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 807.

Plaintiff Thomas Cullinan is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Joan Mcconnell Cullinan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joan Mcconnell Cullinan and on behalf of all survivors of Joan Mcconnell Cullinan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joan Mcconnell Cullinan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 808.

Plaintiff Mitchum Kelvin Cummings is a resident of the State of New York, the

Child of Decedent Joyce Cummings, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joyce Cummings and on behalf of all survivors of Joyce Cummings and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joyce Cummings was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 809.

Plaintiff Deborah L. Barrett is a resident of the State of Florida, the Fiancé of

Decedent Brian T. Cummins, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Brian T. Cummins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 810.

Plaintiff Maureen Cummins is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Brian T. Cummins, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian T. Cummins and on behalf of all survivors of Brian T. Cummins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian T. Cummins was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

149

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 151 of 978

811.

Plaintiff Laurence Cunningham is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of

Decedent Michael J. Cunningham, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael J. Cunningham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 812.

Plaintiff Mary Ann Curatolo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 813.

Plaintiff Carolyn Piccirillo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 814.

Plaintiff Kathleen Curatolo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 815.

Plaintiff Christine Friscia is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 816.

Plaintiff Dena Nelson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 817.

Plaintiff Christine Curatolo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Curatolo and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert

150

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 152 of 978

Curatolo was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 818.

Plaintiff John Curatolo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 819.

Plaintiff William Curatolo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 820.

Plaintiff Anthony Curatolo, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling

of Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 821.

Plaintiff Anthony Curatolo, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Robert Curatolo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Robert Curatolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 822.

Plaintiff Alice Curia, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey,

and the Parent of Decedent Laurence Curia; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 823.

Plaintiff Alice Sciusco is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Laurence Curia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Laurence Curia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 824.

Plaintiff Joseph Curia, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey,

and the Parent of Decedent Laurence Curia; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

151

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 153 of 978

825.

Plaintiff Daniel Curia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Laurence Curia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Laurence Curia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 826.

Plaintiff DOE 93 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 93,

and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 827.

Plaintiff DOE 93 is a resident of the state of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent

DOE 93, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 93 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 93 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 93 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 828.

Plaintiff Louis Curioli, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York,

and the Sibling of Decedent Paul Dario Curioli; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 829.

Plaintiff Lawrence Curioli is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of

Decedent Paul Dario Curioli, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Dario Curioli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 830.

Plaintiff Dorothy Laverne Green is a resident of the State of Arkansas, the Parent

of Decedent Beverly L. Curry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Beverly L. Curry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 831.

Plaintiff Deborah Marshell Crew-Johnson is a resident of the State of

Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Beverly L. Curry, and brings this action on her own behalf

152

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 154 of 978

as the Sibling of Beverly L. Curry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 832.

Plaintiff Sheila Annette Lollis is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of

Decedent Beverly L. Curry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Beverly L. Curry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 833.

Plaintiff Genee Marie Chase is a resident of the State of Arkansas, the Sibling of

Decedent Beverly L. Curry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Beverly L. Curry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 834.

Plaintiff Frederick E. Curry, III is a resident of the State of District of Columbia,

the Spouse of Decedent Beverly L. Curry, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Beverly L. Curry and on behalf of all survivors of Beverly L. Curry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Beverly L. Curry was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 835.

Plaintiff Susann Brady is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Not Related of

Decedent Gavin Cushny, and brings this action on her own behalf as Not Related and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gavin Cushny and on behalf of all survivors of Gavin Cushny and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gavin Cushny was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 836.

Plaintiff Rupert Eales-White is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of

Decedent Gavin Cushny, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gavin Cushny and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

153

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 155 of 978

837.

Plaintiff Selena Dack Forsyth is a resident of Canada, the Parent of Decedent

Caleb Arron Dack, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Caleb Arron Dack and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 838.

Plaintiff DOE 84 is a resident of the state of Washington, the Spouse of Decedent

DOE 84, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 84 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 84 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 84 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 839.

Plaintiff Sandra Dahl, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Colorado, and

the Spouse of Decedent Jason M. Dahl; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 840.

Plaintiff Sheryl Clark Stoll is a resident of the State of Ohio, and brings this action

as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jason M. Dahl and on behalf of all survivors of Jason M. Dahl and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jason M. Dahl was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 841.

Plaintiff DOE 88 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 88,

and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 842.

Plaintiff Raquel D'Amadeo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Vincent Gerard D'Amadeo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as

154

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 156 of 978

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent Gerard D'Amadeo and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Gerard D'Amadeo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Gerard D'Amadeo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 843.

Plaintiff Jennifer Jeanne Damaskinos is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Spouse of Decedent Thomas Damaskinos, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Damaskinos and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Damaskinos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Damaskinos was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 844.

Plaintiff Catherine Elizabeth Damiani is a resident of the State of California, the

Parent of Decedent Jeannine Damiani-Jones, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jeannine Damiani-Jones and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 845.

Plaintiff Robert Damiani is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of

Decedent Jeannine Damiani-Jones, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jeannine Damiani-Jones and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 846.

Plaintiff Brian Robert Damiani is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of

Decedent Jeannine Damiani-Jones, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jeannine Damiani-Jones and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

155

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 157 of 978

847.

Plaintiff Shawn M. Jones is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of

Decedent Jeannine Damiani-Jones, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeannine Damiani-Jones and on behalf of all survivors of Jeannine Damiani-Jones and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeannine Damiani-Jones was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 848.

Plaintiff Barbara E. DaMota is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Manuel DaMota, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Manuel DaMota and on behalf of all survivors of Manuel DaMota and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Manuel DaMota was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 849.

Plaintiff Mary-Anne Dwyer Danahy is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the

Parent of Decedent Patrick William Danahy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patrick William Danahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 850.

Plaintiff Maryanne Danahy is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick William Danahy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick William Danahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 851.

Plaintiff Kathleen A. Danahy Samuelson is a resident of the State of Connecticut,

the Sibling of Decedent Patrick William Danahy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the

156

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 158 of 978

Sibling of Patrick William Danahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 852.

Plaintiff Denise Danahy Duffy is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the

Sibling of Decedent Patrick William Danahy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick William Danahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 853.

Plaintiff John M. Danahy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Patrick William Danahy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick William Danahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 854.

Plaintiff Michael Francis Danahy is a resident of the State of New York, the

Sibling of Decedent Patrick William Danahy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick William Danahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 855.

Plaintiff Francis L. Danahy, Jr. is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent

of Decedent Patrick William Danahy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Patrick William Danahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 856.

Plaintiff Louisa D'Antonio is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Mary D'Antonio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary D'Antonio and on behalf of all survivors of Mary D'Antonio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary

157

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 159 of 978

D'Antonio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 857.

Plaintiff Linda D'Atri-Potenza is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the

Spouse of Decedent Edward A. D'Atri, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward A. D'Atri and on behalf of all survivors of Edward A. D'Atri and on behalf of minor children A.J.D. and M.E.D. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward A. D'Atri was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 858.

Plaintiff Nancy Daria Cimei is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael D'Auria, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael D'Auria and on behalf of all survivors of Michael D'Auria and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael D'Auria was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 859.

Plaintiff Christine Rinaldi is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of

Decedent Michael D'Auria, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael D'Auria and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 860.

Plaintiff Carmen D'auria is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Michael D'Auria, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael D'Auria and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 861.

Plaintiff Ellen R. Davidson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Michael A. Davidson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the

158

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 160 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael A. Davidson and on behalf of all survivors of Michael A. Davidson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Davidson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 862.

Plaintiff Jeffrey S. Davidson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling

of Decedent Michael A. Davidson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Davidson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 863.

Plaintiff Amy Waters Davidson is a resident of the State of New York, and brings

this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Davidson and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Davidson and on behalf of minor children C.D. and P.D. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Davidson was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 864.

Plaintiff Carla Dimaggio is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Scott Davidson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Scott Davidson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 865.

Plaintiff Stephen Davidson is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Scott Davidson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Scott Davidson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 866.

Plaintiff Michael Davidson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Scott Davidson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Scott Davidson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

159

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 161 of 978

867.

Plaintiff Zenovia M. Cuyler is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of

Decedent Ada M. Davis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ada M. Davis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 868.

Plaintiff Yolanda L. Davis is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of

Decedent Ada M. Davis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ada M. Davis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 869.

Plaintiff Rosslyn D. Davis is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of

Decedent Ada M. Davis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ada M. Davis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 870.

Plaintiff Christine Florence Patterson is a resident of the State of Maryland, the

Sibling of Decedent Ada M. Davis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Ada M. Davis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 871.

Plaintiff Clementene Sue Davis-Westmoreland is a resident of the State of

Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Ada M. Davis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Ada M. Davis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 872.

Plaintiff Georgia Darlene Davis-Leggett is a resident of the State of Maryland, the

Sibling of Decedent Ada M. Davis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Ada M. Davis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 873.

Plaintiff Norris Davis, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Virginia, and

the Sibling of Decedent Ada M. Davis; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

160

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 162 of 978

874.

Plaintiff Phillip Davis, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Georgia, and

the Sibling of Decedent Ada M. Davis; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 875.

Plaintiff William M. Davis, now deceased, was a resident of the State of North

Carolina, and the Sibling of Decedent Ada M. Davis; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 876.

Plaintiff Nolton Christopher Davis is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Child

of Decedent Ada M. Davis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Ada M. Davis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 877.

Plaintiff Simone Mitchell is a resident of the State of New York, and brings this

action on behalf of minor child J.M.D. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 878.

Plaintiff Daphne Rachell Davis is a resident of the State of Texas, the Spouse of

Decedent Clinton Davis, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Clinton Davis, Sr. and on behalf of all survivors of Clinton Davis, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Clinton Davis, Sr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 879.

Plaintiff Helen Katrina Dawson is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of

Decedent Anthony Richard Dawson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony Richard Dawson and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony Richard Dawson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action

161

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 163 of 978

set forth herein. Anthony Richard Dawson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 880.

Plaintiff Brigitte Day is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Edward Day, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Day and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Day and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Day was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 881.

Plaintiff Joaquim T. de Araujo is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the

Child of Decedent Dorothy Alma de Araujo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dorothy Alma de Araujo and on behalf of all survivors of Dorothy Alma de Araujo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dorothy Alma de Araujo was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 882.

Plaintiff Aurora de la Torre, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Azucena de la Torre; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 883.

Plaintiff Gladys de la Torre is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Azucena de la Torre, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Azucena de la Torre and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 884.

Plaintiff Diana de la Torre is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Azucena de la Torre, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the

162

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 164 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Azucena de la Torre and on behalf of all survivors of Azucena de la Torre and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Azucena de la Torre was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 885.

Plaintiff DOE 43 is a resident of the Florida, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 43,

and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 886.

Plaintiff Paul DeAngelis is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Robert J. DeAngelis, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert J. DeAngelis, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert J. DeAngelis, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert J. DeAngelis, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 887.

Plaintiff Christine Caputo is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Thomas P. DeAngelis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Thomas P. DeAngelis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 888.

Plaintiff Thomas James DeAngelis is a resident of the State of New York, the

Child of Decedent Thomas P. DeAngelis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Thomas P. DeAngelis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 889.

Plaintiff Maria Luisa Pocasangre is a resident of El Salvador, the Parent of

Decedent Ana Gloria deBarrera, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Ana Gloria deBarrera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

163

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 165 of 978

890.

Plaintiff Ivonne Pocasangre Lopez is a resident of El Salvador, the Sibling of

Decedent Ana Gloria deBarrera, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Ana Gloria deBarrera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 891.

Plaintiff Alfredo Pocasangre is a resident of El Salvador, the Parent of Decedent

Ana Gloria deBarrera, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Ana Gloria deBarrera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 892.

Plaintiff Omar Wilfredo Pocasangre is a resident of the State of California, the

Sibling of Decedent Ana Gloria deBarrera, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ana Gloria deBarrera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 893.

Plaintiff Pedro E. Pocasangre is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of

Decedent Ana Gloria deBarrera, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ana Gloria deBarrera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 894.

Plaintiff Jacques Dan-El Debeuneure is a resident of the State of North Carolina,

the Child of Decedent James D. Debeuneure, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of James D. Debeuneure and on behalf of all survivors of James D. Debeuneure and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James D. Debeuneure was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 895.

Plaintiff George Debin is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Anna M. DeBin, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anna M. DeBin and on behalf of all survivors of Anna

164

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 166 of 978

M. DeBin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anna M. DeBin was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 896.

Plaintiff DOE 32 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent

DOE 32, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 32 and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 32 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 32 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 897.

Plaintiff DOE 32 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent

DOE 32, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 32 and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 32 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 32 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 898.

Plaintiff Virginia M. Decola is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Spouse of

Decedent Paul DeCola, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul DeCola and on behalf of all survivors of Paul DeCola and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul DeCola was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 899.

Plaintiff Vitora Dedvukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of

165

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 167 of 978

Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 900.

Plaintiff Linda Dedvukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 901.

Plaintiff Lisabeta Dedvukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 902.

Plaintiff Drana Vukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 903.

Plaintiff Joanna Dedvukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 904.

Plaintiff Elizabeta Dedvukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

166

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 168 of 978

905.

Plaintiff Marash Dedvukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 906.

Plaintiff Kola Dedvukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 907.

Plaintiff Michael Dedvukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 908.

Plaintiff Nik Dedvukaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Simon Marash Dedvukaj, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and on behalf of all survivors of Simon Marash Dedvukaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Simon Marash Dedvukaj was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 909.

Plaintiff Rose Ann DeFazio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Jason DeFazio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jason DeFazio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 910.

Plaintiff Michele DeFazio is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Jason DeFazio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

167

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 169 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Jason DeFazio and on behalf of all survivors of Jason DeFazio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jason DeFazio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 911.

Plaintiff Michael DeFazio, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

Jersey, and the Sibling of Decedent Jason DeFazio; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 912.

Plaintiff James Christopher DeFazio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Jason DeFazio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jason DeFazio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 913.

Plaintiff Luis Perez is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jennifer DeJesus, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jennifer DeJesus and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer DeJesus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jennifer DeJesus was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 914.

Plaintiff Gricel G. Zayas-Moyer is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the

Parent of Decedent Manuel Del Valle, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Manuel Del Valle, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Manuel Del Valle, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Manuel Del Valle, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

168

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 170 of 978

915.

Plaintiff Manuel Del Valle, Sr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of

Decedent Manuel Del Valle, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Manuel Del Valle, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Manuel Del Valle, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Manuel Del Valle, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 916.

Plaintiff Lillian Rita DeLeo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 917.

Plaintiff Sally DeLeo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr. and on behalf of all survivors of Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 918.

Plaintiff Michael DeLeo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Vito Joseph Deleo, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 919.

Plaintiff Kristen DeMeo is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of

Decedent Martin N. DeMeo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Martin N. DeMeo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 920.

Plaintiff Joan DeMeo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Martin N. DeMeo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

169

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 171 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin N. DeMeo and on behalf of all survivors of Martin N. DeMeo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martin N. DeMeo was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 921.

Plaintiff Rosemary Deming-Phalon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Francis Deming, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Francis Deming and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 922.

Plaintiff Brian D. Deming is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of

Decedent Francis Deming, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Francis Deming and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 923.

Plaintiff Craig D. Deming is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Francis Deming, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Francis Deming and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 924.

Plaintiff Christopher Deming is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Francis Deming, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Francis Deming and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 925.

Plaintiff Robert J. Deming is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Francis Deming, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Francis Deming and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 926.

Plaintiff Patricia Bingley is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent

Kevin Dennis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kevin Dennis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

170

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 172 of 978

927.

Plaintiff Michele Caviasco is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Jean C. Depalma, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jean C. Depalma and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 928.

Plaintiff DOE 114 is a resident of the state of New York, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 114, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 114 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 114 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 114 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 929.

Plaintiff Angelina Mary Trimboli is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Edward DeSimone, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Edward DeSimone, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 930.

Plaintiff Michele Young is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Edward DeSimone, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Edward DeSimone, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 931.

Plaintiff Joanne DeSimone is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Edward DeSimone, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward DeSimone, III and on behalf of all survivors of Edward DeSimone, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward DeSimone, III was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

171

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 173 of 978

932.

Plaintiff Edward DeSimone, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Edward DeSimone, III; the Representative of his Estate, Mary Ellen DeSimone, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 933.

Plaintiff Grace Lieberman is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Michael Jude D'Esposito, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Jude D'Esposito and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Jude D'Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Jude D'Esposito was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 934.

Plaintiff Ralph D'Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Michael Jude D'Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael Jude D'Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 935.

Plaintiff Margaret H. Owen, now deceased, was a resident of United Kingdom,

and the Parent of Decedent Melanie Louise de Vere; the Representative of her Estate, Ruth de Vere, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 936.

Plaintiff DOE 130 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent

DOE 130, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 937.

Plaintiff David de Vere is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent

Melanie Louise de Vere, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-

172

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 174 of 978

Administrator of the Estate of Melanie Louise de Vere and on behalf of all survivors of Melanie Louise de Vere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Melanie Louise de Vere was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 938.

Plaintiff Frederick de Vere is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of

Decedent Melanie Louise de Vere, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Melanie Louise de Vere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 939.

Plaintiff William G. Dewan is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling

of Decedent Gerard P. Dewan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gerard P. Dewan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 940.

Plaintiff Marie Cirmia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Debra Ann Di Martino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Debra Ann Di Martino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 941.

Plaintiff Cecilia Ucedo De Ruiz Diaz is a resident of Argentina, the Parent of

Decedent Obdulio Ruiz Diaz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Obdulio Ruiz Diaz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 942.

Plaintiff Petronilo Ruiz Diaz Cantero is a resident of Argentina, the Parent of

Decedent Obdulio Ruiz Diaz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Obdulio Ruiz Diaz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 943.

Plaintiff Arcelia Diaz is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Judith Berquis Diaz-Sierra, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of

173

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 175 of 978

Judith Berquis Diaz-Sierra and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 944.

Plaintiff LaShawn Dickens is a resident of the State of District of Columbia, the

Parent of Decedent Rodney Alonzo Dickens, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rodney Alonzo Dickens and on behalf of all survivors of Rodney Alonzo Dickens and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rodney Alonzo Dickens was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 945.

Plaintiff Erin R. Dickinson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of

Decedent Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 946.

Plaintiff Helene Janice Dickinson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Parent of Decedent Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 947.

Plaintiff Deirdre Dickinson Sullivan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 948.

Plaintiff Linda M. Dickinson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse

of Decedent Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and

174

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 176 of 978

as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson and on behalf of all survivors of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lawrence Patrick Dickinson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 949.

Plaintiff Joseph Lawrence Dickinson is a resident of the State of New York, the

Sibling of Decedent Lawrence Patrick Dickinson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lawrence Patrick Dickinson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 950.

Plaintiff Loisanne Diehl is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of

Decedent Michael D. Diehl, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael D. Diehl and on behalf of all survivors of Michael D. Diehl and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael D. Diehl was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 951.

Plaintiff Teresa DiFato is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent John DiFato, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John DiFato and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 952.

Plaintiff Susan DiFato is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent John DiFato, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John DiFato and on behalf of all survivors of John DiFato and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John DiFato was killed at

175

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 177 of 978

One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 953.

Plaintiff Antonio DiFato is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent John DiFato, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John DiFato and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 954.

Plaintiff Patricia A. Difazio is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse

of Decedent Vincent Francis DiFazio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent Francis DiFazio and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Francis DiFazio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Francis DiFazio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 955.

Plaintiff Carole DiFranco is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Carl A. DiFranco, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carl A. DiFranco and on behalf of all survivors of Carl A. DiFranco and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carl A. DiFranco was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 956.

Plaintiff Nancy Di Franco Levy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the

Sibling of Decedent Carl A. DiFranco, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Carl A. DiFranco and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 957.

Plaintiff Carmelo A. DiFranco, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New

York, and the Parent of Decedent Carl A. DiFranco; the Representative of his Estate, Carole

176

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 178 of 978

DiFranco, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 958.

Plaintiff Edrick Dillard is a resident of the State of Texas, the Child of Decedent

Eddie Dillard, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Eddie Dillard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 959.

Plaintiff Angela M. Gutermuth is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé

of Decedent Christopher More Dincuff, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Christopher More Dincuff and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 960.

Plaintiff Georgia Rose DiPasquale is a resident of the State of New York, the

Child of Decedent George DiPasquale, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of George DiPasquale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 961.

Plaintiff Melissa M. DiPasquale is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the

Spouse of Decedent George DiPasquale, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George DiPasquale and on behalf of all survivors of George DiPasquale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George DiPasquale was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 962.

Plaintiff Marjorie A. Ditullio is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the

Parent of Decedent Donald A. DiTullio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald A. DiTullio and on behalf of all survivors of Donald A. DiTullio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald A. DiTullio was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World

177

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 179 of 978

Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 963.

Plaintiff Joanna M. Cook is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Sibling of

Decedent Donald A. DiTullio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Donald A. DiTullio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 964.

Plaintiff Janice L. Fleming is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the

Sibling of Decedent Donald A. DiTullio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Donald A. DiTullio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 965.

Plaintiff Evelena Doctor is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Parent of

Decedent Johnnie Doctor, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Johnnie Doctor, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 966.

Plaintiff JoAnn Doctor is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of

Decedent Johnnie Doctor, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 967.

Plaintiff Evon Arnold is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of

Decedent Johnnie Doctor, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 968.

Plaintiff Elaine Doctor McGraw is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling

of Decedent Johnnie Doctor, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 969.

Plaintiff Andrea Gale Doctor is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of

Decedent Johnnie Doctor, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Johnnie Doctor, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of

178

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 180 of 978

Johnnie Doctor, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Johnnie Doctor, Jr. was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 970.

Plaintiff William Lawrence Doctor is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the

Sibling of Decedent Johnnie Doctor, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 971.

Plaintiff Sheldon Dewayne Doctor is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the

Sibling of Decedent Johnnie Doctor, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Johnnie Doctor, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 972.

Plaintiff Lisa T. Dolan is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of

Decedent Robert E. Dolan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert E. Dolan and on behalf of all survivors of Robert E. Dolan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert E. Dolan was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 973.

Plaintiff Helen Dollard is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Neil M. Dollard, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Neil M. Dollard and on behalf of all survivors of Neil M. Dollard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neil M. Dollard was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

179

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 181 of 978

974.

Plaintiff Diana E. Dollard is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Neil M. Dollard, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 975.

Plaintiff Mary K. Dollard is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Neil M. Dollard, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 976.

Plaintiff Megan Fajardo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Neil M. Dollard, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 977.

Plaintiff Anne Zucchi is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Neil M. Dollard, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 978.

Plaintiff Robert M. Dollard is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of

Decedent Neil M. Dollard, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Neil M. Dollard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 979.

Plaintiff Peter Dollard is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Neil M. Dollard, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 980.

Plaintiff Michael J. Dollard is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Neil M. Dollard, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Neil M. Dollard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 981.

Plaintiff Public Administrator of Suffolk County is a resident of the State of New

York, the Not Related of Decedent Benilda Domingo, and brings this action on own behalf as

180

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 182 of 978

Not Related and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benilda Domingo and on behalf of all survivors of Benilda Domingo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Benilda Domingo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 982.

Plaintiff Frank Dominguez is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jerome Dominguez, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jerome Dominguez and on behalf of all survivors of Jerome Dominguez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jerome Dominguez was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 983.

Plaintiff Cecilia E. Donnelly is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Parent of

Decedent Kevin W. Donnelly, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kevin W. Donnelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 984.

Plaintiff Mary Cay Martin is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Kevin W. Donnelly, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin W. Donnelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 985.

Plaintiff Mary Coughlin is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of

Decedent Kevin W. Donnelly, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Kevin W. Donnelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 986.

Plaintiff Brian J. Donnelly is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of

Decedent Kevin W. Donnelly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin W. Donnelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

181

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 183 of 978

987.

Plaintiff Edward L. Donnelly, Jr. is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling

of Decedent Kevin W. Donnelly, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin W. Donnelly and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin W. Donnelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin W. Donnelly was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 988.

Plaintiff Edward L. Donnelly, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the

Parent of Decedent Kevin W. Donnelly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kevin W. Donnelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 989.

Plaintiff Marion Donovan Puiia is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent

of Decedent Jacqueline Donovan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jacqueline Donovan and on behalf of all survivors of Jacqueline Donovan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jacqueline Donovan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 990.

Plaintiff Jeanine Wiese is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jacqueline Donovan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jacqueline Donovan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 991.

Plaintiff Patrice Kelleher is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jacqueline Donovan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jacqueline Donovan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 992.

Plaintiff James T. Donovan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of

Decedent Jacqueline Donovan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-

182

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 184 of 978

Administrator of the Estate of Jacqueline Donovan and on behalf of all survivors of Jacqueline Donovan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jacqueline Donovan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 993.

Plaintiff Michael Donovan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jacqueline Donovan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jacqueline Donovan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 994.

Plaintiff James Donovan, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of

Decedent Jacqueline Donovan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jacqueline Donovan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 995.

Plaintiff Elaine Marie Donovan is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse

of Decedent William Howard Donovan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Howard Donovan and on behalf of all survivors of William Howard Donovan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Howard Donovan was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 996.

Plaintiff Ann Marie Dorf is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Stephen Scott Dorf, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Scott Dorf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 997.

Plaintiff Linda Sammut is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Stephen Scott Dorf, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Scott Dorf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

183

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 185 of 978

998.

Plaintiff Michelle Dorf is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of

Decedent Stephen Scott Dorf, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Stephen Scott Dorf and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Scott Dorf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Scott Dorf was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 999.

Plaintiff Morris Dorf, now deceased, was a resident of the State of United States,

and the Parent of Decedent Stephen Scott Dorf; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1000. Plaintiff Robert Dorf is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Scott Dorf, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Scott Dorf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1001. Plaintiff Joseph Dorf is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Scott Dorf, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Scott Dorf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1002. Plaintiff Kerri Ann Dowd is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas Francis Dowd, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Francis Dowd and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Francis Dowd and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Francis Dowd was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

184

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 186 of 978

1003. Plaintiff DOE 78 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 78, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1004. Plaintiff Adelaide Maureen Driscoll, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Spouse of Decedent Patrick Joseph Driscoll; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1005. Plaintiff Pamela Marie Gould is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Child of Decedent Patrick Joseph Driscoll, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Executor of the Estate of Patrick Joseph Driscoll and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick Joseph Driscoll and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Joseph Driscoll was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1006. Plaintiff Stephen Michael Driscoll is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Patrick Joseph Driscoll, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Patrick Joseph Driscoll and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1007. Plaintiff Christopher John Driscoll is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Patrick Joseph Driscoll, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Patrick Joseph Driscoll and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

185

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 187 of 978

1008. Plaintiff Patrick Thomas Driscoll is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Patrick Joseph Driscoll, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Patrick Joseph Driscoll and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1009. Plaintiff John M. Driscoll is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick Joseph Driscoll, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick Joseph Driscoll and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1010. Plaintiff DOE 97, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 97; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1011. Plaintiff DOE 97 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 97, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1012. Plaintiff DOE 97 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 97, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1013. Plaintiff DOE 97 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 97, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1014. Plaintiff DOE 97 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 97, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

186

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 188 of 978

1015. Plaintiff Ann P. Driscoll is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Stephen Patrick Driscoll, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen Patrick Driscoll and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Patrick Driscoll and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Patrick Driscoll was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1016. Plaintiff DOE 97, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 97; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1017. Plaintiff DOE 97 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 97, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1018. Plaintiff Robert M. Duffy is a resident of the State of Arkansas, the Sibling of Decedent Gerard J. Duffy, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Gerard J. Duffy and on behalf of all survivors of Gerard J. Duffy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard J. Duffy was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1019. Plaintiff Thomas Duffy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Gerard J. Duffy, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Gerard J. Duffy and on behalf of all survivors of Gerard J. Duffy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard J. Duffy was

187

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 189 of 978

killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1020. Plaintiff DOE 121 is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent DOE 121, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1021. Plaintiff DOE 121 is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent DOE 121, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1022. Plaintiff DOE 86 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 86, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 86 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 86 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 86 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1023. Plaintiff Diana J. Sayegh is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Jackie Sayegh Duggan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jackie Sayegh Duggan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1024. Plaintiff Mitchell Duggan is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Jackie Sayegh Duggan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jackie Sayegh Duggan and on behalf of all survivors of Jackie Sayegh Duggan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jackie Sayegh Duggan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

188

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 190 of 978

1025. Plaintiff George A. Sayegh, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Jackie Sayegh Duggan; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1026. Plaintiff Joel Gary Shapiro is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Sareve Dukat, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Executor; Personal Representative of the Estate of Sareve Dukat and on behalf of all survivors of Sareve Dukat and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sareve Dukat was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1027. Plaintiff Laura D. Dunstan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Richard A. Dunstan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Richard A. Dunstan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1028. Plaintiff Janet A. Dunstan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Richard A. Dunstan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard A. Dunstan and on behalf of all survivors of Richard A. Dunstan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard A. Dunstan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1029. Plaintiff Laura Eaton is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Robert Douglas Eaton, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert Douglas Eaton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

189

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 191 of 978

1030. Plaintiff Barbara J. Stephenson is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Robert Douglas Eaton, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Douglas Eaton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1031. Plaintiff Angela Ridge is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Robert Douglas Eaton, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Douglas Eaton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1032. Plaintiff Douglas Eaton is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Robert Douglas Eaton, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Robert Douglas Eaton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1033. Plaintiff Johanna L. Kmetz is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Margaret R. Echtermann, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Margaret R. Echtermann and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1034. Plaintiff Cheryl Olivieri is a resident of the State of Washington, the Fiancé of Decedent Paul R. Eckna, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Paul R. Eckna and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1035. Plaintiff Audrey Economos is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Constantine Economos, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Constantine Economos and on behalf of all survivors of Constantine Economos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Constantine Economos was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

190

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 192 of 978

1036. Plaintiff Frank Michael Edwards is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Child of Decedent Barbara Gollan Edwards, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Barbara Gollan Edwards and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1037. Plaintiff Scott C. Edwards is a resident of the State of Texas, the Child of Decedent Barbara Gollan Edwards, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Barbara Gollan Edwards and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1038. Plaintiff Douglas C. Edwards is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Barbara Gollan Edwards, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Barbara Gollan Edwards and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1039. Plaintiff Ellen R. Judd is a resident of Canada, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Christine Egan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Domestic Partner and on behalf of all survivors of Christine Egan and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Egan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christine Egan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1040. Plaintiff Denise Egan is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Christine Egan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christine Egan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

191

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 193 of 978

1041. Plaintiff Patricia Egan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Martin Egan, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Martin Egan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1042. Plaintiff Colleen D'amato is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Martin Egan, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Egan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1043. Plaintiff Diane Egan is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Martin Egan, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Egan, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Egan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martin Egan, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1044. Plaintiff Mark Egan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Martin Egan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Egan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1045. Plaintiff Michael Egan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Martin Egan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Egan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1046. Plaintiff Martin Egan, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Martin Egan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Martin Egan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1047. Plaintiff Anna Maria Egan is a resident of Beaconsfield, Canada, the Spouse of Decedent Michael Egan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

192

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 194 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Michael Egan and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Egan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Egan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1048. Plaintiff Jonathan J. Egan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael Egan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Michael Egan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1049. Plaintiff Matthew B. Egan is a resident of Beaconsfield, Canada, the Child of Decedent Michael Egan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Michael Egan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1050. Plaintiff Paula Shapiro is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Eric Adam Eisenberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Eric Adam Eisenberg and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Adam Eisenberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric Adam Eisenberg was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1051. Plaintiff Josephine Elder is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Daphne Elder, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Daphne Elder and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1052. Plaintiff Jimmy Paul Elder is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Daphne Elder, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Daphne Elder and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

193

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 195 of 978

1053. Plaintiff Mary Elferis is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael J. Elferis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael J. Elferis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1054. Plaintiff Nancy Chalmers is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael J. Elferis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael J. Elferis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1055. Plaintiff Elizabeth Wild is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael J. Elferis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael J. Elferis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1056. Plaintiff Robert E. Elferis is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael J. Elferis, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael J. Elferis and on behalf of all survivors of Michael J. Elferis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Elferis was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1057. Plaintiff Joseph Elferis is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael J. Elferis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael J. Elferis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1058. Plaintiff Robert G. Elferis is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael J. Elferis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael J. Elferis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1059. Plaintiff Irinie Guiguis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Albert W. Elmarry, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

194

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 196 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Albert W. Elmarry and on behalf of all survivors of Albert W. Elmarry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Albert W. Elmarry was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1060. Plaintiff DOE 68 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 68, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 68 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 68 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 68 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1061. Plaintiff Rogelio R. Escarcega is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Spouse of Decedent Sarah Ali Escarcega, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sarah Ali Escarcega and on behalf of all survivors of Sarah Ali Escarcega and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sarah Ali Escarcega was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1062. Plaintiff Marlyse Bosley is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Sibling of Decedent Jose Espinal, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jose Espinal and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1063. Plaintiff Michael Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Bridget Ann Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bridget Ann Esposito and on behalf of all survivors of Bridget Ann Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

195

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 197 of 978

Bridget Ann Esposito was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1064. Plaintiff Dorothy Helen Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Francis Esposito, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Francis Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1065. Plaintiff Catherine Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Francis Esposito, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Francis Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1066. Plaintiff Dawn Marie Picciano is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Francis Esposito, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francis Esposito and on behalf of all survivors of Francis Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francis Esposito was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1067. Plaintiff Michael A. Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Francis Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Francis Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1068. Plaintiff Dominick Esposito is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Francis Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Francis Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1069. Plaintiff Richard Esposito is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Francis Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Francis Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

196

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 198 of 978

1070. Plaintiff Vincent Esposito is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Francis Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Francis Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1071. Plaintiff Rose Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Esposito, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1072. Plaintiff Salvatore Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1073. Plaintiff Simone Esposito is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1074. Plaintiff Frank Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1075. Plaintiff Joseph Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1076. Plaintiff Simone Esposito, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

197

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 199 of 978

1077. Plaintiff Susan Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent William J. Esposito, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of William J. Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1078. Plaintiff Stephanie Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent William J. Esposito, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William J. Esposito and on behalf of all survivors of William J. Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William J. Esposito was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1079. Plaintiff Craig Esposito is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent William J. Esposito, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of William J. Esposito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1080. Plaintiff Maria Luisa Bey is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Ruben Esquilin, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ruben Esquilin, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Ruben Esquilin, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ruben Esquilin, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1081. Plaintiff Priscilla Esquilin is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Ruben Esquilin, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Ruben Esquilin, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1082. Plaintiff Jean Etzold is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Barbara Etzold, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal

198

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 200 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Barbara Etzold and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara Etzold and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barbara Etzold was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1083. Plaintiff David Konigsberg is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé of Decedent Barbara Etzold, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Fiancé of Barbara Etzold and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1084. Plaintiff Corrine J. Evans is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Eric Brian Evans, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Eric Brian Evans and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Brian Evans and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric Brian Evans was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1085. Plaintiff Charles R. Evans, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Connecticut, and the Parent of Decedent Eric Brian Evans; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1086. Plaintiff Catherine Ewart is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Meredith Emily June Ewart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Meredith Emily June Ewart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1087. Plaintiff Jennifer Ewart is a resident of Montreal, Canada, the Sibling of Decedent Meredith Emily June Ewart, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Meredith Emily June Ewart and on behalf of all

199

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 201 of 978

survivors of Meredith Emily June Ewart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Meredith Emily June Ewart was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1088. Plaintiff Robert G. Ewart is a resident of Canada, the Parent of Decedent Meredith Emily June Ewart, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Meredith Emily June Ewart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1089. Plaintiff Diane Dorothy Fairben is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Keith George Fairben, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Keith George Fairben and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1090. Plaintiff Kenneth Bruce Fairben is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Keith George Fairben, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith George Fairben and on behalf of all survivors of Keith George Fairben and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Keith George Fairben was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1091. Plaintiff Patricia A. Fallon is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Parent of Decedent Jamie Lynn Fallon, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jamie Lynn Fallon and on behalf of all survivors of Jamie Lynn Fallon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jamie Lynn Fallon was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

200

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 202 of 978

1092. Plaintiff Ruth M. Fangman is a resident of the State of Delaware, the Parent of Decedent Robert John Fangman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert John Fangman and on behalf of all survivors of Robert John Fangman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert John Fangman was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1093. Plaintiff Carole L. Ricci is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Robert John Fangman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1094. Plaintiff Deborah A. Fangman is a resident of the State of Delaware, the Sibling of Decedent Robert John Fangman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1095. Plaintiff Theresa M. Frakes is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Robert John Fangman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1096. Plaintiff Stephen G. Fangman is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling of Decedent Robert John Fangman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1097. Plaintiff Paul M. Fangman is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of Decedent Robert John Fangman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

201

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 203 of 978

1098. Plaintiff Michael W. Fangman is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Robert John Fangman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert John Fangman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1099. Plaintiff Beverly Faragher is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Parent of Decedent Kathleen Faragher, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kathleen Faragher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1100. Plaintiff Mary F. Waterman is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Sibling of Decedent Kathleen Faragher, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kathleen Faragher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1101. Plaintiff Beth Ann Faragher is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Sibling of Decedent Kathleen Faragher, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kathleen Faragher and on behalf of all survivors of Kathleen Faragher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kathleen Faragher was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1102. Plaintiff William E. Faragher is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Parent of Decedent Kathleen Faragher, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kathleen Faragher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1103. Plaintiff James A. Faragher is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Sibling of Decedent Kathleen Faragher, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kathleen Faragher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

202

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 204 of 978

1104. Plaintiff William Faragher is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Sibling of Decedent Kathleen Faragher, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kathleen Faragher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1105. Plaintiff Marie A. Farrell is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John G. Farrell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John G. Farrell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1106. Plaintiff James F. Farrell is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John G. Farrell, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John G. Farrell and on behalf of all survivors of John G. Farrell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John G. Farrell was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1107. Plaintiff Helenora M. Farrell is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Terrence Patrick Farrell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Terrence Patrick Farrell and on behalf of all survivors of Terrence Patrick Farrell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terrence Patrick Farrell was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1108. Plaintiff Theresa Farrelly, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Joseph Farrelly; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1109. Plaintiff Stacey Farrelly is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Farrelly, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

203

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 205 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Joseph Farrelly and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Farrelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Farrelly was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1110. Plaintiff Ryan Farrelly is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Joseph Farrelly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Joseph Farrelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1111. Plaintiff Devin Farrelly is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Joseph Farrelly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Joseph Farrelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1112. Plaintiff Joseph Farrelly is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Farrelly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Farrelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1113. Plaintiff Patrick M. Farrelly is a resident of the State of Wyoming, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Farrelly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Farrelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1114. Plaintiff Dennis Farrelly is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Farrelly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Farrelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1115. Plaintiff Michael Farrelly is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Farrelly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Farrelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

204

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 206 of 978

1116. Plaintiff Lorna Clelland Morris is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Parent of Decedent Wendy Ruth Faulkner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Wendy Ruth Faulkner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1117. Plaintiff Jeanette Morris-Friedrich is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Wendy Ruth Faulkner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Wendy Ruth Faulkner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1118. Plaintiff Gay L. Morris is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Sibling of Decedent Wendy Ruth Faulkner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Wendy Ruth Faulkner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1119. Plaintiff Rose Jean Nielsen is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Shannon Marie Fava, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Shannon Marie Fava and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1120. Plaintiff Frank Joseph Fava is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Shannon Marie Fava, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Shannon Marie Fava and on behalf of all survivors of Shannon Marie Fava and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Shannon Marie Fava was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1121. Plaintiff Dennis Nielsen, Jr. is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of Decedent Shannon Marie Fava, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Shannon Marie Fava and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

205

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 207 of 978

1122. Plaintiff Dennis Joseph Nielsen, Sr. is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Shannon Marie Fava, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Shannon Marie Fava and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1123. Plaintiff Linda Ann Favuzza is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Bernard Favuzza, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bernard Favuzza and on behalf of all survivors of Bernard Favuzza and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bernard Favuzza was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1124. Plaintiff Felicia C. Fazio, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Robert Fazio, Jr.; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1125. Plaintiff Carole Lovero is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert Fazio, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Fazio, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1126. Plaintiff Robert Fazio, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Robert Fazio, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Fazio, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Fazio, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Fazio, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

206

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 208 of 978

1127. Plaintiff Lauren Marie Fazio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Ronald C. Fazio, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ronald C. Fazio, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1128. Plaintiff Janet Fazio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Ronald C. Fazio, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald C. Fazio, Sr. and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald C. Fazio, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald C. Fazio, Sr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1129. Plaintiff Robert Fazio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Ronald C. Fazio, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Ronald C. Fazio, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1130. Plaintiff Ronald C. Fazio, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Ronald C. Fazio, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Ronald C. Fazio, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1131. Plaintiff Elizabeth Feehan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent William M. Feehan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of William M. Feehan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1132. Plaintiff Tara Feehan Davan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent William M. Feehan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of William M. Feehan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

207

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 209 of 978

1133. Plaintiff John Feehan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent William M. Feehan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of William M. Feehan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1134. Plaintiff William B. Feehan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent William M. Feehan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William M. Feehan and on behalf of all survivors of William M. Feehan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William M. Feehan was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1135. Plaintiff Dorothy A. Fergus is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1136. Plaintiff Allison M. Fergus is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1137. Plaintiff Maureen Fergus Sheehan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1138. Plaintiff Anne Marie Fergus Rayhill is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the

208

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 210 of 978

Sibling of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1139. Plaintiff Linda Fergus is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1140. Plaintiff Edward T. Fergus, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Edward Thomas Fergus, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1141. Plaintiff DOE 09 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 09, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 09 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 09 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 09 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1142. Plaintiff DOE 09 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 09, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

209

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 211 of 978

1143. Plaintiff Rosanna M. Ferrugio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent David Francis Ferrugio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Francis Ferrugio and on behalf of all survivors of David Francis Ferrugio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Francis Ferrugio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1144. Plaintiff Minnie Ferro is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Louis V. Fersini, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Louis V. Fersini, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1145. Plaintiff Cathy Lyn Fersini is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Louis V. Fersini, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Louis V. Fersini, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Louis V. Fersini, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louis V. Fersini, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1146. Plaintiff DOE 103 is a resident of the Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent DOE 103, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1147. Plaintiff DOE 103 is a resident of the state of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent DOE 103, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 103 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 103 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 103 was killed at Two World Trade

210

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 212 of 978

Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1148. Plaintiff Evelyn L. Fialko is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Jennifer Louise Fialko, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jennifer Louise Fialko and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Louise Fialko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jennifer Louise Fialko was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1149. Plaintiff Robert J. Fialko is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Jennifer Louise Fialko, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jennifer Louise Fialko and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Louise Fialko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jennifer Louise Fialko was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1150. Plaintiff Andrew C. Fialko is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Jennifer Louise Fialko, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jennifer Louise Fialko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1151. Plaintiff Isabel Fiedel, now deceased, was a resident of the State of , and the Parent of Decedent Kristen Nicole Fiedel; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1152. Plaintiff Lindsey Beth Fiedel is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Kristen Nicole Fiedel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Kristen Nicole Fiedel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

211

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 213 of 978

1153. Plaintiff Warren Fiedel is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kristen Nicole Fiedel, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Kristen Nicole Fiedel and on behalf of all survivors of Kristen Nicole Fiedel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kristen Nicole Fiedel was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1154. Plaintiff William H. Fields, Sr. is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Amelia V. Fields, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Amelia V. Fields and on behalf of all survivors of Amelia V. Fields and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Amelia V. Fields was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1155. Plaintiff Loretta J. Filipov is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Alexander M. Filipov, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alexander M. Filipov and on behalf of all survivors of Alexander M. Filipov and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alexander M. Filipov was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1156. Plaintiff Madeline F. Fiore, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Michael Curtis Fiore; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

212

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 214 of 978

1157. Plaintiff Linda S. Fiore is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Curtis Fiore, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Curtis Fiore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1158. Plaintiff Michael Fiore, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Michael Curtis Fiore; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1159. Plaintiff Karen Fiorito is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent John B. Fiorito, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John B. Fiorito and on behalf of all survivors of John B. Fiorito and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John B. Fiorito was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1160. Plaintiff Jean C. Fischer is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent John R. Fischer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John R. Fischer and on behalf of all survivors of John R. Fischer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John R. Fischer was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1161. Plaintiff DOE 107 is a resident of the state of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 107, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 107 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 107 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 107 was killed at Two

213

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 215 of 978

World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1162. Plaintiff Serena Fisher Dugan is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Gerald Paul Fisher, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Gerald Paul Fisher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1163. Plaintiff Christine Karas Fisher is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of Decedent Gerald Paul Fisher, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gerald Paul Fisher and on behalf of all survivors of Gerald Paul Fisher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerald Paul Fisher was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1164. Plaintiff Jonathan Michael Fisher is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Gerald Paul Fisher, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Gerald Paul Fisher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1165. Plaintiff Denise Dileo Fisher is a resident of the State of New York, and brings this action on behalf of minor children A.F. and D.F. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1166. Plaintiff Susan M. Fisher is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas J. Fisher, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Fisher and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. Fisher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Fisher was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

214

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 216 of 978

1167. Plaintiff Mary Frances Bracken is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Lucy Fishman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Lucy Fishman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1168. Plaintiff Edward P. Bracken is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Lucy Fishman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lucy Fishman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1169. Plaintiff Diane Keating is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Ryan D. Fitzgerald, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ryan D. Fitzgerald and on behalf of all survivors of Ryan D. Fitzgerald and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ryan D. Fitzgerald was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1170. Plaintiff Roseanna Fitzpatrick is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1171. Plaintiff Marianne Fitzpatrick is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Fitzpatrick was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

215

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 217 of 978

1172. Plaintiff Michael J. Fitzpatrick is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1173. Plaintiff Michael S. Fitzpatrick is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas J. Fitzpatrick, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas J. Fitzpatrick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1174. Plaintiff Loretta A. Palisay is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Salvatore A. Fiumefreddo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Salvatore A. Fiumefreddo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1175. Plaintiff Joan Fiumefreddo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Salvatore A. Fiumefreddo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Salvatore A. Fiumefreddo and on behalf of all survivors of Salvatore A. Fiumefreddo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Salvatore A. Fiumefreddo was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1176. Plaintiff Michael E. Flagg is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Darlene Embree Flagg, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Co-Executor of the Estate of Darlene Embree Flagg and on behalf of all survivors of Darlene Embree Flagg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Darlene Embree Flagg was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as

216

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 218 of 978

a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1177. Plaintiff Michael E. Flagg is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Wilson Falor Flagg, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Wilson Falor Flagg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1178. Plaintiff Lila May Walkden Flounders is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Joseph W. Flounders, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph W. Flounders and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph W. Flounders and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph W. Flounders was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1179. Plaintiff Christian C. Croner is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Patricia V. Flounders, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patricia V. Flounders and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patricia V. Flounders was the spouse of decedent Joseph W. Flounders who was killed at Two World Trade Center on September 11, 2001. Mrs. Flounders died three months after September 11, 2001 as a result of the grief that she sustained due to the traumatic death of her husband. 1180. Plaintiff Deborah Fodor, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Spouse of Decedent Michael N. Fodor; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1181. Plaintiff Michael Thomas Fodor is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael N. Fodor, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the

217

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 219 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael N. Fodor and on behalf of all survivors of Michael N. Fodor and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael N. Fodor was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1182. Plaintiff Judith Fodor is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael N. Fodor, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael N. Fodor and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1183. Plaintiff Michael Fodor, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Michael N. Fodor; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1184. Plaintiff Andrew Fodor is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael N. Fodor, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Michael N. Fodor and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1185. Plaintiff Samantha Lee Foo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Chih Min Foo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Chih Min Foo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1186. Plaintiff Mary Lou Lee is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Chih Min Foo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Chih Min Foo and on behalf of all survivors of Chih Min Foo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Chih Min Foo was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

218

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 220 of 978

1187. Plaintiff Jason Lee Foo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Chih Min Foo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Chih Min Foo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1188. Plaintiff Dorrette Williams is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1189. Plaintiff Dunston Forbes is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1190. Plaintiff Carlton Forbes is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1191. Plaintiff Christopher R. Forbes is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham and on behalf of all survivors of Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Del Rose Forbes-Cheatham was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

219

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 221 of 978

1192. Plaintiff Cheryl D. Cooper is a resident of the State of New York, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Donald A. Foreman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Domestic Partner of Donald A. Foreman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1193. Plaintiff Tessie Molina is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Christopher Hugh Forsythe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Hugh Forsythe and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Hugh Forsythe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Hugh Forsythe was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1194. Plaintiff Marion Rosette Foster is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Noel John Foster, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Noel John Foster and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1195. Plaintiff John Alfred Foster is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Noel John Foster, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Noel John Foster and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1196. Plaintiff Mary Grace Foti is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Foti, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Foti and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Foti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Foti was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

220

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 222 of 978

1197. Plaintiff DOE 94 is a resident of the state of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 94, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 94 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 94 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 94 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1198. Plaintiff Michael J. Fox is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey L. Fox, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey L. Fox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1199. Plaintiff Annie Marie Carter is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Virginia E. Fox, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Virginia E. Fox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1200. Plaintiff Karen M. Carlucci is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Peter Christopher Frank, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Peter Christopher Frank and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1201. Plaintiff Henry Lambert is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Lillian Frederick-Lambert, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lillian Frederick-Lambert and on behalf of all survivors of Lillian Frederick-Lambert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lillian Frederick-Lambert was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

221

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 223 of 978

1202. Plaintiff Carol Freund is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Louis Freund, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Louis Freund and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1203. Plaintiff Barbara Freund Salvadore is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Louis Freund, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Louis Freund and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1204. Plaintiff Mary Froehner is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Gregg J. Froehner, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregg J. Froehner and on behalf of all survivors of Gregg J. Froehner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregg J. Froehner was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1205. Plaintiff Margaret Fumando, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Clement Fumando; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1206. Plaintiff Catherine Marotte is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Clement Fumando, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Clement Fumando and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1207. Plaintiff Katherine Marie Fumando is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Spouse of Decedent Clement Fumando, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Clement Fumando and on behalf of all survivors of Clement Fumando and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

222

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 224 of 978

Clement Fumando was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1208. Plaintiff Stephen Fumando is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Clement Fumando, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Clement Fumando and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1209. Plaintiff Gregory Fumando is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Child of Decedent Clement Fumando, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Clement Fumando and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1210. Plaintiff Carlo Fumando is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Clement Fumando, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Clement Fumando and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1211. Plaintiff Margaret Furmato is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Paul Furmato, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Paul Furmato and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1212. Plaintiff Carol Margaret Debenedictis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Furmato, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Furmato and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1213. Plaintiff Jill Mary Keough is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Furmato, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Furmato and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1214. Plaintiff Cynthia Anne Velardi is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Paul Furmato, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Furmato and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Furmato and

223

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 225 of 978

is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Furmato was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1215. Plaintiff Mark Furmato is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Furmato, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Furmato and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1216. Plaintiff Joseph Furmato, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Furmato, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Furmato and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1217. Plaintiff Joseph Furmato, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Paul Furmato, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Paul Furmato and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1218. Plaintiff Haven A. Fyfe-Kiernan is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Karleton D. Fyfe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karleton D. Fyfe and on behalf of all survivors of Karleton D. Fyfe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karleton D. Fyfe was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1219. Plaintiff DOE 40 is a resident of the state of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent DOE 40, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 40 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 40 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 40 was killed at One World Trade Center

224

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 226 of 978

as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1220. Plaintiff Kevin Richard Gaff is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Pamela Lee Gaff, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Pamela Lee Gaff and on behalf of all survivors of Pamela Lee Gaff and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pamela Lee Gaff was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1221. Plaintiff Patricia A. Hill is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Irving Vincent Gailliard, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Irving Vincent Gailliard and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1222. Plaintiff Margaret Ann Micciulli is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Deanna Micciulli Galante, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Deanna Micciulli Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1223. Plaintiff Tina Louise Micciulli is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Deanna Micciulli Galante, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Deanna Micciulli Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1224. Plaintiff Joseph Anthony Micciulli is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Deanna Micciulli Galante, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of

225

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 227 of 978

Deanna Micciulli Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1225. Plaintiff Joseph Christopher Micciulli is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Deanna Micciulli Galante, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Deanna Micciulli Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1226. Plaintiff Anthony Galante is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Deanna Micciulli Galante, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Deanna Micciulli Galante and on behalf of all survivors of Deanna Micciulli Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Deanna Micciulli Galante was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1227. Plaintiff Lucrezia Ida Susca is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Grace Catherine Galante, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Grace Catherine Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1228. Plaintiff Cathy Marie Cava is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Grace Catherine Galante, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Grace Catherine Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1229. Plaintiff Francesco Susca is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Grace Catherine Galante, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of

226

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 228 of 978

Grace Catherine Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1230. Plaintiff Frank Susca is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Grace Catherine Galante, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Grace Catherine Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1231. Plaintiff Giovanni Galante is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Grace Catherine Galante, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Grace Catherine Galante and on behalf of all survivors of Grace Catherine Galante and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Grace Catherine Galante was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1232. The Representative of the Estate of Daniel James Gallagher brings this action on behalf of all survivors of Daniel James Gallagher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel James Gallagher was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. Plaintiff Regina E. Gallagher, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey and the Parent of Decedent Daniel James Gallagher; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1233. Plaintiff Maryann Gambale is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Giovanna G. Gambale, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Giovanna G. Gambale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

227

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 229 of 978

1234. Plaintiff Antonia Gambale is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Giovanna G. Gambale, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Giovanna G. Gambale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1235. Plaintiff Anthony J. Gambale is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Giovanna G. Gambale, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Giovanna G. Gambale and on behalf of all survivors of Giovanna G. Gambale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Giovanna G. Gambale was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1236. Plaintiff Matthew Gambale is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Giovanna G. Gambale, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Giovanna G. Gambale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1237. Plaintiff Maria Regina Merwin is a resident of the State of Kentucky, the Sibling of Decedent Ronald L. Gamboa, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald L. Gamboa and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald L. Gamboa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald L. Gamboa was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1238. Plaintiff DOE 117 is a resident of the state of Georgia, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 117, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 117 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 117 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 117 was killed at One World Trade Center

228

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 230 of 978

as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1239. Plaintiff Virginia Garbarini, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Charles Garbarini; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1240. Plaintiff Joan Cuneo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Charles Garbarini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1241. Plaintiff Donna Marie Garbarini is a resident of the State of Oregon, the Sibling of Decedent Charles Garbarini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1242. Plaintiff Beryl Ann Zawatsky is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Charles Garbarini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1243. Plaintiff Cathy Jean Kostiw is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Charles Garbarini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1244. Plaintiff Peggy Mary Garbarini is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Charles Garbarini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1245. Plaintiff Janet Garbarini is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Charles Garbarini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Charles Garbarini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

229

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 231 of 978

1246. Plaintiff Andrea DeGeorge Garbarini is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Charles Garbarini, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Garbarini and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Garbarini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles Garbarini was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1247. Plaintiff Charles Garbarini, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Charles Garbarini; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1248. Plaintiff Dorothy Garcia is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Andrew Garcia, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Executor of the Estate of Andrew Garcia and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Garcia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andrew Garcia was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1249. Plaintiff Andrew T. Garcia is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Andrew Garcia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Andrew Garcia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1250. Plaintiff Celeste Marino Garcia is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Cesar R. Garcia, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cesar R. Garcia and on behalf of all survivors of Cesar R. Garcia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cesar R.

230

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 232 of 978

Garcia was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1251. Plaintiff Deborah Ann Garcia is a resident of the State of Vermont, the Spouse of Decedent David Garcia, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Garcia and on behalf of all survivors of David Garcia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Garcia was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1252. Plaintiff Susan L. Gardner is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Christopher S. Gardner, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher S. Gardner and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher S. Gardner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher S. Gardner was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1253. Plaintiff Jennifer Radding Gardner is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Douglas B. Gardner, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Douglas B. Gardner and on behalf of all survivors of Douglas B. Gardner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Douglas B. Gardner was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1254. Plaintiff Harvey J. Gardner, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Harvey Joseph Gardner, III; the Representative of his Estate,

231

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 233 of 978

Joseph W. Gardner, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1255. Plaintiff Joseph W. Gardner is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the sibling of Decedent Harvey Joseph Gardner, III, and brings this action on own behalf as the sibling of Harvey Joseph Gardner, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1256. Plaintiff Judith Torea is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Harvey Joseph Gardner, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Harvey Joseph Gardner, III and on behalf of all survivors of Harvey Joseph Gardner, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Harvey Joseph Gardner, III was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1257. Plaintiff Anthony Gardner is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Harvey Joseph Gardner, III, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Harvey Joseph Gardner, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1258. Plaintiff Amy Gardner is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey B. Gardner, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey B. Gardner and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey B. Gardner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey B. Gardner was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

232

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 234 of 978

1259. Plaintiff Antonia Gargano is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Rocco Nino Gargano, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rocco Nino Gargano and on behalf of all survivors of Rocco Nino Gargano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rocco Nino Gargano was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1260. Plaintiff DOE 145 is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent DOE 145, and brings this action on own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1261. Plaintiff DOE 145 is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent DOE 145, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1262. Plaintiff DOE 145 is a resident of the state of New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 145, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 145 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 145 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 145 was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1263. Plaintiff Rosemarie Gavagan, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Donald R. Gavagan, Jr.; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1264. Plaintiff Suzanne Mascitis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Donald R. Gavagan, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

233

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 235 of 978

Donald R. Gavagan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1265. Plaintiff Jacqueline S. Gavagan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Donald R. Gavagan, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald R. Gavagan, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Donald R. Gavagan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald R. Gavagan, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1266. Plaintiff Donald Richard Gavagan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Donald R. Gavagan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Donald R. Gavagan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1267. Plaintiff Joseph Bernard Gavagan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Donald R. Gavagan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Donald R. Gavagan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1268. Plaintiff Linda Rose Gay is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Peter A. Gay, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter A. Gay, Sr. and on behalf of minor child L.L.G. and on behalf of all survivors of Peter A. Gay, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter A. Gay, Sr. was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

234

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 236 of 978

1269. Plaintiff Tracy M. Gazzani is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Terence D. Gazzani, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Terence D. Gazzani and on behalf of all survivors of Terence D. Gazzani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terence D. Gazzani was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1270. Plaintiff Maurizio D. Gazzani is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Terence D. Gazzani, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Terence D. Gazzani and on behalf of all survivors of Terence D. Gazzani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terence D. Gazzani was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1271. Plaintiff Patricia M. Geidel, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Gary Paul Geidel; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1272. Plaintiff Christine Ann Norris is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Gary Paul Geidel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Gary Paul Geidel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1273. Plaintiff Mathilda M. Geidel is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Gary Paul Geidel, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gary Paul Geidel and on behalf of all survivors of Gary Paul Geidel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gary Paul

235

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 237 of 978

Geidel was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1274. Plaintiff Paul Ernest Geidel is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Parent of Decedent Gary Paul Geidel, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Gary Paul Geidel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1275. Plaintiff Michael George Geidel is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Gary Paul Geidel, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gary Paul Geidel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1276. Plaintiff Ralph W. Geidel, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of California, and the Sibling of Decedent Gary Paul Geidel; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1277. Plaintiff Shelly Genovese is a resident of the State of Texas, the Spouse of Decedent Steven G. Genovese, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Steven G. Genovese and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1278. Plaintiff Carolyn M. George is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Linda George, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Linda George and on behalf of all survivors of Linda George and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Linda George was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1279. Plaintiff Richard A. George is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Linda George, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-

236

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 238 of 978

Administrator of the Estate of Linda George and on behalf of all survivors of Linda George and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Linda George was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1280. Plaintiff Hans J. Gerhardt is a resident of Canada, the Parent of Decedent Ralph Gerhardt, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Ralph Gerhardt and on behalf of all survivors of Ralph Gerhardt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph Gerhardt was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1281. Plaintiff Stephan J. Gerhardt is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Ralph Gerhardt, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ralph Gerhardt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1282. Plaintiff Lorraine Adele Gerlich is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Robert J. Gerlich, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert J. Gerlich and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1283. Plaintiff Rochelle Gerlich is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Robert J. Gerlich, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert J. Gerlich and on behalf of all survivors of Robert J. Gerlich and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert J. Gerlich was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

237

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 239 of 978

1284. Plaintiff Matt Gerlich is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Robert J. Gerlich, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Robert J. Gerlich and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1285. Plaintiff Daniel Gerlich is a resident of the State of Texas, the Child of Decedent Robert J. Gerlich, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Robert J. Gerlich and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1286. Plaintiff Anna Gertsberg, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Marina Romanovna Gertsberg; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1287. Plaintiff Roman Gertsberg is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Marina Romanovna Gertsberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marina Romanovna Gertsberg and on behalf of all survivors of Marina Romanovna Gertsberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marina Romanovna Gertsberg was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1288. Plaintiff Jo Ann S. Geyer, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent James G. Geyer; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1289. Plaintiff Geralyn Marasco is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James G. Geyer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Fiduciary of the Estate of James G. Geyer and on behalf of all survivors of James G. Geyer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James G. Geyer was killed

238

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 240 of 978

at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1290. Plaintiff Philip G. Geyer, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent James G. Geyer; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1291. Plaintiff Philip Joseph Geyer is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Sibling of Decedent James G. Geyer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James G. Geyer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1292. Plaintiff John Edward Geyer is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James G. Geyer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James G. Geyer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1293. Plaintiff Theresa Giammona is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Vincent F. Giammona, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vincent F. Giammona and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent F. Giammona and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent F. Giammona was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1294. Plaintiff Heather Gibbon is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Debra L. Gibbon, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Debra L. Gibbon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1295. Plaintiff Adam Gibbon, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Child of Decedent Debra L. Gibbon; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

239

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 241 of 978

1296. Plaintiff Zachary Gibbon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Debra L. Gibbon, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Debra L. Gibbon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1297. Plaintiff J. Frederick Gibbon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Debra L. Gibbon, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Spouse of Debra L. Gibbon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1298. Plaintiff Susan Giberson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent James Giberson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Giberson and on behalf of all survivors of James Giberson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Giberson was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1299. Plaintiff Eric Patrick Gibson is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Child of Decedent Brenda Colbert Gibson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Brenda Colbert Gibson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1300. Plaintiff Joseph Milton Gibson, III is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of Decedent Brenda Colbert Gibson, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brenda Colbert Gibson and on behalf of all survivors of Brenda Colbert Gibson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brenda Colbert Gibson was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

240

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 242 of 978

1301. Plaintiff Jacqueline Gilbert is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Timothy Paul Gilbert, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Timothy Paul Gilbert and on behalf of all survivors of Timothy Paul Gilbert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy Paul Gilbert was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1302. Plaintiff Jane Jones is a resident of United Kingdom, and brings this action on behalf of minor child H.G. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1303. Plaintiff Deena Gilbey is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Paul Stuart Gilbey, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Stuart Gilbey and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Stuart Gilbey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Stuart Gilbey was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1304. Plaintiff Maria Acosta is a resident of the State of New York, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Paul John Gill, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Domestic Partner of Paul John Gill and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1305. Plaintiff Gisele Jean-Gilles is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Mark Y. Gilles, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Y. Gilles and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Y. Gilles and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Y. Gilles was

241

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 243 of 978

killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1306. Plaintiff Myriam Jean-Gilles is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Mark Y. Gilles, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Y. Gilles and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1307. Plaintiff Eleanor Gillette is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Evan Gillette, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Evan Gillette and on behalf of all survivors of Evan Gillette and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Evan Gillette was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1308. Plaintiff Ashley Gilligan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent Ronald L. Gilligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ronald L. Gilligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1309. Plaintiff Ainsley Gilligan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent Ronald L. Gilligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ronald L. Gilligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1310. Plaintiff Elizabeth Gilligan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Ronald L. Gilligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald L. Gilligan and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald L. Gilligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald L. Gilligan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

242

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 244 of 978

1311. Plaintiff Dherran Gilligan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent Ronald L. Gilligan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Ronald L. Gilligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1312. Plaintiff Raymond L. Gilligan is a resident of England, the Sibling of Decedent Ronald L. Gilligan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ronald L. Gilligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1313. Plaintiff Colin Vincent Gilligan is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Ronald L. Gilligan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ronald L. Gilligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1314. Plaintiff Geraldine Gilliam is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Parent of Decedent Rodney C. Gillis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Rodney C. Gillis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1315. Plaintiff Ronald C. Gillis is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Rodney C. Gillis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Rodney C. Gillis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1316. Plaintiff April Grace Ginley is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent John F. Ginley, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John F. Ginley and on behalf of all survivors of John F. Ginley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John F. Ginley was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1317. Plaintiff DOE 95 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 95, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of

243

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 245 of 978

DOE 95 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 95 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 95 was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1318. Plaintiff DOE 95 is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 95, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1319. Plaintiff Domenica Giovinazzo, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Martin Giovinazzo; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1320. Plaintiff Concetta Bonner is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Martin Giovinazzo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Giovinazzo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1321. Plaintiff Angela Carmela Quinn is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Martin Giovinazzo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Giovinazzo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1322. Plaintiff Rosemarie Mahoney is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Martin Giovinazzo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Giovinazzo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1323. Plaintiff Dorothy Giovinazzo is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Martin Giovinazzo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Giovinazzo and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Giovinazzo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

244

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 246 of 978

Martin Giovinazzo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1324. Plaintiff Martin Giovinazzo, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Martin Giovinazzo; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1325. Plaintiff Sali Gjonbalaj is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Mon Gjonbalaj, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mon Gjonbalaj and on behalf of all survivors of Mon Gjonbalaj and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mon Gjonbalaj was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1326. Plaintiff Jayne Marie Marx is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Dianne Gladstone, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dianne Gladstone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1327. Plaintiff Herbert Gladstone is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Dianne Gladstone, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dianne Gladstone and on behalf of all survivors of Dianne Gladstone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dianne Gladstone was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1328. Plaintiff Veronica Squef is a resident of the State of New York, the Not Related of Decedent Keith Alexander Glascoe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Not Related and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith Alexander Glascoe and on behalf of all

245

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 247 of 978

survivors of Keith Alexander Glascoe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Keith Alexander Glascoe was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1329. Plaintiff Gloria Oliver (Maiden) Glascoe is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Keith Alexander Glascoe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Keith Alexander Glascoe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1330. Plaintiff Benjamin Alexander Glascoe is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Keith Alexander Glascoe, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith Alexander Glascoe and on behalf of all survivors of Keith Alexander Glascoe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Keith Alexander Glascoe was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1331. Plaintiff Judith M. Glick is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Barry H. Glick, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Barry H. Glick and on behalf of all survivors of Barry H. Glick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barry H. Glick was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1332. Plaintiff Mari Glick Stuart is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Steven L. Glick, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

246

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 248 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven L. Glick and on behalf of all survivors of Steven L. Glick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven L. Glick was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1333. Plaintiff Aleese Mills Hartmann is a resident of the State of Florida, the Fiancé of Decedent William Robert Godshalk, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of William Robert Godshalk and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1334. Plaintiff Grace M. Parkinson-Godshalk is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent William Robert Godshalk, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Robert Godshalk and on behalf of all survivors of William Robert Godshalk and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Robert Godshalk was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1335. Plaintiff Daniela Gogliormella is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Michael Gogliormella, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Gogliormella and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Gogliormella and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Gogliormella was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

247

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 249 of 978

1336. Plaintiff Marilyn Goldberg is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Brian F. Goldberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Brian F. Goldberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1337. Plaintiff Gerald Goldberg is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Brian F. Goldberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Brian F. Goldberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1338. Plaintiff Ashley Goldflam is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Jeffrey Goldflam, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Jeffrey Goldflam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1339. Plaintiff Rise Goldflam is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Jeffrey Goldflam, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey Goldflam and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey Goldflam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey Goldflam was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1340. Plaintiff Joshua Goldflam is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Jeffrey Goldflam, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Jeffrey Goldflam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1341. Plaintiff Cecilia Goldstein is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Monica Goldstein, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Monica Goldstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

248

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 250 of 978

1342. Plaintiff Adrienne Triggs is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Monica Goldstein, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Monica Goldstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1343. Plaintiff Morris Sonny Goldstein is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Monica Goldstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Monica Goldstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1344. Plaintiff Alyce Goldstein is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Steven Ian Goldstein, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Steven Ian Goldstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1345. Plaintiff Robert Jay Goldstein is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Steven Ian Goldstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Steven Ian Goldstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1346. Plaintiff Sara Clark is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Ronald F. Golinski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ronald F. Golinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1347. Plaintiff Marcellia Potler is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of Decedent Ronald F. Golinski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ronald F. Golinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1348. Plaintiff Amanda Golinski is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of Decedent Ronald F. Golinski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ronald F. Golinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1349. Plaintiff Irene Mary Golinski is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of Decedent Ronald F. Golinski, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

249

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 251 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald F. Golinski and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald F. Golinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald F. Golinski was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1350. Plaintiff Migdalia Coleman is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Rosa J. Gonzalez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rosa J. Gonzalez and on behalf of all survivors of Rosa J. Gonzalez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rosa J. Gonzalez was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1351. Plaintiff Ellen Reynolds Goodchild is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Lynn Catherine Goodchild, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Lynn Catherine Goodchild and on behalf of all survivors of Lynn Catherine Goodchild and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lynn Catherine Goodchild was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1352. Plaintiff Neil K. Goodchild is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Lynn Catherine Goodchild, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lynn Catherine Goodchild and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1353. Plaintiff William Clark Goodchild, III is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Lynn Catherine Goodchild, and brings this action on his own behalf as

250

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 252 of 978

Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Lynn Catherine Goodchild and on behalf of all survivors of Lynn Catherine Goodchild and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lynn Catherine Goodchild was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1354. Plaintiff Helene W. Nelson is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Catherine C. Gorayeb, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Catherine C. Gorayeb and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1355. Plaintiff Claire A. Gorayeb is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Catherine C. Gorayeb, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Catherine C. Gorayeb and on behalf of all survivors of Catherine C. Gorayeb and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Catherine C. Gorayeb was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1356. Plaintiff Joseph Gorayeb is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Catherine C. Gorayeb, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Catherine C. Gorayeb and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1357. Plaintiff Christopher J. Gorayeb is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Catherine C. Gorayeb, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Catherine C. Gorayeb and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

251

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 253 of 978

1358. Plaintiff Andrew T. Gorayeb is a resident of the State of Oregon, the Sibling of Decedent Catherine C. Gorayeb, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Catherine C. Gorayeb and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1359. Plaintiff Theresa Rachel Gorman is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Thomas E. Gorman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas E. Gorman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1360. Plaintiff Theresa Mary Creedon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas E. Gorman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas E. Gorman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1361. Plaintiff John Edward Gorman, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Sibling of Decedent Thomas E. Gorman; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1362. Plaintiff Edward Thomas Gorman is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Thomas E. Gorman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Thomas E. Gorman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1363. Plaintiff Kathryn G. Anderson is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Michael Edward Gould, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Edward Gould and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Edward Gould and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Edward Gould was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1364. Plaintiff Robert W. Gould is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Edward Gould, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of

252

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 254 of 978

Michael Edward Gould and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1365. Plaintiff Jessica Gowell is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Douglas A. Gowell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Douglas A. Gowell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1366. Plaintiff Barbara Gowell is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Douglas A. Gowell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Douglas A. Gowell and on behalf of all survivors of Douglas A. Gowell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Douglas A. Gowell was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1367. Plaintiff Michael Gowell is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Douglas A. Gowell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Douglas A. Gowell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1368. Plaintiff Rita M. Grady, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Christopher Michael Grady; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1369. Plaintiff Deirdre Marie Grady is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Michael Grady, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Michael Grady and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

253

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 255 of 978

1370. Plaintiff DOE 70 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 70, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 70 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 70 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 70 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1371. Plaintiff Brendan Micheal Grady is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Michael Grady, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Michael Grady and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1372. Plaintiff Ruth Graifman is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent David Martin Graifman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of David Martin Graifman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1373. Plaintiff Christine R. Huhn is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent David Martin Graifman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Martin Graifman and on behalf of all survivors of David Martin Graifman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Martin Graifman was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1374. Plaintiff Julius Graifman is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent David Martin Graifman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of

254

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 256 of 978

David Martin Graifman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1375. Plaintiff Brian Dale Graifman is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent David Martin Graifman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of David Martin Graifman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1376. Plaintiff Jack A. Grandcolas is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Lauren C. Grandcolas, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lauren C. Grandcolas and on behalf of all survivors of Lauren C. Grandcolas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lauren C. Grandcolas was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1377. Plaintiff James S. Gray is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Stewart Gray, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Stewart Gray and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Stewart Gray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Stewart Gray was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1378. Plaintiff Lisa Anne Gray is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of Decedent Ian J. Gray, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ian J. Gray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

255

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 257 of 978

1379. Plaintiff Anne Margaret Policelli is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Ian J. Gray, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Ian J. Gray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1380. Plaintiff Ana M. Raley is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Ian J. Gray, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ian J. Gray and on behalf of all survivors of Ian J. Gray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ian J. Gray was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1381. Plaintiff Mary Madden is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent James Michael Gray, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of James Michael Gray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1382. Plaintiff DOE 49 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 49, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1383. Plaintiff DOE 49 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 49, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 49 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 49 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 49 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

256

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 258 of 978

1384. Plaintiff DOE 49 is a resident of the Florida, the Parent of Decedent DOE 49, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1385. Plaintiff Tina Grazioso is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent John Grazioso, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Grazioso and on behalf of all survivors of John Grazioso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Grazioso was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1386. Plaintiff Danielle Tiffany Green is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Wade Brian Green, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Wade Brian Green and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1387. Plaintiff Wilhelmina Mary Green is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Wade Brian Green, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Wade Brian Green and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1388. Plaintiff Alicia Marie Govia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Wade Brian Green, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Wade Brian Green and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1389. Plaintiff Roxanne Green is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Wade Brian Green, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wade Brian Green and on behalf of all survivors of Wade Brian Green and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

257

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 259 of 978

Wade Brian Green was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1390. Plaintiff Thomas Green, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Wade Brian Green; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1391. Plaintiff Barry Vincent Green is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Wade Brian Green, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Wade Brian Green and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1392. Plaintiff Anthony Green is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Wade Brian Green, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Wade Brian Green and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1393. Plaintiff Eva Greenstein, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Eileen Greenstein; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1394. Plaintiff Edward W. Greenstein is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Eileen Greenstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Eileen Greenstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1395. Plaintiff Howard Greenstein is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Eileen Greenstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Eileen Greenstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1396. Plaintiff Michael J. Greenstein is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Eileen Greenstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eileen Greenstein and on behalf of all survivors of

258

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 260 of 978

Eileen Greenstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eileen Greenstein was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1397. Plaintiff Amanda Marie Walling is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent Donald H. Gregory, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Donald H. Gregory and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1398. Plaintiff Sara Elizabeth Carpenter is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent Donald H. Gregory, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Donald H. Gregory and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1399. Plaintiff Maureen A. Gregory is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Donald H. Gregory, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald H. Gregory and on behalf of all survivors of Donald H. Gregory and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald H. Gregory was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1400. Plaintiff Victoria Blaksley is a resident of Argentina, the Spouse of Decedent Pedro Grehan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Pedro Grehan and on behalf of all survivors of Pedro Grehan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pedro Grehan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

259

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 261 of 978

1401. Plaintiff Teresa L. Grimner, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent David Joseph Grimner; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1402. Plaintiff Mary Ann Elizabeth Peters is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent David Joseph Grimner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of David Joseph Grimner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1403. Plaintiff Virginia Margaret Kwiatkoski is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent David Joseph Grimner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of David Joseph Grimner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1404. Plaintiff Judith A. Grimner is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent David Joseph Grimner, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Joseph Grimner and on behalf of all survivors of David Joseph Grimner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Joseph Grimner was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1405. Plaintiff Charles Gregory Grimner is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent David Joseph Grimner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of David Joseph Grimner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

260

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 262 of 978

1406. Plaintiff Ann M. Browne is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Francis E. Grogan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Francis E. Grogan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1407. Plaintiff Joanne Grzelak is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Grzelak, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Grzelak and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Grzelak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Grzelak was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1408. Plaintiff Patricia Grzymalski is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Matthew James Grzymalski, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew James Grzymalski and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew James Grzymalski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew James Grzymalski was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1409. Plaintiff Cai Zhang is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Liming Gu, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Liming Gu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1410. Plaintiff Yuau Ku is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Liming Gu, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Liming Gu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

261

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 263 of 978

1411. Plaintiff Jin Liu is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Liming Gu, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Liming Gu and on behalf of all survivors of Liming Gu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Liming Gu was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1412. Plaintiff Fushan Gu is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Liming Gu, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Liming Gu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1413. Plaintiff Yu Zhou Gu is a resident of China, the Sibling of Decedent Liming Gu, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Liming Gu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1414. Plaintiff Beatrice Josephine Guadagno, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Richard J. Guadagno; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1415. Plaintiff Lori M. Guadagno is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Richard J. Guadagno, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard J. Guadagno and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1416. Plaintiff Jerry F. Guadagno is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Richard J. Guadagno, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard J. Guadagno and on behalf of all survivors of Richard J. Guadagno and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard J. Guadagno was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville,

262

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 264 of 978

Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1417. Plaintiff Elise S. Guadalupe is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Jose Antonio Guadalupe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jose Antonio Guadalupe and on behalf of all survivors of Jose Antonio Guadalupe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jose Antonio Guadalupe was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1418. Plaintiff Edwin H. Yuen is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Cindy Yanzhu Guan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cindy Yanzhu Guan and on behalf of all survivors of Cindy Yanzhu Guan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cindy Yanzhu Guan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1419. Plaintiff Naoemi P. Gullickson is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph P. Gullickson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph P. Gullickson and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Gullickson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph P. Gullickson was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1420. Plaintiff Thomas Guza is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Child of Decedent Philip T. Guza, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Philip T. Guza and on behalf of all survivors of Philip T. Guza

263

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 265 of 978

and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip T. Guza was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1421. Plaintiff Anthony C. Guzzardo is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Barbara Guzzardo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Barbara Guzzardo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1422. Plaintiff Anthony Guzzardo, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Barbara Guzzardo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Barbara Guzzardo and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara Guzzardo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barbara Guzzardo was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1423. Plaintiff Marjorie Ann Farley is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Parent of Decedent Paige Farley Hackel, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paige Farley Hackel and on behalf of all survivors of Paige Farley Hackel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paige Farley Hackel was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1424. Plaintiff Allan R. Hackel is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Paige Farley Hackel, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Spouse of Paige Farley Hackel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

264

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 266 of 978

1425. Plaintiff Patricia Ann Thompson-Haentzler is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Philip Haentzler, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Philip Haentzler and on behalf of all survivors of Philip Haentzler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip Haentzler was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1426. Plaintiff Maryjane Hagis is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Steven M. Hagis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Steven M. Hagis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1427. Plaintiff Stacy Hagis Bruno is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Steven M. Hagis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Steven M. Hagis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1428. Plaintiff Gloria Hagis is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Steven M. Hagis, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven M. Hagis and on behalf of all survivors of Steven M. Hagis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven M. Hagis was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1429. Plaintiff Christopher Hagis is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Steven M. Hagis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Steven M. Hagis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

265

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 267 of 978

1430. Plaintiff Steve Hagis, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Steven M. Hagis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Steven M. Hagis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1431. Plaintiff Elizabeth J. Adams is a resident of the State of West Virginia, the Parent of Decedent Marylou Hague, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marylou Hague and on behalf of all survivors of Marylou Hague and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marylou Hague was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1432. Plaintiff Eugene T. Hague, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of West Virginia, and the Parent of Decedent Marylou Hague; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1433. Plaintiff Geraldine Halderman is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent David Halderman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Halderman and on behalf of all survivors of David Halderman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Halderman was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1434. Plaintiff Marianne Angelo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent David Halderman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of David Halderman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

266

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 268 of 978

1435. Plaintiff Yanique Hall is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Vaswald George Hall, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Vaswald George Hall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1436. Plaintiff Beverly Hall is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Vaswald George Hall, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vaswald George Hall and on behalf of all survivors of Vaswald George Hall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vaswald George Hall was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1437. Plaintiff Brenda Halligan, now deceased, was a resident of United Kingdom, and the Parent of Decedent Robert John Halligan; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1438. Plaintiff Lara Stacey is a resident of United Kingdom, the Child of Decedent Robert John Halligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert John Halligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1439. Plaintiff Sarah Jane Robbins is a resident of Burnside, Australia, the Child of Decedent Robert John Halligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert John Halligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1440. Plaintiff Emma Louise Arro is a resident of Hong Kong, the Child of Decedent Robert John Halligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert John Halligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

267

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 269 of 978

1441. Plaintiff Mary Kathleen Lynn is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Robert John Halligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert John Halligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1442. Plaintiff Jeraldine Halligan is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Robert John Halligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert John Halligan and on behalf of all survivors of Robert John Halligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert John Halligan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1443. Plaintiff James E. Halligan is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Child of Decedent Robert John Halligan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Robert John Halligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1444. Plaintiff Trevor Andrew Halligan is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent Robert John Halligan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Robert John Halligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1445. Plaintiff William G. Halligan is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Robert John Halligan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert John Halligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1446. Plaintiff David Mitchell Halligan is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Robert John Halligan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert John Halligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1447. Plaintiff Mary Alice Halloran is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Vincent Gerard Halloran, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of

268

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 270 of 978

Vincent Gerard Halloran and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1448. Plaintiff Maureen Ruth Halvorson is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent James D. Halvorson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James D. Halvorson and on behalf of all survivors of James D. Halvorson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James D. Halvorson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1449. Plaintiff Lisa A. Ventura is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Felicia Hamilton, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Felicia Hamilton and on behalf of all survivors of Felicia Hamilton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Felicia Hamilton was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1450. Plaintiff Walter E. Hamilton is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Felicia Hamilton, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Felicia Hamilton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1451. Plaintiff Elizabeth Hamilton is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Hamilton, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Hamilton and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Hamilton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Hamilton was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

269

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 271 of 978

1452. Plaintiff Sue Hammond is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Parent of Decedent Carl Max Hammond, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Carl Max Hammond, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1453. Plaintiff Cynthia Sue Sumner is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Sibling of Decedent Carl Max Hammond, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carl Max Hammond, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Carl Max Hammond, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carl Max Hammond, Jr. was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1454. Plaintiff Carl M. Hammond, Sr. is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Parent of Decedent Carl Max Hammond, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Carl Max Hammond, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1455. Plaintiff Patricia Rose Hanley is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Sean Hanley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Sean Hanley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1456. Plaintiff Gerald Hanley is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Sean Hanley, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Sean Hanley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1457. Plaintiff Gerald T. Hanley is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Hanley, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Hanley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

270

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 272 of 978

1458. Plaintiff Kevin E. Hanley is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Hanley, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Hanley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1459. Plaintiff Bryan T. Hanley is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Hanley, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Hanley and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Hanley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean Hanley was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1460. Plaintiff Nancy Elizabeth Hannaford is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Kevin James Hannaford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kevin James Hannaford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1461. Plaintiff Elizabeth L. Saraceno is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Kevin James Hannaford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin James Hannaford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1462. Plaintiff Eileen A. Hannaford is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Kevin James Hannaford, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin James Hannaford and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin James Hannaford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin James Hannaford was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

271

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 273 of 978

1463. Plaintiff James Joseph Hannaford is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Kevin James Hannaford, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kevin James Hannaford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1464. Plaintiff Patrick Gerard Hannaford is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Kevin James Hannaford, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin James Hannaford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1465. Plaintiff Gaye Hannon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Dana Rey Hannon, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Dana Rey Hannon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1466. Plaintiff Kyle Hannon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Dana Rey Hannon, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dana Rey Hannon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1467. The Representative of the Estate of Dana Rey Hannon brings this action on behalf of all survivors of Dana Rey Hannon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dana Rey Hannon was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. Plaintiff Thomas Hannon, now deceased, was a resident of the State of NEw Jersey and the Parent of Decedent Dana Rey Hannon; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1468. Plaintiff C. Lee Hanson is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Grandparent of Decedent Christine Lee Hanson, and brings this action on his own behalf as Grandparent and

272

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 274 of 978

as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Lee Hanson and on behalf of all survivors of Christine Lee Hanson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christine Lee Hanson was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1469. Plaintiff Eunice Katherine Hanson is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Peter Burton Hanson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Peter Burton Hanson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1470. Plaintiff Kathryn Lee Barrere is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Burton Hanson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Burton Hanson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1471. Plaintiff C. Lee Hanson is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Peter Burton Hanson, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Burton Hanson and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Burton Hanson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Burton Hanson was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1472. Plaintiff John Hyunsool Kim is a resident of the State of Hawaii, the Sibling of Decedent Sue Ju Hanson, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sue Ju Hanson and on behalf of all survivors of Sue Ju Hanson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sue Ju Hanson was

273

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 275 of 978

killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1473. Plaintiff Julia K. Haramis is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Vassilios G. Haramis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Vassilios G. Haramis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1474. Plaintiff Gloria Haramis is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Vassilios G. Haramis, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vassilios G. Haramis and on behalf of all survivors of Vassilios G. Haramis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vassilios G. Haramis was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1475. Plaintiff George Vassilion Haramis is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Vassilios G. Haramis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Vassilios G. Haramis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1476. Plaintiff Judith Kay Hardacre is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Gerald Hardacre, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gerald Hardacre and on behalf of all survivors of Gerald Hardacre and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerald Hardacre was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

274

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 276 of 978

1477. Plaintiff Lawrence Hardacre, now deceased, was a resident of the State of California, and the Sibling of Decedent Gerald Hardacre; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1478. Plaintiff Patricia E. Hargrave is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Timothy J. Hargrave, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Timothy J. Hargrave and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1479. Plaintiff Caroline Anna Harlin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Daniel Edward Harlin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Daniel Edward Harlin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1480. Plaintiff Joan Patricia Harlin is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Edward Harlin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Edward Harlin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1481. Plaintiff Debra A. Harlin is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Daniel Edward Harlin, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Edward Harlin and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Edward Harlin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Edward Harlin was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1482. Plaintiff Wilbur Harlin, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Daniel Edward Harlin; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

275

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 277 of 978

1483. Plaintiff James Harlin is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Edward Harlin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Edward Harlin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1484. Plaintiff Robert W. Harlin is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Edward Harlin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Edward Harlin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1485. Plaintiff Andrea Caldarella is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Frances Haros, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Frances Haros and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1486. Plaintiff Maria Ann Galea is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Frances Haros, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frances Haros and on behalf of all survivors of Frances Haros and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frances Haros was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1487. Plaintiff Nicholas Haros, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Frances Haros, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Frances Haros and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1488. Plaintiff Miriam F. Harrell, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Harvey L. Harrell; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

276

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 278 of 978

1489. Plaintiff Molly Dune is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Harvey L. Harrell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Harvey L. Harrell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1490. Plaintiff DOE 37 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 37, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1491. Plaintiff David W. Harrell is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Harvey L. Harrell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Harvey L. Harrell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1492. Plaintiff Harvey L. Harrell, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Harvey L. Harrell; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1493. Plaintiff Miriam F. Harrell, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Stephen G. Harrell; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1494. Plaintiff Molly Dune is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen G. Harrell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen G. Harrell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1495. Plaintiff DOE 37 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 37, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

277

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 279 of 978

1496. Plaintiff David W. Harrell is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen G. Harrell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen G. Harrell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1497. Plaintiff Harvey L. Harrell, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Stephen G. Harrell; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1498. Plaintiff Arvette Denise Harris is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Parent of Decedent Aisha Ann Harris, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Aisha Ann Harris and on behalf of all survivors of Aisha Ann Harris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Aisha Ann Harris was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1499. Plaintiff Marcus J. Harris is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Aisha Ann Harris, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Aisha Ann Harris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1500. Plaintiff Robert Harris, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of North Carolina, and the Parent of Decedent Aisha Ann Harris; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1501. Plaintiff Mildred Harris is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Stewart D. Harris, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Stewart D. Harris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

278

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 280 of 978

1502. Plaintiff Rubin Jay Harris, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Stewart D. Harris; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1503. Plaintiff Lloyd Harris is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Stewart D. Harris, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stewart D. Harris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1504. Plaintiff Betty J. Mathwig, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Wisconsin, and the Parent of Decedent John P. Hart; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1505. Plaintiff Christine Louise Reichert-Hart is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Hart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Hart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1506. Plaintiff Mary Elizabeth Meixelsperger is a resident of the State of Kentucky, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Hart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Hart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1507. Plaintiff Sandra Ellen Shelley is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Hart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Hart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1508. Plaintiff Jeanine Hart Seaman is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Hart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Hart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1509. Plaintiff Laurie Sue Hart is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Spouse of Decedent John P. Hart, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

279

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 281 of 978

Representative of the Estate of John P. Hart and on behalf of all survivors of John P. Hart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John P. Hart was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1510. Plaintiff James A. Hart, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of Alaska, and the Sibling of Decedent John P. Hart; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1511. Plaintiff Rita A. Hashem is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Peter Paul Hashem, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Paul Hashem and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Paul Hashem and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Paul Hashem was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1512. Plaintiff Grace Susan Hatton is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Terence Sean Hatton, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Terence Sean Hatton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1513. Plaintiff Grace Susan Hatton is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Terence Sean Hatton, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Terence Sean Hatton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1514. Plaintiff Elizabeth Petrone Hatton is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Terence Sean Hatton, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Terence Sean Hatton and on behalf of all

280

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 282 of 978

survivors of Terence Sean Hatton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terence Sean Hatton was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1515. Plaintiff Kenneth Roberts Hatton is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Terence Sean Hatton, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Terence Sean Hatton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1516. Plaintiff Erika Ann Haub is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael Haub, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Haub and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Haub and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Haub was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1517. Plaintiff Susan Conklin is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Donald G. Havlish, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Donald G. Havlish, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1518. Plaintiff Fiona Michaela Havlish is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Spouse of Decedent Donald G. Havlish, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald G. Havlish, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Donald G. Havlish, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald G. Havlish, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

281

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 283 of 978

1519. Plaintiff William Havlish is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Donald G. Havlish, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Donald G. Havlish, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1520. Plaintiff Donald G. Havlish, Sr. is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Parent of Decedent Donald G. Havlish, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Donald G. Havlish, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1521. Plaintiff Elizabeth Gail Hayden is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent James E. Hayden, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James E. Hayden and on behalf of all survivors of James E. Hayden and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James E. Hayden was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1522. Plaintiff Deborah Lynn Hayes is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Jay Hayes, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Jay Hayes and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Jay Hayes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Jay Hayes was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1523. Plaintiff Janice Hazelcorn is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Scott Hazelcorn, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Scott Hazelcorn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

282

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 284 of 978

1524. Plaintiff Charles Hazelcorn is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Scott Hazelcorn, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Hazelcorn and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Hazelcorn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Hazelcorn was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1525. Plaintiff Eric Hazelcorn is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Scott Hazelcorn, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Scott Hazelcorn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1526. Plaintiff Bernard Heeran is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Charles F.X. Heeran, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Charles F.X. Heeran and on behalf of all survivors of Charles F.X. Heeran and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles F.X. Heeran was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1527. Plaintiff Thomas P. Heidenberger is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of Decedent Michele M. Heidenberger, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michele M. Heidenberger and on behalf of all survivors of Michele M. Heidenberger and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michele M. Heidenberger was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

283

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 285 of 978

1528. Plaintiff Debora Hemschoot is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Mark Hemschoot, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Hemschoot and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Hemschoot and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Hemschoot was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1529. Plaintiff David C. Hemschoot is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Mark Hemschoot, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Mark Hemschoot and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1530. Plaintiff Jeffrey W. Hemschoot is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Mark Hemschoot, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Mark Hemschoot and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1531. Plaintiff DOE 11 is a resident of the state of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 11, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 11 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 11 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 11 was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1532. Plaintiff Patricia A. Henrique is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michelle Marie Henrique, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michelle Marie Henrique and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

284

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 286 of 978

1533. Plaintiff Christina Henrique is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michelle Marie Henrique, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michelle Marie Henrique and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1534. Plaintiff George Henrique is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michelle Marie Henrique, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michelle Marie Henrique and on behalf of all survivors of Michelle Marie Henrique and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michelle Marie Henrique was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1535. Plaintiff Paul R. Henrique is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michelle Marie Henrique, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michelle Marie Henrique and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1536. Plaintiff Michael Henrique is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michelle Marie Henrique, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michelle Marie Henrique and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1537. Plaintiff Alice A. Henry is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph P. Henry, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Joseph P. Henry and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Henry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph P. Henry was

285

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 287 of 978

killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1538. Plaintiff Kathleen S. Henry is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph P. Henry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1539. Plaintiff Mary Henry is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph P. Henry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1540. Plaintiff Edward Henry is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph P. Henry, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Joseph P. Henry and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Henry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph P. Henry was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1541. Plaintiff Michael Henry is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph P. Henry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1542. Plaintiff Daniel Henry is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph P. Henry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1543. Plaintiff Edward Henry, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph P. Henry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph P. Henry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

286

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 288 of 978

1544. Plaintiff Ethel M. Henry is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent William Henry, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Henry and on behalf of all survivors of William Henry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Henry was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1545. Plaintiff Allyson Hepburn is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Robert Allan Hepburn, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert Allan Hepburn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1546. Plaintiff Jennifer Hepburn is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Robert Allan Hepburn, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert Allan Hepburn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1547. Plaintiff Theresa Lynn Hepburn is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Allan Hepburn, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Allan Hepburn and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Allan Hepburn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Allan Hepburn was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1548. Plaintiff Margaret Mccrane is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Mary Herencia, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Herencia and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Herencia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary Herencia was

287

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 289 of 978

killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1549. Plaintiff Peter Carr, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent Mary Herencia; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1550. Plaintiff Kevin Carr, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent Mary Herencia; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1551. Plaintiff Julio Herencia is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Mary Herencia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Mary Herencia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1552. Plaintiff Joseph Herencia is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Mary Herencia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Mary Herencia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1553. Plaintiff Carmen Eneida Irizarry is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Claribel Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Claribel Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1554. Plaintiff Maribel Topaltzas is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Claribel Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Claribel Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1555. Plaintiff Jaime Villalobos, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Claribel Hernandez; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

288

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 290 of 978

1556. Plaintiff Eslyn Hernandez, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Claribel Hernandez, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Claribel Hernandez and on behalf of all survivors of Claribel Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Claribel Hernandez was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1557. Plaintiff Jacqueline Hernandez is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1558. Plaintiff Catherine Hernandez is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1559. Plaintiff Alejandrina Feliciano is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1560. Plaintiff Marisol Hernandez is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Sibling of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1561. Plaintiff Miriam Luz Khatri is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

289

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 291 of 978

1562. Plaintiff Luz Milagros Luna is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1563. Plaintiff Merquiades Diaz is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1564. Plaintiff Eulogia Hernandez is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Norberto Hernandez and on behalf of all survivors of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Norberto Hernandez was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1565. Plaintiff Willy Alberto Hernandez is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1566. Plaintiff Pablo Luis Hernandez is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1567. Plaintiff Hector Luis Hernandez is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

290

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 292 of 978

1568. Plaintiff Venancio Hernandez, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1569. Plaintiff Venancio Hernandez, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1570. Plaintiff Eslyn Hernandez, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Norberto Hernandez, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Norberto Hernandez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1571. Plaintiff Leslie Sue Hersch is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Jeffrey A. Hersch, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey A. Hersch and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey A. Hersch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey A. Hersch was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1572. Plaintiff Barbara Marille Hetzel is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Thomas J. Hetzel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas J. Hetzel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1573. Plaintiff Dorine Hetzel is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas J. Hetzel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas J. Hetzel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

291

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 293 of 978

1574. Plaintiff Diana Hetzel is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas J. Hetzel, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Hetzel and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. Hetzel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Hetzel was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1575. Plaintiff Egon Hermann Hetzel is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Thomas J. Hetzel, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Thomas J. Hetzel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1576. Plaintiff Daniel Hetzel is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas J. Hetzel, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas J. Hetzel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1577. Plaintiff Ana Rosario is a resident of the State of New York, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Emencio Dario Hidalgo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Domestic Partner of Emencio Dario Hidalgo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1578. Plaintiff Caren Higgins is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Spouse of Decedent Timothy Higgins, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Timothy Higgins and on behalf of all survivors of Timothy Higgins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy Higgins was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

292

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 294 of 978

1579. Plaintiff Rachael Higley is a resident of the State of Louisiana, the Sibling of Decedent Robert Dale Warren Higley, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Dale Warren Higley, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1580. Plaintiff Todd E.H. Higley, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Sibling of Decedent Robert Dale Warren Higley, II; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1581. Plaintiff John Douglas Higley is a resident of the State of Louisiana, the Parent of Decedent Robert Dale Warren Higley, II, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Robert Dale Warren Higley, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1582. Plaintiff Virginia A. Hindy is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Mark D. Hindy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Mark D. Hindy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1583. Plaintiff George V. Hindy is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Mark D. Hindy, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark D. Hindy and on behalf of all survivors of Mark D. Hindy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark D. Hindy was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1584. Plaintiff Gregory J. Hindy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Mark D. Hindy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark D. Hindy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

293

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 295 of 978

1585. Plaintiff Sheila C. Hobin, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Connecticut, and the Spouse of Decedent James J. Hobin; the Representative of her Estate, Sean Michael Hobin, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1586. Plaintiff Donna Dietrich is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent James J. Hobin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James J. Hobin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1587. Plaintiff Sean Michael Hobin is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent James J. Hobin, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James J. Hobin and on behalf of all survivors of James J. Hobin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James J. Hobin was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1588. Plaintiff Derrick J. Hobin is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent James J. Hobin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of James J. Hobin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1589. Plaintiff Judith Hobson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Robert Wayne Hobson, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert Wayne Hobson, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1590. Plaintiff Lisa Ann Hopkins is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert Wayne Hobson, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

294

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 296 of 978

Robert Wayne Hobson, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1591. Plaintiff Laura J. Decoster is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Robert Wayne Hobson, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Wayne Hobson, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1592. Plaintiff Cynthia Hobson McNutt is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Wayne Hobson, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Wayne Hobson, III and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Wayne Hobson, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Wayne Hobson, III was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1593. Plaintiff Matthew Hobson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert Wayne Hobson, III, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Wayne Hobson, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1594. Plaintiff Barbara A. Hoerner is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Ronald George Hoerner, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald George Hoerner and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald George Hoerner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald George Hoerner was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

295

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 297 of 978

1595. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Child of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1596. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1597. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1598. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1599. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1600. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 03 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 03 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 03 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

296

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 298 of 978

1601. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Child of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1602. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the Maryland, the Child of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1603. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the Virginia, the Child of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1604. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1605. Plaintiff DOE 03 is a resident of the Florida, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 03, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1606. Plaintiff Alicia Hofer is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent John Hofer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of John Hofer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1607. Plaintiff Billie Ann Hofer is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent John Hofer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John Hofer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

297

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 299 of 978

1608. Plaintiff Susan Caneso is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent John Hofer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Hofer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1609. Plaintiff Rebecca Hofer is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent John Hofer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Hofer and on behalf of all survivors of John Hofer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Hofer was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1610. Plaintiff Richard Hofer is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent John Hofer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Hofer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1611. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1612. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1613. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

298

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 300 of 978

1614. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1615. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the California, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1616. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1617. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 76 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 76 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 76 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1618. Plaintiff DOE 76, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 76; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1619. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the California, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

299

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 301 of 978

1620. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the California, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1621. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1622. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1623. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1624. Plaintiff DOE 76 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 76, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1625. Plaintiff Gail Hoffmann is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Frederick Hoffmann, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frederick Hoffmann and on behalf of all survivors of Frederick Hoffmann and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frederick Hoffmann was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1626. Plaintiff Gail Hoffmann is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Michele Hoffmann, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the

300

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 302 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Michele Hoffmann and on behalf of all survivors of Michele Hoffmann and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michele Hoffmann was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1627. The Representative of the Estate of Judith Florence Hofmiller brings this action on behalf of all survivors of Judith Florence Hofmiller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Judith Florence Hofmiller was killed in One World Trade Center area in New York City on September 11, 2001." 1628. Plaintiff Robert Thomas Winkis, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Tennessee, and the Spouse of Decedent Judith Florence Hofmiller; the Representative of his Estate, Richard J. Winkis, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1629. Plaintiff Robin Hohlweck is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Thomas Warren Hohlweck, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Thomas Warren Hohlweck, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1630. Plaintiff Randolph T. Hohlweck is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Thomas Warren Hohlweck, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Thomas Warren Hohlweck, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1631. Plaintiff Todd W. Hohlweck is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Thomas Warren Hohlweck, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of

301

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 303 of 978

Thomas Warren Hohlweck, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1632. Plaintiff Jessica Lin Hidalgo Holland is a resident of the State of New Mexico, the Child of Decedent Cora Hidalgo Holland, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Cora Hidalgo Holland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1633. Plaintiff Stephanie Denise Hidalgo Holland-Brodney is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Cora Hidalgo Holland, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Cora Hidalgo Holland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1634. Plaintiff Maria Y. Aldaco is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Cora Hidalgo Holland, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Cora Hidalgo Holland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1635. Plaintiff Gonzalo A. Hidalgo, now deceased, was a resident of the State of California, and the Sibling of Decedent Cora Hidalgo Holland; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1636. Plaintiff Nathaniel K. Holland is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Cora Hidalgo Holland, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Cora Hidalgo Holland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1637. Plaintiff Ernie Hidalgo is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Cora Hidalgo Holland, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Cora Hidalgo Holland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

302

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 304 of 978

1638. Plaintiff Stephen K. Holland is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Cora Hidalgo Holland, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cora Hidalgo Holland and on behalf of all survivors of Cora Hidalgo Holland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cora Hidalgo Holland was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1639. Plaintiff Carol Ann O'Toole is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Holland, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Holland, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1640. Plaintiff Tara Holland-Hickey is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Holland, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Holland, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1641. Plaintiff Joseph Holland is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Holland, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Holland, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1642. Plaintiff Martha R. Jackson-Holley is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of Decedent Jimmie I. Holley, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jimmie I. Holley and on behalf of all survivors of Jimmie I. Holley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jimmie I. Holley was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

303

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 305 of 978

1643. Plaintiff Beaulah Holmes, now deceased, was a resident of the State of South Carolina, and the Parent of Decedent Elizabeth Holmes; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1644. Plaintiff Doris Holmes is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Elizabeth Holmes, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1645. Plaintiff Louise Ellerbe is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Elizabeth Holmes, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1646. Plaintiff Vivian Byas is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Elizabeth Holmes, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Elizabeth Holmes and on behalf of all survivors of Elizabeth Holmes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Elizabeth Holmes was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1647. Plaintiff Walter Byas is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Elizabeth Holmes, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1648. Plaintiff Thomas Holmes is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Elizabeth Holmes, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

304

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 306 of 978

1649. Plaintiff Christopher Holmes, Jr. is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Elizabeth Holmes, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Elizabeth Holmes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1650. Plaintiff Winifred M. Homer is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Herbert Wilson Homer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Herbert Wilson Homer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1651. Plaintiff Karen L. Homer is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Herbert Wilson Homer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Herbert Wilson Homer and on behalf of all survivors of Herbert Wilson Homer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Herbert Wilson Homer was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1652. Plaintiff William T. Homer is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Herbert Wilson Homer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Herbert Wilson Homer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1653. Plaintiff Stephen H. Homer is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Herbert Wilson Homer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Herbert Wilson Homer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

305

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 307 of 978

1654. Plaintiff Rita Hopper is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent James P. Hopper, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James P. Hopper and on behalf of all survivors of James P. Hopper and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James P. Hopper was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1655. Plaintiff Lisa Hord is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Montgomery Hord, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Montgomery Hord and on behalf of all survivors of Montgomery Hord and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Montgomery Hord was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1656. Plaintiff Mary A. Horn is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Joseph Horn, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Joseph Horn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1657. Plaintiff Christine M. Grauer is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Joseph Horn, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Horn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1658. Plaintiff Maureen Ann Horn is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Joseph Horn, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Joseph Horn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1659. Plaintiff Charles H. Horn is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Joseph Horn, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the

306

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 308 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Joseph Horn and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Joseph Horn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Joseph Horn was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1660. Plaintiff DOE 108 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 108, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1661. Plaintiff DOE 108 is a resident of the Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 108, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1662. Plaintiff DOE 108 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 108, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 108 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 108 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 108 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1663. Plaintiff Patricia M. Horohoe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

307

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 309 of 978

1664. Plaintiff Patricia M. Witschel is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1665. Plaintiff Donna M. Erskine is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1666. Plaintiff Michael E. Horohoe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1667. Plaintiff Robert L. Horohoe, Sr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Robert L. Horohoe, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert L. Horohoe, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1668. Plaintiff Miriam Horrocks is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Michael Robert Horrocks, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Robert Horrocks and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Robert Horrocks and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Robert Horrocks was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

308

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 310 of 978

1669. Plaintiff Elizabeth Horwitz is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Aaron Horwitz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Aaron Horwitz and on behalf of all survivors of Aaron Horwitz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Aaron Horwitz was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1670. Plaintiff Tara Horwitz is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Aaron Horwitz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Aaron Horwitz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1671. Plaintiff Allan Horwitz is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Aaron Horwitz, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Aaron Horwitz and on behalf of all survivors of Aaron Horwitz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Aaron Horwitz was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1672. Plaintiff Blake Horwitz is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Aaron Horwitz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Aaron Horwitz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1673. Plaintiff Robert Horwitz is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Aaron Horwitz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Aaron Horwitz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1674. Plaintiff Sonya M. Houston is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Uhuru Gonja Houston, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

309

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 311 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Uhuru Gonja Houston and on behalf of all survivors of Uhuru Gonja Houston and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Uhuru Gonja Houston was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1675. Plaintiff Julia P. Shontere is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of Decedent Angela Marie Houtz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angela Marie Houtz and on behalf of all survivors of Angela Marie Houtz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Angela Marie Houtz was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1676. Plaintiff Emily Howell is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael C. Howell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael C. Howell and on behalf of all survivors of Michael C. Howell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael C. Howell was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1677. Plaintiff Kevin M. Howell is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael C. Howell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Michael C. Howell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1678. Plaintiff Donna M. Howell, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent Steven Leon Howell; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

310

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 312 of 978

1679. Plaintiff Fay Caputo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Steven Leon Howell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Steven Leon Howell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1680. Plaintiff Ralph L. Howell is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Steven Leon Howell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Steven Leon Howell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1681. Plaintiff Joseph W. Hromada is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Milagros Hromada, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Milagros Hromada and on behalf of all survivors of Milagros Hromada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Milagros Hromada was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1682. Plaintiff Katelyn Ann Huczko is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Stephen Huczko, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Stephen Huczko, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1683. Plaintiff Kathleen C. Mcguire is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Stephen Huczko, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen Huczko, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Huczko, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Huczko, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

311

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 313 of 978

1684. Plaintiff Elaine L. Hughes is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kris Robert Hughes, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kris Robert Hughes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1685. Plaintiff Kimberly Franco is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Kris Robert Hughes, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kris Robert Hughes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1686. Plaintiff Henry R. Hughes is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kris Robert Hughes, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kris Robert Hughes and on behalf of all survivors of Kris Robert Hughes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kris Robert Hughes was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1687. Plaintiff Keith Hughes is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Kris Robert Hughes, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kris Robert Hughes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1688. Plaintiff Donna Sara Hughes is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Paul Rexford Hughes, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Rexford Hughes and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Rexford Hughes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Rexford Hughes was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1689. Plaintiff Louise Hughes is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Robert T. Hughes, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the

312

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 314 of 978

Co-Administrator of the Estate of Robert T. Hughes, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert T. Hughes, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert T. Hughes, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1690. Plaintiff Leigha Hughes is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert T. Hughes, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert T. Hughes, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1691. Plaintiff Shanin Hughes is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert T. Hughes, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert T. Hughes, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1692. Plaintiff Lyndsey Hughes is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert T. Hughes, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert T. Hughes, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1693. Plaintiff Robert T. Hughes is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Robert T. Hughes, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Robert T. Hughes, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert T. Hughes, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert T. Hughes, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1694. Plaintiff Rosanne Hughes is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas F. Hughes, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas F. Hughes, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas F. Hughes, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

313

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 315 of 978

Thomas F. Hughes, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1695. Plaintiff Tennyson Huie is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Susan Huie, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Huie and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Huie and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susan Huie was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1696. Plaintiff Gordon Huie is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Susan Huie, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Susan Huie and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1697. Plaintiff Jennifer Woodward Hunt is a resident of the State of Maine, the Spouse of Decedent William Christopher Hunt, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Christopher Hunt and on behalf of all survivors of William Christopher Hunt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Christopher Hunt was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1698. Plaintiff Natalie Christina Conners is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Robert Joseph Hymel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert Joseph Hymel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1699. Plaintiff Beatriz E. Hymel is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Joseph Hymel, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Joseph Hymel and on behalf of all survivors of

314

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 316 of 978

Robert Joseph Hymel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Joseph Hymel was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1700. Plaintiff Carolyne Yacoub Hynes is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas Edward Hynes, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Edward Hynes and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Edward Hynes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Edward Hynes was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1701. Plaintiff Monica Palatucci is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Joseph A. Ianelli, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Joseph A. Ianelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1702. Plaintiff Barbara Ellen Ianelli is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Joseph A. Ianelli, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph A. Ianelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1703. Plaintiff Jennifer Thompson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph A. Ianelli, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph A. Ianelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1704. Plaintiff Joseph Ianelli is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Joseph A. Ianelli, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph A. Ianelli and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph A. Ianelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

315

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 317 of 978

Joseph A. Ianelli was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1705. Plaintiff Ayse Ibis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Zuhtu Ibis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Zuhtu Ibis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1706. Plaintiff Hacer Ibis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Zuhtu Ibis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Zuhtu Ibis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1707. Plaintiff Leyla Uyar is a resident of Turkey, the Spouse of Decedent Zuhtu Ibis, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Zuhtu Ibis and on behalf of all survivors of Zuhtu Ibis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Zuhtu Ibis was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1708. Plaintiff Ali Ibis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Zuhtu Ibis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Zuhtu Ibis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1709. Plaintiff Mehmet Ibis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Zuhtu Ibis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Zuhtu Ibis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1710. Plaintiff Anne Habeeb, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent Michael Patrick Iken; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

316

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 318 of 978

1711. Plaintiff Monica Iken is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael Patrick Iken, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Patrick Iken and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Patrick Iken and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Patrick Iken was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1712. Plaintiff Gerard Iken is a resident of the State of Oregon, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Patrick Iken, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Patrick Iken and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1713. Plaintiff Alice Ill, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Frederick J. Ill, Jr.; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1714. Plaintiff Jane C. Ill is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Frederick J. Ill, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Frederick J. Ill, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1715. Plaintiff Frederick J. Ill, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Frederick J. Ill, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Frederick J. Ill, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1716. Plaintiff Gloria Ingrassia is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Noble Ingrassia, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Noble Ingrassia and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Noble Ingrassia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Noble Ingrassia was killed at One World Trade Center as a

317

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 319 of 978

result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1717. Plaintiff Elisa M. Ingrassia is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Noble Ingrassia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Noble Ingrassia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1718. Plaintiff Anthony Arcangelo Ingrassia is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Noble Ingrassia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Christopher Noble Ingrassia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1719. Plaintiff Anthony W. Ingrassia is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Noble Ingrassia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Noble Ingrassia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1720. Plaintiff Paul B. Ingrassia is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Noble Ingrassia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Noble Ingrassia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1721. Plaintiff Lucy A. Aita is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé of Decedent Paul W. Innella, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Paul W. Innella and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

318

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 320 of 978

1722. Plaintiff Joanne Irgang is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Doug Irgang, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Doug Irgang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1723. Plaintiff Steven Irgang is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Doug Irgang, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Doug Irgang and on behalf of all survivors of Doug Irgang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Doug Irgang was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1724. Plaintiff Lauri T. Isbrandtsen is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Parent of Decedent Erik Hans Isbrandtsen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Erik Hans Isbrandtsen and on behalf of all survivors of Erik Hans Isbrandtsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Erik Hans Isbrandtsen was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1725. Plaintiff Dirk H. Isbrandtsen is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Erik Hans Isbrandtsen, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Erik Hans Isbrandtsen and on behalf of all survivors of Erik Hans Isbrandtsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Erik Hans Isbrandtsen was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1726. Plaintiff May Marconet is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Waleed Iskandar, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the

319

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 321 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Waleed Iskandar and on behalf of all survivors of Waleed Iskandar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Waleed Iskandar was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1727. Plaintiff Anthony DeTullio is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Sibling of Decedent Virginia Jablonski, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Virginia Jablonski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1728. Plaintiff Barry Jablonski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Virginia Jablonski, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Virginia Jablonski and on behalf of all survivors of Virginia Jablonski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Virginia Jablonski was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1729. Plaintiff DOE 47 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 47, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 47 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 47 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 47 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1730. Plaintiff Jennifer Brady is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Michael Grady Jacobs, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Michael Grady Jacobs and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

320

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 322 of 978

1731. Plaintiff Mary Brady is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Michael Grady Jacobs, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Michael Grady Jacobs and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1732. Plaintiff Peter Brady is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Michael Grady Jacobs, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Michael Grady Jacobs and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Grady Jacobs and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Grady Jacobs was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1733. Plaintiff Michael John Brady is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent Michael Grady Jacobs, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael Grady Jacobs and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Grady Jacobs and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Grady Jacobs was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1734. Plaintiff Deborah B. Jacobson, now deceased, was a resident of the State of California, and the Spouse of Decedent Steven A. Jacobson; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1735. Representative of the Estate of Steven A. Jacobson, Deceased, brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Steven A. Jacobson and on behalf of all survivors of Steven A. Jacobson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven A. Jacobson was killed at One World Trade Center s a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

321

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 323 of 978

1736. Plaintiff Rachel Bess Jacobson is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Steven A. Jacobson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Steven A. Jacobson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1737. Plaintiff Kimberly H. Jacoby is a resident of the State of Kentucky, the Spouse of Decedent Steven Donald Jacoby, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Donald Jacoby and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Donald Jacoby and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Donald Jacoby was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1738. Plaintiff Anna May Jagoda is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jake D. Jagoda, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Jake D. Jagoda and on behalf of all survivors of Jake D. Jagoda and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jake D. Jagoda was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1739. Plaintiff Louis John Jagoda is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jake D. Jagoda, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Jake D. Jagoda and on behalf of all survivors of Jake D. Jagoda and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jake D. Jagoda was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

322

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 324 of 978

1740. Plaintiff Sneh Jain is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Yudh V. Jain, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Yudh V. Jain and on behalf of all survivors of Yudh V. Jain and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Yudh V. Jain was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1741. Plaintiff Julie Ann Jalbert is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Robert A. Jalbert, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert A. Jalbert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1742. Plaintiff Suzanne E. Mccormick is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Robert A. Jalbert, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert A. Jalbert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1743. Plaintiff Catherine L. Jalbert is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Robert A. Jalbert, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert A. Jalbert and on behalf of all survivors of Robert A. Jalbert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert A. Jalbert was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1744. Plaintiff Michael A. Jalbert is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Robert A. Jalbert, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Robert A. Jalbert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

323

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 325 of 978

1745. Plaintiff Paul H. Jalbert is a resident of the State of Maine, the Sibling of Decedent Robert A. Jalbert, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert A. Jalbert and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1746. Plaintiff Marilyn R. Trudeau is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Parent of Decedent Amy Nicole Jarret, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Amy Nicole Jarret and on behalf of all survivors of Amy Nicole Jarret and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Amy Nicole Jarret was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1747. Plaintiff Alicia N. Curran is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Amy Nicole Jarret, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Amy Nicole Jarret and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1748. Plaintiff Matthew R. Jarret is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Amy Nicole Jarret, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Amy Nicole Jarret and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1749. Plaintiff Marc Douglas Jarret is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Amy Nicole Jarret, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Amy Nicole Jarret and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1750. Plaintiff Aram P. Jarret, III is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Amy Nicole Jarret, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Amy Nicole Jarret and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

324

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 326 of 978

1751. Plaintiff Aram P. Jarret, Jr. is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Parent of Decedent Amy Nicole Jarret, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Amy Nicole Jarret and on behalf of all survivors of Amy Nicole Jarret and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Amy Nicole Jarret was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1752. Plaintiff Jennifer Jenkins is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Joseph Jenkins, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Jenkins, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Jenkins, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Jenkins, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1753. Plaintiff Aline Jenkins is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Jenkins, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Jenkins, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1754. Plaintiff Debra Jenkins is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Jenkins, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Jenkins, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1755. Plaintiff Steven Jenkins is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Jenkins, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Jenkins, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

325

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 327 of 978

1756. Plaintiff Gordon R. Jenkins is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Jenkins, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Jenkins, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1757. Plaintiff Michael Jenkins is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Jenkins, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Jenkins, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1758. Plaintiff DOE 17 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 17, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 17 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 17 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 17 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1759. Plaintiff DOE 17 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Child of Decedent DOE 17, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1760. Plaintiff FuMei Chien Huang is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Hweidar Jian, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Hweidar Jian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1761. Plaintiff Hui-Cheng Chien is a resident of Taiwan, the Sibling of Decedent Hweidar Jian, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hweidar Jian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

326

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 328 of 978

1762. Plaintiff Hui-Chuan Jian is a resident of Taipei, Taiwan, the Sibling of Decedent Hweidar Jian, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hweidar Jian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1763. Plaintiff Hiuchun Jian is a resident of Taoyuan, Taiwan, the Sibling of Decedent Hweidar Jian, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hweidar Jian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1764. Plaintiff Ju-Hsiu Jian is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Hweidar Jian, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hweidar Jian and on behalf of all survivors of Hweidar Jian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hweidar Jian was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1765. Plaintiff Haomin Jian is a resident of the State of District of Columbia, the Child of Decedent Hweidar Jian, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Hweidar Jian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1766. Plaintiff Hui-Zon Jian is a resident of Taiwan, the Sibling of Decedent Hweidar Jian, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Hweidar Jian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1767. Plaintiff DOE 131 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent DOE 131, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1768. Plaintiff DOE 131 is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent DOE 131, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 131

327

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 329 of 978

and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 131 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 131 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1769. Plaintiff DOE 131 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 131, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1770. Plaintiff DOE 131 is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 131, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 131 and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 131 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 131 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1771. Plaintiff Dawn Marie Johnson is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Dennis M. Johnson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Dennis M. Johnson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1772. Plaintiff Elva Johnson is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Parent of Decedent Dennis M. Johnson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Dennis M. Johnson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1773. Plaintiff Gail Lindner is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent Dennis M. Johnson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dennis M. Johnson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

328

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 330 of 978

1774. Plaintiff Diane Czlapinski is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent Dennis M. Johnson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dennis M. Johnson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1775. Plaintiff Joyce L. Johnson is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Dennis M. Johnson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis M. Johnson and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis M. Johnson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis M. Johnson was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1776. Plaintiff Robert Johnson is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Parent of Decedent Dennis M. Johnson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Dennis M. Johnson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1777. Plaintiff Harry T. Jones, IV is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Spouse of Decedent Allison H. Jones, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Allison H. Jones and on behalf of all survivors of Allison H. Jones and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Allison H. Jones was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1778. Plaintiff Mary J. Jones is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Charles Edward Jones, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Edward Jones and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Edward Jones and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles Edward Jones was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the

329

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 331 of 978

World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1779. Plaintiff Susan Jones is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Christopher Jones, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Jones and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Jones and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Jones was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1780. Plaintiff Judith Jones is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Donald T. Jones, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Donald T. Jones, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1781. Plaintiff Donald T. Jones, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Donald T. Jones, II; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1782. Plaintiff William B. Jones, II is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Donald T. Jones, II, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Donald T. Jones, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1783. Plaintiff Ellen Jordan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Andrew B. Jordan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Andrew B. Jordan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1784. Plaintiff Ellen Green is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew B. Jordan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

330

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 332 of 978

1785. Plaintiff Elizabeth Kobel is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew B. Jordan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1786. Plaintiff Bernadette M Giuliani is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew B. Jordan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1787. Plaintiff Mary B Jordan-Potash is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew B. Jordan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1788. Plaintiff Margaret Gregory is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew B. Jordan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1789. Plaintiff Thomas Jordan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Andrew B. Jordan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Andrew B. Jordan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1790. Plaintiff Thomas P Jordan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew B. Jordan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1791. Plaintiff John C. Jordan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew B. Jordan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew B. Jordan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1792. Plaintiff Jennifer E. Josiah is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Jane Eileen Josiah, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Co-

331

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 333 of 978

Administrator of the Estate of Jane Eileen Josiah and on behalf of all survivors of Jane Eileen Josiah and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jane Eileen Josiah was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1793. Plaintiff Kelly C. Josiah is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Jane Eileen Josiah, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Jane Eileen Josiah and on behalf of all survivors of Jane Eileen Josiah and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jane Eileen Josiah was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1794. Plaintiff Sentija Jovic is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Anthony Jovic, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony Jovic and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony Jovic and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Jovic was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1795. Plaintiff Miriam Juarbe is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Angel L. Juarbe, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Angel L. Juarbe, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1796. Plaintiff Angel L. Juarbe, Sr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Angel L. Juarbe, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Angel L. Juarbe, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

332

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 334 of 978

1797. Plaintiff Richard A. Pecorella is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Karen S. Juday, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Fiancé of Karen S. Juday and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1798. Plaintiff Joan C. Kane, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Vincent D. Kane, Jr.; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1799. Plaintiff Patricia E. Flanders, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent Vincent D. Kane, Jr.; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1800. Plaintiff Elizabeth Kane Reich is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Vincent D. Kane, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Vincent D. Kane, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1801. Plaintiff Vincent D. Kane, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Vincent D. Kane, Jr.; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1802. Representative of the Estate of Vincent D. Kane, Jr., Deceased, brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Vincent D. Kane, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent D. Kane, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent D. Kane, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1803. Plaintiff Pilsoon Kang is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joon Koo Kang, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joon Koo Kang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

333

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 335 of 978

1804. Plaintiff Jamie Kang is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Joon Koo Kang, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joon Koo Kang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1805. Plaintiff Janet Kang is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joon Koo Kang, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joon Koo Kang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1806. Plaintiff Rebecca S. Hoang is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joon Koo Kang, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joon Koo Kang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1807. Plaintiff Seong Soon Kang is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joon Koo Kang, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Joon Koo Kang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1808. Plaintiff DOE 27 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 27, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 27 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 27 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 27 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1809. Plaintiff DOE 27 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Child of Decedent DOE 27, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

334

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 336 of 978

1810. Plaintiff DOE 27 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Child of Decedent DOE 27, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1811. Plaintiff Harold T. Kaplan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Deborah H. Kaplan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Deborah H. Kaplan and on behalf of all survivors of Deborah H. Kaplan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Deborah H. Kaplan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1812. Plaintiff Francine Charlotte Kaplan is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Robin Kaplan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robin Kaplan and on behalf of all survivors of Robin Kaplan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robin Kaplan was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1813. Plaintiff Edward Harvey Kaplan is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Robin Kaplan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Robin Kaplan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1814. Plaintiff Mark Kaplan is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Sibling of Decedent Robin Kaplan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robin Kaplan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

335

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 337 of 978

1815. Plaintiff Brenda Vandever is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Sibling of Decedent William A. Karnes, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William A. Karnes and on behalf of all survivors of William A. Karnes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William A. Karnes was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1816. Plaintiff Kara Kasper is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Charles Kasper, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Charles Kasper and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1817. Plaintiff Melissa Kasper is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Charles Kasper, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Charles Kasper and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1818. Plaintiff Laureen Kasper is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Charles Kasper, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Kasper and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Kasper and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles Kasper was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1819. Plaintiff Cynthia Ann Polo is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Child of Decedent Edward T. Keane, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Edward T. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1820. Plaintiff Barbara E. Keane is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Edward T. Keane, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

336

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 338 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward T. Keane and on behalf of all survivors of Edward T. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward T. Keane was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1821. Plaintiff Mark Edward Keane is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of Decedent Edward T. Keane, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Edward T. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1822. Plaintiff Charlotte Florence Keane is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1823. Plaintiff Constance Anne Keane is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1824. Plaintiff Theresa Irene Wilson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1825. Plaintiff Judith Ann Keane is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard M. Keane and on behalf of all survivors of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard M. Keane was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

337

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 339 of 978

1826. Plaintiff Richard Matthew Keane, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Massachusetts, and the Parent of Decedent Richard M. Keane; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1827. Plaintiff Robert F. Keane, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, and the Sibling of Decedent Richard M. Keane; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1828. Plaintiff Matthew Eamon Keane is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1829. Plaintiff Sean Michael Keane is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1830. Plaintiff Timothy Brendan Keane is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1831. Plaintiff Patrick James Keane is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1832. Plaintiff Paul Anthony Keane is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

338

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 340 of 978

1833. Plaintiff Garrett Paul Keane is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Sibling of Decedent Richard M. Keane, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard M. Keane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1834. Plaintiff Denise K. Keasler is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Parent of Decedent Karol Ann Keasler, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karol Ann Keasler and on behalf of all survivors of Karol Ann Keasler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karol Ann Keasler was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1835. Plaintiff Joann Anderson is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Barbara A. Keating, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Barbara A. Keating and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1836. Plaintiff Michael Keating is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Barbara A. Keating, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Administrator of the Estate of Barbara A. Keating and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara A. Keating and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barbara A. Keating was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1837. Plaintiff John Keating is a resident of Canada, the Child of Decedent Barbara A. Keating, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Barbara A. Keating and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

339

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 341 of 978

1838. Plaintiff Paul J. Keating is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Barbara A. Keating, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Barbara A. Keating and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1839. Plaintiff Martha Susan Grimm is a resident of the State of Louisiana, the Parent of Decedent Leo Russell Keene, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Leo Russell Keene, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1840. Plaintiff Krista Sue Keene is a resident of the State of Louisiana, the Sibling of Decedent Leo Russell Keene, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leo Russell Keene, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1841. Plaintiff Jennifer Keene Clyde is a resident of the State of Louisiana, the Sibling of Decedent Leo Russell Keene, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leo Russell Keene, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1842. Plaintiff Kristen M. Keene is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Leo Russell Keene, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Leo Russell Keene, III and on behalf of all survivors of Leo Russell Keene, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Leo Russell Keene, III was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1843. Plaintiff Leo R. Keene, II, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Louisiana, and the Parent of Decedent Leo Russell Keene, III; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

340

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 342 of 978

1844. Plaintiff Alice Buchholz Kelly is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Anthony Kelly, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Anthony Kelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1845. Plaintiff Carolyn Kelly is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Richard J. Kelly, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard J. Kelly, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Richard J. Kelly, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard J. Kelly, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1846. Plaintiff JoAnne Marie Kelly is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent William Hill Kelly, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of William Hill Kelly, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of William Hill Kelly, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Hill Kelly, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1847. Plaintiff Meigan Kelly is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent William Hill Kelly, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of William Hill Kelly, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1848. Plaintiff Kathleen K. Hamilton is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent William Hill Kelly, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of William Hill Kelly, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

341

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 343 of 978

1849. Plaintiff Maureen Kelly Donegan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent William Hill Kelly, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of William Hill Kelly, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1850. Plaintiff William Hill Kelly, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent William Hill Kelly, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of William Hill Kelly, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of William Hill Kelly, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Hill Kelly, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1851. Plaintiff Catherine Kennedy Miller is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Robert C. Kennedy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert C. Kennedy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1852. Plaintiff Meredith Andrews is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Robert C. Kennedy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert C. Kennedy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1853. Plaintiff Maureen Kennedy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Robert C. Kennedy, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert C. Kennedy and on behalf of all survivors of Robert C. Kennedy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert C. Kennedy was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

342

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 344 of 978

1854. Plaintiff Mary Keohane is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent John Richard Keohane, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of John Richard Keohane and on behalf of all survivors of John Richard Keohane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Richard Keohane was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1855. Plaintiff Darlene Keohane is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent John Richard Keohane, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Richard Keohane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1856. Plaintiff Donald Keohane is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent John Richard Keohane, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of John Richard Keohane and on behalf of all survivors of John Richard Keohane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Richard Keohane was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1857. Plaintiff Hedi N. Kershaw is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Ralph Francis Kershaw, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Executor of the Estate of Ralph Francis Kershaw and on behalf of all survivors of Ralph Francis Kershaw and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph Francis Kershaw was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

343

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 345 of 978

1858. Plaintiff Dianne P. Kerwin is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Ronald T. Kerwin, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald T. Kerwin and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald T. Kerwin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald T. Kerwin was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1859. Plaintiff Granvilette W. Kestenbaum is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Howard L. Kestenbaum, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Howard L. Kestenbaum and on behalf of all survivors of Howard L. Kestenbaum and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Howard L. Kestenbaum was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1860. Plaintiff Robert Dow is a resident of the State of New York, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Ruth Ketler, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Domestic Partner of Ruth Ketler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1861. Plaintiff Nazam Khan is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Sarah Khan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sarah Khan and on behalf of all survivors of Sarah Khan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sarah Khan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1862. Plaintiff Tahira Khan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Taimour Khan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal

344

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 346 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Taimour Khan and on behalf of all survivors of Taimour Khan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Taimour Khan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1863. Plaintiff Zara Khan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Taimour Khan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Taimour Khan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1864. Plaintiff Solomon Gayle is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé of Decedent Seilai Khoo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Fiancé and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Seilai Khoo and on behalf of all survivors of Seilai Khoo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Seilai Khoo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1865. Plaintiff Patricia Lynn Kiefer is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Vernon Kiefer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Vernon Kiefer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1866. Plaintiff Henry F. Kiefer is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Vernon Kiefer, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Vernon Kiefer and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Vernon Kiefer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Vernon Kiefer was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

345

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 347 of 978

1867. Plaintiff Darlene Therese Kinney is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Brian Kevin Kinney, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Brian Kevin Kinney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1868. Plaintiff Alison Kinney is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Spouse of Decedent Brian Kevin Kinney, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian Kevin Kinney and on behalf of all survivors of Brian Kevin Kinney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Kevin Kinney was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1869. Plaintiff Norman P. Kinney is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Brian Kevin Kinney, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Brian Kevin Kinney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1870. Plaintiff Donna M. Kirby is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Chris M. Kirby, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Chris M. Kirby and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1871. Plaintiff KellyAnn Racanelli is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Chris M. Kirby, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Chris M. Kirby and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1872. Plaintiff Jennifer M. Kirby is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Chris M. Kirby, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Chris M. Kirby and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

346

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 348 of 978

1873. Plaintiff James M. Kirby is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Chris M. Kirby, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Chris M. Kirby and on behalf of all survivors of Chris M. Kirby and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Chris M. Kirby was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1874. Plaintiff Brian P. Kirby is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Chris M. Kirby, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Chris M. Kirby and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1875. Plaintiff James M. Kirby, III is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Chris M. Kirby, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Chris M. Kirby and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1876. Plaintiff Lauren Kirschbaum is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Howard Barry Kirschbaum, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Howard Barry Kirschbaum and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1877. Plaintiff Rochelle Kirschbaum is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Howard Barry Kirschbaum, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Howard Barry Kirschbaum and on behalf of all survivors of Howard Barry Kirschbaum and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Howard Barry Kirschbaum was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

347

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 349 of 978

1878. Plaintiff Matthew Adam Kirschbaum is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Howard Barry Kirschbaum, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Howard Barry Kirschbaum and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1879. Plaintiff Barbara Kirwin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Glenn Davis Kirwin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Glenn Davis Kirwin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1880. Plaintiff Paul Harris Kirwin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Glenn Davis Kirwin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Glenn Davis Kirwin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1881. Plaintiff Lauren Kleinberg is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Alan D. Kleinberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Alan D. Kleinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1882. Plaintiff Vivian Lerner Shoemaker is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Alan D. Kleinberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Alan D. Kleinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1883. Plaintiff Marci Kleinberg-Bandelli is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Alan D. Kleinberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alan D. Kleinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1884. Plaintiff Marla Parker is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Alan D. Kleinberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alan D. Kleinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

348

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 350 of 978

1885. Plaintiff DOE 05 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 05, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1886. Plaintiff Mindy Kleinberg is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Alan D. Kleinberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alan D. Kleinberg and on behalf of all survivors of Alan D. Kleinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alan D. Kleinberg was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1887. Plaintiff DOE 05, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of DOE 05; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1888. Plaintiff Jacob Kleinberg is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Alan D. Kleinberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alan D. Kleinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1889. Plaintiff Sam Kleinberg is a resident of the State of , the Child of Decedent Alan D. Kleinberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alan D. Kleinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1890. Plaintiff Patricia B. Knox is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Thomas Patrick Knox, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas Patrick Knox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

349

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 351 of 978

1891. Plaintiff Mary Ellen Knox is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Patrick Knox, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1892. Plaintiff Patricia B. Lalley is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Patrick Knox, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1893. Plaintiff Kathleen Doolan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Patrick Knox, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1894. Plaintiff Nancy S. Knox is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas Patrick Knox, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Patrick Knox and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Patrick Knox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Patrick Knox was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1895. Plaintiff Denis Knox is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Patrick Knox, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1896. Plaintiff James Knox is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Patrick Knox, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Patrick Knox and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

350

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 352 of 978

1897. Plaintiff Leokadia Kobus, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Deborah Kobus; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1898. Plaintiff Robert Kobus is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Deborah Kobus, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Deborah Kobus and on behalf of all survivors of Deborah Kobus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Deborah Kobus was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1899. Plaintiff Irene Smolicz is a resident of the State of New York, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank J. Koestner and on behalf of all survivors of Frank J. Koestner and on behalf of minor child C.K. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank J. Koestner was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1900. Plaintiff Michelle A. Stabile is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Frank J. Koestner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Frank J. Koestner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1901. Plaintiff Maria Koestner is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Frank J. Koestner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Frank J. Koestner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

351

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 353 of 978

1902. Plaintiff Julianna M. Lanzer is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Frank J. Koestner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Frank J. Koestner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1903. Plaintiff Melissa White is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Fiancé of Decedent Ryan Ashley Kohart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Ryan Ashley Kohart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1904. Plaintiff Joy A. Kohart is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Ryan Ashley Kohart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Ryan Ashley Kohart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1905. Plaintiff Brett D. Kohart is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Ryan Ashley Kohart, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ryan Ashley Kohart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1906. Plaintiff Adam P. Kohart is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Ryan Ashley Kohart, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ryan Ashley Kohart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1907. Plaintiff Geoffrey A. Kohart, Jr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Ryan Ashley Kohart, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ryan Ashley Kohart and on behalf of all survivors of Ryan Ashley Kohart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ryan Ashley Kohart was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1908. Plaintiff Geoffrey A. Kohart, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Ryan Ashley Kohart, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the

352

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 354 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Ryan Ashley Kohart and on behalf of all survivors of Ryan Ashley Kohart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ryan Ashley Kohart was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1909. Plaintiff Patricia Anne Kondratenko is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Parent of Decedent Suzanne Kondratenko, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Suzanne Kondratenko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1910. Plaintiff Katherine J Kondratenko is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Suzanne Kondratenko, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Suzanne Kondratenko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1911. Plaintiff Caroline Ruestow is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling of Decedent Suzanne Kondratenko, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Suzanne Kondratenko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1912. Plaintiff Patricia Kondratenko-Collins is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Sibling of Decedent Suzanne Kondratenko, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Suzanne Kondratenko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1913. Plaintiff Sarah M. Kondratenko is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Sibling of Decedent Suzanne Kondratenko, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Suzanne Kondratenko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

353

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 355 of 978

1914. Plaintiff Aimee E Garrison is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling of Decedent Suzanne Kondratenko, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Suzanne Kondratenko and on behalf of all survivors of Suzanne Kondratenko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Suzanne Kondratenko was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1915. Plaintiff Eric Kondratenko is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Parent of Decedent Suzanne Kondratenko, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Suzanne Kondratenko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1916. Plaintiff Joyce Mercer is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Scott Kopytko, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Kopytko and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Kopytko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Kopytko was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1917. Plaintiff Christine Kopytko is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Scott Kopytko, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Scott Kopytko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1918. Plaintiff Susanna Ferm is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Bojan Kostic, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Bojan Kostic and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

354

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 356 of 978

1919. Plaintiff Nina Kostic is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Bojan Kostic, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Bojan Kostic and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1920. Plaintiff Olga Kostic-Jovanovic is a resident of Yugoslavia, the Sibling of Decedent Bojan Kostic, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Bojan Kostic and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1921. Plaintiff Zoe P. Kousoulis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Danielle Kousoulis, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Danielle Kousoulis and on behalf of all survivors of Danielle Kousoulis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Danielle Kousoulis was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1922. Plaintiff Eleni Kousoulis is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Danielle Kousoulis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Danielle Kousoulis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1923. Plaintiff Faith K. Hagerty is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling of Decedent Danielle Kousoulis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Danielle Kousoulis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1924. Plaintiff George P. Kousoulis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Danielle Kousoulis, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Danielle Kousoulis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1925. Plaintiff Lisa Maria Inzerillo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent William E. Krukowski, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

355

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 357 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of William E. Krukowski and on behalf of all survivors of William E. Krukowski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William E. Krukowski was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1926. Plaintiff DOE 51 is a resident of the California, the Child of Decedent DOE 51, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1927. Plaintiff DOE 51 is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent DOE 51, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1928. Plaintiff Felix Ksido is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Lyudmila Ksido, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lyudmila Ksido and on behalf of all survivors of Lyudmila Ksido and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lyudmila Ksido was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1929. Plaintiff Yachiyo Kuge is a resident of Japan, the Parent of Decedent Toshiya Kuge, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Toshiya Kuge and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1930. Plaintiff Hajime Kuge is a resident of Japan, the Parent of Decedent Toshiya Kuge, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Toshiya Kuge and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

356

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 358 of 978

1931. Plaintiff Naoya Kuge is a resident of Japan, the Sibling of Decedent Toshiya Kuge, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Toshiya Kuge and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1932. Plaintiff Lois H. Kumpel, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Kenneth B. Kumpel; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1933. Plaintiff Nancy Kumpel is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Kenneth B. Kumpel, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth B. Kumpel and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth B. Kumpel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth B. Kumpel was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1934. Plaintiff Kristen Kuveikis is a resident of the State of Kentucky, the Child of Decedent Thomas J. Kuveikis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Thomas J. Kuveikis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1935. Plaintiff James Kuveikis is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas J. Kuveikis, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Kuveikis and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. Kuveikis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Kuveikis was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

357

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 359 of 978

1936. Plaintiff Harlan Gene Yancey is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Parent of Decedent Kathryn Laborie, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kathryn Laborie and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1937. Plaintiff Eric Laborie is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Kathryn Laborie, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kathryn Laborie and on behalf of all survivors of Kathryn Laborie and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kathryn Laborie was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1938. Plaintiff Sonia Gawas is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Ganesh Ladkat, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ganesh Ladkat and on behalf of all survivors of Ganesh Ladkat and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ganesh Ladkat was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1939. Plaintiff Dolores Ladley is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent James Patrick Ladley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of James Patrick Ladley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1940. Plaintiff Eileen Ladley is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James Patrick Ladley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Patrick Ladley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

358

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 360 of 978

1941. Plaintiff Mary Ann Raymond is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent James Patrick Ladley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Patrick Ladley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1942. Plaintiff Daniel Edward Ladley is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Patrick Ladley, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James Patrick Ladley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1943. Plaintiff Patrick John Ladley is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Patrick Ladley, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James Patrick Ladley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1944. Plaintiff Dominick V. Lafalce is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph A. LaFalce, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph A. LaFalce and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph A. LaFalce and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph A. LaFalce was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1945. Plaintiff Anita Lafond Korsonsky is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Jeanette Lafond-Menichino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jeanette Lafond-Menichino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1946. Plaintiff Samuel J. Laforte is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Michael LaForte, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael LaForte and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

359

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 361 of 978

1947. Plaintiff Madelyn Beatrice LaFrance is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Alan Charles LaFrance, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Alan Charles LaFrance and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1948. Plaintiff Aubrey J. LaFrance, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Alan Charles LaFrance; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1949. Plaintiff Hui Fen Pan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Neil Kwong-Wah Lai, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Neil Kwong-Wah Lai and on behalf of all survivors of Neil Kwong-Wah Lai and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neil Kwong-Wah Lai was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1950. Plaintiff Linda Lalama is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Franco Lalama, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Franco Lalama and on behalf of all survivors of Franco Lalama and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Franco Lalama was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1951. Plaintiff Fongpein L. Chan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Chow Kwan Lam, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Chow Kwan Lam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

360

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 362 of 978

1952. Plaintiff Amy Zhang Lam is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Chow Kwan Lam, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Chow Kwan Lam and on behalf of all survivors of Chow Kwan Lam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Chow Kwan Lam was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1953. Plaintiff Chow Leing Lam is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Chow Kwan Lam, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Chow Kwan Lam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1954. Plaintiff Janet L. Lane is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Robert T. Lane, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert T. Lane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1955. Plaintiff Suzanne R. Stevenson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert T. Lane, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert T. Lane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1956. Plaintiff Richard L. Lane is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Robert T. Lane, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert T. Lane and on behalf of all survivors of Robert T. Lane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert T. Lane was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

361

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 363 of 978

1957. Plaintiff Jason M. Lane is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert T. Lane, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert T. Lane and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1958. Plaintiff Sandra Pangborn is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Brendan Mark Lang, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brendan Mark Lang and on behalf of all survivors of Brendan Mark Lang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brendan Mark Lang was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1959. Plaintiff Donna Marsh O'Connor is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Vanessa Lang Langer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Vanessa Lang Langer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1960. Plaintiff Joseph P. Langley is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Mary Lou Langley, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Lou Langley and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Lou Langley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary Lou Langley was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1961. Plaintiff Ethel Chamberlain, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Michele Lanza; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

362

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 364 of 978

1962. Plaintiff Cynthia D. Oricchio is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michele Lanza, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michele Lanza and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1963. Plaintiff Susan Gail Chamberlain is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michele Lanza, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michele Lanza and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1964. Plaintiff Albert A. Chamberlain, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Michele Lanza; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1965. Plaintiff Albert G. Chamberlain is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Michele Lanza, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michele Lanza and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1966. Plaintiff DOE 65 is a resident of the state of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 65, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 65 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 65 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 65 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1967. Plaintiff Danielle Lemack is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Judith Camilla Larocque, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Judith Camilla Larocque and on behalf of all survivors of Judith Camilla Larocque and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Judith Camilla Larocque was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed

363

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 365 of 978

into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1968. Plaintiff Carie Lemack is a resident of the State of District of Columbia, the Child of Decedent Judith Camilla Larocque, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Judith Camilla Larocque and on behalf of all survivors of Judith Camilla Larocque and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Judith Camilla Larocque was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1969. Plaintiff Janet L. Satterfield is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Christopher R. Larrabee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Christopher R. Larrabee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1970. Plaintiff Nicole Larrabee is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher R. Larrabee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher R. Larrabee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1971. Plaintiff Paige M. Larrabee is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher R. Larrabee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher R. Larrabee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1972. Plaintiff Jessica Larrabee is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher R. Larrabee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

364

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 366 of 978

Christopher R. Larrabee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1973. Plaintiff Stephen R. Larrabee is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Christopher R. Larrabee, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher R. Larrabee and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher R. Larrabee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher R. Larrabee was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1974. Plaintiff Scott Larrabee is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher R. Larrabee, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher R. Larrabee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1975. Plaintiff Carolann Larsen is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Scott Larsen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Larsen and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Larsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Larsen was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1976. Plaintiff Linda LeBlanc is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Natalie Janis Lasden, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Natalie Janis Lasden and on behalf of all survivors of Natalie Janis Lasden and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Natalie Janis Lasden was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the

365

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 367 of 978

World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1977. Plaintiff Barbara J. Lasko is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Gary E. Lasko, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gary E. Lasko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1978. Plaintiff Kim Lombard Lasko is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Spouse of Decedent Gary E. Lasko, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gary E. Lasko and on behalf of all survivors of Gary E. Lasko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gary E. Lasko was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1979. Plaintiff Edward R. Lasko is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Gary E. Lasko, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Gary E. Lasko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1980. Plaintiff Jennifer Laszczynski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Paul Laszczynski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Paul Laszczynski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1981. Plaintiff Amy Laszczynski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Paul Laszczynski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Paul Laszczynski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1982. Plaintiff Charlene Talarico is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé of Decedent Paul Laszczynski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Paul Laszczynski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

366

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 368 of 978

1983. Plaintiff Raphael P. Evans is a resident of Grenada, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey LaTouche, and brings this action on own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey LaTouche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1984. Plaintiff Donna D. Bhagwan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Jeffrey LaTouche, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Jeffrey LaTouche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1985. Plaintiff Rosanna LaTouche is a resident of Grenada, the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey LaTouche, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jeffrey LaTouche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1986. Plaintiff Esther G. LaTouche is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey LaTouche, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey LaTouche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1987. Plaintiff Virginia LaTouche is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Jeffrey LaTouche, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey LaTouche and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey LaTouche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey LaTouche was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1988. Plaintiff Jefferson Patterson is a resident of Grenada, the Child of Decedent Jeffrey LaTouche, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Jeffrey LaTouche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

367

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 369 of 978

1989. Plaintiff Karl LaTouche is a resident of Grenada, the Child of Decedent Jeffrey LaTouche, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Jeffrey LaTouche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1990. Plaintiff Michael Samuel is a resident of Grenada, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey LaTouche, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey LaTouche and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1991. Plaintiff Birther Laurencin-Bannister is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Charles Augustus Laurencin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Charles Augustus Laurencin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1992. Plaintiff Jercienne Laurencin is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Charles Augustus Laurencin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Charles Augustus Laurencin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1993. Plaintiff Mary Jane Lavache is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Maria LaVache, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Maria LaVache and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1994. Plaintiff Bernice M. Lavache is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Maria LaVache, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Maria LaVache and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1995. Plaintiff Joseph L. Lavache is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Maria LaVache, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maria LaVache and on behalf of all survivors of Maria LaVache

368

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 370 of 978

and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maria LaVache was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 1996. Plaintiff Barbara J. Dziadek is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Denis Lavelle, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Denis Lavelle and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1997. Plaintiff Emily Lavelle, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Denis Lavelle; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1998. Plaintiff Kathleen C. Palacio is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Denis Lavelle, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Denis Lavelle and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 1999. Plaintiff Patricia Caloia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Denis Lavelle, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Denis Lavelle and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2000. Plaintiff Marie Ann Paprocki is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Denis Lavelle, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Denis Lavelle and on behalf of all survivors of Denis Lavelle and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Denis Lavelle was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2001. Plaintiff Dolores LaVerde is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jeannine LaVerde, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the

369

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 371 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeannine LaVerde and on behalf of all survivors of Jeannine LaVerde and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeannine LaVerde was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2002. Plaintiff Thomas A. LaVerde is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Jeannine LaVerde, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jeannine LaVerde and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2003. Plaintiff Deena Laverty is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Anna A. Laverty, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anna A. Laverty and on behalf of all survivors of Anna A. Laverty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anna A. Laverty was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2004. Plaintiff Kevin P. Laverty is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Anna A. Laverty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Spouse of Anna A. Laverty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2005. Plaintiff Victoria Louise Lawn is a resident of United Kingdom, the Spouse of Decedent Steven Lawn, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Lawn and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Lawn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Lawn was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

370

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 372 of 978

2006. Plaintiff Eileen Lawrence is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2007. Plaintiff Elizabeth E. Lawrence Andersen is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2008. Plaintiff Suzanne Lawrence is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert A. Lawrence, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2009. Plaintiff Robert A. Lawrence is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2010. Plaintiff Walter Lawrence is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Robert A. Lawrence, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert A. Lawrence, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

371

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 373 of 978

2011. Plaintiff Laurie Miller Laychak is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent David William Laychak, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David William Laychak and on behalf of all survivors of David William Laychak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David William Laychak was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2012. Plaintiff Jeanette Leahy is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent James P. Leahy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of James P. Leahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2013. Plaintiff Michele Safatle is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James P. Leahy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James P. Leahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2014. Plaintiff Danielle Vella is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James P. Leahy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James P. Leahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2015. Plaintiff Denise Heneck is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James P. Leahy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James P. Leahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2016. Plaintiff Arthur Leahy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James P. Leahy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James P. Leahy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2017. Plaintiff Carole Leavey is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Leavey, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

372

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 374 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Joseph Leavey and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Leavey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Leavey was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2018. Plaintiff Brian Leavey is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Joseph Leavey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Joseph Leavey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2019. Plaintiff Ann Leavy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Neil J. Leavy, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Neil J. Leavy and on behalf of all survivors of Neil J. Leavy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neil J. Leavy was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2020. Plaintiff John P. Leavy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Neil J. Leavy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Neil J. Leavy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2021. Plaintiff Mark Leavy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Neil J. Leavy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Neil J. Leavy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2022. Plaintiff Rosanne Helen Costanza is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Daniel John Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Daniel John Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

373

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 375 of 978

2023. Plaintiff Deborah Ann Schumann is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel John Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel John Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2024. Plaintiff DOE 138 is a resident of the state of Nevada, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 138, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 138 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 138 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 138 was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2025. Plaintiff Timothy Provenzano is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel John Lee, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel John Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2026. Plaintiff DOE 90 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 90, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 90 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 90 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 90 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2027. Plaintiff Jungmi Lee is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Dong Chul Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dong Chul Lee and on behalf of all survivors of Dong Chul Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dong Chul Lee was

374

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 376 of 978

killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2028. Plaintiff Nichole Williams is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Child of Decedent Juanita Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Juanita Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2029. Plaintiff Geneva Johnson is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Parent of Decedent Juanita Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Juanita Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2030. Plaintiff Janet Johnson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Juanita Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Juanita Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2031. Plaintiff Cheryl Witherspoon is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Juanita Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Juanita Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2032. Plaintiff Shirley Walker is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Juanita Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Juanita Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2033. Plaintiff Edward N. Lee, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Georgia, and the Spouse of Decedent Juanita Lee; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2034. Representative of the Estate of Juanita Lee, Deceased, brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Juanita Lee and on behalf of all survivors of Juanita Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Juanita Lee was was killed at Two World Trade

375

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 377 of 978

Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2035. Plaintiff Anthony Johnson is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Juanita Lee, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Juanita Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2036. Plaintiff John Johnson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Juanita Lee, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Juanita Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2037. Plaintiff Hyong O. Lee is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of Decedent Linda C. Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Linda C. Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2038. Plaintiff Myong H. Lee is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of Decedent Linda C. Lee, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Linda C. Lee and on behalf of all survivors of Linda C. Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Linda C. Lee was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2039. Plaintiff Joan Greene, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Lorraine Lee; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2040. Plaintiff Barbara Wentworth is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Lorraine Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Lorraine Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

376

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 378 of 978

2041. Plaintiff Patricia Marie Reilly is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Lorraine Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Lorraine Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2042. Plaintiff Timothy R. Greene, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, and the Sibling of Decedent Lorraine Lee; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2043. Plaintiff Thomas Michael Greene is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Lorraine Lee, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lorraine Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2044. Plaintiff Terence Joseph Greene is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Lorraine Lee, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lorraine Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2045. Plaintiff Johnny Lee is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Lorraine Lee, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lorraine Lee and on behalf of all survivors of Lorraine Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lorraine Lee was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2046. Plaintiff Mi Yong Lee is a resident of the State of Washington, the Spouse of Decedent Myoung Woo Lee, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Myoung Woo Lee and on behalf of all survivors of Myoung Woo Lee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

377

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 379 of 978

Myoung Woo Lee was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2047. Plaintiff Lillian Lefkowitz, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Stephen Paul Lefkowitz; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2048. Plaintiff Rubin Lefkowitz, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Stephen Paul Lefkowitz; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2049. Plaintiff Daniel Jay Lefkowitz is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Paul Lefkowitz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Paul Lefkowitz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2050. Plaintiff Hayley Natalie Lehrfeld is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Eric Andrew Lehrfeld, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eric Andrew Lehrfeld and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Andrew Lehrfeld and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric Andrew Lehrfeld was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2051. Plaintiff Ruth M. Lemagne is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent David Prudencio Lemagne, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of David Prudencio Lemagne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

378

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 380 of 978

2052. Plaintiff Magaly J. Lemagne is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent David Prudencio Lemagne, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David Prudencio Lemagne and on behalf of all survivors of David Prudencio Lemagne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Prudencio Lemagne was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2053. Plaintiff Prudencio Lemagne is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent David Prudencio Lemagne, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of David Prudencio Lemagne and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2054. Plaintiff Ann K. Lenihan, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Connecticut, and the Parent of Decedent Joseph A. Lenihan; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2055. Plaintiff Suzanne L. Faulkner is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph A. Lenihan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph A. Lenihan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2056. Plaintiff Ingrid Maria Lenihan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph A. Lenihan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph A. Lenihan and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph A. Lenihan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph A. Lenihan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

379

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 381 of 978

2057. Plaintiff John Lenihan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph A. Lenihan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph A. Lenihan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2058. Plaintiff Melissa Lennon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent John J. Lennon, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of John J. Lennon, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2059. Plaintiff Lucille Lennon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent John J. Lennon, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John J. Lennon, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2060. Plaintiff Nancy Lennon Frain is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John J. Lennon, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John J. Lennon, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2061. Plaintiff Patricia Lennon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent John J. Lennon, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John J. Lennon, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of John J. Lennon, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. Lennon, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2062. Plaintiff John Lennon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent John J. Lennon, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of John J. Lennon, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

380

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 382 of 978

2063. Plaintiff James L. Lennon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John J. Lennon, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John J. Lennon, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2064. Plaintiff John J. Lennon, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent John J. Lennon, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John J. Lennon, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2065. Plaintiff Jennifer A. Levi-Longyear is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent John D. Levi, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of John D. Levi and on behalf of all survivors of John D. Levi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John D. Levi was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2066. Plaintiff Dennis J. Levi is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent John D. Levi, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of John D. Levi and on behalf of all survivors of John D. Levi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John D. Levi was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2067. Plaintiff Stephanie Giglio is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Robert Levine, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Levine and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Levine and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Levine was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center

381

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 383 of 978

Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. Stephanie Giglio also brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roni M. Levine, Spouse of decedent Robert Levine, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2068. Plaintiff Judy Levinhar is a resident of Israel, the Parent of Decedent Shai Levinhar, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Shai Levinhar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2069. Plaintiff Iris Kramer is a resident of Israel, the Sibling of Decedent Shai Levinhar, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Shai Levinhar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2070. Plaintiff Liat Levinhar is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Shai Levinhar, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Shai Levinhar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2071. Plaintiff Zvi Levinhar is a resident of Israel, the Parent of Decedent Shai Levinhar, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Shai Levinhar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2072. Plaintiff Raz Levinhar is a resident of Israel, the Sibling of Decedent Shai Levinhar, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Shai Levinhar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2073. Plaintiff Mor Levinhar is a resident of Israel, the Sibling of Decedent Shai Levinhar, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Shai Levinhar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

382

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 384 of 978

2074. Plaintiff Peggy Sue Lewin is a resident of Israel, the Parent of Decedent Daniel Lewin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Daniel Lewin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2075. Plaintiff Charles Jay Lewin is a resident of Israel, the Parent of Decedent Daniel Lewin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Daniel Lewin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2076. Plaintiff Michael Lewin is a resident of Israel, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Lewin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Lewin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2077. Plaintiff Jonathan A. Lewin is a resident of Israel, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Lewin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Lewin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2078. Plaintiff Dolores Libretti is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Daniel Libretti, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Libretti and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Libretti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Libretti was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2079. Plaintiff Joseph Libretti is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Libretti, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Libretti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

383

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 385 of 978

2080. Plaintiff Carmel-Ann Sullivan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Ralph M. Licciardi, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Ralph M. Licciardi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2081. Plaintiff Jennifer Licciardi is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Ralph M. Licciardi, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ralph M. Licciardi and on behalf of all survivors of Ralph M. Licciardi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph M. Licciardi was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2082. Plaintiff Ralph Licciardi is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Ralph M. Licciardi, and brings this action on own behalf as the Child of Ralph M. Licciardi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2083. Plaintiff Sebastiano Licciardi is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Ralph M. Licciardi, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Ralph M. Licciardi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2084. Plaintiff Anthony Licciardi is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Ralph M. Licciardi, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ralph M. Licciardi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2085. Plaintiff DOE 44 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 44, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 44 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 44 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 44 was killed at One World Trade Center

384

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 386 of 978

as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2086. Plaintiff Vyacheslav Ligay is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Zhentta Ligay, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Zhentta Ligay and on behalf of all survivors of Zhentta Ligay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Zhentta Ligay was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2087. Plaintiff Marcia Lillianthal is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Steven Barry Lillianthal, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Steven Barry Lillianthal and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2088. Plaintiff Mindi Cohen is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Steven Barry Lillianthal, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Steven Barry Lillianthal and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2089. Plaintiff Sherman Lillianthal is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Steven Barry Lillianthal, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Steven Barry Lillianthal and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2090. Plaintiff Haydee C. Lillo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Carlos R. Lillo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carlos R. Lillo and on behalf of all survivors of Carlos R. Lillo

385

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 387 of 978

and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carlos R. Lillo was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2091. Plaintiff Caroline Lilore is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Craig Damian Lilore, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Craig Damian Lilore and on behalf of all survivors of Craig Damian Lilore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Craig Damian Lilore was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2092. Plaintiff Rong Di You is a resident of China, the Parent of Decedent Wei Rong Lin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Wei Rong Lin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2093. Plaintiff Se Jua Au is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Spouse of Decedent Wei Rong Lin, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wei Rong Lin and on behalf of all survivors of Wei Rong Lin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wei Rong Lin was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2094. Plaintiff Zeng Lu Lin is a resident of China, the Parent of Decedent Wei Rong Lin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Wei Rong Lin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

386

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 388 of 978

2095. Plaintiff Hong Lin is a resident of China, the Sibling of Decedent Wei Rong Lin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Wei Rong Lin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2096. Plaintiff Duryel Lindo is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Nickie Lindo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Nickie Lindo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2097. Plaintiff Deryck D Lindo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Nickie Lindo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nickie Lindo and on behalf of all survivors of Nickie Lindo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nickie Lindo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2098. Plaintiff Carol Ann Linehan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas V. Linehan, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas V. Linehan, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas V. Linehan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas V. Linehan, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2099. Plaintiff Sharon L. Linton is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Parent of Decedent Alan Patrick Linton, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Alan Patrick Linton, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2100. Plaintiff Laura Renee Anspach is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling of Decedent Alan Patrick Linton, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

387

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 389 of 978

Alan Patrick Linton, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2101. Plaintiff Alan Patrick Linton is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Parent of Decedent Alan Patrick Linton, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alan Patrick Linton, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Alan Patrick Linton, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alan Patrick Linton, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2102. Plaintiff Scott P. Linton is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Sibling of Decedent Alan Patrick Linton, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Alan Patrick Linton, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2103. Plaintiff Seelochini Liriano is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Francisco Alberto Liriano, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francisco Alberto Liriano and on behalf of all survivors of Francisco Alberto Liriano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francisco Alberto Liriano was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2104. Plaintiff Jiun-Min H. Liu is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Ming-Hao Liu, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ming-Hao Liu and on behalf of all survivors of Ming-Hao Liu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ming-Hao Liu was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

388

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 390 of 978

2105. Plaintiff DOE 123 is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 123, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2106. Plaintiff DOE 123 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 123, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2107. Plaintiff DOE 123 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 123, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2108. Plaintiff DOE 123 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 123, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 123 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 123 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 123 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2109. Plaintiff Leopold Victor Lizzul, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Martin Lizzul; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2110. Plaintiff Eugenia R. Llanes is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent George Andrew Llanes, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George Andrew Llanes and on behalf of all survivors of George Andrew Llanes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

389

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 391 of 978

herein. George Andrew Llanes was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2111. Plaintiff Jorge Llanes, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent George Andrew Llanes; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2112. Plaintiff Douglas C. Cleary is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Elizabeth C. Logler, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Fiancé of Elizabeth C. Logler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2113. Plaintiff Robert Logler is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Elizabeth C. Logler, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Elizabeth C. Logler and on behalf of all survivors of Elizabeth C. Logler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Elizabeth C. Logler was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2114. Plaintiff Catherine Masak is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Catherine Lisa Loguidice, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Catherine Lisa Loguidice and on behalf of all survivors of Catherine Lisa Loguidice and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Catherine Lisa Loguidice was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2115. Plaintiff Carmelo Loguidice, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Catherine Lisa Loguidice; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

390

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 392 of 978

2116. Plaintiff Michael Loguidice is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Catherine Lisa Loguidice, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Catherine Lisa Loguidice and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2117. Plaintiff Dening Lohez is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Jerome Lohez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jerome Lohez and on behalf of all survivors of Jerome Lohez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jerome Lohez was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2118. Plaintiff Sandra S. Weaver, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Indiana, and the Parent of Decedent Stephen V. Long; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2119. Plaintiff Cynthia Long is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen V. Long, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen V. Long and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2120. Plaintiff Nancy A. Burcham is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen V. Long, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen V. Long and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2121. Plaintiff DOE 66 is a resident of the state of South Carolina, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 66, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 66 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 66 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 66 was killed at Pentagon as a

391

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 393 of 978

result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2122. Plaintiff David B. Long, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Indiana, and the Sibling of Decedent Stephen V. Long; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2123. Plaintiff George T. Long is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Parent of Decedent Stephen V. Long, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Stephen V. Long and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2124. Plaintiff George W. Long is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen V. Long, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen V. Long and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2125. Plaintiff Anne Maria Pettus is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Laura M. Longing, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Laura M. Longing and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2126. Plaintiff Kevin Russel Pettus is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Laura M. Longing, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Laura M. Longing and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2127. Plaintiff Keith B. Pettus is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Laura M. Longing, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Laura M. Longing and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2128. Plaintiff Christopher Longing is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Laura M. Longing, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Laura M. Longing and on behalf of all survivors of

392

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 394 of 978

Laura M. Longing and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Laura M. Longing was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2129. Plaintiff Elizabeth Davila-Lopez is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Daniel Lopez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Lopez and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Lopez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Lopez was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2130. Plaintiff Rhonda Lopez is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Maclovio Lopez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maclovio Lopez and on behalf of all survivors of Maclovio Lopez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maclovio Lopez was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2131. Plaintiff Theresann Lostrangio is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Lostrangio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Lostrangio and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Lostrangio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Lostrangio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

393

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 395 of 978

2132. Plaintiff DOE 64 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 64, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 64 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 64 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 64 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2133. Plaintiff Maxine McCormack is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Joseph Lovero, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Joseph Lovero and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2134. Plaintiff James Lovero is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Joseph Lovero, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Lovero and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Lovero and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Lovero was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2135. Plaintiff Bobbie Jean Low is a resident of the State of Arkansas, the Parent of Decedent Sara Elizabeth Low, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Sara Elizabeth Low and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2136. Plaintiff Rebecca Alyson Low is a resident of the State of Arkansas, the Sibling of Decedent Sara Elizabeth Low, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sara Elizabeth Low and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2137. Plaintiff Gary Michael Low is a resident of the State of Arkansas, the Parent of Decedent Sara Elizabeth Low, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the

394

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 396 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Sara Elizabeth Low and on behalf of all survivors of Sara Elizabeth Low and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sara Elizabeth Low was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2138. Plaintiff Rosemary Lozowsky, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent John Peter Lozowsky; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2139. Plaintiff Debra A. Rhody is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Sibling of Decedent John Peter Lozowsky, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Peter Lozowsky and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2140. Plaintiff John Peter Lozowsky, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent John Peter Lozowsky; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2141. Plaintiff Maureen Kelly is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Mark G. Ludvigsen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark G. Ludvigsen and on behalf of all survivors of Mark G. Ludvigsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark G. Ludvigsen was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2142. Plaintiff Ashley Michelle Ludwig is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent Lee Charles Ludwig, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Lee Charles Ludwig and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

395

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 397 of 978

2143. Plaintiff Luann Martin is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Lee Charles Ludwig, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Lee Charles Ludwig and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2144. Plaintiff Michelle Ludwig is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Lee Charles Ludwig, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lee Charles Ludwig and on behalf of all survivors of Lee Charles Ludwig and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lee Charles Ludwig was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2145. Plaintiff Louis Ludwig, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Lee Charles Ludwig; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2146. Plaintiff Christopher Ludwig is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Lee Charles Ludwig, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Lee Charles Ludwig and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2147. Plaintiff Lawrence Andrews Ludwig is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Lee Charles Ludwig, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lee Charles Ludwig and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2148. Plaintiff Louis Ludwig, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Lee Charles Ludwig, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lee Charles Ludwig and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

396

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 398 of 978

2149. Plaintiff Eileen D. Lugano is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Sean Thomas Lugano, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Thomas Lugano and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Thomas Lugano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean Thomas Lugano was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2150. Plaintiff Stephanie Mccuin is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Thomas Lugano, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Thomas Lugano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2151. Plaintiff Michael Lugano is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Thomas Lugano, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Thomas Lugano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2152. Plaintiff John C. Lugano is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Thomas Lugano, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Thomas Lugano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2153. Plaintiff Marie Lukas is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Marie Lukas, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marie Lukas and on behalf of all survivors of Marie Lukas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marie Lukas was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2154. Plaintiff Maureen C. Lunder is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Edmund Lunder, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of

397

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 399 of 978

Christopher Edmund Lunder and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2155. Plaintiff Rosemary Sercia is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Edmund Lunder, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Edmund Lunder and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2156. Plaintiff Karen B. Lunder is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Christopher Edmund Lunder, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Administrator of the Estate of Christopher Edmund Lunder and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Edmund Lunder and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Edmund Lunder was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2157. Plaintiff Edmund Lunder is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Edmund Lunder, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Christopher Edmund Lunder and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2158. Plaintiff David Lunder is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Edmund Lunder, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Edmund Lunder and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2159. Plaintiff Geraldine Canillas is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Anthony Luparello, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Anthony Luparello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

398

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 400 of 978

2160. Plaintiff Maria Lipari is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Anthony Luparello, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Anthony Luparello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2161. Plaintiff Geraldine Luparello is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Anthony Luparello, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony Luparello and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony Luparello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Luparello was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2162. Plaintiff Anthony Luparello, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Anthony Luparello, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Anthony Luparello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2163. Plaintiff Edith Lutnick is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Gary Frederick Lutnick, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Gary Frederick Lutnick, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2164. Plaintiff Howard Lutnick is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Gary Frederick Lutnick, III, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gary Frederick Lutnick, III and on behalf of all survivors of Gary Frederick Lutnick, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gary Frederick Lutnick, III was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

399

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 401 of 978

2165. Plaintiff Debra Luzzicone is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Linda Anne Luzzicone, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Linda Anne Luzzicone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2166. Plaintiff Cheryl Zaffuto is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Linda Anne Luzzicone, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Linda Anne Luzzicone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2167. Plaintiff Ralph Luzzicone is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Linda Anne Luzzicone, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Linda Anne Luzzicone and on behalf of all survivors of Linda Anne Luzzicone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Linda Anne Luzzicone was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2168. Plaintiff Ralph Luzzicone, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Linda Anne Luzzicone, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Administrator of the Estate of Linda Anne Luzzicone and on behalf of all survivors of Linda Anne Luzzicone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Linda Anne Luzzicone was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2169. Plaintiff Valentina Lygina is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Parent of Decedent Alexander Lygin, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Alexander Lygin and on behalf of all survivors of Alexander Lygin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alexander

400

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 402 of 978

Lygin was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2170. Plaintiff Natasha Lygina is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Alexander Lygin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alexander Lygin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2171. Plaintiff Vladimir Lygin, now deceased, was a resident of the State of North Carolina, and the Parent of Decedent Alexander Lygin; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2172. Plaintiff Lorne Lyles is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Spouse of Decedent CeeCee Louise Lyles, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of CeeCee Louise Lyles and on behalf of all survivors of CeeCee Louise Lyles and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. CeeCee Louise Lyles was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2173. Plaintiff Margaret Dugdale is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James Francis Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2174. Plaintiff Carol A. Penna is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent James Francis Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2175. Plaintiff William F. Burns-Lynch is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James Francis Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling

401

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 403 of 978

of James Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2176. Plaintiff David W. Lynch is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent James Francis Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2177. Plaintiff Peter J. Lynch is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James Francis Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2178. Plaintiff Catherine T. Lynch is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael F. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael F. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2179. Plaintiff Barbara Mcmanus is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael F. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2180. Plaintiff Bernadette Rafferty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael F. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2181. Plaintiff Rosemary Elizabeth Pumilia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael F. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2182. Plaintiff Mary L. Coster is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael F. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

402

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 404 of 978

2183. Plaintiff Denise Lynch is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael F. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael F. Lynch and on behalf of all survivors of Michael F. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael F. Lynch was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2184. Plaintiff Daniel F. Lynch is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael F. Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael F. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2185. Plaintiff Daniel J. Lynch is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael F. Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael F. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2186. Plaintiff Kathleen V. Lynch is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Francis Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2187. Plaintiff Kathleen Ann Lynch is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Francis Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2188. Plaintiff Colleen M. Parigen is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Francis Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

403

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 405 of 978

Michael Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2189. Plaintiff Maureen Lynch Baker is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Francis Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2190. Plaintiff John B. Lynch is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Francis Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Francis Lynch and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Francis Lynch was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2191. Plaintiff Frederick Lynch is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Francis Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2192. Plaintiff Paul Lynch is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Francis Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2193. Plaintiff John B. Lynch, Jr. is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Francis Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of

404

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 406 of 978

Michael Francis Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2194. Plaintiff Marguerite Lynch, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Robert H. Lynch; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2195. Plaintiff Barbara Cotter is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert H. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert H. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2196. Plaintiff Linda Helck is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert H. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert H. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2197. Plaintiff Patricia Curry is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert H. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert H. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2198. Plaintiff DOE 69 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 69, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 69 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 69 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 69 was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2199. Plaintiff Margaret A. Lynch is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Sean Patrick Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Sean Patrick Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

405

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 407 of 978

2200. Plaintiff Laureen A. Sutera is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Patrick Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Patrick Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2201. Plaintiff Kathleen A. Hallstrom is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Patrick Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Patrick Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2202. Plaintiff Colleen M. Watson is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Patrick Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Patrick Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2203. Plaintiff John J. Lynch is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Sean Patrick Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Sean Patrick Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2204. Plaintiff Michael J. Lynch is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Patrick Lynch, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Patrick Lynch and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Patrick Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean Patrick Lynch was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2205. Plaintiff Ashley Nicole Lynch is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Terence M. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Terence M. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

406

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 408 of 978

2206. Plaintiff Tiffany M. Lynch is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent Terence M. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Terence M. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2207. Plaintiff Jacqueline E. Lynch is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Terence M. Lynch, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Terence M. Lynch and on behalf of all survivors of Terence M. Lynch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terence M. Lynch was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2208. Plaintiff Patricia Lyons is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Patrick John Lyons, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patrick John Lyons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2209. Plaintiff Kelly Jean Lyons is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick John Lyons, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick John Lyons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2210. Plaintiff Kristen Elizabeth Lyons is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick John Lyons, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick John Lyons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2211. Plaintiff Irene Lyons- Loeffler is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Patrick John Lyons, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick John Lyons and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick John Lyons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

407

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 409 of 978

Patrick John Lyons was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2212. Plaintiff Brian Patrick Lyons is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Patrick John Lyons, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Patrick John Lyons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2213. Plaintiff Brian Charles Lyons is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick John Lyons, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick John Lyons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2214. Plaintiff Sean Lyons is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick John Lyons, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick John Lyons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2215. Plaintiff Kenneth J. Mace is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Robert Francis Mace, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Francis Mace and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Francis Mace and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Francis Mace was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2216. Plaintiff Kazimierz Maciejewski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Jan Maciejewski, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jan Maciejewski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2217. Plaintiff Pawel Maciejewski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Jan Maciejewski, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jan Maciejewski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

408

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 410 of 978

2218. Plaintiff Douglas Mackay is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Susan Mackay, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Mackay and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Mackay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susan Mackay was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2219. Plaintiff Michelle Marie Madden is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Parent of Decedent Richard B. Madden, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Richard B. Madden and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2220. Plaintiff Melissa Madden Crowley is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Richard B. Madden, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard B. Madden and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2221. Plaintiff Maura Lezynski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Richard B. Madden, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard B. Madden and on behalf of all survivors of Richard B. Madden and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard B. Madden was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2222. Plaintiff Joshua Powers Madden is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Richard B. Madden, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard B. Madden and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

409

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 411 of 978

2223. Plaintiff Robert Twining Madden, Jr. is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Richard B. Madden, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard B. Madden and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2224. Plaintiff Penelope Joan Hassell is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Simon Maddison, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Simon Maddison and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2225. Plaintiff Elizabeth Collis is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Simon Maddison, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Simon Maddison and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2226. Plaintiff Maureen Maddison is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Simon Maddison, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Simon Maddison and on behalf of all survivors of Simon Maddison and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Simon Maddison was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2227. Plaintiff Peter John Maddison is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Simon Maddison, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Simon Maddison and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2228. Plaintiff Stephen Peter Maddison is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Simon Maddison, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Simon Maddison and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

410

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 412 of 978

2229. Plaintiff Jennifer Lyn Maerz is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Noell Maerz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Noell Maerz and on behalf of all survivors of Noell Maerz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Noell Maerz was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2230. Plaintiff Ralph S. Maerz, Jr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Noell Maerz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Noell Maerz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2231. Plaintiff Jean Maffeo, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Joseph Maffeo; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2232. Plaintiff Susan Maffeo Drury is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Maffeo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Maffeo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2233. Plaintiff Linda Maffeo Manfredi is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Maffeo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Maffeo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2234. Plaintiff Debra Maffeo Morri is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Maffeo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Maffeo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

411

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 413 of 978

2235. Plaintiff Donna Maffeo is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Maffeo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Maffeo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2236. Plaintiff Linda Maffeo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Maffeo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Maffeo and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Maffeo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Maffeo was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2237. Plaintiff Louis Maffeo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Maffeo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Maffeo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2238. Plaintiff Beth A. Mahon is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas A. Mahon, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas A. Mahon and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas A. Mahon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas A. Mahon was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2239. Plaintiff Donna Mahoney is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent William J. Mahoney, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William J. Mahoney, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of William J. Mahoney, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

412

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 414 of 978

herein. William J. Mahoney, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2240. Plaintiff Beverly M. Maler is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Alfred Russell Maler, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Alfred Russell Maler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2241. Plaintiff Beverly V. Maler is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Alfred Russell Maler, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alfred Russell Maler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2242. Plaintiff Jeanine M. Sherman is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Alfred Russell Maler, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alfred Russell Maler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2243. Plaintiff DOE 59 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 59, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 59 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 59 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 59 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2244. Plaintiff Keith E. Maler is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Alfred Russell Maler, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Alfred Russell Maler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2245. Plaintiff Edward Dwain Maler is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Alfred Russell Maler, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Alfred Russell Maler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

413

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 415 of 978

2246. Plaintiff Michael A. Maler, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Alfred Russell Maler; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2247. Plaintiff Kathleen Maloney is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Maloney, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Maloney and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Maloney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Maloney was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2248. Plaintiff DOE 58 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 58, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 58 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 58 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 58 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2249. Plaintiff Kathleen Mangano is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Mangano, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Mangano and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Mangano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Mangano was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2250. Plaintiff Robert William Harvey is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Sarah Elizabeth Manley, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse

414

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 416 of 978

and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sarah Elizabeth Manley and on behalf of all survivors of Sarah Elizabeth Manley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sarah Elizabeth Manley was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2251. Plaintiff Kenneth R. Mannetta is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Debra M. Mannetta, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Debra M. Mannetta and on behalf of all survivors of Debra M. Mannetta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Debra M. Mannetta was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2252. Plaintiff Elizabeth Kemmerer, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, and the Child of Decedent Hilda Marcin; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2253. Plaintiff Carole O'Hare is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Child of Decedent Hilda Marcin, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the of the Estate of Hilda Marcin and on behalf of all survivors of Hilda Marcin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hilda Marcin was killed at United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2254. Plaintiff Shakeh Mardikian is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Peter Edward Mardikian, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Peter Edward Mardikian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

415

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 417 of 978

2255. Plaintiff Monica N. Mardikian is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Edward Mardikian, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Edward Mardikian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2256. Plaintiff Alexander Paul Mardikian is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Peter Edward Mardikian, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Peter Edward Mardikian and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2257. Plaintiff Amelia J. Margiotta is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Charles Joseph Margiotta, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Charles Joseph Margiotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2258. Plaintiff Norma Margiotta is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Charles Joseph Margiotta, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Joseph Margiotta and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Joseph Margiotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles Joseph Margiotta was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2259. Plaintiff Charles V. Margiotta is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Charles Joseph Margiotta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Charles Joseph Margiotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

416

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 418 of 978

2260. Plaintiff Michael Margiotta is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Charles Joseph Margiotta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Charles Joseph Margiotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2261. Plaintiff Charles Vito Margiotta, III is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Charles Joseph Margiotta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Charles Joseph Margiotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2262. Plaintiff Mary Ann Marino is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kenneth Marino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth Marino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2263. Plaintiff Lynda Ann Marino is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth Marino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth Marino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2264. Plaintiff Katrina Margit Marino is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Kenneth Marino, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth Marino and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth Marino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth Marino was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2265. Plaintiff Pat Marino is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kenneth Marino, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth Marino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

417

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 419 of 978

2266. Plaintiff Antonina Joan Marino is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Vita Marino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Vita Marino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2267. Plaintiff James Martin Marino is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Vita Marino, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Vita Marino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2268. Plaintiff Martin Anthony Marino is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Vita Marino, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Vita Marino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2269. Plaintiff Michael Patrick Marino is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Vita Marino, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Vita Marino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2270. Plaintiff DOE 38 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 38, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 38 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 38 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 38 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2271. Plaintiff Rosemary Claire Meyer is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent Kevin D. Marlo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kevin D. Marlo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2272. Plaintiff Dennis Marlo is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent Kevin D. Marlo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal

418

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 420 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Kevin D. Marlo and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin D. Marlo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin D. Marlo was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2273. Plaintiff Jodi A. Marrero is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Jose Marrero, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jose Marrero and on behalf of all survivors of Jose Marrero and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jose Marrero was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2274. Plaintiff Doreen E. Rowland, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Sibling of Decedent John Daniel Marshall; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2275. Plaintiff Jeanette A. Marshall is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John Daniel Marshall, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John Daniel Marshall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2276. Plaintiff Lori T. Marshall is a resident of the State of Iowa, the Spouse of Decedent John Daniel Marshall, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Daniel Marshall and on behalf of all survivors of John Daniel Marshall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Daniel Marshall was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

419

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 421 of 978

2277. Plaintiff Donn E. Marshall is a resident of the State of West Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Shelley A. Marshall, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Shelley A. Marshall and on behalf of all survivors of Shelley A. Marshall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Shelley A. Marshall was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2278. Plaintiff John A. Martin is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Karen A. Martin, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Karen A. Martin and on behalf of all survivors of Karen A. Martin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karen A. Martin was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2279. Plaintiff Paul R. Martin, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Hampshire, and the Sibling of Decedent Karen A. Martin; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2280. Plaintiff Deborah D. Martin is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent William J. Martin, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William J. Martin and on behalf of all survivors of William J. Martin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William J. Martin was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

420

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 422 of 978

2281. Plaintiff Luis Gaston, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Betsy Martinez; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2282. The Representative of the Estate of Betsy Martinez brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Betsy Martinez and on behalf of all survivors of Betsy Martinez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Betsy Martinez was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2283. Plaintiff DOE 124 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 124, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 124 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 124 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 124 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2284. Plaintiff Michael Jesse Martinez is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Jose Angel Martinez, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Jose Angel Martinez, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2285. Plaintiff Lourdes Lebron is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Waleska Martinez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Waleska Martinez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2286. Plaintiff Marino Calderon is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Lizie Martinez-Calderon, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the

421

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 423 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Lizie Martinez-Calderon and on behalf of all survivors of Lizie Martinez-Calderon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lizie Martinez-Calderon was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2287. Plaintiff Lisa Martini is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Paul Richard Martini, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Richard Martini and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Richard Martini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Richard Martini was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2288. Plaintiff Mildred Martino, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Anne Marie Martino-Cramer; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2289. Plaintiff Patricia Nilsen is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Anne Marie Martino-Cramer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Anne Marie Martino-Cramer and on behalf of all survivors of Anne Marie Martino-Cramer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anne Marie Martino-Cramer was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2290. Plaintiff Anthony Demitrio Martino is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Anne Marie Martino-Cramer, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Anne Marie Martino-Cramer and on behalf

422

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 424 of 978

of all survivors of Anne Marie Martino-Cramer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anne Marie Martino-Cramer was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2291. Plaintiff Joan Masi, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Spouse of Decedent Stephen F. Masi; the Representative of her Estate, Theresa Bevilacqua, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2292. Plaintiff Theresa Bevilacqua is a resident of the State of Florida, the step-child of Decedent Stephen F. Masi, and brings this action on her own behalf as step-child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen F. Masi and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen F. Masi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen F. Masi was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2293. Plaintiff Stephen J. Masi is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Stephen F. Masi, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Stephen F. Masi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2294. Plaintiff Anna Ella Cimaroli is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Patricia Ann Massari, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patricia Ann Massari and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2295. Plaintiff Richard Patrick Cimaroli is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Patricia Ann Massari, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Patricia Ann Massari and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

423

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 425 of 978

2296. Plaintiff Joseph Cimaroli is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patricia Ann Massari, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patricia Ann Massari and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2297. Plaintiff Josephine Holubar is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Massaroli, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Massaroli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2298. Plaintiff Joann Cleary is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Massaroli, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Massaroli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2299. Plaintiff Diane Massaroli is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael Massaroli, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Massaroli and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Massaroli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Massaroli was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2300. Plaintiff Rosalie Annette Mastrandrea is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2301. Plaintiff Lynn Marie Paragano is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

424

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 426 of 978

2302. Plaintiff Karen Elizabeth Mastrandrea is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2303. Plaintiff Robert Mastrandrea is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2304. Plaintiff Philip William Mastrandrea, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Philip William Mastrandrea, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2305. Plaintiff Isabelle Mastrocinque is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2306. Plaintiff Sharon Swailes is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

425

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 427 of 978

2307. Plaintiff Rudy Mastocinque, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2308. Plaintiff Rudy Mastrocinque, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Rudy Mastrocinque, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2309. Plaintiff Teresa Mathai is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Mathai, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Mathai and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Mathai and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Mathai was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2310. Plaintiff Margaret Louisa Mathers is a resident of the State of Texas, the Spouse of Decedent Charles W. Mathers, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles W. Mathers and on behalf of all survivors of Charles W. Mathers and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles W. Mathers was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2311. Plaintiff Marguerite Mattson, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Robert Mattson; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

426

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 428 of 978

2312. Plaintiff Jean E. Mattson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Robert Mattson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Robert Mattson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2313. Plaintiff Elizabeth A. Mattson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Mattson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Mattson and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Mattson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Mattson was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2314. Plaintiff James F. Mattson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Robert Mattson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Robert Mattson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2315. Plaintiff William G. Mattson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert Mattson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert Mattson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2316. Plaintiff Denise Matuza is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Walter Matuza, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Walter Matuza and on behalf of all survivors of Walter Matuza and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Walter Matuza was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2317. Plaintiff Margaret Mauro is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Sibling of Decedent Dorothy Mauro, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the

427

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 429 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Dorothy Mauro and on behalf of all survivors of Dorothy Mauro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dorothy Mauro was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2318. Plaintiff Nancy A. May is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Parent of Decedent Renee A. May, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Renee A. May and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2319. Plaintiff Ronald F. May is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Parent of Decedent Renee A. May, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Renee A. May and on behalf of all survivors of Renee A. May and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Renee A. May was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2320. Plaintiff Jeffrey M. May is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Sibling of Decedent Renee A. May, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Renee A. May and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2321. Plaintiff Kenneth May is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Renee A. May, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Renee A. May and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2322. Plaintiff David Spivock, Jr. is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Fiancé of Decedent Renee A. May, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Fiancé of Renee A. May and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

428

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 430 of 978

2323. Plaintiff Susan M. Brannigan is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent Edward Mazzella, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Edward Mazzella, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2324. Plaintiff Catherine Mazzella is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Edward Mazzella, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Mazzella, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Mazzella, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Mazzella, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2325. Plaintiff Michael T. Mazzella is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Edward Mazzella, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Edward Mazzella, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2326. Plaintiff Catherine Mazzotta is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jennifer Mazzotta, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jennifer Mazzotta and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Mazzotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jennifer Mazzotta was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2327. Plaintiff Michelle Bonetti is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jennifer Mazzotta, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jennifer Mazzotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

429

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 431 of 978

2328. Plaintiff Anthony Roman is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Jennifer Mazzotta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Fiancé of Jennifer Mazzotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2329. Plaintiff Vito V. Mazzotta is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jennifer Mazzotta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jennifer Mazzotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2330. Plaintiff Charles Mazzotta is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jennifer Mazzotta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jennifer Mazzotta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2331. Plaintiff Vertistine Beaman Mbaya is a resident of the State of Kenya, the Parent of Decedent Kaaria William Mbaya, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kaaria William Mbaya and on behalf of all survivors of Kaaria William Mbaya and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kaaria William Mbaya was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2332. Plaintiff Kibabu Mbaya is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Kaaria William Mbaya, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kaaria William Mbaya and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2333. Plaintiff Njue W. Mbaya is a resident of the State of Alaska, the Sibling of Decedent Kaaria William Mbaya, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kaaria William Mbaya and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

430

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 432 of 978

2334. Plaintiff Dawn McAleese is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Brian G. McAleese, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian G. McAleese and on behalf of all survivors of Brian G. McAleese and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian G. McAleese was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2335. Plaintiff Margaret E. Cruz is a resident of the State of New York, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Patricia A. McAneney, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Domestic Partner of Patricia A. McAneney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2336. Plaintiff James McAneney is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patricia A. McAneney, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patricia A. McAneney and on behalf of all survivors of Patricia A. McAneney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patricia A. McAneney was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2337. Plaintiff Sheila Mcpherson is a resident of Canada, the Sibling of Decedent Colin Richard McArthur, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Colin Richard McArthur and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2338. Plaintiff Philomena McAvoy is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John K. McAvoy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John K. McAvoy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

431

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 433 of 978

2339. Plaintiff Paula M. McAvoy is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent John K. McAvoy, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John K. McAvoy and on behalf of all survivors of John K. McAvoy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John K. McAvoy was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2340. Plaintiff Michael McAvoy is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Sibling of Decedent John K. McAvoy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John K. McAvoy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2341. Plaintiff Marsha K. McBrayer is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Kenneth M. McBrayer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth M. McBrayer and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth M. McBrayer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth M. McBrayer was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2342. Plaintiff Lynn C. McCabe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Michael J. McCabe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael J. McCabe and on behalf of all survivors of Michael J. McCabe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. McCabe was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

432

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 434 of 978

2343. Plaintiff Natalie Mary McCann is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Thomas J. McCann, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas J. McCann and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2344. Plaintiff Natalie Mary Moriarty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas J. McCann, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas J. McCann and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2345. Plaintiff Anne Marie McCann is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas J. McCann, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. McCann and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas J. McCann and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. McCann was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2346. Plaintiff George Gerard McCann is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas J. McCann, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas J. McCann and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2347. Plaintiff Marie McCarthy is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Kevin Micheal McCarthy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kevin Micheal McCarthy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2348. Plaintiff Kathleen Marie Sullivan is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Kevin Micheal McCarthy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin Micheal McCarthy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

433

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 435 of 978

2349. Plaintiff Debra Menich is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Kevin Micheal McCarthy, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin Micheal McCarthy and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Micheal McCarthy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Micheal McCarthy was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2350. Plaintiff Charles Mccarthy, Jr. is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Kevin Micheal McCarthy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin Micheal McCarthy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2351. Plaintiff Charles Mccarthy, Sr. is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Kevin Micheal McCarthy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kevin Micheal McCarthy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2352. Plaintiff Cynthia Elaine McDay, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Tonyell F. McDay; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2353. Representative of the Estate of Tonyell F. McDay brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Tonyell F. McDay and on behalf of all survivors of Tonyell F. McDay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Tonyell F. McDay was killed in One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

434

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 436 of 978

2354. Plaintiff Rufus J. McDay is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Tonyell F. McDay, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Tonyell F. McDay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2355. Plaintiff Ruvaughn McDay is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Tonyell F. McDay, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Tonyell F. McDay and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2356. Plaintiff Jacqueline A. McDermott is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Matthew Thomas McDermott, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Matthew Thomas McDermott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2357. Plaintiff Margaret McDermott is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Matthew Thomas McDermott, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Matthew Thomas McDermott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2358. Plaintiff Suzanne P. McDermott is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Matthew Thomas McDermott, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew Thomas McDermott and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew Thomas McDermott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew Thomas McDermott was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2359. Plaintiff John E. McDermott is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Parent of Decedent Matthew Thomas McDermott, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of

435

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 437 of 978

Matthew Thomas McDermott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2360. Plaintiff John C. McDermott is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Matthew Thomas McDermott, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Matthew Thomas McDermott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2361. Plaintiff DOE 139 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 139, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 139 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 139 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 139 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2362. Plaintiff Ann Claire McDonnell is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Brian G. McDonnell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Brian G. McDonnell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2363. Plaintiff Alicia Arancibia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Brian G. McDonnell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Brian G. McDonnell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2364. Plaintiff Margaret McDonnell is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Brian G. McDonnell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian G. McDonnell and on behalf of minor children K.M. and T.M. and on behalf of all survivors of Brian G. McDonnell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian G. McDonnell was killed at Two World

436

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 438 of 978

Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2365. Plaintiff Robert McDonnell is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Brian G. McDonnell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Brian G. McDonnell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2366. Plaintiff Kevin Michael McDonnell is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Brian G. McDonnell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Brian G. McDonnell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2367. Plaintiff Cheryl Ann McDonnell is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Michael Patrick McDonnell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Patrick McDonnell and on behalf of minor children B.M.M. and K.M.M. and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Patrick McDonnell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Patrick McDonnell was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2368. Plaintiff Bonnie McEneaney is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Eamon McEneaney, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eamon McEneaney and on behalf of all survivors of Eamon McEneaney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eamon McEneaney was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

437

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 439 of 978

2369. Plaintiff Agnes Marie McErlean is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Parent of Decedent John T. McErlean, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John T. McErlean, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2370. Plaintiff Marie McErlean Hunter is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John T. McErlean, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John T. McErlean, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2371. Plaintiff Agnes Marie Duhamel is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent John T. McErlean, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John T. McErlean, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2372. Plaintiff Catherine Francese is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John T. McErlean, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John T. McErlean, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2373. Plaintiff Thomas M. McErlean, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent John T. McErlean, Jr.; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2374. Plaintiff John T. McErlean, Sr. is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Parent of Decedent John T. McErlean, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John T. McErlean, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

438

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 440 of 978

2375. Plaintiff Patricia D. McGinly is a resident of the State of Louisiana, the Parent of Decedent Mark Ryan McGinly, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Mark Ryan McGinly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2376. Plaintiff William C. McGinly is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Parent of Decedent Mark Ryan McGinly, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Ryan McGinly and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Ryan McGinly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Ryan McGinly was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2377. Plaintiff Sean M. Mcginly is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Mark Ryan McGinly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Ryan McGinly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2378. Plaintiff Andrew M. McGinly is a resident of the State of Louisiana, the Sibling of Decedent Mark Ryan McGinly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Ryan McGinly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2379. Plaintiff Marilyn Mcgovern Zurica is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent William J. McGovern, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of William J. McGovern and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2380. Plaintiff Mary Sue McGovern is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent William J. McGovern, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William J. McGovern and on behalf of all survivors of William J. McGovern and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

439

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 441 of 978

William J. McGovern was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2381. Plaintiff Frances N. Sennas is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Stacey Sennas McGowan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Stacey Sennas McGowan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2382. Plaintiff Semo P. Sennas is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Stacey Sennas McGowan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Stacey Sennas McGowan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2383. Plaintiff Danielle McGuinn is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Francis Noel McGuinn, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Francis Noel McGuinn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2384. Plaintiff Lynn S. McGuinn is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Francis Noel McGuinn, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francis Noel McGuinn and on behalf of all survivors of Francis Noel McGuinn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francis Noel McGuinn was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2385. Plaintiff Danielle McGuire is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Patrick McGuire, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick McGuire and on behalf of all survivors of

440

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 442 of 978

Patrick McGuire and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick McGuire was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2386. Plaintiff DOE 56 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 56, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 56 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 56 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 56 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2387. Plaintiff DOE 56 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 56, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2388. Plaintiff DOE 56 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 56, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2389. Plaintiff Bernadette Marie McHugh is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent Denis J. McHugh, III, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2390. Plaintiff Bernadette McHugh Torres is a resident of the state of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Denis J. McHugh, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and on behalf of all survivors of Denis J. McHugh, III and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Denis J. McHugh, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set

441

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 443 of 978

forth herein. Denis J. McHugh, III was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2391. Plaintiff Timothy S. McHugh is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent Denis J. McHugh, III, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2392. Plaintiff Una Margaret McHugh is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Dennis P. McHugh, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis P. McHugh and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis P. McHugh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis P. McHugh was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2393. Plaintiff Maria C. McHugh is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael E. McHugh, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael E. McHugh, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. McHugh, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael E. McHugh, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2394. Plaintiff Jeannine McIntyre is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Donald J. McIntyre, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald J. McIntyre and on behalf of all survivors of Donald J. McIntyre and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald J. McIntyre was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

442

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 444 of 978

2395. Plaintiff Agnes Mckenna is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Stephanie McKenna, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Stephanie McKenna and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2396. Plaintiff Patricia Mckenna is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Stephanie McKenna, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephanie McKenna and on behalf of all survivors of Stephanie McKenna and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephanie McKenna was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2397. Plaintiff Eugene Mckenna is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Stephanie McKenna, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Stephanie McKenna and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2398. Plaintiff Maureen Sproha is a resident of the State of Florida, the Aunt of Decedent Gavin McMahon, and brings this action on her own behalf as Aunt and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Gavin McMahon and on behalf of all survivors of Gavin McMahon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gavin McMahon was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2399. Plaintiff John A. Sproha, Sr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Uncle of Decedent Gavin McMahon, and brings this action on his own behalf as Uncle and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Gavin McMahon and on behalf of all survivors of Gavin McMahon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gavin

443

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 445 of 978

McMahon was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2400. Plaintiff Kathryn Walker McNeal is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Parent of Decedent Daniel W. McNeal, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel W. McNeal and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel W. McNeal and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel W. McNeal was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2401. Plaintiff Jennifer McNulty-Ahern is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Christine Sheila McNulty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2402. Plaintiff Catherine McNulty is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Christine Sheila McNulty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2403. Plaintiff Helen McNulty is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Christine Sheila McNulty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2404. Plaintiff Clive McNulty is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Christine Sheila McNulty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

444

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 446 of 978

2405. Plaintiff Mike McNulty is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Christine Sheila McNulty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2406. Plaintiff Luke McNulty is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Christine Sheila McNulty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christine Sheila McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2407. Plaintiff William Jorn Skead is a resident of United Kingdom, the Spouse of Decedent Christine Sheila McNulty, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Sheila McNulty and on behalf of all survivors of Christine Sheila McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christine Sheila McNulty was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2408. Plaintiff Rosanne McNulty, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Sean Peter McNulty; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2409. Plaintiff Gerald R. McNulty, III, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Sean Peter McNulty; the Representative of Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2410. Plaintiff Richard McNulty is a resident of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Peter McNulty, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sean Peter McNulty and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Peter McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean Peter

445

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 447 of 978

McNulty was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2411. Plaintiff Sara Schultz is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Peter McNulty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Peter McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2412. Plaintiff Bridgette McNulty is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Peter McNulty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Peter McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2413. Plaintiff Michelle McNulty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sean Peter McNulty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sean Peter McNulty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2414. Plaintiff Katherine M. Richardson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Robert W. McPadden, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert W. McPadden and on behalf of all survivors of Robert W. McPadden and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert W. McPadden was killed at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2415. Plaintiff Lynn Mcwilliams is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Martin Edward McWilliams, and brings this action on own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Edward McWilliams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

446

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 448 of 978

2416. Plaintiff DOE 85 is a resident of the state of New York, the Domestic Partner of Decedent DOE 85, and brings this action on her own behalf as Domestic Partner and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 85 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 85 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 85 was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2417. Plaintiff Mary Mcwilliams is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Martin Edward McWilliams, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Martin Edward McWilliams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2418. Plaintiff Barbara Mcwilliams is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Martin Edward McWilliams, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Edward McWilliams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2419. Plaintiff Joseph Mcwilliams is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Martin Edward McWilliams, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Martin Edward McWilliams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2420. Plaintiff Enid Medina is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Abigail Medina, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Abigail Medina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2421. Plaintiff Eli Medina is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Abigail Medina, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

447

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 449 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Abigail Medina and on behalf of all survivors of Abigail Medina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Abigail Medina was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2422. Plaintiff Michael Tavolarella is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Deborah Medwig, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Deborah Medwig and on behalf of all survivors of Deborah Medwig and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Deborah Medwig was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2423. Plaintiff Maureen E. Meehan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent William J. Meehan, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William J. Meehan, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of William J. Meehan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William J. Meehan, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2424. Plaintiff Daniel A. Meehan is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent William J. Meehan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of William J. Meehan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2425. Plaintiff William Meehan, III is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent William J. Meehan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of William J. Meehan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

448

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 450 of 978

2426. Plaintiff Gopal Mehta is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Parent of Decedent Alok K. Mehta, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alok K. Mehta and on behalf of all survivors of Alok K. Mehta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alok K. Mehta was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2427. Plaintiff Joanne Meisenheimer is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Spouse of Decedent Raymond Meisenheimer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Raymond Meisenheimer and on behalf of all survivors of Raymond Meisenheimer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Raymond Meisenheimer was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2428. Plaintiff Julia Hernandez is a resident of the State of New York, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Antonio Melendez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Domestic Partner of Antonio Melendez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2429. Plaintiff Ramon Melendez is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Mary Melendez, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Melendez and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Melendez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary Melendez was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

449

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 451 of 978

2430. Plaintiff Joyce Meltzer is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Stuart Todd Meltzer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Stuart Todd Meltzer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2431. Plaintiff Lisa Meltzer is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Stuart Todd Meltzer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stuart Todd Meltzer and on behalf of all survivors of Stuart Todd Meltzer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stuart Todd Meltzer was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2432. Plaintiff Zachary Meltzer is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Stuart Todd Meltzer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Stuart Todd Meltzer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2433. Plaintiff Kenneth Meltzer is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Stuart Todd Meltzer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stuart Todd Meltzer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2434. Plaintiff Lawrence Meltzer is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Stuart Todd Meltzer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stuart Todd Meltzer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2435. Plaintiff Victor Barahona is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Diarelia J. Mena, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Diarelia J. Mena and on behalf of all survivors of Diarelia J. Mena and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

450

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 452 of 978

Diarelia J. Mena was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2436. Plaintiff Earl A. Dorsey is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Dora Marie Menchaca, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dora Marie Menchaca and on behalf of all survivors of Dora Marie Menchaca and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dora Marie Menchaca was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2437. Plaintiff Kerri Ann Mendez is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Charles Mendez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Mendez and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Mendez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles Mendez was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2438. Plaintiff Myrtle Bazil is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Shevonne Olicia Mentis, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Shevonne Olicia Mentis and on behalf of all survivors of Shevonne Olicia Mentis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Shevonne Olicia Mentis was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2439. Plaintiff Debra Mercurio is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Ralph Mercurio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

451

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 453 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Ralph Mercurio and on behalf of all survivors of Ralph Mercurio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph Mercurio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2440. Plaintiff Barbara Merdinger is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Alan Merdinger, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alan Merdinger and on behalf of all survivors of Alan Merdinger and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alan Merdinger was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2441. Plaintiff Zenaida Merino, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent George Merino; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2442. Plaintiff Maria Lourdes Lehr is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent George Merino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of George Merino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2443. Plaintiff Luis Merino is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent George Merino, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of George Merino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2444. Plaintiff Wendy Anne Metz is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Raymond Joseph Metz, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Raymond Joseph Metz, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

452

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 454 of 978

2445. Plaintiff Raymond Joseph Metz, Jr. is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Raymond Joseph Metz, III, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Raymond Joseph Metz, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2446. Plaintiff Maureen Racioppi is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Peter T. Milano, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter T. Milano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2447. Plaintiff Patricia Milano is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Peter T. Milano, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter T. Milano and on behalf of all survivors of Peter T. Milano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter T. Milano was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2448. Plaintiff Alfred Milano is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Peter T. Milano, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Peter T. Milano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2449. Plaintiff Thomas Milano is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Peter T. Milano, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Peter T. Milano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2450. Plaintiff Frank Milano is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Peter T. Milano, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Peter T. Milano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

453

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 455 of 978

2451. Plaintiff Adele Milanowycz is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Gregory Milanowycz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gregory Milanowycz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2452. Plaintiff Joseph M. Milanowycz is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Gregory Milanowycz, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory Milanowycz and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory Milanowycz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory Milanowycz was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2453. Plaintiff Steven Milanowycz is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Gregory Milanowycz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gregory Milanowycz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2454. Plaintiff Holly Ann Miller Hedley is a resident of the State of Montana, the Spouse of Decedent Craig James Miller, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Craig James Miller and on behalf of all survivors of Craig James Miller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Craig James Miller was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2455. Plaintiff Stella Lazarra, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Joel Miller; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

454

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 456 of 978

2456. Plaintiff Sondra Beverly Foner is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joel Miller, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joel Miller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2457. Plaintiff Adam Eric Miller is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Child of Decedent Joel Miller, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Joel Miller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2458. Plaintiff Patricia Skic is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Fiancé of Decedent Michael Matthew Miller, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Michael Matthew Miller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2459. Plaintiff Betty Ann Miller is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Michael Matthew Miller, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael Matthew Miller and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Matthew Miller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Matthew Miller was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2460. Plaintiff James H. Miller, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Connecticut, and the Parent of Decedent Michael Matthew Miller; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2461. Plaintiff Catherine Stefani is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Nicole Carol Miller, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Nicole Carol Miller and on behalf of all survivors of Nicole Carol Miller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nicole Carol

455

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 457 of 978

Miller was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2462. Plaintiff Tiffney Miller is a resident of the State of Idaho, the Sibling of Decedent Nicole Carol Miller, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Nicole Carol Miller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2463. Plaintiff David James Miller is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Nicole Carol Miller, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Nicole Carol Miller and on behalf of all survivors of Nicole Carol Miller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nicole Carol Miller was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2464. Plaintiff Mitoko Miller is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Robert C. Miller, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert C. Miller, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert C. Miller, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert C. Miller, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2465. Plaintiff Terry Richard Miller is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Robert C. Miller, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert C. Miller, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

456

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 458 of 978

2466. Plaintiff James Ronald Miller is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Robert C. Miller, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert C. Miller, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2467. Plaintiff Ivy Maria Moreno is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Yvette Nicole Miller, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Yvette Nicole Miller and on behalf of all survivors of Yvette Nicole Miller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Yvette Nicole Miller was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2468. Plaintiff Toby Millman is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Benjamin Millman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benjamin Millman and on behalf of all survivors of Benjamin Millman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Benjamin Millman was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2469. Plaintiff Charles M. Mills, III is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Charles M. Mills, II, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Charles M. Mills, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2470. Plaintiff Paula A. Minara is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Minara, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Robert Minara and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2471. Plaintiff Christian Minara is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Robert Minara, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Co-

457

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 459 of 978

Administrator of the Estate of Robert Minara and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Minara and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Minara was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2472. Plaintiff Ryan Paul Minara is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Robert Minara, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Robert Minara and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Minara and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Minara was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2473. Plaintiff Antonina Mingione is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Thomas Mingione, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas Mingione and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2474. Plaintiff Gerald Mingione is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Thomas Mingione, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Thomas Mingione and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2475. Plaintiff Philomena Mistrulli is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph D. Mistrulli, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph D. Mistrulli and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph D. Mistrulli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph D. Mistrulli was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

458

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 460 of 978

2476. Plaintiff Angela M. Mistrulli-Cantone is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent Joseph D. Mistrulli and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2477. Plaintiff Joseph J. Mistrulli is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent Joseph D. Mistrulli and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2478. Plaintiff Mary Ann Mistrulli-Rosser is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent Joseph D. Mistrulli and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2479. Plaintiff Christine Mitchell is a resident of the State of District of Columbia, the Child of Decedent Paul T. Mitchell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Paul T. Mitchell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2480. Plaintiff Jennifer Mitchell is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Paul T. Mitchell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Paul T. Mitchell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2481. Plaintiff Marie D. Mitchell is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Paul T. Mitchell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Paul T. Mitchell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2482. Plaintiff Maureen Mitchell is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Paul T. Mitchell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul T. Mitchell and on behalf of all survivors of Paul T. Mitchell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul T.

459

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 461 of 978

Mitchell was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2483. Plaintiff Laura Marie Lopez is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Richard P. Miuccio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Richard P. Miuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2484. Plaintiff Mary Urs is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Richard P. Miuccio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard P. Miuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2485. Plaintiff Joyce Miuccio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Richard P. Miuccio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard P. Miuccio and on behalf of all survivors of Richard P. Miuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard P. Miuccio was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2486. Plaintiff Owen Richard Miuccio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Richard P. Miuccio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Richard P. Miuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2487. Plaintiff Thomas Paul Miuccio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Richard P. Miuccio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Richard P. Miuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2488. Plaintiff Robert Peter Miuccio, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Richard P. Miuccio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard P. Miuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

460

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 462 of 978

2489. Plaintiff Kathleen Mladenik, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Illinois, and the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey P. Mladenik; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2490. Plaintiff Suzanne S. Mladenik is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Spouse of Decedent Jeffrey P. Mladenik, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey P. Mladenik and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey P. Mladenik and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey P. Mladenik was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2491. Plaintiff Richard Mladenik, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Illinois, and the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey P. Mladenik; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2492. Plaintiff Scott L. Mladenik is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey P. Mladenik, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey P. Mladenik and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2493. Plaintiff Michael Mladenik is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey P. Mladenik, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey P. Mladenik and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2494. Plaintiff Hortensia Gonzalez is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Dennis Mojica, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis Mojica and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis Mojica and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis Mojica

461

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 463 of 978

was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2495. Plaintiff Valentina Ferreira Diaz is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Manuel Dejesus Molina, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Manuel Dejesus Molina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2496. Plaintiff Marina Molina is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Manuel Dejesus Molina, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Manuel Dejesus Molina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2497. Plaintiff Maria Carmen Molina is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Manuel Dejesus Molina, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2498. Plaintiff Fanny Dejesus Molina is a resident of Dominican Republic, the Sibling of Decedent Manuel Dejesus Molina, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2499. Plaintiff Milede Atlagracia Molina is a resident of Dominican Republic, the Sibling of Decedent Manuel Dejesus Molina, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

462

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 464 of 978

2500. Plaintiff Juan Jose Molina is a resident of Dominican Republic, the Sibling of Decedent Manuel Dejesus Molina, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2501. Plaintiff Ramon Dejesus Molina is a resident of Dominican Republic, the Sibling of Decedent Manuel Dejesus Molina, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Manuel Dejesus Molina and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2502. Plaintiff Joan Olivia Molinaro is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent Carl Eugene Molinaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Carl Eugene Molinaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2503. Plaintiff Deborah Ann Atchley is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Sibling of Decedent Carl Eugene Molinaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Carl Eugene Molinaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2504. Plaintiff DOE 41 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 41, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2505. Plaintiff DOE 41 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 41, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2506. Plaintiff DOE 41 is a resident of the state of Hawaii, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 41, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 41

463

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 465 of 978

and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 41 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 41 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2507. Plaintiff Eugene Molinaro is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent Carl Eugene Molinaro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Carl Eugene Molinaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2508. Plaintiff Lawrence Charles Molinaro is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Carl Eugene Molinaro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Carl Eugene Molinaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2509. Plaintiff Jodi Ann Molisani is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Justin John Molisani, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Justin John Molisani, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Justin John Molisani, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Justin John Molisani, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2510. Plaintiff Jeanne Ann Monaghan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Brian Patrick Monaghan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Brian Patrick Monaghan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2511. Plaintiff Danielle Monaghan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Brian Patrick Monaghan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

464

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 466 of 978

Brian Patrick Monaghan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2512. Plaintiff Bernard J. Monaghan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Brian Patrick Monaghan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian Patrick Monaghan and on behalf of all survivors of Brian Patrick Monaghan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Patrick Monaghan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2513. Plaintiff Matthew Monahan is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Franklyn Monahan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Franklyn Monahan and on behalf of all survivors of Franklyn Monahan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Franklyn Monahan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2514. Plaintiff DOE 75 is a resident of the state of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 75, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 75 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 75 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 75 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2515. Plaintiff Margaret P. Montesi, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Michael G. Montesi; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

465

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 467 of 978

2516. Plaintiff Maria E. Lauria is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael G. Montesi, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael G. Montesi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2517. Plaintiff Nancy Eileen Montesi is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael G. Montesi, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael G. Montesi and on behalf of all survivors of Michael G. Montesi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael G. Montesi was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2518. Plaintiff George R. Montesi, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Michael G. Montesi; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2519. Plaintiff Doris Marie Monyak is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Cheryl Ann Monyak, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Cheryl Ann Monyak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2520. Plaintiff Michael J. Monyak is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Cheryl Ann Monyak, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Cheryl Ann Monyak and on behalf of all survivors of Cheryl Ann Monyak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cheryl Ann Monyak was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

466

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 468 of 978

2521. Plaintiff Barbara Bridges is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Sharon Moore, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Sharon Moore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2522. Plaintiff Karina Moore is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Sibling of Decedent Sharon Moore, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sharon Moore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2523. Plaintiff Arina Bridges is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sharon Moore, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sharon Moore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2524. Plaintiff Violet Maddix is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sharon Moore, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sharon Moore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2525. Plaintiff Eugene Moore is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Parent of Decedent Sharon Moore, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Sharon Moore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2526. Plaintiff Rayburn Moore is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling of Decedent Sharon Moore, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sharon Moore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2527. Plaintiff Betty E. Moran is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent John Christopher Moran, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John Christopher Moran and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2528. Plaintiff Elizabeth Louise Moran is a resident of England, the Spouse of Decedent John Christopher Moran, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

467

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 469 of 978

Representative of the Estate of John Christopher Moran and on behalf of all survivors of John Christopher Moran and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Christopher Moran was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2529. Plaintiff Kevin M. Moran is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent John Christopher Moran, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Christopher Moran and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2530. Plaintiff Mary Ann Moran is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Kathleen Moran, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kathleen Moran and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2531. Plaintiff Kathleen S. Maycen is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Lindsay S. Morehouse, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lindsay S. Morehouse and on behalf of all survivors of Lindsay S. Morehouse and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lindsay S. Morehouse was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2532. Plaintiff Theodore C. Morehouse is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Lindsay S. Morehouse, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Lindsay S. Morehouse and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2533. Plaintiff Nykia Morgan is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Dorothy R. Morgan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the

468

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 470 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Dorothy R. Morgan and on behalf of all survivors of Dorothy R. Morgan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dorothy R. Morgan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2534. Plaintiff DOE 48 is a resident of the Illinois, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 48, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2535. Plaintiff Glenn Morgan is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Richard J. Morgan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Richard J. Morgan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2536. Plaintiff Kevin J. Morgan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Richard J. Morgan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard J. Morgan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2537. Plaintiff Maria Morocho Sanchez is a resident of Ecuador, the Parent of Decedent Blanca Morocho, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Blanca Morocho and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2538. Plaintiff Manuel Llanos Morocho is a resident of Ecuador, the Sibling of Decedent Blanca Morocho, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Blanca Morocho and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2539. Plaintiff Maria Morocho Sanchez is a resident of Ecuador, the Parent of Decedent Leonel G. Morocho, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Leonel G. Morocho and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

469

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 471 of 978

2540. Plaintiff Manuel Llanos Morocho is a resident of Ecuador, the Sibling of Decedent Leonel G. Morocho, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Leonel G. Morocho and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2541. Plaintiff Patricia M. Morris is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Lynne Irene Morris, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Lynne Irene Morris and on behalf of all survivors of Lynne Irene Morris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lynne Irene Morris was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2542. Plaintiff Christine Morris is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Lynne Irene Morris, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Lynne Irene Morris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2543. Plaintiff Edward G. Morris is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Lynne Irene Morris, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lynne Irene Morris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2544. Plaintiff Harold C. Morris, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Lynne Irene Morris, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Lynne Irene Morris and on behalf of all survivors of Lynne Irene Morris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lynne Irene Morris was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2545. Plaintiff Lynn Morris is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Seth A. Morris, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

470

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 472 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Seth A. Morris and on behalf of all survivors of Seth A. Morris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Seth A. Morris was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2546. Plaintiff Laura Mazzarella is a resident of the State of Florida, the Fiancé of Decedent Stephen Phillip Morris, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Stephen Phillip Morris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2547. Plaintiff DOE 91 is a resident of the Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent DOE 91, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2548. Plaintiff DOE 91 is a resident of the Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 91, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2549. Plaintiff DOE 91 is a resident of the Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 91, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2550. Plaintiff DOE 91 is a resident of the Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent DOE 91, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2551. Plaintiff Lorraine Moskal is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Spouse of Decedent William David Moskal, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Fiduciary of the Estate of William David Moskal and on behalf of all survivors of William David Moskal and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William

471

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 473 of 978

David Moskal was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2552. Plaintiff Alexandra Mouchinskaia, now deceased, was a resident of Russia, and the Parent of Decedent Iouri Mouchinski; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2553. Plaintiff Iryna Ushakova is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Iouri Mouchinski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Iouri Mouchinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2554. Plaintiff Olena Pavlova is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Iouri Mouchinski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Iouri Mouchinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2555. Plaintiff Nadejda Grib is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Iouri Mouchinski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Iouri Mouchinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2556. Plaintiff Natalia Mushinski is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Iouri Mouchinski, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Iouri Mouchinski and on behalf of all survivors of Iouri Mouchinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Iouri Mouchinski was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2557. Plaintiff Vladimir Mushinsky is a resident of Russia, the Sibling of Decedent Iouri Mouchinski, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Iouri Mouchinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

472

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 474 of 978

2558. Plaintiff DOE 89 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 89, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 89 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 89 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 89 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2559. Plaintiff Lydia Mozzillo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Mozzillo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Christopher Mozzillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2560. Plaintiff DOE 80 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 80, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2561. Plaintiff Michael Mozzillo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Mozzillo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Mozzillo and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Mozzillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Mozzillo was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2562. Plaintiff Daniel Mozzillo is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Mozzillo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Mozzillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2563. Plaintiff Constance Muldowney is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Richard Muldowney, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

473

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 475 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Muldowney and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Muldowney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Muldowney was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2564. Plaintiff Nancy Mulligan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Peter James Mulligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Peter James Mulligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2565. Plaintiff Sara M. Mulligan is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Peter James Mulligan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter James Mulligan and on behalf of all survivors of Peter James Mulligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter James Mulligan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2566. Plaintiff Thomas Mulligan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Peter James Mulligan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Peter James Mulligan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2567. Plaintiff Lynn Anne Mullin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Joseph Mullin, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Joseph Mullin and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Joseph Mullin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Joseph Mullin was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

474

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 476 of 978

2568. Plaintiff Fredric John Mullin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Joseph Mullin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael Joseph Mullin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2569. Plaintiff Susan King Munhall is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent James Donald Munhall, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Donald Munhall and on behalf of all survivors of James Donald Munhall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Donald Munhall was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2570. Plaintiff Maritza Arzayus is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Carlos Munoz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carlos Munoz and on behalf of all survivors of Carlos Munoz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carlos Munoz was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2571. Plaintiff Christine M. Munson is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Theresa Ann Munson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Theresa Ann Munson and on behalf of all survivors of Theresa Ann Munson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Theresa Ann Munson was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

475

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 477 of 978

2572. Plaintiff Laurie Murach is a resident of the State of Idaho, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Murach, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Murach and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Murach and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Murach was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2573. Plaintiff Nilvia Mitchell is a resident of the State of Vermont, the Parent of Decedent Cesar A. Murillo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Cesar A. Murillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2574. Plaintiff Carolyn Alderman is a resident of the State of Vermont, the Sibling of Decedent Cesar A. Murillo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Cesar A. Murillo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2575. Plaintiff Catherine Goldsborough White Murphy is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of Decedent Christopher W. Murphy, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher W. Murphy and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher W. Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher W. Murphy was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2576. Plaintiff Evelyn M. Murphy, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Massachusetts, and the Parent of Decedent Edward Charles Murphy; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

476

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 478 of 978

2577. Plaintiff Ryan Lewis Murphy is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Nephew of Decedent Edward Charles Murphy, and brings this action on his own behalf as Nephew and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Charles Murphy and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Charles Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Charles Murphy was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2578. Plaintiff Daniel W. Murphy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Edward Charles Murphy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Edward Charles Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2579. Plaintiff Richard E. Murphy is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Edward Charles Murphy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Edward Charles Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2580. Plaintiff Helen Marie Murphy, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent James Francis Murphy, IV; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2581. Plaintiff Kristin M. Murphy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Francis Murphy, IV, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Francis Murphy, IV and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

477

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 479 of 978

2582. Plaintiff Kathleen Marie Murphy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Francis Murphy, IV, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Francis Murphy, IV and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2583. Plaintiff Helen Marie Sweeney is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Francis Murphy, IV, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Francis Murphy, IV and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2584. Plaintiff Elizabeth Murphy Cooke is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Francis Murphy, IV, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Francis Murphy, IV and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2585. Plaintiff James F. Murphy, III, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent James Francis Murphy, IV; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2586. Plaintiff Joan V. Murphy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent James Thomas Murphy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of James Thomas Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2587. Plaintiff Mary L. Murphy is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Spouse of Decedent James Thomas Murphy, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Thomas Murphy and on behalf of all survivors of James Thomas Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

478

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 480 of 978

herein. James Thomas Murphy was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2588. Plaintiff Thomas J. Murphy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James Thomas Murphy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James Thomas Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2589. Plaintiff William C. Murphy, III is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James Thomas Murphy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James Thomas Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2590. Plaintiff William C. Murphy, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent James Thomas Murphy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of James Thomas Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2591. Plaintiff Dolores Barbara Murphy is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Patrick Sean Murphy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patrick Sean Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2592. Plaintiff Thomas Joseph Murphy is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Patrick Sean Murphy, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Patrick Sean Murphy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2593. Plaintiff Linda Murphy is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Raymond E. Murphy, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Raymond E. Murphy, Sr. and on behalf of all

479

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 481 of 978

survivors of Raymond E. Murphy, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Raymond E. Murphy, Sr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2594. Plaintiff Raymond Murphy, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Raymond E. Murphy, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Raymond E. Murphy, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2595. Plaintiff Mary Louise Murray, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Delaware, and the Parent of Decedent John J. Murray; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2596. Plaintiff Jayne E. Dellose is a resident of the State of Delaware, the Sibling of Decedent John J. Murray, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John J. Murray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2597. Plaintiff Virginia M. Regan is a resident of the State of Delaware, the Sibling of Decedent John J. Murray, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John J. Murray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2598. Plaintiff Catherine Marie Datz is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent John J. Murray, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John J. Murray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2599. Plaintiff Rory Owens Murray is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent John J. Murray, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John J. Murray and on behalf of all survivors of John J.

480

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 482 of 978

Murray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. Murray was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2600. Plaintiff Philip C. Murray, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Delaware, and the Parent of Decedent John J. Murray; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2601. Plaintiff Michael Christopher Murray is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent John J. Murray, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John J. Murray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2602. Plaintiff Philip J. Murray is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent John J. Murray, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John J. Murray and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2603. Plaintiff DOE 07 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 07, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 07 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 07 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 07 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2604. Plaintiff Marjorie Napier is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Alexander Napier, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Alexander Napier and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2605. Plaintiff Nicola Napier is a resident of United Kingdom, the Spouse of Decedent Alexander Napier, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

481

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 483 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Alexander Napier and on behalf of all survivors of Alexander Napier and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alexander Napier was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2606. Plaintiff Gerald Napier is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Alexander Napier, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Alexander Napier and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2607. Plaintiff Mark Napier is a resident of the State of United States, the Sibling of Decedent Alexander Napier, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Alexander Napier and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2608. Plaintiff Madhu Narula is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Maniki Narula, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Maniki Narula and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2609. Plaintiff Baldev Narula is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Maniki Narula, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maniki Narula and on behalf of all survivors of Maniki Narula and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maniki Narula was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2610. Plaintiff Margaret M. Nassaney is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Shawn Michael Nassaney, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Shawn Michael Nassaney and on behalf of all survivors of Shawn Michael Nassaney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action

482

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 484 of 978

set forth herein. Shawn Michael Nassaney was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2611. Plaintiff Ryan A. Nassaney is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Shawn Michael Nassaney, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Shawn Michael Nassaney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2612. Plaintiff Patrick J. Nassaney, Jr. is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Shawn Michael Nassaney, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Shawn Michael Nassaney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2613. Plaintiff Patrick John Nassaney, Sr. is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Shawn Michael Nassaney, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Shawn Michael Nassaney and on behalf of all survivors of Shawn Michael Nassaney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Shawn Michael Nassaney was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2614. Plaintiff Keolahmatie Nath is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Spouse of Decedent Narender Nath, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Narender Nath and on behalf of all survivors of Narender Nath and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

483

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 485 of 978

Narender Nath was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2615. Plaintiff Rosemarie Navas is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Michael Navas, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Michael Navas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2616. Plaintiff Lisa Ann Lopiccolo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Michael Navas, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Michael Navas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2617. Plaintiff Joseph N. Navas, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Joseph Michael Navas; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2618. Plaintiff Julianne Nazario is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Francis J. Nazario, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Francis J. Nazario and on behalf of all survivors of Francis J. Nazario and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francis J. Nazario was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2619. Plaintiff Zandra Lena Neblett is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Rayman Marcus Neblett, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Rayman Marcus Neblett and on behalf of all survivors of Rayman Marcus Neblett and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rayman Marcus Neblett was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

484

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 486 of 978

2620. Plaintiff Patricia B. Nee O'keefe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Luke G. Nee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Luke G. Nee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2621. Plaintiff Mary Nee Reilly is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Luke G. Nee, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Luke G. Nee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2622. Plaintiff John G. Nee is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Luke G. Nee, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Luke G. Nee and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2623. Plaintiff Leila Negron is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Pete Negron, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Pete Negron and on behalf of all survivors of Pete Negron and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pete Negron was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2624. Plaintiff Francisca A. Wester is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Child of Decedent Laurie Ann Neira, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Laurie Ann Neira and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2625. Plaintiff Gilberto A. Neira, now deceased, was a resident of the State of California, and the Spouse of Decedent Laurie Ann Neira; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2626. Representative of the Estate of Laurie Ann Neira brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Laurie Ann Neira and on behalf of all survivors of Laurie Ann Neira and is entitled

485

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 487 of 978

to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Laurie Ann Neira was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2627. Plaintiff Christopher O. Neira is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Laurie Ann Neira, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Laurie Ann Neira and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2628. Plaintiff Jenette Nelson is a resident of the State of North Dakota, the Parent of Decedent Ann Nicole Nelson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Ann Nicole Nelson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2629. Plaintiff Gary S. Nelson is a resident of the State of North Dakota, the Parent of Decedent Ann Nicole Nelson, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ann Nicole Nelson and on behalf of all survivors of Ann Nicole Nelson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ann Nicole Nelson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2630. Plaintiff Scott T. Nelson is a resident of the State of North Dakota, the Sibling of Decedent Ann Nicole Nelson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ann Nicole Nelson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2631. Plaintiff Rosanne Nelson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent James Nelson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Nelson and on behalf of all survivors of James Nelson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Nelson was killed in

486

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 488 of 978

the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2632. Plaintiff Lillian C. Tetreault is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Parent of Decedent Renee Tetreault Newell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Renee Tetreault Newell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2633. Plaintiff Ronnie R. Tetreault is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Renee Tetreault Newell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Renee Tetreault Newell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2634. Plaintiff Paul Newell is a resident of the State of Vermont, the Spouse of Decedent Renee Tetreault Newell, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Renee Tetreault Newell and on behalf of all survivors of Renee Tetreault Newell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Renee Tetreault Newell was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2635. Plaintiff Tu A. Honguyen is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Khang N. Nguyen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Khang N. Nguyen and on behalf of all survivors of Khang N. Nguyen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Khang N. Nguyen was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

487

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 489 of 978

2636. Plaintiff Charles W. Niederer is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Parent of Decedent Martin Stewart Niederer, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Stewart Niederer and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Stewart Niederer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martin Stewart Niederer was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2637. Plaintiff Carol Niedermeyer is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Alfonse J. Niedermeyer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Alfonse J. Niedermeyer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2638. Plaintiff Nancy Niedermeyer is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Alfonse J. Niedermeyer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alfonse J. Niedermeyer and on behalf of all survivors of Alfonse J. Niedermeyer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alfonse J. Niedermeyer was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2639. Plaintiff Alfonse Niedermeyer is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Alfonse J. Niedermeyer, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Alfonse J. Niedermeyer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2640. Plaintiff Adelma Reyes Jiminez is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of Decedent Gloria Reyes Nieves, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Gloria Reyes Nieves and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

488

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 490 of 978

2641. Plaintiff Michelle Nieves is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Juan Nieves, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Juan Nieves, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Juan Nieves, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Juan Nieves, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2642. Plaintiff Irma Nieves is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Juan Nieves, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Juan Nieves, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2643. Plaintiff John Nieves is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Juan Nieves, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Juan Nieves, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2644. Plaintiff David Nieves is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Juan Nieves, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Juan Nieves, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2645. Plaintiff Jennifer Nilsen is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Troy Edward Nilsen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Troy Edward Nilsen and on behalf of all survivors of Troy Edward Nilsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Troy Edward Nilsen was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

489

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 491 of 978

2646. Plaintiff Edward Carl Nilsen is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Troy Edward Nilsen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Troy Edward Nilsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2647. Plaintiff Ellen Niven is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent John Ballentine Nivin, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Ballentine Nivin and on behalf of all survivors of John Ballentine Nivin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Ballentine Nivin was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2648. Plaintiff Kathryn M. McGarry is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Parent of Decedent Katherine McGarry Noack, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Katherine McGarry Noack and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2649. Plaintiff Everett Joseph McGarry, now deceased, was a resident of the State of North Carolina, and the Parent of Decedent Katherine McGarry Noack; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2650. Plaintiff Theresa Noel is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Curtis T. Noel, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Curtis T. Noel and on behalf of all survivors of Curtis T. Noel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Curtis T. Noel was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

490

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 492 of 978

2651. Plaintiff Michael Noel is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Curtis T. Noel, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Curtis T. Noel and on behalf of all survivors of Curtis T. Noel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Curtis T. Noel was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2652. Plaintiff Renee E. Nolan-Riley is a resident of the State of Kansas, the Spouse of Decedent Daniel R. Nolan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel R. Nolan and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel R. Nolan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel R. Nolan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2653. Plaintiff Joanne Lovett is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Brian Nunez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian Nunez and on behalf of all survivors of Brian Nunez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Nunez was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2654. Plaintiff Neal Green is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Brian Nunez, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Brian Nunez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

491

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 493 of 978

2655. Plaintiff Eric Nunez is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Brian Nunez, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Brian Nunez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2656. Plaintiff Denise I. Oakley is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent James A. Oakley, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James A. Oakley and on behalf of all survivors of James A. Oakley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James A. Oakley was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2657. Plaintiff Christine M. O'Berg is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Dennis P. O'Berg, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis P. O'Berg and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis P. O'Berg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis P. O'Berg was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2658. Plaintiff James O'Brien is a resident of the State of Maine, the Parent of Decedent James O'Brien, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James O'Brien, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of James O'Brien, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James O'Brien, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

492

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 494 of 978

2659. Plaintiff Mary Lou O'Brien is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Parent of Decedent Michael P. O'Brien, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael P. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2660. Plaintiff Bridget Ann Paluzzi is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Sibling of Decedent Michael P. O'Brien, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael P. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2661. Plaintiff Mary Kathleen Dishaw is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael P. O'Brien, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael P. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2662. Plaintiff Rachel O'Brien is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Michael P. O'Brien, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael P. O'Brien and on behalf of all survivors of Michael P. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael P. O'Brien was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2663. Plaintiff Robert T. O'Brien, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Hampshire, and the Parent of Decedent Michael P. O'Brien; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2664. Plaintiff Andrew Thomas O'Brien is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Michael P. O'Brien, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael P. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

493

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 495 of 978

2665. Plaintiff Marilyn Jeanne O'Brien is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Timothy M. O'Brien, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Timothy M. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2666. Plaintiff Kathleen Marie Tighe is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Timothy M. O'Brien, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Timothy M. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2667. Plaintiff Therese A. Visconti is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Timothy M. O'Brien, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Timothy M. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2668. Plaintiff Bernard Joseph O'Brien is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Timothy M. O'Brien, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Timothy M. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2669. Plaintiff Patrick O'Brien is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Timothy M. O'Brien, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Timothy M. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2670. Plaintiff Robert L. O'Brien is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Timothy M. O'Brien, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Timothy M. O'Brien and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2671. Plaintiff Rhonda Lee O'Callaghan is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Daniel O'Callaghan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel O'Callaghan and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel O'Callaghan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

494

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 496 of 978

Daniel O'Callaghan was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2672. Plaintiff DOE 22 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 22, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 22 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 22 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 22 was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2673. Plaintiff Antoinette D. Ognibene, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Philip Paul Ognibene; the Co-Representative of her Estate, ESTHER R. BARBUTO, BLAISE J. OGNIBENE, AND ANNA M. RUESS, bring this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2674. Plaintiff Theresa Ogonowski is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent John Alexander Ogonowski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John Alexander Ogonowski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2675. Plaintiff Carol A. Ogonowski is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent John Alexander Ogonowski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Alexander Ogonowski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2676. Plaintiff Margaret Mary Ogonowski is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent John Alexander Ogonowski, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Alexander Ogonowski and on

495

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 497 of 978

behalf of all survivors of John Alexander Ogonowski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Alexander Ogonowski was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2677. Plaintiff James Ogonowski is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent John Alexander Ogonowski, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Alexander Ogonowski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2678. Plaintiff Joseph Ogonowski is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Sibling of Decedent John Alexander Ogonowski, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Alexander Ogonowski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2679. Plaintiff Rachel Uchitel is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Andrew O'Grady, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Andrew O'Grady and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2680. Plaintiff Mary Ellen Malone is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2681. Plaintiff Anne Marie Moran is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

496

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 498 of 978

2682. Plaintiff Kathleen Brigid Gaetano is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2683. Plaintiff Jeanne Theresa McCabe is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2684. Plaintiff Clare R. Mayer is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2685. Plaintiff Andrea O'Hagan is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Gerard O'Hagan was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2686. Plaintiff John O'Hagan is a resident of the State of United States, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

497

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 499 of 978

2687. Plaintiff Raymond T. O'Hagan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2688. Plaintiff Joseph E. O'Hagan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2689. Plaintiff Francis Patrick O'Hagan, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Gerard O'Hagan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2690. Plaintiff Francis P. O'Hagan, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Thomas Gerard O'Hagan; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2691. Plaintiff Karen Lisa O'Keefe is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Patrick Joseph O'Keefe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick Joseph O'Keefe and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick Joseph O'Keefe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Joseph O'Keefe was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2692. Plaintiff Virginia O'Keefe is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent William S. O'Keefe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

498

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 500 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of William S. O'Keefe and on behalf of all survivors of William S. O'Keefe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William S. O'Keefe was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2693. Plaintiff Lynn A. Olcott is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Gerald M. Olcott, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gerald M. Olcott and on behalf of all survivors of Gerald M. Olcott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerald M. Olcott was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2694. Plaintiff Christopher Graig Olcott is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Gerald M. Olcott, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Gerald M. Olcott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2695. Plaintiff Graig Aaron Olcott is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Gerald M. Olcott, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Gerald M. Olcott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2696. Plaintiff Stella Olender is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Parent of Decedent Christine Olender, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Olender and on behalf of all survivors of Christine Olender and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christine Olender was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

499

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 501 of 978

2697. Plaintiff Therese Winters is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling of Decedent Christine Olender, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christine Olender and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2698. Plaintiff John Casimir Olender is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Parent of Decedent Christine Olender, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Christine Olender and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2699. Plaintiff Conrad S. Olender is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling of Decedent Christine Olender, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christine Olender and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2700. Plaintiff Barbara Olsen is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Eric Taube Olsen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Eric Taube Olsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2701. Plaintiff Taube Olsen, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Eric Taube Olsen; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2702. Representative of the Estate of Eric Taube brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Eric Taube and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Taube and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric Taube was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2703. Plaintiff Clifford I. Olsen is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Eric Taube Olsen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Eric Taube Olsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

500

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 502 of 978

2704. Plaintiff Kenneth Olsen is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Eric Taube Olsen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Eric Taube Olsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2705. Plaintiff Todd Olsen is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Eric Taube Olsen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Eric Taube Olsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2706. Plaintiff DOE 82 is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 82, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2707. Plaintiff DOE 82 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 82, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2708. Plaintiff Denise Marie Olsen is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Jeffrey James Olsen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey James Olsen and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey James Olsen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey James Olsen was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2709. Plaintiff DOE 82 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 82, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

501

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 503 of 978

2710. Plaintiff DOE 82 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 82, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2711. Plaintiff Patricia Olson is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Steven J. Olson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven J. Olson and on behalf of all survivors of Steven J. Olson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven J. Olson was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2712. Plaintiff Kenneth D. Olson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Steven J. Olson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Steven J. Olson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2713. Plaintiff Helen O'Mahony Bradley is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Matthew T. O'Mahony, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Matthew T. O'Mahony and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2714. Plaintiff Karen O'Mahony Speidell is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Matthew T. O'Mahony, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Matthew T. O'Mahony and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2715. Plaintiff John O'Mahony is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Matthew T. O'Mahony, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Matthew T. O'Mahony and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

502

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 504 of 978

2716. Plaintiff Stephen O'Mahony is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Matthew T. O'Mahony, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Matthew T. O'Mahony and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2717. Plaintiff Robert J. O'Mahony is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Matthew T. O'Mahony, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Matthew T. O'Mahony and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2718. Plaintiff Jeanne O'Neill is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Peter J. O'Neill, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter J. O'Neill, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2719. Plaintiff Bridie O'Neill is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Peter J. O'Neill, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2720. Plaintiff Thomas W. O'Neill is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Peter J. O'Neill, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2721. Plaintiff Peter J. O'Neill, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Peter J. O'Neill, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Peter J. O'Neill, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter J.

503

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 505 of 978

O'Neill, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2722. Plaintiff Carol A. Smee is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael C. Opperman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael C. Opperman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2723. Plaintiff Joyce Christopher is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Christopher T. Orgielewicz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Christopher T. Orgielewicz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2724. Plaintiff Laurie Ann Christopher is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher T. Orgielewicz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher T. Orgielewicz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2725. Plaintiff Olga Orgielewicz is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Christopher T. Orgielewicz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher T. Orgielewicz and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher T. Orgielewicz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher T. Orgielewicz was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2726. Plaintiff Corinne O'Rourke is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Kevin M. O'Rourke, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Kevin M. O'Rourke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

504

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 506 of 978

2727. Plaintiff Hannah O'Rourke is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kevin M. O'Rourke, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kevin M. O'Rourke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2728. Plaintiff Patricia O'Keefe is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Kevin M. O'Rourke, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin M. O'Rourke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2729. Plaintiff Maryann J. O'Rourke is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Kevin M. O'Rourke, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin M. O'Rourke and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin M. O'Rourke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin M. O'Rourke was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2730. Plaintiff Jamie O'Rourke is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Kevin M. O'Rourke, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Kevin M. O'Rourke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2731. Plaintiff Dennis O'Rourke is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kevin M. O'Rourke, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kevin M. O'Rourke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2732. Plaintiff Dennis P. O'Rourke is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Kevin M. O'Rourke, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin M. O'Rourke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

505

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 507 of 978

2733. Plaintiff Gilbert Ortale is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Keith Ortale, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Keith Ortale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2734. Plaintiff Agatina Iaci is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Parent of Decedent Jane Marie Orth, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jane Marie Orth and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2735. Plaintiff Gae Ferruolo is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Sibling of Decedent Jane Marie Orth, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jane Marie Orth and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2736. Plaintiff Wanda Garcia-Ortiz is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Emilio Ortiz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Emilio Ortiz and on behalf of all survivors of Emilio Ortiz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Emilio Ortiz was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2737. Plaintiff Edna Velez-Mundo is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Pablo Ortiz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Administrator of the Estate of Pablo Ortiz and on behalf of all survivors of Pablo Ortiz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pablo Ortiz was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

506

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 508 of 978

2738. Plaintiff Elizabeth Sherry is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert O'Shea, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert O'Shea and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2739. Plaintiff Beverly Ann Ostrowski is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent James Robert Ostrowski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of James Robert Ostrowski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2740. Plaintiff DOE 81 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 81, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2741. Plaintiff Stephen V. Ostrowski, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent James Robert Ostrowski; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2742. Plaintiff Stephen W. Ostrowski is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Robert Ostrowski, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James Robert Ostrowski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2743. Plaintiff Marion Susan Otten is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael J. Otten, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael J. Otten and on behalf of all survivors of Michael J. Otten and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Otten was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

507

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 509 of 978

2744. Plaintiff Andrea Ouida is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Todd Joseph Ouida, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Todd Joseph Ouida and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2745. Plaintiff Amy Morik is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Todd Joseph Ouida, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Todd Joseph Ouida and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2746. Plaintiff Herbert Ouida is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Todd Joseph Ouida, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Todd Joseph Ouida and on behalf of all survivors of Todd Joseph Ouida and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Todd Joseph Ouida was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2747. Plaintiff Jordan Ouida is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Todd Joseph Ouida, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Todd Joseph Ouida and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2748. Plaintiff Annie Guerrero is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé of Decedent Roland Pacheco, and brings this action on her own behalf as Fiancé and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roland Pacheco and on behalf of all survivors of Roland Pacheco and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roland Pacheco was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

508

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 510 of 978

2749. Plaintiff Ryan Pacheco is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Roland Pacheco, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Roland Pacheco and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2750. Plaintiff Rekha D. Packer is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael B. Packer, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael B. Packer and on behalf of all survivors of Michael B. Packer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael B. Packer was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2751. Plaintiff Juana B. Borrero, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Puerto Rico, and the Parent of Decedent Diana B. Padro; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2752. Plaintiff Miriam Borrero, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Puerto Rico, and the Sibling of Decedent Diana B. Padro; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2753. Plaintiff Lillian Borrero is a resident of the State of Puerto Rico, the Sibling of Decedent Diana B. Padro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Diana B. Padro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2754. Plaintiff Jose Javier Padro is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Diana B. Padro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Diana B. Padro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

509

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 511 of 978

2755. Plaintiff Juan Carlos Padro is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Diana B. Padro, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Diana B. Padro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2756. Plaintiff Jose E. Padro-Lebron is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Diana B. Padro, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Diana B. Padro and on behalf of all survivors of Diana B. Padro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Diana B. Padro was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2757. Plaintiff Annette M. Palazzolo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Richard A. Palazzolo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard A. Palazzolo and on behalf of all survivors of Richard A. Palazzolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard A. Palazzolo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2758. Plaintiff DOE 54 is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 54, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2759. Plaintiff DOE 54 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 54, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

510

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 512 of 978

2760. Plaintiff DOE 54 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 54, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2761. Plaintiff DOE 54 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 54, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2762. Plaintiff DOE 54, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 54; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2763. Plaintiff DOE 54 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 54, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2764. Plaintiff DOE 54 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 54, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2765. Plaintiff Fortunata Palombo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Frank Palombo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Frank Palombo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2766. Plaintiff Marie Palombo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Frank Palombo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Frank Palombo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

511

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 513 of 978

2767. Plaintiff Barbara Polisar is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Frank Palombo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Frank Palombo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2768. Plaintiff Barbara Pandolfo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Dominique Lisa Pandolfo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dominique Lisa Pandolfo and on behalf of all survivors of Dominique Lisa Pandolfo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dominique Lisa Pandolfo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2769. Plaintiff Linda Ellen Panik, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, and the Parent of Decedent Jonas Martin Panik; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2770. Plaintiff Martina Lyne-Anna Panik is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Sibling of Decedent Jonas Martin Panik, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jonas Martin Panik and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2771. Plaintiff Martin Anthony Panik is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent Jonas Martin Panik, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jonas Martin Panik and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2772. Plaintiff Loretta Halpert is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul J. Pansini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Paul J. Pansini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2773. Plaintiff Janice Pansini is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Paul J. Pansini, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

512

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 514 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Paul J. Pansini and on behalf of all survivors of Paul J. Pansini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul J. Pansini was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2774. Plaintiff Joseph Pansini is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul J. Pansini, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul J. Pansini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2775. Plaintiff Robert Joseph Pansini, Sr. is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Paul J. Pansini, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul J. Pansini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2776. Plaintiff Patricia N. Papa is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Edward J. Papa, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward J. Papa and on behalf of all survivors of Edward J. Papa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward J. Papa was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2777. Plaintiff Theresa Papasso is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Salvatore T. Papasso, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Salvatore T. Papasso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2778. Plaintiff Christine E. Papasso is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Salvatore T. Papasso, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Salvatore T. Papasso and on behalf of all survivors of Salvatore T. Papasso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

513

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 515 of 978

Salvatore T. Papasso was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2779. Plaintiff Salvatore Papasso is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Salvatore T. Papasso, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Salvatore T. Papasso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2780. Plaintiff Vincent Papasso is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Salvatore T. Papasso, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Salvatore T. Papasso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2781. Plaintiff Gina Pinos is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent James N. Pappageorge, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of James N. Pappageorge and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2782. Plaintiff Juana Olga Pappageorge is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent James N. Pappageorge, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James N. Pappageorge and on behalf of all survivors of James N. Pappageorge and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James N. Pappageorge was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2783. Plaintiff Helen Pappageorge is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James N. Pappageorge, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James N. Pappageorge and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2784. Plaintiff Maria Koutny is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Marie Pappalardo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marie Pappalardo and on behalf of all survivors of

514

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 516 of 978

Marie Pappalardo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marie Pappalardo was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2785. Plaintiff Vernon Alfred Randlett is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Marie Pappalardo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Marie Pappalardo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2786. Plaintiff Gary Pappalardo is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Marie Pappalardo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Marie Pappalardo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2787. Plaintiff Gangadei Ramrup is a resident of Guyana, the Sibling of Decedent Hardai Parbhu, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2788. Plaintiff Parboti Parbhu is a resident of Canada, the Sibling of Decedent Hardai Parbhu, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2789. Plaintiff Denesh N. Parbhu is a resident of Trinidad, the Sibling of Decedent Hardai Parbhu, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2790. Plaintiff Rajaram Parbhu is a resident of Canada, the Sibling of Decedent Hardai Parbhu, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

515

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 517 of 978

2791. Plaintiff Kenneth Persaud is a resident of Guyana, the Sibling of Decedent Hardai Parbhu, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Hardai Parbhu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2792. Plaintiff Lachman Parbhu is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Hardai Parbhu, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hardai Parbhu and on behalf of all survivors of Hardai Parbhu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hardai Parbhu was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2793. Plaintiff Rose Paris is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent George Paris, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of George Paris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2794. Plaintiff Christina Paris is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent George Paris, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George Paris and on behalf of all survivors of George Paris and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George Paris was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2795. Plaintiff Jung Hea Shin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Gye Hyong Park, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gye Hyong Park and on behalf of all survivors of Gye Hyong Park and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gye

516

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 518 of 978

Hyong Park was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2796. Plaintiff Myong Kyu Park is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Gye Hyong Park, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Gye Hyong Park and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2797. Plaintiff Jin Han Park is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Gye Hyong Park, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gye Hyong Park and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2798. Plaintiff DOE 141, now deceased, was a resident of United Kingdom, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 141; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2799. Plaintiff Bharti Parmar is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Hashmukhrai C. Parmar, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hashmukhrai C. Parmar and on behalf of all survivors of Hashmukhrai C. Parmar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hashmukhrai C. Parmar was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2800. Plaintiff DOE 141 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 141, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2801. Plaintiff DOE 141 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 141, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

517

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 519 of 978

2802. Plaintiff Karen Parro is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Parro, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Parro and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Parro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Parro was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2803. Plaintiff Karen Tatum is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Diane Moore Parsons, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Diane Moore Parsons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2804. Plaintiff Frank Tatum is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Diane Moore Parsons, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Diane Moore Parsons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2805. Plaintiff Imelda Reyes Soriano is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Leobardo Lopez Pascual, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Domestic Partner of Leobardo Lopez Pascual and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2806. Plaintiff Sarah P. Rubinstein is a resident of the State of Minnesota, the Sibling of Decedent Jerrold H. Paskins, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jerrold H. Paskins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2807. Plaintiff Inez Paskins- Slick is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Jerrold H. Paskins, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jerrold H. Paskins and on behalf of all survivors of Jerrold H. Paskins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

518

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 520 of 978

Jerrold H. Paskins was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2808. Plaintiff Robert R. Paskins is a resident of the State of Oregon, the Child of Decedent Jerrold H. Paskins, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Jerrold H. Paskins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2809. Plaintiff Marie Passananti is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Horace Robert Passananti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Horace Robert Passananti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2810. Plaintiff Sandra Passananti is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Horace Robert Passananti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Horace Robert Passananti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2811. Plaintiff Michael Robert Passananti is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Child of Decedent Horace Robert Passananti, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Horace Robert Passananti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2812. Plaintiff Sean Robert Passananti is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Horace Robert Passananti, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Horace Robert Passananti and on behalf of all survivors of Horace Robert Passananti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Horace Robert Passananti was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

519

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 521 of 978

2813. Plaintiff Sushilaben R. Patel is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Avnish Ramanbhai Patel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Avnish Ramanbhai Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2814. Plaintiff Ramanbhas M. Patel is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Avnish Ramanbhai Patel, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Avnish Ramanbhai Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2815. Plaintiff Yogesh R. Patel is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Avnish Ramanbhai Patel, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Avnish Ramanbhai Patel and on behalf of all survivors of Avnish Ramanbhai Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Avnish Ramanbhai Patel was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2816. Plaintiff Kapila Jayant Patel is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Dipti Patel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Dipti Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2817. Plaintiff Vibhuti Patel is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Dipti Patel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dipti Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2818. Plaintiff Nimisha Patel is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Dipti Patel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dipti Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

520

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 522 of 978

2819. Plaintiff Jayant R. Patel is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Dipti Patel, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dipti Patel and on behalf of all survivors of Dipti Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dipti Patel was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2820. Plaintiff Rantik Patel is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Dipti Patel, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Dipti Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2821. Plaintiff Niraj Patel is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Dipti Patel, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Dipti Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2822. Plaintiff Sakae Takushima is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Manish Patel, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Manish Patel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2823. Plaintiff Lois Paterson Gallo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Steven Bennett Paterson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Steven Bennett Paterson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2824. Plaintiff Lisa Paterson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Steven Bennett Paterson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Bennett Paterson and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Bennett Paterson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

521

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 523 of 978

herein. Steven Bennett Paterson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2825. Plaintiff George Paterson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Steven Bennett Paterson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Steven Bennett Paterson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2826. Plaintiff Joseph J. Paterson is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Sibling of Decedent Steven Bennett Paterson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Steven Bennett Paterson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2827. Plaintiff Barbara A. Patrick is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent James Matthew Patrick, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of James Matthew Patrick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2828. Plaintiff Kathryn M. Patrick is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Matthew Patrick, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Matthew Patrick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2829. Plaintiff Alicia M. Patrick is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Matthew Patrick, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Matthew Patrick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

522

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 524 of 978

2830. Plaintiff Jerry Gale Patrick is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent James Matthew Patrick, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of James Matthew Patrick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2831. Plaintiff Kevin M. Patrick is a resident of the State of Vermont, the Sibling of Decedent James Matthew Patrick, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James Matthew Patrick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2832. Plaintiff Frances Patti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Cira Marie Patti, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Cira Marie Patti and on behalf of all survivors of Cira Marie Patti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cira Marie Patti was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2833. Plaintiff Juliann Patti-Andolpho is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Cira Marie Patti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Cira Marie Patti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2834. Plaintiff Michael Patti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Cira Marie Patti, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Cira Marie Patti and on behalf of all survivors of Cira Marie Patti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cira Marie Patti was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

523

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 525 of 978

2835. Plaintiff Richard P. Patti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Cira Marie Patti, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Cira Marie Patti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2836. Plaintiff Michael Patti, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Cira Marie Patti, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Cira Marie Patti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2837. Plaintiff Bobbie Catherine Peak, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Indiana, and the Parent of Decedent Stacey Lynn Peak; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2838. The Represenative of the Estate of Stacey Lynn Peak, Decedent, brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Stacey Lynn Peak and on behalf of all survivors of Stacey Lynn Peak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stacey Lynn Peak was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2839. Plaintiff Toni Peak is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Sibling of Decedent Stacey Lynn Peak, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stacey Lynn Peak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2840. Plaintiff Judy Peak Rhodes is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Sibling of Decedent Stacey Lynn Peak, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stacey Lynn Peak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2841. Plaintiff Phillip Peak is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Stacey Lynn Peak, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stacey Lynn Peak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

524

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 526 of 978

2842. Plaintiff Michael R. Peak is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Sibling of Decedent Stacey Lynn Peak, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stacey Lynn Peak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2843. Plaintiff Natalee Moore is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Pecorelli, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Pecorelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2844. Plaintiff Kia Polyxena Pavloff is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas Pecorelli, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Pecorelli and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Pecorelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Pecorelli was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2845. Plaintiff Nancy N. Pedicini, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Thomas Pedicini; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2846. Plaintiff June Coppola is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Pedicini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Pedicini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2847. Plaintiff Anne Pedicini is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Pedicini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Pedicini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

525

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 527 of 978

2848. Plaintiff Pamela Morace is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Pedicini, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Pedicini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Pedicini was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001." 2849. Plaintiff Albert Pedicini, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Thomas Pedicini; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2850. Plaintiff Michele T. Pena is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Angel R. Pena, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angel R. Pena and on behalf of all survivors of Angel R. Pena and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Angel R. Pena was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2851. Plaintiff Cielita Peralta is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Carl Allen Peralta, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carl Allen Peralta and on behalf of all survivors of Carl Allen Peralta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carl Allen Peralta was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

526

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 528 of 978

2852. Plaintiff Oscar Figueroa Peralta is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Carl Allen Peralta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Carl Allen Peralta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2853. Plaintiff Lucia Perconti, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Jon A. Perconti; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2854. Plaintiff Tammy Perconti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Jon A. Perconti, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jon A. Perconti and on behalf of all survivors of Jon A. Perconti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jon A. Perconti was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2855. Plaintiff Carmen Rodriguez is a resident of the State of Puerto Rico, the Parent of Decedent Angel Perez, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angel Perez, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Angel Perez, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Angel Perez, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2856. Plaintiff Mariela Flores is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Angel Perez, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Angel Perez, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

527

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 529 of 978

2857. Plaintiff Ramon Rodriguez is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Angel Perez, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Angel Perez, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2858. Plaintiff Shawn Bittner is a resident of the State of New York, the Not Related of Decedent Angela Susan Perez, and brings this action on his own behalf as Not Related and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angela Susan Perez and on behalf of all survivors of Angela Susan Perez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Angela Susan Perez was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2859. Plaintiff Patricia J. Perry is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Parent of Decedent John William Perry, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John William Perry and on behalf of all survivors of John William Perry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John William Perry was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2860. Plaintiff Janice Lynn Montoya is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Sibling of Decedent John William Perry, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John William Perry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2861. Plaintiff Joel R. Perry is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John William Perry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John William Perry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2862. Plaintiff Chiara Pesce is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Danny Pesce, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-

528

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 530 of 978

Administrator of the Estate of Danny Pesce and on behalf of all survivors of Danny Pesce and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Danny Pesce was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2863. Plaintiff Angela Frunzi is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Danny Pesce, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Danny Pesce and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2864. Plaintiff Paul Pesce is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Danny Pesce, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Danny Pesce and on behalf of all survivors of Danny Pesce and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Danny Pesce was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2865. Plaintiff Frank Pesce is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Danny Pesce, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Danny Pesce and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2866. Plaintiff Anne Marie Pescherine is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Michael John Pescherine, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael John Pescherine and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2867. Plaintiff Nancy Gionco is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Michael John Pescherine, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

529

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 531 of 978

Michael John Pescherine and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2868. Plaintiff Lynn Pescherine is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Michael John Pescherine, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael John Pescherine and on behalf of all survivors of Michael John Pescherine and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael John Pescherine was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2869. Plaintiff William Kevin Pescherine is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Michael John Pescherine, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael John Pescherine and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2870. Plaintiff Thomas F. Pescherine, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Michael John Pescherine; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2871. Plaintiff DOE 16 is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 16, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2872. Plaintiff DOE 16 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 16, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

530

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 532 of 978

2873. Plaintiff Dawn Peterson is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Davin N. Peterson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Davin N. Peterson and on behalf of all survivors of Davin N. Peterson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Davin N. Peterson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2874. Plaintiff Norman Peterson, now deceased, was a resident of the State of California, and the Parent of Decedent Davin N. Peterson; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2875. Plaintiff DOE 16 is a resident of the California, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 16, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2876. Plaintiff Charles R. Peterson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Donald A. Peterson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Donald A. Peterson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2877. Plaintiff D. Hamilton Peterson is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of Decedent Donald A. Peterson, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Donald A. Peterson and on behalf of all survivors of Donald A. Peterson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald A. Peterson was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

531

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 533 of 978

2878. Plaintiff Virginia Ann Petrocelli is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Mark James Petrocelli, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Mark James Petrocelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2879. Plaintiff Nicole Petrocelli is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Mark James Petrocelli, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark James Petrocelli and on behalf of all survivors of Mark James Petrocelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark James Petrocelli was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2880. Plaintiff Albert Peter Petrocelli, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Mark James Petrocelli, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark James Petrocelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2881. Plaintiff Albert Peter Petrocelli, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Mark James Petrocelli, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Mark James Petrocelli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2882. Plaintiff Catherine Petti is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Philip S. Petti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Philip S. Petti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2883. Plaintiff Jacqueline Lee Butt is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Philip S. Petti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Philip S. Petti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

532

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 534 of 978

2884. Plaintiff Adrian Lee Foran is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Philip S. Petti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Philip S. Petti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2885. Plaintiff Eileen R. Petti is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Philip S. Petti, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Philip S. Petti and on behalf of all survivors of Philip S. Petti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip S. Petti was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2886. Plaintiff Antimo Petti, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Philip S. Petti; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2887. Plaintiff Thomas Daniel Petti is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Philip S. Petti, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Philip S. Petti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2888. Plaintiff Susan L. Picarro is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Ludwig John Picarro, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ludwig John Picarro and on behalf of all survivors of Ludwig John Picarro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ludwig John Picarro was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2889. Plaintiff Petrina M. Picerno is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Matthew M. Picerno, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

533

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 535 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew M. Picerno and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew M. Picerno and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew M. Picerno was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2890. Plaintiff Marie E. Puccio-Pick is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Pick, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Pick and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Pick and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Pick was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2891. Plaintiff Patricia Marie Pietronico is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Bernard Pietronico, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Bernard Pietronico and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2892. Plaintiff Patricia Keelan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Bernard Pietronico, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Bernard Pietronico and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2893. Plaintiff Jacqueline Pietronico is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Bernard Pietronico, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bernard Pietronico and on behalf of all survivors of Bernard Pietronico and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bernard Pietronico was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

534

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 536 of 978

2894. Plaintiff Michael Pietronico is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Bernard Pietronico, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Bernard Pietronico and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2895. Plaintiff Janet Ciaramello is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Nicholas P. Pietrunti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Nicholas P. Pietrunti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2896. Plaintiff John J. Pietrunti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Nicholas P. Pietrunti, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Nicholas P. Pietrunti and on behalf of all survivors of Nicholas P. Pietrunti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nicholas P. Pietrunti was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2897. Plaintiff Dorothy Ancona is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Susan Pinto, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Susan Pinto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2898. Plaintiff Barbara Gray is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Susan Pinto, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Susan Pinto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2899. Plaintiff Douglas Pinto is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Susan Pinto, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Pinto and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Pinto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susan Pinto was killed at

535

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 537 of 978

One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2900. Plaintiff Virginia Martha Dominguez is a resident of Australia, the Child of Decedent Alberto Dominguez Piriz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Alberto Dominguez Piriz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2901. Plaintiff Maria Reina Dominguez Piriz is a resident of Uruguay, the Sibling of Decedent Alberto Dominguez Piriz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alberto Dominguez Piriz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2902. Plaintiff Martha Isabel Dominguez is a resident of Australia, the Spouse of Decedent Alberto Dominguez Piriz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alberto Dominguez Piriz and on behalf of all survivors of Alberto Dominguez Piriz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alberto Dominguez Piriz was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2903. Plaintiff Diego Dominguez is a resident of Australia, the Child of Decedent Alberto Dominguez Piriz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alberto Dominguez Piriz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2904. Plaintiff Alvaro Dominguez is a resident of Australia, the Child of Decedent Alberto Dominguez Piriz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alberto Dominguez Piriz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

536

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 538 of 978

2905. Plaintiff Alberto Dominguez is a resident of Australia, the Child of Decedent Alberto Dominguez Piriz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alberto Dominguez Piriz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2906. Plaintiff Carlos Dominguez Perez is a resident of Uruguay, the Sibling of Decedent Alberto Dominguez Piriz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Alberto Dominguez Piriz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2907. Plaintiff Laura Marie Piskadlo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Joseph Piskadlo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Joseph Piskadlo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2908. Plaintiff Rosemary Piskadlo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Piskadlo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Piskadlo and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Piskadlo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Piskadlo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2909. Plaintiff Brian Joseph Piskadlo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Joseph Piskadlo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Joseph Piskadlo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2910. Plaintiff Steven John Piskadlo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Joseph Piskadlo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Joseph Piskadlo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

537

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 539 of 978

2911. Plaintiff Eric J. Pitman is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Todd Pitman, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Todd Pitman and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Todd Pitman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Todd Pitman was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2912. Plaintiff Susan Piver is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Joshua Michael Piver, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joshua Michael Piver and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua Michael Piver and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joshua Michael Piver was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2913. Plaintiff Doreen Plumitallo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Plumitallo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Plumitallo and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Plumitallo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Plumitallo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2914. Plaintiff Laura A. Grygotis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent John M. Pocher, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John M. Pocher and on behalf of all survivors of John M. Pocher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John M.

538

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 540 of 978

Pocher was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2915. Plaintiff Bernard Polatsch is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Laurence Michael Polatsch, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Laurence Michael Polatsch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2916. Plaintiff Olga L. Polhemus, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Thomas H. Polhemus; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2917. Plaintiff Jane Lynn Skrzyniarz is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas H. Polhemus, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas H. Polhemus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2918. Plaintiff Dorothy Gail McGrath is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas H. Polhemus, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas H. Polhemus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2919. Plaintiff Barbara L. Polhemus is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas H. Polhemus, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Administrator of the Estate of Thomas H. Polhemus and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas H. Polhemus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas H. Polhemus was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

539

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 541 of 978

2920. Plaintiff Harold Lowe Polhemus is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Thomas H. Polhemus, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Thomas H. Polhemus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2921. Plaintiff Phyllis Pollio, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Susan M. Pollio; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. The Representative of the Estate of Susan M. Pollio brings this action on behalf of all survivors of Susan M. Pollio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susan M. Pollio was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001." 2922. Plaintiff Sandra Gonzales is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Susan M. Pollio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Susan M. Pollio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2923. Plaintiff Joyce Oxley is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Susan M. Pollio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Susan M. Pollio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2924. Plaintiff Devora Wolk Pontell is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of Decedent Darin Howard Pontell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Administrator of the Estate of Darin Howard Pontell and on behalf of all survivors of Darin Howard Pontell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Darin Howard Pontell was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

540

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 542 of 978

2925. Plaintiff Vasile Poptean is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joshua I. Poptean, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joshua I. Poptean and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua I. Poptean and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joshua I. Poptean was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2926. Plaintiff Nikki L. Stern is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent James E. Portorti, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James E. Portorti and on behalf of all survivors of James E. Portorti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James E. Portorti was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2927. Plaintiff Lisa Sarni is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Richard N. Poulos, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Richard N. Poulos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2928. Plaintiff Margaret Poulos is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Richard N. Poulos, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard N. Poulos and on behalf of all survivors of Richard N. Poulos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard N. Poulos was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

541

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 543 of 978

2929. Plaintiff Erin Poulos is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Richard N. Poulos, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Richard N. Poulos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2930. Plaintiff Richard J. Poulos is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Richard N. Poulos, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Richard N. Poulos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2931. Plaintiff Norma L. Powell is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Brandon J. Powell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Brandon J. Powell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2932. Plaintiff Harry J. Powell is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Brandon J. Powell, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brandon J. Powell and on behalf of all survivors of Brandon J. Powell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brandon J. Powell was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2933. Plaintiff Catherine Powell is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Parent of Decedent Scott Allen Powell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Allen Powell and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Allen Powell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Allen Powell was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

542

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 544 of 978

2934. Plaintiff Asmareli Sago, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Domestic Partner of Decedent Antonio Pratt; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2935. Plaintiff Dolores Alba Preziose is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Gregory M. Preziose, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gregory M. Preziose and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2936. Plaintiff Lori A. Preziose is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Gregory M. Preziose, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory M. Preziose and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory M. Preziose and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory M. Preziose was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2937. Plaintiff Alexander Preziose, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Gregory M. Preziose; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2938. Plaintiff Christopher Paul Preziose is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Gregory M. Preziose, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gregory M. Preziose and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2939. Plaintiff John Michael Preziose is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Gregory M. Preziose, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gregory M. Preziose and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

543

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 545 of 978

2940. Plaintiff James Alexander Preziose is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Gregory M. Preziose, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Gregory M. Preziose and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2941. Plaintiff Edward Prince is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Wanda Prince, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wanda Prince and on behalf of all survivors of Wanda Prince and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wanda Prince was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2942. Plaintiff Marian A. Prior is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kevin M. Prior, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kevin M. Prior and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2943. Plaintiff Gerard J. Prior is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kevin M. Prior, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kevin M. Prior and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin M. Prior and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin M. Prior was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2944. Plaintiff Catherine B. Proctor, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Massachusetts, and the Parent of Decedent Everett M. Proctor, III; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

544

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 546 of 978

2945. Plaintiff Mary E. Griffin is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Everett M. Proctor, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Everett M. Proctor, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2946. Plaintiff Everett Proctor, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of Massachusetts, and the Parent of Decedent Everett M. Proctor, III; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. The Representative of the Estate of Everett M. Proctor, III brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Everett M. Proctor, III and on behalf of all survivors of Everett M. Proctor and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Everett M. Proctor, III was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2947. Plaintiff Kathleen A. Progen is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Carrie Beth Progen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Carrie Beth Progen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2948. Plaintiff Donald H. Progen is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Carrie Beth Progen, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carrie Beth Progen and on behalf of all survivors of Carrie Beth Progen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carrie Beth Progen was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2949. Plaintiff Matthew Eric Progen is a resident of the State of Vermont, the Sibling of Decedent Carrie Beth Progen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Carrie Beth Progen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

545

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 547 of 978

2950. Plaintiff Kathryn S. Pruim is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent David L. Pruim, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David L. Pruim and on behalf of all survivors of David L. Pruim and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David L. Pruim was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2951. Plaintiff DOE 42 is a resident of the New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 42, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2952. Plaintiff DOE 42 is a resident of the state of New York, the Child of Decedent DOE 42, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 42 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 42 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 42 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2953. Plaintiff Melissa Pullis is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Edward Frank Pullis, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Frank Pullis and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Frank Pullis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Frank Pullis was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

546

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 548 of 978

2954. Plaintiff Eleanor Wilson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Patricia Ann Puma, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patricia Ann Puma and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2955. Plaintiff Antoinette Nicholasi is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Patricia Ann Puma, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patricia Ann Puma and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2956. Plaintiff William Wilson, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Patricia Ann Puma; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2957. Plaintiff Robert Wilson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patricia Ann Puma, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patricia Ann Puma and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2958. Plaintiff Kevin Puma is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Patricia Ann Puma, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patricia Ann Puma and on behalf of all survivors of Patricia Ann Puma and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patricia Ann Puma was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2959. Plaintiff Dominic J. Puopolo, Jr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Sonia Morales Puopolo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Sonia Morales Puopolo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2960. Plaintiff DOE 45 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 45, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of

547

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 549 of 978

DOE 45 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 45 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 45 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2961. Plaintiff DOE 45, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 45; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2962. Plaintiff DOE 45 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 45, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2963. Plaintiff Gail Quackenbush is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Quackenbush, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Quackenbush and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2964. Plaintiff Michael Allen Quackenbush is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Quackenbush, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher Quackenbush and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2965. Plaintiff James Dunne, III is a resident of the State of New York, the Not Related of Decedent Christopher Quackenbush, and brings this action on his own behalf as Not Related and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Quackenbush and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Quackenbush and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action

548

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 550 of 978

set forth herein. Christopher Quackenbush was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2966. Plaintiff Louella Jean Quigley is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Beth Ann Quigley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Beth Ann Quigley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2967. Plaintiff John Eugene Quigley is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Beth Ann Quigley, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Beth Ann Quigley and on behalf of all survivors of Beth Ann Quigley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Beth Ann Quigley was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2968. Plaintiff Mija Quigley is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Patrick J Quigley, IV, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patrick J Quigley, IV and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2969. Plaintiff Ruth Quigley-Lawrence is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick J Quigley, IV, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick J Quigley, IV and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2970. Plaintiff John V. Quigley is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick J Quigley, IV, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick J Quigley, IV and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

549

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 551 of 978

2971. Plaintiff Patrick J. Quigley, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Patrick J Quigley, IV; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2972. Plaintiff Anna Maria Morales is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Ricardo J. Quinn, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Ricardo J. Quinn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2973. Plaintiff Virginia A. Quinn is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Ricardo J. Quinn, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ricardo J. Quinn and on behalf of all survivors of Ricardo J. Quinn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ricardo J. Quinn was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2974. Plaintiff Nicholas Monaco, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Child of Decedent Ricardo J. Quinn; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2975. Plaintiff Adam Quinn is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Ricardo J. Quinn, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Ricardo J. Quinn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2976. Plaintiff Gregory Vincent Quinn is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Ricardo J. Quinn, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ricardo J. Quinn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

550

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 552 of 978

2977. Plaintiff Bernard J. Quinn is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Ricardo J. Quinn, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Ricardo J. Quinn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2978. Plaintiff Sandra L. Racaniello is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Anthony Peter Racaniello, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Christopher Anthony Peter Racaniello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2979. Plaintiff Frank V. Racaniello is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Anthony Peter Racaniello, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Anthony Peter Racaniello and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Anthony Peter Racaniello and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Anthony Peter Racaniello was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2980. Plaintiff Edward Radburn is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Betty Browne Radburn, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Betty Browne Radburn and on behalf of all survivors of Betty Browne Radburn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Betty Browne Radburn was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2981. Plaintiff Maureen Frances Ragaglia is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

551

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 553 of 978

2982. Plaintiff Colleen Ragaglia is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2983. Plaintiff Debra Ann Ragaglia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2984. Plaintiff Janice Pucciarelli is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2985. Plaintiff Lauren Pietrina LaCapria is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2986. Plaintiff Christine Teresa Durante is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2987. Plaintiff Linda Marie Taccetta is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2988. Plaintiff Maureen Elizabeth Scparta is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2989. Plaintiff Donna Ragaglia is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

552

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 554 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Leonard J. Ragaglia and on behalf of all survivors of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Leonard J. Ragaglia was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2990. Plaintiff Leonard Salvatore Ragaglia is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2991. Plaintiff Paul Joseph Ragaglia is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2992. Plaintiff Danny Ragaglia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2993. Plaintiff Stephen Anthony Ragaglia is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Leonard J. Ragaglia, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Leonard J. Ragaglia and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2994. Plaintiff Domenica Ragusa is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Paul Ragusa, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Paul Ragusa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2995. Plaintiff Christine Saladeen is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Paul Ragusa, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Paul Ragusa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

553

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 555 of 978

2996. Plaintiff Vincent Joseph Ragusa is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Paul Ragusa, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Paul Ragusa and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Paul Ragusa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Paul Ragusa was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 2997. Plaintiff Vincent Carl Ragusa is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Paul Ragusa, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Paul Ragusa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2998. Plaintiff Kenneth Ragusa is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Paul Ragusa, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Paul Ragusa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 2999. Plaintiff Lenore Raimondi is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Peter F. Raimondi, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter F. Raimondi and on behalf of all survivors of Peter F. Raimondi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter F. Raimondi was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3000. Plaintiff Lauren Christine Raines is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Harry A. Raines, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Harry A. Raines and on behalf of all survivors of Harry A. Raines and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Harry

554

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 556 of 978

A. Raines was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3001. Plaintiff Marilyn Raines, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Lisa Joy Raines; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3002. Plaintiff Sosamma George, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Valsa Raju; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3003. Plaintiff Ammini G. Abraham is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Valsa Raju, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Valsa Raju and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3004. Plaintiff Saramma John is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Valsa Raju, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Valsa Raju and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3005. Plaintiff Annamma Thomas is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of Decedent Valsa Raju, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Valsa Raju and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3006. Plaintiff Sosamma Mukkadan is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Valsa Raju, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Valsa Raju and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3007. Plaintiff Thankachan Raju is a resident of the State of Texas, the Spouse of Decedent Valsa Raju, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Valsa Raju and on behalf of all survivors of Valsa Raju and is

555

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 557 of 978

entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Valsa Raju was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3008. Plaintiff Joan P. Rall is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Parent of Decedent Edward J. Rall, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Edward J. Rall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3009. Plaintiff Darlene G. Rall is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Edward J. Rall, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward J. Rall and on behalf of all survivors of Edward J. Rall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward J. Rall was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3010. Plaintiff Edward A. Rall is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Parent of Decedent Edward J. Rall, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Edward J. Rall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3011. Plaintiff William F. Rall is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Edward J. Rall, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Edward J. Rall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3012. Plaintiff Keith G. Rall is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Sibling of Decedent Edward J. Rall, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Edward J. Rall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3013. Plaintiff Migdalia Ramos is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Harry Ramos, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal

556

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 558 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Harry Ramos and on behalf of all survivors of Harry Ramos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Harry Ramos was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3014. Plaintiff Jessica Bors is a resident of Canada, the Sibling of Decedent Vishnoo Ramsaroop, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Vishnoo Ramsaroop and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3015. Plaintiff Barbara B. Rancke, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Alfred Todd Rancke; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3016. Plaintiff Cynthia Rancke Bienemann is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Alfred Todd Rancke, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alfred Todd Rancke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3017. Plaintiff Barbara R. Speni is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Alfred Todd Rancke, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alfred Todd Rancke and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3018. Plaintiff Alfred E. Rancke, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Alfred Todd Rancke; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3019. Plaintiff Virginia Bladen is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Jonathan Randall, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jonathan Randall and on behalf of all survivors of

557

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 559 of 978

Jonathan Randall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jonathan Randall was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3020. Plaintiff DOE 46 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Child of Decedent DOE 46, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3021. Plaintiff DOE 46 is a resident of the state of New York, the Child of Decedent DOE 46, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 46 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 46 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 46 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3022. Plaintiff DOE 46 is a resident of the New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 46, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3023. Plaintiff Anna Rasmussen Stansbury is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Spouse of Decedent Robert A. Rasmussen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert A. Rasmussen and on behalf of all survivors of Robert A. Rasmussen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert A. Rasmussen was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

558

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 560 of 978

3024. Plaintiff Claudia Marie Stallworth is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Parent of Decedent Marsha Ratchford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Marsha Ratchford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3025. Plaintiff Cynthia Watts is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Sibling of Decedent Marsha Ratchford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Marsha Ratchford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3026. Plaintiff Angelia Stallworth Blunt is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Sibling of Decedent Marsha Ratchford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Marsha Ratchford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3027. Plaintiff Reginald Simpson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Marsha Ratchford, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Marsha Ratchford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3028. Plaintiff Rodney Ratchford is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Spouse of Decedent Marsha Ratchford, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marsha Ratchford and on behalf of all survivors of Marsha Ratchford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marsha Ratchford was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3029. Plaintiff Roosevelt Stallworth, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of Michigan, and the Parent of Decedent Marsha Ratchford; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3030. Plaintiff DOE 104 is a resident of the state of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 104, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all

559

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 561 of 978

survivors of DOE 104 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 104 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 104 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3031. Plaintiff Maureen A. Raub is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent William Ralph Raub, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Ralph Raub and on behalf of all survivors of William Ralph Raub and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Ralph Raub was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3032. Plaintiff DOE 133 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent DOE 133, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3033. Plaintiff Jane Marie Thompson is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Sarah Anne Redheffer, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sarah Anne Redheffer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3034. Plaintiff DOE 133 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent DOE 133, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3035. Plaintiff Alice Regan is a resident of New York, the Parent of Decedent Donald Regan, and brings this action on own behalf as the Parent of Donald Regan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

560

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 562 of 978

3036. Plaintiff Joseph Regan is a resident of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Donald Regan, and brings this action on own behalf as the Sibling of Donald Regan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3037. Plaintiff Margaret Regan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Donald Regan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Donald Regan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3038. Plaintiff Eileen Regan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Donald Regan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Donald Regan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3039. Plaintiff Katherine Regan Dey is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Donald Regan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Donald Regan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3040. Plaintiff Mary L. Reidy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Gregory Reidy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gregory Reidy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3041. Plaintiff Thomas Reidy is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Gregory Reidy, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory Reidy and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory Reidy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory Reidy was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

561

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 563 of 978

3042. Plaintiff Joan E. Reilly is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kevin Owen Reilly, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kevin Owen Reilly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3043. Plaintiff Regina Reilly Madigan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Kevin Owen Reilly, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin Owen Reilly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3044. Plaintiff George M. Reilly, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Kevin Owen Reilly; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3045. Plaintiff Brendan H. Reilly is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Timothy E. Reilly, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Timothy E. Reilly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3046. Plaintiff Rosemarie Reina is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Reina, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Reina, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3047. Plaintiff Joann O' Keefe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Reina, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Reina, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3048. Plaintiff Lisa Reina is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Reina, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Reina, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Reina, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

562

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 564 of 978

Joseph Reina, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3049. Plaintiff Michael Reina is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Reina, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Reina, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3050. Plaintiff Joseph Reina, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Reina, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Reina, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3051. Plaintiff DOE 24 is a resident of the state of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 24, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 24 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 24 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 24 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3052. Plaintiff DOE 24 is a resident of the California, the Child of Decedent DOE 24, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3053. Plaintiff DOE 24 is a resident of the Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent DOE 24, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3054. Plaintiff Gayle Reisman is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Frank Reisman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank Reisman and on behalf of all survivors of Frank Reisman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Reisman was

563

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 565 of 978

killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3055. Plaintiff Judith Jackson Reiss is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent Joshua Scott Reiss, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joshua Scott Reiss and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3056. Plaintiff Daniel Renda is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Karen Renda, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Karen Renda and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3057. Plaintiff Charles Renda is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Karen Renda, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karen Renda and on behalf of all survivors of Karen Renda and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karen Renda was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3058. Plaintiff Christina Resta is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent John Thomas Resta, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Thomas Resta and on behalf of all survivors of John Thomas Resta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Thomas Resta was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3059. Plaintiff Dawn Angrisani is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John Thomas Resta, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Thomas Resta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

564

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 566 of 978

3060. Plaintiff Christine Mazzeo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John Thomas Resta, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Thomas Resta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3061. Plaintiff Bernard Thomas Resta is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent John Thomas Resta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John Thomas Resta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3062. Plaintiff Michael Resta is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John Thomas Resta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Thomas Resta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3063. Plaintiff Thomas Resta is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John Thomas Resta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Thomas Resta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3064. Plaintiff Jo Ann R. Riccio is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Rudolph N. Riccio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rudolph N. Riccio and on behalf of all survivors of Rudolph N. Riccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rudolph N. Riccio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3065. Plaintiff Maria Elena Santorelli is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Ann Marie Riccoboni, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ann Marie Riccoboni and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

565

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 567 of 978

3066. Plaintiff Janine Passelis is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Ann Marie Riccoboni, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Ann Marie Riccoboni and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3067. Plaintiff John Riccoboni is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Ann Marie Riccoboni, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ann Marie Riccoboni and on behalf of all survivors of Ann Marie Riccoboni and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ann Marie Riccoboni was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3068. Plaintiff Cynthia J. Rice is a resident of the State of Oklahoma, the Parent of Decedent David H. Rice, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of David H. Rice and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3069. Plaintiff Hugh David Rice is a resident of the State of Oklahoma, the Parent of Decedent David H. Rice, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David H. Rice and on behalf of all survivors of David H. Rice and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David H. Rice was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3070. Plaintiff DOE 102 is a resident of the Tennessee, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 102, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

566

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 568 of 978

3071. Plaintiff DOE 102 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 102, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3072. Plaintiff DOE 102 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 102, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3073. Plaintiff DOE 102 is a resident of the Tennessee, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 102, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3074. Plaintiff DOE 102 is a resident of the state of New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 102, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 102 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 102 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 102 was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3075. Plaintiff Paula A. Rigo is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of Decedent John Matthews Rigo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Matthews Rigo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3076. Plaintiff Theodore P. Rigo is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Sibling of Decedent John Matthews Rigo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Matthews Rigo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

567

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 569 of 978

3077. Plaintiff Julia Rivas is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Moises Rivas, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Moises Rivas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3078. Plaintiff Nancy Elizabeth Rivas Molina is a resident of Ecuador, the Sibling of Decedent Moises Rivas, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Moises Rivas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3079. Plaintiff Carmen Rivera is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Isaias Rivera, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Isaias Rivera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3080. Plaintiff Gloria Gonzalez is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Isaias Rivera, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Isaias Rivera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3081. Plaintiff Nilsa Milagros Rivera is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Isaias Rivera, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Isaias Rivera and on behalf of all survivors of Isaias Rivera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Isaias Rivera was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3082. Plaintiff Adrian Isaac Rivera is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Isaias Rivera, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Isaias Rivera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

568

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 570 of 978

3083. Plaintiff Josue Rivera Trujillo is a resident of the State of Puerto Rico, the Sibling of Decedent Isaias Rivera, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Isaias Rivera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3084. Plaintiff Moises Rivera is a resident of the State of Puerto Rico, the Sibling of Decedent Isaias Rivera, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Isaias Rivera and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3085. Plaintiff Teresa Riverso is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph R. Riverso, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph R. Riverso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3086. Plaintiff Maria Riverso is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph R. Riverso, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph R. Riverso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3087. Plaintiff Domenico Riverso is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph R. Riverso, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Joseph R. Riverso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3088. Plaintiff Ralph J. Riverso is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph R. Riverso, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph R. Riverso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3089. Plaintiff William D. Riverso is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph R. Riverso, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph R. Riverso and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

569

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 571 of 978

3090. Plaintiff Vivian Rizza is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Paul V. Rizza, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Paul V. Rizza and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3091. Plaintiff Elaine M. Rizza is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Paul V. Rizza, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul V. Rizza and on behalf of all survivors of Paul V. Rizza and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul V. Rizza was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3092. Plaintiff Paul Rizza is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Paul V. Rizza, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Paul V. Rizza and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3093. Plaintiff Concetta Rizzo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent John Rizzo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Rizzo and on behalf of all survivors of John Rizzo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Rizzo was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3094. Plaintiff Lucy Roberto is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Roberto, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Roberto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

570

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 572 of 978

3095. Plaintiff Lorraine Caiazzo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Roberto, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Roberto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3096. Plaintiff Robert Roberto, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Roberto, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Roberto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3097. Plaintiff Robert Roberto, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Roberto, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Roberto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3098. Plaintiff Debra Roberts is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Leo A. Roberts, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Leo A. Roberts and on behalf of all survivors of Leo A. Roberts and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Leo A. Roberts was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3099. Plaintiff Paulette Roberts is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael E. Roberts, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Michael E. Roberts and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. Roberts and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael E. Roberts was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3100. Plaintiff Thomas Roberts is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael E. Roberts, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-

571

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 573 of 978

Administrator of the Estate of Michael E. Roberts and on behalf of all survivors of Michael E. Roberts and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael E. Roberts was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3101. Plaintiff Veronica M. Roberts is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Edward Roberts, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Edward Roberts and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3102. Plaintiff Karen E. Roberts is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Edward Roberts, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Edward Roberts and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3103. Plaintiff John J. Roberts is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Edward Roberts, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Edward Roberts and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Edward Roberts and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Edward Roberts was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3104. Plaintiff Marcee E. Robertson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Donald W. Robertson, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Donald W. Robertson, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

572

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 574 of 978

3105. Plaintiff Kathleen Robertson Cunningham is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Donald W. Robertson, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Donald W. Robertson, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3106. Plaintiff Elizabeth Robertson is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Donald W. Robertson, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Donald W. Robertson, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3107. Plaintiff Donald W. Robertson, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Donald W. Robertson, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Donald W. Robertson, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3108. Plaintiff William H. Robotham, III is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Spouse of Decedent Michell L. Robotham, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Spouse of Michell L. Robotham and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3109. Plaintiff Marilyn Rocha is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Antonio Rocha, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Antonio Rocha and on behalf of all survivors of Antonio Rocha and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Antonio Rocha was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

573

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 575 of 978

3110. Plaintiff Regina E. Rodak is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent John Rodak, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John Rodak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3111. Plaintiff Joanne Rodak Gori is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent John Rodak, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Rodak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3112. Plaintiff Joyce Ann Marie Rodak is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent John Rodak, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Rodak and on behalf of all survivors of John Rodak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Rodak was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3113. Plaintiff John J. Rodak is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent John Rodak, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John Rodak and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3114. Plaintiff Sara Rodrigues is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Antonio J. Rodrigues, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Antonio J. Rodrigues and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3115. Plaintiff Cristina Rodrigues is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Antonio J. Rodrigues, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Antonio J. Rodrigues and on behalf of all survivors of Antonio J. Rodrigues and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

574

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 576 of 978

Antonio J. Rodrigues was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3116. Plaintiff Deivi Rodriguez is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent David Bartolo Rodriguez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of David Bartolo Rodriguez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3117. Plaintiff Lenny Rodriguez is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent David Bartolo Rodriguez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of David Bartolo Rodriguez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3118. Plaintiff Melania Gil is a resident of the State of New York, the Other of Decedent David Bartolo Rodriguez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Other of David Bartolo Rodriguez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3119. Plaintiff DOE 98 is a resident of the New Hampshire, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 98, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3120. Plaintiff Elizabeth A. Soudant is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Gregory E. Rodriguez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory E. Rodriguez and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory E. Rodriguez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory E. Rodriguez was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

575

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 577 of 978

3121. Plaintiff Cindy Rodriguez is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Richard Rodriguez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Rodriguez and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Rodriguez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Rodriguez was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3122. Plaintiff Marian Rogan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Matthew Sean Rogan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Matthew Sean Rogan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3123. Plaintiff John Rogan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Matthew Sean Rogan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Matthew Sean Rogan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3124. Plaintiff DOE 133 is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 133, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3125. Plaintiff DOE 133 is a resident of the state of New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 133, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 133 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 133 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 133 was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

576

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 578 of 978

3126. Plaintiff DOE 133 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 133, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3127. Plaintiff DOE 140 is a resident of Northern Ireland, the Parent of Decedent DOE 140, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 140 and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 140 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 140 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3128. Plaintiff DOE 140 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 140, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3129. Plaintiff DOE 140 is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent DOE 140, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 140 and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of DOE 140 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 140 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3130. Plaintiff Kristen Nepola is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Scott W. Rohner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Scott W. Rohner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3131. Plaintiff Katie A. Rohner is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Scott W. Rohner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Scott W. Rohner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

577

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 579 of 978

3132. Plaintiff Thomas G. Rohner is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Scott W. Rohner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Scott W. Rohner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3133. Plaintiff Stephen J. Rohner is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Scott W. Rohner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Scott W. Rohner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3134. Plaintiff Michael R. Rohner is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Scott W. Rohner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Scott W. Rohner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3135. Plaintiff Rosemary Roma is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Keith Roma, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Keith Roma and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3136. Plaintiff Maureen Roma is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Keith Roma, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Keith Roma and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3137. Plaintiff Arnold Roma is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Keith Roma, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Keith Roma and on behalf of all survivors of Keith Roma and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Keith Roma was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

578

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 580 of 978

3138. Plaintiff Kevin Roma is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Keith Roma, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Keith Roma and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3139. Plaintiff Diane Romero is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Elvin Romero, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Elvin Romero and on behalf of all survivors of Elvin Romero and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Elvin Romero was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3140. The Representative of the Estate of Sean Rooney brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Sean Rooney and on behalf of all survivors of Sean Rooney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean Rooney was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. Plaintiff Beverly Eckert, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Connecticut, and the Parent of Decedent Sean Rooney; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3141. Plaintiff Patricia Rosen is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Mark H. Rosen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark H. Rosen and on behalf of all survivors of Mark H. Rosen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark H. Rosen was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

579

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 581 of 978

3142. Plaintiff Bobbi Rosner is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Sheryl Rosenbaum, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Sheryl Rosenbaum and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3143. Plaintiff Barry Rosner is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Sheryl Rosenbaum, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Sheryl Rosenbaum and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3144. Plaintiff Susan S. Rosenblum is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Joshua Rosenblum, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Joshua Rosenblum and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua Rosenblum and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joshua Rosenblum was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3145. Plaintiff Richard M. Rosenblum, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Joshua Rosenblum; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3146. Plaintiff Dean Rosenblum is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joshua Rosenblum, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joshua Rosenblum and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3147. Plaintiff Marilynn M. Rosenthal, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Michigan, and the Parent of Decedent Joshua Alan Rosenthal; the Representative of her Estate, Helen Rosenthal, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

580

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 582 of 978

3148. Plaintiff Helen Rosenthal is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joshua Alan Rosenthal, and brings this action on own behalf as the Sibling of Joshua Alan Rosenthal and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3149. Plaintiff Avram Rosenthal is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Parent of Decedent Joshua Alan Rosenthal, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Joshua Alan Rosenthal and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua Alan Rosenthal and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joshua Alan Rosenthal was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3150. Plaintiff Loren Rosenthal is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Richard Rosenthal, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Rosenthal and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Rosenthal and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Rosenthal was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3151. Plaintiff Shirley Ann Rosetti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Daniel James Rosetti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Daniel James Rosetti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3152. Plaintiff Darlene Rosetti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel James Rosetti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel James Rosetti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

581

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 583 of 978

3153. Plaintiff Cheryl Rosetti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel James Rosetti, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel James Rosetti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3154. Plaintiff Rick Rosetti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel James Rosetti, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel James Rosetti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3155. Plaintiff Robert J. Rosetti, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel James Rosetti, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel James Rosetti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3156. Plaintiff Donna Mattera is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Nicholas P. Rossomando, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Nicholas P. Rossomando and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3157. Plaintiff Peter A. Rossomando, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Nicholas P. Rossomando; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3158. Plaintiff Christopher Rossomando is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Nicholas P. Rossomando, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Nicholas P. Rossomando and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3159. Plaintiff Peter Charles Rossomando is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Nicholas P. Rossomando, and brings this action on his own behalf as the

582

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 584 of 978

Sibling of Nicholas P. Rossomando and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3160. Plaintiff Iris E. Rothberg is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Michael C. Rothberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael C. Rothberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3161. Plaintiff Rhonda B. Rothberg is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Michael C. Rothberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael C. Rothberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3162. Plaintiff Jason Rothberg is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Michael C. Rothberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael C. Rothberg and on behalf of all survivors of Michael C. Rothberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael C. Rothberg was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3163. Plaintiff Meredith H. Rothenberg is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Mark D. Rothenberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark D. Rothenberg and on behalf of all survivors of Mark D. Rothenberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark D. Rothenberg was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

583

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 585 of 978

3164. Plaintiff Nancy Kelly is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, and brings this action on behalf of minor children P.R. and J.R. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3165. Plaintiff Alexander William Rowe is a resident of South Africa, the Parent of Decedent Nicholas Charles Alexander Rowe, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Nicholas Charles Alexander Rowe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3166. Plaintiff Maureen Murphy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent David Michael Ruddle, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of David Michael Ruddle and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3167. Plaintiff Fern Ruhalter is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Adam K. Ruhalter, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Adam K. Ruhalter and on behalf of all survivors of Adam K. Ruhalter and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Adam K. Ruhalter was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3168. Plaintiff Marie Russell is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Stephen P. Russell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen P. Russell and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen P. Russell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen P. Russell was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

584

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 586 of 978

3169. Plaintiff William Russell is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen P. Russell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen P. Russell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3170. Plaintiff Clifford S. Russell, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen P. Russell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen P. Russell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3171. Plaintiff Clifford Russell, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Stephen P. Russell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Stephen P. Russell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3172. Plaintiff Gloria Russin is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Steven Harris Russin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Steven Harris Russin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3173. Plaintiff Edward Russin is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Steven Harris Russin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Steven Harris Russin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3174. Plaintiff Barry Russin is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Steven Harris Russin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Steven Harris Russin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3175. Plaintiff Arlene Russo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Wayne A. Russo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Wayne A. Russo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3176. Plaintiff Arthur Russo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Wayne A. Russo, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the

585

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 587 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Wayne A. Russo and on behalf of all survivors of Wayne A. Russo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wayne A. Russo was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3177. Plaintiff Colleen Ryan, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Sibling of Decedent John Joseph Ryan, Jr.; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3178. Plaintiff Mary V. Ryan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent John Joseph Ryan, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John Joseph Ryan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3179. Plaintiff Aileen Anne Ryan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John Joseph Ryan, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Joseph Ryan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3180. Plaintiff Patrick Ryan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John Joseph Ryan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Joseph Ryan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3181. Plaintiff Teague M. Ryan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John Joseph Ryan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Joseph Ryan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3182. Plaintiff John Joseph Ryan, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent John Joseph Ryan, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John Joseph Ryan, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

586

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 588 of 978

3183. Plaintiff Martine Saada is a resident of France, the Parent of Decedent Thierry Saada, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thierry Saada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3184. Plaintiff Cindy Saada is a resident of France, the Sibling of Decedent Thierry Saada, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thierry Saada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3185. Plaintiff Jean Marc Saada is a resident of France, the Parent of Decedent Thierry Saada, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Thierry Saada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3186. Plaintiff Rudy Saada is a resident of France, the Sibling of Decedent Thierry Saada, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thierry Saada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3187. Plaintiff Rohy Saada is a resident of France, the Sibling of Decedent Thierry Saada, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thierry Saada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3188. Plaintiff Anthony Saada is a resident of France, the Sibling of Decedent Thierry Saada, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thierry Saada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3189. Plaintiff Gary Saada is a resident of France, the Sibling of Decedent Thierry Saada, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thierry Saada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

587

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 589 of 978

3190. Plaintiff Brigitte Sabbag is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Jason Elazar Sabbag, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jason Elazar Sabbag and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3191. Plaintiff Laurence Hagan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jason Elazar Sabbag, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jason Elazar Sabbag and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3192. Plaintiff Ralph Sabbag is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Jason Elazar Sabbag, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jason Elazar Sabbag and on behalf of all survivors of Jason Elazar Sabbag and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jason Elazar Sabbag was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3193. Plaintiff Clifton Sabbag is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jason Elazar Sabbag, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jason Elazar Sabbag and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3194. Plaintiff Angelina Sabella, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Thomas E. Sabella; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3195. Plaintiff Loretta Sabella-Viglione is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas E. Sabella, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas E. Sabella and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3196. Plaintiff Diana Sabella is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas E. Sabella, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

588

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 590 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas E. Sabella and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas E. Sabella and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas E. Sabella was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3197. Plaintiff Edward Sabella, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Thomas E. Sabella; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3198. Plaintiff Charles Thomas Sabella is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas E. Sabella, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas E. Sabella and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3199. Plaintiff Elaine Saber is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Scott Saber, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Scott Saber and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3200. Plaintiff Bruce D. Saber is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Scott Saber, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Scott Saber and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Saber and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Saber was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3201. Plaintiff Brian Saber is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Scott Saber, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Scott Saber and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Saber and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Saber was killed at One

589

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 591 of 978

World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3202. Plaintiff Paul Sabin is a resident of the State of Texas, the Child of Decedent Charles E. Sabin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Charles E. Sabin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3203. Plaintiff Charles E. Sabin, Jr. is a resident of the State of Louisiana, the Child of Decedent Charles E. Sabin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Charles E. Sabin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3204. Plaintiff Andrea Sacerdote is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Joseph Francis Sacerdote, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Joseph Francis Sacerdote and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3205. Plaintiff Arlene Sacerdote is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Francis Sacerdote, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Francis Sacerdote and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Francis Sacerdote and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Francis Sacerdote was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3206. Plaintiff Karen A. Sachs is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Parent of Decedent Jessica Leigh Sachs, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Jessica Leigh Sachs and on behalf of all survivors of Jessica Leigh Sachs and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jessica Leigh Sachs was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center

590

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 592 of 978

North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3207. Plaintiff Katherine Scoville is a resident of the State of Minnesota, the Sibling of Decedent Jessica Leigh Sachs, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jessica Leigh Sachs and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3208. Plaintiff Stephen R. Sachs is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Parent of Decedent Jessica Leigh Sachs, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Jessica Leigh Sachs and on behalf of all survivors of Jessica Leigh Sachs and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jessica Leigh Sachs was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3209. Plaintiff Eric M. Sachs is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Sibling of Decedent Jessica Leigh Sachs, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jessica Leigh Sachs and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3210. Plaintiff Norma T. Sadocha is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Francis John Sadocha, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Francis John Sadocha and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3211. Plaintiff Susan T. Sadocha is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Francis John Sadocha, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Francis John Sadocha and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

591

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 593 of 978

3212. Plaintiff Frank Carl Sadocha is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Francis John Sadocha, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Francis John Sadocha and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3213. Plaintiff John S. Sadocha is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Francis John Sadocha, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Francis John Sadocha and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3214. Plaintiff Elias Safi is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jude Elias Safi, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jude Elias Safi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3215. Plaintiff Ahlam Safi is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jude Elias Safi, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jude Elias Safi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3216. Plaintiff John Safi is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jude Elias Safi, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jude Elias Safi and on behalf of all survivors of Jude Elias Safi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jude Elias Safi was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3217. Plaintiff Silveria Segura is a resident of the State of New York, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Juan G. Salas, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Domestic Partner of Juan G. Salas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

592

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 594 of 978

3218. Plaintiff Debra Saloman is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Wayne J. Saloman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wayne J. Saloman and on behalf of all survivors of Wayne J. Saloman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wayne J. Saloman was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3219. Plaintiff Rosemarie Giallombardo is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Paul Richard Salvio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Richard Salvio and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Richard Salvio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Richard Salvio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3220. Plaintiff Dina Giallombardo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Richard Salvio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Richard Salvio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3221. Plaintiff Vincent Giallombardo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Richard Salvio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Richard Salvio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3222. Plaintiff Robert Giallombardo, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Richard Salvio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Richard Salvio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3223. Plaintiff Gladys H. Salvo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Samuel Robert Salvo, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as

593

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 595 of 978

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Samuel Robert Salvo, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Samuel Robert Salvo, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Samuel Robert Salvo, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3224. Plaintiff Eugenia Bogado is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Carlos A. Samaniego, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Carlos A. Samaniego and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3225. Plaintiff Luis S. Samaniego is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Carlos A. Samaniego, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Carlos A. Samaniego and on behalf of all survivors of Carlos A. Samaniego and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carlos A. Samaniego was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3226. Plaintiff Linda J. Samuel is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent James K. Samuel, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James K. Samuel, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of James K. Samuel, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James K. Samuel, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3227. Plaintiff Jennifer Agresto is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James K. Samuel, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James K. Samuel, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

594

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 596 of 978

3228. Plaintiff James K. Samuel, Sr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent James K. Samuel, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of James K. Samuel, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3229. Plaintiff Jose Luis San Pio is a resident of Spain, the Parent of Decedent Sylvia San Pio, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Sylvia San Pio and on behalf of all survivors of Sylvia San Pio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sylvia San Pio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3230. Plaintiff Maria Carmen Penafiel is a resident of Ecuador, the Parent of Decedent Hugo Manuel Sanay-Perefiel, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hugo Manuel Sanay-Perefiel and on behalf of all survivors of Hugo Manuel Sanay-Perefiel and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hugo Manuel Sanay-Perefiel was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3231. Plaintiff Felicita Maria Sanchez is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Jesus Sanchez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jesus Sanchez and on behalf of all survivors of Jesus Sanchez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jesus Sanchez was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

595

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 597 of 978

3232. Plaintiff Jesus Sanchez Rosado, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Jesus Sanchez; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3233. Plaintiff Carol Sue Sandler is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Herman S. Sandler, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Herman S. Sandler and on behalf of all survivors of Herman S. Sandler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Herman S. Sandler was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3234. Plaintiff Jennifer Sands is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent James Sands, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Sands, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of James Sands, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Sands, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3235. Plaintiff DOE 10 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 10, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3236. Plaintiff DOE 10 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 10, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 10 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 10 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 10 was killed at One World Trade Center

596

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 598 of 978

as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3237. Plaintiff Maureen Santora is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Christopher A. Santora, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Christopher A. Santora and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher A. Santora and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher A. Santora was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3238. Plaintiff Jennifer Santora is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher A. Santora, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher A. Santora and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3239. Plaintiff Kathleen Santora-Montali is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher A. Santora, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher A. Santora and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3240. Plaintiff Patricia Santora is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher A. Santora, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Christopher A. Santora and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3241. Plaintiff Alexander Santora is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Christopher A. Santora, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher A. Santora and on behalf of all survivors of

597

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 599 of 978

Christopher A. Santora and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher A. Santora was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3242. Plaintiff Frances Santore is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent John A. Santore, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John A. Santore and on behalf of all survivors of John A. Santore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John A. Santore was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3243. Plaintiff Alberto Angel Santoro is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Parent of Decedent Mario L. Santoro, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mario L. Santoro and on behalf of all survivors of Mario L. Santoro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mario L. Santoro was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3244. Plaintiff Anne C. Saracini, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Ohio, and the Parent of Decedent Victor J. Saracini; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3245. Plaintiff Joanne Renzi is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Victor J. Saracini, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Victor J. Saracini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3246. Plaintiff Ellen Louise Saracini is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Victor J. Saracini, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as

598

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 600 of 978

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Victor J. Saracini and on behalf of all survivors of Victor J. Saracini and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Victor J. Saracini was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3247. Plaintiff DOE 04 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 04, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 04 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 04 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 04 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3248. Plaintiff Kishan Sarkar is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Kalyan K. Sarkar, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Kalyan K. Sarkar and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3249. Plaintiff Manish Rai is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Deepika Sattaluri, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Deepika Sattaluri and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3250. Plaintiff Ryan Pemberton is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Nephew of Decedent Susan Marie Sauer, and brings this action on his own behalf as Nephew and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Susan Marie Sauer and on behalf of all survivors of Susan Marie Sauer and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susan Marie Sauer was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

599

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 601 of 978

3251. Plaintiff Valentina Savinkina is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Vladimir Savinkin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Vladimir Savinkin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3252. Plaintiff Galina Savinkina is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Vladimir Savinkin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Vladimir Savinkin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3253. Plaintiff Valeriy Savinkin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Vladimir Savinkin, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vladimir Savinkin and on behalf of all survivors of Vladimir Savinkin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vladimir Savinkin was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3254. Plaintiff Jude Monteserrato is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Fiancé of Decedent John Michael Sbarbaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of John Michael Sbarbaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3255. Plaintiff Margaret Scandole is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Robert L. Scandole, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert L. Scandole and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3256. Plaintiff Sheila Marie Scandole is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Robert L. Scandole, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert L. Scandole and on behalf of all survivors of Robert L. Scandole and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

600

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 602 of 978

Robert L. Scandole was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3257. Plaintiff Robert Scandole is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Robert L. Scandole, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Robert L. Scandole and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3258. Plaintiff Christopher Scandole is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert L. Scandole, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert L. Scandole and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3259. Plaintiff Julie Scarpitta, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Michelle Scarpitta; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3260. Plaintiff Steven Scarpitta, a resident of the State of New York, brings this action as the Representative of the Estate of Michelle Scarpitta and on behalf of all survivors of Michelle Scarpitta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michelle Scarpitta was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3261. Plaintiff Steven Scarpitta is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michelle Scarpitta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michelle Scarpitta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3262. Plaintiff Margaret Ti Schardt is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John Schardt, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John Schardt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

601

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 603 of 978

3263. Plaintiff Debra Sacco is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent John Schardt, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Schardt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3264. Plaintiff Jeanette Schardt is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent John Schardt, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Schardt and on behalf of all survivors of John Schardt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Schardt was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3265. Plaintiff Robert Albert Schardt is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John Schardt, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John Schardt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3266. Plaintiff Kenneth Schardt is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John Schardt, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Schardt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3267. Plaintiff Elliot Scheinberg is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Angela Susan Scheinberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angela Susan Scheinberg and on behalf of all survivors of Angela Susan Scheinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Angela Susan Scheinberg was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

602

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 604 of 978

3268. Plaintiff DOE 28 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 28, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3269. Plaintiff DOE 28 is a resident of the California, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 28, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3270. Plaintiff DOE 28 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent DOE 28, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 28 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 28 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 28 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3271. Plaintiff Lauren J. Osnato is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Karen Helene Schmidt, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Karen Helene Schmidt and on behalf of all survivors of Karen Helene Schmidt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karen Helene Schmidt was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3272. Plaintiff Karl H. Schmidt is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Karen Helene Schmidt, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Karen Helene Schmidt and on behalf of all survivors of Karen Helene Schmidt and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karen

603

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 605 of 978

Helene Schmidt was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3273. Plaintiff Dina M. Schott is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Frank G. Schott, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank G. Schott, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Frank G. Schott, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank G. Schott, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3274. Plaintiff Lisa A. Schunk is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Edward W. Schunk, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Edward W. Schunk and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3275. Plaintiff Jennifer Abbe Levine is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Mark Schwartz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Mark Schwartz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3276. Plaintiff Nancy Berliner is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Mark Schwartz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mark Schwartz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3277. Plaintiff Patricia Schwartz is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Mark Schwartz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Schwartz and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Schwartz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Schwartz was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

604

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 606 of 978

3278. Plaintiff Andrew David Schwartz is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent Mark Schwartz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Mark Schwartz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3279. Plaintiff Charles Scibetta is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Adriana Scibetta, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Adriana Scibetta and on behalf of all survivors of Adriana Scibetta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Adriana Scibetta was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3280. Plaintiff Crystal Marie Scott is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Janice Marie Scott, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Janice Marie Scott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3281. Plaintiff Geraldine Holmes is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Parent of Decedent Janice Marie Scott, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Janice Marie Scott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3282. Plaintiff Darlene Bonita Caldwell is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Janice Marie Scott, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3283. Plaintiff Delores Diane James is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent Janice Marie Scott, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

605

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 607 of 978

3284. Plaintiff Denise M. Holmes is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent Janice Marie Scott, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3285. Plaintiff Claudette McKahn Staley is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Janice Marie Scott, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3286. Plaintiff Willette Wages is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Janice Marie Scott, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Janice Marie Scott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3287. Plaintiff George A. Holmes, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Wisconsin, and the Sibling of Decedent Janice Marie Scott; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3288. Plaintiff Abraham Scott is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Janice Marie Scott, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Janice Marie Scott and on behalf of all survivors of Janice Marie Scott and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Janice Marie Scott was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3289. Plaintiff DOE 34 is a resident of the Connecticut, the Child of Decedent DOE 34, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

606

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 608 of 978

3290. Plaintiff DOE 34 is a resident of the Connecticut, the Child of Decedent DOE 34, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3291. Plaintiff DOE 34 is a resident of the state of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 34, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 34 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 34 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 34 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3292. Plaintiff Daniel Paul Seaman is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Herman Seaman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Herman Seaman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3293. Plaintiff Loreen Sellitto is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Matthew Carmen Sellitto, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Matthew Carmen Sellitto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3294. Plaintiff Matthew T. Sellitto is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Matthew Carmen Sellitto, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew Carmen Sellitto and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew Carmen Sellitto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew Carmen Sellitto was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

607

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 609 of 978

3295. Plaintiff Jonathan DiGiovanni Sellitto is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Matthew Carmen Sellitto, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Matthew Carmen Sellitto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3296. Plaintiff Frances Ruth Selwyn is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Howard Selwyn, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Howard Selwyn and on behalf of all survivors of Howard Selwyn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Howard Selwyn was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3297. Plaintiff James Selwyn is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Howard Selwyn, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Howard Selwyn and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3298. Plaintiff Debbi Ellen Senko is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Larry John Senko, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Larry John Senko and on behalf of all survivors of Larry John Senko and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Larry John Senko was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3299. Plaintiff Christina Serva is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Marian Teresa Serva, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Marian Teresa Serva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

608

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 610 of 978

3300. Plaintiff Bruce E. Serva is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Spouse of Decedent Marian Teresa Serva, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marian Teresa Serva and on behalf of all survivors of Marian Teresa Serva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marian Teresa Serva was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3301. Plaintiff Irene Sessa is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Adele Sessa, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Adele Sessa and on behalf of all survivors of Adele Sessa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Adele Sessa was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3302. Plaintiff Elena Sandberg is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Adele Sessa, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Adele Sessa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3303. Plaintiff Christine Patterson is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Adele Sessa, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Adele Sessa and on behalf of all survivors of Adele Sessa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Adele Sessa was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

609

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 611 of 978

3304. Plaintiff Alberico Sessa is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Adele Sessa, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Adele Sessa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3305. Plaintiff Jenny Rahaman is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sita N. Sewnarine, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sita N. Sewnarine and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3306. Plaintiff Lilmatie Didora is a resident of Canada, the Sibling of Decedent Sita N. Sewnarine, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sita N. Sewnarine and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3307. Plaintiff Bhoopaul Sewnarine is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sita N. Sewnarine, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sita N. Sewnarine and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3308. Plaintiff DOE 73 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Domestic Partner of Decedent DOE 73, and brings this action on his own behalf as Domestic Partner and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 73 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 73 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 73 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3309. Plaintiff Janine L. Van Riper is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Child of Decedent Barbara A. Shaw, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Barbara A. Shaw and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara A. Shaw and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barbara A.

610

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 612 of 978

Shaw was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3310. Plaintiff Debra Shaw is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Jeffrey J. Shaw, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey J. Shaw and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey J. Shaw and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey J. Shaw was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3311. Plaintiff Maureen Shay is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3312. Plaintiff Kathleen Shay is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3313. Plaintiff Leanne Shay is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3314. Plaintiff Eileen Shay is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3315. Plaintiff Carolyn Shay is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

611

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 613 of 978

3316. Plaintiff Maureen Surko is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3317. Plaintiff Dawn M. Shay is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert J. Shay, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3318. Plaintiff James Shay is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3319. Plaintiff Michael A. Shay is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3320. Plaintiff Robert J. Shay, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Robert J. Shay, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Robert J. Shay, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3321. Plaintiff Daniel J. Sheehan, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Arizona, and the Parent of Decedent Linda June Sheehan; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3322. The Representative of the Estate of Linda June Sheehan brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Linda June Sheehan and on behalf of all survivors of Linda June Sheehan

612

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 614 of 978

and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Linda June Sheehan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3323. Plaintiff Robert D. Sheehan is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Sibling of Decedent Linda June Sheehan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Linda June Sheehan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3324. Plaintiff Esther Shefi is a resident of Israel, the Parent of Decedent Hagay Shefi, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Hagay Shefi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3325. Plaintiff Pazit Shefi Baum is a resident of Israel, the Sibling of Decedent Hagay Shefi, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hagay Shefi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3326. Plaintiff Sigal Shefi Asher is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Hagay Shefi, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hagay Shefi and on behalf of all survivors of Hagay Shefi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hagay Shefi was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3327. Plaintiff Dov Shefi is a resident of Israel, the Parent of Decedent Hagay Shefi, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Hagay Shefi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

613

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 615 of 978

3328. Plaintiff Yishai Shefi is a resident of Israel, the Sibling of Decedent Hagay Shefi, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Hagay Shefi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3329. Plaintiff DOE 71 is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 71, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3330. Plaintiff DOE 71 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 71, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3331. Plaintiff DOE 71 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 71, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3332. Plaintiff DOE 71 is a resident of the Washington, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 71, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3333. Plaintiff DOE 71 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 71, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3334. Plaintiff DOE 71 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 71, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 71 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 71 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 71 was killed at Two World Trade Center

614

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 616 of 978

as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3335. Plaintiff Frank Sherry is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John Anthony Sherry, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John Anthony Sherry and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3336. Plaintiff Sachiko Shiratori is a resident of Japan, the Parent of Decedent Atsushi Shiratori, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Atsushi Shiratori and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3337. Plaintiff Haruhiro Shiratori is a resident of Japan, the Parent of Decedent Atsushi Shiratori, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Atsushi Shiratori and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3338. Plaintiff Ahuva Shwartzstein is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Allan Abraham Shwartzstein, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Allan Abraham Shwartzstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3339. Plaintiff Orly Small is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Allan Abraham Shwartzstein, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Allan Abraham Shwartzstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3340. Plaintiff Avigdor Shwartzstein, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Allan Abraham Shwartzstein; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3341. Plaintiff Michael Shwartzstein is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Allan Abraham Shwartzstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling

615

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 617 of 978

of Allan Abraham Shwartzstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3342. Plaintiff DOE 99 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 99, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 99 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 99 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 99 was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3343. Plaintiff Kathleen H. Simmons is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Bruce E. Simmons, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bruce E. Simmons and on behalf of all survivors of Bruce E. Simmons and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bruce E. Simmons was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3344. Plaintiff DOE 57 is a resident of the Florida, the Child of Decedent DOE 57, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3345. Plaintiff Christopher Simmons is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent George W. Simmons, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of George W. Simmons, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3346. Plaintiff George W. Simmons, Jr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent George W. Simmons, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of

616

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 618 of 978

George W. Simmons, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3347. Plaintiff Eileen Heather Simon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Michael John Simon, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael John Simon and on behalf of all survivors of Michael John Simon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael John Simon was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3348. Plaintiff Scott S. Simon is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Michael John Simon, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael John Simon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3349. Plaintiff Shelley Simon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Paul J. Simon, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul J. Simon and on behalf of all survivors of Paul J. Simon and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul J. Simon was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3350. Plaintiff Lisa Cardinali is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Marianne Simone, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Marianne Simone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3351. Plaintiff Teresa Hargrave is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Marianne Simone, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marianne Simone and on behalf of all survivors of

617

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 619 of 978

Marianne Simone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marianne Simone was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3352. Plaintiff Virginia M. Liquori is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Marianne Simone, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Marianne Simone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3353. Plaintiff Lucille Bleimann is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Marianne Simone, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Marianne Simone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3354. Plaintiff Stephen Simone is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Marianne Simone, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Marianne Simone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3355. Plaintiff Ann Simpkin is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Jane Louise Simpkin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jane Louise Simpkin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3356. Plaintiff Helen C. Simpkin-Whalen is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jane Louise Simpkin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jane Louise Simpkin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3357. Plaintiff Diane Java is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Jeff L. Simpson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeff L. Simpson and on behalf of all survivors of Jeff L. Simpson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeff L. Simpson was

618

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 620 of 978

killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3358. Plaintiff Craig W. Sincock is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Cheryle D. Sincock, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Spouse of Cheryle D. Sincock and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3359. Plaintiff Alana Siracuse is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Peter Siracuse, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Siracuse and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Siracuse and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Siracuse was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3360. Plaintiff Irene Lesiw is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Skala, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John P. Skala and on behalf of all survivors of John P. Skala and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John P. Skala was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3361. Plaintiff Michael Skala is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Skala, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Skala and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3362. Plaintiff Jaroslawa Skala is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Skala, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Skala and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

619

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 621 of 978

3363. Plaintiff Loretta T. Slavin, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Vincent R. Slavin; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3364. Plaintiff Anna L. Baez is a resident of the State of Florida, the Fiancé of Decedent Vincent R. Slavin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Vincent R. Slavin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3365. Plaintiff Patricia B. Sloan is a resident of the State of California, the Parent of Decedent Paul Kenneth Sloan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Paul Kenneth Sloan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3366. Plaintiff Ronald S. Sloan is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Parent of Decedent Paul Kenneth Sloan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Kenneth Sloan and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Kenneth Sloan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Kenneth Sloan was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3367. Plaintiff Lawanda Simmons is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Wendy L. Small, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wendy L. Small and on behalf of all survivors of Wendy L. Small and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wendy L. Small was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3368. Plaintiff Elba Cedeno is a resident of the State of Florida, the Domestic Partner of Decedent Catherine T. Smith, and brings this action on her own behalf as Domestic Partner and

620

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 622 of 978

as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Catherine T. Smith and on behalf of all survivors of Catherine T. Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Catherine T. Smith was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3369. Plaintiff Annette Smith is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Catherine T. Smith, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Catherine T. Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3370. Plaintiff Lisa Ann Ethredge is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Catherine T. Smith, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Catherine T. Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3371. Plaintiff Barbara Schielzo is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Catherine T. Smith, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Catherine T. Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3372. Plaintiff Vincent J. Smith is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Catherine T. Smith, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Catherine T. Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3373. Plaintiff Walter Smith is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Catherine T. Smith, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Catherine T. Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3374. Plaintiff Madeline W. Smith is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey R. Smith, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jeffrey R. Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

621

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 623 of 978

3375. Plaintiff Brenda Smith Clark is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey R. Smith, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey R. Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3376. Plaintiff DOE 61 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 61, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 61 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 61 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 61 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3377. Plaintiff Arthur Abraham Smith is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey R. Smith, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jeffrey R. Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3378. Plaintiff Millicent Miller is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joyce Patricia Smith, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joyce Patricia Smith and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3379. Plaintiff DOE 135 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 135, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3380. Plaintiff Georgia Ruth Smith is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Karl T. Smith, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Karl T. Smith, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3381. Plaintiff DOE 87 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 87, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of

622

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 624 of 978

DOE 87 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 87 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 87 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3382. Plaintiff Peter Hibbard Smith is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Karl T. Smith, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Karl T. Smith, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3383. Plaintiff Matthew G. Smith is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Karl T. Smith, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Karl T. Smith, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3384. Plaintiff DOE 87 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 87, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3385. Plaintiff Philip Trumbull Smith, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Karl T. Smith, Sr.; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3386. Plaintiff DOE 87 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Child of Decedent DOE 87, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3387. Plaintiff DOE 52, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 52; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

623

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 625 of 978

3388. Plaintiff DOE 52 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 52, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3389. Plaintiff DOE 52 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 52, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3390. Plaintiff Jennifer Ann Tucker is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Rochelle Monique Snell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Rochelle Monique Snell and on behalf of all survivors of Rochelle Monique Snell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rochelle Monique Snell was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3391. Plaintiff Charles O'Neal Snyder is a resident of the State of Hawaii, the Parent of Decedent Christine Ann Snyder, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christine Ann Snyder and on behalf of all survivors of Christine Ann Snyder and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christine Ann Snyder was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3392. Plaintiff John B. Snyder is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Dianne Bullis Snyder, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dianne Bullis Snyder and on behalf of all survivors of Dianne Bullis Snyder and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

624

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 626 of 978

Dianne Bullis Snyder was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3393. Plaintiff Marion Elaine Kminek is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Mari-Rae Sopper, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Mari-Rae Sopper and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3394. Plaintiff Tammy Lynn Sopper-Sergovia is a resident of the State of Illinois, the Sibling of Decedent Mari-Rae Sopper, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mari-Rae Sopper and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3395. Plaintiff Christina Kminek is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Mari-Rae Sopper, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mari-Rae Sopper and on behalf of all survivors of MariRae Sopper and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mari-Rae Sopper was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3396. Plaintiff R. Bill Sopper, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Mari-Rae Sopper; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3397. Plaintiff Elda Giron is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Fabian Soto, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Fabian Soto and on behalf of all survivors of Fabian Soto and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fabian Soto was killed at

625

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 627 of 978

One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3398. Plaintiff Paul A. Spagnoletti is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Gregory T. Spagnoletti, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory T. Spagnoletti and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory T. Spagnoletti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory T. Spagnoletti was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3399. Plaintiff Doreen Lanza, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Sparacio; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3400. Plaintiff Edith A. Sparacio is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Thomas Sparacio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas Sparacio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3401. Plaintiff Deborah Ann Klemowitz is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas Sparacio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas Sparacio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3402. Plaintiff Cheri Magnus Sparacio is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas Sparacio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas Sparacio and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas Sparacio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Sparacio was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

626

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 628 of 978

3403. Plaintiff Jack Joseph Sparacio, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Thomas Sparacio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Thomas Sparacio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3404. Plaintiff Patricia Ellen Wellington is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent John Anthony Spataro, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Anthony Spataro and on behalf of all survivors of John Anthony Spataro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Anthony Spataro was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3405. Plaintiff Irene Desantis is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Robert W. Spear, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert W. Spear, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3406. Plaintiff Barbara P. Keane is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert W. Spear, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert W. Spear, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3407. Plaintiff Christine Vollkommer is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Robert W. Spear, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Robert W. Spear, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3408. Plaintiff Lorraine Spear is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Robert W. Spear, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert W. Spear, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Robert W. Spear, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

627

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 629 of 978

Robert W. Spear, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3409. Plaintiff DOE 136 is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent DOE 136, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3410. Plaintiff DOE 136 is a resident of the New York, the Child of Decedent DOE 136, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3411. Plaintiff DOE 136 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 136, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 136 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 136 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 136 was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3412. Plaintiff Irene Spina is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Lisa L. Spina-Trerotola, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Lisa L. Spina-Trerotola and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3413. Plaintiff Mario Francis Spina is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Lisa L. Spina-Trerotola, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Lisa L. Spina-Trerotola and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3414. Plaintiff Paul M. Spina is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Lisa L. Spina-Trerotola, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Lisa L. Spina-Trerotola and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

628

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 630 of 978

3415. Plaintiff Michelle Spinelli is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Frank J. Spinelli, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank J. Spinelli, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Frank J. Spinelli, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank J. Spinelli, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3416. Plaintiff Pamela Spitz is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent William Edward Spitz, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of William Edward Spitz, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3417. Plaintiff Lauren Spitz is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent William Edward Spitz, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of William Edward Spitz, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3418. Plaintiff Michael J. Spitz is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent William Edward Spitz, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of William Edward Spitz, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3419. Plaintiff Colleen Casey Spor is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph P. Spor, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse, and on behalf of minor child C.M.S., and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph P. Spor, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph P. Spor, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph P. Spor, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a

629

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 631 of 978

result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3420. Plaintiff Lauren Stabile is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael F. Stabile, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Michael F. Stabile and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3421. Plaintiff Michele Stabile is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael F. Stabile, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Michael F. Stabile and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3422. Plaintiff Roseanna Stabile is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael F. Stabile, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael F. Stabile and on behalf of all survivors of Michael F. Stabile and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael F. Stabile was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3423. Plaintiff Robert Stabile is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael F. Stabile, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Michael F. Stabile and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3424. Plaintiff Vee Stadelberger is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Richard Stadelberger, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard Stadelberger and on behalf of all survivors of Richard Stadelberger and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Stadelberger was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

630

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 632 of 978

3425. Plaintiff Renee Stahlman is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Eric Stahlman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Eric Stahlman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3426. Plaintiff Blanca Stahlman is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Eric Stahlman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eric Stahlman and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Stahlman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric Stahlman was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3427. Plaintiff Samuel Stahlman is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Eric Stahlman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Eric Stahlman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3428. Plaintiff Ellen Stajk Shelnutt is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Gregory Stajk, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Gregory Stajk and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3429. Plaintiff Jeanie Somerville is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Gregory Stajk, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory Stajk and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory Stajk and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory Stajk was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

631

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 633 of 978

3430. Plaintiff Lucia Balzan is a resident of Halifax Canada, the Sibling of Decedent Mary Domenica Stanley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mary Domenica Stanley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3431. Plaintiff Paul J. Stanley is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Mary Domenica Stanley, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Domenica Stanley and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Domenica Stanley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary Domenica Stanley was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3432. Plaintiff Rosemary Ann Stark is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey Stark, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey Stark and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey Stark and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey Stark was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3433. Plaintiff Kathleen Stark is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey Stark, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey Stark and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3434. Plaintiff Therese Stark is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey Stark, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey Stark and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

632

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 634 of 978

3435. Plaintiff John Stark is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey Stark, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey Stark and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3436. Plaintiff Joseph C. Stark is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey Stark, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey Stark and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3437. Plaintiff Nancy Statkevicus is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Parent of Decedent Derek James Statkevicus, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Derek James Statkevicus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3438. Plaintiff Joseph R. Statkevicus is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Parent of Decedent Derek James Statkevicus, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Derek James Statkevicus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3439. Plaintiff Joel Statkevicus is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Derek James Statkevicus, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Derek James Statkevicus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3440. Plaintiff Florence Wittner Staub is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Craig William Staub, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Craig William Staub and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

633

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 635 of 978

3441. Plaintiff Carolyn Staub Bilelis is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Craig William Staub, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Craig William Staub and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3442. Plaintiff Barbara Maneja is a resident of the State of Hawaii, the Sibling of Decedent Craig William Staub, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Craig William Staub and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3443. Plaintiff Stacey A. Staub is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Craig William Staub, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Craig William Staub and on behalf of all survivors of Craig William Staub and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Craig William Staub was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3444. Plaintiff Kenneth Donohue is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Craig William Staub, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Craig William Staub and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3445. Plaintiff Blanche Steen is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Eric Thomas Steen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eric Thomas Steen and on behalf of all survivors of Eric Thomas Steen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric Thomas Steen was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

634

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 636 of 978

3446. Plaintiff George D. Steen, II is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Eric Thomas Steen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Eric Thomas Steen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3447. Plaintiff Meredith Alayne Steiner is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent William R. Steiner, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of William R. Steiner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3448. Plaintiff Wilma E. Steiner, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent William R. Steiner; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3449. Plaintiff Russa Steiner is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent William R. Steiner, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William R. Steiner and on behalf of all survivors of William R. Steiner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William R. Steiner was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3450. Plaintiff Jordon Christofer-William Steiner is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent William R. Steiner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of William R. Steiner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3451. Plaintiff Darren Alexander Steiner is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent William R. Steiner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of William R. Steiner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

635

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 637 of 978

3452. Plaintiff Robert Steiner is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent William R. Steiner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of William R. Steiner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3453. Plaintiff George Steiner is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent William R. Steiner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of William R. Steiner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3454. Plaintiff Angela Stergiopoulos is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Andrew Stergiopoulos, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Andrew Stergiopoulos and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Stergiopoulos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andrew Stergiopoulos was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3455. Plaintiff Kathleen Stergiopoulos is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew Stergiopoulos, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew Stergiopoulos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3456. Plaintiff George N. Stergiopoulos is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Andrew Stergiopoulos, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Andrew Stergiopoulos and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Stergiopoulos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andrew Stergiopoulos was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

636

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 638 of 978

3457. Plaintiff George Stergiopoulos, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew Stergiopoulos, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew Stergiopoulos and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3458. Plaintiff Katherine Stern is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Andrew Stern, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Andrew Stern and on behalf of all survivors of Andrew Stern and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andrew Stern was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3459. Plaintiff Nancy A. Cosban is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Daniel E. Stewart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Daniel E. Stewart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3460. Plaintiff Richard W. Stewart is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Daniel E. Stewart, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel E. Stewart and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel E. Stewart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel E. Stewart was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3461. Plaintiff Russel F. Stewart is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel E. Stewart, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel E. Stewart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

637

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 639 of 978

3462. Plaintiff James R. Stewart is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel E. Stewart, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel E. Stewart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3463. Plaintiff DOE 25 is a resident of the New Jersey, and brings this action on behalf of minor children DOE 25 and DOE 25 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3464. Plaintiff Elizabeth Stewart is a resident of Northern Ireland, the Parent of Decedent Michael James Stewart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael James Stewart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3465. Plaintiff Janet Stewart is a resident of Northern Ireland, the Sibling of Decedent Michael James Stewart, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael James Stewart and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3466. Plaintiff Joan B. Stewart is a resident of the State of Texas, the Parent of Decedent Richard H. Stewart, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Richard H. Stewart, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Richard H. Stewart, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard H. Stewart, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3467. Plaintiff Susan Stewart Tillier is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Richard H. Stewart, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard H. Stewart, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

638

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 640 of 978

3468. Plaintiff Richard H. Stewart, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of North Carolina, and the Parent of Decedent Richard H. Stewart, Jr.; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3469. Plaintiff Charles Parker, III is a resident of the State of New Hampshire, the Not Related of Decedent Douglas Stone, and brings this action on his own behalf as Not Related and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Douglas Stone and on behalf of all survivors of Douglas Stone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Douglas Stone was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3470. Plaintiff Evelyn Stone, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Lonny Jay Stone; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3471. Plaintiff Gayle Stone is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Lonny Jay Stone, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Lonny Jay Stone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3472. Plaintiff Ben Stone is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Lonny Jay Stone, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Lonny Jay Stone and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3473. Plaintiff TERRY STRADA is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas S. Strada and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of minor child J.T.S. and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas S. Strada and as the Personal

639

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 641 of 978

Representative of the Estate of Thomas S. Strada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas S. Strada was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3474. Plaintiff Kaitlyn C. Strada is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Thomas S. Strada, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Thomas S. Strada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3475. Plaintiff Thomas J. Strada is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Thomas S. Strada, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Thomas S. Strada and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3476. Plaintiff Mary Emma Straine is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Parent of Decedent James J. Straine, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of James J. Straine, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3477. Plaintiff Patricia A. Straine is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent James J. Straine, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James J. Straine, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of James J. Straine, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James J. Straine, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3478. Plaintiff James Joseph Straine is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Parent of Decedent James J. Straine, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of James J. Straine, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

640

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 642 of 978

3479. Plaintiff Kevin Joseph Straine is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James J. Straine, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James J. Straine, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3480. Plaintiff Daniel Matthew Straine is a resident of the State of Maine, the Sibling of Decedent James J. Straine, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James J. Straine, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3481. Plaintiff Michael Straine is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James J. Straine, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James J. Straine, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3482. Plaintiff Sandra N. Straub is a resident of the State of Utah, the Spouse of Decedent Edward W. Straub, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward W. Straub and on behalf of all survivors of Edward W. Straub and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward W. Straub was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3483. Plaintiff Samuel E. Straub is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Edward W. Straub, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Edward W. Straub and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3484. Plaintiff Virginia Strauch is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent George Strauch, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of George Strauch and on behalf of all survivors of George Strauch and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George

641

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 643 of 978

Strauch was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3485. Plaintiff Olga C. Strickland, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Washington, and the Parent of Decedent Larry L. Strickland; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3486. Plaintiff Julia Dill is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Larry L. Strickland, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Larry L. Strickland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3487. Plaintiff Donna M. McBride is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Larry L. Strickland, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Larry L. Strickland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3488. Plaintiff Debra Louise Strickland is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Larry L. Strickland, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Larry L. Strickland and on behalf of all survivors of Larry L. Strickland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Larry L. Strickland was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3489. Plaintiff Lee Strickland, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Washington, and the Parent of Decedent Larry L. Strickland; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3490. Plaintiff Matthew Lee Strickland is a resident of the State of Washington, the Child of Decedent Larry L. Strickland, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Larry L. Strickland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

642

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 644 of 978

3491. Plaintiff Christopher Robert Strickland is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Child of Decedent Larry L. Strickland, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Larry L. Strickland and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3492. Plaintiff Thelma Stuart is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Walwyn W. Stuart, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Walwyn W. Stuart, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Walwyn W. Stuart, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Walwyn W. Stuart, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3493. Plaintiff Sally Ann Suarez is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Benjamin Suarez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benjamin Suarez and on behalf of all survivors of Benjamin Suarez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Benjamin Suarez was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3494. Plaintiff Elma A. Sugra is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent William Christopher Sugra, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of William Christopher Sugra and on behalf of all survivors of William Christopher Sugra and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Christopher Sugra was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

643

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 645 of 978

3495. Plaintiff William J. Sugra is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent William Christopher Sugra, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of William Christopher Sugra and on behalf of all survivors of William Christopher Sugra and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Christopher Sugra was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3496. Plaintiff Jean Suhr Ryan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Suhr, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Suhr and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3497. Plaintiff Leeann M. Suhr Klein is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Suhr, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Suhr and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3498. Plaintiff Nancy Suhr is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Daniel Suhr, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Daniel Suhr and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Suhr and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Suhr was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3499. Plaintiff Christopher Suhr is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Suhr, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Suhr and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3500. Plaintiff Evelyn Sullins is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent David Marc Sullins, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

644

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 646 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of David Marc Sullins and on behalf of all survivors of David Marc Sullins and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Marc Sullins was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3501. Plaintiff Mary Sullivan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Patrick Sullivan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patrick Sullivan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3502. Plaintiff Patrick J. Sullivan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Patrick Sullivan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick Sullivan and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick Sullivan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Sullivan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3503. Plaintiff Gerald Sullivan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick Sullivan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick Sullivan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3504. Plaintiff Gregory Sullivan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick Sullivan, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick Sullivan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3505. Plaintiff Arlene R Sullivan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Thomas G. Sullivan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Thomas G. Sullivan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

645

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 647 of 978

3506. Plaintiff Norene Schneider is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Thomas G. Sullivan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Thomas G. Sullivan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3507. Plaintiff Deirdre Dickinson Sullivan is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Thomas G. Sullivan, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas G. Sullivan and on behalf of all survivors of Thomas G. Sullivan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas G. Sullivan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3508. Plaintiff Estrella Sumaya is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr. was killed in One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3509. Plaintiff Christine Trotta is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3510. Plaintiff Marivel Passacantando is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the

646

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 648 of 978

Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3511. Plaintiff Charito Leblanc is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3512. Plaintiff Lisa Sumaya is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3513. Plaintiff Reynaldo Sumaya is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Hilario Soriano Sumaya, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3514. Plaintiff Noreen Supinski is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent Colleen M. Supinski, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Colleen M. Supinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3515. Plaintiff Steven A. Supinski is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent Colleen M. Supinski, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Colleen M. Supinski and on behalf of all survivors of Colleen M. Supinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Colleen M. Supinski was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

647

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 649 of 978

3516. Plaintiff Nathan Supinski is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Colleen M. Supinski, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Colleen M. Supinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3517. Plaintiff Benjamin Supinski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Colleen M. Supinski, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Colleen M. Supinski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3518. Plaintiff Patricia Sutcliffe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Robert Sutcliffe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert Sutcliffe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3519. Plaintiff Margaret Sutcliffe is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Sutcliffe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Sutcliffe and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Sutcliffe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Sutcliffe was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3520. Plaintiff Robert Sutcliffe, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Robert Sutcliffe; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3521. Plaintiff Bernell Sutton is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Claudia Sutton, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Claudia Sutton and on behalf of all survivors of Claudia Sutton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Claudia Sutton was

648

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 650 of 978

killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3522. Plaintiff Julie Sweeny Roth is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Brian D. Sweeney, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Brian D. Sweeney and on behalf of all survivors of Brian D. Sweeney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian D. Sweeney was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3523. Plaintiff Michael Gerard Sweeney is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Madeline Amy Sweeney, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Madeline Amy Sweeney and on behalf of all survivors of Madeline Amy Sweeney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Madeline Amy Sweeney was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3524. Plaintiff Maureen Sullivan is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Derek O. Sword, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Derek O. Sword and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3525. Plaintiff Michael Sztejnberg is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Gina Sztejnberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gina Sztejnberg and on behalf of all survivors of Gina Sztejnberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gina

649

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 651 of 978

Sztejnberg was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3526. Plaintiff Eleanor Neville is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joann Tabeek, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joann Tabeek and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3527. Plaintiff Maureen Pickering is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joann Tabeek, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3528. Plaintiff Patricia A. Heyne is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joann Tabeek, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3529. Plaintiff Alex Tabeek is a resident of the State of New York, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joann Tabeek, on behalf of minor child K.T., and on behalf of all survivors of Joann Tabeek, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joann Tabeek was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3530. Plaintiff Vincent A. Milotta is a resident of the State of Florida, the Fiancé of Decedent Joann Tabeek, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Fiancé of Joann Tabeek and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3531. Plaintiff James E. Smith is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joann Tabeek, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

650

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 652 of 978

3532. Plaintiff William Smith is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joann Tabeek, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3533. Plaintiff Michael Smith is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joann Tabeek, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joann Tabeek and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3534. Plaintiff Danielle Taddonio is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael Taddonio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Michael Taddonio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3535. Plaintiff Nicole Taddonio is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael Taddonio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Michael Taddonio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3536. Plaintiff Denise Taddonio is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Michael Taddonio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Michael Taddonio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3537. Plaintiff Michael Taddonio is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Michael Taddonio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Michael Taddonio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3538. Plaintiff Joseph Keith Talbot is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Child of Decedent Phyllis Talbot, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Phyllis Talbot and on behalf of all survivors of Phyllis Talbot and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Phyllis Talbot was killed

651

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 653 of 978

at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3539. Plaintiff Diana Talhami is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Robert R. Talhami, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert R. Talhami and on behalf of all survivors of Robert R. Talhami and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert R. Talhami was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3540. Plaintiff Eileen Bertorelli-Zangrillo is a resident of the State of New York, the Niece of Decedent John Marcy Talignani, and brings this action on her own behalf as Niece and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Marcy Talignani and on behalf of all survivors of John Marcy Talignani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Marcy Talignani was killed at United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3541. Plaintiff Alice Bertorelli is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John Marcy Talignani, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John Marcy Talignani and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3542. Plaintiff Armand Talignani, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Sibling of Decedent John Marcy Talignani; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

652

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 654 of 978

3543. Plaintiff Gloria Talty is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Paul Talty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Paul Talty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3544. Plaintiff Kerry Mccall is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Talty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Talty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3545. Plaintiff Patricia Dougan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Talty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Talty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3546. Plaintiff Barbara Talty is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Paul Talty, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Paul Talty and on behalf of all survivors of Paul Talty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Talty was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3547. Plaintiff John Paul Talty is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Paul Talty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Paul Talty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3548. Plaintiff Kevin Talty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Talty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Talty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

653

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 655 of 978

3549. Plaintiff Steven Talty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Talty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Talty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3550. Plaintiff Mark Talty is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Paul Talty, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Paul Talty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3551. Plaintiff Julie M.Y. Tam is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Maurita Tam, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Maurita Tam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3552. Plaintiff Stephanie Tam is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Maurita Tam, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Maurita Tam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3553. Plaintiff Jin Ark Tam is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Maurita Tam, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Maurita Tam and on behalf of all survivors of Maurita Tam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maurita Tam was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3554. Plaintiff Donald Tam is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Maurita Tam, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Maurita Tam and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

654

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 656 of 978

3555. Plaintiff Pamela M. Tamayo is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Hector R. Tamayo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Hector R. Tamayo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3556. Plaintiff Elna R. Tamayo-Prado is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Hector R. Tamayo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3557. Plaintiff Sheila R. Tamayo-Punzalan is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Hector R. Tamayo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3558. Plaintiff Evangeline R. Tamayo-Iguina is a resident of the State of Philippines, the Sibling of Decedent Hector R. Tamayo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3559. Plaintiff Evelyn Mercene Tamayo is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Hector R. Tamayo, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Hector R. Tamayo and on behalf of all survivors of Hector R. Tamayo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hector R. Tamayo was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3560. Plaintiff Julian Ian Tamayo is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Hector R. Tamayo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Hector R. Tamayo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

655

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 657 of 978

3561. Plaintiff Luther Rogan Tamayo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Hector R. Tamayo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3562. Plaintiff Severino Rogan Tamayo, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Hector R. Tamayo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Hector R. Tamayo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3563. Plaintiff Severino Y. Tamayo, Sr. is a resident of the State of Philippines, the Parent of Decedent Hector R. Tamayo, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Hector R. Tamayo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3564. Plaintiff Patricia E. Tamuccio is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Michael Andre Tamuccio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Andre Tamuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3565. Plaintiff Dana M. Tamuccio is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Andre Tamuccio, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Andre Tamuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3566. Plaintiff James W. Tamuccio, II is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Andre Tamuccio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Andre Tamuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3567. Plaintiff James W. Tamuccio, Sr. is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Michael Andre Tamuccio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of

656

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 658 of 978

Michael Andre Tamuccio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3568. Plaintiff Diane Taormina is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Dennis G. Taormina, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dennis G. Taormina, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Dennis G. Taormina, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis G. Taormina, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3569. Plaintiff Theresa Marie Tarantino is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Kenneth J. Tarantino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth J. Tarantino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3570. Plaintiff Victoria Jane Melone is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth J. Tarantino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth J. Tarantino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3571. Plaintiff DOE 62 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 62, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 62 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 62 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 62 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3572. Plaintiff Kenneth Thomas Tarantino is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Kenneth J. Tarantino, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent

657

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 659 of 978

of Kenneth J. Tarantino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3573. Plaintiff Mehr A. Tariq is a resident of the State of California, the Spouse of Decedent Amanulah Tariq, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Amanulah Tariq and on behalf of all survivors of Amanulah Tariq and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Amanulah Tariq was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3574. Plaintiff Patricia Peterson Tarrou is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Michael C. Tarrou, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael C. Tarrou and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3575. Plaintiff Demetra T. Lumia is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael C. Tarrou, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael C. Tarrou and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3576. Plaintiff Gigi T. Hintz is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael C. Tarrou, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael C. Tarrou and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3577. Plaintiff James Tarrou, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Michael C. Tarrou; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3578. Plaintiff Charles J. Tarrou is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael C. Tarrou, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael C. Tarrou and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

658

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 660 of 978

3579. Plaintiff Teresa Tartaro is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Ronald G. Tartaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Ronald G. Tartaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3580. Plaintiff Rosanna P. Tartaro is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Ronald G. Tartaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Ronald G. Tartaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3581. Plaintiff Karen Reilly is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Ronald G. Tartaro, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ronald G. Tartaro and on behalf of all survivors of Ronald G. Tartaro and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald G. Tartaro was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3582. Plaintiff William Tartaro, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Ronald G. Tartaro; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3583. Plaintiff Sarah Taylor is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Donnie B. Taylor, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donnie B. Taylor, Sr. and on behalf of all survivors of Donnie B. Taylor, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donnie B. Taylor, Sr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

659

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 661 of 978

3584. Plaintiff Clara S. Taylor is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Parent of Decedent Michael M. Taylor, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael M. Taylor and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3585. Plaintiff Kathryn Taylor Teare is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Sibling of Decedent Michael M. Taylor, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael M. Taylor and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3586. Plaintiff Mary Kaye Crenshaw is a resident of the State of Arkansas, the Sibling of Decedent Michael M. Taylor, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael M. Taylor and on behalf of all survivors of Michael M. Taylor and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael M. Taylor was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3587. Plaintiff James H. Taylor, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Alabama, and the Parent of Decedent Michael M. Taylor; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3588. Plaintiff James J. Taylor is a resident of the State of Tennessee, the Sibling of Decedent Michael M. Taylor, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael M. Taylor and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3589. Plaintiff Elaine S. Teague is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Parent of Decedent Sandra D. Teague, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sandra D. Teague and on behalf of all survivors of Sandra D. Teague and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sandra D. Teague was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the

660

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 662 of 978

Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3590. Plaintiff Wendy Teepe Green is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Child of Decedent Karl W. Teepe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Karl W. Teepe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3591. Plaintiff Donna D. Teepe is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Karl W. Teepe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karl W. Teepe and on behalf of all survivors of Karl W. Teepe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karl W. Teepe was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3592. Plaintiff Adam Karl Teepe is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Karl W. Teepe, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Karl W. Teepe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3593. Plaintiff Dorothy Maria Tempesta is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Anthony Tempesta, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Anthony Tempesta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3594. Plaintiff Ana Tempesta is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Anthony Tempesta, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony Tempesta and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony Tempesta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Tempesta was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

661

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 663 of 978

3595. Plaintiff Clifford Daniel Tempesta is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Anthony Tempesta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Anthony Tempesta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3596. Plaintiff Clifford M. Tempesta is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Anthony Tempesta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Anthony Tempesta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3597. Plaintiff Michael Tempesta is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Anthony Tempesta, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Anthony Tempesta and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3598. Plaintiff Rosalyn Temple, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent Dorothy Temple; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3599. The Representative of the Estate of Dorothy Temple brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Dorothy Temple and on behalf of all survivors of Dorothy Temple and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dorothy Temple was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3600. Plaintiff Jacqueline Temple is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Dorothy Temple, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Dorothy Temple and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3601. Plaintiff Louis Temple, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Ohio, and the Sibling of Decedent Dorothy Temple; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

662

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 664 of 978

3602. Plaintiff Willie Temple is a resident of the State of New York, the Nephew of Decedent Dorothy Temple, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Nephew of Dorothy Temple and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3603. Plaintiff Larry J. Temple is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Dorothy Temple, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Dorothy Temple and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3604. Plaintiff Britt Ehnar is a resident of Sweden, the Parent of Decedent David Tengelin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of David Tengelin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3605. Plaintiff Petra Ehnar is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent David Tengelin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of David Tengelin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3606. Plaintiff Patric Tengelin is a resident of Germany, the Sibling of Decedent David Tengelin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of David Tengelin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3607. Plaintiff Lucy E. Thompson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Clive Thompson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Clive Thompson and on behalf of all survivors of Clive Thompson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Clive Thompson was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

663

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 665 of 978

3608. Plaintiff Keith B. Thompson is a resident of United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent Clive Thompson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Clive Thompson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3609. Plaintiff Violet Thompson is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Glenn Thompson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Glenn Thompson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3610. Plaintiff Christine E. Thompson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Glenn Thompson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Glenn Thompson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3611. Plaintiff Kai Hernandez is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Glenn Thompson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Glenn Thompson and on behalf of all survivors of Glenn Thompson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Glenn Thompson was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3612. Plaintiff Edward Thompson is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Glenn Thompson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Glenn Thompson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3613. Plaintiff Scott M. Thompson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Glenn Thompson, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Glenn Thompson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3614. Plaintiff Charlette Thompson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Perry Thompson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

664

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 666 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Perry Thompson and on behalf of all survivors of Perry Thompson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Perry Thompson was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3615. Plaintiff Marilyn Williams Thorpe is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Eric R. Thorpe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Eric R. Thorpe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3616. Plaintiff Susan Thorpe Burghouwt is a resident of the State of Rhode Island, the Sibling of Decedent Eric R. Thorpe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Eric R. Thorpe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3617. Plaintiff Linda Perry Thorpe is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Eric R. Thorpe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eric R. Thorpe and on behalf of all survivors of Eric R. Thorpe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric R. Thorpe was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3618. Plaintiff Raymond R. Thorpe is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Eric R. Thorpe, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Eric R. Thorpe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3619. Plaintiff Maureen Tieri is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Salvatore Tieri, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Salvatore Tieri and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

665

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 667 of 978

3620. Plaintiff Helen Mary Tierney is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John P. Tierney, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John P. Tierney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3621. Plaintiff Mary E. Digiacomo is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Tierney, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Tierney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3622. Plaintiff Jeanne Neumeyer is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Tierney, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Tierney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3623. Plaintiff John Tierney, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent John P. Tierney; the Representative of his Estate, Helen Mary Tierney, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3624. Representative of the Estate of John P. Tierney brings this action on behalf of the Estate of John P. Tierney nd on behalf of all survivors of John P. Tierney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John P. Tierney was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3625. Plaintiff Thomas Tierney is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John P. Tierney, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John P. Tierney and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

666

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 668 of 978

3626. Plaintiff Linda G Tieste is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent William R. Tieste, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of William R. Tieste and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3627. Plaintiff Debra Anne Tieste is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent William R. Tieste, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William R. Tieste and on behalf of all survivors of William R. Tieste and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William R. Tieste was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3628. Plaintiff Ronald Tieste, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Delaware, and the Sibling of Decedent William R. Tieste; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3629. Plaintiff William Charles Tieste is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent William R. Tieste, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of William R. Tieste and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3630. Plaintiff Keith Tieste is a resident of the State of Florida, the Child of Decedent William R. Tieste, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of William R. Tieste and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3631. Plaintiff Karen Dallavalle is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé of Decedent Kenneth F. Tietjen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Kenneth F. Tietjen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

667

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 669 of 978

3632. Plaintiff Janice Tietjen is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Kenneth F. Tietjen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth F. Tietjen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3633. Plaintiff Cindy Tietjen is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth F. Tietjen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth F. Tietjen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3634. Plaintiff Laurie Tietjen is a resident of Taiwan, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth F. Tietjen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth F. Tietjen and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth F. Tietjen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth F. Tietjen was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3635. Plaintiff Kenneth A. Tietjen is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Kenneth F. Tietjen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth F. Tietjen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3636. Plaintiff Jane M. O'Dea is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Edward Tighe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Edward Tighe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3637. Plaintiff Roberta L. Shea is a resident of the State of Idaho, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Edward Tighe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Edward Tighe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3638. Plaintiff Kathleen Marie Tighe is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Stephen Edward Tighe, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as

668

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 670 of 978

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Stephen Edward Tighe and on behalf of all survivors of Stephen Edward Tighe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Edward Tighe was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3639. Plaintiff Timothy J. Tighe, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Edward Tighe; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3640. Plaintiff James H. Tighe is a resident of the State of Indiana, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Edward Tighe, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Edward Tighe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3641. Plaintiff Kristine Timmes is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent Scott Charles Timmes, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Scott Charles Timmes and on behalf of all survivors of Scott Charles Timmes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Charles Timmes was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3642. Plaintiff Jenna Tinley Mather is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Michael Ernest Tinley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Michael Ernest Tinley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3643. Plaintiff Lisa Kennedy is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Child of Decedent Michael Ernest Tinley, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Michael Ernest Tinley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

669

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 671 of 978

3644. Plaintiff Joan E. Tino is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Jennifer M. Tino, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jennifer M. Tino and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer M. Tino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jennifer M. Tino was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3645. Plaintiff Pamela Schiele is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Jennifer M. Tino, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jennifer M. Tino and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3646. Plaintiff Richard Tipaldi is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Robert Tipaldi, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Tipaldi and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Tipaldi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Tipaldi was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3647. Plaintiff Arlene M. Tipping is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John J. Tipping, Ii, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John J. Tipping, Ii, II and on behalf of all survivors of John J. Tipping, Ii, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. Tipping, Ii, II was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

670

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 672 of 978

3648. Plaintiff Stephanie L. Tipping is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John J. Tipping, Ii, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of John J. Tipping, Ii, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3649. Plaintiff John J. Tipping is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John J. Tipping, Ii, II, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John J. Tipping, Ii, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3650. Plaintiff Marina Irene Ugarte Tirado is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Child of Decedent Hector Luis Tirado, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Hector Luis Tirado, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3651. Plaintiff Sheneque Tirado Jackson is a resident of the State of Ohio, the Spouse of Decedent Hector Luis Tirado, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of Hector Luis Tirado, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3652. Plaintiff Angel Luis Tirado is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Hector Luis Tirado, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Hector Luis Tirado, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Hector Luis Tirado, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hector Luis Tirado, Jr. was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3653. Plaintiff Beverly J. Titus is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Parent of Decedent Alicia Nicole Titus, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alicia Nicole Titus and on behalf of all survivors of Alicia Nicole Titus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alicia Nicole Titus was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade

671

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 673 of 978

Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3654. Plaintiff John L. Titus is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Parent of Decedent Alicia Nicole Titus, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Alicia Nicole Titus and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3655. Plaintiff Maria Teresa Rueda De Torres is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Luis Eduardo Torres, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Luis Eduardo Torres and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3656. Plaintiff Monica Torres is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Luis Eduardo Torres, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Luis Eduardo Torres and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3657. Plaintiff Martin Toyen is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Amy E. Toyen, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Amy E. Toyen and on behalf of all survivors of Amy E. Toyen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Amy E. Toyen was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3658. Plaintiff Hadidjatou Traore is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Abdoul Karim Traore, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Abdoul Karim Traore and on behalf of all survivors of Abdoul Karim Traore and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

672

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 674 of 978

Abdoul Karim Traore was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3659. Plaintiff Elyse Travers is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Walter P. Travers, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Walter P. Travers and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3660. Plaintiff Rosemary Travers is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Walter P. Travers, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Walter P. Travers and on behalf of all survivors of Walter P. Travers and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Walter P. Travers was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3661. Plaintiff Kevin Travers is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Walter P. Travers, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Walter P. Travers and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3662. Plaintiff Brian Francis Travers is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Walter P. Travers, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Walter P. Travers and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3663. Plaintiff Sharon B. Schultz is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Karamo Trerra, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Karamo Trerra and on behalf of all survivors of Karamo Trerra and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karamo Trerra was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

673

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 675 of 978

3664. Plaintiff Brenda Trinidad is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael A. Trinidad, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3665. Plaintiff Carol Payne is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Sibling of Decedent Michael A. Trinidad, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3666. Plaintiff Betty Andrade is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael A. Trinidad, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3667. Plaintiff Jeanette Trinidad Rzek is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Michael A. Trinidad, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3668. Plaintiff Jane Trinidad Hennes is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael A. Trinidad, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3669. Plaintiff Millie Caseres Schifano is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Michael A. Trinidad, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3670. Plaintiff Denise Trinidad is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael A. Trinidad, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

674

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 676 of 978

3671. Plaintiff Monique Padilla-Ferrer is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Michael A. Trinidad, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael A. Trinidad and on behalf of all survivors of Michael A. Trinidad and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Trinidad was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3672. Plaintiff Robert Trinidad is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Michael A. Trinidad, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael A. Trinidad and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3673. Plaintiff Marie Claire Trost is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Gregory J. Trost, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gregory J. Trost and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3674. Plaintiff Jeanne Trost is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Gregory J. Trost, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Gregory J. Trost and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3675. Plaintiff George D. Trost is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Gregory J. Trost, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory J. Trost and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory J. Trost and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory J. Trost was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

675

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 677 of 978

3676. Plaintiff Renee M. Troy is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Child of Decedent Willie Quincy Troy, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Willie Quincy Troy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3677. Plaintiff Judy S. Troy is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Spouse of Decedent Willie Quincy Troy, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Willie Quincy Troy and on behalf of all survivors of Willie Quincy Troy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Willie Quincy Troy was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3678. Plaintiff Elizabeth Rachel Turner is a resident of United Kingdom, the Spouse of Decedent Simon James Turner, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Simon James Turner and on behalf of all survivors of Simon James Turner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Simon James Turner was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3679. Plaintiff John Richard Turner is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Simon James Turner, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Simon James Turner and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3680. Plaintiff Nancy Doris Tzemis is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jennifer Lynn Tzemis, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

676

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 678 of 978

Jennifer Lynn Tzemis was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3681. Plaintiff Sophia Tzemis is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jennifer Lynn Tzemis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3682. Plaintiff Nicole Tzemis is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jennifer Lynn Tzemis, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3683. Plaintiff Stamatios K. Tzemis is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jennifer Lynn Tzemis, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis and on behalf of all survivors of Jennifer Lynn Tzemis and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jennifer Lynn Tzemis was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3684. Plaintiff Linda Buffa is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Michael A. Uliano, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael A. Uliano and on behalf of all survivors of Michael A. Uliano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Uliano was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3685. Plaintiff Susan Ruth Blomberg is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Jonathan Uman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jonathan Uman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

677

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 679 of 978

3686. Plaintiff Anne Marie Vaccacio is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John Damien Vaccacio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Damien Vaccacio and on behalf of all survivors of John Damien Vaccacio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Damien Vaccacio was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3687. Plaintiff James R. Vaccacio is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John Damien Vaccacio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John Damien Vaccacio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3688. Plaintiff Christopher J. Vaccacio is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent John Damien Vaccacio, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Damien Vaccacio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3689. Plaintiff Donald Joseph Vadas is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent Bradley H. Vadas, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Bradley H. Vadas and on behalf of all survivors of Bradley H. Vadas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bradley H. Vadas was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3690. Plaintiff Carmen Garcia is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Felix Antonio Vale, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Felix Antonio Vale and on behalf of all survivors of Felix Antonio Vale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

678

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 680 of 978

Felix Antonio Vale was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3691. Plaintiff Carmen Garcia is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Ivan Vale, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ivan Vale and on behalf of all survivors of Ivan Vale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ivan Vale was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3692. Plaintiff Grissel Rodriguez Valentin is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Benito Valentin, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benito Valentin and on behalf of all survivors of Benito Valentin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Benito Valentin was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3693. Plaintiff DOE 08, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 08; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3694. Plaintiff Sarah B. Van Auken is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Kenneth Warren Van Auken, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Kenneth Warren Van Auken and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

679

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 681 of 978

3695. Plaintiff DOE 08 is a resident of the North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 08, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3696. Plaintiff DOE 08 is a resident of the New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 08, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3697. Plaintiff Lorie Jill Van Auken is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Kenneth Warren Van Auken, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth Warren Van Auken and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth Warren Van Auken and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth Warren Van Auken was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3698. Plaintiff DOE 08, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 08; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3699. Plaintiff Matthew D. Van Auken is a resident of the State of Oregon, the Child of Decedent Kenneth Warren Van Auken, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Kenneth Warren Van Auken and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3700. Plaintiff M. Rita Van Laere, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Daniel Maurice Van Laere; the Co-Administrators of her

680

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 682 of 978

Estate Rita M. Wiley and Paul Van Laere bring this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3701. Plaintiff Cheryl Rinbrand is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Fiancé of Decedent Daniel Maurice Van Laere, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Daniel Maurice Van Laere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3702. Plaintiff Jacqueline Van Laere is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Maurice Van Laere, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Maurice Van Laere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3703. Plaintiffs Rita M. Wiley and Paul Van Laere are residents of the State of New Jersey, and Siblings of Decedent Daniel Maurice Van Laere, and bring this action on behalf of the Estate of Daniel Maurice Van Laere and on behalf of all survivors of Daniel Maurice Van Laere and are entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Maurice Van Laere was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3704. Plaintiff Rita M. Wiley is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Maurice Van Laere, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Daniel Maurice Van Laere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3705. Plaintiff Paul Van Laere is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Daniel Maurice Van Laere, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of

681

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 683 of 978

Daniel Maurice Van Laere and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3706. Plaintiff Eileen Varacchi is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Frederick Varacchi, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frederick Varacchi and on behalf of all survivors of Frederick Varacchi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frederick Varacchi was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3707. Plaintiff Vasundara Varadhan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Gopalakrishnan Varadhan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gopalakrishnan Varadhan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3708. Plaintiff Srinivasa Varadhan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Gopalakrishnan Varadhan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gopalakrishnan Varadhan and on behalf of all survivors of Gopalakrishnan Varadhan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gopalakrishnan Varadhan was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3709. Plaintiff Rosa Caicedo is a resident of the State of New York, the Common Law Spouse of Decedent David Vargas, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Common Law Spouse of David Vargas and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

682

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 684 of 978

3710. Plaintiff DOE 53 is a resident of the New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 53, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3711. Plaintiff DOE 53 is a resident of the state of New York, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 53, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 53 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 53 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 53 was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3712. Plaintiff DOE 53, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent DOE 53; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3713. Plaintiff DOE 53, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent DOE 53; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3714. Plaintiff Eloisa Rodriguez is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Azael Vasquez, and brings this action on her own behalf as Fiancé and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Azael Vasquez and on behalf of all survivors of Azael Vasquez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Azael Vasquez was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

683

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 685 of 978

3715. Plaintiff Melissa Vazquez is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Arcangel Vazquez, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Arcangel Vazquez and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3716. Plaintiff Marcella T. Veling is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Lawrence J. Veling, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Lawrence J. Veling and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3717. Plaintiff Teresa Veling Czark is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Lawrence J. Veling, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Lawrence J. Veling and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3718. Plaintiff Marcella J. Tuohy is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Lawrence J. Veling, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Lawrence J. Veling and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3719. Plaintiff Diane J. Veling is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Lawrence J. Veling, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Lawrence J. Veling and on behalf of all survivors of Lawrence J. Veling and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lawrence J. Veling was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3720. Plaintiff Lisa A. Ventura is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Anthony M. Ventura, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Anthony M. Ventura and on behalf of all survivors of Anthony M. Ventura and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

684

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 686 of 978

Anthony M. Ventura was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3721. Plaintiff Marion Rita Paolo, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Loretta A. Vero; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3722. Plaintiff Catherine Pedersen is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Loretta A. Vero, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Fiduciary of the Estate of Loretta A. Vero and on behalf of all survivors of Loretta A. Vero and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Loretta A. Vero was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3723. Plaintiff Katherine Vialonga is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Christopher Vialonga, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Christopher Vialonga and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3724. Plaintiff Gary Vialonga is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Christopher Vialonga, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Vialonga and on behalf of all survivors of Christopher Vialonga and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Vialonga was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3725. Plaintiff Jill Robin Vicario is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Robert Vicario, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Robert Vicario and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Vicario

685

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 687 of 978

and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Vicario was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3726. Plaintiff Jeanette Vigiano is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John Thomas Vigiano, II, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John Thomas Vigiano, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3727. Plaintiff John T. Vigiano is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent John Thomas Vigiano, II, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of John Thomas Vigiano, II and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3728. Plaintiff Jeanette Vigiano is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Vincent Vigiano, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Joseph Vincent Vigiano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3729. Plaintiff Kathleen Vigiano is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Joseph Vincent Vigiano, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Vincent Vigiano and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Vincent Vigiano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Vincent Vigiano was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3730. Plaintiff John T. Vigiano is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Vincent Vigiano, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of

686

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 688 of 978

Joseph Vincent Vigiano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3731. Plaintiff Frances Vignola is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Frank J. Vignola, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Frank J. Vignola, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3732. Plaintiff Diane Frances Antolos is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Frank J. Vignola, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Frank J. Vignola, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3733. Plaintiff Ellen B. Vignola is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Frank J. Vignola, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank J. Vignola, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Frank J. Vignola, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank J. Vignola, Jr. was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3734. Plaintiff James Anthony Vignola is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Frank J. Vignola, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Frank J. Vignola, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3735. Plaintiff Antionette Vilardo, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Joseph B. Vilardo; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

687

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 689 of 978

3736. Plaintiff Diane Braitsch is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph B. Vilardo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph B. Vilardo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3737. Plaintiff Margaret Mahon is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph B. Vilardo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph B. Vilardo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3738. Plaintiff Janet Vilardo is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph B. Vilardo, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph B. Vilardo and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3739. Plaintiff Benedict Vilardo, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Joseph B. Vilardo; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3740. Plaintiff Tanya Villanueva Tepper is a resident of the State of Florida, the Fiancé of Decedent Sergio Villanueva, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Sergio Villanueva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3741. Plaintiff Delia Villanueva is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Sergio Villanueva, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sergio Villanueva and on behalf of all survivors of Sergio Villanueva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sergio Villanueva was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

688

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 690 of 978

3742. Plaintiff Maria Suarez is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sergio Villanueva, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sergio Villanueva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3743. Plaintiff Steve Villanueva is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Sergio Villanueva, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Sergio Villanueva and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3744. Plaintiff Lucille A. Vincent is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Melissa Vincent, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Melissa Vincent and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3745. Plaintiff Carrie B. Vincent is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Melissa Vincent, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Melissa Vincent and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3746. Plaintiff David Relf Vincent is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Melissa Vincent, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Melissa Vincent and on behalf of all survivors of Melissa Vincent and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Melissa Vincent was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3747. Plaintiff Matthew D. Vincent is a resident of the State of Wisconsin, the Sibling of Decedent Melissa Vincent, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Melissa Vincent and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3748. Plaintiff Nunzio G. Virgilio is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Francine Virgilio, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the

689

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 691 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Francine Virgilio and on behalf of all survivors of Francine Virgilio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francine Virgilio was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3749. Plaintiff Marie Visciano is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joseph Gerard Visciano, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joseph Gerard Visciano and on behalf of all survivors of Joseph Gerard Visciano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Gerard Visciano was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3750. Plaintiff Frank Visciano, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Joseph Gerard Visciano; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3751. Plaintiff Robert Visciano is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Gerard Visciano, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Gerard Visciano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3752. Plaintiff Jason Visciano is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Joseph Gerard Visciano, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Joseph Gerard Visciano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

690

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 692 of 978

3753. Plaintiff Ina Leventhal is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Joshua S. Vitale, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Joshua S. Vitale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3754. Plaintiff Susan R. Rosen is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Joshua S. Vitale, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Joshua S. Vitale and on behalf of all survivors of Joshua S. Vitale and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joshua S. Vitale was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3755. Plaintiff DOE 112 is a resident of the New York, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 112, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3756. Plaintiff Irma Vukosa, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Alfred Vukosa; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3757. Plaintiff Sonja M. Vukosa is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Alfred Vukosa, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alfred Vukosa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3758. Plaintiff Shirimattie Lalman is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Alfred Vukosa, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alfred Vukosa and on behalf of all survivors of Alfred Vukosa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alfred Vukosa was

691

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 693 of 978

killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3759. Plaintiff Sime Vukosa, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Alfred Vukosa; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3760. Plaintiff Austin Vukosa is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Alfred Vukosa, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Alfred Vukosa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3761. Plaintiff Nassima M. Wachtler is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Gregory Kamal Bruno Wachtler, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Gregory Kamal Bruno Wachtler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3762. Plaintiff Paul W. Wachtler is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Gregory Kamal Bruno Wachtler, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory Kamal Bruno Wachtler and on behalf of all survivors of Gregory Kamal Bruno Wachtler and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory Kamal Bruno Wachtler was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3763. Plaintiff Scott E. Wahlstrom is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent Mary Alice Wahlstrom, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Mary Alice Wahlstrom and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

692

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 694 of 978

3764. Plaintiff Michael O. Wahlstrom is a resident of the State of Oregon, the Child of Decedent Mary Alice Wahlstrom, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Alice Wahlstrom and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Alice Wahlstrom and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary Alice Wahlstrom was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3765. Plaintiff Mary Louise White is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Honor Elizabeth Wainio, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Honor Elizabeth Wainio and on behalf of all survivors of Honor Elizabeth Wainio and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Honor Elizabeth Wainio was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3766. Plaintiff Clara Rosario is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Wendy A. Wakeford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Wendy A. Wakeford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3767. Plaintiff Ada Dolch is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Wendy A. Wakeford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Wendy A. Wakeford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3768. Plaintiff Raquel Negron is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Wendy A. Wakeford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Wendy A. Wakeford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

693

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 695 of 978

3769. Plaintiff Miriam Paine is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of Decedent Wendy A. Wakeford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Wendy A. Wakeford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3770. Plaintiff Clara L. Pachomski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Wendy A. Wakeford, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Wendy A. Wakeford and on behalf of all survivors of Wendy A. Wakeford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wendy A. Wakeford was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3771. Plaintiff Edwin Rosario is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Wendy A. Wakeford, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Wendy A. Wakeford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3772. Plaintiff Laura Walker is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Benjamin James Walker, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Benjamin James Walker and on behalf of all survivors of Benjamin James Walker and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Benjamin James Walker was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3773. Plaintiff Noreen V. McDonough is a resident of the State of New York, the Fiancé of Decedent Mitchel Scott Wallace, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Fiancé of Mitchel Scott Wallace and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

694

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 696 of 978

3774. Plaintiff Rita Wallace is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Mitchel Scott Wallace, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Mitchel Scott Wallace and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3775. Plaintiff Michele Miller is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Mitchel Scott Wallace, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mitchel Scott Wallace and on behalf of all survivors of Mitchel Scott Wallace and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mitchel Scott Wallace was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3776. Plaintiff Ken Wallace is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Mitchel Scott Wallace, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Mitchel Scott Wallace and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3777. Plaintiff Susan Ann Wallace is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Roy Wallace, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roy Wallace and on behalf of all survivors of Roy Wallace and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roy Wallace was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3778. Plaintiff Raina Wallens is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Matthew Blake Wallens, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew Blake Wallens and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew Blake Wallens and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

695

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 697 of 978

herein. Matthew Blake Wallens was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3779. Plaintiff Ashley Jordan Wallens is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Matthew Blake Wallens, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Matthew Blake Wallens and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3780. Plaintiff Chrislan Fuller Manuel is a resident of the State of Michigan, the Niece of Decedent Meta L. Waller, and brings this action on her own behalf as Niece and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Meta L. Waller and on behalf of all survivors of Meta L. Waller and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Meta L. Waller was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3781. Plaintiff Allison A. Dimarzio is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Barbara P. Walsh, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Barbara P. Walsh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3782. Plaintiff Jennifer L. Landstrom is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Barbara P. Walsh, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Barbara P. Walsh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3783. Plaintiff Jeffrey M. Walsh is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Barbara P. Walsh, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Barbara P. Walsh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3784. Plaintiff James J. Walsh is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Barbara P. Walsh, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the

696

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 698 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of Barbara P. Walsh and on behalf of all survivors of Barbara P. Walsh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barbara P. Walsh was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3785. Plaintiff James J. Walsh, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Barbara P. Walsh, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Barbara P. Walsh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3786. Plaintiff Kate Walsh is a resident of the State of Florida, the Spouse of Decedent James Walsh, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Walsh and on behalf of all survivors of James Walsh and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Walsh was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3787. Plaintiff Jennie Walz is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey P. Walz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jeffrey P. Walz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3788. Plaintiff Karen Ciaccio is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey P. Walz, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey P. Walz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3789. Plaintiff Rani Deborah Walz is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Jeffrey P. Walz, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jeffrey P. Walz and on behalf of all survivors of Jeffrey P. Walz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey P. Walz was

697

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 699 of 978

killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3790. Plaintiff Raymond G. Walz is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey P. Walz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jeffrey P. Walz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3791. Plaintiff Raymond E. Walz is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey P. Walz, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey P. Walz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3792. Plaintiff Wen Shi is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Weibin Wang, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Weibin Wang and on behalf of all survivors of Weibin Wang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Weibin Wang was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3793. Plaintiff Zhenjie Wang is a resident of China, the Parent of Decedent Weibin Wang, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Weibin Wang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3794. Plaintiff Denis A. Warchola is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Warchola, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael Warchola and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Warchola and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Warchola was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

698

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 700 of 978

3795. Plaintiff Michael Warchola, Sr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Michael Warchola; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3796. Plaintiff Victoria Randall is a resident of the State of Maine, the Parent of Decedent Stephen Gordon Ward, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Stephen Gordon Ward and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3797. Plaintiff Susan Moore is a resident of the State of Maine, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Gordon Ward, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Gordon Ward and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3798. Plaintiff Kathryn Ward Hazel is a resident of the State of Maine, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Gordon Ward, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Gordon Ward and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3799. Plaintiff Gordon M. Ward is a resident of the State of Florida, the Parent of Decedent Stephen Gordon Ward, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Stephen Gordon Ward and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3800. Plaintiff Kenneth R. Ward is a resident of the State of Nevada, the Sibling of Decedent Stephen Gordon Ward, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Stephen Gordon Ward and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3801. Plaintiff Susanne Ward Baker, now deceased, was a resident of the State of California, and the Parent of Decedent Timothy Ray Ward; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3802. The Representative of the Estate of the Estate of Timothy Ray Ward brings this action on behalf of all survivors of Timothy Ray Ward and is entitled to recover damages on the

699

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 701 of 978

causes of action set forth herein. Timothy Ray Ward was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3803. Plaintiff Doyle Raymond Ward, now deceased, was a resident of the State of California, and the Parent of Decedent Timothy Ray Ward; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3804. Plaintiff Maria A. Waring is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent James Arthur Waring, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Arthur Waring and on behalf of all survivors of James Arthur Waring and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Arthur Waring was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3805. Plaintiff Lettie Washington is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Derrick Christopher Washington, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Derrick Christopher Washington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3806. Plaintiff Keisha Washington is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Derrick Christopher Washington, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Derrick Christopher Washington and on behalf of all survivors of Derrick Christopher Washington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Derrick Christopher Washington was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

700

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 702 of 978

3807. Plaintiff Tracey Washington is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Derrick Christopher Washington, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Derrick Christopher Washington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3808. Plaintiff Brandon Washington is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Derrick Christopher Washington, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Derrick Christopher Washington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3809. Plaintiff Earnest Washington, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Derrick Christopher Washington, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Derrick Christopher Washington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3810. Plaintiff Barbara Waters is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Charles Waters, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Charles Waters and on behalf of all survivors of Charles Waters and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles Waters was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3811. Plaintiff Joanne Marie Waters is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent James Thomas Waters, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of James Thomas Waters, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

701

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 703 of 978

3812. Plaintiff Karen Marie Smart is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent James Thomas Waters, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Thomas Waters, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of James Thomas Waters, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Thomas Waters, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3813. Plaintiff Kristopher T. Waters is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent James Thomas Waters, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of James Thomas Waters, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3814. Plaintiff Janice Waters is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Patrick J. Waters, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick J. Waters and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick J. Waters and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick J. Waters was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3815. Plaintiff DOE 74 is a resident of the Florida, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 74, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3816. Plaintiff Zoe Louise Ghirarduzzi is a resident of United Kingdom, the Child of Decedent Dinah Webster, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Dinah Webster and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

702

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 704 of 978

3817. Plaintiff Sonia Hopwood is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Dinah Webster, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Dinah Webster and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3818. Plaintiff Peter Herbert Hopwood is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Dinah Webster, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dinah Webster and on behalf of all survivors of Dinah Webster and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dinah Webster was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3819. Plaintiff Clive Hopwood is a resident of Belgium, the Sibling of Decedent Dinah Webster, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Dinah Webster and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3820. Plaintiff Lisa Anne Weems is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent William Michael Weems, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Michael Weems and on behalf of all survivors of William Michael Weems and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Michael Weems was killed on board United Airlines Flight 175 that crashed into World Trade Center South Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3821. Plaintiff Mary P. Weinberg, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Michael T. Weinberg; the Representative of her Estate, Marilyn Weinberg, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

703

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 705 of 978

3822. Plaintiff Patricia Wangerman is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael T. Weinberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael T. Weinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3823. Plaintiff Morton Weinberg is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael T. Weinberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael T. Weinberg and on behalf of all survivors of Michael T. Weinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael T. Weinberg was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3824. Plaintiff John Weinberg is a resident of the State of United States, the Sibling of Decedent Michael T. Weinberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael T. Weinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3825. Plaintiff Marilyn Weinberg is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Steven Weinberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Steven Weinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3826. Plaintiff Laurie Sue Weinberg is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Steven Weinberg, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven Weinberg and on behalf of all survivors of Steven Weinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Weinberg was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3827. Plaintiff Leonard Weinberg, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Steven Weinberg; the Representative of his Estate, Marilyn

704

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 706 of 978

Weinberg, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3828. Plaintiff Paul Weinberg is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Steven Weinberg, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Steven Weinberg and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3829. Plaintiff Kathlyn Mae Carriker is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent Steven George Weinstein, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Steven George Weinstein and on behalf of all survivors of Steven George Weinstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven George Weinstein was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3830. Plaintiff Alissa Loriann Weiss is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent David Martin Weiss, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of David Martin Weiss and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3831. Plaintiff Joan Weiss Prowler is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Parent of Decedent David Martin Weiss, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of David Martin Weiss and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3832. Plaintiff Michele Weiss-Little is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent David Martin Weiss, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of David Martin Weiss and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3833. Plaintiff Karla Weiss is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Spouse of Decedent David Martin Weiss, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the

705

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 707 of 978

Personal Representative of the Estate of David Martin Weiss and on behalf of all survivors of David Martin Weiss and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Martin Weiss was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3834. Plaintiff Michael Paul Weiss is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Child of Decedent David Martin Weiss, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of David Martin Weiss and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3835. Plaintiff Barry Weiss is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent David Martin Weiss, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of David Martin Weiss and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3836. Plaintiff Julia Ann Wells is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Vincent Michael Wells, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Vincent Michael Wells and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Michael Wells and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Michael Wells was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3837. Plaintiff DOE 137 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 137, and brings this action on her own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3838. Plaintiff Charles Thomas Wells is a resident of United Kingdom, the Parent of Decedent Vincent Michael Wells, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Vincent Michael Wells and on behalf of all survivors of Vincent Michael Wells and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

706

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 708 of 978

herein. Vincent Michael Wells was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3839. Plaintiff DOE 137 is a resident of the United Kingdom, the Sibling of Decedent DOE 137, and brings this action on his own behalf and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3840. Plaintiff Adele Nina Welty is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Timothy Welty, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Timothy Welty and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3841. Plaintiff Shu-Nu Chen is a resident of the State of Texas, the Parent of Decedent Ssu-Hui Wen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Ssu-Hui Wen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3842. Plaintiff Yun-Ju Wen is a resident of the State of Texas, the Sibling of Decedent Ssu-Hui Wen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ssu-Hui Wen and on behalf of all survivors of Ssu-Hui Wen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ssu-Hui Wen was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3843. Plaintiff Shun-Fa Wen is a resident of the State of Texas, the Parent of Decedent Ssu-Hui Wen, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Ssu-Hui Wen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3844. Plaintiff Meredith W. Nelson is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Peter Matthew West, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of Peter Matthew West and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

707

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 709 of 978

3845. Plaintiff Mary Louise Ball is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Matthew West, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3846. Plaintiff Catherine Cecilia McLaughlin is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Matthew West, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3847. Plaintiff Regina Marie Townsend is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Matthew West, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3848. Plaintiff Eileen K. West is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Peter Matthew West, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Peter Matthew West and on behalf of all survivors of Peter Matthew West and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Matthew West was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3849. Plaintiff Matthew Peter West is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Child of Decedent Peter Matthew West, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Peter Matthew West and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3850. Plaintiff Gregory J. West is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Matthew West, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

708

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 710 of 978

3851. Plaintiff Vincent Matthew West is a resident of the State of Vermont, the Sibling of Decedent Peter Matthew West, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Peter Matthew West and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3852. Plaintiff Arthur H. West, Jr., now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Sibling of Decedent Peter Matthew West; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3853. Plaintiff Patricia J. Whalen is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Parent of Decedent Meredith Lynn Whalen, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Administrator of the Estate of Meredith Lynn Whalen and on behalf of all survivors of Meredith Lynn Whalen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Meredith Lynn Whalen was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3854. Plaintiff Kristen E. Whalen is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Meredith Lynn Whalen, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Meredith Lynn Whalen and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3855. Plaintiff Joan A. Whelan is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Eugene Michael Whelan, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Eugene Michael Whelan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3856. Plaintiff Alfred L. Whelan, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Eugene Michael Whelan, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Eugene Michael Whelan and on behalf of all

709

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 711 of 978

survivors of Eugene Michael Whelan and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eugene Michael Whelan was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3857. Plaintiff Joan A. White is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent James Patrick White, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of James Patrick White and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3858. Plaintiff Alphonse J. White, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent James Patrick White; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3859. Plaintiff Michael John White is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent James Patrick White, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of James Patrick White and on behalf of all survivors of James Patrick White and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Patrick White was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3860. Plaintiff Elaine Clancy, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth W. White; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3861. Plaintiff Laura Jeanne Kenny is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth W. White, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth W. White and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

710

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 712 of 978

3862. Plaintiff Elizabeth Ann Alverson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth W. White, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth W. White and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3863. Plaintiff Catherine C. White is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Kenneth W. White, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kenneth W. White and on behalf of all survivors of Kenneth W. White and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth W. White was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3864. Plaintiff Thomas George White is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth W. White, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth W. White and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3865. Plaintiff Allison Vadhan is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent Kristin White-Gould, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Kristin White-Gould and on behalf of all survivors of Kristin White-Gould and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kristin White-Gould was killed on board United Airlines Flight 93 that crashed into Shanksville, Pennsylvania as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3866. Plaintiff Carol Ann Whitford is a resident of the State of Delaware, the Parent of Decedent Mark P. Whitford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Mark P. Whitford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

711

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 713 of 978

3867. Plaintiff Lisa A. Walker is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Mark P. Whitford, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Mark P. Whitford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3868. Plaintiff Renee Whitford is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Mark P. Whitford, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark P. Whitford and on behalf of all survivors of Mark P. Whitford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark P. Whitford was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3869. Plaintiff Roger Paul Whitford is a resident of the State of Delaware, the Parent of Decedent Mark P. Whitford, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Mark P. Whitford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3870. Plaintiff Christopher Whitford is a resident of the State of Delaware, the Sibling of Decedent Mark P. Whitford, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark P. Whitford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3871. Plaintiff Dennis Whitford is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Mark P. Whitford, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Mark P. Whitford and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3872. Plaintiff Ruth S. Koch, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Georgia, and the Parent of Decedent Leslie Ann Whittington; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

712

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 714 of 978

3873. Plaintiff Sara Guest is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Leslie Ann Whittington, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Leslie Ann Whittington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3874. Plaintiff Horace G. Whittington is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Parent of Decedent Leslie Ann Whittington, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Leslie Ann Whittington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3875. Plaintiff Michael T. Whittington is a resident of the State of Minnesota, the Sibling of Decedent Leslie Ann Whittington, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Leslie Ann Whittington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3876. Plaintiff Kirk Whittington is a resident of the State of Georgia, the Sibling of Decedent Leslie Ann Whittington, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Leslie Ann Whittington and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3877. Plaintiff Margaret Winifred Wholey is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael T. Wholey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael T. Wholey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3878. Plaintiff Maryann Wholey is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael T. Wholey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael T. Wholey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

713

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 715 of 978

3879. Plaintiff Diane Wholey Bugge is a resident of the State of North Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Michael T. Wholey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael T. Wholey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3880. Plaintiff Bernadette Wholey is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael T. Wholey, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Michael T. Wholey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3881. Plaintiff Jennifer Wholey is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Michael T. Wholey, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Michael T. Wholey and on behalf of all survivors of Michael T. Wholey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael T. Wholey was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3882. Plaintiff Michael Joseph Wholey is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael T. Wholey, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Michael T. Wholey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3883. Plaintiff Marc Wieman is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Mary Wieman, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mary Wieman and on behalf of all survivors of Mary Wieman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary Wieman was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

714

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 716 of 978

3884. Plaintiff Wilma Wiener is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey David Wiener, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Jeffrey David Wiener and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3885. Plaintiff Robin Kim Wiener is a resident of the State of District of Columbia, the Sibling of Decedent Jeffrey David Wiener, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Jeffrey David Wiener and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3886. Plaintiff Donald S. Wiener is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Jeffrey David Wiener, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Jeffrey David Wiener and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3887. Plaintiff June M. Wildman, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Alison M. Wildman; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3888. Plaintiff Jill Saladino is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Alison M. Wildman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Alison M. Wildman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3889. Plaintiff Robert E. Wildman is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Alison M. Wildman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Alison M. Wildman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3890. Plaintiff Richard M. Borquist is a resident of the State of California, the Sibling of Decedent Alison M. Wildman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Alison M. Wildman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

715

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 717 of 978

3891. Plaintiff Arthur S. Wildman, III, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Sibling of Decedent Alison M. Wildman; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3892. Plaintiff Arthur S. Wildman, Jr. is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Alison M. Wildman, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alison M. Wildman and on behalf of all survivors of Alison M. Wildman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alison M. Wildman was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3893. Plaintiff Margaret E. Wilkinson is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Glenn E. Wilkinson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Glenn E. Wilkinson and on behalf of all survivors of Glenn E. Wilkinson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Glenn E. Wilkinson was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3894. Plaintiff Shirley N. Willcher is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of Decedent Ernest M. Willcher, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ernest M. Willcher and on behalf of all survivors of Ernest M. Willcher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ernest M. Willcher was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

716

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 718 of 978

3895. Plaintiff Joel Willcher is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of Decedent Ernest M. Willcher, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Ernest M. Willcher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3896. Plaintiff Benjamin Willcher is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of Decedent Ernest M. Willcher, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Ernest M. Willcher and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3897. Plaintiff Lucille C. Willett is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Parent of Decedent John Charles Willett, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of John Charles Willett and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3898. Plaintiff Ronald J. Willett is a resident of the State of Missouri, the Parent of Decedent John Charles Willett, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Charles Willett and on behalf of all survivors of John Charles Willett and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Charles Willett was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3899. Plaintiff Sherri A. Williams, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Connecticut, and the Parent of Decedent Candace Lee Williams; the Representative of her Estate, Corey G. Gaudioso, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3900. Plaintiff Corey G. Gaudioso is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent Candace Lee Williams, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Candace Lee Williams and on behalf of all survivors of Candace Lee Williams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

717

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 719 of 978

herein. Candace Lee Williams was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3901. Plaintiff Valrie M. Williams is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Crossley R. Williams, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Crossley R. Williams, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3902. Plaintiff Crossley R. Williams, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Crossley R. Williams, Jr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Crossley R. Williams, Jr. and on behalf of all survivors of Crossley R. Williams, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Crossley R. Williams, Jr. was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3903. Plaintiff Debra Johnson is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Domestic Partner of Decedent David J. Williams, and brings this action on her own behalf as Domestic Partner and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David J. Williams and on behalf of all survivors of David J. Williams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David J. Williams was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3904. Plaintiff Tammy G. Williams is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Spouse of Decedent Dwayne Williams, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Dwayne Williams and on behalf of all survivors of Dwayne Williams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

718

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 720 of 978

Dwayne Williams was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3905. Plaintiff Patricia Ann Williams is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kevin Michael Williams, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Kevin Michael Williams and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Michael Williams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Michael Williams was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3906. Plaintiff Roger Michael Williams is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Kevin Michael Williams, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Kevin Michael Williams and on behalf of all survivors of Kevin Michael Williams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Michael Williams was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3907. Plaintiff Murna T. Williams is a resident of the State of Delaware, the Parent of Decedent Louie Anthony Williams, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Louie Anthony Williams and on behalf of all survivors of Louie Anthony Williams and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louie Anthony Williams was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3908. Plaintiff Lucy Williamson, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Connecticut, and the Parent of Decedent John P. Williamson; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

719

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 721 of 978

3909. Plaintiff Mary B. Williamson is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent John P. Williamson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John P. Williamson and on behalf of all survivors of John P. Williamson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John P. Williamson was killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3910. Plaintiff George P. Williamson, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Sibling of Decedent John P. Williamson; the Representative of his Estate, Sally A. Williamson, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3911. Plaintiff Maureen Ruth Halvorson is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent William Eben Wilson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of William Eben Wilson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3912. Plaintiff Jeanne McDermott is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent William Eben Wilson, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of William Eben Wilson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3913. Plaintiff Elizabeth Ann Payne is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent William Eben Wilson, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Eben Wilson and on behalf of all survivors of William Eben Wilson and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Eben Wilson was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

720

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 722 of 978

3914. Plaintiff Joan W. Winton is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Parent of Decedent David H. Winton, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of David H. Winton and on behalf of all survivors of David H. Winton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David H. Winton was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3915. Plaintiff Sara Winton Coffey is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Sibling of Decedent David H. Winton, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of David H. Winton and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3916. Plaintiff Elaine Winuk is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Glenn J. Winuk, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Glenn J. Winuk and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3917. Plaintiff Seymour Winuk, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Glenn J. Winuk; the Representative of his Estate, Jay S. Winuk, brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3918. Plaintiff Jeff M. Winuk is a resident of the State of South Carolina, the Sibling of Decedent Glenn J. Winuk, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Glenn J. Winuk and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3919. Plaintiff Jay S. Winuk is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Glenn J. Winuk, and brings this action on his own behalf as Sibling and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of Glenn J. Winuk and on behalf of all survivors of Glenn J. Winuk and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Glenn J. Winuk was

721

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 723 of 978

killed in the World Trade Center area as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3920. Plaintiff Carol D. Wisniewski is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Frank Thomas Wisniewski, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Frank Thomas Wisniewski and on behalf of all survivors of Frank Thomas Wisniewski and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Thomas Wisniewski was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3921. Plaintiff Ute Mitchell is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Parent of Decedent Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3922. Plaintiff Birgit Wiswe is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, the Sibling of Decedent Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3923. Plaintiff Victor M. Turcios is a resident of the State of Pennsylvania, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sigrid Charlotte Wiswe was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

722

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 724 of 978

3924. Plaintiff Barbara Wittenstein is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Robert Wittenstein, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Michael Robert Wittenstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3925. Plaintiff Caryn Hinson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Robert Wittenstein, and brings this action on her own behalf as Sibling and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael Robert Wittenstein and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Robert Wittenstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Robert Wittenstein was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3926. Plaintiff Arnold R. Wittenstein is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Michael Robert Wittenstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Co-Administrator of the Estate of Michael Robert Wittenstein and on behalf of all survivors of Michael Robert Wittenstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Robert Wittenstein was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3927. Plaintiff Jeffrey Wittenstein is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Michael Robert Wittenstein, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Michael Robert Wittenstein and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3928. Plaintiff Susan Wohlforth is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Martin Phillips Wohlforth, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as

723

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 725 of 978

the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Phillips Wohlforth and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Phillips Wohlforth and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martin Phillips Wohlforth was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3929. Plaintiff DOE 26 is a resident of the state of New York, the Parent of Decedent DOE 26, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 26 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 26 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 26 was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3930. Plaintiff Mary Elizabeth Woodall is a resident of the State of Arizona, the Parent of Decedent Brent James Woodall, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Brent James Woodall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3931. Plaintiff Erin Elizabeth Konstantinow is a resident of the State of Alabama, the Sibling of Decedent Brent James Woodall, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Brent James Woodall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3932. Plaintiff John W. Woodall, now deceased, was a resident of the State of California, and the Parent of Decedent Brent James Woodall; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3933. Plaintiff Craig Walker Woodall is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Sibling of Decedent Brent James Woodall, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Brent James Woodall and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

724

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 726 of 978

3934. Plaintiff Joyce A. Woods is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent James Woods, and brings this action on her own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of James Woods and on behalf of all survivors of James Woods and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Woods was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3935. Plaintiff Eileen J. Woods is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent James Woods, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of James Woods and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3936. Plaintiff John F. Woods, Jr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent James Woods, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the CoAdministrator of the Estate of James Woods and on behalf of all survivors of James Woods and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Woods was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3937. Plaintiff Eileen Woods is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Patrick Woods, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Patrick Woods and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3938. Plaintiff Chris Woods is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick Woods, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick Woods and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

725

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 727 of 978

3939. Plaintiff Thomas Woods is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Patrick Woods, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Patrick Woods and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3940. Plaintiff Patrick Woods, Sr. is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Patrick Woods, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Patrick Woods and on behalf of all survivors of Patrick Woods and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Woods was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3941. Plaintiff Pamela Woodwell Geerdes is a resident of the State of Minnesota, the Sibling of Decedent Richard H. Woodwell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Richard H. Woodwell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3942. Plaintiff Linda Preston Woodwell is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Richard H. Woodwell, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Richard H. Woodwell and on behalf of all survivors of Richard H. Woodwell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard H. Woodwell was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3943. Plaintiff John Knowles Woodwell, III is a resident of the State of Washington, the Sibling of Decedent Richard H. Woodwell, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Richard H. Woodwell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

726

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 728 of 978

3944. Plaintiff Mary A. Otto, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent David T. Wooley; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3945. Plaintiff Edgar B. Wooley, III is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent David T. Wooley, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of David T. Wooley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3946. Plaintiff Timothy Edwin Works is a resident of Victoria, Canada, the Sibling of Decedent John Bentley Works, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of John Bentley Works and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3947. Plaintiff Karen L. Wortley is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Martin Wortley, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Martin Wortley and on behalf of all survivors of Martin Wortley and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martin Wortley was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3948. Plaintiff DOE 01 is a resident of the state of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent DOE 01, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and on behalf of all survivors of DOE 01 and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of DOE 01 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 01 was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3949. Plaintiff Martha Oliverio Wright is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent John Wayne Wright, III, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse

727

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 729 of 978

and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John Wayne Wright, III and on behalf of all survivors of John Wayne Wright, III and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Wayne Wright, III was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3950. Plaintiff Nancy Yambem is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Jupiter Yambem, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Jupiter Yambem and on behalf of all survivors of Jupiter Yambem and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jupiter Yambem was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3951. Plaintiff Santi Yambem is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Jupiter Yambem, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Jupiter Yambem and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3952. Plaintiff Lorraine Yamnicky Dixon is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of Decedent John David Yamnicky, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of John David Yamnicky, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3953. Plaintiff Jennifer Lynn Yamnicky is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Child of Decedent John David Yamnicky, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Child of John David Yamnicky, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3954. Plaintiff Janet W. Yamnicky is a resident of the State of Maryland, the Spouse of Decedent John David Yamnicky, Sr., and brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of

728

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 730 of 978

John David Yamnicky, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3955. Plaintiff Mark Yamnicky is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent John David Yamnicky, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of John David Yamnicky, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3956. Plaintiff John David Yamnicky, Jr. is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Child of Decedent John David Yamnicky, Sr., and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of John David Yamnicky, Sr. and on behalf of all survivors of John David Yamnicky, Sr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John David Yamnicky, Sr. was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3957. Plaintiff Ajitha Vemulapalli is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Suresh Yanamadala, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Suresh Yanamadala and on behalf of all survivors of Suresh Yanamadala and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Suresh Yanamadala was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3958. Plaintiff David M. Yancey is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Vicki L. Yancey, and brings this action on his own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Vicki L. Yancey and on behalf of all survivors of Vicki L. Yancey and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vicki L.

729

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 731 of 978

Yancey was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3959. Plaintiff Rui Zheng is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Child of Decedent Shuyin Yang, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Shuyin Yang and on behalf of all survivors of Shuyin Yang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Shuyin Yang was killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3960. Plaintiff Shidong Zheng is a resident of Japan, the Child of Decedent Shuyin Yang, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Shuyin Yang and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3961. Plaintiff Michele Yarnell is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Matthew David Yarnell, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Matthew David Yarnell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3962. Plaintiff Ted Yarnell is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Matthew David Yarnell, and brings this action on his own behalf as Parent and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Matthew David Yarnell and on behalf of all survivors of Matthew David Yarnell and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew David Yarnell was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001.

730

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 732 of 978

3963. Plaintiff Adele Pearl, now deceased, was a resident of the State of Florida, and the Parent of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3964. Plaintiff Bonnie Shimel is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3965. Plaintiff Lorna Kaye is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3966. Plaintiff Ina Stanley is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3967. Plaintiff Hal Yaskulka is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Myrna Yaskulka and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3968. Plaintiff Brian Yaskulka is a resident of the State of California, the Child of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Myrna Yaskulka and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3969. Plaintiff Jay Yaskulka is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka, and brings this action on his own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Myrna Yaskulka and on behalf of all survivors of Myrna Yaskulka and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Myrna

731

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 733 of 978

Yaskulka was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3970. Plaintiff Shawn Pearl is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3971. Plaintiff Philip Pearl is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3972. Plaintiff Ivan Pearl is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Myrna Yaskulka, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Myrna Yaskulka and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3973. Plaintiff Kimberly G. York is a resident of the State of Connecticut, the Spouse of Decedent Edward Philip York, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Edward Philip York and on behalf of all survivors of Edward Philip York and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Philip York was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3974. Plaintiff Mary E. Peled is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Kevin Patrick York, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin Patrick York and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3975. Plaintiff Susan York is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Kevin Patrick York, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Kevin Patrick York and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

732

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 734 of 978

3976. Plaintiff Felicia Young is a resident of the State of Virginia, the Spouse of Decedent Donald McArthur Young, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Donald McArthur Young and on behalf of all survivors of Donald McArthur Young and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald McArthur Young was killed at Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3977. Plaintiff Mehasen A. Zakhary is a resident of Egypt, the Sibling of Decedent Adel A. Zakhary, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Adel A. Zakhary and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3978. Plaintiff Nadia A. Zakhary is a resident of Egypt, the Sibling of Decedent Adel A. Zakhary, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Adel A. Zakhary and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3979. Plaintiff Nagat H. Zakhary is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Adel A. Zakhary, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Adel A. Zakhary and on behalf of all survivors of Adel A. Zakhary and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Adel A. Zakhary was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3980. Plaintiff George Adel Agaiby is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Child of Decedent Adel A. Zakhary, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Adel A. Zakhary and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

733

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 735 of 978

3981. Plaintiff Talat A. Zakhary is a resident of Egypt, the Sibling of Decedent Adel A. Zakhary, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Adel A. Zakhary and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3982. Plaintiff Patricia Zampieri is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Robert Alan Zampieri, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Robert Alan Zampieri and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3983. Plaintiff Robert Zampieri, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New Jersey, and the Parent of Decedent Robert Alan Zampieri; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3984. Representative of the Estate of Robert Alan Zampieri brings this action on behalf of the Estate of Robert Alan Zampieri and on behalf of all survivors of Robert Alan Zampieri and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Alan Zampieri was killed in One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3985. Plaintiff Jill Zangrilli is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Spouse of Decedent Mark Zangrilli, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Mark Zangrilli and on behalf of all survivors of Mark Zangrilli and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Zangrilli was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3986. Plaintiff Sheila A. Kiernan is a resident of the State of Massachusetts, the Spouse of Decedent Christopher Rudolph Zarba, Jr., and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Christopher Rudolph Zarba, Jr. and on behalf

734

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 736 of 978

of all survivors of Christopher Rudolph Zarba, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Rudolph Zarba, Jr. was killed on board American Airlines Flight 11 that crashed into the World Trade Center North Tower as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3987. Plaintiff Felice Zaslow is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Ira Zaslow, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Ira Zaslow and on behalf of all survivors of Ira Zaslow and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ira Zaslow was killed at One World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3988. Plaintiff Adam Zaslow is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Ira Zaslow, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Ira Zaslow and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3989. Plaintiff Bryan Zaslow is a resident of the State of New York, the Child of Decedent Ira Zaslow, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Ira Zaslow and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3990. Plaintiff Ruth Zelman is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Kenneth Albert Zelman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth Albert Zelman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3991. Plaintiff Carrie Burlock is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth Albert Zelman, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of

735

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 737 of 978

Kenneth Albert Zelman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3992. Plaintiff Jack Zelman is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Parent of Decedent Kenneth Albert Zelman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Kenneth Albert Zelman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3993. Plaintiff Barry Zelman is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Kenneth Albert Zelman, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Kenneth Albert Zelman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3994. Plaintiff Leona Zeplin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Marc Scott Zeplin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Parent of Marc Scott Zeplin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3995. Plaintiff Joslin Zeplin is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Marc Scott Zeplin, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Marc Scott Zeplin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3996. Plaintiff Leonard Zeplin is a resident of the State of New York, the Parent of Decedent Marc Scott Zeplin, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Parent of Marc Scott Zeplin and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3997. Plaintiff Rui Zheng is a resident of the State of Colorado, the Child of Decedent Yuguang Zheng, and brings this action on her own behalf as Child and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Yuguang Zheng and on behalf of all survivors of Yuguang Zheng and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Yuguang Zheng was

736

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 738 of 978

killed on board American Airlines Flight 77 that crashed into the Pentagon as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 3998. Plaintiff Shidong Zheng is a resident of Japan, the Child of Decedent Yuguang Zheng, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of Yuguang Zheng and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 3999. Plaintiff Rosemarie C. Martie is a resident of the State of New Jersey, the Sibling of Decedent Salvatore J. Zisa, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Salvatore J. Zisa and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 4000. Plaintiff Sue Zucker, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Andrew Steven Zucker; the Representative of her Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 4001. Plaintiff Cheryl Dianne Shames is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew Steven Zucker, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew Steven Zucker and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 4002. Plaintiff Gayle Mosenson is a resident of the State of New York, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew Steven Zucker, and brings this action on her own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew Steven Zucker and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 4003. Plaintiff Saul Zucker, now deceased, was a resident of the State of New York, and the Parent of Decedent Andrew Steven Zucker; the Representative of his Estate brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

737

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 739 of 978

4004. Plaintiff Stuart Craig Zucker is a resident of the State of Florida, the Sibling of Decedent Andrew Steven Zucker, and brings this action on his own behalf as the Sibling of Andrew Steven Zucker and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 4005. Plaintiff Alla Plakht is a resident of the State of New York, the Spouse of Decedent Igor Zukelman, and brings this action on her own behalf as Spouse and as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Igor Zukelman and on behalf of all survivors of Igor Zukelman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Igor Zukelman was killed at Two World Trade Center as a result of a terrorist attack on the World Trade Center Towers in New York City on September 11, 2001. 4006. Yvonne V. Abdool, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Yvonne V. Abdool was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4007. Celso J Abreu, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Celso J Abreu was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4008. John J. Acerno, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. Acerno was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

738

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 740 of 978

4009. Humberto R. Acosta, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Humberto R. Acosta was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4010. Kevin John Adams, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin John Adams was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4011. Darryl J. Adone, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Darryl J. Adone was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4012. Mark Aiken, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Aiken was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4013. James F. Albach, Jr., a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James F. Albach, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4014. Thomas Albert, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas

739

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 741 of 978

Albert was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4015. Karium Ali, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karium Ali was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4016. Ronald Allen, a resident of Maryland, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald Allen was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4017. Ingrid Alleyne-Robertson, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ingrid Alleyne-Robertson was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4018. Ivan Almendarez, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ivan Almendarez, Jr. was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4019. Neil Alper, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neil Alper was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

740

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 742 of 978

4020. Leonor Alvarez, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Leonor Alvarez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4021. Robert E. Alverson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert E. Alverson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4022. Jocelyne Ambroise, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jocelyne Ambroise was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4023. Mitchell B. Amerbach, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mitchell B. Amerbach was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4024. Douglas William Anderson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Douglas William Anderson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4025. Thomas Anderson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

741

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 743 of 978

Thomas Anderson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4026. Morien Angaroo, a resident of the United States, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Morien Angaroo was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4027. Ioannis Antoniadis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ioannis Antoniadis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4028. Joseph P. Antony, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph P. Antony was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4029. Daniel J. Archbold, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel J. Archbold was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4030. Peter Archer, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Archer was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

742

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 744 of 978

4031. Tony Archer, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Tony Archer was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4032. Joseph Ariola, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Ariola was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4033. Michael Arniero, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Arniero was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4034. Cynthia Arnold, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cynthia Arnold was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4035. Suzanne Arnold, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Suzanne Arnold was present at Five World Trade Center - Northeast Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4036. Benjamin Arroyo, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

743

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 745 of 978

Benjamin Arroyo was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4037. Andrea L. Asbury, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andrea L. Asbury was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4038. Shawn Ashe, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Shawn Ashe was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4039. Philipson Azenabor, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philipson Azenabor was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4040. George Bachmann, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George Bachmann was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4041. Paul J. Bader, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul J. Bader was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

744

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 746 of 978

4042. Diana Baez, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Diana Baez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4043. Lynette Bangaree, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lynette Bangaree was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4044. Gentil Baptiste, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gentil Baptiste was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4045. Mary Ellen Barbieri, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary Ellen Barbieri was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4046. Garrett Raymond Barbosa, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Garrett Raymond Barbosa was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4047. Armando Bardales, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

745

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 747 of 978

Armando Bardales was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4048. DOE 72, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 72 was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4049. Thomas J. Baroz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Baroz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4050. John T. Barry, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John T. Barry was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4051. Patrick T. Barry, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick T. Barry was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4052. Frank Barton, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Barton was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

746

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 748 of 978

4053. Burney Bates, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Burney Bates was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4054. Pedro Garrido Batista, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pedro Garrido Batista was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4055. James A. Bauer, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James A. Bauer was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4056. Christopher A. Baumann, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher A. Baumann was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4057. Faveur Bazilme, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Faveur Bazilme was present at One World Financial Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4058. Frank J. Bazzicalupo, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

747

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 749 of 978

Frank J. Bazzicalupo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4059. Larry Bealer, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Larry Bealer was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4060. Thomas A Beattie, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas A Beattie was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4061. Janice Beatty, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Janice Beatty was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4062. Richard A. Beatty, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard A. Beatty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4063. Jonathan M. Becker, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jonathan M. Becker was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

748

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 750 of 978

4064. Christian Bediako, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christian Bediako was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4065. Michael Beehler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Beehler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4066. Thomas Joseph Beirne, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Joseph Beirne was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4067. Michael J. Bell, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Bell was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4068. John Bellew, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Bellew was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4069. Anthony Bellisari, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

749

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 751 of 978

Anthony Bellisari was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4070. Scott R. Beloten, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott R. Beloten was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4071. Vanessa Benjamin, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vanessa Benjamin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4072. Derek P. Bennett, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Derek P. Bennett was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4073. Ian J. Bennett, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ian J. Bennett was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4074. Frances Berdan, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frances Berdan was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

750

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 752 of 978

4075. James W. Berghorn, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James W. Berghorn was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4076. Juliette Bergman, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Juliette Bergman was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4077. Deborah E. Berk, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Deborah E. Berk was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4078. Eric Berntsen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric Berntsen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4079. Joseph T. Berry, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph T. Berry was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4080. Dominic Bertucci, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

751

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 753 of 978

Dominic Bertucci was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4081. Francisco Betancourt, a resident of Georgia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francisco Betancourt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4082. Prakash Bhatt, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Prakash Bhatt was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4083. Donald S. Bigi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald S. Bigi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4084. Stephen Bileski, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Bileski was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4085. Christopher Bilotti, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Bilotti was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

752

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 754 of 978

4086. James A. Bittles, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James A. Bittles was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4087. Daniel Bivona, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Bivona was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4088. Patrick Charles Blaine, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Charles Blaine was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4089. James Blake, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Blake was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4090. Robert Blake, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Blake was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4091. Jody Blanchard, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jody

753

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 755 of 978

Blanchard was present at Seven World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4092. Stan Blaskey, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stan Blaskey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4093. Richard J. Blatus, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard J. Blatus was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4094. Aaron Bogad, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Aaron Bogad was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4095. Edward P. Bolger, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward P. Bolger was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4096. Jan Bonanza, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jan Bonanza was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

754

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 756 of 978

4097. Luis Bonilla, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Luis Bonilla was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4098. Quinceyann Booker-Jackson, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Quinceyann Booker-Jackson was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4099. Chester P. Botch, Jr., a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Chester P. Botch, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4100. Ronald Boyce, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald Boyce was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4101. James J. Boyle, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James J. Boyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4102. James R. Boyle, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

755

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 757 of 978

James R. Boyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4103. John W. Boyle, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John W. Boyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4104. Joseph M. Boyle, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph M. Boyle was present at World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4105. Kevin Bradbury, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Bradbury was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4106. Frank Brancato, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Brancato was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4107. George Brennan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George Brennan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

756

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 758 of 978

4108. DOE 142, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 142 was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4109. Raymond Bressingham, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Raymond Bressingham was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4110. Jeffrey A. Brezil, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey A. Brezil was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4111. Carmen Bridgeforth, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carmen Bridgeforth was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4112. David Allen Bridgeforth, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Allen Bridgeforth was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4113. James M. Briordy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

757

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 759 of 978

James M. Briordy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4114. Michael P. Brodbeck, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael P. Brodbeck was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4115. Eric J. Brodin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric J. Brodin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4116. Boris Bronshteyn, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Boris Bronshteyn was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4117. Robert Broome, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Broome was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4118. Edward M. Brown, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward M. Brown was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

758

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 760 of 978

4119. Ernest O. Brown, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ernest O. Brown was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4120. Kevin Jerome Brown, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Jerome Brown was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4121. Michael P. Brown, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael P. Brown was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4122. Stephen Charles Brown, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Charles Brown was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4123. Eduardo E. Bruno, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eduardo E. Bruno was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4124. Thomas J. Bubelnik, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

759

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 761 of 978

Thomas J. Bubelnik was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4125. Johnathan Buchsbaum, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Johnathan Buchsbaum was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4126. Joseph L. Buda, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph L. Buda was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4127. Brook A. Budd, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brook A. Budd was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4128. Vincent Bulzomi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Bulzomi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4129. Javier Burgos, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Javier Burgos was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

760

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 762 of 978

4130. Thomas Burke, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Burke was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4131. Timothy J. Burke, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy J. Burke was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4132. Michael R. Burns, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael R. Burns was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4133. Barry L. Buss, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barry L. Buss was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4134. Kevin Butler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Butler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4135. Lois Buxbaum, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lois

761

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 763 of 978

Buxbaum was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4136. Pasquale Buzzelli, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pasquale Buzzelli was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4137. Richard Bylicki, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Bylicki was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4138. Louie D. Cacchioli, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louie D. Cacchioli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4139. James Patrick Caddigan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Patrick Caddigan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4140. Kevin Cahill, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Cahill was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

762

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 764 of 978

4141. Kevin J. Cahill, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin J. Cahill was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4142. Michael Cain, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Cain was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4143. John A. Cairney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John A. Cairney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4144. Christopher Calamia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Calamia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4145. Ronald Calcagno, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald Calcagno was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4146. William Callahan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

763

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 765 of 978

William Callahan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4147. Jose Callejas, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jose Callejas was present at Five World Trade Center - Northeast Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4148. Fernando Camacho, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fernando Camacho was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4149. William Cantres, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Cantres was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4150. Robert Carberry, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Carberry was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4151. Luis Carbonell, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Luis Carbonell was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

764

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 766 of 978

4152. Salvatore F. Carcaterra, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Salvatore F. Carcaterra was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4153. Martha F. Carden, a resident of Tennessee, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martha F. Carden was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4154. Ralph Cardino, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph Cardino was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4155. Colette Cardoza, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Colette Cardoza was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4156. Michael J. Carlisi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Carlisi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4157. Anita Carmine, a resident of Nevada, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anita

765

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 767 of 978

Carmine was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4158. Dominick J. Carolei, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dominick J. Carolei was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4159. David W. Carpenter, Jr., a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David W. Carpenter, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4160. Gary E. Carpentier, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gary E. Carpentier was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4161. Venus Christine Carreras-Ortiz, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Venus Christine Carreras-Ortiz was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4162. Charles F. Carroll, Jr., a resident of Illinois, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles F. Carroll, Jr. was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

766

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 768 of 978

4163. Robert J. Carroll, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert J. Carroll was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4164. Eugene J. Carty, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eugene J. Carty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4165. Desiret Carvache, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Desiret Carvache was present at Five World Trade Center - Northeast Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4166. Frank Casalino, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Casalino was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4167. Vincent Cascone, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Cascone was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4168. Joseph Castellano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

767

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 769 of 978

Joseph Castellano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4169. Maria E. Castillo, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maria E. Castillo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4170. John J. Castles, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. Castles was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4171. Frank Castrogiovanni, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Castrogiovanni was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4172. Juan Cayetano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Juan Cayetano was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4173. Maria Ceballos, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maria Ceballos was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

768

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 770 of 978

4174. Domingo Cepeda, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Domingo Cepeda was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4175. Robert Ceresia, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Ceresia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4176. Arlene Charles, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Arlene Charles was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4177. Salvatore Chillemi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Salvatore Chillemi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4178. Arthur Christensen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Arthur Christensen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4179. Gary Christensen, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

769

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 771 of 978

Gary Christensen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4180. Anthony Ciarnella, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Ciarnella was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4181. Nicholas Cicero, Jr., a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nicholas Cicero, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4182. Thomas Alfred Cinotti, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Alfred Cinotti was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4183. Michael Cioffi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Cioffi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4184. John Citarella, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Citarella was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

770

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 772 of 978

4185. Patricia Ciuzio, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patricia Ciuzio was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4186. Guillermo Clark, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Guillermo Clark was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4187. Brian Clarke, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Clarke was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4188. Thomas J. Clarke, a resident of Minnesota, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Clarke was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4189. Christine Claudi-Petosa, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christine Claudi-Petosa was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4190. John J. Clavin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J.

771

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 773 of 978

Clavin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4191. Sharron L. Clemons, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sharron L. Clemons was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4192. Robert Cobb, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Cobb was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4193. Steve Coffin, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steve Coffin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4194. Lisa Cohn, a resident of California, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lisa Cohn was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4195. Anthony J. Coiro, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony J. Coiro was present at Seven World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

772

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 774 of 978

4196. David Collins, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Collins was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4197. George A. Collins, III, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George A. Collins, III was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4198. Richard L. Collins, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard L. Collins was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4199. Bruce R. Collister, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bruce R. Collister was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4200. Carmen Colon, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carmen Colon was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4201. John A. Colon, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John A.

773

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 775 of 978

Colon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4202. John Combos, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Combos was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4203. Gary K. Connelly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gary K. Connelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4204. Thomas J. Connolly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Connolly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4205. William V. Connolly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William V. Connolly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4206. Jose M. Contes, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jose M. Contes was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

774

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 776 of 978

4207. Theodore Cook, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Theodore Cook was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4208. Walter Cooper, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Walter Cooper was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4209. Brian Corcoran, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Corcoran was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4210. Gregory A. Corona, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory A. Corona was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4211. Patrick Corr, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Corr was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4212. Stephen Corr, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen

775

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 777 of 978

Corr was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4213. Matthew Corrigan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew Corrigan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4214. Lawrence Costello, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lawrence Costello was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4215. Joel Council, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joel Council was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4216. Scott Cowan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Cowan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4217. Andre Cox, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andre Cox was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

776

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 778 of 978

4218. Dudley Cox, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dudley Cox was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4219. Stephen A. Cox, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen A. Cox was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4220. Brian Coyle, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Coyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4221. John J. Coyle, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. Coyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4222. Walter Henry Cramer, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Walter Henry Cramer was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4223. Peter J. Creegan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter

777

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 779 of 978

J. Creegan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4224. John Cretella, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Cretella was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4225. Craig Crichlow, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Craig Crichlow was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4226. Robert H. Cristadoro, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert H. Cristadoro was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4227. Brent G. Crobak, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brent G. Crobak was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4228. Enrique Cruz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Enrique Cruz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

778

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 780 of 978

4229. Luis Cruz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Luis Cruz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4230. DOE 101, a resident of Puerto Rico, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 101 was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4231. James J. Csorny, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James J. Csorny was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4232. Fernando Cuba, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fernando Cuba was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4233. Carmen Cubero, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carmen Cubero was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4234. Sean Cummins, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean

779

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 781 of 978

Cummins was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4235. Thomas Cunneen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Cunneen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4236. Muriel Cunningham, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Muriel Cunningham was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4237. Ronald Curaba, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald Curaba was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4238. Edward James Cusack, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward James Cusack was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4239. Alan W. Dagistino, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alan W. Dagistino was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

780

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 782 of 978

4240. Philip D'Agostino, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip D'Agostino was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4241. Joanne Dalton, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joanne Dalton was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4242. Christopher D'Ambrosio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher D'Ambrosio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4243. Mark Damitz, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Damitz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4244. Flory Danish, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Flory Danish was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4245. Roger Danvers, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roger

781

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 783 of 978

Danvers was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4246. Richard Davan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Davan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4247. Felipe David, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Felipe David was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4248. Jeremy Brandon Davids, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeremy Brandon Davids was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4249. Jean. L. Davis, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jean. L. Davis was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4250. Thomas P. Davis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas P. Davis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

782

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 784 of 978

4251. James E. D'Avolio, a resident of Connecticut, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James E. D'Avolio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4252. Judith Day, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Judith Day was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4253. Andres De La Rosa, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andres De La Rosa was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4254. Maria De Olio-Beato, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maria De Olio-Beato was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4255. Anthony W. De Vita, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony W. De Vita, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4256. Beverly Diane De Witt, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set

783

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 785 of 978

forth herein. Beverly Diane De Witt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4257. John Debenedittis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Debenedittis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4258. Carlota Rodriguez DeCastillo, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carlota Rodriguez DeCastillo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4259. Henry Decker, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Henry Decker was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4260. Kevin Deehan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Deehan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4261. Edward J. DeGaetano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward J. DeGaetano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

784

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 786 of 978

4262. Warren Degen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Warren Degen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4263. John Delaney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Delaney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4264. Paul DeLeo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul DeLeo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4265. Edward Delfino, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Delfino was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4266. Julio Delgado, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Julio Delgado was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4267. Bruce DelGiorno, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

785

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 787 of 978

Bruce DelGiorno was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4268. Richard Dell Italia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Dell Italia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4269. August C. DeLorenzo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. August C. DeLorenzo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4270. Todd C. DeMayo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Todd C. DeMayo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4271. Jan Demczur, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jan Demczur was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4272. Michael T. Dempsey, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael T. Dempsey was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

786

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 788 of 978

4273. Stephen Dempsey, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Dempsey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4274. Gary A. Demry, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gary A. Demry was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4275. John M. Deneau, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John M. Deneau was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4276. Dwayne Dent, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dwayne Dent was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4277. Peter DePalma, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter DePalma was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4278. John M. DePrizio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John

787

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 789 of 978

M. DePrizio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4279. Anthony DeSimone, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony DeSimone was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4280. George J. DeSimone, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George J. DeSimone was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4281. Anex Desinor, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anex Desinor was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4282. James F. DeStasio, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James F. DeStasio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4283. John DeStefano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John DeStefano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

788

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 790 of 978

4284. Richard Dion DeStefano, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Dion DeStefano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4285. Kiernan B. Deto, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kiernan B. Deto was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4286. Gregory J. DeVerna, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory J. DeVerna was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4287. James Edward Devery, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Edward Devery was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4288. Kevin D. Devine, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin D. Devine was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4289. David DeVito, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David

789

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 791 of 978

DeVito was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4290. John Devoti, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Devoti was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4291. Nelson Rafael Diaz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nelson Rafael Diaz was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4292. Salvatore DiBlasi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Salvatore DiBlasi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4293. Jerrold Dietz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jerrold Dietz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4294. Jessica Diggs, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jessica Diggs was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

790

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 792 of 978

4295. John M. Dilillo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John M. Dilillo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4296. Steven DiMaggio, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven DiMaggio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4297. Omar A. Dixon, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Omar A. Dixon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4298. Vincent Dodd, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Dodd was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4299. Kevin John Doherty, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin John Doherty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4300. Scott Doherty, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott

791

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 793 of 978

Doherty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4301. Hipolito D'Oleo, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hipolito D'Oleo was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4302. Stephen Dominick, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Dominick was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4303. Walter Donahue, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Walter Donahue was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4304. John Donnelly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Donnelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4305. James F. Donovan, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James F. Donovan, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

792

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 794 of 978

4306. Kenneth Donovan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth Donovan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4307. Michael Donovan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Donovan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4308. Vincent D'Orio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent D'Orio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4309. Gregory Dougherty, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory Dougherty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4310. Michael J. Dowling, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Dowling was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4311. Heather Downey, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

793

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 795 of 978

Heather Downey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4312. Daniel D. Doyle, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel D. Doyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4313. Edward Doyle, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Doyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4314. Steven T. Doyle, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven T. Doyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4315. Thomas M. Doyle, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas M. Doyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4316. DOE 18, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 18 was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4317. Duncan Driscoll, a resident of Massachusetts, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

794

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 796 of 978

Duncan Driscoll was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4318. Eugene Drury, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eugene Drury was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4319. Roman Ducalo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roman Ducalo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4320. Elaine Duch, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Elaine Duch was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4321. Dennis G. Duffy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis G. Duffy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4322. Timothy Duffy, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy Duffy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

795

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 797 of 978

4323. William Duffy, a resident of Massachusetts, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Duffy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4324. Kevin Duggan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Duggan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4325. Patrick D. Duignan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick D. Duignan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4326. Darrell Dunbar, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Darrell Dunbar was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4327. Philip Duncan, a resident of Texas, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip Duncan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4328. Thomas Dunn, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas

796

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 798 of 978

Dunn was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4329. Thomas M. Dunne, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas M. Dunne was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4330. Michael Dunphy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Dunphy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4331. Curtis Durning, Sr., a resident of District of Columbia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Curtis Durning, Sr. was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4332. Francis B. Durr, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francis B. Durr was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4333. Brian Eagers, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Eagers was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

797

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 799 of 978

4334. Douglas Edel, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Douglas Edel was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4335. Jeff Ehret, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeff Ehret was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4336. Barbara Einzig, a resident of Maryland, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barbara Einzig was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4337. Joseph Eivers, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Eivers was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4338. Duke A. Ellis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Duke A. Ellis was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4339. Justin Enzmann, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

798

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 800 of 978

Justin Enzmann was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4340. Gabe Esposito, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gabe Esposito was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4341. Joseph J. Falco, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph J. Falco was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4342. James J. Falcone, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James J. Falcone was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4343. John C. Falconite, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John C. Falconite was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4344. Paul Fanara, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Fanara was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

799

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 801 of 978

4345. Robert Farley, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Farley was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4346. Peter V. Farr, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter V. Farr was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4347. Patricia Farrar, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patricia Farrar was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4348. John S. Farrell, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John S. Farrell was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4349. Anthony Farrington, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Farrington was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4350. Francis Fee, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

800

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 802 of 978

Francis Fee, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4351. John T. Fee, Sr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John T. Fee, Sr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4352. Mark Feldman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Feldman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4353. Russell Feliciano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Russell Feliciano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4354. Edgar Felix, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edgar Felix was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4355. Delio A. Feliz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Delio A. Feliz was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

801

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 803 of 978

4356. Fern L. Feller, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fern L. Feller was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4357. Barton Fendelman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barton Fendelman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4358. Stephen P. Fenley, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen P. Fenley was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4359. Christopher M. Fenya, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher M. Fenya was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4360. Frank Ferdinandi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Ferdinandi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4361. Erasmo Fernandes, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

802

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 804 of 978

Erasmo Fernandes was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4362. Nuno Fernandes, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nuno Fernandes was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4363. Antonio Fernandez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Antonio Fernandez was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4364. Hernando Fernandez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hernando Fernandez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4365. Jenny Fernandez, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jenny Fernandez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4366. Larissa Fernandez, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Larissa Fernandez was present at Five World Trade Center - Northeast Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

803

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 805 of 978

4367. Roger Fernandez, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roger Fernandez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4368. Vincent Ferranti, a resident of Arizona, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Ferranti was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4369. Michael A. Ferrara, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Ferrara was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4370. Douglas Ferretti, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Douglas Ferretti was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4371. Gerard Ferrin, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard Ferrin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4372. Steven Ferriolo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

804

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 806 of 978

Steven Ferriolo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4373. John Finamore, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Finamore was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4374. Joseph P. Finley, a resident of Tennessee, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph P. Finley was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4375. Edward Finnegan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Finnegan was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4376. Michael Finnegan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Finnegan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4377. Terence P. Finneran, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terence P. Finneran was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

805

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 807 of 978

4378. Victor J. Fiorella, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Victor J. Fiorella was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4379. Glenn Fischer, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Glenn Fischer was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4380. Jay F. Fischler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jay F. Fischler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4381. Stephen Fish, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Fish was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4382. Neil C. Fitzpatrick, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neil C. Fitzpatrick was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4383. Zachary H. Fletcher, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

806

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 808 of 978

Zachary H. Fletcher was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4384. Patrick Flynn, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Flynn was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4385. Theresa E Folino-Montuori, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Theresa E Folino-Montuori was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4386. Thomas J. Forbes, a resident of California, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Forbes was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4387. Frederick J. Ford, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frederick J. Ford was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4388. Nicholas Fornario, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nicholas Fornario was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

807

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 809 of 978

4389. Gregory A. Forsyth, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory A. Forsyth was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4390. Leileth Foster, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Leileth Foster was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4391. Eugene W. Fox, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eugene W. Fox was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4392. Michael Anthony Francese, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Anthony Francese was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4393. Stanley Freedner, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stanley Freedner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4394. Charles Freeman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

808

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 810 of 978

Charles Freeman was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4395. Dennis Freyre, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis Freyre was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4396. Robert T. Froner, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert T. Froner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4397. Xiang Qun Fu, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Xiang Qun Fu was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4398. Daniel Fucella, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Fucella was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4399. Steven Fucile, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Fucile was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

809

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 811 of 978

4400. Henry Fuerte, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Henry Fuerte was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4401. Sheila M. Fuller, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sheila M. Fuller was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4402. Paul P. Fusaro, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul P. Fusaro was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4403. Thomas A. Gabay, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas A. Gabay was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4404. Thomas R. Gaby, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas R. Gaby was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4405. Philip Gaetani, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip

810

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 812 of 978

Gaetani was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4406. Michael D. Gager, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael D. Gager was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4407. Emma F. Gaitan, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Emma F. Gaitan was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4408. Ana Galang, a resident of Arizona, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ana Galang was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4409. Brian J. Gallagher, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian J. Gallagher was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4410. Hugh J. Gallagher, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hugh J. Gallagher was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

811

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 813 of 978

4411. John Gallagher, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Gallagher was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4412. John F. Gallagher, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John F. Gallagher was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4413. Kevin P. Gallagher, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin P. Gallagher was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4414. Terence Gallagher, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terence Gallagher was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4415. April D. Gallop, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. April D. Gallop was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4416. Lawrence J. Garda, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

812

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 814 of 978

Lawrence J. Garda was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4417. Robert C. Garrett, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert C. Garrett was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4418. John T. Gatto, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John T. Gatto was present at One Liberty Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4419. Joseph M. Gavitt, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph M. Gavitt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4420. Brendan Gebert, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brendan Gebert was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4421. Getachew Gedfe, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Getachew Gedfe was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

813

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 815 of 978

4422. John D. Gennosa, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John D. Gennosa was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4423. Greg Gessner, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Greg Gessner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4424. Daniel P. Geysen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel P. Geysen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4425. Ronald Ghiraldi, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald Ghiraldi was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4426. Louis Giaconelli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louis Giaconelli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4427. Joseph A. Giampa, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

814

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 816 of 978

Joseph A. Giampa was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4428. Garry George Giannandrea, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Garry George Giannandrea was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4429. Michael J. Gibbons, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Gibbons was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4430. Joseph Gibney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Gibney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4431. Robert F. Gibson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert F. Gibson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4432. Bonnie Jean Giebfried, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bonnie Jean Giebfried was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

815

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 817 of 978

4433. John C. Giebler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John C. Giebler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4434. Thomas Gillam, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Gillam was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4435. Andrew Frank Gilmore, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andrew Frank Gilmore was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4436. John E. Ginty, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John E. Ginty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4437. Vincent Giordano, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Giordano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4438. Theodore Goddard, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

816

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 818 of 978

Theodore Goddard was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4439. Raymond Going, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Raymond Going was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4440. Fausto A. Gomez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fausto A. Gomez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4441. Lisa F. Gong, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lisa F. Gong was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4442. Paul E. Gonzales, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul E. Gonzales was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4443. Manuel Gonzalez, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Manuel Gonzalez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

817

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 819 of 978

4444. Ruben Gordillo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ruben Gordillo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4445. Edwin J. Gordon, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edwin J. Gordon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4446. Frank Gorglinoe, a resident of the United States, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Gorglinoe was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4447. Thomas Edward Gorham, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Edward Gorham was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4448. Gerard J. Gorman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard J. Gorman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4449. Joseph R. Gorman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

818

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 820 of 978

Joseph R. Gorman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4450. Albert Gotay, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Albert Gotay was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4451. Andrew Graf, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andrew Graf was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4452. Carmen Gray, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carmen Gray was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4453. Joseph Graziano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Graziano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4454. Albert Greene, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Albert Greene was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

819

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 821 of 978

4455. Edmund James Greene, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edmund James Greene was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4456. Michael Sean Greene, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Sean Greene was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4457. James Gregoretti, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Gregoretti was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4458. James T. Grillo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James T. Grillo was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4459. Michael Grillo, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Grillo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4460. John F. Grogan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John

820

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 822 of 978

F. Grogan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4461. Thomas J. Grogan, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Grogan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4462. Daniel P. Grossi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel P. Grossi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4463. Scott F. Grubert, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott F. Grubert was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4464. John Guarneri, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Guarneri was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4465. Arthur Guastamacchia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Arthur Guastamacchia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

821

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 823 of 978

4466. John Gubelli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Gubelli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4467. Rafael Gudmuch, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rafael Gudmuch was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4468. Nichola Gugliemo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nichola Gugliemo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4469. Vincent A. Gugliuzzo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent A. Gugliuzzo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4470. John Gulotta, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Gulotta was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4471. Kenneth M. Gunther, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

822

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 824 of 978

Kenneth M. Gunther was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4472. Peter Stephen Gunther, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Stephen Gunther was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4473. Wilbert Carnell Gurganious, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wilbert Carnell Gurganious was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4474. Steven Gurnick, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Gurnick was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4475. Edgar Gutierrez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edgar Gutierrez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4476. Francine Gutwilik, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francine Gutwilik was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

823

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 825 of 978

4477. Angel Guzman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Angel Guzman was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4478. Maritza Guzman, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maritza Guzman was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4479. Matthew Hackett, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew Hackett was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4480. Michael Hadden, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Hadden was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4481. Alexander Hagan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alexander Hagan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4482. Steve Hagis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steve

824

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 826 of 978

Hagis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4483. Paul V. Haley, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul V. Haley was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4484. Robert Hall, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Hall was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4485. David Handschuh, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Handschuh was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4486. William Hankins, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Hankins was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4487. David R. Hanley, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David R. Hanley was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

825

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 827 of 978

4488. Philip A. Hanna, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip A. Hanna was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4489. Anthony K. Hanson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony K. Hanson was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4490. Rajkumar Hardeo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rajkumar Hardeo was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4491. Catherine Harding, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Catherine Harding was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4492. Dennis Hargett, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis Hargett was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4493. Darren C. Harkins, a resident of Iowa, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Darren

826

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 828 of 978

C. Harkins was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4494. Robert I. Harper, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert I. Harper was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4495. Thomas Harris, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Harris was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4496. Carmela M. Harrison, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carmela M. Harrison was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4497. James P. Harten, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James P. Harten was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4498. Shirley Harvey, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Shirley Harvey was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

827

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 829 of 978

4499. Paul Hashagen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Hashagen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4500. William R. Hasseck, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William R. Hasseck was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4501. Howard Hawkins, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Howard Hawkins was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4502. Scott William Hawkins, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott William Hawkins was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4503. Raymond Hayden, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Raymond Hayden was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4504. Norma Haynes, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

828

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 830 of 978

Norma Haynes was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4505. Joseph Healy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Healy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4506. Joseph John Healy, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph John Healy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4507. Marilyn Denise Heckstall, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marilyn Denise Heckstall was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4508. Dennis J. Heedles, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis J. Heedles was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4509. James A. Heerey, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James A. Heerey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

829

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 831 of 978

4510. Glen Heffel, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Glen Heffel was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4511. Eugene R. Heghmann, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eugene R. Heghmann was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4512. John Heigl, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Heigl was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4513. Mark B. Heintz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark B. Heintz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4514. William T. Heintz, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William T. Heintz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4515. Robert J. Hellmers, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

830

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 832 of 978

Robert J. Hellmers was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4516. Elaine Helms, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Elaine Helms was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4517. Robert G. Heney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert G. Heney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4518. Jeffrey A. Henkel, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey A. Henkel was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4519. Edward Henry, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Henry was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4520. Lucille D. Henry, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lucille D. Henry was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

831

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 833 of 978

4521. Patricia Ann Herbert, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patricia Ann Herbert was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4522. Thomas Herrlich, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Herrlich was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4523. Thomas Hickey, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Hickey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4524. John A. Hinchey, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John A. Hinchey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4525. William Gerard Hiney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Gerard Hiney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4526. Michael R. Hipsman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

832

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 834 of 978

Michael R. Hipsman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4527. Gregg Andrew Hirschfield, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregg Andrew Hirschfield was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4528. William Hodgens, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Hodgens was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4529. Daniel Hogan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Hogan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4530. Vincent D. Hogan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent D. Hogan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4531. Todd A. Holgan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Todd A. Holgan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

833

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 835 of 978

4532. Clifford J. Hollywood, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Clifford J. Hollywood was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4533. Janeth Holmes-Alfred, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Janeth Holmes-Alfred was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4534. George Holzmann, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George Holzmann was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4535. James Joseph Horch, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Joseph Horch was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4536. Doug R. Horning, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Doug R. Horning was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4537. Alicia T. Howard, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

834

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 836 of 978

Alicia T. Howard was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4538. Mary Hrabowska, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary Hrabowska was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4539. Vincent F. Hubner, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent F. Hubner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4540. Gerald M. Hunt, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerald M. Hunt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4541. Jean Marlene Hunt, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jean Marlene Hunt was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4542. John Hunt, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Hunt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

835

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 837 of 978

4543. Kenneth Hutchinson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth Hutchinson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4544. Amirha Victoria Hutto, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Amirha Victoria Hutto was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4545. Paul Hyland, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Hyland was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4546. James Andrew Hynes, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Andrew Hynes was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4547. Frederick J. Ill, III, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frederick J. Ill, III was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4548. Sharon Imbert, a resident of Connecticut, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

836

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 838 of 978

Sharon Imbert was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4549. Patrick Imperato, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Imperato was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4550. Joseph P. Intintoli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph P. Intintoli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4551. Michael A. Iovino, a resident of Georgia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Iovino was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4552. Eric Iversen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eric Iversen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4553. Walter Nicholas Iwachiw, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Walter Nicholas Iwachiw was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

837

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 839 of 978

4554. John Jackson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Jackson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4555. Neil Jacobson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neil Jacobson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4556. Brenda James, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brenda James was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4557. Joseph James, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph James was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4558. Matthew R. James, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew R. James was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4559. Elian Jaramillo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Elian

838

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 840 of 978

Jaramillo was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4560. Clifford Jenkins, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Clifford Jenkins was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4561. Christopher C. Jensen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher C. Jensen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4562. Marc C. Jensen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marc C. Jensen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4563. Rose Jeunes, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rose Jeunes was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4564. Humberto Jimenez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Humberto Jimenez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

839

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 841 of 978

4565. Luis B. Jimenez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Luis B. Jimenez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4566. Ysidro Jimenez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ysidro Jimenez was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4567. Fitz-Harry Alexander Johnson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fitz-Harry Alexander Johnson was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4568. John Johnson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Johnson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4569. Kurt Dominick Johnson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kurt Dominick Johnson was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4570. Robert Johnson, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

840

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 842 of 978

Robert Johnson, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4571. Robert Johnson, Sr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Johnson, Sr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4572. Sylvia J. Johnson, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sylvia J. Johnson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4573. John T. Jones, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John T. Jones was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4574. Terrence George Jordan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terrence George Jordan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4575. Mark D. Joseph, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark D. Joseph was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

841

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 843 of 978

4576. Luke J. Jurain, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Luke J. Jurain was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4577. Joseph F. Kadillac, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph F. Kadillac was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4578. James A. Kadnar, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James A. Kadnar was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4579. Jane Kahoro, a resident of Delaware, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jane Kahoro was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4580. Razi S. Kalish, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Razi S. Kalish was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4581. George Kaperonis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

842

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 844 of 978

George Kaperonis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4582. Christopher Kazimer, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Kazimer was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4583. Dennis P. Keane, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis P. Keane was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4584. Lawrence Gerald Keating, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lawrence Gerald Keating was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4585. Thomas Keeling, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Keeling was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4586. John E. Keenan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John E. Keenan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

843

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 845 of 978

4587. Michael M. Kelleher, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael M. Kelleher was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4588. Racquel K. Kelley, a resident of District of Columbia, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Racquel K. Kelley was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4589. Derek T. Kelly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Derek T. Kelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4590. James J. Kelly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James J. Kelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4591. John Kelly, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Kelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4592. John J. Kelly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J.

844

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 846 of 978

Kelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4593. Kevin Kelly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Kelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4594. Patrick Kelly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Kelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4595. Robert Kelly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Kelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4596. William C. Kelly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William C. Kelly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4597. Donald P. Kennedy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald P. Kennedy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

845

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 847 of 978

4598. Lisa Ann Kennedy, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lisa Ann Kennedy was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4599. Richard Kenney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Kenney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4600. Peter A. Kenny, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter A. Kenny was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4601. John F. Kershis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John F. Kershis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4602. Robert T. Keys, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert T. Keys was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4603. Patrick M. Kiernan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

846

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 848 of 978

Patrick M. Kiernan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4604. Susanne Bachmann Kikkenborg, a resident of Connecticut, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susanne Bachmann Kikkenborg was present at Three World Trade Center Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4605. Michael Killarney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Killarney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4606. Michael J. Killcommons, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Killcommons was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4607. David J. King, Jr., a resident of Maryland, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David J. King, Jr. was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4608. Emanuel G. King, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Emanuel G. King was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

847

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 849 of 978

4609. Stephen J. King, III, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen J. King, III was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4610. John L. Kinta, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John L. Kinta was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4611. Blaik Kirby, a resident of Canada, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Blaik Kirby was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4612. Ronald J. Kirchner, a resident of Arizona, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald J. Kirchner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4613. Robert Klaum, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Klaum was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4614. Steven J. Klein, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

848

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 850 of 978

Steven J. Klein was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4615. David Kletsman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Kletsman was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4616. Larry J. Klingener, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Larry J. Klingener was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4617. Richard Kobbe, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Kobbe was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4618. Edward R. Kohler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward R. Kohler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4619. Nicholas Koloszuk, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nicholas Koloszuk was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

849

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 851 of 978

4620. Robert Korfman, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Korfman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4621. Armen Koroghlian, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Armen Koroghlian was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4622. Daniel Kruesi, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Kruesi was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4623. Kevin Kubler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Kubler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4624. Louise A. Kurtz, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louise A. Kurtz was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4625. Sidney Kyle, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sidney

850

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 852 of 978

Kyle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4626. John R. La Sala, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John R. La Sala was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4627. Rosetta La Vena, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rosetta La Vena was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4628. David Labatto, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Labatto was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4629. Orfelina Lachapel, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Orfelina Lachapel was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4630. John J. LaFemina, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. LaFemina was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

851

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 853 of 978

4631. Romano Esteban Lake, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Romano Esteban Lake was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4632. Thomas LaMacchia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas LaMacchia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4633. George Lamoreaux, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George Lamoreaux was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4634. Brian Landau, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Landau was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4635. James C. Lang, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James C. Lang was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4636. Paul P. Lang, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul P.

852

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 854 of 978

Lang was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4637. George Lantay, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George Lantay was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4638. James Lanza, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Lanza was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4639. James F. Lanze, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James F. Lanze was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4640. Richard James LaPiedra, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard James LaPiedra was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4641. Jean Jacques Laraque, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jean Jacques Laraque was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

853

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 855 of 978

4642. Philip Larimore, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip Larimore was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4643. Brain R. Larney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brain R. Larney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4644. John Larocchia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Larocchia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4645. Anthony R. Larosa, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony R. Larosa was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4646. Joseph M. Lashendock, III, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph M. Lashendock, III was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4647. Peter Laudati, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter

854

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 856 of 978

Laudati was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4648. Kevin Lavelle, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Lavelle was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4649. Michael J. Lavin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Lavin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4650. Kevin P. Lawe, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin P. Lawe was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4651. Barry Roger Lee, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barry Roger Lee was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4652. Larry Lee, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Larry Lee was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

855

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 857 of 978

4653. Robert Lee, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Lee was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4654. Alicia LeGuillow, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alicia LeGuillow was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4655. Joyce Leigh, a resident of Georgia, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joyce Leigh was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4656. Robert J. Leonick, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert J. Leonick, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4657. Hursley H. Lever, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hursley H. Lever was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4658. James W. Lewis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

856

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 858 of 978

James W. Lewis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4659. Otis Lewis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Otis Lewis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4660. Veronica O. Li, a resident of Texas, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Veronica O. Li was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4661. Michael Liantonio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Liantonio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4662. Joseph Libretti, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Libretti was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4663. Frank A. Licausi, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank A. Licausi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

857

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 859 of 978

4664. Christopher Lindberg, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Lindberg was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4665. Elena Linis, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Elena Linis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4666. Rosemaria Lipari, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rosemaria Lipari was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4667. Emanuel Alexander Lipscomb, Jr., a resident of District of Columbia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Emanuel Alexander Lipscomb, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4668. Antonio R. Lloret, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Antonio R. Lloret was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4669. Anthony P. LoMeli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

858

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 860 of 978

Anthony P. LoMeli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4670. Christopher V. Long, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher V. Long was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4671. Arnaldo Lopez, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Arnaldo Lopez was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4672. Mario Lopez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mario Lopez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4673. Daniel Lopuzzo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Lopuzzo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4674. Joseph Lowney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Lowney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

859

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 861 of 978

4675. Brendan P. Lowrey, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brendan P. Lowrey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4676. Edmund Scott Lucia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edmund Scott Lucia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4677. Kenneth J. Lucianin, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth J. Lucianin was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4678. Evelyn A. Lugo, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Evelyn A. Lugo was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4679. Leoncio Luis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Leoncio Luis was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4680. Dennis A. Lusardi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

860

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 862 of 978

Dennis A. Lusardi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4681. Jane Luther-Umstadter, a resident of Michigan, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jane Luther-Umstadter was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4682. Jesse L. Lynch, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jesse L. Lynch was present at Five World Trade Center - Northeast Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4683. Michael P. Lynch, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael P. Lynch was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4684. Thomas S. Lynch, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas S. Lynch was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4685. Charlie Lyons, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charlie Lyons was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

861

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 863 of 978

4686. John Lyons, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Lyons was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4687. Michael Lyons, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Lyons was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4688. Peter M. Mabanta, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter M. Mabanta was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4689. Neil MacIntyre, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neil MacIntyre was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4690. Michael A. Macko, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Macko was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4691. Janissa Evaline Macon, a resident of Nevada, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

862

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 864 of 978

Janissa Evaline Macon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4692. Rico Magalhaes, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rico Magalhaes was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4693. Thomas James Magee, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas James Magee was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4694. Robert Maguire, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Maguire was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4695. Eugene S. Mahlstadt, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eugene S. Mahlstadt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4696. Joseph Francis Mahoney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Francis Mahoney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

863

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 865 of 978

4697. Thomas Mahoney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Mahoney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4698. Llewellyn Malcolm, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Llewellyn Malcolm was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4699. Jose Maldonado, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jose Maldonado was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4700. Frank hisrba, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank hisrba was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4701. Patrick M. Malloy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick M. Malloy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4702. Frank Malone, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank

864

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 866 of 978

Malone was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4703. John M Maloney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John M Maloney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4704. Adriana Belo Maluendas, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Adriana Belo Maluendas was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4705. Judy Maria Manalastas, a resident of Tennessee, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Judy Maria Manalastas was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4706. Michael Mandala, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Mandala was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4707. Ralph Mandia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph Mandia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

865

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 867 of 978

4708. Thomas Manley, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Manley was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4709. DOE 109, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 109 was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4710. Robert J. Mansberger, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert J. Mansberger was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4711. Wayne N. Manzie, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wayne N. Manzie was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4712. Jodie Marcusi, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jodie Marcusi was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4713. Claudia P. Marin, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

866

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 868 of 978

Claudia P. Marin was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4714. Patrick Michael Marinelli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Michael Marinelli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4715. Anthony J. Marino, Jr., a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony J. Marino, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4716. Donald Marino, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald Marino was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4717. Martin Anthony Marino, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martin Anthony Marino was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4718. Michael Patrick Marino, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Patrick Marino was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

867

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 869 of 978

4719. Jessie Marius, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jessie Marius was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4720. Timothy Marmion, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy Marmion was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4721. Juan R. Marrero, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Juan R. Marrero was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4722. Robert W. Marshall, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert W. Marshall was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4723. Dennis J. Martin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis J. Martin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4724. Edward E. Martin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

868

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 870 of 978

Edward E. Martin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4725. Edward P. Martin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward P. Martin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4726. Michael G. Martin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael G. Martin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4727. Angela Martinez, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Angela Martinez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4728. Jose Martinez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jose Martinez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4729. Rafaela Martinez, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rafaela Martinez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

869

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 871 of 978

4730. James Mascarella, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Mascarella was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4731. Anthony Mastrelli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Mastrelli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4732. Vincenzo Mastropasqua, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincenzo Mastropasqua was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4733. Anthony John Mattone, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony John Mattone was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4734. Richard Anthony Mattone, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Anthony Mattone was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4735. Shawn May, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Shawn

870

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 872 of 978

May was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4736. Michael A. Maye, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Maye was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4737. Jaysen Jeffrey Mayo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jaysen Jeffrey Mayo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4738. Thomas Mazza, a resident of Colorado, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Mazza was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4739. Edward McAleer, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward McAleer was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4740. John P. McAleese, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John P. McAleese was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

871

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 873 of 978

4741. John R McAllister, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John R McAllister was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4742. Thomas H. McAllister, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas H. McAllister was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4743. John McAndrews, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John McAndrews was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4744. Maureen B McArdle-Schulman, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maureen B McArdle-Schulman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4745. Joseph McAuley, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph McAuley was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4746. Carl R. McBratney, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

872

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 874 of 978

herein. Carl R. McBratney, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4747. Mary L. McCall, a resident of Alabama, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mary L. McCall was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4748. Michael McCall, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael McCall was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4749. Kevin McCarren, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin McCarren was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4750. James Raymond McCarthy, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Raymond McCarthy was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4751. Dan McCarvill, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dan McCarvill was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

873

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 875 of 978

4752. Timothy McCarvill, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy McCarvill was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4753. Michael McClelland, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael McClelland was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4754. Dennis McConville, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis McConville was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4755. Charles McCormack, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles McCormack was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4756. Marianne McCormack, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marianne McCormack was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4757. Richard G McCoy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

874

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 876 of 978

Richard G McCoy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4758. Arthur McCrossen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Arthur McCrossen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4759. James P. McDermott, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James P. McDermott was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4760. Scott Ashley McDonnell, a resident of Colorado, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Ashley McDonnell was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4761. David J. McDonough, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David J. McDonough was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4762. Gregory L. McFarland, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory L. McFarland was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

875

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 877 of 978

4763. Kevin McGeary, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin McGeary was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4764. Lawrence G. McGee, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lawrence G. McGee was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4765. Stephen Mcgee, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen Mcgee was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4766. Jon J. McGillick, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jon J. McGillick was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4767. Mark McGinty, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark McGinty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4768. Joseph G. McGovern, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

876

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 878 of 978

herein. Joseph G. McGovern was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4769. Thomas F. McGrade, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas F. McGrade was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4770. Patrick J. McGreen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick J. McGreen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4771. Joseph F. McGrory, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph F. McGrory was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4772. Daniel M. McGuinn, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel M. McGuinn was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4773. James P. McGuire, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James P. McGuire was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

877

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 879 of 978

4774. Robert Michael McGuire, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Michael McGuire was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4775. John F. McGurren, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John F. McGurren was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4776. James McHugh, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James McHugh was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4777. Edward M. McKallen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward M. McKallen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4778. John J. McKenna, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. McKenna was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4779. Patrick McKenna, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

878

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 880 of 978

Patrick McKenna was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4780. Richard D. McKenna, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard D. McKenna was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4781. Martin McKeon, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martin McKeon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4782. James McLoughlin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James McLoughlin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4783. Kevin M. McLoughlin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin M. McLoughlin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4784. Gerard F. McMahon, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard F. McMahon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

879

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 881 of 978

4785. Frederick J. Mcneely, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frederick J. Mcneely was present at Four World Trade Center - Commodities Exchange Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4786. Kevin J. McPike, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin J. McPike was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4787. Kevin McQuilly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin McQuilly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4788. Ernest Medaglia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ernest Medaglia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4789. Donald Meeg, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald Meeg was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4790. Oscar H. Mejia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

880

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 882 of 978

Oscar H. Mejia was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4791. Nexhat Mela, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nexhat Mela was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4792. Josefina Mendez, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Josefina Mendez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4793. Benjamin Mercado, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Benjamin Mercado was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4794. Carmelo Mercado, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carmelo Mercado was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4795. Ronald F. Merrill, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald F. Merrill was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

881

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 883 of 978

4796. Roberto Mesa, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roberto Mesa was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4797. John J. Messina, Jr., a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. Messina, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4798. Edward F. Metz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward F. Metz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4799. Rafaela J. Meurer, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rafaela J. Meurer was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4800. Harold Meyers, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Harold Meyers was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4801. Thomas Meyers, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

882

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 884 of 978

Thomas Meyers was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4802. Kenneth G. Miccio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth G. Miccio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4803. Richard Frank Miccio, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Frank Miccio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4804. Judy Michaels, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Judy Michaels was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4805. Joseph Mickiewicz, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Mickiewicz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4806. Glen A. Midbo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Glen A. Midbo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

883

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 885 of 978

4807. Ciro Milano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ciro Milano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4808. Roland Miletti, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roland Miletti was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4809. Robert Miller, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Miller was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4810. Thomas A. Milton, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas A. Milton was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4811. Joseph Michael Minogue, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Michael Minogue was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4812. William J. Mirro, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

884

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 886 of 978

William J. Mirro was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4813. Donald H. Mischke, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald H. Mischke was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4814. Steve S. Modica, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steve S. Modica was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4815. Bill Moffat, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bill Moffat was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4816. Ram Anthony Mohabir, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ram Anthony Mohabir was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4817. Michael Molloy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Molloy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

885

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 887 of 978

4818. Joseph William Montaperto, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph William Montaperto was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4819. Frank J. Montaruli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank J. Montaruli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4820. Josephine Monte, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Josephine Monte was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4821. John P. Mooney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John P. Mooney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4822. Joseph Patrick Mooney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Patrick Mooney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4823. Kevin Moore, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin

886

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 888 of 978

Moore was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4824. Robert E. Moore, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert E. Moore, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4825. Tarnisa Tetenya Moore, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Tarnisa Tetenya Moore was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4826. Edwin Morales, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edwin Morales was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4827. Noel A. Moran, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Noel A. Moran was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4828. James L. Morandi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James L. Morandi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

887

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 889 of 978

4829. Marc J. Morello, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marc J. Morello was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4830. David M. Moriarty, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David M. Moriarty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4831. Steven Mormino, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Mormino was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4832. John Morris, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Morris was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4833. Nancy Marie Morrison, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nancy Marie Morrison was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4834. Peter Morrissey, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter

888

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 890 of 978

Morrissey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4835. Michael Moschitta, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Moschitta was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4836. Steven Moss, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Moss was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4837. Omar Mota, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Omar Mota was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4838. Dennis A. Muia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis A. Muia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4839. Matthew S. Mulhan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew S. Mulhan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

889

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 891 of 978

4840. Michael J. Mullarkey, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Mullarkey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4841. George E. Mullen, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George E. Mullen, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4842. Brian D. Muller, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian D. Muller was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4843. Steven J. Muller, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven J. Muller was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4844. Michael P. Mulligan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael P. Mulligan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4845. Michael Mulqueen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

890

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 892 of 978

Michael Mulqueen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4846. Thomas J. Mundy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Mundy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4847. Lois J. Mungay, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lois J. Mungay was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4848. Valeriy Muratov, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Valeriy Muratov was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4849. Jennifer Murawski, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jennifer Murawski was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4850. Allen P. Murphy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Allen P. Murphy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

891

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 893 of 978

4851. David S. Murphy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David S. Murphy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4852. Joseph J. Murphy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph J. Murphy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4853. Richard Murphy, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Murphy was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4854. Vincent Joseph Murphy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Joseph Murphy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4855. James A. Murray, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James A. Murray was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4856. Richard S. Murray, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

892

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 894 of 978

Richard S. Murray was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4857. Robert J. Murray, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert J. Murray was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4858. Kenneth J. Muxie, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth J. Muxie was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4859. John E. Najmy, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John E. Najmy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4860. Parasar Nandan, a resident of Canada, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Parasar Nandan was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4861. Louis Napoli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louis Napoli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

893

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 895 of 978

4862. Thomas Napolitano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Napolitano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4863. Robert V. Narducci, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert V. Narducci was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4864. Daniel Narlock, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Narlock was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4865. Ralph Negron, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph Negron was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4866. Dean A. Neligan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dean A. Neligan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4867. John Nesbitt, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John

894

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 896 of 978

Nesbitt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4868. Allan P. Neuendorf, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Allan P. Neuendorf was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4869. Brian A. Neville, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian A. Neville was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4870. Sean S. Newman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean S. Newman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4871. Fook Sam Ngooi, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fook Sam Ngooi was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4872. James Niebler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Niebler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

895

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 897 of 978

4873. Elizabeth Nielsen, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Elizabeth Nielsen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4874. John Nimmo, III, a resident of Connecticut, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Nimmo, III was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4875. Jose L. Nivar, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jose L. Nivar was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4876. Richard E. Nogan, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard E. Nogan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4877. Terry Lin Norton, a resident of Massachusetts, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terry Lin Norton was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4878. Santos Nunez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Santos

896

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 898 of 978

Nunez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4879. DOE 23, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 23 was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4880. DOE 23, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as the Spouse of DOE 23 an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 4881. DOE 23, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of DOE 23 an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 4882. DOE 23, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as the Child of DOE 23 an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 4883. Kofi Osei Nyantakyi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kofi Osei Nyantakyi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4884. Frank O'Brien, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank O'Brien was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

897

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 899 of 978

4885. John O'Brien, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John O'Brien was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4886. John F. O'Brien, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John F. O'Brien was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4887. Michael O'Brien, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael O'Brien was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4888. Richard O'Brien, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard O'Brien was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4889. Luis S. O'Campo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Luis S. O'Campo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4890. Radames Ocasio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

898

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 900 of 978

Radames Ocasio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4891. Christopher O'Connell, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher O'Connell was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4892. Sean M. O'Connor, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sean M. O'Connor was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4893. Gerard O'Donnell, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard O'Donnell was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4894. John J. O'Donnell, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. O'Donnell was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4895. Brian O'Flaherty, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian O'Flaherty was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

899

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 901 of 978

4896. Robert E. O'Flaherty, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert E. O'Flaherty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4897. Joseph T. O'Hagan, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph T. O'Hagan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4898. Edward O'Hare, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward O'Hare was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4899. Christopher O'Keefe, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher O'Keefe was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4900. Patrick J. O'Keefe, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick J. O'Keefe was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4901. Kayode Oladunjoye, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

900

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 902 of 978

Kayode Oladunjoye was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4902. Dalisay Saenz Olaes, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dalisay Saenz Olaes was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4903. Martin J. O'Leary, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Martin J. O'Leary was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4904. Thomas O'Meara, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas O'Meara was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4905. Joseph O'Neil, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph O'Neil was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4906. Kevin O'Neill, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin O'Neill was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

901

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 903 of 978

4907. Eugene F. O'Reilly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eugene F. O'Reilly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4908. Francisco Ortiz, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francisco Ortiz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4909. Petero R. Otigho, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Petero R. Otigho was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4910. Vincent J. Panaro, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent J. Panaro was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4911. Keith Pander, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Keith Pander was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4912. Carol A. Pantalone, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

902

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 904 of 978

Carol A. Pantalone was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4913. Jennifer Panzella, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jennifer Panzella was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4914. Victor D. Panzella, Jr., a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Victor D. Panzella, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4915. Thomas Papaccio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Papaccio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4916. Mark Papadopulos, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Papadopulos was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4917. Dean G. Pappas, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dean G. Pappas was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

903

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 905 of 978

4918. Ralph Paprocki, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph Paprocki was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4919. Valentin Paredes, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Valentin Paredes was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4920. Salvatore Parisi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Salvatore Parisi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4921. Wilston Lambert Parris, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wilston Lambert Parris was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4922. Anant Patel, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anant Patel was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4923. Gregory Patsos, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

904

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 906 of 978

Gregory Patsos was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4924. Paul Patsos, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul Patsos was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4925. Louis M. Pecora, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louis M. Pecora was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4926. Richard Peitler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Peitler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4927. Maria I. Pellot, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maria I. Pellot was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4928. Michael Pena, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Pena was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

905

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 907 of 978

4929. Milcia C. Pena, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Milcia C. Pena was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4930. Francesca Penora, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francesca Penora was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4931. Ralph Pepe, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph Pepe was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4932. Steven M. Perez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven M. Perez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4933. Steven C. Perry, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven C. Perry was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4934. William J. Pesature, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

906

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 908 of 978

herein. William J. Pesature was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4935. Joseph G. Pesce, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph G. Pesce was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4936. Robert E. Peters, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert E. Peters was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4937. Nathan Peterson, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nathan Peterson was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4938. Joseph M. Petrassi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph M. Petrassi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4939. Gregory M. Petrik, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory M. Petrik was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

907

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 909 of 978

4940. Lori A. Pfeil, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lori A. Pfeil was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4941. Christopher P. Piazza, a resident of Connecticut, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher P. Piazza was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4942. Manuela Pichardo, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Manuela Pichardo was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4943. Pedro Pichardo, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pedro Pichardo was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4944. Ruben Dario Pimentel, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ruben Dario Pimentel was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4945. Vincent A. Pinto, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

908

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 910 of 978

Vincent A. Pinto was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4946. Gerard Pirraglia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard Pirraglia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4947. Carl J. Pisani, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carl J. Pisani was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4948. Leonard Pittz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Leonard Pittz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4949. Larrie Placide, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Larrie Placide was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4950. Edmund L. Plunkett, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edmund L. Plunkett was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

909

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 911 of 978

4951. Daniel J. Pollicino, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel J. Pollicino was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4952. Dan J. Potter, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dan J. Potter was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4953. Sharon Premoli, a resident of the State of Vermont, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sharon Premoli was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4954. John Prendergast, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Prendergast was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4955. Kevin J. Prendergast, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin J. Prendergast was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4956. John Prenty, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John

910

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 912 of 978

Prenty was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4957. Frank Prescia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Prescia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4958. Salvatore T. Princiotta, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Salvatore T. Princiotta, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4959. Michael J. Prior, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael J. Prior was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4960. Brian Pritchard, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Pritchard was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4961. William Privitar, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Privitar was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

911

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 913 of 978

4962. Vincent Puleo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Puleo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4963. Robert Pulizzotto, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Pulizzotto was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4964. Daniel P. Purcell, a resident of Connecticut, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel P. Purcell was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4965. Francis Paul Pursley, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francis Paul Pursley was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4966. John M. Quevedo, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John M. Quevedo, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4967. Michael J. Quevedo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

912

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 914 of 978

Michael J. Quevedo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4968. Edwin Quinn, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edwin Quinn was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4969. Peter Adam Quinn, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Adam Quinn was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4970. Antonio Quinones, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Antonio Quinones was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4971. Godwin Quinones, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Godwin Quinones was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4972. Paul G. Quirke, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul G. Quirke was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

913

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 915 of 978

4973. James P. Rae, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James P. Rae was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4974. Robert Rae, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Rae was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4975. Raymond Ragucci, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Raymond Ragucci was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4976. Kenneth M. Rallis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth M. Rallis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4977. Richard Ramaizel, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Ramaizel was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4978. Juan Ramirez, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Juan

914

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 916 of 978

Ramirez was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4979. Vigita Ramnath, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vigita Ramnath was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4980. Alfonso Ramos, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alfonso Ramos was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4981. Mildred Ramos, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mildred Ramos was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4982. Robert Ramos, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Ramos was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4983. Michael Ramputi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Ramputi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

915

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 917 of 978

4984. Sebastian Raspanti, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sebastian Raspanti was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4985. James Reddan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James Reddan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4986. Joshua M. Reder, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joshua M. Reder was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4987. Daniel James Reeber, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel James Reeber was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4988. Pamela Rose Reeves, a resident of New Mexico, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Pamela Rose Reeves was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4989. Richard Regis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard

916

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 918 of 978

Regis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4990. Joseph Reid, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Reid was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4991. Timothy J. Reid, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy J. Reid was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4992. Charles Reilly, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles Reilly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4993. Thomas P. Reilly, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas P. Reilly was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4994. John E. Reinhardt, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John E. Reinhardt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

917

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 919 of 978

4995. Lloyd Rendall, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lloyd Rendall was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4996. John Renna, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Renna was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4997. Francis W. Renois, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Francis W. Renois was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4998. Richard Resto, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Resto was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 4999. Alfred W. Retundie, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alfred W. Retundie was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5000. Christopher Revere, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

918

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 920 of 978

Christopher Revere was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5001. Fernando Reyes, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fernando Reyes was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5002. Juan L. Reyes, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Juan L. Reyes was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5003. Karem Reynoso, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Karem Reynoso was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5004. Frank Ricca, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank Ricca was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5005. William J. Riccardulli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William J. Riccardulli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

919

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 921 of 978

5006. Daniel Ricciardi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Ricciardi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5007. Arthur J. Riccio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Arthur J. Riccio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5008. Steven J. Richards, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven J. Richards was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5009. Maurice Richardson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maurice Richardson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5010. Franco Riggio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Franco Riggio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5011. William Riordan, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

920

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 922 of 978

William Riordan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5012. David M. Rivas, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David M. Rivas was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5013. Carlos A. Rivera, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carlos A. Rivera was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5014. Edwin Rivera, a resident of Puerto Rico, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edwin Rivera was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5015. Edwin Rivera, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edwin Rivera was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5016. Grace Rivera, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Grace Rivera was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

921

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 923 of 978

5017. Jose Rivera, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jose Rivera was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5018. Omayra Rivera, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Omayra Rivera was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5019. Vincent Rivera, a resident of Texas, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Vincent Rivera was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5020. Michael Rizzo, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Rizzo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5021. Douglas Robinson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Douglas Robinson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5022. Kenneth James Robulak, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

922

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 924 of 978

herein. Kenneth James Robulak was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5023. Anthony Rocco, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Rocco was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5024. Nelson Rocha, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nelson Rocha was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5025. John Roche, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Roche was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5026. Bryan A. Rodrigues, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bryan A. Rodrigues was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5027. Abimael Rodriguez, a resident of Puerto Rico, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Abimael Rodriguez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

923

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 925 of 978

5028. Carlota Rodriguez brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carlota Rodriguez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5029. David Rodriguez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Rodriguez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5030. Miriam Rodriguez, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Miriam Rodriguez was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5031. Rosaulina Rodriguez, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rosaulina Rodriguez was present at Five World Trade Center - Northeast Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5032. John Robert Rogers, a resident of Connecticut, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Robert Rogers was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5033. Julio Roig, Jr., a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Julio

924

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 926 of 978

Roig, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5034. Susana Rojas, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susana Rojas was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5035. John T. Rokee, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John T. Rokee was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5036. Arnold Roma, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Arnold Roma was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5037. William Romaka, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Romaka was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5038. Filomena Roman, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Filomena Roman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

925

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 927 of 978

5039. Frank J. Romano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank J. Romano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5040. John B. Rooney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John B. Rooney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5041. Victor J. Rosa, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Victor J. Rosa was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5042. Anthony A. Rosado, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony A. Rosado was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5043. Gwennett Rosario, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gwennett Rosario was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5044. Michael J. Rossello, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

926

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 928 of 978

Michael J. Rossello was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5045. Joseph Camillo Rotondi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Camillo Rotondi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5046. Louis Rotondo, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louis Rotondo was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5047. David Rowan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Rowan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5048. Mark J. Rowan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark J. Rowan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5049. James J. Rozas, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James J. Rozas was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

927

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 929 of 978

5050. Steven Ruggiero, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Ruggiero was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5051. Louis Ruggirello, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louis Ruggirello was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5052. Donald J. Ruland, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald J. Ruland was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5053. Mark Ruppert, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mark Ruppert was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5054. Damian Rusin, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Damian Rusin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5055. Marshall Ryan, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

928

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 930 of 978

Marshall Ryan was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5056. Susan S. Ryan, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Susan S. Ryan was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5057. Thomas D. Ryan, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas D. Ryan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5058. Michael G. Rynn, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael G. Rynn was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5059. Matthew John Salmon, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Matthew John Salmon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5060. Robert Salmon, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Salmon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

929

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 931 of 978

5061. Reina Salzedo, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Reina Salzedo was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5062. Audrey J. Sammis, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Audrey J. Sammis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5063. Clide R. Sampson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Clide R. Sampson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5064. Carlos H. Sanchez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carlos H. Sanchez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5065. Concepcion Sanchez, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Concepcion Sanchez was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5066. Jose Antonio Sanchez, Jr., a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

930

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 932 of 978

herein. Jose Antonio Sanchez, Jr. was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5067. Joe N. Sanders, a resident of Georgia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joe N. Sanders was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5068. Oscar F. Sandoval, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Oscar F. Sandoval was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5069. David P. Sandvik, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David P. Sandvik was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5070. Robert Santandrea, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Santandrea was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5071. Luis Santiago, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Luis Santiago was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

931

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 933 of 978

5072. David A. Santise, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David A. Santise was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5073. Christopher Santos, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Santos was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5074. LaShea Saunders, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. LaShea Saunders was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5075. Glenn Savery, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Glenn Savery was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5076. Thelma Savery, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thelma Savery was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5077. Thomas Scally, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas

932

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 934 of 978

Scally was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5078. Philip J. Scarfi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Philip J. Scarfi was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5079. Benedict Scarsella, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Benedict Scarsella was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5080. Carl Scheetz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carl Scheetz was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5081. DOE 28, a resident of California, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 28 was present at One Liberty Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5082. Donald Schipf, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald Schipf was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

933

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 935 of 978

5083. Brian M. Schmitt, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian M. Schmitt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5084. Robert Schmitt, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Schmitt was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5085. Edward J. Schneider, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward J. Schneider was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5086. Peter A. Schoepe, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter A. Schoepe was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5087. Daniel R. Schofield, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel R. Schofield was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5088. Daniel Schug, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel

934

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 936 of 978

Schug was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5089. Robert Schumacker, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Schumacker was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5090. Richard Edward Scola, a resident of North Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Edward Scola was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5091. Anthony F. Scolavino, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony F. Scolavino was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5092. Howard Scott, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Howard Scott was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5093. Daniel Paul Seaman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel Paul Seaman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

935

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 937 of 978

5094. David Sears, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Sears was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5095. David Sedacca, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Sedacca was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5096. Ralph P. Seiter, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ralph P. Seiter was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5097. Robert Senn, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Senn was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5098. Jeffrey Sentowski, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jeffrey Sentowski was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5099. Lawrence R. Senzel, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

936

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 938 of 978

Lawrence R. Senzel was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5100. Anthony E. Sercia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony E. Sercia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5101. William J. Sergio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William J. Sergio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5102. Barbara Serna, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barbara Serna was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5103. Kevin Shaeffer, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Shaeffer was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5104. Abida Shaikh, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Abida Shaikh was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

937

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 939 of 978

5105. Stephen J. Sharp, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen J. Sharp was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5106. Kevin M. Shea, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin M. Shea was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5107. John B. Sheehan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John B. Sheehan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5108. Marilyn Joy Shepard, a resident of California, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marilyn Joy Shepard was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5109. Rodney C. Sherard, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rodney C. Sherard was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5110. Edward John Shields, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

938

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 940 of 978

herein. Edward John Shields was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5111. Scott Shields, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott Shields was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5112. Steve M. Shtab, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steve M. Shtab was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5113. Frederic Siboulet, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frederic Siboulet was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5114. John Signorelli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Signorelli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5115. Fabian Silva, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Fabian Silva, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

939

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 941 of 978

5116. Wendy Christina Silva-Smith, a resident of California, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wendy Christina Silva-Smith was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5117. Brian Singer, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Singer was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5118. Donna Singer, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donna Singer was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5119. DOE 77, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 77 was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5120. Clarence Singleton, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Clarence Singleton was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5121. Neil Jeffrey Skow, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

940

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 942 of 978

Neil Jeffrey Skow was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5122. Terence P. Slane, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Terence P. Slane was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5123. Eugene Slater, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eugene Slater was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5124. Brandon J. Smith, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brandon J. Smith was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5125. Gareth A. Smith, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gareth A. Smith was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5126. Lauren A. Smith, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lauren A. Smith was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

941

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 943 of 978

5127. Michael A. Smith, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Smith was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5128. Neta Smith, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neta Smith was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5129. Peter Smith, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Smith was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5130. Todd M. Smith, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Todd M. Smith was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5131. Andrew W. Sochinski, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Andrew W. Sochinski was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5132. Salvatore Sodano, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

942

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 944 of 978

Salvatore Sodano was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5133. Richard Souto, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Souto was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5134. David Sozio, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. David Sozio was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5135. Michael Spiller, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Spiller was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5136. Robert S. Spinelli, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert S. Spinelli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5137. Donald J. Spurrell, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Donald J. Spurrell was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

943

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 945 of 978

5138. Anthony Joseph Squillante, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Joseph Squillante was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5139. Christopher Suhr, a resident of the State of New York brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Suhr was present at the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5140. Clifford William Stabner, a resident of Delaware, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Clifford William Stabner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5141. Joseph R. Stach, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph R. Stach, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5142. Nelly Stanicich, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nelly Stanicich was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5143. DOE 111, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE

944

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 946 of 978

111 was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5144. John Starace, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Starace was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5145. Peter Stathis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Peter Stathis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5146. Dennis Stefanak, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis Stefanak was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5147. Harry F. Stefandel, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Harry F. Stefandel was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5148. William A. Steinbuch, III, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William A. Steinbuch, III was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

945

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 947 of 978

5149. Maximino Sterling, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Maximino Sterling was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5150. John M. Stiastny, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John M. Stiastny was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5151. Eugene Stolowski, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Eugene Stolowski was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5152. Ethan Strauss, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ethan Strauss was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5153. Rasmond E. Streker, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Rasmond E. Streker was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5154. Paul Stroessner, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul

946

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 948 of 978

Stroessner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5155. Stephen E. Stroh, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stephen E. Stroh was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5156. Scott C. Stromer, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Scott C. Stromer was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5157. Anthony E. Suchon, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony E. Suchon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5158. Gerard Suden, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard Suden was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5159. Devindra Sukhram, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Devindra Sukhram was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

947

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 949 of 978

5160. Linda Sulfaro, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Linda Sulfaro was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5161. Edward Sullivan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Sullivan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5162. John Joseph Sullivan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Joseph Sullivan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5163. John M. Sullivan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John M. Sullivan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5164. Lawrence J. Sullivan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lawrence J. Sullivan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5165. Michael P. Sullivan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

948

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 950 of 978

Michael P. Sullivan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5166. Kenneth A. Summers, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth A. Summers was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5167. Randolph J. Supek, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Randolph J. Supek was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5168. Robert Sutton, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Sutton was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5169. Alfred Suwara, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alfred Suwara was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5170. Otto W. Suwara, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Otto W. Suwara was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

949

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 951 of 978

5171. Ronald Svec, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ronald Svec was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5172. Thomas Swannick, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas Swannick was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5173. Gerard F. Sweeney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard F. Sweeney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5174. Joseph Swick, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph Swick was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5175. Steven M. Syrop, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven M. Syrop was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5176. Joseph Szymanski, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

950

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 952 of 978

Joseph Szymanski was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5177. Soudabeh Tabatabai, a resident of California, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Soudabeh Tabatabai was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5178. John Francis Taggart, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Francis Taggart was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5179. Carol L. Tannenbaum, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Carol L. Tannenbaum was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5180. Timothy J. Tarpey, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy J. Tarpey was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5181. Expedito Tavarez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Expedito Tavarez was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

951

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 953 of 978

5182. Havergail Taylor, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Havergail Taylor was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5183. Roxanne Taylor, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roxanne Taylor was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5184. Geraldine Teixeira, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Geraldine Teixeira was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5185. Michael A. Telesca, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Telesca was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5186. Bidiawattie Tewari, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bidiawattie Tewari was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5187. Recioe Thomas, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

952

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 954 of 978

Recioe Thomas was present at One Liberty Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5188. Denise Thompson, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Denise Thompson was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5189. Lloyd Anthony Thompson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lloyd Anthony Thompson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5190. Dennis J. Thomson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis J. Thomson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5191. Frank R. Thurlow, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank R. Thurlow was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5192. DOE 92, a resident of District of Columbia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 92 was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

953

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 955 of 978

5193. Roderic S. Tierney, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roderic S. Tierney was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5194. Richard Tishler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Tishler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5195. John A. Tiska, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John A. Tiska was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5196. Anthony Tito, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Tito was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5197. Michael K. Tobin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael K. Tobin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5198. Edward H. Tomaszewski, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth

954

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 956 of 978

herein. Edward H. Tomaszewski was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5199. Salvatore S. Torcivia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Salvatore S. Torcivia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5200. Gabriel Torres, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gabriel Torres was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5201. Johnny Torres, a resident of Arizona, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Johnny Torres was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5202. Louis Torres, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louis Torres was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5203. Miguel Torres, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Miguel Torres was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

955

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 957 of 978

5204. Michael Tracy, a resident of Connecticut, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Tracy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5205. John Treglia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Treglia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5206. Joseph M. Trezza, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph M. Trezza was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5207. Alfred Trinidad, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alfred Trinidad was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5208. Douglas Tripken, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Douglas Tripken was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5209. Michael Tripptree, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

956

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 958 of 978

Michael Tripptree was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5210. Louis M. Troisi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Louis M. Troisi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5211. Stanley Trojanowski, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Stanley Trojanowski was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5212. Larry Troy, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Larry Troy was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5213. Dell Truax, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dell Truax was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5214. Kevin M. Tully, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin M. Tully was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

957

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 959 of 978

5215. Steven Turilli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steven Turilli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5216. Thomas V. Turilli, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas V. Turilli was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5217. Joseph A. Tursi, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Joseph A. Tursi was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5218. Antonina Tutkaj, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Antonina Tutkaj was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5219. John M. Tyson, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John M. Tyson was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5220. Nosa E. Ugiagbe, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nosa

958

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 960 of 978

E. Ugiagbe was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5221. Gisela Valencia, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gisela Valencia was present at Five World Trade Center - Northeast Plaza and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5222. Dennis J. Valentin, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis J. Valentin was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5223. Hilda Valentine, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Hilda Valentine was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5224. Robert Van Houten, a resident of Pennsylvania, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Van Houten was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5225. William C. Van Name, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William C. Van Name was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

959

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 961 of 978

5226. Bruce J. Van Nosdall, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bruce J. Van Nosdall was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5227. Jennifer Leigh Van Zanten, a resident of Delaware, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Jennifer Leigh Van Zanten was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5228. Anthony Vanacore, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Anthony Vanacore was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5229. Robert Varese, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Varese, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5230. Yuni Vasquez, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Yuni Vasquez was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5231. Al Vega, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Al Vega

960

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 962 of 978

was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5232. Emmanuel Vega, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Emmanuel Vega was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5233. Charles Vella, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Charles Vella was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5234. James A. Vella, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James A. Vella was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5235. Lawrence Vento, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Lawrence Vento was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5236. Nellie Verdejo, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Nellie Verdejo was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

961

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 963 of 978

5237. John S. Verme, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John S. Verme was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5238. John Verrengia, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John Verrengia was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5239. Timothy Villari, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Timothy Villari was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5240. Dominick Vincenti, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dominick Vincenti was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5241. Bryan Violetto, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Bryan Violetto was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5242. Darlene Helen Vollenberg, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set

962

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 964 of 978

forth herein. Darlene Helen Vollenberg was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5243. Gerard Von Essen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gerard Von Essen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5244. Brian Voos, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian Voos was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5245. Edward Wagner, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Edward Wagner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5246. Daniel S. Walis, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Daniel S. Walis was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5247. Mickey Walker, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Mickey Walker was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

963

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 965 of 978

5248. Brian P. Wall, a resident of New Hampshire, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brian P. Wall was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5249. Patrick Wall, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Patrick Wall was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5250. Kerry M. Walsh, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kerry M. Walsh was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5251. DOE 113, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. DOE 113 was present at Six World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5252. Neil Patrick Walsh, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neil Patrick Walsh was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5253. Cecil R. Ward, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cecil

964

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 966 of 978

R. Ward was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5254. Frank J. Ward, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Frank J. Ward was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5255. Richard H. Ward, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard H. Ward was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5256. Sandra Ward, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Sandra Ward was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5257. Thomas P. Ward, a resident of South Carolina, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas P. Ward was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5258. Thomas A. Warkenthien, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas A. Warkenthien was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

965

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 967 of 978

5259. Cynthia Warren, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Cynthia Warren was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5260. Wayne A. Warren, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Wayne A. Warren was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5261. Romuald Waszielewicz, a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Romuald Waszielewicz was present at One World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5262. Christian R. Waugh, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christian R. Waugh was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5263. Michael A. Weaver, Sr., a resident of Maryland, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael A. Weaver, Sr. was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5264. David Weber, Sr., a resident of New Jersey, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

966

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 968 of 978

David Weber, Sr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5265. William G. Weinert, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William G. Weinert was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5266. Gregg Weisenburger, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregg Weisenburger was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5267. Gary Dennis Welge, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gary Dennis Welge was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5268. Michael Welsh, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Welsh was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5269. James M. Werner, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. James M. Werner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

967

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 969 of 978

5270. Kevin Whalen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kevin Whalen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5271. Paul A. Whalen, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Paul A. Whalen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5272. Brendan J. Whelan, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Brendan J. Whelan was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5273. Henry W. White, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Henry W. White was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5274. Yaeno White, a resident of California, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Yaeno White was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5275. Steve Wiesner, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Steve

968

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 970 of 978

Wiesner was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5276. Michael Wilbur, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Michael Wilbur was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5277. Barbara Matilda Williams, a resident of Florida, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Barbara Matilda Williams was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5278. George Wilton, Jr., a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. George Wilton, Jr. was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5279. Ken Wiltse, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Ken Wiltse was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5280. Kenneth Winkler, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kenneth Winkler was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

969

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 971 of 978

5281. Walter Wissell, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Walter Wissell was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5282. John J. Wojcik, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John J. Wojcik was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5283. Clifford Wolken, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Clifford Wolken was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5284. Phidia Wong, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Phidia Wong was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5285. William E. Woodlon, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William E. Woodlon was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5286. William Woytkin, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

970

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 972 of 978

William Woytkin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5287. Robert Eric Wright, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Robert Eric Wright was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5288. William K. Wright, a resident of District of Columbia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William K. Wright was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5289. Gregory Wyckoff, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory Wyckoff was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5290. John D. Yates, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John D. Yates was present at Pentagon and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5291. Neal Yellen, a resident of Florida, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Neal Yellen was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

971

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 973 of 978

5292. Kah L. Yeoh, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Kah L. Yeoh was present at Three World Trade Center - Marriott Hotel and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5293. Christopher Young, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Christopher Young was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5294. Dianne Young, a resident of Virginia, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dianne Young was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5295. John E. Young, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. John E. Young was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5296. Thomas H. Young, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas H. Young was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5297. Angelo Zecca, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Angelo

972

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 974 of 978

Zecca was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5298. Helen Zerlin, a resident of New York, brings this action on her own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Helen Zerlin was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5299. Dennis Zimmerman, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Dennis Zimmerman was present in the World Trade Center area and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5300. Richard Stephen Zletz, a resident of New York, brings this action on his own behalf as an Injured Party, and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Richard Stephen Zletz was present at Two World Trade Center and sustained injuries as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5301. Plaintiff Teri D. Fields is a resident of GA, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Adolfo Martin Arzu and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Adolfo Martin Arzu was present in the World Trade Center area and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5302. Plaintiff Hillary Katzman is a resident of Florida, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Howard Katzman and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Howard Katzman was present in the World Trade Center area and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001.

973

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 975 of 978

5303. Plaintiff Denise E. Kelly is a resident of New York, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Thomas J. Kelly and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Thomas J. Kelly was present in the World Trade Center area and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5304. Plaintiff Michelle Luchetti is a resident of New York, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Alfred Luchetti and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Alfred Luchetti was present in the World Trade Center area and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5305. Plaintiff Lynn McKnight is a resident of New York, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roger J. McKnight and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roger J. McKnight was present Two World Trade Center and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5306. Plaintiff Lisa Ortiz is a resident of New York, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Angel R. Ortiz and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Angel R. Ortiz was present Three World Trade Center Marriott Hotel and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5307. Plaintiff Irene Provenzano is a resident of New York, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Salvatore Provenzano and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Salvatore Provenzano was present Two World Trade Center and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5308. Plaintiff Kathleen Shagi is a resident of New York, and brings this action as the Executor of the Estate of Michael Shagi and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of

974

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 976 of 978

action set forth herein. Michael Shagi was present in the World Trade Center area and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5309. Plaintiff Thomas D. Duling is a resident of Virginia, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Marion Morvet Ward and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Marion Morvet Ward was present the Pentagon and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5310. Plaintiff Peggy J. Waters is a resident of New York, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Gregory A. Waters and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Gregory A. Waters was present in the World Trade Center area and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5311. Plaintiff Danielle Cioffi is a resident of New York, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of William Tracy and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. William Tracy was present in the World Trade Center area and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5312. Plaintiff Ina Barnes is a resident of New Jersey, and brings this action as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Roy J. Barnes and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. Roy J. Barnes was present in the World Trade Center area and killed as a result of a terrorist attack on September 11, 2001. 5313. Fada Silva brings a claim as the Personal Representative of the Estate of Louis M. Garriz who was previously injured in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, and is now deceased. The Estate of Louis M. Garriz brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

975

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 977 of 978

5314. Mary Jean Holly brings a claim as the Representative of the Estate of James Holly who was previoulsy injured in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 and is now deceased. The Estate of James Holly brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 5315. Plaintiff Melanie A. Hunt is a resident of the State of New Jersey and brings a claim as the child of Jean Marlene Hunt who was injured in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 5316. Plaintiff Candee J. Maltese is a resident of the State of New Jersey and brings a claim as the child of Jean Marlene Hunt who was injured in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 5317. America Peralta brings a claim as the Representative of the Estate of Guido Omar Peralta who was previously injured in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, and is now deceased. The Estate of Guido Omar Peraltal brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 5318. Virtudes Prianto brings a claim as the Representative of the Estate of Bambang Prianto who was previously injured in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, and is now deceased. The Estate of Bambang Prianto brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein. 5319. Plaintiff Teresa Roig is a resident of the State of New Jersey and is the ex-wife of Julio Roig, Jr. who was injured in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001. Teresa Roig brings this action on her own behalf and on behalf of the minor children of Julio Roig, Jr. and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

976

Case 1:03-cv-09849-GBD Document 741-7 Filed 03/17/17 Page 978 of 978

5320. Gail Sullivan brings a claim on behalf of the Estate of James Holly as his wife. James Holly was previoulsy injured in the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001 and is now deceased. The Estate of James Holly brings this action and is entitled to recover damages on the causes of action set forth herein.

977