Menu
(/content/search)
Subscribe (/)
(/About/Contact/Feedback/About-these-Ads)
BOOKS (/BOOKS) | BOOK REVIEWS (/BOOKS/BOOK-REVIEWS)
'Showdown' tells how Strom Thurmond tried to keep Thurgood Marshall off the Supreme Court Marshall was black and liberal, two too many questionable traits for many US senators as the senate confirmation hearings began in what would become known as 1967’s 'Summer of Love.' By Randy Dotinga
OCTOBER 29, 2015 About these ads (/About/Contact/Feedback/About-these-Ads) About video ads (/About/Contact/Feedback/About-video-ads)
Monitor's Best: Top 5 1 (/USA/Politics/2018/0410/Behindshock-of-Cohen-raid-signs-of-ameticulous-process)
Behind shock of Cohen raid, signs of a meticulous process (/USA/Politics/2018/0410/Behindshock-of-Cohen-raidsigns-of-a-meticulousprocess)
2 (/World/Europe/2018/0410/Anti-
View Caption
Semitism-stains-Labour-Corbyn-
View Caption
again.-Why-does-this-keep-
The most important civil rights attorney of the 20th century had escaped men who
happening)
wanted to kill him because of what – and whom – he stood for. He’d grilled and
Anti-Semitism stains Labour, Corbyn again. Why does this keep happening? (/World/Europe/2018/0410/AntiSemitism-stainsLabour-Corbyn-again.Why-does-this-keephappening)
been grilled in courtrooms all the way up to the highest in the land, the one he now hoped to join as its first African-American justice. But as he sat before a Senate panel debating his fate, a Southern firebrand treated Thurgood Marshall as if he were a contestant on a quiz show called “Know Everything or Else.”
3
(/Commentary/themonitors-
Could Marshall name the committee behind the 14th Amendment and identify its
view/2018/0410/A-creative-
members? What legal basis did supporters of the Civil Rights Act of 1866 rely
solution-to-the-US-China-trade-
upon? What did a 19th-century congressman see as difficulties “in congressional
dispute)
A creative solution to the US-China trade dispute (/Commentary/themonitorsview/2018/0410/Acreative-solution-to-theUS-China-trade-dispute)
enforcement of the privileges and immunity of article IV, section 2, through the necessary and proper clauses of article I, section 8?” Recommended: How much do you know about African-American literature? Take the quiz (/Books/2015/0812/How-much-do-you-know-about-AfricanAmerican-literature-Take-the-quiz/Alice-Walker)
4 The man behind the questions, Senator Strom Thurmond, wanted to place extra
(/TheCulture/2018/0406/Wanted-
obstacles in front of Marshall, forcing him – and only him – to be a superhuman in
Volunteers-who-like-history-and-
order to rise. It’s an old strategy in American life, set in code through poll taxes and
can-read-cursive)
impossible quizzes at the ballot box, and one that Marshall had devoted his life to
Wanted: Volunteers who like history ... and can read cursive (/TheCulture/2018/0406/WantedVolunteers-who-likehistory-and-can-readcursive)
extinguishing. Yet here it came again, the rigged expectations game, threatening to snuff out his far-from-guaranteed bid to join the Supreme Court. Many of us remember a later series of dramatic Senate hearings over a black man who hoped to
5
become a Supreme Court justice, but Marshall’s own
(/World/AsiaPacific/2018/0409/In-
inquisition has largely been lost to history until now.
the-Philippines-divided-politics-
In his new book Showdown: Thurgood Marshall
feed-and-feed-on-a-divided-web)
and the Supreme Court Nomination that
FOCUS
(/csmlists/special/focus) In the Philippines, divided politics feed – and feed on – a divided web (/World/AsiaPacific/2018/0409/In-thePhilippines-dividedpolitics-feed-and-feedon-a-divided-web)
Changed America, historian Wil Haygood expertly (/Books/2015/0812/How-much-do-you-
brings an remarkable time and place back to life.
know-about-African-Americanliterature-Take-the-quiz)
As he writes, Marshall was black and liberal, two
TEST YOUR KNOWLEDGE
too many questionable traits for many senators as the
(/csmlists/quizzes) | How much do you
hearings began in what would become known as
know about African-American literature? Take the quiz (/Books/2015/0812/How-
1967’s “Summer of Love.”
much-do-you-know-about-African-
American-literature-Take-the-quiz/AliceWalker)
Haywood, author of the article that inspired the film titled “The Butler” and biographies of Sammy Davis Jr. and Sugar Ray Robinson, is a master at bringing characters from history to life. In “Showdown,” he’s especially skilled at helping readers understand the personalities and motives of the men – and they’re
(/Books/2015/0812/How-much-do-you-
all men – who sought victory at the hearings.
know-about-African-American-literatureTake-the-quiz) (/Photo-Galleries/Photos-of-the-Day-
On Marshall’s side was President Lyndon Johnson,
How much do you know about African-American literature? Take the quiz. (/Books/2015/0812/How-much-do-you-knowabout-African-American-literature-Take-the-quiz)
Archives/2017/Photos-of-the-day-05-
who told him that “I’m nominating you because
05)
you’re like me: bigger than life, and we come from
PHOTOS OF THE DAY
the same kind of people.” On the other side were
Galleries/Photos-of-the-Day) | Photos
(/Photo-
of the day 05/05 (/Photo-
Johnson’s occasional allies, Democratic senators
Galleries/Photos-of-the-Day-
from the South raised on segregation, Civil War
Archives/2017/Photos-of-the-day-05-05)
nostalgia and – as one stunningly put it on the Senate floor – the belief that “the Negro race is an inferior race.” Other men in “Showdown” refuse to fit into their assigned roles, like the maverick South Carolina exjudge who championed Marshall. Or landed parts they didn’t want, like the Republican black man
WHAT ARE YOU READING?
surprised to find himself recruited as an alternate if
about the book that's currenly on your
Marshall lost. Then there’s the most vivid character
bedside table.
| Tell us
(/d-right-300)
SUBSCRIBE
of all, previous Haygood biography subject Adam Clayton Powell Jr., a loose-cannon Harlem congressman who “bedeviled the White
(/d-right-300)
House with his antics” during the hearings and even managed to get thrown out of Congress but still return. Against this backdrop, Marshall somehow becomes one of the less colorful figures in “Showdown” even as he jousts with the senators hoping to catch him in a revealing slip. He actually had an exuberant personality, full of passions and joy in life, as best revealed in 2012’s Pulitzer Prize-winning “Devil in the Grove: Thurgood Marshall, the Groveland Boys, and the Dawn of a New America.” In “Showdown,” a college acquaintance named Langston Hughes – yes, that one – hints at his personality, remembering him as “rough and ready, loud and wrong, good natured and uncouth.” As Haygood writes, Marshall was the “steady drumbeat” in contrast to Congressman Powell’s “jazzy horn.” It’s sad to wonder about how Marshall must have had to hold himself in, even in private conversations with potential allies, to show the extra gravitas expected of a black man who hoped to move up. But that he did. Marshall joined the Supreme Court and became one of its most influential and renowned justices. He lives on in the names of campuses, scholarships, and a new journalism outfit devoted to criminal justice. Other echoes remain. “Judicial activism,” the epithet of Marshall’s congressional foes in 1967, is still a verbal weapon in jousting over judges. Conservatives continue to challenge Marshall’s record, even weaponizing it in their failed bid to shut down the Supreme Court nomination of a onetime Marshall law clerk named Elena Kagan. But thanks to the events chronicled in “Showdown,” America still keeps time to the “steady drumbeat” of Marshall’s legacy.
Next up About these ads (/About/Contact/Feedback/About-these-Ads)
(/Books/2015/0812/How-much-do-you-
know-about-African-American-literature-Take-the-quiz) TEST YOUR KNOWLEDGE
(/csmlists/quizzes) How much do you know about AfricanAmerican literature? Take the quiz (/Books/2015/0812/Howmuch-do-you-know-about-African-American-literature-Takethe-quiz/Alice-Walker)
(/Books/Book-
Reviews/2012/0307/Devil-in-the-Grove) REVIEW
Devil in the Grove (/Books/Book-Reviews/2012/0307/Devil-inthe-Grove)
(/Books/Book-Reviews/2013/0304/Out-
of-Order-Stories-from-the-History-of-the-Supreme-Court) REVIEW
Out of Order: Stories from the History of the Supreme Court (/Books/Book-Reviews/2013/0304/Out-of-Order-Stories-fromthe-History-of-the-Supreme-Court)
(/Books/Book-Reviews/2012/1219/The-
Oath) REVIEW
The Oath (/Books/Book-Reviews/2012/1219/The-Oath)
(/layout/set/print/Books/Book-Reviews/2015/1029/Showdown-tells-how-StromThurmond-tried-to-keep-Thurgood-Marshall-off-the-Supreme-Court)
About these ads (/About/Contact/Feedback/About-these-Ads)
(/d-above-footer)
Global Galleries (/Photo-Galleries)
Latest News
(/Photo-Galleries/Photos-of-the-
Doing Good (/World/Making-a-difference)
(/USA/Society/2017/0505/Why-the-new-
Movies (/The-Culture/Movies/2017/0 After-the-Storm-what-we-see-is-too all-we-get)
(/World/Making-a-
(/The-Culture/Movies/2017/0317/
04/09 Photos of the week (/PhotoGalleries/Photos-of-the-Week/2018/04-09Photos-of-the-week)
FIRST LOOK
(/csmlists/special/first-look) Why the new health-care bill may keep affordable care out of reach for some (/USA/Society/2017/0505/Why-the-newhealth-care-bill-may-keep-affordable-careout-of-reach-for-some)
After hurricane Maria, he's helping the ocean – and its fishers – recover (/World/Making-a-difference/2018/0409/Afterhurricane-Maria-he-s-helping-the-oceanand-its-fishers-recover)
In 'After the Storm,' what we see is to all we get (/TheCulture/Movies/2017/0317/In-After-th Storm-what-we-see-is-too-often-all-w
(/About/Contact/Feedback/About-these-Ads)
(/)
STAY CURRENT. GO FAR. D ISC OVER TH E MON ITOR D IFFER EN C E
(/About) (http://www.facebook.com/ChristianScienceMonitor) (http://www.twitter.com/CSMonitor) (https://plus.google.com/u/0/+TheChristianScienceMonitor/posts) ABOUT (/ABOUT)
|
CONTACT US (/ABOUT/CONTACT) |
|
SUBSCRIBE (/D-FOOTER)
CAREERS (/ABOUT/CAREERS)
|
|
FREE NEWSLETTERS (/D-FOOTER-NSLR)
|
ADVERTISE WITH US (/ABOUT/ADVERTISE)
FIND US ONLINE (/ABOUT/FIND-US-ONLINE)
CONTENT MAP (/CSM/CONTENTMAP) | TEXT (/LAYOUT/SET/TEXT/TEXTEDITION) | CORRECTIONS (/ABOUT/CORRECTIONS) | REPRINTS & PERMISSIONS © The Christian Science Monitor. All Rights Reserved. Terms under which this service is provided to you. (/About/Terms) Privacy Policy. (/About/Privacy-Policy) (HTTP://WWW.CSMONITORREPRINTS.COM/) | MULTIMEDIA (/MULTIMEDIA) | A CHRISTIAN SCIENCE PERSPECTIVE (/COMMENTARY/A-CHRISTIAN-SCIENCE-PERSPECTIVE)